Latest / Entangled Reality / Can Forcing Someone to Listen Make Them Free?
Transcript
- 0:03SPEAKER_00: Welcome to Entangled Reality,
- 0:05SPEAKER_00: exploring the hidden relationships,
- 0:07SPEAKER_00: constraints, and forms of trust that shape our world.
- 0:11SPEAKER_00: I'm Kerry Southworth.
- 0:13SPEAKER_00: As we often do, let's start with a question.
- 0:16SPEAKER_00: Can forcing someone to listen ever make them more compliant?
- 0:21SPEAKER_00: At first, the answer seems obvious.
- 0:23SPEAKER_00: If you have to force someone toward a belief,
- 0:26SPEAKER_00: you have probably undermined the very freedom that makes belief meaningful.
- 0:30SPEAKER_00: But what if the person is not choosing freely to begin with?
- 0:35SPEAKER_00: What if fear,
- 0:35SPEAKER_00: family loyalty,
- 0:37SPEAKER_00: social pressure,
- 0:38SPEAKER_00: or years of inherited hostility have made a fair hearing almost impossible?
- 0:44SPEAKER_00: Could outside pressure break the hold of those influences and create room for
- 0:48SPEAKER_00: a more genuine choice?
- 0:51SPEAKER_00: That was, in essence, the problem Augustine faced in North Africa during the early 5th century.
- 0:57SPEAKER_00: And the answer he developed would shape Christian thinking about religious coercion
- 1:01SPEAKER_00: for centuries.
- 1:03SPEAKER_00: This episode accompanies my Substack essay also entitled, Can Love Be Compelled?
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: The essay develops the historical and philosophical argument in greater detail.
- 1:14SPEAKER_00: But here I wanted to stay with the central question.
- 1:17SPEAKER_00: Can pressure ever prepare someone to receive the truth?
- 1:21SPEAKER_00: The conflict involved a Christian movement known as the Donatists.
- 1:26SPEAKER_00: Its origins reached back to the persecution under the Emperor Diocletian
- 1:30SPEAKER_00: when Christians were ordered to surrender scriptures,
- 1:33SPEAKER_00: church property, and sometimes the names of other believers.
- 1:38SPEAKER_00: Some clergy complied.
- 1:40SPEAKER_00: Others refused and suffered for it.
- 1:43SPEAKER_00: When the persecution ended, Christians now had to decide what faithfulness required.
- 1:48SPEAKER_00: Could clergy who had surrendered sacred books return to office?
- 1:53SPEAKER_00: Were the sacraments they performed still valid?
- 1:57SPEAKER_00: And could a church remain holy if it accepted leaders who had failed under pressure?
- 2:01SPEAKER_00: These questions divided the North African church.
- 2:06SPEAKER_00: The immediate dispute concerned Sicilian, the bishop of Carthage.
- 2:10SPEAKER_00: His opponents claimed that one of the bishops who consecrated him had been a tradidore.
- 2:16SPEAKER_00: A person who had handed over sacred materials.
- 2:20SPEAKER_00: They rejected Sicilian and established a rival line of bishops.
- 2:24SPEAKER_00: By Augustine's lifetime, this was no longer a disagreement confined to theologians.
- 2:30SPEAKER_00: Catholics and Donatists lived in the same towns.
- 2:34SPEAKER_00: They had separate bishops,
- 2:35SPEAKER_00: separate congregations, and separate memories of who had betrayed the faith.
- 2:41SPEAKER_00: Families often inherited their allegiance before anyone sat down to examine the arguments.
- 2:48SPEAKER_00: Both sides were protecting something real.
- 2:51SPEAKER_00: Donatists cared about the moral credibility of the Church.
- 2:54SPEAKER_00: Catholics cared about whether human failure could cancel the work of Christ.
- 2:59SPEAKER_00: Augustine argued that baptism belonged to Christ, not to the minister.
- 3:04SPEAKER_00: A corrupt priest could betray his office,
- 3:06SPEAKER_00: but he could not make grace depend upon his own goodness.
- 3:10SPEAKER_00: At first, Augustine opposed forcing Donatus into Catholic communion.
- 3:16SPEAKER_00: He wanted public debate, documentary evidence, scriptural argument, and voluntary reunion.
- 3:22SPEAKER_00: That fits what we discussed in the previous episode.
- 3:26SPEAKER_00: A command can restrain behavior, but it cannot heal the will.
- 3:30SPEAKER_00: The church can present the good.
- 3:31SPEAKER_00: It cannot make another person love it.
- 3:34SPEAKER_00: Then Augustine began to change his mind.
- 3:37SPEAKER_00: Part of the reason was violence.
- 3:39SPEAKER_00: Catholics reported intimidation and attacks, some associated with groups called circumcellions.
- 3:46SPEAKER_00: We have to be careful here because the surviving accounts are often polemical.
- 3:50SPEAKER_00: Not every Donatist was violent and the Catholic side was hardly untouched by coercion.
- 3:57SPEAKER_00: Still real people were injured and Augustine did not think
- 4:00SPEAKER_00: a bishop could simply ignore that danger.
- 4:03SPEAKER_00: There was another reason.
- 4:05SPEAKER_00: Imperial laws were already being used against Donatist communities
- 4:09SPEAKER_00: and Augustine heard from former Donatists who said the pressure had helped them.
- 4:15SPEAKER_00: They had entered Catholic communion reluctantly but later came to believe
- 4:18SPEAKER_00: that they had been freed from an inherited error.
- 4:21SPEAKER_00: What Augustine had rejected in theory now seemed, at least in some cases, to work.
- 4:27SPEAKER_00: Augustine's reasoning was not simply, we have the power, so we should use it.
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: His argument was subtler.
- 4:34SPEAKER_00: Suppose someone's present refusal is shaped by fear, custom and social dependency.
- 4:40SPEAKER_00: Leaving that person alone might look respectful,
- 4:43SPEAKER_00: but it may also leave the existing pressures in control.
- 4:46SPEAKER_00: A different kind of pressure might interrupt the pattern long enough for the person
- 4:51SPEAKER_00: to hear what had previously been excluded.
- 4:55SPEAKER_00: In a letter to Adonidas named Vincentius,
- 4:57SPEAKER_00: Augustine compared correction to a physician restraining a patient
- 5:01SPEAKER_00: who could not recognize the cure or apparent discipline in a child.
- 5:06SPEAKER_00: The pain is not the goal.
- 5:08SPEAKER_00: The goal is to restore the person to hell.
- 5:10SPEAKER_00: He also appealed to Scripture.
- 5:13SPEAKER_00: Paul had not been gently invited to reconsider his persecution of Christians.
- 5:18SPEAKER_00: He had been struck down on the road to Damascus,
- 5:21SPEAKER_00: and in Jesus' parable of the great banquet,
- 5:23SPEAKER_00: the master tells his servant to compel them to come in.
- 5:27SPEAKER_00: Augustine did not think that a fine, a confiscation, or an imperial decree could create faith.
- 5:35SPEAKER_00: The state could produce fear, but it could not produce love.
- 5:39SPEAKER_00: His claim was that pressure might remove an obstacle,
- 5:42SPEAKER_00: after which grace could do what force could never do.
- 5:46SPEAKER_00: And we should acknowledge what is true in that argument.
- 5:50SPEAKER_00: Freedom is not merely being left alone.
- 5:52SPEAKER_00: A person trapped by addiction,
- 5:54SPEAKER_00: manipulation,
- 5:55SPEAKER_00: threats,
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: or an all-encompassing social world may need an interruption
- 5:59SPEAKER_00: before meaningful choice becomes possible.
- 6:03SPEAKER_00: Restraining the person who is doing the threatening can enlarge someone else's freedom.
- 6:10SPEAKER_00: The trouble begins when protection from coercion becomes coercion toward a predetermined answer.
- 6:16SPEAKER_00: A magistrate can restrain assault without deciding which church the victim and
- 6:21SPEAKER_00: the offender must attend.
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: Once the state attaches penalties to religious belonging itself,
- 6:27SPEAKER_00: it is no longer just creating the conditions for a fair hearing.
- 6:30SPEAKER_00: It is shaping the conclusion.
- 6:33SPEAKER_00: Augustine's medical comparison makes this easy to miss.
- 6:37SPEAKER_00: The physician is supposed to act according to some independent account of health.
- 6:41SPEAKER_00: But in this controversy,
- 6:43SPEAKER_00: the Catholic institution declared itself healthy,
- 6:46SPEAKER_00: diagnosed the Donatist refusal as sickness,
- 6:49SPEAKER_00: prescribed the treatment,
- 6:50SPEAKER_00: and then treated conformity as evidence that the cure had worked.
- 6:54SPEAKER_00: Some people who were compelled may have become sincere Catholics.
- 6:59SPEAKER_00: Their testimony matters.
- 7:01SPEAKER_00: But what about the outward conformist?
- 7:03SPEAKER_00: What about the person who stayed silent or learned to associate Christian teaching with fear?
- 7:09SPEAKER_00: Those people are less likely to appear in the institution's record of success.
- 7:14SPEAKER_00: That is the key distinction.
- 7:16SPEAKER_00: Law may be able to bring a body through a church door.
- 7:20SPEAKER_00: It cannot tell us what has happened in the heart.
- 7:23SPEAKER_00: Attendance can be compelled.
- 7:25SPEAKER_00: Property can be transferred.
- 7:27SPEAKER_00: Clergy can be exiled.
- 7:30SPEAKER_00: But none of those actions can create the love that makes Christian communion more
- 7:34SPEAKER_00: than administrative unity.
- 7:37SPEAKER_00: That brings us to the larger question of order.
- 7:40SPEAKER_00: Order is not good simply because it is orderly.
- 7:43SPEAKER_00: A system can be coherent, stable, and efficient while serving a destructive purpose.
- 7:49SPEAKER_00: We have to ask what the order is for,
- 7:52SPEAKER_00: whether its methods remain aligned with that purpose,
- 7:54SPEAKER_00: and what its stability costs the relationships around it.
- 7:59SPEAKER_00: The Catholic order Augustine defended named good ends, truth, unity, peace, and love.
- 8:05SPEAKER_00: I do not think those were cynical slogans.
- 8:08SPEAKER_00: The danger was more subtle.
- 8:11SPEAKER_00: An institution can sincerely pursue a good purpose while adopting methods
- 8:15SPEAKER_00: that gradually change what the purpose means.
- 8:19SPEAKER_00: Unity begins as reconciled relationship and becomes the absence of visible disagreement.
- 8:25SPEAKER_00: Peace begins as rightly ordered communion and becomes administrative control.
- 8:31SPEAKER_00: The institution first uses power to serve its mission.
- 8:34SPEAKER_00: Eventually, preserving its power begins to look like part of the mission itself.
- 8:40SPEAKER_00: I've been thinking of this as malign drift.
- 8:43SPEAKER_00: The order may have not begun with a malign purpose.
- 8:46SPEAKER_00: The people maintaining it may believe they are acting for the good.
- 8:50SPEAKER_00: But the means begin to damage the very good the institution exists to protect.
- 8:55SPEAKER_00: Augustine's own theology gives us language for that danger.
- 8:59SPEAKER_00: People can love a real good in the wrong way.
- 9:02SPEAKER_00: Institutions can do the same.
- 9:05SPEAKER_00: Unity is good.
- 9:06SPEAKER_00: Authority and continuity can be good.
- 9:09SPEAKER_00: But if every method of protecting them becomes justified,
- 9:12SPEAKER_00: love of order has itself become disordered.
- 9:16SPEAKER_00: So can love be compelled?
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: No, at least not if we mean the force can produce love.
- 9:23SPEAKER_00: Augustine did not quite claim that it could.
- 9:25SPEAKER_00: His more difficult claim was that force might remove the obstacles that prevent love
- 9:30SPEAKER_00: from awakening.
- 9:32SPEAKER_00: Sometimes intervention really does restore agency.
- 9:36SPEAKER_00: That is why simply saying all pressure is wrong does not answer him.
- 9:41SPEAKER_00: But pressure that protects the possibility of a choice is different from pressure
- 9:45SPEAKER_00: that manages the result.
- 9:48SPEAKER_00: In the Donatist controversy, those purposes became too closely joined.
- 9:53SPEAKER_00: The Church asked imperial authority not only to stop violence but to secure Christian unity.
- 10:00SPEAKER_00: The means used to defend grace began to obscure the character of grace itself.
- 10:05SPEAKER_00: That is the question Augustine leaves with us.
- 10:09SPEAKER_00: Not whether truth matters enough to defend,
- 10:11SPEAKER_00: but whether our way of defending it remains aligned with the truth we claim
- 10:16SPEAKER_00: to serve.
- 10:18SPEAKER_00: Not whether order is stable, but whether it still serves the love for which it was made.
- 10:23SPEAKER_00: If you would like the fuller historical argument,
- 10:25SPEAKER_00: including Augustine's letters,
- 10:27SPEAKER_00: the Donatist's understanding of the Church,
- 10:29SPEAKER_00: and the idea of malign drift,
- 10:31SPEAKER_00: the accompanying essay is available on Entangled Reality.
- 10:35SPEAKER_00: You can also find the developing glossary at entangledreality.org.
- 10:40SPEAKER_00: Thank you for listening.
- 10:41SPEAKER_00: I'm Kerry Southworth.