Latest / Thacher Report / Necons were wrong about Iraq. Liberals are wrong about a two-state solution. They're linked.
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everybody. Thanks for joining the Thatcher Report. Once again,
- 0:04I've been on a little bit of a tear lately.
- 0:06I don't know how having a newborn has assisted this process while I work from
- 0:10home, but apparently I've got a lot to say about the continuing and unfolding
- 0:17implosion of the Democratic Party,
- 0:20and I think the left in general,
- 0:22in the face of Trump's and Republican victories across the country last November.
- 0:27And with the ever-evolving situation in Israel, which is something I pay close attention to.
- 0:36Before I get into my latest essay, which is called Neocons Got Iraq Wrong?
- 0:42Ditto liberals with two states.
- 0:44When you hear someone say solution, run. So I have a critique of the two-state
- 0:49solution. I think it's kind of similarly stupid as the neocon ideas in the George
- 0:57W. Bush administration.
- 0:58But kind of the big picture, if people are wondering, why do I talk about Israel so much?
- 1:03And when I'm talking about the Democrats or Trump, it's, sure,
- 1:07I'm Jewish. And I think that Jewish identity after 1948 changed.
- 1:12And Israel has become a central factor, the state of Israel,
- 1:18the actual brick and mortars, the land.
- 1:20It's become a central aspect of contemporary Jewish identity all over the world.
- 1:26Now, there's dissent, not all Jews think alike, but by and large,
- 1:33the vast majority, according to some surveys, 80% of Jews feel a really close connection to Israel.
- 1:41It's quite profound if you think about the biblical history,
- 1:45the exile from the Romans after killing Jesus in 70 AD,
- 1:50and then the historic return of the Jewish people to our homeland,
- 1:57which is more or less, this follows the borders of the state of Israel to this day.
- 2:02There's some disagreement, obviously, in the West Bank, but.
- 2:06That's the big picture. And this is something that the New York Times and other
- 2:14more liberal media entities,
- 2:17and perhaps in just conventional mainstream left-wing society,
- 2:21doesn't really understand why Israel is so important to a contemporary Jew just
- 2:28walking down the street in Brooklyn or Topeka or Los Angeles.
- 2:33And they're puzzled by it. And the coverage reflects that.
- 2:37Even the word anti-Semitism, which comes from the Germans, I don't even know
- 2:41when, maybe the 19th century, it's completely the wrong term.
- 2:46Semites are an ethnic, linguistic, ethnic category that includes Arabs.
- 2:52That's not really the issue anymore.
- 2:54The issue is anti-Judaism, which is really the best way to say it,
- 2:58which has changed over the years, over the millennia.
- 3:01But if you read the New York Times, if you listen to NPR,
- 3:06if you have a college education from a secular university, you're not going
- 3:13to be exposed to the kind of thinking that's animated contemporary Jewish identities.
- 3:17That those ideas are reserved more for synagogues where there's more Hebrew
- 3:22spoken, which is the language of Israel, you'll note,
- 3:26and maybe in yeshivas and in more particular narrow niches where American Jews,
- 3:34if you're an American, find themselves.
- 3:36So we're only a couple of million people in America, maybe six million people.
- 3:40That's not a lot of people. So you're forgiven if you don't understand this,
- 3:44or if you grew up as a secular Jew without any Jewish content in the form of
- 3:49Hebrew and what I call wisdom literature, the Torah,
- 3:53and all of its many components, the Talmud,
- 3:56and on and on and on and on.
- 3:59I wasn't raised with much knowledge of any of those things, so I feel connected
- 4:03to the secular Jewish liberal American experience.
- 4:06It was one that was predicated on ignorance and assimilation.
- 4:10A holdover for survival maybe, but no longer useful if you're interested in
- 4:15passing down Judaism and living a Jewish life.
- 4:19In any event, Israel is central to the Jewish identity now, and that's a reason
- 4:26I think about it a lot, because it's central to my identity as a Jew.
- 4:31I'm also an American, and I care very much about this country.
- 4:35Its country has been incredibly good to me and my family, and I plan to stay
- 4:41in this country. I'm raising a son in this country.
- 4:43I am excited about being an American, although I'm deeply skeptical about it.
- 4:48Of our trajectory, not just because of Trump, but because I think the Democratic
- 4:54Party and the larger left-wing culture that supports that party or that is enmeshed with that party.
- 5:01Is completely off the rails and offers no practical solutions for the things
- 5:07that I think most people care about.
- 5:09And I feel like I can prove that they're off the rails by looking at the last
- 5:14election, and noting that Trump won every single swing state.
- 5:18Maybe not by a lot per state, but he won every single one.
- 5:23So I think that's an indication that people don't prefer the Democrats. It seems kind of clear.
- 5:30So I'm going to focus back into the essay, and then hopefully later this week,
- 5:36I'm going to be talking, or I shouldn't say this week, but hopefully soon,
- 5:39I'll be talking a little bit more about what is left-wing, because I don't know
- 5:44what it is anymore in 2025.
- 5:45I can't really define it beyond being derisive and thinking that it's a rabbit
- 5:52hole of, it's gone down a rabbit hole of first racial identity,
- 5:57which I don't even really believe race exists, but racial identity is very,
- 6:01very important to the left-wing, and then it added gender identity,
- 6:05which I didn't know was a thing until a couple of years ago.
- 6:08And those are the two items that seem the most important to the left wing and sort of foundational.
- 6:14And everything seems to come from there. And it seems kind of weird to me that
- 6:19that's a belief structure people care about because skin color is definitely
- 6:24very important for identity construction for a lot of people.
- 6:28Obviously, there's been racism in this country. There continues to be.
- 6:31But is that the Most important thing in the world, I think, and certainly,
- 6:37or gender identity for the very, very, very, very, very small fraction of humans
- 6:42who feel the need to change their gender.
- 6:46But setting aside anyone under the age of 25 who I don't think should be able
- 6:51to make that type of surgical or biological medical decision,
- 6:56setting aside that, the very, very, very small amount of people who feel that
- 7:01they have a gender that's different than their sex,
- 7:04okay, that's a thing, I guess. I've had to realize that that's a thing.
- 7:08Is that the most important thing for America right now?
- 7:12And obviously, you can tell from my tone that I don't think it is.
- 7:15I think it's incredibly unimportant.
- 7:17I'm sure some families struggle with it, and it's really important to them.
- 7:21And I don't deny that it's important to these people.
- 7:24But I think the most important things are your personal safety.
- 7:30You should feel safe when you go out of the house or in your house.
- 7:34I think you should have a house or a home. So I think affordability after safety
- 7:39is a very, very important thing that the Democrats do not talk about in a convincing
- 7:44way, meaning things should be affordable.
- 7:46We should have subsidies for the things that people need, like education,
- 7:51and we should have bureaucracies that help build housing, not hinder housing, and food, and so on.
- 8:00And then I think opportunity is really important, meaning you got to get a job,
- 8:06you got to work and you got to make money and it should be available to you
- 8:10if you're or you have to move to the right place.
- 8:13It's very complicated. But I think people kind of agree that you want opportunities,
- 8:18whatever, however you define them for yourself to be financially self-sufficient.
- 8:23You want those opportunities to exist in a world that's affordable.
- 8:28Right now, I'd say our world is ever increasingly unaffordable to most people.
- 8:34And then, of course, you just need to feel safe. In New York,
- 8:36that means riding the subway, walking around, and other places that's in your car.
- 8:42But you should just feel safe all the time, as much as you can.
- 8:45And I think America is pretty good about that.
- 8:48But, you know, school shootings or mental illness in the subway system that
- 8:52continues to go unaddressed in a convincing or in a pragmatic way, in an effective way.
- 8:59Those are things that I think people care about. All right, so I'm going to
- 9:03stop. Let's go back to this essay and we'll pick up with the rap a little later on.
- 9:08So neocons got it wrong in Iraq. We can all agree about that.
- 9:12I think liberals are in America and maybe other countries, I don't know,
- 9:17are completely wrong about the two-state solution. I think these are similarly wrong.
- 9:22Similar ideas that are similarly wrong. So, 20 years is a good amount of hindsight.
- 9:28Looking back, we can now see what happened with the neocon intellectual paradigm
- 9:32that dominated Bush W's administration.
- 9:35Those men at the time, I think they were mostly men, they were brilliant,
- 9:39they had pedigreed analyses of post-World
- 9:41War II history, economics and statementship, high acting degrees,
- 9:45media credentials, think tank support, wealthy patrons, and they held court
- 9:50at the pinnacle of global power, the American White House and the State Department.
- 9:55And what they promised was that a very powerful executive could remake countries
- 10:00like Afghanistan and later Iraq into freedom-loving lands with Walmart superstores,
- 10:05Apple consumers, and fair elections.
- 10:07It would take brute strength and looking the other way as contractors' guns massacred innocents.
- 10:12It would take Ivy League plus institution-building experts like Noah Feldman.
- 10:16It would require billion-dollar infrastructure contracts with multinational
- 10:20corporations, where you sat on the board, thinking about Dick Cheney and Halliburton,
- 10:25and then voila, free markets and democracy would bloom.
- 10:29And that was their idea. And now looking back, we can say, that's kind of interesting.
- 10:34There's just a problem I'm noticing is none of that stuff happened.
- 10:38Iraq is not a place that you want to go to or move to. Afghanistan, I would say, even less.
- 10:45So after For decades, decades and decades, the longest war in American history was in Afghanistan.
- 10:50American service members were pointlessly dying, and American taxpayers burned Himalayas of cash.
- 10:58Himalayas of cash. But you still can't use the Target app to schedule a parking
- 11:02lot pickup at the Baghdad store for baby supplies, and Afghanistan is even worse.
- 11:07So, putting aside Trump's Gaza Gulf jingoism, Literally no one anymore talks
- 11:18about state building. That's just not a thing.
- 11:20And I think that if you look a little bit behind, a little bit earlier than
- 11:25the George W. Bush administration—.
- 11:27That there's an older sibling to this neocon concept, which is the liberal two-state
- 11:34solution for Israel and Palestine.
- 11:35So if you kind of want to wind back the clock a little bit, a few years before
- 11:409-11, where the neocons really got their audience that they had been seeking,
- 11:45similarly pedigreed people on the other side of the aisle also promoted a utopian
- 11:49colonialist discourse for, quote-unquote, solving Middle East instability and violence.
- 11:54Shockingly, many people still talk about this.
- 11:58The idea of the two-state solution emerged in the Clinton administration.
- 12:02It was reported, we were told it was great by people like Thomas Friedemann
- 12:06and important media outlets.
- 12:07I was taught in classrooms where I would say that ideology is more important
- 12:12than facts, ideology being this liberation tale that liberals tell themselves
- 12:17and never ask, well, what happens the day after things are liberated?
- 12:20What would that country be like. And this was a bipartisan concept.
- 12:25It started on the left, maybe the center left wasn't too radical or anything.
- 12:30And then George W. Bush, Obama for two terms, the initial Trump administration
- 12:35and Biden, they all paid lip service, if not more, to this idea.
- 12:40So the two state solution was born in the Oslo Accords of the early 1990s.
- 12:45And it originated even earlier in 1937, probably earlier than that,
- 12:49but I can certainly point to the year 1937 as the Peel Commission with this
- 12:55idea that here's the answer for the war between the Jews in Israel and the Arabs
- 13:00in Israel, or Palestine,
- 13:03or whatever you want to call it, and we can argue about it.
- 13:05And this idea was supposed to solve everything.
- 13:09It's been 30 years since the Oslo Accords, a little bit longer, and the wars keep going.
- 13:15Right now, there's a war today in Israel and Gaza, Lebanon, Syria.
- 13:20There's military action, the Houthis, Yemen, you name it.
- 13:24The wars are raging, and I don't know that you could find anyone who knows anything
- 13:30about the region who could tell you with a straight face that Palestinians are capable of creating,
- 13:35managing, enhancing a peaceful democracy that's safe for its own majority people,
- 13:40let alone minorities like Christians or, God forbid, Jewish people.
- 13:45I don't understand why Jewish people can't live in the free Palestine that liberals talk about.
- 13:50I don't understand why Christians can't live there and have equal rights.
- 13:54But forget about that. Do you think a Muslim woman is going to have equal rights
- 13:59in Palestine? It seems unlikely.
- 14:01So I feel like I can prove this very clearly, very easily. You can look at the
- 14:06Arab Spring. I think that was around 2010.
- 14:09And that was breathlessly reported by a lot of the mainstream leftist news organizations.
- 14:15The Obama administration was certainly very excited. The Israelis were not very
- 14:19excited about it, if you remember.
- 14:21And the lesson that came out of this quote-unquote spring, which indicates a
- 14:25thawing, is that the best solution, as we can observe,
- 14:30that's happened, or the, I don't know, maybe best isn't the right word,
- 14:34but the actual solution that emerged, is for military dictators or monarchies,
- 14:40all helmed by Sunni Arabs.
- 14:43Those are the ones that can create stability.
- 14:46Syria is an interesting maybe exception because it was an Alawite dictatorship.
- 14:53No longer, of course, that's evolving, but I don't need to go down too many
- 14:58digressions. You get it.
- 15:00Democracy didn't happen. Tunisia is where it started. My a very good friend,
- 15:05thinks climate change is really the motivator here and not a desire for democracy.
- 15:10That's kind of interesting, but it doesn't. But for these purposes.
- 15:14Tunisia experiment with democracy didn't work. Egypt didn't work.
- 15:18And then, of course, Iraq we talked about before.
- 15:21And I kind of pick on Noah Feldman. I don't know why. I just think that these
- 15:25kind of self-appointed experts are sort of ridiculous in writing up a constitution
- 15:29in a place that won't abide at all. so,
- 15:35Despite all of the evidence that you can keep on looking at,
- 15:39you can look at the wars, you can look at the Second Intifada,
- 15:42you can look at the Arab Spring, you can look at the internal politics of Syria,
- 15:46the devastation of Lebanese internal politics, Tunisia.
- 15:50You can just kind of look around the region to ask yourself how democracy is going.
- 15:55But the diplomatic two-state solution formulation for Israel and Palestine continues
- 16:02to be talked about over and over again. And I think it's almost like a metaphysical
- 16:07incantation, like this kind of prayer.
- 16:09It's important to say over and over, yet it's ineffable and transcendent of reality.
- 16:16So who's talking about the two-state solution? I think there's two main groups.
- 16:20One of them, near and dear to my heart, are liberal Jews.
- 16:23And I used to consider myself a liberal Jew. I'll talk about more why I don't
- 16:28understand what liberalism is anymore. I'm talking about more narrowly defined
- 16:32liberalism, not like big picture.
- 16:35People should be able to vote and have freedom. I still believe in that very strongly.
- 16:40But the kind of classic leech, you know, left-wing, lefty liberal Jews that
- 16:45we think about, I think some of them, I notice, talk about the two-state solution,
- 16:49and I think they use it as cover.
- 16:52They're saying something like this, quote, I'm Jewish, so Israel is important
- 16:55to me, like Ireland is important to Irish Americans, but of course I support a two-state solution.
- 17:00Please don't attack me. I'm not like those bad Zionists. I mean,
- 17:03those bad Jews or Zionists. I don't know.
- 17:06So I think that's the subtext of the left, of the Jewish left.
- 17:09They just kind of give lip service to the two-state solution.
- 17:11Maybe they believe it in their hearts. Maybe they have never been to Israel
- 17:15or never been to an Arab country and asked if there's a democracy there.
- 17:18I don't know why it seems a good idea to them, but I think they do it just to
- 17:23protect their butts from anti-Semitic people in mainstream society right now.
- 17:29Now I'm saying anti-Semitic, and I just said earlier that I shouldn't say that
- 17:32anymore, so it's hard, but anti-Jewish elements, particularly in the left.
- 17:37And so that's a small group of people, not that many Jews in the world.
- 17:41You also hear the two-state solution for mainstream people, regular non-Jewish
- 17:46people, who are kind of like trying to surf between two different camps or different
- 17:54camps of their audiences.
- 17:57Kamala Harris is maybe a good example of this, but it could be a university
- 18:00professor. It could be maybe an editor in a newspaper.
- 18:04I don't know. They seem like unable to talk about the Middle East in a clear way, mostly.
- 18:09But they don't like the anti-Jewish bigotry of the far left,
- 18:14which talks about globalizing the Intifada, which literally means kill Jews
- 18:20everywhere, if you want to understand what that means.
- 18:23I asked those globalized Antifada people, what did they think about the ISIS
- 18:28lone wolf attack in New Orleans on New Year's?
- 18:32Are they in favor of that? That kind of seems like an Antifada,
- 18:35a guy just killing a bunch of people in the West, which is a colonial superpower.
- 18:40Is that good or bad, according to Columbia University extremists?
- 18:45And I think it's kind of a dumb question. They're going to say,
- 18:48oh, of course, that's bad. But if a Palestinian does the same thing in Tel Aviv,
- 18:53and there's an American citizen sitting at that cafe in Tel Aviv,
- 18:57and he or she gets killed, is that okay?
- 19:00And that's intifada, right? Intifada doesn't mean civil rights movement,
- 19:05I have a dream, march on Washington.
- 19:07Intifada means killing Jewish people.
- 19:09That's what it is. So, in any event, the mainstream people, when they say two-state
- 19:15solution, they know they're talking to some of those anti-Jewish nutjobs,
- 19:19which are progressives, I guess.
- 19:22And I think progressives are anti-Jewish. I think those streams of intellectual
- 19:27thought have fully merged in the past year, and there's no way to tease them
- 19:30apart anymore in a meaningful way.
- 19:33And so let's think about, so Kamala Harris, who however is in charge of the
- 19:39train wreck clown car of the Democratic Party, continued to use this magical
- 19:43formula to signal that they're on the right side of history.
- 19:46Arabs, progressives, even Jews can vote for Kamala Harris without conflict.
- 19:51It's okay. The Queers for Palestine, Suicide Pack, Ultra Orthodox of the far
- 19:56left, and White Shoe Liberals with property in Martha's Vineyard can all agree.
- 20:03We got the wealthy, liberal, rich people who went to good schools and have done
- 20:07very well for themselves.
- 20:08We get the people who call themselves Queers for Palestine.
- 20:12And we get the Jewish people who listen to NPR or something.
- 20:17They can all go shop at Whole Foods. They can all get together.
- 20:20There, oh, sure, let's vote for that. It's a solution. It's for two states.
- 20:23Doesn't that sound great? Everyone wins.
- 20:26And I think that's why Kamala Harris, who's a very smart person,
- 20:29perhaps not an expert in the Middle East, but she's smarter than I am.
- 20:32And that's why she says two-state solution, because she wants all these different people to vote for her.
- 20:36The problem that I see, that I think you can tell, is that it's a solution is
- 20:41utter and total nonsense.
- 20:43It's just as nonsensical as neocons spending trillions of dollars. And here's the kicker.
- 20:502,459 American soldiers fell in the war in Afghanistan, which was over 20 years.
- 20:58Why did they die? Why were they there?
- 21:01We had other military options after 9-11. We could have carpet bombed,
- 21:05as they say, the training camps.
- 21:07We killed Osama bin Laden eventually. He wasn't in Afghanistan.
- 21:13Now, maybe we pushed them out. I don't know. You can go down different route holes.
- 21:16But I don't think a single drop of American blood should have been shed in Afghanistan.
- 21:22I think we could have bombed the crap out of the bases. We could have used the
- 21:28CIA, which we eventually did use to kill bin Laden. And,
- 21:32No need for an American to die. Maybe there's some deep secret espionage stuff
- 21:36I don't know about, which involves some heroic sacrifices.
- 21:41Okay, that might be a good idea. And hats off to those people and their families.
- 21:46But for 2,500 nearly Americans to die in Afghanistan, I don't know why that's
- 21:51fair to any of those families.
- 21:53And I think it's easy to say that that's a shame and perhaps criminal of the
- 22:00neocons who advocated this belief.
- 22:02I don't know that any children of any neocon died in Afghanistan.
- 22:06And I include Iraq in this, too. I'm sure many, many more service members died there.
- 22:12So neocons were willing to literally sacrifice the lives of Americans for their
- 22:16idea, which was proven to be wrong.
- 22:18And I'm asking, are liberals any better for the two-state solution,
- 22:22and who are they willing to sacrifice?
- 22:24Now, nobody's talking about American soldiers going over there,
- 22:26but obviously there are American citizens, dual citizens, or American tourists.
- 22:31Israel is a great place for tourism, biblical tourism, hanging out in Tel Aviv,
- 22:36playing some beach volleyball, all types of things to do as a tourist in Israel.
- 22:39So maybe the liberals are just willing to sacrifice the Israelis,
- 22:43who are a freedom-loving people, and the Americans in their midst.
- 22:47Their Americans have been hostages. I don't know if there's any American remaining
- 22:51hostages in Gaza right now, but some just got freed over this past weekend.
- 22:55And that doesn't seem like a good idea, to sacrifice other peoples for a wrong idea.
- 23:01So what are we talking about, the two-state solution? This was an idea.
- 23:05It wasn't called two-state solution until more recently, but it was started
- 23:09by the British during their colony that they had in the area.
- 23:13So the area, they called it Palestine.
- 23:15That's after the Roman name. We're not going to get into that right now.
- 23:17The Romans de-Judaized that area.
- 23:21You'll remember that they killed Jesus.
- 23:24That was an attempt to decapitate leadership, Jewish leadership.
- 23:28And they eventually just got rid of essentially all the Jews.
- 23:33Some still live there, but they were able to rename it.
- 23:37Palestine, Palestina, and the British took that name for whatever reason.
- 23:42And that would be interesting to think about why the British didn't call it
- 23:46Judea or Israel, why they called it Palestine.
- 23:48But in any event, the British were there after World War I in 1919.
- 23:52They defeated the Ottoman Empire, and it was a restive population.
- 23:59Meaning there were riots that were started by Arabs against Jews.
- 24:03We'll talk about that in a second, over and over and over again.
- 24:06And then there were counter-riots, and there was crime and bloodshed and terrible things done.
- 24:11And the British basically said, we don't know what to do.
- 24:14Let's have a blue-ribbon commission to figure it out, the Peel Commission, P-E-E-L.
- 24:20And they said, hey, I have a great idea. Split it up.
- 24:23And the Arabs at the time said no.
- 24:26And later, what we now would call Palestinian, that leadership eventually joined
- 24:31Common Cause with the Nazis, who, if you remember, were attacking the British.
- 24:35So no, I'm not making any of that up. The Palestinian National Movement was
- 24:40originally pro-fascist, pro-Nazi.
- 24:43All of those Nazi ideas, like a big one is wanting to kill Jews everywhere,
- 24:48you might remember, is alive and well with groups like Hamas.
- 24:51And I'm sure the people at the Palestinian Authority chuckle and agree in private.
- 24:56So So the British later, it's a little bit complicated, but they did decide
- 25:01to create an Arab state that didn't exist there before. It's called Transjordan and then Jordan.
- 25:05That was not a country. There were no countries. It was all the Ottoman Empire.
- 25:09They, the British and the French, carved it all up and they created an Arab state.
- 25:16I guess most states there would be Arab because there's now half a billion Arabs
- 25:19in the world. And they called it Jordan.
- 25:22It's on the other side of the Jordan River.
- 25:26And that would not be Jewish. There was no Jewish ancestral concept there.
- 25:30Okay, that's not totally true, but it's not for political purposes. It doesn't matter.
- 25:35And then obviously there would be an Israel. There would be a Jewish area on the left. Okay.
- 25:42That didn't work out very well. Jordan, to this day, still has quote-unquote
- 25:47refugees, Palestinian refugees, for like many generations.
- 25:51I don't know what that is. There's nowhere else in the world that has multiple
- 25:53generation refugees, but usually they either become citizens or move on to somewhere else.
- 26:00So that didn't really work out so great.
- 26:03But then obviously the UN, 10 years later, roughly said, hey, I got a great idea.
- 26:09The British don't want to deal with it anymore. The UN says,
- 26:12let's split it up. The Arabs at the time said no.
- 26:15The Jews said yes. That's 1947. 1948, the Jews declare their little tiny little
- 26:21sliver as Israel. There is a war.
- 26:24The Arabs attacked Israel. The Arabs, meaning multiple Arab countries,
- 26:29and then local Palestinians had sort of what you call like a civil war because
- 26:33it was within the British mandate. And you know the rest.
- 26:36The Jewish Israelis were devastated but won.
- 26:41And that's why there's a state of Israel. And so, you know, every 10 years or so, 1937, 1947.
- 26:49There's 20 years, there's always this kind of diplomatic people,
- 26:55venues that really could make it happen, often say, okay, let's do the two-state
- 27:00solution. What a great idea.
- 27:02And every time, as up to the early 2000s, the local Arab governance,
- 27:07Palestinian governance, has said no every single time.
- 27:11And so you might notice a pattern here that if you have a PhD from the Kennedy
- 27:15School at Harvard, or if you're like a very well-paid columnist,
- 27:20you can't understand this because they don't ever seem to acknowledge it.
- 27:24It's only two letters. They appear in order in the alphabet.
- 27:29But no, it's not understood by the establishment, by the left establishment.
- 27:34And not only have the two groups of people required to have a two-state solution,
- 27:39not only have one of the two groups of people required to have a two-state solution
- 27:43refuse to let it happen, they've been very clear and consistent in both physical,
- 27:47military, violent, and in diplomatic terms, they've stated their preference.
- 27:51What they want, they, the Palestinians, what they want is a one-state solution.
- 27:55Does every single Palestinian want this? No.
- 27:58Does the Palestinian leadership want this since the 1930s? Yes.
- 28:02And they want to remove Jews by violence. They want to create international
- 28:07vibes to denigrate Jews globally, which is working just great after October 7th, 2023.
- 28:12Just walk through Colombia. Oh, no, you can't walk through Colombia because
- 28:15it's shut now to outsiders because of anti-Jewish protests.
- 28:20And the Palestinians, that's their solution.
- 28:25They have a great idea for them. And it's awfully similar to the Nazi idea. Funny how that works.
- 28:31But again, if you have a PhD, if you're a journalist at an establishment media
- 28:37outlet, you can't understand this.
- 28:40Now, why you can't understand this, and you're a highly intelligent person,
- 28:43that's a longer conversation about ideology and make-believe,
- 28:48but an anti-Jewish sentiment that's so deeply ingrained in our society.
- 28:54And you can tell it's deeply ingrained when people say, oh, no,
- 28:56I'm not an anti-Semite. And you're like, well, OK.
- 28:59Maybe the fact that you have to say that is kind of indicative of what you're really thinking.
- 29:05But, you know, there was all these attempts. And meanwhile, when there were
- 29:08all these attempts, 37, 47, Camp David, there's talk about it. It's in the 70s.
- 29:14Oslo, yada, yada, yada. There's a Madrid plan. There's all these different plans
- 29:18over and over and over again. And always around these times,
- 29:21before or after, there were intense bouts of Arab violence against Jews.
- 29:26And it started in the 1900s. I wrote about this for my college thesis in Jerusalem.
- 29:33And then much later, much larger scale in Hebron, which is now in the West Bank.
- 29:38And then obviously all these massive land wars against Israel.
- 29:42Why is it so important to kill Jews in Israel? I don't know if you're in Iraq,
- 29:46why that's so important to you, but that's what happened.
- 29:49And today, Iran, same thing, still happening. There are attacks emanating from
- 29:54Iraq today from militias aligned with Iran, but whatever it is,
- 30:00and we continue to see it again.
- 30:01Now with October 7th, 2023, we're being told again about the two-state solution.
- 30:08So it's always kind of around times of Arab violence or Arabs have their Palestinian
- 30:12violence as a reaction to some of the diplomatic movements like in the Second Intifada after Oslo.
- 30:19But you can kind of track it like this.
- 30:22One of my favorite sort of asides is that I really love it when I listen to
- 30:26NPR, which I do less and less these days, is that they call it the Gaza War.
- 30:30And it's like the Palestinians were really hoping it'd be called the Israel War.
- 30:35Like there's fighting in Gaza because there was fighting in Israel.
- 30:38They share a border and then you attack back.
- 30:41And now it's the Gaza War. And it's just the naming, you know,
- 30:44the naming tells you something about the viewpoint of the person talking.
- 30:48And now we've learned that Hamas was really actively coordinating with Hezbollah
- 30:54via Iran to create a pincer movement.
- 30:56So they would attack from the south in Gaza, Hezbollah would come from the north,
- 30:59and then they would have a big Armageddon and kill all the Jews.
- 31:03And thankfully, that collab didn't happen, which is the sardonic and sarcastic
- 31:09quote that Palestinians never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity, but thank God.
- 31:14And all of this is just to say that how could you have a two-state solution
- 31:19if one of the groups consistently is fighting?
- 31:22It doesn't seem to work that way.
- 31:26And to be fair, there are some extremists in Israel. They get a ton of attention
- 31:31in America. I would say it's disproportionate.
- 31:34But they're there. They are politicians.
- 31:36They do win seats. There's not a lot of them, but some of them wield power for
- 31:40sure in the current administration in the Knesset.
- 31:43And they also have a one-state solution, and they want to annex, and it's complicated.
- 31:48But let's just say, for simplification purposes, they're kind of the bad guys in Israeli politics.
- 31:55There's definitely strains of racism and all types of bad things from these
- 31:59people, and we're talking not a lot of people, but they're there.
- 32:02But you'll notice that when they're in power, which they are now,
- 32:05they don't do anything. They talk a lot, and it's scary, and they get headlines,
- 32:10and people should pay attention.
- 32:11I think it's good to be educated. But there are millions of Arab citizens in Israel.
- 32:16There are millions of Arabs in the West Bank, for example, and obviously,
- 32:21famously, two million in Gaza.
- 32:23But in Israel, in the state of Israel, there are Arab political parties,
- 32:27some of them which wield quite a bit of power and are really fascinating to watch.
- 32:32There are Supreme Court justices, there are business tycoons,
- 32:36and many are excluded from certain military institutions,
- 32:41from certain institutions, excuse me, like the military, where they're self-excluded
- 32:46and it's okay, they get a pass, and that seems kind of obvious why that would be that way.
- 32:50And sure, a lot of the Arab areas are relatively poor compared to the Jewish areas.
- 32:55Many Jewish areas are poor too, but many Arab areas are poor.
- 32:59It's something you're going to notice when you go to Israel and you'll be like,
- 33:02they're not dire poverty, but they're not quite as nice for sure.
- 33:06And you sort of wonder, oh, is that like discrimination? Ta'an S.A.
- 33:09Coates says it's discrimination, it's racism.
- 33:11Well, what you'd notice is that if you go over the border to Jordan or to Egypt,
- 33:16and I have not been to Lebanon or Syria, my dad has, but if you go over the
- 33:20border, you'll notice that there's dire poverty everywhere.
- 33:24And all of the Arab world is impoverished outside of the Gulf states that have
- 33:27oil, which is a handful of exceptions.
- 33:30It's a poor part of the world. This is not a part of the world that's ever been
- 33:34capable since the dawn of modernity of making much money.
- 33:38So the Arabs in Israel don't do that well compared to the Jews in Israel,
- 33:42but they're far, far better than across the border.
- 33:45And you could sort of say, well, why is that cultural or whatever?
- 33:48And I can't go down that rabbit hole right now. But.
- 33:53It seems like one should have a broader vision and understanding of the Middle
- 33:58East before delving too deep in their critique of Israeli Arabs.
- 34:03Is there a critique to be had? Of course.
- 34:05Show me a society with a minority population that is perfect and are treated perfectly.
- 34:12And we should always strive to do better.
- 34:14But what I'm going to notice is that what about the Jewish politicians that we have?
- 34:19We have Arab politicians in Israel. Where is the Jewish politicians in Iraq?
- 34:23Jews lived in Iraq for 2,000 years, predates Islam by a lot.
- 34:27Same in Egypt, large Jewish populations in Cairo and Alexandria,
- 34:32Jewish populations in Tripoli, Jewish populations all over the Middle East. How are they doing?
- 34:37And the answer is, they aren't there anymore. And why aren't they there anymore?
- 34:41It's because they were kicked out violently in the 1950s, some left much later,
- 34:47up into the 70s and 80s, but they're all gone now.
- 34:50And so if you're going to look at, with Israel, treatment of Arabs with precision,
- 34:57I think you also have to look at how Jews have been treated and why they're
- 35:01in Israel in the first place.
- 35:02It doesn't justify racism against anybody, but I think it shows you the scope of the issue.
- 35:09So anyways, let's talk about America. So the two-state solution has no historical
- 35:14precedent or evidence of ever working, except for Jordan. Jordan's a relatively
- 35:19stable place. It's full of Arabs.
- 35:21A lot of them call themselves Palestinians. Maybe other ones call themselves Jordanians.
- 35:25Jordan was not a thing. There's not an ethnicity of Jordanianism.
- 35:29There's not an ethnicity of Palestinianism.
- 35:31These are areas that are very, very close to each other. These are people living
- 35:35there very, very close to each other.
- 35:36Now, I'm sure there's cultural differences and maybe some linguistic differences
- 35:40that have evolved. But Jordan wasn't a country.
- 35:43It's not a historic place. It was created by the British by taking some people
- 35:48from Saudi Arabia to rule over the local central peasantry of the Ottoman Empire.
- 35:54The Hashemite Kingdom came, which is still in control.
- 35:59So outside of Jordan, maybe there is a two-state solution if you want to talk
- 36:02about Jordan, but outside of that, there's no evidence of it working.
- 36:06Peace requires warring parties to stop fighting, right? That's how you get peace.
- 36:11Two people in a war, Japan, America, one of them gives up, and then the other
- 36:16one hopefully is nice about it and helps them get back on their feet.
- 36:21And now Japan is a staunch ally of America, and it's an incredible relationship.
- 36:26And it seems kind of like a long time ago that we were at war.
- 36:31But empirically, Palestinians aren't pursuing peace.
- 36:34Now, there's a whole digression I go into about the UN and their role in maintaining
- 36:39Palestinians' war position with UNRWA and their idea of refugee camps for multiple
- 36:44generations, which doesn't make any sense.
- 36:47Nobody ever questions it in the New York Times, but I don't understand how it's
- 36:51a thing. But you have to have two groups that want peace to have peace.
- 36:58And it doesn't really matter what you want or how you feel about things.
- 37:02It's what the people on the ground want.
- 37:04And you can see on October 7th, 2023, what people on the ground wanted.
- 37:09Hamas's elected leadership.
- 37:12They are criminal kind of mafia terrorist types.
- 37:15It's not like they're asking everybody for a focus group before they do something, but they're popular.
- 37:20You can do polling in the Arab world and the Palestinian world. They're still popular.
- 37:25They're maybe slightly less popular, but Hamas is not like a separate.
- 37:30It's made up of Palestinian people, right?
- 37:33So why are people in America talking about the two-state solution?
- 37:39Obviously, it's more left-wing people, but why? It's obviously a fiction.
- 37:43There's just absolutely no empirical evidence that it's happened,
- 37:46and it seems like it's not going to happen.
- 37:49And I stated a little bit about the cause, you know, oh, yeah,
- 37:52you get votes from different groups, or Jews use it as cover to defend themselves
- 37:55from anti-Judaism, but...
- 37:59I think that the ultimate conclusion I've come up with is that the only reason
- 38:02people talk about a two-state solution is because it's useful domestically.
- 38:06And it's not diplomatic. It has nothing to do with the Middle East.
- 38:10It's great to win elections if you want to get progressive anti-Jews and Jews
- 38:15to vote with each other, which Kamala Harris was able to do.
- 38:19It's great to protect yourself from bigotry if you're Jewish and you're worried
- 38:23about maybe not getting tenure because you, like most Jews, which I've argued,
- 38:27care about Israel. Well, it's really built into us.
- 38:30Our prayers are in the language of Israel.
- 38:33Jerusalem is in Israel. We are very kind of geographically focused religious culture.
- 38:39So if you want tenure or you want to stay in office as a Jewish politician,
- 38:44you might talk about the two states, but that's about your life here in America.
- 38:48That's not about Israel or Palestine. It doesn't help any of those people.
- 38:53So, okay, the Trump plan, right? Lots to say about that.
- 38:58It seems kind of crazy. It seems maybe slightly like a timeshare scam kind of thing.
- 39:04But the only thing I'll say about it for right now is that at least it's not
- 39:07the repeated fabrication of the left of the two states.
- 39:11It's perhaps a new fabrication, and we could talk about that.
- 39:15But I've seen some footage of Palestinians in Gaza saying that they like this idea.
- 39:20I think it's important to listen to people. So maybe it has legs that I don't know about.
- 39:25But I think the two-state solution is kind of like land acknowledgments in this
- 39:29country, which maybe are kind of going out of fashion.
- 39:32I think any thinking person could agree that if you go to a museum or a theater,
- 39:38which I've heard this at a theater,
- 39:40or I heard that at the Brooklyn Botanical Garden a couple years ago,
- 39:44so maybe some kind of public institution like that, college campus,
- 39:49that land acknowledgments don't help a descendant of, let's say, the Iroquois.
- 39:56They aren't designed to help Native Americans.
- 39:59They're designed to help the people saying the land acknowledgements feel good
- 40:03about living on the land of dead Native Americans.
- 40:07And I think it's interesting to note that many of the people saying land acknowledgements
- 40:12or who are receptive to them tend to be better educated, wealthier,
- 40:17more successful people.
- 40:18Not all of them. There are some progressive anti-Jews out there who don't fit
- 40:23those categories and have a sincere belief about it.
- 40:27But okay, they might have a sincere belief about it, but I'm not sure how a
- 40:31land acknowledgement helps a Native American family.
- 40:35And so I think that's kind of like the two-state solution. It's just kind of
- 40:38this repeated piety that means nothing.
- 40:41But at worst, it's dangerous. It's a dangerous belief to talk about the two-state solution.
- 40:46And I can point to the neocons to say, well, that was a dangerous belief for
- 40:49interesting, same region. And that didn't work out very well.
- 40:53And maybe we should have criminal action against some of these neocons or whoever,
- 40:58the Cheneys or people who have actual blood on their hands for Americans.
- 41:03But the two-state solution is also dangerous. And, you know,
- 41:06I can just show you how many thousands of people have died after Oslo and before
- 41:12Oslo and every other earlier attempt for a two-state solution.
- 41:16And, you know, instead of Americans dying on this altar of ego and avarice of the neocons,
- 41:23now it's the liberals are willing to sacrifice Israelis and Palestinians on
- 41:27the altar of their superior morals because they know the moral right that the
- 41:31two-state, that's just right.
- 41:32It doesn't matter what people on the ground want or how they behave.
- 41:36The liberals in America are going to tell you what the moral solution is.
- 41:40And okay, so let's wrap it up to the Democrats.
- 41:45It's like waiting for Godot. They're talking a lot. They're waiting for something.
- 41:50Spoiler of the Samuel Beckett play, Godot doesn't show up.
- 41:54So if you want to, if the Democrats, I don't know who they are anymore.
- 41:58I don't know that I'm a Democrat. I'm registered as a Democrat because I live
- 42:01in a blue area, but I don't understand the parties.
- 42:04I don't feel a kinship to it at all anymore because I don't know what my kinship is to.
- 42:10What do they stand for beyond some kind of catchphrases or something, maybe?
- 42:16But if you care about having an opposition to Trump, you would have to come up with an alternative.
- 42:24And Trump went from, the Republicans went from Reagan to Trump,
- 42:30right? We've gone from corporate.
- 42:32Conservatism to Trump authoritarianism. That's the big picture sweep.
- 42:38It's been a very effective change for the Republicans. They've won more votes doing it.
- 42:43And Democrats haven't. They're still in the 1960s, maybe, 1970s,
- 42:49civil rights movement, Vietnam War, feminism, Stonewall era.
- 42:56It doesn't seem to have changed. I'll note that it's 2025, so it's been a long
- 43:01time since Stonewall and the closing of the Vietnam War and the Civil Rights Voting Act.
- 43:08Those are all really important things. I'm glad we're not in Vietnam anymore.
- 43:12I'm glad that there's gay marriage and rights for gay people, finally.
- 43:17I'm glad that the Civil Rights Voting Act existed. I wish it was much stronger
- 43:23and John Roberts hadn't devastated it. But the point is, you get it.
- 43:27Those are great innovations in the mid to late 20th century,
- 43:32kind of mid-ish 20th century.
- 43:34And the Democrats are still kind of there. I don't know what they believe in now.
- 43:38They seem to believe in those things, which are good things,
- 43:41but not the challenges I'm dealing with and my neighbors who are black are dealing with. Yeah.
- 43:48Democrats just kind of have this kind of mystical beliefs.
- 43:52And one of them, you know, about race and gender, you could say,
- 43:55and then another mystical belief is this two-state solution.
- 43:58And I harp on it because I think if the Democrats are willing to have this mysticism
- 44:02about the two-state solution, what else are they mystical about?
- 44:06About does a very important and precise focus on transgender rights make your house affordable?
- 44:15There are a lot of people, there are people who are transgender,
- 44:18right? I think there are more people who live in houses or want to live in houses.
- 44:23And so while you should care about minorities and their rights,
- 44:27maybe also caring about everyone is a good idea.
- 44:32So Republicans moved on from neocons. They did it. They graduated.
- 44:35Neocons was terrible. It was stupid.
- 44:38Republicans have moved on. They have a new foreign policy.
- 44:41A lot of it's about ending mass immigration or what they call illegal or asylum or whatever.
- 44:47I could talk about that more. I don't agree with the Republicans about that,
- 44:51but that's a big focus. They talk about immigration. That's popular.
- 44:54That resonates. And they also say, and Trump says it himself,
- 44:57he is not going to launch wars he can't win.
- 44:59He doesn't want to launch any wars, according to him, but he certainly doesn't
- 45:02want to launch a war that they can't win.
- 45:04America has lost every single war at scale, with the exception of the Persian
- 45:09Gulf War, which predates Iraq, small, relatively small.
- 45:12We've basically lost every single war since World War II.
- 45:16Lost Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, and we cannot win wars with our current
- 45:22leadership on the right or the left.
- 45:24Or the past right, now the new right, has a different way of doing it.
- 45:28The left, what are they, where are they in this debate?
- 45:32I'm saying they're nowhere because they're still talking about the two-state
- 45:34solution. It's kind of like a symbol, a signifier that they haven't evolved
- 45:38any of their thinking about any of this stuff.
- 45:41Democrats helped a lot of American service members die in Afghanistan.
- 45:44And if you remember, Obama was there for two years.
- 45:47Terms. And he thought about it a lot. I'm sure he cared about it.
- 45:52Biden at the time was against expansion and the surge and all this nonsense.
- 45:57But there's blood on his hands and there's blood on Bush's hands and certainly and Trump's too.
- 46:03Not on Biden's. Biden got out of it, to his great credit.
- 46:06But going back to the two states, it's a symbol of the failures of the left.
- 46:12And I just think it's time for the Democrats to drop the falsehoods.
- 46:16The two-state solution is a falsehood.
- 46:20Focusing on gender identity for a very tiny fraction of people who occupy a
- 46:26very specific political ideology, we're told that's the priority.
- 46:31I don't think that's a priority. I don't know if that's a lie,
- 46:33but I think it's kind of dumb to make it a priority.
- 46:35Or I live in a blue state. I've always lived in blue states.
- 46:38The taxes always go up and the services always go down. The subway is not any better.
- 46:43The highways are terrible in New York. The airports very rarely get updated.
- 46:49Penn Station is a joke. Yeah, they
- 46:52added Moynihan Station, but they didn't expand a single train below it.
- 46:55So that doesn't make a bit of difference for riding the trains.
- 46:59Joe Biden, Amtrak Joe. Okay. How's Amtrak doing four years after that?
- 47:03Absolutely no difference.
- 47:05So I think maybe raising taxes and lowering services is not a good idea.
- 47:10Maybe creating plans and policies that actually make a difference locally is a better idea.
- 47:16So I'm saying you could look to Israel as a symbol for some of the rot on the
- 47:21left, or you could just look here.
- 47:24But for the left right now, it's nowhere.
- 47:27All right. Thank you so much for listening. I know I digressed a lot there,
- 47:30but I'm experimenting with some new formats. Please stay tuned. Thank you so much.