Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / On Just Terms S2 E10: Directors' duties, class actions and the courts with Michael Pelly, Legal Writer at Capital Brief
Transcript
- 0:09SPEAKER_00: Today I'm delighted to welcome Michael Pelley back to On Just Terms.
- 0:14SPEAKER_00: Michael's the legal reporter at Capitol Brief, and he was previously the legal affairs editor at the Australian Financial Review.
- 0:20SPEAKER_00: He's been a senior advisor to State and Federal Attorneys General and is the author of many works, including The Smiler, a biography of former Chief Justice Murray Gleason.
- 0:31SPEAKER_00: In today's episode, we'll be discussing the problems with complex legal litigation and some of the complex cases regarding director's duties that have recently been published.
- 0:43SPEAKER_00: So, Michael, thanks again.
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: It's been a couple of years since we last spoke, and uh it's good to see you again on the podcast.
- 0:49SPEAKER_01: Always a pleasure to be with you, Jason.
- 0:50SPEAKER_00: So look, I'm interested in tapping in on what you've seen in the corporate and legal risk environment since we last spoke.
- 0:58SPEAKER_00: Every week is a new story, and you're interested in everything.
- 1:01SPEAKER_00: So what's different from the last time we spoke?
- 1:04SPEAKER_01: Well, I think uh obviously in the last week we've had the ASIC versus Star judgment and um the 500 pages of reasons by Michael Lee, which uh I think is very interesting across the board, not only for director's duties cases, which ASIC will pursue, but also for you as a as a class actions lawyer, because a lot of what you do goes to whether director's conduct was reasonable or officer's conduct was reasonable.
- 1:31SPEAKER_01: 100%.
- 1:32SPEAKER_00: And so where should we start when talking about I mean everyone's talking about it, a lot of ink's already been spilled, it's only less than a week old.
- 1:38SPEAKER_00: What struck you, what stood out for you of that judgment?
- 1:41SPEAKER_01: Well, I think you should start with what ASIC was trying to achieve in this case.
- 1:46SPEAKER_01: It was launched a very long time ago.
- 1:48SPEAKER_01: I think it was 2023.
- 1:51SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 1:52SPEAKER_01: ASIC was very keen to raise the bar for directors, but also to raise the bar for lawyers and general counsel.
- 2:02SPEAKER_01: Now you could possibly argue through various reasons that ASIC did not get up on the first thing.
- 2:08SPEAKER_01: In fact, I read with great interest uh the comments by your chairman, Rebecca Maslin Stanich, which says that the bar's pretty much where we thought it was.
- 2:18SPEAKER_01: And I think the case comes, unless section 180 and its various bits are actually revised, that's it's not going to change terribly much.
- 2:27SPEAKER_01: But as far as lawyers go, Joe Longo, the ASIC chairman, has had a real B in his bonnet about lawyers and the role they play in corporate life.
- 2:37SPEAKER_01: As you know, Joe was um, I think he's a Herald, I think he's a HSF alumni, isn't he, Joseph?
- 2:43SPEAKER_00: He is indeed.
- 2:44SPEAKER_01: Well, he well, Joe was a GC himself for Deutsche Bank.
- 2:49SPEAKER_01: So I think he has a very different view or a heightened view of what a GC can bring to the table.
- 2:56SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 2:57SPEAKER_01: He was very keen to push the idea that it's not just a checklist of obligations, as he said, but it's a positive duty to bring matters to the attention of the board and to help the CEO present, obviously, fulsome board papers and have proper discussions about risk before the board.
- 3:14SPEAKER_01: And he pretty much put Paula Martin in the doghouse on this one because uh through a combination of some fairly average testimony with long, long, long poisons and an ability to make any concessions, it was a bit of a horror show for Ms.
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: Martin.
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: In fact, um one thing I noticed uh in the course of the credit findings was that um he gave Paula Martin the same credit finding that he gave to uh Bruce Lerman in the uh Lerman versus Ten case, which is not good news for her because he basically said, I don't believe anything you say unless it's corroborated by someone else or you're speaking against your own interests.
- 3:59SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 3:59SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I look, I agree.
- 4:00SPEAKER_00: There seems to be a flavor here that there is going to be some tension in being able to attach liability to non-executive directors because they're innately reliant on what management are telling them.
- 4:13SPEAKER_01: Do they get a free pass in this judgment, Jason?
- 4:15SPEAKER_01: Because it looks to me like Lee said some things about what they should be doing.
- 4:22SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 4:22SPEAKER_01: But that's a big gap from what they should be doing, from what the law actually requires to do.
- 4:27SPEAKER_01: And as Rebecca says, the law is sitting where you always thought it sat.
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 4:33SPEAKER_00: I think the judgment does have a legal tract and then something closer to a purposive track.
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: A morality of the morality tract, one might say.
- 4:40SPEAKER_01: This is the way you should, whether it's the way we expect you to behave, if even if the law doesn't say that.
- 4:46SPEAKER_00: My reading was he was trying to inject some narrative around the the the decisions that follow in the next few years to uh platform.
- 4:54SPEAKER_01: Do you get the sense it was a warning?
- 4:55SPEAKER_00: Yes, I I do.
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: Although one that uh seemed to be laced with a bit of frustration that he didn't have the case from ASIC that he wanted.
- 5:04SPEAKER_00: What was the case he wanted?
- 5:06SPEAKER_00: I'm asking you as a litigator.
- 5:07SPEAKER_00: Yeah, it seemed seemed to me he wanted a case where he where ASIC could allege and demonstrate that the board ought to have essentially, I'm uh paraphrasing here, but lost confidence in the senior conduits of information to them and so should have said, look, we're not getting what we need.
- 5:22SPEAKER_00: It's time to get new people in, we're asking different questions.
- 5:24SPEAKER_01: And absent something in the papers or all the documents they're filed with the court.
- 5:29SPEAKER_01: That would only come out through cross-examination, I imagine.
- 5:32SPEAKER_01: Correct.
- 5:32SPEAKER_01: And none of the NEDs stepped into the box.
- 5:35SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 5:35SPEAKER_01: A decision which Justice Lee said was justified.
- 5:38SPEAKER_00: He did, and and a strategy that that has been effective.
- 5:41SPEAKER_00: That's a conduit, I guess, to then have the narrative around board papers and the need to ensure that they're distilled into something that guides judgment rather than a publication of every possible permutation and combination of risk.
- 5:55SPEAKER_00: I I'm a little bit sympathetic, as you'd expect me to be, for corporate Australia in this space because life's complex, way more complex than it was in some of the decisions cited in the judgment.
- 6:06SPEAKER_01: Well, there was one passage in the judgment where he's talking about the raising of the credit facilities and everything like that.
- 6:13SPEAKER_01: And he basically says, Well, you have this, there was this ASIC pointed to one line in an appendix that basically said, Well, you should have been aware that he was jailed on suspicion of money laundering in China in 2012.
- 6:29SPEAKER_00: Well, yeah.
- 6:30SPEAKER_01: That strikes me as a bit of a high bar.
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: It's a high bar, and it's also Justice Lee, if I make it.
- 6:36SPEAKER_01: And that's but that's where ASIC wanted to take it.
- 6:38SPEAKER_01: It is.
- 6:39SPEAKER_00: And indeed, they're not alone.
- 6:41SPEAKER_00: Most cases, you know, every class action that I've defended is an attempt to sort of withdraw hindsight from the line four of document 200.
- 6:51SPEAKER_00: But Lee put it right back in.
- 6:53SPEAKER_00: He said it's you can't do this with that.
- 6:55SPEAKER_00: That's right.
- 6:55SPEAKER_00: And so it's a it's a it's a balance.
- 6:57SPEAKER_00: And I think that's why there's so much, this is a warning in the sense that on the particular facts of this case, this outcomes occurred, but the next case might be totally different.
- 7:06SPEAKER_01: What do we draw from the fact, I'm asking you, of course.
- 7:08SPEAKER_01: That we've had effectively four executive officers and seven NEDs.
- 7:13SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 7:13SPEAKER_01: And the four executive officers, two went two were two admitted and made concessions before the case, and the other two went down.
- 7:21SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 7:22SPEAKER_01: Nothing from the NEDs.
- 7:23SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 7:24SPEAKER_00: ASICs had a very, I don't say this pejoratively, but their track record of establishing liability against non-executive directors is very poor.
- 7:32SPEAKER_00: I mean, they they've left shareholder class actions to do that work, not against directors individually, but against companies for failure to disclose.
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: They've they've not really had success in identifying liability against directors for any Australian corporate.
- 7:45SPEAKER_01: And I don't imagine the bar for liability for directors and shareholder class actions is any lower than it is Precisely in this in this case.
- 7:53SPEAKER_00: Which is why we don't see them sued directly.
- 7:55SPEAKER_00: First you've got to have the corporate conduct, then you've got to have the knowing involvement from the directors.
- 7:59SPEAKER_00: And it's all coming down to reasonableness.
- 8:00SPEAKER_01: So all this commentary we've seen by Lee coming out and saying, oh, directors should be doing this, you know, the Marquis of we're not the Marquis of Butte anymore.
- 8:09SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 8:10SPEAKER_01: Again, coming at the point, is this going to have any practical I mean, can it be a warning unless there's other changes legislatively?
- 8:19SPEAKER_00: Well, one you might say it's not a common law construct, is it?
- 8:23SPEAKER_00: No.
- 8:24SPEAKER_00: In fact, on common law, you might say this judgment hasn't moved the dial.
- 8:27SPEAKER_00: Like, is it new that managers, senior C-suite executives have responsibility to make sure important information goes to the board?
- 8:34SPEAKER_00: No.
- 8:34SPEAKER_00: No.
- 8:35SPEAKER_00: Is it new that a board places reliance on management?
- 8:37SPEAKER_00: No.
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: So on the facts of this case, there was risk for everyone, but it turned out that it stuck pretty much to where the common law has been.
- 8:45SPEAKER_01: Why haven't things changed since Cintro?
- 8:47SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 8:47SPEAKER_01: Well, because that's the big judgment he referred to.
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: Justice John Middleton.
- 8:51SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 8:52SPEAKER_01: Basically saying 14, 15 years ago.
- 8:56SPEAKER_00: Yes, yes.
- 8:57SPEAKER_01: You guys should be limiting the amount of information you get.
- 9:00SPEAKER_01: It's not an excuse.
- 9:01SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
- 9:03SPEAKER_01: We've gone nowhere.
- 9:03SPEAKER_01: No, it's true.
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: Are these directors just sort of using this as a way, almost as an out.
- 9:09SPEAKER_00: Well, we don't really have to do terribly much.
- 9:12SPEAKER_00: Well, I I've got a very simple answer to why it hasn't changed since Central, a case I was involved in.
- 9:16SPEAKER_00: But before I do, I saw the reference in the judgment to Centro.
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: I thought that was an unusual one in the sense that it's a completely different case.
- 9:25SPEAKER_00: That's a billion-dollar misclassification issue as opposed to the conduct in this case.
- 9:31SPEAKER_00: So it's factually very different.
- 9:32SPEAKER_00: But I think the reason it hasn't changed is shareholder class actions.
- 9:36SPEAKER_00: Because every defense to a shareholder class action is lots of information was had regard to, and we ultimately came to this decision.
- 9:44SPEAKER_00: The implication of these cases is make sure the record is replete with all of the detail that's possible so that you can demonstrate a reasonable basis.
- 9:54SPEAKER_01: And by the way, discharge at least says that's a disaster because that leads you down to appendix 55, you know, line 56.
- 10:02SPEAKER_01: You should be reading that too.
- 10:04SPEAKER_00: Indeed.
- 10:04SPEAKER_00: And and but he's dealing with the director's duties case.
- 10:07SPEAKER_00: And and companies in the rest of their corporate restructure are dealing with allegations that they failed to keep the market informed.
- 10:13SPEAKER_00: And the best way to defend those is to have a record that demonstrates that everything was thought through and this was the reasonable outcome.
- 10:20SPEAKER_01: It also struck me a little bit during this case that a couple of the assumptions on which ASIC was operating were let's just say were very pure.
- 10:32SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 10:32SPEAKER_01: You know, for example, they they talked about Philip Crawford somehow engaging with them, and but it looked to us as though Philip Crawford wasn't telling, you know, uh Starr that there were terribly many problems.
- 10:47SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 10:48SPEAKER_01: So if the casino regulator isn't telling you there are many problems or we've got a good relationship with Star, where's the urgency to act?
- 10:58SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 10:59SPEAKER_01: Well, ASIC seemed to think that as soon as you had that one piece of information, there's a you're almost compelled to act.
- 11:06SPEAKER_00: Well, there are parallels for that.
- 11:07SPEAKER_00: I mean, the the CBA Zonia case, one of the narratives there is that once you're in a dialogue with your regulator, in that case Ostrak, and they're expressing a level of dissatisfaction, even though things have moved on, that should be a trigger or a warning that there's a bigger problem at play.
- 11:26SPEAKER_00: Uh, which is a strange narrative.
- 11:28SPEAKER_00: I mean, one might interpret it the other way.
- 11:30SPEAKER_01: Regulators, I imagine, liage with you on a whole lot of different levels.
- 11:34SPEAKER_01: Indeed.
- 11:35SPEAKER_01: Another might ring you up and say, How are you today, Jason?
- 11:38SPEAKER_01: And the next day you say, Mr.
- 11:39SPEAKER_01: Bitch, we need to have a discussion.
- 11:41SPEAKER_00: Well, never in my case.
- 11:41SPEAKER_00: It's always never.
- 11:42SPEAKER_00: But you're right.
- 11:43SPEAKER_00: And the longer you have that dialogue, one might say the less uh critical the issue is because it's being s it's being worked through.
- 11:50SPEAKER_00: So it this judgment, I think it is correct to say it's a warning.
- 11:53SPEAKER_00: I'd interested in your views because it sets a narrative for a higher bar of corporate conduct, but it doesn't actually change the law.
- 12:00SPEAKER_01: Hmm.
- 12:01SPEAKER_01: So where do we where do we go with for Paula Martin and GCs?
- 12:05SPEAKER_01: Because I think that's the big takeaway for lawyers.
- 12:08SPEAKER_01: Isn't the answer we just use AI?
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: That seemed to be.
- 12:13SPEAKER_01: Okay, then if we're gonna use AI, are we opening up courts to to question what prompts we use?
- 12:19SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it is.
- 12:20SPEAKER_01: Because that's that's getting into very interesting territory.
- 12:23SPEAKER_00: It is.
- 12:23SPEAKER_00: I'm interested in your take.
- 12:25SPEAKER_00: There's a role for AI and everything, clearly.
- 12:27SPEAKER_00: That that that's the new world.
- 12:28SPEAKER_00: We we we're uh debating re the the emergence of reality if we try to say AI is not gonna be have a role.
- 12:35SPEAKER_00: But this case seemed to me it wasn't a question of uh let's get a machine to tell us what the critical summaries are, it's judgment.
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: What issues need to be elevated, what issues don't.
- 12:46SPEAKER_00: That's a human aspect.
- 12:47SPEAKER_00: And you're passing over judgment to the to the um the AI.
- 12:51SPEAKER_01: To the AI tool.
- 12:52SPEAKER_01: Would you like to defend that in court?
- 12:54SPEAKER_00: Well, um it's the new what is it, the new form of reasonable reliance.
- 12:59SPEAKER_01: Can we ever get to a point where a court or maybe a judge like Justice Lee says it's quite reasonable for you to rely on this to provide a summary?
- 13:09SPEAKER_01: And um, if the summary is not adequate, well, that's not really a problem.
- 13:15SPEAKER_01: Not I think not in my career.
- 13:16SPEAKER_00: I I think the element of I don't think that's ever gonna happen.
- 13:19SPEAKER_00: Come on, I agree.
- 13:20SPEAKER_00: You know.
- 13:21SPEAKER_00: And that that's why I thought the the narrative in The Judgment about AI, there's certainly a role to distill information, but at the end of the day, you need humans making decisions.
- 13:30SPEAKER_01: Was it curious that Lee put it in there?
- 13:32SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it it I I think it was a little um Because it's classico, but it went nowhere towards the or extracurial observations, which he's famous for.
- 13:41SPEAKER_00: Well, he my sense is he's trying to give some helpful guidance on how systems might be uplifted.
- 13:48SPEAKER_00: But at the end of the day, it seems the judgment turned to me on hu hu decisions by humans as to what to report and what not to report.
- 13:54SPEAKER_01: Did you get the sense that he would have really liked to have found against the Neds?
- 13:59SPEAKER_00: That's a hard read.
- 14:00SPEAKER_00: I mean, I I he did express frustration with the way that ASIC brought the case, which could be an indicator of precisely that.
- 14:07SPEAKER_01: Do you do you think maybe he as a as a as a great litigator himself maybe could have could have foreseen another path?
- 14:14SPEAKER_00: Maybe every judge is in that space.
- 14:17SPEAKER_00: But yeah, I do think there was a a narrative there around the over-intellectualization or or over-complication of the case that ASIC tried to bring.
- 14:27SPEAKER_00: Uh, because as we've just been discussing, it boiled down to did the board get the critical information it needed by those that it relied on.
- 14:34SPEAKER_00: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 14:34SPEAKER_01: And and as you said, was it reasonable to rely on on Matt Beckier and Paula Martin?
- 14:40SPEAKER_00: And there's nothing in most of the documents I saw.
- 14:43SPEAKER_00: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 14:43SPEAKER_00: That that's the issue for ASIC's case.
- 14:45SPEAKER_00: It's it's relying, isn't it, on connecting the dots between quite discrete and sometimes areas of minutiae within board papers that are themselves voluminous.
- 14:55SPEAKER_00: But that there is a challenge for all corporations.
- 14:57SPEAKER_00: How do I make sure the directors are actually spending their time exercising judgment as opposed to uh getting across minutiae?
- 15:05SPEAKER_00: I'm very sympathetic there because these days boards are spending 60-70% of their time on compliance to avoid legal risk as opposed to exercising judgment.
- 15:14SPEAKER_01: Well, Jason, you're you're also very up with this idea about how these sorts of cases all cross over.
- 15:22SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 15:22SPEAKER_01: Now they cross over to your favourite subject of class action.
- 15:25SPEAKER_01: Yeah, they do.
- 15:26SPEAKER_00: They do.
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: So with the High Court about to take on another class actions case, yeah.
- 15:31SPEAKER_01: Do you see any impact of this judgment on your on your space?
- 15:36SPEAKER_00: Yeah, uh look, I think this is uh the the pathway that connects this case to many what I'll call corporate governance class actions is what's what's reasonable.
- 15:47SPEAKER_00: Because every every shareholder class action turns on did the company act reasonably in relation to the information that it had.
- 15:55SPEAKER_00: And the answer is often these were the best judgments that were made on the information available.
- 16:01SPEAKER_00: And by the way, nothing was within the awareness of an officer that ought to have caused them to form a different opinion.
- 16:07SPEAKER_01: And we don't need a Danish philosopher to tell us.
- 16:10SPEAKER_00: Well, I had to Google that one.
- 16:12SPEAKER_00: Sorin, Soren Kierkengyard.
- 16:14SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 16:14SPEAKER_00: But there is there is force in the proposition, isn't there, that a case and that's the tyranny of defending these cases.
- 16:19SPEAKER_00: You're defending them in the shadow of hindsight.
- 16:21SPEAKER_00: The decisions are being made in the cut and thrust of the real world, where no one can really anticipate the significance of page 50.
- 16:28SPEAKER_01: How bad does it have to be there?
- 16:29SPEAKER_01: Because you're pointing out they're not winning these cases.
- 16:32SPEAKER_00: They're not winning, although it's pretty fluid.
- 16:34SPEAKER_00: I mean, when you look at the decisions to date, one might say that the losses have been on questions of causation and loss, which are a little bit more technical than breach, contravention of the law in terms of did I have material information that I failed to disclose.
- 16:48SPEAKER_00: In fact, some courts have found yes, there's material information, but it wouldn't have affected share price.
- 16:53SPEAKER_01: Now there's room for morality in the common law, common law construct.
- 16:56SPEAKER_01: Is there room for morality around the director's duties in section 180?
- 17:00SPEAKER_00: Yeah, um, hard question because the I think once courts decide to put an overlay of morality over the plain language of the text of the statute, it gets pretty murky, doesn't it?
- 17:12SPEAKER_01: That's one thing to uh give them a little bit of a touch up, it's another thing to say you have broken the law or you have you have broken your duty.
- 17:20SPEAKER_00: Precisely.
- 17:20SPEAKER_00: And so real really what some cases do, maybe this is an example, is they put a narrative out that is ultimately designed for the legislature to pick up and change our normative standards.
- 17:31SPEAKER_00: And so maybe it could that's not gonna happen.
- 17:33SPEAKER_01: We've seen uh the same way it's not gonna happen in your world.
- 17:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 17:36SPEAKER_01: I well class actions.
- 17:38SPEAKER_01: I don't think I think we're seeing a government that was very active in the first in its first term, the Albanese government.
- 17:46SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 17:46SPEAKER_01: With an attorney general who was very keen to pursue a number of issues, but interestingly, one of those was not class actions.
- 17:54SPEAKER_00: Indeed.
- 17:54SPEAKER_00: Well what what do you see?
- 17:56SPEAKER_00: Let's talk about the politics for a minute, because we've had prior to the current Labour government, a couple of Conservative governments, lots of pressure on the what I call the class action industry, almost no uh reform.
- 18:07SPEAKER_01: They'd made a bit of noise and they really put much pressure on it because when they'd made that noise, when we were working on those stories, when Michaelia Cash came to that, that was at five minutes to midnight in the Morrison government.
- 18:19SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 18:19SPEAKER_01: They didn't have time to get it through.
- 18:21SPEAKER_01: It almost seen like a a little, we'd like to do this, and uh, this is a rallying point against Labour who are all for class actions.
- 18:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 18:29SPEAKER_00: So parliamentary joint committee, to me, that took it up a level.
- 18:33SPEAKER_00: You've got you really a public hearing about whether class actions are money-making enterprises or recovery systems.
- 18:41SPEAKER_01: And that's what that that's what that inquiry basically descended into.
- 18:44SPEAKER_01: I think that's all it was.
- 18:45SPEAKER_01: It was all about cost.
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: It's to show that you're making too much you're making too much money.
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: That's what it was.
- 18:50SPEAKER_01: It didn't get down to our favourite subject, the circularity of shareholder class actions.
- 18:54SPEAKER_00: Didn't deal with that, but but in a l other than in a cursory way.
- 18:57SPEAKER_00: And it didn't do, and I know this is not uh a headline grabber, but it didn't deal with how do we make the class action regime quicker and less expensive.
- 19:06SPEAKER_00: Like it didn't really get into that.
- 19:08SPEAKER_00: What it got into is, oh, 15% of all settlements go to lawyers, another 25% go to funders.
- 19:14SPEAKER_00: Isn't this a problem?
- 19:16SPEAKER_00: It is a problem, but there are many more problems.
- 19:18SPEAKER_01: I think the biggest problem is you've got to sort out how a class action seems to cost both the defence and and the plaintiff 10 million bucks before they even get in a court door.
- 19:30SPEAKER_01: We get to a hearing.
- 19:32SPEAKER_00: Because I agree, that that is a that is maybe the issue.
- 19:35SPEAKER_01: Is there is there it seems to be, you know, an agreed facts process seems to be difficult in class actions?
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: It is.
- 19:42SPEAKER_01: Unlike crime or other things, that seem to agree facts and they can move forward from the facts quite easily to the legal issues.
- 19:48SPEAKER_00: Because the the fact that it can't be agreed is what opinions should have been formed.
- 19:52SPEAKER_00: That's the only fact that really matters.
- 19:54SPEAKER_00: Everyone knows when the company was founded, everyone knows the revenue numbers.
- 19:58SPEAKER_00: The hard decision is should we have formed a different opinion?
- 20:01SPEAKER_01: So how have we moved on from, you know, before before Meyer, you know, no class action had gone to judgment.
- 20:09SPEAKER_01: Yeah, yeah.
- 20:09SPEAKER_01: And no shareholder class action had gone to judgment, rather.
- 20:13SPEAKER_01: Has Meyer really changed things?
- 20:16SPEAKER_00: I don't think Meyer was uh a landmark decision in the sense that it it was a finding of on particular facts of a contravention resulting in no loss.
- 20:25SPEAKER_00: It didn't go into the same minutia that cases like Luca, um, CBA, and and some of these other cases are potentially brambles in terms of what's the content of.
- 20:36SPEAKER_01: Ian Jackman, just as Ian Jackman's an interesting figure in all this, isn't he?
- 20:40SPEAKER_01: He is.
- 20:40SPEAKER_00: He has a more relaxed view, can we say, about things?
- 20:45SPEAKER_00: Hard to know.
- 20:46SPEAKER_00: He he is responsible for the second Wally uh judgment, as you know.
- 20:52SPEAKER_00: And he he did find a finding of uh contravention in the sense of an unreasonable budget, but ultimately no causation and loss.
- 20:59SPEAKER_00: Well, that's the whole point.
- 21:00SPEAKER_01: I mean, this is the the bit that always puzzled me.
- 21:04SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 21:05SPEAKER_01: How do you actually link the knowledge to actual loss?
- 21:10SPEAKER_01: Because, you know, um Beach introduced this concept, or not introduced the concept, but stressed this concept of the sophisticated investor.
- 21:18SPEAKER_00: Yes, yes.
- 21:19SPEAKER_01: You know, they don't just sort of go, oh yes, I believe what the chairman told me, and I'm going to go and go and invest because of that.
- 21:26SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 21:27SPEAKER_01: Well, one one issue.
- 21:29SPEAKER_00: Uh no, so I didn't mean to talk about it.
- 21:31SPEAKER_00: I agree.
- 21:31SPEAKER_00: On your point, one one thing that struck me about Meyer is that the finding was that the market had already sort of impounded this.
- 21:38SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 21:38SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 21:39SPEAKER_00: And yet uh Justice Beach was prepared to say, but I'm sure there are some retail investors.
- 21:44SPEAKER_00: Well, he didn't want to give up on market based causation, did he just?
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: No.
- 21:47SPEAKER_00: So it's a it's a mix.
- 21:48SPEAKER_00: It's it's a mix.
- 21:49SPEAKER_00: These cases at the end of the day are only being brought because of one goal to to generate some money ultimately for group members and those that promote them.
- 21:56SPEAKER_00: And that's not happening.
- 21:58SPEAKER_00: Unless you're in Victoria?
- 22:00SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 22:00SPEAKER_01: Well Victoria Well that's that leads us back to our thing about why there hasn't been any change.
- 22:05SPEAKER_00: Do you think there will be?
- 22:05SPEAKER_00: Will will other jurisdictions embrace contingency fees?
- 22:09SPEAKER_01: Look, it'd be Andrew Bell would have to go and twist the arm of his um of his Attorney General, and I don't see that I don't see that happening.
- 22:16SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 22:17SPEAKER_01: Um Andrew Bell being the Chief Justice of New South Wales, who was a little bit annoyed that New South Wales doesn't get any class actions anymore.
- 22:24unknown: Right.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: And the federal court's a little bit annoyed that it's getting less class actions these days.
- 22:29SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 22:30SPEAKER_01: But nobody's doing anything about it.
- 22:32SPEAKER_00: Do you think it's putting the debate about whether contingency fees are good or not to one side, should we have a national uh regime?
- 22:39SPEAKER_00: Everyone's paid in the same way, irrespective of which court they're Well, obviously.
- 22:43SPEAKER_01: Because then you're getting into forum shopping.
- 22:45SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 22:45SPEAKER_01: I remember when the Victorian legislation came through, everybody said, well, this will be another another another more favorable way to do business.
- 22:55SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 22:56SPEAKER_01: And it has worked out that if you look at where the how the cases have drifted, the numbers don't lie.
- 23:01SPEAKER_01: Yes, yes.
- 23:01SPEAKER_01: Victoria is now the I think tied with Victor the Feds.
- 23:04SPEAKER_01: The Feds is the mainly popular terms of growth rates.
- 23:06SPEAKER_00: It's not the same.
- 23:07SPEAKER_01: Oh, the growth rates they've gone through, but they're and all the other states have basically lost out.
- 23:12SPEAKER_01: Now, will the feds go this way?
- 23:14SPEAKER_01: Can't see it.
- 23:15SPEAKER_01: Because there seems to be, especially with this government, a little bit of a willingness to lead a lot of reform around legal issues to the courts.
- 23:23SPEAKER_01: I see.
- 23:24SPEAKER_01: I see.
- 23:25SPEAKER_01: So as long as Labour's in, I don't see anything happening.
- 23:29SPEAKER_01: Really interesting.
- 23:30SPEAKER_01: And if the Libs do get back in, well, we've got hard to see them the next election, maybe the election after that, then they gotta get up, then they've probably got a list of things they're gonna do, and I don't see class actions being at the top of the pile.
- 23:43SPEAKER_01: So I think it's uh I think all the reform's gonna be coming out of the courts, and whether the High Court wants to do anything to clarify how common fund orders work, they want to do it clarify anything around directors' duties, hello, Commonwealth Bank versus uh Zonder, which is one of yours.
- 24:01SPEAKER_01: And if they want to do anything around this about ASIC versus Starr, because ASIC has seemed to be taking, has had an appetite recently for taking what are long shot test cases to the court.
- 24:15SPEAKER_01: If you look at the blockchain case, they or the block earner case, they lost heavily at trial and on appeal.
- 24:23SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 24:24SPEAKER_01: And something tells me there'll be an appeal in this uh in this case.
- 24:28SPEAKER_01: So regardless of what happens, I think we're headed to the high high court to get some sort of uh guidance around directors' duties and around how they operate and what is the standard they're meant to actually operate.
- 24:43SPEAKER_01: Is is reasonable what does reasonable mean in these circumstances?
- 24:48SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 24:48SPEAKER_01: As you know, it's always been how long's a how long's a piece of string.
- 24:52SPEAKER_00: And very factually, you know, driven.
- 24:54SPEAKER_00: Um so what what so that's an interesting take that you really think it'll be over to the courts to reform the law in this space rather than well, let's take a look at another example.
- 25:05SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: ASIC has been very keen to get some movement around Chapter 7 of the Corporations Act.
- 25:12SPEAKER_01: As we know, there was a huge, long inquiry by the ALRC.
- 25:18SPEAKER_01: They sent all their recommendations in.
- 25:20SPEAKER_01: Everyone from John Middleton, who's one of the commissioners, has been urging them to go and do something.
- 25:25SPEAKER_01: They've done nothing.
- 25:26SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 25:26SPEAKER_01: And they don't even look like doing anything.
- 25:29SPEAKER_01: Because, again, another thing, everything's about cost of living now.
- 25:33unknown: Yeah, yeah.
- 25:33SPEAKER_01: And think, though, we're gonna we're gonna reform class actions and no votes in that.
- 25:39SPEAKER_01: There was no votes in it.
- 25:40SPEAKER_01: And I just don't see to for them to do it, that would be again to go through another long consultation process.
- 25:48SPEAKER_01: Daniel Molino's still new to the job, and he would probably have carriage of it because the treasurer doesn't seem terribly interested.
- 25:55SPEAKER_01: Be nice if it was in the Attorney General's portfolio, but it's not.
- 25:59SPEAKER_01: She has social media laws to look after and things like that.
- 26:02SPEAKER_01: And I don't see it happening.
- 26:04SPEAKER_00: In a sense, um cybersecurity, data breaches, there's a range of other sort of legal issues that might ultimately be receiving more attention.
- 26:13SPEAKER_00: ESG, climate change.
- 26:15SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think if you had a top ten, I think you'd be you might even be struggling to get into the top ten with Class X.
- 26:20SPEAKER_01: Very deflating for my career prospects.
- 26:22SPEAKER_01: Oh, well, and you just you just keep going according to uh don't don't lawyers always uh thrive on a little bit of doubt in the law.
- 26:30SPEAKER_00: That's true.
- 26:31SPEAKER_00: This is an area with so much uncertainty.
- 26:32SPEAKER_00: I mean, the it is the last time um uh solicitor, common fund orders, you know, so could a solicitor forget contingency fees just as a matter of common law and court order extract a percentage of the recovery from group members, the high court says no.
- 26:47SPEAKER_00: It contributes I'd still find I don't know.
- 26:49SPEAKER_01: I mean, maybe I find the whole the way the high court's done this, even going back right to right to the earliest cases where they said, Oh, yeah, yeah, I know you've got a problem with Champany, but really it's all about access to justice.
- 27:03SPEAKER_01: Fostiff.
- 27:04SPEAKER_01: They really bent over the backwards on their whole access to justice issue.
- 27:09SPEAKER_00: Well, you might but you might think that the current high court's pretty different to that FOSTIF court, because they're basically saying to lawyers, no, you can't get a contingency fee.
- 27:15SPEAKER_01: Yeah, but you've also got Robert Beets Jones saying, hang on, don't you don't don't you go down running around class actions.
- 27:23SPEAKER_01: Remember the one of the various earliest speeches Robert Beats Jones made.
- 27:26unknown: Yes.
- 27:27SPEAKER_01: And I've sort of he of the he of the Grantham Floods class action who said that uh no, we've there's absolutely a place for them anybody who thinks that class actions aren't uh serving a good purpose now.
- 27:40SPEAKER_01: This is where we get into the other side of the um argument, uh Jason, where do we where we um hive off uh or we separate class actions into the good and the and the avaricious and the maybe the bad, if we're talking about and I think look, from my point of view, I think there's a discussion around class actions on on product liability cases and stolen wages and everything.
- 28:06SPEAKER_01: I think the issue there has become not so much whether they're right to be bringed, but how they're administered.
- 28:12SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 28:13SPEAKER_01: There's a real groundswell of emerging excuse like judicial distaste for how the costs that are racked up on administrations and stuff like that.
- 28:25SPEAKER_01: Now, then we go over to class actions, where does anybody see any real utility in class actions?
- 28:33SPEAKER_01: I've always been interested in the argument that oh they promote better, better behaviour.
- 28:38SPEAKER_01: And possibly you couldn't you could make that argument.
- 28:42SPEAKER_01: But also the whole circularity of it all, it just beats me that you're taking from, for example, take the classic, like the my uh the the your case, that you if you bought shares between a certain date and a certain date, yeah, you were in.
- 28:59SPEAKER_01: Now, what if you never sold those shares?
- 29:01SPEAKER_01: Sorry.
- 29:03SPEAKER_00: Or what if you did, and and on the plaintiff's theory you were perfectly compensated for the overpayment by selling at a higher level as well.
- 29:10SPEAKER_01: And what if you didn't sell the shares?
- 29:11SPEAKER_01: Yes.
- 29:12SPEAKER_01: Are you are there for are there for are therefore entitled to a second buying?
- 29:15SPEAKER_00: Right, or or your investment improves after the period of alleged non-disclosure.
- 29:20SPEAKER_00: You make a good point about we we don't have a supply issue for what I'll call corporate class actions.
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: And it's telling, I think, that when contingency fees came into Victoria, the goal was to increase diversity of claims, but that didn't work.
- 29:34SPEAKER_01: Well, why is there why why has every other case been about how much I can get out of the out of the thing?
- 29:39SPEAKER_01: It seems to be courts seem to be a little bit reluctant to go over 30%.
- 29:44SPEAKER_00: They are, or they have been there, but they uh the I find it hard to comment on that because I I'm not sure of the machinery by which these numbers are being.
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: I don't know.
- 29:52SPEAKER_01: Somebody just sort of throw the balls up in there, looks like a 24 case.
- 29:56SPEAKER_01: What do you reckon?
- 29:57SPEAKER_01: 28, 32, you reckon we can go for?
- 29:59SPEAKER_00: You're not giving the evidence much credit, although I haven't seen it, but um it's not Well, this is a really hard case, maybe 32.
- 30:06SPEAKER_00: That is the narrative that's coming through.
- 30:07SPEAKER_00: Cases are hard.
- 30:08SPEAKER_01: I don't think it's a really hard case.
- 30:09SPEAKER_01: So therefore we should be getting more money, you know.
- 30:11SPEAKER_01: That's and we and we should be employing like I love one of the recent cases where Justice Mortimer pointed out that uh the expert who was hired in the case was getting paid less than the than the than the law clerks who were viewing the evidence.
- 30:27SPEAKER_00: I remember that judgment, yeah.
- 30:28SPEAKER_00: That and and look, that's exposing.
- 30:30SPEAKER_00: And that's an industry, an ongoing industry issue.
- 30:33SPEAKER_00: Your broader point, though, was there aren't enough, my sense is, what I might call social justice class actions, where uh when you do see them brought, they generally result in outcomes.
- 30:45SPEAKER_00: Or what about, as you mentioned, stolen wages, um, underpayment cases, uh climate change.
- 30:52SPEAKER_00: Um, there's just not the finance.
- 30:54SPEAKER_00: When they're brought, that they generally have an impact.
- 30:56SPEAKER_01: Now, all these things could could actually be done through legislative means, but governments don't want to do that.
- 31:01SPEAKER_00: No, regulators aren't bringing those cases.
- 31:03SPEAKER_00: And you know, 30 years ago, the government rejected a scheme that would have a s a fighting fund for social justice claims.
- 31:11SPEAKER_01: Well, in fact, Bob Debitts put up this idea.
- 31:14SPEAKER_01: I remember this is how sadly how long I've been around.
- 31:17SPEAKER_01: Bob Devus put up this idea at a meeting of the Attorneys General, with this the old SCAG they used to call it standing committee.
- 31:26SPEAKER_01: The worst acronym in the law, but I loved it.
- 31:28SPEAKER_01: I was still about it.
- 31:29SPEAKER_01: But he put up this idea that they could take a percentage out of each judgment, put it into a pool.
- 31:35SPEAKER_01: Right.
- 31:36SPEAKER_01: And then you would have a self-funding or public interest claims.
- 31:40SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 31:41SPEAKER_01: And class action would effectively be become public interest litigation.
- 31:45SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 31:45SPEAKER_00: If it met certain criteria, like being for a social Victorian Law Reform Commission, a number of um good reform bodies have suggested it, but I guess maybe no votes in it either.
- 31:56SPEAKER_01: Well, yeah, it's the other one too.
- 31:58SPEAKER_01: You're possibly putting money in the pockets of lawyers by pursuing you know money out of public funds.
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: It's a tricky one, that one.
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: Put it this way, there's 55 ways to ask to argue against uh whether you should bring a legal claim or not.
- 32:13SPEAKER_00: Yes.
- 32:13SPEAKER_00: Okay, well, look, what what haven't I asked you that we is useful that we mentioned before we sign off today?
- 32:20SPEAKER_01: I just think it's interesting how how does litigation continually get more complex and expensive.
- 32:28SPEAKER_01: Well, is to be because it isn't the great skill of the lawyer, and meant to be of the lawyers of the judges, yeah, to bring the case down to its essence.
- 32:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah, it's a different practice now.
- 32:39SPEAKER_01: Is the bench not asserting itself as much?
- 32:43SPEAKER_01: Or are lawyers just in the old vernacular, just always want to cover every base, and I could have put it another way.
- 32:49SPEAKER_00: It might yeah, it might be more.
- 32:51SPEAKER_00: I I think frankly, it's more the latter.
- 32:53SPEAKER_00: There doesn't seem to be any lack of I mean, Justice Lee's an example of wanting to get to the point and but party.
- 33:00SPEAKER_01: Because what used to be the two-week trial, I mean, the four-day trial now is very rare.
- 33:06SPEAKER_01: Why can't we bring it back?
- 33:07SPEAKER_01: Well For me, that is everyone talks about legal costs and everyone.
- 33:12SPEAKER_01: Length.
- 33:12SPEAKER_01: Length is a problem.
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: Length is the issue.
- 33:14SPEAKER_00: And and discovery, I mean, when you've produced a hundred.
- 33:21SPEAKER_00: Well, I think AI could.
- 33:22SPEAKER_00: It could at least say, here are the documents that you you need to have focus on to build the chronology.
- 33:28SPEAKER_01: It could distill Could you could you see your practice and preparing for a class action go go the other way and become less voluminous?
- 33:38SPEAKER_00: On discovery, 100%.
- 33:40SPEAKER_00: I just think there's a a world in which reviewing materials to identify where potentially the important ones are could be reduced drastically.
- 33:47SPEAKER_00: I think that's our future.
- 33:49SPEAKER_00: Doesn't substitute the need for a human to say here's the implication of that important document, but it might reduce the search time.
- 33:55SPEAKER_01: Because that's where I think lawyers and courts and the legal system lose the public.
- 34:01SPEAKER_01: Lose the public and how long things take and how many boxes or trolleys have to be wheeled into a courtroom for a court case.
- 34:10SPEAKER_00: And that's what's changed.
- 34:11SPEAKER_00: I think there's many more of those now than there ever used to be.
- 34:14SPEAKER_00: Now, part of that is the digital world.
- 34:16SPEAKER_00: There are just more documents now that need to be reviewed.
- 34:18SPEAKER_00: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
- 34:19SPEAKER_01: But shouldn't the digital world make it easier for us to find what's actually of essence?
- 34:23SPEAKER_00: Precisely, because I I think one thing that hasn't changed is the cases turn on three or four folders.
- 34:28SPEAKER_00: Uh, and it's how do you get to those three or four quickly?
- 34:32SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 34:33SPEAKER_00: Well, Michael, as usual, quite a tour de force uh there in terms of the current legal landscape.
- 34:39SPEAKER_00: I'm so grateful for you being generous with your time and joining the joining the podcast.
- 34:43SPEAKER_00: Thank you so much, Michael Pelly.
- 34:44SPEAKER_00: Thank you, Jason Pitt.
- 34:47SPEAKER_00: As we close today's discussion, two important themes emerge.
- 34:51SPEAKER_00: Firstly, the implications of regulatory litigation will likely be far reaching both for directors and corporations.
- 34:58SPEAKER_00: And secondly, class actions, including the politics of how these cases are run and financed, will continue to evolve.
- 35:06SPEAKER_00: Michael's perspective highlights the potential scale of the changes to the perception of both directors and companies' liability and class action proceedings.
- 35:15SPEAKER_00: Thank you for joining us on On Just Terms.
- 35:18SPEAKER_00: We look forward to continuing the conversation.