Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Prevent Disintermediation to Protect Take Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: You spend months building a marketplace. You attract buyers and sellers, liquidity forms, transactions happen. And then — the users look at each other and say, 'Hey, why are we paying the platform? Let's just swap phone numbers and go direct.' Luna: That's the disintermediation nightmare. Every marketplace operator I've talked to loses sleep over it. Lucas: Right. Because if users bypass your platform, your take rate evaporates. So today we're looking at how marketplaces actually fight this — the tools, policies, and design choices that keep transactions on-platform. And the best place to start is Upwork. Luna: Upwork's entire business depends on preventing clients and freelancers from taking relationships off the platform. Their average take rate is around 14 to 20 percent, depending on the contract size. Lucas: Exactly. And they have a famous non-circumvention policy. If a client and freelancer meet on Upwork and then try to work directly within the next 24 months, Upwork charges a fee equivalent to what they would have made. But they also use technology. Luna: What kind of tech? Scanning messages for phone numbers and email addresses? Lucas: That's part of it. Upwork's system automatically detects contact information in messages — phone numbers, email addresses, even images that might contain them. They'll flag those messages, sometimes block them. But smart users try workarounds: writing numbers as words, using voice calls. Luna: So it's a cat and mouse game. How does Upwork make the on-platform experience so good that users don't want to leave? Lucas: That's the critical piece. They add value that's hard to replicate: escrow payments, time tracking, milestone management, dispute resolution. For a freelancer, the risk of not getting paid outweighs saving 15 percent. For a client, having built-in protection if the work is bad — that's worth the fee. Luna: So it's a mix of carrots and sticks. The stick is the policy and monitoring. The carrot is the trust infrastructure. Lucas: Right. And other marketplaces do the same thing differently. Take Airbnb. They hide guest and host contact information completely until a booking is confirmed. No phone numbers, no email addresses in messages. And they have a billion-dollar host guarantee. Going direct means losing that insurance. Luna: That makes sense for high-value, infrequent transactions. But what about Uber? The ride is low-value and happens instantly. The driver could easily hand the passenger a business card. Lucas: They can. And some do. But Uber relies on a different model: the transaction is so small and immediate that the friction of going direct — remembering a number, negotiating a price, dealing with cash — just isn't worth it. Plus Uber's dynamic pricing means drivers earn more during surge times, which keeps them on the app. Luna: Interesting. So the prevention mechanism depends on the nature of the transaction. For long-term freelancing, you need legal and technical barriers. For commodity services, you need speed and convenience. Lucas: Exactly. There's also the 'freemium' approach. Some marketplaces only take a fee on premium or matched leads. Angi — formerly Angie's List — lets service pros keep 100 percent of jobs they source themselves, but charges for leads from the platform. That reduces the incentive to bypass. Luna: But there's a tension. If you lock down communication too much, you hurt the user experience. People need to exchange details to complete a transaction. How do marketplaces balance that? Lucas: It's a design challenge. Many marketplaces allow contact info sharing only after a payment has been processed. That way, the platform gets its cut first, and then users can take the relationship wherever they want. Up to a point. Luna: So the transaction itself becomes the handshake. That's clever. Lucas: Speaking of clever design, there's another tactic: 'walled garden' features like escrow, messaging, and scheduling tools that only work within the platform. If users leave, they lose access to those tools. That's a real loss in efficiency. Luna: Let's talk numbers. Is there data on how prevalent disintermediation actually is? Lucas: There is. A 2022 study by marketplace researchers found that 30 to 40 percent of users attempt some form of direct dealing after a few transactions. For marketplaces without strong prevention, that number can hit 50 percent. That's why the best platforms treat it as a board-level issue. Luna: And what about marketplaces that just accept it? Some subscription-based models don't even try. Lucas: Some do — like LinkedIn's Recruiter product. You pay a subscription, and you can contact anyone. There's no per-transaction fee, so disintermediation doesn't matter. But for commission-based marketplaces, it's existential. Luna: So the takeaway: if you're building a marketplace, your take rate is only as strong as your moat against disintermediation. Lucas: And that moat is built from a combination of legal terms, technical enforcement, and genuine value-add on both sides. It's a constant evolution. Upwork, for instance, started with a simple policy and then built the escrow and time-tracking features over time. Luna: Before we wrap, I want to say that this kind of deep dive is exactly why we love making this show. And we keep it ad-free because listeners like you support it. If you find value in these episodes, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture that helps us stay independent. Lucas: Absolutely. And we genuinely appreciate each one. So, back to the topic: what's the one thing a new marketplace should do first? I'd say, think about the escape hatches. If you can't make the on-platform experience better than going around it, your revenue is fragile. Luna: That's a great closing thought. Next time you design a marketplace, build the moat first. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for listening.