Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 6 - Turning Point)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter six in our deep dive on the
- 0:03psychology of Joshua Powell. Let's get into it. My name is doctor Kirkanda,
- 0:10I'm a therapist and a professor. Who are you, Burrow? My
- 0:13name is Umberto and I clean Clouds. So to review where we've been at
- 0:21this point in the story. They are in their twenties, they have two
- 0:25kids. They're in Utah. Joshua and the family just had to declare bankruptcy
- 0:31because josh has racked up two hundred thousand dollars in debt. This leads us
- 0:37up to what I think is a turning point for josh And I'm speculating a
- 0:43lot about his state of mind because he didn't write about this specifically in his
- 0:48journal, but I think this might have been happening. I think by this
- 0:52point he probably is suspecting that he'll never be successful. I think a big
- 0:59part of what keep him going in life was this dream and hope and assumption
- 1:07that he would be rich and famous if he did suffer from narcissistic person I
- 1:11shorter, that is a must you maybe not necessarily prestige and power and rich
- 1:18and famous. That is often a narcissistic dream and goal and assumption. But
- 1:23for other people with narcisism, it might be that they're going to make the
- 1:27perfect family, or they're going to look perfect or whatever. But a lot
- 1:33of people with narcissism have aspirations of being rich and famous, which could either
- 1:40drive them to do what it takes to be rich and famous, or they
- 1:45will just invent that they're rich and famous and lie about it or something,
- 1:49or have fantasies. So for Josh, I think that he had that dream,
- 1:55and yet with his career he kept conflicting with management saying that Josh knew
- 2:01better and he would get fired. And imagine it was a fairly complicated syndrome
- 2:07for him. So at this point in two thousand and seven, when they
- 2:13declare bankruptcy, he's thirty one, and at this point he has to admit
- 2:19that he is failing in his career. You know, when people turn thirty,
- 2:23there's often kind of a reckoning. When things are going well, a
- 2:29lot of thirty year olds today will beat themselves up for not being for not
- 2:36being as successful as that seemingly very successful classmate that they see on Instagram or
- 2:42whatever. It's a time where people think, oh, I'm not in my
- 2:46twenties, I'm now like adult adult in your twenties, you can still kind
- 2:52of think, well, you know, it's that's a shade off of being
- 2:54a teenager, you know, But when you turn thirty, it's like no,
- 2:58no, no, you're you're an adult. No, there's no denying
- 3:00it. And I imagine that he might have been going through something like that
- 3:05and he's realizing that his career is going nowhere. He also is facing the
- 3:14very strong possibility that his marriage is a failure and he's a failure with money,
- 3:20and he's two hundred thousand dollars in debt with no way out. It's
- 3:23not like he has a line on a good career and he'll be able to
- 3:28dig himself out, Like, how are they going to pay that? If
- 3:31things didn't go the way that it does, and you know, as it
- 3:34will in the future of the story, I imagine that they would have that
- 3:38debt and they'd only be able to pay the interest for the rest of their
- 3:44life. Maybe I don't know, that's why they went bankrupt. So no
- 3:46more dreams, no more narcissistic dreams, no more narcissistic hopes of superiority,
- 3:53and that's clashing with his defensive structure. I need to be superior, need
- 4:00to prove to the world and to myself that I am better than others.
- 4:03I had this dream of becoming famous and being rich and all this stuff.
- 4:09So you know, he's a total failure at this point. And for anyone
- 4:14this is going to be a rough time emotionally, but for him, given
- 4:16his fragile ego developed because of the abuse he went through, you can imagine
- 4:23the dark abyss that he is falling into at this point. Have you ever
- 4:30felt this before? Burtw Yeah, absolutely, I mean certainly at thirty.
- 4:33That happened to me, and I remember a lot of my friends went through
- 4:36a very similar thing, where like that's when I started going to therapy and
- 4:40all that. Right around there. I was like twenty nine or whatever.
- 4:44But it was it was because of those feelings of I mean not only but
- 4:50I had those feelings of like, WHOA, I'm getting old? What am
- 4:55I doing with my life? You know? And then yeah, you like
- 4:58mentally compare yourself to people all these things, and it happened to be that
- 5:03I sabotage myself dramatically like he was doing. But maybe not quite as much,
- 5:09but quite dramatically actually arguably almost as dramatically right around the same time too,
- 5:15you know, and sort of like tripling down on the feelings. So
- 5:21yeah, I can totally relate. Yeah, So another aspect to consider that
- 5:28I think is present is that he's completely disconnected. I think it's tempting to
- 5:32look at Josh as this psychopathic monster that doesn't want relationships, but I imagine
- 5:39that he did. There's no evidence to suggest he didn't, and I'm looking
- 5:43at his life at this point. His marriage has been distant for years now
- 5:47and probably hasn't really been feeling good to him since the very very beginning.
- 5:54Stephen, his father isn't there for him, and he has a complicated relationship
- 5:59with Stephen anyway, you know, So that's not necessarily bad that his father
- 6:04isn't around. He doesn't have any friends, he doesn't go to church,
- 6:09not that church. Yeah, there's no a community, there's there's no fun,
- 6:13there's no relationships, there's there's nothing, no work. And well,
- 6:17so at some point he starts working in real estate. But well but that,
- 6:21yeah, like that meaning a work with like you have at least friends
- 6:26from work, you have a community at work, you know, yeah,
- 6:29so he he's completely disconnected and there's there's no checks and balances. You know,
- 6:33there's nobody that says like, ah, you know, things will get
- 6:36better, You'll figure it out. Like just nothing right, But Burdo,
- 6:43there's one solution that I think emerges in his mind at this point. There's
- 6:48evidence anyway that it emerges in his mind at this point. This is to
- 6:53remind people. Two years before Susan disappears, he realizes that if he can
- 7:00get Susan on life insurance, Remember he's in debt, Yeah, two hundred
- 7:02thousand dollars, no way out. His career is over or it's going nowhere,
- 7:08it's floundering. I'm gonna get Susan on life insurance. I will kill
- 7:12her, or she'll have an accident, whatever, I'll get the money,
- 7:16I'll get out of debt, I'll get the kids to myself because Susan is
- 7:21this horrible authoritarian parent, and I'll get to start over. That will solve
- 7:30the marriage problem because she'll be dead. Maybe I'll get some sympathy. I
- 7:33will get money, and I can't overemphasize how weird Josh was about money.
- 7:41He obsessed about money. He was very, very frugal, and yet he
- 7:45would get himself into two hundred thousand dollars in debt, mainly buying power tools.
- 7:49He thought about money all the time, he had spreadsheets. He would
- 7:54dictate Susan's spending on the tiniest of things she would have to give him and
- 8:00receipts if she bought like a pen or. He was very obsessive about this,
- 8:07so going into debt and how weird he was about this, It's not
- 8:11hard to imagine, in given what we now know about his personality is having
- 8:16a lack of empathy and a you know, perhaps a vengeful heart on some
- 8:22level, that this would be attractive to him, you know, don't you
- 8:26think absolutely. The thing that shocks me the most is you're saying that two
- 8:31years prior so you hear about premeditation. People don't plan anything two years in
- 8:37advance, not even weddings, you know. Well, yeah, I mean,
- 8:43and I'll get more into that later, But I just suspect, and
- 8:46I think this is true for a lot of situations like this, that it's
- 8:50initially a fantasy that the individual thinks about maybe when things are going particularly bad,
- 9:00they indulge it, but ultimately they say, nah's that's going too far.
- 9:05Did he get the insurance? Well, so I'll get to that.
- 9:09Yeah, so next year two thousand and eight. Yeah, so remember two
- 9:13hundred thousand dollars a debt heading into two thousand and eight, marriage is falling
- 9:16apart. Good time to be that and that because that's when well, so
- 9:20we'll get that. So at this point two thousand and eight, they're having
- 9:26even more marital conflict. At this point, they're fighting openly. Now,
- 9:31in the past, it would be the typical way that parents would fight,
- 9:35where it would be behind closed doors or there would be some limits to their
- 9:39behavior towards each other. At this point, they're they're just full on screaming
- 9:43at each other all the time, perhaps because both of them might have been
- 9:46mostly giving up. And I've seen that as a couple therapists and just as
- 9:50a human being. It's not hard to witness this and other people that there's
- 9:54a line that people will cross where it'll become so bad enough of the time
- 10:00that when they get into a fight, they just don't have any reason that
- 10:05they connect with to monitor their behavior and it just becomes brutal. So it
- 10:11was starting to get like that, and she is starting to fight back.
- 10:16She's starting to stand up for herself. She is starting to say, you
- 10:20can't control me the way that you have been doing this whole time. She's
- 10:24starting to learn, and she has supports at church and with friends that are
- 10:30helping her to know that she doesn't have to put up with that shit anymore.
- 10:35And it's getting absurd, the kinds of things. And you know,
- 10:37she would write about this in her journal. She saw, just like josh
- 10:41is strange, and so she's starting to say, you know, in the
- 10:46beginning, she was younger, she was hoping things would change. At this
- 10:50point, she's like, no, we're not going to do this. She's
- 10:52still being fairly compliant a lot of the time, but a lot less so.
- 10:56So she said she was worried also that he would take the kids away
- 11:01from her, just like Steven took the kids away from Teresa, and Joshuad
- 11:07occasionally threatened to do this in the middle of their fights, and she was
- 11:11worried that he would have her killed. Oh, even though he never seemingly
- 11:16directly threatened to kill her. This is starting to run through her mind,
- 11:20which I'll get to in a second. Okay, So getting to the life
- 11:24insurance. All of a sudden at this point in two thousand and eight,
- 11:28in early two thousand and eight, he's suddenly insistent that they get life insurance,
- 11:33and she is fighting back, and she's saying, look, if we
- 11:37can't afford to buy anything other than top ramen for our family, what are
- 11:45we doing buying voluntary life insurance on us when we're in our twenties and early
- 11:52thirties. Like that can wait, right? But they fight about They fight
- 11:56about it, and he's badgering her and badgering her and badgering her. So
- 12:03what does this tell you, Burtle? I mean this to me is an
- 12:07indication that he I'm not denying that he was probably vacillating between the thoughts in
- 12:15his head, but I think it's pretty clear that one side was winning,
- 12:20which is, we got to put this plan in motion right right, Because
- 12:26what would be an alternative explanation that he's you know, so the alternative explanation
- 12:31would be that they're doing pretty well financially and he's actually learned a ton about
- 12:35finances, and they're at that point in their finances where like, actually,
- 12:39the next thing we need to do is get life insurance. You know,
- 12:41we're young, but actually we'll save a lot on rates, our kids will
- 12:45it. That's not what's happening, right, Yeah, he's frugal, remember,
- 12:50so why would he want to spend money on this? So he badgeres
- 12:56her and badges her, and there's journal entries about this, and finally she
- 13:01gives in after just many many matty, really intense fighting, and he got
- 13:07her to get a policy, and she gets a policy for a million dollars
- 13:15or more, and he would be the sole beneficiary, which isn't unusual but
- 13:20okay, And it costs one hundred dollars per month, which is probably more
- 13:26than their entire food budget for the month. So it just contrasts how odd
- 13:31it is that Josh is pushing for this. So, according to Susan,
- 13:37at this point she writes, the marriage deteriorated so quickly. She writes in
- 13:41her journal, it's getting really bad. And at this point she's starting to
- 13:46tell others that we're headed towards divorce. And at this point she's also secretly
- 13:52saving money, not so she can like run away necessarily, but so she
- 13:58can just pay their bills. So this is another thing that's happening. He's
- 14:01so bad with money and such a dick about money that even like their regular
- 14:07utility bills aren't being paid because of him. He lives in the house,
- 14:13but he just I don't know, he's just so hoarding of the money.
- 14:18Meanwhile, he's spending thousands of dollars on a new saw that he'll never use
- 14:24and doesn't even know how to use really or not very well anyway. So
- 14:28she's saving money just so she can pay their bills. She's also secretly consulting
- 14:35with a divorce attorney. So that's the state of affairs heading into the end
- 14:43of two thousand and eight. So Berto, what happened at the end of
- 14:46two thousand and eight, Well, I mean, so actually heading into two
- 14:50thousand and eight is when the Lehman Brothers and all the banks started folding because
- 14:58of all the deriva of trading on house mortgages. That was big gambles essentially
- 15:05started folding on themselves, and that means all the mortgage companies started basically,
- 15:13let's put it this way, a lot of people that had mortgages that they
- 15:16had gotten through legitimate means, but they were ballooning into extreme high rates.
- 15:24That was all coming due, and so people started not being able to pay
- 15:28their mortgages, started losing houses left and right, and the world economy collapsed.
- 15:35Right. Yeah, good point that this all started in two thousand and
- 15:39seven, but well at the end of two thousand and seven, but it
- 15:41didn't really like hit you till mid to to a eight. Yeah, it
- 15:46didn't really cause ground level average person problems until mid to late two thousand and
- 15:54eight. So it's like, so like, for my example is I I
- 15:58was at the time, I had two rental properties that I owned, and
- 16:03I had a townhouse, and I got the one of the rental properties I
- 16:07got in two thousand and seven, like right before all this happened, and
- 16:11it was at a time where they were just like handing mortgages. Here's a
- 16:14mortgage, Oh don't how much do I need to put down? What?
- 16:17Don't just take it? Just take it. And then two thousand and eight
- 16:19hits Everything's still I mean, I know that markets are collapsing, I'm hearing
- 16:23about stuff I don't know. I don't know, but it's still not hit
- 16:26home. Of course, when it started hitting home was when all of a
- 16:32sudden our renters started not being able to pay and then I'm stuck with the
- 16:36mortgage payments every month, and then that starts happening, and then it goes
- 16:40on for a year. So like I wasn't by the time I was fully
- 16:44affected, it was well into two thousand and nine, like actually near the
- 16:48end of two thousand nine. Yeah, So remember that for years Josh has
- 16:56been really hoping to become rich and famous, and he works in real estate.
- 17:03I don't know the details about what was going on, but there's a
- 17:07possibility that as his last hope for financial security and narcissistic supply was in the
- 17:14real estate market. I've seen this a lot where you talk to someone that
- 17:18just entered or they're going to enter the real estate business and they like I
- 17:23was in an uber once and or a lift and the driver was talking about
- 17:30and he was a very lovely guy, nice guy, but he's like,
- 17:33yeah, you know, I was thinking about getting into real estate. And
- 17:37I'm like, oh, really, you know, because and I'm thinking he
- 17:40has some sort of expertise, he's a contractor or something, and basically he
- 17:45didn't know anything. I, as a layperson, knew a hundred times more
- 17:49than he did about construction, about the market, about flipping house, just
- 17:53because I've just absorbed that information. But the way he was talking, he's
- 17:57like, yeah, you know, you just a house and you fix it
- 18:00up and you flip it, and then you take that money and then you
- 18:04buy another place. He was talking like it was super easy to do.
- 18:08And I think that the real estate market, particularly back then two thousand and
- 18:15seven, it just attracted a lot of people like the gold Rush must have
- 18:19you know, like, oh, there's gold in them dar Hills. Look
- 18:22in nineteen ninety eight and ninety nine, everyone was a stock trading genius.
- 18:27All your friends are like, oh, you should need to buy So you
- 18:30would buy whatever stock and they would all go up. It's like, oh
- 18:33my gosh, I'm actually really good at this stuff. It turns out who
- 18:36knew Wall Street can come from? And then two thousand hits and everyone's like,
- 18:41oh, oh shoot, I lost all my money. Well, with
- 18:44the real estate it was similar, like in the mid two thousands, everyone's
- 18:47a genius real estate broker or whatever because you're getting a place and it's going
- 18:52up in valley and you're flipping it or whatever, and then everything collapses.
- 18:56Right. So for me, I had bought a house in four and I
- 19:07didn't really know much about real estate or anything, but I started to I
- 19:11don't know if Zillah was around back then or what, but I did know
- 19:18that my house that I had bought was appreciating in value. And I was
- 19:25like, oh my god, this is great. My house is now worth
- 19:30five thousand more dollars. That means I have five thousand more dollars. Just
- 19:34that feeling. It was the first time that had ever happened to me.
- 19:38I had no investments, I had no four to one K, I had
- 19:44no assets, and all of a sudden, because I'm paying on this very
- 19:49very cheap fixer upper house, all of a sudden, I'm like a rich
- 19:55person who has like this. I just sit there, you know, I
- 19:57don't even have to do anything, and money, just money just starts,
- 20:02you know, and I'm counting these virtual bucks in my hand. You know.
- 20:07It was intoxicating, and everyone was going through that. The housing prices
- 20:10were just skyrocking, particularly in Seattle because of various different factors that we won't
- 20:15go into. But I remember everyone just talking about it all the time.
- 20:18And you know, I had family members and friends that worked in the real
- 20:22estate industry or in the loan industry, and as he said, they would
- 20:26give out loans like candy. When I applied for my loan to buy that
- 20:32house, they said, well, since you're self employed as a therapist,
- 20:37we don't have like a pay stub to go off of. So what we'll
- 20:41do is we'll do stated income. And I'm like, stated income. They
- 20:47give it a name as if it's a thing, right, what's that And
- 20:51he's like, well, you just stay And I'm like, well, what's
- 20:56the point of a pay stub if all you have to do is just say
- 21:02whatever you want? Oh? No, no, but that's easy. So
- 21:03with a pay stubb, it's nonstated exactly. And how it was also explained
- 21:11to me of well, you know how when you're in when you're in business
- 21:15for yourself, you will claim a lot of expenses that aren't really expenses,
- 21:22and so your income that's on your irs, you know, tax return,
- 21:27isn't really how much you're making because you're artificially driving down your profits by lying
- 21:36to the government. If we learned anything from Enron, Yeah, And I
- 21:41just remember thinking what a scam. And I didn't know that this was a
- 21:45new thing. I thought this was just the way it always was. So
- 21:49I did that, and I remember the loan agent sitting down with me and
- 21:52saying, Okay, here's how much your house is, here's how much the
- 21:56mortgage will likely be. So here's how much money you have to state that
- 22:00you made. So just tack on some more and then we're good to go.
- 22:04And I was like, okay, yeah, And I didn't even have
- 22:08money to put down in the house because you know, no, you don't.
- 22:11Who needs money down? So I got a second mortgage a helock,
- 22:15right, So you know I was. I was in that situation. Then
- 22:19the crash happens in two thousand and eight, and I remember everyone freaked out.
- 22:27I mean just everyone was just you know, you and I were friends,
- 22:33and I just remember it was all anyone could talk about, particularly in
- 22:37Seattle, because so many people had bought houses banking on what they thought was
- 22:42a fact that their house, that the graph would line goes up. Yeah,
- 22:48that the trend is that my house will be worth double in three years,
- 22:53So I can afford to spend seventy percent of my paycheck on this house
- 23:00because it'll pay off in three years. And so many people had done that,
- 23:04and so many people had bought in two thousand and seven, I remember,
- 23:08because or two thousand and six, because they had passed on buying properties
- 23:15in two thousand and three, and they had seen the graph go up on
- 23:18and all their friends and the news is talking about it, and they want
- 23:22to get in on that action. So there was all this spending, which
- 23:23of course Jack's the price is up because everyone's like, oh yeah, well
- 23:27once right. You know, all these houses were artificially expensive to begin with,
- 23:32just because everyone thought it was a fact that the market would never crash,
- 23:37and no one was talking about this. You know, it's all depicted
- 23:40in the big short right that there were you know, these very quiet minority
- 23:45voices going there might be a problem here. So it was. I just
- 23:51remember it was very upsetting to people. It was upsetting to me to suddenly
- 23:56see that my house was now worth less than what I bought it for.
- 24:00But I was not as bad as other people because I plan on living in
- 24:06my house. You know, I wasn't planning on selling it anytime soon.
- 24:08And my house was not worth much to begin with, so it didn't really
- 24:11appreciate that much and it didn't really depresh it that much. But I knew
- 24:15people that they would lose, you know, on paper, millions of dollars,
- 24:21you know what I mean, just like overnight, right. You know,
- 24:25therapy is for a lot of people a luxury. It's not really a
- 24:30luxury, but if you're tightening your belt, a lot of people will say,
- 24:36ah, I gotta put the therapy on pause. I gotta eat,
- 24:37right, I gotta eat. I gotta pay my food for my kids.
- 24:41I gotta buy my tools and my life insurance. Yeah, And so my
- 24:48client load shriveled very quickly. I went from a full time practice in mid
- 24:56two thousand and eight to two clients at the end of two thousand and eight.
- 25:03In December, I remember looking at my schedule and I had two clients.
- 25:08If I you know, if I don't see so if I'm if I
- 25:11only see two clients that week, then I'm only making like because you know,
- 25:15typically I would have like twenty seven clients a week or something. So
- 25:21in a very short amount of time, I was making what a tenth or
- 25:26less of what revenue I was making anyway, And I wasn't rich, you
- 25:30know, I wasn't like saving money again, no investments. I was banking
- 25:33on my house, you know, selling for ten billion dollars in a few
- 25:37years, and I was I was smart enough to have saved cash for a
- 25:44rainy day, but that had gone away completely and I was very close to
- 25:49losing my house. And then Burdo, we had one of the biggest snowstorms
- 25:55we've ever had in Seattle. I don't think we've had a snowstorm as big
- 26:02since then. Isn't that where we lost power for like three days or I
- 26:06think parts? But also the roads were such that because we don't have plows
- 26:10in Seattle because it it never snows or rarely, and so it shut down
- 26:14the entire city and my clients couldn't make it to therapy. And this is
- 26:18before teletherrapy was thing, so I couldn't justify charging them. So even though
- 26:23so even those two clients, but it wouldn't have mattered anyway, because I
- 26:29two clients worth of revenue isn't going to pay my mortgage and everything else.
- 26:33It's incredible, by the way, how little you and I were talking to
- 26:36each other about our problems at this point. Yeah, because I didn't know
- 26:38and you didn't know about my no ridiculous financial struggles at that point. Yeah,
- 26:44I mean we might have, but I don't remember, not to that
- 26:48extent. Yeah. But then on New Year's Eve, you decide to get
- 26:56some guys together to rent a hotel room. Oh, yes, at the
- 27:00W Hotel, which I think meant each of us guys would pay one hundred
- 27:04dollars. Wasn't that also our limo? We got a limo and everything or
- 27:07was that a different year? I don't remember, Okay, but I remember
- 27:12really stressing about my portion. I remember thinking I never should have agreed to
- 27:21this one hundred dollars thing. I should have just did something else, and
- 27:27I just I just remember that like like I should. But that wasn't the
- 27:30magical year, Like there was that one year when we went to like Ken's
- 27:33thing and then we had the limo, we went to the casino and then
- 27:37we had like that was a previous year. No, this is the one
- 27:41where we the W Hotel had a party downstairs and we anyway, So yeah,
- 27:49I also remember a lot of clients were suffering, And I also remember
- 27:56that one of my clients got a divorce because of the stress of the being
- 28:03house poor and suddenly having their future prospects dry up, and also like most
- 28:10of their paycheck is going off to pay off their mortgage. So it was
- 28:12it was a very stressful time. I say all this to contextualize what Josh
- 28:18is going for ease, right, yeap. Things have not been going well
- 28:22for him. Yeah, they were already in the hole massively, massively before
- 28:25this happened. Yeah, he has very little hope of a career. The
- 28:33hope, the tiny little shred of hope he has is in real estate.
- 28:36Oh my god, in two thousand and eight. Yeah, so let me
- 28:41add on to this picture. But first, let's take a break. What
- 28:44do you say, Let's do it all right, we're back from the break.
- 28:51So to add to the picture, Josh I think at this point starts
- 28:57to become disturbed and paranoid about the end of society. There's not a lot
- 29:03of data, but there's some data pointing in this direction that he did worry
- 29:07about things like the water crisis and similar things like that. I'm guessing he
- 29:12was going down some toxic early internet rabbit holes. Did those rabbit holes exist?
- 29:21I was on four Chune constantly at that Okay, so I suspect that
- 29:25he was consuming some of that stuff. And remember, he's mostly isolated.
- 29:30He doesn't have friends, he's not going to church, his marriage is falling
- 29:33apart, Steven isn't really around, so he's just left there to stew in
- 29:41these worries and his life is falling apart. He's also having no access to
- 29:47narcissistic supply, which is a very scary situation for people and people around narcissistic
- 29:53people. And also research shows that when society is going through a color elective
- 30:00fear like the financial crisis two thousand and eight or COVID or other kinds of
- 30:07nine to eleven, then people start to show signs that they are becoming more
- 30:12paranoid and desperate. So I think that could have been a factor. And
- 30:17I think this is a common road that I want to talk about a little
- 30:22bit here because I've seen it clinically and I've seen it personally, and I
- 30:25think we might be seeing it here with Josh, that a lot of men
- 30:30will go down this common problematic path that I want to lay out in steps.
- 30:37So the first is that you have someone that went through attachment attachment trauma
- 30:42to some degree, maybe to a great degree. Josh definitely went through that.
- 30:48And it's not just the trauma, but everything that happens from that,
- 30:51you know, difficulty with emotions, you know, chronic anxiety, difficulty coping,
- 30:56relationship issues, you know, it all stems from that. Two.
- 31:00As they age, they either fail or they find that success doesn't really fix
- 31:07their problems. So Josh obviously was experiencing this. So I think this is
- 31:12another factor that leads men, and I'm sure women do too, but I
- 31:18don't know. I just feel like the stories I've heard, it's always men
- 31:22in the news or people I know, so attachment trauma. They have these
- 31:26dreams like Okay, if I could just get over this hill, or if
- 31:27I could just get that thing, and they either fail at that or they
- 31:33even achieve that, but they still feel the same, and they've been socialized
- 31:36as a man not to reach out for help or ask for therapy or any
- 31:38think. So Number three, they start to plummet with their mood. They
- 31:42might get depressed or whatever, but they are becoming chronically demoralized, and they
- 31:49might even turn to substances to soothe. Maybe that's why Josh was spending more.
- 31:56Number four, there's some societal issue. It could be a crisis like
- 32:02nine to eleven or in twenty sixteen, a lot of things happened, pandemic
- 32:09qan on this sort of thing. For Josh, it could have been the
- 32:13financial crisis it was, you know, That's why I wanted to flesh out
- 32:15what we went through. Yeah, because we were mostly okay and it was
- 32:22really hard on us and scary for us. Imagine what it would be for
- 32:27Josh. Well, And I got to say, I think I would have
- 32:31come close to not surviving that period of time had it happened a few years
- 32:37sooner, Because oddly, by two thousand and eight, I was already starting
- 32:45starting to crawl out of disaster, even though I had made things so much
- 32:51worse, even all the way up to two thousand and seven. But it
- 32:54was in two thousand and eight actually where I started being able to recognize the
- 32:58problems and things. But if this had happened, if the collapse had happened
- 33:01in like two thousand and six or five, I don't know, man,
- 33:07I would have been bankrupt. I would have been I don't know. It
- 33:10would have been a lot harder because I didn't have the same tools then that
- 33:15I did later. Yeah, that's lucky. So he goes through this crisis,
- 33:21and it's a collective crisis. The fifth thing that happens along this problematic
- 33:27path for these men is that their anxiety increases exponentially. It was already there,
- 33:31they were already going down some rabbit holes. The crisis happens. Now
- 33:37they shoot through the roof and they don't have any way to cope with it.
- 33:40And normally, if they escalate an anxiety and symptoms, their support system
- 33:49would calm them down, there'd be some checks and balances. But if it's
- 33:52a societal crisis, everyone's freaking out and or they might even agree with your
- 33:59anxiety, so that that protective factor isn't present. The sixth thing that happens
- 34:06is they become desperate. You know, they're frantically searching for an answer,
- 34:10and they have no coping skills there. You know, maybe they're online all
- 34:15the time. Maybe they're hoarding a bunch of guns. Maybe they're preparing for
- 34:19the end times. Maybe they're moving into a shack in the middle of the
- 34:22woods. Maybe they're buying a lot of things. Maybe they're you know,
- 34:25who knows. They're frantically behaving to get out of this hole. Number seven,
- 34:32they start to go down even more weird rabbit holes as a part of
- 34:38that franticness, which is easier than you might think. I think all of
- 34:44us are a certain amount of anxiety and one crisis away from being brainwashed by
- 34:50some sort of algorithm, you know what I mean, particularly if you don't
- 34:52have ways of protecting yourself from that. And of course you have politicians and
- 34:58content providers who will make money from the collective fear, including your fear,
- 35:02which only increases the paranoia. Which there's no evidence that that happened to Josh,
- 35:07but it's not hard to imagine Number eight. At this point, this
- 35:13guy will take drastic measures. Maybe it's suicide, maybe it's divorced, Maybe
- 35:19it's an affair, maybe it's murder. Maybe it's moving far away, maybe
- 35:23it's running for office. Maybe it's starting a podcast. I don't know,
- 35:28but you know they'll In fact, well we started the podcast in two thousand
- 35:32and eight, but it was before I was impacted by all this. But
- 35:37anyway, so this is someone that is demoralized. They're terrified. They see
- 35:45the problem to be systemic. They don't have any connection with anyone. Their
- 35:50brain has been infected with all these weird ideas, and they're taking action.
- 35:54They're taking a drastic measure. And I think for Josh, there's a possibility
- 35:59that he was in this state. And remember that he attempted suicide seriously when
- 36:06he was a teenager, which when you're thirty one isn't that long prior,
- 36:09right, And so in two thousand and eight and this year, he basically
- 36:15doesn't have anything to live for anymore, and the idea of suicide or the
- 36:20idea of taking drastic action, you know, it's not hard to imagine that
- 36:22that would pop into his head. And I think that he started to fantasize
- 36:28even more. I think he was already because you know, he was already
- 36:31fighting for this life insurance policy and managed to get it. But at this
- 36:36point, I think he's like, fuck it, it's the end of the
- 36:38world anyway, or something along those lines. I might as well get mine.
- 36:44I deserve it, or it'll all be over anyway. There's no way
- 36:47out of this, even if I did manage to get a career, which
- 36:52probably won't happen. I mean, let's be serious, the economy will pull
- 36:55a rug out from underneath me or something. And I think that fantasy that
- 37:00he had already built of because he'd already gotten the liventerspot I think at this
- 37:07point he's like, Okay, let's let's let's make it happen. So at
- 37:13this point, Susan writes a will late two thousand and eight because the lawyer
- 37:20she was going to secretly had advised her to go through the house with a
- 37:23video camera and record all of their assets for potential divorce purposes, right because
- 37:31he might if he catches wind of the divorce, he might pack everything into
- 37:36a car and drive off, And if she doesn't have a catalog of everything,
- 37:39then he might be able to sell it and cheat her out of a
- 37:43bunch of money. So she writes a will, and she also does this
- 37:47video will. So let's watch some clips from that. What do you say,
- 37:52Let's do it covering all my bases, making sure that if something happens
- 37:58to me or my family are all of us, that our assets are documented.
- 38:02Shortly after making this video, Susan also wrote up a will. Contained
- 38:07in that will, Susan made this statement, if I die, it might
- 38:10not be an accident, even if it looks like one. By the way,
- 38:15this video is from the YouTube channel called Stay Awake, Crime and Psychology.
- 38:20What do you think about this video clip? Oh my gosh, I
- 38:22mean the mindset that you have to be in to actually put those things,
- 38:28like on a video and then put them to paper. Just think about it.
- 38:31The thought didn't casually cross your mind. You're thinking about it all the
- 38:36time. She must have literally been every day of those days going, I
- 38:42think he's trying to kill me. Right, Yeah, So in her journal
- 38:46she writes, and she puts that journal and that will, her will is
- 38:52handwritten, right, and she puts that in a safe deposit box that she
- 38:55rents and specifically tells the bank do not let my has been into the safe
- 39:00deposit box. And in that will, and in the journal art journal entry,
- 39:05she says, I want it to be documented that there is extreme turmoil
- 39:08in our marriage. And she also writes, if I die, it may
- 39:13not be an accident, even if it looks like one who says that.
- 39:17Yeah, no, unless you have a reason to it. It's not a
- 39:21random thing one writes down and puts in a vault. Right, So I
- 39:25want to rewind this and actually look at her specific writing here. Right,
- 39:30So she says, if I die, it may not be an accident,
- 39:34even if it looks like one. Take care of my boys. I want
- 39:37my parents Chuck Knox very involved and in charge of their lives. So again
- 39:44she's saying, if if I die, probably wasn't an accident, even looks
- 39:47like one. And I don't want Josh and his side of the family Stephen,
- 39:53to be in charge of the children if they aren't there, meaning her
- 40:00parents, if they've died, then I want my sister can hopefully take the
- 40:05kids. I love my boys. I live for them. I choose not
- 40:08to cheat or do drugs because I wouldn't want to risk losing them Susan Powell.
- 40:15So it's you know, interesting, will you know? And she's still
- 40:22in her twenties, right, yeah, she I think is twenty six.
- 40:24I mean, who That's what I'm saying. Who writes a will at twenty
- 40:29six with these words in them? That's not terrified for their lives? If
- 40:31I die, it may not be an accident, even if it looks like
- 40:36a one. What do you think would prompt her, in terms of her
- 40:39experiences with Josh to have her write that. That's a really good question because
- 40:45you just can't imagine that this is just because they've been arguing loudly. He
- 40:50must have said things that and maybe it was, like you know, he
- 40:59might have even said things it's like, don't you don't know the things I've
- 41:01done? Or you're like, oh, I'm capable of a lot more whatever,
- 41:05you know, stuff like that that, But it had to be enough
- 41:09to where it's not like, huh, that's a weird thing to say,
- 41:15but rather like, oh, I'm starting to believe him, you know,
- 41:17I'm starting to believe him, because yeah, it's it's horrifying to think that
- 41:22one would be in a relationship like that where it's getting to the point where
- 41:24you're like, I think they're trying to kill me. Yeah, there's some
- 41:30data, but not a lot giving us hints as to why Susan would say
- 41:35something like this, and I imagine it was some of what you're saying.
- 41:39And also he would watch documentaries about crime and other things, oh, and
- 41:46would say things he might say, well, hmm, if I were to
- 41:52kill oh my gosh, you know that kind of stuff. Oh, that's
- 41:54horrible. And it's hard to know if he was communicating, so maybe he
- 41:59was just up. But there's enough there, Like I'm not saying it's horrible
- 42:04that someone will do it, because I think everyone does that. It's horrible
- 42:07in the context yeah, yeah, so I think it's likely that Josh was
- 42:13either hinting on purpose to try to control and or it was sneaking out,
- 42:19which it often will. People have a really hard time holding on and keeping
- 42:23under wraps these kinds of fantasies that I think have been mounting over the past
- 42:30year or two. Even though in his mind he's saying, Okay, well,
- 42:32don't say anything. I think I don't think he would have the ability
- 42:37to hold back and not indicate. He must have, right, he must
- 42:43have let something sneak out. I'm sure it wasn't a plan to hint that
- 42:49he was going to kill her. He probably had enough sense to know best
- 42:52case scenario, she doesn't suspect a thing, she doesn't indicate to anyone,
- 42:57and then whatever I do to kill her, people will have no suspicion that
- 43:05I did anything. But he apparently would let things sneak out. But it's
- 43:09interesting that she says accident, right. Yeah. It's hard to know what
- 43:13her state of mind was when she wrote that, But you know, there's
- 43:15a lot of ways, and there are a lot of examples of people making
- 43:20these kinds of statements before they get are killed by their partner. But that's
- 43:23specific right, Yeah, that's it may not be an accident, even if
- 43:28it looks like one, which points in the direction that Josh was specifically talking
- 43:32about staging an accident, yeah, right, or he was faced or he
- 43:37was like, hmm, if I were to stage an accident to kill someone,
- 43:40or you know, something like that, right, yeah, because you
- 43:43can imagine any number of things, like they could have been having one of
- 43:45their multiple very bad arguments, and he says something like listen, I I'm
- 43:52a good person whatever, but if I wanted to, no one would ever
- 43:54find you or something, you know, weird stuff like that, or like
- 43:58what you were saying where he's watching the show and was like, huh,
- 44:00they would never they would never figure out what happened to them if it was
- 44:04me or whatever. Right, And and given the context of their their increasingly
- 44:08aggressive arguing all the time, she's just going and she knows how desperate he
- 44:14is financially, she knows that she's got a life insurance policy. Yeah.
- 44:19I mean. Another thing is that you know, millions upon millions of couples,
- 44:24even during this time, were in the exact same situation, lots of
- 44:29conflict, right, yelling at each other, undermining each other and financial collapse,
- 44:34financial difficulty. But there was something about Josh that Susan would worry and
- 44:43worry enough to take these kinds of actions to leader to believe that he was
- 44:47going to kill her, and not only kill her, but in a specific
- 44:51way. And that points at the way Josh came across he And remember it,
- 44:57you know, at this point, Josh has killed nobody. He as
- 45:00far as we know, the only thing he's ever killed is a Gerbil when
- 45:04he was a kid, And we don't even know if Susan knows about that.
- 45:07So Josh looks like a mild mannered but occasionally bad tempered guy. He
- 45:14doesn't drink, he doesn't use drugs, he doesn't seem to be having an
- 45:16affair or anything. He's got a spending problem and a marriage is falling apart.
- 45:22But what was he doing? And I wish I could ask Susan,
- 45:25like, what is it? Is it the look in his eye? Is
- 45:29it his temper? Is it things that he said specifically, because it was
- 45:32so different than the typical situation that Susan would suspect this. You know,
- 45:37I wonder if if there had been actually like weird, unsuccessful attempts, even
- 45:42like where she comes home and she trips on some stuff and then she's like,
- 45:46why was that there? What the yeah? Yeah, maybe and there
- 45:51is some evidence that that might have been happening. Okay, so two thousand
- 45:54and nine, Brito, this is the year that she disappears. But the
- 45:59rest of this episode is just going to be for patrons of the podcast.
- 46:01So if you want to hear what the rest of this episode, become a
- 46:05patron of the podcast on patreon dot com. Otherwise, please take care of
- 46:08yourself because you deserve it.