Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / Episode 102: NWSL Exodus: Reality or Overblown Myth? (Spoiler Alert, LDG Thinks the Latter) Naomi Girma, Jenna Nighswonger and more — The Women’s Soccer Podcast
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome back to the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 0:02I'm your host, Liam Greco.
- 0:03You may remember me better as LDG.
- 0:06Today, we're taking time to discuss a controversial topic
- 0:08within the women's soccer community,
- 0:10whether or not the NWSL exodus is a reality
- 0:13or an overblown myth.
- 0:15I guess I'm gonna spoil my opinion 16 seconds
- 0:18into the episode, but I hope you stay along to hear why.
- 0:20I think it's the latter.
- 0:22I first wanna start before I get into my justifications
- 0:25by explaining the problem.
- 0:27I really spent a lot of time thinking about this episode
- 0:31and how I wanted to frame it,
- 0:31because it's obviously been a very crazy off-season
- 0:35in the NWSL, along with all of the women's sports.
- 0:37The WNBA has been crazy.
- 0:39I don't know what's happening,
- 0:40what's in the air to make this whole year
- 0:42as crazy as it's been.
- 0:44But overall, for those who are lucky enough
- 0:46to not have had to deal with all of the influx of news,
- 0:50in this window, an increasing number of international stars
- 0:53have departed the NWSL for foreign opportunities.
- 0:56And this has left fans, and journalists alike,
- 0:59questioning the strength of the league to its competitors.
- 1:02I think a lot of the headlines that have been
- 1:05kind of rash decisions have really left me
- 1:07questioning my opinions on this.
- 1:09And I think I wanted to take the time to really
- 1:12plan out a thoughtful case for why I think,
- 1:15the way I do about this topic.
- 1:17Of course, Naomi Girma left the way for Chelsea
- 1:21on a world record.
- 1:22Jenna Nighswonger left the Gotham for Arsenal,
- 1:25and then three top Brazilians are the five players
- 1:28that we're gonna be talking about today.
- 1:29Of course, there were many other players
- 1:31who left the NWSL last season.
- 1:32That's not to say that they aren't as talented
- 1:35or deserve the coverage that these signings
- 1:39have gotten more of.
- 1:40But I think for today, these five case studies
- 1:43are the ones that I wanna talk about
- 1:44just to explain my thesis on the claim.
- 1:46And additionally, there's been links between European,
- 1:51specifically WSL clubs, to US Women's National Team stars,
- 1:54Sam Coffey and Trinity Rodman.
- 1:55And given all of this information that I've thrown at you
- 1:57in the first two minutes of the episode,
- 1:58you might have expected me to claim that these fans
- 2:01are valid in thinking that the NWSL exodus is a reality
- 2:05and it's something to be scared about.
- 2:07But these moves occurred for specific reasons
- 2:10that I don't think represent a league-wide trend
- 2:14that we should be fearing.
- 2:15I think if the NWSL doesn't continue to step up
- 2:18their standard when it comes to pay off the pitch,
- 2:21and then a lot of the other training environment aspects
- 2:25of a professional athlete that we can't see,
- 2:27which is why it's hard to obviously judge
- 2:30and compare clubs from Europe and abroad to American clubs
- 2:33when we, one, don't see them on the pitch
- 2:35in competitive environments ever,
- 2:37and two, it's hard to give an apples-to-apples comparison
- 2:40when they compete in completely different competitions.
- 2:43So I'm gonna try and avoid comparing
- 2:46in a way that we can't speak for certain enough,
- 2:48but I wanted to just talk about,
- 2:50before we get into the players that left,
- 2:52remind everyone that a lot of amazing players
- 2:55came to the NWSL last year.
- 2:57Before the season even started,
- 2:58players like Anne Couchen, Berger, Banda,
- 3:01Cho Binga, Oshweila, Fleming joined the league.
- 3:05And so much talent right there.
- 3:06I know Berger joined a little bit later,
- 3:08but it was before the summer linto.
- 3:09And then Santos had signed early on.
- 3:11She didn't obviously join until the summer.
- 3:14Cascavino, Arnold, Jess Carter, Rose Kowasi,
- 3:18Katie Zelim, Esa Morgan.
- 3:19These are top-class players
- 3:20that could've had opportunities overseas in England,
- 3:24in their home countries, or some of them in the WSL,
- 3:27or even Liga FA and many other opportunities,
- 3:29but they chose NWSL.
- 3:30And I think when we consider whether or not
- 3:33this exodus is real, we have to remember
- 3:35how many other people have come in as well.
- 3:37And though it's obviously disappointing
- 3:39for any league to lose a player of Germa's quality
- 3:42and much more, Germa wanted this move.
- 3:45She's in a very interesting wave environment right now,
- 3:49or well, she was before the move.
- 3:52The allegations surrounding the team are obviously severe
- 3:54in any player for their mental health, of course.
- 3:57Obviously, I don't wanna speak on behalf of her.
- 3:59I don't know how specific, what was going on
- 4:02had really been affecting her.
- 4:03But what we do know is, I'll stick to the facts,
- 4:05that she requested a trade early on this year,
- 4:07and I'm happy for her that she was able to find an environment
- 4:09that she seemed really excited to be on.
- 4:11I have always loved Chelsea women
- 4:14and what they've been doing for women's football.
- 4:16So I'm really excited to see her
- 4:18go to that training environment.
- 4:19So I'll just speak for that.
- 4:20And we might as well just start by talking about Germa,
- 4:23the world record move that has captivated American
- 4:27and European audiences alike on the pitch
- 4:29due to her performances in the Olympics more specifically.
- 4:32But overall, even at the Women's World Cup,
- 4:34where the US Women's National Team
- 4:36definitely didn't put their best foot forward,
- 4:38Germa was a rock in that back line for them
- 4:41alongside Julie Ertz in that two center back position.
- 4:45And I think for a player as young as Germa,
- 4:48who has mentioned her desire numerous times
- 4:50to play in Europe, considering the state of the wave right now,
- 4:53as I've alluded to, and also, I don't know if this is a factor
- 4:56that she considered, but this is not a horrible time
- 4:59to go over broad, politically speaking, or soccer wise.
- 5:03Politically, the climate of the US is not the best right now.
- 5:08It's very controversial, and a lot of horrible things
- 5:10are happening in this country.
- 5:12So if you had the opportunity to step away and play soccer
- 5:16against the best players in the world,
- 5:17I don't think you wouldn't do that either.
- 5:19And also, soccer wise, for a player like Ne,
- 5:22who's of such high quality, she wouldn't
- 5:23want to move so close to a major tournament.
- 5:25And now the Olympics, the World Cup, are behind her.
- 5:28She can go to Chelsea as there's no big tournaments
- 5:31for the women's players in the next few years of America.
- 5:34I'm going to be at the Euros this summer,
- 5:36and I will give amazing coverage of that.
- 5:38But unfortunately, we won't see players like Ne and Germa
- 5:40there for obvious reasons.
- 5:41So she will have time to make a move and adjust,
- 5:45which is the smartest thing to do if she was going
- 5:47to look to make a move.
- 5:48And even though it's always sad to see the world's best
- 5:50center back, in my opinion, leave the NWSL
- 5:52as someone like myself, and I feel like a lot of you,
- 5:54a lot of my listeners are Americans.
- 5:56I think you can all relate to this idea
- 5:57of being super protective of the NWSL
- 5:59and wanting for it to succeed.
- 6:01But I think the fact that it's gone to a point where players
- 6:04have choice in women's soccer besides staying in the NWSL
- 6:07will ultimately push the NWSL to be in a place
- 6:10where it has to compete for talent.
- 6:11It shouldn't just be a destination league.
- 6:16It shouldn't just be the default home
- 6:18for women's national team players.
- 6:19Players should be able to experience environments.
- 6:21And I think for Ne, she'll still mean
- 6:23only the thrilling competitive.
- 6:25The WSL is so much talent.
- 6:26I loved watching it in the NWSL offseason.
- 6:28To be frank, whenever the NWSL starts back up again,
- 6:31I usually slow down on the amount of WSL content
- 6:34on the pitch that I consume.
- 6:35But I still think that she'll be turning
- 6:37against some of the best players that she'll ultimately
- 6:40play against internationally with the women's national team.
- 6:42So this is a good move for all parties,
- 6:44except for the way I'd argue, although they
- 6:46got a pretty good fee considering that Ne has
- 6:48won it out for a while now.
- 6:49So that's just my quick little thoughts.
- 6:51This is the move I probably wrote the least about in my notes
- 6:54because I think you've all read a lot about it in the last few
- 6:57weeks.
- 6:57I wanted to keep it brief and give you my personal take.
- 7:00I'm really happy for Ne.
- 7:01She's such a great person.
- 7:02And on the pitch, obviously, she's
- 7:04one of the most talented players.
- 7:05Instead, the women's national team has had a center back
- 7:08role for a while now.
- 7:09I think it's unfair to ever compare players directly
- 7:12from different generations because Naomi
- 7:14Germa has things that Sauerbrunn doesn't have and vice versa.
- 7:16So I'm not going to say it's a direct for like switch.
- 7:20But at the end of the day, when players retire from the program
- 7:23and leaving with such storied careers like Becky Sauerbrunn
- 7:26has, it's great to know that there's players like Naomi
- 7:29Germa, Emily Sams, and Chana Davidson who are ready.
- 7:32They've been waiting on the sidelines
- 7:33to get even more of their moment after Naomi has been waiting.
- 7:36She's been doing just fine with Becky
- 7:39as playing with the US team as well.
- 7:41But overall, yeah, that's someone just that's on the group move.
- 7:44And I think for her to get a chance
- 7:46to go into new environment and test herself outside
- 7:49her comfort zone is going to be really great for the US team.
- 7:51And this is not a goodbye necessarily from the NNP cell.
- 7:54I'm sure she'll come back someday.
- 7:56But it's good for her to see that she is making the money
- 7:59that she deserves even though we don't
- 8:01know the details on it.
- 8:01It's great to see that clubs like Chelsea are investing
- 8:03in football and that will drive the growth of the game
- 8:05in general.
- 8:06Speaking of clubs investing in a center back and growing game,
- 8:09Tarciani moved to Lyon, who's one of the three resilient
- 8:12players I alluded to.
- 8:13She was first reported to be leaving
- 8:15by at least five American journalists by Theo Lohuise,
- 8:18a follower of the pod.
- 8:19So I wanted to give him that quick shout out there
- 8:21because it's great to see how many journalists have been
- 8:24really on the case all season with a lot of the moves
- 8:26as a fan.
- 8:27And from that perspective, at least,
- 8:29I love seeing all of the transfer members.
- 8:32I think everyone loves all the fun that comes with it,
- 8:35especially when it's not your own team.
- 8:36But I think for Tarciani, she's such a talented player.
- 8:38She came in to the dash for a reported fee of around,
- 8:40I think, $50,000.
- 8:43And they recouped almost double that.
- 8:45So in such a short time period, Tarciani definitely
- 8:48raised her stock, I think, from that silver medal performance
- 8:51at the Olympics and all three players
- 8:53that I'm going to talk about.
- 8:54I think winning a silver medal or a gold medal
- 8:56definitely did not dissuade European bidders.
- 9:00But overall, Tarciani is a tall center back.
- 9:03She's very agile.
- 9:04She over six foot frame.
- 9:05But she's so good at her feet.
- 9:07She's really comfortable in possession,
- 9:09strong player who is willing to put a tackle in.
- 9:12I will say sometimes she flops a little too much.
- 9:14But that just might be my American bias from the gold
- 9:16medal match showing.
- 9:17Overall, I think it's great to see owners like Michelle Kang,
- 9:20who we've seen her investment with Washington Spirit.
- 9:23Now we're seeing with Olympic Lyon.
- 9:24I've seen some of the comments that she's
- 9:26made about Lyon not making as much money as they should
- 9:29for the club that they are.
- 9:30But I think of all sports in general,
- 9:34women's sports is still in its not startup phase,
- 9:37but its growing phase.
- 9:38There's still a lot of room to grow.
- 9:40And I think the fact that these owners,
- 9:42like Chelsky's owners and Michelle Kang at Olympic Lyon,
- 9:45have invested into their clubs like they have
- 9:47is really going to push NWSL's game.
- 9:49So I know Michelle is also an amazing owner
- 9:51of the Washington Spirit, who were the finalist last year
- 9:53at the NWSL.
- 9:54But I love to see that it's not just the NWSL,
- 9:56it's not a one horse race.
- 9:58Because I think, as I think Sam Lewis is someone who
- 10:00alluded to this the other day, it's only
- 10:02going to make everyone better.
- 10:04She mentioned that in Lumen's Game podcast.
- 10:05So you should have to check that out if you haven't listened.
- 10:07Sam's a great journalist in this field who's inspired me a lot.
- 10:11But overall, I think the league will
- 10:13be pushed by players like Tarciani going overseas.
- 10:16Because now they're going to have to try and get
- 10:18more of that Brazilian talent into the league,
- 10:20or any other talent into the league.
- 10:22And I think, yeah, it really goes, my same logic applies.
- 10:25I think you never want a player to stay at a club where they
- 10:28don't want to be there.
- 10:29I think even though, of course, we've seen,
- 10:31there's a lot of controversy.
- 10:32I keep making WNBA analogies with Marina
- 10:36at the Connecticut Sun right now.
- 10:39And she who has to trade in the club's not trading her team.
- 10:42Sorry, not a basketball fan.
- 10:43But I think there's a lot of balancing factors with any move.
- 10:49Every party wants to be satisfied.
- 10:51And I think it's really great to see that in both these instances,
- 10:54the player is able to make the move that they wanted to make.
- 10:56The club is able to recoup the cash
- 10:58that they needed to make for a player of that talent.
- 11:00And it is a business at the end of the day.
- 11:02And it's obviously not the most comfortable thing
- 11:05to attach these public price values to players,
- 11:07which is why I try not to luge them in these episodes as much.
- 11:10But yeah, I think Tarciani is a great talent who will certainly
- 11:13show her abilities.
- 11:15I think with Randy Barnard getting up there,
- 11:17and she still has such a great talent,
- 11:19I think the partnership of Tarciani and Vanessa Gilles
- 11:24in the future is going to be so good.
- 11:25Because we all know Vanessa Gilles is never
- 11:27coming back in needle study.
- 11:28I'm sorry, ACFC fans at this point.
- 11:30The writing's kind of on the wall there.
- 11:32But I think it's good to see the investment against similar
- 11:35rhetoric to what I was saying about Gurma
- 11:36when it comes to the Tarciani move.
- 11:38And I can't wait to see her impact in the latter stage
- 11:40of the Champions League.
- 11:41Naomi Gurma wasn't the only American
- 11:43to head England and London.
- 11:45This January, Trans-Rondo did a nice walker
- 11:48of Gotham FC, who as a season ticket holder of my local club,
- 11:52I got to see her play very consistently
- 11:55from her first professional match
- 11:57to her second season of Gotham, where in my opinion,
- 12:00she was a little bit weaker than her first season.
- 12:03I thought her first year was significantly better
- 12:05than the team.
- 12:06She's an incredible offensive fullback.
- 12:07But as the season went on, especially in the second year,
- 12:10I felt like she got exploited a lot
- 12:14for her lack of previous defensive abilities
- 12:19and responsibilities in the field.
- 12:21And she got beat down the line so much.
- 12:23And she only became such a liability for the team
- 12:27that one ended up starting Mandy Freeman, who
- 12:30was playing amazing soccer right away over her
- 12:33for the playoff matches.
- 12:34And I want to preface that I'm a huge Genna fan who
- 12:37rates her game significantly in a lot of ergas.
- 12:40I feel like defensive is definitely something
- 12:43that she can improve on.
- 12:44And we're going to get into some numbers that
- 12:46don't look great for Genna in a minute.
- 12:48But I think that she's such a great player.
- 12:50And I'm really super excited to see
- 12:52what she has with Renee at Arsenal.
- 12:54And I think her development is going to be great.
- 12:55And I always like to have a sex.
- 12:57And I feel like talking about the numbers that aren't as kind,
- 13:02but I guess they're the numbers.
- 13:04So you've got to look at them.
- 13:06And I think I'll start by talking about the playoff game.
- 13:09And I think one moment should never
- 13:11define a player's two-year career for club.
- 13:13But she came in a second half sub
- 13:15after Mandy Freeman locked down Tritney Rodman
- 13:20with her mature and intelligent play.
- 13:22But Genna made a reckless foul defensively,
- 13:25that legendary kick that ultimately
- 13:27caused the game to tangle.
- 13:28And even though Gotham was the weaker team in the playoff game,
- 13:31it should not have come down to that.
- 13:33And I was really disappointed in Genna's play
- 13:35when she ultimately missed a penalty kick and the shootout.
- 13:38There's a lot of issues there.
- 13:39And I think overall, it was just like a gut punch
- 13:42from the whole team that that performance is really not
- 13:45the best.
- 13:45But yeah, thinking more holistically,
- 13:49Gotham's fee that they received, according to Meg Glenahan,
- 13:52I trust her journalism very much so, was $100,000.
- 13:56Which honestly, my first reaction is, that's really low.
- 14:00For a player who's super young, US women's national experience,
- 14:04gold medalist, and it really was interesting to me
- 14:07that Gotham did not get more for Genna.
- 14:10I feel like for a player like Jaze Bryan,
- 14:13who looked for a much higher fee, I wonder if Genna's
- 14:16defensive abilities that were exploited not only at club
- 14:18level for Gotham, but also in US women's national team
- 14:22friendlies against Netherlands, I wonder if that maybe would
- 14:25have been a worry for Arsenal.
- 14:27And that might have led them to move over to the midfield,
- 14:29higher up the field instead.
- 14:30Who knows?
- 14:30We don't know inside of the minds of the Arsenal management
- 14:32team, so we can't make any accurate guesses.
- 14:34But even though I might not be keen on a tennis defense,
- 14:37her offensive value is why, at least I think so,
- 14:41Arsenal was willing to overlook some of her previous defensive
- 14:44roles, because she's still a really young player,
- 14:45and she's a lot of pieces to play for top sides,
- 14:48but she just needs a little bit of time and direction
- 14:51to grow and to become a more complete player.
- 14:54And I think, I've been saying this for a while on the show,
- 14:56outside of the show, that Genna should not
- 14:58have been a fullback from day one.
- 15:00I mean, she was subbed in after Krieger got injured in that ACFC
- 15:03home opener in 2023, home opener, sorry, away game,
- 15:06first game of the season.
- 15:07And I felt like it was never a position that
- 15:11was going to be beneficial for her long term,
- 15:13because she's a 10 in college.
- 15:15That was her position.
- 15:16She's an attacking player.
- 15:17She loves to get up the field.
- 15:18And that was very much a part of her game,
- 15:21but I felt it wasn't exactly getting the best out of her.
- 15:25And I feel like she could have been
- 15:27playing in a different role.
- 15:28And I think this move hopefully will give her the flexibility
- 15:31to move into wider spaces, sure.
- 15:33And she's done that with Arsenal so far,
- 15:35though it's a small sample size of two games,
- 15:37but also not have to worry about some of those defensive skills.
- 15:40And she'll still grow playing with players like Lea Valti
- 15:43in the midfield, Guy R. Kouni-Cross
- 15:45is another young talent.
- 15:47She won't have to be as rely on the skill.
- 15:49She can use her creative 10 skills in the midfield.
- 15:52And I really have loved how Arsenal's used her so far.
- 15:55And I think it's important to say that her statistics
- 15:57against fullbacks, though the fullbackism usually
- 16:00can be not as offensive as a midfielder.
- 16:03Her stats are great offensively, 98% in through balls,
- 16:0795% in crosses in the penalty box, 80% in shot greeting
- 16:10actions, which are all positive thing
- 16:12and figures for Garnet's fans.
- 16:14Defensive stats were not as great.
- 16:15They were like the orange area and to red sometimes.
- 16:19So of course those areas for her to grow,
- 16:21but she's a great person.
- 16:22And I have like wishing her all the best luck.
- 16:25I've had the fortunate pleasure of meeting her
- 16:27multiple times over the last few years,
- 16:29taking three or four times through different events.
- 16:31And she's just an amazing person and player.
- 16:34And I can't wait to see her continue to grow even more.
- 16:36And I can have those same wishes for our next player,
- 16:38Caroline, who left for Man City from North Carolina courage
- 16:43during the three-agency period this year.
- 16:45Caroline's been linked with European clubs,
- 16:48specifically ManTest United was one of them ones that
- 16:50was highly on her radar before her ACL injury,
- 16:53after her incredible performances in the 2022 season,
- 16:56and then the World Cup.
- 16:57Definitely amped that conversation up.
- 17:01The Courageous evolving playstyle
- 17:02meant that bringing a player like Jade and Shaw,
- 17:05and this might be controversial, but hear me out,
- 17:07who's a more flexible nine and 10.
- 17:09I think she's not bold to be a nine,
- 17:11but she can score goals and she's super creative.
- 17:13And at the end of the day,
- 17:14Neyhaas isn't like a nine like Caroline.
- 17:16I think we've seen the Courageous growth
- 17:19with Caroline off the field.
- 17:20And I think they still missed her last season
- 17:22and they need someone that could score goals consistently.
- 17:24But I think Kara has wanted, has expressed a desire
- 17:28to play in a club that was in Europe.
- 17:32She wants to win the Champions League.
- 17:33And then it's a global market that's really competitive
- 17:36and that's great for the sport.
- 17:37And there's never a real reason whatsoever
- 17:39to keep player captive in an environment
- 17:42that they're not interested in.
- 17:43Caroline's a pre-agent.
- 17:44She is her prerogative to choose where she wants to play.
- 17:47And I think Courage fans and the club itself
- 17:50would have much rather preferred to garner fees
- 17:53for players like Caroline and Rumi,
- 17:54who we've talked about in the series of off season moves
- 17:57which you should listen to if you haven't,
- 17:58episodes 99, 97, 98, 99.
- 18:02And I will say at least the good news for Courage fans,
- 18:05it doesn't seem like losing these players for free
- 18:08has impeded on their ability to get top players
- 18:11this off season.
- 18:12They signed Jaden Shaw for over $500,000
- 18:15considering all fees.
- 18:16And I've talked a lot about her in this part,
- 18:17even though I talked about her more
- 18:19in one of our previous episodes
- 18:20because she feels like the person
- 18:21that they invested in a lot
- 18:23knowing that Caroline was gone
- 18:24to try and replace and replicate that goalscoring ability.
- 18:27She's a 20 year old who's the present
- 18:31and she's now in the future.
- 18:32And I think losing her like Caroline obviously sucks
- 18:35for everyone, the NWSL, the Courage,
- 18:37but to look at Jaden Shaw is not too out of the draw either.
- 18:41She's one of my favorite players in the NWSL in the world.
- 18:43And I think in fact,
- 18:45maybe this isn't as big of a thing,
- 18:47but Messi chose her for one of the different product drops
- 18:51that speaks volumes to how a lot of people on the world,
- 18:55the greatest football brains in that 10 role
- 18:57have seen J as such a strong player,
- 19:00not on a first name basis, so,
- 19:01whole art Shaw in this episode.
- 19:03But I think Caroline going back to her
- 19:05is a top player who will get back to full fitness
- 19:09and get more minutes and be more productive in the pitch
- 19:12than she was last season for the Courage
- 19:14where she was still like coming back from the injuries.
- 19:15I think obviously losing Carol sucks
- 19:18considering that it didn't exactly end with her
- 19:21being able to be at her best self and Nerumi left as well,
- 19:24but they got Koyama for a quarter of a million dollars
- 19:27after her good performance in the U-20 World Cup.
- 19:30They've got it Shaw and they really had attacking
- 19:33placements lined up for the players they've lost.
- 19:35So again, it's always about honoring the players requests
- 19:38and the Courage didn't really have the ability
- 19:41to prevent her when she's a free agent,
- 19:42but I think it's good to see from a perspective
- 19:45that they were able to do the smart business
- 19:47and personal decision, which we love.
- 19:49And I can't wait to see Caroline play
- 19:52in the Women's Super League.
- 19:53The next player, I don't know how we're gonna be able
- 19:54to watch her in Saudi League.
- 19:55I know some of their games are on his own,
- 19:57but I feel a little like he's supporting anything
- 20:00with Saudi Arabia.
- 20:02It's Adriana.
- 20:03Adriana is a player who has many clutch moments,
- 20:05the pride over the last few years.
- 20:07She scored nine goals, though only in 31 afters,
- 20:11which is not a very consistent basis with 62 caps.
- 20:15And at 28 years old, Adriana is in the peak of her career.
- 20:17You would have expected that if she left the pride
- 20:19of the NB cell, it would have been for a European club,
- 20:21but no, it's quite shocking to see her move
- 20:23to the Saudi League.
- 20:24And I think the money is definitely a factor
- 20:28for a lot of players to go to Saudi Arabia.
- 20:30I was quite not confident, but I wouldn't be surprised.
- 20:35I will say, like when I heard the rumblings
- 20:38of people potentially considering going there
- 20:40with the immense contract that they were offering,
- 20:43I'm surprised any player though,
- 20:44who's an open member of the LGBTQ community,
- 20:47because I've added this multiple times, guys,
- 20:49don't worry, to move to a country
- 20:51that holds a large president prejudiced against that group,
- 20:54to say the very least.
- 20:55And even though on the pitch, obviously,
- 20:58she'll be great for them.
- 20:59She's such a talented player for Brazil.
- 21:02She's in a high-XG creator who lacked clinicality
- 21:05in the final third.
- 21:06And I don't think that she had the ability
- 21:10to make the right pass often.
- 21:11I felt like a lot of the times,
- 21:13she was quite wasteful in games at points,
- 21:16and ultimately that led to the Pride.
- 21:18Looking at other options,
- 21:20Ali Watt started a lot in the quarterfinals specifically,
- 21:24but I think that they were really flexible at the Pride
- 21:27and who they started and they've broadened people
- 21:31who are ready to get more minutes.
- 21:32Doril is coming back with, after a great year last year,
- 21:36Charlie is coming back from injury,
- 21:38and then they signed Azzamine International
- 21:40from the Mexican league.
- 21:41Chilufa, sorry, I completely butchered that pronunciation.
- 21:44I'll work on that before the season.
- 21:46And she's a talented player for the Pride,
- 21:49so fans might be disappointed,
- 21:50even though I would say she was still quite compactful,
- 21:53played a lot of minutes as a team.
- 21:54She didn't obviously have the bandit impact
- 21:56that Barbara Bandit did for the team last year,
- 22:01but I think Adriana is a big game player
- 22:03who was a part of the Pride's identity,
- 22:05but winning teams can't just stay the same.
- 22:07They need to change.
- 22:08And although maybe too much change isn't the best,
- 22:11we saw it off-gossom last year,
- 22:13I think making some moves to better the team,
- 22:16not just now but for the future, is the right thing,
- 22:17and allowing Adriana to pursue this opportunity
- 22:19that she was interested in is ultimately the best.
- 22:22So wish her the best of luck in Saudi Arabia,
- 22:24even though that's quite surprising to me.
- 22:26That was the first of the portion of our episode.
- 22:28Now I wanna get into the overall league talk.
- 22:30We talked about five moves
- 22:31that were maybe not the best news for NB cell fans,
- 22:35but I wanted to tackle the big question,
- 22:37is the NB cell still the best league in the world?
- 22:39And I'm gonna say my most honest answer,
- 22:41I think it is from a competitive standpoint,
- 22:43from a viewing standpoint,
- 22:44if I had to choose between watching any league in the world,
- 22:47I would choose NB cell.
- 22:48If you put Chelsea versus Gotham,
- 22:51I know the friendlies were arbitrary,
- 22:53and Gotham lost 3-1, Spirit lost 2-1 to Arsenal,
- 22:57Bay lost 5-2 to Barcelona,
- 22:58and now their team are at full strength,
- 23:01and any of those friendlies, I do think, sorry,
- 23:03Chelsea would be Gotham most days.
- 23:05I think the fact that they're in an ecosystem
- 23:08where they're not restrained by a salary cap
- 23:11definitely helps those clubs to the top,
- 23:13but ultimately for the health of the whole league,
- 23:15I look at teams in that league
- 23:17that draw barely 1,000 fans a game,
- 23:18and it's lack of professionalism
- 23:21that we have in the United States,
- 23:22the fact that we average 10,000 fans a game,
- 23:24it's great that Arsenal are doing what they're doing,
- 23:26but the fact that there's so much talent in the WSL
- 23:28that play in front of 3,000, 4,000 fans a game,
- 23:31it's really ridiculous to see, I think.
- 23:33I've seen a lot of reactions for people
- 23:35who have now gotten interest in Chelsea
- 23:38from the Grimaceinings,
- 23:39are shocked to see the stadium that they play at,
- 23:41and I'm like, yep, we've been watching there for years,
- 23:43it's hard to even get good camera angles at that stadium,
- 23:46and I think the league at the end of the WSL
- 23:49is professionally so far ahead of most of the league.
- 23:52I think there's no way around it.
- 23:54I think it's great to see that more WSL clubs
- 23:57are playing at the club's main stadiums.
- 23:59I think the fact that the Emirates is hosting
- 24:01the majority of Arsenal's home games is great,
- 24:02but that's one club, and for a league to be successful,
- 24:05there needs to be more business success than one club.
- 24:08I think the business of the NB cell teams is much bigger.
- 24:11So that's my personal opinion on the pitch.
- 24:13I think watching Chelsea play Lyon,
- 24:16yeah, it's hard to beat that,
- 24:18but best league in the world,
- 24:20the Champions League's not a league,
- 24:21it's a collection of leagues, the best team's there.
- 24:23I think the NB cell's the best league,
- 24:24and now brings me to the point,
- 24:27how can the NB cell keep and retain
- 24:28the world's best talent?
- 24:30So there's a lot of different mechanisms
- 24:32that have floated around.
- 24:33I think the designated player role is probably my favorite
- 24:35because I'll get into the salary cap in a minute.
- 24:39I think the salary cap obviously is annoying
- 24:41for clubs like Angel City and Washington Spirit,
- 24:43who would spend literally as much money as they need to
- 24:47to build an invisible side if they could.
- 24:50But I do think the salary cap does keep some order.
- 24:53I think if teams are lightweight, sorry,
- 24:56I'm not gonna name names in this episode,
- 24:58but they should be not given a raft
- 25:02to help that be one of the swimmery sink.
- 25:05And the situation is professional sports,
- 25:06it's a cut road environment, and if the league's growing,
- 25:09you don't need that old friend to hold you back, right?
- 25:12And that's what the league is getting this intersection
- 25:14of a lot of historic clubs that are great for the league,
- 25:18right, but they need new owners and sin.
- 25:20But all in all, I think the designated player role
- 25:23is a good opportunity because it keeps the parity,
- 25:25but also clubs may not use the designated player role.
- 25:29I mean, we just talked, I think it's no secret,
- 25:30we talked with Becky Morgan on the show,
- 25:32which is a great episode if you haven't heard already
- 25:34about Louisville's financial ability.
- 25:36So they can still stay somewhat competitive
- 25:38if the salary cap's in place, but the designated player role,
- 25:41only clubs that really wanna spend will spend on that,
- 25:44and they'll get the best players, and that's how it'll go.
- 25:46And I think the parity will still be there in some way.
- 25:49I think the salary cap is a main,
- 25:52keeping parity, obviously, our cap isn't a perfect system,
- 25:55but I don't think that abolishing it
- 25:57is the right situation.
- 25:58I think testing out other mechanisms
- 26:01like the designated player role
- 26:02would be my personal selection of how we address this.
- 26:05I think it wouldn't just be used to keep players, right?
- 26:09Samuels mentioned this on the women's game,
- 26:11and I'll build off of this, right?
- 26:13She used Bunny Shaw as an example.
- 26:15A player like Bunny Shaw would probably be much more
- 26:17appealing to come to that end of the sale
- 26:19if she can make a million dollars in the club compare
- 26:21however much she wanted,
- 26:22and however much they wanted to give her
- 26:24outside of the salary cap,
- 26:25and they could still build around the other part
- 26:27of the salary cap.
- 26:28I think Louisville could look towards MLS for this
- 26:30because the DP rule is not a novel concept.
- 26:33The MLS as of today gives each team three DP spots
- 26:38with their tradable assets,
- 26:39just like international spots in the NWSL.
- 26:41And I think if you gave every team, say, three DP spots,
- 26:44the salary cap would still be really the same,
- 26:47but you'd be able to give players more money
- 26:49because you're able to spread it out on fewer players,
- 26:51because instead of having to use the salary cap
- 26:53on hypothetically 26 players,
- 26:56if you used all three DP spots,
- 26:58then it would only have to be on 23 players.
- 27:00And then the other three would just be outside of the cap,
- 27:02and that would probably be your three highest paid players
- 27:05because you wouldn't want to have them impede
- 27:08on your salary caps.
- 27:09And I feel like it would be really good
- 27:11for the NWSL as a whole.
- 27:12What will convince players from Germany
- 27:14who have the German national team from England,
- 27:16more of those people to come to the NWSL?
- 27:18Right, we've seen players,
- 27:19I don't know, again, these are just two examples,
- 27:21but I keep using them again and again.
- 27:23Berger and Cardo came to Gotham, my hometown club,
- 27:26and I saw, again, firsthand,
- 27:28the impact that the two of them made on the defense.
- 27:30The defense at Gotham was very good before,
- 27:32but those two made it great.
- 27:34And I think having more players that would come
- 27:36to the NWSL, of course, Berger came
- 27:37because it was a good option for a career
- 27:39to get more minutes.
- 27:40Cardo came due to her romantic association with Berger,
- 27:44but at the end of the day,
- 27:44they both benefited professionally from it.
- 27:46Cardo's getting more starts of England
- 27:48thanks to her time in the NWSL.
- 27:49So the NWSL is to view this as a very good league,
- 27:52which is a misconception that many European fans have
- 27:54by the international managers.
- 27:56And I think more players, like for instance, Kira Walsh,
- 27:59I think would be much more compelled to go across the sea
- 28:03and come to the NWSL if she could make a lot more money
- 28:06than what she would make me at Arsenal, say,
- 28:09or Chelsea with her new move there.
- 28:11And I think it really speaks volumes
- 28:14to how this league could grow.
- 28:15And if the NWSL is really serious,
- 28:16Jessica, remember, you're somehow listening to this.
- 28:19If you mean the talk to make this
- 28:22and be the best league in the world and keep it there,
- 28:24because I think it is there right now, for now,
- 28:26it's been nice that you're skating on,
- 28:29you need to actually walk the walk
- 28:31and give these teams a way to invest.
- 28:33You have owners like Angel City and Washington Spirits
- 28:36and many, many more who are so invested in their teams
- 28:39and they would spend a lot more money on your players.
- 28:41Players like Banda, Trini Rodman
- 28:44are all free agents this off season.
- 28:46If you don't introduce a DP rule,
- 28:47you could see them do the same exact thing as Germa.
- 28:50This league is built on stars like any sport.
- 28:52And when spars walk, you can keep your parity.
- 28:55But what's better?
- 28:57Having a league full of, you know, not bad players,
- 29:00but like a league without the biggest stars that's even,
- 29:03or a league that has a lot of the best stars
- 29:05of the whole world, not just the US women's national team,
- 29:08there might be a little imbalance.
- 29:09Even right now at the salary cap, there's still imbalance.
- 29:11If you look at last season's table,
- 29:13the difference between the Dash and the Orlando
- 29:15probably was enormous.
- 29:16And I think it speaks volumes to how it's not just
- 29:19about the salary cap being in place,
- 29:20it's the investment that needs to be there across the board
- 29:23from all 14.
- 29:24And in the next season, 16 owners
- 29:26with Denver and Boston coming in 2026.
- 29:28So that's my personal opinion on that.
- 29:30And I wanted to end the episode by talking about
- 29:33in a more positive light this off season,
- 29:35because a lot of good players have come
- 29:36into the league in general.
- 29:37So before we go into some of those figures,
- 29:40I wanted to ask,
- 29:41do you have more talent left the league
- 29:43than entered at this off season?
- 29:44I would say even though most of the top tier players
- 29:48that were in the league have stayed,
- 29:51yes, some have left.
- 29:52And the players that have left are stars, right?
- 29:54We can admit that Naomi Gurma is one of the faces of the league.
- 29:58But I don't think the quality on the pitch
- 29:59will be diminished that much.
- 30:01And that doesn't speak to what I think of Gurma.
- 30:03I think if you've listened to any episode of this podcast,
- 30:06quite frankly, you'll know how highly I think of Gurma
- 30:08and how it was a monstrosity that she wasn't selected
- 30:12for the Ballon d'Or shortlist whatsoever.
- 30:14She could have been top five, top 10 on that, in my opinion.
- 30:16But nevertheless, I think there's so much talent in the league
- 30:18and it goes beyond just a few players.
- 30:20And so even though it's obviously really sad to lose them
- 30:22from a Pizl perspective,
- 30:23there's a lot of good internationals who joined the league this off season,
- 30:26a lot of good rookies who joined the league this off season
- 30:27instead of going overseas.
- 30:28And that should be viewed as a positive because who knows,
- 30:31maybe the future Naomi Gurma is lying somewhere in there.
- 30:34And, you know, I said that these comparisons are harmful
- 30:36and we shouldn't be comparing players.
- 30:37And I still stand by that.
- 30:39But you got the idea that there's so much talent in the league
- 30:41and the fact that the international clubs like Chelsea and Lyon
- 30:46are paying huge fees for NAB style players
- 30:49represents how much talent there was in the last season.
- 30:51And that the idea of NAB being a retirement league
- 30:55that was starting by multiple European women's soccer fans is ridiculous.
- 30:58It's the best league in the world, top to bottom.
- 31:00And until what more happens, nothing will change me at that.
- 31:03Players come and go from a team just like they will from a league
- 31:06in a global market.
- 31:07And that's the nature of the sport.
- 31:09And let's get into some of those top tier players,
- 31:11because even though you know their names,
- 31:13like you know Naomi Gurma's name and Dinah Niles-Longer's name,
- 31:16they'll still make impact this year and you should look at them
- 31:18as players to be on the watch for this year.
- 31:20So talking on some international players,
- 31:23we by the way, we've gone into many of these players
- 31:25in our signings through episodes 97 and 99.
- 31:27We've talked about a lot of these players in moving to the NAB cell.
- 31:30So if you haven't listened already, we talked about this first player,
- 31:32Julie Duflois, in one of those episodes.
- 31:35We have 99, 98 and 97 are all episodes about these players.
- 31:41Julie Duflois is the way we talked about episode 98.
- 31:43And she's going to be a great player that's coming into the league.
- 31:46There's so much talent.
- 31:47Gabby Portillo is another player joining the league this offseason.
- 31:50She's in episode 99.
- 31:51Lorena Aisha Suarez-Ola, Gia Corley, Alana Kendi,
- 31:56Shion Mikooma, Ken Zadali, Nuria Rabono,
- 32:00Miyabi Moria, Ohani Hernandez, and potentially Rebecca Vernal
- 32:04are all in their nationals.
- 32:05They're coming into the league.
- 32:06That's a pretty good list of players that I acknowledge.
- 32:09Half of those names are probably butchered.
- 32:10So sorry in advance for that.
- 32:12But that's a pretty good list of players.
- 32:14And look at the rookies that have come in.
- 32:16There's many more than this, of course.
- 32:17But I chose 10 that really stuck out to me.
- 32:19Byers, McManon, Courtenell, Maisie Hodge, Lee Real, Kaya Harper,
- 32:25Maddie DeLeon, Pietra Tordon, Taylor Huff, Trinity Armstrong, Maggie Graham,
- 32:30Hannah Baybar.
- 32:32These are players that played in top conferences.
- 32:34A lot of them were on Duke at some point in their career, UCLA,
- 32:38or at Texas, like Trinity Byers, UNC, their cop from top colleges.
- 32:43Kaya Harper is one I threw in there as a Gotham signing.
- 32:46He may not be as known as someone like Byers or Real,
- 32:48but she got 20 goals for the University of Minnesota.
- 32:50So there's the Gophers star alongside many other rookies.
- 32:53There's lots of talent in this league to look forward to joining.
- 32:56And I'm really excited to see these players find a way
- 32:59to make their impact in this side.
- 33:01And so there's a lot of talent in the NDB cell,
- 33:03but there's also a lot of talent in Europe.
- 33:05And even though a lot of came into the NDB cell,
- 33:07a lot of European teams drank from their rosters.
- 33:10And so multiple users on our social platforms,
- 33:13including one on Blue Scott, asked Quincy88,
- 33:16who asked directly about the Club World Cup that's upcoming.
- 33:20And I wanted to respond to their request.
- 33:23And basically, my answer is that a lot of talent in the world
- 33:28is present and spread across multiple different continents.
- 33:32I think it's not just the Europe and European leagues,
- 33:34and it's not just that in the NDB cell.
- 33:36League MX Women is a great example
- 33:38of how there's a lot of talent that
- 33:40resides outside of the traditional footballing
- 33:42countries that we've looked at.
- 33:44And I think the Women's Cup's been
- 33:46a great example that's been hosted.
- 33:47This year, it was in Kansas City and Louisville.
- 33:49And there's a lot of talent in those quarterfinals
- 33:52that come from smaller countries that
- 33:54don't have well-known players, but they
- 33:56would compete with NDB cell sides.
- 33:58And it speaks volumes to the talent that there is.
- 34:00See, I'm really excited on paper for the idea of a Club World
- 34:02Cup because of how much talent there is out there.
- 34:05But one thing that I really am worried about
- 34:08is how it will be managed.
- 34:10Usually, the summer is a time where players can take a break,
- 34:15especially when there's not a big international tournament.
- 34:17And I'm worried about fixture congestion also,
- 34:19considering the schedules don't align
- 34:21for European and American clubs.
- 34:24The sacrifices that NDB cell teams
- 34:26would have to make to participate
- 34:27in that tournament is something I really worry about.
- 34:29If two or so teams, for instance,
- 34:31participate in the Club World Cup, well,
- 34:33how would that affect their seasons?
- 34:34Would it be on hold?
- 34:35What would happen?
- 34:36There's not enough clarity there yet.
- 34:38So I'm cautiously optimistic is my idea with this tournament.
- 34:42I think it's going to be a fun concept on paper.
- 34:45And it's going to obviously be fun to watch all the matches.
- 34:47I don't think it'll be a perfect indicator of success
- 34:50for these sides because at the end of the day,
- 34:53it's just a snapshot of their talent.
- 34:55And it's going to be fun from the perspective of,
- 34:58I think, a lot of players from teams
- 35:00that wouldn't have gotten the platform to show their talent
- 35:02could get it.
- 35:03If an American club plays aside from South America or Africa
- 35:07or an Asian team, outside of Europe,
- 35:09there's obviously a real lack, unfortunately,
- 35:12of coverage of women's football.
- 35:14I think the A-League in Australia
- 35:15does a pretty good job, Australia and New Zealand.
- 35:17So those continents usually have more representation
- 35:22in the NDB cell side due to the fact
- 35:23that it's a lot easier to scout.
- 35:25And obviously, it's getting a lot better.
- 35:26Players like Tamu Atuiga and Barbara Banda
- 35:28were the two top goal scorers last year.
- 35:30And they come from small countries in Africa.
- 35:32And I think it really speaks volumes
- 35:34to the importance of trusting talent
- 35:36from different countries and ensuring
- 35:38that scouting is holistic.
- 35:40And I think this tournament could
- 35:41be a great way to do that.
- 35:42That's one of the more optimistic viewpoints
- 35:44I think I've had about this tournament.
- 35:46I think it's a lot of worries when
- 35:48it comes to the overload of on players, physically
- 35:51and mentally.
- 35:52So I hope that it's done in a smart way.
- 35:54But yeah, to answer your question,
- 35:56I'm really excited for the tournament as a whole.
- 35:57I think there could be some logistical issues
- 36:00that FIFA is going to have to work out.
- 36:01And I don't know how much I trust FIFA to do that.
- 36:04But overall, I'm really hopeful for the tournament.
- 36:07Again, cautious of the optimistic.
- 36:09And I can't wait to see so many clubs that we've
- 36:11known to love, the players that are the stars of this game
- 36:14and the future stars of this game
- 36:16that maybe we don't even know about right now
- 36:17go up against each other in that tournament.
- 36:20So thanks so much for submitting your question.
- 36:22And thanks so much for everyone who's
- 36:24listened to this episode.
- 36:25I hope that you can be like this listener
- 36:27and follow us on social media.
- 36:29And maybe you'll submit some questions of your own
- 36:31that we would love here at the Women's Soccer Podcast
- 36:33to answer.
- 36:34At that time, after you follow us on Instagram,
- 36:36follow us over at your podcast to make sure you
- 36:38don't miss an episode.
- 36:39Because if we do answer your question,
- 36:41make sure you don't want to miss that.
- 36:42And while you're at it, we'll give a five star
- 36:44review and tell all your friends about the show.
- 36:45It means the world to us as it really
- 36:47helps us to expand this community of women's soccer
- 36:49fans that we love to grow.
- 36:51We're hoping to be a really open community that's
- 36:53accepting to others and that really
- 36:55captures the essence of the world's most beautiful game
- 36:58and the fans that keep it alive.
- 37:00So that's what our goal is with the show.
- 37:02It's really never been about numerical success.
- 37:06Obviously, getting to 100 episodes is great and all.
- 37:08But I love seeing the impact that this show has on you all
- 37:11and meeting you all at games.
- 37:12It's been so much fun.
- 37:13So this is for the 102nd time, LDG signing off.
- 37:17Peace out and see you next time.
- 37:18Bye.