Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mindfulness for the Discerning Lawyer with Emily Nagisa Keehn
Transcript
- 0:06Hi everybody. Welcome. We are very excited for
- 0:10a program today. I'm excited because my daughter
- 0:13is here with me. She's a BHBA ambassador and
- 0:16she actually was the one who sourced this program
- 0:19for us. So she'll be handling the actual introductions.
- 0:23My name is Dean Sirwin. I am the section chair
- 0:26of the Beverly Hills Bar Law Practice Management
- 0:29and Wellness sections. Take it away Rachel. Hi,
- 0:34everyone. I'm Rachel Serwin, and I'm a student
- 0:36ambassador with the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:39As a student ambassador, I'm going to be connecting
- 0:41students with networking opportunities and keeping
- 0:44them updated on key BHBA events. And now on to
- 0:48today's program, I'm delighted to introduce today's
- 0:50speaker, Emily Nagisa Keen. Emily is the Assistant
- 0:54Dean of Law Student Affairs at the University
- 0:56of San Diego, where I am a 1L, where she leads
- 0:59programs that support law student life, academic
- 1:02success, and well -being. She also teaches contemplative
- 1:05practice of law, helping students build mindfulness,
- 1:09resilience, and ethical awareness. She spent
- 1:11over a decade working in human rights, including
- 1:14roles at Harvard Law School, the Joan B. Kroc
- 1:17School of Peace Studies, and the Sankeh Gender
- 1:20Justice in South Her work has influenced national
- 1:24policies, impacted litigation, and health and
- 1:28human rights advocacy, earning her recognition
- 1:30from the University of San Diego and the Mail
- 1:33and Guardian in South Africa. We're very excited
- 1:36to see what she has to share with us today. Emily,
- 1:38the floor is yours. Thank you very much. Okay,
- 1:42I'm going to start my presentation. Great. Thank
- 1:51you very much, everybody. Thank you. especially
- 1:54to Dean and to Rachel Serwin for inviting me.
- 1:58As they both mentioned, this presentation came
- 2:01about out of a conversation that I had with Rachel
- 2:04who is a 1L student here, very talented and highly
- 2:07accomplished already. We had a chat about some
- 2:10of these ideas and that led to me coming to present
- 2:13today and I'm very honored and grateful to the
- 2:16Beverly Hills Bar Association for inviting me
- 2:19today. If you had told me, you know, a decade
- 2:23ago that I would be leading this session, I would
- 2:26have been very confused and probably laugh because
- 2:29I hadn't. try meditating yet. I was working as
- 2:33a human rights lawyer in South Africa. I was
- 2:37probably born a little bit stressed and anxious,
- 2:40but doing that kind of field work where you're
- 2:43engaged face to face quite closely with some
- 2:46of the worst of human behavior, it's a lot of
- 2:49stress. And I was not somebody who was handling
- 2:54that stress well. I started to get really intense
- 2:59migraines that would last two to three days at
- 3:02a time, completely debilitating me. I couldn't
- 3:04do anything. I would get full body hives sometimes
- 3:09just from stress and would need a round of steroids
- 3:13just to be able to. kind of recover and start
- 3:16to be mobile again. I had chronic low blood pressure
- 3:20for a period, depression, anxiety, disrupted
- 3:25sleep, all of the things that many lawyers are
- 3:29familiar with. And for me, it kind of hit the
- 3:33nadir when I was suffering from stomach ulcers.
- 3:37I had a couple of rounds of stomach ulcers. One
- 3:39round wasn't enough. I had to have two rounds
- 3:41of stomach ulcers to realize that what I was
- 3:45doing and how I was handling myself in my career
- 3:48and dealing with my stress was not working. And
- 3:50it wasn't for a lack of trying. I had been going
- 3:53to therapy. I was doing really intensive exercise,
- 3:56running five days a week. I was doing tight kickboxing,
- 4:00creative pursuits, all these things. They helped,
- 4:04but they didn't really measurably make a big
- 4:06impact in reducing my stress. And so I finally
- 4:11decided to try something different and I signed
- 4:14up for a 10 -day silent meditation retreat. There
- 4:17was a center, I was living and working in Cape
- 4:20Town and there was a retreat center in the Western
- 4:22Cape that I was able to sign up for. And 10 days
- 4:26of silence with your own thoughts, all the different
- 4:30voices, very challenging, probably the most challenging
- 4:35experience in my whole life. I kind of had that
- 4:40great epiphany that people talk about when they
- 4:43really develop a meditation practice. for me
- 4:47was that a lot of the psychic pain that I was
- 4:50experiencing and that was manifesting in really
- 4:53pretty serious physical pain was something that
- 4:56I was really doing to myself. I was tying knots
- 4:59in my mind and I was making myself very tense
- 5:02and I was gripping onto negative experiences
- 5:05and I didn't have to do that anymore and I learned
- 5:08how to meditate and I stopped doing that to myself
- 5:12and after that first retreat I basically never
- 5:17had a migraine again. I haven't had a migraine
- 5:19since 2014. I haven't had full body hives since
- 5:232014. I certainly haven't had stomach ulcers
- 5:26since then. So I know this stuff works. But I
- 5:31can also say that that great epiphany that I
- 5:33have really wasn't enough on its own. Old mental
- 5:37habits really have a way of reestablishing themselves
- 5:40very easily. I had a lifetime of thinking one
- 5:43way. What I've learned over the last 10 years
- 5:46or so is that establishing a regular meditation
- 5:49practice is really important to continue to remember
- 5:52the key insights that helped me be healthier
- 5:55and happier. But what really kind of helped me
- 5:58progress in terms of my practice and my sense
- 6:01of contentment and staying less anxious and all
- 6:04of that. has been taking my practice from the
- 6:09meditation cushion and into my daily life on
- 6:12the job and at home, and to apply the insights
- 6:16that I've gained from meditation, not just to
- 6:20benefit from that when I'm actually meditating
- 6:23and on my cushion, but applying them in my daily
- 6:26life as an opportunity to practice my wisdom.
- 6:29And so that's what this presentation is going
- 6:31to be about today. This is an overview of what
- 6:37I'll discuss. I'll talk about The landscape of
- 6:42mindfulness and meditation kind of as we refer
- 6:44to it colloquially in our contemporary society,
- 6:47I'll talk about how to respond to stress and
- 6:51we'll do a little practice there. I'll then talk
- 6:54about a couple of meditation techniques that
- 6:56are very helpful for training our minds and I'll
- 7:00guide us through one technique there. And then
- 7:02I'll discuss some theories of the mind, engaging
- 7:05with some theories around how the mind works
- 7:07can be really helpful. in developing yourself
- 7:10in your practice. And then I'll shift to talking
- 7:15about cultivating good qualities, which is very
- 7:19helpful in terms of sustained happiness and developing
- 7:24our wisdom. And then I'll close with talking
- 7:26about bringing the practice and the lessons into
- 7:30our lives as lawyers and to our daily lives.
- 7:34So when we're talking about mindfulness, kind
- 7:39of in the Western colloquial sense, in the American
- 7:41colloquial sense, we're talking about certain
- 7:44Buddhist practices that have been secularized
- 7:47and popularized. Of course, there are meditative
- 7:50and contemplative techniques that don't come
- 7:52from Buddhism. There's Catholic contemplative
- 7:56practices, there's Christian ones, there's Hindu
- 7:58ones, there are many different types. But what's
- 8:01generally been popularized here in America comes
- 8:04from certain Buddhist practices. And what's been
- 8:09popularized and secularized, it's largely strands
- 8:15that are similar to things like mindfulness -based
- 8:18stress reduction. an approach to mindfulness
- 8:23and meditation that was developed by Dr. Don
- 8:26Kabat -Zinn of the University of Massachusetts
- 8:28Medical Center all the way back in 1979. He's
- 8:32a medical doctor who found that these techniques
- 8:36were really helpful with helping his patients
- 8:39who are dealing with painful chronic illnesses
- 8:42or recovering from severe injury. It helped them
- 8:46to manage their pain to reduce their reactivity
- 8:50to their physical pain and also reduce their
- 8:53emotional reactivity to the hardships of their
- 8:56illness. So he's done really wonderful work to
- 8:59develop methods that are kind of scientifically
- 9:03grounded. He's trained lots of teachers to use
- 9:07this type of technique and he's done a lot to
- 9:09reduce suffering in our society. The secularized
- 9:14mindfulness, like I said, he started to develop
- 9:17this in 1979. It came at a time when, you know,
- 9:22it was the 70s, right? It was a time when...
- 9:26Mindfulness and meditation were really seen as
- 9:29kind of far out, esoteric, hippy -dippy things.
- 9:33You know, you had to adopt all the spiritual
- 9:36trappings around these practices. It was seen
- 9:39as something for the seekers, not for the mainstream,
- 9:43not for the everyday Joe. So here's some different,
- 9:46you know, teachers from back then. In the middle
- 9:49is, in the white outfit is Ram Dass. For example,
- 9:53he came back from a trip to India. time and his
- 9:57dad said, his dad saw him in his robes and said,
- 10:00what are you some kind of yogurt, you know, instead
- 10:02of yogi, you know, it was that kind of moment.
- 10:05So the efforts to secularize and study scientifically
- 10:11mindfulness were an effort to kind of break from
- 10:14that perception of hippie dippy out there, not
- 10:17for the average person. And it's true, you don't
- 10:20need to believe in all the spiritual trappings
- 10:24around these things in order to derive a benefit.
- 10:29And the fact that these practices are being studied
- 10:33at universities across the world by doctors,
- 10:36by scientists, the benefits are measured. We've
- 10:40seen that it works for reducing anxiety, for
- 10:44helping people who are dealing with pain. it's
- 10:48so mainstream and well appreciated at this point
- 10:51that even doctors are even prescribing meditation
- 10:53and mindfulness to their patients for things
- 10:56like fibromyalgia or any number of things. And
- 11:00it's so well kind of supported and accepted by
- 11:05the mainstream because it's known to reduce stress,
- 11:09but it can improve the clarity of your thinking.
- 11:12So it also increases your productivity and improves
- 11:15clarity and the quality of decision making by
- 11:18executives. So GM, Google, Ford, all these big
- 11:23companies have serious programs that engage with
- 11:26these techniques. And now mindfulness and meditation,
- 11:30there's like a multi -billion dollar industry
- 11:33around it. If there's something that's going
- 11:35to have a multi -billion dollar industry, I think
- 11:36that's a good thing to have a lot of capital
- 11:40and interest supporting. So what is this standard,
- 11:46the secular, popularized approach to meditation
- 11:50and mindfulness that's promoted? This is a definition
- 11:56that's on the screen that I pulled from the Greater
- 11:59Good Science Center. It's a really wonderful
- 12:01repository of resources on mindfulness and meditation
- 12:04that's curated by scientists and practitioners
- 12:08and housed at UC Berkeley. And the definition
- 12:12says, which is in line with the kind of mindfulness
- 12:15-based stress reduction approach says, mindfulness
- 12:19means maintaining a moment -by -moment awareness
- 12:22of our thoughts, feelings, bodily sensations,
- 12:25and surrounding environment through a gentle,
- 12:28nurturing lens. It involves acceptance, meaning
- 12:32that we pay attention to our thoughts and feelings
- 12:34without judging them. without believing, for
- 12:38instance, that there's a right way or a wrong
- 12:41way to think or feel in a given moment. This
- 12:46is a helpful kind of standard definition and
- 12:48starting place, especially in our culture, in
- 12:52America, in the American legal profession. Our
- 12:56culture is known for overwork, for perfectionism,
- 13:00for competition. We're engaging with conflict.
- 13:02We're hyper analytical. We can't stop judging
- 13:05and analyzing. And so a definition that encourages
- 13:10us to observe and accept without interference
- 13:14what is there is helpful because we have so many
- 13:19maladaptive cognitive patterns that exist that
- 13:22without this kind of definition we might meditate
- 13:26observe what is there and then feel a lot of
- 13:30aversion for what is there feel a lot of shame
- 13:32and judgment and frustration and disgust all
- 13:36sorts of things because we shouldn't be feeling
- 13:39the way that we're feeling So observing what
- 13:45is there and accepting what is there, I think
- 13:48is helpful because it helps us increase our self
- 13:51-acceptance and kindness. And in our profession,
- 13:54in this country, with the kinds of ways that
- 13:57we tend to think about ourselves towards ourselves,
- 13:59it's a very good place to start. However, I would
- 14:03also say that it's a little bit out of sync with
- 14:06deeper teachings. For example, like I said, until
- 14:10the late 1970s, this was not really mainstream.
- 14:13It wasn't really secular. We're talking about
- 14:16a practice that for at least 2 ,500 years was
- 14:21being used as part of a spiritual philosophical
- 14:24tradition highly concerned with ethical decision
- 14:27-making, morality, and self -development. For
- 14:30millennia, these practices were used to acquire
- 14:34and develop individual wisdom in order to reduce
- 14:38individual suffering and increase our love and
- 14:41peace in our own lives, but also to reduce suffering
- 14:45and increase love and peace in our societies.
- 14:49These are wisdom practices. Looking at our own
- 14:53minds, activity honestly and accepting what is
- 14:57there, as in not denying what's there, it's a
- 15:00really important vital step, but it's only one
- 15:02of the steps in a greater practice. The definition
- 15:07of accepting and non -interfering is the standard
- 15:11interpretation, but it can also kind of sometimes
- 15:14be misinterpreted if it's not understood correctly,
- 15:17and it can lead someone to land in a funny place.
- 15:21So let me actually go back two slides. Oh, no,
- 15:24here. So for example, and I've seen this happen
- 15:29with a student before, you're meditating and
- 15:34you're observing what arises. And sometimes what
- 15:38arises could be something like, hey, you're thinking
- 15:42about a really awful memory, something that somebody
- 15:45did to you or to somebody you care about, and
- 15:49hate arises. So you just observe the hate that's
- 15:53arisen. You accept that the hate is there. It's
- 15:57okay to hate. It's not right or wrong that I'm
- 16:00feeling hate. I think with an ancient wisdom
- 16:04practice, that's not where we would be stopping
- 16:06with the practice. And again, this is because
- 16:11practicing wisdom is not about staying with unpleasant
- 16:15things, simply to accept them. It's about observing
- 16:18them to understand them for what they really
- 16:21are, so we can know how to deal with what's there,
- 16:24and then also to cultivate skillful qualities
- 16:27in their place through sustained effort. And
- 16:30to do that, we need to know what the skillful
- 16:32qualities are that we should be trying to cultivate.
- 16:35That's kind of the ethical and the moral framework
- 16:36that surrounded this ancient wisdom practice.
- 16:39And then we have to learn how to apply those
- 16:42skills beyond the time we're meditating on a
- 16:44cushion and out in the world throughout our daily
- 16:47lives at work and at home. So let's talk about
- 16:53what we're actually trying to do with mindfulness
- 16:56and meditation in a little more. So this graphic
- 16:59I adapted from a really wonderful book called
- 17:02The Mindful Law Student written by Scott Rogers,
- 17:04who is a professor and mindfulness instructor
- 17:08at University of Miami. And he wrote this really
- 17:11wonderful little textbook that I draw upon in
- 17:14the mindfulness meditation course that I teach
- 17:17at University of San Diego. And so generally
- 17:21speaking, we're existing. And then with the green
- 17:25circle, Life happens, something happens to us.
- 17:29And that experience registers in our field of
- 17:32experience, our bodies, our minds, our feelings,
- 17:35it registers. And there are times when we register,
- 17:39that experience registers and we respond with
- 17:41more resistance in the moment. And we're responding
- 17:44with more resistance. We engage in type one thinking,
- 17:48very kind of intuitive, instinctive, quick, emotional,
- 17:53reactive thinking. And then there's times where
- 17:58we're able to respond to the moment where life
- 18:00happened with less resistance and we're able
- 18:03to engage more easily in type two thinking, deliberative,
- 18:07conscientious, thoughtful decision -making around
- 18:10our thoughts, our speech and our actions. And
- 18:15so when we're doing meditation practices, what
- 18:17we're trying to do is train our minds through
- 18:21meditation to build our reservoir of self -knowledge
- 18:25and awareness. So we're building our reservoir
- 18:27so that when life happens we can observe our
- 18:30reactions and more easily respond with less resistance
- 18:34and engage in that more deliberative thoughtful
- 18:37conscientious type two thinking. Of course we're
- 18:42human beings life is going to happen and sometimes
- 18:45we're just going to be super reactive. And part
- 18:48of the practice is also being able to observe
- 18:51when that's happening so that we can know how
- 18:54to engage techniques that relax us, that calm
- 18:58us down, that affirm us, and make us feel confident
- 19:01and capable of feeling safe and then engaging
- 19:06and shifting away from that type one thinking
- 19:08into the type two thinking. So generally speaking,
- 19:12this is what we're working on. So let's talk
- 19:18about those moments of stress when the stress
- 19:21is flooding our bodies and it's just taken over.
- 19:27It's really easy to kind of have those reactions
- 19:30when you're suffering from chronically stressful
- 19:33conditions. So we should never feel bad when
- 19:36it happens. We just wanna know how to handle
- 19:38it. And it's helpful to know what's happening
- 19:41to us physiologically in those moments. So we're
- 19:45human beings. We have something called an autonomic
- 19:48nervous system that regulates a bunch of involuntary
- 19:52physiological processes in our bodies, including
- 19:54our heart rate, our blood pressure, respiration,
- 19:58digestion, et cetera. And that autonomic nervous
- 20:02system is made up of the sympathetic nervous
- 20:04system, which governs our fight or flight response.
- 20:08And then our parasympathetic nervous system,
- 20:11which governs our rest and digest, our calming
- 20:14response. And in moments of stress, so when life
- 20:20happens and a big stress trigger occurs, changes
- 20:24start to happen in our mind and body so quickly
- 20:27that we often aren't even aware of them. And
- 20:30the amygdala and the hypothalamus in our brain,
- 20:33the emotional center, kicks into gear, our sympathetic
- 20:36nervous system, even before our brain's visual
- 20:40centers have had a chance to fully process what
- 20:43is happening. So that fight or flight response
- 20:45triggers before we're even aware of what's going
- 20:47on. It's very quick. And that's really helpful,
- 20:51for example, when we need to jump out of the
- 20:53way of a moving car. It's a really important
- 20:55survival mechanism. Or, you know, back in the
- 20:58day when we're walking along and it was like
- 21:00a sudden snake or a sudden tiger. We needed to
- 21:04have that very, very quick response. Unfortunately,
- 21:08everyday life also will trigger that response
- 21:11for us, even when it's not life -threatening.
- 21:15The same physiological response can happen when
- 21:17we're flooded with stress, our hearts are palpitating,
- 21:21we're feeling very anxious. It can be quite physically
- 21:23painful and distressing. Luckily, there are breathing
- 21:28techniques we can deploy that will trigger our
- 21:32parasympathetic nervous system that rest and
- 21:34digest response. So with certain controlled slow
- 21:39breathing techniques, we can trigger our vagus
- 21:42nerve, which runs down both sides of our body.
- 21:45It's the largest nerve system in our body. And
- 21:49when we breathe slowly and deploy certain techniques,
- 21:52we trigger that vagus nerve, which sends signals
- 21:56to our heart to slow down. And it triggers that
- 22:00parasympathetic nervous system response of calming
- 22:04ourselves down. And then our amygdala, which
- 22:08had previously hijacked our brain, our emotional
- 22:11center had hijacked our brain, making it harder
- 22:13for us to engage our prefrontal cortex and our
- 22:16logical reasoning parts of ourselves. It reverses
- 22:20that and we can start thinking logically, carefully
- 22:23with reason again. Let's try a couple of... We'll
- 22:29try one technique. I'll describe two of them.
- 22:324 -7 -8 breathing. Many of you have probably
- 22:34heard of these techniques before. 4 -7 -8 breathing
- 22:38is very well studied and thought to probably
- 22:41be one of the most efficient ways of triggering
- 22:45the parasympathetic nervous system. And basically,
- 22:49you're inhaling through your nose gently for
- 22:52the count of four. gently holding for the count
- 22:54of seven, and then exhaling through your mouth
- 22:57like you're blowing through a straw. Okay, so
- 23:00I'll guide you through that for a couple of rounds.
- 23:03So you inhale through your nose to the count
- 23:05of four, two, three, four, gently hold to the
- 23:10count of seven, two, three, four, five, six,
- 23:16seven, exhale like you're blowing through a straw
- 23:19to the count of eight, three, four, five, six,
- 23:24seven, eight, again, inhale for four, two, three,
- 23:30four, hold for seven, two, three, four, five,
- 23:36six, seven, and exhale for eight, two, three,
- 23:41four, five, six, seven, eight. This technique
- 23:46is really helpful when you've been triggered
- 23:48by stress. Someone could have been rude to you
- 23:52in a board meeting or they're coming for you.
- 23:54The judge is a jerk, you know, anything. It's
- 23:58also really helpful when you can't sleep at night
- 24:01and your mind is running. This is very common
- 24:03for lawyers. I've seen this in survey results
- 24:06about lawyers' mental health. I'll do this when
- 24:09I can't sleep at night because my mind is running.
- 24:12After a few minutes. I'm always asleep. It's
- 24:15very helpful. Box breathing is similar, but you're
- 24:18doing things to the count of four. You're inhaling
- 24:20for the count of four, holding for the count
- 24:22of four, exhaling for the count of four, and
- 24:26holding for the count of four. I prefer four,
- 24:30seven, eight, but that's just me. Everybody is
- 24:32different. So now let's talk about meditation
- 24:39techniques. So with mindfulness meditation, we're
- 24:44training our minds to be able to focus and pay
- 24:46attention to what we want our minds to pay attention
- 24:50to in order to calmly observe what is there without
- 24:53judgment, to then be able to direct our mind
- 24:57in ways that are more discerning and discerning
- 25:01as in wiser and healthier. It's really critical
- 25:06to train your mind to focus and pay attention
- 25:08to what you want it to in order to be able to
- 25:11cultivate your attention awareness to build that
- 25:14reservoir of attention and awareness as I talked
- 25:17about before. You're developing a muscle. It's
- 25:20not the natural way of kind of existing in the
- 25:23world. So techniques that sharpen your focus
- 25:26will often ask you to train your mind on something
- 25:29very specific. And I like focusing on the breath.
- 25:34The breath is really helpful because it's a biological
- 25:36function that is always with you if you're alive.
- 25:40You always have to be breathing if you're alive.
- 25:42And if you're awake and conscious, you can control
- 25:46it. It's a really helpful anchor in that way.
- 25:50So the best way to learn is through direct experience.
- 25:53So I'm going to guide you through a brief practice.
- 26:00So. Go ahead and sit in a way that's very comfortable
- 26:03to you, with your back and your neck straight
- 26:07in alignment. You want to be relaxed, but you
- 26:12want to have enough tension to keep yourself
- 26:14alert. You're not trying to fall asleep. So relax
- 26:19yourself, sit comfortably, but keep just enough
- 26:22tension to keep yourself alert. And now gently
- 26:26close your eyes, or if you prefer, you may lower
- 26:29your gaze. It can help to take off your glasses
- 26:34if you wear those. And now do some grounding
- 26:40breaths. You can do some 478 breathing or box
- 26:45breathing just to ground yourself and prepare
- 26:49your mind and your body for practice. So settle
- 27:24into breathing through your nose and just breathe
- 27:31in and out of your nose in a way that's comfortable
- 27:34to you, that feels natural and comfortable to
- 27:39you. You don't need to force a certain way of
- 27:45breathing. Your breath is your anchor and your
- 27:51refuge. So allow yourself to breathe in a way
- 27:56that feels comfortable to you at this time. And
- 28:04if you stop feeling comfortable, change the way
- 28:06you're breathing. Faster, slower, deeper or shallower.
- 28:14Make yourself comfortable with your breath. Because
- 28:17if you're comfortable, then you'll want to stay
- 28:19with the meditation. Now, train your focus on
- 28:27your breath and observe yourself breathing, observe
- 28:32your breath in and out of your nose, all the
- 28:38way in and all the way out. Or if you prefer,
- 28:44you may observe the rising and falling of your
- 28:47chest or your belly. Just pick a spot. and train
- 28:52your attention there. And observe your breath
- 28:57all the way in and all the way out. And when
- 29:04your mind wanders, without frustration, without
- 29:11chastising yourself, just bring your attention
- 29:15back to your breath. When your mind wanders again,
- 29:23gently let go of the thought and train your attention
- 29:28back on your breath. Do this again and again.
- 29:34We'll do this for a couple of minutes. And back
- 31:37to the talk. What we learned from this type of
- 31:44focused attention and concentration technique
- 31:47is how our minds are constantly wandering. That's
- 31:54why you shouldn't feel bad if your mind is wandering.
- 31:57It wanders, it likes to wander. And sometimes
- 32:01it's just a second or two before we're distracted.
- 32:05Our thoughts are constantly percolating. We're
- 32:08wandering. Our emotions are bubbling. We're in
- 32:11the past. We're perseverating about the future.
- 32:15Our mind is anywhere but the here and now. It
- 32:18really resists being here and now. And this technique
- 32:23gives us the chance to directly experience just
- 32:26how transient and fickle our thoughts and feelings
- 32:28are. What's happening with our thoughts and our
- 32:33feelings at the start of a meditation? Often
- 32:36what's happening at the end? Our thoughts are
- 32:40jumping from object to object to object. An emotion
- 32:44is punching its way to the foreground of our
- 32:46mind. And then before we realize it, it's faded
- 32:49away and we're thinking about something totally
- 32:51different. So through practice, we can directly
- 32:55observe this fickleness. and this impermanence,
- 32:59how changing our thoughts and feelings always
- 33:01are, which gives us the insight to know that
- 33:05we don't have to cling to or identify to thoughts
- 33:09and feelings that are just bubbling up and passing
- 33:11away and constantly changing. They're so impermanent.
- 33:16So instead of clinging to the thought or feeling
- 33:19and identifying with it, you can just let it
- 33:22pass and just come back to your breath. There
- 33:26are other techniques, which I'll just briefly
- 33:29describe, but I won't guide us through. There
- 33:32are many different ways to do mindfulness meditation.
- 33:35What they all have in common is that you're dealing
- 33:38with the reality of your mind as it really is.
- 33:41You're not doing mantras or visualization. You're
- 33:46observing your mind in its natural state. And
- 33:51so open monitoring, is a practice where you are
- 33:55observing sounds. You're mapping the sounds in
- 33:59your environment. You can close your eyes and
- 34:01do grounded breaths and then map the sounds in
- 34:04front of you as far as you can sense them behind
- 34:07you, to your left, to your right, above you and
- 34:12below you. To map the sounds in your environment
- 34:16as far as you can perceive them. And when you're
- 34:19distracted, Bring your attention back to your
- 34:22breath, ground yourself, and then expand your
- 34:25awareness with the sounds again. There's also
- 34:29body scanning, which some people really like.
- 34:32Some people really struggle to train their attention
- 34:34on one fixed thing, and it gives you a chance
- 34:37to move your attention throughout your body.
- 34:40You're working with the sensations that are in
- 34:43your body. Could be really ordinary sensations
- 34:46like the touch of your sock or your shoe or the
- 34:49chair. But it could also just be the sensations
- 34:53that our body produces that are tied to certain
- 34:56thoughts and feelings that we have. We have an
- 34:58experience, sometimes a big experience, perhaps
- 35:01a traumatic experience. Certain sensations in
- 35:04our bodies arise in us. Our mind tells a story
- 35:08about what that sensation means. But very rarely
- 35:12is that sensation indicative of that same experience
- 35:15happening again. So when we Just observe our
- 35:19body sensations without reacting, without judgment.
- 35:23The good feelings, the bad feelings, the neutral
- 35:26feelings. We're training our minds to change
- 35:30the way we orient to what our mind says those
- 35:33feelings mean. We're just observing reality as
- 35:35it is by observing our body sensations. And you
- 35:39can start at the tips of your toes and map your
- 35:42sensations on your body a few inches at a time,
- 35:45covering your entire body. all the way up to
- 35:47the top of your head, and you just cycle that
- 35:50way. And then there's open awareness, which is
- 35:54more of a Tibetan -style technique. Tibet, up
- 35:57in the Himalayas, really big vistas, huge skies,
- 36:01their techniques are often tied to a sense of
- 36:05awe. And so open awareness is a little more subtle.
- 36:09You're just... Coming to the present moment and
- 36:14you're observing and being aware of the present
- 36:16moment and then trying to expand the space between
- 36:20your thoughts. So you're just aware of what's
- 36:24happening in the present moment. You're trying
- 36:26to expand the space between your thoughts. It's
- 36:28definitely subtle, but sometimes it can be very
- 36:32helpful. And I'm happy to share instructions
- 36:34for these different techniques later on as well.
- 36:41So a natural next thought then, if we're observing
- 36:44our mind and how much it jumps from things to
- 36:49things all the time, is what is that about? Why
- 36:53do our minds work like that? And it can be helpful
- 36:57to engage with some theory about how the mind
- 37:00works, talking about that 2 ,500 year old ancient
- 37:03wisdom practice that was part of the practice.
- 37:06In Buddhism, there are theories about how the
- 37:10mind works and what it means to be you. And I'm
- 37:15not a Buddhist scholar. I really am not qualified
- 37:17to speak deeply about any of this, but I'll just
- 37:19do a very brief summary. The general idea is
- 37:22that there's not a single stable you. We're made
- 37:27up of different aggregates, different processes
- 37:30that are always functioning separately. For example,
- 37:34our physical experience, our emotions. though
- 37:37our perceptions, the way we form opinions and
- 37:40judgments, our consciousness, these are all distinct
- 37:44processes that are operating and interrelated
- 37:49and constantly changing but collectively create
- 37:53this feeling of being you. There are also contemporary
- 37:58working theories about how the mind works. A
- 38:01lot of advances in neuroscience and philosophy
- 38:04and evolutionary psychology, but, you know, they're
- 38:08theories of the mind. And one that I find very
- 38:11helpful is described by Robert Wright, a science
- 38:14writer in his book, Why Buddhism is True, and
- 38:16it's the modular theory of the mind. It's a theory
- 38:20from evolutionary psychology and also from philosophy.
- 38:25And the basic idea is that our bodies and minds
- 38:28were not designed as a perfect system by an engineer.
- 38:33But rather, our minds evolved naturally over
- 38:36time to fit our environments. For example, we
- 38:40developed a mate acquisition module at some point
- 38:43along the evolutionary path. We developed a cheater
- 38:46detection module because Fairness and rules are
- 38:52really important in more complicated societies.
- 38:56We developed a snake detection module, really
- 39:00important for survival. So we have this system
- 39:03of messy modules inside of us that are basically
- 39:08a loose collection of overlapping in ourselves.
- 39:11And some of them periodically take over the driver's
- 39:14seat, or many of them are operating simultaneously.
- 39:18Another way of thinking about the modular theory
- 39:21of the mind is that our minds are full of different
- 39:23sub -personalities. With meditation, we're becoming
- 39:27familiar with the inner array of personalities
- 39:30and how to deal with them. Learning them through
- 39:34observation results in them having less and less
- 39:37power over you. Through meditation, we can start
- 39:44to see certain emotions trigger when one of these
- 39:47modules into action. For example, someone cuts
- 39:51in front of you in line at the grocery store.
- 39:54Oh my goodness, cheater detection module goes
- 39:57into overdrive. What a jerk and selfish person
- 40:00that is. How could they be doing this? Very emotionally
- 40:04reacted. Or we see our boyfriend talking to someone
- 40:10very good looking, so jealous, make acquisition
- 40:14modules activated. At those times, we know we're
- 40:18in an emotional state and we should wait before
- 40:21we act further on any of those thoughts and feelings.
- 40:25Another idea that can be helpful is the default
- 40:29mode network. And this is the idea that in our
- 40:33minds, we have a system of connected brain areas
- 40:36that show increased activity when we're not really
- 40:39engaged in something that demands our focus.
- 40:42It's basically like entering an autopilot. And
- 40:45we start to engage in mind wandering and rumination
- 40:48and a lot of self -referential thinking. Why
- 40:51did I do that stupid thing earlier? What's going
- 40:53to happen to me with this thing that I don't
- 40:55know about? Or, you know, what did I do in the
- 40:58past that was wrong? we start mauling over ourselves
- 41:01with increasing anxiety. And it's a state of
- 41:06kind of autopilot and mind -wandering that we're
- 41:08engaging in for something like half of our waking
- 41:10life. And it's very highly correlated with unhappiness
- 41:14and anxiousness. So when we lack present moment
- 41:18awareness, our default mode network has kicked
- 41:21in. So with meditation, we're training our minds
- 41:25to be aware. And I really like this quote from
- 41:28Sam Harris. He says, the habit of spending nearly
- 41:32every waking moment lost in thought leaves us
- 41:35at the mercy of whatever our thoughts are. Meditation
- 41:38is a way of breaking the spell. In other words,
- 41:42it's a way of reducing the activity of our default
- 41:45mode network. So like I said, we're learning
- 41:51to observe what's actually happening. And we're
- 41:55observing what's happening inside ourselves without
- 41:57judgment, and then dealing with what's in our
- 42:00mind through disarrayment. So that's the part
- 42:04where we're taming our mind, where we're taming
- 42:06those different messy modules, overlapping systems
- 42:09of selves inside of ourselves. And we don't have
- 42:13to rest in a harmful thought or feeling state.
- 42:16We can try to disarm those states. We contain
- 42:19them. And it's also helpful to know that sometimes
- 42:24Some of those cells that are activated are a
- 42:28lot more obnoxious than others. And you might
- 42:31need to deploy a very firm technique with them
- 42:33sometimes. For example, a very obnoxious board
- 42:38member who won't stop taking up all the oxygen
- 42:40in the room. We all know that we have that overwhelming
- 42:44thought that dominates our minds sometimes, and
- 42:46we've all met that person. Well, you can also...
- 42:50Use a firm hand to tame that voice, bang the
- 42:55gavel, bring order to the court, ask that unruly
- 42:59voice to quiet down, and invite someone wiser
- 43:03to speak instead. So you don't just have to rest
- 43:06with what is there. Next, I'll shift to talking
- 43:13about cultivating good qualities in our minds.
- 43:16So we talked about we're trying to train our
- 43:17minds to focus. to develop awareness, calmly
- 43:21observe its activities, accept what is there,
- 43:24and then deal with what is there in discerning
- 43:26ways. And then to cultivate good and skillful
- 43:29qualities in their place. What are those good
- 43:31and skillful qualities that we're trying to cultivate?
- 43:34Again, I'm gonna reach back to the ancient wisdom
- 43:37practice. In Buddhism, there's something called
- 43:41the Brahma Viharas, which are the heightened
- 43:44emotional mental states. sometimes called the
- 43:48four immeasurables, the four infinite minds,
- 43:51the sublime states. It all depends on the specific
- 43:54tradition. But basically these states are the
- 43:59ways that a fully awakened person, a wise person
- 44:02relates to others and to themselves. Regular
- 44:07persistent meditation practice supports the development
- 44:10of these states in ourselves. And the increased
- 44:15presence of these states in ourself are also
- 44:18yardsticks for our progress on our path. How
- 44:20do we know the meditation is working? Well, we're
- 44:23feeling more of these positive skillful emotions.
- 44:30They're also universal virtues, which I find
- 44:34helpful to remember. In addition to them being
- 44:39yardsticks of our progress, There are ways to
- 44:42purposely invoke them through meditation techniques
- 44:45that build on the basic foundation of having
- 44:48a kind disposition in all of our thoughts, words,
- 44:51and deeds as we relate to ourselves and to others.
- 44:55So it's a really important component of the practice.
- 44:58And it's important because when we're increasingly
- 45:01governed by these, you know, wise states, we
- 45:06tend to harbor less resentment, tension, and
- 45:09irritability in our minds. and tension, irritability,
- 45:14and resentment have a lot of negative reverberations
- 45:17which disturb our minds and make it difficult
- 45:20to meditate. It also, these kind of tension,
- 45:26irritation, and resentment throws off our mental
- 45:28balance and results in us behaving towards ourselves
- 45:32and towards others in ways that are stress -reducing,
- 45:35that are harmful. So we want to cultivate these
- 45:41better mental states because they're helpful
- 45:43to ourselves, but we also are creating less stress
- 45:46in the world. So it's helpful to look at the
- 45:50definitions of these and there's kind of tradition
- 45:54of looking at their opposites as well as their
- 45:57near enemies to get a better sense of what they
- 45:59really mean. So we'll start with equanimity because
- 46:02I think this one's really important. Equanimity
- 46:06is basically an even -minded mental state toward
- 46:09all experiences, whether they're pleasant, unpleasant,
- 46:13or neutral. It's about having a balanced mind
- 46:18and being open and even -minded. And you cultivate
- 46:23this mental state through formal practice. And
- 46:28also, it's something that you try to deploy throughout
- 46:31your life in your daily activities. And it's
- 46:34also an enduring state That's the end result
- 46:37of mindfulness and meditation practice. So the
- 46:41opposite of equanimity is essentially being super
- 46:44emotionally reactive. It's being spiraling. It's
- 46:48clinging or rejecting with a lot of strength
- 46:51to what's going on around you and to you. Its
- 46:56near enemy is indifference. Sometimes people
- 46:59hear equanimity or being a quantumist, and they
- 47:02think it's about being detached and not caring.
- 47:05It's absolutely not that. It's about maintaining
- 47:09your inner balance in the face of something difficult
- 47:12so that you can act on your care as effectively
- 47:16as possible. It's about taking care of yourself
- 47:20and your emotional balance in the face of overwhelming
- 47:23needs and suffering that exists in the world
- 47:25and that we generally don't have a lot of control
- 47:27over. The Dalai Lama said, With equanimity, you
- 47:32can deal with situations like calm and reason
- 47:35while keeping your inner happiness. So, how do
- 47:41we respond with equanimity to something? We use
- 47:44our mindfulness. For example, we engage in cognitive
- 47:50reframing exercises. This is using the discernment
- 47:53and the taming. We can observe our minds something
- 47:59unwanted, unpleasant, something unhappy happens
- 48:03to us. And we observe our minds, start to weave
- 48:07a narrative around this unwanted experience.
- 48:10We very quickly start to identify with the unpleasant
- 48:13emotions and thoughts that are triggered by making
- 48:16what happened to us very personal. Our egos are
- 48:19triggered and fluffed up. So. This unpleasant
- 48:23thing happens and then we start to double and
- 48:25triple down on this initial unpleasant thing
- 48:28with blame, accusations, resentment, anger. So
- 48:33-and -so did this to me because whatever reason
- 48:36you want to give. We start to tell a story about
- 48:38it and that initial unwanted and unpleasant experience
- 48:43starts to intensify and all of a sudden you're
- 48:45really reactive and you're off balance. So one
- 48:50really important way of reframing when we're
- 48:53feeling that way and to invite equanimity in
- 48:55ourselves is to diminish the significance of
- 48:59the narrative. Stop the storytelling. Just deal
- 49:02with what happened for what it is without layering
- 49:05on top a lot of extra meaning and identification
- 49:10with it. Another technique that can be helpful
- 49:15is called noting. And that's something you can
- 49:18do when you're meditating as well, when you're
- 49:20doing that focused attention meditation. And
- 49:23it's another way to tame the selves that come
- 49:25up by naming them. So for example, you could
- 49:33be meditating and anger arises. Normally we go,
- 49:39I am angry. We immediately identify with it and
- 49:43it becomes bigger. Instead, When you observe
- 49:47that, that feeling come up, you just observe
- 49:50that it is there without identifying with it.
- 49:52You just say, here is anger. And you can do that
- 49:56with any of the states that come up. Here is
- 49:59frustration. Ah, shame has arisen. Here is jealousy.
- 50:05Here is impatience. And that is a way to de -identify
- 50:10with the experience, create some space. It is
- 50:13no longer you. So you can let it go and come
- 50:17back to being in a balanced state. A really very
- 50:22well known and accomplished meditation teacher
- 50:25in the US is Joseph Goldstein. He wrote this
- 50:29book of practice notes that I read and it really
- 50:32helped me kind of connect the dots and realize
- 50:35how much effort is actually involved to try to
- 50:37develop your wisdom. And one of his two to three
- 50:41page notes was he called Judgment 500. And he
- 50:47was describing a day or two in his life when
- 50:51he was in a really judgy space. So -and -so closed
- 50:55the door really loudly when I was trying to meditate.
- 50:58So -and -so was taking so much salad at the salad
- 51:01bar that there was almost none left for me. So
- 51:03-and -so was breathing with her mouth, and it
- 51:05was really annoying. All the little annoyances
- 51:08that come up that he was creating judgments around.
- 51:12And this is a great meditation teacher, so he
- 51:14was like, why am I doing this? And he just started
- 51:17to count the judgments that he was engaging in.
- 51:20Judgment one, judgment two. Before he knew it,
- 51:24he reached judgment 500 and he burst out laughing
- 51:27because that's ridiculous and he could let go
- 51:29of that part and just let, you know, let those
- 51:32annoying things go. It doesn't matter. Another
- 51:35technique he described was the sky is blue. And
- 51:39basically, this was saying that whatever's happening
- 51:44is really ordinary. Suffering, annoyance, even
- 51:48injustice. It's as old as humankind. It doesn't
- 51:53mean that it's okay, but it doesn't mean that
- 51:56it's special. It's just normal. So he would say
- 52:01so -and -so, something, something happened, someone
- 52:03cut me off on the road, and the sky is blue.
- 52:07You can pick whatever phrase you like. And then
- 52:10another technique is the view from the outside.
- 52:13You try to step outside and like, and observe
- 52:16your situation like you're a neutral third party.
- 52:19A neutral third party can look at what's happening
- 52:21without emotion and see exactly what needs to
- 52:24happen and then just act. So that's a very helpful
- 52:27technique. How do you know if you're developing
- 52:30in your equanimity? There's a temporal signature.
- 52:34How fast do you get back to baseline? Again,
- 52:38we're human. It's not about having a reaction.
- 52:41It's about how quickly can you return to your
- 52:43baseline? So. That's very helpful to know as
- 52:47you're working on your practice. There are three
- 52:52other immeasurable kind of heightened feelings
- 52:55which I'll just go through very quickly. One
- 52:57is called loving kindness or loving friendliness.
- 53:01And it's basically the emotion state of wishing
- 53:04well for oneself and for all beings based on
- 53:08the recognition that you know that all beings,
- 53:11all of us wish to be happy. It's not just us,
- 53:16everyone shares this in common. So it's heartfelt
- 53:20well -wishing, knowing that this is a universal
- 53:22truth, and it's opposite is hatred, and its near
- 53:28enemy is kind of conditional clingy love. This
- 53:31is open, boundless well -wishing. Another one
- 53:37is compassion. And that's natural well -wishing
- 53:40that your own suffering and everybody's suffering
- 53:43will cease again out of the recognition that
- 53:46all of us share the desire to live life free
- 53:51from misery and free from suffering. Its opposite
- 53:55is cruelty and its near enemy is pity because
- 53:58pity has a way of distancing the person who is
- 54:01suffering from us or saying that they are different.
- 54:04It is a recognition of this shared universal
- 54:07truth that all of us wish to be free from suffering.
- 54:11And then there's sympathetic joy. And this is
- 54:15the natural appreciation of others' good fortunes,
- 54:19joy, good qualities, and abilities. Its opposite
- 54:23is envy and jealousy. And it's near enemy is
- 54:28often described as basically only rejoicing in
- 54:31somebody's material successes or material good
- 54:33fortune. And it's more complete when we feel
- 54:38joyful and appreciative of somebody who's wise
- 54:41and behaving well with good qualities. Because
- 54:44we know that when you're behaving wisely with
- 54:47more equanimity, with more calmness, with more
- 54:49care, you're going to feel better. And so you're
- 54:53happy for that person because you know they're
- 54:55going to be feeling good. So these are feeling
- 55:01states that provide positive reinforcement as
- 55:03we're developing our mindfulness and meditation
- 55:05practices. And they can give us stronger confidence,
- 55:09awareness, and concentration. And all of them
- 55:15have a lot to do with, again, shared experience
- 55:18and our deep interconnection. All of us share
- 55:22you know, the desire to be happy, to be free
- 55:25from suffering, to behave wisely, to be happy
- 55:29in a way that is lasting. And so there are techniques
- 55:34we can use to also strengthen these feeling states
- 55:38in ourselves. So this is the last technique I'm
- 55:40going to guide us through. And it's often colloquially
- 55:43called Metta in the kind of mindfulness and meditation
- 55:46world. Metta is the Pali word for for loving
- 55:52kindness, but it's also often taught around the
- 55:58feeling of compassion, which has actually a different
- 56:00Pali word, but metta kind of is used to describe
- 56:03the umbrella term for those four really heightened
- 56:07virtuous feeling states. And the basic idea of
- 56:11the practice is to repeat set phrases and invoke
- 56:14these feeling states towards ourselves and then
- 56:17radiate them out towards our loved ones and to
- 56:19people we know and care about. and then out towards
- 56:22people who are more neutral, to people who are
- 56:25perhaps difficult for us, and then to everybody
- 56:27and all beings everywhere. So I'm going to use
- 56:32instructions that are modified and similar to
- 56:36what Jack Formfield teaches, another great meditation
- 56:38teacher. And he adapted the instructions to kind
- 56:43of... better suit that American psychology, which
- 56:46can often be really hard towards ourselves. Sometimes
- 56:49it's really hard for us to start with well wishes
- 56:52towards ourselves. So again, relax, make sure
- 56:58you're feeling comfortable. With this technique,
- 57:01it's really important that you sit comfortably
- 57:04and make yourself feel good in your body. Relax,
- 57:07release tension, stretch, change your posture,
- 57:11et cetera. And now settle down in a pose that
- 57:17feels comfortable and full of ease for you. Gently
- 57:22close your eyes and do some grounded breathing.
- 57:31Settle yourself down. And now think of someone
- 57:38you care about and love a great deal. Someone
- 57:43you love very naturally, very easily. And let
- 57:49natural phrases of good wishes come to your mind
- 57:52and your heart. Some traditional phrases are,
- 57:59may you be safe, may you be healthy, may you
- 58:04be happy and live in ease, may you be peaceful.
- 58:12all the natural good wishes. And now think of
- 58:20a second person you care about with great ease,
- 58:24very naturally. It's so easy for you to love
- 58:26this person. Someone you care about. And extend
- 58:33the same good wishes and intentions toward them.
- 58:38May you be safe. May you be healthy and happy.
- 58:43May you be peaceful. May you live in ease. And
- 58:51now imagine these two people whom you love, who
- 58:57you love dearly so easily, turn to you and offer
- 59:04you their loving kindness. You can picture how
- 59:09they look at you with concern and love and say
- 59:13to you, may you be peaceful, may be happy and
- 59:18healthy, may be free from suffering and live
- 59:24in ease. Absorb their good wishes and turn them
- 59:34towards yourself. Some people find it helps to
- 59:40place their hand on their heart and say the phrases
- 59:45to yourself. May I be safe. May I be healthy.
- 59:52May I be happy and live in ease. May I be free
- 59:55from suffering. May I be peaceful. And now extend
- 1:00:03these well wishes. that you've cultivated in
- 1:00:07yourself, outwards, to your friends, your colleagues,
- 1:00:15out to neutral people, strangers you pass on
- 1:00:18the road, or who share your building who you
- 1:00:21don't really know. May they be peaceful. May
- 1:00:28they be healthy and happy. May they be free from
- 1:00:32suffering. May they live in ease. And if you're
- 1:00:38up to it, if it comes naturally to you, bring
- 1:00:43someone who is difficult into your mind, maybe
- 1:00:45a little challenging. Don't go straight away
- 1:00:50for someone who's really harmed you unless it's
- 1:00:53coming to you naturally right now. Don't force
- 1:00:58it. But if you're up for it, extend that person
- 1:01:02your good wishes. May they be safe. May they
- 1:01:07be happy and healthy and live in ease. And now,
- 1:01:15think of yourself as a beacon spreading the light
- 1:01:18of loving friendship, goodwill, and compassion
- 1:01:20in all directions. Out as far as the world extends,
- 1:01:27out in all directions. May all beings, may all
- 1:01:33beings near and far, May all beings be peaceful
- 1:01:38and happy and free from suffering. May all beings
- 1:01:45live in ease and feel joy. So that's the Metta
- 1:01:53practice and you can do that any time of the
- 1:01:56day. You can do that before you meditate and
- 1:02:00to close your meditation. It really helps. You
- 1:02:04can do that before you go to sleep. You can also
- 1:02:07try to practice it when something agitated happens,
- 1:02:10agitating happens to you. It's often something
- 1:02:14that my students say is the most helpful to them
- 1:02:17as they're developing their practice. So, bringing
- 1:02:30the practice into our lives as lawyers and into
- 1:02:33our everyday lives. Cultivating a balanced state
- 1:02:36of mind through mindfulness meditation enables
- 1:02:40us basically to create a reflective mental space
- 1:02:43so that we can go from blind reactivity to our
- 1:02:46experiences to conscientious decision making,
- 1:02:50choosing a thoughtful response in our thoughts,
- 1:02:52our speech and our actions, as opposed to going
- 1:02:56with whatever our big initial reaction is. So
- 1:02:59again, engaging in that type two thinking. And
- 1:03:02we can use these skills in our work as lawyers.
- 1:03:05For example, well number one, well actually before
- 1:03:10that, let me go back. So in our skills as lawyers,
- 1:03:14so number one, one really helpful way to draw
- 1:03:19on our mindfulness is to increase our facility
- 1:03:22to actively and deeply listen to others. For
- 1:03:25example, to be mindful of what our minds are
- 1:03:30doing when we're attempting to listen to a client
- 1:03:33or a colleague. We stay present in the moment
- 1:03:39and actually hear what the other person is saying,
- 1:03:42instead of judging, analyzing, assuming, jumping
- 1:03:45to conclusions, or just waiting to speak. You
- 1:03:50can use that breathing technique, the focused
- 1:03:52attention, and anchor your mind on your breath.
- 1:03:56And actually giving your mind that anchor is
- 1:03:58just enough distraction to keep yourself focused
- 1:04:01and actually paying attention. Observe your breath
- 1:04:06and listen and notice if your mind starts to
- 1:04:09wander to somewhere else and then just bring
- 1:04:11it back again and listen. This is a really important
- 1:04:15way of demonstrating care and compassion because
- 1:04:18you're actually able to hear what the person
- 1:04:20is saying and attend to what is most important
- 1:04:23to them. Another way to deploy these techniques
- 1:04:27is when we're in the midst of a contentious exchange
- 1:04:30or a charged negotiation or something similarly
- 1:04:32distressing. We can practice equanimity by depersonalizing
- 1:04:38the experience. View yourself from the outside,
- 1:04:41a third party watching the interaction. Observe
- 1:04:45your mind and notice when it's being triggered,
- 1:04:48when your ego has been fluffed up and trying
- 1:04:51to protect yourself. Take a pause if you need
- 1:04:54to so you can stop and understand why you're
- 1:04:57triggered. Try to view it objectively and then
- 1:05:00respond purposely. You can also draw on those
- 1:05:06four heightened feeling states, those four virtues
- 1:05:09that I talked about when you're interacting with
- 1:05:11others. For example, through direct observation
- 1:05:15of our own minds, we've seen how messy and untamed
- 1:05:18our minds actually are. The stress and tension
- 1:05:22we create in our own minds, we can start to observe
- 1:05:26that. And we can see how we start listening to
- 1:05:31the narratives about why so -and -so is a terrible
- 1:05:33person because they did this and they did that.
- 1:05:36Before we know it, we're not acting with wisdom,
- 1:05:39we're being very reactive. And we've experienced
- 1:05:42the same process in ourselves. And so we know
- 1:05:46that other people are experiencing these same
- 1:05:49difficult, stressful, tension -building, messy,
- 1:05:54reactive kind of blind mental states. And so
- 1:05:57we can have compassion for somebody in those
- 1:05:59moments instead of getting angry at them. We
- 1:06:02can see they're having a tough moment and we
- 1:06:05can wish for them to feel better and to be able
- 1:06:08to behave more wisely. And our own wise behavior
- 1:06:11in those moments can encourage that wise behavior
- 1:06:14in others. So bringing these practices into our
- 1:06:18lives as lawyers. Daily practice is really important.
- 1:06:23You're training that mental muscle. It's not
- 1:06:27something that you'll naturally just do on your
- 1:06:29own. We'll just naturally inter autopilot, right?
- 1:06:33So we need to engage in daily practice. And I
- 1:06:35think, you know, 15, 20 minutes at least a day
- 1:06:37is really important. And to do that as regularly
- 1:06:40as possible in the morning or in the evening
- 1:06:43or in the middle of the day, or, you know, find
- 1:06:47moments throughout the day. Calm yourself in
- 1:06:51moments of stress. Understand what's happening
- 1:06:54to you and deploy the techniques to trigger your
- 1:06:59parasympathetic nervous system and calm yourself
- 1:07:01down. Soothe yourself in those moments of stress.
- 1:07:06Cognitive reframing. Tame your mind. Don't just
- 1:07:09observe what is there. Tame it and make it wiser.
- 1:07:15And then cultivate good qualities, honor our
- 1:07:17shared humanity and interconnectedness. We all
- 1:07:20suffer in the same way and we all wish to be
- 1:07:23happy and joyful and healthy and balanced in
- 1:07:26the same way. Cultivate these good skillful qualities.
- 1:07:31And then again, bring this into your daily activities.
- 1:07:33So there's active listening, mindfulness through
- 1:07:36tough interactions, trying to increase that time
- 1:07:42between your reaction and your response. And
- 1:07:45you can do Short little mindfulness breaks out
- 1:07:48the day. If I've had an annoying meeting or I
- 1:07:50can't quite focus on an email that I really need
- 1:07:52to understand properly or a case I need to understand
- 1:07:55properly, I'll stop and I'll just engage in a
- 1:07:59short practice. And if you're lucky enough to
- 1:08:02have colleagues also meditate, it's really helpful
- 1:08:04to do this together. I have a few colleagues
- 1:08:06here at the law school who like to meditate and,
- 1:08:09you know, we'll get together every so often and
- 1:08:11try to meditate for 30 minutes on a lunch break.
- 1:08:13It's really powerful way to strengthen your practice.
- 1:08:18Just closing thoughts. Ultimately, the punchline
- 1:08:22is applying these techniques and skills to lawyering
- 1:08:26is really about applying them in our lives. We
- 1:08:29dedicate time to meditate each day, like I said,
- 1:08:31and we use normal mundane life, everyday challenges,
- 1:08:37opportunities to strengthen our skills for practical
- 1:08:40wisdom. In my job as Dean of Students, my goal
- 1:08:45is to Practice every day and to treat each interaction
- 1:08:49I have with a student as an opportunity to develop
- 1:08:52my wisdom. To show up with care and concern and
- 1:08:56love and compassion in my heart and to listen
- 1:08:59and try to hear what they really need and then
- 1:09:02respond to the real needs that are being expressed.
- 1:09:07The simple act of being present, of being mindful,
- 1:09:10listening attentively. and responding with care
- 1:09:13and concern can be really encouraging to the
- 1:09:15person you're talking to and really helpful to
- 1:09:18yourself. You feel better. And my goal is a student
- 1:09:23comes in and distress, can I help them? And can
- 1:09:26I help them leave with a smile? And if not, if
- 1:09:29they're a really difficult person or it's a really
- 1:09:30difficult interaction, can I protect my own internal
- 1:09:34balance and happiness? I believe meditation and
- 1:09:37mindfulness can change our profession as well.
- 1:09:40Cultural transformation occurs in many ways,
- 1:09:43but one way it occurs is person by person, interaction
- 1:09:47by interaction. Each of us strengthening our
- 1:09:49minds and our awareness, cultivating our kindness,
- 1:09:52our equanimity, our compassion. The profession
- 1:09:55can also increasingly reflect these good qualities.
- 1:10:00And I think any occupation can be used from the
- 1:10:04custodian in our building to the highest office.
- 1:10:07Any occupation can be used to connect with deep
- 1:10:13internal meaning and provide us with daily practice
- 1:10:16to develop in our own insight and wisdom and
- 1:10:19to grow our own sense of freedom and to practice
- 1:10:22lightness and cultivate lightness and joy in
- 1:10:24our lives. Every job can be a training ground
- 1:10:27for this and every person can be one of our teachers
- 1:10:33on this path. And I think more than many other
- 1:10:39occupations Being a lawyer is rife with lots
- 1:10:43of opportunities. People are coming to us in
- 1:10:45moments of distress. We're doing high pressure
- 1:10:48work. We're walking alongside others and helping
- 1:10:51them make really big decisions. Our occupation
- 1:10:54is rife and rich with opportunities to train
- 1:10:57ourselves and to cultivate good and to try to
- 1:11:03understand what's really happening with the other
- 1:11:06person that we're working with and to be responsive
- 1:11:09with wisdom and kindness and to honor our own
- 1:11:13humanity in that way and to honor the humanity
- 1:11:17of the person we're interacting with. So thank
- 1:11:20you very much. I also have some resources that
- 1:11:24are at the end of the slide that's been circulated
- 1:11:26that I drew upon for this presentation. I'm happy
- 1:11:30to take, and I'm also happy if anyone wants to
- 1:11:33email me, I'm happy to field questions now or
- 1:11:36later on. Thank you very much, Emily. I don't
- 1:11:48know if I'm seeing the Q &A properly, but it
- 1:11:51looks like we haven't had any unanswered questions
- 1:11:56that haven't been handled by the BHBA moderator.
- 1:12:01So if anyone has any that they'd like to share,
- 1:12:07I have a question for you. Yes. and I may have
- 1:12:11missed it if you pointed any out. We're lawyers,
- 1:12:15we're analytical, we like to read. Are there
- 1:12:19any works that you could suggest as an entree
- 1:12:24point? I know for myself, Ten Percent Happier
- 1:12:28was I think the first book I read on meditation.
- 1:12:31Yeah. Are there any works like that that you'd
- 1:12:34suggest? Yeah, that's a really great one. So
- 1:12:38on this resource page, at the end of the slides,
- 1:12:42there's a book called The Anxious Lawyer, which
- 1:12:44is actually commissioned by the ABA. And it takes
- 1:12:48you through an eight -week basically training
- 1:12:51to learn how to meditate. So that one's very,
- 1:12:54very helpful, written by meditating lawyers for
- 1:12:57lawyers. And you can find that one on Amazon.
- 1:13:00The textbook, there's a short textbook I use
- 1:13:03called The Mindful Law Student written by Scott
- 1:13:05Rogers and it's written for law students. But
- 1:13:08a lawyer can use it, too. You don't have to be
- 1:13:10a law student. It's really, really wonderful.
- 1:13:16He uses the same training with attorneys, with
- 1:13:18judges. It's a very helpful one. And he has a
- 1:13:23lot of different guided techniques, including
- 1:13:26movement meditation and not just the ones that
- 1:13:29I described. Everybody is different. We all have
- 1:13:32different histories and experiences. the technique
- 1:13:35that works for me might not be what's most helpful
- 1:13:38to you. So I think it's really important to experiment
- 1:13:41and try different things out. And then once you
- 1:13:43find something that works, really kind of develop
- 1:13:45yourself with that technique. So I think those
- 1:13:47are really good. The book I referred to in terms
- 1:13:51of all those practice notes and different cognitive
- 1:13:54reframing techniques that was helpful was written
- 1:13:57by Joseph Goldstein. It's called Insight Meditation,
- 1:13:59the Practice of Freedom. And that was also very
- 1:14:03helpful. And then lastly, the website greatergood
- 1:14:07.berkeley .edu has a lot of really helpful introductory
- 1:14:11guided meditation, including audios and videos
- 1:14:14that you can follow. Do you have a particular
- 1:14:21guided meditation resource, an app that you like?
- 1:14:29I don't really use an app other than the Insight
- 1:14:31timer, which gives you lots of different. friendlier
- 1:14:37sounds other than your alarm on your phone. So
- 1:14:40there's like soft gongs and other things. So
- 1:14:42if you're learning how to meditate, sometimes
- 1:14:45it can be helpful to have intervals that kind
- 1:14:48of encourage you as you go. So for example, if
- 1:14:51you're trying to get to your first 15 minutes,
- 1:14:54you can set an interval of five minutes and every
- 1:14:57five minutes you'll get a soft gong that tells
- 1:14:59you. You're getting there. So I find that one
- 1:15:02really helpful. But Dean, I know you use an app
- 1:15:05that you find helpful. Maybe you want to share
- 1:15:07what you use. Yeah, I've used a couple of them.
- 1:15:12There's the one that I use more often than not.
- 1:15:15There's two basic ones. There's Headspace, which
- 1:15:19people might be aware of. I've noticed that it
- 1:15:23keeps its they seem to be moving their focus
- 1:15:27into mental health in general. The one that I
- 1:15:31really like is called Waking Up, which is by
- 1:15:33a gentleman named Sam Harris that a lot of people
- 1:15:35are familiar with. The thing that I like about
- 1:15:37the Waking Up app, it offers you a free 30 -day
- 1:15:40entry that has a guided every day. You don't
- 1:15:44have to do it every day, and he's very clear
- 1:15:46on that. It's not about counting, but it has
- 1:15:5130 steps to And it's good for analytical people
- 1:15:55because it explains why do we meditate? What
- 1:15:58are we doing? What are we not doing? And as you
- 1:16:02pointed out at the beginning, you know, it's
- 1:16:03not about there's no answer, right? We're not
- 1:16:05we're not looking for an answer here. And I like
- 1:16:09that one because it not only has a meditation,
- 1:16:12but then it has a short three to 15 minute sort
- 1:16:17of analytical behind the behind the the the the
- 1:16:22screen. Why do we do this? Although I am still
- 1:16:27frustrated with his look for who's looking and
- 1:16:30it just hasn't landed yet. It's been at it for
- 1:16:33over a year now and I still don't know what the
- 1:16:35heck he wants. There's many selves looking. Emily,
- 1:16:43thank you. Rachel, did you have any thoughts,
- 1:16:45feedback, questions? No, I really enjoyed the
- 1:16:48program though I thought. a lot of that is very
- 1:16:51helpful to me as a law student. You know, it's
- 1:16:53a very stressful time and I'm sure that it's
- 1:16:56only going to get more stressful. So I think
- 1:16:58a lot of the stuff that you talked about is really
- 1:17:01important to be thinking about as we're all in
- 1:17:04this crazy industry. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah,
- 1:17:08thank you very much. Most of our questions were
- 1:17:11just saying thank you and I want to acknowledge
- 1:17:14you for taking the time and for doing this good
- 1:17:16work with students. It's very vital. And thank
- 1:17:20you again, Rachel, for bringing Emily to my awareness
- 1:17:23so that we could create this program. So with
- 1:17:28that, I'm going to thank us all for our time.
- 1:17:31Yeah, just another one saying thank you, this
- 1:17:33was great. So again, tell your friends, your
- 1:17:38other lawyers to check this out. It was a very
- 1:17:42useful program for myself and I think it would
- 1:17:45be for others. You can go check it out at BHB
- 1:17:47On Demand. And with that, thank you for your
- 1:17:52time.