Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Future Cleantech Festival 2026
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market. I'm Aberdeen Features lead Ryan
- 0:13Duff, and joining me this week is a whole panel of people that
- 0:16you'll be introduced through in just a second because I've been
- 0:18off in Bremshade, Germany for the Future Cleantech Architects
- 0:23Future Cleantech Festival, and we launched their latest report
- 0:28on base load power. It was very interesting.
- 0:30So I'm not going to keep you any longer.
- 0:33I'll join you after the panel's done.
- 0:35Fine, I would introduce everyone.
- 0:37So. We're obviously familiar with
- 0:39Maria and Antoine, but we also know about Karen from the.
- 0:43Arena. And we have Phil from Queen Air
- 0:46Cast Force as well. So thank you very much for
- 0:49joining us. Now, we spoke about this power
- 0:51session before before we started and I said I'm not the world's
- 0:56biggest fan. The panel in which the the
- 0:58moderator just does a column response the entire time.
- 1:02So we already have this. As much of a conversation.
- 1:04As we can, everyone's going to be jumping in throughout the
- 1:07conversation and if you've got questions, raise your hand and
- 1:10we'll get to you as quickly as we can as well.
- 1:13So I think to start with, despite saying we're not going
- 1:16to do a call in response, I'm going to start with you, Karen,
- 1:18I'm going to ask you a question. What was your key take away from
- 1:23those two presentations? So for me.
- 1:25I think the report really talks. About reaching to a 100% clean
- 1:30grid and there are two 2 but to that Apple I think the first
- 1:36reaching the 1st 90% it's there is either the certainty you
- 1:40build solar you build wind, you will transmission you build
- 1:42storage right now and nobody was building these things right now
- 1:48in two or three years will say I should not have built that and
- 1:52the cost of these these technologies is is low.
- 1:56That being said, we also need to look on the divine side a little
- 1:59bit. We we need to see how we can
- 2:01charge irrespectively. We went to start book today.
- 2:04You saw that a little bit, need that a lot more.
- 2:08We also need to have a little bit more creativity, little bit
- 2:12more sociologist working on selling demand setting.
- 2:15Solutions, but once we have built.
- 2:18All of these things to the maximum, we're still left with
- 2:22the last. 10% and this is. What the report goes into and
- 2:29the situation we had right now is that we don't have that much
- 2:32information on some of these technologies.
- 2:35So what this report does lonely well is that it highlights some
- 2:37of the trade-offs between between these things.
- 2:40And for example, I really like the use of operational hours and
- 2:45how that affects the competitive best sort of technology.
- 2:47So the strategies, the the trade-offs with some of these
- 2:50strategies is very important to highlight and forbid as the the
- 2:55key data today. Yeah, Phil, same question to
- 2:58yourself. What's your key takeaways from
- 3:00those presentations? I mean, I have to say what an
- 3:02amazing report it was and really good information, Project
- 3:06Temper, It was really enlightening to see how the
- 3:11public think about the challenges with that, the energy
- 3:16system and the decarbonisation and how climate change has now
- 3:20moved slightly down the agenda. And you highlighted the point
- 3:24going to energy security, which is increasingly of the agenda.
- 3:31And I think I think for Europe, we need to move away from being
- 3:36reliant on imports and that includes fossil fuels.
- 3:39And so this report highlights one of the key ways that we can
- 3:44become self-sufficient as a as a region.
- 3:49And, and all I'll say is that the the technologies, the
- 3:53geothermal and the and the nuclear, they need the support
- 3:58to develop. So these technologies aren't
- 4:00available today. They need the support to really
- 4:03bring them up. Geothermal for example, needs
- 4:06lots to bring down the cost of geothermal.
- 4:09We not need lots of drilling rigs across Europe. the US
- 4:15because of the Shell revolution has lots of drilling rigs though
- 4:19those aren't available in Europe.
- 4:20We need to that investment to bring in those drilling rigs to
- 4:24really bring down the cost of these technologies.
- 4:26You know, other than the, the fact that Antoine, when I heard
- 4:29you presenting, I realized possibly in the most
- 4:31embarrassing place that I've been pronouncing Dankin flight
- 4:33wrong for years. I, I, I really found, I really
- 4:38found the takeaways interesting. But in the in the report itself,
- 4:40we spoke about is, but it speaks specifically around policy
- 4:44drivers, which obviously will lead into Maria as well.
- 4:47But we spoke about the idea of using, yeah, using nuclear and
- 4:53geothermal and hydroelectric and a different way to maybe it's
- 4:56traditionally thought of. Now when you're telling a
- 4:59nuclear developer that's used to emitting same sort of base load
- 5:02power as it's traditionally thought of, how do you then tell
- 5:06tell the developer, well, you came in need to fluctuate to
- 5:09meet certain changes in demand? No, indeed, that's sort of a
- 5:15tough sell, certainly at face value for for a developer and
- 5:19and for sort of conventional plants.
- 5:21I would say in some countries it's already sort of being done
- 5:24like France, because the nuclear fleet is already so large.
- 5:28Some of the balancing is done with with hydro historically.
- 5:32But also they do flex their plants, but the problem is they
- 5:37flex downwards. There's only sort of One
- 5:39Direction and it's it's not great for the economic viability
- 5:43of the plants, not so much the on the technology side, it's
- 5:46sort of doable. But yes, these technologies,
- 5:50they're very CapEx heavy. So you want to maximize selling
- 5:55as much energy as you can over their lifetime to make as much
- 5:58revenue to pay back that CapEx. But The thing is, there's, I
- 6:07don't see much point in nuclear sort of maximizing its capacity
- 6:10factor if it's also selling the electricity during periods of
- 6:14the day when solar is super abundant and prices are
- 6:17negative. That's also keep the reactor bit
- 6:21at base load. That's good for your CapEx.
- 6:24And if you flex the steam side, then you can have power
- 6:27generation going up and down, not 100% to 0 and to 200%, but
- 6:33if you can already flex even a little bit, even ±10%, that's
- 6:37valuable for the energy system. And I just want to sort of give
- 6:40a shout out to my colleague, Doctor James Laisenby, who wrote
- 6:44an award-winning paper on this actually two years ago, looking
- 6:47at how integrating thermal storage within a nuclear power
- 6:50plant, a conventional plant, you can actually flex more or less
- 6:5410% including upwards. And so this is one of the the
- 7:00yeah, bits of the report that if you can do that, if you can
- 7:04avoid selling your electricity when the price is zero or or
- 7:12close to 0 and instead sell that same electricity later thanks to
- 7:16this integrated storage when the prices are much higher, then
- 7:20that should be better for the economics of the nuclear plants
- 7:22as well. But it is sort of a change from
- 7:27base load operation. If you really want to operate
- 7:30base load, you can also, another alternative is to find a client
- 7:34who wants base load. And that sort of ties into what
- 7:36you were saying earlier about data centers and those customers
- 7:42really want reliable 24/7 power and they're big enough and have
- 7:48deep enough pockets to to pay for this kind of plant
- 7:52potentially. So that's the alternative.
- 7:56I would first of all comment on the geothermal part.
- 7:58It's geothermal has been operating for a while, but the
- 8:02the bad thing has been that it's been concentrated in some
- 8:05regions near the load. But I am really excited to see
- 8:11personally about the potential applications of this enhanced
- 8:14geothermal that we are hearing more and more about.
- 8:16And if you look at some of these DOE first, well DOE Earth short
- 8:23or sorry Earth short program, the cost reductions they
- 8:25targeted there, you can have a fundamentally different role of
- 8:29geothermal in your energy system, not just on the supply
- 8:32side also like yes, you can generate electricity, but also
- 8:34on the demand side with heat pumps.
- 8:37So that being said, coming back to the point about nuclear, one
- 8:42of the things that we need to understand about nuclear is that
- 8:44the age of the current reactive fleet is now quite old.
- 8:48It's about 3033 years. And it can be, we need to, they
- 8:53are nearing their age and operating them, extending their
- 8:58lifetime is a little bit dangerous.
- 9:00It can be a little bit dangerous and we need to to be able to
- 9:05sustain the generation they have been giving for the last 30
- 9:07years, which has not changed much.
- 9:10We need to build a lot of new reactors which we have not been
- 9:12able to do in a timely or a cost effective manner.
- 9:18So a lot of these strategies, I'm very interested to read a
- 9:21little bit more about these strategies to make nuclear a
- 9:23little bit more viable, because the, the only reason that
- 9:28nuclear gets built is because the state takes all the risks.
- 9:32They provide concessional finance below the market rates,
- 9:35a lot of supply chain support, Technical Support, personal
- 9:38support, and the private sector just doesn't take the risk.
- 9:43So it's very, it would be very interesting to see that happen.
- 9:46In other words, if I put this, there would be no nuclear, there
- 9:50wouldn't be any nuclear reactor if the state doesn't take all
- 9:52the risks and it has been happening like like nuclear is
- 9:56having a moment right now again and the poster child are small
- 10:01modular reactors. I have my reservations because
- 10:05if you consider a very strict definition of small modular
- 10:08reactors that are smaller than 300 megawatts, they are factory
- 10:12built, assembled at sites, assembled at site.
- 10:15There are none that are operating today.
- 10:17There are this couple from last I read which are just small, so
- 10:24it's it would be interesting to see how that scales up.
- 10:30The history of nuclear reactors has been that the most promising
- 10:34designs were small, like they were initially built small and
- 10:39they were the most promising designs were scaled up to take
- 10:41economies of scale, the advantages that come with it.
- 10:45And if you scale them back down, some of the costs don't reduce
- 10:48in the same factor, the the construction cost, the licensing
- 10:52cost, they don't reduce by a factor of 4.
- 10:54If you reduce the scale of the reactors by 4.
- 10:59That being said, to me, it doesn't feel like small module
- 11:04reactors, if they are, if they are built in the strictest of
- 11:07definition can compete with, even with conventional nuclear,
- 11:10especially if you take advantage of these innovative business
- 11:13models, let alone with renewables.
- 11:15So it's a, it's a very difficult case.
- 11:17And I, I think a lot of pragmatism about nuclear comes
- 11:21from understanding the fact that they are not going, they're only
- 11:23going to play a niche role in some remote, especially small,
- 11:29small reactors in a, in a niche, niche role in some military
- 11:33applications or in a remote mining site as they have been
- 11:36doing right now. You know what, just just
- 11:38thinking there, your, your point around sort of government by and
- 11:42government support for, for nuclear.
- 11:45That makes me think I want to come to you next, Maria, because
- 11:48in, in the same way that as a, as a company, it needs to have
- 11:51its shareholders backing investments and its investors
- 11:55agreeing with investment for government to, to get behind the
- 11:59technology. It really needs voters on side.
- 12:02And the interesting I'm, I'm seeing a little bit of
- 12:04similarities between Germany and Scotland in terms of political
- 12:09consensus around nuclear in a bit.
- 12:11The SNP, the, the government in Scotland aren't overtly happy
- 12:15with the, with nuclear, although some of some polling have
- 12:19suggested that their voters are more keen on it than they are
- 12:22here. It seems like there's, there's a
- 12:24bit of a push back against nuclear.
- 12:27When you were gathering your data, how, how much input did
- 12:31you need to give the average person about what an SMR is?
- 12:34What's the difference between fission and fusion and does that
- 12:38make a difference? Yes, that's actually an
- 12:40excellent question because what we did before that, that server
- 12:45that I showed were focus groups, so where we actually got
- 12:49together with a group of people and really were able to ask
- 12:52follow up questions and let them discuss different technologies.
- 12:56So that was was a much better setting to really understand if,
- 13:00you know, people understand the technology.
- 13:03And indeed, there's a lot of confusion, especially around
- 13:08nuclear and especially around nuclear fission and fusion.
- 13:14And I think on the data you saw, I found really interesting that
- 13:20the, the data when we then did the poll where we didn't provide
- 13:22an explanation because, you know, as I don't know, in the
- 13:26newspaper as a politician, you're also not always able to
- 13:29make a long explanation. So it's often just, you know,
- 13:34when people are confronted with technology, do they what's their
- 13:37intuition, even if they don't completely understand what it
- 13:40is? Because we also need to live
- 13:41with that uncertainty. And what I find really telling
- 13:44is that the data for nuclear fusion and fission was almost
- 13:49exactly the same in Germany. Same party divides.
- 13:53And I think for the German government, now that that's
- 13:57really Germany specific, but the German government is really
- 14:00betting on fusion at the moment in Germany.
- 14:02And I think for some good reasons, because there are some
- 14:05promising start-ups. So the government are also all
- 14:09political parties, even the Greens are not against fusion.
- 14:12They see that as a promising technology.
- 14:14But I think our data is a little bit of an early, early warning
- 14:18signal for, for fusion that you really need to explain that
- 14:20technology because otherwise people were confused, confused
- 14:24with fission, even though it's, it's different.
- 14:27So, so it's, it's important you know, to, to, to look at us and
- 14:32to understand that early on, because otherwise you will have
- 14:35the same conflict, conflict lines As for, for fission.
- 14:39I'd just like to come back to you on that.
- 14:41The Scotland point. I, I used to work for the UK
- 14:45civil service and in that there was a much more, they were much
- 14:50more proponents of nuclear and every, all the modelling we've
- 14:54seen showed that nuclear and SMRS had a vital role in
- 14:58bringing down the cost of energy for for the UK.
- 15:00So while Scotland isn't necessary pro nuclear, the UK
- 15:07are building 2 expensive reactors I should say.
- 15:11But we're hoping that SMRS and fusion are going to play a very
- 15:16important role in the future energy.
- 15:17System, of course, yeah, we've got size.
- 15:18We'll see, which as you say is very expensive and going
- 15:21slightly over over budget and slightly is maybe a, a generous
- 15:25way of putting it. But then we've also got Wilfa,
- 15:29the small modular, modular reactor that's going ahead in
- 15:31Wales as well. I was mainly bringing up
- 15:34Scotland for the the comparisons with their political, political
- 15:37consensus. But you're right to to call that
- 15:39out. Phil, do you know what?
- 15:40We'll, we'll stick with you actually because I want the
- 15:42pivot to a different technology that's maybe wasn't mentioned in
- 15:46Antoine's presentation too heavily, but it was mentioned in
- 15:49the report itself because you were wanting to speak with CCS
- 15:51before we started as well because you've got a background
- 15:54of the US and you maybe come to a slightly different conclusion
- 15:56to the report. Yeah, the US is a very different
- 16:01situation politically as well as economically and resources.
- 16:07So in the US there's there is plentiful they're they're one of
- 16:12the biggest gas producers in the world.
- 16:14So there's plentiful supplies of gas and I think you showed a, a
- 16:19graphic of the cost of gas within the US earlier today.
- 16:23And the, the gas, the gas cost in the US is a fraction of what
- 16:27the gas cost is in Europe. So what we're finding with the
- 16:32hyperscalers which are the, the companies building or the OR
- 16:36proposing to build all the data centres that we need for the
- 16:39build out of AI is they are going down the gas route and
- 16:43they are going down with at gas plus CCS.
- 16:47And so I think whilst for Europe it may be a different story, gas
- 16:51plus CCS is a really important part of the clean firm agenda
- 16:55and clean firm conversation. I'd love to give a bit more
- 16:58detail maybe on the, our sort of viewpoint on gas plus CCS in the
- 17:04report. And there's sort of a couple of
- 17:07different reasons that sort of made us very hesitant and kind
- 17:10of downgrade it. And what we think is, should
- 17:13play a role, certainly in Europe.
- 17:15So #1 concerns around the climate integrity of gas plus
- 17:21CCS, because, I mean, it's only as green as 2 assumptions #1
- 17:28very high capture rates and which is not necessarily
- 17:33trivial, achieving that. And #2 low upstream emissions,
- 17:39which is not addressed by the CCS part.
- 17:41And this is sort of a chronic problem with the natural gas
- 17:43industry, leaks upstream in the extraction.
- 17:46And natural gas has a very high global warming potential.
- 17:49So any leaks are sort of very, very detrimental very quickly to
- 17:53the climate. Case number 2, energy security I
- 17:58think is, yeah, doesn't need to sort of be sort of detail too
- 18:03much. Certainly in Europe situation,
- 18:05obviously in the US it's different because there's a lot
- 18:07more home grown, home grown home extracted gas.
- 18:13And on the cost side, sort of two things.
- 18:16We see natural gas plus CCS as unlike some of the other
- 18:21technologies, there's, there's really sort of no perspective of
- 18:24cost reduction or learning curves.
- 18:25Sort of structurally by definition, natural gas plus CCS
- 18:29is more expensive than natural gas.
- 18:32And, and unless you have obviously carbon pricing, but
- 18:36carbon pricing is very much sort of a strong policy tool.
- 18:41And as we've seen with recent changes in administration, you
- 18:44can't always count on policy continuity.
- 18:47So there's that. And then also if you're locking
- 18:52in continued natural gas use, it does, I figure it will interplay
- 18:59with other parts of gas in our energy system.
- 19:02And if we're getting rid of natural gas in industrial heat
- 19:06and buildings and homes etcetera, the cost, the small
- 19:11cost that we took for granted for natural gas I think will
- 19:14become much larger. So like networks, all those
- 19:16pipelines, yes, we've already built them, but if suddenly the
- 19:18user base that's using them becomes much, much smaller than
- 19:22the, IT becomes disproportionately more
- 19:24expensive to maintain those those pipelines in that network.
- 19:29So that's why we were sort of quite skeptical in the end.
- 19:32And certainly for Europe, obviously the US is a very
- 19:35different situation. And finally, also again, the,
- 19:39the focus of the report was very much for the EU, but if you took
- 19:43clean tech architects, we sort of are keen to, for Europe to
- 19:47develop clean technologies, but not just for Europe, but to
- 19:50develop technologies in Europe that will spill over and scale
- 19:52globally. Otherwise, I mean, yes, it's,
- 19:56it's good to decarbonize Europe, but the the impact is much lower
- 19:59CCS, gas plus CCS again coming back to this policy thing of
- 20:03needing a carbon pricing, we don't see that as very scalable
- 20:08on a global level convincing every single country or more
- 20:13countries to back this. So one of the arguments that is
- 20:17used for Fossil Plus CCS is that it is even if you if if you
- 20:23remove the carbon prices that on the cost basis, they say that
- 20:28you have to include the cost of system services to a solar plant
- 20:31and a wind plant. And by that logic, a gas plus
- 20:35CCS project is cheaper and it's clean and it because it provides
- 20:39system services which your variable renewable don't and you
- 20:43have to add the cost. And to that, I sometimes think
- 20:47they are not the best arguments because it is first of all, if
- 20:51you're not adding costs of system services, any other
- 20:54technology, doesn't make sense to add it to a particular
- 20:57renewable technology just because it's variable.
- 21:01And secondly, it's not the responsibility of a single
- 21:06generator to ensure that the system is stable.
- 21:09It is the property of the system to be stable, so you don't need
- 21:13and that is sometimes the confusion that I sometimes read
- 21:16that people read dispatch ability and system reliability
- 21:19as use the use them interchangeably.
- 21:22But in fact they're very different things.
- 21:23The goal for the consumers is to have a reliable grid which can
- 21:28be which is operational in periods of high high risk or
- 21:33otherwise. Yeah.
- 21:34I mean, I have to agree on the upstream methane emissions that
- 21:39you know, they're essential to, to bring down as part of any gas
- 21:43system. I mean that doesn't just rely on
- 21:46CCS and gas CCS, it we should be targeting bringing down the, the
- 21:51upstream methane emissions across our methane demand.
- 21:55We, you know, in Europe we are going to be using natural gas
- 22:00probably into the 20 fifties, you know, to some extent.
- 22:03So it's essential that we really bring down those upstream
- 22:06emissions and that's something that isn't just linked to CCS.
- 22:12And I agree we need high capture rates as well in the US it's a
- 22:17very different market than in Europe.
- 22:20And so it's whilst I agree it is going to make the power more
- 22:25expensive, we are seeing people investing in these hyperscalers
- 22:30investing in it today. Well, they're claiming to invest
- 22:34in the they're investing in the gas generation pub and they're
- 22:38claiming that the CCS ready. So it's important that we hold
- 22:43them to that CCS part because those gas generators are getting
- 22:47put in today. I just wanted to make a point on
- 22:49regional differences because we were talking about obvious
- 22:52differences between Europe and the US, but I think especially
- 22:56for came from power and that also became clear in your
- 22:59report. We should also allow for
- 23:01differences within Europe because there are huge
- 23:04differences on some technologies like I mean hydropower was also
- 23:07in your report and then obviously geothermal.
- 23:12They, they are like differences in the geology, geology where
- 23:17these projects can be built of course.
- 23:19And I think we, we definitely need to allow for regional
- 23:23differences from that perspective, but also from a
- 23:25political perspective, because I mean, for nuclear, I think
- 23:29that's pretty obvious that they are, I mean, big differences
- 23:32between countries where France with a big nuclear fleet, where
- 23:36we have other countries that phase out nuclear.
- 23:40And you made a really interesting point also on
- 23:42scaling up these technologies, especially on nuclear that you
- 23:45actually need to quite that you need them at scale.
- 23:48So it doesn't really make sense to build like single nuclear
- 23:51plants, if I understood you correctly.
- 23:53So we need to allow for regional differences, but we also need to
- 23:56see that there's enough, I mean capacity or enough project in
- 24:00like 1 region or I don't know if a couple of countries where the
- 24:05collision and you know, the scale 1 technology or one type
- 24:09of nuclear technology. I think that's also important to
- 24:13take into consideration. Yeah, if I if I can just
- 24:17continue that point. Yes, scale is one of the, the
- 24:21big points in the report that we make.
- 24:23And this is for honestly, like all the technologies and, and
- 24:26energy technology in general, if you want competitiveness and
- 24:29sort of cost reductions, then you need to make the produce
- 24:33that thing at scale. And this is true for nuclear,
- 24:36this is true for geothermal, for nuclear.
- 24:38You can sort of see this quite clearly in how back in the 70s
- 24:44and 80s, countries like France or Sweden built whole fleets of
- 24:48nuclear reactors and they did it much better than we're doing it
- 24:51today. So it's very weird to think, oh,
- 24:53we've regressed some, we've gotten worse, worse at building
- 24:56this stuff. But the difference is sort of in
- 25:00France, for example, where I'm from in the 1970s, there was the
- 25:04Prom Mesmer, which was a whole fleet.
- 25:08And they said within this fleet, within this program, we're going
- 25:11to be the same reactor over and over again, no changes.
- 25:13And all of this within a relatively short time span.
- 25:17Today, the situation is the complete opposite, where you
- 25:20have the same countries like the UK or France, we're building
- 25:23sort of 1 reactor every decade or so.
- 25:26And which is why going back to the UK, when you mentioned it
- 25:30earlier, building plants, but building so few of them that
- 25:33there's really, they're not reaping those sort of the, the
- 25:36rewards that they're looking for.
- 25:38So it's kind of one of those technologies where I, I want to
- 25:41say go big or go home. And it's, you know, if you don't
- 25:45want it at all, fine. But if you're going to do it,
- 25:48doing it in homeopathic doses, that doesn't deliver much.
- 25:53So you, you really need to and yeah, the, the, the same logic
- 25:58also applies to geothermal, especially given that we're at
- 26:02an earlier stage. It's, it's much less mature
- 26:04technologically. Again, next generation
- 26:06geothermal, not conventional. So if you want to see any real
- 26:10progress again, you need scale, you need to build many of these.
- 26:13You need to go from first of a kind to NTH of a kind if you
- 26:17want to see real improvements. And I think we can and and kind
- 26:21of going back to what you were alluding to earlier, what we've
- 26:24seen so far in next generation geothermal, especially enhanced
- 26:27geothermal and a lot of it in the US unfortunately, hopefully
- 26:30some in Europe is the learning rates have have been very
- 26:35promising. So we need to to keep moving
- 26:38forward, keep deploying them more because R&D only takes you
- 26:42so far. You need to deploy in the real
- 26:44world because that's where supply chains get built.
- 26:47That's where the real lessons are learned on the ground and
- 26:49you get the cost reductions, which is exactly what happened
- 26:52with solar PV over the past 20 years with manufacturing in
- 26:55China. So on that point, so wells
- 26:59probably a controversial subject, shale gas, they moved
- 27:03brought down the cost of shale gas, which has similar
- 27:06technologies to geothermal by moving into the process, into a
- 27:11manufacturing process where the rigs were used consistently.
- 27:14They were moving from site to site to site and that really
- 27:18brought down the costs of Shell gas and also it you could see it
- 27:25also working for geothermal as well.
- 27:27Do you know, I think we could, I think we've, we struck a nerve
- 27:29and we're able to keep this conversation going, which is
- 27:31exactly what I asked for. However, we do now have quite a
- 27:34number of questions coming in online and also believe this
- 27:38gentleman in the corner here was been waiting patiently to ask a
- 27:41question. So.
- 27:42Thanks Gil Kapila from Biluna, Germany.
- 27:46Following the the discussion around the the the fossil gas
- 27:50and CCS power plants, because Biluna is kind of the NGO famous
- 27:57or infamous to bring CCS frequently in the debate.
- 28:00And we currently published the second version of our CCS letter
- 28:04and looked a bit in depth on the on these gas power plants and
- 28:07played around with various scenarios was European
- 28:11perspective in the thing. So AUS perspective might look
- 28:14differently, but basically if you look at also the kind of a
- 28:18development over a bit of a period of time so that it
- 28:21doesn't just stick to right now, you basically didn't find a case
- 28:25where it made sense to to to to use that case.
- 28:30Basically if you either have them in in a in a violent future
- 28:35just for for the seasonal bufferings or for some out
- 28:42interim period within a day, you will always find something else
- 28:45you could rather do in a cheaper manner because you just are have
- 28:50to have a lot of infrastructure on these things.
- 28:54So might be different in different case, and you might
- 28:58find a fringe case somewhere, but it's not going to run in.
- 29:00Europe. I'm going to say, does anyone
- 29:02want to respond to that? And I feel like the man sitting
- 29:04directly to my left will be the person that does.
- 29:07When you say it's not going to run in Europe, you mean for
- 29:09power or do you mean in general? So CCS for industry
- 29:13decarbonization we see as essential as of one of those
- 29:17routes for decarbonization. So we we work very closely with
- 29:22Bologna. So so I guess I know the answers
- 29:27to that question. I was specifically referring to
- 29:31fossil gas power plants. That's like there, there are a
- 29:36lot of other cases and we looked through a lot of other cases and
- 29:40it's totally different thing like for a cement plant or waste
- 29:43incinerator and so on. We yeah, check out this letter,
- 29:48like the CCS letters, 2 point O. You'll, you'll find it when you
- 29:52just Google it. And a lot of other cases will
- 29:55definitely have a case. You know, we've got a number of
- 29:59questions piling in from our online broadcast as well.
- 30:01So I'm going to try to get through as many as we can.
- 30:04Although the conversation has gotten away from us a little
- 30:06bit. We only have about 3 minutes
- 30:08left. So if if whoever you think is
- 30:11the best person to answer, raise your hand really quickly.
- 30:13It's first come first serve. So I'm going to, I'm going to go
- 30:16from Aaron on Riverside to start with.
- 30:18Who said what is the panelists opinion on bio gas and bio
- 30:23methane? Germany has one of the biggest
- 30:25fleets of bio gas plants. Thanks.
- 30:29I believe that's Antoine, right? I guess so, yeah.
- 30:32So we, we do discuss bio gas briefly in the report and here,
- 30:38well, it's actually kind of similar to the CCS discussion in
- 30:42terms of also the the concept of this ladder.
- 30:46I think we need a bio gas ladder as well because bio gas sort of
- 30:50two things, limited supply and it's it's a valuable molecule
- 30:55because yeah, it's the same thing as as natural gas methane.
- 30:59So, you know, you can use that. Well, given you have a limited
- 31:04supply, you should prioritize that for the sectors that have
- 31:07the fewest alternatives. So that could include, you know,
- 31:13making fuels for shipping and aviation.
- 31:16It could include bio gas for covering Dunkle flouter with
- 31:21existing gas turbines. But yes, don't use it to heat
- 31:26your home, don't bleed it into the rest of the gas grid and
- 31:29kind of waste it there. The caveat I'll add to this
- 31:32though, is bio gas. From all my reading of the
- 31:36literature, I never get a clear answer on how green is it
- 31:40really. And, and, and this is really
- 31:42kind of a major sticking point for us is the numbers are all
- 31:45over the place. You know, sometimes it's like,
- 31:48oh, it's actually carbon negative overall.
- 31:51Sometimes you see numbers where it's just as bad as natural gas
- 31:55because you get methane leakage in the production and and things
- 31:58like that. So that's why I see a fairly
- 32:02niche role for it. And I don't want Europe to go
- 32:05down full steam ahead on on relying on bio gas and maybe
- 32:10making some kind of mistake where we rely on something that
- 32:14turns out in 20 years we'll have newspaper headlines saying
- 32:16actually this was really bad for the climate.
- 32:19Whereas the the other technologies in the report, we
- 32:23can be more confident certainly on the climate integrity.
- 32:25I I agree with what Antoine said.
- 32:27And I think a lot of uncertainty comes from the fact that some,
- 32:30some estimates of emissions do not include indirect land use
- 32:34change, which can be huge. It can.
- 32:37It can be worse than using gasoline, yeah.
- 32:42You know, I've got another question here.
- 32:44They're both from the same person and they are kind of
- 32:48similar, so I'll try to try to wrap them together.
- 32:50But the first question was, as energy systems transition
- 32:54towards low carbon technologies, how do you balance the need for
- 32:58reliable clean energy with long with long term risks to water
- 33:03resources, land, biodiversity in local communities?
- 33:07Should environmental and water security be given equal priority
- 33:11alongside energy security? I feel like this might be a
- 33:15public public question, so I might hand it over to Maria for
- 33:19the. Next poll.
- 33:21Now actually maybe I can advertise our next poll because
- 33:24I believe there are some questions on the environment in
- 33:26there and at European level I can check whether there's one on
- 33:28water. But I mean, I personally, I
- 33:30mean, totally agree that we should not elect like factors
- 33:34like that. I don't have the technical
- 33:36answer to that, but I do find it important to look at that from a
- 33:41public perspective. And we've got a question here on
- 33:46some some wave and tidal from a monorousman who has asked.
- 33:53Today's discussion focuses on energy abundance and resilience
- 33:57resilient clean power systems. I've been exploring 2 surface
- 34:01water energy concepts published through Clean Innovation Wire 1
- 34:06based on wave driven pumping, and another on reimagined river
- 34:11water river wheel hydropower. If experts believe that the
- 34:15ideas merit further investigation, what would be the
- 34:18best pathway to obtain technical feedback, mentorship, or
- 34:22collaboration for early stage validation?
- 34:26Does anyone feel particularly confident in giving someone with
- 34:30an interesting new technology some advice?
- 34:32Yeah, I'll give it a go. I used to work in innovation, so
- 34:36it's been a while, but speak to, I don't know where they're
- 34:40based, but speak to relevant authorities or that have a look.
- 34:46I know what it's based. Well, it's like in the UK, but I
- 34:49don't know what it's like in Europe.
- 34:51But there are, there are organizations out there that
- 34:54will support you with developing your bid and developing your
- 34:58technology and giving you advice on that.
- 34:59There are accelerator programs out there and they will, they'll
- 35:04give you very good. Advice.
- 35:06Congratulations to Mono Rusman, because I think that's the last
- 35:09question of the day. So they've wrapped up the panel
- 35:11session. I did have one extra question
- 35:13that I'm going to be really cheeky and fit in just now, but
- 35:16we are already over time now, we've discussed quite a lot of
- 35:20technologies, a lot of policy drivers throughout this
- 35:23conversation. But if there was one concrete
- 35:26thing that Europe could do right now to better a situation, what
- 35:29would it be? We're going to start with Fell,
- 35:30we're going to Emma Maria and then that'll be as done.
- 35:36I think it's actually target your innovation to the needs.
- 35:39You know, look where the innovation is needed.
- 35:43You know, the innovation fund seems to be not as focused as it
- 35:51should be that we, you know, we've got past the point where
- 35:54we have to be neutral about all technologies.
- 35:56We need to now start looking at what the technologies we think
- 35:59are going to be successful and needed for the future of Europe.
- 36:03So and that's where we should target the money.
- 36:06So that's things like industrial electrification investment,
- 36:09industrial electrification, really trying to scale that
- 36:13technology so it's can meet the scale of the future.
- 36:18I think dramatically scaling up, going bonkers and building solar
- 36:22wind storage could would be the best thing we could do.
- 36:26Yeah, I absolutely agree with that.
- 36:28We're in the middle of an energy crisis, so Europe should be
- 36:30ambitious. The last time this happened in
- 36:321970s, Europe rose to the challenge and I think it should
- 36:35again today, if I can be sort of, if we want one more specific
- 36:40recommendation, concrete action, well at the European level,
- 36:43which is where future Clean Tech Architects is focused, we would
- 36:46like to see a dedicated geothermal action plan because
- 36:49currently it's kind of there's support for it in Brussels, but
- 36:54it kind of floats around in different policy packages.
- 36:57It's in the heating and cooling plan and over here and over
- 37:00there. And if we could just give it
- 37:02sort of its own due attention, because I think that would go
- 37:06much further. Yes, my recommendation would be
- 37:09to be even more serious on energy security because in many
- 37:12cases, there's an overlap with climate technologies.
- 37:17And I will also echo your point on geothermal because as we've
- 37:20seen in our data, I think there's also a public opening
- 37:24for for geothermal. So I believe it's a good timing
- 37:27to really double down on geothermal specifically.
- 37:30You reckon improv and I, I throw to the, to the whole, the whole
- 37:34event. Well, thank you very much for
- 37:35joining us. We are 5 minutes over.
- 37:37But I think considering everything we covered, we can be
- 37:40forgiven for that. So thank you for sticking around
- 37:43to the end of the festival. And, and I believe if, if this
- 37:53conversation has piqued your interest, if you and if you've
- 37:55stayed around this long, I'm sure it has.
- 37:57Antoine's report can be found online as of now, right?
- 38:00Everything's on our website. Everything's on the website.
- 38:03Perfect. Well, thank you very much for
- 38:04joining us and for everyone that was watching the live stream,
- 38:07thank you to you too. And that did it for this week's
- 38:13episode of Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 38:15Very different. I can't say next week is going
- 38:17to be quite the same, although we will be at our Women in New
- 38:21Energy event in Aberdeen if you fancy coming by and saying
- 38:24hello. Now that does it for us this
- 38:26week. We'll join you same time, same
- 38:28place next week.