Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / Rekindling High School Friendship at Fifty: Navigating Different Life Stages | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I watched her hand her toddler a piece of raw cheese, and for a split second, my mother-instinct screamed loud enough to wake the dead. Then I remembered that she is not me, and her child is not mine, and I had to swallow the advice before it fell out of my mouth. There is a specific kind of panic that rises in your chest when you watch someone you love make a choice that feels dangerously wrong to you. It’s not just worry; it’s a visceral, almost physical recoil. Last week, I was sitting on a friend’s living room floor, watching her four-year-old climb onto the coffee table with the reckless abandon only children possess. My instinct was to jump up, to say, "Be careful, please," or better yet, to physically guide him down. But I stayed still. I gripped the edge of the rug until my knuckles turned white. Because here is the truth that is so much harder to admit than the simple desire to correct: we are often parenting our own ghosts through other people’s children. When we see a parent making a mistake, or choosing a path we would never take, it triggers something primal in us. We fear that if they fail, it reflects poorly on us. Or worse, we fear that the world is less safe because their child is navigating it without the armor we think they need. Let’s sit with that for a second. That tightness in your throat? It’s not always about the child. It’s about your own unresolved anxieties about control, safety, and what it means to be a good person in a chaotic world. I have spent years trying to untangle the knot between judgment and care. And I’ll be honest, it is messy work. There was a time when I couldn’t watch another mom let her kid eat sugar before dinner without feeling a surge of moral superiority. I thought I was protecting them from cavities, from energy crashes, from the chaos of unregulated blood sugar. But really, I was protecting myself from the discomfort of seeing someone else do something differently. It’s easy to judge when you’re on the outside looking in. You don’t see the exhaustion in their eyes at 8 PM. You don’t know if this meal was the one thing that kept everyone alive today. You don’t hear the whispered apologies after bedtime when the house finally goes quiet. When we judge a friend’s parenting style, we are usually judging based on a highlight reel of their behavior, stripped of all context. We see the outcome, not the struggle. And because we assume our way is the right way, we forget that there are thousands of ways to raise a human being, and most of them are valid. Tell me more about why that matters to you. Why does it feel so urgent to fix what isn’t broken in your eyes? Here is where it gets personal, and maybe a little uncomfortable. Our reactions to other people’s parenting are almost always mirrors of our own childhoods. If I grew up with strict rules, I might react with anger when I see permissiveness. If I grew up with neglect, I might overcompensate by trying to save every child I see. I realized this about myself when I started noticing my reactions to my best friend, Sarah. She lets her kids wear whatever they want, even in winter. For years, I judged her for it. I thought she was lazy, or indifferent, or perhaps too self-absorbed to care about warmth. But then one day, I asked her why. Really asked her. Not in an accusatory way, but with genuine curiosity. She told me that her parents had controlled every aspect of her appearance, and she wanted her children to feel autonomy over their bodies. She wanted them to choose who they were, starting with what they wore. Suddenly, her "negligence" transformed into a profound act of liberation. It wasn’t that I agreed with every decision she made, but I understood the root of it. And that understanding changed everything. It softened the edges of my judgment. It reminded me that behind every parenting choice is a history, a trauma, a hope, or a dream. We are all carrying invisible backpacks full of our own pasts, and sometimes we trip over each other’s bags. So, how do we navigate this without becoming the annoying aunt or the critical uncle? How do we stay close to our friends without letting our differences drive a wedge between us? The answer lies in shifting from correction to connection. Instead of asking, "Why are you doing that?" try asking, "How is this working for you?" It’s a subtle shift, but it changes the entire dynamic. It invites conversation instead of defense. It acknowledges that they are the expert on their family, not you. I’ve learned to treat my friendships like gardens, not construction sites. I don’t go in with a shovel to dig up their foundation and rebuild it according to my blueprint. I water them. I weed out the negativity when it arises. I celebrate the blooms. But I don’t try to force flowers to grow where they aren’t meant to. This doesn’t mean you have to agree with everything. It means you trust that your friend is capable of figuring things out, just as you are. We’re all just figuring it out as we go. And sometimes, the best thing you can offer is your presence, not your prescription. Now, I want to be clear about one thing. This advice applies to choices, not harm. If you are witnessing abuse, neglect, or genuine danger, the rules change. Your role shifts from supportive friend to protective advocate. But for the vast majority of our interactions—the screen time debates, the dietary choices, the discipline styles—we are dealing with preference, not peril. The line can be blurry, and it requires discernment. Ask yourself: Is this actually hurting anyone? Or am I just uncomfortable because it challenges my worldview? Most of the time, it’s the latter. And that discomfort is okay. It’s a signal to look inward, not outward. It’s an invitation to examine your own biases and assumptions. When we can sit with that discomfort without acting on it, we create space for our friends to be exactly who they are. And paradoxically, that acceptance often makes them more open to hearing our perspectives later. Trust builds slowly, brick by brick, through moments of restraint and respect. In the end, parenting is a lonely journey. Even in community, you are ultimately responsible for your own child. Your friend doesn’t need you to validate her methods; she needs you to witness her effort. She needs to know that even if she struggles, even if she makes mistakes, she is loved. She is seen. She is not alone. When we drop the need to fix, we give them the greatest gift of all: the freedom to be imperfect. And in that imperfection, we find our shared humanity. We realize that we are all doing our best with the tools we have. So next time you feel that urge to intervene, pause. Take a breath. Remember that you are a guest in their home, their life, their story. Listen more. Judge less. Love fiercely. And trust that they are learning, just as you are. Thank you for letting me sit in the messy middle with you today. I’m Rhiannon, and I’ll see you in the next episode. Until then, be gentle with yourself, and with others.