Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS Leans Toward Catholic Schools at Expense of LGBTQ Rights
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Let's get to it. Your school can reject a child
- 0:14Speaker 2: because their parents are homosexual. St.
- 0:17Speaker 3: Mary's Catholic Parish and the Archdiocese of Denver argue that
- 0:21Speaker 3: the state of Colorado is violating their First Amendment rights
- 0:25Speaker 3: by excluding their preschools that refuse to admit the children
- 0:29Speaker 3: of gay and transgender parents From the state's universal preschool program,
- 0:35Speaker 3: liberal justice Sonia Sotomayor repeatedly clarified the school's policy in
- 0:41Speaker 3: her questioning.
- 0:42Speaker 2: I'm asking you a direct question. Your Catholic schools will
- 0:46Speaker 2: reject the child merely because their parents are homosexual.
- 0:51Speaker 4: I would say if it's the sincere religious exercise of
- 0:53Speaker 4: the petitioner, then I think that would be permitted.
- 0:56Speaker 5: Respectfully, no, that elides.
- 0:58Speaker 2: That is completely what you're saying. We can exclude children
- 1:02Speaker 2: of same-sex marriage. We can exclude children who might have
- 1:07Speaker 2: transgender feelings or beliefs because exposing other children to them
- 1:15Speaker 2: creates a problem.
- 1:16Speaker 3: And Liberal Justice Elena Kagan said the Catholic schools were
- 1:20Speaker 3: not being discriminated against but were asking for an exemption
- 1:24Speaker 3: from the non-discrimination law.
- 1:27Speaker 6: Even though religious people are being treated the same way
- 1:30Speaker 6: on the face of the statute, that's not enough. They
- 1:33Speaker 6: need a special accommodation. They need to be treated differently
- 1:38Speaker 6: from other people because of their religious faith.
- 1:43Speaker 3: And the court's conservatives appeared open to doing just that,
- 1:48Speaker 3: at times even invoking the state's dismal track record before
- 1:52Speaker 3: the court in recent years in cases tied to religious beliefs.
- 1:57Speaker 3: Here's Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
- 1:59Speaker 7: So you've gotten a number of questions about how it's
- 2:02Speaker 7: hard to imagine that Colorado couldn't have seen this coming.
- 2:06Speaker 7: I mean, especially given the history of disputes that have
- 2:10Speaker 7: been in front of this court between Colorado and religious entities,
- 2:13Speaker 7: whether we're talking about bakers or web designers or therapists.
- 2:17Speaker 3: In a line of three cases, the conservatives on the
- 2:20Speaker 3: court have sided with religious schools in similar disputes. finding
- 2:24Speaker 3: that state efforts to block religious schools from public dollars
- 2:29Speaker 3: violate the free exercise clause. And the conservative justices, like
- 2:33Speaker 3: Neil Gorsuch, repeatedly referred to those cases.
- 2:37Speaker 1: So Carson itself and Trinity Lutheran and Espinoza, we were
- 2:41Speaker 1: just wasting our time for the last 10 years on
- 2:44Speaker 1: those cases.
- 2:45Speaker 3: And conservative justices Brett Kavanaugh and Samuel Alito said, pointed
- 2:50Speaker 3: out that there are plenty of other schools that the
- 2:52Speaker 3: children of LGBTQ parents can attend.
- 2:56Speaker 8: Little evidence, if any evidence, you'll tell me if I'm wrong,
- 3:00Speaker 8: that there are LGBTQ couples who cannot find other preschools
- 3:08Speaker 8: to send their children to.
- 3:11Speaker 9: But there are 2,000 schools. There are only 34 Catholic schools.
- 3:15Speaker 9: There are plenty of opportunities to respect LGBTQ the rights
- 3:20Speaker 9: of the religious believers and respect the ability of LGBT
- 3:27Speaker 9: parents to find among the 2,000 schools appropriate fit for
- 3:34Speaker 9: their children.
- 3:35Speaker 3: Joining me is a First Amendment expert, Caroline Malla-Corbin, a
- 3:39Speaker 3: professor at the University of Miami Law School. Caroline, so
- 3:43Speaker 3: set the stage for these oral arguments.
- 3:46Speaker 5: So it starts with Colorado. And Colorado wants to provide
- 3:52Speaker 5: free universal pre-K education to all the Colorado little ones.
- 3:57Speaker 5: It doesn't yet have the infrastructure to do that itself.
- 4:00Speaker 5: So it's going to partner with existing private schools. So
- 4:04Speaker 5: they're going to fund private schools to provide free pre-K
- 4:09Speaker 5: education to little Coloradans. Not surprisingly, the state has certain
- 4:15Speaker 5: standards for what schools it's going to fund. So it
- 4:18Speaker 5: has rules about the curriculum, classroom size, teacher training. And
- 4:23Speaker 5: it also says that schools are not eligible if they
- 4:28Speaker 5: discriminate on the basis of various criteria. And that includes
- 4:33Speaker 5: sexual orientation or gender identity. So basically, that's it. We
- 4:37Speaker 5: want pre-K, we want to give you money, but you
- 4:40Speaker 5: have to meet our standards. And one of our standards
- 4:43Speaker 5: is you may not discriminate in who you admit to
- 4:46Speaker 5: the school. Now, here's where there's a problem. There are
- 4:50Speaker 5: certain Catholic schools, not all of them, mind you. There
- 4:54Speaker 5: are a few Catholic schools that say our religion requires
- 4:59Speaker 5: us to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation and
- 5:03Speaker 5: gender identity. It's like, we cannot have the children of
- 5:07Speaker 5: gay parents or trans parents in our school that undermines
- 5:11Speaker 5: our religion. And, they argue, we want to be able
- 5:16Speaker 5: to refuse these children and still get taxpayer money. And
- 5:21Speaker 5: they argue that it violates our religious liberty, the Free
- 5:26Speaker 5: Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, if you do not
- 5:29Speaker 5: give us money. In other words, to not allow them
- 5:32Speaker 5: to discriminate on the government's dime. is religious discrimination. So
- 5:36Speaker 5: that's what we are presented with in this case. There
- 5:39Speaker 5: is a free exercise claim brought by the Catholic schools
- 5:45Speaker 5: against the state of Colorado for saying you cannot have
- 5:50Speaker 5: taxpayer dollars from the people of Colorado if you're going
- 5:54Speaker 5: to discriminate against some of the people of Colorado.
- 5:58Speaker 3: The district court and a unanimous Tenth Circuit panel rejected
- 6:04Speaker 3: the Catholic schools here. Why did the Supreme Court even
- 6:07Speaker 3: take this case?
- 6:09Speaker 5: I am surprised that the Supreme Court took this case
- 6:14Speaker 5: because it is a poor case on the existing law.
- 6:18Speaker 5: Under the existing law, there is a rule that says
- 6:22Speaker 5: if the state's law is neutral and generally applicable, in
- 6:27Speaker 5: other words, if the state law is not targeting religion
- 6:31Speaker 5: in any way, then it's not a free exercise problem.
- 6:34Speaker 5: And this very much seems like a law that is
- 6:38Speaker 5: not singling religion out for disfavor because it's basically saying
- 6:43Speaker 5: you can get the money if you meet our requirements,
- 6:46Speaker 5: whether you're religious or secular, and you can't get the
- 6:49Speaker 5: money if you don't meet our requirements, if you're religious
- 6:53Speaker 5: or secular. And so there is no discrimination against religion
- 6:59Speaker 5: such that, the law would fail this requirement that it
- 7:05Speaker 5: be neutral and generally applicable. And the existing law does
- 7:08Speaker 5: not argue otherwise.
- 7:10Speaker 3: But during the oral arguments, the conservatives suggested over and
- 7:14Speaker 3: over that this case falls in line with the three
- 7:17Speaker 3: other cases where they found that state efforts to block
- 7:22Speaker 3: religious schools from getting public dollars violates the free exercise clause.
- 7:28Speaker 5: Some people may be familiar with a series of cases
- 7:32Speaker 5: where the Supreme Court has been insisting that the government
- 7:37Speaker 5: fund religious schools. And so you might think, isn't this
- 7:41Speaker 5: part and parcel of that? Is this a quartet of
- 7:44Speaker 5: cases rather than a trio? This is different from the
- 7:47Speaker 5: prior cases because the prior cases, what the government was
- 7:52Speaker 5: saying was, We have money. We have grant money. It's
- 7:56Speaker 5: either for schools or it's for playground resurfacing. And we
- 8:01Speaker 5: are explicitly excluding religious schools because of the Establishment Clause,
- 8:07Speaker 5: which the court pretends doesn't exist. But again, that was
- 8:10Speaker 5: the reason offered is we are worried about establishment. The
- 8:14Speaker 5: government's not supposed to fund churches or we want to
- 8:17Speaker 5: promote separation of church and state. So even though we
- 8:21Speaker 5: have this program of benefits, we are gonna exclude religious organizations.
- 8:26Speaker 5: And the Supreme Court has said, you cannot do that.
- 8:30Speaker 5: You cannot offer money to private secular schools and not
- 8:36Speaker 5: also make it available to private religious schools just because
- 8:40Speaker 5: they're religious. And that was sort of the holding in
- 8:43Speaker 5: a series of cases. So again, the existing rule right
- 8:47Speaker 5: now is that if the government is going to offer
- 8:51Speaker 5: money to private schools, it cannot exclude private religious schools
- 8:57Speaker 5: just because they're religious. And Colorado hasn't done this. That's
- 9:01Speaker 5: not at all what it's doing. It has absolutely said,
- 9:04Speaker 5: are you a private religious school that wants to offer
- 9:08Speaker 5: pre-K education? Come on down. You're welcome to government money.
- 9:14Speaker 5: You can still teach religion however you want. The only
- 9:19Speaker 5: thing that we are requiring is that you're not allowed
- 9:22Speaker 5: to discriminate against who's allowed to come. So this is
- 9:25Speaker 5: not the same situation as the prior cases. Again, in
- 9:30Speaker 5: the prior cases, the state law explicitly said no religious
- 9:36Speaker 5: schools because they're religious. This case is like the religious
- 9:40Speaker 5: schools are welcome. We just don't want to spend our taxpayers'
- 9:45Speaker 5: money on schools that are going to discriminate against some
- 9:47Speaker 5: of the people of Colorado.
- 9:49Speaker 3: And I think Justice Kagan explained that distinction very well. Caroline, legally,
- 9:56Speaker 3: why were Justices Kavanaugh and Alito pointing? out that Catholic
- 10:01Speaker 3: preschools are in the minority and there are plenty of
- 10:04Speaker 3: other schools that LGBTQ parents can take their children to?
- 10:10Speaker 5: So, again, I think that the state was trying to
- 10:15Speaker 5: highlight that there are interests on the the people who
- 10:20Speaker 5: are going to suffer from discrimination. Historically, discrimination was harmful
- 10:25Speaker 5: for two reasons, right? One reason was you're denying equal access.
- 10:30Speaker 5: And the second is it was a gross dignity harm.
- 10:35Speaker 5: You're saying these people not worthy of being treated equally.
- 10:39Speaker 5: And the court with the first one, denial of equal access,
- 10:43Speaker 5: was trying to minimize the fact that Parents who are
- 10:47Speaker 5: trans or gay don't have the same access to schools
- 10:51Speaker 5: as everybody else does. They could just go to another school.
- 10:55Speaker 5: And Helen Norton, who did a fabulous job, was trying
- 10:58Speaker 5: to say, yeah, but for some parents, the Catholic school
- 11:01Speaker 5: is right down the street. And now that's the school
- 11:04Speaker 5: they need to go to. And they can't. She was
- 11:07Speaker 5: really hitting back on this idea that you can just
- 11:10Speaker 5: go to another school and that doesn't deny you access.
- 11:12Speaker 5: And she's like, yeah, it does deny you access. You're
- 11:15Speaker 5: denying them access to the school down the street, which
- 11:18Speaker 5: is precisely the school they need. And the dignity harm,
- 11:21Speaker 5: this idea that it's a-okay to refuse entry to people
- 11:26Speaker 5: because of a protected characteristic like gender identity is or
- 11:30Speaker 5: sexual orientation just does not register with this court. They
- 11:33Speaker 5: don't acknowledge it. They don't care about it. It's not
- 11:37Speaker 5: on their radar. And so that was their attempt to
- 11:40Speaker 5: minimize the state's compelling interests on the other side, which
- 11:44Speaker 5: was ensuring equal access, ensuring equal dignity for everybody in Colorado,
- 11:50Speaker 5: especially if it's going to be on the state's dime.
- 11:54Speaker 3: At one point, it sounded as if Justice Elena Kagan
- 11:58Speaker 3: was sort of Throwing her hands up in exasperation.
- 12:03Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, forgive me, Ms. Harris, but I think
- 12:06Speaker 6: given the fact that this court is never going to
- 12:09Speaker 6: really question the sincerity of anybody's beliefs, it's going to
- 12:14Speaker 6: be pretty easy for religious groups or religious individuals to
- 12:18Speaker 6: come forward and say this would be a substantial burden
- 12:21Speaker 6: on my religious belief or on my religious practice. That
- 12:26Speaker 6: seems like, yeah, maybe in once in a blue moon,
- 12:28Speaker 6: you're going to have somebody fail that, but not very often.
- 12:31Speaker 5: So what's going on is the existing rule is if
- 12:35Speaker 5: it's a neutral law of general applicability, then you're fine.
- 12:39Speaker 5: If it's not, then you are entitled to an exemption.
- 12:43Speaker 5: And they're essentially seeking this exemption from the rule that
- 12:46Speaker 5: they can't discriminate. You're entitled to an exemption if the
- 12:50Speaker 5: law imposes a substantial burden on your ability to practice
- 12:54Speaker 5: your religion. And the law can't pass strict scrutiny. In
- 12:58Speaker 5: other words, the state doesn't have a really comparing justification
- 13:01Speaker 5: for imposing that substantial burden on your religious liberty. And
- 13:06Speaker 5: the concern is that the religious person bringing a claim
- 13:11Speaker 5: is always going to argue that the law that they
- 13:13Speaker 5: want an exemption from imposes a substantial burden. Because you
- 13:17Speaker 5: might question that. Is discriminating against the children of gay
- 13:20Speaker 5: parents really required by their religion? Maybe it's a burden.
- 13:24Speaker 5: Is it a substantial burden? You might question whether that's
- 13:29Speaker 5: really a substantial burden, assuming it's a burden on their religion.
- 13:34Speaker 5: And her argument is, you're always going to agree it's
- 13:36Speaker 5: a substantial burden. You're never going to question that it's
- 13:39Speaker 5: a substantial burden. And so what you're left with is
- 13:44Speaker 5: that Anytime a religious person is going to argue that
- 13:47Speaker 5: a law imposes a substantial burden, if you don't have
- 13:50Speaker 5: that screening question where it's okay if it's neutral and
- 13:52Speaker 5: general applicable, if the argument is instead that doesn't apply,
- 13:55Speaker 5: and I'm entitled to an exemption anytime it poses a
- 13:59Speaker 5: substantial burden, it's always going to impose a substantial burden.
- 14:02Speaker 5: And so the only way you can enforce the law
- 14:05Speaker 5: is if it passes strict scrutiny, which means the government
- 14:09Speaker 5: has to make a very strong showing that this is
- 14:12Speaker 5: advancing a compelling government interest and there's no other way
- 14:15Speaker 5: to do it. And she's just frustrated. She's like, a
- 14:18Speaker 5: conservative religious person doesn't want to follow the law. All
- 14:22Speaker 5: they have to do is say, you're discriminating against me
- 14:25Speaker 5: and imposes a substantial burden and they get an exemption
- 14:29Speaker 5: unless the court can argue it passes strict scrutiny. And
- 14:32Speaker 5: you might think, well, this is an anti-discrimination law. Of
- 14:36Speaker 5: course it passes. What is a more compelling government interest
- 14:40Speaker 5: than any discrimination? against people based on things like race
- 14:45Speaker 5: and sex and sexual orientation. And you would not be
- 14:50Speaker 5: a member of the Supreme Court because they don't think
- 14:52Speaker 5: it's a compelling government interest to protect the LGBT community
- 14:56Speaker 5: from discrimination. Certainly not when on the other side is
- 15:00Speaker 5: a religious liberty claim by a conservative Christian. That's really
- 15:05Speaker 5: where her frustration is. It's like, we can't win these
- 15:08Speaker 5: cases because you're not following the existing doctrine. You're always
- 15:12Speaker 5: going to admit there's a substantial burden. And none of
- 15:15Speaker 5: these laws are going to pass strict scrutiny because you
- 15:18Speaker 5: do not care about the LGBT community.
- 15:22Speaker 3: Both Justice Sonia Sotomayor and Katonji Brown Jackson asked whether
- 15:27Speaker 3: the Catholic preschools could discriminate based on race then.
- 15:31Speaker 10: But the bottom line is that the religious entity does
- 15:34Speaker 10: not want to have to commit to discrimination. opening its
- 15:37Speaker 10: schools to students, children of LGBTQ couples. Couldn't that same
- 15:46Speaker 10: logic support a religious entity who says we don't want
- 15:49Speaker 10: to open our schools to students of races that we
- 15:53Speaker 10: disagree with or ethnicities that we disagree with? Why wouldn't
- 15:57Speaker 10: the same logic from the standpoint of the First Amendment
- 16:00Speaker 10: claim be the same?
- 16:02Speaker 5: Her argument is, listen, if they want to discriminate based
- 16:06Speaker 5: on race, they're going to get money. And they're like, no, no, no, no, no,
- 16:09Speaker 5: because we're not going to say that not ending discrimination
- 16:13Speaker 5: against racial minorities is compelling government interest. So that's how
- 16:16Speaker 5: they would distinguish it. But that does not acknowledge the
- 16:20Speaker 5: importance of and the centrality of anti-discrimination law in the
- 16:26Speaker 5: government's provision of education, especially when they're funding it. So
- 16:31Speaker 5: just to be clear, This is not a rule that
- 16:33Speaker 5: says Catholic schools can't discriminate. They can, right? The government
- 16:38Speaker 5: is not banning them from discriminating. The government is saying,
- 16:42Speaker 5: we're not going to give you our money to discriminate, right?
- 16:47Speaker 5: If you want our money, and if you want to
- 16:49Speaker 5: participate in our pre-K education program, you have to follow
- 16:54Speaker 5: our rules. And the court is like, not if you're
- 16:57Speaker 5: a religious school. If you're a religious school, we have
- 17:00Speaker 5: special rules, right? When I say special rules, I really
- 17:04Speaker 5: mean apart from the new doctrinal rule they create, which
- 17:08Speaker 5: is they claim that, well, if it's benefits, you go
- 17:11Speaker 5: directly to substantial burden, which is not at all what
- 17:14Speaker 5: the doctrine says. But the protection that religious organizations get
- 17:19Speaker 5: from religious discrimination, what they're seeking is very different than
- 17:24Speaker 5: the kind of protection the court currently offers against race
- 17:28Speaker 5: discrimination and sex discrimination. So again, if a law discriminates
- 17:34Speaker 5: against religion on its face, that law is not neutrally
- 17:38Speaker 5: and generally applicable. That gets subject to strict scrutiny. Same
- 17:41Speaker 5: thing with race. If you discriminate based on race on
- 17:43Speaker 5: the face of the statue and like in the language,
- 17:45Speaker 5: it says we are going to treat black people differently
- 17:48Speaker 5: than white people. That triggers strict scrutiny. But if the
- 17:51Speaker 5: law is neutral on its face. If a law doesn't
- 17:56Speaker 5: specifically mention race of people, but it has a really
- 18:01Speaker 5: disparate impact based on race. So, for example, if you
- 18:06Speaker 5: redistrict something so that you exclude all the black people
- 18:10Speaker 5: and none of the white people, but you don't mention
- 18:12Speaker 5: race anywhere in it, that is not going to be
- 18:15Speaker 5: considered discrimination anymore. Unless there is both a disparate impact
- 18:20Speaker 5: and a discriminatory intent, you have to show both under
- 18:23Speaker 5: equal protection law. And the rule that they're seeking is
- 18:28Speaker 5: that if you want to show discrimination with religion and
- 18:32Speaker 5: it's neutral on its face, you only have to show
- 18:35Speaker 5: that there's a disparate impact based on religion. You don't
- 18:38Speaker 5: need to show that there's discriminatory intent. So they're saying
- 18:44Speaker 5: it is discrimination just because there are more religious schools
- 18:48Speaker 5: than secular schools affected by this law. And that is
- 18:52Speaker 5: enough for it to be considered discrimination and trigger strict scrutiny. Again,
- 18:56Speaker 5: that is not the regime that we provide for race.
- 19:02Speaker 5: If you have a law that is neutral on its
- 19:05Speaker 5: face with regard to race and it has a racially
- 19:08Speaker 5: disparate impact, that is not considered discrimination. under existing equal
- 19:13Speaker 5: protection law. So basically, they want two levels of special treatment, right?
- 19:19Speaker 5: They want special treatment and they alone are allowed to
- 19:22Speaker 5: discriminate on the government's dime. But even more broadly, they
- 19:26Speaker 5: want to recognize disparate impact against religion as religious discrimination,
- 19:33Speaker 5: even when disparate impact on race is not recognized as
- 19:36Speaker 5: racial discrimination. They want special rules that for what counts
- 19:41Speaker 5: as discrimination for religion. They want to make it very
- 19:45Speaker 5: easy to say that there's religious discrimination while they've made
- 19:48Speaker 5: it very hard to say that there's racial discrimination. So
- 19:53Speaker 5: the level of privileging of religion is astounding if they're
- 19:59Speaker 5: actually going to rule in favor of the schools and
- 20:04Speaker 5: if they're going to adopt the rule that the schools
- 20:07Speaker 5: are seeking, which is If there's a substantial burden, we
- 20:11Speaker 5: get strict scrutiny.
- 20:12Speaker 3: But it still seems that at least five of the conservatives,
- 20:16Speaker 3: I'm excluding the Chief Justice because he seemed to have
- 20:19Speaker 3: some concerns about limits to this principle that the Catholic
- 20:23Speaker 3: schools are asserting. But at least five of the conservatives
- 20:28Speaker 3: appear ready to rule for the Catholic schools.
- 20:32Speaker 5: I mean, realistically speaking, If the conservative Christian wants it
- 20:37Speaker 5: and a conservative Christian is going to get it from
- 20:39Speaker 5: this court. I've said it before. I'm going to say
- 20:42Speaker 5: it again. If you are a conservative Christian and you
- 20:46Speaker 5: make a religious liberty claim before this Roberts court, you
- 20:50Speaker 5: are going to win. It almost doesn't matter what the
- 20:53Speaker 5: existing rule is. I mean, I'm telling you the existing
- 20:57Speaker 5: doctrine very clearly states that they don't have a claim.
- 21:03Speaker 5: This is not at all like the prior cases. One
- 21:06Speaker 5: more time, the prior cases explicitly excluded religious schools because
- 21:12Speaker 5: they were religious. Colorado is not explicitly excluding religious schools
- 21:19Speaker 5: because they're religious. They are welcoming religious schools. What they
- 21:23Speaker 5: are excluding are any schools, religious or secular, because they discriminate.
- 21:29Speaker 5: But the conservatives are like, you're still discriminating. because they're
- 21:33Speaker 5: still not going to get the money. And that is discrimination.
- 21:36Speaker 5: And that should trigger strict scrutiny. So just to be clear,
- 21:40Speaker 5: this is not a rule that says Catholic schools can't discriminate.
- 21:44Speaker 5: They can, right? The government is not banning them from discriminating.
- 21:49Speaker 5: The government is saying, we're not going to give you
- 21:52Speaker 5: our money to discriminate. If you want our money, and
- 21:56Speaker 5: if you want to participate in our pre-K education program,
- 22:00Speaker 5: you have to follow our rules. And the court is like,
- 22:03Speaker 5: not if you're a religious school. If you're a religious school,
- 22:06Speaker 5: we have special rules.
- 22:08Speaker 3: I'm going to have to do some research to see
- 22:10Speaker 3: the last time that a religious liberties case lost at
- 22:14Speaker 3: this Supreme Court. Thanks so much, Caroline. Always a pleasure.
- 22:18Speaker 3: That's Professor Caroline Malik-Corbin of the University of Miami Law School.
- 22:24Speaker 1: And I'm ashamed of certain members of the court. Absolutely ashamed.
- 22:29Speaker 1: for not having the courage to do what's right for
- 22:32Speaker 1: our country.
- 22:33Speaker 3: President Trump has not always been happy with the justices
- 22:36Speaker 3: he appointed to the Supreme Court, especially after losses in
- 22:41Speaker 3: the tariffs and birthright citizenship cases. This despite the fact
- 22:46Speaker 3: that the three justices he named have made up a
- 22:49Speaker 3: conservative supermajority that has overturned abortion rights, bolstered religious and
- 22:55Speaker 3: gun rights, and broadly shielded the president from criminal prosecution.
- 23:00Speaker 3: But now, with Democrats poised to take control of the
- 23:04Speaker 3: Senate on January 3rd, Trump has most likely appointed his
- 23:08Speaker 3: last Supreme Court justice. After all, Democrats watched as Republicans
- 23:14Speaker 3: used their power to remake the court, blocking President Obama's
- 23:18Speaker 3: nominee Merrick Garland in 2016 for 14 months until Trump
- 23:24Speaker 3: could put Justice Neil Gorsuch on the court. And then,
- 23:28Speaker 3: when Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died in 2020, Republicans rushed
- 23:33Speaker 3: to push through Justice Amy Coney Barrett, confirming her just
- 23:37Speaker 3: eight days before Trump lost the elections. And it doesn't
- 23:41Speaker 3: appear that the court's oldest and most conservative members, Justices
- 23:46Speaker 3: Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito, will take the highly unusual
- 23:50Speaker 3: step of retiring now in the middle of a term.
- 23:54Speaker 3: In fact, Justice Alito has said several times, including in
- 23:58Speaker 3: a CBS interview, that he's not retiring this term.
- 24:02Speaker 11: Well, it's something I think that somebody at my age
- 24:07Speaker 11: has to think about every term. But I thought that
- 24:11Speaker 11: I could still make a valuable contribution, which is why
- 24:15Speaker 11: I became a justice and a judge in the first place.
- 24:19Speaker 11: So that was basically it.
- 24:20Speaker 3: So the big question is, could the court actually be
- 24:24Speaker 3: moved from the far right back to the middle? Here
- 24:27Speaker 3: to answer that question and many others is Bloomberg Supreme
- 24:31Speaker 3: Court reporter Greg Storr. Greg, will there be more pressure
- 24:35Speaker 3: on Thomas and Alito to retire now so Perhaps a
- 24:39Speaker 3: successor can be pushed through during the lame duck session.
- 24:43Speaker 4: There absolutely will be pressure, but there are zero signs
- 24:47Speaker 4: so far that either of them is interested in doing that.
- 24:51Speaker 4: I had an interview with Justice Alito last month in
- 24:54Speaker 4: which I specifically asked him, if Democrats take over the Senate,
- 24:57Speaker 4: will you consider stepping down so that the lame duck
- 24:59Speaker 4: Republican controlled Senate can confirm your successor? And he said no.
- 25:04Speaker 4: Justice Thomas, people I've talked to who are close to
- 25:07Speaker 4: him say he has no interest in retiring right now.
- 25:10Speaker 4: And even if either of them did, there is no
- 25:13Speaker 4: guarantee that Trump at this political moment would be able
- 25:17Speaker 4: to get a successor through the Senate, even though it
- 25:20Speaker 4: will stay in Republican hands for another two months.
- 25:23Speaker 3: Although Senate Majority Leader John Thune said in July that
- 25:27Speaker 3: it could be done.
- 25:28Speaker 4: He did say that. And, you know, he was being
- 25:31Speaker 4: a good Republican by saying that. But, you know, we
- 25:34Speaker 4: have this moment where Democrats are going to, the voters
- 25:37Speaker 4: have said, we want Democrats to control Congress and it's
- 25:40Speaker 4: going to be a big Senate majority. And you have
- 25:43Speaker 4: a number of Republicans whose support, I'm not sure I
- 25:47Speaker 4: would take for granted if I were Donald Trump or
- 25:49Speaker 4: for that matter, Sam Alito or Clarence Thomas thinking about
- 25:53Speaker 4: You have folks like Susan Collins, who's on her way out,
- 25:57Speaker 4: having been defeated. Tom Tillis, who was sort of pushed
- 25:59Speaker 4: out by Donald Trump into retirement. Lisa Murkowski, who was
- 26:03Speaker 4: never a sure vote. And keep in mind that one
- 26:06Speaker 4: of those elections was a special election, Ohio elections. So
- 26:10Speaker 4: the Republican Senator John Husted is actually going to be
- 26:13Speaker 4: out of his seat on December 15th. So Republicans are
- 26:16Speaker 4: going to lose a vote at that moment. So to
- 26:19Speaker 4: the extent they have a majority now, it's not the
- 26:21Speaker 4: kind of majority where you can confidently say, oh, they
- 26:24Speaker 4: could absolutely confirm somebody before January 3rd.
- 26:27Speaker 3: Why would Republicans even want to push this? I mean,
- 26:30Speaker 3: they have this super majority right now. Isn't six enough?
- 26:35Speaker 4: Well, the question is extending that supermajority over time. So
- 26:39Speaker 4: Justice Alito is 76. Justice Thomas is 78. They're not
- 26:43Speaker 4: going to serve forever. And if one of them had retired, say,
- 26:48Speaker 4: after the last term and had a successor nominated and confirmed,
- 26:52Speaker 4: that person could have served another 25, 30 years, sort
- 26:57Speaker 4: of strengthening that Republican majority over time. Now you have
- 27:01Speaker 4: the prospect that if Democrats retain the Senate, say win
- 27:05Speaker 4: the White House in 2028. We're going to be wondering,
- 27:08Speaker 4: will the conservative justices be able to stick around until
- 27:12Speaker 4: there's another moment like this? Or are they going to
- 27:14Speaker 4: leave the court one way or the other with Democrats
- 27:17Speaker 4: able to confirm a successor and potentially shift the court
- 27:20Speaker 4: back towards the middle?
- 27:21Speaker 3: Are people viewing that as a real possibility, moving the
- 27:25Speaker 3: court back to the middle?
- 27:26Speaker 4: People are absolutely talking about it. It's hard not to
- 27:29Speaker 4: think about it just when you look at the political
- 27:32Speaker 4: realities that we discovered are out there in this election.
- 27:36Speaker 4: With a majority of potentially four seats, five seats, six seats,
- 27:40Speaker 4: Democrats have a really good chance of maintaining control of
- 27:43Speaker 4: the Senate after the 2028 election, regardless of who wins
- 27:46Speaker 4: the White House. And so if Democrats win the White
- 27:49Speaker 4: House in 2028, there is this moment where they will
- 27:52Speaker 4: have the potential to change the composition of the Supreme
- 27:56Speaker 4: Court very likely. You know, look, we saw with Justice
- 27:59Speaker 4: Scalia dying, Justice Ginsburg dying, that justices can't always control
- 28:04Speaker 4: when they have to leave the court. Go back a
- 28:06Speaker 4: little further in time and you'll find justices who had
- 28:09Speaker 4: to leave because they were very, very ill, not necessarily
- 28:12Speaker 4: at a time of their choosing. Those things happen. That's
- 28:15Speaker 4: just the actuarial reality of the situation. So Absolutely, people
- 28:20Speaker 4: on both sides are now confronting a world in which
- 28:23Speaker 4: this Republican supermajority or the conservative supermajority that we've imagined
- 28:27Speaker 4: might be there for a very, very long time now
- 28:30Speaker 4: might just be there for a few more years.
- 28:33Speaker 3: Explain how the conservative supermajority has made changes in the
- 28:37Speaker 3: law that have affected so many aspects of our society.
- 28:43Speaker 4: It's hard to overstate how important this conservative supermajority has been.
- 28:48Speaker 4: The most widely known decision, of course, was the Dobbs
- 28:51Speaker 4: abortion ruling overturning Roe v. Wade and the constitutional right
- 28:54Speaker 4: to abortion. But they have expanded gun rights. They have
- 28:58Speaker 4: expanded religious rights. They have backed Donald Trump's claims of
- 29:03Speaker 4: very broad presidential power and shielded the president to a
- 29:07Speaker 4: large degree from criminal prosecution for things that the president
- 29:11Speaker 4: does while in office. And the court has given every
- 29:14Speaker 4: sign that it wants to keep moving in that direction.
- 29:18Speaker 4: And this may be a moment where the court has
- 29:21Speaker 4: to take stock and say, where are we going with this?
- 29:24Speaker 3: I'm wondering how this huge blue wave might affect the justices' thinking.
- 29:31Speaker 3: For example, the conservative justices have given all this power
- 29:35Speaker 3: to a Republican president. What happens if a Democratic president
- 29:40Speaker 3: takes office? Backtracking?
- 29:42Speaker 4: That is a really good question, and it's really impossible
- 29:45Speaker 4: to answer at this point. Certainly, these are justices who
- 29:49Speaker 4: believe they are applying constitutional principles and not doing things
- 29:55Speaker 4: because they necessarily like the person in the White House
- 29:58Speaker 4: or necessarily like the policies. They are believers in, among
- 30:02Speaker 4: other things, a strong president and a strong executive branch
- 30:06Speaker 4: of the government. Those decisions necessarily could cut the other
- 30:11Speaker 4: way if a Democrat is in the White House. It
- 30:14Speaker 4: will be fascinating to see the extent to which we
- 30:18Speaker 4: can sense that they are sort of looking ahead to
- 30:21Speaker 4: what the practical effect of their decisions might be if
- 30:25Speaker 4: and when a Democrat does go in the White House.
- 30:27Speaker 4: You know, one thing they may be is a little
- 30:29Speaker 4: bit less aggressive in the cases they take up, the
- 30:32Speaker 4: issues they choose to resolve. They may ultimately come out
- 30:36Speaker 4: the same way on these questions, but they can slow
- 30:39Speaker 4: down the pace at which they're changing the law, recognizing
- 30:42Speaker 4: that the implications of that at this point seem pretty uncertain.
- 30:46Speaker 3: The Democrats are now going to control the House and
- 30:48Speaker 3: the Senate. A lot of these Democrats have talked about
- 30:51Speaker 3: reforming the court. Do you see a movement toward some
- 30:55Speaker 3: sort of reform on the court? Term limits seem the easiest.
- 30:58Speaker 4: Term limits are certainly easier than adding seats to the
- 31:01Speaker 4: Supreme Court. Undoubtedly, Democrats now have more votes to potentially
- 31:05Speaker 4: do that. There was already going to be more talk
- 31:08Speaker 4: of those sorts of structural changes on the Supreme Court
- 31:11Speaker 4: because Democrats were just vowing to make them more of
- 31:13Speaker 4: an issue. With that being said, If we end up
- 31:16Speaker 4: in a world where, let's say, Democrats do sweep the
- 31:20Speaker 4: 2028 elections and they end up getting a vacancy to
- 31:24Speaker 4: fill of a conservative justice and we see the court
- 31:28Speaker 4: swing back a bit to the left, that might take
- 31:31Speaker 4: some wind out of the sails of the movement to
- 31:35Speaker 4: have these big structural reforms, at least the notion of
- 31:39Speaker 4: adding seats to the Supreme Court. So I think we're
- 31:42Speaker 4: going to be talking about this a lot in the
- 31:44Speaker 4: next few years. Term limits, especially if they're done in
- 31:47Speaker 4: a way that doesn't kind of obviously make the court
- 31:50Speaker 4: less conservative, say if it's not going into effect for
- 31:53Speaker 4: some time down the road, that may still be more
- 31:57Speaker 4: doable because there is some agreement across the ideological divide
- 32:02Speaker 4: that that might actually be a better way of appointing
- 32:05Speaker 4: Supreme Court justices to limit the amount of time and
- 32:08Speaker 4: to guarantee that each president will get at least a
- 32:10Speaker 4: couple of vacancies to fill.
- 32:11Speaker 3: As far as expanding the court, I mean, FDR had
- 32:14Speaker 3: a court packing plan in 1937 that didn't go through.
- 32:20Speaker 3: Explain what would have to happen in order to put
- 32:23Speaker 3: more justices on the court.
- 32:25Speaker 4: That would take an act of Congress to do it.
- 32:27Speaker 4: Congress absolutely has the power to add seats to the
- 32:30Speaker 4: Supreme Court. It has done it a number of times.
- 32:33Speaker 4: It just so happens that those number of times were
- 32:36Speaker 4: back in the 1700s and 1800s. It's not something that
- 32:40Speaker 4: has happened in the modern day. But no question, Congress
- 32:43Speaker 4: could do that with the president's signature or overriding a veto.
- 32:47Speaker 4: It could do that on its own without a constitutional amendment.
- 32:50Speaker 3: By a simple majority?
- 32:51Speaker 4: Yes, it could do that by a simple majority.
- 32:53Speaker 3: And before I let you go, Greg, what's the next
- 32:56Speaker 3: big case coming up at the Supreme Court?
- 32:59Speaker 4: June, a very big case that people are going to
- 33:02Speaker 4: be watching closely is coming up in December when the
- 33:04Speaker 4: court hears the case over the challenges to state bans
- 33:08Speaker 4: on so-called assault weapons. There's a case out of Illinois
- 33:11Speaker 4: and a case out of Connecticut, which, of course, is
- 33:13Speaker 4: the place where the horrific Sandy Hook shooting took place.
- 33:17Speaker 4: This is a court that has fairly consistently bolstered gun rights.
- 33:21Speaker 4: And so this could be a significant change in the
- 33:24Speaker 4: law if they say that states, including Connecticut, cannot ban
- 33:27Speaker 4: assault weapons.
- 33:28Speaker 3: It's always great to talk to you, Greg. Thanks so much.
- 33:31Speaker 3: That's Bloomberg Supreme Court reporter Greg Storr. I'm June Grosso,
- 33:36Speaker 3: and you're listening to Bloomberg. It would have been the
- 33:41Speaker 3: biggest supermarket chain merger ever. Now it could turn out
- 33:46Speaker 3: to be a very expensive breakup. Kroger's $ 24. 6 billion deal
- 33:51Speaker 3: to buy Albertsons was blocked by a federal court in
- 33:55Speaker 3: December of 2024. The judge sided with the FTC that
- 34:00Speaker 3: said combining more than 4,000 stores would leave the grocery
- 34:05Speaker 3: giants with too much market power. And now they're back
- 34:08Speaker 3: in court, this time against each other. Albertsons wants to
- 34:13Speaker 3: get not only the $ 600 million termination fee, but also
- 34:18Speaker 3: more than $ 8 billion in damages, claiming Kroger knowingly breached
- 34:23Speaker 3: their merger agreement. The 10-day trial ended last week but
- 34:27Speaker 3: a decision isn't likely anytime soon. There'll be post-trial briefings
- 34:33Speaker 3: and post-trial arguments before the judge makes a decision in
- 34:37Speaker 3: the case. Joining me is antitrust expert Harry First, a
- 34:41Speaker 3: professor at NYU Law School. Harry, tell us about the
- 34:44Speaker 3: deal that failed.
- 34:46Speaker 1: My view is, what were they thinking for this whole thing?
- 34:49Speaker 1: What were they thinking? So, This was announced in 2022
- 34:53Speaker 1: and done in 2024 in litigation. Litigation both in federal
- 34:59Speaker 1: court and in state court. Very unusual litigation for state court,
- 35:02Speaker 1: another matter. So two years they spent on this case
- 35:06Speaker 1: and then in litigation. Huge merger. First and second largest
- 35:10Speaker 1: supermarket chains in the United States, $ 24 billion merger. But
- 35:15Speaker 1: if you put Walmart in, and Costco is one of
- 35:18Speaker 1: the market definitions, it's still the second and fourth largest
- 35:22Speaker 1: chain of supermarkets, of food sellers in the United States.
- 35:26Speaker 1: So this is huge. 5,000 stores, 4,000 pharmacies, 710,000 store associates.
- 35:30Speaker 1: A huge merger. And they propose this to an administration
- 35:39Speaker 1: that has merger guidelines, that has lowered the thresholds for
- 35:43Speaker 1: concentration and mergers, more aggressive on mergers, that has taken
- 35:48Speaker 1: a position saying, you know, the days of making deals
- 35:51Speaker 1: first are out. You know, we're not really in favor
- 35:54Speaker 1: of taking deals. We want to slow down the merger wave.
- 35:59Speaker 1: And that means we're going to litigate more.
- 36:01Speaker 6: Right.
- 36:02Speaker 1: And then you come along. with a merger of huge proportions.
- 36:06Speaker 1: And in what industry?
- 36:08Speaker 6: Food.
- 36:09Speaker 1: Now, this is at a time when prices were going up.
- 36:13Speaker 1: Prices of food. It's like the core. And you say, okay,
- 36:17Speaker 1: we'd like to merge. What happens in a merger? What's
- 36:20Speaker 1: the theory of mergers? You get two competitors together. What
- 36:23Speaker 1: do they do? They raise prices. So, you know, what
- 36:27Speaker 1: are they thinking? They really think this is going to
- 36:30Speaker 1: go through? And put aside even the federal government, the
- 36:34Speaker 1: states are up at arms. So you have Washington state,
- 36:38Speaker 1: you have Colorado suing in state court. Never happened to
- 36:43Speaker 1: stop this merger. My question was, why did it take
- 36:45Speaker 1: the FTC so long to oppose it? What was the
- 36:47Speaker 1: possible case for it? So, you know, in Kroger's brief,
- 36:52Speaker 1: they wrote, but there was nothing they could have done
- 36:56Speaker 1: to have made a difference to settle the case. Really?
- 36:59Speaker 1: And they wrote regulators, including the FTC under Lina Khan,
- 37:03Speaker 1: were entrenched in a fundamentally different view of the product
- 37:07Speaker 1: market that excluded Amazon, Costco and others. In other words,
- 37:11Speaker 1: lawyers for Kroger, they're now being sued, are saying Albertson
- 37:14Speaker 1: said we didn't make our best efforts to settle this
- 37:17Speaker 1: case and not have litigation, which we lost. There was
- 37:21Speaker 1: nothing we could have done.
- 37:22Speaker 6: Seriously?
- 37:23Speaker 1: Who went into the merger and spent a billion dollars,
- 37:27Speaker 1: they say, on a merger that they said there was
- 37:29Speaker 1: nothing we could have done? And then the testimony in
- 37:34Speaker 1: court from Kroger's, I think he's still the current CEO,
- 37:38Speaker 1: that the merger was doomed from the start because of
- 37:42Speaker 1: Lina Khan, the chair of the FTC's hostility to making deals. Well,
- 37:48Speaker 1: you know, it wasn't like this was a secret deal.
- 37:50Speaker 1: It wasn't, you know, she wrote it in lemon juice
- 37:53Speaker 1: and it disappeared. Everybody knew it. Everybody knew it.
- 37:58Speaker 3: And despite all that, it didn't take Albertsons long to
- 38:01Speaker 3: sue Kroger's.
- 38:03Speaker 1: The day after federal judge and the state judge in
- 38:07Speaker 1: Washington say the merger is illegal, the day after Albertsons
- 38:11Speaker 1: files suit in court in Delaware, Chancery Court in Delaware,
- 38:15Speaker 1: which has jurisdiction over corporate matters, files suit against Kroger.
- 38:20Speaker 1: for the failure of the deal, a deal which, you know,
- 38:24Speaker 1: could it have possibly happened? I don't see how, but
- 38:27Speaker 1: they're suing now saying that Kroger didn't make its best
- 38:30Speaker 1: efforts to come up with some divestiture of stores that
- 38:35Speaker 1: would have satisfied both the federal government and the state government.
- 38:40Speaker 1: And they asked for roughly, I guess, a little more
- 38:42Speaker 1: than $ 9 billion in damages on a $ 24 billion merger.
- 38:47Speaker 1: So that's what they're in court fighting about, whether Kroger
- 38:50Speaker 1: made best efforts. And Kroger is saying to counter that,
- 38:54Speaker 1: not only did we make our best efforts, you know,
- 38:56Speaker 1: you helped to scuttle the deal. So we don't owe
- 38:59Speaker 1: you this reverse breakup fee of $ 600 million. So we
- 39:03Speaker 1: don't owe you anything.
- 39:05Speaker 3: Isn't spending a billion dollars pursuing a deal, isn't that
- 39:08Speaker 3: good faith enough?
- 39:09Speaker 4: No.
- 39:09Speaker 1: You might say that's a good marker. You know, the
- 39:12Speaker 1: specifics of who negotiated what, when. I mean, the deal
- 39:17Speaker 1: itself that was on the table, which the district court
- 39:20Speaker 1: judge eventually said was not adequate relief. And what the
- 39:24Speaker 1: FTC didn't accept, which was divestiture to CNS, which runs
- 39:29Speaker 1: Piggly Wiggly. So yes, you might think a marker of
- 39:32Speaker 1: good faith is we spent a lot of money on this,
- 39:35Speaker 1: a billion dollars, they say. Whether true or not, I
- 39:37Speaker 1: have no idea. But they certainly spent a lot of
- 39:40Speaker 1: money on it, as did Albertson spend a lot of
- 39:42Speaker 1: money on it, I assume, because they had antitrust counsel
- 39:45Speaker 1: as well looking at this before they signed the deal.
- 39:49Speaker 1: So yes, you might say that shows good faith. Or
- 39:53Speaker 1: on the other hand, you might say that shareholders ought
- 39:55Speaker 1: to be suing them for wasting a billion dollars on
- 39:59Speaker 1: this litigation and that that was a waste of assets
- 40:03Speaker 1: and that they're subject to a shareholder's derivative suit. I'm
- 40:06Speaker 1: waiting for that one.
- 40:07Speaker 3: The former CEO of Kroger's testified that Kroger relied on
- 40:12Speaker 3: the advice of antitrust counsel to come up with the
- 40:15Speaker 3: stores and assets that were to be sold.
- 40:18Speaker 1: Seriously? Seriously?
- 40:21Speaker 3: I'm not saying it, Harry.
- 40:22Speaker 7: They're saying it.
- 40:23Speaker 1: You're the CEO of Kroger and you're turning over this
- 40:26Speaker 1: huge $ 24 billion deal saying, I don't have anything to
- 40:30Speaker 1: do with it. It's up to you guys, lawyers who
- 40:33Speaker 1: don't know business. The lawyers don't drive this ship. The
- 40:38Speaker 1: CEO does. I mean, the CEO knows the business. The
- 40:43Speaker 1: CEO comes in and makes the pitch. The enforcers don't
- 40:47Speaker 1: want to hear from the lawyers. They know what the
- 40:49Speaker 1: lawyers are going to say. We draw little circles around
- 40:52Speaker 1: each store. It's the overlaps, and that's what we do.
- 40:55Speaker 1: The CEO comes in and says, we're going to divest
- 40:58Speaker 1: enough stores to make a chain that will be a
- 41:00Speaker 1: viable competitor, and let me show you how. Let me
- 41:03Speaker 1: talk to you about the business and why we need
- 41:05Speaker 1: to do this. That's what CEOs do. It's hard for
- 41:09Speaker 1: me to believe the Kroger guy. I mean, that's count
- 41:12Speaker 1: two in the shareholder suit. Really? He left it up
- 41:15Speaker 1: to the lawyer. I'm not the judge. I'm not judging
- 41:17Speaker 1: his credibility. Maybe that's in fact what happened. But again,
- 41:21Speaker 1: if that's what happened, what was he thinking? Frankly, I
- 41:24Speaker 1: can't imagine the lawyers taking this strategically. What the lawyer
- 41:30Speaker 1: wants to do is to bring in the business people
- 41:33Speaker 1: to make the case that this is a good business
- 41:37Speaker 1: deal that will serve consumers. Lawyers can't make this pitch
- 41:41Speaker 1: as well as the business people. And frankly, the enforcers
- 41:45Speaker 1: don't really want to hear, as I said, from the lawyers.
- 41:47Speaker 1: They want to hear from the business people. So maybe
- 41:50Speaker 1: this is a case of saying, not me, I was
- 41:53Speaker 1: the guy.
- 41:54Speaker 3: So the last public fight, big public fight over a
- 41:57Speaker 3: deal that collapsed for antitrust reasons was the $ 48 billion
- 42:02Speaker 3: merger of Cigna and Anthem. And there the Chancery judge
- 42:06Speaker 3: concluded Cigna had breached the merger but refused to award
- 42:10Speaker 3: billions of dollars in damages because the deal was likely
- 42:13Speaker 3: to have been blocked for antitrust reasons anyway. That sounds
- 42:17Speaker 3: an awful lot like this case.
- 42:19Speaker 1: Yeah. Well, I mean, if the argument is you didn't
- 42:22Speaker 1: make best efforts to settle the case, you know, and
- 42:24Speaker 1: you write in your papers and you say in your
- 42:26Speaker 1: testimony this case was unsettlable, I don't know what best
- 42:29Speaker 1: efforts anybody should have expected. in a way, you'd have
- 42:33Speaker 1: to say, well, they threw the litigation. And that's patently
- 42:36Speaker 1: not true. Case was heavily litigated with experts. And, you know,
- 42:40Speaker 1: they didn't just say, hi, judge, we should win and
- 42:44Speaker 1: sit down. There was good faith litigation. So you have
- 42:47Speaker 1: to find something in sort of the entrails of the
- 42:50Speaker 1: way they negotiated that had they done something different, something
- 42:54Speaker 1: else might have happened. And you're right. I think that's
- 42:57Speaker 1: probably another difficulty of even if they had negotiated in
- 43:02Speaker 1: a different way, would it have made a difference? And
- 43:06Speaker 1: if it wouldn't have made a difference, what is Albertsons
- 43:09Speaker 1: exactly complaining about? They didn't do something which didn't harm them.
- 43:14Speaker 3: So the termination fee is obviously set in case the
- 43:19Speaker 3: deal falls through. But does it often happen that the
- 43:22Speaker 3: parties then end up in court fighting over whether the
- 43:25Speaker 3: termination fee should be paid or not?
- 43:28Speaker 1: I mean, my guess is that Albertson's litigation then sparked
- 43:33Speaker 1: resistance from Kroger for paying the termination fee at all
- 43:37Speaker 1: and looking for a reason for why they didn't know
- 43:41Speaker 1: the termination fee. Now, I don't know how that clause
- 43:44Speaker 1: is written in the contract and what obligations Albertson had.
- 43:48Speaker 1: So you certainly wouldn't want to write in a termination
- 43:51Speaker 1: fee that would allow one party to sabotage the deal
- 43:55Speaker 1: so it could get the $ 600 million. No, certainly parties
- 43:59Speaker 1: can object to that and maybe they can always settle
- 44:03Speaker 1: it too for some reduced amount of determination fee. But
- 44:06Speaker 1: what I'm reminded of, and maybe this in part is
- 44:09Speaker 1: the model driving Albertsons, AT & T T-Mobile merger, which
- 44:15Speaker 1: ultimately failed. And the breakup fee was $ 4 billion, which
- 44:22Speaker 1: AT & T had to pay to Deutsche Telekom. That
- 44:25Speaker 1: allowed Deutsche Telekom to revive Sprint as a competitor. It
- 44:30Speaker 1: was a $ 3 billion termination fee, and then there was
- 44:33Speaker 1: some additional wireless spectrum thing. So over this failure, Deutsche
- 44:38Speaker 1: Telekom ended up reviving Sprint and then went on to
- 44:42Speaker 1: become a more successful competitor. So sometimes these fees can
- 44:47Speaker 1: turn out to have good implications for competition, but no guarantee.
- 44:53Speaker 1: So maybe Albertsons is looking for a little cash infusion.
- 44:56Speaker 1: So maybe they'll end up being a better competitor. Actually,
- 44:59Speaker 1: one other thing, Kroger is trying to acquire Giant Eagle,
- 45:05Speaker 1: another supermarket chain for $ 1. 7 billion. So that was announced
- 45:10Speaker 1: in July. I haven't seen anything further, a much smaller
- 45:15Speaker 1: merger than Kroger Albertsons, but a different FTC.
- 45:21Speaker 3: Very different.
- 45:22Speaker 1: Um, Still, maybe not one that's highly disposed to just
- 45:27Speaker 1: simply allowing grocery store mergers at a time of high
- 45:30Speaker 1: food price. So we'll see.
- 45:32Speaker 3: And we'll see what happens in this case, but probably
- 45:35Speaker 3: not until next year. There'll be post-trial briefings and post-trial
- 45:40Speaker 3: arguments in a few months, and then the judge will
- 45:44Speaker 3: make her decision. I'm sure we'll talk then, Harry. Thanks
- 45:47Speaker 3: so much. That's Professor Harry First of NYU Law School.
- 45:52Speaker 3: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember,
- 45:55Speaker 3: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 45:57Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 46:02Speaker 3: and at www.bloomberg.com slash podcast slash law. And remember to
- 46:08Speaker 3: tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at 10 p.m.
- 46:11Speaker 3: Wall Street time. I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg.