Latest / HOOSIER FOOTBALL TAILGATE / Separating Fact From Fiction: NCAA Threats, Vacated Wins & Indiana's Title
Transcript
- 0:00Get the ultimate Indiana football coverage with Hoosier
- 0:03Football Tailgate, hosted by the coach Shannon Griffith, a 28
- 0:07year college football coaching veteran and lead analyst for
- 0:11thehoosier.com. We bring you in depth analysis,
- 0:14exclusive interviews and recruiting updates year round.
- 0:18Tune and twice a week during the season and weekly in the
- 0:21offseason. Don't miss out.
- 0:23Subscribe today to stay ahead with the number one source for
- 0:26Hoosier football. You're listening to Hoosier
- 0:29Tailgate on the hoosier.com with the coach Shannon Griffith.
- 0:34Your go to locker room for Indiana football insight,
- 0:39recruiting, breakdowns, film room talk and Big 10 battles.
- 0:45So grab your headset, crank it up, and let's talk Hoosier
- 0:50football. Hello and welcome in to another
- 0:55edition of the Hoosier Tailgate live here on the hoosier.com.
- 0:59Appreciate you joining us here this evening.
- 1:01Going to talk about some things that have been occurring here
- 1:03because all the rumors have been flying across college football
- 1:06right now. And Indiana fans are hearing
- 1:09everything from vacated wins to speculation about the national
- 1:13championship, all centered around Lewis Moore's lawsuit
- 1:17that he filed back in the summer that gave him a temporary
- 1:22injunction to enable him to play one more year of collegiate
- 1:27football. But there's been a lot of things
- 1:33that have been put out, you know, a lot of clickbait
- 1:37storylines and titles about Indiana.
- 1:40And we're going to talk about what is fact, what is fiction,
- 1:45and what Indiana fans can garner from everything that's occurring
- 1:50right now in college football. Taking a break from our series
- 1:54about the portal additions for this year.
- 1:56We'll get back on to that here next week as we continue on
- 2:00before we get to spring football here shortly.
- 2:03And want to make sure everybody kind of gets everything in line
- 2:08so we know what's going on when we come to the start of spring
- 2:13practice, which is coming very fast right now.
- 2:16We got the combine that's getting ready to be ran down
- 2:21there in Indianapolis, 9 Hoosiers down there.
- 2:25If you head over to the hoosier.com, they got great
- 2:27coverage on it. They've got the guys in there,
- 2:29some of their interviews and some of the pressors and things
- 2:31of that magnitude. Get a chance to catch up with
- 2:34some of those guys and what they've been up to since the
- 2:36national championship. But the hoosier.com got all that
- 2:40information for you as well, as well as other information based
- 2:44on recruiting. You name it, they've got it
- 2:47covered. 8 is those guys do a great job over there, appreciate
- 2:50of being a part of that group with the best coverage you can
- 2:55get on the Indiana Hoosiers as we say in that respects.
- 3:00But really what we want to accomplish out of the night is
- 3:04get this basic to this, the concept of what is real, what is
- 3:09just noise. Take our time, slow it down a
- 3:12little bit, get some things addressed about what did occur,
- 3:17kind of a timeline and things like that.
- 3:19Because the best way to understand things of this
- 3:22magnitude and what the NCAA may be trying or not trying to do is
- 3:29take your time, go through it A-Z and dot the IS and cross the
- 3:33T so that if you do see something out there that is just
- 3:38flat out false, you'll know that it's flat out false or
- 3:42misinformation in that respect. But you know, we'll get through
- 3:45it. They'll be, you know, pretty
- 3:48good talking about what the NCAA is, what it isn't and what it's,
- 3:52you know, tasks are going to be moving forward in this new look
- 3:56college football alignment and how does the college football
- 3:59play offs play and all this and things of that nature.
- 4:01But couple things talked about, I don't know if you saw some of
- 4:05this week was the season tickets for the 2026 season have been
- 4:10completely sold out and probably the first time, if any, that the
- 4:16season tickets for Indiana football have been sold out this
- 4:21early in the of the season for that.
- 4:27It's great to have that that in the bank, so to speak, get all
- 4:31the season tickets there. But yes, you know, that means
- 4:34tickets will be a premium come the time that we start the
- 4:37football season. So once they start selling those
- 4:40individual game tickets, you're going to probably want to make
- 4:43some purchases there so you can get yourself a ticket for any of
- 4:47those home games that will be announced in times and such as
- 4:50we get closer and closer to, you know, the end of spring and into
- 4:54the latter part of, you know, late spring when they kind of
- 4:58released some of that stuff. But it was good to see that
- 5:00Indiana has sold out their 2026 season tickets.
- 5:04And like I said, I don't ever remembering it being this early
- 5:08in that regard in terms of season tickets.
- 5:12I know last year, I think they end up selling out, but it was
- 5:15later, if I'm not mistaken there in the first couple weeks of the
- 5:19season. But that's going to be something
- 5:23that again, you get a chance to pick up some tickets early on
- 5:28for individual games. You're going to want to do that
- 5:30as as well. Some things going on as well as
- 5:33the down in Indianapolis right now they're meeting with the
- 5:37rules and Rules Committee and such.
- 5:40And they're one thing that they're talking about is
- 5:45basically two things. They're talking about transfer
- 5:48windows for the portal and the other they're talking about is
- 5:53tampering. First thing here, let's talk
- 5:55about this. The proposal stiff penalties on
- 5:59schools for adding transfers outside of the portal window.
- 6:03Last year there were some ways that guys got it around some of
- 6:10the portal windows and basically they we, you know, waited to the
- 6:14spring, they unenrolled from school A and then re enrolled at
- 6:22school B. And that officially makes you
- 6:25eligible at school B if you bring forward all the credits
- 6:29and things of that nature. And there were some kids that
- 6:31did that last year. And it's kind of one of those
- 6:34loopholes that you probably wouldn't know about until it
- 6:37actually happens. Well, it's happened, and the
- 6:40NCAA is going to try to curtail that practice from happening
- 6:46moving forward when it comes to it.
- 6:48And if something of that nature happens, the head coach would be
- 6:52prohibited from all football on field and field coaching and
- 6:58recruiting and administrative duties through the 6th contest
- 7:03of the season. So they would be on the sideline
- 7:07up through the first 6-7 weeks of the season.
- 7:11The school would be fined 20% of its football budget, which will
- 7:15be a That's a pretty stiff penalty and the school would
- 7:19require to reduce the number of roster spots by 5 for the next
- 7:22season, regardless of the head coach's employment status or
- 7:25not. One correction there, the head
- 7:29coach would be prohibited from all football recruiting an on
- 7:33field coaching and administrative duties for six
- 7:36contests. I said that already.
- 7:37So Rossdellinger is reporting that over and on three, but
- 7:41that's a pretty stiff penalty for that type of situation
- 7:47involving transfers and such. And like I said, this was
- 7:51happening at the end of last spring when guys were on on
- 7:58enrolling at their school and going to enroll at another
- 8:02school, thus making a transfer and maybe a school be picking up
- 8:07a pretty darn good player. So that's one thing that they're
- 8:11addressing with that aspect of things as we moved through this
- 8:17new era of college football. And then the other thing that's
- 8:21also on the docket is tampering. The NCAA does have a tampering
- 8:27rule. It's not ever been utilized in
- 8:32the past, but there is something there that would involve if a
- 8:38school is guilty or found guilty of tampering with a player or
- 8:43players, then the school that has been found to have broken
- 8:50the rules on tampering, that head coach would be suspended
- 8:55for one. One full season I believe is 1
- 8:58penalty that they're putting out and some other things like fines
- 9:03and reduction in roster spots and so, so forth and so on.
- 9:08So you can see right now how the NCAA is really trying to get a
- 9:12handle on some of the major issues that are in front of them
- 9:18as it involves the transfer windows of opportunity and
- 9:25tampering. And as you can see, I think the
- 9:31the the proverbial red line has been drawn in the sand.
- 9:36And if you cross that line and are found to have tampered with
- 9:42a player, you're going to pay a pretty stiff penalty for that.
- 9:46We know what Dabo Sweeney did at Clemson and his allegations
- 9:49against Ole Miss. And it's a good thing that the
- 9:55NCAA is going to kind of Brussel up and make some statements here
- 10:01as it pertains to that. The other thing that they also
- 10:04are pushing forward is a window of investigation that goes a lot
- 10:10quicker than two to three years. We're talking a three to four
- 10:13week period of time to make determinations on whether a
- 10:17school did or did not break a tampering rule and things of
- 10:22that may nature or the the portal rule aspect of things.
- 10:25So you can see the NCAA and the American Football Coaches
- 10:34Association have been actively involved in talking about these
- 10:37subject matters here over the end of the season.
- 10:41But it kind of leads us into what we're going to discuss
- 10:44tonight with this Lewis Moore eligibility stuff.
- 10:48And what is the NCAA trying to do?
- 10:50Because this does not only involve Indiana.
- 10:55There's a a, you know, a plethora of schools out there
- 11:00that are in the same boat, as well as some new additional
- 11:04lawsuits that have come about and over the last week.
- 11:08And the NCAA is trying to do some things to get out in front
- 11:14of this. And we're going to talk about
- 11:15that as we get going here. But you know, the biggest thing
- 11:20is that Indiana for the for what they are involved with has
- 11:28really nothing to do with Indiana.
- 11:30It's really an individual situation with Lewis Moore.
- 11:33Now Indiana ultimately played Lewis in all their games, but
- 11:38that was granted by a temporary injunction in the state of Texas
- 11:43that was put forward before the start of the season and it held
- 11:49true until the end of the end of the season.
- 11:51So let's go through some of this.
- 11:53We'll talk about if you got any questions tonight, by all means,
- 11:56again, does go ahead and ask them in the in the comments
- 12:00section of whether you're on YouTube, Facebook or even I
- 12:04think X you can do it as well. If you got a question, by all
- 12:08means, ask away. And if it's not, even if it's
- 12:11not something that pertains to this subject matter, I'll try to
- 12:15answer in the best that I can. As you know, I'd like for this
- 12:18to be as much as a open forum as much as possible, but again,
- 12:23appreciate you joining us. Remember to hit that that, like
- 12:26and subscribe button. Hit the notification bell to get
- 12:30all the alerts when we are making a live show available as
- 12:36well as anything else. But we appreciate that goes a
- 12:39long way. And if you like to listen to us
- 12:42on your favorite podcast platform out there, Spotify,
- 12:46Apple podcast, whatever, by all means if you could also give us
- 12:50a rating there and maybe a comment or two about the about
- 12:54the show. We greatly appreciate that as
- 12:56well as we jump into tonight's opening of, of what we're trying
- 13:03to get done here with this situation with Louis Moore and
- 13:12what, what all is involved. So the biggest thing is let's
- 13:17see here kind of the, the, the legal breakdown of all this.
- 13:24And again, I'm trying to blow this up a little bit more if I
- 13:27can with everything. And hopefully everybody can see
- 13:32that, OK. But when you look at all this,
- 13:40the biggest thing we're trying to do is bring clarity to the
- 13:42situation, you know, because understanding how this all came
- 13:48about is the best way to really get a hold of what is all
- 13:53occurring here with Louis Moore, his eligibility, things of that
- 13:56nature, nature from the start to the end.
- 14:02And really the breakdown of it was he challenged eligibility.
- 14:08He challenged his eligibility under the NCAA participation
- 14:11limits. He had gone to a junior college
- 14:15as like Diego Pavia had and others, and they felt that their
- 14:21argument was that the junior college playing should not have
- 14:26counted against their NCAA eligibility at a four year
- 14:34institution. Now, it's always been understood
- 14:40because we used to recruit junior college players and we
- 14:43had to know whether they were a 2 for two or three for, you
- 14:47know, three, you know, 3 for three years of eligibility
- 14:50because they came out after their freshman year at a JUCO.
- 14:53Most guys were two for two. That meant they graduated and
- 14:57they've got two more years of eligibility, you know, for them
- 15:03to play. And so that's what the challenge
- 15:06was. You know, it basically try the
- 15:11lawsuit filed challenge the rule legality, whether it was a a
- 15:17legally valid rule. The judge ultimately offered a
- 15:24what they call a temporary injunction May, meaning that the
- 15:28NCAA could not do anything that would prohibit Lewis from
- 15:36participating this year until after the season when they would
- 15:40bring the subject matter back to the forefront and he would
- 15:45compete under the protection of the courts.
- 15:48And in some respects, so would Indiana in that regard.
- 15:53And Indiana and this respect is wanting to continue the appeals
- 16:00process. And the reason why what happened
- 16:04was after the season was over, there was a scheduled court date
- 16:09for like January the 29th to go into this process of hearing
- 16:15this case. Well, because the season was
- 16:19done, Louis Louis Moore with his attorneys advice, they dropped
- 16:27the lawsuit because it was kind of over and done with at that
- 16:32point because he wasn't going to try to go on.
- 16:34And a lot of kids have done that because you would see that
- 16:39there's no need to go to court, pay legal fees, things of that
- 16:43nature to fight and argue about something that is a is a done
- 16:47deal because the year is completely over.
- 16:50And that's what Lewis did. Now, what the NCAA wants and
- 16:55what they're fighting for, and I don't know if they will or will
- 16:58not be successful in this Ave., is they want there to be a
- 17:06process of appealing this because they want a ruling on
- 17:09whether the rule itself is a valid legal rule that they can
- 17:14enforce or if it's not. And this is where everything
- 17:20came into the news cycle with this because the NCAA says if
- 17:26they would win a case on appeal, then they could go back and
- 17:34implement what they call the rules of restitution.
- 17:39OK. And we'll get into that here in
- 17:40a second. But as many have argued, there's
- 17:46no need for an appeal because the case was never decided
- 17:49because it was ultimately dropped by the party that was
- 17:52suing the NCAA. So there's no need for an
- 17:55appeal. But that is what the NCAA is
- 17:58pushing for because they want a red line in the sand, just like
- 18:03they did with the transfer window, just like what they did
- 18:05with the tampering aspect of things.
- 18:07They want a ruling on this so they know whether or not they
- 18:12can enforce the rules that are on the book and such.
- 18:15So I can understand the NCAA wanting that dynamic aspect of
- 18:21it now, whether or not in the court of law, if this can
- 18:25proceed, even though there's no underlying case anymore because
- 18:29it's been been dropped and and the parties have been released
- 18:33from their responsibilities in the lawsuit, Whether or not they
- 18:37can get some type of judge or appeals court to make a ruling
- 18:43on a case that no longer is before the court.
- 18:46So that's kind of the dynamic. And this is where the the all
- 18:51the noise started coming in with the NCAA becoming and banging on
- 18:57their chest because they wanted this to be out there.
- 18:59They wanted it to be in the news cycle.
- 19:01They wanted to stir conversation.
- 19:03And they wanted that all the schools participating at the
- 19:07Division One level to hear this loud and clear that the NCAA, if
- 19:13they were allowed to, they would invoke the rules of restitution,
- 19:19which would allow them to go back and penalize a a team for
- 19:23playing a player that did not meet eligibility requirements
- 19:29because they used up all their years of eligibility.
- 19:32And that's where you started hearing about forfeiture of
- 19:36wins, removing a player's statistics and data from all the
- 19:40record books, fines of, you know, X amount of dollars, as
- 19:46you can imagine, pretty steep fines.
- 19:50And again, what many were trying to say was vacating the national
- 19:55title game. And, you know, that is something
- 19:58that we'll talk about here in a second.
- 20:02But you can understand why the NCAA is saying, look, regardless
- 20:09of whether somebody is has dropped the lawsuit or not, we
- 20:14need a ruling on this particular subject matter because we've
- 20:18already gotten other cases in front of us now.
- 20:21Arguing the same thing. And we need to know if our rules
- 20:27are valid and can we enforce them to the letter of the law
- 20:33per SE that is written in the NCA manual.
- 20:36And remember, these rules were brought together and came up
- 20:40with a body, a committee per SE of presidents and athletic
- 20:45directors over years and years of going through this.
- 20:50And now those are being challenged in the court of law.
- 20:54And therefore, the NCAA, like I said, wanting that clarification
- 20:59to let them be able to do what they need to do as it pertains
- 21:03to enforcing this rule. And again, like I alluded to
- 21:06there, this is where the NCAA became very vocal in the media
- 21:10about what they could do if they were found to be in the right.
- 21:16And the suits were, you know, not as not not good lawsuits to
- 21:22begin with. So trying to get through that.
- 21:25Let's kind of go through here through this legal timeline
- 21:30again. Again, Lewis kind of challenged
- 21:35his eligibility. You know, there there was a
- 21:38question. And remember, Indiana had signed
- 21:40him out of the portal from Mississippi where he did play
- 21:48and Indiana signed him and everything was was signed with
- 21:54the ideal in mind that would it become an enforceable contract
- 21:59upon clarification of his eligibility.
- 22:03So they filed A lawsuit right in the state of Texas because, and
- 22:08I'm not sure that's the one thing I'm not quite sure of why
- 22:11they went to a state court as opposed to a federal court.
- 22:14And that's one of the arguments the NCAA made and everything.
- 22:19And that's going to be one of those things that, again, we'll
- 22:25talk about here as we go along. The judge ultimately entered,
- 22:28like I said, the the injunction that allowed him to play.
- 22:31Lewis competed, of course, Indiana wins the national title.
- 22:37Then we saw the case dismissed and NCAA pursue pursues the
- 22:42legal clarification and precedent on appeal because they
- 22:47need to understand what they can or cannot do.
- 22:51It's a this legal process in some respects is not a rules
- 22:56violation per SE because nothing was ruled on the particular rule
- 23:00of eligibility. So that's kind of where some of
- 23:03the difference in this kind of gets caught up with.
- 23:06But again, this is very similar to Pavia's.
- 23:11There's other guys out there that are doing the same thing or
- 23:13did the same thing a year ago. And like I said, there's
- 23:17already, I think two or three lawsuits up and running for the
- 23:25same exact thing about junior college and how that should or
- 23:30should not affect your NCAA eligibility at the school that
- 23:36they're at now. That's going to be that's going
- 23:41to be the thing that the NCAA is trying to get out of the most
- 23:47with all this in that respect. Because again, and you can agree
- 23:51with this or understand this, they want to know where they
- 23:55stand on that. So like we talked about the
- 23:57transfer window and how their kids are getting around that.
- 24:00They put a stop to that. And there's going to be severe
- 24:02fines and penalties for the head coach if they don't abide by the
- 24:07true transfer window. And #2 the tamperings, the
- 24:13tampering issue that we've seen going on for the better part of
- 24:16two years now has also got some teeth to it now that the NCAA
- 24:20can now be able to bring punishment to those schools that
- 24:27violate the the tampering rule that is already on the books per
- 24:31SE. So that is kind of where we're
- 24:34at with this type of thing and everything that goes with it.
- 24:38But when you look at this, you know, and in the case of what
- 24:47was the situation with everything, it kind of like I
- 24:54said, kind of starts with this, how it kind of how it all plays
- 25:02out where it happened in the, you know, middle, mid to fall of
- 25:062025. That was in the injunction plays
- 25:09it When's the national championship case is dismissed
- 25:14or closed after the season because there's no more suit
- 25:17because he already played the year and no penalties.
- 25:22Theoretically the pills are ongoing and nothing changes for
- 25:26Indiana's season and everything stands as is as of right now.
- 25:31So again, we're talking about situations here that Indiana, as
- 25:39the institution goes, really wasn't a part of the lawsuit
- 25:44that Lewis Moore filed. So they weren't a party that
- 25:48went in together with with Moore to sue the NCAA.
- 25:54They were just this entity or the school that was awaiting
- 25:59whether or not he could play this year based upon the
- 26:03lawsuit. And once that injunction was
- 26:09given, that allowed them to play them without any, you know,
- 26:14threat or issues with the NCAA. And but that's kind of the
- 26:21timeline of all this and how it's gone.
- 26:24And now we're getting into the meat of everything and what Hap
- 26:29is happening with everything when it comes to Indiana and
- 26:34where their involvement is or ends or starts and all that.
- 26:38We're going to talk about what is fact, what is fiction when it
- 26:40comes to these rules or supposed rules and what Indiana could
- 26:44jeopardize or not jeopardize. All those things.
- 26:48We're going to talk about more when we have a chance to come
- 26:51back. But I want to take a quick break
- 26:53here. Head get over to fanatics.
- 26:55Listen to the facts. I put the in the in the comments
- 26:59section tonight, put the links to the the National Title Store
- 27:04for Fanatics as well as the Indiana Basic store for
- 27:07Fanatics. We'll hear from them as well.
- 27:10And a little talk from thehoosier.com as we come back
- 27:13here in a few minutes, right back here on the Hoosier
- 27:17tailgate on the hoosier.com. Who's your fans?
- 27:21Take a moment and soak this in. Indiana is national champions,
- 27:25History made, banners raised, a season we'll talk about forever.
- 27:30And now it's time to wear the moment.
- 27:32Head to my Fanatics store and grab the official Indiana
- 27:35Hoosiers National Championship gear.
- 27:38T-shirts, hoodies, hats and championship designs built for
- 27:41fans who lived every snap, every 4th down, every win.
- 27:46This is authentic Fanatics gear, not knockoffs.
- 27:49Designed to last, Comfortable and ready to Rep anywhere you
- 27:52go. Whether you're at the game,
- 27:54around town or watching next season knowing who sits on top,
- 27:58This is how you show it. Supplies won't last forever, and
- 28:02once it's gone, it's gone. So don't wait.
- 28:06Hit the Hoosier Tailgate Fanatics store, lock in your
- 28:09Indiana National Champions gear and wear it with pride, because
- 28:13this championship is forever. Who's your fan?
- 28:22Listen up. If you're serious about the
- 28:24Hoosiers, thehoosier.com is where you need to be.
- 28:28We're talking insider reporting, film breakdowns, recruiting and
- 28:31transfer portal coverage you won't get anywhere else.
- 28:35And when you subscribe, it's more than just one site.
- 28:38You also Get full access to Rivals on Three and The Athletic
- 28:42at no extra cost. Right now, you can jump in for
- 28:45just $1.00. Then it renews annually at the
- 28:48regular rate, $1.00 total access.
- 28:52No brainer. Head to the hoosier.com and join
- 28:55today. Welcome back to the Hoosier
- 29:01Tailgate here on the hoosier.com.
- 29:05Now we're going to talk about the separation of fact from
- 29:08fiction. And there's been so many, so
- 29:11much speculation, opinions and misinformation out there.
- 29:15So I thought tonight we kind of break it down like this from the
- 29:21standpoint of what is or what isn't fact and what is fiction
- 29:28in that regard. The idea that the NCAA is about
- 29:32to punish Indiana, that narrative is not truly accurate
- 29:37because like I said, this is a lawsuit that involved Louis
- 29:40Moore and did not have anything to do with Indiana.
- 29:44We'll get to that part here in a second.
- 29:50What the NCAA is doing, they're looking for some legal precedent
- 29:54so that they can be able to enforce the rules that are on
- 29:58the books. And for them to do that and not
- 30:01continually get challenged in the court of law.
- 30:04That's why they're they're pursuing these appeals.
- 30:09And I'm not a lawyer, but I've heard some lawyers discuss this.
- 30:15They think that's going to be a long shot in itself because
- 30:18there's no case for them to appeal.
- 30:21They've been dismissed. So that's one thing as well.
- 30:25The winds will be definitely vacated.
- 30:29That's another one of those things that is been throwing out
- 30:34there that they would be essentially lose all their
- 30:38regular season games, including the Big 10 championship in that
- 30:45regard. But the only thing the NCA has
- 30:50done is discussed or bring to the forefront the restitution
- 30:54and what that is. And it's a theoretical way for
- 30:58them to go back and penalize the school for doing something that
- 31:05they had felt that they were in the right with.
- 31:08And with the NCAA, they had initially ruled Lewis Moore not
- 31:14eligible for the 2025 season. So that is going to be, again,
- 31:25like we were talking about the appeals process and why the NCAA
- 31:28is pushing so hard with it. National championship at risk.
- 31:33There has been no other penalties announced with this,
- 31:38but the NCAA does not have jurisdiction over the College
- 31:44Football Playoffs. It's a different entity than the
- 31:46NCAA had this been in basketball, where the NCAA
- 31:50tournament, the field of 64 is ran under the NCAA umbrella.
- 31:56Their national championship is ran by the NCAA umbrella, but
- 32:00the College Football Playoffs are not.
- 32:03So that pretty no pretty much locks in that Indiana's national
- 32:09title is safe and never really in jeopardy.
- 32:17Even if they said Indiana has to forfeit their regular season
- 32:20games in the Big 10 championship, theoretically they
- 32:23would finish 20253 and O because that was what their record of
- 32:27college football play offs were as a hypothetical scenario.
- 32:33But the national championship is not under the jurisdiction of
- 32:37the NCAA, so therefore they cannot vacate that under a
- 32:43penalty for Indiana unless there would be some type of an
- 32:48agreement with the college football play offs.
- 32:50And I just don't see that happening in that regard, in
- 32:57that respect. And then the other one fiction
- 32:59as they were trying to say that this lawsuit proves that there
- 33:03was wrongdoing by Indiana and that wasn't it at all.
- 33:09The only thing that was going on as it pertains to Louis Moore's
- 33:15situation and after he dropped the lawsuit or his attorney
- 33:19filed papers to drop the lawsuit, Indiana or the NCAA was
- 33:25adamant that they needed Ave. for appeal process to get a
- 33:30ruling on this scenario where it involves junior college athletes
- 33:37and how many years of eligibility do they have when
- 33:40they go to a four year institution in that respect.
- 33:44So that is been the biggest thing with Indiana in this whole
- 33:50thing. And here's some things that I
- 33:52kind of pulled out from thumbnails that I saw here and
- 33:56there. Indiana to vacate wins.
- 34:00Another one here, did Indiana cheat?
- 34:02The NCAA says yes. Again, these are all fabric, you
- 34:08know, click bait type of titles, Indiana's title under fire.
- 34:12And then the last one that I saw was more eligibility case drop
- 34:16chaos. And well, that is a little true.
- 34:19It's he did drop it, but I don't know if there's any chaos overly
- 34:23involved with it in that respect.
- 34:25So that really did not have any bearing in it.
- 34:30But that was some of the things that were out there on many
- 34:35different platforms, mostly national Big 10 type of
- 34:39platforms and other schools. I know one of the Miami
- 34:43Hurricanes site had something big on there about Indiana
- 34:49cheating and the Hurricanes could be by default the national
- 34:53champions, which was totally bogus in that regard.
- 34:56But again, you can see why people put out stuff like that.
- 35:00They want people's attention. They want to get clicks.
- 35:03They want to get people involved in their sites and stuff.
- 35:06And I get it. And that's kind of the way the
- 35:09NCAA wanted it to because like I said, they were the ones
- 35:12screaming the loudest when all this was going down over the
- 35:15last couple weeks. Has it pertained to them?
- 35:18Let's see here. Had a couple questions here.
- 35:23Punishing Indiana storybook season would end the end.
- 35:26Many already view the NCA as a paper tiger unworthy of respect.
- 35:30Any action against IU would be a horrific mistake.
- 35:34Yeah, I don't. Like I said, I I just don't
- 35:36think it's in their interest. And I think what the NCA
- 35:40ultimately is trying to do is put the fear into everybody for
- 35:47the 2026 season. And those that have filed a
- 35:51lawsuit that if they get some type of, you know, relief from
- 35:58the courts about this particular subject matter where we're
- 36:02talking during your college eligibility, going to a four
- 36:06year school, how many years you would have left, then those kids
- 36:12that are theoretically out of the eligibility would not be
- 36:17eligible. And they've already been ruled
- 36:19that way. But because they filed a lawsuit
- 36:22in the courts, now we're in a situation where for the NCAA,
- 36:26it's kind of here we go again, you know, kids going to go
- 36:31through the season and then when we go back to try the case, it's
- 36:33going to be dismissed. So I can get that in in, in that
- 36:38respects from the NCAA in that regard.
- 36:43But the whole thing is predicated on the legal theory
- 36:53of a junior college player who plays two years at a junior
- 36:58college should have an additional 2 years of or three
- 37:03years of eligibility because you get the COVID year.
- 37:06And that's not the case because when Lewis Moore came here, he
- 37:09played his junior year at Indiana, transferred because
- 37:13that was the season that Tom Allen was let go, went to Ole
- 37:16Miss, played there and he thought he had another year of
- 37:20eligibility or should be granted another year of eligibility.
- 37:23And that's kind of where this all kind of took off in that
- 37:26respect from that perspective. And that and again, the media
- 37:32narratives and things of that magnitude goes back to the fact
- 37:35is you have to understand the dynamics of what makes a rule
- 37:44and how that rule rather, you know, impacts, you know, a
- 37:49school. And we just talked about, you
- 37:53know, the transfer window and tampering and how those rules
- 37:58will be enforced moving forward. And this rule in itself, how
- 38:06this rule will ultimately be enforced moving forward.
- 38:12And it's not about penalties as it is about the legality of what
- 38:19the NCAA has from that standpoint.
- 38:24The NCAA needs to amend their rules to match the majority of
- 38:27court decision. Yeah, well, again, until they
- 38:29get a rendering or a decision on this particular type of lawsuit.
- 38:36And that's why they're wanting this appeal for these cases to
- 38:43go through and have a ruling made on the merits of the case
- 38:47per SE. That's what they are wanting and
- 38:53that's what they need to have in order to have the rules be
- 38:58effective in that regard. And again, we've changed
- 39:04overnight, it feels like from what it was in terms of two
- 39:10years ago, how the rules were interpreted before we went into
- 39:14the paying of athletes and things of that nature because
- 39:17that was a a no no two years ago to now where there are Rev
- 39:25sharing NIL money. All these other dynamics that
- 39:29are involved in college athletics now that you can
- 39:33understand why a kid may sue the NCAA for another year of
- 39:36eligibility. Because in Lewis Moore's case,
- 39:39as he put in his lawsuit, he had a $400,000 package that he was
- 39:45in jeopardy of losing if he wasn't granted the temporary
- 39:51injunction. And therefore you can see now
- 39:55why these student athletes or these kids are now wanting to
- 40:00test the waters in that regard, because if they're not a quote,
- 40:04UN quote pro prospect. They're going to make a pretty
- 40:07good chunk of money for one year being eligible to play in that
- 40:12respect. The last thing here is talking
- 40:16about what is this rule of restitution or how is this all
- 40:25brought to? How does this all come out?
- 40:30It's a legal mechanism. It's not a penalty.
- 40:33It records, like I said, a court reversal.
- 40:38Plus the NCAA has the discretionary action.
- 40:41They could choose to utilize it or they can choose not if
- 40:43something would go in their favor.
- 40:45So again, they could do all these things A-Z, but they may
- 40:52not look at it as the new life brought up of taking advantage
- 40:58of it all. And maybe they would just do a
- 41:01fine and something else to make their point, but not start doing
- 41:07the, you know, stripping away of statistics and forfeiting games
- 41:12and so forth and so on. In that respects not automatic,
- 41:18rarely applied in major cases. Again, this is just an Ave.
- 41:22The NCAA is theoretically trying to see if it's a value.
- 41:30And again, it depends on whether there's a court going to give
- 41:34them what they're they're wanting as in terms of some type
- 41:39of ruling so they can move forward on this.
- 41:44There has not been any enforcement action been issued,
- 41:48meaning the NCA has not theoretically notified Indiana
- 41:52of these are the this is the question and here are the here
- 41:57are our remedies or potential enforcement if so, if something
- 42:03comes to light with it. So nothing theoretically is out
- 42:08there, but I know the NCAA did send letters to institutions
- 42:14that had these type of players with this junior college stuff
- 42:18to let them know that if they were to win, they could in
- 42:26theory, they could come back and ask for these things to come to
- 42:32to light in the sense of stripping away statistics of the
- 42:38of the player, forfeit of games, some form of penalty and and
- 42:46monetary penalty on the school, so forth and so on.
- 42:52So they did send that out as a way to, you know, again, bump
- 42:57their chest out a little bit and say we are the legal body of
- 43:01college athletics and therefore you will follow our rules per SE
- 43:07in that respect. So again, the other thing as we
- 43:12stated earlier, the national championship is not under the
- 43:18NCAA control and therefore not up for debate as per SE a
- 43:30subject area of trying to say that they must forfeit it
- 43:34because that probably would not happen and it's kind of already
- 43:40happened anyway with Indiana winning it.
- 43:42So it makes a it's kind of a moot point in that regard.
- 43:48But the message possibility does not equal punishment.
- 43:52And I think that's the one big thing.
- 43:54So just because somebody says it's there doesn't mean it's
- 43:58actually in the form of a punishment against Indiana or
- 44:03Louis Moore in that respect. So those are some of the things
- 44:06too, that kind of got out of hand over the last couple weeks
- 44:12when it came to this particular case and how it was presented to
- 44:18the viewing or reading public about what was sent to the
- 44:21schools and how they were interpreting it and listing that
- 44:28these. This is the recourse that's
- 44:29going to happen to Indiana. They're going to have to forfeit
- 44:31games, they're going to have to pay money back.
- 44:33They're going to have to vacate the championship and they're
- 44:36going to have to pay a big fine. I mean, that was kind of how it
- 44:40was presented outwardly and that was the furthest from the truth
- 44:45because nothing had been said that Indiana was going to be
- 44:50punished for playing Lewis Moore after they had ruled him
- 44:56ineligible for the season. So that's the biggest thing
- 45:03there. Now the potential outcomes from
- 45:05all this and we talked a little bit about this earlier, so you
- 45:13can kind of see some of the worst case scenarios in all this
- 45:22potential and this is kind of the things that they were
- 45:24notified on. They could.
- 45:26Some regular season winds vacated stats adjusted
- 45:30historical record changes, administrative ruling issued and
- 45:34how it would impact the record in that respect.
- 45:39Administrative ruling. Could that mean suspension of
- 45:42Coach Signetti? Yeah, Conveying that because at
- 45:45the end of the day, even though the injunction was given, the
- 45:49NCAA wanted them to go by what they had said and said that
- 45:55Lewis Moore was not eligible to play and they didn't care
- 45:59whether ATR, a temporary restraining order was in place.
- 46:04They wanted the school to to air on the side of caution and
- 46:08that's not what schools did in that respect.
- 46:10So most likely affect not no enforcement action and appeals
- 46:17continues without penalties, administrative resolution only
- 46:21minimal competitive impact and program stability remains
- 46:26intact. No penalties have been
- 46:27announced, nor do I think there will be any at all in this
- 46:32manner because this is more like Clemson wanting Ole Miss to be
- 46:40punished for the tampering of their player.
- 46:42And it's doubtful the NCAA is going to go back and tell Ole
- 46:46Miss, well, this is what's going to happen to you.
- 46:49I think what they're trying to do, like I said earlier, they're
- 46:53trying to put a red line in the sand from this point forward and
- 47:01saying this is what's going to happen ultimately with
- 47:05everything to date that could happen to a school in the coming
- 47:13years. The key takeaways, I would say
- 47:15with this, the lawsuit involves eligibility, not a misconduct
- 47:19from Indiana's point of view, you know, from a governance
- 47:25stand standpoint, restitution is a possibility, not a penalty.
- 47:33No action has been announced. We talked about the CFP and that
- 47:39is and the national championship would not be at risk for
- 47:45Indiana. So that's kind of the the big
- 47:48picture of it all when it comes right down to it.
- 47:51And you can see that Indiana really has nothing to overly
- 47:58worry about until they have. There's a need to cross that
- 48:03bridge per SE. But I think what Indiana fans
- 48:08and the greater good of the whether it's a student body or
- 48:13anyone out there about talking about this is understanding that
- 48:19there's nothing been decided hypotheticals has all been
- 48:23presented. There's no way of knowing what
- 48:27is or isn't on the on the on the docket per SE for punishment.
- 48:33And like some of the things that I've read are it may not be
- 48:37anything in that regard from a punishment standpoint, because
- 48:41this really centered around the players eligibility and not the
- 48:45misconduct of an institution. Now, where the NCA, like I said,
- 48:49they wanted Indiana to follow the ruling that they had given
- 48:52saying he was ineligible. But Indiana's like, well, the
- 48:55judge gave him a trip temporary restraining order.
- 48:57So therefore he's eligible. And that's kind of what they
- 49:00followed and went by. And I don't blame him.
- 49:01I would have too. I mean, I'm not going to keep a
- 49:04kid that's doing the right thing out from playing when the courts
- 49:10have said there's no, there's no ruling here until we get done
- 49:17with the year and stuff from that standpoint.
- 49:19So that's the biggest thing that you can take away from here and
- 49:24that from that perspective. And like I said, if the NCAA can
- 49:31get the courts to give them a ruling on this particular rule,
- 49:37which regard in regards to a junior college number of years
- 49:41that a player played in junior college and how many years that
- 49:45would give them at a four year institution, that's what they're
- 49:49looking for. And I think what they're trying
- 49:52to do is find a way to draw the red line in the sand and say
- 49:57from this point forward, if this court says these lawsuits are
- 50:05not going to go through anymore because we've already made a
- 50:08ruling on it, but let's say a kid tries to do it.
- 50:13I think the NCAA is going to tell the school, if you playing,
- 50:17this is what's going to happen to you.
- 50:18Once we get clarification on this, and if we get the
- 50:21clarification that he truly is ineligible, then this is what is
- 50:25going to happen to you. And that's what I would be
- 50:27looking for from the future of this debacle that's out there in
- 50:33the world that we live in now as it pertains to something that,
- 50:37A, Indiana really has no control over, and B, there's no more
- 50:45suit. So how can they be in this
- 50:48respect? Because there is absolutely no
- 50:50more lawsuit on the book. So we'll see what all comes of
- 50:54that moving forward, but we got to get ourselves ready for
- 50:58spring practice as it's coming up next week.
- 51:00When we come back, we're back to football.
- 51:03No more legality. I don't just did this tonight
- 51:06because it was such a big story and so many people were talking
- 51:11like the NCAA had already made these decisions and so forth and
- 51:14so on. And it wasn't even even a case
- 51:18that they could even do what some people were trying to say
- 51:21that they're going to have. That's going to happen to
- 51:22Indiana. So next week we're going on with
- 51:25our series with the portal editions.
- 51:27We're going to start again. We're on the defensive side of
- 51:30the ball. We're going to talk about the
- 51:31two defensive ends that came here from Kansas State.
- 51:36And let me tell you, these two guys can get it.
- 51:40And I think Indiana defense is going to be off the edge, is
- 51:45going to be very in very good hands with these two young men
- 51:48that came in from Kansas State. We'll talk about them as well as
- 51:52others as we continue on our series on the portal editions at
- 51:56Indiana. But until next Thursday night,
- 51:587:30, I'm the coach, Shannon Griffith and you've been
- 52:02watching the Hoosier tailgate right here on the hoosier.com.
- 52:06Good night everybody. You.
- 52:07Have been listening to the Hoosier Tailgate Podcast with
- 52:10Coach Shannon Griffith. If you want the edge in
- 52:12recruiting, breaking news and film room breakdowns, head to
- 52:16the hoosier.com. Stay connected, stay locked in.
- 52:22Catch us on the next episode.