Latest / Bloomberg Law / $137 Million Verdict Against Tesla Over Racism
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloombird Law with June Brusso from Bloombird Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: A stunning one D thirty seven million dollar verdict unprecedented
- 0:14Speaker 1: in a racial discrimination in employment case. But that's what
- 0:18Speaker 1: a jury has ordered Tesla to pay to a former
- 0:20Speaker 1: black elevator operator. O and d As claimed that the
- 0:23Speaker 1: electric carmaker turned a blind eye to racial talents and
- 0:27Speaker 1: offensive graffiti at its factory in Fremont, California. This is
- 0:31Speaker 1: about a verdict data a jury made to to let
- 0:37Speaker 1: Tesla know that they're being put on notice to clean
- 0:40Speaker 1: up their factories. Joining me as employment law expert Anthony
- 0:44Speaker 1: on CD, a partner at Proscauer Rose Tony. The jury
- 0:47Speaker 1: deliberated for only about four hours, came back with a
- 0:51Speaker 1: verdict of six point nine million in compensatory damages and
- 0:55Speaker 1: one thirty million in punitive damages. Well, obviously it's a whopper.
- 1:00Speaker 1: There have been very few verdicts in the employment area
- 1:04Speaker 1: in California that have come anywhere close to that. The
- 1:07Speaker 1: amount of about a D eighty five million dollars against
- 1:09Speaker 1: Auto Zone a few years ago on behalf of a
- 1:13Speaker 1: female employee who sued, and there was another one against
- 1:16Speaker 1: a hospital that was around the same amount. But it's
- 1:19Speaker 1: even in California a rarity to see verdicts of a
- 1:22Speaker 1: magnitude like this. It does happen on occasion, but it's
- 1:27Speaker 1: more frequent that you see, at least in Los Angeles
- 1:29Speaker 1: and in San Francisco, verdicts that are still very large
- 1:32Speaker 1: in the million dollar range, and those happened with a
- 1:36Speaker 1: great deal frequency these days. And the reason is that
- 1:39Speaker 1: in California, basically, juries are unlimited in terms of the
- 1:43Speaker 1: amounts of money they are allowed to award in cases
- 1:46Speaker 1: like this. There are limits in some jurisdictions, there is
- 1:48Speaker 1: not such a thing in California. One of the jurors
- 1:51Speaker 1: said that the intent was to send a strong message
- 1:55Speaker 1: to the company that it has to take racial harassment seriously.
- 1:59Speaker 1: So they intended that tunitive damage award to be so high. Yeah. Absolutely.
- 2:05Speaker 1: And the other thing that I've detected, and some of
- 2:08Speaker 1: the interviews with jurors that I have read and some
- 2:10Speaker 1: of the other stories, is that the jury particularly did
- 2:13Speaker 1: not like the fact that Diaz was a contractor as
- 2:17Speaker 1: opposed to a direct employee of Tesla. I think probably
- 2:22Speaker 1: what happened was that the Planetts lawyers probably tried to
- 2:26Speaker 1: make as much of that as they possibly could by
- 2:28Speaker 1: suggesting that Tesla was trying to, you know, pull a
- 2:34Speaker 1: fast one by retaining these workers as contract employees as
- 2:38Speaker 1: opposed to direct employees. And I can see how if
- 2:42Speaker 1: presented in the right way, that could be quite damaging
- 2:45Speaker 1: to Tesla. So I detected that was going on in
- 2:48Speaker 1: addition to, of course, the allegations that existed with respect
- 2:52Speaker 1: of the use of the N word, and the drawings
- 2:55Speaker 1: and other visual depictions that have been widely reported that
- 3:00Speaker 1: allegedly occurred in this workplace. The employment cases against Tesla
- 3:05Speaker 1: usually go through arbitration, but because he was a contract worker,
- 3:10Speaker 1: Diaz didn't sign a mandatory arbitration agreement. So this is
- 3:15Speaker 1: the first time that Tesla has had to face these
- 3:17Speaker 1: kind of charges at a trial. Ironically, because he wasn't
- 3:22Speaker 1: an employee and he was a contractor, he apparently was
- 3:25Speaker 1: not subject to an arbitration obligation, which had he been
- 3:29Speaker 1: a direct employee, probably would have been. Tesla said, while
- 3:33Speaker 1: we strongly believe that these facts don't justify the verdict,
- 3:37Speaker 1: we do recognize that in ten we were not perfect.
- 3:41Speaker 1: We're still not perfect, but we've come a long way
- 3:43Speaker 1: from five years ago. Do you think that means they're
- 3:47Speaker 1: going to accept the verdict and not appeal. Oh, I'm
- 3:50Speaker 1: sure they are going to appeal. And in fact, even
- 3:52Speaker 1: before they appeal, what is almost certain to happen is
- 3:56Speaker 1: the company will file a number of post trial motion
- 4:00Speaker 1: with the judge in the case, meaning that they will
- 4:03Speaker 1: ask the judge on the case to reduce the verdict.
- 4:08Speaker 1: And judges have that power to do that. They don't
- 4:11Speaker 1: have to do it, obviously, but they can be convinced
- 4:14Speaker 1: by way of emotion and the citation obviously to case
- 4:18Speaker 1: law that would suggest that this verdict obviously cannot stand.
- 4:22Speaker 1: And I would tell you for sure it obviously cannot stand.
- 4:25Speaker 1: It is way outside what would be acceptable by any
- 4:29Speaker 1: appellate court. So, in other words, the trial court judge
- 4:31Speaker 1: can try to fix this even before it would get
- 4:35Speaker 1: to an appeal. Typically, what that looks like is the
- 4:37Speaker 1: trial judge will conditionally reduce the verdict, and if the
- 4:42Speaker 1: planetiff refuses to accept the reduction, the judge may order
- 4:46Speaker 1: a new trial, either overall or on the damages says,
- 4:50Speaker 1: or some combination of the two. So is that because
- 4:53Speaker 1: the punitive damages are almost twenty times as large as
- 4:57Speaker 1: the actual damages explain a relation between punitive and compensatory.
- 5:03Speaker 1: In an employment case, a verdict has a number of
- 5:07Speaker 1: component parts. Number one usually is lost wages, both past
- 5:11Speaker 1: and future lost wages. I have not seen any report
- 5:14Speaker 1: at all in this case about lost wages for DIA's
- 5:17Speaker 1: He was a relatively short term employee there on my understanding,
- 5:20Speaker 1: as he was an elevator operator who worked there for
- 5:23Speaker 1: about a year before he quit his employment. He claimed
- 5:27Speaker 1: he was constructively terminated because of the harassment that was
- 5:30Speaker 1: going on. So what I gathered from that is that
- 5:34Speaker 1: he probably found another job relatively quickly after he quit
- 5:39Speaker 1: this job, So that is not a major part of
- 5:42Speaker 1: this verdict. The second component, in addition to lost wages,
- 5:47Speaker 1: and this is where the money really starts to mount
- 5:51Speaker 1: in a verdict like this, is emotional distress damages, and
- 5:55Speaker 1: in this case, he was awarded obviously substantial amount of
- 6:00Speaker 1: emotional distress damages close to seven million dollars. So that
- 6:04Speaker 1: will be the first point of attack both at the
- 6:06Speaker 1: trial court level and on an appeal from Tesla in
- 6:09Speaker 1: the event that the case doesn't get settled, and of
- 6:11Speaker 1: course that could also happen, there could be a settlement amount.
- 6:14Speaker 1: What do I mean by the first point of attack.
- 6:15Speaker 1: What Tesla's lawyers, I think will argue is that even
- 6:19Speaker 1: though the facts are as they are in this case,
- 6:22Speaker 1: even assuming everything that Diaz alleged and everything the jury
- 6:26Speaker 1: believed happened here did happen, six point nine million dollars
- 6:30Speaker 1: is still a very very large amount of money for
- 6:32Speaker 1: emotional distress damages. And there's a relatively recent case in
- 6:36Speaker 1: California where there was a three point five million dollar
- 6:39Speaker 1: emotional distress damages award. This was against the City of
- 6:43Speaker 1: West Cobina. It was it was a employment case, and
- 6:47Speaker 1: the appellate court in that case, at three point five
- 6:49Speaker 1: million dollars in emotional distress was quote shockingly disproportionate given
- 6:54Speaker 1: what the harm was that was proved at the time
- 6:56Speaker 1: of the trial. That was a whistleblower case, and so
- 7:00Speaker 1: as a result of that, the appellate court reduced that
- 7:04Speaker 1: three point five million dollar emotional distress damages down to
- 7:07Speaker 1: one point one million. So I think there's a lot
- 7:10Speaker 1: of reduction that Tesla will seek just on the emotional
- 7:15Speaker 1: distress component. And then the third component is punitive damages.
- 7:19Speaker 1: As you mentioned, and there's another recent case from California.
- 7:22Speaker 1: These are appellate court cases, so they are binding on
- 7:25Speaker 1: at least state courts in these situations where the court
- 7:28Speaker 1: said that a two to one ratio of punitive compensatory
- 7:31Speaker 1: damages was appropriate, so in that case, the court reduced
- 7:36Speaker 1: a larger two point one million dollars punitive to compensatories.
- 7:40Speaker 1: So if that were the case, even if the seven
- 7:42Speaker 1: million dollars were to stay in terms of emotional distress,
- 7:46Speaker 1: there couldn't be more than say, fourteen million dollars in
- 7:50Speaker 1: punitive damages on top of the seven million. Is there
- 7:54Speaker 1: a possibility of a settlement even after the jury trial. Yes, absolutely.
- 8:00Speaker 1: Of course, the plaintiff's lawyer has all aces in terms
- 8:05Speaker 1: of these negotiations. It's difficult to upset a jury verdict typically,
- 8:11Speaker 1: But as I just said, I think the greatest set
- 8:14Speaker 1: of weapons that will be used by TESLA and trying
- 8:18Speaker 1: to reverse this or change this will be to attack
- 8:21Speaker 1: the amounts because they really are outside the scope of
- 8:24Speaker 1: what appellate courts would permit in a case such as this,
- 8:28Speaker 1: And therefore I think the judge in this matter may
- 8:30Speaker 1: be governed by that. There may have also been things
- 8:33Speaker 1: that occurred at trial that that I'm just not aware
- 8:35Speaker 1: of that Tesla will say prejudice them or harm them,
- 8:39Speaker 1: or that we're an abuse of discretion by the judge
- 8:41Speaker 1: something like that. Those are all things that I'm sure
- 8:43Speaker 1: that they're thinking about it at this point at Tesla.
- 8:47Speaker 1: So let's say you're defending Tesla. You have this verdict.
- 8:51Speaker 1: This is the second time in recent months that Tesla
- 8:55Speaker 1: has been found liable in a case involving claims of
- 8:58Speaker 1: race based discriminating Asian. What do you do in the
- 9:01Speaker 1: other cases that Tesla is facing. What kind of defense
- 9:05Speaker 1: can you put up? Well, every case is different, of course,
- 9:08Speaker 1: and every employee who is coming at them is going
- 9:10Speaker 1: to be somewhat different. Although there also is a class action,
- 9:13Speaker 1: as I understand it, penning against them. So that actually
- 9:16Speaker 1: would be a situation where the lawyers are claiming that
- 9:19Speaker 1: there was actually commonality in terms of what happened to
- 9:23Speaker 1: their various clients, but just taking them one by one,
- 9:26Speaker 1: you know, every employee has a different set of circumstances
- 9:30Speaker 1: and I think each will have to be evaluated. It
- 9:33Speaker 1: is not too much of a leap of faith though
- 9:35Speaker 1: to assume that it's going to be more difficult for
- 9:38Speaker 1: Tesla going forward because now there's blood in the water,
- 9:42Speaker 1: and I suspect that no plaintiffs lawyer is going to
- 9:45Speaker 1: want to settle cases if they think they've got any
- 9:47Speaker 1: facts that are even close to those that existed in
- 9:51Speaker 1: this case. There's an investor proposal up for consideration at
- 9:56Speaker 1: the annual shareholder meeting that calls for the board to
- 10:00Speaker 1: oversee preparation of a report about how the company's use
- 10:03Speaker 1: of mandatory arbitration affects employees and corporate culture. From the
- 10:09Speaker 1: verdict in this case compared to the one million dollar
- 10:12Speaker 1: verdict in the arbitration case, can we see the difference
- 10:16Speaker 1: when a jury is involved. Absolutely, this is a laboratory uh.
- 10:22Speaker 1: The laboratory example of the difference between arbitration and jury trials,
- 10:28Speaker 1: I was struck by um the comparison. You may remember
- 10:32Speaker 1: from the whole Cold War years between East Berlin and
- 10:35Speaker 1: West Berlin. You had similar circumstances that existed in East
- 10:39Speaker 1: Berlin and West Berlin. One was a communist dictatorship and
- 10:41Speaker 1: one was a democracy. UH. And it wasn't difficult to
- 10:44Speaker 1: to to look at the difference between those two systems
- 10:48Speaker 1: What has just happened to Tesla is almost identical to
- 10:52Speaker 1: that kind of experiment. We have a black employee who's
- 10:56Speaker 1: claiming that he was subjected to racial harassment and discrimination
- 11:01Speaker 1: in the workplace, and he has signed an arbitration agreement.
- 11:04Speaker 1: That employee got a million dollars, which is still a
- 11:06Speaker 1: very sizeable award. Obviously, that was back in August UM.
- 11:12Speaker 1: A couple of months later, another employee, an other black employee,
- 11:15Speaker 1: claims he was subjected to almost the same kind of
- 11:17Speaker 1: if not exactly the same kind of harassment discrimination and
- 11:21Speaker 1: he gets a hundred and thirty seven million dollars from
- 11:25Speaker 1: a jury. Uh. It doesn't take a rocket scientists to
- 11:29Speaker 1: say that one system is more employer friendly and one
- 11:32Speaker 1: system is more employee friendly. And that is all you
- 11:35Speaker 1: really need to know about why plaintiffs, like jury trials
- 11:38Speaker 1: and employers tend to prefer arbitration. In terms of that
- 11:41Speaker 1: board meeting, which is tomorrow, I think you know, obviously
- 11:45Speaker 1: it's never a good time I suspect for a company
- 11:47Speaker 1: to suffer an adverse verdict like this, but the timing
- 11:51Speaker 1: could not be better for Tesla in terms of the
- 11:54Speaker 1: board which I believe is against the proposal that is
- 11:57Speaker 1: going to be considered tomorrow on the issue of reporting
- 12:02Speaker 1: and investigating whether arbitration is better than jury trials. TESLA
- 12:08Speaker 1: presumably is in the business of making money, and I
- 12:11Speaker 1: can't imagine any investor who would come to the conclusion
- 12:16Speaker 1: that they are better off suffering a hundred thirty seven
- 12:19Speaker 1: million dollar verdict versus potentially a million dollar award from
- 12:23Speaker 1: our arbitrator. I think those results speak for themselves. Thanks Tony.
- 12:28Speaker 1: That's Anthony on CD a partner Proscower Rose. Hello, I'm
- 12:33Speaker 1: Bob Ross. If this is your first time with us,
- 12:36Speaker 1: then let me extend a personal invitation for you to
- 12:38Speaker 1: get out your brushes and paint along and spend a
- 12:41Speaker 1: relaxing half power enjoying some of nature's masterpieces. That's why
- 12:46Speaker 1: I paint. It's because I can create the kind of
- 12:49Speaker 1: world that I want, and I can make this world
- 12:51Speaker 1: as happy as I wanted. The Netflix documentary about painter
- 12:55Speaker 1: Bob Ross Happy Accidents, Betrayal and Greed, is about an
- 13:00Speaker 1: unhappy accident in the intellectual property fight over the rights
- 13:04Speaker 1: to Ross's name and image. After his death, his son
- 13:07Speaker 1: Steve lost the long court battle over Ross's intellectual property
- 13:12Speaker 1: because of the corporate structure of Bob Ross, Inc. His
- 13:15Speaker 1: father's company, Steve Ross was left with nothing despite what
- 13:19Speaker 1: his father's will dictated, joining me his intellectual property litigator
- 13:23Speaker 1: Terence Ross, a partner at Captain Nuchen Rosenman so Terry.
- 13:27Speaker 1: For those who haven't seen the PBS show or all
- 13:30Speaker 1: the products and merchandise out there, tell us a little
- 13:34Speaker 1: about Bob Ross. Well, Bob Ross, like many young men
- 13:38Speaker 1: of his generation, had to do time with the military,
- 13:42Speaker 1: and he enlisted with the Air Force and had some
- 13:46Speaker 1: time on his hands while he was stationed in Alaska
- 13:48Speaker 1: and took a class from the USO on basic oil
- 13:51Speaker 1: painting technique, fell in love with it, and when his
- 13:54Speaker 1: career in the Air Force concluded and he did a
- 13:57Speaker 1: twenty year or full twenty year career, he wanted to
- 14:00Speaker 1: bring all that he had learned about painting two common
- 14:04Speaker 1: people like him, and so he started a show called
- 14:08Speaker 1: The Joy of Painting, which eventually caught on from a
- 14:12Speaker 1: single station in Indiana to nationwide, and he became a
- 14:18Speaker 1: very popular teacher of what's now called do it yourself
- 14:22Speaker 1: painting for a better part of twelve years across the
- 14:26Speaker 1: entire PBS network of stations. His approach was very similar
- 14:32Speaker 1: to Mr Rogers and Fred Rogers. Mr Rogers neighborhood is
- 14:36Speaker 1: very positive and upbeating, uplifting and looking for the beauty
- 14:40Speaker 1: and join things. And this was seen in the paintings
- 14:43Speaker 1: that he thought folks to paint, just very happy paintings.
- 14:47Speaker 1: He often we've heard of clouds as these happy little
- 14:49Speaker 1: clouds floating across the sky. It was all very delightful.
- 14:52Speaker 1: And then he sort of fell out of favor, and
- 14:54Speaker 1: in the last few years he has suddenly back in
- 14:58Speaker 1: favor again. PBS is once again running his shows. You're
- 15:02Speaker 1: seeing his image on virtually everything having to do with painting,
- 15:06Speaker 1: paint brushes, paint types, paint starter kits. His image was
- 15:10Speaker 1: even on a lunchbox recently. It's coffee cups, t shirts, costumes, pajamas, blankets,
- 15:16Speaker 1: jigsaw puzzles, on and on and June. It's this commercialization
- 15:20Speaker 1: that you're referring to there that is the cause of
- 15:23Speaker 1: the legal problems here because at its court, the intellectual
- 15:26Speaker 1: property issues at stake here involve what's known as right
- 15:32Speaker 1: of publicity, which a lot of people are unaware of.
- 15:36Speaker 1: Can you will your publicity rights to someone else. It
- 15:39Speaker 1: depends on which state you live in. Rights of publicity
- 15:43Speaker 1: are not federally recognized intellectual property rights to the extent
- 15:48Speaker 1: that they exist at all. They exist as a creature
- 15:51Speaker 1: of state law. And according to one study, I've seen
- 15:55Speaker 1: approximately two thirds of the states in the United States
- 15:59Speaker 1: how these rights the publicity laws, and they can if
- 16:04Speaker 1: the state legislature deems it's appropriate, provide for the inheritability
- 16:10Speaker 1: of these publicity rights. And so it really, at the
- 16:14Speaker 1: end of the day, depends in which state the owner
- 16:18Speaker 1: of the publicity rights is considered a resident of. At
- 16:21Speaker 1: the time of his or her death, Ross intended to
- 16:25Speaker 1: give the rights to his son and his half brother.
- 16:28Speaker 1: He even altered his will with a clause that specified
- 16:31Speaker 1: that his name, likeness, voice, and visual, written or otherwise
- 16:36Speaker 1: recorded work would go to his son and his half brother.
- 16:39Speaker 1: So why didn't that happen? Here we have an example
- 16:42Speaker 1: of not merely the rights of publicity passing by way
- 16:47Speaker 1: of state law, you know, in the normal course to
- 16:50Speaker 1: the next of ken. But you have Bob Ross prior
- 16:54Speaker 1: to that, making an affirmative representation that he wanted these
- 16:58Speaker 1: rights of publicity the pass on to his son and
- 17:02Speaker 1: brother and yet that did not happen, and why did
- 17:05Speaker 1: it not happen? By happenstance, the way that Bob Ross
- 17:10Speaker 1: set up his company is called bob Ross Inc. Defeated
- 17:14Speaker 1: the intent of his will or the estate laws of
- 17:18Speaker 1: his home state. The way bob Ross Inc. Was set
- 17:22Speaker 1: up It involved a licensing of all intellectual property rights
- 17:27Speaker 1: from Bob Ross to this company, bob Ross Inc. And
- 17:31Speaker 1: that might have been fined in the normal course. If
- 17:33Speaker 1: he was the only owner of bob Ross Inc. Then
- 17:37Speaker 1: those rights would have passed through his estate. But he
- 17:40Speaker 1: was not the only owner of bob Ross Inc. The
- 17:43Speaker 1: owners for himself, his wife, and to their friends, the Kulaskis,
- 17:47Speaker 1: who had assisted in setting up and launching his painting business.
- 17:51Speaker 1: And Moreover, the way bob Ross Inc. Was set up
- 17:56Speaker 1: was that stock, if you will, those ownership rights passed
- 17:59Speaker 1: by contract upon the death of any of the other owners.
- 18:02Speaker 1: So when Bob Ross's wife predeceased him, her ownership and
- 18:06Speaker 1: bob Rossing passed to the other three owners. And then
- 18:09Speaker 1: when Bob Ross passed away next his rights passed to
- 18:12Speaker 1: the Kawawskis. And so simply by that happenstance, the order
- 18:17Speaker 1: of death, the Kawski's ended up with all of the
- 18:20Speaker 1: ownership of bob Rossinc. And bob Ross Inc. Owned to
- 18:24Speaker 1: all the intellectual property rights of Bob Ross, which included
- 18:28Speaker 1: the right of publicity according to the court. Do you
- 18:31Speaker 1: think that bob Ross was confused when he made that
- 18:34Speaker 1: partnership agreement because later he's trying to give away his
- 18:38Speaker 1: publicity rights to his son and half brother, Well June.
- 18:42Speaker 1: Those facts certainly suggest that he did not understand what
- 18:46Speaker 1: he was doing, or else he would not at a
- 18:48Speaker 1: later date have attempted to bequeath those rights of publicity
- 18:52Speaker 1: to his son and his brother. It is unclear to
- 18:55Speaker 1: me whether he had legal representation at the time that
- 18:58Speaker 1: he established bob Ross Inc. And set up this formula
- 19:01Speaker 1: by which, in effect there is a lottery as to
- 19:04Speaker 1: who survived the longest amongst the owners of bob Ross
- 19:07Speaker 1: Think and therefore ended up with the intellectual property right.
- 19:10Speaker 1: But it is certainly a cautionary tale for all creators
- 19:14Speaker 1: who have intellectual property rights that they have to obtain
- 19:18Speaker 1: competent Intellectual Property Council with respect to any aspect of
- 19:23Speaker 1: those intellectual property rights, whether it's setting up a corporation
- 19:26Speaker 1: whether it's doing licensing agreements, whether it's even doing your will.
- 19:30Speaker 1: There's some debate about whether publicity rights should be transferable.
- 19:35Speaker 1: What's your opinion. So it's a very good question and
- 19:39Speaker 1: one that you correctly point out is being debated at
- 19:42Speaker 1: the academic level. My personal view is that this sort
- 19:47Speaker 1: of intellectual property right has to be transferable to prevent
- 19:51Speaker 1: such a transfer would take away from the original owner
- 19:55Speaker 1: of those rights. In this case, Bob Ross, the ability
- 19:58Speaker 1: to monitor is write a publicity by transferring, selling, licensing
- 20:01Speaker 1: it to some other company that may be able to
- 20:04Speaker 1: make good use of it. And if you prevent him
- 20:06Speaker 1: from doing that, you prevent him from monetizing Foy his
- 20:09Speaker 1: name and likeness, which in this case we're very valuable.
- 20:12Speaker 1: Thanks Terry. That's Terence Ross of Katon Uten Rosenman. And
- 20:16Speaker 1: that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show.
- 20:18Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg