Latest / CXOTalk / Inside Lenovo’s AI Plans for 2025! | CXOTalk #887
Transcript
- 0:00How does one of the world's largest companies think about
- 0:04scaling AI, making AI investments, and the impact of
- 0:10AI on chief information officers?
- 0:13Today on CXO Talk number 887, we discussed these questions with
- 0:20Art Who Global CIO at Lenovo, who is also the Chief Delivery
- 0:26and Technology Officer of Lenovo Services and Solutions Group.
- 0:31The Chief Technology and Chief Delivery Officer role for our
- 0:35Solution and Services business group is the newer one.
- 0:38In addition to my global CIO role, I'm privileged to be at
- 0:41the leading edge of Lenovo's services and AI transformations.
- 0:45Lenovo is one of the largest technology providers in the
- 0:50world. Where do you stand with AI
- 0:55today? It's a very general question, so
- 0:58you're just your perspectives. The upcoming decade will be very
- 1:01much around hybrid AI and in all its incarnations.
- 1:06So, and if we think about as a technologist and a business
- 1:10practitioner of technology, meaning that I really focus on
- 1:15of course exploring the leading edge of what's possible in
- 1:17technology, but helping land it in a relevant way for the
- 1:20business. I really try to chunk it up and
- 1:22look at it in domains. The first one, for example,
- 1:26around innovation and product development, right?
- 1:29We're, we're selling right, more than four devices a second,
- 1:33right, We have AI services and solutions.
- 1:35And so when we think about the product development, we're
- 1:38really bringing that into all aspects of our portfolio, right?
- 1:42So the AI is coming to our PC experience, our edge experience,
- 1:46our phone experience, our server experience, our services and
- 1:50solutions. So that's around product
- 1:52development, right? AI is coming into our entire
- 1:54portfolio and offering in a way that's going to be more and more
- 1:57integrated. It's also coming into our
- 1:59innovation process and we're accelerating the discovery and
- 2:04product development on both the hardware and software and
- 2:07solution. Side and then the last.
- 2:09Area that I think about is around our operations.
- 2:12So and that again is all aspects of our end to end value chain,
- 2:16all of our functions, all of our geographies, legal marketing,
- 2:20sales. For example, we actually have an
- 2:23enterprise seller AI coach who can improve your selling motion,
- 2:29but HR and our supply chain is one of the top supply chains in
- 2:32the world according to Gartner. So like you said, I wanted to do
- 2:35an overview, right? Whether it's innovation or
- 2:37offering portfolio or how we run a world class operation, we're
- 2:41finding ways where AI is relevant.
- 2:43And that's what's interesting. There's it's relevant
- 2:47everywhere. There's nowhere you can point in
- 2:48the company where someone says, you know what?
- 2:50That doesn't apply to me. How do you think about AI
- 2:54related investment decisions? It is advancing at such a rapid
- 2:59pace, right? Whether it's, and you can count
- 3:01this almost by day or by week or by month, but the pace is
- 3:06incredible. With that being said, I still
- 3:09think it makes sense to have a framework because what you don't
- 3:12want to do is suddenly feel like you are lost or that you're
- 3:15swimming and drowning in too much That's happening.
- 3:18The best way to avoid this analysis paralysis because it's
- 3:22very easy. What's what's best?
- 3:23Should I just, should I just keep waiting because the
- 3:25frontier seems to be moving so quickly?
- 3:29I'm very much and at Lenovo, we're very much about learning
- 3:32by doing and tolerating ambiguity.
- 3:35So when it comes to our a investment strategy, it is very
- 3:39much where it is a full court press, right, everyone in the
- 3:41company. And this is not just me and any
- 3:43of my roles, but it's the entire executive committee.
- 3:46We have a joint commitment to make AIA key part of our
- 3:51business because we fundamentally believe that it's
- 3:54going to bring the return. And so in terms of the
- 3:59investment question and our investment strategy, the overall
- 4:03is everyone is expected to engage and that helps
- 4:05tremendously, right? There's no need to explain what
- 4:07we're doing or why and that really helps the team step
- 4:10forward. And then the other part of it is
- 4:13that we help from a technology perspective.
- 4:16We help inform the business on when should we open the aperture
- 4:19and exploration, right. We'll have many parallel
- 4:21experiments. We're going to see and test what
- 4:23is the boundary and we're going to have times where we come back
- 4:26together and want to do a little bit bit of summarization and
- 4:28harvesting of what we've learned so that we can focus and really
- 4:31apply. And so I think the couple of key
- 4:35parts is we're all in and we're all in as a team, not just as a
- 4:38technology team, but with the business teams.
- 4:40And then we have to be flexible. Yes, we use what's worked in
- 4:43terms of having some framework to evaluate, but recognize that
- 4:46it's not going to work perfectly and there's going to be some
- 4:48ambiguity. For example, in areas that are
- 4:50more mature, we might not want so much ambiguity and parallel
- 4:54processing and maybe having overlap, because why overlap if
- 4:56you already know what you're you're doing?
- 4:58But in a in a field that's changing so quickly, right, We
- 5:01explicitly have to say it's OK if we do things that seem
- 5:04duplicative, because we might find different things for
- 5:07different approaches towards similar, seemingly similar
- 5:10things might generate different results when the teams come back
- 5:13together. As you mentioned, AI is changing
- 5:18so rapidly, the technology is evolving and the usage inside
- 5:24organizations of every size. And so how does that factor into
- 5:32your investments? I mean, how do you, how do you
- 5:34ensure that you're picking the right horse when it comes to
- 5:39specific AI technologies, for example?
- 5:42We will want to find investments that are no regret, meaning that
- 5:45we are going to get value from them with the business in the
- 5:49window we're wanting. And that makes it easy because
- 5:52if we've gotten the value on a fixed window, then even if that
- 5:54doesn't end up being the long term solution, then we're still
- 5:58getting a return on investment, which is responsible for our
- 6:01shareholders and our stakeholders.
- 6:03And so in that respect, that's from a financial management
- 6:06perspective, right. You can still find the
- 6:07investments that everyone's excited about because it
- 6:10generates that return. At the same time, there is there
- 6:13is no guarantee and and I think that's can be very scary for a
- 6:17controlling function or right, if you want that absolute
- 6:19certainty, you will definitely not find that here to say the AI
- 6:23solution we picked today, whether it's the model or it's a
- 6:26gateway or whatever it is, it's a quantization method.
- 6:30None of those things are guaranteed to be cutting edge in
- 6:32six months or 12 months, right? That just doesn't.
- 6:35Exist, but I think the point is around no regret.
- 6:39What we have to think is you have to keep moving forward.
- 6:42And so the fundamental response, because another way of saying
- 6:46things are changing very quickly is uncertainty, right?
- 6:49That means there's uncertainty. There's no guarantees.
- 6:51But what we believe at Lenovo and what we're practicing is
- 6:54that the best strategic response is agility.
- 6:58And that AI definitely affords the way that we can help plan
- 7:01better, the way that it can help get more information, the way
- 7:05you can help get more very data, the way you can help simplify
- 7:08processes. All those things come together
- 7:10whether in the micro right or at the company or the department
- 7:14level are things that you can use to create agility.
- 7:17And I think that's what's so important, which is if you can
- 7:19reframe some of the strategic discussion where investing in AI
- 7:23is actually going to help your agility, and that's of strategic
- 7:27value for the enterprise, right? That's a very worthwhile
- 7:29discussion because that clears the deck about, well, how do we
- 7:31know? Because it's very natural to
- 7:33say, and we've seen things that were cutting edge a year ago are
- 7:36now no longer cutting edge, right?
- 7:38They're commoditized, but if you've gotten the value right,
- 7:41if you've already helped increase your AI index for the
- 7:44company, that's OK. And then you can continue to
- 7:47explore. And the point is to not lose
- 7:49momentum and to continue in the face of that uncertainty.
- 7:51That's what's so important. We know that AI is fundamentally
- 7:57important, requires investment and organization of the team
- 8:02behind it, as you were describing, even if we don't
- 8:06know the exact shape of the technology.
- 8:09And so therefore agility enables you to invest strategically but
- 8:16essentially keep your technology options open.
- 8:19Is that an accurate way to describe the what what you just
- 8:21said? Yes.
- 8:22And then the final point I would add on top of that on what why
- 8:26the mindset and having the right mindset for this is so important
- 8:29is this is one of those things. Where?
- 8:32You may not know what the next mountain you will need to climb
- 8:35is, right. You may not know what the road
- 8:36looks like beyond the next bend until you actually get there.
- 8:39You can guess, you can simulate, you can approximate, you can
- 8:43estimate. But the point is, unless you
- 8:45move forward, you won't know. And only by moving forward can
- 8:49you get to the next. There is definitely not the
- 8:52Please provide a three-year road map and a guaranteed vendor list
- 8:55and techniques and a budget that's going to fit down to the
- 8:58dollar that we can reconcile. Folks, right now you can ask
- 9:02your questions of art who, if you're watching on LinkedIn, pop
- 9:08your questions into the chat and I see some questions are showing
- 9:11up there. Now, if you're watching on
- 9:15Twitter on X, then use the #cxotalk, but use this
- 9:21opportunity, take advantage of it.
- 9:23When else will you be able to ask the global CIO of Lenovo
- 9:27pretty much whatever you want. So take advantage of it.
- 9:29Ask your questions. Art.
- 9:32In addition to the technology shifting, right now we have
- 9:39tremendous economic trade tariff changes and shifts.
- 9:45How does all of that play into what you're doing with AI, how
- 9:52you're thinking about it and how you're making investments and
- 9:54also your your customers as well?
- 9:56On the technology. Side I think it is really a
- 9:59Seminole moment because there are now new possibilities.
- 10:04So Lenovo, where the world's we have the world and we're very
- 10:07proud of having the world's best hardware portfolio right now.
- 10:11We're enriching that with services.
- 10:13But even for us, the new possibilities because
- 10:15historically we've had in the last few decades, if you think
- 10:18about it, we've had a very fixed paradigm right from the dawn of
- 10:21the modern computer age. We had decades where the command
- 10:24prompt was the primary way of interacting.
- 10:27Then we had the graphical user interface, the GUI, and that was
- 10:30that's been going for probably four or five decades.
- 10:34But now we really have for the first time a way that some of
- 10:39the augmented reality and voice how may change the interaction
- 10:45with compute, right? We went from command prompts to
- 10:47Gui's voice has always been hanging around there as kind of
- 10:51on the peripheral, but we never got there quite because of the
- 10:54inability to really understand intent and have multi turn and
- 10:58true human dialogue. But as that becomes more and
- 11:01more capable with the latest generation of technology, the
- 11:04way that we interact with compute will change.
- 11:07And so that evolution is tremendously exciting, right?
- 11:09This has not happened for decades.
- 11:11Where there was. Truly something that we could be
- 11:13on the cusp of. And that's so interesting on the
- 11:15technology side as we transition into, Michael, what you're
- 11:18asking about the economic is because this starts to make
- 11:20things that were not really possible to do or really just
- 11:23impossible to do into the possible.
- 11:25Now to be clear, I don't want to be hyperbolic.
- 11:28We're not talking about physically impossible things
- 11:30that are now impossible. But technology capabilities in a
- 11:33business and a consumer context are opening up.
- 11:37New Frontiers, right, if we think about the real time
- 11:40capabilities and the ability, right, we see, for instance, as
- 11:44a very simple example, right? If we go have one of the leading
- 11:47language models go into deep research mode and say, hey, I
- 11:51would like a master's level thesis that is 50 pages.
- 11:54They can go off and work on that for 30 minutes, 60 minutes, 90
- 11:57minutes and come back with something that you know, you can
- 12:00say 50% there, 70% there, but something right And that was
- 12:04not, that was not possible five years ago.
- 12:06And those, those are the types of things where right as they
- 12:10become possible, they open up all these new frontiers, whether
- 12:12you're in a consumer space or a kind of a more business to
- 12:16business and enterprise space. Does that make sense?
- 12:19It does. Let's jump to some questions.
- 12:23I love taking questions from the audience.
- 12:25This, this audience is just a smart is so smart.
- 12:29And let's start from LinkedIn. And there's a question from Ravi
- 12:34Karkara. And Ravi says in an era where AI
- 12:40is reshaping every function across industries, why is it
- 12:44mission critical for corporate corporations to invest in
- 12:47skilling, upskilling and reskilling their workforce at
- 12:51entry, mid and senior levels? Not just to stay competitive,
- 12:56but also to drive responsible and strategic adoption of AI
- 13:03across core business functions. So the importance of investing
- 13:08in skilling and reskilling, but at every level.
- 13:11The importance is simply that we still run the businesses, right?
- 13:16And with all this change and as part of the business, if we are
- 13:20not changing, then we're being left behind, right.
- 13:24And so I think the imperative I at this point, I run into
- 13:27basically nobody, everyone would support the imperative that
- 13:31reskilling is necessary, right? But I think in, in some sense,
- 13:36Robbie, if I could try to get underneath the question, right?
- 13:38So no one would disagree. If you go to any chief HR
- 13:40officer, right? And you're like, oh, we need to
- 13:42re skill for generative AI and the agentic and the hybrid AI
- 13:46era, right? I think 99 to 100% people will
- 13:48agree. But I I think the more
- 13:50interesting question is. How do you reskill?
- 13:54Because there's different ways to go about it.
- 13:57The fact that you do need to reskill for entry level, mid
- 14:01level as well as senior and even the C-Suite is absolutely there,
- 14:06but you need to take different pads.
- 14:10So let me give a couple of examples or try to talk and more
- 14:12specific. I think from a general, from an
- 14:14overall approach perspective, what does not work is a top down
- 14:19right? The the office of the chairman
- 14:22and the office of the CEO say you must learn AI now right here
- 14:25are the 10 courses and you must be certified by the end of the
- 14:29quarter or you will not get a good bonus or something like
- 14:32that, right? You can imagine something that's
- 14:33very top down and driven. I think this ties very well with
- 14:37what Michael teed up so wonderfully in the questions,
- 14:40which is this notion of uncertainty and the pace of
- 14:43change, right? That has to inform the approach.
- 14:45And so the approach has to be much more organic where the
- 14:49company is not mandating, but the company is encouraging at.
- 14:53The company is creating the fertile ground in the
- 14:56environment that invites employees in to explore and to
- 15:00change because the reskilling that happens when you are
- 15:04exploring, because you think it will make you and your team
- 15:08deliver better outcomes is way better than someone sitting in a
- 15:11central right Coe trying to guess at what you need.
- 15:16And so I think that principle of the the best thing the company
- 15:20can do is to. Create the preconditions.
- 15:23And the right environment to go reskill.
- 15:25So for example, at the Lenovo, right, we are trying, we have
- 15:28built hundreds of agents, we have hundreds of environments,
- 15:32all of all approved in case my security team listens to this at
- 15:36some point. But we're creating the
- 15:38environment that invites people in, right?
- 15:39If you want to work in legal, right, if you're in marketing,
- 15:42if you're in finance, if you're in HR, there's something for you
- 15:45to work with that will help invite you in the door.
- 15:48And what we're finding then is there's a pull.
- 15:50People will say, oh, I've already learned these things,
- 15:53now how I would like to learn more.
- 15:54And that's a much better way in terms of what we've found.
- 15:57So we approach it not as a, you shall or shall not do these
- 16:01things, but creating the the pull, creating the impetus so
- 16:04that the employees are leading the charge and they pull the
- 16:08company behind them. And I think that approach works
- 16:11equally well whether you are a first line employee, a first
- 16:14line manager, a middle manager or an executive.
- 16:19The way you do it of course is different, but the whole point
- 16:23is you have to spend enough time getting hands on with the
- 16:26technology and this is then as you start to become a middle
- 16:29manager or as an executive. The final piece I would say is
- 16:32it does take an additional point to read, to go use to try out
- 16:37some of these tools to see how powerful they are because it is
- 16:40intrinsically my belief that it is impossible to go work on and
- 16:46to effectively lead the technology if you don't know
- 16:49what it is. So the more senior you are,
- 16:51because it's not as natural, you are not going as a CIA.
- 16:53I'm not coding 100% of the time. And any CIO who is probably
- 16:57right, why are they the CIO? But the more senior you are, the
- 17:00more the it's important that you spend the time to understand
- 17:05what it is by getting hands on with it, by understanding what
- 17:08is at the frontier so that you can lead and create the right
- 17:11environment for your teams. Go to cxotalk.com and subscribe
- 17:16to our newsletter and we want you to come back audience to our
- 17:21upcoming shows. We really do have tremendous
- 17:25shows. How do you overcome the fear
- 17:29that many employees have that hey, AI is going to take my job
- 17:38and I'm not sure what to do about it?
- 17:42The framing is what is less than constructive, we'll say, right,
- 17:47because so I've got two issues with that.
- 17:49One is just from a personal philosophy.
- 17:51It's very passive, right? We talked about agents.
- 17:54Well, let's go back to what the root of agents are.
- 17:56It is agency, and agency is a fundamentally human thing.
- 18:00I am right, yes, there's, you know, constraints, but
- 18:03fundamentally I am able to take decisions and actions that will
- 18:06change my path, right? That's what agency fundamentally
- 18:09is. So just from that framing, AI
- 18:11will take my job. Makes it sound like you were
- 18:12sitting there a static entity waiting for something to happen
- 18:16to you. So I, in that sense, I, I
- 18:18already, I tend to reject that framing or in its most
- 18:21simplistic form, if we then think about, well, what else,
- 18:25how can we reframe it So it's more constructive?
- 18:28I, I think it's more AI is coming.
- 18:31So how do I understand? And how do we step back and make
- 18:35it a more constructive framing, which is, it's a technology and
- 18:38it's going to make its way into everything you can dispute,
- 18:41right? The ticky tack stuff.
- 18:42Is it three years, five years, 20 years?
- 18:44I think we'd all be shocked if things in 1520 years look at all
- 18:48the same that they are today. But the final part of this is
- 18:51that AI doesn't take jobs, right?
- 18:55What it does, it's a technology that automates tasks.
- 18:57Jobs are still fundamentally designed by people, right?
- 19:02Because it's a very human enterprise of what is this
- 19:05company trying to do. And so if you understand that AI
- 19:09is just automating or augmenting some tasks by embracing that,
- 19:14you are taking agency back unto yourself.
- 19:17Because then it's not about I'm waiting for someone to take my
- 19:21job and no, no. And now what do I do?
- 19:23It's much more if you are in the curiosity and if you've been
- 19:26experimenting, then it's much more about redefining the tasks
- 19:31that compose your job, right? So yes, you can in the narrow
- 19:34form, AI is taking tasks and making it better, but those are
- 19:38probably not the tasks that you wanted to do, right?
- 19:41Did you really want to go to the website, right?
- 19:43Download the report. I put it in Excel at the same.
- 19:46But you don't, you can automate that and you can actually do
- 19:49that much more flexibly. But if you don't have to do so
- 19:51much of the grunt work and by applying just this very
- 19:55classical approach to problem solving of decomposition, it's
- 19:58much more manageable, right? For let me just again, let me
- 20:00make it very specific with an example.
- 20:03If you are and so developers, if you are software engineering,
- 20:06it's very easy to even get unsettled because, oh right, all
- 20:10the headlines you see are about. Right in the future, right, this
- 20:14company doesn't want to hire software developers.
- 20:17Oh, you can just write code, right?
- 20:19Oh, how many, how many more lines of code can you write?
- 20:21My code is 100% faster with people and now, right, it's
- 20:24already as good as a junior developer.
- 20:26Next year it'll be good as a senior.
- 20:28So it's easy to get swept up in that.
- 20:31But if you go back to tasks we all know, and, and this is one
- 20:34of my pet peeves, which I'm always trying to help educate
- 20:38more, Many senior leaders believe engineering is about
- 20:42just writing more code, right? Kind of the the Hollywood trope
- 20:45of someone who's at their computer rooms kind of dark and
- 20:48your fingers are flying over the keyboard and maybe smoke is
- 20:50coming off of them. But as a developer, that is
- 20:54maybe 10 to 15% of your time, right?
- 20:57There's thinking about design, they're testing, there's
- 21:00regression, there's performance, there's architecture, there's
- 21:03security, right? And so just let's take even one
- 21:07part of that, right? The whole design.
- 21:11You can now as a developer do things that previously you might
- 21:14have needed a user experience designer to do, right?
- 21:16If you wanted to create a prototype, right?
- 21:19Previously you might have worked with a, a prototype specialist,
- 21:22right? And work done something online
- 21:24and one of the modeling tools, but that would have taken time.
- 21:27Now you can just say a few words and a few minutes later you get
- 21:29something that is a starting point.
- 21:31Maybe you can even show it to the business, right?
- 21:34And so that then helps you reframe something that you
- 21:37couldn't do before, you can now get almost for free and almost
- 21:40in real time creating a workable demo.
- 21:42And that helps you go back to think about your job.
- 21:44Are you really just there to write code and get requirements?
- 21:47No, right, right. The fundamental point of
- 21:49software engineering is to deliver an outcome for the
- 21:53business, right. So as long as you have the
- 21:55framing, right, all you've done is you can do more and you have
- 22:00better tools to do so. And now you can redefine your
- 22:02job to focus on either broader scope or more value added
- 22:07components, right. And so I, I think the point is,
- 22:11and, and again, I think history for everyone who is concerned
- 22:14about that, it is not without reason because in the moment it
- 22:18will feel like someone is coming for your job.
- 22:20But for all of these technologies that have come
- 22:23historically, it is always the things that are created
- 22:26afterwards, right? Certain jobs, if you define it
- 22:30very statically of it can, like a software engineer just needs
- 22:32to write code and run the test case, then yeah, I would agree
- 22:35that job is not going to really exist in that exact form in
- 22:39three years, five years, 10 years.
- 22:40But having a valuable software engineer who really understands
- 22:44what the enterprise is about and can fully use the tools to
- 22:48create something, right? Maybe it's not even a classical
- 22:51application anymore, right? Maybe it's a chat bot.
- 22:53But the, if you were thinking from that, then you're still a
- 22:57software engineer. Are you swapped out three 5710
- 23:00of the tasks that were more laborious?
- 23:03But you can define for yourself what that is.
- 23:04So, and that, and, and I've had this discussion so many times
- 23:07with my teams because software developers, if you read the
- 23:10headlines, you think they were an endangered species, right?
- 23:13But this is fundamentally something that's much more
- 23:15constructive and much more empowering for the AI is coming
- 23:20from my job. This is an excellent time to
- 23:22subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter so we can notify you
- 23:27of shows that we have just like this.
- 23:29We have amazing shows coming up, so just go to cxotalk.com and
- 23:34subscribe to our newsletter and do that right now.
- 23:38We have a question from Preeti Narayan on LinkedIn and she says
- 23:45which sectors are leading in AI innovation and what's driving
- 23:50their success. It's an It's an interesting
- 23:53question. There's a quote about economists
- 23:55saying that they see the impact of technology everywhere, but
- 23:59but the numbers, right? And So what I mean by that is I,
- 24:02I think given the very early stage, right, I think it is in
- 24:05general going to take some time before you can see true
- 24:10acceleration and relative acceleration in macro economic
- 24:16data, right? At that level, right?
- 24:17Something you'd get from the National Bureau of Statistics
- 24:19and other official agencies, right?
- 24:22That being said, I think in general industries that are that
- 24:28are highly regulated, we'll have to move a bit more cautiously,
- 24:33right? And that's just for the very
- 24:34simple reason that the laws, the regulations, the compliance
- 24:38requirements will impose some additional process overhead and
- 24:42boxes to go check, right. You know, things that are around
- 24:46sensitive data, critical infrastructure, personally
- 24:49identifiable private data, right?
- 24:53Any any scenarios that touch those will necessarily need.
- 24:56To. Be a bit more Well, they'll need
- 25:00to invest more again in the compliance, right?
- 25:04So I think that's it. As a general rule, I, I also not
- 25:08being a macro economist, right? I would also love to see the
- 25:10statistics as they come out to see what might be some leading
- 25:13indicators where AI is being applied.
- 25:16What we do see though is very practical use cases and I think
- 25:23many of them are familiar, right?
- 25:26But fundamentally these are the ones that are leaning into the
- 25:31strengths of generative AI around creativity, around the
- 25:35ability to understand intent better than any class of
- 25:39technology previously. So that's one aspect.
- 25:43And I think the other one is not only using the strengths of
- 25:46that, but also being tolerant of it's shortcomings.
- 25:50And I think that's particularly important, right, If we shift
- 25:52from kind of the macro and sectors because there's some
- 25:54general conditions there that I talked about.
- 25:57But and if we look at which use cases are going to make more and
- 26:01where are they going to cluster, it's not only it uses the
- 26:04strengths, but tolerant of the weakness.
- 26:06Isn't that very important, right?
- 26:08If you think about right, Because then the weakness is
- 26:11being of course, is that the current architecture and class
- 26:15of technology that powers generative AI around
- 26:18Transformers will hallucinate. And you can say is that a
- 26:21feature or a bug? Because it's meant to
- 26:22approximate, right how human brains work, right, with some of
- 26:26the technologies and propagation and weighting of neurons and and
- 26:29cells. So you can argue with the
- 26:32feature or bug, but the reality is that kind of happens.
- 26:35And so if you look at the areas, for example, around marketing,
- 26:40right around things that around human talk scenarios where you
- 26:45can still do something very meaningful, but have a human in
- 26:48the in the loop around contact centers, all those things really
- 26:52tap the creativity. So around marketing, around
- 26:55writing press releases, those are things were getting the
- 26:58wrong comma, right, having one wrong word.
- 27:01It's highly tolerant for that because it's already 100 X
- 27:03better and 100 X faster than what it was before, right.
- 27:08And so people will say, OK, well, you know, if it's, if it's
- 27:10only 90% as good from an end product, but it's 100 X faster,
- 27:14right and 10 times cheaper, that's a win win in many
- 27:17people's books. And so I, I think those are the
- 27:20areas because we are all continuing to search.
- 27:22We are still very much at the dawn of who can go more quickly.
- 27:28But I think ultimately because I think the question is very
- 27:30important, which is around speed, right?
- 27:32I think everyone wants to use generative AI for their
- 27:34enterprise to find that additional velocity that they
- 27:37can get for their business. And so a search pattern I could
- 27:40offer is, is that right? How do you continue to lean into
- 27:45and continue to identify cases in your company in your context
- 27:50that use the good parts of generative AI and are tolerant?
- 27:52Not that you know, you never want to accept, but you that are
- 27:55more tolerant of some of the the drawbacks primarily around the
- 27:59the fancy word is stochastic, but the human word is random
- 28:03randomness that is innate to the technology and that and I think
- 28:07that's ultimately we can talk a little bit more about it here,
- 28:11Michael. I'll leave us a stub, but
- 28:12essentially that's going back to the you have to keep moving
- 28:16because only by continuing to move can you compound the
- 28:19advantage. It's very unlikely a single
- 28:21project will take you from a a middling performer to a world
- 28:25beater company. It's going to be the compounding
- 28:28of finding these use cases and continuing to move forward.
- 28:31And so it is super important to have some search criteria in
- 28:35mind to help sift through and identify what those use cases
- 28:39are for you. It seems to me you're always
- 28:42bringing the technology back to the context of what the business
- 28:47actually requires. So it's not just technology in
- 28:50abstract, it's not just change in abstract, but it's what's
- 28:54going on, what's the impact on the business and how do we have
- 28:57to adapt as the business and the technology and the environment
- 29:01are all simultaneously changing and evolving.
- 29:04You've just summarized a a lesson.
- 29:07It's a bit of a bitter lesson in the sense that as the technology
- 29:09industry, we learn repeatedly, because even until today, as you
- 29:13said, if you do just technology shorn and stripped of its
- 29:17context or you say I'm just doing the technology without a
- 29:20Clearview, this is how you end up with large project failures.
- 29:24And even today, you see in the news, you can just search ERP
- 29:27failures, right? And you will see from the public
- 29:29sector to the private to government, right, we still see
- 29:33projects that are exactly making that mistake that you just
- 29:37summarized, Michael. We have a couple of questions
- 29:41now, which I'm going to combine from LinkedIn and Twitter.
- 29:45Greg Walters is asking about the impact of AI on the C-Suite.
- 29:52Specifically, he says he thinks that ultimately AI removes the
- 29:55the need for the for the C-Suite.
- 29:59And on Twitter, Arsalan Khan is asking about the role of IT when
- 30:10it comes to AIAI discussions. And and Arsalan says whoever has
- 30:18executive power might shut out IT from these discussions.
- 30:24So in both cases, we have this impact of AI on senior leaders
- 30:32in an organization. Any any thoughts on that?
- 30:35Let's start with the last one around leaders who have power
- 30:39shutting IT out, right? And I think this is a bit of a
- 30:43fallacy in my mind, right? Or if that's really what's
- 30:46either happening or perceived should be happening, then I
- 30:51think there's something wrong with the relationship between
- 30:53the CIO where the technology function more broadly, let's
- 30:56call it and, and that and that business, right?
- 30:59And just very practically, the whole point about technology is
- 31:02to empower the the business, right?
- 31:06So, and this has a little bit with the first question.
- 31:09I would love to be out of my job as it is because if we can make
- 31:12the technology so democratized, so modular and so low barrier to
- 31:17entry, right? If the low code, right, no code
- 31:21and agentic framework really comes into its own right, and
- 31:25pick your time frame, I would love to have a very different
- 31:27job, right? And so fundamentally, I think if
- 31:30there's a business leader that is somehow perceived as shutting
- 31:34out IT, then I think that relationship needs a reset
- 31:38because that doesn't even make sense because it means I want to
- 31:40shut down or there must be something else there.
- 31:43So my first question, if you parachuted me in and I could
- 31:45have a friend conversation with either the technology leader or
- 31:48the business leader or together is what's causing the need to
- 31:53shut anyone out, right? Because this is the same thing
- 31:56with shadow IT. Shadow IT is in and of itself
- 31:59not bad. It's a symptom that there's some
- 32:01unmet technology need that the central IT team or the
- 32:05technology team can't provide. And so it's a bit of an anti
- 32:09pattern. Anytime I've seen the business
- 32:11fields need to shut out or hide right or not say something about
- 32:15what they're doing, it's because there's a bit of an underlying
- 32:18current that's not healthy about the interaction, interaction
- 32:21dynamic between the technology and the business functions.
- 32:23They have to be partnered and shutting out just means for
- 32:26whatever reason, there's not the trust.
- 32:27And so in that situation, I think the most important thing
- 32:30for that company is to help reset that relationship to start
- 32:34building the trust. Now leading to the question, the
- 32:37first the were you started that one in the compound question
- 32:40about we don't need AC suite anymore, Well, it goes back to
- 32:43the earlier one, right? I think yeah, we may not need
- 32:46the C-Suite in the current form, right?
- 32:48But someone has to lead the companies, right?
- 32:51I don't think anyone here believes in the next 5 to 10
- 32:53years we're going to have, right?
- 32:55We are all going to be working just for robots, right?
- 32:57Because again, this is a right, this is a human choice to the
- 33:01point, right, building an enterprise, building a business,
- 33:04building a startup, building something new.
- 33:06These are, and we're going to get a little bit philosophical
- 33:09here, but those are fundamentally human things,
- 33:12right? And because at the, at the core
- 33:14of it, what right. And I'm very open, right, If we
- 33:18modify the question not to say we don't need AC suite, but if
- 33:21we say we don't need the C-Suite in its current incarnation, I
- 33:24could totally buy into that, right?
- 33:25In fact, I, I hope I'm certainly working that by increasing the
- 33:31democratization, I hope we can have way more citizen, right
- 33:36and, and, and citizen developers at Lenovo who are able to
- 33:40contribute right, using our platforms, using the agents that
- 33:43we've built and building on top, extending them doing things that
- 33:46I definitely didn't think of my team may not have thought about
- 33:49it, right. That's fundamentally what the
- 33:51platform is for. And so I wouldn't say we don't
- 33:54need AC Suite because again, words are not so important here,
- 33:58right? I think the point is we will
- 34:00always need some leadership, right?
- 34:02We need someone to set the vision for the company.
- 34:05That's fundamentally a human thing, right?
- 34:07If you believe that that's not human thing, right, then we have
- 34:10a very fundamental different vision of what the future of
- 34:12technology is. But I'm very open, right?
- 34:14We don't write that the role of the CEO, the CTO, the CFO,
- 34:18right? Yeah, for sure.
- 34:19These are not immune. There's no armor that comes with
- 34:22being in the C-Suite, right? And in fact, the pressure is
- 34:25extremely high to go find the next and what's new.
- 34:28And just As for our frontline managers, right, frontline
- 34:33operators, first line support people, their jobs will evolve.
- 34:37There's no exception. The C-Suite, the senior leaders
- 34:39absolutely have to evolve, right.
- 34:41So if you permit me that slight tweak, I, I agree we don't need.
- 34:44And in fact, it would be weird, right if if the if the C-Suite
- 34:48operated the same way in five years and 10 years after
- 34:51sustained investment and transformation and evolution,
- 34:54bumping up against the frontier of the possible with what these
- 34:57capabilities afford. It's so interesting to hear your
- 35:02perspective on embracing adapt, adaptability, embracing the
- 35:09change, recognizing that again, this seems to be the common
- 35:14theme, recognizing that there is change.
- 35:17And I don't see you pushing away that change, but rather trying
- 35:25to understand its roots in order to embrace it and therefore take
- 35:29advantage and essentially roll with it.
- 35:32One thing for leaders and managers to keep in mind is this
- 35:35is part of, I think leading with empathy and leading with
- 35:42authority as well, because it's right.
- 35:44I, I, I think why, why run away from it, right?
- 35:47Yeah. If a, if a, if augmented by an
- 35:50agent, I can make decisions better and I can do it, then we
- 35:54should, right? There's no one who's immune.
- 35:55So I think that's very important.
- 35:58I, I think it is also, but again, for everyone, right,
- 36:02again, at any level, I think it really the hard part and the
- 36:05challenging part is to think through what is as a, as a
- 36:08person and you know, in Lenovo, we sometimes call it carbon
- 36:11based labor, right, as opposed to silicon based labor.
- 36:14What's carbon as a carbon based labor representative?
- 36:21What's my, what's my unique contribution, right?
- 36:24What? What can I do?
- 36:26That is still better. And again, this sometimes gets a
- 36:29little bit philosophical. We'll, we'll take chess as an
- 36:31example. It's been some time actually,
- 36:34that the best human player in chess who is unassisted, there's
- 36:40no chance for that person to beat the best chess engine.
- 36:44And that's been true for decades now.
- 36:46And that's been true for decades.
- 36:48And if you were before, you'd say, well, I guess chess will
- 36:51just die because now it will just be machines moving the
- 36:53pieces around. But in fact, competitive chess
- 36:56has evolved, right? There's new forms, right?
- 36:58It's as popular as ever. And you would say, well, why
- 37:02would people watch? Admittedly, by any objective
- 37:04performance, if objective means ability to win the game, like
- 37:09people who are watching chess are watching and objectively
- 37:12inferior competition. And yet it's as popular as ever,
- 37:15right? It delights millions of people
- 37:16around the world. Why, right.
- 37:18And it's because there's still something intrinsically human
- 37:21about that. And I'm an optimist around that,
- 37:23right? I, I firmly believe This is why
- 37:25we still need people, right and right, representative of carbon
- 37:29based labor to really think about what are the important
- 37:32things, right? And actually AI accentuates that
- 37:34fundamentally. In a world where answers and
- 37:37data are now easy, it's more important than ever that humans
- 37:43in the loop really mean what are the questions that are worth
- 37:47asking, right? What are the ones that are worth
- 37:50paying attention to? And so again, I'm an optimist,
- 37:53but I even in the business world, right?
- 37:55If you say, oh, well, the bot said this, people will say, why
- 37:58does it really understand our business?
- 38:00Has it really that ingrained knowledge to make the call by
- 38:04itself? And the answer today is no.
- 38:06And so it really forces hard discussions and it pushes the
- 38:09boundaries of fundamentally, what can humans continue to do
- 38:13and add to the enterprise. Chris Peterson says Lenovo so
- 38:17far isn't a name we usually hear in talks about building out
- 38:22hyperscale AI data centers in the US.
- 38:26What roles are you playing and looking to play in the future in
- 38:31the AI supply chain? Many of you know says making
- 38:35Thinkpads, right and some of the world's greatest laptops in
- 38:38computing gear, but we also have GPU hardware, we have servers,
- 38:42servers, we have edge equipment. And we also the, the team and
- 38:47the group that I'm the chief technology and delivery officer
- 38:50for the solution and services. It's about helping make AI and
- 38:54the hybrid cloud real for companies in ways that are
- 38:57linked for the business. And so the, I think this is one
- 39:02of the points where as computing intensity increases, So if we
- 39:06look at how data centers are being built, the power density
- 39:09is going up by an order of magnitude in terms of how much
- 39:13power is required because of the GPU dense compute, both on
- 39:18training, but ultimately it's going to show up in inferencing
- 39:21as we continue to move forward. And so for Lenovo, it's win win,
- 39:24right? We have the compute that powers
- 39:27the devices because we will always fundamentally at the edge
- 39:31and at the, the client device level, we'll need phones, we'll
- 39:36need laptops or whatever the next iteration is.
- 39:38Maybe it's more voice LED, but people always need some way of
- 39:42interacting and accessing that compute, right?
- 39:46Because all of this is really compute to help you achieve your
- 39:49outcomes better personally, right?
- 39:51With your friends at work, all of those.
- 39:53So whether that comes from GPU computer, CPU computer or more
- 39:57models or more agents, people still need to consume those,
- 40:01right? And so we're very bullish there
- 40:02about continuing to provide the next generation of hardware at
- 40:05the client. And that will help you consume
- 40:08that in the best way, whether it's a display, whether it's
- 40:10augmented reality, whether it's a phone, whether it's A next
- 40:13generation wearable, right. That is something we're
- 40:16fundamentally bullish around. And then we move away from the
- 40:19edge and the client. The, our infrastructure group
- 40:23provides basically the compute that powers the Internet.
- 40:26So again, whether it's CPU dense compute or GPU dense compute, we
- 40:32are working across all segments of the market, right?
- 40:34We work with public cloud providers.
- 40:36We help enterprises with their private cloud and on premise,
- 40:40we're increasingly helping our customers with managing hybrid
- 40:43cloud because large enterprises have a mixture, right?
- 40:46They'll often have multiple public cloud providers as well
- 40:49as a private cloud. And so bringing that together is
- 40:52a non trivial challenge in managing scalability, managing
- 40:55cost, managing transparency, transparency, observability, all
- 41:00of those things. And so fundamentally that's
- 41:02another area where rising demand is something that we're
- 41:05extremely well positioned to meet.
- 41:07And then finally landing it for enterprises is very much about
- 41:11services, right? We're also very aware that and
- 41:15I'm the CIO, this is where the dual nature and having multiple
- 41:17hats is very helpful for perspective as a CIOI am not
- 41:21excited at all to say go let me buy a new server, right.
- 41:25That does not excite me, but I am very excited if you say,
- 41:29well, I've got a solution that will help your legal team manage
- 41:34your multi billion dollar litigation with much more
- 41:38accuracy and with much less staffing.
- 41:41Oh, and by the way, you have to buy a few servers and a few
- 41:43agents and we can help you with that.
- 41:45That's an exciting conversation. And so I think relative to all
- 41:49of those things, right, because these are fundamentally
- 41:52computing intense, we're going to need a way on the back end to
- 41:55provide all that computing power.
- 41:56We're going to need devices and ways and think about devices,
- 41:59not necessarily in the traditional sense because as I
- 42:02said, who knows what the future form factors will be, but you
- 42:04need some way to consume it and then you need somewhere to land
- 42:07that in the enterprises because enterprises are trying to use
- 42:10this for their business as well. So I think that was a broad
- 42:13answer of right along any of those dimensions, right?
- 42:16But because fundamentally this is going to be a rising tide and
- 42:20of course there's going to be bumps along the way, but it's
- 42:22going to be around for decades. Think about steam power took
- 42:24decades, right? Electricity took many decades to
- 42:27really reach. They're going to be here a long
- 42:29time and Lenovo as providing the things that are underlying all
- 42:33of these, right. I'm fundamentally very bullish
- 42:36about each of those aspects and of course therefore the whole
- 42:39picture. Here's a question from Elizabeth
- 42:42Shaw. You put out a Lenovo put out a
- 42:46report that discussed AI nomics. Can you talk about what is AI
- 42:53nomics? AI Nomics is a research report
- 42:56that we did and we released earlier this year that talks
- 43:00about how our enterprises thinking about the gentic around
- 43:05generative AI in 2025. We do one every year.
- 43:08This was the theme we picked, and the main findings is that
- 43:12there are tremendous pressures to demonstrate return on
- 43:15investment, that it's not just a toy that was #1 the second part
- 43:19is that the ability to get the skills ready.
- 43:23We had a question ready about skills is important because
- 43:26there's still a perceived gap that enterprises are not getting
- 43:30the full value out of this without the right readiness in
- 43:33their workforce. And then finally, one that
- 43:36continues to be common is it's all about the data.
- 43:40No matter how sexy the technology is, no matter how
- 43:43cool the algorithms you use or what frontier model or how many
- 43:46tokens you can get per second on ACPU, if you don't have the
- 43:50right data and you don't use it the right way, also not going to
- 43:54work. So ROI skills and readiness and
- 43:58it's all about the data where some of the key findings that we
- 44:00highlighted. And this is from Pawan Chudari
- 44:04who says thank you Art for sharing insights on agility with
- 44:09AI. Could you please share your
- 44:12thoughts on the top three priorities you had when
- 44:16allocating time and effort for various programs during the
- 44:20scaling of AI in the CIO function?
- 44:25Could do a whole show on this. So 3 priorities you had when
- 44:29scaling AI on on the CIO function.
- 44:33The first one is the kind of the ROI on paper, right?
- 44:37Because you want something that you think is good return for the
- 44:39investment. The second one is actually the
- 44:42probability of success. Like a, sometimes we all know
- 44:45business cases look great on paper, but they're actually a
- 44:49bit stickier to realize, right? So who's actually doing this?
- 44:52Do they have a good track record?
- 44:53So that's number two. And then the final one is, I
- 44:56would call it the lighthouse effect.
- 44:57If we are successful, how can we make this a very attractive
- 45:03package it up so that it creates disproportionate excitement
- 45:07where we can really get people fired up to say, oh, OK, that's
- 45:11what good AI implementation looks like.
- 45:13I want to do something like that.
- 45:15So ROI and probability of success and then ability to
- 45:19create a lighthouse to excite other people and demonstrating
- 45:22what's possible. We have two questions now on the
- 45:26on ethical dimensions. The first one is from Nicole
- 45:31Jeffries on LinkedIn, who says one of the societal concerns
- 45:36about AI is its potential to even further widen the digital
- 45:42divide. How are you thinking about
- 45:45longer term implications to people and societies around the
- 45:50world? Again, we could do a whole hour
- 45:52long discussion and days of discussion on this one so but
- 45:55keep it pretty short. There is a reality around
- 45:59priorities, which is, for example, for the many people in
- 46:04the world who unfortunately today do not have access to
- 46:07reliable electricity or even water and enough food, right?
- 46:10Using AI is not going to be on the top of their concerns,
- 46:13right? And that's something we don't
- 46:14always talk about enough. But that, that is a fact, right?
- 46:17And that needs to be acknowledged.
- 46:19Now, that being said, I think the point about AI and what
- 46:22gives me hope is that because it is a general purpose technology
- 46:27that it is something that we can use just as we talked about and
- 46:30I spoke about earlier, I want to use it within my company to
- 46:33lower the barriers for access, to lower the barriers.
- 46:37There are many, many entrepreneurs as well who are
- 46:39using AI and applying it to solving the additional social
- 46:43problems of providing better access to what we would consider
- 46:46the basics of living a dignified life.
- 46:49So I think what there, I think the the optimism, if you look
- 46:53around, there are many social entrepreneurs who are grabbing
- 46:56onto AI to help increase their reach to really helping everyone
- 47:02on the planet. Another question related to this
- 47:05from Arsalan Khan. He says as we have outsourced
- 47:10manufacturing, hired contract software engineers, would we be
- 47:15contracting out AI capabilities to other organizations that
- 47:21might be better at doing the particular task, but who do not
- 47:27necessarily share the same ethical boundaries as our own
- 47:31organization? So the question is about
- 47:36outsourcing AI to technically proficient groups who may not
- 47:40share our values and perspectives.
- 47:43Right. Well, and this one I think is 1
- 47:46instance of a general class of problems.
- 47:49But I think of this typically, as you know, don't outsource
- 47:51your brain. It's just it it today if you are
- 47:54just as when you would use a consultant, right?
- 47:56You can imagine if you were thinking about any project, you
- 47:58would, right? It's up to you as the project
- 48:01owner or the business owner, you're accountable for the
- 48:04outcome. You may choose someone to be
- 48:05responsible to help deliver it, to execute it.
- 48:09But in terms of so Arsalan, for your question, I think that's
- 48:13part of the due diligence, right?
- 48:14Making sure, a, you yourself are clear on what it is you are
- 48:18looking for. And then B, as part of selecting
- 48:21who are the partners of the providers with whom you would
- 48:24work that you do the due diligence on, right?
- 48:27Just like you would on their financials, right, on their
- 48:29ability to deliver, right, on their soundness as a company, on
- 48:32their customer references, right?
- 48:34That especially if there is reason to believe that it's
- 48:36going to get into some things that are sensitive for you or
- 48:39your company, that you would want to make sure that is a a
- 48:42conversation. And so I think the point here is
- 48:44not to walk in blind. You would apply the same level
- 48:47of due diligence as you would in other parts of your business,
- 48:49right? Yeah.
- 48:50And that's one super important message.
- 48:52There's nothing magical or special about AI where somehow
- 48:56core solid business basics don't apply.
- 48:59You are evaluating A vendor and they are technically the best.
- 49:06They're great, be more profitable working with them,
- 49:10but they don't share your values.
- 49:12How do you draw that line and make those distinctions and make
- 49:15the decision? Well, I think it's a weight,
- 49:17right. If you just very tactically, if
- 49:18you think about a procurement and a vendor evaluation
- 49:20scorecard that gets a line that gets a weight and from a
- 49:24committee of the decision makers who represent the interests of
- 49:29the company, then you will be able to properly score that and
- 49:33make an outcome. So for even if it's great on all
- 49:35the dimensions Michael just mentioned, but you it's really
- 49:39right. It's A Knockout criteria that
- 49:40boy, we're not sure these people are going to be ethical, right?
- 49:43Then you can knock them out. And so I think it's making sure
- 49:45then that the at the point about ethics makes its way into your
- 49:48processes, including about due diligence and procurement.
- 49:51So you're going through a thoughtful evaluation process
- 49:56to, as you said, to, to weigh the pros, to weigh the cons, and
- 50:00then you come to the best decision you can come to.
- 50:03Exactly. As you talk with Lenovo
- 50:06customers, what are the AI challenges they face?
- 50:10For our customers, I think the what we hear a lot is that
- 50:14somehow expectations run ahead of the reality.
- 50:18And so the hype cycle creates a lot of unnecessary angst.
- 50:22And so that is the biggest challenge because when you have
- 50:25that incoming condition, then it's easy for people to misjudge
- 50:29and form the wrong mental model. They think it's 80% done because
- 50:32the demo looks great, but we all know the 80% looking done demo
- 50:35is really 10% done. And so it's super important to
- 50:39help the stakeholders understand where you actually are in the
- 50:42journey so that you're mentally equipped and that you're
- 50:44systematically equipped to actually go all the way.
- 50:47Where can CIO's add the most value to their organizations in
- 50:53this new AI based world? The first is making sure that
- 50:59one, the executive team is aligned about what is and isn't
- 51:03possible, right? Secondly, about really changing
- 51:06the culture by providing the right tools, by holding the
- 51:09right discussions, by creating the right environment, as we
- 51:11said, to invite people in and not use a hammer, people over
- 51:14the head to adopt AI, right? And then the final piece I think
- 51:18is role modelling, right? I think there is an expectation
- 51:20as the CIO or the leading technology figure at your
- 51:23company to practice as your preach, right?
- 51:25You don't want to forget about your your own teams and how do
- 51:28you upskill them and make sure they are properly equipped and
- 51:31that they're walking the talk as well?
- 51:34What advice do you have for CIOs when it comes to scaling AII?
- 51:38Think three things. One is create friendly
- 51:41competition to get adoption and scale right.
- 51:43There's nothing better than having the business with you arm
- 51:46in arm saying that hey, we did the best project ever.
- 51:49Second, stay grounded, right? And that means figuring out
- 51:53where you are as a company, not where you hope you are, but
- 51:55where you are and get the right on ramps.
- 51:57Don't under or over assume knowledge of where your business
- 52:00is. And then finally, I think
- 52:02sometimes people call it a race, but that's not quite right.
- 52:04So the right mental model is that it's more of an ongoing
- 52:07journey, definitely not a Sprint, not even a marathon
- 52:10because you don't finish right? And recognizing that each
- 52:13company has their own journey to be on not and that you were not
- 52:18necessarily running the same race as someone else.
- 52:22And that's really the sweet spot more than ever about sitting at
- 52:25the intersection of really a tremendously set of tremendously
- 52:28dynamic set of technology, business and market forces that
- 52:32I think CIOs can really help bring their companies to the
- 52:34next level with that recognition.
- 52:37With that, we're out of time. A huge thank you to Art who.
- 52:41He's the global CIO at Lenovo. He's also the chief delivery and
- 52:45technology officer of Lenovo Services and Solutions Group.
- 52:50Art, I'm so grateful for you to have come back and spent your
- 52:54time with us. Thank you so much.
- 52:56Thank you, Michael. You made it easy with your
- 52:57insightful questions and thank you to the audience for your
- 53:00great questions also. Go to cxotalk.com and subscribe
- 53:05to our newsletter and we want you to come back audience to our
- 53:09upcoming shows. We really do have tremendous
- 53:13shows. This video will be posted on the
- 53:17CXO Talk website by Monday. Tell other CIOs, you know to
- 53:23come check it out. We'll have a summary this
- 53:26there's there's a lot of valuable information for chief
- 53:30information officers here. So I encourage you share this
- 53:33with the CIOs, you know, because there's a there's a lot here to
- 53:37learn. Thank you so much, everybody.
- 53:39Thanks to Artu and we'll see you again next time.
- 53:41Take care.