Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP268: Unified Commerce: What Does It Really Mean? Unpicking The Latest Ecommerce Buzzword To Focus On What Matters To Ecommerce Businesses
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast track to digital knowledge
- 0:10feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry Thoughtleys and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital. Strategy, customer experience,
- 0:19and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the. Latest episode.
- 0:35Thanks for tuning in to the Inside Commerce podcast
- 0:38sponsored by Centra and Graben more about them later.
- 0:42So let's do our little scene setting today.
- 0:44Myself and Paul are going to be talking about a topic that is
- 0:48being hammered around the industry, unified commerce.
- 0:50And what we want to do is pull it apart.
- 0:52And like the the myth, the mystery of unified commerce.
- 0:54Is this something new? Is this just the emperor's new
- 0:57clothes? And to cut Long story short,
- 1:00yes. So the latter we think it is.
- 1:03So the way that unified commerce has been positioned and there's
- 1:08a there's one definition that I'm going to pull out, which is
- 1:11unified commerce is a practice connecting your back end
- 1:14systems, your customer facing channels via single platform.
- 1:17It's a set up companies requiring order to support Omni
- 1:19channel journeys and create a unified view of shopper
- 1:21interactions, products and management system.
- 1:24This for me, and that's from big commerce, I think is actually
- 1:27one of the best better descriptions of what this is
- 1:29meant to be. And that is that it's not about
- 1:32trying to replace everything into a standardised vendor
- 1:35because e-commerce doesn't exist in the silo.
- 1:39It exists. Businesses that have retail,
- 1:41that have B2B trade, you name it.
- 1:44And actually you cannot for most businesses of that that size and
- 1:47complexity just find one platform that does absolutely
- 1:49everything. But trying to consolidate front
- 1:52end experience into the same ecosystem technologies makes
- 1:57perfect sense. And then also trying to unify
- 2:00data to create a unified view of data, to provide people with the
- 2:06the views of data they need across the business.
- 2:08And standardising technology around that, where previously
- 2:11different parts of business would invest in different data
- 2:13tools is a really sensible thing.
- 2:15However, where we're coming at it from is that actually this
- 2:18isn't new. And a lot of people are saying
- 2:21that unified is different Omni channel.
- 2:23I'm going to politely disagree because Omni channel was always
- 2:26the evolution from multi channel.
- 2:28Multi channel, which is just we can sell in different channels.
- 2:31Omni channel was putting the customer thinking at the centre
- 2:34of that and looking at aligning the channels so that you had
- 2:37greater synergy between customer service, customer experience,
- 2:41data, technology and and one example would be like returns in
- 2:46a, in a multi channel world. If you bought online and tried
- 2:50to take it to a store to return, it wouldn't work because the
- 2:52systems weren't joined up. The store had no idea about what
- 2:55that order was and couldn't process it.
- 2:57In the Omni channel world and retailers like has the phrase of
- 3:00doing this since 2015, actually, you buy online, you take it into
- 3:03store that that order can be scanned, they can recognise it,
- 3:07they can process it, they can take it back, they can offer you
- 3:10exchange credit, whatever it might be.
- 3:12That is an Omni channel service. And that's what I think a lot of
- 3:16people are trying to package Unified as as being different,
- 3:19but it's not. So there's my there's my opening
- 3:21gambit. Paul, what what's yours in terms
- 3:23of what unified is being positioned as and what you see
- 3:26it being? Yeah.
- 3:27So I think you've definitely got a lot more knowledge on what's
- 3:30actually behind these terms that I do.
- 3:32So I think I've looked, I, I mean, my exposure to unified
- 3:36commerce has been at events and it's typically been different
- 3:38vendors talking about how they consider them or like the role
- 3:42they consider themselves to play in unified commerce.
- 3:45And I hadn't really, to be honest, considered the like the
- 3:49definition is around 1 platform. Because and as we were talking
- 3:53about before we started this, like I think if someone said to
- 3:56me, what are the best examples of unified commerce or Omni
- 4:00channel or whatever else, I would be talking about, you
- 4:02know, Rafa and you know, other brands that just have very
- 4:06connected experiences across the native app, loyalty, retail,
- 4:11web, physical events, whatever else.
- 4:14And I think I would have said, you know, it's a great example,
- 4:17unified commerce. But actually, yeah, I think the
- 4:19actual definition is probably slightly different to what I
- 4:21thought it was. But I think my view on it is
- 4:24that I think it's got so broad now that I just think it's, it's
- 4:27the same as e-commerce, you know, it's just good commerce,
- 4:30good commerce strategy. I always felt like Omni channel
- 4:33was kind of needed when it first came about, or maybe not Omni
- 4:36channel, maybe more multi channel, but I think they were
- 4:38needed at the time because that was when people were starting to
- 4:43look more connecting retail and web in particular.
- 4:47And I felt like, you know, people, they, it just kind of
- 4:50helped the industry to invest in that.
- 4:53And there's a lot of content around it.
- 4:54It kind of needed terminology, whereas I feel like unified come
- 4:58as yeah, it just feels really broad and to me it doesn't feel
- 5:01like it's it's needed. Grebin create digital flagship
- 5:04stores for iconic brands of today and tomorrow.
- 5:07We are the number one Sentra agency in the world with more
- 5:10than 50 Centra implementations to date.
- 5:13We are also e-commerce design specialists, platform and tech
- 5:16partner agnostic. Try our new e-commerce design
- 5:19subscription. Visit greben.com.
- 5:22Yeah. And I, I think hearing lies the,
- 5:23the issue because there are the definition that I'm taking is
- 5:26from, from things that I've read, but there are, there are
- 5:28different definitions, people are using it to mean different
- 5:31things. And, and hearing lies one of the
- 5:33inherent problems within our industry.
- 5:34And I love being part of this industry because there's a lot
- 5:36of amazing people, but there is a lot of jargon.
- 5:39And often this comes from a, a genuine place of trying to
- 5:43provoke discussion and create connections and you know, and
- 5:46therefore drive leads from a marketing and sales point of
- 5:48view. But I think often it, it, it
- 5:51kind of like obscures things for, for the recipients of it,
- 5:55like the people working in brands and retailers who are
- 5:57trying to make strategic decisions about what is it that
- 6:00they need to be thinking and focusing on and what is a
- 6:03distraction. And I, I just, for me, this is a
- 6:06repackaging of what I'm, I mean, Omni channel was always meant to
- 6:08mean. And it's articulating one of
- 6:11those key strategic goals of an Omni channel strategy, which is
- 6:13consolidation. And that's not just tech, it's
- 6:16process, it's customer experience, it's data, it's
- 6:19standardisation of technology. And that has always been there.
- 6:23And I think that's what we want to do in this is, is dispel the
- 6:26myth about is unified something new?
- 6:28Is this a new trend? No.
- 6:31Is it valid? Fundamentally, yes, because it's
- 6:33telling us that we need to simplify how we operate and how
- 6:37we interact with customers and the technologies and processes
- 6:40that enable that. But I think maybe maybe let's
- 6:44move on to a cup what we're seeing, how we're seeing people
- 6:47evolve strategically in this area.
- 6:50And I guess I'll start with one bit and I know that you were
- 6:54great things. We work with different types of
- 6:55businesses, so we get to see different things, which is why
- 6:58we will share a lot of information.
- 6:59But one of the areas I've seen the biggest consolidation in and
- 7:03this is working with either from from big department stores down
- 7:07to like you know, small 1,000,000 lbs E com retailer
- 7:11single channel is the common. The commonality is no matter
- 7:16which business there is this, there are disparate systems and
- 7:20there are disparate data flows. The people don't have a joined
- 7:23up view of data, whether that's analytic state and BI data or
- 7:27whether it's financial data. Coming in for a team to do like
- 7:31month end accounts for and conciliation processes and
- 7:34trying to connect disparate systems is complex, time
- 7:38consuming and often fool's gold from most small business.
- 7:42They can't afford to do it. I don't have the resource.
- 7:44So people are using more modern integration layers now to be
- 7:49able to take data flows from multiple places, do
- 7:52transformation in that middleware, whether that is a
- 7:54patch works, it's a custom one that an agency's built.
- 7:57It's a high occasion. You know, you pick your, you
- 7:59pick your middleware going up to the higher end, then you've and
- 8:03you're going to like marks like US and you've got different
- 8:05players coming in as well. But it's doing that piece there.
- 8:09So that actually all the end points that need data in the
- 8:12right formats have got it and you've got that for me is the
- 8:16unification piece. You you are.
- 8:19You're unifying without having to consolidate into a single
- 8:21system or do lots of extension work in each system.
- 8:27Yeah. I think I, yeah, I think I agree
- 8:29with that. I think when, when we were
- 8:30talking before, I think we both said like I think data is at the
- 8:33heart of unification. And I think the only other thing
- 8:36I would add to that is on the front end, I think it's, you
- 8:39know, being orientated around identifying a customer and being
- 8:45able to collect data around that customer.
- 8:49I think one of the big trends that I've seen across our
- 8:51clients has been like account first strategy.
- 8:53So trying to get a higher proportion of users, I've been
- 8:56trying to, you know, get people building accounts, collecting
- 8:59more first party data as part of that process and like
- 9:01incentivizing that. And then being able to use that
- 9:05as part of what I would consider an Omni channel strategy or what
- 9:08I would say. But I guess it's the same thing.
- 9:10And then as you say, it's like it's investing in the resources
- 9:14and the tooling to then, yeah, pass the data that's needed
- 9:18around different systems to be able to like, yeah, understand
- 9:22as much as possible, create the best experience and just
- 9:26generally kind of connect those touch points.
- 9:29So yeah, I would completely agree.
- 9:31And, and to be honest, you know, the, whatever you call it, I, I,
- 9:34I always say to, to, to Clos away.
- 9:36It doesn't matter what you call it, call it only channel, multi
- 9:38channel unified. I mean, it's wording, it's
- 9:41semantics. The key point is the strategic
- 9:43aim and the process to get there and what the end goals and
- 9:46outcomes and success criteria are going to be.
- 9:48And, and if I take a couple of small businesses I've worked
- 9:50with over the last few years who've gone to a Shopify big
- 9:53commerce, so they've gone SAS from like legacy.
- 9:57Often it's open source like a woo commerce or a Magento.
- 10:02They they don't have the funds or the resources to then buy
- 10:07into like a a fully integrated ecosystem where they've got the
- 10:11best in class tool. And what they actually need to
- 10:12do is, is use the systems they've currently got at the
- 10:17moment, but give them better data and more accurate and
- 10:19reliable data so that they can do better financial reporting
- 10:22and reconciliation, for example. And that's tick great.
- 10:25We're on the journey And then in the future when they reach the
- 10:29right size in income and therefore investment capability,
- 10:33then you probably look at enhancing richer systems on top
- 10:37of that, whether that's like data warehousing, proper BI,
- 10:39etcetera. So I think I think a lot of this
- 10:42is about an evolution rather than a revolution.
- 10:45Piece Centre is the only. Commerce platform built
- 10:48exclusively. For fashion brands, over 300
- 10:50fashion brands run on Centre, including icons like Paul Smith,
- 10:53Jeff Ave. and Nudie Jeans. Centre solves business logic
- 10:55challenges for fashion brands. I know of the platform and they
- 10:58are on a mission to help you scale up rapidly globally across
- 11:01all online and offline channels. Take your fashion brand global.
- 11:04Faster, further, stronger today. Yeah.
- 11:07Again, I completely agree. Yeah, I think the only other
- 11:10thing I would say though, I do think because I think a lot of
- 11:14people see that the connectivity is the key to this.
- 11:18And like there's usually a lot of like goals within a business
- 11:21of achieving certain things and it, you know, the big investment
- 11:25or like the material piece of work is the integration.
- 11:28I have seen businesses just to be sold like Mule Soft as a
- 11:32solution and you know, they go and invest hundreds of thousands
- 11:35of pounds into, you know, something that ties together
- 11:39these systems. And it's not just Mule Soft, you
- 11:41know, Dell Boomi or whatever else like all these like
- 11:43enterprise like I passes or integration platforms and has
- 11:49not the like it's a bigger, it's a bigger project in most cases.
- 11:52And just bringing in the software and you know, people is
- 11:55probably a bigger thing than the software.
- 11:56And yeah, see anything out of that?
- 11:58Yeah, that's a really good point.
- 11:59And also needing to understand any limitations that these,
- 12:04these enterprise systems have in terms of like their, their
- 12:07throughputs, their, their like concurrency, like how much can
- 12:10go through that platform at once and what impact that has to you
- 12:13if you're, when you're in peak. I've seen people who've, who've
- 12:16had setups where actually it's really restraining the speed at
- 12:19which data is thrown through those is not the speed they'd
- 12:22need to execute on their business strategy.
- 12:25And you've got really flexible modern technology now you've
- 12:28yeah, you've got the likes of Air Table.
- 12:31And I know that like Ollie Rhodes is running know that apps
- 12:33is working with, with some of the brands that you work with
- 12:36from a consultancy point of view, like current body, for
- 12:41example, where actually, instead of having to go, right, let's
- 12:44let's buy another big vendor. Well, we'll use a more agile
- 12:48modern tooling and we'll use an API based tool where we can just
- 12:51take two or three T functions and connect it and make it work
- 12:55and do our transformation. And there we go.
- 12:57And that's fixed the gaps that we have.
- 12:58So we are that. I think that's The thing is that
- 13:01it doesn't have to be all or nothing to be unified.
- 13:06Yeah, completely agree. I don't know why that just from
- 13:08I was just thinking about current body and them being kind
- 13:11of almost single channel. And that kind of just made me
- 13:13think about one thing that I personally feel is maybe because
- 13:18I feel like this whole unified piece has come from Gartner or
- 13:22one or the other, like analysts, organisations, whatever you call
- 13:27it. And then a lot of the platforms
- 13:29have responded to it. And I feel like the difference
- 13:31with unified is there's more of a consideration around B to B
- 13:34and wholesale. Maybe at least I look at it
- 13:37more. So I typically you would see if
- 13:39you were looking at a diagram or like some kind of marketing
- 13:41material, B to B and wholesale would be a part of it.
- 13:45Whereas I feel Omni channel is not as it's not as broad.
- 13:50I don't know if you agree with that or whether that's just my
- 13:52perception. I, I just, I find, I find the
- 13:56semantics around it is what confuses people because at the
- 14:01end of the day, the, the, the goal is you want consolidation,
- 14:06you want effective processes and you want to be able to execute
- 14:09channel strategies how you want to not be constrained by techno
- 14:12technology, process people, etcetera.
- 14:14And I actually, it doesn't bother me what term people use.
- 14:18The reason for doing this podcast is a bit provocative,
- 14:21but also to bit of clarification on what we think and what we see
- 14:25in other people doing. So I don't, I don't think it
- 14:27really matters. I've worked with B to B
- 14:29companies and the the two that I worked with most recently in the
- 14:33last couple of years on RE platform and none of them are
- 14:35talking about unified, unified commerce.
- 14:37Maybe maybe they're the type of business, you know, I'm not
- 14:41working with a massive global like B to B or more complex B to
- 14:45B like manufacturing, for example.
- 14:47Maybe the discourse around it varies outside of the the
- 14:51ecosystem in which I operate, but the people I'm talking about
- 14:55are I'm talking to and working with.
- 14:58Coming back to your origin point, they want better data
- 15:01because they've got loads of data over and it's not joined up
- 15:05and therefore they can't make effective decisions.
- 15:07They can't they can't analyse customer behaviour.
- 15:09They can't segment accurately because they because they've got
- 15:13their data in different places and they want simplified and
- 15:17consistent tooling across channels.
- 15:19So if they've got a a trade store and BTC store, they want
- 15:24to be able to run it from ACMS point of view, for example, the
- 15:26same, even though the execution is different.
- 15:28They want to have a, you know, a sing if they have in a promotion
- 15:33engine, they would want a single engine that can handle B to B&B
- 15:35to C promotions rather than having two different vendors
- 15:38doing it. So I'm, I'm seeing it, I'm not
- 15:41seeing people that I work with in B2B seen unified as something
- 15:45different or really using that that terminology.
- 15:50No, I think it's just something that I'd recognise from a
- 15:52marketing perspective that I think Omni is actually very
- 15:55multi channel orientated, like more like direct consumer versus
- 16:00I wonder whether that's a part of the real definition of
- 16:04unified. Yeah.
- 16:06And and I guess the fact that that we're not 100% sure of it
- 16:09tells you that, that this is, can be really confusing and
- 16:12misleading, which this is on my habit terminology.
- 16:16We've had this discussion about headless so many times before
- 16:18and I headless for me is it, it creates so much noise and that
- 16:22headless is an architectural solution to a business need.
- 16:24It's not a business goal. And I think this was unified is,
- 16:28is the, the, the, the strategic aim to offer to simplify
- 16:33technology so you have fewer vendors to deal with, fewer
- 16:35licenses, greater cost efficiencies because you can use
- 16:39them at scale across, you know, more channels.
- 16:42Good example being like if you're using Shopify for, for
- 16:46online and retail and using the POS because the POS is fit for
- 16:48purpose for what your business needs.
- 16:50I, I think those, those are the goals that people need rather
- 16:53than going right. We want to be unified because I
- 16:55don't think it means anything. Yeah, I think I'm just a grumpy
- 16:59old econ bastard who just hates terminology.
- 17:02Now I think let's talk about other areas where we're seeing
- 17:05people making this move strategically to to what what,
- 17:09you know, unified should mean. And what I've always thought on
- 17:11the and payments is 1 area. I think it's really interesting.
- 17:15So, and I know you will have worked with a lot of businesses
- 17:18like this as well where they will have, so they might have a
- 17:22different payment while they're set up in like connected to the
- 17:25ERP that's doing offline sales to trade or is being used in
- 17:29stores. Even like B2B businesses who do
- 17:32loads of Rd. shows and events where they're using it connected
- 17:35to remote terminals. And then Ecom's got its own
- 17:38gateway and they might have ecom and Shopify payments or they
- 17:41might have a Magento connected to agent and you pick your
- 17:44payment provider. But that makes things much more
- 17:47challenging for finance for handling reconciliation because
- 17:52you've got to reconcile against different systems, different
- 17:54reports, and then you've got different contracts, different
- 17:59payment rates, which is always fun.
- 18:02And I'm seeing more people looking not not necessarily out
- 18:06of re platform cycles, but when they're reviewing technology of
- 18:09can they consolidate payment providers into a single contract
- 18:12that can go across all those channels.
- 18:14Are you seeing a similar thing? I think a lot, I haven't seen it
- 18:18as as a massive trend, but I definitely know that's what
- 18:21people won. But equally I think in some ways
- 18:26it's getting more difficult and I actually mean that it's purely
- 18:30in Shopify world. I think it's getting more
- 18:31difficult, yeah, because I think we've got a lot of clients that
- 18:35we use, you know, Agen in store, Agen for like pay by link for
- 18:39like trade payments, like you say, kind of isolated just cat
- 18:44or like payments, yeah, and maybe some other solutions
- 18:48around business. And then they're kind of forced
- 18:50or not forced, but definitely in a position where they need but
- 18:56not need but are pushed towards shop.
- 18:59Don't be diplomatic. I'm trying to be diplomatic and
- 19:02I think you think obviously the goal is that Shop 5 Pause
- 19:06becomes a solution where you know, they've got these High
- 19:09Street brands with 203 hundred 400 stores using it long term
- 19:13and then they can use Shopify payments directly there.
- 19:15And then I think that'll probably have a solution or I've
- 19:18potentially look to broaden draft orders or something that
- 19:23kind of off manage some of the other areas.
- 19:26But I think actually a lot of our clients aren't on Shopify
- 19:30happily using Agen, for example, globally across all channels.
- 19:33And and like you say, there's benefits to a finance team and
- 19:37other kind of internal processes and refunds and whatever else.
- 19:42Yeah. Whereas I think it's a bit more
- 19:43difficult in Shopify that. It is and then coming back to
- 19:48the the, the principle of this podcast is what a business is
- 19:51trying to achieve. They're trying to simplify their
- 19:54landscape and what a fine cost efficiencies, but without
- 19:57compromising like business tool in operational capability and
- 20:01the customer experience because if you switch to payment gateway
- 20:04that doesn't offer you. A specific payment wallet in a
- 20:06country where it's, you know, 60% of of revenue, then it's a
- 20:12massive problem because you might have, you might have
- 20:15ticked the consolation box for the tech and the simplification,
- 20:17but you've screwed up your channel and your, your sales
- 20:21potential. So yeah, 100% it's, it is
- 20:25payments is one of the most, I think is one of the most complex
- 20:27areas. But the bit that I see a lot of
- 20:29frustration in, in finance teams with e-commerce is the, there's
- 20:35the reporting that they get out of the payment providers to do
- 20:40the reconciliation. And I guess one thing where
- 20:42Shopify's made it easy for people and other platform
- 20:46payment providers that do blended rates is when you know
- 20:48it's a blended rate, it's very easy to check you're being
- 20:50charged the right thing. When you've got different rates
- 20:53across all different card schemes and lots of different
- 20:56additional ancillary charges on top, trying to reconcile and
- 21:00make sure that not just transactional transaction to
- 21:03transaction from system to system, but actually are we
- 21:05being charged the right rate here?
- 21:07Have they got us on the right tier?
- 21:09And I've seen this with Agens. Great for global sales, but it
- 21:12does make the analysis more complex.
- 21:17Yeah, absolutely. I think payments can be a really
- 21:20big friction point and a re platforming project.
- 21:22And you rightfully mention the other thing is in Shopify land,
- 21:25if you've got, if you're quite an international business,
- 21:28chances are you'll be using like a Molly or an A Wall X or
- 21:31something else to enable some of those other international
- 21:35payment methods. Yeah.
- 21:37And it's just friction, like that's the thing.
- 21:40Yeah. And I guess finance teams in
- 21:42particular just want to buy one vendor.
- 21:43They want to, they want rates based on global volume.
- 21:48Yeah. And it does complicate things
- 21:49and it makes change harder to manage.
- 21:52It isn't and these are the conversations that often don't
- 21:54happen because if or don't happen in the right depth
- 21:58because if you change tech, you can from an IT perspective, and
- 22:01this is not criticizing anyone working in IT because from an IT
- 22:04perspective, you can tick the organizational technology goals
- 22:08of a consolidation by buying a platform that is that fits for
- 22:11fit for purpose works fits into the systems architecture.
- 22:15Great. It integrates how you need it
- 22:16to. But actually, if you haven't
- 22:20gone in the in detail on each of this, the subject matter experts
- 22:23who will then have a dependency, you can find issues.
- 22:26I had it recently with Shopify and Shopify is fantastic for
- 22:29many things, but it's not great on default reports and exports
- 22:33for like order reporting, you need a proper BI, you need a
- 22:37solution in place, whether that's using like a Google or
- 22:41you're using a Power BI or whatever it might be that you're
- 22:44doing it and or you create something custom and, and you've
- 22:48realised you've got all these gaps.
- 22:49So this great aim of like the one system to bind them all with
- 22:53is, is a myth because every, every system has limitations.
- 22:57And this is where I think all of these, these like middlewares
- 23:00and these, these, I'll call them what you want Ipass's
- 23:03integration layers. Yeah, air tables start to come
- 23:06in handy because anything where you can take a compromise, fix
- 23:11it so that the subject matter expert isn't, isn't adding
- 23:14friction to their daily life, then that to me is what what I
- 23:17would then call unified. And it doesn't have to be 1
- 23:20system to do that. Yeah, I agree.
- 23:25I think I went on a bit of a ramble there.
- 23:27My brain was trying to work out where I was going with that one
- 23:29as well. Yeah, a question I had for you,
- 23:32which I think is really interesting because you work a
- 23:33lot of brands who are global as well.
- 23:35So they've got lots of different countries size and often brands
- 23:39that are trying to like bring themselves onto 1E COM platform
- 23:42for global. And then they will have a like
- 23:45legacy stacks in different regions that will be different.
- 23:48So they might have different back office systems, different
- 23:50payment providers and you get local market variations and
- 23:54local market challenges like compliance haven't got, I'm
- 23:57going for a German launch at the moment.
- 24:00You've got all these additional data requirements of what you
- 24:02have to show on the front end, which requires customisations
- 24:06and not all platforms are as easy to how do you, what are you
- 24:09seeing in terms of the challenges around this Omni
- 24:13channel unified approach and an international context?
- 24:19And is it, is it achievable or do people need to accept that
- 24:22it's always going to be compromised?
- 24:24So I think, I think we've seen a lot in this area and I'm sure
- 24:28you have as well. So I think we have a bit of a
- 24:31myth over the last since we started for seven years ago,
- 24:34we've worked with quite a lot of global brands and it's been a
- 24:36mix of how like teams are structured, text stacks are
- 24:39structured. But I can certainly think of a
- 24:41few where we're working solely with Amir and they have a end to
- 24:45end, completely different text stack, completely team
- 24:48structure, completely different way of operating.
- 24:52And I think when you see that and then a brand trying to
- 24:56globalize, I think it's usually just a massive change project.
- 25:01And at that point, it's like a transformation.
- 25:03And typically you'll see a lot of people lose jobs and you'll
- 25:06see, yeah, a lot of like new investment lines and everything
- 25:10else. Yeah, Sometimes that comes as a
- 25:13result of acquisition. Sometimes it's, yeah, just like
- 25:16huge transformation projects. But to be honest, I I feel like
- 25:21that's what drives that more so than we haven't had loads of
- 25:25clients where and even now we've got quite a few where we're only
- 25:28doing a mirror that I have. We haven't had many where like
- 25:31high on their agenda is like building a global data
- 25:35structure, for example. But I think that comes as a
- 25:38result of like maybe how the teams and P and LS are
- 25:40structured more so than that not being the right thing I was
- 25:43doing. And where I have said it, like I
- 25:45said, it's been more of like a business change that's and quite
- 25:48often it'll be an efficiency thing as well.
- 25:50Like there's someone we were working with where it's
- 25:52completely cut Europe recently and, you know, started managing
- 25:55it globally. And, you know, as part of that
- 25:58they've, you know, moved another market to their platform
- 26:02integrated with an existing ERP. Yeah.
- 26:06And basically, I mean, it was, it was a budget saving project.
- 26:10But yeah, I think that varies a lot, I'd say.
- 26:14Yeah, it does. And and I think it's the you're
- 26:17right, the team structure and the the operational processes
- 26:22that exist within those teams, aligning those globally is so
- 26:26hard. If you take like a North
- 26:28America, like Europe, UK, Asia, it's, it's, it is so complex.
- 26:34You can't I I personally. I guess I don't work at
- 26:37transformation level. At that, they're right.
- 26:40Sure, as an I am. No.
- 26:42Well, I guess let's say these days, but I don't work at
- 26:46transformation level globally in that way.
- 26:48And there are transformation experts out there then we should
- 26:50do a project on and we should do a podcast on this actually.
- 26:52That's just our need for it. But I, I, I guess I question
- 26:56whether, whether it's achievable to, to create a uniform
- 27:00approach. I think simplify often where I
- 27:03sit. So I did some work with Mars
- 27:05where I was training there like global ecom teams around digital
- 27:08store optimization and I could see that as well.
- 27:12So they each had they they're concept of perfect digital store
- 27:15and they each had systems in market like Profiteero, for
- 27:19example. I think Europeans were using
- 27:21things different using the US, they were doing the same thing
- 27:24but in a different way with different formats.
- 27:27So what it meant is their reporting wasn't standardized.
- 27:30And one of the, one of the key aims is actually, well, if we,
- 27:33if we standardize the KPIs and the dashboards, we don't have to
- 27:37change tooling because not all vendors operate in all countries
- 27:42and are set up to do so there. They might have a platform you
- 27:44can log into, but do they have local country support?
- 27:46So when your team really needs that help, they can get it.
- 27:48No, they're waiting for somebody to come back online tomorrow.
- 27:51And that doesn't really cut it when you're working in a fast
- 27:54pace like FM, FM CGCCPG environment.
- 27:57So I sometimes it's, it's just about tweaking that you've got
- 28:01rather than rather than trying to put it all into the same
- 28:03supplier. Yeah, absolutely.
- 28:06Yeah. I think on that transformation
- 28:07episode, we should get John Godwin on.
- 28:10So we've worked with him a little bit at Travis Perkins and
- 28:13he obviously went to Space 48, but he's got a really good
- 28:16background. I think, well, we can get him.
- 28:17And obviously what I was saying this live on a recording, so.
- 28:20Yeah. And and then we're telling
- 28:22people we're going to do an episode that if it doesn't
- 28:24happen, you can just call a charlatan space and play that
- 28:28because we are. OK.
- 28:30So who do you think? Have you, have you got a good
- 28:33example of of somebody who has embraced the principles of
- 28:36unified e-commerce, even if they aren't calling it that?
- 28:40Yeah. So I think I've already used
- 28:42Rafa, so I won't use them. I think Nike and Adidas have
- 28:44both got really hot on this. And particularly historically,
- 28:49Nike had, you know, a number of apps that weren't really
- 28:51connected with their like, web interface or their physical
- 28:56retail stores. And then I didn't know when
- 28:59their transformation project started, but they moved way
- 29:02close or they moved towards like, you know, a global
- 29:04account, a global experience. And I feel like every touch
- 29:09point you have with them now has been kind of globalised.
- 29:12And there's references of other channels.
- 29:14And like, you know, you could go to like an activation they would
- 29:16do in Berlin and you would still, you know, have a similar
- 29:20experience to online. And you might, you know, it
- 29:22might be driven by account. And yeah, certainly they're kind
- 29:25of account and loyalty strategy, I think is has been at the heart
- 29:29of that. But I think they're a great
- 29:30example. Yeah, I think that is a nice
- 29:33one. I guess it helps when you have
- 29:37the the pockets to invest in proper transformation and to
- 29:41invest in the systems architecture and the data flows
- 29:44behind it. Yeah.
- 29:45I think the thing with them as well, they like they famously
- 29:48years ago went super focused on direct and less focused on
- 29:51wholesale, which I think they reversed a bit recently, but I
- 29:55would imagine that was a big part of their direct strategy as
- 29:58well. Yes, yeah, exactly.
- 30:00And the people I've worked with who are trying to adopt these
- 30:04principles, I see the conversation around data is the
- 30:08central part to not the focus is talking about data more than
- 30:12systems, which which is good because you've got to have a
- 30:15data strategy to then know where you've got technology gaps.
- 30:20And the data strategy is, is basically aligned from a, you
- 30:24know all of the angles, customer experience, trader, you name it.
- 30:28Yeah. So you think sorry.
- 30:32Sorry, I was just going to say, I think actually almost because
- 30:35I was just thinking of some other examples in my head of
- 30:37brands I've had a good experience that I've put into
- 30:39this bracket like Space NK, lots of other kind of like premium
- 30:43brands. And actually if you think about
- 30:46it that a lot of them, it's centred around a very well
- 30:50structured loyalty program. And like, obviously the two
- 30:53aren't the same, but I do feel like, you know, often loyalty is
- 30:58the mechanism to get people to log in or identify themselves in
- 31:02store, etcetera. So I do feel like the two tie in
- 31:06together quite well. Yes, agreed.
- 31:10So let's like nice nice pithy summary that we like to do at
- 31:15the end of this episode. So my 1 is going to be.
- 31:17And please, if you think I'm talking bollocks, call me out on
- 31:20it. Disagree.
- 31:22Let me know why though, it's always useful.
- 31:24So for me, unified commerce isn't anything new at all.
- 31:27It's a re badging of the the whole strategic premise of Omni
- 31:32channel. But I think maybe it's done
- 31:35deliberately to try and get deeper discussion now about what
- 31:40this means at an enterprise level, what it means
- 31:43operationally, what it means technology data wise.
- 31:45But fundamentally it's about putting customers at the central
- 31:48decision making and creating a systems architecture that
- 31:51enables and simplifies your ability to execute consistently
- 31:54across channels. And I don't think that's changed
- 31:56in the last five years as a, as a strategic goal of businesses.
- 32:00What is changing is the data connectivity and systems
- 32:04connectivity, the, the and also the, I guess let's call it the
- 32:08barriers to entry. There's greater democratisation
- 32:11in terms of smaller businesses with smaller budgets being able
- 32:14to afford to use tools that help them, you know, create more
- 32:19consistently around channels or, or get better data.
- 32:21And we've talked about, you know, ecosystems like Shopify.
- 32:24Then you've got like being a big commerce with it.
- 32:26It's it's app ecosystem as well. You've got, you know, platforms
- 32:31with stronger APIs to to get data out of systems.
- 32:35You got the likes of air tables coming.
- 32:37So it just the, the, I guess the barrier to entry for starting to
- 32:41achieve some of this has come down and I think that's probably
- 32:44the biggest change I'm seeing. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 32:47I think just your initial point around it being created
- 32:50deliberately, I definitely think that the more by the likes of
- 32:54Gartner who are just trying to create demand, it's like it's a
- 32:58new way of justifying investment and like you know, signing off
- 33:01vendors and signing off transformation projects and
- 33:03everything else. And I think that's what Omni was
- 33:05years ago. Yeah, I completely agree on that
- 33:10point. And I think I feel like I've
- 33:12been a little bit more negative on Shopify's time.
- 33:14I know you say that I always fanboy Shopify, but I do think
- 33:18they're driving at the lowest level.
- 33:20Like I don't think, you know, they position themselves as
- 33:22unified at every level, which I don't think they are yet.
- 33:26But I do think a lot of brands, small brands that I know that
- 33:29I've done have grown up in Shopify world and you know,
- 33:31they've taken advantage of the ease to introduce a native app
- 33:35or a different sales channel and everything else.
- 33:37So do you think they're kind of creating that little operating
- 33:40system, but typically for the smaller brands and maybe brands
- 33:43that have always lived in Shopify world?
- 33:45Yeah, I, I think, I think the SAS platforms have done a really
- 33:50good job of that because they've, this is what I mean
- 33:53about the democratisation. Because if you, if you're on a
- 33:56more legacy platform, if you take the the like go back a few
- 34:00years on on an open source Magenta, then you need more
- 34:03engineering resource to get plug insurance work in or to do
- 34:08integrations because you don't have all the pre connections.
- 34:11Shopify is clearly the leader with the the breadth and depth
- 34:13of apps that you've got to just, you know, one click connect
- 34:17connections, the integration works done.
- 34:19Yes, there's, there's often configuration work and there's
- 34:23settings to manage and there's theme impacts.
- 34:25So it's never it's rarely just turn it one click and you're
- 34:28done. Although there are some, and
- 34:31that's the bit that I think shifting is, is if you're a
- 34:33small business and you can't afford to spend 5 to 10 grand on
- 34:37a developer to do an integration for you, but you can afford
- 34:40$30.00 a month on an app and spend a bit of time yourself in
- 34:43the theme code. Well, hey presto, we've we've
- 34:46got that ability to create that, that more seamless experience
- 34:50for the, the. Econ team completely.
- 34:52I think pause is a big part of that.
- 34:55And I actually think the only other person, the only other
- 34:57platform that's maybe got a proposition alongside that is
- 35:01Sentra with like a Voyado and a city where actually combined
- 35:05they've got really strong kind of unified view of the world.
- 35:09Yeah, agreed. I think Central was the other
- 35:11one I was going to mention so that they don't feel we're not
- 35:15giving them the love on this episode.
- 35:16But I think it's they've they've targeted specific ecosystem
- 35:20around the the fashion lifestyle focus they've got and it works
- 35:23well. You know, they've got, they've
- 35:25got the search, the merchandise in and they've also got the Omni
- 35:29channel capabilities with like Ingrid.
- 35:33And so they they've got ability for I guess from the SME level
- 35:36up to the more enterprise, larger businesses as well.
- 35:40I think even I mean, even shop Ware went down the street on
- 35:43their version 6 when they started to to build out more
- 35:46apps to enable this connectivity just on a smaller level, I'd
- 35:49imagine. And and I'm sure if I'm big
- 35:51commerce, but right. So that is our that's our ramble
- 35:54on unified commerce. I quite enjoyed this episode.
- 35:57It's nice to just sit and chat about and stuff.
- 36:00Tell us what you think. I hope it was useful.
- 36:01What do you think? You're working in e-commerce, a
- 36:03retailer, you're working as a brand, you're an agency, a
- 36:07developer. What's your perspective?
- 36:09Is this any, is this for anything you or do you agree?
- 36:12Do you do you think we're talking broadly in the right
- 36:14terms that actually this is just repackaging what is what has
- 36:17always been sensible ecom strategy?
- 36:19Let us know and thanks for listening.
- 36:24You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 36:27by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 36:30Insidecommerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 36:32featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 36:35industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 36:38explore the latest digital strategy.
- 36:40Customer experience and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 36:43really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 36:46help fine tune your E Comm strategy and tech stack.
- 36:49Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 36:52like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 36:54We hope you enjoy the latest episode.