Latest / Science Behind the Glass: illuminating the human side / Treasures of the Sea: Exploring the Potential of Marine Life with Dr. Monica Puyana
Transcript
- 0:01Who are the characters behind science? This is
- 0:04Science Behind the Glass, illuminated in the
- 0:06human side. In this podcast, we unveil the human
- 0:10side of laboratories and science. Scientists
- 0:13share personal experiences and we discuss their
- 0:16meanings from different perspectives and fields
- 0:18of research. Disclaimer, this is an English version
- 0:23of the original interview, which may be summarized
- 0:27or reinterpreted. Welcome to another exciting
- 0:29episode of Science Behind the Glass, Illuminating
- 0:32the Human Side. On this occasion, we dive into
- 0:35the depths of the ocean to explore the fascinating
- 0:37world of bioprospection, alongside our distinguished
- 0:40expert in the field, Dr. Monica Pujana, recently
- 0:43appointed Director of Faculty of Biological and
- 0:46Environmental Sciences at the Jorgeta de Olozano
- 0:49University. From her roots as a marine biologist
- 0:52to her leadership in innovative research projects,
- 0:55we will delve into her passion for uncovering
- 0:57the potential of marine organisms in the cosmetic
- 1:00industry and her commitment to environmental
- 1:02conservation. Monica, thank you very much for
- 1:05accepting the invitation. It's a pleasure to
- 1:07have you here. Could you explain in simple words
- 1:09what bioprospecting is? Thank you for having
- 1:12me here. Bioprospecting is essentially everything
- 1:14related to the assessment and use of biodiversity.
- 1:17Behind having a multitude of species and being
- 1:21one of the most biodiverse countries. What is
- 1:23the purpose of biodiversity? We have to ask this.
- 1:27Biodiversity serves as the basis of our products
- 1:30and services used by numerous communities. and
- 1:33individuals. Think about plants and animals,
- 1:35how they could serve people in the short and
- 1:39medium term. From the dyes we use for the food
- 1:42that we consume, cosmetics and pharmaceutical
- 1:45products, much of those are derived from nature.
- 1:49This is especially significant in a mega diverse
- 1:51country like Colombia. Traditionally, biodiversity
- 1:54is associated with animals and landscapes, but
- 1:57we are also part of that biodiversity, and this
- 2:00can be harnessed. We must move away from the
- 2:03notion that biodiversity cannot be touched or
- 2:06explored. There are organisms we can use, so
- 2:09we must do it responsibly. Yes. Could you tell
- 2:12us a little about the moment when you decided
- 2:14to specialize in the field of marine bioprospecting?
- 2:17That's a good question. I always had an interest
- 2:20in chemistry, but my aunts discouraged me, saying
- 2:23it wasn't suitable for me. My mother was an avid
- 2:26reader, and her passion for medical plants, along
- 2:29with the marine work, became my inspiration.
- 2:32I started working with mollusks, making significant
- 2:35contributions in the field of taxonomy. However...
- 2:38I reached a point where I felt limited and I
- 2:41wanted to incorporate chemistry into my work.
- 2:43So I pursued a doctorate in oceanography, but
- 2:47I focused mostly on chemical ecology. This field
- 2:50is closely related to bioprospective, exploring
- 2:53compounds found in marine organisms. After a
- 2:55while, the country began to get interested in
- 2:58bioprospective. people started recognizing the
- 3:01potential of what we could achieve. However,
- 3:03this term was still unfamiliar to environmental
- 3:06lawyers. Some assumed that their perspective
- 3:09meant patenting everything, making billions,
- 3:12and curing all the world's ills. But the reality
- 3:16is that during the initial research assessment,
- 3:18we don't always know what will emerge. There's
- 3:21also the economic recognition given by the communities.
- 3:25How do we strike that balance? Articles from
- 3:28other countries claim that bioprospecting is
- 3:30still from indigenous communities. However, laws
- 3:33prevent the exploitation of natural resources
- 3:36without the community's consent. At our university,
- 3:39we offer a course on bioprospecting. It challenges
- 3:42students to think differently. We want them to
- 3:46realize that biodiversity is a resource that
- 3:48can be harnessed. How exciting! The word bioprospecting
- 3:52may sound complex, but in reality many communities
- 3:55have been harnessing the resources and biodiversity
- 3:58of various organisms for countless years. Additionally,
- 4:01you mentioned something crucial. Discovering
- 4:04a new product, especially those with pharmaceutical
- 4:06potential, doesn't happen overnight. It involves
- 4:09years of research and significant financial investment.
- 4:14Could you tell us what has been the most exciting
- 4:17or surprising discovery in your scientific career?
- 4:20Well, I won't claim that I have a novel worthy
- 4:23discovery. However, let me share an example.
- 4:26When we work with an anti -inflammatory compounds
- 4:29from soft corals, our initial expectation was
- 4:32to find an abundant species that had industrial
- 4:35applications. Back in the late 80s, a cosmetic
- 4:38line was developed from these soft corals due
- 4:41to their anti -inflammatory properties. We conducted
- 4:44our research in San Andres and Providence Island.
- 4:47Surprisingly, we found that there were very few
- 4:50of these corals. Moreover, the chemical composition
- 4:53was similar to existing compounds in the marker,
- 4:56and the quantities were low. However... This
- 4:58investigation paved the way for numerous undergraduate
- 5:02and postgraduate projects. The chemistry of these
- 5:05particular species revealed that they were distinct.
- 5:08It made us rethink the complexity of organisms
- 5:10and the need to re -evaluate these species or
- 5:13other species. Other topics such as cyanobacteria
- 5:16also fascinate me. There are so many new species
- 5:20yet to be documented. The dynamics within coral
- 5:23reefs are incredibly interesting. I believe this
- 5:26is a constant experience. It was extraordinary
- 5:28because we initially thought we could cultivate
- 5:31corals and extract other compounds from them,
- 5:33but no, none of that happened. It wasn't due
- 5:36to poor project planning. We followed rigorous
- 5:38procedures. Nothing turned out to be patentable,
- 5:41and we didn't solve all the world's problems.
- 5:44Instead, we evaluated our results. People often
- 5:47fear the world's chemistry and the activities
- 5:50associated with it. Many assume that that discovery
- 5:52must lead to a marketable or industrial product,
- 5:56something that generates revenue. However, the
- 5:58mere discovery of these compounds, even in smaller
- 6:01quantities, is significant, even if it isn't
- 6:05scalable for large -scale industrial use. This
- 6:08mindset persists because people tend to highlight
- 6:10their success. I always tell my students that
- 6:13negative results are also results. When writing
- 6:16a thesis, include everything that didn't work.
- 6:18This way, future researchers won't repeat the
- 6:21same mistakes. Unfortunately, the scientific
- 6:23community often neglects negative results, treating
- 6:26them as failures. In reality, they contribute
- 6:28to valuable learning experiences. So in summary,
- 6:31what we have obtained from these projects not
- 6:35only led to different discoveries in these coral
- 6:39species, but also new knowledge. Yeah, that's
- 6:42nice. In your opinion, what are the main obstacles
- 6:45that marine bioprospecting faces in Colombia
- 6:48and the world? In Colombia, knowledge is scarce
- 6:51due to the limited number of experts, and my
- 6:54prospecting is expensive. While we don't need
- 6:56to go to the sea every week, the expenses associated
- 6:59with these trips can be add up. This is somewhat
- 7:02solvable, but much of the challenge lies in the
- 7:05obtaining permits and filling reports. When collecting
- 7:08samples in protected areas, we do have our rich
- 7:11information that covers multiple species, which
- 7:14is beneficial. However, bureaucracy remains a
- 7:17significant hurdle. In the past, I was even asked
- 7:20to provide coordinates for where I had collected
- 7:23bacteria. There's an apprehension because some
- 7:26perceive this is a commercialization. Now, if
- 7:29we look at the other side. There's a lack of
- 7:32crucial dialogue between universities and businesses
- 7:35in Colombia. The pace differs significantly.
- 7:38Companies operate swiftly while universities
- 7:40move more slowly, which doesn't align with business
- 7:44needs. Additionally, we have a lack of a strong
- 7:47industry focus on research and development. Permits
- 7:50and requests are evaluated also by lawyers, and
- 7:53their language and scope are different. Here,
- 7:56we grapple with numerous regulations and bureaucracy.
- 7:59This delays a lot of the projects and is quite
- 8:01frustrating. This has improved compared to 20
- 8:04years ago, but still is not perfect. Other challenges
- 8:07include development issues and costs. When we
- 8:10compare ourselves to other regions, we have abundant
- 8:13biodiversity. But our technology, especially
- 8:16in the chemical field, lags behind. We are limited
- 8:19by equipment, whereas other places are not as
- 8:22constrained as we are. And what are measures
- 8:25that are being implemented to ensure that this
- 8:28exploitation of marine natural resources is sustainable.
- 8:32People think that when you collect a sample,
- 8:34you will take the entire resource. The challenge
- 8:36is how we are going to produce it. We found an
- 8:39interesting molecule, so we are going to cultivate
- 8:42the algae. We are going to harvest. With bioprospecting,
- 8:46the goal is for nature to tell us, look at the
- 8:49molecule that I have invented. Now, produce it
- 8:51synthetically. It's no longer about extracting
- 8:54the resource. Just like the exploitation of quinine
- 8:57during the botanical expeditions in the 1819
- 8:59century. That was terrible. Nowadays, in the
- 9:03laboratory, we can achieve all that by understanding
- 9:05the molecule, but it requires collaboration,
- 9:08work with people, and everyone needs to be interested.
- 9:11From my perspective, speaking about bioprospective,
- 9:14we have been quite timid in Colombia, despite
- 9:17attempts to focus on priority areas. Basic science
- 9:20is fascinating, but what are we going to do with
- 9:23that biodiversity before it disappears? Before
- 9:26we face more biodiversity losses due to climate
- 9:29change? The idea is to integrate... into the
- 9:31process. When working with fishermen, we should
- 9:34learn how they use the resource. Listen to them.
- 9:37That's what we are talking about now. The dialogue
- 9:39of knowledge, local ecological knowledge. It's
- 9:43about leveraging the community knowledge to advance
- 9:46the work we are doing and to share these discoveries
- 9:48with people. Another important aspect is that
- 9:51bioprospective should address a market need,
- 9:54not just what I find interesting to research.
- 9:57Sometimes this can be challenging for researchers.
- 10:00Let's take our current project, for example,
- 10:02which focuses on cosmetics, particularly everything
- 10:05related to sun protection. This addresses the
- 10:08real market need, and we are collaborating with
- 10:11many individuals, including pharmaceutical chemists,
- 10:14to solve this specific problem. Regarding synthesis,
- 10:17well, it is viable, but not always straightforward.
- 10:21Synthesizing a molecule in the laboratory can
- 10:24be quite challenging. However, we can also improve
- 10:27existing molecules. Natural products inspire
- 10:29many pharmaceuticals. but they undergo modifications
- 10:32to enhance their bioavailability. Take aspirin,
- 10:36for instance. The acetylation of salicylic acid.
- 10:39This modification was applied to the compound
- 10:41originally isolated from willow bark, which indigenous
- 10:45people in North America used as an anti -inflammatory.
- 10:48It is essential to understand that just because
- 10:50a product has a chemical component doesn't automatically
- 10:53make it harmful. It depends on how the synthesis
- 10:56is carried out. Even soaps go through a chemical
- 10:59process. We use them for bathing. People often
- 11:03get stuck thinking about petrochemicals, assuming
- 11:06that natural products are always safe. However,
- 11:09it is crucial to consider that some plants contain
- 11:11cyanide, which can be lethal. also another issue
- 11:15is the continuity of the projects which is crucial
- 11:18let's take an example of the salt corals species
- 11:20i mentioned a professor in the united states
- 11:23monitored the colonies for 10 years after 12
- 11:26years he realizes that the seemingly harmless
- 11:29collection which appeared like pruning, and coral
- 11:32regeneration could lead to successful reproduction,
- 11:36because all the coral resources were directly
- 11:39towards growth. Then, without the continuity
- 11:42of these studies, we could not have been able
- 11:44to understand what is happening with these colors.
- 11:47Yes, and also, as you mentioned, it's beyond
- 11:50just basic science. It's about going beyond a
- 11:54scientific article. How do we make people understand
- 11:57that part? Indeed. It is more important to solve
- 11:59our local problems than publish in a journal
- 12:02like Science of Nature. When you submit an article
- 12:05and then they say, no, we are not interested.
- 12:08Well, it doesn't matter. Let's publish it where
- 12:11it can have an impact. However, the perverse
- 12:14system of rankings doesn't account for the realities
- 12:17of our country. Moreover, it becomes a cult of
- 12:21ego. As we are talking about the human side of
- 12:23science, you have already told us a bit about
- 12:25this part, but we would like to ask you how the
- 12:28science of bioprospecting and biotechnology affects
- 12:31the common people. Often, people don't really
- 12:34know how this type of research is carried out.
- 12:36A rejection arises. How have you talked before,
- 12:39for example, about genetically modified organisms
- 12:42and so -called transgenics? What can you tell
- 12:45us about that part? It is lack of knowledge and
- 12:47ignorance. People in general are not very keen
- 12:50on evaluating and seeking the resources that
- 12:52allow them to solve those concerns. Now, with
- 12:56this issue of influencers, I tell my students
- 12:59that there is nothing more perverse than an influencer.
- 13:02They are now the ones who give medical advice
- 13:05and recommended diets. People believe it. They
- 13:08say transgenics are terrible. but they are in
- 13:11everything. The soil consumed by vegans is transgenic.
- 13:15Everything that is being cultivated, but for
- 13:17most of the things, because transgenic have higher
- 13:20yields and resistant to PET. In the bioprospecting
- 13:22class, we talk about various topics. The students
- 13:25learn to read labels, for example. One has to
- 13:29be a responsible consumer. But traditionally,
- 13:31Colombians are now responsible consumers because
- 13:34often the factor is either fashion or cost. But
- 13:38scientifically, knowledge is within reach of
- 13:41the general public. However, most people don't
- 13:43realize that they are consuming genetically modified
- 13:45organisms every day, using internet and benefiting
- 13:49from all kinds of technology and scientific discoveries,
- 13:53all of which stem from rigorous scientific work.
- 13:56The idea is for people to understand in simple
- 13:59terms that these academic scientists and the
- 14:01individuals working behind the scenes in science
- 14:04are ordinary people facing similar challenges.
- 14:07It's about making science accessible to the public.
- 14:10That's right. Just moving on to this part about
- 14:13the people involved in science, we want to ask
- 14:16you in your experience, what role do students
- 14:19and human talent in general play in research
- 14:22projects, biotechnology and bioprospecting, and
- 14:25how do they benefit from the participation in
- 14:28these projects? When they have been linked to
- 14:30projects and asking for recommendation, I gladly
- 14:33give it. Or when they tell me, Monica, I got
- 14:36accepted into a doctorate program. I got a master's
- 14:39degree in such a place. For me, it is the greatest
- 14:43thing when they are willing to work, but especially
- 14:46in... thesis when it's undergraduate work or
- 14:49postgraduate thesis is a discovery a constant
- 14:52learning they benefit by learning skills besides
- 14:55the contribution they are making at science level
- 14:58is very important that's right finally we wanted
- 15:02to know how it has been for you to dedicate your
- 15:05working life to science and if it has been difficult
- 15:08to manage those demands of the scientific world
- 15:11in your personal life as a woman and a mother
- 15:14often we believe that we never do anything right
- 15:18and we are very hard on ourselves. Should I dedicate
- 15:21myself to do this or that? But this is life.
- 15:24Personally, I never felt less or experienced
- 15:28that chauvinism because I believe that in science,
- 15:30particularly in biology, it's not as prevalent
- 15:33as in other areas. Yes, there have been challenging
- 15:36situations and instances of harassment, but we
- 15:39manage and move forward. Perhaps it's also partially
- 15:42because... due to my personality and temperament.
- 15:46As a female marine biologist from Jorge Tayo,
- 15:49San Luis University, we always have been quite
- 15:52strong. Like our warriors, I could say. I don't
- 15:55think a perfect environment in life it is. I
- 15:57would love to have more time to write articles,
- 16:00but time is scarce. Even now with my current
- 16:02role, I have less time. For example, during maternity
- 16:05leave, I have to travel for a project and my
- 16:08older son didn't recognize me after a month.
- 16:10I thought that he might be traumatized, but no.
- 16:13He doesn't even remember. Marine biology has
- 16:16been my passion, my life. I can't imagine doing
- 16:19anything else. It has brought me immense satisfaction.
- 16:23The opportunity to travel and meet wonderful
- 16:25people. People assume that we spend, for example,
- 16:29our time as a marine biologist in bikinis on
- 16:32the beach. But that's not the case. We spend
- 16:34just one week a year. And the rest of the time,
- 16:36we just glue to computers working. While always
- 16:39I have loved for perfumes and even considering
- 16:42starting a perfume company, I'm not frustrated
- 16:45because I didn't achieve it. I have made contributions
- 16:48to science and in other fields. Thanks, Monica.
- 16:53Those were the questions we had for today. Thanks
- 16:56for sharing all those knowledge experiences and
- 16:59for this pleasant conversation. Thank you for
- 17:01the invitation and the space. It's interesting
- 17:05how Dr. Monica pointed out that one of her most
- 17:10intriguing discoveries was precisely finding
- 17:12that a compound wasn't usable as expected in
- 17:15a species of soft corn. These situations are
- 17:18learning opportunities and show how bioprospecting
- 17:21isn't just about investigating a plant species
- 17:24or an extract from an animal and discovering
- 17:27a new compound. This can take more than 15 years.
- 17:31Discoveries in science are unnecessary products
- 17:33that can be exploited or industrialized. Simply
- 17:37discovering differences between organisms and
- 17:39their chemistry helps us understanding biodiversity
- 17:42and the changes that organisms undergo. Now,
- 17:46it's important that when starting bioprospecting,
- 17:49one keeps in mind the need they are trying to
- 17:52fulfill or the question they are trying to answer.
- 17:55As Monica also pointed out, the products obtained
- 17:58from these scientific findings can initially
- 18:00be used solely as a foundational knowledge and
- 18:04later developed in applied science. What do you
- 18:06think, Dani? It's true. Many discoveries initially
- 18:09have uncertainty utility, but later another researcher
- 18:13finds a way to apply what someone else discovered
- 18:17previously. Furthermore, I think there's a wealth
- 18:20of knowledge that is sometimes overlooked because
- 18:22it's considered folk wisdom. or the practices
- 18:26of indigenous communities, among other cases.
- 18:29I believe many in science need to set aside arrogance
- 18:32and seize the opportunities already available
- 18:34to truly improve people's lives, not just the
- 18:38lives of those who can afford to buy your product
- 18:40with biomolecules, but also the lives of communities
- 18:44that already have the knowledge and resources
- 18:46at hand in their day -to -day lives. It's true,
- 18:50we can simplify organisms. Just because they
- 18:53are located close by doesn't mean that they are
- 18:56the same. And here it is worth mentioning that
- 18:59not only can organisms within the same community
- 19:01be very different, but each individual can also
- 19:04present different profile of compounds. For example,
- 19:07during my thesis working with funnel web spiders,
- 19:10I found that the spiders of the same species
- 19:13and from the same location have different venom
- 19:15profiles. That is to say, they belong to the
- 19:18same species, but they each have their own fingerprint,
- 19:21like us. Wow, does that mean that there were
- 19:25different compounds in the venom of each individual?
- 19:28Yes, juveniles show differences compared to adults,
- 19:32but they belong to the same species. And they
- 19:35have like a venom fingerprint, which differentiates
- 19:38them from other individuals. That's very interesting
- 19:42because it highlights the care researchers must
- 19:45take in bioprospecting when proposing a scaling
- 19:48process for industrial production. It's also
- 19:51further evidence of why investment in long -term
- 19:53projects and monitoring is necessary because
- 19:56organisms, their physiology and metabolites are
- 20:00dynamic and change on different temporal or population
- 20:03scales. Another interesting point that Dr. Mani
- 20:06can mention is that natural molecules are necessarily
- 20:09better than synthetic ones, which is a commonly
- 20:13held belief. For example, there are synthetic
- 20:15products that are derived from natural molecule
- 20:18models or modified ones that aren't harmful.
- 20:21They have the same effects and properties. And
- 20:24on the other hand, there are natural clones that
- 20:26can be toxic. yeah this is something quite amusing
- 20:30that we see all the time in advertising for example
- 20:32of cosmetic products or dietary supplements a
- 20:36lot of inaccurate information or even misinformation
- 20:39is circulating sometimes it even seems deliberate
- 20:43To make bio -perspective progress in developing
- 20:45countries like Colombia, we need to facilitate
- 20:48communication between the government and scientific
- 20:50institutions. You don't actually have to be an
- 20:53expert in a scientific topic to endorse or approve
- 20:56a project. With the tools available today, like
- 20:59artificial intelligence, there are facilities
- 21:01to understand a project. They don't ask not even
- 21:03the geographic coordinates, so it doesn't make
- 21:06sense, these kind of questions, or they don't
- 21:09have a context. Yes, that's right. in many cases
- 21:12the people in charge of science resources have
- 21:15been and seem to continue to be incompetent to
- 21:18carry out such responsibility they are supposed
- 21:21to have advisers and consultants entire ministries
- 21:24for that But that's a topic for another episode.
- 21:27To wrap up, we want to thank our guests once
- 21:30again and our audience for tuning in to this
- 21:33episode of our podcast Science Behind the Glass,
- 21:35Illuminating the Human Side. This episode was
- 21:38inspired by the article Bioprospecting in Colombia.
- 21:41We'll leave the reference to this material in
- 21:43the episode description. If you enjoyed this
- 21:45episode, give it a like and subscribe to our
- 21:48channel. This podcast is self -funded and self
- 21:51-edited by its host. Find us on our YouTube channel,
- 21:54Spotify, on our official website. Follow us on
- 21:58our social media at X, Facebook and Instagram.
- 22:01Original music by our colleague and friend Bernardo
- 22:04Aguirre.