Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - AV Network Security (There's no such thing as an island)
Transcript
- 0:05This is AV Super Friends Off the Rails,
- 0:07an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:09discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:11education.
- 0:12We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:14ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:15and everything in between.
- 0:17And because this conversation will almost
- 0:18certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:20we'll end up covering just about
- 0:21everything else.
- 0:23And now, the AV Super Friends.
- 0:29For March twenty twenty twenty six,
- 0:31it's the best sounding and most secure
- 0:32podcast in higher ed.
- 0:33This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:36Episode number one hundred and thirty
- 0:38four.
- 0:38Two good ones broadcasting live at the
- 0:40exact moment.
- 0:41Day and night finally agree on something.
- 0:44This is the spring equinox edition of
- 0:46super friends.
- 0:47The sun is rising.
- 0:48The semester is dragging in somewhere on
- 0:50campus.
- 0:50An unsecured device is still begging to be
- 0:52adopted by the nearest unmanaged switch.
- 0:55So lock down your ports and add one
- 0:56to all your passwords.
- 0:57We're talking network security today.
- 0:59I'm Chris Hector.
- 1:00You're tuned in for another Friday
- 1:01afternoon podcast adventure.
- 1:04And let's say hello to today's panel of
- 1:06AV Super Friends, which, as you see,
- 1:07is larger than normal.
- 1:08We'll get to that in a second here.
- 1:10Our first panelist oversees the—whoops.
- 1:12No, no, no, no, no.
- 1:13Hold on.
- 1:13We need music.
- 1:14Hold on.
- 1:14You can do this dry.
- 1:15Here we go.
- 1:17Hey.
- 1:18Well, I pushed it, but it didn't—hold on.
- 1:20Our first panelist oversees the delicate
- 1:22balance between open collaboration and
- 1:24absolutely not letting anyone plug random
- 1:26crap into the courtesy LAN port on the
- 1:28lectern.
- 1:28He's a director of endpoint risk
- 1:31mitigation from Kansas City.
- 1:32Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:33That doesn't seem right.
- 1:35I plug everything in.
- 1:39Our next panelist designs secure AV
- 1:41ecosystems while quietly judging IT staff
- 1:43for every unmanaged switch ever hidden
- 1:45above a ceiling tile.
- 1:46He's a senior network AV security
- 1:48architect from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 1:49Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolowazinski.
- 1:51Senior.
- 1:52I love having to have ladders to manage
- 1:53my network.
- 1:54Sorry, that was a typo.
- 1:55Senior.
- 1:56Oh, senior.
- 1:57Sorry.
- 1:58Different.
- 1:58A whole different role.
- 2:00Our next panelist investigates mysterious
- 2:02audio traffic storms and explains,
- 2:04for the hundredth time,
- 2:05why the network is not the cloud.
- 2:07He's a principal analyst for Multicast
- 2:11Forensic from Greensboro, North Carolina,
- 2:13Salem, Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:15All of my audio storms are on private
- 2:17islands.
- 2:17I don't know what this has to do
- 2:19with me.
- 2:20It's in the cloud.
- 2:21Island-like weather.
- 2:22Island clouds.
- 2:24Our next panelist leads enterprise
- 2:25strategy for protecting classroom
- 2:27technology from malware, misconfiguration,
- 2:29and faculty who somehow have admin
- 2:31privileges.
- 2:31He's a vice president for Zero Trust
- 2:33Infrastructure from Bowling Green,
- 2:34Kentucky.
- 2:34Say hello to Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:36I'm also running Network Island,
- 2:38so super secure, zero trust.
- 2:42Perfect.
- 2:43And we're joined by some special guest
- 2:45panelists.
- 2:45Our first guest panelist is brought in
- 2:47whenever a campus decides the only truly
- 2:49secure AV system is one nobody can
- 2:51actually use.
- 2:52He's a senior manager for AirGap
- 2:54Educational Operations from Indianapolis.
- 2:55Say hello to Mr. Doug Schaefer.
- 3:01It's audio, Doug.
- 3:01You got to say something.
- 3:02Oh, hi.
- 3:05Sorry.
- 3:05You can tell I'm the theater of the
- 3:07mind.
- 3:07He was just being super secure.
- 3:09Yes, super secure.
- 3:11There's also live video,
- 3:13so people are looking at you.
- 3:14Yeah, yeah.
- 3:16Our next guest, Panas,
- 3:17is dedicated to minimizing every possible
- 3:19vulnerability,
- 3:19including unsecured touch panels and that
- 3:21one projector that is still on a publicly
- 3:23accessible network.
- 3:23He's a director of AV threat reduction
- 3:25from Northern Virginia.
- 3:26Say hello to Mr. Colin Burney.
- 3:28Hello.
- 3:30I reduced all the threats by force.
- 3:32And our final special guest panelist
- 3:34focuses on protecting campuses from the
- 3:35terrifying intersection of enterprise
- 3:37networking, outdated AV control systems,
- 3:39and hardware that still uses admin as the
- 3:41password.
- 3:42He's a distinguished fellow in cyber
- 3:44physical defense from New York's ALM, Mr.
- 3:45Frank Patakala.
- 3:46Hey, how's it going?
- 3:46Look at this.
- 3:51And the song?
- 3:54for having three extra guests we got
- 3:56through that very fast i was pushing we
- 4:00planned it that way we had a rehearsal
- 4:02yesterday did we yeah on the live run
- 4:04through this went just fine so um so
- 4:06on today's show we're going to discuss av
- 4:08network security and the lack of av
- 4:11network security
- 4:13But first, a little bit of housekeeping.
- 4:14So if you're listening to this as a
- 4:15recorded MP three, remember,
- 4:16we do stream live on Fridays at about
- 4:17three fifteen Eastern or twelve fifteen
- 4:18Pacific or whenever Larry remembers which
- 4:20authenticator app is his two factor to
- 4:22join the show.
- 4:23You can join us live for that on
- 4:24YouTube, LinkedIn, Twitter,
- 4:25where the packets are mostly clean.
- 4:27The opinions are barely filtered and the
- 4:28firewall is really more of a suggestion.
- 4:30If you can't join us live,
- 4:31please keep your connection persistent.
- 4:32You can follow the AV Super Friends on
- 4:34Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube, and Blue Sky.
- 4:35You can share the show with your
- 4:36coworkers, your campus IT folks,
- 4:38your least secure vendor in that one
- 4:39department still using the same password
- 4:41for every computer.
- 4:42Spread the word like an unpatched
- 4:43vulnerability.
- 4:44We'd appreciate it.
- 4:45Of course,
- 4:45if you'd like to support the show,
- 4:46please consider donating.
- 4:47Your contributions help us to keep the
- 4:48signal strong, our nonsense encrypted,
- 4:50and the content flowing like suspicious
- 4:51traffic from an unknown foreign IP that
- 4:53somehow shows up every now and then.
- 4:55This spring, clean out your closets,
- 4:56rotate your credentials,
- 4:57and for the love of all that is
- 4:59holy, please do not cross the VLANs.
- 5:01And finally,
- 5:01while you're listening to us on YouTube,
- 5:02Spotify, Apple Podcasts,
- 5:03or any other platform you're getting this,
- 5:05please rate and review us.
- 5:07Your feedback helps us grow and reach more
- 5:08listeners.
- 5:09Thank you for your support.
- 5:10We couldn't do this without you.
- 5:15purely stolen all right um and now I'm
- 5:25going to shoehorn this in because for
- 5:26those of you who missed the last episode
- 5:28or sixty seconds of what you missed Jamie
- 5:30give me that other slate a full minute
- 5:32If you missed the last episode of AV
- 5:34Super Friends Off the Rails,
- 5:36we did the hard work of discussing AV
- 5:38cybersecurity, design drawings,
- 5:40and the uniquely infuriating art of campus
- 5:43departments buying random gear and
- 5:44creating disasters for everyone else to
- 5:46clean up.
- 5:47It was the exact kind of episode people
- 5:49claim they want more of right before they
- 5:51skip it.
- 5:52We discussed AV trust and the fact that
- 5:55maybe, just maybe,
- 5:56leaving things plugged into the network
- 5:58for fifteen to twenty years with telnet
- 6:00hanging out is not a flawless long-term
- 6:02strategy.
- 6:03Then we wandered into schematics, CAD,
- 6:05napkin sketches, one-off room designs,
- 6:08and the eternal question of where a real
- 6:10AV design actually starts, which, frankly,
- 6:13is more useful than ninety percent of the
- 6:15thought leadership floating around this
- 6:17industry.
- 6:18So, if you missed the last episode,
- 6:20congratulations.
- 6:21You passed up security problems,
- 6:23design arguments,
- 6:24and real-world AV pain in favor of
- 6:27whatever else you were doing,
- 6:28which was almost certainly less
- 6:29informative and somehow dumber.
- 6:32Go fix that.
- 6:33We'll wait.
- 6:36Who was that?
- 6:38Was that Al?
- 6:38That's Al.
- 6:40That was Al, yeah.
- 6:41He sounds different.
- 6:43All right.
- 6:45And now,
- 6:46because everyone's waited for it all week,
- 6:47Justin, you ready to sing along live?
- 6:48Do, do.
- 6:49Here we go.
- 6:49Do it.
- 6:49Do, do, do.
- 6:50Do, do, do, do, do, do.
- 6:51Do, do, do, do, do, do.
- 6:57Time for the news.
- 6:58So this week's article comes to us from
- 7:00Ed Surge,
- 7:01which I gave our guest panelists the
- 7:02better part of four seconds to read.
- 7:04But sorry about that.
- 7:06It happens.
- 7:07Planning.
- 7:08So basically,
- 7:08the article is about a program dealing
- 7:12with K- Twelve kids,
- 7:13but getting them kind of
- 7:15trained up in cybersecurity while they're
- 7:17in high school.
- 7:17So they kind of hit the job market
- 7:19ready to jump right in.
- 7:21It focuses on kind of what partnership
- 7:24with with AV industry or with IT industry
- 7:27manufacturers to try to get that so they
- 7:28get real world training,
- 7:29real world hands on,
- 7:31and basically sets these kids up for
- 7:33success right out of the gate.
- 7:34So those of you who did skim the
- 7:36article, thoughts,
- 7:38I think it's the right direction.
- 7:40Absolutely.
- 7:41I would love to see the content because
- 7:43I bet you it's probably not
- 7:45incredibly relevant but awareness precedes
- 7:48control it's something it's a step in the
- 7:50right direction that's my take the one
- 7:52thing i did like about what they were
- 7:54doing where they were partnering with
- 7:55employers to develop the content and it
- 7:58was constantly evolving because that's in
- 8:01my history of working with computer
- 8:03science students that's one of the
- 8:05complaints i always hear
- 8:07is they're being taught stuff that's no
- 8:09longer relevant in the real world the
- 8:12closer you can get that gap i feel
- 8:14like the the better off you are larry
- 8:17does that class use books because if it
- 8:19does it's probably behind stone tablets
- 8:22brother that's all we have abacus teaching
- 8:24portrait and still out there yeah hey i
- 8:28i like this idea too um especially in
- 8:31this kind of field
- 8:33I,
- 8:34being with coaching and having a bunch of
- 8:35high school kids and everything,
- 8:36I talk to kids a lot all the
- 8:37time and they're like, well, what do you,
- 8:39Hey, what's your next step?
- 8:40What are you going to do?
- 8:40Hey, I'm going to go to college.
- 8:41I'm going to study cybersecurity.
- 8:43Oh really?
- 8:44How'd you get into that?
- 8:45Well, I just heard it pays well.
- 8:47Hold on.
- 8:48They're not wrong.
- 8:49Well, it may not.
- 8:52Isn't that the number one incentive for
- 8:54everything?
- 8:54Well, it is.
- 8:56But I feel like, you know,
- 8:57sometimes we tailor that like, well,
- 8:59I'm going to be a doctor.
- 9:00No, I'm not.
- 9:00I hate biology.
- 9:01Right.
- 9:02You know that by the end of high
- 9:03school that you're not doctor material.
- 9:05You're not whatever it is.
- 9:07But you can be a doctor in a
- 9:08lot of different things, though.
- 9:09I don't know.
- 9:10I think in this I like this because
- 9:13it is kind of that.
- 9:15um that merger like trade schools but it's
- 9:19very it's tactical yes and and set these
- 9:22kids up to on the right pathway now
- 9:25to you guys's point usually the content's
- 9:27a little behind but that's fine i mean
- 9:29they'll catch up as they go it's more
- 9:30of the exposure it's the awareness
- 9:33I think the exposure is the important part
- 9:35because there's a lot,
- 9:36there's a certain level of risk that you
- 9:38have to be comfortable with to work in
- 9:40cybersecurity.
- 9:42And I, for one,
- 9:43am not comfortable with that.
- 9:44So like.
- 9:45Well, you have insurance for that.
- 9:46You're fine.
- 9:47It's like you make a mistake,
- 9:48you're covered.
- 9:49I have been places where the network has
- 9:51been compromised.
- 9:53Insurance does not keep your job.
- 9:56Cybersecurity insurance.
- 9:57So out of curiosity, you know,
- 10:01As you were teenagers learning technology,
- 10:03you were the ones testing the boundaries
- 10:05anyway, right?
- 10:07I mean, I guess.
- 10:08I mean, we got three experts on here.
- 10:09I'm pretty sure that you guys were,
- 10:11I might've been the guy putting the blue
- 10:14screen of death as the screensaver on all
- 10:16the lab computers so that we didn't have
- 10:17to have class because the teacher didn't
- 10:19know how to do it, right?
- 10:21That might've been this guy.
- 10:23So maybe this is right up some of
- 10:24these kids' alleys.
- 10:25Like if they're playing around here
- 10:26anyway, maybe.
- 10:27Yeah,
- 10:27you give them something that's practical
- 10:30that they can kind of use that
- 10:31discretionary energy on versus using it
- 10:33for,
- 10:36now teaching them how to be malicious but
- 10:39there's also two but there's also that
- 10:41element of like danger just like you
- 10:43mentioned right they're like oh this this
- 10:45is working with like a bit of that
- 10:46dark side so there there may be a
- 10:48natural kind of leaning element is to know
- 10:50what is their curiosity because this can
- 10:53be this can go in a different direction
- 10:55right i think there's there is some
- 10:57element of that maybe it's a different
- 10:58crowd than our traditional i.t
- 11:00I don't know.
- 11:01I think it's good to expose more kids
- 11:03to potentially this avenue.
- 11:05And it also don't think cybersecurity is
- 11:08necessarily like a singular thing, right?
- 11:12There's a lot of overlap and you can
- 11:14it's I guess one of those things that's
- 11:15very cross-functional.
- 11:17You can take the cybersecurity skills and
- 11:19apply it almost anywhere.
- 11:20I mean,
- 11:20here we are talking about security.
- 11:22Most of us know each other from our
- 11:24AV backgrounds and our IT chops.
- 11:26And here we are,
- 11:27we're moving into cybersecurity.
- 11:29The fact that it is essentially a part
- 11:31of our conversation today.
- 11:32So I think it's great that schools are
- 11:35investing in that.
- 11:36And I don't think any educational program
- 11:39will ever equip you to do a job.
- 11:41I mean, to be honest,
- 11:42because it doesn't give you,
- 11:44it gives you the skills to learn, right?
- 11:46It teaches you how to learn.
- 11:48And when they go into their first jobs,
- 11:50I think what they've learned,
- 11:51they'll be able to
- 11:52probably apply it somewhere and just grow
- 11:54with it it and cyber security so it's
- 11:56so it's volatile it's dynamic it's
- 11:59changing all the time there's no way you
- 12:01can keep up so you got to be
- 12:02in a job to get the bleeding edge
- 12:04thing so if nothing else it's about giving
- 12:06the exposure like do you want to learn
- 12:08something new every single day then this
- 12:10is a path for you exactly yeah yeah
- 12:13and i think that's that's the thing that
- 12:14struck me about this is that uh i
- 12:15don't know there's two things that kind of
- 12:17struck me about one is it almost feels
- 12:19a little bit like the uh
- 12:21know the after-school programs where
- 12:23you're like hey come play basketball
- 12:25instead of doing something else like they
- 12:27found the kids that are you know because
- 12:29we talk about money as a motivator you
- 12:31know what pays really well too ransomware
- 12:34pays real good that is a huge industry
- 12:39and if you're glad that's not offered in
- 12:42our school
- 12:43Right, but it's offered online.
- 12:47The other thing that I like about it,
- 12:48as I said, credentials matter.
- 12:51They only tell part of the story.
- 12:52And I like that because it sounds like
- 12:54this program is giving people, it's like,
- 12:56yeah,
- 12:56you can go get a CISSP or Security
- 12:59Plus or whatever.
- 13:00You can get those certifications.
- 13:01But unless you've actually sat down and
- 13:04dealt with this, that's an issue.
- 13:06And I'm hoping that...
- 13:08This gives them a couple years of
- 13:10experience because the thing that we found
- 13:13is that like every tech industry,
- 13:15there are about fifty percent too many
- 13:18entry level people for entry level jobs
- 13:22and about ninety percent too few for any
- 13:26level above that.
- 13:27Like if you can break through that three
- 13:29year barrier,
- 13:31suddenly you just have jobs aplenty.
- 13:32And so if they can kind of get
- 13:34them to do that little hop
- 13:36out of that entry level piece,
- 13:38that is a valuable, that's valuable.
- 13:41And I think that that's the issue with
- 13:43with what we're dealing with in the
- 13:45industry is that we have to figure out
- 13:46how to get people past entry level
- 13:47because, yeah,
- 13:48you're going to get burned out and
- 13:49disappointed and frustrated because no one
- 13:51wants to hire you.
- 13:52And we talk to people, you know,
- 13:53AV in general,
- 13:54it's like we talk to people all the
- 13:55time that they're trying to get their
- 13:56first AV job
- 13:58And even though there's this huge need,
- 14:00everyone wants an installer who already
- 14:02knows something.
- 14:04They don't have to reinvent and rebuild.
- 14:06I think just any level of experience is
- 14:08good experience.
- 14:08Right.
- 14:09And so getting people curious and not
- 14:12making it seem like the first thing you
- 14:14need for success is to go past this
- 14:16massive exam somewhere.
- 14:18Right.
- 14:18Like that's,
- 14:18that's not going to get a workforce that's
- 14:20ready to go.
- 14:20So show them a path to immediate placement
- 14:22and get,
- 14:23get them moving as fast as possible.
- 14:26Yep.
- 14:28I also like,
- 14:29I like the premise at least of giving
- 14:31people exposure to cybersecurity without
- 14:32the stress, right?
- 14:35Like teaching people about it as a
- 14:36discipline and like being able to learn
- 14:37some of the skills,
- 14:38but not immediately be also, you know,
- 14:41stressed out all the time about securing
- 14:43an environment that's your responsibility
- 14:44to take care of.
- 14:46I think that's a good way to kind
- 14:47of ease people into it a little bit
- 14:48because some of that anxiety sometimes
- 14:50comes from lack of education.
- 14:52So having the knowledge and then being
- 14:53able to kind of deal with the real
- 14:54world problems afterwards,
- 14:57it feels like it's the right order.
- 14:59So I hope that works out.
- 15:01I think that'd be really cool.
- 15:04Or if nothing else,
- 15:04this is going to generate an entire cadre
- 15:07of awesome hackers who just start getting
- 15:09into all our systems.
- 15:11Which will then in turn create another
- 15:14training profile for more.
- 15:16It's the cycle of life.
- 15:18Yeah,
- 15:18the AV equipment will be first on their
- 15:20list.
- 15:20It's the easiest.
- 15:25This certificate expired ten years ago.
- 15:28Speaking of,
- 15:29isn't that what we're talking about today?
- 15:31We are, but first... Just wait a minute.
- 15:34We've got to pay some bills.
- 15:35We're going to take a quick break.
- 15:37Jamie's going to go find that other thing,
- 15:39and then we'll come back and we're going
- 15:40to talk with Doug and Frank and Colin
- 15:42about how we can fix this mess.
- 15:44Hopefully.
- 15:45Possibly.
- 15:46It's like a thirty-year plan.
- 15:47We're good.
- 15:48Yeah.
- 15:49Fifty.
- 15:50Fifty years.
- 15:50Do it.
- 15:51Alright.
- 15:53The AV Superfriends are supported by
- 15:55Computer Comforts,
- 15:56and they've got a brand new product
- 15:57hitting the lineup.
- 15:58Last year,
- 15:59CCI's Evolve lectern was a big hit,
- 16:01a push-button power table combined with a
- 16:03super flexible AV cabinet.
- 16:05But let's be honest,
- 16:06not every room needs twenty-four units of
- 16:07rack space.
- 16:08Shocking, I know.
- 16:10And that's where the new AV Hub comes
- 16:12in.
- 16:12It's a lighter,
- 16:13more space-efficient solution for
- 16:15classrooms that still need real AV
- 16:16infrastructure.
- 16:17you get eight units of rack space and
- 16:19the whole thing sits only about ten inches
- 16:21off the wall which makes it a great
- 16:22fit when you're pairing it with a
- 16:23sit-stand power table instead of building
- 16:25a massive lectern footprint into the room
- 16:27and this wasn't designed in isolation the
- 16:29av hub was developed in collaboration with
- 16:31texas state university so it's built
- 16:33around real higher ed classrooms and real
- 16:35deployment needs and that means fewer
- 16:37compromises cleaner installs and way less
- 16:40why is this furniture the size of a
- 16:41refrigerator if you want to see photos
- 16:43spec
- 16:44and all the details,
- 16:45head over to computercomforts.com slash
- 16:47av-hub.
- 16:49That's the new AV Hub from Computer
- 16:50Comforts.
- 16:51Purpose built, space efficient,
- 16:53and designed for how classrooms actually
- 16:54work.
- 16:55And thanks again to Computer Comforts for
- 16:57supporting the AV Super Friends.
- 17:02All righty.
- 17:04Security, big stuff.
- 17:06Lots of good things with no actual plan
- 17:10and no provisions, no capability.
- 17:11Well, good show, guys.
- 17:12Good show, yeah.
- 17:13So who are these gentlemen on this show
- 17:15with us, Chris?
- 17:16Three people right up here.
- 17:17So Colin, Doug, and Frank.
- 17:19We teased this three weeks ago,
- 17:21two weeks ago,
- 17:23about the announcement about AV Trust.
- 17:25And you guys came a couple weeks ago.
- 17:27You announced the AV Trust as a nonprofit
- 17:30to kind of,
- 17:31get the industry moving forward to at
- 17:33least, hey,
- 17:34you guys don't need to be pointing in
- 17:35the same direction about securing your
- 17:37stuff because we want all the stuff on
- 17:39the network.
- 17:39We want our single panes of glass.
- 17:41We want all the monitoring.
- 17:42I'm just plugging a cable into the wall
- 17:44and walking away.
- 17:45And let's be honest,
- 17:46I don't have any plans to touch, replace,
- 17:48maintain,
- 17:49or configure that device for fifteen
- 17:50years,
- 17:51which is not a good place to be.
- 17:53So I'm kind of curious.
- 17:55Let me finish.
- 18:00So, yeah, I'll throw it to you guys.
- 18:02Why don't you give us a quick overview
- 18:03of AV Trust,
- 18:04kind of how it came to be and
- 18:05kind of your plan.
- 18:05And then we've got a whole list of
- 18:07topics, except for Justin,
- 18:08who couldn't wait.
- 18:09Justin, what?
- 18:11No, I was just making comments.
- 18:13He's excited.
- 18:14Grunting noises.
- 18:14He's excited.
- 18:15Yeah.
- 18:16I'm thrilled that you already talked about
- 18:18us.
- 18:19That's pretty exciting.
- 18:21I think we can.
- 18:22When you guys dropped the press release,
- 18:24I think all of us went to our
- 18:26back channel.
- 18:27We're like, holy cow, what is this?
- 18:29We actually know these guys,
- 18:30and they're talking about things that are
- 18:31important.
- 18:34So we thought, hey, it's good show fodder.
- 18:36Let's bring them on because we've said it
- 18:38all individually, but we're not experts.
- 18:41I mean, I guess my first question is,
- 18:43you all realize how big this mountain is
- 18:45to climb, right?
- 18:46I mean, I'm pretty sure you know.
- 18:47Ain't no mountain high enough.
- 18:49So how, yeah, you probably recognize that.
- 18:51How did you get this started?
- 18:53Why are we doing,
- 18:54why are you doing this?
- 18:55Not we, you.
- 18:56You're doing the hard work.
- 18:59I got phished.
- 19:00I had no idea what I was saying.
- 19:08This has been bothering me for a while.
- 19:11Security as a topic has been frustrating.
- 19:13And like anything in the industry,
- 19:15I think if you want to find a
- 19:21solution,
- 19:22you kind of have to start doing it
- 19:23yourself.
- 19:23we've talked in the past about like
- 19:25creating communities and spaces and you
- 19:27know places where we can have honest
- 19:28conversation and this is another space
- 19:30that i think at the core is about
- 19:32honest conversation because this
- 19:35potentially involves a lot of negativity
- 19:38and i tested the waters last infocomm by
- 19:41talking to a whole bunch of manufacturers
- 19:43it's like hey
- 19:46We, you know, do you do security?
- 19:48And they're like, yeah, very secure.
- 19:49And it's like, cool.
- 19:52That's not true.
- 19:54No, it's not true.
- 19:55Right.
- 19:56It's like, well,
- 19:56you donate some gear for a hackathon.
- 19:59And they're like, no.
- 20:01We don't need that kind of publicity.
- 20:04Colin, they're already secure.
- 20:05They don't need you to be messing with
- 20:06it.
- 20:06It's secure.
- 20:07Right.
- 20:08You can't stop me,
- 20:09but I'd love for you to participate.
- 20:12After scaring everyone,
- 20:14I had some conversations with Doug and
- 20:17with a few other folks,
- 20:19and we talked about,
- 20:21how do we make this a reality?
- 20:22One of the big gaps that Doug brought
- 20:24up that I thought was really important is
- 20:25that there's no secretariat council for
- 20:28what we do.
- 20:29There has been a history of researchers
- 20:33finding vulnerabilities, reaching out,
- 20:35and then getting threatened.
- 20:37That was number one on our list to
- 20:39say, hey,
- 20:39we'll create a buffer of communication,
- 20:42a legal buffer,
- 20:44and allow a safe way for research to
- 20:47interface with us.
- 20:47Because if we start exposing the industry
- 20:50to more of the broader security community,
- 20:55they're going to get curious and they're
- 20:56going to start poking on stuff and they're
- 20:58going to find out some information.
- 21:00We put the brakes on going straight to
- 21:03hackathon,
- 21:05And Doug said, let's start a nonprofit.
- 21:09So we are the founding board of the
- 21:10nonprofit.
- 21:11I am the vice president and treasurer.
- 21:13Doug is the president.
- 21:14Frank is the secretary.
- 21:16And so that's sort of how this was
- 21:17born is like, well,
- 21:18we need some way to funnel people into
- 21:21something.
- 21:21You know, we're still figuring this out.
- 21:24I think we have some good plans and
- 21:28we have some good people joining in.
- 21:29But this really needs to be a
- 21:31collaborative effort or it's not going to
- 21:32work.
- 21:33And so, you know, thankfully,
- 21:34with that press release,
- 21:35we've gotten a lot of manufacturers
- 21:36reaching out to us.
- 21:37We've had a lot of individuals reaching
- 21:39out saying, Oh, finally,
- 21:41someone doing this.
- 21:43We're still I'm still working.
- 21:44There's a few key security folks I'd
- 21:47really like to be involved who are like
- 21:49hardcore
- 21:50IoT security researchers that we would
- 21:52like to have on board.
- 21:54I think that's the direction.
- 21:56It's like there's a multi-pronged way to
- 21:58deal with this.
- 21:59I think our first push right now is
- 22:00education.
- 22:02I think we were talking to a manufacturer.
- 22:05I was like, yeah,
- 22:05I don't want to be the person that
- 22:07comes in and starts flipping tables and
- 22:09slapping people saying,
- 22:10what's wrong with you?
- 22:11Because I think most people know people
- 22:16don't think about it like if I'm and
- 22:20I'm told to plug that thing in I
- 22:21plug it in I turn it on and
- 22:23I leave and I'm not gonna like it's
- 22:26not gonna be Beneficial or productive to
- 22:28be mad at everyone right off the gate.
- 22:30I think after a while we have to
- 22:31go Hey What are we doing here?
- 22:35We've talked about this.
- 22:36Are you serious?
- 22:37We're still doing this.
- 22:39But I think right now it's like, okay,
- 22:40now we have a platform to start saying
- 22:42that, to start saying,
- 22:43these are standards.
- 22:44You must meet these minimum standards or
- 22:46it doesn't work for us as an industry.
- 22:48It exposes us to risk.
- 22:50It exposes customers at risk.
- 22:52It makes everyone upset.
- 22:53You gotta stop.
- 22:54So that's where we're at.
- 22:57It's really simple.
- 22:58I mean,
- 22:59either we could do it or somebody else
- 23:01could expose us and hold us responsible
- 23:05for it.
- 23:06I mean,
- 23:06the options are pretty much pretty simple
- 23:08right there.
- 23:09And I think all of us, Colin,
- 23:12Doug and myself,
- 23:13I've spent a better part of my career
- 23:14just talking about security.
- 23:16My background is in cybersecurity.
- 23:18I use that cybersecurity knowledge to be
- 23:22useful in my job every day.
- 23:24I mean,
- 23:24so that's that's kind of been my niche.
- 23:26And when this came along,
- 23:28I was like all in.
- 23:29And the reason is like
- 23:30Education is very important.
- 23:32But I also,
- 23:33I want to start this off by saying
- 23:36we're not the doom and gloom people,
- 23:38right?
- 23:38Security never has to be painful.
- 23:41It doesn't have to be challenging.
- 23:42There's a better way to do it.
- 23:44And the reason why anything is challenging
- 23:47is a lack of awareness and most
- 23:50importantly,
- 23:50lack of the language and how to speak
- 23:53it and how to communicate security.
- 23:55The fact of the matter is
- 23:57I feel AV has come a long way.
- 23:58I mean,
- 23:59there's a lot of people who are doing
- 24:00security practices,
- 24:01but just don't know what they're doing.
- 24:03They change their password.
- 24:05The thing is,
- 24:06security as an industry has existed for a
- 24:08long time,
- 24:09probably longer than AV in itself.
- 24:11And what it has done is given us
- 24:13plenty of standards,
- 24:14plenty of ways of communicating these
- 24:16things.
- 24:16and the hope is that we can kind
- 24:18of make this popular make it common
- 24:20knowledge i mean av needs to be integrated
- 24:22with security the the next generation of
- 24:25integrators the next generation of
- 24:27manufacturers the next generation of av
- 24:29designers need to have a security first
- 24:32mindset and that's that's just the way it
- 24:34is as long as you plan on existing
- 24:36on a shared infrastructure
- 24:38As long as you're not going to pull
- 24:40your own cables.
- 24:42That didn't exist.
- 24:44I don't know who.
- 24:46It's my pet peeve.
- 24:47When I hear island,
- 24:48I don't think there's ever been an island.
- 24:50There's no such thing as an island.
- 24:55Yes!
- 24:55Yes!
- 24:56That's a whole other show.
- 24:58Jamie and Mark are on Frank's team.
- 24:59We're on Frank's team.
- 25:01Pick me, pick me.
- 25:03The network.
- 25:04The network.
- 25:08Yes.
- 25:09Yeah.
- 25:09I think we've kind of defaulted to a
- 25:12very simple way of approaching AV
- 25:14deployments by saying, yeah,
- 25:15we're isolated, we're segregated.
- 25:17And you go into network teams and say,
- 25:19hey,
- 25:19can I have a VLAN that has fifty
- 25:21devices?
- 25:22You have no idea the challenges involved
- 25:25with some of these things and how security
- 25:27operates and how networking teams operate.
- 25:29And so what do you do?
- 25:30You're antagonizing the people who are
- 25:32supposed to be friends with.
- 25:34And then I think there's an entire group
- 25:36of people.
- 25:38I think the AV's IT argument that was
- 25:40like, I guess,
- 25:41every day in the Twitter spheres for a
- 25:43long time.
- 25:43That is so old at this point.
- 25:45I know, but the thing is,
- 25:47we try to paint ourselves as something
- 25:49we're not.
- 25:51Yes, AV is all about the experiences.
- 25:53Yes,
- 25:54AV is all about the visual and the
- 25:56experiential impact that we give.
- 25:58But at the end of the day,
- 26:00are you saying that we don't need
- 26:02electricity or we do we not need the
- 26:04infrastructure do we not need the
- 26:05resources yeah and we have to play by
- 26:08their rules right you can create your own
- 26:09rules by saying i'll bring my own switch
- 26:12and i'll create my own network you're
- 26:14saying i will do this whole thing by
- 26:16myself and they're like no you can't
- 26:17because you're in my space you're in my
- 26:20building you're in my facility
- 26:21And that's basically what security has
- 26:23become.
- 26:24And we're hoping that by creating a space
- 26:26where people can come in and contribute
- 26:29and build that next standard future of AV,
- 26:34we'll give people the voice to do that.
- 26:35And that's practically the hope behind
- 26:37this nonprofit.
- 26:39And I know there's people that are
- 26:40listening right now.
- 26:40Their blood is just like boiling.
- 26:43And because there's like the path of
- 26:46getting something done versus the path of
- 26:48getting something done correctly.
- 26:49And there's philosophical differences
- 26:52about getting my ass out of this room
- 26:54and being done, done for me.
- 26:56and making my systems and services work
- 26:59versus it living harmoniously in this
- 27:01luxurious cloud connected and enterprise
- 27:04environment where do i care i don't know
- 27:07and i think there's a lot of ground
- 27:09in between these two examples and we talk
- 27:11about it i don't know every day justin
- 27:15yeah pretty much my my biggest question is
- 27:21we we all understand you know how windows
- 27:24and apple and all these
- 27:25big companies deal with security and their
- 27:28challenges with it.
- 27:29And they have teams of what?
- 27:30I don't know.
- 27:31You guys know more than I do.
- 27:32Thousands of people dealing with security
- 27:34on their whatever more secure numbers.
- 27:37So how I want to like, logically speaking,
- 27:40it's like a guy in the basement.
- 27:42How do these small manufacturers that are
- 27:45all making these products that live on the
- 27:46network have a security team each in their
- 27:49house?
- 27:50Because we all understand that it
- 27:53changes daily, right?
- 27:55We all talked about that.
- 27:56So producing a product with Firmware X and
- 27:59then not releasing another firmware for
- 28:01six months.
- 28:02So are we expecting these people to
- 28:04release updates weekly, daily?
- 28:06Like,
- 28:06what is your thoughts on the long term
- 28:09here and how this is actually achievable?
- 28:13So there's a multifaceted approach to
- 28:17that,
- 28:17and I think it does vary a little
- 28:18bit based on what type of product it
- 28:20is.
- 28:20So you see a lot of Windows-based devices
- 28:24in audio visual today,
- 28:25and there's an existing security framework
- 28:27and a lot of rules that kind of
- 28:28wrap around Windows just by itself,
- 28:30not even including the other parts that
- 28:33would be Teams or Zoom or whatever
- 28:34specific, right?
- 28:37It's pretty hard to say that as a
- 28:41mandated standard,
- 28:43you should have X amount of security
- 28:44professionals regardless of your business
- 28:46size or anything like that.
- 28:47But I think part of what we're trying
- 28:50to kind of help with too is identify
- 28:53what should be expected as far as
- 28:55standards for the products that people
- 28:57kind of buy.
- 28:58um how somebody decides to make sure that
- 29:00those are in their products is up to
- 29:02them it can be a full-time person it
- 29:03can be a contracted team it can be
- 29:05you know a software development team it
- 29:06can be a cio right and i think
- 29:08how that works is going to be different
- 29:10based on the organization and the type of
- 29:11product that they sell and where they're
- 29:13trying to sell it
- 29:14But part of I think some of the
- 29:16variance amongst the vendors in the space
- 29:18has been a little bit just because there's
- 29:21not been a constant,
- 29:22a consistent type of communication about,
- 29:25hey,
- 29:25this is going to be the bare minimum
- 29:26stuff that we for sure expect out of
- 29:28everything that we're going to see go into
- 29:30a corporate or higher education or
- 29:32whatever environment from a networking and
- 29:34application security side of things.
- 29:36And having those standards would make a
- 29:39world of difference towards helping then
- 29:41the companies making the products staff
- 29:43and plan appropriately for product
- 29:45development.
- 29:45Some will know exactly what needs to go
- 29:47in there when they do want to take
- 29:48something to market, right?
- 29:50Because right now it is all over the
- 29:51place.
- 29:51What would some of that be?
- 29:53I mean, we have our ideas,
- 29:54but from your guys' experiences,
- 29:57what are some of those bare minimums?
- 29:59If I'm evaluating in the future today,
- 30:02yesterday,
- 30:03What do you feel some of that bare
- 30:05minimum?
- 30:06What,
- 30:06what kind of things should we be asking
- 30:08from,
- 30:08from the end user side to this
- 30:10manufacturer says, look,
- 30:12we all agree that these are the things
- 30:14you don't have to be super specific
- 30:15because none of us know,
- 30:17but just the overarching thing.
- 30:19What is, what is that?
- 30:20What's it look like?
- 30:21I.
- 30:22I think that there's part of it,
- 30:24and this is a discussion that we've all
- 30:25had,
- 30:25is that our method of updating devices has
- 30:32been broken from the start.
- 30:33And it's the idea that security updates
- 30:36are tied to feature updates.
- 30:37So there's companies,
- 30:38they won't patch a security issue until
- 30:40they have a new feature to roll out.
- 30:42Because you remember the whole thing.
- 30:44It's like there's certain brands where
- 30:45once you get an unstable firmware,
- 30:47don't touch it.
- 30:48Don't touch it.
- 30:50It's working.
- 30:50Walk away.
- 30:51Manufacturers are like, we're done.
- 30:53This is it.
- 30:54We're done.
- 30:55I've even had somewhere,
- 30:55it's like if you want this feature,
- 30:57it's on this one.
- 30:58If you want this feature on this one,
- 30:59they do not exist across these two because
- 31:01we couldn't figure out how to do it.
- 31:03I think that there needs to be a
- 31:04difference between security patching,
- 31:06which should be mandatory over the year
- 31:08patching,
- 31:10and features which are optional.
- 31:12I shouldn't have to accept a new version
- 31:15just because I want to patch a security
- 31:17issue.
- 31:19I think that's a big thing that customers
- 31:21can be asked for to be like, hey,
- 31:23you need to separate these two things.
- 31:25And I think that's part of the issue.
- 31:27I think the other big issue that we
- 31:28have as an industry and this is going
- 31:30to, you know,
- 31:31we're already starting to kind of like
- 31:32poke on some some sore spots is we
- 31:36have a serious issue with rebadged
- 31:39devices.
- 31:40So there's an original manufacturer
- 31:43And then there's,
- 31:44like we play that game where you go
- 31:45to the little tiny tables around the edge
- 31:47of InfoComm and you take notes.
- 31:49Yeah,
- 31:50and then you go and find it in
- 31:52a thirty booths.
- 31:53And so if the OEM finds a security
- 31:57issue,
- 31:58they can't patch that because everyone has
- 32:00written custom firmware that at the very
- 32:03least has a different name and logo in
- 32:05it, or even better has, you know,
- 32:08some other items,
- 32:10but it means that there's this long,
- 32:11complicated process of communicating
- 32:13through.
- 32:13And we've seen this in the past.
- 32:14And we've called them out on that.
- 32:15They're like, yeah,
- 32:16that's the company we buy this shit from,
- 32:18from Australia or whatever.
- 32:19And you're like, well,
- 32:21it's still a problem.
- 32:23It's still your name on this invoice, sir.
- 32:25Yeah.
- 32:26Yeah,
- 32:26you're still the support number I was told
- 32:27to call.
- 32:29And at a certain point, it's like, okay,
- 32:32you're torpedoing your business model by
- 32:34pointing backwards.
- 32:35It's like, well,
- 32:36then why wouldn't I just buy from the
- 32:37person who's guaranteed to patch it?
- 32:39And I think that's a big issue.
- 32:42And these are things that I think are
- 32:43important discussions to have.
- 32:44And I'm hoping that this is part of
- 32:47what we're talking about is to say, okay,
- 32:49why don't we start pushing on these points
- 32:51in a little more serious manner?
- 32:54The other thing I just want to jump
- 32:56in and say is like,
- 32:57when we talk about security,
- 33:00if you've noticed the last twenty minutes,
- 33:02we're all trying to go towards that
- 33:03technical conversation, right?
- 33:05We're looking for how to secure things.
- 33:07The fact of the matter is security never
- 33:09starts from a technical conversation.
- 33:11Security starts from a pure non-technical
- 33:14documentation.
- 33:15My favorite security term,
- 33:16and I love using this, is risk profile.
- 33:20What's a risk profile?
- 33:21A risk profile is telling the stakeholder
- 33:24that, hey,
- 33:24I'm giving you this box and I have
- 33:27no idea what it does.
- 33:29Right.
- 33:30And if Larry says, I'm cool with that,
- 33:33I know what it does.
- 33:34I'll take care of the risk.
- 33:36I've done my job.
- 33:38I've informed you that I'm clueless as far
- 33:40as the security is concerned.
- 33:42And Larry's like,
- 33:43I know the function of the box.
- 33:45I have a strategy in place for dealing
- 33:48with boxes that have no security profile.
- 33:51This is not uncommon in the world of
- 33:53IT.
- 33:55You'd think that IT is completely
- 33:57standards-based and all uniform.
- 33:59Heck no.
- 34:00It's worse than this.
- 34:02IT people and security people deal with
- 34:04the same problems that we're talking
- 34:05about.
- 34:06Manufacturing inconsistencies,
- 34:09firmware issues, patching problems,
- 34:11security patching updates.
- 34:13There are several products out there that
- 34:15are very popular in the IT world today
- 34:17that have not had a security update for
- 34:19months.
- 34:20And you know what?
- 34:21That's common, they know it.
- 34:23The thing is what we need to enable
- 34:25the AV community as a whole is to
- 34:28understand how do we deal with the risk
- 34:30of it and what is the strategy associated
- 34:33with it?
- 34:33That is what we lack from the get-go,
- 34:36right?
- 34:36Once we've identified the strategy
- 34:38associated with dealing with the risk,
- 34:40then you'll have the right questions to
- 34:42say, hey,
- 34:42my network team will not accept something
- 34:45that does not do this.
- 34:46That is a more informed conversation to
- 34:50your manufacturer than this saying, hey,
- 34:51can you give me a document that says
- 34:53all the different things you do?
- 34:55They don't know what you're looking for.
- 34:56And so maybe help the community as a
- 34:58whole by building a collaborative
- 35:00environment.
- 35:01The problem is nobody knows what to ask
- 35:03and nobody knows what to say.
- 35:04So it's like it's a completely confusing
- 35:06environment.
- 35:06You have to build a common lexicon.
- 35:08And I look at this and it feels
- 35:09like this is a coming of age of
- 35:10AV.
- 35:11Are we finally being tall enough to ride
- 35:14this IT rollercoaster in a way that we're
- 35:16not just taking black boxes and just
- 35:18pushing shit around structured cable?
- 35:20Because that's really where this all came
- 35:21from.
- 35:22How can I save money and not have
- 35:23to put this Klingon cable through this
- 35:24wall where I can just use this CatFive
- 35:26that's right here?
- 35:27It all just kind of grew up a
- 35:29little bit.
- 35:30It was cheaper for a lot of people
- 35:32to kind of...
- 35:34basically put the blinders on and say,
- 35:35hey, you know what?
- 35:36I'm going to not care about that right
- 35:37now because I can put this in a
- 35:39closet and not look at it.
- 35:41Network island.
- 35:42And to Frank's point,
- 35:45the whole premise about communication
- 35:48is...
- 35:49called security by obscurity and something
- 35:51that's a big problem in av is like
- 35:53this stuff is secured by basically not
- 35:55having information available about it and
- 35:57they say you know nobody knows how to
- 35:59find anything so it's it's fine we're not
- 36:01we're not gonna look it's all good yeah
- 36:03uh and that's that's not a as functional
- 36:06it never really was a strategy but it
- 36:09kind of finds a lot of holes
- 36:11as people are starting to require that
- 36:13information in order to adopt the
- 36:15technology properly because it needs to
- 36:17integrate with the rest of your network
- 36:18security profile, right?
- 36:20That's how you communicate.
- 36:21That's how communication works.
- 36:22I like how Frank brought that up because
- 36:24Mark and I,
- 36:26you know,
- 36:26when we're trying to put everything on,
- 36:28on our enterprise, right, we had to have,
- 36:30like,
- 36:30one of the things I really struggled with
- 36:32right away was I didn't understand network
- 36:34names and terms.
- 36:35And the the white sheet you get from
- 36:39manufacturers, like, well,
- 36:39QoS has to be well, that on enterprise,
- 36:42that's not necessarily how work.
- 36:44No, it's not.
- 36:45Right.
- 36:45And so I had just bark out orders
- 36:47and say, do this.
- 36:48It's not I had, yeah,
- 36:49I had to learn all that I had
- 36:50to learn the lexicon,
- 36:51I had to learn
- 36:53And I don't even know how to be
- 36:54a systems admin,
- 36:55but I had to know the language and
- 36:56I had to be able to talk to
- 36:57him.
- 36:58And to Mark's point earlier,
- 37:00I feel like this is the next step.
- 37:02Like, I don't know what to ask.
- 37:04I don't know what's going to get blocked
- 37:05tomorrow until it is.
- 37:06And then I say, well, why?
- 37:09Well, because of these things.
- 37:10Oh, well, I'll remember to ask next time.
- 37:14Is this something for that lexicon thing?
- 37:16Is that something that's kind of part of
- 37:18the pathway too?
- 37:19Kind of like, hey, dummy,
- 37:20here's your primer.
- 37:22These are the key words that you need
- 37:24to ask even if you don't understand them.
- 37:26So we can print them on AVSF cards
- 37:27and have them at Infocomm.
- 37:29These are the key security words you need
- 37:30to know.
- 37:31Know these words or know how to use
- 37:32them in a sentence to sound like you
- 37:34know these words.
- 37:35Honestly, it's like even in the networks.
- 37:38When I do teaching across managed
- 37:39services, across IT stuff,
- 37:41and now across security,
- 37:42vocabulary is really big because
- 37:45Everyone has acronyms that they know,
- 37:48and they all speak this language,
- 37:50and they have common meaning for words
- 37:53that might just be normal words to the
- 37:55rest of us.
- 37:56And I think that is really important.
- 37:58And I think the great thing about what
- 37:59we're doing,
- 38:00and this was a discussion early on about
- 38:03how we were approaching this,
- 38:04we don't want to create,
- 38:06we don't want to baby the AV people
- 38:09and say, oh, we're special.
- 38:12We run IOT devices,
- 38:14which are the most miserable,
- 38:16hateful devices you could possibly put on
- 38:18a network.
- 38:19And once we accept that, we go, okay,
- 38:21there's a framework for containing this
- 38:23threat.
- 38:24There's a vocabulary to go around it.
- 38:25There are some specific things that are
- 38:27unique to what we do because we have
- 38:30things like Dante and we have NDI and
- 38:32we have all sorts of fun stuff like
- 38:33that.
- 38:34But there does need to be a common
- 38:36language.
- 38:36And I think the nice thing is that
- 38:37all that training is available and free
- 38:39and
- 38:40right now like i always tell people like
- 38:41go get the cc it's an easy like
- 38:43it's a it's a sort of one-on-one
- 38:45vocabulary lesson okay cc expand that what
- 38:48is like an acronym what does that mean
- 38:50it's the sort of processor to the cissp
- 38:53it's kind of like if you went to
- 38:55infocomm and you got the
- 38:57What's the one you do the little tests
- 38:58for where it's like,
- 38:59you're a certified AV technician?
- 39:02What is that one?
- 39:03There's a really easy test that you do
- 39:06on InfoComm that gets you a really easy
- 39:07test.
- 39:07Oh, the recognized AV technologist one?
- 39:09Yes, that one.
- 39:11It's basically that for security.
- 39:13It's a little more in-depth,
- 39:15but it basically spends a lot of time
- 39:17on the security triad and a lot of
- 39:19the language,
- 39:20because there is that sort of divergent
- 39:22path within security.
- 39:24there are the managers like cso's
- 39:27generally aren't sitting and configuring
- 39:31all of the security tools and at the
- 39:33same time people who configure security
- 39:35tools aren't generally writing policy
- 39:37around risk and setting you know our risk
- 39:40appetite around you know certain products
- 39:42and that sort of piece so there's a
- 39:45little bit of the language you have to
- 39:47have just to get into the technical part
- 39:49of it because they have to work together
- 39:51and so yeah that is part of our
- 39:52plan is to say
- 39:53look, if we don't have the training,
- 39:54I'll point you at it all day long.
- 39:56And there's a lot of great resources
- 39:57already available.
- 40:00Exactly.
- 40:01There's plenty of certifications in IT.
- 40:03CC is one, Security Plus.
- 40:06Heck, get a good network certification.
- 40:09Even a vendor-based network certification
- 40:12will give you some understanding of how
- 40:14these things operate.
- 40:15The problem is we come into it
- 40:17saying that we're AV designers,
- 40:19AV integrators, AV people,
- 40:22and we have no idea what we're asking
- 40:24of other people,
- 40:26the other communities involved in our
- 40:28deployment.
- 40:29The crazy part is we do this really
- 40:31well with everybody other than IT.
- 40:34We have coordination documents
- 40:37that are excellent, that go to architects,
- 40:39that go to mechanical vendors,
- 40:40that go to contractors, right?
- 40:42But when it comes to IT,
- 40:44you send them a signal flow drawing,
- 40:45which is every network person that looks
- 40:49at a signal flow is like,
- 40:50what the hell is this?
- 40:52Why are you giving me this?
- 40:53What does this mean?
- 40:55And that's the problem, right?
- 40:56We've stopped somewhere along the way
- 40:58saying this is not my job.
- 40:59I don't know why.
- 41:01But it is our job.
- 41:01There's a lot of animosity still that's
- 41:03built up over the years, right?
- 41:04And so I think a lot of us,
- 41:06we put things on,
- 41:07I'm going to use their network, right?
- 41:09So here that is.
- 41:11And then we get the sense,
- 41:13we're going to go talk to a network
- 41:15security group today.
- 41:16And everybody's like, okay,
- 41:16you got your cheat sheet.
- 41:17You got to just have the lingo right.
- 41:19Because it's like unlocking an API.
- 41:22If you don't have the correct code words,
- 41:24it's done.
- 41:24They're like,
- 41:24you don't even know what the fuck you're
- 41:26talking about.
- 41:27Well,
- 41:27and also to just as well as we
- 41:29do, like they use their acronym.
- 41:30We don't know what it is.
- 41:31And that's it.
- 41:31It's open.
- 41:32And also you get one shot to authenticate.
- 41:34In reality,
- 41:35when you're communicating with a network
- 41:37group or security group,
- 41:39you as a AV professional, any of us,
- 41:43don't make these things.
- 41:44We're not making these boxes.
- 41:47And so we're relying on the manufacturer's
- 41:49documentation.
- 41:50And so we conjure that up.
- 41:52We call our reps.
- 41:53We're like, do you have anything else?
- 41:54Because this is shit.
- 41:55I need some more information.
- 41:56They send you some more stuff that's like
- 41:58closed up in the back room that they're
- 42:00not going to let out.
- 42:01And you give that to the network group
- 42:02and they're like,
- 42:03none of this makes any sense.
- 42:04You're an idiot.
- 42:05We're like, ah,
- 42:07so it starts with the manufacturers
- 42:09really.
- 42:10And it, and it flows from there.
- 42:12That's the reality of it.
- 42:13The biggest,
- 42:13whatever thing in the world and give them
- 42:15that.
- 42:16I think this is an immature product.
- 42:18Like we can't make up what the boxes.
- 42:21Hold on here.
- 42:24Here's the thing that I,
- 42:25I struggle with is that,
- 42:27Yes.
- 42:27Security people are kind of throwing their
- 42:29hands up and, you know, be like,
- 42:32I think there's some there's some there's
- 42:34something to be said for, hey,
- 42:36we need to go patch things up with
- 42:37security people.
- 42:38We've been, you know,
- 42:39letting our dog take a dump in their
- 42:40yard every day and not cleaning it up
- 42:42and then going, hey, neighbor.
- 42:43And that's rude.
- 42:44Moving on.
- 42:45That's rude.
- 42:46Wait.
- 42:47It is.
- 42:48One thing I would say is,
- 42:49is I can't think of anyone who got
- 42:52all the gear to the to their warehouse.
- 42:55got it in a rack and then just
- 42:57ran a basic vulnerability like a standard
- 42:59vapt test on that gear and just check
- 43:03to see if there's anything going on on
- 43:04it yeah right and so hey okay cool
- 43:06did you you know have you done your
- 43:09basics like did you did you at least
- 43:10check it out and make sure it's not
- 43:11goofy or weird and you go i don't
- 43:13know what you're talking about where i'm
- 43:14just gonna throw it on your network so
- 43:16now i have to do it while it's
- 43:18on my production network
- 43:20Well, we've been burned on this.
- 43:21So we will, you know,
- 43:23we'll lab it up or whatever one time.
- 43:25Yeah, that's great.
- 43:26Oh, this thing, this thing.
- 43:28That's the other thing is the scale of
- 43:29this.
- 43:29So we lab it up.
- 43:31Let's say it's a manufacturer X model Y.
- 43:34We're like, OK, well, it passed.
- 43:36There's no documentation that it says it's
- 43:37using Telnet and you buy them.
- 43:39And then, you know,
- 43:40part of our practice is, you know,
- 43:43we have to have the security group scan
- 43:45our devices when they do end up on
- 43:47our network because sometimes they do.
- 43:50Um, I joke about network islands a lot,
- 43:51but you know, it's whatever.
- 43:53Yeah.
- 43:54And then all of a sudden they,
- 43:55they have this new firmware and then
- 43:57there's this new thing exposed.
- 43:59And now we look like idiots again,
- 44:00because the security team caught it.
- 44:01Like, why didn't you catch this?
- 44:02Well, I'm not,
- 44:03I'm not scanning every system that I have.
- 44:05Cause we don't have the personnel to do
- 44:07that.
- 44:07And it goes,
- 44:08it kind of goes back to the resources
- 44:09too.
- 44:10It's a, it's a.
- 44:11it's a game cyclical thing that just never
- 44:14ends.
- 44:14Right.
- 44:15But,
- 44:15but I think that understanding who's
- 44:17responsible, if you know that you're,
- 44:20you're kind of responsible because you're
- 44:21going to allow that firmware to go on,
- 44:23but giving them a heads up being like,
- 44:25Hey,
- 44:25we're going to be pushing some new
- 44:26firmware.
- 44:27Just so you know.
- 44:29Well, you don't even know.
- 44:30You buy the product and it came with
- 44:31it.
- 44:32And you're like,
- 44:32I didn't read every manual every time I
- 44:34buy a product.
- 44:36The one I tested came with version two
- 44:39point oh.
- 44:40And well, I mean,
- 44:42I'll let you in on a secret.
- 44:43I don't think all the manufacturers made
- 44:44it either.
- 44:46Exactly.
- 44:47That's my point, Frank.
- 44:49There's probably one person or two or a
- 44:51small group of people who understand that
- 44:53six-page white paper.
- 44:54You're probably getting it from a rep.
- 44:56They've seen two pages in it.
- 44:58Heck, we have AI today, right?
- 45:01I think AI is going to be a
- 45:02bridge in a lot of these communications.
- 45:04It has to.
- 45:05It has to.
- 45:07At some point,
- 45:08we have to understand that our language
- 45:11needs to align with whoever we're talking
- 45:13to, otherwise our products.
- 45:15And it doesn't help that there are still
- 45:18strong proponents of,
- 45:19let's build it out on our own island,
- 45:21let's build it out on our own thing.
- 45:23And you know what?
- 45:24I'm okay with that.
- 45:26If that's how your deployment strategy
- 45:28works,
- 45:29and if the client is okay with it,
- 45:32Attach a risk profile to that and tell
- 45:34them, hey,
- 45:35we have no idea what's on your switch,
- 45:37but we know your switches exist.
- 45:39If that's okay with the client, sure.
- 45:41But that's the thing.
- 45:42We need to be able to give those
- 45:44educated opinions, educated, qualified,
- 45:47technical conversations about our
- 45:49products.
- 45:49If we're selling a product,
- 45:51if we own a product,
- 45:52we need to own it.
- 45:54We need to understand it.
- 45:55That's basic, basic, basic.
- 45:57Any sales one-on-one.
- 46:00I'm curious about how
- 46:03we go beyond this black box strategy.
- 46:06Because as we look forward,
- 46:09I for one believe that it becomes less
- 46:11about the black boxes.
- 46:12When we start throwing in things like
- 46:14cloud,
- 46:15And service delivery from that.
- 46:18That is a whole different layer of this
- 46:20cake that I can tell right now from
- 46:22my recent interactions with all these
- 46:25monitoring companies and the manufacturers
- 46:27they're tying up to.
- 46:28I believe the industry is way out over
- 46:31its skis.
- 46:32Way out over its skis on a lot
- 46:34of things right now.
- 46:35And I don't know how...
- 46:37they're going to pull things back because
- 46:38right now they're trying to figure out how
- 46:39to monetize things faster than they can
- 46:41even support them.
- 46:42And I think one of the things I
- 46:45was going to ask on,
- 46:46I think it dovetails here, Mark,
- 46:47under your question is that I've heard
- 46:49Colin say several times, IOT, IOT.
- 46:51The only thing that my, like my people,
- 46:54uh,
- 46:54security people hate the term more than AV
- 46:57is IOT.
- 46:57Um,
- 46:59but IOT because of the internet of things,
- 47:01right?
- 47:01That's the internet connected to the
- 47:03cloud.
- 47:03I agree.
- 47:04I think we are moving to Mark's point.
- 47:06We are moving to an IOT.
- 47:08We are moving to a cloud persistence.
- 47:10We are moving to a true internet of
- 47:12things, whether or not they'd move audio,
- 47:15video, something else.
- 47:17So I was interested.
- 47:18I was going to ask similar to call
- 47:20it like you keep saying IOT,
- 47:21which I agree with.
- 47:22Um,
- 47:23but that brings all these other challenges
- 47:25to what Mark said.
- 47:26How do we merge that?
- 47:27How do we take it from the trons
- 47:30to the cloud?
- 47:32It's not just to have an account and
- 47:33you owe your provision and you're paying
- 47:34your thousands of dollars a month.
- 47:35Well, everything's good.
- 47:36It's like, no, no, no, no, no.
- 47:37There's so much more to this story.
- 47:40I think this is a little bit,
- 47:41this is a challenge for even the IT
- 47:43folks because, you know,
- 47:45removing AV from the conversation,
- 47:47the area of IoT security is honestly kind
- 47:50of a new space for a lot of
- 47:51people by itself, right?
- 47:53So, you know,
- 47:55it's helpful to be able to articulate,
- 47:57I think,
- 47:58that your devices are non-standard on the
- 48:00network,
- 48:01but also
- 48:03the IT folks that a lot of people
- 48:05are used to working with don't necessarily
- 48:07have an immediate answer to the question,
- 48:08hey,
- 48:08how do you secure your IoT devices either?
- 48:12Which is why it's all the more important
- 48:14that we're able to articulate at least for
- 48:16our own technology stack,
- 48:18like what the needs and responsible usage
- 48:20of that is.
- 48:22I agree with the being out over our
- 48:23skis thing.
- 48:24History kind of usually shows that there's
- 48:26a little bit of a rubber band effect
- 48:28at some point when that starts to bite
- 48:30us on the butt.
- 48:33That was the journey and the experience
- 48:35when we started to venture onto the
- 48:37network in the first place with a couple
- 48:38of things about application security and
- 48:40functions online.
- 48:41networking protocols and stuff like that.
- 48:44I don't know what that catalyst is going
- 48:46to be, but supply-demand situation,
- 48:49if people are looking for more features
- 48:51for maturation of their devices,
- 48:53then usually there's a lot of stuff that
- 48:54happens to catch up when it needs to
- 48:56happen.
- 48:57Usually there's a little bit of a
- 48:58punishment first.
- 49:00I think we all have CISOs or some
- 49:03version of that on our campus.
- 49:05I've had some recent conversations and a
- 49:07lot of the belief is it's not the
- 49:08traditional vector of attack.
- 49:10It's not from an actor who's going to
- 49:12come into our network.
- 49:13The calls are going to come from inside
- 49:14of the house.
- 49:15That's going to be something that's here
- 49:17that's going to call out and invite in
- 49:19what's going on.
- 49:20Probably those high school students we
- 49:22just talked about earlier.
- 49:23That's a different traditional posture
- 49:25than your normal security.
- 49:27And I think just the volume of stuff
- 49:29that we have
- 49:31makes them look at us a little bit
- 49:33differently.
- 49:33You have a lot of stuff that can
- 49:35potentially communicate to the cloud
- 49:36system, which we have no control over.
- 49:38Well, not only that,
- 49:40we have a lot of stuff,
- 49:41and this is a very, very real concern,
- 49:44is that anymore,
- 49:47we're getting a little deeper into some of
- 49:49the major issues and the things that give
- 49:51me stress.
- 49:52is that it is entirely possible,
- 49:55because it has been caught numerous times
- 49:57already,
- 49:58for a device to record information
- 50:02locally,
- 50:04wait for an opportunity to open up a
- 50:05window to open up,
- 50:06and then exfiltrate that data out.
- 50:08And when you have devices that are sitting
- 50:09and listening to private conversations,
- 50:12privileged conversations,
- 50:15I can set advice to be like, hey,
- 50:16look for the CEO of this company.
- 50:18When you see that dude's face,
- 50:19you start recording that audio.
- 50:20Transcribe it to text.
- 50:22Hide that text somewhere encrypted and
- 50:24next time there's a little call out,
- 50:25send that out and maybe we'll learn
- 50:27something, you know,
- 50:28and that's the kind of thing that we
- 50:30are.
- 50:31We are especially dangerous,
- 50:32not just because we are an attack vector
- 50:35that exists and is kind of forgotten
- 50:37about.
- 50:39But we are also capable of doing a
- 50:41lot more damage because of what we can
- 50:42bring in.
- 50:43You've seen what's happened with the flock
- 50:45cameras.
- 50:45Their credibility is absolutely destroyed
- 50:47right now.
- 50:48And you watch the videos.
- 50:49It's so easy to get into a flock
- 50:51camera and just watch what's going on.
- 50:54That's a lot of power.
- 50:55Because if I can find a flock camera
- 50:56somewhere that has privileged activities
- 51:00going on in it,
- 51:02I'm not now just getting into a camera.
- 51:04I'm potentially getting information that I
- 51:06should not have access to and probably
- 51:08wouldn't have any other way.
- 51:09And so we are in a very dangerous
- 51:12position because we have put these things
- 51:14inside of boardrooms.
- 51:16We put this inside of government agencies.
- 51:19And that's what stresses me out about it
- 51:23is that we're such a widespread
- 51:29technology based like everyone just
- 51:30assumed you're going to have some sort of
- 51:31video calling at this point.
- 51:34But we're I don't think we're really up
- 51:36to it.
- 51:36I think it's the philosophical approach
- 51:41from the years is like in q one,
- 51:42we're going to sell this black box q
- 51:43two, we're gonna sell this black box.
- 51:45And yeah,
- 51:45I think the industry is just overly
- 51:47concerned about the better mousetrap
- 51:49continuously that they're just not seeing
- 51:51the entirety of this picture.
- 51:53And they're not even staffed and their
- 51:55organizational structure is not made up to
- 51:58even dive into this.
- 52:00We've engaged with the conversation and
- 52:02they're just like,
- 52:05they look at you in the biggest of
- 52:07the big ones, all AV.
- 52:08I want to throw them all in the
- 52:09same bucket.
- 52:11Nobody is tall enough to engage in this
- 52:14for this ride and have the conversation
- 52:16that they're too concerned about staying
- 52:18solvent than they are solving the network
- 52:20problem.
- 52:21I mean, to be honest,
- 52:22that's one of the reasons it was really
- 52:24important to us to start AV Trust as
- 52:26a nonprofit.
- 52:28I think it's really tricky for a company
- 52:31to prioritize security over revenue when
- 52:34your whole business model revolves around
- 52:36sales, right?
- 52:39something that we kind of have to our
- 52:41advantage or to our credit.
- 52:42And I hope this is, you know,
- 52:44ultimately what helps other people or help
- 52:46other organizations is like we would be
- 52:49one of the only, you know,
- 52:50bodies of people that are actively working
- 52:53on us because we care about it and
- 52:54not because we're being forced to in order
- 52:56to make money.
- 52:57Right.
- 52:59And that's really important in the
- 53:00security space.
- 53:01There are other industries where that's
- 53:02been a precedent to where it's like, hey,
- 53:04in order for there to be any kind
- 53:06of consistent work put in to help kind
- 53:10of keep this thing afloat, you know,
- 53:12some some nonprofit participation is
- 53:14required.
- 53:15And that's that's kind of you know,
- 53:17it was very important to us for that
- 53:19reason,
- 53:19that we would be a source of trust,
- 53:22but also just
- 53:24People know that we're not making money.
- 53:30They're not doing it to make money.
- 53:32They're doing it to make sure that it's
- 53:33happening and happening for the right
- 53:34reasons.
- 53:37That's one of the most important parts of
- 53:39that.
- 53:40So for some of our, there's probably,
- 53:42we may have a listener or two that
- 53:45are very interested in this.
- 53:49Well, not total listeners,
- 53:51just that are interested in this.
- 53:55Like if they're sitting there thinking,
- 53:56how do I get involved with this?
- 53:57This sounds awesome.
- 53:59This is where I want to go.
- 54:01This is my passion also.
- 54:03And I've never heard somebody do an
- 54:05organization like this.
- 54:07How can they get involved with you?
- 54:09And what kind of things are you like?
- 54:11What kind of helpers are you looking for?
- 54:14I'm going to guess you don't just need
- 54:15some nerd.
- 54:16You know,
- 54:17like you have specific initiatives you
- 54:19want to go to.
- 54:21No more nerds,
- 54:22only non-nerds who can communicate.
- 54:24No super nerds.
- 54:25Got my candy, right?
- 54:28But like what skill set,
- 54:30not skill set in particular,
- 54:32but like your initiatives are X, Y,
- 54:34Z right now, your short term goals.
- 54:36What kind of people are you looking for
- 54:37to help you get there?
- 54:39Because as a nonprofit,
- 54:40it's not like you're just out there
- 54:41throwing money at all these people.
- 54:43So if somebody is passionate,
- 54:45what kind of passionate person do you
- 54:46want?
- 54:48Yeah, so I mean,
- 54:48it was important to us to be able
- 54:50to have a lot of different types of
- 54:51people contribute.
- 54:53There are going to be people that care
- 54:54that don't have a whole bunch of
- 54:56cybersecurity training formally,
- 54:57but they would potentially want to learn.
- 55:00There's also some people that have come to
- 55:02us from actual full-time cybersecurity
- 55:04jobs that haven't done very much AV that
- 55:06were like,
- 55:06this is really interesting to us because
- 55:08of the IoT conversation, right?
- 55:10which is really great.
- 55:11And that was honestly the goal.
- 55:12We were really,
- 55:12really hoping we would get people from
- 55:14both sides because that's that's what's
- 55:16going to make us better,
- 55:16because I think the the being able to
- 55:20translate from cybersecurity as a whole to
- 55:22audio visual and make sure the lexicon
- 55:24works and stuff like that,
- 55:25it's going to require a good understanding
- 55:27of our environment, our ecosystem,
- 55:29our technology stack,
- 55:31but also a good understanding of how the
- 55:32industry as a whole does things we can
- 55:33learn from each other.
- 55:34Right.
- 55:36So we're kind of putting together a couple
- 55:38of different councils about one is
- 55:41generally for standards development,
- 55:43you know, just understanding, hey,
- 55:45this is going to be, you know,
- 55:47we talked about what the bare minimum is
- 55:48going to be for technology that goes on
- 55:50the network that we see from vendors like
- 55:53putting together councils to start to
- 55:54build those standards a little bit so that
- 55:55we can say, hey,
- 55:57if you guys want to, you know,
- 55:59X vendor,
- 55:59if you guys want to have a technology
- 56:01product that gets reviewed by us or,
- 56:02you know, by a client,
- 56:03they ask us for help or whatever.
- 56:05These are the standards we're going to use
- 56:06to kind of benchmark that, so to speak,
- 56:09and kind of start to put that together
- 56:12so that people can understand what that is
- 56:13and have a common understanding of like
- 56:15what the expectation is.
- 56:16We're also kind of looking for people to
- 56:18help with some events and some training
- 56:21materials, education,
- 56:22writing documentation,
- 56:23because there is a ton of that that's
- 56:24so very needed that they'd be able to
- 56:27interface with some of our nerds and help
- 56:30with some of that in writing and help
- 56:32with the education part of it,
- 56:33because that's going to be really
- 56:34important for us as well.
- 56:36I think contact information wise and we
- 56:37can share this in any format necessary,
- 56:40but we have a Discord right now that
- 56:41that's been kind of doing well,
- 56:43popping off.
- 56:45We have a website, which is aviatrust.org,
- 56:48which Colin put a lot of time and
- 56:50effort into.
- 56:50So that's awesome.
- 56:51And our email address and contact info is
- 56:53on there as well.
- 56:56I put a lot of time and effort
- 56:57into it because I'm not good at making
- 56:58websites.
- 56:59So what you see on there is the
- 57:01absolute best I can do.
- 57:04Yeah,
- 57:05a lot of time and a lot of
- 57:06like...
- 57:07why why doesn't this work no but yeah
- 57:11i think i think the and the other
- 57:13thing too is like we do have the
- 57:14secretariat council that is meant to uh
- 57:17ingest the any sort of security sides to
- 57:21it um i i think
- 57:23to it's like, yes, we're a nonprofit.
- 57:26Yes, we do need money.
- 57:27I think one of the things that some
- 57:29of the people that we need to interface
- 57:31with will not work for free and I
- 57:32wouldn't expect them to.
- 57:34If I want to hire a security researcher
- 57:36to study a family of products,
- 57:40I need to be able to buy those
- 57:41products,
- 57:41pay for that person's time and then
- 57:42present that information.
- 57:44I'd love to do that in partnership with
- 57:45someone so I can put their name on
- 57:47it, we use it for marketing, whatever.
- 57:49But then it will be freely available to
- 57:50everyone.
- 57:51That is a really important piece about
- 57:53what we talked about is that there's not
- 57:55really membership.
- 57:56People will be on councils,
- 57:57people will be sponsors,
- 57:59but everything we do,
- 58:00we want to be available.
- 58:01If we put on an event,
- 58:02we're going to record it,
- 58:03we're going to put it on for free
- 58:04because it is better for all of us
- 58:06that that information is available.
- 58:09than to try and turn it into some
- 58:11sort of incentive to give us money.
- 58:13I just want to get things out there.
- 58:15But there is some money necessary to get
- 58:18into that,
- 58:18because I would like to pay researchers to
- 58:20just dive on stuff.
- 58:21Send them a box full of stuff and
- 58:23say, hey, take this apart.
- 58:24Look at the boards.
- 58:25Tell me what components are on it.
- 58:27tell me what's going on.
- 58:28I'd love to, you know, to that point,
- 58:29it's like when we talk about like,
- 58:30how do we get better with this?
- 58:32I don't think anyone,
- 58:34there is not currently a YouTube channel
- 58:36where someone gets AV gear and opens it
- 58:38up and looks at what's actually on there.
- 58:40And there's a famous picture that, um,
- 58:44this has gone around us every time the
- 58:46sticker, the warranty sticker.
- 58:48Oh yeah.
- 58:48There's that last screw and you can't,
- 58:50you cannot get through it.
- 58:52It stops me every time.
- 58:53I'll just tell you.
- 58:55It's your deep conscious.
- 58:57No,
- 58:57but there's a famous picture of this
- 58:59converter box that is filled with USB to
- 59:04BNC converters.
- 59:06And then there's an Arduino and a
- 59:09Raspberry Pi.
- 59:10And it's in a chassis.
- 59:11It looks like a product,
- 59:12but you open it up and they just...
- 59:13have stuffed a bunch of stuff in there,
- 59:15coded it together,
- 59:16put some nice interfaces on it,
- 59:17and shipped it out.
- 59:21It's insane.
- 59:22Chris is already on it.
- 59:25He's like, I got this.
- 59:28I think this is actually a really good...
- 59:32chance for higher ed to just like you
- 59:34mentioned before to really dive in because
- 59:36I think there is a level of importance
- 59:38of like third party in this right where
- 59:40it's sometimes we're not going to take the
- 59:44manufacturers and say, Okay,
- 59:45they've they've done these things where
- 59:47we're talking about large scale enterprise
- 59:49deployments that have mature security
- 59:52parts within their organization,
- 59:54they can actually do
- 59:56this testing and do the reporting at
- 59:58scale,
- 59:58I think higher ed is perfectly positioned
- 1:00:01to do that.
- 1:00:02And I think that this is a great
- 1:00:04vertical to kind of start getting that
- 1:00:06word out.
- 1:00:06And if nothing else,
- 1:00:07like if you're listening to this now and
- 1:00:10you think you can contribute,
- 1:00:11you have to reach out to these guys.
- 1:00:13Sounds like a thesis material to me.
- 1:00:14That's what it sounds like.
- 1:00:16And especially since so many of our
- 1:00:18colleges are in the process of opening up
- 1:00:20cybersecurity centers and test hubs,
- 1:00:23like this sounds like a perfect
- 1:00:24partnership.
- 1:00:27I agree.
- 1:00:30And I think that would be a huge
- 1:00:31tool to even the manufacturers because you
- 1:00:33got to look at it from their perspective
- 1:00:35too, right?
- 1:00:36What are they trying to solve?
- 1:00:37Because you have the entire spectrum in
- 1:00:40AV.
- 1:00:41We have people who just want the box
- 1:00:43and they don't care about any security all
- 1:00:45the way up to government deployments that
- 1:00:47are ultimately there.
- 1:00:49Yeah.
- 1:00:51So it's that entire spectrum.
- 1:00:52So
- 1:00:53Our hope with AV Trust is that it
- 1:00:56becomes that information is crowdsourced
- 1:00:59and crowd driven and the community is able
- 1:01:01to push the industry forward together in
- 1:01:04saying, hey, this is what we need.
- 1:01:05And then once that baseline is set,
- 1:01:07I think it makes it easy on everyone.
- 1:01:09You know, there's no animosity here.
- 1:01:12The goal is to make sure that everybody
- 1:01:14plays to the same, you know,
- 1:01:15tunes and everybody's talking well and
- 1:01:17communicating.
- 1:01:18And eventually we have a more secure AV
- 1:01:21industry,
- 1:01:21which is what we need before we have,
- 1:01:24we end up in the news as some
- 1:01:25box that caused the entire thing to crash.
- 1:01:28That's not an if, that's a when, right?
- 1:01:29I'll tell you, I was a little terrified.
- 1:01:32Like this excites me because I was a
- 1:01:34little terrified earlier when you were
- 1:01:35like,
- 1:01:36nobody puts their stuff in a stack and
- 1:01:37just runs a security system.
- 1:01:39audit on it i'm like oh god don't
- 1:01:41don't just know that i don't want to
- 1:01:44know it's that ignorance is bliss right
- 1:01:47yep but i do need to know and
- 1:01:49and some of the reason is that i
- 1:01:50can see why integrators and some
- 1:01:52manufacturers are like well that just
- 1:01:54that's that's a bottom dollar thing at
- 1:01:56that point where to everybody's point like
- 1:01:59in higher ed we're like well we can
- 1:02:01run these tests all day long and we
- 1:02:02all have these enterprise systems and and
- 1:02:05we're not making money on these most of
- 1:02:07the time
- 1:02:08So I've always said that higher ed will
- 1:02:11definitely lead the AV industry in setting
- 1:02:14the security standards.
- 1:02:15It's been my belief because they're
- 1:02:18uniquely positioned, they're enterprise,
- 1:02:20yet they also have resources and the need,
- 1:02:23frankly, to secure some of these things.
- 1:02:25I'm going to say something controversial.
- 1:02:29Do it.
- 1:02:29Do it.
- 1:02:29Do it.
- 1:02:30This is not the show for this, Colin.
- 1:02:32I think also higher ed leads the industry
- 1:02:37in putting AV devices on public IP
- 1:02:40addresses.
- 1:02:42Yeah, let's do it.
- 1:02:44There is some absolutely incredible stuff
- 1:02:50that happens.
- 1:02:51Yeah,
- 1:02:51like throwing everything in the DMZ
- 1:02:52because, well, it's just easier.
- 1:02:55I'm not like, again,
- 1:02:58this is not what we're trying to do
- 1:02:59with AV Trust.
- 1:02:59It's like, call people out.
- 1:03:00That's too easy.
- 1:03:01The better thing is to be like,
- 1:03:02I'm going to do education that may happen
- 1:03:04to mention your specific situation.
- 1:03:07And then when I check back with you
- 1:03:08in a year,
- 1:03:09you better not see this thing still
- 1:03:11happening.
- 1:03:12And that's the kind of stuff I'd like
- 1:03:14to see.
- 1:03:16I'm curious, like as a goal,
- 1:03:17do you see yourself as like a scoring
- 1:03:18and grading service?
- 1:03:21You know,
- 1:03:22that's something that we've had some
- 1:03:23discussion about.
- 1:03:26Like one of the things I've been trying
- 1:03:29to work with is trying to find good
- 1:03:32vendors that we can vet
- 1:03:35and actually offer services to to be like,
- 1:03:38Hey,
- 1:03:38here's like if you want to do security
- 1:03:40training for your, you know,
- 1:03:44for your staff,
- 1:03:45here's a product we recommend.
- 1:03:47Go use, you know,
- 1:03:48you use discount code AV Trust and we
- 1:03:50get a little, you know,
- 1:03:51a little money for us and you get
- 1:03:53a product that we've added because I think
- 1:03:54what's what's happening,
- 1:03:56what will happen with this because this is
- 1:03:57this has been a discussion with like
- 1:03:59managed services
- 1:04:00where you get to the stage like, okay,
- 1:04:01pick a ticketing platform and they go,
- 1:04:03and you start looking and you look at
- 1:04:04the quadrant and you see six thousand
- 1:04:06logos and then you go,
- 1:04:08I'll do this some other time.
- 1:04:09And then you just leave and you never
- 1:04:10come back.
- 1:04:11And I want people to be able to
- 1:04:12say, okay,
- 1:04:13if this is a concern of yours, here's,
- 1:04:15here's something to buy.
- 1:04:16And because to a certain extent,
- 1:04:17it's like,
- 1:04:18if you're not an expert in it,
- 1:04:20someone's got to just say, do this,
- 1:04:22just do this, be good.
- 1:04:24And I, and I do agree.
- 1:04:25Like,
- 1:04:25I think that scoring is a potential piece
- 1:04:26of it.
- 1:04:27I think that one of the things I'm
- 1:04:29trying to find right now is a trusted
- 1:04:31partner to do vulnerability testing and,
- 1:04:34on hardware so that if you, a customer,
- 1:04:37want to test gear, we can say, okay,
- 1:04:39this is someone we trust that has good
- 1:04:41output.
- 1:04:42They have expertise in this area.
- 1:04:44They're good to go.
- 1:04:45Or if you're a manufacturer that says,
- 1:04:47hey, I want to take this more seriously.
- 1:04:49Who can I ship some boxes to to
- 1:04:52actually hammer on this stuff and scan it
- 1:04:55and try to break it and then come
- 1:04:58back to me?
- 1:04:58And that is something that we would like
- 1:05:00to do just as a...
- 1:05:02as a point of service for the industry,
- 1:05:04because it'll be easier if we do all
- 1:05:06the legwork and just go, hey,
- 1:05:08this person is trusted.
- 1:05:09Go for it.
- 1:05:10You know,
- 1:05:10and that's that's what we're trying to get
- 1:05:11to.
- 1:05:12You're going to come in, right?
- 1:05:14You're going to build these types of
- 1:05:16things pretty quick to actually leverage
- 1:05:18that and start that kind of service.
- 1:05:20Have you thought about partnering with a
- 1:05:21higher ed institution about doing security
- 1:05:23audits through the whole campus?
- 1:05:27That would be...
- 1:05:28Or just sitting in the parking lot of
- 1:05:29one of them and doing... Yeah,
- 1:05:31you don't have to...
- 1:05:32Scattering USB drives and seeing that.
- 1:05:34I mean, you all know this,
- 1:05:35but a lot of IT companies...
- 1:05:36You could probably just show up and be
- 1:05:37like, oh,
- 1:05:38I just did this ten minutes ago.
- 1:05:40You might think about it.
- 1:05:41But, I mean, that's the thing,
- 1:05:42because I think IT companies hire,
- 1:05:44you know, third party to, you know,
- 1:05:46do a self-test on themselves.
- 1:05:48Like, why wouldn't AV do the same thing?
- 1:05:50And that could be you all, too,
- 1:05:51just to get some extra money.
- 1:05:52Just a ransom attack without the actual...
- 1:05:53Potentially.
- 1:05:53I mean, I think, I think the other,
- 1:05:56I think the other piece is like,
- 1:05:57you know,
- 1:05:57if we're talking about AV as a business,
- 1:06:00this is a huge opportunity.
- 1:06:02Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:03As a, as a practice,
- 1:06:05like there's no real,
- 1:06:05like these are services that are valuable
- 1:06:09and have like have real value.
- 1:06:12They can't be afterthoughts.
- 1:06:13Yeah,
- 1:06:13and so I think that I think that
- 1:06:15this is an opportunity.
- 1:06:16It's like sure.
- 1:06:17Well,
- 1:06:17we'll probably look at some stuff But
- 1:06:19honestly,
- 1:06:19I think that some people out there as
- 1:06:21they get going or kind of you know,
- 1:06:24figure this out They're gonna go.
- 1:06:25Okay.
- 1:06:25This is this is a way to this
- 1:06:27is a way to make money and that's
- 1:06:29exactly if you're if you're good at it
- 1:06:31and you hit it and
- 1:06:32man, go develop it.
- 1:06:34And that's a big,
- 1:06:37I think that is a big potential to
- 1:06:39say, okay,
- 1:06:40when does the first firm pop up that
- 1:06:41has a suite of security services
- 1:06:44specifically tailored to AV?
- 1:06:46Dedicated to AV, that's right.
- 1:06:47Because you have to, yeah.
- 1:06:50And you don't think we're,
- 1:06:51we're there to partner after there's a
- 1:06:52major vulnerability,
- 1:06:53which takes out a huge university.
- 1:06:56Well,
- 1:06:56and so we're all starting to play around
- 1:06:59with AI and Mark,
- 1:07:00Mark and I have been doing some open
- 1:07:02call stuff.
- 1:07:02So daily I have a network security scan
- 1:07:05and a vulnerability test on my home
- 1:07:07network.
- 1:07:08And guess what?
- 1:07:09And I'll say the manufacturer's name
- 1:07:11because it's not AV related really,
- 1:07:13but I've got six or seven whaps here
- 1:07:16at the house and,
- 1:07:18And a specific manufacturer called
- 1:07:20Ubiquity, for some reason,
- 1:07:23has three of the WAPs open on Telnet,
- 1:07:25and I can't figure out how to turn
- 1:07:26it off yet.
- 1:07:27And so I didn't know that because I
- 1:07:29did my own security scan on my AV
- 1:07:32devices, but here we are with...
- 1:07:34Some of the access points in my house,
- 1:07:36they're all the same model number.
- 1:07:38Three of them run Intel net wide open.
- 1:07:40I think that speaks to like,
- 1:07:42we have to lower the threshold of like
- 1:07:46interest in this and curiosity, right?
- 1:07:48There has to be a level of folks
- 1:07:49because we talk about InfoComm or any
- 1:07:51other trade show you go to,
- 1:07:52people are going to be like,
- 1:07:53How many IO spigots does it have?
- 1:07:56What's the latest chip that does on it?
- 1:07:57Nobody's ever said, oh,
- 1:07:58how's the security work?
- 1:07:59Right.
- 1:08:00And so I think.
- 1:08:02Would that even be interesting on a
- 1:08:03marketing document, though?
- 1:08:05Try that next time you're at a trade
- 1:08:06show.
- 1:08:06Right.
- 1:08:08But we as consumers,
- 1:08:10because let's face it,
- 1:08:10we are consuming these products.
- 1:08:12We're not voting with our dollars
- 1:08:15correctly.
- 1:08:15We are not asking the questions.
- 1:08:17Sometimes we don't have an option, Mark.
- 1:08:19But yes, I agree with you.
- 1:08:20But sometimes it's like,
- 1:08:21don't look around.
- 1:08:22We don't look.
- 1:08:23It's just not in the lexicon.
- 1:08:24And the sales reps are doing everything
- 1:08:26they can to not talk about that.
- 1:08:28Look at how many ports are on this
- 1:08:30black box.
- 1:08:31so frank a minute ago you mentioned would
- 1:08:32that be interesting absolutely yes so i've
- 1:08:34run into and mark i do vote with
- 1:08:36my dollars in this case but it's a
- 1:08:37very small amount of dollars so who cares
- 1:08:40i've run into some some displays these are
- 1:08:42large lcd panel big displays that we're
- 1:08:44all putting all over the place that did
- 1:08:46not support um uh modern namespace network
- 1:08:49identification it was basically like you
- 1:08:51could put in a
- 1:08:52a pseudo hard-coded static IP address.
- 1:08:55If you could wedge in a name,
- 1:08:57it had to be within like eight characters.
- 1:08:59It's like all these like semi-arbitrary
- 1:09:01limitations on just how it even reports to
- 1:09:04the network,
- 1:09:05which didn't meet any current modern
- 1:09:07standards of like ten, fifteen years ago.
- 1:09:10And to the point where when I went
- 1:09:11to buy another set of displays for another
- 1:09:13building,
- 1:09:13I did not buy from that brand because
- 1:09:16I didn't want to deal with their nonsense.
- 1:09:17And I'm currently dealing with that with
- 1:09:18another huge, huge brand of displays.
- 1:09:22It does projectors and displays and all
- 1:09:23sorts of stuff that has trouble with how
- 1:09:25their NICs report on the network.
- 1:09:27And I don't want to deal with that.
- 1:09:28So the next round,
- 1:09:29I'm not buying that brand of displays.
- 1:09:31Now,
- 1:09:32I didn't actually light them up and tell
- 1:09:33them that's why,
- 1:09:34but I think that's a valid feature set
- 1:09:37and a valid kind of, you know,
- 1:09:39you know, customer feedback to say,
- 1:09:41I can't use your stuff on my network
- 1:09:43because of X, Y, and Z.
- 1:09:44You don't meet the basic threshold.
- 1:09:46You don't meet the modern requirements.
- 1:09:47You don't meet whatever these,
- 1:09:49and they're, they're so,
- 1:09:50there's such a low bar.
- 1:09:51It's so easy to kind of get across
- 1:09:53these things, but you know,
- 1:09:54it's that same challenge of like,
- 1:09:56how do we,
- 1:09:57how do we get that across to
- 1:09:58manufacturers?
- 1:09:59And so I love that you guys are
- 1:10:00putting this together as a potential
- 1:10:01content to do that.
- 1:10:02And also to Mark's point,
- 1:10:04maybe this helps us start to square that
- 1:10:06circle of,
- 1:10:07Most AV devices, now,
- 1:10:09even if everything moves to the cloud,
- 1:10:10we're still going to have endpoints that
- 1:10:12are a display or speakers or whatever that
- 1:10:14is,
- 1:10:14something that has to be in the physical
- 1:10:15space.
- 1:10:16I'm going to purchase that once.
- 1:10:18That is going to be good for ten,
- 1:10:20twelve, fifteen years.
- 1:10:21I'm not going to think about it again,
- 1:10:24which means that thing never gets updated.
- 1:10:26It never gets refreshed.
- 1:10:27There's no firmware revs to it because
- 1:10:29it's, let's be honest, it's a dumb device.
- 1:10:32device a dumb endpoint that doesn't need
- 1:10:34you know we talked about earlier those
- 1:10:36security features transducer with no no
- 1:10:38logic well the security may come with
- 1:10:40feature updates but that you know a giant
- 1:10:42lcd panel is not going to get a
- 1:10:44feature update hopefully or older
- 1:10:46equipment that like we're still rocking
- 1:10:48mps-one-hundreds on our campus on right
- 1:10:50that's my point because that's lower
- 1:10:52restaurant patched by mps-one-hundred
- 1:10:54So what's our conduit to the industry to
- 1:10:56say,
- 1:10:56you need to be more up to speed
- 1:10:58with this.
- 1:10:59We are interested in this,
- 1:11:01but you also have to go back to
- 1:11:02your monstrous back catalog of those four
- 1:11:05other companies you purchased over the
- 1:11:06last ten years and either fix that stuff
- 1:11:08or give us some way to go in
- 1:11:09and disable things,
- 1:11:10or I'm taking it off the network and
- 1:11:12I'm building an island because that's the
- 1:11:13only way it'll work.
- 1:11:14Yeah,
- 1:11:15and I think that's why the information is
- 1:11:17one of the most important parts of this,
- 1:11:19because it's not going to be affordable
- 1:11:21for everybody to just go throw away
- 1:11:23everything they bought and buy something
- 1:11:25else.
- 1:11:26So at minimum,
- 1:11:28we need to be able to say like,
- 1:11:29all right, well,
- 1:11:30we know that this one is not great,
- 1:11:32but we know what it is doing and
- 1:11:34what it's not doing,
- 1:11:35and we can kind of respond appropriately.
- 1:11:36If it needs to be on its own
- 1:11:37segment, cool,
- 1:11:38we can make the changes we need to
- 1:11:39make, right?
- 1:11:40But that's not information that we've
- 1:11:41historically had publicly available.
- 1:11:44And that's why I think the information and
- 1:11:46the communication part is is also the most
- 1:11:47important part of this for the short term,
- 1:11:49especially because then that's going to be
- 1:11:51what allows people to actually plan their
- 1:11:54hardware strategy around that for long
- 1:11:55term stuff.
- 1:11:56And I, for one, you know,
- 1:11:59I really like that the information part in
- 1:12:01the in the bringing it all together is
- 1:12:03there because it is an intimidating thing
- 1:12:06to people who aren't used to it.
- 1:12:07So I personally,
- 1:12:09it's like it seems big and scary.
- 1:12:13And I keep putting off learning more about
- 1:12:15it.
- 1:12:15But if you can give me a baby's
- 1:12:17first step,
- 1:12:18or these are what to look for,
- 1:12:20then all of a sudden,
- 1:12:21it's not a scary conversation.
- 1:12:22It is not a,
- 1:12:23how did I learn that this was insecure?
- 1:12:25Well,
- 1:12:25somebody else told me I couldn't have it
- 1:12:27anymore.
- 1:12:28You know, usually my CISO.
- 1:12:32But...
- 1:12:33I like this.
- 1:12:34I like that you guys are trying to
- 1:12:37go to baby's first step and take it
- 1:12:39to a higher level and be that
- 1:12:41intermediary.
- 1:12:43I'm kind of excited for this.
- 1:12:44I hope you guys,
- 1:12:46they're all listening to the show,
- 1:12:47our twenty thousand listeners.
- 1:12:50Twenty two thousand six hundred and
- 1:12:51fourteen.
- 1:12:52And they all call you.
- 1:12:53We get some real good experts and they're
- 1:12:55throwing cash at you.
- 1:12:56I really hope that this goes because I'm
- 1:12:58looking forward to somebody being kind of
- 1:13:01that centralized force.
- 1:13:03to bring us all together and start having
- 1:13:05that conversation without boxing gloves.
- 1:13:11You're not going to have to commit to
- 1:13:13this,
- 1:13:13but I would really love a cheat sheet
- 1:13:14preamble.com.
- 1:13:15Oh, asking for a friend, just stay.
- 1:13:18I will give you all of Chris's time
- 1:13:20to put that together.
- 1:13:21Go ahead.
- 1:13:21If you guys can focus on two things,
- 1:13:23yeah, the cheat sheet,
- 1:13:23the common dictionary,
- 1:13:25know these terms and what they mean so
- 1:13:26you can start speaking the language and
- 1:13:28build from there.
- 1:13:28Colin, like you said, there's some early,
- 1:13:29there's a lot of certs out there and
- 1:13:31things you can kind of build towards,
- 1:13:32but that first step.
- 1:13:33The other thing is,
- 1:13:34I think if you guys build this common
- 1:13:36framework for like communicating security
- 1:13:39issues, both directions,
- 1:13:41like from manufacturers down to end users,
- 1:13:43because God knows some of them are,
- 1:13:45terrible at it and others just don't do
- 1:13:46it um and then also the same direction
- 1:13:48hey we're seeing this weird kind of thing
- 1:13:50on our network how do we get in
- 1:13:51touch with the right people at some of
- 1:13:53these manufacturers and other
- 1:13:55organizations and whatnot to to kind of
- 1:13:56start community so like some sort of
- 1:13:57framework to go both directions on like
- 1:13:59centralizing and communicating some of
- 1:14:00this stuff uh in that kind of like
- 1:14:02you said kind of like we're gonna legally
- 1:14:04like protect you pull you back one step
- 1:14:07so you're removed slightly from that
- 1:14:08you're not going to get hammered about it
- 1:14:09but at the same time this is important
- 1:14:10stuff to be able to communicate if you
- 1:14:11can do those two things i think you
- 1:14:13guys are going to be in a great
- 1:14:15great great place because it puts us in
- 1:14:17a good spot for conversation and that's
- 1:14:19where we want to be yeah and if
- 1:14:20you haven't looked at look at the educause
- 1:14:22heck that as a potential model because it
- 1:14:24is a very wide range if you haven't
- 1:14:25looked at that it's free if not i'll
- 1:14:27dig all universities should at least have
- 1:14:28awareness of the heck that
- 1:14:30Well,
- 1:14:30somebody on each university campus has
- 1:14:33awareness of it,
- 1:14:33probably not the right person,
- 1:14:35but it's a comprehensive kind of like
- 1:14:37vendor evaluation thing for how you do
- 1:14:41updates, how you do security,
- 1:14:42how you maintain your security posture on
- 1:14:44things, how you maintain your software,
- 1:14:45all sorts of stuff.
- 1:14:46It's very wide ranging,
- 1:14:47but it's a framework you could use as
- 1:14:49a model to kind of like, I mean,
- 1:14:50it's very comprehensive,
- 1:14:51but you could use it as like,
- 1:14:52how do we even just communicate some of
- 1:14:53this stuff?
- 1:14:54Yeah.
- 1:14:54a good starting point yeah i think it's
- 1:14:56a fantastic starting point look at that
- 1:14:57steal from the best keep doing all those
- 1:14:58things they spend all the time on it
- 1:14:59why not just take that so um no
- 1:15:02and i agree and i think that's that's
- 1:15:03an important thing to realize that this is
- 1:15:06already a mature practice for a lot of
- 1:15:08people and i don't want us to come
- 1:15:09in like
- 1:15:10I feel like the old way of doing
- 1:15:11things would have been like, okay,
- 1:15:12in order to be more secure,
- 1:15:13we're going to create a new proprietary
- 1:15:15network port.
- 1:15:16We need a new standard.
- 1:15:17We have a new connector.
- 1:15:20You'll know that if you plug into it
- 1:15:24and you have to get a special switch,
- 1:15:26which some manufacturers would love.
- 1:15:28Yeah.
- 1:15:28It's like, we can't,
- 1:15:31we can't keep doing this.
- 1:15:32Like we have this stuff in place and
- 1:15:33it also, like, I think it'll,
- 1:15:36I think it'll sort of clear a lot
- 1:15:38of the, um,
- 1:15:41How do I say this?
- 1:15:41It'll clear up a lot of the...
- 1:15:46opacity we have right now with hardware
- 1:15:50specifically,
- 1:15:51because I struggle to have those
- 1:15:54conversations because there are companies
- 1:15:55that are manufacturers that do not have a
- 1:15:58factory.
- 1:15:58They're a marketing company that will mail
- 1:16:01you a box.
- 1:16:02And that is something that I don't
- 1:16:07particularly care for.
- 1:16:08And I think that a lot of customers
- 1:16:11don't know any better because the
- 1:16:13branding's really nice and it comes in a
- 1:16:15good box and everything's logoed and it's
- 1:16:17good to go.
- 1:16:18But I think that there's an obscurity
- 1:16:19there.
- 1:16:20And the people that are doing their own
- 1:16:21work,
- 1:16:22like I don't think it's necessarily bad to
- 1:16:24OEM something,
- 1:16:25but you have to do it in a
- 1:16:26way that inspires some trust,
- 1:16:31not that feels like you're trying to
- 1:16:32obscure where it's going.
- 1:16:34Like that's always the game.
- 1:16:35Like every time a new product comes out,
- 1:16:37you run over to alibaba and you see
- 1:16:39uh which picture matches it and what their
- 1:16:41unit cost is there you go oh cool
- 1:16:43neat yeah that new phone found it i
- 1:16:46could make one too i guess um why
- 1:16:50not and that's not it's not all gear
- 1:16:51but there's a lot of it every every
- 1:16:53rack has
- 1:16:54those little doodads and widgets and
- 1:16:56things in there.
- 1:16:56And like some of them,
- 1:16:57I guess it doesn't matter.
- 1:16:57Like some of them,
- 1:16:58it does not matter because if it's just,
- 1:17:00you know,
- 1:17:02point A to point B transmitting HDMI,
- 1:17:05I don't care.
- 1:17:06And I think that there has to be
- 1:17:07something to say.
- 1:17:08It's like,
- 1:17:08I agree that it's nice to know what's
- 1:17:10going on with stuff,
- 1:17:12but some stuff just doesn't need to be
- 1:17:13on the network.
- 1:17:15Like a TV, I don't know.
- 1:17:17If I can tell whether it's drawing enough
- 1:17:18power to keep that little LED light on
- 1:17:20that says, you know, red or green,
- 1:17:22I can probably tell if it's alive.
- 1:17:24And that's all I need.
- 1:17:25Because anything else that's wrong with it
- 1:17:27is going to be something I cannot detect
- 1:17:28remotely.
- 1:17:29If someone punched a hole in it,
- 1:17:31or there's a big red line running up
- 1:17:32and down it,
- 1:17:33No amount of remote monitoring tells me
- 1:17:35that.
- 1:17:35And so is it really worth it to
- 1:17:37have that device on the network for
- 1:17:41minimal benefits?
- 1:17:42I have a massive amount of risk for
- 1:17:44almost no return because I'm not updating
- 1:17:46the firmware on it.
- 1:17:47I'm not patching it.
- 1:17:48I'm not pulling logs.
- 1:17:50And all I'm doing is putting a device
- 1:17:51on there that could end up part of
- 1:17:53a bot network or something like that.
- 1:17:55Everything should be serial controlled.
- 1:17:57Yes.
- 1:17:58Honestly, that's the network-based,
- 1:18:02the IP-based RS-DU-DU controllers.
- 1:18:06There is something to say for, okay,
- 1:18:08if I have a bunch of unsecured devices,
- 1:18:11the easiest way to secure them is to
- 1:18:12have a device I know I can secure.
- 1:18:16I can have a jump box with two
- 1:18:17NIC cards on it.
- 1:18:19Okay,
- 1:18:19I only have to worry about that one
- 1:18:21thing, and if something goes sideways,
- 1:18:23I can pull the plug on it,
- 1:18:24and it doesn't really matter what's
- 1:18:25downstream of it because they're going to
- 1:18:26be having their own issues,
- 1:18:29and we can segregate it.
- 1:18:30Is that the best idea?
- 1:18:31Probably not, but that's how IoT is.
- 1:18:34I mean, that's how IoT is dealt with.
- 1:18:35There's devices that are specifically for
- 1:18:37that that have a bunch of, like,
- 1:18:38a billion USB ports because they're there
- 1:18:41to keep track of a bunch of IoT
- 1:18:42devices, and they don't want...
- 1:18:44They don't want those devices actually on
- 1:18:47a production network.
- 1:18:48They don't want it on Wi-Fi.
- 1:18:49That's why a lot of IoT devices,
- 1:18:51like you throw a SIM card in and
- 1:18:53it's like, great, it can get to something,
- 1:18:55but it's not getting to my network.
- 1:18:57So who cares?
- 1:18:58Who cares about T-Mobile?
- 1:19:00You know what?
- 1:19:01That's their problem.
- 1:19:02If they get taken down by my errant
- 1:19:05air sensor, that's their problem.
- 1:19:09Humidity is just right,
- 1:19:11but T-Mobile went down.
- 1:19:13Yeah.
- 1:19:15Well,
- 1:19:15I think this has been a fantastic
- 1:19:17conversation.
- 1:19:17We'll have to have you guys back because,
- 1:19:18you know, let's check in six months.
- 1:19:19And I think Mark gave us a good,
- 1:19:21and I hope you have plans for it,
- 1:19:22a good kind of benchmark.
- 1:19:23It's like, what do you got at Infocom?
- 1:19:25Because there's got to be something big.
- 1:19:26You got, what, ninety days or so.
- 1:19:27I'm sure you have some plans and things.
- 1:19:30We'll have a new website, Colin.
- 1:19:31A new one.
- 1:19:32Come on.
- 1:19:32You come up with little stickers you go
- 1:19:34around and put on products.
- 1:19:35Say, this thing sucks on your network.
- 1:19:37Please don't.
- 1:19:38We'll do it for you.
- 1:19:39We love doing that kind of stuff.
- 1:19:40A.V.
- 1:19:40Trust acknowledged.
- 1:19:43This is going to be a problem.
- 1:19:44A.V.
- 1:19:44Trust, just to get on there.
- 1:19:47We have to get the word out somewhere.
- 1:19:48And there's a lot of stuff that just
- 1:19:50gets unpacked.
- 1:19:51Firmware never gets touched.
- 1:19:52It never gets configured.
- 1:19:53It just gets plugged into the network.
- 1:19:54People walk away.
- 1:19:54So there's all sorts of problems.
- 1:19:55So to that end,
- 1:19:57people want to get involved.
- 1:19:58People want to find out what's going on.
- 1:20:00Where are we going?
- 1:20:00Where are we sending them?
- 1:20:01What are we doing?
- 1:20:01Where are we looking for all that stuff?
- 1:20:04AVTrust.org.
- 1:20:05There is the link to the Discord on
- 1:20:07there.
- 1:20:08Link to our LinkedIn if you're a big
- 1:20:10LinkedIn user.
- 1:20:11Or, I mean, you have our names.
- 1:20:14We're all online.
- 1:20:15Come and find us.
- 1:20:16Yeah, reach out.
- 1:20:17Yeah, you can get up through LinkedIn,
- 1:20:19through the website, through Discord.
- 1:20:20We're all on there.
- 1:20:22Yeah, definitely.
- 1:20:23We're starting to form councils,
- 1:20:24so if you have interest in creating
- 1:20:27education, reviewing standards,
- 1:20:29putting out information, great.
- 1:20:33We joke,
- 1:20:33but I would love someone who knows more
- 1:20:35about making a website,
- 1:20:36because if we're gonna have a lot more
- 1:20:37content going out,
- 1:20:40I can't spend twenty hours putting one
- 1:20:41page up on a WordPress site.
- 1:20:43You're gonna get spammed by every
- 1:20:44contractor out there that has a Wix
- 1:20:45account.
- 1:20:46Everybody who's got their Clawbot running
- 1:20:48is gonna be like, oh,
- 1:20:48I can do that for you.
- 1:20:51Doug and Frank, last words.
- 1:20:52Any last things we didn't cover or didn't
- 1:20:54mention you want to throw out there?
- 1:20:56No, I mean, thanks for having us.
- 1:20:57This was great.
- 1:20:59I'm really excited about this.
- 1:21:00It's nice to hear other people feel the
- 1:21:02same.
- 1:21:04You know, next up for us is definitely,
- 1:21:06you know,
- 1:21:06the documentation stuff you guys asked for
- 1:21:08is already absolutely on our list anyway.
- 1:21:12Specific feedback about stuff that you
- 1:21:13guys would like to see in the lexicon
- 1:21:15or other stuff,
- 1:21:15we will take that feedback in any way
- 1:21:17that you are willing to give it.
- 1:21:19Because, you know,
- 1:21:20we want it to be a community-guided thing.
- 1:21:22We want the stuff to actually feel useful
- 1:21:23to people,
- 1:21:24and that helps get that real-time
- 1:21:26feedback.
- 1:21:27And, you know,
- 1:21:27we're working with vendors and stuff like
- 1:21:29that right now, actually,
- 1:21:31having some early conversations about,
- 1:21:33you know,
- 1:21:33what would shared training materials look
- 1:21:34like, what would, you know,
- 1:21:36making sure that we have some kind of
- 1:21:37consistent modus operandi sound like for
- 1:21:39reporting things.
- 1:21:41So more announcements to come from our
- 1:21:42side on that as well.
- 1:21:45Again, thank you for having us.
- 1:21:47This has been great.
- 1:21:47It's a fantastic conversation.
- 1:21:49I think the conclusion is we understand
- 1:21:52that AV is not so unique in that
- 1:21:55we're just part of the network,
- 1:21:57but we're also unique enough where there's
- 1:21:59some nuances to the way we operate things.
- 1:22:01Hopefully,
- 1:22:01AV Trust can come in and bridge some
- 1:22:03of that through education and training.
- 1:22:05community participation we just want to
- 1:22:07make security friendly uh security doesn't
- 1:22:10have to be that taboo topic that we
- 1:22:12avoid because you can't avoid it anymore
- 1:22:15and hopefully more people talk about it
- 1:22:16and you know there's a lot of like
- 1:22:18we that we started this off on a
- 1:22:20very nice note but with the with the
- 1:22:22education platforms and how people are
- 1:22:24talking about cyber security education
- 1:22:26there's an opportunity in av there's like
- 1:22:28thousands of boxes there's thousands of
- 1:22:30networks
- 1:22:31We could spur new businesses.
- 1:22:32We could spur new job opportunities,
- 1:22:34things that are absolutely necessary.
- 1:22:37You know,
- 1:22:37hopefully we can be the center point of
- 1:22:39education or just the gateway to make
- 1:22:41security friendly for AV people and AV
- 1:22:43friendly for security people.
- 1:22:45And hopefully this all becomes,
- 1:22:46we'll all have our kumbaya moment,
- 1:22:48you know?
- 1:22:50Tons of opportunity.
- 1:22:51Love it.
- 1:22:51Indeed.
- 1:22:52Yep.
- 1:22:52So looking for that first huge
- 1:22:54vulnerability.
- 1:22:56It's out there.
- 1:22:57Probably people will know about it, too.
- 1:22:59All right.
- 1:23:00Well, we're going to wrap this up,
- 1:23:01and we'll see what the future brings and
- 1:23:04what you guys have for us at Infocomm.
- 1:23:06And hopefully,
- 1:23:06I like those little stickers that says
- 1:23:08this thing's terrible on your network.
- 1:23:10Those just floating around.
- 1:23:12If we don't make them, I will,
- 1:23:13and we'll go put them out there.
- 1:23:14We won't do the security scans.
- 1:23:16Anyway, so thanks again to everybody.
- 1:23:18Head over to abtrust.org,
- 1:23:19see what's going on,
- 1:23:19and we'll catch you guys next week with
- 1:23:22another episode of Nonsense.
- 1:23:23Same bat channel, same bat time.
- 1:23:26Thank you.
- 1:23:31Well,
- 1:23:32we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:23:34of AV Super Friends Off the Rails.
- 1:23:36You can contact us with questions,
- 1:23:37topic ideas,
- 1:23:38or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:23:40avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:23:42If you complain loud enough,
- 1:23:43we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:23:50Nice work, everyone.
- 1:23:50Short broadcast.
- 1:23:54Really good.
- 1:23:54Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:23:55Best sounding podcast.
- 1:23:56The opinions expressed by the AV Super
- 1:23:57Friends are solely those of the
- 1:23:58individuals and do not represent their
- 1:24:00respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:24:02companies, or clients.
- 1:24:08Hello.
- 1:24:08Hello.