Latest / Mark and Pete / Starmer: Stifled or Stuffed?

Transcript

Starmer: Stifled or Stuffed? · Mark and Pete

• 0:04
  Starmer stifled or stuffed? Welcome to Mark and Pete, the
• 0:10
  show where we look at the news and shake our heads slowly in
• 0:15
  despair. Yes, this is Mark and Pete, 2
• 0:17
  blokes with half an opinion. Now here's our first thought.
• 0:21
  Political storm The storm over Starmer is brewing.
• 0:25
  Misfortune is starting to flood. The political sharks are
• 0:29
  circling and they sense the smell of blood.
• 0:34
  Yes, it's been yet again, another bad week for Sir Keir
• 0:38
  Starmer. Well, we've already had more
• 0:40
  revelations over Mandleson documents.
• 0:43
  At the same time, we've also seen that Morgan McSweeney quits
• 0:47
  as the Prime Minister's chief of staff, Mr. Pete.
• 0:51
  It seems as though no matter what Sir Keir Starmer does,
• 0:55
  there seems to be problems on his doorstep.
• 0:58
  Is there a way in which he can survive as the Sharks are
• 1:02
  starting to circle? Well, we've been in situations
• 1:06
  before, Mr. Mark, where a politician in Britain is looking
• 1:11
  like it's the end of his presidency.
• 1:13
  A presidency might as well be end of his prime ministership
• 1:17
  sooner than than you would have thought.
• 1:20
  We've been in fact in this position several times just in
• 1:23
  the past few years. And each time it seems like,
• 1:28
  well, there's a way out of this. You can simply do X whatever it
• 1:32
  might be. But no knowing that
• 1:35
  constitutionally, as in their constitution, not the
• 1:38
  constitution of the Britain, they're incapable of doing it.
• 1:41
  They just so fixed in their ideology and in their way of
• 1:47
  operating that they can't do it. And Starmer is like an extreme
• 1:51
  version of that. He has a past in very left wing
• 1:55
  politics. He's now a suppose what you
• 1:58
  might call a globalist leftist. His sympathies are not really
• 2:03
  with Britain, but with some sort of ridiculous and yet firmly
• 2:10
  held belief in the world order and international law and and
• 2:15
  this castle thing, when really, you know, that's not true.
• 2:20
  And we're seeing that's idea falling apart in real time.
• 2:24
  But he's fixed to that. And also he's just not maybe
• 2:28
  he's not intelligent. I know he's certainly not very
• 2:29
  quick on his feet. He doesn't read the room.
• 2:32
  He has a way of operating. He looks very boring.
• 2:35
  And I, I think that's possibly Mr. Maher because because he is,
• 2:40
  he's he has a certain way of operating.
• 2:43
  I mean, I don't think he's so obviously boring as the previous
• 2:47
  Prime Minister, John Major, but I think in terms of his actual
• 2:52
  ability to change, he's more insufferably boring.
• 2:56
  He won't be able to change. So in answer to your question,
• 2:58
  no, I see there's nothing that he there's, there are things
• 3:02
  that could be done, but there's nothing that he can do.
• 3:06
  Well, as we've seen, he has faced plenty of leadership
• 3:10
  crisis situations and questions at Prime Minister's Question
• 3:14
  Time over not just the state of the nation, but also his
• 3:19
  leadership. Now, I think that probably we
• 3:21
  should come down to what is it that's got him to this place?
• 3:25
  Well, we know that his judgement, it was his call to
• 3:28
  ultimately appoint former Lord Mandelson.
• 3:32
  We now know that Lord Mandelson has resigned his position from
• 3:37
  the House of Lords. But at the end of the day, many
• 3:39
  people have questioned how on earth that decision could ever
• 3:41
  have been made, knowing that, of course, Lord Mandelson did have,
• 3:46
  at the time, some relationships with obviously Jeffrey Epstein.
• 3:51
  More and more revelations have started to come out to prove
• 3:54
  those points. So how on earth could Keir
• 3:55
  Starmer make that mistake? Now you could sort of, dare I
• 3:59
  say, as bad as that is, say well maybe that was 1 aberration.
• 4:04
  But then you have to look at the other things that are on the the
• 4:06
  nation's plate. We've got certainly the problems
• 4:10
  with the economy now as we already know that there have
• 4:14
  been some revelations of what really is the true state of the
• 4:17
  nation's debt. So that's one issue.
• 4:19
  One of the things that Labour did say that it was going to do
• 4:23
  was address the black hole. This was what they perceived at
• 4:27
  the time as a 22 billion black hole narrative from the
• 4:30
  Conservatives. Well, believe me, that black
• 4:34
  hole has got extremely large. It's become an almost infinite
• 4:37
  universe. So that's a concern in itself on
• 4:40
  the economy front. So the economy has got worse.
• 4:43
  Then we come on to the state of education, the state of the
• 4:46
  health service. We then look at some of the
• 4:48
  foreign policies. Now we know that Sir Keir
• 4:51
  Starmer went to China. This was something that perhaps
• 4:55
  was criticized not just by his own Labour Bank benches, but
• 4:59
  also given criticism from the United States President Donald
• 5:04
  Trump. So it's all about judgement or
• 5:07
  politics is all about making the right decisions.
• 5:10
  But here's the other thing I'm wondering, Mr. Pete, is Sir Keir
• 5:14
  Starmer in an ironic sort of strength of position, because
• 5:18
  there isn't anybody better to take over.
• 5:21
  That's a, That's a. That is a good point, yeah.
• 5:25
  I mean, there are people within the Labour Party who'd like to
• 5:28
  take over, but they're either compromised or they just don't
• 5:36
  have it. They, you've got a bit have at
• 5:38
  least some sort of recognition factor to be in a position where
• 5:45
  the Labour MPs and other stakeholders within Labour, when
• 5:49
  they vote for Labour will think that you can do it.
• 5:52
  And there really isn't anyone who is neither compromised or
• 5:57
  just not known or just doesn't have the ability.
• 6:00
  So well, you could say Starwood didn't have the ability, but he
• 6:04
  at least had the appearance before he became leader of
• 6:07
  having some level of competence. I don't know, Mr. Malpass, you
• 6:12
  can correct me on this, but I don't think there's anyone like
• 6:15
  that. So I think you're, I think
• 6:17
  you're right to suggest that that strengthens his position.
• 6:20
  However it's in such, it's in such a, a, a poor position.
• 6:26
  It's, it may be that he has to actually resign now.
• 6:30
  Kemi Balanol, the leader of the Opposition has said that
• 6:36
  Kierstamel, we need to be dragged kicking and screaming
• 6:39
  from #10 and ask for help for Labour MPs.
• 6:43
  She said this in the House of Parliament.
• 6:45
  She said she asked for their help in bringing him down.
• 6:49
  You know, they she wants to put forward a vote of no confidence.
• 6:53
  Now that would mean that if enough even bottom of bring
• 6:58
  forward a vote of no confidence, the likelihood would be that he
• 7:03
  would resign. But yeah, the kicking and
• 7:07
  screaming is persuade that. So yeah, with no one likely to
• 7:11
  challenge him, at least not in the in the near term, in the
• 7:15
  short term and no one and him not likely to resign, perhaps he
• 7:19
  will sort of struggle on as a lame duck Prime Minister not
• 7:25
  having able to do it much despite his huge majority
• 7:29
  because the Labour MPs just don't want to support him.
• 7:33
  It's looking to be very looking to get worse and worse for Keir
• 7:37
  Starmer. I think eventually he'll be
• 7:39
  forced out. But one thing I, I think we can
• 7:41
  be pretty sure of, we're not going to get a general election
• 7:45
  because that would mean that the they, the they're not signing
• 7:49
  their own death, but signing their own death warrant for
• 7:51
  their careers. Because recent polls have shown
• 7:55
  most of the front bench, the leadership of the Labour Party
• 7:59
  would lose their seats, would no longer be MPs whether to be a
• 8:02
  general election. So yeah, it's looking like he's
• 8:05
  going to get a replacement. Things are bad.
• 8:08
  There must surely come a point where even someone as averse to
• 8:17
  integrity as Keir Starmer would resign.
• 8:21
  Well now here's the thing. Because I've mentioned before,
• 8:24
  the sharks are swimming around. Now here's some names to conjure
• 8:28
  with Angela Rayner. Well, that was the this is the
• 8:32
  compromise candidate I was talking about because of the
• 8:35
  revelations about a a home and not on on payment of tax.
• 8:42
  She is compromised in that way, although she is the one person
• 8:46
  who has the most personality. Well, quite.
• 8:50
  Now she exactly that. So she perhaps has some
• 8:55
  skeletons in her closet. Now, here's the other one for
• 8:58
  you, Ed Miliband. I know that you're inspired.
• 9:02
  Come on. I know.
• 9:04
  Well, Ed Miliband. Ed Miliband was Libra, the
• 9:07
  leader of the Labour Party, and famously had.
• 9:10
  Yes. Trouble eating a bacon sandwich.
• 9:13
  I believe it was on on television.
• 9:16
  He's like, he'd never come across such a proletariat type
• 9:20
  dish before. And he, yeah, he, he's.
• 9:23
  Just he is climate loving. Climate change loving.
• 9:28
  I know climate change enthusiast and you know you you have to say
• 9:33
  that that of course in itself is a is a very much a controversy
• 9:38
  over basically moving our energy policy into.
• 9:42
  Chaos. But here's one candidate that
• 9:45
  potentially is seen as a safe pair of hands, not really seen
• 9:49
  that much in the media, but is actually, ironically, doing a
• 9:52
  reasonable job, and that is a Defence secretary, John Healey.
• 9:57
  Now, what's interesting here is, is that he may not necessarily
• 10:01
  be seen as a sparkling personality, but maybe what we
• 10:04
  now need is a safe pair of hands, somebody who can come in,
• 10:07
  bring a bit of discipline and actually start to address some
• 10:11
  of the matters that really Sir Keir Starmer has struggled with.
• 10:14
  I, I wonder whether, whether you, you know of him, I think he
• 10:17
  has some good credibility. I think, you know, with an armed
• 10:21
  force Minister Al Khans as well, maybe as a sort of a supporting
• 10:27
  body there. But I either way, I do agree
• 10:30
  that we're sort of scraping the barrel a little bit here.
• 10:34
  But I, I in my opinion, and this is the thing that we've talked
• 10:37
  about over recent weeks, it's isn't it interesting that almost
• 10:41
  every week that goes by Sakir Starmer fails to address some of
• 10:45
  these issues and seems to be culpable on almost all of them?
• 10:50
  That's the question which I really question now, how far can
• 10:53
  he carry on making these? Yes.
• 10:55
  I think clearly he's another sort of charisma accum, isn't
• 10:58
  he? But you know, going going back
• 11:00
  to Starmer, I think, yeah, it, it's, do you know that old
• 11:05
  phrase? It was used after the Second
• 11:08
  World War to to describe Eichmann.
• 11:11
  I think it's when he first first used the banality of evil.
• 11:18
  You get real evil done when boring weak men are leading and
• 11:23
  is is the what the phrase means. And that's, that's I think what
• 11:28
  we're seeing. You highlighted the fact that
• 11:30
  Keir Starmer failed to address issues his his weak leadership
• 11:35
  means effectively evil occurring in that it's destroying the
• 11:40
  country economically, culturally, bring you know, you
• 11:46
  know about the weakness over the bringing in many migrants who
• 11:51
  are who are culturally different.
• 11:54
  The not the kowtowing, as people put it, even though kowtow is, I
• 11:59
  think, a Japanese term, kowtowing to China.
• 12:02
  There's another example of weakness.
• 12:04
  And and then they're not dealing with Mandy, as we call it, Peter
• 12:09
  Mandelson and those issues with Jeffrey Epstein.
• 12:12
  You know, weakness, weakness, weakness.
• 12:14
  But it's still evil. You don't need to be strong to
• 12:18
  be evil. You can be a boring weak man and
• 12:21
  still result in having a evil effect on the country.
• 12:24
  And that's, I think, what's happening.
• 12:26
  Well, there are a lot of nostrils flaring and there's a
• 12:29
  sense of blood in the air. So my question to our listeners
• 12:33
  is it's just Keen Starmer, a dead man walking.