Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 72: Iran Threatens Hormuz Shipping as Nuclear Deal Stalls
Transcript
- 0:16The ceasefire is holding tenuously.
- 0:19A French shipping Giants vessel was attacked while transiting
- 0:22the Strait of Hormuz, injuring crew members and damaging the
- 0:25ship. The UAE engaged 2 Iranian
- 0:28ballistic missiles and three drones on Friday.
- 0:31Bahrain arrested 41 people alleged to have links to Iran's
- 0:35Revolutionary Guard Corps. Iran's foreign ministry said on
- 0:39Friday is not paying attention to deadlines.
- 0:42Iran's army added on Saturday that states complying with U.S.
- 0:45sanctions may face difficulties transiting the Strait of Hormuz,
- 0:49a direct threat at countries honoring the blockade, which
- 0:52includes most of Iran's major pre war oil customers.
- 0:56An unnamed Iranian official said the supreme leader is in
- 0:58complete health and will eventually appear in public.
- 1:01The first public statement about Khamenei's fiscal status since
- 1:05the war began 72 days ago. Pakistan's Prime Minister said
- 1:09his country is in contact with the United States and Iran day
- 1:13and night, and Iran's government told Al Jazeera's Tehran
- 1:16correspondent that at this stage is not negotiating its nuclear
- 1:20program. It is Sunday, May 10th, 2026,
- 1:25day 72 of Operation Epic Fury. The framework letter has not
- 1:30publicly arrived. Iran's officials are saying
- 1:32they're not negotiating the nuclear program at this stage.
- 1:36The US ceasefire holds, says Washington, and the French
- 1:40aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle is moving toward the Red
- 1:43Sea and Gulf of Aden to prepare for a future freedom of
- 1:46navigation mission in a Strait that is still producing attacks
- 1:49on commercial vessels. This is episode 72 of Epic Fury,
- 1:54the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 1:58podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 2:01Let's get into it. Begin with the nuclear statement
- 2:04from Tehran, because it is the most significant single piece of
- 2:07information about Iran's actual negotiating position to emerge
- 2:11since the framework document was reported on Wednesday, and
- 2:14because it directly and publicly contradicts Trump's Oval Office
- 2:17claim that they have agreed. Al Jazeera's correspondent,
- 2:20reporting from Tehran on Thursday, told the network that
- 2:23Iranian officials are specifically saying at this
- 2:26stage they are not negotiating their nuclear program.
- 2:30The negotiation, as Iran's officials describe it, is only
- 2:33about ending the war on all fronts.
- 2:36That formulation, not negotiating the nuclear program
- 2:39at this stage, is the Iranian government's public
- 2:42characterization of what the document it is reviewing
- 2:44actually contains from Tehran's perspective.
- 2:48Al Jazeera additionally reported that Iran is requiring direct
- 2:51guarantees from the United Nations Security Council that it
- 2:54will not be subject to renewed US or Israeli strikes, a demand
- 2:58that exists alongside the nuclear non negotiation
- 3:00position. That is an extraordinary demand.
- 3:04The UN Security Council guarantee against renewed US or
- 3:07Israeli military action would require the Security Council to
- 3:11pass a binding resolution constraining the United States,
- 3:14which the US holds a power to veto and has vetoed every
- 3:17attempt to constrain its military actions through that
- 3:20body. No such resolution has ever been
- 3:23passed against a permanent members own military operations.
- 3:26Iran's demand for UN Security Council guarantees it maintained
- 3:30as a genuine condition rather than a negotiating position,
- 3:34represents A structural impossibility.
- 3:36The demand for UN Security Council guarantees, if it
- 3:39represents Iran's genuine and non negotiable position rather
- 3:43than a maximalist opening point designed to be traded away, may
- 3:46itself be a substantial part of the explanation for why the
- 3:49letter has not yet arrived. Not a nuclear deal, Not a
- 3:53nuclear moratorium. An end to the war on all fronts,
- 3:57including Lebanon, including the blockade, and possibly including
- 4:01security guarantees from the United Nations Security Council.
- 4:05That position appears on its face to be irreconcilable with
- 4:08the framework is reported by Axios, Reuters and The Times of
- 4:11Israel, which described the US document as containing a 12 year
- 4:15enrichment moratorium, the removal of Iran's highly
- 4:18enriched uranium stockpile from the country, a prohibition on
- 4:21underground nuclear facilities, and a snap IA inspection regime.
- 4:25If Iran's government is telling journalists on the ground in
- 4:28Tehran that the nuclear program is not being negotiated at this
- 4:31stage, and the US document contains exactly those
- 4:34provisions, then one of three possibilities is true.
- 4:37First, Iran's public statements about what is in the document,
- 4:41characterizing it as a war ending arrangement rather than a
- 4:43nuclear framework, are accurate from Iran's perspective because
- 4:47Iran has not accepted the nuclear provisions and regards
- 4:50the document as a ceasefire framework that includes nuclear
- 4:53language it has not agreed to. Second, Iran's public statements
- 4:57about the documents contents are deliberately inaccurate,
- 5:00strategically designed to maintain the domestic political
- 5:03position that the nuclear program is non negotiable, while
- 5:06internal deliberation on exactly how negotiable it might be under
- 5:09sufficient economic pressure continues behind closed doors.
- 5:133rd, the document Iran is reviewing is a different or
- 5:16later version of the proposed framework than what was
- 5:18described to American media, one that may have deferred or soften
- 5:22the nuclear specifics in favor of a more general war ending
- 5:25arrangement during the negotiations that have continued
- 5:27since Wednesday's reporting. All three possibilities are
- 5:31genuinely consistent with a publicly available information.
- 5:35The most important question they generate is whether the
- 5:37framework, when it is eventually agreed or rejected, will contain
- 5:40specific and verifiable nuclear constraints or will rely on the
- 5:44creative vagueness that vase described language that allows
- 5:48both governments to sign something while the genuinely
- 5:50substantive nuclear question is deferred to the 30 day follow on
- 5:54negotiations. If the framework is sufficiently
- 5:56vague on nuclear terms, it may be signed if it requires the
- 6:01specific 12 year moratorium and physical stockpile removal from
- 6:05the country that U.S. officials described to American media.
- 6:08It faces the same obstacle that has blocked every previous
- 6:11Iranian proposal, no confirmed internal Iranian consensus on
- 6:15making those specific concessions, and a supreme
- 6:17leader who has not been publicly visible to issue that
- 6:20authorization for 72 days. Ali Vais, director of the Iran
- 6:24Project at the International Crisis Group and one of the most
- 6:27reliable independent analysts of US Iran negotiations, offered
- 6:31the clearest summary of where things stand.
- 6:34He told Al Jazeera that both sides would either have to make
- 6:36painful concessions or leave the main areas of disagreement vague
- 6:40if they are to finalize a framework understanding at all
- 6:43that is a precise and accurate diagnosis of the core problem,
- 6:47painful concessions, or strategic vagueness.
- 6:50Either Iran explicitly accepts a specific nuclear constraint, A
- 6:54moratorium, stockpile removal for Dow prohibition, and the
- 6:58IRGC accepts that commitment is something other than
- 7:01capitulation under duress. Or the framework uses language
- 7:04that both sides can describe to their respective domestic
- 7:07establishments, is consistent with their positions, language
- 7:10vague enough to allow each government to call it a win,
- 7:13while the genuinely substantive nuclear questions are deferred
- 7:16to the 30 day negotiating period that follows the vagueness
- 7:19option. A framework that uses
- 7:21deliberately ambiguous language on the nuclear question to allow
- 7:24both sides to sign something they can describe to their
- 7:27respective domestic establishments is consistent
- 7:29with their positions is the mechanism that has produced
- 7:32signed agreements in previous diplomatically intractable
- 7:35situations. It is not a genuine resolution
- 7:38of the nuclear question. It is a postponement of the
- 7:41resolution wrapped in signing ceremony language.
- 7:44The 2015 JCPOA required 2 full years of negotiation precisely
- 7:50because the nuclear provisions were not vague but specific.
- 7:53Enrichment levels, centrifuge numbers, stockpile caps,
- 7:56inspection mechanisms, sunset clauses, all defined with the
- 8:00precision that produced a verifiable agreement.
- 8:03A1 page framework with a 30 day follow on process has
- 8:06structurally less space for the specificity that produces
- 8:09genuine mutual constraint, and structurally more space for the
- 8:13creative ambiguity that produces a signing ceremony without
- 8:16resolving the underlying dispute.
- 8:18A document that commits Iran to never seeking a nuclear weapon.
- 8:21The formulation Trump described from the Oval Office is
- 8:24different from a document that commits Iran to a 12 year
- 8:27enrichment moratorium with physical stockpile removal.
- 8:30The 1st is a political statement.
- 8:33The second is a verifiable technical commitment with
- 8:36physical consequences. Iran's government can sign the
- 8:391st and argue it has not conceded anything substantive
- 8:43because it has always maintained it is not seeking a nuclear
- 8:46weapon. The second requires physical,
- 8:48irreversible action, moving uranium out of Iranian territory
- 8:52and into foreign custody. That cannot be undone by a
- 8:55change of government or a reinterpretation of the
- 8:58agreements text. Whether a creatively ambiguous
- 9:01nuclear formulation satisfies Trump's stated floor, they will
- 9:04not have nuclear weapons. They are handing over the
- 9:06nuclear dust is the question that the frameworks exact
- 9:09language, when it becomes public, will definitively
- 9:12answer. If the language requires the
- 9:15physical removal of the nuclear material, the framework is
- 9:18substantive. If it requires only a political
- 9:21commitment, the hard work has been deferred to the 30 days.
- 9:25Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesperson said on Friday that
- 9:28Iran is not paying attention to deadlines.
- 9:31That statement is directed at the American pressure
- 9:34architecture, the implied 48 hour window, the sign fast
- 9:37imperative, the one big low threat Project Freedom Plus
- 9:41warning that has characterized the administration's
- 9:43communications since Wednesday. Iran is explicitly saying that
- 9:47the American pressure calendar does not govern its
- 9:50deliberation. Whether that means Iran is
- 9:52genuinely indifferent to the US pressure timeline or whether it
- 9:56means Iran is managing its domestic audience's perception
- 9:59of the deliberation is sovereign rather than coerced is what the
- 10:02letters eventual arrival or non arrival will show.
- 10:06Turn now to the common a health statement because Friday's
- 10:08unnamed Iranian official assertion marks the first time
- 10:12any Iranian official sources publicly addressed the Supreme
- 10:15Leader's physical conditions since Operation Epic Fury began
- 10:1872 days ago. An unnamed Iranian official told
- 10:22reporters on Friday that Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei is in
- 10:25complete health and will eventually appear in public.
- 10:29Khamenei has not been seen on camera since the war began.
- 10:32He has not delivered a public address.
- 10:35He has not appeared at any ceremony, prayer or state
- 10:38function. His image has been presented
- 10:41through AI generated video. His decisions have been
- 10:44communicated through official statements attributed to him.
- 10:47Russia's government confirmed receiving a written message from
- 10:50him, but no living appearance of any kind, No video footage, no
- 10:55photograph, no audio of his voice has been made public in
- 10:58the 72 days since the war began. The complete health statement
- 11:02made by an unnamed official rather than by a name senior
- 11:05Iranian figure does not resolve the questions about Common A's
- 11:09governing capacity that have surrounded his absence for 72
- 11:12days. It confirms that at least one
- 11:14person with sufficient access to make the claim is willing to
- 11:17assert on the record that the Supreme Leader is healthy.
- 11:20That is not a trivial statement. Is the first time anyone in the
- 11:24Iranian government has publicly addressed Common A's physical
- 11:27conditions since the February 28th strikes, but it is notably
- 11:31lacking in detail and attribution.
- 11:34The will eventually appear in public formulation is worth
- 11:37examining closely. Not soon, Not imminently, Not in
- 11:42the coming days. Eventually.
- 11:45That specific word choice, eventually, rather than soon,
- 11:48imminently or in the coming days, leaves open an enormous
- 11:51range of possibilities about when that appearance might
- 11:54occur. Eventually can mean next week.
- 11:57It can mean next year. It can mean when the security
- 12:00situation allows it, which may itself be undefined.
- 12:04Whether Common A's continued absence from any public view, no
- 12:07camera, no photograph, no audio, no appearance is primarily a
- 12:11security decision or primarily a physical one has significant
- 12:15implications for the framework deliberation.
- 12:18A physically healthy supreme leader who is choosing not to
- 12:21appear publicly for security reasons, keeping his location
- 12:24unknown during an act of conflict is a very different
- 12:27governing reality from a supreme leader who is unable to appear
- 12:30publicly because of an injury or illness that limits his
- 12:33functioning capacity. The former can issue
- 12:36authorizations, direct internal deliberations, and approve
- 12:39framework documents with a full institutional authority of a
- 12:43functioning head of state. The latter raises legitimate
- 12:46questions about whether the decisions attributed to him are
- 12:48genuinely his own and whether any nuclear commitment made in
- 12:52his name carries the institutional weight and long
- 12:54term durability that a permanent framework agreement requires.
- 12:58The Officials complete health assertion does not definitively
- 13:01resolve that question, but its existence.
- 13:04The fact that an Iranian official felt the need to make
- 13:06that assertion publicly on Friday after 72 days of silence
- 13:11is itself a response to the 72 day accumulation of
- 13:14international and domestic uncertainty about the Supreme
- 13:17Leader's status. It was issued the same day Rubio
- 13:20was hoping for a serious Iranian offer.
- 13:23The timing is not incidental. The Bahrain arrest of 41 people
- 13:28alleged to have links to Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps is the
- 13:31largest single Gulf state domestic security action of the
- 13:34conflict to date. Bahrain's Interior Ministry
- 13:37described the 41 detainees as the core of an alleged
- 13:41organization tied to the IRGC. Legal proceedings are underway
- 13:45and further investigations are continuing, the ministry said.
- 13:49The cases involve alleged espionage for foreign entities
- 13:52and expressions of support for Iranian attacks during the war.
- 13:56Bahrain hosts the US Navy's Fifth Fleet at Naval Support
- 13:59Activity Bahrain, the primary US naval base in the Persian Gulf.
- 14:03Bahrain, hosting the US Navy's Fifth Fleet, the primary US
- 14:07naval command for the Gulf region, makes the alleged
- 14:09presence of an IRGC linked organization inside the country
- 14:13among the most operationally sensitive domestic security
- 14:16discoveries of the entire conflict.
- 14:19It follows the UAE's arrest of 27 people in April and Kuwait's
- 14:22arrest of 24 people in late April for broadly similar
- 14:26alleged offenses, forming a clear and consistent regional
- 14:29pattern of Gulf states hardening their domestic security postures
- 14:32against alleged Iranian proxy and espionage networks during
- 14:36the ceasefire period. The attack on the CMACGM San
- 14:39Antonio is a significant escalation of the maritime
- 14:43threat to commercial shipping in the Strait.
- 14:45CMA and CGM is one of the world's three largest container
- 14:49shipping operators, a French headquarter conglomerate that
- 14:52moves approximately 12% of global container cargo.
- 14:56Its decisions about which routes are safe for its vessels set the
- 14:58commercial benchmark for the entire container shipping
- 15:01industry. When CMACGM stops routing ships
- 15:04through a waterway, the insurance market and smaller
- 15:07operators follow. A CMA CGM vessel being attacked
- 15:11with crew members injured in the ship Physically damaged while
- 15:14transiting the Strait is not an anonymous third flag tanker hit
- 15:18by unidentified projectiles. It is a named vessel belonging
- 15:21to a Tier one global shipping operator damaged in a publicly
- 15:25reported attack with injured crew on record.
- 15:28That attack will be processed by the global shipping industry is
- 15:31clear evidence that the Strait of Hormuz is not safe for
- 15:34commercial transit and that U.S. military guidance Project
- 15:37Freedom does not provide sufficient security for
- 15:40commercial vessels to return. France's decision to move the
- 15:43Charles de Gaulle Carrier Strike Group into the Red Sea and Gulf
- 15:47of Aden in preparation for a future freedom of navigation
- 15:50mission in the Strait of Hormuz is France's institutional
- 15:53response to the commercial and security reality its own
- 15:56shipping is experiencing. France led the Maritime
- 15:59Coalition planning meetings at the RAF base in Britain in late
- 16:02April. It announced the second round of
- 16:05Israel Lebanon peace negotiations on Friday and is
- 16:08now moving its primary carrier strike capability toward the
- 16:12Strait. Britain and France have both
- 16:14stressed that their freedom of navigation mission will not
- 16:17launch until there is a sustainable ceasefire and the
- 16:20maritime industry is reassured ships can pass safely.
- 16:23The CMA CGM San Antonio attack makes both of those
- 16:27preconditions sustainable ceasefire and maritime industry
- 16:30reassurance further from being met rather than closer.
- 16:34Pakistan Prime Minister Shabash Sharif said on Saturday that
- 16:37Pakistan has been in contact with the United States and Iran
- 16:40day and night in an effort to extend the ceasefire and reach a
- 16:43peace deal. The day and night formulation is
- 16:45notable. It suggests the pace of
- 16:47Pakistan's mediation activity has not slowed during the
- 16:50framework letter delay, but has, if anything, intensified as the
- 16:54gap between the US nuclear position and Iran's publicly
- 16:57stated non negotiation of the nuclear program persists.
- 17:01Every day that passes without the letter arriving is another
- 17:04day. Pakistani mediation
- 17:05infrastructure is actively engaged in attempting to close a
- 17:09gap that has resisted closure for 72 days.
- 17:12Russia's Foreign Ministry said Saturday that Russia and Saudi
- 17:15Arabia were both calling for diplomatic efforts to reach a
- 17:18sustainable long term agreement to end the war.
- 17:21Russia calling for a sustainable long term agreement while
- 17:24simultaneously maintaining its intelligence sharing
- 17:26relationship with Iran, its defense meeting, coordination
- 17:29with the Iranian deputy defense minister and its commitment to
- 17:33do everything that serves Iran's interest.
- 17:35Is Russia playing both sides of the diplomatic Ledger, publicly
- 17:38supporting a deal while ensuring Iran knows it has a powerful
- 17:41backer regardless of what the deal contains or whether it
- 17:44materializes? Egypt and Qatar's foreign
- 17:47ministers spoke on Saturday and jointly affirmed that diplomacy
- 17:51is the sole path to resolution. The two countries represent the
- 17:55Arab League's most active diplomatic voices in this
- 17:57conflict and their Saturday call reflects the Arab world shared
- 18:01interest in a negotiated end that does not leave the Gulf
- 18:04state security architecture permanently altered by a failed
- 18:07or absent deal. The diplomatic coalition around
- 18:10the US Iran process is now broader than at any previous
- 18:13point in the war. Pakistan, Oman, Russia, Saudi
- 18:17Arabia, Egypt, Qatar, France, Germany and implicitly China,
- 18:21whose entities were sanctioned on Friday for supporting Iran's
- 18:24defense industrial base. Every major regional and
- 18:28international power is simultaneously calling for a
- 18:31deal and will not get one through their calling.
- 18:34The only force compelling Iran's consideration of the nuclear
- 18:37framework is the American blockade that none of them
- 18:39operates and the American military threat that none of
- 18:42them has issued. The coalition's diplomatic
- 18:45unanimity exists. The course of capacity that
- 18:48makes it matter belongs exclusively to Washington.
- 18:52If this podcast is helping you make sense of what's happening,
- 18:55take 2 seconds to leave a five star rating on Spotify or Apple
- 18:58Podcasts. It makes a huge difference to
- 19:01how many people find the show. And if you want the deeper
- 19:04breakdown of what's really going on and where this is heading,
- 19:07you can unlock the premium episodes directly in Spotify or
- 19:10Apple Podcasts. This has been episode 72 of Epic
- 19:14Fury, the US Iran war podcast. Iran's officials say the nuclear
- 19:19program is not being negotiated at this stage.
- 19:22Trump says they have already agreed to it.
- 19:25France's Charles de Gaulle is moving toward the region.
- 19:29Bahrain arrested 41 people with alleged IRGC links.
- 19:33The ceasefire holds. The letter has not publicly
- 19:36arrived. Pakistan is working day and
- 19:39night, and the war is simultaneously closer to
- 19:43resolution and further from certainty than it has been at
- 19:45any point in 72 days. We will be back very soon.