Latest / Bloomberg Law / Lawsuits Against 'Clean Beauty' Claims, Trump and the 14th Amendment
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Lawn Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 0:05Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 0:09Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand wherever
- 0:12Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 0:16Speaker 2: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm Lydio Wheeler and
- 0:19Speaker 2: I'm Greg Store.
- 0:19Speaker 3: We're in for Jin Grosso, who's out this week. Head
- 0:22Speaker 3: In this hour, we'll talk about the legal fight over
- 0:24Speaker 3: whether former President Donald Trump is prohibited under the Constitution
- 0:28Speaker 3: from holding office again because of the role he played
- 0:30Speaker 3: in the January sixth attack on the Capitol.
- 0:33Speaker 2: All that to come, but first we're going to talk
- 0:35Speaker 2: about clean beauty products.
- 0:37Speaker 4: You know, we all try to become more conscious of
- 0:39Speaker 4: the things we're putting in our body.
- 0:41Speaker 3: It's not just limited to food, but also includes your
- 0:44Speaker 3: beauty products.
- 0:45Speaker 5: Yes, your skin is your biggest org out.
- 0:47Speaker 6: Oh yeah, well they going down too, Like even with
- 0:49Speaker 6: something like sunscreen, Like, well, we do these micro zincs.
- 0:52Speaker 6: Well zinc isn't terrible for you, but you know, you
- 0:54Speaker 6: can do all these different other things that are non
- 0:56Speaker 6: nano to where they don't go into your bloodstream. There's
- 0:58Speaker 6: just so much that needs to be learned.
- 1:00Speaker 2: That was a clip from Daytime Chicago. The new show
- 1:03Speaker 2: did a segment on the best clean beauty products like icreams, cleansers,
- 1:06Speaker 2: and moisturizers. Some big retailers have now found themselves entangled
- 1:11Speaker 2: in litigation over these very products. Joining us now to
- 1:14Speaker 2: talk about the litigation is Heather Bustos, a Food and
- 1:17Speaker 2: Drug Administration compliance attorney and managing partner of Bustos Law Group. Heather,
- 1:22Speaker 2: thanks for joining us. Can you tell us what retailers
- 1:25Speaker 2: are being sued over and why?
- 1:27Speaker 7: Sure? So, thank you so much for having me so
- 1:31Speaker 7: right now, Target and Sephora are actually facing lawsuits, and
- 1:36Speaker 7: really the issue is that they are essentially claiming that
- 1:40Speaker 7: the products that they're selling are considered clean, and these
- 1:44Speaker 7: lawsuits are stating that consumers do not really agree with
- 1:51Speaker 7: the definition of clean that Sephori and Target have and
- 1:54Speaker 7: so this is one of many. These are a couple
- 1:57Speaker 7: of many lawsuits that are now in the wings and
- 2:01Speaker 7: probably will continue moving forward.
- 2:03Speaker 3: Heather. For those of us who think of clean beauty
- 2:05Speaker 3: as making sure there's a bar of soap in the shower,
- 2:08Speaker 3: can you just sort of define a little bit what
- 2:10Speaker 3: we're talking about. Are we talking about products that you know,
- 2:13Speaker 3: don't have things that harm the person using it. Are
- 2:15Speaker 3: we talking about products that are environmentally sensitive? Are both?
- 2:20Speaker 7: I think there's a little bit of both. There are
- 2:24Speaker 7: ranges of definitions amongst different companies, and that's why there's
- 2:29Speaker 7: so much confusion around the term. But most people tend
- 2:33Speaker 7: to think it means free from harmful chemicals. In some cases,
- 2:39Speaker 7: harmful is also an issue where it can be, you know,
- 2:43Speaker 7: something that's cancer causing, and people have difficulty even defining
- 2:48Speaker 7: what's considered harmful, and so that's why this litigation is
- 2:53Speaker 7: happening because essentially the definition is not really clear.
- 2:58Speaker 2: Can you walk us back again us a little history here.
- 3:01Speaker 2: When did this trend begin and how did it start?
- 3:05Speaker 7: That's a great question. So clean beauty kind of began
- 3:08Speaker 7: as really with makeup in the nineteen seventies, and then
- 3:13Speaker 7: it moved into the clean eating movement during the nineteen
- 3:16Speaker 7: nineties in California, and since then, obviously we've seen a rise.
- 3:21Speaker 7: It's really popular with gen z and millennials, and so
- 3:25Speaker 7: this has become like a really strong marketing term and
- 3:29Speaker 7: it allows companies to really succeed in the market. Utilizing
- 3:33Speaker 7: clean you know in their marketing.
- 3:35Speaker 3: Are there any regulations out there? The Food and Drug Administration,
- 3:39Speaker 3: the Federal Trade Commission, it states, anybody who has tried
- 3:43Speaker 3: to define what clean means.
- 3:46Speaker 7: So the FTC does have some green guides, what they
- 3:49Speaker 7: call green guides, that go into some vague definitions, but
- 3:54Speaker 7: not specific to the term clean. That's why these lawsuits
- 3:58Speaker 7: have been able to move forward is because there's not
- 4:01Speaker 7: a lot of, you know, clarity on what the meaning is.
- 4:04Speaker 2: What about regulations for advertisers, you know, aren't there rules
- 4:08Speaker 2: about deceptive or unfair advertising practices? And would this even
- 4:13Speaker 2: fall into that? Like is this considered deceptive to call
- 4:16Speaker 2: something clean if we don't really know how to define clean?
- 4:19Speaker 1: Right?
- 4:19Speaker 7: And that is that is the big question, and that
- 4:23Speaker 7: is what the courts will have to kind of come
- 4:25Speaker 7: come up with, you know, the answer to that, because
- 4:28Speaker 7: essentially you're looking at a consumer's perspective. That's what the
- 4:31Speaker 7: FDA uses the FTC. They look at, you know, what
- 4:35Speaker 7: a lay person would look at that product and essentially
- 4:38Speaker 7: think clean means, and so they will have to come
- 4:43Speaker 7: up with that definition.
- 4:44Speaker 3: Tell us a little more about these lawsuits that are
- 4:47Speaker 3: out there against folks like Target and Sephora, what who's
- 4:51Speaker 3: behind them, what are they claiming, what are they asking for?
- 4:55Speaker 7: Currently? I'm there are quite a few plaintiffs attorneys that
- 5:00Speaker 7: are bringing consumer lawsuits. And this is not just in
- 5:02Speaker 7: the cosmetic space. This is happening in the food space,
- 5:05Speaker 7: the supplement space, and essentially it's going back to deceptive practices,
- 5:10Speaker 7: and they're claiming that companies are being deceptive in their
- 5:15Speaker 7: marketing and they're using terms that would deceive the customer
- 5:19Speaker 7: into purchasing it. And so that's where a lot of
- 5:23Speaker 7: these issues are coming from.
- 5:24Speaker 2: What are the retailers here, Sephora and Target saying in
- 5:27Speaker 2: response to this litigation?
- 5:29Speaker 7: In the lawsuits themselves, essentially they're stating that they haven't
- 5:33Speaker 7: made any environmental claims. So I think at this point
- 5:37Speaker 7: they're trying to claim that number one, that the definitions
- 5:41Speaker 7: are not solid and number two that you know, they're
- 5:45Speaker 7: not actually being deceptive, And so it's really going to
- 5:48Speaker 7: come down to a lot of evidence about what consumers
- 5:52Speaker 7: believe these terms mean.
- 5:54Speaker 3: Why is this litigation happening now? If clean beauty products
- 5:58Speaker 3: have been around for decades all of a sudden, now
- 6:01Speaker 3: is there are these these allegations that companies are miss
- 6:07Speaker 3: marketing things.
- 6:08Speaker 7: I think we're seeing a trend and you're seeing this
- 6:11Speaker 7: for example in California where they're coming out and banning ingredients.
- 6:15Speaker 7: You're seeing consumers become more educated on what's in their products.
- 6:20Speaker 7: And a lot of it is I think social media.
- 6:23Speaker 7: There's a lot of education out there for consumers. Now.
- 6:27Speaker 7: You know, you have different apps like Yuka or websites
- 6:32Speaker 7: like the EWG which are giving consumers more education and
- 6:36Speaker 7: so that allowing them to know a little bit more
- 6:39Speaker 7: about what should or shouldn't be in their products. But yeah,
- 6:42Speaker 7: we're generally seeing that trend rise.
- 6:45Speaker 2: So you mentioned education, So what should consumers know about
- 6:49Speaker 2: clean beauty products?
- 6:50Speaker 7: I think that consumers need to definitely look deeper than
- 6:54Speaker 7: just the term clean and look at the ingredients themselves. Unfortunately,
- 6:59Speaker 7: in the there there are likely I don't want to
- 7:03Speaker 7: overgeneralize that companies think this per se, but if you
- 7:07Speaker 7: were to look at just regulations from you know, on
- 7:12Speaker 7: the FDA side and look at what ingredients are banned,
- 7:16Speaker 7: there's only eleven banned ingredients by the FDA for cosmetics,
- 7:21Speaker 7: and so a lot of companies may believe that well,
- 7:24Speaker 7: if the ingredients are not banned, then they can be used,
- 7:29Speaker 7: and so that's really that's really the issue that I
- 7:33Speaker 7: see there.
- 7:34Speaker 3: Sure, Heather, can you talk just a little bit about
- 7:36Speaker 3: the industry and the market. How big is it? How
- 7:39Speaker 3: many companies are there out there out there marketing clean
- 7:43Speaker 3: beauty products, and who is the target audience?
- 7:47Speaker 7: So the market is massive. I remember looking at it
- 7:51Speaker 7: and it said as of it's expected that by twenty
- 7:55Speaker 7: twenty seven, it'll be eleven point six billion dollars the
- 7:58Speaker 7: clean beauty markets. So it's massive, and that's why there's
- 8:02Speaker 7: a lot of benefit to marketing your product as clean,
- 8:07Speaker 7: and so a lot of companies are having to make
- 8:09Speaker 7: this decision between being competitive and trying to avoid risk
- 8:15Speaker 7: in the case of these the litigation that's coming forward.
- 8:19Speaker 2: You know, I mentioned earlier in the segment about that clip.
- 8:23Speaker 2: They were talking about moisturizers and lotions and I creams
- 8:26Speaker 2: and that kind of thing. But when you're talking about
- 8:28Speaker 2: beauty products, like what does this encompass? Are we talking
- 8:31Speaker 2: about everything including makeup and stuff? Can you talk a
- 8:34Speaker 2: little bit about the types of products that you've seen beauty.
- 8:37Speaker 7: Products at least in terms of the definition by FDA,
- 8:41Speaker 7: it's anything that's applied to the outside of the body
- 8:46Speaker 7: for beautification purposes. And so it's like you said, it
- 8:50Speaker 7: can be a very wide range of products. Really, cosmetics
- 8:56Speaker 7: can be anything from lotions to some you know, hair
- 9:01Speaker 7: products like shampoos. It can also include nail products. So
- 9:06Speaker 7: there's a very wide range when it comes to what's
- 9:08Speaker 7: considered a cosmetic. Even perfumes are considered cosmetics as well.
- 9:12Speaker 3: Coming up on the program, we'll get more on the
- 9:14Speaker 3: litigation over clean beauty products with attorney Heather Boustos. Remember
- 9:19Speaker 3: you can always get the latest legal news by listening
- 9:21Speaker 3: to our Bloomberg Law podcast on Apple, Spotify, or wherever
- 9:25Speaker 3: you get your podcasts.
- 9:26Speaker 5: I'm Greg Store and I'm Lydio Wheeler. This is Bloomberg.
- 9:37Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Cat's the program
- 9:41Speaker 1: weekdays at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg Radio, the tune
- 9:44Speaker 1: in app, Bloomberg dot Com, and the Bloomberg Business App.
- 9:47Speaker 1: You can also listen live on Amazon Alexa from our
- 9:50Speaker 1: flagship New York station, Just say Alexa play Bloomberg eleven thirty.
- 9:57Speaker 3: I'm Greg Store and.
- 9:58Speaker 2: I'm Video Wheeler. We're in for June Grasso. We've been
- 10:01Speaker 2: speaking with Heather Boosto's, an FDA compliance attorney and partner
- 10:05Speaker 2: at Bousto's Law Group about litigation over clean beauty products. So, Heather,
- 10:10Speaker 2: what do you see happening with these lawsuits against Sephora
- 10:13Speaker 2: and Target.
- 10:14Speaker 7: It's really hard to say what the outcome will be.
- 10:18Speaker 7: There have been I believe there have been some lawsuits recently.
- 10:23Speaker 7: There was one against Loreel that was thrown out because
- 10:27Speaker 7: there I believe that in that case there was no
- 10:31Speaker 7: real harm shown to consumers, and that's always an issue
- 10:36Speaker 7: that comes up in some of these class action type
- 10:38Speaker 7: lawsuits that come forward. So it's hard to say what
- 10:42Speaker 7: will happen, but hopefully we'll get some idea as to
- 10:47Speaker 7: what the courts deem is at least a shell of
- 10:51Speaker 7: a definition. We're hoping that will be the case. And
- 10:54Speaker 7: in the meantime, there are agencies or organizations like the
- 10:58Speaker 7: Independent Beauty of trying to push agencies like the FDA
- 11:03Speaker 7: and FCC to give a definition in the meantime, so
- 11:07Speaker 7: we're trying to see who will win in that case
- 11:12Speaker 7: of providing a clear definition.
- 11:14Speaker 3: Are these sorts of legal fights new or has there
- 11:17Speaker 3: been similar litigation over other product claims? In the past.
- 11:22Speaker 7: These are definitely not new. There are many issues across
- 11:28Speaker 7: the board, So in cosmetics, this is something that I
- 11:32Speaker 7: believe is maybe newer on the cosmetics side, but especially
- 11:36Speaker 7: on the food side. There have been many lawsuits around
- 11:41Speaker 7: the terms natural for example, and that also comes in
- 11:45Speaker 7: on the beauty side, and in those two cases, in
- 11:48Speaker 7: different product categories, there's going to be different definitions. So
- 11:52Speaker 7: this is definitely not new, and I think the trend
- 11:55Speaker 7: is just going up and up, and with my own clients,
- 11:59Speaker 7: I'm having these conversations on a daily basis. Where it
- 12:02Speaker 7: used to be, you know, maybe not as much of
- 12:05Speaker 7: an issue, it's definitely coming to the forefront, and I'm
- 12:09Speaker 7: thinking about it as the products are being developed.
- 12:12Speaker 2: So, Heather, you mentioned your clients and this is something
- 12:15Speaker 2: that you're giving counsel on what exactly are you telling
- 12:18Speaker 2: them then, So.
- 12:20Speaker 7: What we're trying to do is balance the risk of
- 12:24Speaker 7: a lawsuit with their competitive edge in the market. And
- 12:28Speaker 7: every client's going to be a little different in terms
- 12:30Speaker 7: of how they see risk, and so I'm definitely bringing
- 12:35Speaker 7: up a lot of the claims that are at issue
- 12:39Speaker 7: in litigation currently and what I'm expecting to be in
- 12:43Speaker 7: litigation and allowing clients to make those decisions, but definitely
- 12:47Speaker 7: trying to steer them towards taking as little risk as possible.
- 12:52Speaker 7: The issue here that I see is companies are not
- 12:55Speaker 7: really immune. I don't think there's any company that's immune
- 12:59Speaker 7: because of the fact that we don't have clear definitions.
- 13:02Speaker 7: So ultimately, if clean, if that term is allowing companies
- 13:07Speaker 7: to market and be successful, then they really don't have
- 13:13Speaker 7: a huge amount of choice in whether they use it
- 13:16Speaker 7: or not. And so what something that that I've provided
- 13:21Speaker 7: guidance on is using asterisks and providing their own definitions
- 13:26Speaker 7: so that consumers are at least on notice of what
- 13:29Speaker 7: their definition of clean means.
- 13:31Speaker 3: So you co authored a legal insight for Bloomberg Lawn
- 13:35Speaker 3: and that article touched on equity issues involved in the
- 13:39Speaker 3: marketing of these products. Can you just tell us a
- 13:41Speaker 3: little bit about that.
- 13:43Speaker 7: So, in terms of equity, there are issues with natural
- 13:48Speaker 7: ingredients used in beauty products not being attributed to people
- 13:54Speaker 7: of color and their essentially where those ingredients came from,
- 14:00Speaker 7: and so in terms of marketing, it's almost erasing some
- 14:05Speaker 7: of the origins of these ingredients.
- 14:07Speaker 2: You mentioned before about counseling your clients about, you know,
- 14:12Speaker 2: how to avoid this litigation. You mentioned that some of
- 14:15Speaker 2: them are defining what clean is on their own. How
- 14:19Speaker 2: else can they protect themselves? Is are some clients just saying, Okay,
- 14:24Speaker 2: I'm not going to market this as clean and if so,
- 14:27Speaker 2: is that them not being competitive? I mean, what are
- 14:30Speaker 2: they doing here, you know, to try to avoid that risk?
- 14:32Speaker 7: Yeah, I think with different clients it's turned out differently.
- 14:36Speaker 7: Some of them are willing to take on the risk
- 14:39Speaker 7: of using the term and just providing the definition. Others
- 14:46Speaker 7: have just completely removed it from their marketing and kind
- 14:49Speaker 7: of focused on educating on the ingredients they do use
- 14:54Speaker 7: and the ingredients that they're keeping out. So instead of
- 14:57Speaker 7: using an overarching term of clean, they're just providing the
- 15:01Speaker 7: definition by showcasing the ingredients they're using or keeping out
- 15:06Speaker 7: of the product.
- 15:07Speaker 3: Ask you a look into the future a little bit.
- 15:09Speaker 3: What impact would you imagine this litigation might have on
- 15:14Speaker 3: the industry.
- 15:16Speaker 7: Well, it's definitely going to cause a lot of companies
- 15:20Speaker 7: to be more aware of the claims that they're placing
- 15:23Speaker 7: on their products. It's going to cause them to be
- 15:27Speaker 7: probably more conservative than they would have been in the past.
- 15:30Speaker 7: And this is something we're seeing even you know, within
- 15:34Speaker 7: the FTC regulations and what they're coming out with. They've
- 15:38Speaker 7: issued a few new guidances in the past i'd say
- 15:43Speaker 7: six months or so up to a year, and these
- 15:46Speaker 7: guidances are causing, you know, people to be more aware
- 15:50Speaker 7: of our companies rather to be more aware of the
- 15:54Speaker 7: types of claims they're using. And so I think it's
- 15:56Speaker 7: all leading up to the same result, which is companies
- 16:01Speaker 7: being more cautious with the types of claims that they're
- 16:04Speaker 7: using on their products.
- 16:05Speaker 2: Can you talk a little bit more about that new
- 16:07Speaker 2: guidance from the FTC, What exactly are they saying.
- 16:10Speaker 7: So, there is one of the new guidances that was
- 16:13Speaker 7: released as a health Products compliance guidance, which has now
- 16:19Speaker 7: it really focuses more on the substantiation side, but it's
- 16:22Speaker 7: provided a lot of guidance to companies as to what
- 16:27Speaker 7: kinds of claims require what levels of substantiation and so,
- 16:32Speaker 7: like I said, it's ultimately the more guidance industry has,
- 16:38Speaker 7: the more able they are to be within the bounds
- 16:41Speaker 7: of what's expected. And so when these guidances come out,
- 16:45Speaker 7: Number one, they're very easy. They're much easier to read
- 16:48Speaker 7: than to read through legal you know, through opinions from
- 16:51Speaker 7: court cases, and so it allows companies to be more
- 16:55Speaker 7: educated on what they can or can't do.
- 16:58Speaker 2: Heather, I mean, we're talking about clear beauty products, but
- 17:01Speaker 2: is there anything else that's popped up in the marketplace
- 17:04Speaker 2: that's similar to this, Like when we're thinking thinking about
- 17:07Speaker 2: beauty products that you think could be the next thing
- 17:10Speaker 2: that causes there to be litigation some other marketing tool
- 17:14Speaker 2: or scheme.
- 17:15Speaker 7: Currently, the terms that we're looking at obviously clean, the
- 17:20Speaker 7: term natural has been a source of confusion and there's
- 17:25Speaker 7: been a lack of clarity on that as well. And
- 17:29Speaker 7: the term green, which I think goes across product categories.
- 17:32Speaker 7: It's not just in the cosmetic space, it goes into
- 17:36Speaker 7: like I said, into the food space, and even into
- 17:40Speaker 7: consumer products like cleaning products where they're using natural and green.
- 17:45Speaker 7: So I definitely think in the future these are going
- 17:48Speaker 7: to continue to be a source of contention.
- 17:51Speaker 3: Our thanks to Heather boost Os, an FDA compliance attorney
- 17:54Speaker 3: and managing partner at Bluestos Law Group. Coming up next
- 17:57Speaker 3: on The Bloomberg Law Show, we'll dive into the cost
- 17:59Speaker 3: of tutional fight over whether former President Donald Trump can
- 18:02Speaker 3: hold office again.
- 18:04Speaker 5: I'm Greg Storr and I'm Lydia Wheeler. This is Bloomberg.
- 18:15Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 18:19Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio
- 18:23Speaker 1: app and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand
- 18:25Speaker 1: wherever you get your podcasts.
- 18:29Speaker 3: I'm Lydia Wheeler and I'm Greg store We're in for
- 18:32Speaker 3: June Grosso. The Colorado Supreme Court last week considered whether
- 18:36Speaker 3: Donald Trump is prohibited under the Constitution's insurrection clause from
- 18:39Speaker 3: becoming president again after the January sixth attack on the Capitol.
- 18:43Speaker 3: Here's Colorado Supreme Court Justice William W. Hood as the insurrection.
- 18:49Speaker 3: Why isn't it enough that a violent bob breached the
- 18:53Speaker 3: capital when Congress was performing a core constitutional function? In
- 18:57Speaker 3: some ways, that seems like a poster child friends. It's
- 19:01Speaker 3: one of several cases that seek to keep Trump off
- 19:03Speaker 3: the twenty twenty four presidential ballot and ultimately could land
- 19:07Speaker 3: at the Supreme Court. Joining us to discuss it all
- 19:09Speaker 3: is Bloomberg News reporters Zewe. Tillman, who covers the intersection
- 19:13Speaker 3: of law and politics, and especially law and Donald Trump
- 19:17Speaker 3: these days. Zoe, thanks for joining us. Let's start with
- 19:22Speaker 3: the constitutional basics. What is the insurrection clause?
- 19:26Speaker 4: Going back to the post Civil War period, you know,
- 19:30Speaker 4: the Reconstruction era, US government was looking for ways to
- 19:34Speaker 4: make sure that high level officials or really a number
- 19:38Speaker 4: of people who had supported secession and you know, the
- 19:41Speaker 4: Confederacy were barred from participating in government, at least for
- 19:46Speaker 4: the time being. So in eighteen sixty eight they ratify
- 19:50Speaker 4: Section three, which is the language that we're all dealing
- 19:53Speaker 4: with now, a fourteenth Amendment which basically says, you know,
- 19:56Speaker 4: if you took an oath under the Constitution to support
- 20:00Speaker 4: constitution and held in office, what office exactly is a
- 20:04Speaker 4: matter of contention, but if you did that and then
- 20:07Speaker 4: you engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the Constitution, you
- 20:12Speaker 4: were barred from holding other office under the United States
- 20:15Speaker 4: going forward. You know, it's language that was very relevant
- 20:19Speaker 4: at the time it was ratified and used and invoked,
- 20:24Speaker 4: but then was mostly dormant for a lot of American
- 20:27Speaker 4: history after that point. It really didn't come up. There
- 20:30Speaker 4: weren't many rebellions or insurrections that we had to contend with,
- 20:35Speaker 4: and then it suddenly roared back to life after the
- 20:38Speaker 4: attack on the Capitol on January sixth, where you know,
- 20:41Speaker 4: a lot of scholars said, hey, this language is still there,
- 20:45Speaker 4: and just because it hasn't been used doesn't mean it's
- 20:48Speaker 4: not still operative. It doesn't say, you know, only applies
- 20:52Speaker 4: to the Civil War of the nineteenth century. It just
- 20:56Speaker 4: says insurrection. And it really revived a debate about whether
- 21:00Speaker 4: it could apply to folks who participated in January sixth,
- 21:04Speaker 4: and then sort of more relevant to our discussion today,
- 21:07Speaker 4: whether it could apply to people like Donald Trump who
- 21:09Speaker 4: didn't physically storm the Capitol. But we're sort of at
- 21:12Speaker 4: the heart of what happened on January sixth.
- 21:16Speaker 2: So can you give us an overview of the biggest
- 21:19Speaker 2: cases out there involving Trump and the insurrection clause? Who
- 21:23Speaker 2: exactly is pressing this issue? And where are these cases?
- 21:27Speaker 4: So there are a lot of them. There are more
- 21:29Speaker 4: than three dozen that we've found so far that have
- 21:32Speaker 4: been filed in courts across the country. The vast majority
- 21:36Speaker 4: have been dismissed really early on, and you know, are
- 21:40Speaker 4: not considered sort of the major challenges. A lot of
- 21:42Speaker 4: them have been brought by a sort of minor GOP
- 21:47Speaker 4: presidential candidate who's been you know, filing student federal court
- 21:53Speaker 4: and claiming, you know, because he's registered to run in
- 21:56Speaker 4: the primary against Donald Trump, he has sort of a
- 21:58Speaker 4: competitor standing to sue over Trump's eligibility. But courts have
- 22:04Speaker 4: largely been saying that's not doesn't give us jurisdiction here,
- 22:08Speaker 4: and those have been tossed out. Now there are four
- 22:12Speaker 4: cases at this point that everyone is watching for a
- 22:16Speaker 4: number of reasons. They're all in state court, which is
- 22:19Speaker 4: important because you know, what we're really dealing with this
- 22:23Speaker 4: state election law and what each state has to say
- 22:26Speaker 4: about how election officials decide who gets on the ballot,
- 22:31Speaker 4: the timeline for that, the process. So the four cases
- 22:34Speaker 4: have been in Colorado, Michigan, Minnesota, and most recently Oregon.
- 22:40Speaker 4: The case in Colorado, which has really gotten the most
- 22:43Speaker 4: attention and has moved along as farther in the process,
- 22:47Speaker 4: was brought by a group called Citizens for Responsibility and
- 22:50Speaker 4: Ethics in Washington or crew and that's important because they
- 22:54Speaker 4: actually won.
- 22:55Speaker 7: So far.
- 22:56Speaker 4: The only case to prevail in getting someone removed from
- 23:00Speaker 4: office under Section three, and that was a county commissioner
- 23:04Speaker 4: in New Mexico who was convicted of a crime for
- 23:07Speaker 4: being part of the capital attack, and they successfully went
- 23:11Speaker 4: to court to get him removed from office. So they're
- 23:13Speaker 4: now bringing this case in Colorado that was just argued
- 23:16Speaker 4: in the state Supreme Court. And then another group called
- 23:19Speaker 4: Free Speech for People, they've brought the other three cases,
- 23:23Speaker 4: or they're one of several groups and law firms involved
- 23:26Speaker 4: in Michigan, Oregon, and Minnesota.
- 23:29Speaker 3: One thing I didn't hear you mention in there is
- 23:32Speaker 3: the idea of a state trying to keep Donald Trump
- 23:35Speaker 3: off the ballot. One might have thought that, say a
- 23:37Speaker 3: state secretary of state who's in charge of the elections
- 23:41Speaker 3: might have said, no, I'm not going to put him.
- 23:45Speaker 3: I'm going to try to keep him off the ballot
- 23:47Speaker 3: because he engaged in insurrection. Has that not happened.
- 23:51Speaker 4: It has not. And even secretaries of state who are
- 23:55Speaker 4: Democrats who are opposed to Trump have been really to
- 24:00Speaker 4: be the ones to take the leap first. And we've
- 24:03Speaker 4: seen a number of these officials say this is extremely untested,
- 24:08Speaker 4: uncharted waters for all of us, and I would much
- 24:11Speaker 4: rather have a court be the ones that sort of
- 24:14Speaker 4: punted it over to the judiciary and said you know,
- 24:18Speaker 4: we'd much rather have a judge or our state Supreme
- 24:21Speaker 4: court or the US Supreme Court make an official determination
- 24:25Speaker 4: on these legal questions before I a humble state servant,
- 24:29Speaker 4: go so far as to tell, you know, a candidate,
- 24:32Speaker 4: major candidate, probably you know, the front runner for the
- 24:35Speaker 4: GOP nomination, that he can't appear on the ballot. So
- 24:39Speaker 4: they've you know, they're in court as defendants in these
- 24:42Speaker 4: cases because they are the actors that a court would
- 24:46Speaker 4: order to do something, whether it's to keep someone off
- 24:50Speaker 4: a ballot or take additional steps to deal with these challenges.
- 24:55Speaker 4: But they are not sort of actively litigating for one
- 24:59Speaker 4: side or the other. They're basically saying, whatever judge you decide,
- 25:03Speaker 4: we will follow your ruling. You know, some have supported
- 25:08Speaker 4: the challengers insofar as you know, arguing that January sixth
- 25:12Speaker 4: was an insurrection and kind of getting behind that theory,
- 25:16Speaker 4: but not wanting to be the ones to say, you know,
- 25:19Speaker 4: yes or no, he is eligible or not to appear
- 25:22Speaker 4: on ballance.
- 25:23Speaker 2: So what exactly is this argument? What's the basic argument
- 25:26Speaker 2: that those seeking to keep Trump off the ballot are making.
- 25:29Speaker 4: You know, first and foremost that January sixth was an insurrection,
- 25:33Speaker 4: and that's not necessarily a given the term. The word
- 25:36Speaker 4: insurrection isn't clearly defined in the Constitution, so it's sort
- 25:42Speaker 4: of potentially open for debate what an insurrection is. And
- 25:46Speaker 4: that was something that the Colorado Supreme Court went back
- 25:49Speaker 4: and forth with the lawyers about. You know, at one
- 25:51Speaker 4: point it was Donald Trump's lawyer was saying, well, you know,
- 25:55Speaker 4: there weren't enough firearms that it could be an insurrection
- 26:01Speaker 4: because they couldn't have they didn't have the weaponry to
- 26:04Speaker 4: actually overthrow Congress. And then the justices it was sort
- 26:07Speaker 4: of this extraordinary back and forth where they were saying, well,
- 26:10Speaker 4: they had makeshift weapons that they could use, and there
- 26:12Speaker 4: were certainly a lot of violence. So what is the
- 26:15Speaker 4: where's the line for how much you know, violence there
- 26:19Speaker 4: has to be or how much weaponry there has to
- 26:21Speaker 4: be for something to be an insurrection. But the challenges
- 26:24Speaker 4: are saying, yes, what they wanted was to overthrow lawfully
- 26:29Speaker 4: elected government and governance at the time, and that is
- 26:34Speaker 4: an insurrection. So that's one of the main arguments. And
- 26:38Speaker 4: then the next question is did Donald Trump engage in
- 26:41Speaker 4: that insurrection? And the challengers are saying yes, that he
- 26:44Speaker 4: was the driving force in you know, directing his supporters
- 26:49Speaker 4: that day to go to the capital, and before that,
- 26:54Speaker 4: you know, really inciting them, motivating them by saying the
- 26:58Speaker 4: election was stolen and it's up to you to you know,
- 27:02Speaker 4: go to your state lawmakers and go to Congress to
- 27:05Speaker 4: stop the stolen election. And then the sort of big
- 27:09Speaker 4: picture are overarching constitutional question and issue that the challengers
- 27:14Speaker 4: are are arguing is that Section three, you know, does
- 27:20Speaker 4: apply to a president or a former president who is
- 27:24Speaker 4: seeking the presidency again. And that has been you know,
- 27:28Speaker 4: actually a major one of the primary issues in contention
- 27:33Speaker 4: here because Section three is and everyone agrees silent on
- 27:38Speaker 4: this issue. It lists other offices. It mentioned senators, representative,
- 27:43Speaker 4: federal electors, but it doesn't say president or vice president.
- 27:47Speaker 4: And what they're saying is there's a catch all reference
- 27:50Speaker 4: to officers federal officers office under the United States. And
- 27:56Speaker 4: the question is was that meant to capture everything that's
- 28:00Speaker 4: not listed, including and up to the presidency.
- 28:04Speaker 3: Zoe, How have these cases been faring so far as
- 28:07Speaker 3: of now?
- 28:08Speaker 4: Donald Trump has been winning in the sense that no
- 28:11Speaker 4: one has succeeded in stopping him from appearing on a ballot,
- 28:15Speaker 4: especially heading into the primary season, when you know, states
- 28:18Speaker 4: are literally getting ready in the next few weeks to
- 28:21Speaker 4: print their ballots and get ready for primary contests. You know,
- 28:25Speaker 4: he is appealing. However, in Colorado, the judge's determination that
- 28:31Speaker 4: it was an insurrection on January sixth and that he
- 28:34Speaker 4: engaged in it. Where he won that case was the
- 28:37Speaker 4: judge said, however, I don't find that Section three applies
- 28:41Speaker 4: to a former president seeking office again, so it was
- 28:45Speaker 4: you know, a win in that he stays on the ballot,
- 28:49Speaker 4: but they would prefer they're not to be official court
- 28:53Speaker 4: ruling out there that he engaged in insurrection, So they
- 28:57Speaker 4: are fighting that, but for the most part, he's won
- 28:59Speaker 4: and diferent reasons. You know. In Michigan, the judge there
- 29:03Speaker 4: said that this was a political question that the courts
- 29:06Speaker 4: simply shouldn't decide, and there's some disagreement among judges on
- 29:10Speaker 4: that question, so that issue is up on appeal. In Minnesota,
- 29:14Speaker 4: the state Supreme Court said basically that the primary contest
- 29:20Speaker 4: wasn't really an area where a state election official had
- 29:24Speaker 4: power to keep someone off the ballot, so it was
- 29:27Speaker 4: sort of loot and not really right at this point,
- 29:30Speaker 4: and the question of the general election, it was just
- 29:32Speaker 4: too early to decide any of the issues. So they
- 29:36Speaker 4: sort of said the primary, we don't really have jurisdiction
- 29:39Speaker 4: to deal with this. It's just for states to help
- 29:43Speaker 4: the parties decide who their nominees are going to be,
- 29:46Speaker 4: and maybe we bring this back for the general election.
- 29:50Speaker 2: So does this ever become a case for the United
- 29:52Speaker 2: States Supreme Court? And if so, when does that happen?
- 29:55Speaker 4: You know, I think that all of the state judges
- 29:57Speaker 4: are hoping it does. In that no one's to want
- 30:00Speaker 4: to be the final word on this issue. The number
- 30:04Speaker 4: of the state judges have expressed concern, you know that
- 30:07Speaker 4: if one state does something that conflicts with what another
- 30:10Speaker 4: state does, that this causes, you know, a mass national
- 30:14Speaker 4: constitutional crisis. And there's been several exchanges where lawyers and
- 30:18Speaker 4: judges have said and hopefully, you know, if it becomes
- 30:22Speaker 4: really a problem, the US Supreme Court will just step
- 30:25Speaker 4: in and resolve all of this. You know, whatever the
- 30:28Speaker 4: state supreme courts do can be then taken to the justices,
- 30:33Speaker 4: and they don't obviously have to take it. But deciding
- 30:38Speaker 4: not to take a case is of course action in
- 30:40Speaker 4: and of itself. And if Donald Trump continues to win
- 30:44Speaker 4: in these cases, and the challengers petition the justices to intervene,
- 30:47Speaker 4: and they say, no, it really does end the fight.
- 30:50Speaker 4: There isn't much more they can do at that point.
- 30:53Speaker 4: So we're really waiting for these state supreme courts to
- 30:57Speaker 4: take enough action and then see if the challengers decide
- 31:01Speaker 4: that they want to take that next step of bringing
- 31:04Speaker 4: it to the justices.
- 31:06Speaker 3: So is there an argument that the Supreme Court should
- 31:08Speaker 3: decide this at the first available opportunity because it's it
- 31:11Speaker 3: isn't the case that certainty is better for everybody to
- 31:14Speaker 3: get it sooner rather than later.
- 31:16Speaker 4: Yeah, you know, one of the Colorado Supreme Court justices
- 31:19Speaker 4: made that point and asked, you know, what is the
- 31:21Speaker 4: point in waiting and potentially opening the door to far
- 31:25Speaker 4: more chaos if the electoral process gets farther along. You know,
- 31:31Speaker 4: why not just resolve all of these issues now? And
- 31:35Speaker 4: you know, there are overarching legal questions that Trump and
- 31:39Speaker 4: his campaign are saying. You know, these cases don't even
- 31:41Speaker 4: belong in court, So no one should get to the
- 31:44Speaker 4: question of its applicability to Donald Trump, and no one
- 31:47Speaker 4: should be deciding anything about January sixth, because they don't
- 31:51Speaker 4: belong in court.
- 31:52Speaker 2: At all.
- 31:52Speaker 4: So they're arguing that this needs to just end now.
- 31:57Speaker 4: But other folks are making the case that it's it's
- 32:00Speaker 4: out there and perhaps it would be better to get
- 32:03Speaker 4: some clarity before Americans head to the polls.
- 32:06Speaker 3: Undoubtedly a topic we will be talking about again and
- 32:10Speaker 3: perhaps frequently. That was Bloomberg News reporters Zoe Tillman. Zoe,
- 32:14Speaker 3: thanks so much for joining us. That's going to do
- 32:16Speaker 3: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm
- 32:19Speaker 3: Greg Storr.
- 32:20Speaker 5: And I'm Lydia Wheeler. Stay with us.
- 32:22Speaker 2: Top stories and global business headlines are coming up right now.