Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E004: Wealth Management in the Bitcoin Era with Morgen & Pierre Rochard
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:12having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are having all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an
- 1:26international asset. We are spending like drunken
- 1:29sailors. Bitcoin is the only economic
- 1:32entity where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 1:38If you want to preserve your wealth, you have to convert that
- 1:41currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 1:46durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom
- 1:56and I'm happy to welcome you to the 4th episode of Scarce
- 1:58Assets, a show that examines scarcity, the most fundamental
- 2:02driver of economics and markets, and the scarcest asset of all,
- 2:05which is Bitcoin. Today, I'm delighted to be here
- 2:08with my Co host Jesse Myers and our guests, the brilliant Pierre
- 2:12and Morgan Richard. Now, I had the pleasure of
- 2:15saying a few things about Pierre and Morgan.
- 2:18Morgan may be the most knowledgeable financial planner
- 2:21that I know, and she's demonstrated this with proof of
- 2:24work in the form of her book, the Personal Finance Quick Start
- 2:27Guide. Now, I've read the book twice
- 2:30and I've learned a lot from it. It's comprehensive, it's well
- 2:33written, and it's full of useful information for anyone who has
- 2:36any assets, which hopefully is everyone listening right now.
- 2:40I know she's also working on another book, which I'm sure
- 2:43we'll talk about. And of course she runs Origin
- 2:46Wealth Advisors which is an independent, fee only registered
- 2:50investment advisor. OK, now I get to talk about
- 2:52Pierre. Pierre is frankly legendary in
- 2:55the Bitcoin space and he's one of my absolute favorite Bitcoin
- 2:59educators. He runs the Bitcoin to Saving
- 3:01Twitter account which has hundreds of thousands of
- 3:04followers, and he and his friend Michael Goldstein Co host the
- 3:08noted podcast, which is one of my personal favorites.
- 3:12Pierre's been helping people learn about Bitcoin for many
- 3:15years and today he's the VP of Research at Riot Platforms which
- 3:19is a large publicly traded Bitcoin mining company.
- 3:21And disclosure, I'm a shareholder now.
- 3:25I also want to mention the Bitcoin for Advisors podcast,
- 3:27which Morgan hosts and Pierre assists just like I do with
- 3:31Jesse. So maybe we'll get to talk about
- 3:33the fascinating world of podcast hosting, Co hosting and
- 3:37assisting even with that introduction.
- 3:39I'm sure I've missed some great things you're both up to, but
- 3:42it's great to see you today and thank you for being here and how
- 3:45are you go? Ahead.
- 3:48See this is going to be a problem.
- 3:51Thanks for having us on. Is the nicest introduction I
- 3:53think I've ever received. So I really appreciate that.
- 3:56Thank you, Andy. Very kind words.
- 3:58Thanks, Andy. Thanks for having us on.
- 4:00Well, well deserved and can't wait to talk to you.
- 4:03So let's talk about, let's start with your combined Bitcoin
- 4:06journey. And I'm, I actually don't mean
- 4:08the story of how you met, though that is a good story.
- 4:11I mean how you've thought about Bitcoin over time.
- 4:14So for example, I might invoke 3 words, speculation, investment
- 4:20and savings. So, Pierre, what what do these
- 4:23words mean to you and how have you applied them to Bitcoin over
- 4:27the years? Yeah.
- 4:29So I think that from an Austrian perspective, the word
- 4:32speculation does not have the negative connotation that it has
- 4:36kind of in the mainstream. I think that for for Austrians,
- 4:40most things that we do in life are speculative.
- 4:44That is that we're performing an action with a particular
- 4:48expectation about something in the future happening.
- 4:50And so that that kind of speculation can broadly kind of
- 4:55go into two different buckets. One is taking a risk and a risk
- 5:00from an Austrian perspective is something where the outcome is
- 5:04quantitative, quantifiable and ideally that you even have some
- 5:09data that you could have an actuarial model on and be able
- 5:12to model that risk and to have some kind of expected values
- 5:17around that. And so that's one form of
- 5:20speculation is, is taking risk And then the other one is
- 5:24uncertainty. And uncertainty is more
- 5:27qualitative and I I when I think about speculation, speculation
- 5:32on uncertainty, probably the the, the most positive form of
- 5:36it is entrepreneurship or kind of technology.
- 5:40You know, research and development of doing something
- 5:43new where nobody's done it before or nobody's done it in
- 5:48the same way before or with the same combination of resources
- 5:51such that you you can't really build a actuarial model around
- 5:56entrepreneurship and say, oh, here are the probabilities of
- 5:59this person succeeding or not. Do I know that VCs try to do
- 6:03that and maybe that's their downfall.
- 6:05And so VCs are always coming out with, oh, it turns out that a 40
- 6:10year old founder is better than a 20 year old founder or vice
- 6:13versa, because they're trying to create quantitative models when
- 6:16that it just doesn't apply. And so they're constantly having
- 6:19to correct to their investment approach.
- 6:23So that's on the speculation side, and specifically with
- 6:28regards to Bitcoin. Bitcoin's a combination of risk
- 6:32and uncertainty, and so different aspects of the Bitcoin
- 6:36system are uncertain and others are risky.
- 6:39So for example, risky is the purchasing power, right, the
- 6:43price of Bitcoin. And we can have debates on how
- 6:47it should be modeled, how it should not be modeled.
- 6:49But nevertheless it is quantitative, There's a finite
- 6:53range of values that it can have.
- 6:56And then an uncertainty would be, for example, what would an
- 7:01uncertainty be? Bitcoin has very few
- 7:03uncertainties, is actually one of the points compared to, for
- 7:06example, the Fiat system. An uncertainty is how much money
- 7:13will the government print, right?
- 7:14Because ultimately there that's qualitative.
- 7:17It's going to be decided by humans at the Federal Reserve
- 7:19and in Congress. It's not going to be decided by
- 7:22by a quantitative, although they they again they pretend to be
- 7:26quantitative whereas Bitcoins money supply has very little
- 7:31uncertainty because it is algorithmic.
- 7:34It actually is quantitative in the sense of, you know, you've
- 7:37got the halving every 210,000 blocks.
- 7:40And then on the investment side, you know the I think that this
- 7:44is really where folks like Warren Buffett and and others
- 7:47trip up is that they only look at the world through the lens of
- 7:51investment and they, you know, bitcoins complicated for them
- 7:55because an investment generates cash flow.
- 7:59I think fundamentally it's kind of the the the the idea of an
- 8:02investment, whether it's a liability or equity that is
- 8:05going to throw off some kind of cash flow.
- 8:07And Bitcoin being cash itself does not generate a cash flow,
- 8:12it is cash. And so that I think is for for
- 8:17investors out there confounding because they don't like the idea
- 8:21of purchasing an asset and then just sitting on it, you know
- 8:24putting it in cold storage and not earning A yield, you know
- 8:28not earning some kind of cash flow that is.
- 8:32And that that perspective I think is a result of the Fiat
- 8:37system where yes indeed you you do want to own assets that
- 8:42generate cash flows. Otherwise you're just taking on
- 8:46inflation and you know you're going to get diluted out of your
- 8:49dollars. So I'll, I'll let Morgan spend
- 8:53on them if she wants to or we can take the next question.
- 8:57I think you summarized that pretty well.
- 8:58I would say, just to add on the investment piece, like when
- 9:02people are looking for investments, they're
- 9:05specifically looking to grow themselves out of the inflation
- 9:10predicament that they're in. And so for the average person,
- 9:14right, investment is simply that, right?
- 9:15There are obviously expert investors who are looking at it
- 9:17very differently than the average person is.
- 9:19But for the average person, they're just saying, OK, I was
- 9:21told to invest because there's inflation over time.
- 9:23And therefore I have to take the money that I earn, anything that
- 9:25I save in excess of that and put it into something.
- 9:28And so if they're thinking of Bitcoin as cash, not Bitcoin
- 9:31cash, but as cash there, they would not necessarily be.
- 9:36And if they're looking for that, quote UN quote, cash flow that
- 9:39the investors are always talking about that you're supposed to
- 9:41receive, they're not going to necessarily value Bitcoin
- 9:43properly as opposed to looking at it as a savings vehicle
- 9:46whereby they can just sit on their money and they they won't
- 9:50lose purchasing power over time until they actually decide
- 9:53whether or not they're going to spend it or actually deploy it
- 9:55as some sort of investment. It gives you a lot more
- 9:57optionality to sit on savings rather than to sit on an
- 9:59investment. Interesting.
- 10:03So I'm going to try and pin you on it though is so it's a
- 10:05combination of a speculation and investment and savings or
- 10:11Morgan, do you do you think that the savings element or the
- 10:15savings framing sort of resonates most strongly for you?
- 10:20It's definitely savings. So when I look at it in a client
- 10:23portfolio, yes, we're looking at it in terms of investable
- 10:26assets, OK. For as far as investable assets
- 10:27are concerned, how are we going to allocate to this savings
- 10:31versus these investments? And so I guess it doesn't
- 10:35necessarily pin down exactly what you're what you're looking
- 10:37for here, but it is savings, right, because the difference is
- 10:40that I'm not taking it and putting it into something that
- 10:42has all these other extraordinary risks that are
- 10:44associated with investment. I think that we often minimize
- 10:48those risks because it's become so commonplace to use something
- 10:50like the S&P 500 as a savings account.
- 10:53And so we just think, OK, if we own 500 companies and we've
- 10:55diversified all away all the issues, right.
- 10:58But we haven't diversified away the systematic risk of just
- 11:00owning investments in general. And so you're it's just it's all
- 11:04trade-offs, right. So what you're trading here is
- 11:06that you're owning a long term savings vehicle and yeah, in
- 11:09that long term savings vehicle you're going to have a high
- 11:12volatility to aspect to that savings vehicle with you know
- 11:16the trade-offs of necessarily investing which comes with a
- 11:18slew of other risks. Yeah.
- 11:20And to to piggyback off of that with with the index investing, I
- 11:24I think that the, the main limitation there is that there's
- 11:30not really the kind of oversight that you would expect from the
- 11:34owner of the business. It's so essentially you know
- 11:38you're you're splitting up the ownership among so many
- 11:40different people and then you're putting so many middle men
- 11:43between the you know retail investor and the company and the
- 11:49management that I think that it's it we're we live in a world
- 11:55where there should be a lot less invest investors, right.
- 11:58There should be fewer people making investment decisions but
- 12:03making better ones, not ones that are based on automations,
- 12:07right? Oh, I'm automatically going to
- 12:09buy more of this portfolio of stocks.
- 12:13I I I think that that leads to capital misallocation, even
- 12:17though people do it for a reason today, right?
- 12:19Which is that it solves a particular problem they're
- 12:21facing that their their dollars are a melting ice cube.
- 12:27I I think there's an interesting conundrum here where Pierre
- 12:32thank you for sort of popularizing the Bitcoin is
- 12:35savings idea. I've I've certainly run with
- 12:38that quite a bit. I think that is the way that
- 12:40people should think of Bitcoin first and foremost as savings
- 12:45technology technology that grows the the purchasing power of your
- 12:49savings and happens to do it in a way that outperforms every
- 12:54other asset class out there. And and historically and I think
- 12:57in my opinion looking forward as well and that creates this
- 13:01conundrum because Morgan you as a wealth manager have to decide
- 13:06how much or or help inform, help advise how much of your
- 13:11portfolio should be in this asset class versus this asset
- 13:15class. But we have this, this problem
- 13:17of Bitcoin might be the the, the most certain, as Pierre pointed
- 13:23out and the highest performing because of its inherent
- 13:28properties and the certainty that that comes with all that.
- 13:31And so how do you Morgan and and I guess maybe how do you as as a
- 13:36pair talk about what is the right way to approach how to
- 13:42allocate or how much to allocate.
- 13:44And obviously it's on a case by case basis based on the
- 13:47circumstances of your clients, but how do you guys think about
- 13:50that and specifically you Morgan.
- 13:51Yeah. So the number one thing that you
- 13:55need to look at is spending. People don't like to do this
- 13:57because spending is the least interesting part of Bitcoin,
- 14:01right? Most people think, OK, I'll just
- 14:02buy Bitcoin and then I can get out of jail free.
- 14:06Basically, I don't need to worry about how much I'm spending.
- 14:08I don't need to even worry about how much I'm saving.
- 14:10I don't need to worry about how much I'm going to need in the
- 14:12future because I'll just buy this asset Bitcoin, and then the
- 14:15future, It'll go to the moon and then it'll solve all these other
- 14:18financial planning problems that I otherwise would have had.
- 14:20And it's just simply not the case on a case by case basis.
- 14:23Every time a client comes in, the first thing we look at is
- 14:25net worth and spending. And the reason why is because
- 14:27net worth and spending dictate literally every single aspect of
- 14:30personal finance down to how much Bitcoin you can even own.
- 14:34Because if you don't have something so like Menial is just
- 14:37a emergency savings account, you can't even buy Bitcoin, right?
- 14:40Because you will be selling that Bitcoin should an emergency come
- 14:42up. And so, like, not to get too
- 14:45deep into the weeds with specific, you know, examples on
- 14:49people, but if you're looking at spending, right, if you're
- 14:50looking at how much you're spending overtime, how much
- 14:53money you have coming in, how much money you have going out,
- 14:55how much you're actually saving. And you're sort of projecting
- 14:57out into the future your ability to either save or when you're
- 15:00actually going to need to spend this Bitcoin, right.
- 15:02Then from there, you can make asset allocation decisions based
- 15:05on how much I want to have in savings versus how much I want
- 15:07to have an investment. And so because there are so many
- 15:10different factors that go into all of those ideas, right, it's
- 15:13really, really hard to give a, you know, a specific number to
- 15:16people about what how much should they allocate and how
- 15:19much do they need for the future, right?
- 15:21Because all of those things are going to depend on how much they
- 15:23spend and how much they save. And so for a person who, you
- 15:26know, let's say they only spend 50 grand a year, they're going
- 15:28to need a lot less than somebody who's spending $500,000 a year,
- 15:31right? Those numbers are they're
- 15:33they're nowhere close to each other.
- 15:34And just projecting that out over many, many years, right?
- 15:38You're going to need just exponentially more money to keep
- 15:41up with $500,000 worth of spending versus $50,000 worth of
- 15:44spending. Yeah, that's helpful.
- 15:48That's helpful framing. So my one of my personal, so I
- 15:53don't know, realizations over time, I guess I'll say is I've
- 15:56just become more comfortable with Bitcoin and a sizable
- 15:59portion of net worth and Bitcoin with time.
- 16:02And what I haven't figured out is whether that's a change in my
- 16:06investment thesis, quote UN quote, or it's more about
- 16:10comfort and having lived through a couple of market cycles.
- 16:14Do you have any thoughts about that, Pierre?
- 16:16Do you think that over the years your investment thesis has
- 16:20changed, or your thoughts about why to hold Bitcoin have changed
- 16:25quite a bit? Or has it been more of sort of
- 16:28an evolution of your comfort level increasing?
- 16:32Or were you always very comfortable?
- 16:34Yeah, well, I mean, I think at first it was like, OK, I'm, I'm
- 16:38in my early 20s, let's call it. And I also, you know, it's like
- 16:44ideological right of oh, I'm buying Bitcoin to protest
- 16:48against the Fiat system and so it it doesn't really matter, you
- 16:52know, any kind of question about allocation or returns or things
- 16:58like that. Or responsibility?
- 17:00Yeah, exactly. And now though, I I think that
- 17:05now it's like, OK, what if if I was not, if I was not holding
- 17:12Bitcoin or if I was not allocating capital to to
- 17:16Bitcoin, what are the alternatives?
- 17:18What would I allocate it to otherwise and how do I evaluate
- 17:23those on their merits? And that's where, you know, I go
- 17:26back to Mr. Sailors. There's no second best because
- 17:30even on the consumption side, you know, it's like, do you want
- 17:33to buy a, a sports car that then you have to maintain And it does
- 17:38it really incrementally increase, you know, your
- 17:41enjoyment of life or your utility.
- 17:44And for some people that might be the case.
- 17:46For me, like, I'm not a car guy. So I think just in general,
- 17:50like, I I don't really have particularly expensive tastes
- 17:53when it comes to consumption. So it's pretty easy for me to be
- 17:56like, OK, well I I I don't care about what the Bitcoin price is
- 18:00because I'm not looking to cash out or anything like that.
- 18:06Yeah, that makes complete sense. You know, when you're in your
- 18:08early 20s, the good news is you don't have any capital to
- 18:11allocate any anyway, right? So who knows, maybe maybe you
- 18:15secretly had made a fortune in your teens.
- 18:17But absent that kind of scenario, unlikely that the
- 18:21stakes are are are very high. Yeah, no.
- 18:24And quite the opposite. I mean, going back to to what
- 18:26Morgan was saying that, you know, I, I, I paid off my
- 18:29student loan debt after graduating before, you know,
- 18:33acquiring more Bitcoin. And you know, hindsight 2020, if
- 18:36you did the math, it's like, oh, wow, that's that was not a good
- 18:39move. But I think that's only with
- 18:41hindsight. And if we think about financial
- 18:44planning as like a set of best practices, there is a best
- 18:47practice of, hey, pay off your debt, put up, you know, an
- 18:51emergency savings account of, you know, six months of expenses
- 18:56and then you're ready to start allocating to Bitcoin.
- 19:00And I think for bitcoiners, it's like the the immediate reaction
- 19:04to that is, well, first of all, that's an infringement on our
- 19:07freedom. And you know, Bitcoin doesn't
- 19:09care about my debt and I can do whatever I want.
- 19:13And that's true. Bitcoin gives you that freedom.
- 19:15Bitcoin gives you the freedom to go 100X leverage and to get
- 19:19wrecked, right? You can absolutely destroy all
- 19:22of your capital by using Bitcoin, sending it to a burner
- 19:27address if you want to, right. And so when I I think that the
- 19:32kind of the narrative around Bitcoin of, hey, it's freedom,
- 19:36Money has to be balanced with the fact that with tremendous
- 19:39freedom comes tremendous responsibility.
- 19:42And if you misuse Bitcoin, you might be thinking that, hey,
- 19:46you're sticking it to the Maxis, right?
- 19:48Oh, I'm doing this because, you know, other people don't like me
- 19:52doing this or whatever, But the reality is you're only hurting
- 19:54yourself, right? You're just destroying your own
- 19:56capital. And that that I think is is
- 20:00something to reflect upon. To circle back also to what you
- 20:03said about best practices, it does.
- 20:05Best practices don't necessarily mean best outcomes.
- 20:07And I think that people misconstrue that because they
- 20:10think, OK, well, in the best outcome.
- 20:12Right. I don't have the emergency fund,
- 20:14and I don't pay off my student loan debt that has high yield.
- 20:17And I don't pay off some consumer debt because I'm, you
- 20:20know, Bitcoin is going to go to the moon and I'm going to get
- 20:22and, you know, it's going to get inflated away, and it's not
- 20:24going to matter. Right.
- 20:25And that might be true, let's say, in 10% of the
- 20:29circumstances, that happens in Bitcoin.
- 20:31Right. But then there's maybe the other
- 20:3290% of circumstances where it doesn't actually go exactly
- 20:35according to your plan. In which case there's a reason
- 20:37why there are best practices. It's like it doesn't necessarily
- 20:40mean that always the best practices are going to cause the
- 20:42best outcomes, But most of the time, they will.
- 20:45And that's why we have these procedures in place to help
- 20:47protect people so that they're not thinking about themselves as
- 20:50retired before they're actually retired.
- 20:51Right. If you're already spending all
- 20:53your capital before you've actually accumulated enough
- 20:55capital, right, you're never going to retire.
- 20:56So there are a lot of little steps that you have to take,
- 20:59little financial planning best practices that are there to save
- 21:02you from yourself. Yeah, that's that's very well
- 21:06said. And I want to loop in a question
- 21:08from our or really a comment from our mutual friend Jim
- 21:12Crater, which his, his comment is, don't underestimate how long
- 21:16gradually can take, but also don't underestimate how fast
- 21:20suddenly can happen. And of course he's talking about
- 21:24Bitcoin, let's say reaching its potential or perhaps the value
- 21:29reaching a a higher order of magnitude, A significantly
- 21:32higher order of magnitude than we're seeing currently.
- 21:35So what are, what are your latest thoughts, both of you, on
- 21:40timing? Do you think about or do you
- 21:44plan based on an expectation of where Bitcoin's price could go,
- 21:50let's say, over the coming few years?
- 21:53Or do you set a very wide range and just kind of sit back and
- 21:57wait for it to happen? I think general rule of thumb is
- 22:01after anyone buys Bitcoin, the price immediately goes down.
- 22:07Yeah, and. That's happened to me.
- 22:08That's my experience. Yeah, yeah.
- 22:10I don't know. I don't know who's on the other
- 22:12side of these trades. You know where they're like
- 22:14they're. Always on the losing side.
- 22:16But I'm definitely always on the losing side.
- 22:18So I think that this is where Matt Odell's, you know, stay
- 22:23humble, Stack Sats is really critical because the humility is
- 22:28knowing that, hey, look, Bitcoin is volatile.
- 22:32That's like the number one people say thing about Bitcoin
- 22:35is, is it volatile? And yes, that is true.
- 22:37Bitcoin is volatile. And therefore when you think
- 22:41about being in the market or you know, staying invested and and
- 22:45kind of that mentality, it's critical.
- 22:47With Bitcoin in in particular, there's analysis that have been
- 22:51done that essentially say, OK, let's assume you missed the 10
- 22:55best days of Bitcoin over the past year and then they show
- 22:59that you have zero returns, right.
- 23:00It's it's kind of the returns are concentrated in particular
- 23:04time windows and the humility is recognizing that I'm not going
- 23:07to catch that most. I'd say 99.9% of people should
- 23:13not be traders or are are entirely unqualified to be
- 23:17traders And then the remaining ones should not be traitors for
- 23:21for other reasons other than their, you know, yeah they can
- 23:25be skilled, but it's probably still not the best use of their
- 23:27time And so that that's where you have to approach it from the
- 23:33financial planning perspective which which Morgan will get.
- 23:37To add to that, I would say to that people have this price,
- 23:40they have price expectations around the halving and so right.
- 23:44The problem with having price expectations around the halving
- 23:47is that if you're it's like counting your chickens before
- 23:49they hatch. If you're already deciding that,
- 23:52Okay, my stack is gonna be worth between 10 and 100 X what it is
- 23:55today, and therefore on May of May 25th of 2025, I'm going to
- 24:01be able to do whatever I want, you know, flip off my boss, go
- 24:06take my kids on a trip around the world, right?
- 24:08If you're planning all of these things in advance of actually
- 24:11getting that 100 to 150 X return, that may or may not
- 24:14happen, right? The problem is that, like,
- 24:16people start to live in the reality in which they're they're
- 24:19thinking in, right? And you have to live in their
- 24:21current reality. And so I tell bitcoiners this
- 24:23all the time, because bitcoiners always say, OK, well in the
- 24:26future there's not going to be an IRS and therefore estate
- 24:28planning doesn't matter. Iras don't matter, right?
- 24:31You name it, it doesn't matter. I don't need to do any of that
- 24:33stuff because by the time people actually inherit my assets, the
- 24:37government will not, will cease to exist and I will be living on
- 24:40my little sea setting thing or whatever they're going to be
- 24:42doing, right? Except that that's not the
- 24:44current reality, right? The current reality is that they
- 24:46live in Maryland and you know, they might pass away tomorrow
- 24:50and they haven't done any sort of planning whatsoever.
- 24:53They didn't take advantage of the four O 1K match that they
- 24:55have where they could have gone 100% return.
- 24:58They didn't, you know, take deductions along the way.
- 25:00They didn't do any of the things that they could have been doing
- 25:02where they actually could have been stacking more Bitcoin.
- 25:04And you know, whoever would have see if their Bitcoin actually
- 25:07doesn't even know where it is because it's in some treasure
- 25:09map that got lost, right? There's all these things where
- 25:11if we are planning for current reality, then we are going to
- 25:15make good decisions. And if we're planning for some
- 25:16future reality, that may or may not pan out and we're going to
- 25:19make bad decisions. And I would say that's true
- 25:21about whether it's in Bitcoin or whether it's in any sort of
- 25:24traditional finance, right. People do this all the time with
- 25:25estate funding. They think that they can gain
- 25:27the system or somehow, you know, pass money to their to their
- 25:30errors without worrying about estate planning, taxes and then
- 25:33the rules change, right. And then they get locked into
- 25:35these trusts and other things that they should have otherwise
- 25:38not have done because of the estate planning rules.
- 25:40And so my number one thing that we tell our clients is we need
- 25:43to plan based on what is happening today and we need to
- 25:46have long time horizons on these things.
- 25:48If we're thinking about using our Bitcoin in the next, you
- 25:51know, 18 months, then bitcoins not the right savings vehicle
- 25:54for you, right? We need to find a different way.
- 25:57Yeah, I'd say you'd have to have a time horizon of at least five
- 26:01years of, OK, I've, I've acquired this capital, whether
- 26:05it's a bonus or an inheritance or just your, you know, biweekly
- 26:09paycheck and then you have to look at, OK, if I put $50.00
- 26:15into Bitcoin, could I hold that for five years at least?
- 26:20And if the answer is no, then as Morgan said, like that's not
- 26:24going to be the right path forward for you and vice versa,
- 26:27right? If if your circumstances have
- 26:29changed and you are holding a large amount of Bitcoin, that
- 26:33might be time to re evaluate your emergency fund and convert
- 26:37some Bitcoin into a Fiat in order to, you know, make sure
- 26:40that you have what you need. And so in a way, it's not so
- 26:44much that you're buying and selling Bitcoin based off the
- 26:46price chart, you're buying and selling Bitcoin based off of
- 26:50your cash flow and your balance sheet and your income statement.
- 26:54You know, it's very intrinsic to your circumstances rather than
- 26:59extrinsic to what's happening in the market.
- 27:02But there's also that element that you talked about before of
- 27:05the of the certainty that may or may not be there of.
- 27:08And I think that's maybe the trap that we fall into when we
- 27:11project forward past to having and and there's certainty about
- 27:15what will happen in terms of the the block reward but there's not
- 27:19necessarily certainty about what it will mean for the the price
- 27:22of Bitcoin and and those things can can cause us to be overly
- 27:28optimistic or or at least overly certain more certain than than
- 27:33we actually can be about what's possible And I'm certainly
- 27:38guilty of this. You know I I fall into the the
- 27:42the problem of you know they're like when talking about
- 27:47portfolio allocation in BlackRock did their little
- 27:49analysis and came up with the optimal allocation of 87% to
- 27:53Bitcoin which is you know some low level analyst at BlackRock
- 27:57doing that I'm sure. But you know that that's the
- 28:01historical outcome of of what has happened but that's not
- 28:05necessarily what will happen. And and I think that five year
- 28:09time right though funny enough that five year timeline could
- 28:12introduce volatility like depending on if it is a four
- 28:15year cycle and you buy at the top and then you sell a cycle
- 28:19and a year later at the bottom, it could actually come out the
- 28:23the wrong way so. I'd like to go on the record
- 28:25that I'm longer than A5. I just like I think 5 is short.
- 28:30Like I think bitcoin's like 10 plus years, you know, kind of
- 28:34asset, you know where you've been through multiple cycles,
- 28:36not necessarily one. And the other thing I will say
- 28:38on that is that Bitcoin, if it's a large portion of your
- 28:41portfolio is going to be the main, the dominant driver of
- 28:43returns both to the upside and the downside on your portfolio.
- 28:47And so I think that people don't, they look back at the
- 28:51returns, right and they say, OK, if I had bought let's say in
- 28:532014 and then I held you know over the last 10 years to today,
- 28:57then I would have been able to stomach it and I wouldn't have
- 28:59rebalanced and I wouldn't have anything, right.
- 29:01Because and it would have been the main driver of my returns.
- 29:03I would have you know had I don't even know X number percent
- 29:05is A6000. I really don't know it off the
- 29:07top of my head. But the problem right is that
- 29:10because that volatility is both to the upside and the downside,
- 29:13if you are not committed to just holding through and not being a
- 29:16long term asset that you're willing to hold for 10 plus
- 29:18years, right then you aren't actually going to experience
- 29:21that being the main driver of returns.
- 29:24And so like I've been looking into this quite a lot now
- 29:26because we're starting to look at what are, what are reasonable
- 29:29safe withdrawal, safe withdrawal rates for people who have
- 29:33concentrated Bitcoin positions. And we're talking about, you
- 29:35know, people are holding 40% or more of their assets in Bitcoin.
- 29:38And because once you're at that 40% number or higher, Bitcoin is
- 29:42the main driver of returns. And therefore you have to be
- 29:44conscious of, OK, how much can I actually port pull out of My
- 29:47Portfolio at any given period of time without risking my whole
- 29:50portfolio like in the future and then I actually have to go back
- 29:53to work or so forth. So those safe withdrawal rates
- 29:56are very different than what people think of typically in the
- 29:58Fiat world and that 4% number is generally what people are
- 30:01looking at. And I unfortunately don't have
- 30:04all the answers for this podcast, but I think it's just a
- 30:06it's an interesting thing that people are going to be working
- 30:08on going forward. That's a super interesting topic
- 30:11that are you finding that it it varies or that it's a more
- 30:15conservative number or higher number just kind of ballpark?
- 30:20Yeah. So what happens is that, so the
- 30:22way that I guess for the listeners, right, there's this
- 30:25study that was done by Bill Bengan whereby you can take
- 30:28basically what he said is over 30 period, 30 year periods of
- 30:31time, you were able to withdraw a safe withdrawal rate of 4% of
- 30:34that portfolio at the end of every single year.
- 30:36You would basically mark to market the value of your
- 30:39portfolio and then throughout the year you would be able to
- 30:41take out that value until the next 1231 valuation date where
- 30:45you would reassess how much you can take out.
- 30:47And So what we're finding is basically that because Bitcoin
- 30:51is so volatile the the withdrawal rates or like even if
- 30:55the withdrawal rate is very similar, right, the the amount
- 30:57that you can take out what like varies wildly.
- 31:01And so for most people, it's going to be like they have very
- 31:04unexpected ways of predicting what their fixed expenses can be
- 31:08unless they're willing to basically have like kind of
- 31:10muted fixed expenses and then have varied, you know,
- 31:14discretionary expenses over time to make up for those years where
- 31:17you have like a huge change in your portfolio, right, and then
- 31:20a huge down draw in your portfolio and that's the driver
- 31:23of returns. And so with without actually
- 31:26being able to give you hard data, because I'm not totally
- 31:28through all the data that's that's what I'm finding so far
- 31:31is that just the withdrawal rates are so wild that it's
- 31:34actually going to be hard for people to plan around those.
- 31:37Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 31:39exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 31:42about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 31:46allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 31:50We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 31:53Yeah, I think the, the time horizon, you know going longer
- 31:56than five years, talking about maybe 10 years.
- 31:59I think the, to my memory, the classic timeline for holding
- 32:03stocks right, for having an equities portfolio is having
- 32:06something like A at least a decade investment time horizon.
- 32:12Partly perhaps because you get a business cycle right and you get
- 32:15a bear market in equities every decade at least.
- 32:20And so you have to be able to not be drawing on those assets
- 32:23right in the downturn or at the bottom.
- 32:26Good news, I guess is that the cycle so far, good news, bad
- 32:29news is the cycles in Bitcoin have come, have come more
- 32:33frequently. I'd like to turn actually
- 32:36Pierre, to your work in the mining business now.
- 32:40What are the analogies perhaps when it comes to capital
- 32:44allocation and budgeting? I mean, I have to imagine if you
- 32:48are a Bitcoin mining operation, you face a lot of these issues
- 32:53as well. Of course you have the having
- 32:56which complicates your life, but still you got to live through a
- 32:59couple cycles to survive. What are there any parallels to
- 33:03personal behavior and budgeting and balance sheets and and
- 33:08activity? Or is it a different based
- 33:10entirely? Yeah, it's it's a little bit
- 33:14different in the sense that one could think of buying a mining
- 33:20rig as kind of committing yourself to DCA for a particular
- 33:26period of time of like hey, I'm going to DCA for the next four
- 33:29years. And you know, I think that the
- 33:33biggest challenge in the mining industry is the one of the
- 33:38biggest strengths of the Bitcoin system, which is that it's a dog
- 33:42eat dog hyper competitive industry in the sense that
- 33:46around the world everybody is producing the same commodity
- 33:50shot, 256 hashes and they're competing for the same fixed pie
- 33:55of rewards. And so it really is about who
- 33:59can find the best sources of energy and then who can operate
- 34:04these facilities in the best way to, you know accomplish that DCA
- 34:12and and to do it with with margins, right, such that, OK, I
- 34:17could go on an exchange and I could DCA for the next five
- 34:20years, right. Will I be, will I have a higher
- 34:24cost basis of acquiring those coins versus buying a mining
- 34:29rake today and then kind of looking at the cost basis there
- 34:32And then, so I think that there's a lot of different
- 34:36business models that work within the Bitcoin mining industry.
- 34:40But I think that's that's kind of where the parallels end.
- 34:45And I would just highlight, you know, Bitcoin mining is an
- 34:48investment, right, because it generates a cash flow of SAT's
- 34:53and that's how it should be thought about.
- 34:56And yeah, happy to elaborate in any direction there, but there
- 35:02there's it's it's a fascinating world.
- 35:05Yeah. Well, I'd love to learn a little
- 35:06bit more about the mind of a of a capital allocator in a in a
- 35:11Bitcoin operation. You mentioned one of one of the
- 35:15factors you mentioned was operations, basically
- 35:19operational excellence and efficiencies in operations.
- 35:23Does that mean sort of skunk works in, you know, kind of
- 35:27trying different methods for organizing the rigs within the
- 35:33data center, you know, for locating them, for doing
- 35:37immersion cooling versus air cooling?
- 35:40Does it seem to pay dividends in the long run or does it seem to
- 35:44have an investment payoff to try a bunch of different stuff?
- 35:49Or is it better to be a a fast follower?
- 35:52You know, better at copying somebody else's innovation?
- 35:55Or is it a combination? Yeah, that's a great question.
- 35:59So I think that throughout the industry, people are doing
- 36:03experiments, they're trying out different technologies.
- 36:05There's new vendors coming out with different offerings all the
- 36:08time. I do think that it is necessary
- 36:13to engage in that in order to then be able to scale it.
- 36:19I don't think that there's going to be a lot of success from
- 36:23copycat like fast followers because they don't accumulate
- 36:28the right tacit knowledge that comes with actually
- 36:31experimenting with the different technologies and how they come
- 36:35together. And so there's so many different
- 36:39moving parts to a Bitcoin mining facility at scale that if you
- 36:43just try to copycat, you're just going to end up missing one of
- 36:46those pieces and then repeatedly stubbing your toe, right?
- 36:50So I think that anybody who wants to get into the Bitcoin
- 36:54mining industry should probably start with like 1 mining rig and
- 36:59then go to two and then ten and then a hundred and then 1000 and
- 37:04then 10,000 and 100,000, right? If you try to go straight to
- 37:08100,000, you're definitely going to you know be be banging your
- 37:14head against the wall or or worse getting electrocuted.
- 37:17So the, I think the, the, the operational excellence isn't
- 37:23just limited either to kind of the physical reality of
- 37:27electrical and cooling. It's also related to the
- 37:31financial operations of how are you financing this business in
- 37:36order to withstand Bitcoin's volatility, right.
- 37:39You have to have the right capital structure.
- 37:41I mean, if you go all in on debt at the top of the market, you're
- 37:46going to be upside down, right? And you're going to have to go
- 37:49through a a bankruptcy process that's going to be expensive and
- 37:52a big distraction as well as not just from financial operations
- 37:57on the capital market side, but also on the electrical market.
- 38:02Because if you're mining Bitcoin at scale, then you are a large
- 38:07participant in the electricity market of the local grid or you
- 38:12know you're producing your own electricity and that comes with
- 38:15its own can of worms. And so I think that from the
- 38:20cost of electricity perspective, I I've seen and just speaking
- 38:25for myself, not for for Riot, but I think that most people are
- 38:27right. We agree with me on this is that
- 38:29your cost of electricity is going to have a huge influence
- 38:34on what your margins are going to be as a Bitcoin miner.
- 38:38And so if you try to mine at home with like a residential
- 38:42cost of electricity at best you're going to break even.
- 38:46And that's really you know in the most optimistic rosy
- 38:48scenario is you're going to break even at home.
- 38:51What would be more interesting is if you reuse the heat to heat
- 38:55your pool, for example. Now you might be coming out
- 38:57ahead, but you know that that that just shows that if.
- 39:02You're not because you're coming out ahead, right, But because
- 39:04you have made use of this, right?
- 39:07Well, yeah, and and then. You don't.
- 39:09You don't net better applications because you heated
- 39:11your pool. Sorry, right.
- 39:13No, no, I agree with you. But the other thing?
- 39:15But you do get to enjoy a nicely heated pool.
- 39:18And I don't think you come out ahead from if you're billing
- 39:20your hourly labor, right? If you do that, then you realize
- 39:25that you sank a ton of time building a custom pool heater
- 39:28when you could have just bought a pool heater and you know, not.
- 39:32So it's kind of more of a hobby. I know that some folks might not
- 39:35want to hear that, but at the home scale, yes, if you have
- 39:40solar, if you got you know a situation maybe you've got some
- 39:45something to work with. But at scale, you know, you have
- 39:49to be thinking about how do I participate in demand response,
- 39:52How do I keep an eye on the electricity market to be
- 39:54curtailing actively? How do I negotiate long term
- 39:57power purchase agreements with electrical companies such that,
- 40:02you know, all of the economics work from that perspective?
- 40:05So I think that, yeah, it's a, it's a combination of managing a
- 40:09lot of different pieces and including real estate, right.
- 40:14Where is your facility actually sited in construction?
- 40:18How are you building your facility?
- 40:20Who's pouring the foundation etcetera and and lots and lots
- 40:23of engineering from civil engineering to mechanical to
- 40:27electrical to computer science, right.
- 40:29If you're, you got to have the software that's going to manage
- 40:32the facility and all of that does amount to a pretty
- 40:37significant entrepreneurial undertaking.
- 40:40So I think thank you for that overview, very helpful, Pier.
- 40:43I think what I'm hearing is that there's not gonna be a chapter
- 40:47in your upcoming book, Morgan on swimming, pool, immersion,
- 40:52cooling and tactics for for generating income or or savings.
- 40:57But but maybe you could tell us what is coming or at least one
- 41:02or two Nuggets in your upcoming book.
- 41:05Yeah, definitely. So I wrote a book, like you
- 41:08mentioned, about four years ago. Now it's just kind of crazy.
- 41:11The time flies. But the book is a it's a
- 41:15comprehensive personal financial guide.
- 41:18And what I found was that I was getting a lot of Bitcoin
- 41:22questions right. But my guide doesn't necessarily
- 41:24answer those Bitcoin questions, and if you go out into the
- 41:27market, there really isn't any. There's really a dearth of
- 41:31financial planning content for bitcoiners to access.
- 41:34So what bitcoiners need to do now is take current financial
- 41:37planning principles and apply them to their personal financial
- 41:40situation. And for most, right, That's
- 41:42going to be really difficult. If you don't like, if you're not
- 41:44kind of fluid already in financial planning concepts,
- 41:47taking them and then applying them specifically to your
- 41:49Bitcoin situation for most people is going to be difficult.
- 41:52And so the book is, is basically that I'm writing is to help
- 41:56people take current, you know, tried and true best practices in
- 42:02personal financial planning and apply them to portfolios that
- 42:06are, you know, 4050 sixty percent Bitcoin.
- 42:09Because that's basically what we're seeing now in my practice
- 42:12for the most part. People who are coming in our
- 42:14long time bitcoiners who they've been stacking for a while,
- 42:17they're not sure whether or not they're like how much they've
- 42:20amassed is enough, right? Like that question you were
- 42:22asking me earlier, like how do I assess how much is enough?
- 42:25How much should I be saving? How much should I be putting in
- 42:27Bitcoin versus other assets? How much do I actually need to
- 42:30retire? How do I need to be thinking
- 42:32about these withdrawal rates that we were talking about
- 42:34earlier? So all of these are, I think,
- 42:35key components to making sure that you have a solid financial
- 42:38footing, savings technology that people really have not like
- 42:42broached these subjects before just because for the most part,
- 42:44right, people have been saving in a currency that has not had
- 42:48all the attributes that Bitcoin has.
- 42:50And so this obviously it gives people a lot of freedom and how
- 42:55they save, right, because now they have a new place and a new
- 42:58way of doing it. But it, like Pierre was saying
- 43:00earlier, comes with the responsibility of figuring out
- 43:02how to do it for your situation the best.
- 43:05And so that's my hope with this book, and I am admittedly behind
- 43:11on writing it. I'm not as far as I had hoped,
- 43:13but I am like a good third of the way through at this point.
- 43:16So we're getting there. It's going to come out.
- 43:18My hope is that, you know, sometime this year, but Pierre
- 43:20hates when I promise these kinds of things, 'cause then it locks
- 43:23me into doing the work. It doesn't lock you in.
- 43:26I mean you. There's there's so many pre sale
- 43:29promises, yeah that's true. Been delayed in in this industry
- 43:34that as long as you deliver at some point within the next
- 43:37couple decades, Yeah. In the meantime, no.
- 43:40I am. I always do like, you know,
- 43:42personal research and writing. And so there are other things
- 43:45that will come out that are related that will eventually,
- 43:48you know, be fully fleshed out in book form.
- 43:51I think I'm. Hearing that, we need a.
- 43:53We need a white paper for the for the book, you know in the in
- 43:57the interim period just to just to slake people's appetites
- 44:00here, sometimes the only way to book.
- 44:03Tokens. Yeah.
- 44:04Book tokens. There we go.
- 44:06That's that's the. Way to go.
- 44:09That's the only way to get work. I can only finish writing if I.
- 44:14Have a deadline. So sometimes that painful
- 44:17deadline is what it takes. Yeah, yeah, for sure.
- 44:20The book. Is coming out.
- 44:21On March 1st. So we're really excited to be
- 44:26launching the book. Yeah, that'll that'll.
- 44:29Maybe. You can launch it at.
- 44:31May 2025, at the peak that you already predicted and put on the
- 44:34record there, Morgan. That sounds like a perfect.
- 44:39A perfect plan. Well, you know, you obviously
- 44:44Pierre have have managed to function in your role as
- 44:47assistant with respect to the Bitcoin for Advisors podcast.
- 44:51So, you know, maybe there needs to be an assistant for the for
- 44:54the new book who needs to assist with the writing.
- 44:57We tried that. Yeah, yeah, we did.
- 44:58Actually try it. Pierre was.
- 44:59Supposed to be writing the 1st 3 chapters of the book because I
- 45:02thought that people would get a better perspective on Bitcoin
- 45:05and money in the Austrian perspective of everything.
- 45:07But Pierre has also fallen behind.
- 45:09Yeah, just. Trying to heat the pool?
- 45:13Yeah, yeah, this is the layer I had one.
- 45:17Thing I will say about the pool heater.
- 45:18Thing. So this is the pool heater, the
- 45:19garage heater, and so forth. The one benefit I've heard from
- 45:23people is that it actually gets your wife on board.
- 45:25If you have a Bitcoin miner that heats the space that otherwise
- 45:28would have been totally cold, is that now your wife is thinking,
- 45:31oh, this Bitcoin thing is actually pretty useful because
- 45:33now my pool, which normally would have been 60°, is the nice
- 45:3792. Well.
- 45:39That's pretty good. You know, I think pitching.
- 45:43The benefits of Bitcoin to the spouse has been something that
- 45:48all of us have encountered here in this conversation, some more
- 45:54than others. But yeah, there's no doubt that
- 45:57the adjacent benefits have to be have to be understood.
- 46:02And you know, I, I, I sometimes wonder one of the questions
- 46:06that's top of mind for me is what percent of people will ever
- 46:09understand Bitcoin. And you know, I see this with
- 46:13family members, I see this with friends.
- 46:16I'm just curious, what do you, what do you both think about
- 46:19that? And obviously this, that's not
- 46:21to say that any of us fully understands every aspect because
- 46:24it's a complicated phenomenon. But are we going to, are we
- 46:27going to get there? What percent of minds are going
- 46:30to actually wrap themselves around this thing?
- 46:35Well, what percentage? Of people understand cars.
- 46:39Yeah, good question. Well, I would also.
- 46:42Say to add to that. So if you had asked people in
- 46:46the age bracket of, let's call it 55 to 65 S 10 years ago, if
- 46:51you'd asked them if they would be able to very easily use their
- 46:55phone to go on the Internet, right?
- 46:57To buy, I don't know, socks for their, their nieces or grand
- 47:02nieces or whatever, right? They probably would have looked
- 47:03at you that like you were insane because they didn't know that
- 47:06their phone even had that capability.
- 47:08Leather, they could even do something like that, right?
- 47:10Whereas Fast forward 10 years today, right, We have people who
- 47:13are in their, who are 65 to 75 who are very easily using their
- 47:16cell phone to to buy things online or to interact with their
- 47:21friends on Facebook or whatever it is that they're using their
- 47:23phone for, right? They may not be able to use
- 47:25every single app the way a 25 year old can, but they have
- 47:28figured out sort of the basic things that they need to operate
- 47:31on their phone to make their day-to-day lives work.
- 47:34And so I think we often focus on that older group of the like,
- 47:36OK, they're not going to be able to do it and so therefore this
- 47:39whole experiment is going to fail.
- 47:41They're not able to do it today because it's not commonplace to
- 47:43use your phone to do a Bitcoin transaction, but it is becoming
- 47:47commonplace to tap to pay with your phone, right, in certain
- 47:51places. And so maybe a 65 year old
- 47:53person 10 years ago couldn't do that because that wasn't
- 47:55something that was even available to them.
- 47:57But today, right? They're starting to learn or
- 47:59somebody in their family has taught them how to do that.
- 48:01And so I would say that applies across all demographics, right?
- 48:03The more that this technology is around and the more that people
- 48:06are exposed to it, need to use it in some capacity and have
- 48:10easy ways of learning how to do that, the more likely that
- 48:13people will actually be able to do that.
- 48:14And then there's, there's always going to be a subset of the
- 48:16population that, you know, just still wants to use their horse
- 48:19and not their car, still wants to, you know, use their
- 48:22typewriter and not their computer printer, right.
- 48:24So I mean, we can't say that like there's not going to be
- 48:27vast adoption just because, you know, 5% of people are still
- 48:30using a typewriter, right. I would say that most people are
- 48:32using a computer at this point. It's probably not even close to
- 48:345%. I'm just throwing numbers out
- 48:36there, so don't don't get mad at me on Twitter, but I'm just
- 48:38saying, like from from that perspective, right, the longer
- 48:41that a technology is around, the more likely people are going to
- 48:43try to use it and the more likely people in the future will
- 48:46actually be able to use it. Yeah, that's it.
- 48:49And getting to. Your comment about who
- 48:51understands their car Here I understand two things about my
- 48:54car. One is that my primary vehicle
- 48:57is is literally falling apart and I have to replace it.
- 49:00And yeah, I don't know how to, how to, how to fix it myself.
- 49:03There's no chance I would ever understand what's going on under
- 49:07the hood. And the other thing I understand
- 49:09about it is to your much earlier comment, which is I have no
- 49:13desire to spend any more on its replacement than I have to
- 49:17because it means, yeah, it would mean at the margin less savings
- 49:21or less cash into investable assets, including in it,
- 49:26especially the investable asset that I see has the highest risk
- 49:30return potential. Yeah.
- 49:33Shout out to the. Check Engine Light gang on
- 49:36Twitter that is is very proud of their check engine lights.
- 49:40Help. You know what?
- 49:41Gas to put in your car. Andy Yeah, that I've got figured
- 49:45out. That.
- 49:46Well, you know, it's funny. I did put out a tweet of like,
- 49:50it was a picture of a gas station pump.
- 49:53And I was like, there's no way this is going to go mainstream.
- 49:55Nobody understands what any of this means. 9385, Like, what do
- 50:01you what What are you talking about?
- 50:03And yeah, here we are. Yeah, right.
- 50:05It's amazing. I always.
- 50:07I always think. About the Henry Ford quote of if
- 50:10I'd asked people what they wanted they would have said
- 50:12faster horses. You know if you if you ask
- 50:15people what you what they want and money they'd say more
- 50:17dollars we don't need more dollars we need better money.
- 50:22Money that grows in purchasing power.
- 50:24Money that is savings technology.
- 50:26That's what we need. And and and I think Morgan to
- 50:29your point like people will figure this out whether it takes
- 50:32a few generations or you know a long enough timeline of human
- 50:37behavior playing out to prove that the winning strategy was to
- 50:40save in Bitcoin and and use that as your savings vehicle.
- 50:44Eventually that osmotically trickles, you know, through the
- 50:48population and becomes accepted wisdom in the same way that
- 50:51currently the 6040 portfolio is the accepted wisdom because of
- 50:5540 years of declining interest rates.
- 50:57Bearing that out as the winning strategy, I would also say the
- 51:00more invasive. The banking system becomes, and
- 51:03they were becoming even more invasive than ever before.
- 51:06Let him know. Let him know what happened.
- 51:08So I was trying to send. A Zelle transaction for our
- 51:11child's school and it got blocked.
- 51:14And then I tried to send it again because I just thought
- 51:17that the system was being stupid.
- 51:18And then not only did it get blocked, but they actually
- 51:20locked me out of my Chase account.
- 51:22And so I had to call Chase basically to get my account
- 51:26unlocked and also to send this Zelle payment for my kids
- 51:29school. And they proceeded to ask me so
- 51:32six questions right off the bat, which I felt like we're very
- 51:34invasive. And I had answered enough about
- 51:36the fact that this was my for my son's school.
- 51:38And then the woman said no, I'm not done.
- 51:40I have more questions to answer you, for you to answer.
- 51:42And I was like, am I having a colonoscopy right now?
- 51:46Like, what is happening? Like, it's just a small
- 51:48transaction going to my son's school.
- 51:50Like, I'm telling you that it can go there.
- 51:52You're speaking to me, the client on the phone affirming
- 51:55that, yes, in fact, I want to send this like, you have
- 51:57released your responsibility as far as this transaction is
- 52:00concerned. But no, they want to protect
- 52:01people from fraud, or at least that's what they're saying,
- 52:04right? We want to protect you from
- 52:05fraud. We want to get as much
- 52:06information about this as possible.
- 52:07And our point was basically that if I said multiple times that I
- 52:11want to send money to a Nigerian Prince, and they tried to
- 52:14dissuade me of it, but I kept insisting that I send money to a
- 52:17Nigerian Prince, then that Zelle transaction should in fact go
- 52:19through. It's my fault that I sent money
- 52:21to a Nigerian Prince. And so I just think that the
- 52:24more that this kind of thing is happening and the longer that
- 52:26something like Bitcoin is around, the less likely people
- 52:29are going to want to use dollars because they don't want people
- 52:32in their business all the time, right?
- 52:34It's a it's kind of crazy that they have so much data about
- 52:38what people are doing, right? You can basically just pull, I
- 52:40mean we do this for clients all the time, right?
- 52:41We pull all their transaction data and we put together an
- 52:43income statement for them. And we know a lot about a client
- 52:47because we go through all their transactions, right, and put
- 52:49together that income statement for them.
- 52:51And that's just like because I'm doing that as a financial
- 52:53planner and I'm trying to help this person, not because I'm
- 52:55trying to, you know, screen as much, Yeah.
- 52:57Police as much information from this person as possible so that
- 53:00I can then cut off their transactions to certain places
- 53:02and force them to send transactions to other places,
- 53:04right. And so forth.
- 53:05And so I think that the more that the banking system becomes
- 53:08invasive and the more people want to get involved, the more
- 53:10something like a CBDC happens, right?
- 53:11The more the government kind of gets their hands on our big
- 53:14banking gets their their fingers involved in these things, the
- 53:17more likely people are going to not only opt out, but they're
- 53:20going to figure out how to use the new technology very quickly.
- 53:24It's also it's kind. Of funny because sometimes they
- 53:28they put on restrictions with regards to buying Bitcoin,
- 53:31right. So they don't want you
- 53:33transferring dollars to Bitcoin exchange.
- 53:36And I I feel like that is the Streisand effect.
- 53:40It's basically, you know, you're highlighting what the value
- 53:43proposition is here, which is that they control your money and
- 53:47you don't control your own money.
- 53:49And so the the more Bitcoin succeeds and the more they freak
- 53:53out over it and try to stop people from buying it, the more
- 53:56they're advertising what the use case is, what problem Bitcoin is
- 53:59solving. This happened to me in.
- 54:02In 2018 I received a wire from Kraken and Wells Fargo
- 54:09terminated my long relationship with them because of this wire
- 54:13from a crypto exchange. Not only that, but they also
- 54:18they they said that it wouldn't impact my safe deposit box with
- 54:21them, but a month later I found out that they had drilled my
- 54:26safe deposit box as a result of that.
- 54:29Wow. That was a very scary.
- 54:31Very scary day. But yeah, that's that's part of
- 54:35why you set up, Set up. Your security and your.
- 54:39Storage in a, in a in a in a safe, redundant way.
- 54:42You know, it is amazing. How much custom and how much
- 54:47business the banking system has maintained despite behaving so
- 54:52badly over such a long period of time?
- 54:56And I suppose it's because they have been the monopolist, the
- 54:59incumbents and people just haven't really had a credible
- 55:04alternative. And yeah, many of us are pretty
- 55:08interested and excited that Bitcoin can play that role.
- 55:13I don't know if it'll be commonly used for that role in
- 55:17the United States anytime soon. Of course, we know that it's
- 55:20happening globally in countries with much weaker currencies that
- 55:25that debase much more rapidly. But yeah, it seems like the
- 55:29behavior of the banks, they just keep doing it to themselves,
- 55:33right? They just keep shooting
- 55:34themselves in the in the foot, both with respect to customer
- 55:37service as well as their broader activities, whether it be
- 55:42facilitating money laundering or or crime or or what have you.
- 55:49I still have to answer the, you know, the question of what wait
- 55:53doesn't. Isn't Bitcoin for for criminals?
- 55:55No. Here here's the chain analysis
- 55:57report. No, we don't like chain
- 55:59analysis, but yes, we like that. They have nice data for us to
- 56:02send our clients to dissuade us or dissuade them of this of this
- 56:07old trope that Bitcoin is for criminals.
- 56:09When when really more of the criminal activity goes through
- 56:12the existing Fiat system. Yeah, and on.
- 56:16That it's it's. Fascinating to me to to look at
- 56:18the government auctioning off Bitcoin, right, because it
- 56:22raises so many questions. I mean one of first of all,
- 56:25somebody is buying that Bitcoin at the auction.
- 56:28Are they a criminal? Should you know, should the
- 56:30government arrest anybody who bids on the auction?
- 56:33Because that's kind of seems to be the the, the, the thinking
- 56:37there. And then second, if Bitcoin
- 56:39itself is inherently criminal, then the government should be
- 56:42destroying the Bitcoin, right? Just like they would with, you
- 56:46know, if you find crack cocaine in the White House, you know,
- 56:49just laying in a bag there, then you you would destroy that.
- 56:53You wouldn't. Purely hypothetical, you know.
- 56:55Hypothetical. Scenario Purely hypothetical
- 56:58They. Do auction it, but they don't.
- 56:59Tell people yeah, Hunter Biden won the.
- 57:02Auction everyone. You know you got to make money,
- 57:06you. Got to make money somehow,
- 57:07right? You can't.
- 57:08You can't make all your money serving on the boards of foreign
- 57:13companies. Here we we have a deficit in
- 57:16this. Country.
- 57:16We got to, we got to auction these things off, yeah.
- 57:21Yeah, so. And and and then the other thing
- 57:23too is that, you know, if if they're like, well, Bitcoin
- 57:25doesn't have any like utility. I mean the government is using
- 57:29Bitcoin, right, because they are currently holding Bitcoin and
- 57:32it's increasing in value. So they're they're doing well
- 57:34for themselves because they haven't auctioned it off yet.
- 57:37But then the the hilarious part to me is that they're they're
- 57:40selling Bitcoin to acquire an asset that they can create for
- 57:43free. That that part is mind boggling.
- 57:47But obviously it's just like it, I call it a spite auction,
- 57:51right? They they they want to sell
- 57:52Bitcoin to spite bitcoiners, which it's not going to have
- 57:56positive results in the long run, but probably feels good in
- 57:59the short run for them, probably does and for the.
- 58:02For the moment, it seems like they can.
- 58:03They can afford it. Somebody's buying all this, all
- 58:06this Treasury debt, all these T-bills and these notes and
- 58:10these bonds. Who knows, this year long dated
- 58:15bonds might even be a somewhat scarce asset.
- 58:18If they start printing or keep printing more of those the
- 58:21shorter term bills instead of turning out the government debt
- 58:24they're just rolling you know borrowing on a on a 13 year
- 58:29sorry a 13 week maturity basis. It doesn't sound like those guys
- 58:36running the the Treasury have have thought about the safe move
- 58:40of turning out their debt structure like a responsible
- 58:44individual. Well and and then they they.
- 58:47Go on about how payday lenders are predatory.
- 58:50It's like, well, I mean you know what's going on in the treasury
- 58:54market, eventually you'll get to a point where it's a two week,
- 58:58you know, or one day everything's one day, day-to-day
- 59:02we're going to roll our debt. That's.
- 59:05It that's it, that might. Be the direction we're going
- 59:08Well this has been a really fun conversation.
- 59:11We covered a lot of ground. I want to make sure though, that
- 59:15that you each get to leave us with any parting thoughts or
- 59:19anywhere you'd like to send people online to learn more
- 59:23about what you're up to me. OK, so you can find me.
- 59:29On Twitter, I'm at Morgan with an E Rochard.
- 59:32My financial planning practice is originwa.com.
- 59:37We deal predominantly with people in the US We've been
- 59:39getting a lot of outreach from people abroad.
- 59:41And unfortunately, as much as I would love to help people
- 59:43abroad, I simply don't know enough about tax and estate
- 59:47situations abroad to truly be able to help these people.
- 59:50And so people have said, oh, you don't want to deal with me.
- 59:53And it's no, we. We do want to deal with you.
- 59:54We just can't provide like the full plethora of the services
- 59:58that I would normally provide in my financial planning practice.
- 1:00:01So if you are somebody international, feel free to
- 1:00:03reach out, but know that we're going to try to help you find
- 1:00:05somebody internationally instead of working with us domestically.
- 1:00:09I also have a consulting practice called money owners.
- 1:00:11People can find me there if they've got someone off Bitcoin
- 1:00:14questions. Nothing like investment advice
- 1:00:16or investment related there, but I do get a lot of questions
- 1:00:19about estate planning and custody and sort of those sorts
- 1:00:22of things. And so if you've got some
- 1:00:23questions about that, feel free to find me there.
- 1:00:27And you mentioned we have a podcast that is long overdue for
- 1:00:31a current episode, but we did this instead so everybody can
- 1:00:36listen to this episode or and then.
- 1:00:39Eventually we're doing. To fill that role, yeah.
- 1:00:42We're happy to fill that, that role.
- 1:00:44What about, what about you, Pierre?
- 1:00:46What else you got going on? You want to tell people about?
- 1:00:49Yeah. So my my DMS are open at Bitcoin
- 1:00:54Pierre on Twitter, and yeah, subscribe to our podcast.
- 1:01:01I've got a couple of other podcasts.
- 1:01:05Podcasts are abundant, you know, but I think it's great.
- 1:01:08Not scarce. They're not scarce.
- 1:01:10Yeah, except for podcasts with Pierre.
- 1:01:12Rashard are are more scarce than most and and more valuable in my
- 1:01:16humble opinion. So people should definitely and
- 1:01:18scarce under the noted label. I would say too, yeah.
- 1:01:24Yeah, I got to talk with Michael.
- 1:01:25We're. In a bull market now we need to
- 1:01:26be putting out content you get to work as.
- 1:01:29Yeah, I've been. Seeing him.
- 1:01:31Revive some of his old video clips, which are very fun to
- 1:01:35always watch on a Green Day? Yep, absolutely.
- 1:01:40Thanks for having us on. Yeah.
- 1:01:41Thanks for having us. Yeah, it's.
- 1:01:43Been a real pleasure. Real honor.
- 1:01:45Thank you. Both Pierre and Morgan.
- 1:01:46Tremendous conversation and this has been scarce assets.