Man Executes Fiancée for Dumping Him At Football Party

Murder Files Unsealed · Sep 17, 2026 · 30m · transcript

On November 30, 2024, a college football watch party in St. Cloud, Florida, ended in tragedy when Timothy Haidider murdered his fiancée, Natalie "Dawn" Dume. The couple had been embroiled in a heated, alcohol-fueled argument that escalated after Dume called off their engagement and returned her ring. Haidider admitted to police that he snapped due to the rejection, retrieving a .357 Magnum and shooting Dume in the head on their back patio. During a recorded interrogation, he expressed remorse but confessed to the execution-style killing while citing past emotional trauma from previous…