Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Customer data platforms: discipline before architecture
Transcript
- 0:00Host: You're listening to Leaders Insights.
- 0:07Host: Today's subject, does your company actually need a CDP or just better discipline?
- 0:11Expert: Most companies buying a customer data platform are solving a discipline problem with a software
- 0:16Expert: purchase.
- 0:17Expert: And it never works.
- 0:18Expert: That's the whole game, and it's why half the CDP deployments I see are shelfware 18
- 0:23Expert: months in.
- 0:24Expert: A customer data platform, the thing that supposedly stitches all your customer records
- 0:29Expert: into one profile, is architecture.
- 0:32Expert: But the mess underneath it is usually behavior.
- 0:35Host: Define the mess.
- 0:36Host: What are you actually walking into?
- 0:38Expert: Duplicate records.
- 0:40Expert: Three teams each with their own definition of an active customer.
- 0:43Expert: And nobody agreeing what a lead even means.
- 0:46Expert: I sat with a retailer last quarter, mid-size, roughly $400 million in revenue, who'd signed
- 0:52Expert: a three-year contract at about $300,000 a year.
- 0:56Expert: The CDP worked fine.
- 0:58Expert: The data going into it was garbage, so the profiles it built were garbage.
- 1:03Host: But surely the vendor pitch is that the platform cleans that up for you?
- 1:06Expert: The vendor pitch is a lovely fiction.
- 1:09Expert: No tool resolves a definitional argument between your sales director and your email team.
- 1:14Expert: That's a meeting, not a migration.
- 1:17Expert: What the CDP did was make the disagreement more expensive and more visible.
- 1:21Host: So how does a sane operator tell the two problems apart before they sign?
- 1:25Expert: One question.
- 1:26Expert: Can you already answer who are my best customers and what did they do last?
- 1:31Expert: With the systems you own?
- 1:33Expert: If the answer is yes, but it takes a week and three exports, you have a discipline problem.
- 1:38Expert: If the answer is genuinely no, the data physically lives in nine places that can't talk.
- 1:44Expert: Now you might have an architecture problem.
- 1:46Host: Nine places sounds like every company over a certain size, though.
- 1:50Expert: It does, and that's the trap.
- 1:52Expert: Forrester, key independent research shop, they don't sell the software, has been clear
- 1:56Expert: that the failures cluster around governance, not technology.
- 2:01Expert: Who owns the definitions?
- 2:02Expert: Who's allowed to change them?
- 2:04Expert: Who gets blamed when the numbers don't match?
- 2:06Expert: That's unglamorous and nobody wants to fund it.
- 2:09Host: Give me the number on how big this market's gotten, because the hype is doing a lot of
- 2:13Host: work here.
- 2:14Expert: North of $5 billion now, and every quarter another vendor rebrands their old database
- 2:19Expert: as a CDP.
- 2:21Expert: HubSpot will tell you unified data lifts conversion by some cheerful double-digit percentage.
- 2:27Expert: Worth noting they sell the CRM that feeds it, so crosscheck that against someone with
- 2:32Expert: no dog in the fight.
- 2:33Host: You mentioned that, retailer.
- 2:35Host: What would have actually fixed them?
- 2:37Expert: Two people and a spreadsheet for 90 days.
- 2:39Expert: Before you buy anything, you appoint one person who owns the definition of every core
- 2:44Expert: metric.
- 2:45Expert: Customer, active, churned.
- 2:48Expert: You reconcile your existing systems by hand until the numbers agree.
- 2:52Expert: Boring, cheap, and it surfaces whether your problem was ever technical.
- 2:57Host: And if it turns out it genuinely is technical?
- 3:00Expert: Then buy.
- 3:01Expert: But now you buy knowing what you're feeding it, so the thing actually earns its keep.
- 3:06Expert: The order matters.
- 3:07Expert: Discipline first, then architecture.
- 3:09Expert: Do it backwards, and you've automated your confusion at $300,000 a year.
- 3:14Host: Isn't there a risk that get discipline first is just an excuse to never modernize?
- 3:19Host: The stall tactic dressed up as prudence?
- 3:21Expert: There's a version of that, sure.
- 3:23Expert: But I've watched far more money burned rushing than dawdling.
- 3:27Expert: Semrush, again, a vendor.
- 3:29Expert: They sell analytics tools.
- 3:30Expert: So hold their numbers loosely, and Don reckons a big chunk of MarTech spend goes unused.
- 3:36Expert: The people overbuying aren't the cautious ones.
- 3:38Host: What's the tell that a team has actually earned the right to buy?
- 3:42Expert: And the argument in the room stops being which platform and becomes,
- 3:46Expert: We agree on the numbers, we just can't produce them fast enough.
- 3:50Expert: That sentence means you've done the human work.
- 3:53Expert: Until you can say it out loud, you're shopping for a scapegoat, not a solution.
- 3:57Host: Leave the listener with the one thing to do Monday morning.
- 4:00Expert: Pull your top hundred customers from every system you own and lay them side by side.
- 4:06Expert: If the lists don't match, cancel the demo.
- 4:09Expert: Your problem was never the software.
- 4:11Host: This episode draws on Forrester Research, Semrush Vendor, SEO Analytics Tools, DigiDay, HubSpot,
- 4:19Host: Vendor, CRM Marketing Automation.
- 4:22Host: That's it from us.
- 4:23Host: The reading continues at MBA-training.com, new CMO analysis every day.