Latest / Orbital Dreams / 20 Things We Still Don_t Understand About Reality _ Science For Sleep _ No Mid-Video Ads
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: Hello, my friend. Tonight, I want to share a secret
- 0:07that physicists have quietly carried for more than one hundred years.
- 0:13The solid, familiar world all around you, the floor beneath you,
- 0:18the air fill in your lungs, the very light reaching
- 0:22your eyes in this moment is not at all what
- 0:25it appears to be. Look closely enough at any piece
- 0:29of it, and reality begins to soften and dissolve into
- 0:33something far stranger, far more beautiful, and far less certain
- 0:38than anyone ever expected. We like to imagine that we
- 0:42understand the universe. We have mapped distant galaxies and split
- 0:47the atom into its smallest parts, and yet at the
- 0:52very deepest level, almost everything is still a mystery. Why
- 0:56does simply looking at a particle seem to change what
- 0:59it is? What is the unseen substance that holds the
- 1:03galaxies together? Where did all of this come from? And
- 1:08why is there anything here at all? So let yourself
- 1:12grow still, let your shoulders soften, and your breathing slow.
- 1:17There is nothing to solve tonight, and know where you
- 1:21need to be For the next while, we will wander
- 1:25gently through twenty of the deepest unsolved mysteries about reality itself.
- 1:31Each one stands on its own, like a small door
- 1:35swinging open onto the unknown. You do not need to
- 1:39follow a thread or hold on to anything. If you
- 1:42drift off somewhere along the way, that is perfectly all right.
- 1:47The mysteries will keep, and so will I. Let us begin.
- 1:54Picture a single speck of light, smaller than anything your
- 1:59eye could ever see, traveling alone through empty space toward
- 2:04a barrier with two narrow openings cut into it. Behind
- 2:09that barrier sits a screen, waiting to record where the
- 2:12speck lands. You might expect something simple. The particle goes
- 2:18through one opening or the other and arrives at a
- 2:21single spot on the screen, the way a thrown pebble
- 2:25passes through one gap in a fence. Send through many particles,
- 2:30one at a time, and you would expect two little
- 2:34stripes to slowly build up behind the two openings, two
- 2:38soft piles marking where the specks came through. But that
- 2:42is not what happens. Instead, as particle after particle arrives,
- 2:47each one alone with long stretches of nothing in between,
- 2:52a pattern begins to emerge on the screen. Not two stripes,
- 2:56but many bands of brightness and dark darkness, evenly spaced,
- 3:02like ripples frozen in place on the surface of a pond.
- 3:06It is exactly the pattern you would see if waves
- 3:09had passed through both openings at once and overlapped on
- 3:13the far side, some crests adding together into brightness, others
- 3:18meeting and canceling into shadow. This is the strange part
- 3:23Each particle was sent through entirely on its own. There
- 3:27was no other particle for it to ripple against, no
- 3:31companion to interfere with. And yet somehow each lonely speck
- 3:37behaves as though it passed through both openings at the
- 3:40same time and interfered with itself, as if it quietly
- 3:45explored every possible path at once before settling onto the screen.
- 3:51So physicists did the obvious thing. They placed a tiny
- 3:55detector beside the openings, just to watch and see which
- 3:59one each part article truly goes through. And the moment
- 4:03they did, the universe seemed to change its mind. The
- 4:08rippling pattern vanished. The particles began arriving in two simple stripes,
- 4:14like ordinary pebbles, after all, each one passing cleanly through
- 4:19a single opening, behaving themselves at last. Stop watching, and
- 4:25the ripples return watch again, and they disappear. Sit with
- 4:31that for a moment. The act of gaining information about
- 4:34the particle, of measuring which path it took, appears to
- 4:39reach into the experiment and reshape what the particle does.
- 4:44When its journey goes unobserved, it spreads out into a
- 4:47haze of possibility everywhere at once. When its journey is measured,
- 4:53it settles into a single, definite story. The world behaves
- 4:58one way when no one is and another way the
- 5:02moment someone is. It helps to be clear about what
- 5:05is not being claimed here. This is not a matter
- 5:09of the particle being too delicate so that the gentle
- 5:13touch of measurement merely jostles it off course. The mystery
- 5:18runs far deeper than clumsy fingers. The very same particle,
- 5:24sent under the very same conditions, leaves its pattern of
- 5:27possibility when its path goes unrecorded, and abandons that pattern
- 5:33the instant its path becomes known, nothing seems to physically
- 5:38shove it. What changes is only whether the information exists
- 5:43somewhere in the world. The mere fact of which way
- 5:47being recorded appears to be enough to reshape what is real.
- 5:52And this is not a trick of careless equipment, nor
- 5:55a mistake waiting to be corrected. It has been most
- 6:00did countless times with light, with electrons, even with whole
- 6:04molecules built from hundreds of atoms. The result holds. It
- 6:09is one of the most carefully confirmed facts in all
- 6:13of science, and also one of the most baffling. So
- 6:17what does it mean here? Honestly, the certainty ends and
- 6:22the wondering begins. Physicists agree completely on what they will
- 6:26see when they run the experiment. They have argued for
- 6:30a century about what it tells us, and they still
- 6:34do not agree. Some believe the particle truly has no
- 6:39definite location until it is measured, that possibility itself is
- 6:44the deepest layer of the world, and that measurement somehow
- 6:48freezes a single outcome into being. Some believe every possible
- 6:54outcome really does happen, each in its own branching version
- 6:58of reality, and that we simply find ourselves living in
- 7:02one of them. Some believe there are hidden details we
- 7:06have not yet discovered, quietly guiding each particle along a
- 7:10real path our instruments cannot yet see. These are not
- 7:16idle day dreams. They are serious attempts by brilliant minds
- 7:20to explain a result that refuses to sit still? What
- 7:25unsettles and what in chance is the quiet suggestion buried
- 7:30inside it? All that the sharp, solid world, you know,
- 7:34where things are simply here, or there may be only
- 7:38a kind of surface, And just beneath that surface lies
- 7:42something softer and stranger, a realm of pure possibility that
- 7:48gently settles into the definite world only when it is touched,
- 7:52or measured, or somehow known. You are made of these
- 7:56very particles. Every atom in your hand, every flicker of
- 8:01light drifting through this room carries this hidden double nature
- 8:06folded within it. And perhaps on some night long from now,
- 8:10we will finally understand what it means. For now, let
- 8:15the question rest gently in the dark, a single speck
- 8:19of light, alone in the void, quietly being everywhere at
- 8:23once until the moment the world turns to look its way.
- 8:30Take two tiny particles born together in the same fleeting instant,
- 8:36and they can become linked in a way that has
- 8:38no comfortable explanation. Physicists call it entanglement. When two particles
- 8:45interact closely enough, their properties can become woven together, joined
- 8:51into a single shared state. From that moment on, they
- 8:55are no longer two fully separate things. They are too
- 9:00of one connected whole. Even after they drift far apart,
- 9:05now carry one of them away across the room, across
- 9:09the country, in principle, across the entire galaxy. The two
- 9:15particles remain bound to each other. And here's what stops
- 9:19the breath. If you measure one of them, then find
- 9:23it turning, let us say, in a particular direction, then
- 9:27in that very instant you know the other one will
- 9:30be found turning the opposite way. No matter how far
- 9:33it has traveled, the two outcomes are perfectly matched every
- 9:38single time, as though the distant particles somehow knew what
- 9:42had happened to its partner the moment it happened. Einstein
- 9:47found this deeply troubling. He had shown that nothing in
- 9:52the universe can travel faster than light, that there is
- 9:55a strict cosmic speed limit woven into the very fabric
- 9:59of space in time, and yet here was something that
- 10:03seemed to connect two distant points instantly, with no signal
- 10:08passing between them, no messenger crossing the gap. He called it,
- 10:14with a touch of scorn, spooky action. At a distance
- 10:19he suspected it could not really be true. Surely, he
- 10:23thought the particles must carry some secret instructions all along,
- 10:27agreed upon at birth, like two travelers who settled on
- 10:31a plan before parting ways. Then there would be nothing
- 10:35spooky about it at all, just ordinary information decided in
- 10:41advance and carried quietly along. For decades, this remained a
- 10:46matter of philosophy, a disagreement, with no clear way to
- 10:50decide it. Then a physicist named John Bell found something extraordinary.
- 10:56He worked out that these two pictures of the world,
- 11:00the one with secret instructions and the one with genuine entanglement,
- 11:05would not always agree with each other. If you measured
- 11:09many entangled pairs in just the right way, the two
- 11:13ideas predicted different results, different numbers. The question could finally
- 11:19be settled, not by argument, but by experiment. So the
- 11:24experiments were done again and again, growing more careful and
- 11:29more air tight with each passing year, and nature gave
- 11:33her answer clearly and consistently. Einstein's comforting picture was wrong.
- 11:40There are no secret instructions tucked inside the particles, no
- 11:45plan agreed upon in advance. The connection is real. The
- 11:49link between the two distant particles runs deeper than any
- 11:53local explanation can reach. In recent years, the scientists who
- 11:58proved this most rigorously were honored with the highest prize
- 12:03in physics for showing us that the world really is
- 12:06as strange as it first seemed. Now you might wonder
- 12:10whether this lets us send messages instantly across the stars.
- 12:15It does not, and the reason is subtle and quietly beautiful.
- 12:22When you measure your particle, the outcome you get is
- 12:25completely random. You cannot choose it or control it. You
- 12:30only discover afterward that whatever you happen to find your
- 12:35partner's particle is matched to it. To anyone holding the
- 12:39distant particle, their own result looks like pure chance as well,
- 12:45until the two of you compare notes through some ordinary
- 12:48slower channel that obeys the cosmic speed limit. Only then
- 12:53does the perfect correlation reveal itself. The universe guards its
- 12:59speed lift with great care. It allows this strange connection,
- 13:05yet it does not allow you to use it to
- 13:07whisper across the void. So what is actually happening? What
- 13:12is the thread that binds the two particles stretching across
- 13:16any distance, without thinning, without breaking, without taking any time
- 13:21at all to act. Here we reach the edge of
- 13:24our understanding. The mathematics describes it flawlessly. We can predict
- 13:31the results with perfect precision, but the picture behind the mathematics,
- 13:36the story of what reality is truly doing, remains elusive.
- 13:42Some believe it means that distance itself is not as
- 13:46fundamental as it feels, that two points far apart in
- 13:50space may be far closer than they look in some
- 13:53deeper layer of the world. Some believe that the two
- 13:57particles were never truly separate to begin with, that our
- 14:01habit of seeing them as two distinct objects is itself
- 14:06than mistake. The honest truth is that we do not
- 14:10yet know. There is something quietly humbling in this. We
- 14:15tend to imagine the universe as a vast collection of
- 14:19separate things, each one sitting in its own place, touching
- 14:24only when they happen to meet. Entanglement whispers that this
- 14:28might be an illusion of our scale, that underneath the
- 14:33world may be far more connected than it ever appears,
- 14:37stitch together in ways that pay no mind to the distances.
- 14:41We find so impossibly vast. Two particles, once joined, forever,
- 14:47sharing a single hidden state, speaking to each other across
- 14:51the emptiness in a language we can measure but cannot
- 14:55yet read. Let that quiet mystery settle over you now,
- 15:00like the faintest thread of light running silently between two
- 15:05distant stars. Almost everything that exists is something we cannot see.
- 15:14Look up on a clear night, and the sky seems
- 15:17full stars beyond counting the soft river of the Milky Way,
- 15:22the faint glow of galaxies impossibly far away. It feels
- 15:26like a great deal of universe, And yet all of it,
- 15:30every shining thing your eye or your telescope could ever find,
- 15:34makes up only a small fraction of what is truly
- 15:38out there. The rest, the overwhelming majority, is something else, entirely,
- 15:45something that gives off no light and no warmth, no
- 15:49signal of any kind that we have ever caught, something
- 15:53we have never seen and cannot yet name. The first
- 15:58clues came from watching how galaxies turn. A galaxy is
- 16:03a vast, spinning disk of stars, wheeling slowly around its
- 16:08center over millions upon millions of years, and here the
- 16:12laws of gravity, the same laws that hold you gently
- 16:16to the ground and swing the planets around the Sun,
- 16:19make a clear prediction. The stars near the bright, crowded middle,
- 16:24where most of the visible matter gathers should orbit quickly.
- 16:29The stars far out at the lonely edges, with little
- 16:33visible matter around them, should drift more slowly, the way
- 16:38the outer planets circle the Sun, far more lazily than
- 16:42the inner ones. But that is not what the galaxies do.
- 16:46When astronomers measured the speed of stars way out at
- 16:50the edges, they found them racing along just as fast
- 16:54as the stars deeper in. The galaxies were spinning too
- 16:58quickly at their rims. By every rule we know, they
- 17:01should be flying apart, flinging their outer stars off into
- 17:06the dark like a carousel spun far too fast. And
- 17:10yet they hold together, calm and whole, as they have
- 17:14for billions of years. Something is holding them, some great
- 17:19unseen mass wrapped all around each galaxy in a vast,
- 17:23invisible halo, far larger and far heavier than all the
- 17:27stars within it. Its gravity grips the outer stars and
- 17:33keeps them from escaping into the night. We cannot see
- 17:36this mass, We can only feel its pull written into
- 17:40the motion of everything we can see. And the evidence
- 17:44did not stop there. We see the same thing in
- 17:48the way whole clusters of galaxies move far too fast
- 17:52to stay bound together by their visible matter alone. We
- 17:57see it in the way light from distant galaxies bends
- 18:00as it passes by, curving around great hidden clumps of mass,
- 18:05like a stream flowing around stones beneath the surface. Everywhere
- 18:10astronomers look on the largest scales, they find the very
- 18:15same story. There is far more gravity in the universe
- 18:19than there is visible stuff to account for it. The
- 18:23missing ingredient came to be called dark matter, not because
- 18:27it is black, but because it is unseen, perfectly transparent
- 18:32to light, revealing itself only through its weight, and there
- 18:37is a great deal of it. For every gram of
- 18:41ordinary matter in the cosmos, the kind that builds stars
- 18:45and planets in your own body, there appears to be
- 18:49several grams of this dark, unknown substance. It outweighs everything
- 18:55familiar by a wide margin. It forms an invisible scaffolding
- 18:59threaded through all of space, and along that scaffolding the
- 19:03visible galaxies first gathered and grew like dew, collecting along
- 19:09the strands of an unseen web. Without it, the universe
- 19:14as we know it might never have come together at all.
- 19:18So what is it? This is where the honest answer
- 19:22becomes a quiet confession. We do not know. We have
- 19:27searched with enormous care, deep underground, shielded from the noise
- 19:32of the surface world. Physicists have built exquisitely sensitive detectors
- 19:38and waited in the silence for a single particle of
- 19:41dark matter to drift through and gently nudge in at him.
- 19:46We have hunted for it inside the great machines that
- 19:49smash particles together, hoping to conjure a flicker of it ourselves.
- 19:55We have scanned the sky for any faint trace it
- 19:58might leave behind, and so far it has stayed hidden.
- 20:04We know it is there with great confidence because we
- 20:08can feel its gravity stretching across the entire cosmos. But
- 20:13what it is made of, what kind of thing it
- 20:16truly is, remains one of the deepest unsolved puzzles in
- 20:20all of science. There is a strange and beautiful humility
- 20:24in this. We walk through the world feeling sure that
- 20:28we can see what surrounds us, that the lit and
- 20:32solid things are the real things, And then we learn
- 20:36that the visible universe, all the stars and galaxies and
- 20:40glowing clouds we have ever admired, is only the thin,
- 20:44bright foam riding on the surface of a vast dark sea,
- 20:48the greater part of creation moves around us, unseen, holding
- 20:52the galaxies together in its quiet hands, and we have
- 20:56not yet learned its name. To night. As you rest,
- 21:02picture the galaxy you live within, that great slow wheel
- 21:06of stars turning in the dark, and picture wrapped all
- 21:10around it, far wider than the stars themselves, an invisible
- 21:14cloud cradling it gently together, unseen, unknown, and everywhere at once.
- 21:21Let that vast, quiet presence hold you too as you
- 21:25drift softly towards sleep. The emptiness between the galaxies is growing,
- 21:33and it is growing faster every single day. For most
- 21:37of the last century, astronomers knew that the universe was expanding.
- 21:42Long ago, everything was packed together unimaginably close. Then came
- 21:48the great beginning we call the Big Bang, and ever since,
- 21:52space itself has been stretching, carrying the galaxies away from
- 21:57one another, like raisins drifting apart in a slowly rising
- 22:01loaf of bread. This alone was already a wondrous idea.
- 22:07The space between things is not a fixed and empty stage.
- 22:11It swells, it grows. The distances in the cosmos are
- 22:16quietly increasing all the time. Now everyone fully expected this
- 22:21expansion to be slowing down. It made perfect sense. All
- 22:26the matter in the universe pulls on all the other
- 22:29matter through gravity, drawing everything inward, so the outward rush
- 22:35from the Big Bang should be gradually losing speed, like
- 22:39a ball thrown up into the air, rising more and
- 22:42more slowly as the Earth tugs it back home. The
- 22:46only real question astronomer's thought was whether gravity would one
- 22:51day wind and pull everything back together, or whether the
- 22:56expansion would simply coast onward forever, growing slower and slower
- 23:01with each passing age. So in the final years of
- 23:05the last century, two teams of astronomers set out to
- 23:09measure the slowing They studied the light of distant exploding
- 23:14stars far across the cosmos, whose brightness let them gauge
- 23:19enormous distances with remarkable care. By gazing deep into space,
- 23:25they were also gazing deep into the past, seeing the
- 23:29universe as it had been billions of years ago. They
- 23:32expected to find that the expansion back then was faster
- 23:36than it is now, the clear signature of a cosmos
- 23:41gently applying its breaks. What they found instead overturned everything.
- 23:48The distant explosions were dimmer than they should have been,
- 23:52which meant they were farther away than anyone had expected.
- 23:57The expansion had not been slowing down at all. It
- 24:00had been speeding up. For billions of years now, the
- 24:04galaxies have been racing apart faster and faster, the empty
- 24:09space between them widening at an ever quickening pace. Both
- 24:14teams found the same impossible result and checked it and
- 24:19checked it again, and could not make it go away.
- 24:23Something is pushing the universe apart. Something is overpowering the
- 24:28inward pull of all the matter in existence and driving
- 24:31everything outward with growing force. It fills all of space,
- 24:37even the most perfect emptiness you could imagine. It has
- 24:41no glow and casts no shadow. We gave it a
- 24:45name to hold our ignorance, and we called it dark energy.
- 24:50And it is not some minor detail. When physicists add
- 24:54up everything in the cosmos, they find that this dark
- 24:58energy is by far the low just part of it.
- 25:01Roughly two thirds of all the energy in the universe
- 25:05seems to be this strange pushing force, woven silently into
- 25:10empty space itself. The ordinary matter that makes the stars
- 25:14and planets, and even the unseen dark matter that holds
- 25:17the galaxies together, are together. Only the lesser share. This
- 25:22single greatest ingredient in all of reality is something we
- 25:27discovered almost by accident, and still cannot explain what could
- 25:33it possibly be. One old idea, written down long ago
- 25:37and then set aside, is that empty space is not
- 25:42truly empty, that the vacuum itself carries a faint and
- 25:46ceaseless energy, a gentle pressure pushing outward everywhere at once.
- 25:51It is an elegant thought, but when physicists try to
- 25:56calculate how strong this energy of empty space ought to be,
- 26:00their answer comes out staggeringly, almost absurdly wrong, larger than
- 26:06what we actually observe by a number so vast it
- 26:09is nearly impossible to write down. Something is missing from
- 26:14our understanding, something deep, and we do not yet know
- 26:18what it is. There is a quiet weight to where
- 26:22all of this is leading. If the expansion keeps accelerating,
- 26:27then far in the future the galaxies will be carried
- 26:30so far apart, so fast that their light will no
- 26:34longer be able to reach one another. A being living
- 26:39in some distant age might look up into an almost
- 26:42empty sky with nearly every other galaxy long since swept
- 26:46beyond view, and have no way of ever knowing that
- 26:50the wider universe had once been there at all. The
- 26:54cosmos is slowly, gently scattering itself, growing lonelier across spans
- 27:01of time too immense for the mind to truly hold.
- 27:05But that is the far distant future, and not tonight. Tonight,
- 27:10the sky is still full, and the galaxies still shine,
- 27:14and the great mysterious force flows quietly on, doing its
- 27:19patient work in the dark between the stars. Let yourself
- 27:23rest now in that vast, slow stretching of space, the
- 27:27universe gently widening all around you, carried outward by something nameless,
- 27:33opening into an immensity we have only just begun to understand.
- 27:41You can remember the past, but never the future. It
- 27:44seems almost too obvious to question. Of course, time moves forward.
- 27:50Of course, we recall what has already happened, and never
- 27:54what is yet to come. The past feels fixed and finished,
- 27:58the future open and unwritten. A cup slips from the
- 28:03table and shatters on the floor, and it never gathers
- 28:06its pieces back together and leaps up into your waiting hand.
- 28:11Time flows in one direction only, like a river, always onward,
- 28:16never back. And yet when physicists look closely at the
- 28:20deepest laws of nature, they find something astonishing hidden inside them.
- 28:27Almost all of those laws work exactly the same, whether
- 28:31time runs forward or backward. The rules that govern a
- 28:35moving particle, two balls colliding, light traveling through empty space,
- 28:41the gentle pull of gravity between distant worlds, none of
- 28:45them seem to care which way time is pointing. Run
- 28:48them forward and they describe what happens. Run them in reverse,
- 28:55and they describe something equally allowed. At the level of
- 28:59single part articles, a film of events played backward whould
- 29:03look perfectly natural, breaking no law at all. So where
- 29:08does the forward flow of time come from? Why if
- 29:12the basic rules are blind to direction, does the world
- 29:16we actually live in have such a clear and unbreakable arrow.
- 29:20Why does the cup shatter but never gather itself whole again?
- 29:25Why do we grow older and never younger. Why does
- 29:29the past feel so utterly different from the future. The
- 29:34deepest clue we have rests in a single, quiet idea.
- 29:39In any group of things left to itself, disorder tends
- 29:43to increase. A neat arrangement is easy to disturb and
- 29:47hard to restore. There are calveless ways for a thing
- 29:51to be jumbled, and only a precious few ways for
- 29:54it to be tidy, So as time passes, order tends
- 29:58to slip toward disorder, simply because disorder is so much
- 30:03more likely to stumble into. Physicists measure this gradual drift
- 30:07toward disorder and call it entropy, And they have found
- 30:12that in the universe as a whole, it almost always grows.
- 30:17The shattered cup is a more disordered thing than the
- 30:20whole one, and its pieces scattered across the floor are
- 30:25more disordered. Still, the direction in which disorder increases is
- 30:31the very direction we have come to call the future.
- 30:35This is a beautiful answer, and it explains a great deal,
- 30:39but it carries within it a far stranger question. If
- 30:43disorder is always increasing as time moves forward, then it
- 30:47must have been lower in the past, and lower still
- 30:51further back, all the way to the very beginning, which
- 30:55means the universe must have started in a state of
- 30:58extraordinary order, almost unimaginably neat and smooth, near the moment
- 31:05of the Big Bang. And no one knows why. Why
- 31:09did the universe begin in such a special orderly condition
- 31:13when there were so many more disorderly ways for it
- 31:17to have started. This is one of the great unsolved puzzles,
- 31:22and the whole arrow of time. The entire difference between
- 31:26past and future seems to rest delicately upon it sit
- 31:32for a moment with how strange. This is the reason
- 31:36the cup will not reassemble on your table tonight, the
- 31:40reason your memories run backward into the past and never
- 31:44forward into the future. The reason you feel time carrying
- 31:47you gently from what was toward what will be, may
- 31:51trace all the way back to the peculiar tidiness of
- 31:54the infant universe nearly fourteen billion years ago. The forward
- 32:00flow of every moment you have ever lived may be
- 32:04a long, quiet echo of how everything began. And there
- 32:09is something deeper still that we cannot fully grasp. The
- 32:13forward feel of time, the vivid sense that this present
- 32:17moment is real and moving, that the past is gone
- 32:21and the future has not yet arrived, is so central
- 32:25to our experience that we can scarcely imagine being without it.
- 32:30Yet nowhere in the fundamental equations of physics does this
- 32:34flowing present appear. The laws describe a kind of unchanging
- 32:39landscape of all moments, past and future, laid out together
- 32:45with no special marker for now. Why we experience time
- 32:50as a moving stream rather than a still and finished map.
- 32:54Is a mystery that touches both physics and the nature
- 32:58of the mind itself, and it remains unsolved. So the
- 33:03river of time flows on, carrying you along with it,
- 33:06and we still do not fully understand its source, or
- 33:09why it runs the way it does, or even whether
- 33:12it's flowing is a feature of the world or a
- 33:15feature of us. For now, simply let it carry you.
- 33:20Let this moment soften into the next, and that one
- 33:24into the one after, gently, without effort, the way the
- 33:29night drifts quietly toward morning. There is no need to
- 33:33hold on to any of it. Time will do what
- 33:36it has always done and bear you kindly onward into sleep.
- 33:44Trace everything back far enough, and the entire universe shrinks
- 33:48down to something smaller than you could ever imagine. Take
- 33:53the galaxies racing apart tonight, and run the great expansion
- 33:57backward in your mind. The galaxies draw closer together, the
- 34:02space between them shrinks. Go back further billions upon billions
- 34:08of years, and everything grows hotter and denser and more
- 34:12tightly packed, the whole cosmos contracting toward a single searing instant.
- 34:19Go back as far as we possibly can, and we
- 34:23arrive at a moment nearly fourteen billion years ago, when
- 34:28all that would ever become stars and planets and people
- 34:32was gathered into a state of almost unthinkable heat and density.
- 34:37We call that beginning the Big Bang. It is a
- 34:40humble little name for the origin of absolutely everything, and
- 34:45it is easy to picture it wrongly as a great
- 34:48explosion going off somewhere in the middle of empty space.
- 34:54But that is not quite right. There was no surrounding
- 34:57space for it to explode into. Space itself was part
- 35:01of what was tightly furled up in that beginning, and
- 35:04the expansion was not things flying apart through space, but
- 35:09space itself, unfurling and stretching everywhere at once. The Big
- 35:14Bang did not happen at a single point within the universe.
- 35:19In a sense, it happened everywhere, because everywhere was once
- 35:25that single point. We have real evidence that this beginning
- 35:29truly was. There is a faint afterglow still bathing the
- 35:34whole sky in every direction, a whisper of warmth left
- 35:38over from when the universe was young and glowing, now
- 35:43stretched and cooled by all the long eons of expansion
- 35:47into a soft hum of light we can detect with
- 35:50our instruments. We can read in it the conditions of
- 35:54the early cosmos with remarkable precision. The Big Bang is
- 35:59not merely a guess. It is one of the best
- 36:03supported ideas in all of science, written quietly across the
- 36:07entire sky. But here's where our knowledge reaches its furthest edge,
- 36:14and the great question begins. What came before? What happened
- 36:18in that very first instant, and what if anything came
- 36:23before it? Here we must speak carefully and mark clearly
- 36:27the boundary between what we know and what we only wonder.
- 36:31As we trace the universe back toward that first moment,
- 36:35our finest theories begin to falter. The laws we trust
- 36:39break down, the numbers stretch toward the impossible. We cannot
- 36:45yet see all the way to the very beginning, because
- 36:49we do not yet have a theory that works in
- 36:52those extreme conditions, where the whole universe was smaller than
- 36:57a single atom, and the rules of the very very
- 37:00large and the very small crash together. So the honest
- 37:04truth is that the first instant itself and anything before it,
- 37:10lies beyond our current understanding. That has not stopped us
- 37:15from wondering and some of the wondering has taken the
- 37:18shape of serious theory, carefully labeled as such. Some physicists
- 37:25suspect that in its first sliver of a second, the
- 37:29universe went through a burst of staggeringly rapid growth, swelling
- 37:34unimaginably in less than the blink of an eye, and
- 37:38that this could explain why the cosmos looks so smooth
- 37:42and even across vast distances today. This idea fits a
- 37:46number of our observations well, but it remains a theory,
- 37:51not a settled fact, and the finer details are still debated.
- 37:56Others wonder whether our Big Bang was truly the beginning
- 38:00at all, or whether it might have been one chapter
- 38:03in some far longer story, perhaps a universe that expands
- 38:08and contracts in great slow cycles, or a single bubble
- 38:12among countless others in a vaster reality forever hidden from
- 38:17our view. These are imaginative ideas, reaching out beyond the
- 38:23edge of evidence, and they are offered as possibilities, not
- 38:28as truths we have confirmed. And then there is the
- 38:31strangest question of all, the one that makes the mind
- 38:35go quiet? Did time itself have a beginning? If time
- 38:41began together with the universe. Then, asking what came before
- 38:45the Big Bang might be a little like asking what
- 38:48lies north of the North Pole. The question may simply
- 38:53have no answer, not because we are not clever enough,
- 38:57but because there may be no before for there to be.
- 39:01There may have been no earlier moment, no empty waiting,
- 39:05no ticking clock in the dark, just the beginning, with
- 39:09nothing prior to it, including no time in which a
- 39:13prior could even exist. It is nearly impossible to truly picture,
- 39:18and we do not know if it is so. How
- 39:21wondrous and how humbling to live inside something whose beginning
- 39:26we can almost reach out and touch, yet never quite grasp.
- 39:31To know that everything around you, every atom of you,
- 39:35traces back to a single brilliant instant, and to stand
- 39:39at the very edge of that instant and find the
- 39:42deepest question of all still waiting there, unanswered in the dark.
- 39:48Let that great quiet sit with you now, the whole universe,
- 39:53you and the stars alike, born together from one unfathomable beginning,
- 39:58the first moment of all moments, still keeping its oldest secret.
- 40:04Rest there at the edge of the beginning, and let
- 40:07yourself gently drift At this very moment, there is something
- 40:15it is like to be you. You are hearing this voice,
- 40:19Perhaps you feel the soft weight of a blanket, the
- 40:22warmth of the room around you, the slow drift of
- 40:26your own thoughts as you begin to settle. There is
- 40:30an inner world here, a felt experience, a quiet sense
- 40:35of what it is like to be you, right now tonight.
- 40:40It is the most obvious thing in all of existence.
- 40:43It is the one thing you can be absolutely certain of,
- 40:47and it may be the single deepest mystery in the
- 40:50entire universe. Here is the puzzle. As far as we
- 40:54can tell, you are made of ordinary matter. Inside your
- 40:59skull sits the brain, a vast and intricate web of cells,
- 41:04nearly one hundred billion of them, passing tiny pulses of
- 41:08electricity and faint chemical signals between one another in patterns
- 41:13of breathtaking complexity. We can study this. We can watch
- 41:18it work. When you see the color red, certain cells
- 41:21in your brain grow active. When you feel afraid, or
- 41:26remember a face, or taste something sweet. We can find
- 41:30the flickers of activity that go along with it. We
- 41:34have learned a great deal about which parts of the
- 41:36brain do which kinds of work, And the picture grows
- 41:40a little clearer every year. But all of that is
- 41:44the machinery. All of that is matter in motion, signals,
- 41:49and cells, the physical dance of the brain. And here
- 41:54is the question that no one can yet answer. Why
- 41:58is any of it accompanied by an inner experience at all?
- 42:03Why is there something it is like to be that
- 42:05web of cells. Why does the activity in your brain
- 42:09not simply happen silently in the dark, the way the
- 42:13chemistry in a stone or the currents in a machine
- 42:17presumably happen with no one home to feel any of it.
- 42:22Why is there the warm, felt experience of red rather
- 42:25than only the brain quietly registering a wavelength of light
- 42:30and responding. Why is there a someone here looking out
- 42:35from behind your eyes? This is what thinkers have come
- 42:39to call the hard problem. We can imagine, at least
- 42:43in principle, explaining all the workings of the brain, every signal,
- 42:49every behavior, every word you speak, purely in terms of
- 42:53physical cause and effect. And even if we managed it completely,
- 42:59we would still not explained why all that machinery feels
- 43:02like anything at all from the inside. The gap between
- 43:07the physical story and the felt experience seems to be
- 43:11of an entirely different kind. You can describe every last
- 43:15detail of how the eye and brain process light, and
- 43:19nowhere in that description does the actual experience of seeing
- 43:23ever appear. It is as though something has been quietly
- 43:28left out, something we cannot quite point to, and yet
- 43:33it is the only part we know for certain is there.
- 43:37Nobody knows how to close this gap. It is not
- 43:41simply that we are waiting on a better brain scanner
- 43:44or a few more years of patient research, though those
- 43:48will surely teach us a great deal. The difficulty runs
- 43:52deeper than that. We do not even fully understand what
- 43:57kind of answer we are looking for. How could mere
- 44:00matter arranged in any pattern, however clever, give rise to
- 44:06the warm, felt presence of an inner life. Some thinkers
- 44:10suspect that experience somehow emerges when matter is organized in
- 44:15just the right way, though no one can yet say
- 44:19how or why. Some wonder whether a faint trace of
- 44:23experience might be woven into the very fabric of the world,
- 44:27present in some dim form, even in the simplest things,
- 44:31an old and serious idea that is impossible to prove
- 44:36and surprisingly hard to dismiss. Some suspect we are missing
- 44:41a piece of the puzzle. So basic that we cannot
- 44:44yet even imagine its shape. All of these are offered
- 44:48honestly as attempts, not as answers. The truth is that
- 44:54the relationship between the physical brain and conscious experience remains
- 44:59one of the great old in questions, perhaps the very
- 45:02deepest of them all, and the strangeness only grows when
- 45:08you turn it upon yourself. The very thing wondering about
- 45:12this mystery is itself the mystery. The awareness hearing these
- 45:16words is the unexplained thing. You are not standing safely
- 45:21outside the puzzle looking in. You are the puzzle looking out.
- 45:27The universe through you has somehow come to be aware
- 45:31of itself, to feel, and to wonder, and to ask
- 45:34why it feels at all, and how this came to be.
- 45:38No one can say there is a quiet wonder in
- 45:41simply noticing it that behind your eyes, in this very moment,
- 45:46a small piece of the cosmos is awake and aware,
- 45:50having an experience that no instrument can measure, and no
- 45:54theory can yet explain, the most familiar thing in your life,
- 46:00whole life. The simple fact of being here, of there
- 46:04being a someone home is also the most profound unsolved
- 46:09riddle we have ever encountered. You do not need to
- 46:12solve it tonight. You only need to rest gently within it.
- 46:16Let the wondering grow soft, Let the awareness that has
- 46:20carried you through this whole long day begin slowly to
- 46:24dim towards sleep, the inner light lowering like a lamp
- 46:28turned gently down, still glowing, still here, still quietly aware,
- 46:34as you drift away into the dark. There could have
- 46:40been nothing at all. No stars, no galaxies, no light,
- 46:45no space for any of it to fill, No you
- 46:48lying here in the quiet, no world to lie in,
- 46:52not even darkness, for darkness is still something, and emptiness
- 46:56waiting just nothing, no things, no laws, no time, no place.
- 47:03It is almost impossible to truly picture, because the moment
- 47:07you try, you are already imagining a kind of empty stage,
- 47:11and even an empty stage is something. But set that
- 47:14difficulty gently aside for a moment and let the question
- 47:18land in its full weight. There could have been nothing whatsoever,
- 47:23and yet here's all of this, Here is everything. Why
- 47:29this may be the oldest question a mind has ever asked,
- 47:33and also the simplest and also the deepest. Why is
- 47:38there something rather than nothing? Why does the universe bother
- 47:42to exist at all? Visits has given us astonishing answers
- 47:46to a great many questions. We can describe how stars
- 47:50are born and how they die. We can trace the
- 47:53path of light across billions of years. We can write down,
- 47:58in elegant equations the rules that the particles and forces
- 48:02seem to obey. But notice what all of those answers
- 48:06quietly have in common. Every one of them describes how
- 48:11something behaves, given that it already exists. Each explanation reaches
- 48:16back to some earlier thing, some prior law, some starting condition.
- 48:22The star formed from a cloud of gas. The gas
- 48:25was left over from the early universe, the early universe
- 48:30unfolded according to certain rules, and so on, back and back.
- 48:35But this long chain of explanation, however far we follow, it,
- 48:40always assumes that there is already a something there to
- 48:43be explained. It never quite reaches the very bottom. It
- 48:48never tells us why there is a chain at all.
- 48:51You can feel the strangeness if you keep on asking.
- 48:56Suppose we one day discover the deepest law of nature,
- 49:00the final rule from which everything else flows. A beautiful equation,
- 49:06perhaps simple enough to write upon a single page. We
- 49:10would have explained a great deal. But We could still
- 49:13turn to that equation and ask softly, why this law
- 49:17and not some other? Why should any law hold sway
- 49:21at all? Why should there be rules and things for
- 49:25the rules to govern, rather than simply nothing. The deepest law,
- 49:30if we ever find it, would still sit there, unexplained,
- 49:34existing for no reason we can point to. Some thinkers
- 49:39have wondered whether nothingness might be unstable, whether a perfect
- 49:44nothing could not hold itself together and would somehow tip
- 49:49over into something all on its own. There are hints
- 49:54in the strange mathematics of the very small that what
- 49:58we call empty space is not as quiet or as
- 50:02simple as it first seems, and a few physicists have
- 50:06asked whether a universe could emerge from a kind of
- 50:09emptiness through the restless rules of that realm. These are
- 50:14serious and fascinating ideas, and they are worth holding gently,
- 50:20but we must be honest about what they are. Even
- 50:24if a universe could arise from some quantum emptiness, that
- 50:28emptiness is already as something. It already comes with rules,
- 50:33with possibilities, with a stage on which the arising can happen.
- 50:38The very deepest form of the question slips past all
- 50:42of this and asks why there should be any rules,
- 50:45any possibility, any stage, rather than nothing whatsoever, And to
- 50:51that no one has an answer. It may lie forever
- 50:55at the quiet edge where physics meets philosophy, a question
- 50:59we can and ask with perfect clarity and may never
- 51:02be able to close. And yet here you are not nothing,
- 51:08something a warm, breathing wondering, something lying in the dark,
- 51:14made of atoms, forged in the hearts of long dead stars,
- 51:18looking out at a universe that did not have to
- 51:20be here at all, and asking why it is. There
- 51:23is a quiet kind of awe in that, deeper than
- 51:27any answer could ever give. You are a small piece
- 51:31of the something that exists in place of nothing. The
- 51:36very fact that you can wonder about this at all,
- 51:39that there is a you here to do the wondering,
- 51:43is itself part of the great improbable fact of there
- 51:46being anything. Whatever the reason, If there is a reason,
- 51:52the universe leaned toward existence, and it carried that leaning
- 51:57all the way down to this moment, to this breath,
- 52:00to you. So you do not need to answer it tonight,
- 52:03no one ever has. You only need to feel, for
- 52:06a moment the gentle wonder of being here at all,
- 52:10of being something rather than nothing, a small lit candle
- 52:14of existence in the vast and quiet dark. Rest in
- 52:19that simple, astonishing fact there is something, and you are
- 52:23part of it. Let that be enough, and let yourself drift.
- 52:31The universe seems to be balanced on the edge of
- 52:34a knife. Hidden inside the laws of physics are a
- 52:38handful of plain numbers. The strength of gravity, the strength
- 52:44of the force that binds the hearts of atoms together,
- 52:48the masses of the tiny particles that make up everything.
- 52:53These numbers are not things we can calculate or explain
- 52:57from any deeper principle, at least NiFe. Yet we simply
- 53:01measure them the way you might read the settings on
- 53:05a great machine we did not build. And here is
- 53:09the quietly astonishing thing. If you were to reach in
- 53:13and change almost any one of these numbers, even by
- 53:16a tiny amount, the universe that resulted would be barren.
- 53:21No stars, no atoms, no chemistry, no life of any kind,
- 53:26nothing to admire it, and no one to be Consider,
- 53:31the force that holds the centers of atoms together make
- 53:34it just slightly stronger or slightly weaker, and the simplest
- 53:39atoms could not form properly and the stars could not
- 53:42forge the heavier elements that you are made of, Carbon,
- 53:47the very backbone of all life we know, would never
- 53:50come to exist in any useful amount. Or consider gravity itself.
- 53:57If it were much stronger, stars would burn through their
- 54:01fuel in a furious rush and die long before life
- 54:04could ever take hold. If it were much weaker, the
- 54:08gas of the early universe might never have gathered into
- 54:12stars at all, and the cosmos would drift on as
- 54:15a thin, cold haze, dark and empty forever, again and again.
- 54:23When physicists explore these what if universes on paper, they
- 54:27find the same haunting result. The settings that actually hold
- 54:31in our world sit within a narrow band that allows
- 54:35complexity and structure, and eventually living things. Step outside that
- 54:41band and you get a universe where nothing interesting can
- 54:44cover happen. Sit for a moment with how strange this is.
- 54:50Of all the values these numbers could have taken, why
- 54:53do they fall so precisely within the slim window that
- 54:58allows stars to shine, and atoms to bond, and a
- 55:02being like you to one day wake and wonder about it.
- 55:07It can feel almost like walking into a vast control
- 55:10room filled with cowbless dials. And finding every single one
- 55:15turned to exactly the setting needed for life, as though
- 55:19someone had been there before us, carefully adjusting each one
- 55:23in turn. This is what physicists call the fine tuning
- 55:28of the universe, and it is a genuine puzzle taken
- 55:32seriously by serious people. But what it means is very
- 55:36much an open question, and here we must tread carefully,
- 55:40marking clearly where solid ground ends and speculation begins. One idea,
- 55:47offered as a theory and not as a settled truth,
- 55:51is that our universe may be only one among an
- 55:53unimaginable many. Perhaps there's a vast collection of universes, each
- 55:59with its own role of the dials, its own set
- 56:02of these fundamental numbers, most of them barren and lifeless.
- 56:08In such a picture, it would be no surprise that
- 56:11we find ourselves in one of the rare universes where
- 56:14the numbers happen to allow life, because we could only
- 56:17ever exhiver exist in such a place. A being can
- 56:21only ever find itself in a universe capable of producing beings.
- 56:27This is a fascinating thought, and it follows rather naturally
- 56:32from some of our other theories, but it remains unproven.
- 56:37We have no way at present to see these other universes,
- 56:42or to confirm that they are truly there at all.
- 56:45It is a possibility, gently held, not a fact established.
- 56:50Other thinkers wonder whether there might be some deeper law.
- 56:53We have not yet discovered, a hidden principle that fix
- 56:58these numbers and forces them to take the values they have,
- 57:02so that they only appear finely tuned, because we do
- 57:06not yet understand what determines them. In that case, the
- 57:11fine balance would not be luck or design at all,
- 57:14but quiet necessity, a single, deep truth wearing the mask
- 57:19of coincidence. This too is a real possibility, and it
- 57:24too remains unproven. The honest answer, once again is that
- 57:29we do not yet know why the universe is built
- 57:33so finely for its own richness. What stays with you
- 57:37beneath all the careful uncertainty is the sheer delicacy of
- 57:42it that the floor beneath you, the warmth of the
- 57:46distant stars, the carbon in your blood, and the air
- 57:50in your lungs, all of it rests upon a handful
- 57:53of numbers that could so easily have been otherwise, and
- 57:58that happen for reasons we cannot yet neigh to allow
- 58:02a universe gentle enough and rich enough for you to
- 58:05exist within it, and look up and notice. Perhaps it
- 58:10is luck on a scale beyond all imagining. Perhaps it
- 58:14is a necessity we have not yet uncovered. Perhaps it
- 58:18is something we have not yet learned how to dream.
- 58:21We do not know. But tonight you do not need
- 58:25to know. You only need to feel, softly the wonder
- 58:30of living in a universe so finely balanced that your
- 58:34very existence depends upon it, a cosmos delicately poised to
- 58:39allow this quiet moment, this breath, this slow drifting towards sleep,
- 58:44beneath a sky full of stars that did not have
- 58:47to shine. Rest there on that gentle knife edge held
- 58:52by numbers no one can yet explain. For every kind
- 58:59of particle in the universe, there is a mirror twin
- 59:02that can erase it. This is not a fancy or
- 59:05a figure of speech. It is a real feature of nature,
- 59:09confirmed countless times and laboratories around the world. Alongside the
- 59:15ordinary matter that makes up everything you know, there exists
- 59:19a shadow version of it, called antimatter. For each tiny
- 59:24particle of ordinary matter, there is an antiparticle, identical in
- 59:29almost every way, yet opposite as though reflected in some
- 59:34deep and perfect mirror. And when a particle of matter
- 59:38meets its antimatter twin, something dramatic happens. They annihilate each
- 59:43other completely, both vanishing in a flash of pure energy,
- 59:48a tiny burst of light. Nothing solid is left behind.
- 59:53The two opposites cancel, and where they once were there
- 59:57is only a fading glow. We are not guessing about
- 1:00:01any of this. We make antimatter ourselves, in small amounts
- 1:00:06in the great machines where particles are smashed together. It
- 1:00:10appears briefly inside certain kinds of medical scanners that doctors
- 1:00:16use to peer gently into the body. Antimatter is as
- 1:00:20real as the bed you are lying in. It simply
- 1:00:24does not last long in our world, because our world
- 1:00:28is made of matter, and the moment a speck of
- 1:00:31antimatter touches ordinary matter, the two destroy each other and
- 1:00:35are gone. Now Here is where the deep mystery quietly opens.
- 1:00:42When we look back to the very beginning of the universe,
- 1:00:45to the searing first moments after the Big Bang. Our
- 1:00:49best understanding says that matter and antimatter should have been
- 1:00:53created in equal amounts. For every particle an anti particle,
- 1:00:59a perfect balance a cosmos with exactly as much matter
- 1:01:03as antimatter, the two born together in equal measure out
- 1:01:08of the raw energy of the young universe. But if
- 1:01:12that were truly so, then something final and complete should
- 1:01:16have happened next. All that matter and all that antimatter,
- 1:01:21made in equal parts should have found each other and annihilated,
- 1:01:25particle meeting anti particle, twin, cancel and twin, until almost
- 1:01:29nothing remained but a universe flooded with light, no leftover matter,
- 1:01:35no galaxies, no stars, no planets, no atoms, no u
- 1:01:41just a vast bath of gently cooling radiation, drifting forever
- 1:01:46in the dark. By the simplest reckoning, the universe should
- 1:01:50be empty of everything except light. And yet look around
- 1:01:55here the stars, here are the galaxies, here's the Earth
- 1:02:00and the air, and your own hands resting quietly in
- 1:02:03the dark. The universe is full of matter, built from
- 1:02:08the particles that somehow were not annihilated. Something tipped the balance, somehow,
- 1:02:14in those first moments, there came to be a little
- 1:02:18more matter than antimatter, only the faintest bit more, perhaps
- 1:02:23one extra particle of matter for every billion matched pairs.
- 1:02:28But it was enough. The matter and antimatter mostly destroyed
- 1:02:33each other, just as expected, flooding the early universe with light.
- 1:02:38And when that great annihilation was finally over, that tiny
- 1:02:42surplus of matter was all that remained. That faint left over,
- 1:02:47That one part in a billion became every galaxy, every star,
- 1:02:51every living thing. It became you. So what tipped the scales?
- 1:02:58Why was there a little more matter than antimatter when
- 1:03:01our deepest principles suggest there should have been precisely the
- 1:03:05same amount of each. This is one of the great
- 1:03:09unsolved questions in physics, and it carries a quiet weight
- 1:03:14because the answer is the reason there is anything at
- 1:03:17all rather than only light. Physicists have found a few
- 1:03:23tiny hints that matter and antimatter do not behave in
- 1:03:27perfectly mirror identical ways. That there are subtle differences in
- 1:03:32how certain particles and their twins fade and decay. But
- 1:03:37the differences we have measured so far are far too
- 1:03:41small to explain the imbalance. We actually see something else,
- 1:03:47some deeper asymmetry written into the dawn of the universe
- 1:03:51must have been at work. We have not yet found it.
- 1:03:55We know it must be there because we are here
- 1:03:58to wonder about it. Yet its true nature remains hidden.
- 1:04:03There is something humbling and strangely intimate in this. Every
- 1:04:09atom in your body, every particle that makes you who
- 1:04:13you are, is a kind of survivor. It comes from
- 1:04:17that vanishingly thin sliver of matter that escaped the great
- 1:04:21annihilation at the beginning of time, the one part in
- 1:04:25a billion that was left standing when its mirror twin
- 1:04:29was already gone. The overwhelming majority of what the early
- 1:04:34universe created destroyed itself in those first moments and dissolved
- 1:04:40into light. You are made from the remainder. You are
- 1:04:44made from what was left when the mirror emptied. How
- 1:04:47quiet and how astonishing to be built from the tiniest
- 1:04:52imbalance at the beginning of everything, a survivor of a
- 1:04:56silent reckoning between matter and its shadow that was over
- 1:05:00before the first star ever shone to night. As you
- 1:05:04settle into the dark, you can hold that gently. You
- 1:05:08are here because, for reasons no one yet fully understands,
- 1:05:13the universe kept just a little more than it. Let
- 1:05:16go rest in that small surplus of being, that faint
- 1:05:21left over light made solid. Then let yourself drift softly
- 1:05:26towards sleep. A single particle can hold two opposite states
- 1:05:33at the very same time. In the every day world,
- 1:05:37things are one way or another. A coin lies heads
- 1:05:41or tails, a door is open or shut, a light
- 1:05:45is on or off. We never see a coin that
- 1:05:48is somehow both faces at once, or a door that
- 1:05:51is open and closed together. Our world is made of
- 1:05:55definite things, each one settled into a single, clear condition.
- 1:06:00But down in the realm of the very small, this
- 1:06:03comfortable rule quietly dissolves. A tiny particle can spin in
- 1:06:08one direction or in the other. That much sounds ordinary enough,
- 1:06:14But before you measure it, the particle does not have
- 1:06:16to choose. It can exist in a strange blend of
- 1:06:20both possibilities at once, spinning one way and the other
- 1:06:24way at the same time, held in a kind of
- 1:06:27shimmering mixture that has no everyday picture. Physicists call this
- 1:06:32a superposition. And it is not that the particle is
- 1:06:37secretly spinning one definite way and we simply do not
- 1:06:40know which. The mathematics and the experiments tell us something
- 1:06:45far stranger. The particle truly is in both states together,
- 1:06:50a living blend of possibilities, right up until the moment
- 1:06:54it is measured. Only then does it settle all at
- 1:06:58once into a single definite answer, one direction or the other,
- 1:07:04as though the very act of looking forces it to
- 1:07:07finally decide. This is one of the most thoroughly tested
- 1:07:12ideas in all of science. We rely upon it completely.
- 1:07:17The behavior of superposition lies at the heart of how
- 1:07:20adams hold together, how certain materials carry electricity, how the
- 1:07:26newest and strangest computers are beginning to be built. It
- 1:07:30is woven into the fabric of the small world, as
- 1:07:34real as anything we know, and yet it remains deeply,
- 1:07:39almost unbearably mysterious because of one simple and haunting question.
- 1:07:45Where does the small world end and the everyday world begin.
- 1:07:51A physicist named Erwin Schrodinger once dreamed up a thought
- 1:07:54experiment to lay this strangeness bare, and it has haunted
- 1:07:58the field ever since. Imagine, he said, a cat sealed
- 1:08:03inside a box. Inside the box is a single tiny
- 1:08:08particle of the kind that can exist in a superposition,
- 1:08:11poised between two states, and the box is arranged so
- 1:08:16that one of those states would, through a chain of events,
- 1:08:20release something harmful to the cat, while the other state
- 1:08:23would leave the cat safe and well. Now close the
- 1:08:27box and wait the particle unmeasured drifts into its superposition,
- 1:08:33both states at once. But the particle's two states are
- 1:08:37tied to the cat's fate. So if we take the
- 1:08:41mathematics at its plain word, the cat io should fall
- 1:08:44into a superposition both fates at once, the safe one
- 1:08:49in the other, held together in an impossible blend until
- 1:08:53someone opens the box and looks now. Schrodinger did not
- 1:08:58mean this as a true prediction about cats. He meant
- 1:09:02it as a kind of gentle alarm bell. Of course,
- 1:09:05we never open a box and find a cat hovering
- 1:09:08in some blurred mixture of two fates. We always find
- 1:09:12a single, definite cat in one clear condition. The cat
- 1:09:18is far too large, far too warm, far too tangled
- 1:09:22up with the air in the box and the whole
- 1:09:24wide world around it to hover in a delicate superposition.
- 1:09:29The shimmering blend collapses almost instantly at that scale, faster
- 1:09:34than thought, into a single ordinary reality. And yet the
- 1:09:39thought experiment points its quiet finger right at the heart
- 1:09:42of the puzzle. The tiny particle can truly be in
- 1:09:46both states at once. The cat cannot. So where exactly
- 1:09:52is the line at what size, at what point along
- 1:09:56the long path from a single particle to a living cat.
- 1:09:59Does the strange both at once world give way to
- 1:10:02the definite either or a world we live in? What
- 1:10:06counts as a measurement, the thing that forces possibility to
- 1:10:10settle into solid fact. This is the deep open question,
- 1:10:16and physicists do not agree on the answer. Some believe
- 1:10:20the superposition never truly collapses at all, and that every
- 1:10:25possibility goes on quietly existing, the world itself, branching so
- 1:10:31that each outcome happens somewhere. Some believe there is a
- 1:10:35real and definite collapse, perhaps triggered when enough of the
- 1:10:39world becomes involved, though no one can yet say precisely how,
- 1:10:44or where or why. We have learned to predict with
- 1:10:49flawless accuracy what we will measure, we have not learned
- 1:10:53what is truly happening in the moment a blur of
- 1:10:57possibility becomes a single, solid fact. The line between the
- 1:11:02two worlds is one of the great unsolved mysteries, hiding
- 1:11:07in plain sight, inside the most ordinary moment of looking.
- 1:11:12There is a soft wonder in carrying this thought with you.
- 1:11:16The solid, settled world you live in, where things are
- 1:11:20simply one way or another, may rest upon a deeper layer,
- 1:11:25where things hover gently between all their possibilities waiting. Every
- 1:11:30particle in your body can, in principle, hold many states
- 1:11:34at once. It is only in their countless togetherness, in
- 1:11:38the warm, dense weave of you, that the shimmer settles
- 1:11:42into the single, steady reality of a person resting in
- 1:11:46the dark. So let the question lie quietly beside you tonight,
- 1:11:52a tiny thing somewhere, spinning both ways at once, in
- 1:11:57the dark, holding all its possibilities of over the way
- 1:12:01the world itself seems to hold its breath in the
- 1:12:04moment before each moment becomes real. Let it rest, can
- 1:12:09let yourself rest with it gently all the way towards sleep.
- 1:12:17Our two greatest descriptions of reality flatly contradict each other.
- 1:12:22Over the last hundred years, physics built two towering achievements,
- 1:12:27two theories so successful, so precisely confirmed, that they stand
- 1:12:32among the finest things the human mind has ever made.
- 1:12:36Each one describes the world with breathtaking accuracy. Each one
- 1:12:41has been tested again and again and never once been
- 1:12:44found wrong. And yet deep down, the two of them
- 1:12:49tell stories about reality that simply cannot both be true.
- 1:12:54They are like two flawless maps of the same land
- 1:12:57that quietly disagree about its very shape. The first is
- 1:13:02the theory of the very large. It describes gravity and
- 1:13:06space and time on the grand scale of planets and
- 1:13:10stars and galaxies. In this picture, space and time are
- 1:13:15smooth and flowing, woven together into a single, gentle fabric.
- 1:13:20Massive things like stars and planets pressed down into that
- 1:13:25fabric and curve it the way a heavy ball would
- 1:13:29dimple a stretched sheet, and the curving of space is
- 1:13:33what we feel as gravity. The Earth circles the Sun
- 1:13:37not because of any pull on a string, but because
- 1:13:40it is gliding along a valley in the curved shape
- 1:13:43of space itself. This theory paints reality as graceful and continuous,
- 1:13:49a flowing landscape that bends and ripples orderly and serene,
- 1:13:55and it has passed every test we have ever devised,
- 1:13:58guiding our spacecraft to cross the Solar System and correctly
- 1:14:03predicting the faint ripples that spread through space when distant
- 1:14:07black holes collide. The second is the theory of the
- 1:14:12very small. It describes the world of atoms and the
- 1:14:16tiny particles within them, and down there reality wears an
- 1:14:21utterly different face. Nothing is smooth and nothing is certain.
- 1:14:26Particles flicker and jump, They hold many possibilities at once,
- 1:14:32and settle into one only when they are measured. The
- 1:14:36tiny world is grainy, restless, and ruled by chance rather
- 1:14:41than by graceful certainty. This theory, too, has passed every test,
- 1:14:47predicting the behavior of matter and light with a precision
- 1:14:51so exact it is almost beyond belief. It underlies very
- 1:14:55nearly all of our modern technology. It is, by some measure,
- 1:15:00the most successful theory ever written down. So we have
- 1:15:04one theory for the very large, smooth and flowing and orderly,
- 1:15:09and another for the very small, grainy and jittery and
- 1:15:13ruled by chance. And for most purposes this causes no
- 1:15:18trouble at all, because the two domains rarely meet. Gravity
- 1:15:22is far too weak to matter for a single tiny particle,
- 1:15:26and the strangeness of the small world averages quietly away
- 1:15:30long before you reach the scale of planets. Each theory
- 1:15:35rules its own country in peace, and we simply use
- 1:15:39whichever one fits the question before us. But there are
- 1:15:43places in the universe where the very large and the
- 1:15:46very small are forced together, where something enormously heavy is
- 1:15:52also crushed down to a vanishingly tiny size, the center
- 1:15:57of a black hole, where the corpse of a giant
- 1:16:00star is squeezed toward a single point, the very first
- 1:16:05instant of the universe, when everything that exists was packed
- 1:16:09smaller than an atom. In those extreme places, you need
- 1:16:14both theories at the very same time. You need to
- 1:16:18describe something both immensely heavy and unimaginably small. Where gravity
- 1:16:24and the quantum world cannot be kept apart. And when
- 1:16:28physicists try to do exactly that, to bring the two
- 1:16:32great theories together and ask what happens, the mathematics breaks down.
- 1:16:37The equations give nonsense. They produce infinities, answers that mean
- 1:16:44the theory has reached the limit of its understanding and
- 1:16:47can go no further. The two finest descriptions of reality
- 1:16:52we possess simply refuse to be joined. This is the
- 1:16:57great unfinished task at the very heart of physics. We
- 1:17:02do not yet have a single theory that can describe
- 1:17:06both the very large and the very small at once,
- 1:17:10a deeper picture beneath the two from which both of
- 1:17:13them would flow. We call the missing piece a theory
- 1:17:17of quantum gravity, and finding it has resisted the most
- 1:17:22brilliant minds for the better part of a century. There
- 1:17:26are bold attempts, and it is worth being honest about
- 1:17:30exactly where they stand. One famous idea imagines that the
- 1:17:35smallest pieces of reality are not points at all, but
- 1:17:39tiny vibrating threads, and that everything in existence arises from
- 1:17:44their music. Another imagines that space itself is not smooth,
- 1:17:49but woven from tiny, indivisible grains, a fabric with the
- 1:17:53finest possible weave. These are serious, beautiful, deeply worked out
- 1:17:59ideas pursued by gifted people for decades, but it must
- 1:18:04be said plainly that none of them has yet been
- 1:18:07confirmed by any experiment. They remain candidate theories, possible glimpses
- 1:18:13of the deeper truth, and not the answer itself. We
- 1:18:18are still searching for the one description of reality that
- 1:18:21holds true everywhere in the largest and the smallest things alike.
- 1:18:27There is something quietly stirring in this. It means that
- 1:18:31the universe, at its very deepest level, is still hidden
- 1:18:35from us. We hold two magnificent maps, each one flawless
- 1:18:41in its own country, and we have not yet found
- 1:18:44the single greater map, of which they are both only
- 1:18:47pieces somewhere Beneath the smooth, flowing space of the stars
- 1:18:53and the restless, grainy dance of the atoms, there is
- 1:18:56a deeper reality we have not yet learned to see,
- 1:19:00d waiting patiently for us to find the words for it.
- 1:19:05For tonight, you can simply let that mystery rest. The
- 1:19:10world is stranger and deeper than our finest theories can
- 1:19:14yet hold, And that is not a cause for worry,
- 1:19:17but a soft and open wonder. There is still so
- 1:19:21much waiting to be understood, and the universe keeps its
- 1:19:25deepest secret gently in no hurry to be known. Rest
- 1:19:29there in the vast, unfinished mystery of it, and let
- 1:19:33yourself drift towards sleep. Empty space is not truly empty.
- 1:19:41Imagine the emptiest place you possibly can. Not the air
- 1:19:46of a quiet room, which is thick with countless drifting molecules,
- 1:19:50but a true and perfect void. Take a sealed box
- 1:19:55and remove every speck of matter from inside it. Pump
- 1:19:58out all the air, every last atom, every particle of dust,
- 1:20:03shield it from all light and all radiation. Cool it
- 1:20:07down toward the very coldest temperature that nature allows. What
- 1:20:12is left inside, you might think is nothing at all.
- 1:20:16Perfect emptiness. A pure and silent void, still and featureless,
- 1:20:21holding nothing whatsoever. But that is not what the deepest
- 1:20:25physics tells us. According to our finest understanding of the
- 1:20:29small scale world, that perfect emptiness is not still, and
- 1:20:34it is not silent. It quietly seethes down at the
- 1:20:39smallest scales in what should be utterly empty space, tiny
- 1:20:43particles are ceaselessly flickering into being and vanishing again, appearing
- 1:20:49in fleeting pairs and dissolving back into nothing almost before
- 1:20:53they exist. The void churns with a restless, ghostly activity,
- 1:21:00a constant, faint boiling of particles too short lived to
- 1:21:04ever catch and hold, winking in and out faster than
- 1:21:07any clock could ever mark. The emptiness is alive, with
- 1:21:12a soft and ceaseless trembling, never quite at rest, never
- 1:21:16truly still. This sounds like the wildest kind of fantasy.
- 1:21:21How could anyone possibly know that empty space behaves this way?
- 1:21:25When these flickering particles vanish far too quickly to ever
- 1:21:29be caught, and yet we have measured its effects gently
- 1:21:35and unmistakably. Here is the most beautiful demonstration of all.
- 1:21:41Take two perfectly smooth plates and place them extremely close together.
- 1:21:46Facing each other in the void, almost but not quite touching.
- 1:21:52The restless trembling of empty space presses upon them from
- 1:21:56every side. But in the narrow gap between the two plates,
- 1:22:00only some of that trembling can fit, while outside them,
- 1:22:04the full restlessness of the void presses in. The result
- 1:22:09is a faint but real imbalance, a gentle pressure pushing
- 1:22:13the two plates together, arising from nothing at all but
- 1:22:17the seething of the empty space around them. This delicate
- 1:22:22push has been measured in the laboratory exactly as predicted.
- 1:22:27The emptiness, it turns out, can exert a force. Nothing
- 1:22:31can push upon something. The void leans quietly on the world.
- 1:22:37Sit with that for a moment. The most perfect emptiness
- 1:22:41you could ever make is not a quiet absence, but
- 1:22:44a quiet presence, a humming, trembling sea that fills all
- 1:22:49of space, even the space inside your own body, even
- 1:22:53the vast dark reaches between the stars. There is no
- 1:22:57true nothing anywhere. Beneath the very floor of reality. There
- 1:23:01is always this faint, restless shimmer, the lowest possible state
- 1:23:06of the world, And even at its very lowest, it
- 1:23:10is never wholly silent. And here the deep mystery opens.
- 1:23:15If even empty space carries the ceaseless trembling, then empty
- 1:23:20space must carry energy, the energy of all that flickering
- 1:23:24and stirring. So physicists tried to calculate how much energy
- 1:23:29is held within the emptiness, how much this restless shimmer
- 1:23:34of the voiage should weigh when you add it all up,
- 1:23:38And the answer that comes out of our theories is
- 1:23:41one of the strangest and most troubling numbers in all
- 1:23:44of science. By the most natural reckoning, the energy of
- 1:23:49empty space should be enormous, almost unimaginably vast. Yet when
- 1:23:56we look at the actual universe and measure the true
- 1:24:00energy of the emptiness, we find it is extraordinarily small,
- 1:24:05fainter than our calculation by a margin so staggering it
- 1:24:09is hard to even express in words. Our best theory
- 1:24:13of the trembling void and our actual measurement of it
- 1:24:17disagree by one of the largest gaps between prediction and
- 1:24:20reality ever found. Something is deeply missing from our understanding
- 1:24:26of what the emptiness truly is and what it holds,
- 1:24:30and no one yet knows what. There is a quiet
- 1:24:33awe in this, deeper even than the puzzle itself. We
- 1:24:38tend to think of nothingness, as simple as the easy default,
- 1:24:43the plain, blank backdrop against which all the interesting things happen.
- 1:24:48And then we look closely and discover that nothing may
- 1:24:51be the most mysterious thing of all. That the empty
- 1:24:55space cradling every star and every atom, is restless and
- 1:25:00alive and full, trembling with an energy we can feel
- 1:25:05but cannot explain, hiding a secret about reality that has
- 1:25:09eluded our very finest minds. Right now, all around you,
- 1:25:15in the dark of the room and the dark between
- 1:25:17the stars, the void is gently trembling. The emptiest emptiness
- 1:25:23there could ever be, is quietly humming with the faintest
- 1:25:26of activity, never fully still, never fully silent, holding the
- 1:25:31world up softly from beneath. It asks for nothing and
- 1:25:35explains nothing, and simply is the soft, restless ground of everything.
- 1:25:42Let that gentle hum of the emptiness hold you now.
- 1:25:46There is no true silence and no true stillness anywhere,
- 1:25:50only the faint, endless shimmer of the void, cradling all things,
- 1:25:54including you, As you drift quietly down into sleep. A
- 1:26:02choice made in the present can seem to reach back
- 1:26:06and shape what a particle did in the past. To
- 1:26:10feel the strangeness of this picture. A single particle of
- 1:26:14light setting out on a journey. It comes to a fork,
- 1:26:19a place where it might travel along one of two
- 1:26:22paths to reach a final detector. Now, there is a
- 1:26:27deep and well tested fact about the small world. If
- 1:26:31you set things up so that you can tell which
- 1:26:34path the particle took, it behaves like a simple little speck,
- 1:26:38choosing one road and traveling quietly along it. But if
- 1:26:43you set things up so that the two paths blend
- 1:26:47together at the end, with no way to know which
- 1:26:50one it followed, the particle behaves like a spread out wave, somehow,
- 1:26:56traveling both roads at once and rippling against itself when
- 1:27:00they meet. The way you choose to look decides which
- 1:27:05face the particle shows you that much is strange enough,
- 1:27:09and it has been confirmed countless times. But here a
- 1:27:13brilliant physicist named John Wheeler asked a question that turns
- 1:27:17the strangeness inward. What if you wait? What if you
- 1:27:23let the particle pass the fork first, let it already
- 1:27:27be well on its way, committed to its journey, and
- 1:27:31only then, at the very last instant, decide how you're
- 1:27:35going to look at it. The particle has already gone
- 1:27:38by the place where it would have had to choose.
- 1:27:43If it were going to behave like a single speck
- 1:27:46on one road, surely it has already done so. If
- 1:27:51it were going to behave like a wave on both roads,
- 1:27:54surely that is already underway. The particle cannot know what
- 1:28:00you will decide, because you have not decided yet. So
- 1:28:04what happens. This was not only a thought. The experiment
- 1:28:08has actually been done in careful and ingenious ways, with
- 1:28:13the choice delayed until after the particle has passed the fork,
- 1:28:17and the result is the same as ever. When the
- 1:28:21late choice is made to reveal the path, the particle
- 1:28:24is found to have behaved like a single speck on
- 1:28:27one road, as though it had committed to that all along.
- 1:28:32When the late choice is made to blend the paths,
- 1:28:35the particle is found to have behaved like a wave
- 1:28:39on both roads, as though that too had been true
- 1:28:42from the very start. The particle's past behavior seems to
- 1:28:48match a decision that was not made until after that
- 1:28:51past was already over. It is almost as if the
- 1:28:56present choice reaches gently backward and settles what the particle
- 1:29:01was doing after the fact. Now this is the point
- 1:29:07where we must be careful and honest, because it is
- 1:29:10easy to leap to a wild conclusion and say that
- 1:29:13we are changing the past or sending messages backward through time.
- 1:29:18Most physicists believe the truth is stranger and subtler than that.
- 1:29:24The deepest lesson seems to be this, the particle never
- 1:29:28had a definite story to begin with. Before the measurement.
- 1:29:32There simply was no hidden fact about which road it took.
- 1:29:37It is not that the particle secretly chose a path
- 1:29:40and we later forced it to change. It is that
- 1:29:43the path was never a settled thing at all, not
- 1:29:47even to the particle, until the moment the world finally asked.
- 1:29:53The measurement does not rewrite a fixed history. It is
- 1:29:57the very act that brings a definite history in being,
- 1:30:01reaching back to fill in a story that was until
- 1:30:04then genuinely open. Sit with how deeply this unsettles our
- 1:30:10ordinary sense of time. We tend to imagine the past
- 1:30:14as a finished thing, carved in stone, complete in every detail.
- 1:30:19Whether or not anyone ever looks, the delayed choice whispers
- 1:30:24that down at the smallest scales, this may not be
- 1:30:27so that some of what we call the past may
- 1:30:31remain soft and unsettled, a story not yet fully written
- 1:30:36until the present moment reaches back and gives it a
- 1:30:39definite shape. The line between what has happened and what
- 1:30:43is happening may be far less solid than it feels.
- 1:30:48We do not fully understand what this means. The mathematics
- 1:30:52once again predicts every result perfectly, and physicists agree completely
- 1:30:58on what the experiments will do show, But the picture
- 1:31:01of reality behind it, the true relationship between the present
- 1:31:05and the past, at the very deepest level, remains a
- 1:31:09quiet and genuine mystery, argued over by thoughtful people to
- 1:31:14this very day. There is something almost dream like in it.
- 1:31:19In a dream, the past can rearrange itself to fit
- 1:31:23the present, and you do not notice the seams. The
- 1:31:27delayed choice hints that the waking world, in its smallest
- 1:31:32and most hidden workings, may carry a faint echo of
- 1:31:36that same softness, a place where the present and the
- 1:31:40past are gently woven together, rather than fixed one before
- 1:31:44the other. So let that strange and gentle thought rest
- 1:31:48with you now, a single particle of light far away,
- 1:31:54its journey not yet quite decided, waiting in a kind
- 1:31:57of open quiet, for the world to look and make
- 1:31:59it real. Let the past stay soft for a moment,
- 1:32:04Let this present moment be enough, and drift gently towards sleep.
- 1:32:13Time does not pass at the same rate for everyone.
- 1:32:17This is not a feeling or a figure of speech.
- 1:32:20It is one of the most thoroughly proven facts in
- 1:32:23all of physics. The faster you move through space, the
- 1:32:28more slowly time passes for you compared to someone standing still,
- 1:32:34and the closer you are to something very heavy like
- 1:32:37a planet or a star, the more slowly your time runs.
- 1:32:41As well, time is not a single, steady drum beat
- 1:32:45that the whole universe marches to. It is more like
- 1:32:49a soft and flexible thing, stretching and shrinking depending on
- 1:32:54how you move and where you happen to be. The
- 1:32:57differences are far too tiny to notice in everyday life,
- 1:33:01which is exactly why time feels so absolute to us.
- 1:33:06But they are real, and we have measured them with
- 1:33:09exquisite care. Take two perfectly matched clocks ticking in perfect step,
- 1:33:17Place one on a fast flying aircraft and send it
- 1:33:20around the world, and leave the other resting quietly on
- 1:33:24the ground. When the traveling clock comes home, it will
- 1:33:28be found to have ticked a little less than the
- 1:33:30one that stayed behind just a tiny fraction of a second,
- 1:33:35but exactly the amount predicted. The moving clock truly aged less.
- 1:33:42Time itself ran a little more slowly for it. We
- 1:33:46rely on this strange truth every single day, often without
- 1:33:51ever knowing it. High above your head, satellite circle the Earth,
- 1:33:56helping the small device in your pocket know exactly where
- 1:33:59you are. Those satellites move quickly, and they sit far
- 1:34:04from the heavy pull of the Earth, so their clocks
- 1:34:08run at a slightly different rate than clocks down here
- 1:34:11on the ground. The difference is small, but if engineers
- 1:34:17did not carefully account for it, the location on your
- 1:34:21screen would drift further and further from the truth with
- 1:34:25every passing hour. The gentle stretching of time is built
- 1:34:30right into the quiet machinery of modern life. But here's
- 1:34:35where it grows truly strange and touches the very nature
- 1:34:39of reality. Because time can run at different rates for
- 1:34:43different people, the simple idea of now, of this single
- 1:34:48present moment shared by the whole universe, quietly falls apart.
- 1:34:53Imagine two events happening far away from each other, two
- 1:34:57distant flashes of light to w one person moving in
- 1:35:01one direction the two flashes happen at exactly the same instant,
- 1:35:07perfectly together, but to another person moving differently, those very
- 1:35:13same two flashes happen one after the other with a
- 1:35:16clear gap between them, and neither person is wrong. There
- 1:35:20is no master clock, no view from above that can
- 1:35:24settle which of them is truly right. They simply have
- 1:35:28different nows, both equally real, both equally valid. Let that
- 1:35:34quietly sink in your now, in the now of a
- 1:35:37distant traveler, need not agree. Two people can disagree about
- 1:35:43whether two things happened at the same time, then there
- 1:35:46is no deeper truth that decides between them. The present moment,
- 1:35:52which feels so solid and so universal, so obviously the
- 1:35:57same everywhere, turns out to be a local personal to
- 1:36:01your own motion and your own place in the cosmos.
- 1:36:06The universe has no single shared instant ticking through all
- 1:36:10of it at once. It has countless overlapping nows woven
- 1:36:15together into something far richer and stranger than the simple,
- 1:36:19flowing present. We feel some thinkers have followed this idea
- 1:36:23to a startling place. If there is no universal now,
- 1:36:29no single moment that the whole universe agrees is the present,
- 1:36:33then perhaps the past and the future are in some
- 1:36:37sense just as real as this moment. Perhaps all moments
- 1:36:42simply exist, laid out together in the vast fabric of
- 1:36:46space and time, And the feeling that only now is real,
- 1:36:50that the past has vanished and the future has not
- 1:36:54yet come, is something that belongs to us, to the
- 1:36:57way our minds travel through the world, rather than to
- 1:37:01the world itself. This is a real and serious interpretation
- 1:37:06debated by physicists and philosophers alike, though it remains a
- 1:37:11matter of deep argument and not settled fact. We know
- 1:37:15that time bends and stretches, and that now is not universal.
- 1:37:20What this finally tells us about the true nature of past, present,
- 1:37:24and future is still an open and beautiful question. There
- 1:37:29is a strange comfort hidden in all of this. The
- 1:37:34moment you are in right now, this quiet moment as
- 1:37:37you rest, is genuinely your own. It is shaped by
- 1:37:41your own gentle motion through the universe, your own place
- 1:37:45among the stars. No one else anywhere in the cosmos
- 1:37:49shares exactly your now. It belongs to you alone. So
- 1:37:53let your now be soft and unhurried. Let time stretch
- 1:37:58out gently around you the way it truly can slowing
- 1:38:03and easing as you grow still. There is no masterclock.
- 1:38:07You must keep pace, with no single instant rushing the
- 1:38:11whole universe along. There is only this moment, your moment, quietly,
- 1:38:17your own, as you drift away towards sleep. No one
- 1:38:23knows whether space can be cut into smaller and smaller
- 1:38:27pieces forever, or whether it has the smallest possible grain.
- 1:38:32Think of any small distance, the width of a single hair,
- 1:38:36then half of that, then half again. In the ordinary
- 1:38:41world of our imagination, there seems to be no end
- 1:38:45to this. You can always, in your mind cut a
- 1:38:48distance in half, and then in half once more, on
- 1:38:51and on, without limit, into ever tinier slivers of space.
- 1:38:56Space feels perfectly smooth and endlessly visible, a continuous expanse
- 1:39:02with no smallest step, Like a line. You could keep
- 1:39:06magnifying forever and always find more line weighting. This is
- 1:39:12how we usually picture the world, and it is how
- 1:39:14our most successful theory of space and time describes it.
- 1:39:19A smooth, flowing fabric, divisible without end. But there is
- 1:39:25good reason to wonder whether this comfortable picture holds all
- 1:39:29the way down. When physicists combine their deepest ideas about
- 1:39:34gravity with their deepest ideas about the quantum world of
- 1:39:38the very small, a curious number emerges. It is a
- 1:39:43length so unimaginably tiny that it strains the mind to
- 1:39:47even speak of it. Compared to this length, a single
- 1:39:51atom is as vast as the whole Solar system is
- 1:39:54to you, And there is reason to think that at
- 1:39:58this scale something strange begins to happen. To the very
- 1:40:02idea of distance, the smooth fabric of space may begin
- 1:40:06to come apart, the notion of a definite, ever shrinking
- 1:40:10length may stop making sense. Some physicists suspect that this
- 1:40:16tiny length may be a kind of floor, a smallest
- 1:40:20meaningful distance below which the question of where exactly is
- 1:40:25no longer something the universe can even answer. If that
- 1:40:30were true, it would mean that space is not the
- 1:40:33smooth and endless thing it appears to be, but something
- 1:40:37with the finest possible weave, a texture, almost a faint graininess,
- 1:40:43far too small for us to ever see directly. Reality
- 1:40:49at its very deepest level might have something a little
- 1:40:52like the smallest pieces of a picture, a limit to
- 1:40:56how finely the world can ever be divided. The continuous
- 1:41:00flowing space we imagine would then be only how things
- 1:41:04look from far above, the way a smooth sweep of
- 1:41:09sand on a beach is really made of countless separate
- 1:41:12grains when you bring your eye close enough. But and
- 1:41:17this is the heart of it, we do not know.
- 1:41:20This is a genuine and wide open question. We cannot
- 1:41:24reach down to that unimaginably tiny scale with any instrument
- 1:41:28we have, or any instrument we can yet imagine building.
- 1:41:33To probe such a length directly would take energies so
- 1:41:36enormous they are utterly beyond us. So we are left
- 1:41:40an honest uncertainty about one of the most basic features
- 1:41:44of the world. Is space smooth, divisible forever, with no
- 1:41:49smallest step, or is it grainy, woven from tiniest threads,
- 1:41:55with a true floor beneath all distance. Our finest theory
- 1:42:00give us hints in both directions, and they do not
- 1:42:03yet agree, And no experiment has settled it. We simply
- 1:42:08do not know whether reality at the very bottom is
- 1:42:12endlessly smooth or finely grained. Pause for a moment over
- 1:42:18how remarkable that is. You move through space. Every day,
- 1:42:23you reach across a room, you feel distances with your
- 1:42:26whole body. You cross the gentle gaps between things without
- 1:42:30a second thought. Space is the most familiar thing. There
- 1:42:34is the very stage on which your whole life unfolds,
- 1:42:39And yet we do not truly know what it is
- 1:42:41made of, or whether it is made of anything at all,
- 1:42:46or whether the smoothness we feel goes all the way
- 1:42:49down or gives way far beneath our seeing to something
- 1:42:53with the smallest possible step. There is a quiet wonder
- 1:42:58in holding a question this deep about something this near.
- 1:43:02The space around you tonight, the soft dark air of
- 1:43:05the room, the small distance between you and the ceiling,
- 1:43:09the vast distances out to the stars. All of it
- 1:43:12may be perfectly smooth, an endless, seamless expanse. Or all
- 1:43:18of it may be woven at a scale far too
- 1:43:21fine to ever feel, from the tiniest grains of reality,
- 1:43:25a fabric with the finest possible thread. We do not
- 1:43:30yet know which world we live in, and somehow that
- 1:43:33does not trouble the resting body at all. The space
- 1:43:36around you holds you just the same, smooth or grained,
- 1:43:40while the question waits, patient and unhurried, for some far
- 1:43:45off day. Let that gentle uncertainty settle over you. Now,
- 1:43:51the very space that cradles you, so familiar and so near,
- 1:43:55keeping its deepest secret softly, neither smooth nor grained, until
- 1:44:00we someday learn to ask it properly, Rest within it,
- 1:44:04whatever it is, and let yourself drift down towards sleep.
- 1:44:11Ideas dreamed up in quiet rooms with no thought at
- 1:44:15all of the stars keep turning out to describe the
- 1:44:19universe with uncanny precision. Here is one of the strangest
- 1:44:24facts about reality, and it is so familiar that we
- 1:44:27rarely stop to feel how strange it truly is. The
- 1:44:32universe runs on mathematics. The motions of the planets, the
- 1:44:37falling of an apple, the flow of heat, the bending
- 1:44:40of light, the behavior of the very tiniest particles. All
- 1:44:45of it follows patterns that can be captured in clean
- 1:44:48and elegant equations. The world is not a chaos. It
- 1:44:52is deeply, almost suspiciously mathematical, and the deeper we look,
- 1:45:00the more mathematical it turns out to be. Now, you
- 1:45:04might think this is simply because we invented our mathematics
- 1:45:08to fit the world, like tailoring a coat to a
- 1:45:10body we could already see, and there is some truth
- 1:45:14in that. But the truly astonishing thing is how often
- 1:45:19it happens the other way around, again and again. Mathematicians
- 1:45:24have explored ideas purely for their own beauty, chasing patterns
- 1:45:30with no thought of the real world at all, following
- 1:45:33their curiosity down quiet abstract paths, and then sometimes decades
- 1:45:40or even centuries later, those very ideas turn out to
- 1:45:44be exactly the language the universe was speaking all along.
- 1:45:49Consider a strange kind of number that mathematicians once dreamed
- 1:45:53up almost as a game, a number that seemed to
- 1:45:56have no place in the real world, treated for a
- 1:45:59very long time as little more than a curious abstraction.
- 1:46:04Centuries later, that very idea turned out to lie at
- 1:46:08the very heart of how the smallest particles behave woven
- 1:46:13into the deepest equations of the quantum world. It was
- 1:46:17as though the universe had been waiting patiently for us
- 1:46:22to invent the right idea so that we could finally
- 1:46:25read what was already written. Consider too, the curved and
- 1:46:31bending geometries that mathematicians once worked out purely in their imaginations,
- 1:46:37geometries of warped and twisted space that seemed to describe
- 1:46:42nothing real at all, And then long afterward, those same
- 1:46:47strange geometries became the perfect language for describing how gravity
- 1:46:52bends space and time around the stars. Even more wondrous
- 1:46:57are the times when the mathemathematics ran ahead of us
- 1:47:01and pointed to things no one had ever seen. There
- 1:47:05have been moments when a physicist, simply following the equations
- 1:47:09where they led, trusting the mathematics over plane intuition, found
- 1:47:14that the equations insisted on the existence of something entirely unknown,
- 1:47:20a new kind of particle, a faint ripple in space itself.
- 1:47:26And when sometimes many years later, people finally went looking,
- 1:47:30the unknown thing was truly there, exactly as the mathematics
- 1:47:35had promised. The equations knew before we did. The universe
- 1:47:41agreed with the abstract symbols on the page. This is
- 1:47:45what one great physicist called the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics.
- 1:47:53Unreasonable because there is no obvious reason it should work
- 1:47:57so well. Why should the universe care about the elegant
- 1:48:01patterns that human minds happen to find beautiful? Why should reality,
- 1:48:07the hard physical world of matter and energy and space,
- 1:48:11bend itself so faithfully to the abstract dreams of mathematics.
- 1:48:16A thing that seems to live in the mind rather
- 1:48:18than out in the world. Nobody knows. It is one
- 1:48:23of the deepest and quietest mysteries. There is hiding behind
- 1:48:27every equation that has ever turned out to be true,
- 1:48:32and it opens onto an even older question, one that
- 1:48:36thinkers have turned over for thousands of years. When a
- 1:48:40mathematician discovers a new truth, are they inventing it, building
- 1:48:45something new out of the workings of the human mind,
- 1:48:50or are they discovering it, uncovering something that was somehow
- 1:48:54already there true all along, waiting to be found as
- 1:48:59real in its own quiet way, as a distant mountain
- 1:49:03or a hidden star. When we find that a piece
- 1:49:06of mathematics describes the world, does that mean mathematics is
- 1:49:11woven into the very fabric of reality, part of what
- 1:49:15the universe most deeply is. Or is it a reflection
- 1:49:19of how our own minds are built, a pattern we
- 1:49:22cannot help but paint across everything we see. These are
- 1:49:27real and open questions argued over by brilliant people, and
- 1:49:32they have no settled answer. There is a deep and
- 1:49:35gentle wonder in this. It means that when you do
- 1:49:39a simple sum or trace a curve, or feel the
- 1:49:43quiet rightness of a clean and elegant pattern. You may
- 1:49:47be brushing up against something that runs all the way
- 1:49:50down to the foundations of reality. The same quiet order
- 1:49:56that guides the planets in their courses and binds the
- 1:49:59atoms in your body may be the very order that
- 1:50:03a child feels when they first sense that numbers fit
- 1:50:06together just so. The universe and the mind meeting in
- 1:50:12the language of mathematics for reasons no one fully understands.
- 1:50:18So let that quiet mystery rest beside you now, a
- 1:50:22universe that speaks in elegant patterns and a mind that
- 1:50:26can somehow read them, woven together in a harmony far
- 1:50:30deeper than we know how to explain. You do not
- 1:50:34need to solve it tonight. You only need to feel
- 1:50:38softly the gentle order beneath all things, holding the stars
- 1:50:42and the atoms and your own resting breath in the
- 1:50:46same quiet pattern as you drift away towards sleep. When
- 1:50:54something falls into a black hole, the deepest laws of
- 1:50:58physics insist it cannot truly vanish, and yet it seems
- 1:51:02to vanish completely. A black hole is the strangest object
- 1:51:08in the universe. It is what can remain when a
- 1:51:11giant star collapses at the end of its long life,
- 1:51:14crushing itself down under its own immense weight into something
- 1:51:19so dense that not even light can escape its grip.
- 1:51:23Around it lies an invisible boundary, a point of no return.
- 1:51:28Anything that drifts across that boundary, any speck of light,
- 1:51:32any wandering atom, any object at all, is pulled inexorably
- 1:51:37inward and can never come back out from the outside.
- 1:51:41Things simply fall in and are gone, swallowed into a
- 1:51:45darkness from which no signal ever returns. For a long time,
- 1:51:51black holes were thought to be perfectly eternally black. Whatever
- 1:51:56fell in was lost forever, and the black hole itself
- 1:51:59would simply sit there, unchanging for all of time. But
- 1:52:04then a brilliant physicist named Stephen Hawking discovered something that
- 1:52:09changed everything. Using the strange rules of the quantum world,
- 1:52:15he showed that black holes are not entirely black after all.
- 1:52:19They glow, ever so faintly, with a feeble warmth leaking
- 1:52:24out from just outside their edge. And because they glow,
- 1:52:28they slowly lose their energy over spans of time almost
- 1:52:33beyond imagining, far longer than the present age of the universe.
- 1:52:38A black hole will very gradually shrink, fading away, until
- 1:52:42at last it has gone entirely evaporated into that faint
- 1:52:47and patient glow. And here the deep trouble begins. Think
- 1:52:52of everything that fell into the black hole over its
- 1:52:55long life, all the matter, all the light, all the
- 1:52:59intricate detail of whatever it's swallowed. In our deepest understanding
- 1:53:05of the quantum world, there is a sacred principle, almost
- 1:53:09a law. Beneath the laws, information is never truly destroyed.
- 1:53:14The precise details of how things are arranged may be
- 1:53:17scrambled beyond all recognition, but in principle they are always preserved,
- 1:53:23never wholly erased. The story of what a thing was
- 1:53:28can always, in principle, be traced. But when a black
- 1:53:32hole slowly evaporates and finally disappears, what becomes of all
- 1:53:37the information about everything that fell inside? The faint glow
- 1:53:43that leaks out seems to carry no trace of it,
- 1:53:47no memory of what was swallowed. And when the black
- 1:53:50hole is gone, that information appears to be gone, with it,
- 1:53:54erased from reality completely. The black hole seems to break
- 1:54:00the deepest rule there is. This is the black hole
- 1:54:04information paradox. And it has troubled the finest minds in
- 1:54:09physics for half a century. On one side stands our
- 1:54:13understanding of black holes in gravity, which seems to say
- 1:54:17the information is lost. On the other stands our understanding
- 1:54:22of the quantum world, which says information can never be lost.
- 1:54:27Both have been tested and trusted. Both cannot be wholly right.
- 1:54:33Something in our deepest picture of reality must give way,
- 1:54:37and for a very long time no one could see how.
- 1:54:40In recent years there has been real and exciting progress,
- 1:54:45and it is worth being honest about exactly where things stand.
- 1:54:51Many physicists now believe, with growing confidence, that the information
- 1:54:56is not truly lost after all, that it must somehow
- 1:55:00be subtly encoded in that faint, escaping glow, carried out
- 1:55:05of the black hole, in a form so scrambled that
- 1:55:08we cannot yet read it. Clever. New mathematics has begun
- 1:55:12to suggest how this might work, hinting at deep and
- 1:55:16surprising connections woven through the very fabric of space. But
- 1:55:21the full picture is far from settled. Exactly how the
- 1:55:26information escapes, exactly what happens at the boundary and deep within,
- 1:55:31exactly how to bring our two great theories into harmony.
- 1:55:35Here remains genuinely unresolved. We sense that the paradox is
- 1:55:41pointing us towards something profound about the true nature of
- 1:55:45space and gravity and information itself, but we have not
- 1:55:50yet fully grasped what it is. There is something quietly
- 1:55:54humbling in this. A black hole is, in a way
- 1:55:59the universe verse pushed to its most extreme gravity, taken
- 1:56:03to its very furthest linet, and there at that edge,
- 1:56:08two of our deepest truths collide and cannot both stand
- 1:56:13the puzzle of what happens to a single speck of
- 1:56:15light as it falls into the dark, turns out to
- 1:56:18touch the very foundations of reality, and to hint that
- 1:56:22space and information may be far more deeply entwined than
- 1:56:26we ever imagined. So picture it gently now, a black
- 1:56:31hole far across the cosmos, glowing with the faintest imaginable warmth,
- 1:56:36slowly and patiently releasing back into the universe over unimaginable
- 1:56:41ages the secrets of everything it ever swallowed, Nothing truly lost,
- 1:56:47perhaps only hidden, only scrambled, only waiting in a form
- 1:56:52we cannot yet read. Let that quiet thought hold you,
- 1:56:57even at the darkest edge of all the universe may
- 1:57:00forget nothing, Rest in that gentle possibility, and let yourself
- 1:57:05drift towards sleep. Everything inside a region of space may
- 1:57:13be fully written upon its distant outer surface. This is
- 1:57:17one of the strangest ideas in all of modern physics,
- 1:57:21and to feel its strangeness, imagine a great glass sphere
- 1:57:26with a whole little world inside it. Stars and planets,
- 1:57:30perhaps drifting in the space within. Now here's the startling thought.
- 1:57:36According to a serious and influential idea in physics, everything
- 1:57:41happening inside that sphere, every star, every motion, every last
- 1:57:47detail of the three dimensional world within, could be completely
- 1:57:51captured by information painted only on the two dimensional surface
- 1:57:56of the sphere, the thin skin at its edge. Not
- 1:58:00a rough sketch or a faded shadow, but a complete
- 1:58:04and perfect description. Holding every last detail of the rich
- 1:58:09interior written entirely on the boundary. The inside and its
- 1:58:15distant surface would be two ways of telling the very
- 1:58:18same story. If this sounds impossible, you are in good company,
- 1:58:24for it surprised the very physicists who first stumbled upon it.
- 1:58:29The idea grew strangely enough, out of the study of
- 1:58:33black holes, when physicists worked out how much hidden complexity
- 1:58:38a black hole can hold how much information can be
- 1:58:41swallowed into one. They expected the answer to depend on
- 1:58:45its volume, on how much room there is inside, the
- 1:58:50way the number of things you can fit in a
- 1:58:52box depends on how big the box is, But that
- 1:58:57is not what they found. The amount of informationation a
- 1:59:00black hole can hold turned out to depend instead on
- 1:59:04its surface area, on the size of its boundary, and
- 1:59:08not on the space within. It was as though all
- 1:59:12the information were somehow stored on the surface, spread across
- 1:59:16the edge, rather than filling the interior. This was a
- 1:59:22deep and unexpected clue, and it suggested something general and profound,
- 1:59:28that perhaps, for any region of space at all, the
- 1:59:31true accounting of everything inside is written upon its surface.
- 1:59:36From this grew what physicists call the holographic principle. The
- 1:59:42name comes from those shimmering images we call holograms, flat
- 1:59:47surfaces that nonetheless contain a full three dimensional scene, springing
- 1:59:53into depth when the light catches them. Just so. The
- 1:59:57idea is that reality itself might work in something like
- 2:00:01this way, that the three dimensional world we feel all
- 2:00:06around us, with all its depth and volume and solidity,
- 2:00:10might in some deep sense be encoded on a distant
- 2:00:13two dimensional surface, the way a hologram blooms into depth
- 2:00:18from a flat sheet, the world you move through, the
- 2:00:22room around you, the reach of space out to the
- 2:00:25stars might be a kind of projection, a rich inner
- 2:00:29story whose complete telling lives on a faraway boundary. Now
- 2:00:35it is very important to be honest and clear about
- 2:00:39what this is. The holographic principle is a theory, a
- 2:00:43deep and serious and influential idea, but not a proven
- 2:00:48fact about our universe. In certain, carefully constructed imaginary universes,
- 2:00:55ones with shapes and rules a little different from our own,
- 2:00:59physicists have been able to show this idea working with
- 2:01:02great mathematical precision, a complete world inside perfectly mirrored by
- 2:01:08a description living on its boundary. These results are real
- 2:01:13and remarkable, and they have taught us a great deal.
- 2:01:18But whether our own universe truly works this way, whether
- 2:01:22our reality is genuinely written on some distant surface, remains
- 2:01:27an open question, a profound possibility, rather than an established truth.
- 2:01:33It is offered here as one of the most intriguing
- 2:01:36ideas at the frontier of physics, not as something we
- 2:01:40know to be so, And yet even held as a possibility,
- 2:01:46it stirs something deep. It hints that our sense of
- 2:01:50the world as solid and three dimensional, with real depth
- 2:01:54and real volume, might be a kind of beautiful appearance,
- 2:01:58and that the deeper truth of reality might live in
- 2:02:02fewer dimensions than we feel, on a surface we can
- 2:02:05never reach and have never seen. The very thickness of
- 2:02:10the world, the realness of space stretching away in every direction,
- 2:02:15might be in some sense a projection from a thinner
- 2:02:20and more fundamental reality. There is a gentle and dreamlike
- 2:02:25wonder in holding this thought lightly as the kind of
- 2:02:30thing we do not yet know. That the depth of
- 2:02:34the room around you, the distance out to the night sky,
- 2:02:38the whole rich volume of the world you live in,
- 2:02:41might be a story whose truest telling lies somewhere far away,
- 2:02:46on a surface, at the edge of everything, shining quietly
- 2:02:50with the full description of all that is. We do
- 2:02:54not know if it is so, but it is wondrous
- 2:02:57even to wonder. So let that soft, strange possibility rest
- 2:03:03beside you now, a world that feels so solid and
- 2:03:07so deep, perhaps written all the while on a distant
- 2:03:11shining edge, like light blooming into depth from a flat
- 2:03:15and gentle surface. Rest in the rich, apparent depth of
- 2:03:18this quiet moment, whatever its deepest nature, and let yourself
- 2:03:23drift away towards sleep. We cannot entirely rule out that
- 2:03:30the reality around us is a kind of vast computation.
- 2:03:35This is the most speculative thought in our whole gentle wandering,
- 2:03:39and it must be held the most lightly of all,
- 2:03:43for there is no evidence whatsoever that it is true.
- 2:03:47But it is a thought that serious people have taken seriously,
- 2:03:51and it carries a quiet strangeness worth resting in for
- 2:03:55a moment as the night grows deep. The idea is
- 2:03:59simply this, could everything you see and feel, the whole
- 2:04:04rich world around you be something like an extraordinarily detailed simulation,
- 2:04:11a reality computed rather than built, running on some unimaginable
- 2:04:17machine in a world beyond our own. The reasoning behind
- 2:04:21it goes something like this, and it is more careful
- 2:04:24than it might first sound. Imagine a future, perhaps very
- 2:04:29far away, in which it becomes possible to build computers
- 2:04:33of almost unthinkable power, machines so capable that they could
- 2:04:38simulate entire worlds in perfect detail, complete with beings inside
- 2:04:44them who feel and think and wonder, never once suspecting
- 2:04:48that their reality is computed. If such a thing were
- 2:04:52ever truly possible, the argument goes, then there might one
- 2:04:56day be a great many such simulated world, far more
- 2:05:01of them than there are original ones, each teeming with
- 2:05:05minds who believe their world is the true and first reality.
- 2:05:10And if simulated minds came to vastly outnumber the real ones,
- 2:05:16then a thinking being, knowing nothing more, might wonder whether
- 2:05:20the odds favored its own world being one of the
- 2:05:24many simulations rather than the single original. It is a
- 2:05:29strange and slippery line of thought, and people argue about
- 2:05:33every step of it. But it is not foolish, and
- 2:05:36it cannot be easily brushed aside. Now, let us be
- 2:05:40very clear and very honest, because this matters. There is
- 2:05:45no evidence at all that our world is a simulation,
- 2:05:49none whatsoever. This is a philosophical possibility, a thought experiment,
- 2:05:55an idea at the very edge of what can be
- 2:05:57reasoned about. It is not a scientific finding, and it
- 2:06:02may be that it never can be won. Some have
- 2:06:06wondered whether a simulated world might show faint cracks, tiny flaws,
- 2:06:11or limits in the fabric of reality, where the computation
- 2:06:15showed through, and a few have even gone looking for
- 2:06:18such things, But nothing of the kind has ever been found,
- 2:06:23and our reality appears seamless and whole, as deep and
- 2:06:27as detailed as we have ever been able to probe.
- 2:06:32The idea remains pure speculation, offered here not as a truth,
- 2:06:37but as a curiosity, a place where physics and imagination
- 2:06:42brush jently against each other in the dark. And yet
- 2:06:46there is something worth feeling in it, even held this lightly,
- 2:06:51for whether or not our world is computed, the deeper
- 2:06:54question it raises is real and old and beautiful. How
- 2:06:59do you know that the world around you as truly
- 2:07:02as it seems? What is it that makes reality real?
- 2:07:07You have only ever known the world through your senses,
- 2:07:10through signals gathered by your eyes and ears and skin,
- 2:07:14and woven together somewhere within you into the rich, seamless
- 2:07:19experience of being here. You have never touched reality directly,
- 2:07:25only ever this inner picture of it, painted from within.
- 2:07:29And so the simulation, thought strange as it is, is
- 2:07:33really only the newest version of a question as old
- 2:07:36as wonder itself, asked by dreamers and thinkers for thousands
- 2:07:41of years. How can we ever be sure that this,
- 2:07:44all of this is real. Here is the quiet truth
- 2:07:49that lets the question finally rest. Even if we can
- 2:07:53never prove with perfect certainty that the world is exactly
- 2:07:57as it seems, the world remains exact, exactly, as warm
- 2:08:01and as real to you as it has always been.
- 2:08:04The softness of the pillow beneath your head is still soft.
- 2:08:09The quiet of the night is still quiet. The slow
- 2:08:13rhythm of your own breathing is still yours, still steady,
- 2:08:18still carrying you gently towards sleep. Whatever reality turns out
- 2:08:23to be, at its deepest and most hidden level, this experience,
- 2:08:27this very moment, is genuinely and fully here, and so
- 2:08:32are you resting within it. So let that final wondering
- 2:08:37be the softest of all. Perhaps the world is just
- 2:08:41as solid as it feels. Almost certainly it is, And
- 2:08:45even if some far stranger truth lies beneath it, one
- 2:08:48we may never know, it changes nothing at all about
- 2:08:52the gentle realness of this quiet moment, this breath, this
- 2:08:56slow drifting down into rest. The mystery can keep you
- 2:09:01are here, and that is enough. Let the question dissolve
- 2:09:05now like a thought at the very edge of sleep,
- 2:09:08and let yourself drift gently into the dark. If you
- 2:09:15are still here with me, still awake in the quiet,
- 2:09:19then perhaps the wondering has kept you gentle company rather
- 2:09:23than carried you off. And that is perfectly all right.
- 2:09:28There is no hurry, and there is nothing you need
- 2:09:31to do. You might let another of our journeys begin
- 2:09:35and drift along on the soft sound of it, wherever
- 2:09:39it may wander. Or you might simply lie here a
- 2:09:43little longer in the soft dark, letting the great, gentle
- 2:09:48mysteries settle around you like stars coming out one by one.
- 2:09:53For we have wandered tonight through some of the deepest
- 2:09:56unanswered questions there are, and we leave them all just
- 2:10:01as we found them, open and quiet and unhurried, waiting
- 2:10:06patiently in the dark for some far off day. There
- 2:10:11is a strange comfort in that you do not have
- 2:10:14to understand the universe to belong to it. You are
- 2:10:18already part of it, woven from its oldest light, resting
- 2:10:22now beneath its endless sky. So let your thoughts grow
- 2:10:26soft and slow, Let the questions drift away, unanswered as
- 2:10:30gently as they came. And wherever your mind may wander
- 2:10:34as you fall, may it wander somewhere kind sweet dreams
- 2:10:39among the stars. M M.
- 2:12:09Speaker 2: Many one been n the area reminer m M to