Latest / No Way Out / Reorienting Safety: Human and Organizational Performance (HOP) with Todd Conklin
Transcript
- 0:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We love conversation.
- 0:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, Professor Todd Conklin Dr Conklin is with us today.
- 0:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to give you a disposition of how we kind of know each other.
- 0:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This is probably the first time we met online and Steve McCrone is our co-host today.
- 0:34Todd Conklin: Do I owe anyone money?
- 0:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's get that out early.
- 0:37Todd Conklin: That depends no, the check's in the mail, I'm sure it's in the mail.
- 0:41Todd Conklin: It's on its way.
- 0:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's on its way.
- 0:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's on its way.
- 0:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I appreciate that.
- 0:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So 2017, I want to go back to then.
- 0:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a lot going on.
- 0:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Back then we had, I believe, 17 sailors lost their lives in two mishaps 2017.
- 1:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I came across you in 2018.
- 1:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I came back into the active duty Navy.
- 1:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our job was to understand culture safety, how to build better teams.
- 1:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Our job was to understand culture safety, how to build better teams.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Leaders get leading indicators and your name came up right.
- 1:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So this thing called HOP Human and Organizational Performance, safety 2, safety Differently, resilience, engineering, high Reliability Theory All these things kept coming up up.
- 1:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the Naval Safety Command, naval Safety Center, then brought you in to talk to several military leaders and kind of paved the way for what the future of safety looks like.
- 1:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I come from a big safety background fighter, aviation, aviation, crew, resource management, high consequences.
- 1:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know we've learned a lot over the years from failures, if you will.
- 1:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that brought me to the world of complex adaptive systems and that's how I met our co-host today, steve McCrone.
- 1:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We met at a Kenevan retreat, up in Whistler actually, and I was trying to figure it.
- 1:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, you guys go to good meetings.
- 1:59Todd Conklin: Yeah, kind of fun.
- 2:00Steve McCrone: Nice.
- 2:01Steve McCrone: So, todd, my background is in ammunition storage, logistics and destruction, so again, another high consequence environment.
- 2:10Steve McCrone: My first, my first introduction to safety was um, basically, how do you cover your ass when idiots make mistakes?
- 2:18Steve McCrone: Um, and from there, we're kind of fairly dissatisfied with that view.
- 2:22Steve McCrone: Um went on to do a lot of work, believe it or not, in helping organisations really understand safety as an emergent property of a complex system.
- 2:31Steve McCrone: This is when, like me and Brian, got together with another couple of people around the world Marion Keeley, michael Sheveldave, gary Wong, those guys and started really looking at that in detail and, frankly, we drew quite a lot on the early work that you did.
- 2:48Steve McCrone: Pre-accident investigations forms a big part of the way that we approached ammunition safety, for instance.
- 2:56Todd Conklin: Wow.
- 2:58Steve McCrone: What's the worst that can happen.
- 2:59Steve McCrone: That was our catchphrase.
- 3:00Todd Conklin: Yeah, that's true, and the answer was always really bad answers, oh yeah.
- 3:06Steve McCrone: Yeah, not always right.
- 3:07Steve McCrone: And when it wasn't, you could say, okay, let's lighten the load a little bit.
- 3:10Steve McCrone: But oftentimes it was and that's when we really needed to pay attention.
- 3:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so hey, welcome to the no Way Out, Professor Conklin, great to see you, just call me, todd, are you sure that will drive me crazy?
- 3:25Todd Conklin: All right, yeah, the only person I may call me Dr Conklin is my dentist.
- 3:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why is that?
- 3:32Todd Conklin: I think it might be more about me than my dentist.
- 3:34Todd Conklin: All right, but we can talk about it.
- 3:35Todd Conklin: I think that's a different podcast, but we can talk about it.
- 3:38Todd Conklin: All you want to.
- 3:38Todd Conklin: I need the therapy.
- 3:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Hop?
- 3:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I came across Hop again inside Oil Gas.
- 3:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A lot of folks are following this philosophy right.
- 3:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It is a philosophy We've had recently on the show.
- 3:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've had Dr David Slater.
- 3:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think you might be familiar with his work.
- 3:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Fantastic conversation, looking at safety through another lens as well.
- 3:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I kind of want to get your background.
- 4:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: My first question is who coined Hop?
- 4:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I have a couple ideas of who it might be, but where did it?
- 4:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where did it come from?
- 4:09Todd Conklin: So I think that's a really interesting question.
- 4:11Todd Conklin: So so I worked for a really long time at Los Alamos National Laboratory, so, which was operated by the Department of Energy, and I worked a lot with high risk, high consequence stuff.
- 4:24Todd Conklin: You know the department of energy and I worked a lot with high risk, high consequence stuff, you know.
- 4:28Todd Conklin: I mean we all kind of come from the same place and maybe even the same stuff in many cases.
- 4:32Todd Conklin: Right and um, we started looking gosh, I need to pray.
- 4:35Todd Conklin: It had to have been past 25 years ago, so 27, 28 years ago um, kind of a rough estimate.
- 4:43Todd Conklin: We started looking at there must be a better way to manage really this high-risk safety, because the industrial safety rules and the paradigm was okay I don't know if we thought it was bad at that time, it's what we had and behavioral-based safety was starting to get really sexy.
- 5:03Todd Conklin: The problem is, with high risk, high consequence, you learn really quickly that it's almost never a behavioral problem, because scared people don't take scary jobs.
- 5:15Todd Conklin: You know what I mean.
- 5:17Todd Conklin: So you don't really have a problem with people that don't understand the risk they're in the job because in fact, if they don't like risk, they don't do what you guys did for a living.
- 5:28Todd Conklin: I mean, it's just that it's not attractive to them, right?
- 5:29Todd Conklin: And so we started looking around and we found through an organization called IMPO.
- 5:36Todd Conklin: Are you guys familiar with them at all?
- 5:38Steve McCrone: It stands for the Institute of Nuclear Power Operations.
- 5:41Todd Conklin: Ok, and, and it's, it was really the North American kind of version of WAMO.
- 5:46Todd Conklin: It was a consortium of all the new power operators and they had gone through really the tutelage of James Reason into this discussion around how humans interface with the systems.
- 5:59Todd Conklin: And it wasn't really human factors, not in the traditional European definition or the aviation definition, which are somewhat similar.
- 6:06Todd Conklin: It was really more of an understanding of how systems interface with work and it was really now something we call kind of the socio-technical interface, how systems and people come together to function and create success in a highly adaptive, highly dynamic environment with high consequence and really zero acceptability of failure.
- 6:28Todd Conklin: So this human performance stuff became really an interesting part of our discussion and several of us within the Department of Energy community kind of jumped on it and we soon developed some capacity to actually go to all of our facilities, all of which are super high risk.
- 6:46Todd Conklin: But again, I'm sort of preaching to the choir with you guys and so we started having this discussion but we couldn't call it HP OK, because HP was already used up by the health physics people and you learn really quickly in the radiation community that the health physics people are a really good friend to have radiation community, that the health physics people are a really good friend to have.
- 7:07Todd Conklin: You want them.
- 7:07Todd Conklin: You want them to like you because if something happens they're the ones that get you naked and scrub you with a big wire brush.
- 7:12Todd Conklin: So the more relationship you can build early, the higher the payoff is if you have to get crapped up right.
- 7:18Todd Conklin: So we started calling it HPI human performance improvement and I don't think I mean I don't want to speak for everybody, but I don't think any of us really gave a crap what we called it.
- 7:30Todd Conklin: But HPI was for sure a little wonky and a little weird and as it started to diffuse, especially in manufacturing and especially in the energy sector, it became really an interesting discussion.
- 7:43Todd Conklin: Europe had been using a form of HOP and then it was really picked up, probably first by General Electric in their appliance manufacturing facility and they kind of ran with human and organizational performance.
- 7:59Todd Conklin: It's the craziest thing, you guys, because whatever it's called and punch, you just kind of did it earlier when you ran through the litany of names, kind of safety to and safety differently, and I don't know how you guys feel I don't really care what it's called.
- 8:15Todd Conklin: I mean it's not that important, but this one stuck because I think it's kind of clever and a lot of people really liked the fact that it includes the organization in the discussion, so it does sort of take some focus entirely, just off the worker.
- 8:29Todd Conklin: So that was the longest answer ever, but I mean it's kind of a weird question because I kind of think it's here to stay for a while at least.
- 8:37Steve McCrone: I agree I think a lot of people have been trying to carve a space by the nomenclature that they use and, frankly, they're all branches of the same tree, so you can see the kind of root in all of those approaches, regardless of what you call it, and, interestingly enough, people who do this work for kind of at the pointy end of the stick don't really care, I mean I haven't found anybody especially, you know, invested in one name over the other.
- 9:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So is there a connection back to Carl Veik's work in high reliability theory?
- 9:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, yeah, yeah, okay.
- 9:12Todd Conklin: So Carl is amazing and Carl and Kathleen, who were a team of people, they were doing some interesting work.
- 9:22Todd Conklin: Carlene Roberts and Todd Laporte at Berkeley were doing interesting work and it was kind of coming at a simultaneous rate.
- 9:31Todd Conklin: Carleen was really looking at, well like for sure, the Navy and she was doing carrier ride-alongs and her kind of compelling question was how do they get 18-year-old kids to care enough?
- 9:45Todd Conklin: How are they doing it?
- 9:46Todd Conklin: And man, her observations were amazing.
- 9:49Todd Conklin: My employer has always been the University of California, so I had kind of a nice little connection in with Carlene and Todd and so I was able to talk to them and then Carl and Kathleen were just doing amazing work and really Carl sort of kind of wrote the book.
- 10:06Todd Conklin: I mean, not kind of he did, he did write the book and he's the one that sort of encapsulated everything.
- 10:12Todd Conklin: And it was very interesting.
- 10:14Todd Conklin: Because the high reliability depends kind of where you're from, because that title's been in flux too.
- 10:21Todd Conklin: But you know it used to be called a highly reliable organization.
- 10:26Todd Conklin: No, high reliable.
- 10:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I can't say, I can't even get it right.
- 10:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: High reliability, organizing right, is that?
- 10:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, that's now, that's what they call it now.
- 10:33Todd Conklin: Okay, but they used to just use the word organization and they they changed it from a noun to a verb, which is, which is you know kind of um, very Eric Holmegel and Holmegel in you know kind of very Eric Holneglen, holneglen, you know, to show it as an active part of it.
- 10:47Todd Conklin: And that's been really an interesting part as well and that played in really deeply early on in the stuff we were doing at Department of Energy and it was great.
- 10:56Todd Conklin: The problem, if I can say that that seems judgmental, is that what happened is is that they sort of came up with the characteristics of an HRO and then they kind of told companies, go become this, and what was missing was sort of the pathway to which to become this.
- 11:16Todd Conklin: So they started with kind of the end, which is probably good, but they didn't really help people along the way.
- 11:24Todd Conklin: And one of the interesting things about this is that now the HR discussion is coming back into pretty popular discussion and I think the timing is much better now because now people have an understanding.
- 11:37Steve McCrone: I will just tell you that HRO and I'm pretty biased, but HRO has a difficult time working if the organization believes every event is preventable, okay, so if they're really honed around this idea of zero events, then becoming an HRO is virtually impossible, right, but that was never part of the early discussion, I think early discussion, I think With the likes of HRO, what we see is a lot of these methods start out as a pretty authentic response to the complexity of the safety situation and then people try and scale them by replicating them, by saying if you do this, you get that Because we did this and we got that.
- 12:21Steve McCrone: And a lot of the work that we do at the front end is really founded on establishing context.
- 12:30Steve McCrone: What works in our context may not work in your context.
- 12:32Steve McCrone: So context is king, becomes the phrase we use around safety.
- 12:39Todd Conklin: And you saw examples of exactly that.
- 12:41Todd Conklin: Like remember when they started looking at health care really early, then one of the things I said is health care is going to adapt hro, which is fine, that's a good target.
- 12:50Todd Conklin: And then you saw journal articles and pretty elaborate documentaries on you know why hospitals don't fly?
- 12:57Todd Conklin: Yeah, yeah.
- 12:59Todd Conklin: Well, one reason is they're not planes.
- 13:01Todd Conklin: I mean, I'm no genius, but it's not a plane, and so it was exactly that it was.
- 13:07Todd Conklin: This works in one context, therefore it should work in another context, and context drives everything.
- 13:14Todd Conklin: You're exactly right.
- 13:14Todd Conklin: Everything lives in that context.
- 13:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm not sure if you're familiar with the agile community or not the whole agile movement and software development.
- 13:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Have you been tracking any of that over the last 20 years?
- 13:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A?
- 13:24Todd Conklin: little bit, not as much as I find it super, super interesting, yeah, but not as much as I probably should be.
- 13:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, this is interesting, I know the cats, I know the players.
- 13:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, the players.
- 13:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we've had some of the players on here.
- 13:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We've worked with several of them in the past and there's a pathway that they wanted to go on it on about 25 years ago and that pathway is the one that you're on now.
- 13:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They wanted to go down the Carl Veidt pathway, but they end up going down a pseudoscience pathway and this is coming from some of the signatories or people that signed the Agile manifesto.
- 13:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So they identified that the pseudoscience thing was just easier to do.
- 13:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just.
- 13:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's just follow this.
- 14:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think what we're seeing today is a course correction back towards trusting the science, if you will, towards high reliability theory, towards resilience engineering, towards HOP.
- 14:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And when you're in an organization like a large oil and gas company, you see the safety HSE safety community doing HOP.
- 14:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have over here doing design thinking, over here you have them doing agile and over there they're doing lean, and then you got Six Sigma over there.
- 14:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: At the end of the day, that's just way too much energy for an organization to spend.
- 14:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think what we're seeing is and this is my opinion and I want to get your view on it is kind of the convergence on I'll call it hop human and organizational performance, or flow thinking, or whatever you want to call it for maximizing performance in an organization.
- 14:45Todd Conklin: OPEX operational excellence, yeah, operational excellence, same thing, right.
- 14:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So OPEX has a big connection to fighter aviation, a planned execute assess or planned brief execute debrief model, which is fantastic.
- 14:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, all teams should do that.
- 14:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How they do that matters, and that's something that we're learning from the team science world, the world of team steps, from healthcare, the lessons we get from Gary Klein and others, eduardo Salas, that we get from team science, scott Tannenbaum and, of course, amy Edmondson.
- 15:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Looking at all this, but I want to get your thoughts.
- 15:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you seeing a convergence now or what's happening in your space?
- 15:21Todd Conklin: So yeah, and I think it makes sense, right, that it would faction out and people would sort of own their own individual ideas, and they probably needed the time to do that, to develop their ideas and to understand deeply.
- 15:33Todd Conklin: And then people start seeing connections or, as the kids would say, collaborations, collabs.
- 15:39Todd Conklin: Right, they can collab across ideas and the community becomes stronger, better because of the depth that each of these individual ideas brings into the discussion and we start to really synthesize a lot of these ideas across the board.
- 15:53Todd Conklin: The other thing that I think was really interesting is that it became really clear that again at kind of the sharp end, there is not a big difference between lean and Six Sigma and black belt and safety and environment.
- 16:06Todd Conklin: And you know, it's all procedural use and adherence, it's all, it's all the same thing in the mind of the worker and they're just trying to get work done in a in a rapidly changing, highly volatile, adaptive, demanding environment.
- 16:19Todd Conklin: And so the discussion, I think, becomes, it's becoming much more meaningfully synthesized as people really at the practical side of the house are having to take this information and use it in a way that makes a real difference to the organization.
- 16:34Todd Conklin: That's probably normal, I mean, if you look at kind of the study of how ideas diffuse, like Ev Rogers, the diffusion of innovation guy, right, he would tell you that you're going to have these really early adopters who are very sure that what they're saying is the truth and the only way and they're going to fight really hard for it because they have to, because they're really up against relatively significant forces that don't want to change and that, as the early adopters make a space, then kind of those first users and second users and the rest of the bell curve if I may draw a bell curve and every conversation has to have a bell curve in it at some point they become part of that discussion.
- 17:16Todd Conklin: That's actually, I think, one of the more exciting parts of what's happening.
- 17:20Todd Conklin: But I would caution us that I think what's missing is really the foundation, and it is so seductive to go into a place where the world's better, where we'll have fewer events, things will be brighter and smell better and there's free cookies.
- 17:39Todd Conklin: But we can't get there until we establish some really foundational items, and one of the things that I think we're seeing some shift on is really the definition of safety.
- 17:50Todd Conklin: So the biggest challenge that personally I would tell you there are two that I would talk about but that I've had to carry throughout my career is the belief that most people think safety is the absence of harm or the absence of risk.
- 18:08Todd Conklin: You can sort of put any word you want in there, right.
- 18:10Todd Conklin: When in fact what we know is that really robust systems don't ever remove risk.
- 18:17Todd Conklin: They add control, right.
- 18:20Todd Conklin: And so when we started really shifting the conversation from safety as a deficit to safety as an additive, or, as Eric would say, safety to safely, right you go from sort of noun to adverb that that actually helped organizations because they needed to see safety really as a capacity.
- 18:43Todd Conklin: We needed to see safety really as a capacity, the same way you look at, like fuel or food or I don't know, paperclips or you know right.
- 18:54Todd Conklin: And I think that's one advantage that you guys in the Navy, especially Navy aviators, had pretty early is that you saw safety not as an end point but as a capacity in doing operations.
- 19:04Todd Conklin: I mean, this is how we do operations.
- 19:08Todd Conklin: That shift has been really really an important shift, and I think I mean I'm probably naive, but I think that's kind of happening- I mean I don't think it's happened, but I think it's happening.
- 19:19Todd Conklin: The other shift oh, go ahead.
- 19:23Steve McCrone: I was going to say it is happening.
- 19:24Steve McCrone: But in the real world there's a real tension between the capacity to stay safe, the capacity to adapt to change, which is a different type of capacity and the need, particularly in a governance and management perspective, to prove that we're safe, the need to be compliant, the need to show that the ass covering you might call it that happens at the top of the organization can oftentimes dampen the ability for the operational side of the organization to remain adaptive and maintain that capacity to stay safe.
- 20:03Todd Conklin: And predictably so.
- 20:04Todd Conklin: I think you're again 100% right on that.
- 20:06Todd Conklin: I think that is really a data point that tells us we haven't done a good job with the top side of the organization and we do an especially bad job with the regulator in helping them redefine what it is we're trying to accomplish.
- 20:20Todd Conklin: The other big shift that I would toss in here just because I think it needs to be tossed in pretty early in the conversation is the changing role that workers or operators have.
- 20:30Todd Conklin: So traditional safety the safety we all grew up with the idea was that really the operator was the problem.
- 20:38Todd Conklin: So if you want to do high explosive ordnance safety better, you ask high explosive workers to be more safe and all safety programs are directed at them.
- 20:48Todd Conklin: You tell them what to do, or oftentimes in in our world, we tell people what not to do.
- 20:53Todd Conklin: For god's sakes, never do this right, and that actually probably reached the end of its value.
- 21:02Todd Conklin: But that's when we started understanding that the worker is not the problem.
- 21:06Todd Conklin: The worker is really the problem solver.
- 21:07Todd Conklin: Welcome the adaptive community, you guys right.
- 21:11Todd Conklin: The agile community right, the worker has to be agile enough to hold a relatively wonky, pretty poorly designed system together in order to perform some mission, and so, instead of seeing the worker as the problem to be fixed, when you start seeing workers as a solution, as experts, then instead of telling them what to do, you ask them what we need.
- 21:36Todd Conklin: And what's interesting is, recognizing that expertise lives in every level of the organization really changed the way we did problem identification and problem framing, which obviously is going to change how we do problem solving.
- 21:56Steve McCrone: So is this where we start to kind of overlap with the idea of psychological safety and wellbeing.
- 22:02Steve McCrone: I mean the the workers today have an increasing kind of cognitive workload which can, if not managed, diminish their ability to adapt and solve problems as they emerge, and that has an impact on people's ability to stay safe, both from a mental and a physical perspective.
- 22:25Steve McCrone: So I see a lot of health and safety people that now have well-being kind of tacked onto their job role and I don't think it doesn't seem to me like many of them have the capability really in that space.
- 22:39Steve McCrone: Are you seeing that?
- 22:40Todd Conklin: same thing.
- 22:40Todd Conklin: Yeah Well, and it makes sense, right?
- 22:42Todd Conklin: Nobody said that was going to be a part of the game, right?
- 22:46Todd Conklin: So they're adapting that and the wellness part of it, I think, is becoming really an important part of it and we're understanding more.
- 22:52Todd Conklin: But it's early days.
- 22:53Todd Conklin: I would be really cognizant in our discussion and I'm wide open to having this discussion because I'm curious what you think I would really separate out.
- 23:02Todd Conklin: So, unfortunately, I think psychological safety is kind of unfortunately named.
- 23:07Todd Conklin: So Amy Edmondson's idea of psychological safety is not open doors, warm hug, healthy work environment.
- 23:16Todd Conklin: Her definition of psychological safety is how easy it is for you to disagree with power.
- 23:20Todd Conklin: How easy is it for you to give truth to power, which does absolutely impact mental health.
- 23:27Todd Conklin: I mean, there's a lot of crossover here.
- 23:30Todd Conklin: But I think one of the things we're learning is that, as we understand workers have knowledge that planners and leaders don't have because they do the work and they understand the agile nature, the adaptive nature of the work.
- 23:45Todd Conklin: And as we start to understand that as technology increases, the pathways to failure are increasing and it's creating an environment that's much, much more complex under climate sort of the many pieces, tightly coupled definition that it is having dramatic impact on mental health and we're seeing it in some industries greater than in other industries.
- 24:06Todd Conklin: I can't have this conversation with you after the Air India crash of the 8-7 and not think about the overlap between complexity, operational pressure, professional discipline, expertise and mental health.
- 24:24Todd Conklin: I mean just it's.
- 24:25Todd Conklin: It's difficult, even though I know very little about the event, it's very difficult to not think this could be a player in many catastrophic failures that exist, and we certainly know of some, at least plane crashes that have happened because mental health conditions being mental health conditions yeah, there's a lot to go in there.
- 24:51Steve McCrone: Um, I know we.
- 24:52Steve McCrone: We talk about, um, you know, managing in complexity, or, um, you know safety, adaptive safety.
- 25:00Steve McCrone: We talk about distributed decision making and distributed cognition.
- 25:04Steve McCrone: So one of them is about having the people close to the work making the decisions that affect the work Because, as you say, they see the emergence, they have a contextual understanding that cannot be gained from a more kind of linear, categorical approach to describing the work, and they also have a diverse range of opinion, a diverse range of thought that can be harnessed in order to see, you know, areas where they might have weak signals of risk or weak signals of opportunity to improve.
- 25:42Steve McCrone: In a standard bureaucratic organisation, that's very difficult to achieve and oftentimes you have this conflict between centralised control and distributed decision-making, which does have an effect on both mental wellbeing and physical safety.
- 25:56Steve McCrone: Absolutely One of the challenges, I think, is to try and convince leaders that they're better off letting go of some of that control.
- 26:09Todd Conklin: That's tough, right?
- 26:10Todd Conklin: Yeah, because then you could have people running with scissors and cats would be dating dogs and the world goes crazy.
- 26:19Steve McCrone: Yeah, we have the phrase, and I heard it the other day and I'll repeat it, and hopefully the person who said it is listening to this is it doesn't matter what we seem to do, people still do stupid stuff.
- 26:31Todd Conklin: Yeah, so how do you handle that?
- 26:32Todd Conklin: I'm always interested in that.
- 26:35Steve McCrone: Yeah, yeah, and we think about it in terms of what is the system that, or the journey that person has taken through the system, or what is their understanding of the system that provides the circumstances where it's okay or it's necessary to do that.
- 26:59Steve McCrone: So and I come from New Zealand If you want to hurt yourself at work, go be a farmer.
- 27:06Steve McCrone: Farmers will take partially or unmitigated risks all the time.
- 27:09Steve McCrone: We did a big sensemaker project talking to them about gathering narrative around that, and really what we try and do is say what is it about the system that creates the affordance or the opportunity for that person to act in that way?
- 27:21Steve McCrone: And then how do we change the system so that that affordance or the opportunity for that person to act in that way?
- 27:24Steve McCrone: And then how do we change the system so that that affordance or that opportunity changes?
- 27:26Steve McCrone: What we don't do is try and blame and change the person.
- 27:30Todd Conklin: Yeah, because it's not, I mean, it won't really happen.
- 27:33Todd Conklin: It's funny, because that idea you'd run out of farmers pretty quick, yeah, yeah.
- 27:37Todd Conklin: And then you run out of um cheese and dairy goods, which is what you guys in New Zealand do, baby.
- 27:42Todd Conklin: So one of the interesting things about that is that idea you can't fix stupid.
- 27:52Todd Conklin: That's a word we hear a lot, certainly in North America and I hear probably mostly in the energy sector.
- 27:55Todd Conklin: I mean people say that all the time so you think, okay, first of all, if you're hiring stupid, you suck at doing employment and someone else should make your decisions.
- 28:04Todd Conklin: But generally, when they say you can't fix stupid, what they're really saying is it's much easier to blame the operator than it is the system, because it's much easier to create some kind of corrective action to fix the operator terminate three days without pay.
- 28:21Todd Conklin: I mean, we've got lots of elaborate ways to do that.
- 28:23Todd Conklin: Then just to go back and say, wow, the way we do logistics or the way we bring material to the site is fundamentally complex and needlessly stupid and we're trying to control items that we don't need to control and we're trying to control it the wrong place.
- 28:42Todd Conklin: I see it all the time and it really goes to a deeper question which I'd be curious for you guys, because in the world you live in.
- 28:51Todd Conklin: Do workers have agency?
- 28:55Todd Conklin: And let me give you a background.
- 28:58Todd Conklin: Why I'm asking this is I spend an awful lot of my time with companies who start the discussion by saying this worker made a bad choice.
- 29:08Todd Conklin: Right, these workers made a series of bad choices.
- 29:11Todd Conklin: I hear a lot about bad choice and what I find when I look into it is it's not so much that the worker made a bad choice, is that the worker had a bad choice, yeah, and they're choosing from, uh, sort of a, a palette of all relatively crappy choices.
- 29:28Todd Conklin: They're choosing the least crappy choice amongst crappy choices.
- 29:32Todd Conklin: That makes sense to them at the time to move forward, often based on past experiences, and we could go into the context of this forever.
- 29:41Todd Conklin: Yeah, that idea, I think, is really pretty devastating, and that's part of that fundamental discussion we have to have, I think, because I think we have to tell them workplaces are not perfect.
- 29:56Todd Conklin: They're really quite poorly held together and systems, processes, practices, procedures are not where safety lives.
- 30:07Todd Conklin: Safety lives in the adaptive nature of doing the work, and so we actually count on these stupid people to actually create success in real time in all kinds of conditions, and they mostly do it.
- 30:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I come from the world of ass clowns and stupid people in fighter aviation, right?
- 30:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we the way we are taught and the way we run through simulations is that the NATOPS, the guidance that we have, the checklist that we have.
- 30:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're very, very important, but not as important as the gray matter between our ears.
- 30:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, we have to make solid decisions.
- 30:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You'll find yourself in a situation that nobody's ever been in ears.
- 30:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, we have to make solid decisions.
- 30:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You'll find yourself in a situation that nobody's ever been in before.
- 30:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, you don't have that experience, but you just know from the stories that are very important that people tell the lessons you learned and you have to make a decision that may go against what the overall objective is and go.
- 30:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I have to do this because of X or Y, and I think in naval aviation, I'm not going to, and I spent some time with the Air Force.
- 31:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Naval aviation gives you the opportunity to find novelty and be successful, because the way they trained us, the way that we've been trained I don't know if that's true today, but in the 90s and 2000, thousands and 2010s that's how things are or were.
- 31:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it is a you know, having that background in fighter aviation and coming into an organization go.
- 31:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The reason I'm here is because I come from the world of maximum performance right, flying air shows that type of thing.
- 31:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The reason I'm here is because I want to help others get back to that level.
- 31:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want you to enjoy that type of lifestyle, if you will, what it feels like to be max performing and high performing.
- 31:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's hard to do in organizations, right, it's very difficult to do because I don't think people have the agency that they need to make those decisions.
- 32:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I want to go back to this point you just made about they just have I guess they're afforded bad choices.
- 32:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so I'm going to make a choice between one bad or another bad, or one evil or one other evil, and that's what I'm given and I have to make a decision.
- 32:19Todd Conklin: And it happens all the time.
- 32:20Todd Conklin: Workers are constantly thinking I can follow the rules or I can do the work.
- 32:25Todd Conklin: But I can't do both, because in this case the rules won't allow me to do this work, but I have to do this work, and so and we measure the work.
- 32:33Todd Conklin: We don't really measure rule following.
- 32:35Todd Conklin: Rule following only becomes weaponized when they audit me and find I didn't follow the rule, and that's almost always based upon a negative outcome.
- 32:42Todd Conklin: If nothing fails and I didn't follow the rules, then let's call it creativity or agility, adaptive nature of work.
- 32:53Steve McCrone: At choices.
- 32:54Steve McCrone: Oftentimes, particularly when you're doing an investigation, you look at a choice independently of the system.
- 32:58Steve McCrone: So then the incident becomes an isolated frame by which you start to opine on what caused it, what could have happened, what are the system.
- 33:01Steve McCrone: So then the incident becomes an isolated frame by which you start to opine on what caused it, what could have happened, what are the alternatives, who followed the rules, who didn't?
- 33:09Steve McCrone: And that's where you know, critical path analysis, five whys et cetera kind of lead us into a very narrow view.
- 33:15Steve McCrone: Once that becomes the dominant narrative, then you know people are looking at those choices independent of the system that afforded them.
- 33:28Steve McCrone: And I think organisations, particularly when they see safety as an independent element, often get locked into a very sort of categorical and narrow view and we think about safety in terms of an emergent property of a very complex system.
- 33:44Steve McCrone: You have to understand the system and its inherent complexity and then you can start to understand how and why people make the choices they do.
- 33:53Steve McCrone: That takes a lot of time and effort.
- 33:56Steve McCrone: It's much easier to send someone in to do a five-wise investigation on a very narrow, very specific set of circumstances and then jump to a massive conclusion not helped, frankly, by behavioral psychology that makes big assumptions about people's mental state based on their observed behavior, when most of the time people are just trying to get through the day.
- 34:17Todd Conklin: Yeah.
- 34:18Steve McCrone: Yeah, it's true, some deep-rooted theory.
- 34:21Todd Conklin: Add, as a subtext to what you're saying, is that they mostly are looking at counterfactuals, so those choices become more of a discussion of what they didn't do and what they did, yeah.
- 34:31Todd Conklin: So then we say, had they followed the procedure here, this accident wouldn't have happened, ok.
- 34:36Todd Conklin: And then, because we so oversimplify events, that it really looks like the problem is the worker didn't follow the procedure, when in reality, when they do this work, there are always giant gaps where they didn't follow the procedure, because the gray matter between their ears really tells them that this is a better, faster, more efficient, safer, more reliable way to do the work and that's based upon that experience.
- 34:57Todd Conklin: All of these things are fundamentally true, but I had actually and I'm open to discussion on this because I'm not a smart person at all, but I would actually suggest to you that I think those are symptoms.
- 35:14Todd Conklin: I think the bigger problem it goes back to really the paradigm that the organization has for what safety is.
- 35:24Todd Conklin: And if they see safety you know, as you were speaking earlier quite eloquently and beautifully as sort of something that they will attain, not an emergent property of actual doing work, then of course they're going to really try to define things and take it to where they think the biggest change is going to happen.
- 35:44Todd Conklin: And I mean, don't underestimate how emotionally satisfying it is to blame the bad guy.
- 35:51Todd Conklin: I mean it just feels good to say you know this, this guy's an idiot.
- 35:56Todd Conklin: Yeah, I believe the phrase you use was ass clown, ass clown.
- 35:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, radio ass clowns.
- 36:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have a, you know so, in naval aviation we had human factors analysis classification system HVACs.
- 36:07Todd Conklin: I know it well.
- 36:08Todd Conklin: I know it well, yes.
- 36:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to get your thoughts on that.
- 36:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We were looking at it about four years ago to see if there's a way to evolve that away from.
- 36:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, blaming loss of situational awareness.
- 36:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know that, hey, that person lost SA.
- 36:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just want to get your thoughts on where HVAC sits in the hop world right now.
- 36:26Todd Conklin: It's probably too linear.
- 36:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay, that's what I'm thinking.
- 36:29Todd Conklin: So I mean, it just is, hvac was created to really do one thing and that was to unify the accounting process across major enterprise efforts like naval aviation.
- 36:41Todd Conklin: Yeah, I think HVAC was a really important developmental step.
- 36:45Todd Conklin: Yes, because it really helped us create a vocabulary.
- 36:48Todd Conklin: It helped us understand we're better because HVAC existed.
- 36:51Todd Conklin: Yes, the problem is that it's not the panacea, it's not the answer and it's awfully linear.
- 36:56Todd Conklin: It goes right back to what we were saying earlier.
- 36:59Todd Conklin: We look at choices in isolation and then we label them with pull down menus and it helps us trend things across the enterprise, even though I would suggest I don't really see a lot of value in that.
- 37:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But yeah, so let me ask you this the loss of situational awareness, is that the same as saying that's human error?
- 37:20Todd Conklin: No, so so I really this is going to make me not very popular.
- 37:24Todd Conklin: All right, um near.
- 37:26Todd Conklin: As I can tell, the only three people that can even use the term situational awareness are are you guys fighter pilots you know, high performance pilots scuba divers and astronauts.
- 37:39Todd Conklin: I'll go with that, because you really can get to a point where you don't know where up is or down is.
- 37:46Todd Conklin: I mean, right, that's a, that's a?
- 37:49Todd Conklin: I'm not certain I've ever worked a case or done an investigation or done an event learning where the worker lost situational awareness, that they just didn't have the awareness on the situation that they should have had their awareness on.
- 38:03Todd Conklin: So I just did a case where a guy walked through a hatch cover on a platform and he felt it was death, and so I had to go to the senior like the big bosses, right, the senior team because they were about to meet with the board of directors, and I said you know, the only way you can walk through an open hatch to your death is to believe the hatch is closed.
- 38:25Todd Conklin: Right, I promise you.
- 38:28Todd Conklin: I mean, if he'd had any inkling at all that the hatch was open, he would not have stepped in the open hole to his death.
- 38:34Todd Conklin: I can pretty much guarantee it.
- 38:36Todd Conklin: Right, that's not going to happen.
- 38:38Todd Conklin: Well, the the boss said the big boss.
- 38:41Todd Conklin: So well, that's, that's, that's not true.
- 38:43Todd Conklin: He was not paying attention.
- 38:45Todd Conklin: That was sort of senior management talk for loss of situational awareness, right?
- 38:49Todd Conklin: Well, I promise you, he was aware of something and he was so aware of what he was aware of that he didn't think to look.
- 38:57Todd Conklin: Well, lo and behold, when we went into the actual contextual learning, when we started talking about the context, he's carrying this other hatch cover.
- 39:11Todd Conklin: So the one thing he couldn't do was look down at his feet, right?
- 39:13Todd Conklin: I mean, that's the only way you can fall through that hatch is you have to believe there's not a hole, because if there's a hole, you're going to say, hey, I'll use this other hatch cover to cover this hole.
- 39:22Todd Conklin: Until I get across that idea, I think has become a really elegant and I think people think it sounds pretty impressive a really elegant way to sort of blame workers.
- 39:33Todd Conklin: Further, I'm not sure it helps us from an improvement standpoint.
- 39:38Todd Conklin: I mean and you'd be better to answer that than I am I don't know what to say other than I don't know how to fix that.
- 39:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's just an easy way to say that.
- 39:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: To me, it's the easy way to blame it on a person.
- 39:51Todd Conklin: Oh it is, and it sounds science-y.
- 39:54Todd Conklin: I mean, it sounds like a famous person typed it.
- 39:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and you don't have to look at the system it gives you a reason to not look at the system and go yeah, they did that.
- 40:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, their goggles were dirty or whatever.
- 40:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, yeah, yeah, Dust coming up and all that.
- 40:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the next question for you is surveys.
- 40:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have this problem in the Navy.
- 40:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have these Likert scale surveys and all that.
- 40:29Todd Conklin: So we look back at culture and we look back at what happened.
- 40:30Todd Conklin: What's going on in your organization.
- 40:31Todd Conklin: I just want to get your thoughts on where surveys fit in the hop world at the moment.
- 40:33Todd Conklin: So let me just.
- 40:34Todd Conklin: We probably share this, so we're going to probably make a little magic moment right now.
- 40:35Todd Conklin: From my standpoint, in my institution, we're so survey fatigued that they're absolutely horrific.
- 40:42Todd Conklin: They're a horrible intervention that leads to almost nothing, and we've trained people beautifully that it doesn't really matter, even if they say you have to fill it out, I'll fill it out, but nothing's going to happen.
- 40:57Todd Conklin: Surveys are so.
- 40:59Todd Conklin: One of my favorite scholars is Edgar Schein and he recently passed away, kind of the father of organizational culture.
- 41:05Todd Conklin: Super interesting man and got more interesting as he went into his 90s.
- 41:11Todd Conklin: I love a scholar in their 90s because a lot of the barriers go down and they just tell you what they think.
- 41:19Todd Conklin: And they just tell you what they think and he would tell you straight to your face, using lots of colorful language, that a survey is just a gigantic waste of time and that if you want to know how people are thinking, go out and talk to the people, have a conversation, put together focus groups, Do event learning, do learning teams, ask the people, but understand that when you ask them what's wrong, the commitment you've made is that you have to do something with that information and that's really difficult.
- 41:51Todd Conklin: So surveys are almost sterile.
- 41:53Todd Conklin: There's a level of abstraction between the person doing the survey and the people taking the survey.
- 41:58Todd Conklin: That level of abstraction goes away when you ask them, because now it's just you and them and so they become impersonal and I'm not sure the data has.
- 42:11Todd Conklin: I mean, you guys jump in, but I don't think it has any value at all.
- 42:16Todd Conklin: I mean what you see is you see a lot of especially with the Likert scale.
- 42:20Todd Conklin: You see a lot of 1-5 splits.
- 42:21Todd Conklin: So you get your data on your leadership and you've got half of them say you suck and half of them say you're great.
- 42:28Todd Conklin: And tell me what you're going to do with that.
- 42:33Steve McCrone: Yeah.
- 42:33Steve McCrone: So we want to see methods that hold those things in tension.
- 42:36Steve McCrone: You want to see where those natural tensions occur in the organization, occur in the organization, and surveys are a really good way to create a categorical view that makes people feel certain, feel in control, feel like they have knowledge that they didn't have before.
- 42:50Steve McCrone: The emotional response at a high level is really what drives, in my opinion, that feeling of certainty.
- 42:57Steve McCrone: That feeling of new knowledge is really what keeps surveys alive, because they get to determine, and yet everybody knows that it's a waste of time.
- 43:06Steve McCrone: Everybody knows that the result is skewed because people are either gaming or gifting the result, depending on their view, and everybody knows nothing's going to get done and yet the human desire for certainty kind of drives the continuation of that behaviour.
- 43:26Steve McCrone: There are better ways to do it, you know, in terms of getting a really granular understanding of people's.
- 43:33Steve McCrone: We call it the dispositional understanding of people rather than a categorical understanding.
- 43:38Steve McCrone: We want to see, we want to know how they feel in relation to the work and how that changes, changes over time or changes, um, due to, you know, changing circumstances.
- 43:48Steve McCrone: It's fluid.
- 43:49Steve McCrone: Surveys give you a snapshot.
- 44:48Steve McCrone: It's um, yeah, really is a waste of time.
- 44:52Todd Conklin: You kind of know that and they cost a lot of money.
- 44:54Steve McCrone: Oh yeah, it costs a lot of money and if you're in a big government agency.
- 44:58Todd Conklin: You just they just survey the crap out of you I mean, mean it's part of the fallacy, right?
- 45:04Steve McCrone: You value what you pay for.
- 45:05Steve McCrone: You don't pay for what you value.
- 45:06Steve McCrone: Yeah, exactly.
- 45:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to shift over to risk again.
- 45:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Oh, risk.
- 45:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we had risk matrices back in the day.
- 45:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: People love managing risk right and identifying all the potential things that go wrong and coming up with a contingency plan against those things.
- 45:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If possible, Get your thoughts on that in the world.
- 45:26Todd Conklin: Let me ask you a question.
- 45:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 45:28Todd Conklin: Why do you think?
- 45:28Todd Conklin: Why do you think we did risk risk matrix?
- 45:31Todd Conklin: Why do I have risk matrixes?
- 45:34Todd Conklin: I can never say it Risk there's a lot of continents.
- 45:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, there's a lot of continents.
- 45:38Todd Conklin: in that those two words.
- 45:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yes, there are.
- 45:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Why do I think?
- 45:44Todd Conklin: Don't overthink it, okay.
- 45:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You go ahead, then I want to.
- 45:48Todd Conklin: You want me to tell you the answer?
- 45:49Todd Conklin: Yeah, tell me the answer I'm going to.
- 45:50Todd Conklin: Risk matrices are developed entirely to do one thing and that's manage resource level.
- 45:56Todd Conklin: I would have failed.
- 45:59Todd Conklin: They have nothing to do at all with risk.
- 46:03Todd Conklin: What they have to do is where can I get money to manage a problem?
- 46:10Todd Conklin: Because if you're going to ask me to assess my own risk, you know, depending on how I feel and where we are, depending on past practice, depending on current stability, you know I can make it high or low.
- 46:22Todd Conklin: I can make any.
- 46:22Todd Conklin: I can just tell you I've done a lot of investigations and I've done a lot of fatal investigations, a lot of them and I will tell you that a lot of people die falling downstairs, right?
- 46:36Todd Conklin: Well, that's not going to be on the risk matrix because nobody's going to give you resources to do that.
- 46:41Todd Conklin: So you know we're going to make signs that say, use the handrail, but that's actually pretty high risk, right?
- 46:49Todd Conklin: So I've always been a big believer that that's kind of the wrong direction and in fact I would suggest and I'm super interested in what you guys think I actually think risk is not the problem.
- 47:04Todd Conklin: Risk is dynamic.
- 47:06Todd Conklin: It's difficult to assess over time.
- 47:11Todd Conklin: I can take a snapshot, but that snapshot will be inaccurate the next second and that I really believe risk is super normal and somewhat attractive to people, right?
- 47:24Todd Conklin: So risk is risk.
- 47:25Todd Conklin: I absolutely agree.
- 47:28Todd Conklin: Sorry, yeah, I actually think the risk part is a waste of time.
- 47:33Todd Conklin: Instead of doing a risk matrix, what I would go out and do is go out and ask where our control is low.
- 47:43Todd Conklin: So, instead of focusing on the risk, focus on the safeguards or the barriers or whatever word people use, depending on their industry.
- 47:54Todd Conklin: Because I couldn't agree more.
- 47:57Steve McCrone: I just gonna I just sorry, I'll go ahead and um, and then I'm gonna go and teach a class on adaptive strategy, so I'll be gone when I'm finished talking.
- 48:04Todd Conklin: We're going to talk about you, man.
- 48:06Todd Conklin: We're going to talk about you a bunch.
- 48:08Todd Conklin: I know you can go meet that guy Such an idiot.
- 48:12Steve McCrone: If only he knew.
- 48:13Steve McCrone: So here's the thing on risk.
- 48:15Steve McCrone: Certainly, I think I agree with everything you've said.
- 48:18Steve McCrone: Certainly, when I see a risk matrix, what I see is a categorical statement that is essentially laundering your assumptions into fact.
- 48:26Steve McCrone: And then people treat that matrix as if it's real.
- 48:29Steve McCrone: What we would do typically is go back and say how much do you really know about the likelihood or the potential consequence of this?
- 48:41Steve McCrone: And, to your exact point, is say forget about trying to guess those things, let's go back and say when that occurs, how do we stop it Killing people?
- 48:47Steve McCrone: I'm using your words here, todd Always say what controls can we put in place so that we can either mitigate or accept that event or that risk or that potential outcome?
- 48:59Todd Conklin: And the automotive industry taught us.
- 49:00Todd Conklin: I couldn't agree more.
- 49:01Todd Conklin: The automotive industry taught us that your car is designed around the notion that every time you drive, there's a 100% chance you're going to crash 100% you probably won't thank God, but 100%.
- 49:12Todd Conklin: And what they're looking at is what controls need to be in place to make that crash as elegant or, as David Wood would say, gracefully extensible, which is a great set of words.
- 49:21Todd Conklin: Thank you, my friend.
- 49:22Todd Conklin: It was a pleasure meeting you.
- 49:24Steve McCrone: Signing out Cheers Tom Carry on Brian.
- 49:26Steve McCrone: Thanks, mike.
- 49:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I appreciate that, steve.
- 49:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I want to continue with capacity and going back to risk.
- 49:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One of the things about planning or a plan is a lot of people look at a plan as something they need to follow.
- 49:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We look at planning as something that is continuous and we try to help them understand the components of a good planning approach or mental model or process that allows them to scan the environment, to make sense of the environment as they go through the day.
- 49:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I just want to get your view on am I using capacity in the correct term or way there when we're trying to build that capacity for that team or that organization to make sense of the external environment so they can?
- 50:06Todd Conklin: act.
- 50:06Todd Conklin: Yeah, I think so.
- 50:07Todd Conklin: Okay, I mean, unless you can think of a better word than capacity, and I'd love to have it, but capacity.
- 50:13Todd Conklin: We drifted to the word capacity because control is probably not right, and yet it is right.
- 50:18Todd Conklin: Barrier is not right, but it is right.
- 50:20Todd Conklin: You know all the things we do.
- 50:21Todd Conklin: We're creating capacity, we're creating margin, Margin.
- 50:25Todd Conklin: That's less elegant, but it's kind of the same idea.
- 50:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is margin the same as optionality?
- 50:29Todd Conklin: Yeah, optionality, you know what they call it in medicine Rescuability no, I didn't know that Right, I mean, which is sort of a quasi-generic term to sort of encompass all that stuff, because it's all kind of important and it's really context dependent.
- 50:46Todd Conklin: So it depends on what you do.
- 50:47Todd Conklin: The interesting thing about that capacity part of that is that planning is a huge part of that capacity.
- 50:53Todd Conklin: But planning really in and of itself, as a discrete activity, is not terribly valuable.
- 51:01Todd Conklin: In fact it's probably not helpful at all.
- 51:03Todd Conklin: But as you guys realized and really helped develop, you know, remarkable tools like the OODA loops and the things you guys work with, planning as a living practice is really a great thing and maybe we should not call it planning because planning's kind of already got ownership properties.
- 51:21Todd Conklin: What we're constantly doing is really detecting and correcting.
- 51:21Todd Conklin: Maybe we should not call it planning because planning is kind of already got ownership properties.
- 51:21Todd Conklin: Yeah, what we're constantly doing is really detecting and correcting, detecting and adjusting maybe even a better word.
- 51:29Todd Conklin: So you're understanding the risk in real time and it's constantly changing and you're adjusting your performance to match the risk that you've just identified and then you do it again, and that's a real-time process that people do.
- 51:46Todd Conklin: And again, the example I think about all the time is how do you know you're safe enough while you're driving?
- 51:51Todd Conklin: Well, the quick answer is it's really easy to tell if you're safe enough if you get there and you didn't wreck, you were safe enough.
- 51:59Todd Conklin: Or if you wrecked, you weren't safe enough.
- 52:00Todd Conklin: Or if you wrecked, you weren't safe enough.
- 52:01Todd Conklin: But while you're driving you don't really know.
- 52:05Todd Conklin: But that's okay, because driving is not one activity.
- 52:08Todd Conklin: Driving is thousands of micro tasks, right, and it must be what it's like to fly a plane.
- 52:15Todd Conklin: I mean, I don't fly a plane, but it seems like it must be Thousands of micro tasks, where you're constantly assessing conditions and adjusting controls constantly.
- 52:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not everybody does that, though, and they arrive to their location safely.
- 52:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: A lot of times, you see people doing stupid things where they're texting and driving.
- 52:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's something that you could identify and say, hey, that's probably not something you ought to be doing, but the outcome was you arrived to a place.
- 52:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The decisions you made to get there may not be very good, right, yeah, and so then you ask are you good or are you lucky, lucky Right?
- 52:51Todd Conklin: And which is a really good question to ask, because either way you answer that, it's pretty valuable.
- 52:54Todd Conklin: If you're good, then you reinforce what's good, and if you're lucky, then you've identified really a risk that you didn't have control for.
- 53:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So separating decisions from outcomes is important and I want to go to learning teams and learning here.
- 53:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, going back to fighter aviation plan brief, execute debrief for the team life cycle plan, execute, assess, assessment is critical, right.
- 53:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Learning is the most important aspect of a team life cycle the most important aspect of a team life cycle.
- 53:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So, when it comes to facilitating learning teams and how they do their work, is there anything you share with us on how you do it, or maybe we can have a conversation on that?
- 53:30Todd Conklin: So my first advice is don't overcomplicate them and don't overthink them.
- 53:35Todd Conklin: Okay, so the team's already learning in real time.
- 53:37Todd Conklin: What you want to do is swarm together a group of people and you want to ask them to do two things Identify the problem gap, suggest some solutions.
- 53:48Todd Conklin: Now, the reason I said gap between identify the problem and suggest a solution is because you want to make very discreet the problem identification phase from the solution generation phase, because the enemy of the question is always the answer.
- 54:05Todd Conklin: Interesting.
- 54:07Todd Conklin: All right, let me say that again.
- 54:08Todd Conklin: Yeah, that's great.
- 54:09Todd Conklin: It's kind of like what is the sound of one hand clapping, tell me, grasshopper?
- 54:13Todd Conklin: So the answer always stops the question.
- 54:18Todd Conklin: Right, because once you have the answer, you don't need the question.
- 54:23Todd Conklin: Stop asking the question, you don't need the question.
- 54:25Todd Conklin: So if you tell them this first meeting, first half or whatever, no solutions, none Don't even bring them up.
- 54:34Todd Conklin: We're not even going to write them down, we don't even care.
- 54:36Todd Conklin: Tell us what the problem is and dig into the problem as deeply as you can and then, once you identify that problem gap, then take that data and come back with a solution.
- 54:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I love where this is going.
- 54:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we do a lot of work in effective debriefing and so you got to pull things apart from multiple perspectives.
- 54:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Too often people come up with a solution to something rather than identifying what happened.
- 55:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we can run a simulation, a team simulation, that lasts 10 minutes and just ask them what happened in the last 10 minutes, and most people can't tell you what happened.
- 55:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You have to reconstruct it and you have to have data to help build that up.
- 55:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And going back to situational awareness, that's actually one way to build SA is understand what happens so we can understand what's happening now.
- 55:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what we found in the world of debriefing is in the algebra community.
- 55:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They do retrospectives debriefing, but they focus on future things.
- 55:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are we going to do better in the future?
- 55:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, how do you know you need to do that better in the future?
- 55:37Todd Conklin: You have to say that again.
- 55:38Todd Conklin: They call it retrospective debriefing and they focus on the future.
- 55:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I'm sorry it retrospective debriefing and they focus on the future.
- 55:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: No, I'm sorry they call them retrospectives, but a lot of the processes they use are just forward looking Like.
- 55:49Todd Conklin: Just tell me what you're going to do better, why the hell do they call it retrospective?
- 55:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's in the name, isn't it Kind of funny?
- 55:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah Well, it's kind of a little counterintuitive there Right.
- 55:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the hard part and this is, I think this connects back to psych safety and allowing information to flow.
- 56:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to get your thoughts on this.
- 56:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I guess having a leader on a team that may be running a learning team or an effective debrief provides an opportunity for that leader to show fallibility, to stand up and say I did something wrong right.
- 56:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Plus, it affords an opportunity to ask powerful questions.
- 56:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All these things connect back to psych safety.
- 56:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are you creating the right conditions for your people to speak up right?
- 56:34Todd Conklin: I think a lot of it's more than speak up to disagree with you.
- 56:36Todd Conklin: Yeah, yeah, yeah To tell you.
- 56:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're wrong, yeah, so to have that tension, that healthy tension, to have that cognitive diversity that everybody wants, you need to have that touch point, if you will, and we find that debriefing is a great place to do that.
- 56:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what we learned in fighter aviation.
- 56:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If you go back to Amy Edmondson's work and where she learned about psych safety from healthcare organizations or surgical teams, they were being trained by aviators, right.
- 57:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a nice connection here.
- 57:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's pretty cool how all this all kind of connects to HR.
- 57:05Steve McCrone: I like it.
- 57:05Steve McCrone: I think it's fun.
- 57:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, but I'd say the majority of folks we work with don't understand that there are these things, things like team science and effective debriefing approaches, effective planning approaches.
- 57:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you actually leverage the diversity of a group through things like a premortem or a red teaming technique, that type of thing?
- 57:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So these things are out there.
- 57:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But getting back to learning teams and building psych safety, what is it in your workshops or what do you recommend people do to help learn from the past and, at the same time, improve future performance?
- 57:40Todd Conklin: Well.
- 57:40Todd Conklin: So whether the leader is in the room or not is pretty context dependent, and if it creates a chilling effect so people won't talk, then you don't want the leader in the room.
- 57:51Todd Conklin: That's pretty obvious.
- 57:52Todd Conklin: The ability to model that, I think, is pretty powerful, but that's probably not the best place.
- 57:57Todd Conklin: The learning team exists to really perform one function and that's to understand the problem.
- 58:02Todd Conklin: So when you have a, an especially curious problem like this is why aren't they doing this?
- 58:08Todd Conklin: This is, this is, it's our most important safety rule, and no one's following it.
- 58:12Todd Conklin: How come, why aren't they getting the ladder right?
- 58:15Todd Conklin: Then you really swarm together a group of people that do that work.
- 58:18Todd Conklin: You put them in a room and you say formulate, tell me what, what we need to learn, because we don't know.
- 58:23Todd Conklin: Clearly we're answering the wrong question.
- 58:25Todd Conklin: Tell us what, and they're going to tell you well, you know, that's great.
- 58:28Todd Conklin: We probably need some engineering people in here, we need some maintenance people in here.
- 58:31Todd Conklin: That's fine.
- 58:32Todd Conklin: Just bring them in and just allow leadership to sort of develop.
- 58:37Todd Conklin: You could have a facilitator, maybe, to take notes, but just allow the conversation to happen.
- 58:42Todd Conklin: And what's interesting is that the conversation between the group is probably as interesting as anything that's going to happen, and they're going to develop, and in a very adaptive way.
- 58:52Todd Conklin: This emergent understanding of the problem will be co-created by this team of people.
- 58:58Todd Conklin: That's what a learning team does.
- 59:00Todd Conklin: The reason it's advantageous is not because it has strong cultural influences although it does or that it allows leadership the opportunity to respond humbly and to be a part of the problem identification.
- 59:14Todd Conklin: It does that as well.
- 59:14Todd Conklin: What it really does is, in a very fast and accurate way, gets you a lot of information that you probably didn't even know you needed.
- 59:26Todd Conklin: So I've done a million learning teams, a million.
- 59:29Todd Conklin: We started them years ago in Los Alamos and they're not a necessarily novel idea.
- 59:34Todd Conklin: I mean, they've existed a long time.
- 59:36Todd Conklin: We just started doing them for safety curiosities, for really reliability and resilience, curiosities around high-risk work, and what was amazing is these teams would get together and have this deep discussion about what the problem was, almost without fail.
- 59:52Todd Conklin: The problem they brought out of the room was completely different than what we imagined it would be.
- 59:58Todd Conklin: Yes, I mean without fail.
- 1:00:00Todd Conklin: I mean it was amazing and it was always a much better, much more mature, much more enlightened and expert-based understanding of what the problem was.
- 1:00:09Todd Conklin: The cool thing about.
- 1:00:11Todd Conklin: That is, once you identify the problem, the corrective action writes itself.
- 1:00:14Todd Conklin: It's super easy to write the corrective action and it's super easy to prioritize the corrective action.
- 1:00:19Todd Conklin: And what it does is it saves you a ton, a ton of time, a ton of time.
- 1:00:22Todd Conklin: And what it does is it saves you a ton, a ton of time, a ton of time.
- 1:00:24Todd Conklin: It also, I think, creates an opportunity for workers to tell the truth and they can really speak truth to power because they've got the protection of the other team members.
- 1:00:34Todd Conklin: I don't think it fixes the cultural problems of an organization, but that's not its intent.
- 1:00:42Todd Conklin: Its intent is to really help understand why aren't people using the right ladder, or why are they not stopping at this stop sign or why are they not doing lock and tag on this?
- 1:00:49Todd Conklin: You know it's a pretty dangerous job and nobody's doing lock and tag.
- 1:00:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you want all teams to be learning teams.
- 1:00:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, I think all teams are learning.
- 1:00:57Todd Conklin: Teams exist to perform a function, right, and if they're not learning, they're not a team.
- 1:01:03Todd Conklin: Yeah, yeah, they're not a team.
- 1:01:04Todd Conklin: Yeah yeah, they're not a team and they're not going to behave like a team.
- 1:01:06Todd Conklin: Yeah, I mean if they're not.
- 1:01:07Todd Conklin: And so the difference is that think of learning team like a tool, like a data collection.
- 1:01:13Todd Conklin: There you go, there you go, and then what I think they're really good at is helping you prioritize.
- 1:01:18Todd Conklin: So if you use a learning team and they come up with three solutions, the next question I would ask that learning team is tell me which one we should do first, which one we should do second, which one should do third?
- 1:01:27Todd Conklin: Yeah, and let them own that prioritization, which is really really powerful.
- 1:01:32Todd Conklin: And, speaking secretly, no one listening as a leader, it's a million times easier.
- 1:01:38Todd Conklin: A million times easier and way faster way faster Switching over to VUCA.
- 1:01:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: you use VUCA quite a bit, or you have.
- 1:01:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do.
- 1:01:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm a big fan of VUCA.
- 1:01:47Todd Conklin: But you know I worked a lot with those, with both Team Green and Team Blue, a lot.
- 1:01:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So OK, so we get volatility, uncertainty, complexity and ambiguity.
- 1:01:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Some people actually say that there's a tuna framework, there's a, there's a taco framework and you know, there's all.
- 1:02:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It doesn't matter.
- 1:02:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You're just describing the external environment, am I correct?
- 1:02:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right, yeah?
- 1:02:06Todd Conklin: What I was grasping for and the reason I pulled VUCA out of my brain head I mean my memory.
- 1:02:11Todd Conklin: I didn't invent it by any stretch of imagination, but I remember working with these you know highly effective teams that were just really good.
- 1:02:18Todd Conklin: They had very little leadership.
- 1:02:20Todd Conklin: Leadership and they would talk a lot about the VUCA framework is because uncertainty went so high during the pandemic that we really needed an opportunity to talk about.
- 1:02:29Todd Conklin: Vuca does a lot of things really well, but one thing it does is, it said, you have to increase the diversity of your data set, not decrease the diversity.
- 1:02:43Todd Conklin: So I was working a lot with, like, boards of directors and senior leadership teams for these really big companies and we were doing all these Zoom meetings because I started teaching this class called Bouncing Forward, because I don't know, I was bored and it really caught on.
- 1:02:58Todd Conklin: Tons of people I mean big companies would call and say can you do this for our senior leadership team, and it was a really great opportunity using VUCA to tell them that.
- 1:03:09Todd Conklin: I know it feels like, as things become more and more uncertain, you want to circle the wagons, shut the doors and talk to your trusted advisors.
- 1:03:17Todd Conklin: That's exactly the wrong thing to do.
- 1:03:19Todd Conklin: You couldn't make a worse decision.
- 1:03:22Todd Conklin: You want to open the doors, open the access and you want to talk to levels of the organization that you normally would never talk to, because the more diverse the opinion is, the better you are, as a decision maker, in understanding the options you have before you on how the organization is going to move forward in an uncertain world.
- 1:03:40Todd Conklin: I mean, it's a really interesting part of that and that's what I wanted VUCA to do, and it really allows that conversation.
- 1:03:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, I think we use it the same way, so we use it to explain the external environment, and the name of this podcast is called no Way Out, right, I?
- 1:03:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: know, I saw that it's kind of cool.
- 1:03:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me give you some background on this.
- 1:03:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the background on that is from John Boyd in his conceptual spiral brief, which was originally titled no Way Out, and in the brief he has a section in there where he identifies features of the world.
- 1:04:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's several of them quantum uncertainty, numerical imprecision, ambiguity, so forth, like 10 or 12 of them, basically VUCA.
- 1:04:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he says there's no way out of this.
- 1:04:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's no way out of these things, you know, unless we go through a world of reorientation.
- 1:04:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's his OODA loop.
- 1:04:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in order to do that, we need multiple perspectives, a diverse perspective, and it's everything you just said.
- 1:04:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's that's where we got the name of the podcast.
- 1:04:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Was from that brief, about understanding that external environment.
- 1:04:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's a lot of fun, so, uh, unpacking that.
- 1:04:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know things like affordances and you get into the adjacent possible, the acceleration of technology, and I will shift this over to artificial intelligence right now.
- 1:04:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But all these things are happening at the moment and I want to get your thoughts on the pros and cons, if you will, of artificial intelligence, on improving human and organizational performance or making it more challenging.
- 1:05:07Todd Conklin: It's really interesting you'd ask that question.
- 1:05:09Todd Conklin: I just for my podcast.
- 1:05:12Todd Conklin: I just interviewed this person I found who told me that he was not very good at this and he had no expertise.
- 1:05:20Todd Conklin: But in fact, he's probably one of the leading strategic thinkers in AI and it's really hard to talk to AI people that don't want to sell you something.
- 1:05:29Todd Conklin: At least at our level there's a lot of people that say they have expertise in AI and if you buy this product, you're going to be great.
- 1:05:36Todd Conklin: This guy had nothing to sell.
- 1:05:38Todd Conklin: I mean he was such a professor.
- 1:05:40Todd Conklin: I mean I'm kind of surprised he was dressed.
- 1:05:42Todd Conklin: I mean it was crazy, right yeah, but he was amazing.
- 1:05:45Todd Conklin: I mean it's the podcast and you do these a lot, so it was so much better than I thought it was going to be and I didn't think it was going to be bad, but it's really good.
- 1:05:57Todd Conklin: And what he helped me work through because we just had this conversation yesterday is a couple things.
- 1:06:05Todd Conklin: One is what scares me about AI is that it's slowly I'll take that back it looks like it's kind of rapidly drifting towards an elaborate surveillance system.
- 1:06:18Todd Conklin: We're going to use this to monitor worker behavior.
- 1:06:22Todd Conklin: We're going to use this to monitor pilot behavior.
- 1:06:24Todd Conklin: If you don't think that's going to come out of that Air India crash, I'll buy you a hamburger.
- 1:06:28Todd Conklin: I mean, they're going to think of elaborate ways.
- 1:06:31Todd Conklin: One of my favorite Navy stories, if we ever have time, was when that submarine hit that undersea mountain and their solution was to buy the best high-definition cameras they could buy and put them on the navigator's desk in every submarine.
- 1:06:45Todd Conklin: And I told the guy wow, that is amazing, because the next time you hit an undersea mountain with a fast attack submarine, you're going to have the highest quality video of the guy hitting it.
- 1:06:56Todd Conklin: I mean, if it becomes a surveillance tool, it's going to suck.
- 1:07:01Todd Conklin: We don't need new ways to surveil workers.
- 1:07:05Todd Conklin: I mean we just don't.
- 1:07:06Todd Conklin: And I'm not sure that has any value at all.
- 1:07:08Todd Conklin: What this guy taught me yesterday was that, in fact, as AI increases and it's gobbling up pretty much all the data in the world, so it is pretty much consumed pretty much the entire web as it increases, the necessity for humans to be a part of that process is going to be much more important, not less important.
- 1:07:39Todd Conklin: It's going to replace jobs, no question Some jobs are going to go away.
- 1:07:43Todd Conklin: Replace jobs no question.
- 1:07:48Todd Conklin: Right, some jobs are going to go away.
- 1:07:49Todd Conklin: But if you provide that adaptive nature in a complex environment that creates success, like a nurse or or a pilot, it it probably will never replace that fully, because if you provide that sort of creative value, that's something that at this point ai can't do yet right now.
- 1:08:10Todd Conklin: When it starts to write its own questions, then we have to revisit ai.
- 1:08:15Todd Conklin: I left the podcast mostly encouraged.
- 1:08:19Todd Conklin: Now I don't know if other people are going to do this, but it was very interesting to me to realize that that human part of the human and organizational performance is still really what holds the system kind of together Right.
- 1:08:35Todd Conklin: Good workers working in often bad systems create successful outcomes.
- 1:08:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that's just how it works.
- 1:08:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So here's something for you Create successful outcomes.
- 1:08:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's just how it works.
- 1:08:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So here's something for you the loss of capability to like automation bias, to like Waze or Google Maps or something like that.
- 1:08:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, or even just the ability you know, you and I were able to retain several phone numbers many, many, many years ago.
- 1:08:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I got none now, I barely know mine right.
- 1:09:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So these capabilities may be lost, right, right, they probably are lost.
- 1:09:08Todd Conklin: True.
- 1:09:08Todd Conklin: How's your buggy whip doing my?
- 1:09:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: what.
- 1:09:14Todd Conklin: Your buggy whip.
- 1:09:14Todd Conklin: Don't even remember what that is you don't have a buggy whip.
- 1:09:18Todd Conklin: No, because there was a time that technology was really important when we rode in buggies.
- 1:09:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But we rode in buggies.
- 1:09:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it's not important now.
- 1:09:27Todd Conklin: Yeah, and I think, 100 years from now, that's what they're going to say about.
- 1:09:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Memorizing a phone number.
- 1:09:32Todd Conklin: Yeah.
- 1:09:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Or following them up.
- 1:09:34Todd Conklin: Why would you?
- 1:09:35Todd Conklin: And it hurts my heart because we're old, right?
- 1:09:39Todd Conklin: I mean, it drives me bananas that a friend's kid came to my house because his folks live pretty far away and he had to pay taxes for the first time.
- 1:09:49Todd Conklin: He freaked out.
- 1:09:50Todd Conklin: He's talking about adulting.
- 1:09:51Todd Conklin: It was kind of cute because I was like dude, this is just the beginning and I don't want to freak out, but he had to pay almost $300 to you.
- 1:10:00Todd Conklin: So I mean I was like right.
- 1:10:01Todd Conklin: So I mean I was like right.
- 1:10:02Todd Conklin: He did not know from the jump how to write a check.
- 1:10:10Todd Conklin: Oh yeah, no concept at all.
- 1:10:14Todd Conklin: He didn't know how to address an envelope.
- 1:10:16Todd Conklin: He's a super smart kid.
- 1:10:17Todd Conklin: They don't do that Right.
- 1:10:22Todd Conklin: I think the question I would ask in response to your question is is our bias getting in the way of this discussion?
- 1:10:30Todd Conklin: Maybe Because we're going to lose expertise, there's no question?
- 1:10:34Todd Conklin: Or maybe lose is the wrong word.
- 1:10:36Todd Conklin: Expertise is going to move and in some places, like I would suggest, phone number memorization is probably better suited with machine reliability.
- 1:10:48Todd Conklin: Now, if you drop your phone in the toilet, you're screwed and that's a problem, yeah, but less so now that everything's kind of on the cloud.
- 1:10:56Todd Conklin: I mean it's very interesting to see where progress takes us, but it's also kind of scary because it means we're going to have to let go of some paradigms that we thought were pretty important and kind of normal.
- 1:11:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But this pace of change, can we handle it as humans?
- 1:11:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do we have a choice?
- 1:11:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't think so.
- 1:11:15Todd Conklin: How do you feel about driverless cars?
- 1:11:16Todd Conklin: Would you get into a Waymo?
- 1:11:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Five years ago, no way.
- 1:11:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Today probably yeah.
- 1:11:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But this brings up another interesting thing.
- 1:11:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when a Tesla or a Waymo hits somebody, you've got to blame somebody, right?
- 1:11:29Todd Conklin: Yeah, yeah, how does that work?
- 1:11:31Todd Conklin: Who do you blame?
- 1:11:32Todd Conklin: Well, so I helped with an event involving a driverless car and it was very interesting because in this case the two cars were coming down the road, going the same direction in a four lane urban road, so two lanes one way, two lanes the other way.
- 1:11:53Todd Conklin: The outside car was the driverless vehicle.
- 1:11:56Todd Conklin: The inside car, near the curb, was being driven by a person.
- 1:12:00Todd Conklin: The inside car hits a pedestrian, so the person driving the car hits a pedestrian, tosses her up and she falls from the top down in front of the vehicle.
- 1:12:13Todd Conklin: Okay, okay, so it's a pretty icky wreck.
- 1:12:16Todd Conklin: I mean, right, the vehicle at the time, because on their failure modes and effect analysis no one thought that the pedestrian would come from above.
- 1:12:27Todd Conklin: Right, because that seems kind of weird.
- 1:12:30Todd Conklin: But you said this earlier things that never happen happen all the time.
- 1:12:32Todd Conklin: I mean, that's the secret to what you found so interesting in the Navy is that things that never happen happen all the time.
- 1:12:38Todd Conklin: These novel ideas.
- 1:12:40Todd Conklin: That car failed and it was a pretty big event.
- 1:12:45Todd Conklin: Determining where Blaine lived was really really, really difficult and my guess is I didn't really bother myself with that because I don't know anything, but my guess it went to whoever had the biggest pockets.
- 1:13:01Todd Conklin: Okay, right, I'm pretty sure.
- 1:13:04Todd Conklin: Like I wouldn't sue the person that hit the person, I'd sue the company that had the giant.
- 1:13:08Todd Conklin: There you go, right.
- 1:13:09Todd Conklin: Yeah, the challenge is that the learning out of that was really rich and the technology is so fresh and new that they were very willing to learn from it and were very unwilling to blame it Right, and part of it is it was such a weird accident because it came from above that they were just like it was hard to pin that on somebody.
- 1:13:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I mean, I guess, other than the driver that hit the you know, the same things happen in commercial airlines with the removal, you know, maybe having one person in the cockpit.
- 1:13:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now Again, going back four or five years, everybody in my community around here would have said, no freaking way are we going to take humans out of the cockpit, but at least have two in there.
- 1:13:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now people are leaning towards maybe there'll be one, maybe there'll be one or two operating multiple aircraft with AI.
- 1:14:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So these things are all possible.
- 1:14:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: This goes back to your point that it's definitely possible for sure.
- 1:14:10Todd Conklin: Yeah, my guess is this would be a whole other podcast.
- 1:14:12Todd Conklin: So aviation got so safe, which is so naturally occurring.
- 1:14:17Todd Conklin: Phenomena of being really stable is that you become complacent.
- 1:14:21Todd Conklin: So complacency is always a function of stable system.
- 1:14:24Todd Conklin: Complacency is not a failure of the person, it's a failure of us.
- 1:14:27Todd Conklin: If the system is stable enough, you can become complacent, and every improvement initiative we put in to safety which creates higher resilience and reliability, will be eaten up by production.
- 1:14:51Todd Conklin: So when we make it safer to fly a plane, then they're going to fly more planes safer, and so a capacity we create will always be taken away by greed or production or whatever.
- 1:15:04Todd Conklin: Whatever you want to call it.
- 1:15:05Todd Conklin: The idea that high-risk operations can function with one pilot is fine.
- 1:15:13Todd Conklin: The sociology around it is probably a bigger sale.
- 1:15:17Todd Conklin: I think it's going to be hard to sell that, and part of it is going to be right back to the wellness and mental health stuff.
- 1:15:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, hey, Todd, I appreciate your time today.
- 1:15:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks, brother, this has been fun.
- 1:15:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if there's any questions you have about what we do here on the podcast, anything about the OODA Loop, just you know it's your time to shoot away and ask no, I'm good, I'm totally good man.
- 1:15:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You like the OODA Loop?
- 1:15:38Todd Conklin: I'm just super familiar with it just from work.
- 1:15:41Todd Conklin: Yeah, I mean we've talked about it a lot.
- 1:15:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we've made a lot of connections here to things like neuroscience, free energy principle, of course, physics, and I think you found something fascinating in physics over the last few months.
- 1:15:55Todd Conklin: Yeah, complexity, yeah, yeah, yeah, have you looked into that complex physics stuff?
- 1:16:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, we look at complex adaptive systems all the time.
- 1:16:03Todd Conklin: Look at.
- 1:16:03Todd Conklin: It's called complexity physics.
- 1:16:05Todd Conklin: It's worth.
- 1:16:07Todd Conklin: It's worth looking at yeah, anybody to look at specifically, anybody, oh I'm trying to think I got it from carissa sanbamatsu, but I don't think that she's doing it.
- 1:16:22Todd Conklin: I think she just turned she's into it.
- 1:16:23Todd Conklin: I don't think I she's doing it, I think she just turned she's into it.
- 1:16:25Todd Conklin: I don't think I mean.
- 1:16:27Todd Conklin: Once you look at it you'll be like, wow, the physics community is kind of they must be listening to your podcast.
- 1:16:32Todd Conklin: Oh, everything's converging right now.
- 1:16:34Todd Conklin: It's amazing.
- 1:16:34Todd Conklin: Yeah, because the complexity physics talks about the conditions in a system.
- 1:16:39Todd Conklin: Yeah, and how.
- 1:16:40Todd Conklin: If you can understand the conditions, you can predict the outcomes better in a complex process, it's very.
- 1:16:47Todd Conklin: It's kind of cool.
- 1:16:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What do you got going on here?
- 1:16:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: In the near term, anything fun, exciting.
- 1:16:52Todd Conklin: Just the same cool stuff?
- 1:16:53Todd Conklin: Yeah, I'm trying to think if I have anything.
- 1:16:55Todd Conklin: No Any events that you want to share with our listeners, or anything like that, oh we're having a conference in Santa Fe on September 9th, 10th and 11th Nice, yeah, it's got a good.
- 1:17:08Todd Conklin: The crowd of characters is great.
- 1:17:09Todd Conklin: There's seven or eight people doing it.
- 1:17:13Todd Conklin: It's just kind of a deep dive into definitely learning, operational learning, and a pretty big dive in accountability.
- 1:17:22Todd Conklin: Yeah, Because that's always a big issue.
- 1:17:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's a question for you what does accountability mean to you?
- 1:17:27Todd Conklin: uh, so, think, think of accountability as an act of clarity, okay, and when you frame it that way, accountability makes a ton of sense.
- 1:17:35Todd Conklin: So accountability, like we used to call it in in the laboratory r square a square, did you have that?
- 1:17:44Todd Conklin: maybe responsibility, accountability authority, yeah, and you, anytime you were on a big project, you you'd write on the whiteboard r squared, a squared.
- 1:17:51Todd Conklin: And yeah, well, that's a clarification exercise, because accountability is the discussion you have before something bad happens.
- 1:17:59Todd Conklin: Yeah, not a conversation you have after something bad happens.
- 1:18:03Todd Conklin: And so when you think of accountability as providing clarity, then accountability makes a ton of sense.
- 1:18:09Todd Conklin: The problem is is that generally speaking, this is kind of a big paintbrush, but generally speaking, we've sort of convoluted accountability and discipline and they're not the same thing.
- 1:18:21Todd Conklin: Discipline is a response.
- 1:18:22Todd Conklin: Discipline is relatively important.
- 1:18:24Todd Conklin: I mean, I wouldn't take discipline, discipline is a response.
- 1:18:26Todd Conklin: Discipline is relatively important.
- 1:18:27Todd Conklin: I mean I wouldn't take discipline away, but discipline is not accountability.
- 1:18:30Todd Conklin: Accountability is really an act of clarity R squared, a squared.
- 1:18:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let me try this on you.
- 1:18:39Todd Conklin: I've heard this definition, and that is the ability to recount what happened, you know, looking back.
- 1:18:42Todd Conklin: Well, that's, I mean, if you want to do like an exegetic definition, I mean that's the definition of the Latin root, the notion of account.
- 1:18:49Todd Conklin: A bank account is a recollection of what's in your account, or a production of what's in your account, and I guess it does provide clarity, yeah, but I think that's that's not what you're.
- 1:19:00Todd Conklin: I think it's an incredibly desperate attempt to define accountability.
- 1:19:05Todd Conklin: Okay, that's somebody who's getting banged up pretty hard by leaders saying I got to hold people accountable and you can't even tell me what accountability means.
- 1:19:13Todd Conklin: Well, it's an account of what happened.
- 1:19:15Todd Conklin: Well, no, no, that's actually not.
- 1:19:17Todd Conklin: I mean, that's not an account.
- 1:19:20Todd Conklin: I mean that's not accountability.
- 1:19:22Todd Conklin: Accountability happens before.
- 1:19:23Todd Conklin: Think of every good project you've been on.
- 1:19:24Todd Conklin: You knew who.
- 1:19:24Todd Conklin: That's not accountability.
- 1:19:24Todd Conklin: Accountability happens before.
- 1:19:25Todd Conklin: Think of every good project you've been on.
- 1:19:26Todd Conklin: You knew who was responsible for what.
- 1:19:28Todd Conklin: Oh, yeah, and you counted on them doing it.
- 1:19:31Todd Conklin: Yeah, and because it's a good team, they did it.
- 1:19:34Todd Conklin: Yeah, roles, responsibility, accountability, authority those have to be clarified before you can move much further, especially in high risk work.
- 1:19:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I think that's a great place to wrap it up.
- 1:19:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I want to appreciate your time, uh, and thanks for being here with us on no way out.
- 1:19:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, again, uh, human and organizational performance.
- 1:19:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Todd Conklin, uh appreciate your time today.
- 1:19:55Todd Conklin: Thanks, man, it was fun.
- 1:19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It was a lot of fun.
- 1:19:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Appreciate it.
- 1:19:57Todd Conklin: See you later, alligator Cheers.