Latest / The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener / Day 4 of the review application on Phala Phala report heard in WC High Court
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: But we start where we've started for the last two days,
- 0:02Speaker 1: and that is in the High Court in the Western Cape,
- 0:05Speaker 1: because it's day three of President Cyril Ramaphosa's legal challenge
- 0:09Speaker 1: against the report that suggests he should face impeachment. So
- 0:13Speaker 1: the MK Party has been arguing today, the UAT arguing
- 0:18Speaker 1: as well yesterday, other opposition parties claiming the president acted
- 0:22Speaker 1: in bad faith in trying to conceal the events that
- 0:25Speaker 1: transpired at Palapala in 2020. All of this, of course,
- 0:29Speaker 1: to do with the dollars stuffed in the cart that
- 0:32Speaker 1: was stolen. Lindsay Dentlinger, EWN's parliamentary reporter, joins us now.
- 0:36Speaker 2: Lindsay, good afternoon to you. Thanks very much for your time.
- 0:40Speaker 1: What arguments did we hear from Advocate Dallium-Pawful today?
- 0:45Speaker 3: Good afternoon, Mandy.
- 0:46Speaker 4: Well, much a continuation of yesterday's arguments, but it's really
- 0:50Speaker 4: the bench that is really questioning the charges that were
- 0:54Speaker 4: in or are in that original impeachment motion that has
- 0:58Speaker 4: triggered this entire process versus what opposition parties are expecting
- 1:03Speaker 4: to come from this process and more specifically the questions
- 1:06Speaker 4: that they want the president to answer. In particular, Judge
- 1:10Speaker 4: Mark Schur, questioning whether these really add up The questions
- 1:16Speaker 4: that opposition parties have about how the money came into
- 1:19Speaker 4: South Africa. Was it really part of a transaction to
- 1:23Speaker 4: buy buffalo, which ostensibly is still on the president's farm?
- 1:26Speaker 4: How did it come that this money was stored? Who
- 1:28Speaker 4: gave the instruction that this money be stored in a couch?
- 1:32Speaker 3: Who set the.
- 1:33Speaker 4: the head of the president's security unit off to go
- 1:37Speaker 4: and investigate and to go and find this money. And
- 1:40Speaker 4: the judge is really pointing out that this is not... Sorry, Mandy,
- 1:44Speaker 4: I'm being castigated for making a noise in the corridor.
- 1:46Speaker 2: Don't worry, that's what happens at courts. My sympathy is
- 1:50Speaker 2: with you, so we understand.
- 1:51Speaker 4: Don't worry.
- 1:51Speaker 3: I hope the.
- 1:52Speaker 4: I hope the reception is still okay over here. So
- 1:56Speaker 4: really they are questioning whether the charges that are in
- 2:00Speaker 4: this motion really add up and maybe perhaps whether the
- 2:04Speaker 4: opposition parties are not overreaching in what they are expecting
- 2:08Speaker 4: the president to answer. But it is really the insistence
- 2:13Speaker 4: of Darlene Pauful telling the full bench here today that
- 2:16Speaker 4: the money is intrinsic to all the questions that relate
- 2:22Speaker 4: to this impeachment matter and specifically to the charges that
- 2:25Speaker 4: the president is facing. And without knowing the details about
- 2:29Speaker 4: this money, the questions that they are contained in their motion,
- 2:33Speaker 4: whether the president failed to report The theft of this money,
- 2:37Speaker 4: whether he was doing paid work outside his presidential office
- 2:41Speaker 4: and whether he unlawfully abused state resources to go and
- 2:48Speaker 4: chase after the stolen money. How the money got to
- 2:52Speaker 4: South Africa is central to those particular charges in the
- 2:56Speaker 4: motion mandate.
- 2:57Speaker 1: You've now sat through three days of argument. We've heard
- 3:00Speaker 1: from the president, the president's legal counsel. We've heard from
- 3:04Speaker 1: opposition parties. What will the judge now have to decide?
- 3:08Speaker 3: So they advocate Tabani Masuko, yes, currently before the bench.
- 3:13Speaker 4: And he's been questioned by Judge.
- 3:15Speaker 3: Yumi Samayosi about what what the implications would be if
- 3:19Speaker 3: this court were to set aside this report as per
- 3:22Speaker 3: the president's request, and whether that really means in the
- 3:26Speaker 3: arguments of the opposition parties that the judiciary would effectively
- 3:30Speaker 3: be interfering with parliament's duty to hold the president accountable.
- 3:36Speaker 3: And so the bench really has.
- 3:39Speaker 4: to decide whether this independent panel report that contains the
- 3:43Speaker 4: prima facie evidence that suggests the president should face impeachment,
- 3:47Speaker 4: whether that should be set aside, whether it failed to
- 3:51Speaker 4: answer the questions on the president's version put before the court,
- 3:56Speaker 4: whether it failed.
- 3:57Speaker 3: And whether it strayed beyond the four charges in the
- 4:00Speaker 3: motion and erred in understanding and executing the role for
- 4:06Speaker 3: which they only had 30 days really to execute And
- 4:11Speaker 3: what it would mean.
- 4:12Speaker 4: For the process going forward is what judges are now
- 4:15Speaker 4: questioning if they were to accede to the president's request,
- 4:19Speaker 4: what that would then mean for this process going forward, Mandy.
- 4:23Speaker 2: Lindsay, thank you so much.
- 4:24Speaker 1: I appreciate you running around and giving us that report.
- 4:27Speaker 1: Lindsay Dentlinger, EWN parliamentary reporter in court for us. We mentioned,
- 4:31Speaker 1: of course, advocate Dalian Porful arguing earlier. Take a listen
- 4:34Speaker 1: to what he had to say.
- 4:35Speaker 5: Determining whether that case can ultimately be sustained.
- 4:41Speaker 6: There's no way out.
- 4:45Speaker 5: There isn't. So we can try, we all would love
- 4:50Speaker 5: to save the president, I suppose, but he is unsavable
- 4:56Speaker 5: until he answers what those dollars were doing there. This court, therefore,
- 5:04Speaker 5: is not in a position, in terms of our scheme
- 5:07Speaker 5: of democracy, To say when the Constitutional Court tells you
- 5:12Speaker 5: that the panel is to determine whether there's a case
- 5:15Speaker 5: to answer, to say no, the Constitutional Court doesn't know
- 5:20Speaker 5: what it's doing. When will this court get the power
- 5:24Speaker 5: to do that?
- 5:27Speaker 2: That was earlier, Advocate Dallium Porfo.
- 5:29Speaker 1: Let's listen in live now to what's happening at the
- 5:31Speaker 1: moment at the High Court.
- 5:32Speaker 2: And this feed is courtesy of Newsroom Africa.
- 5:36Speaker 7: You look at what ultimately has to be given effect to.
- 5:41Speaker 4: You look at prejudice.
- 5:44Speaker 7: You look at prejudice not just to the president. You
- 5:46Speaker 7: look at prejudice to parliamentary accounting processes. and the ability
- 5:51Speaker 7: of Parliament to hold a member of the executive count,
- 5:53Speaker 7: and you look at the public prejudice. There are a
- 5:56Speaker 7: number of reasons why a defect in the panel report
- 6:00Speaker 7: should not torpedo the entire constitutional accountability process by having
- 6:07Speaker 7: the report set aside.
- 6:09Speaker 6: And it's not absolute. It's not an absolute principle. It
- 6:13Speaker 6: can be deviated from. Is that correct? It's not absolute.
- 6:18Speaker 6: It can be deviated from that principle that she proposes. Absolutely.
- 6:22Speaker 7: And because it's not binding on the impeachment committee, it's
- 6:26Speaker 7: not binding.
- 6:26Speaker 2: You see, it would be prejudicial.
- 6:29Speaker 7: It's unlike the way in which impeachment of judges function.
- 6:34Speaker 7: Parliament takes the view that what the JSC says is
- 6:38Speaker 7: binding on it. And that is why they don't conduct
- 6:41Speaker 7: an impeachment hearing of a judge.
- 6:43Speaker 6: What a menace. The non-interference with the panel process is
- 6:49Speaker 6: not absolute, meaning you can't say the court can never
- 6:52Speaker 6: interfere or refuse.
- 6:53Speaker 7: No, no, no, I'm not saying it can't interfere. I'm
- 6:55Speaker 7: saying it's interference ought to have in top of its mind.
- 6:59Speaker 7: It has to have an enabling effect rather than a
- 7:02Speaker 7: disabling effect in the sense that it has to ask
- 7:04Speaker 7: what value does the judicial interference at this stage give
- 7:09Speaker 7: to the Constitution?
- 7:10Speaker 6: Are we giving.
- 7:11Speaker 7: Effect to the accountability of the, to the power of
- 7:14Speaker 7: the parliament to hold the president account or are we
- 7:18Speaker 7: frustrating that power?
- 7:19Speaker 4: And if you have to frustrate that.
- 7:20Speaker 2: Power, you must.
- 7:21Speaker 7: Because that is entirely your duty.
- 7:23Speaker 2: To do so.
- 7:24Speaker 7: But the way separation of powers, the way the powers
- 7:29Speaker 7: of the courts ought to be exercised, has to have
- 7:34Speaker 7: an enabling effect and not a disabling effect.
- 7:38Speaker 1: Advocate Bani Masuku SC arguing there in the Western Cape
- 7:42Speaker 1: High Court as this argument over the Palo Palo matter continues.