Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / WTKE: Delivering the Future -- Rural Obstetrics in a Changing Maine, Part 1
Transcript
- 0:09Hello, and welcome to Working Together with Kelly Elkins. I'm your host,
- 0:12Kelly Elkins, your Chief Operating Officer for MaineHealth.
- 0:15In this podcast series, I will be joined each episode by guests who are participating
- 0:20on teams focused on how we can support and enhance how we work together across MaineHealth
- 0:26so that we can achieve our vision of working together so that our communities
- 0:30are the healthiest in America.
- 0:31In particular, we will highlight work we are doing in further development of
- 0:35our operating model for MaineHealth and how we are creating structure and processes
- 0:39that make it easier for you to do your work.
- 0:42Today's episode is titled, Delivering the Future, Rural Obstetrics in a Changing Maine.
- 0:48In today's episode, we're exploring a topic that matters deeply to families,
- 0:53communities, clinicians, and healthcare leaders across MaineHealth and the state
- 0:57of Maine, the future of rural obstetric care.
- 1:01For generations, having a baby
- 1:03close to home has been an important part of community life in rural Maine.
- 1:07Yet across our state and throughout the nation, rural maternity care is facing
- 1:11significant challenges.
- 1:13Declining birth rates, changing demographics, workforce shortages,
- 1:18and clinician expectations of work-life balance are making it increasingly difficult,
- 1:24to sustain traditional models of care in many rural communities.
- 1:28At the same time, every family deserves access to safe, high-quality care throughout
- 1:33pregnancy delivery and the postpartum period.
- 1:36So what does the future look like? How can we ensure access,
- 1:40maintain quality and safety, support our workforce and continue to meet the
- 1:45needs of patients and families across Maine?
- 1:48Are there new models of care, new partnerships, new technologies and new ways
- 1:52of working together that can help us build a stronger future?
- 1:56Today we're joined by two MaineHealth leaders who are helping shape that future.
- 2:01We'll discuss what we're learning, what challenges remain and what gives us
- 2:05hope as we work to ensure that rural communities continue to have access to
- 2:10outstanding maternal health care for generations to come.
- 2:14To join me in the conversation today are my guests, Dr. Katherine Campbell,
- 2:18Chief and Chair of the OBGYN Service Line for MaineHealth, and Dr.
- 2:22Maureen Perdue, OBGYN and Chief Medical Officer for Mid Coast Hospital.
- 2:27Welcome to the podcast. Thank you so much for the invitation. Great.
- 2:31So excited to have you all join me and dive into this topic.
- 2:35And as you all are very familiar, recently, MaineHealth announced the decision
- 2:41to discontinue birthing services at our Lincoln Hospital.
- 2:45While every community and hospital is unique, that decision reflects many of
- 2:50the challenges we are seeing today in rural communities.
- 2:53I'd like to spend a few minutes helping our listeners better understand the
- 2:57factors that health systems like ours, clinicians, and communities must consider,
- 3:03when evaluating the future of rural obstetric care.
- 3:07And so, Kat, I want to start with you just kind of stepping back a bit to say,
- 3:12what are the biggest challenges rural communities are facing when it comes to maternity care?
- 3:18Yeah, I think that's a really good place to start the conversation because this
- 3:22is a crisis across our country.
- 3:24We have labor and delivery units that are closing.
- 3:28And I think they're closing sometimes in ways where the alternative are not
- 3:33viable solutions. And so this is a challenge for our rural communities.
- 3:37People continue to live, grow their families.
- 3:40They want to put down roots in these communities.
- 3:42And I think obstetric care really pulls at people's heartstrings because it's
- 3:47where they want to start their family and to have the local hospital be able to do that.
- 3:51We're at a big transition point because how we've been successful in the past
- 3:55is not how we're going to be successful in the future.
- 3:57And we need to think creatively about how we can continue to have these obstetrics
- 4:02services present in our smaller communities and thriving. Yeah, absolutely.
- 4:07Maureen, I know you've spent a lot of your career in more rural communities and being an OBGYN.
- 4:13What are the most significant changes you've seen in rural obstetrics during your career?
- 4:19The biggest change that I've seen over the course of living and working in Maine
- 4:24is really gone are the days of the sole practitioner.
- 4:29I spent most of my career in Lewiston, and there was historically one OBGYN
- 4:36or two OBGYNs that took care of the community.
- 4:38And then I joined a practice of four, and slowly people didn't,
- 4:43you know, that wasn't enough anymore.
- 4:45And so we really started to struggle with recruiting providers to come to small
- 4:50communities, to have high call frequencies.
- 4:54And then I would say the other biggest change is just the complexity of care.
- 4:58We have sicker patients, yes, but I think we also pay attention to more about,
- 5:04the course of a pregnancy than we perhaps once did.
- 5:08It's addressing mental health issues. It's addressing social determinants of
- 5:12health. It's making sure the family is involved. It's really spending time explaining
- 5:17the labor and the birthing process.
- 5:19It's, you know, more complex testing and ultrasounds. And so just the changes
- 5:25and the complexity of prenatal and postnatal care has really evolved over the
- 5:30course of my career. Yeah.
- 5:32And, you know, you mentioned, you know, part of your career,
- 5:34you were in Lewiston, obviously with a different health system,
- 5:38and now you're with MaineHealth.
- 5:41What do you think people often misunderstand about the challenges that rural
- 5:47hospitals in particular face in maintaining obstetric services?
- 5:52The challenges that people understand are that Maine is one of the oldest and
- 5:56most rural states in the country, and our demographics contribute to lower birth
- 6:02volumes in many communities. Right.
- 6:05And in turn, lower birth volumes really challenges our workforce.
- 6:10Right. challenges competency, it challenges, you know, maintenance of skills,
- 6:14it challenges professional fulfillment by obstetrical providers,
- 6:18whether that's midwives or physicians,
- 6:20family practice doctors, because there may not be getting the volume of birth
- 6:25that that keeps them professionally fulfilled, let alone keeps them up their skills.
- 6:29I think the other component that, you know, people don't understand is about
- 6:34is really like part of the change has been, you know, kind of lifestyle and
- 6:40wanting to take care of our own families while taking care of people.
- 6:44And so that has lended itself to just chronic challenges in recruitment
- 6:50and retention of providers, which, you know, significantly strains the sustainability
- 6:55from a financial standpoint, and then again, from workforce management and the
- 7:00clinical quality and competency. Yeah, absolutely.
- 7:04Obviously a lot of maybe.
- 7:08Points that folks understand. You articulated some things that maybe general
- 7:13population who's not closest to the work or doing that work may not fully appreciate.
- 7:18We know the challenges where, as you said, we're a very rural state.
- 7:22We have an aging population. All of those things are creating a lot of these challenges.
- 7:28We know when we're faced with challenges, we're also looked to as a leading
- 7:33healthcare organization in this state of how do we find solutions for that?
- 7:38And it's not just something as, Kat, as you mentioned, that we're facing alone.
- 7:43It's happening all over the country in many, many states, including states that
- 7:47are extremely rural like Maine.
- 7:50So what kind of innovative models are you both hearing about that are emerging
- 7:56around the country that we in Maine should be paying attention to?
- 7:59Kat, you want to take that first? Sure.
- 8:02I think the background in thinking about obstetric care is that medicine and
- 8:06healthcare is just changing exponentially.
- 8:09The amount of new information that we get on a day-to-day basis that is impactful
- 8:15enough to change the way we do things is happening not only in cardiology,
- 8:19but it happens in obstetrics.
- 8:20And so, for many, people have their baby a very similar way they did in our previous generations.
- 8:27I think as Maureen was alluding to, I think we're more conscientious about where
- 8:32our care can be really beneficial to our patients.
- 8:35And we're more responsive to common comorbidities, like things like hypertension,
- 8:41mental health, higher BMIs.
- 8:44And some of the models that have
- 8:46been coming out are really thinking about obstetric care as a shift work.
- 8:51And it's very different from how I think many have thought about their obstetrician
- 8:56or their midwife or their family medicine doctor and their interactions with
- 9:01them during cranial care and during their labor and delivery. This has been studied.
- 9:06And there are lots of data out there that show that looking at labor and delivery
- 9:11as a shift work environment actually helps improve outcomes for our patients.
- 9:15And that's because labor takes time, right? We want to be patient with our patients.
- 9:20We want them to enter labor at their pace. We want to support them through their labor course.
- 9:25And that doesn't always coincide with office hours, Friday night,
- 9:29Sunday mornings, and scheduled surgeries.
- 9:32And so when you set up a shift work model, it actually alleviates a lot of those
- 9:37pressures because you have a team on the floor able to take care of patients.
- 9:41And this has worked very well in high volume places, right? So they can absorb
- 9:45these differences in models a little bit easier because they can try it.
- 9:49They have the volume to support it, and then they can adopt what's working well.
- 9:53So I think, you know, we take from what has been looked at and we adapt it to
- 9:59what we need here in places that have lower birth volumes.
- 10:03And I think this is an example of how we can start looking at alternative ways
- 10:08and new ways to fit sort of modern life of how we can give really high quality
- 10:13obstetric care because we do want our smaller hospitals to stay open.
- 10:17And so I think it's thinking about, can we develop a laborious model?
- 10:21Who are our obstetric providers, right? We talk about OBGYNs,
- 10:24we talk about family medicine, we talk about midwives.
- 10:26And I think we need to be really collaborative and clever about how we bring
- 10:30those teams together to really support a local labor and delivery.
- 10:33We have to be open-minded because it might look really different from how we've
- 10:38been doing it. But I think the ultimate
- 10:40goal is having really high quality obstetric care for our families.
- 10:44Part of it, I know we've been talking a lot about labor and delivery,
- 10:47but so much of that care happens in the office with patient's primary OB provider.
- 10:53Pre-pregnancy, during pregnancy, and then postpartum, which we understand to
- 10:56be very critical parts of having a successful pregnancy.
- 11:00As we update and rebuild some of the ways we deliver that sort of hospital obstetric care.
- 11:07Along with that, we think about what we're doing in the outpatient setting and
- 11:10how we're providing that outpatient obstetric care.
- 11:13Maureen, what about you? Any other innovative models that are,
- 11:17top of mind, really thinking about Maine Health and considering maternal care
- 11:22across the state from a system approach, I think is going to be critical.
- 11:25I think interdisciplinary, interdependent, system-based approach to taking care,
- 11:31of women and pregnant women across the state is crucial.
- 11:34I think that will foster relationships down to Maine Medical Center,
- 11:39where our tertiary care center lives, where our maternal field medicine experts in pregnancy are.
- 11:44And by having some protocols, by having the same, you know, simulation and education opportunities,
- 11:52by strengthening our workforce through floating opportunities,
- 11:56nurses being able to float perhaps to different places to make sure that they maintain their skills.
- 12:01I think that we have an opportunity to employ telehealth in a more robust fashion
- 12:06so that patients who are, you know, further away from Portland can have,
- 12:10you know, high-risk pregnancy consultation,
- 12:12American College of OBGYN and the Society of Maternal Fetal Medicine,
- 12:16you know, have demonstrated that, you know, patient experience for these opportunities is really high.
- 12:21Especially for things like chronic disease management, our diabetes,
- 12:25our hypertensive disorders of pregnancy.
- 12:27It doesn't completely replace the in-person visits, but it's a tool that we
- 12:31need to strengthen to make sure that patients are getting the access to the
- 12:36high-risk care that they need while being closer to home.
- 12:40And then similarly, we need to make sure that, you know, as a healthcare system,
- 12:44we're strengthening our infrastructure.
- 12:46And that's going to include our emergency medical personnel and our transport folks.
- 12:52And I think those are really focusing as the interdisciplinary and interdependent
- 12:58approach as a priority is that, you know, innovative model that the system and
- 13:04the state need to employ to make sure that we're successful in the future.
- 13:07Absolutely. And you were touching on it a little bit, but maybe have you go
- 13:12a little deeper to MaineHealth,
- 13:15We obviously are, in and of itself, what we would consider a regional health system.
- 13:21But within our organization, we have geographic regions.
- 13:25And so as we think about this work, how can regional systems or hospitals within a region,
- 13:33whether they're part of MaineHealth or another organization,
- 13:36how can we be working together differently to provide both that local access, but also.
- 13:43Access to the highly specialized level of care you may need when you're delivering.
- 13:49Within our kind of region, Maine is a little bit unique in that we have lots
- 13:53of small community hospitals and critical access hospitals as opposed to several really big hospitals.
- 13:58So I think we still have within the coastal region where Mid Coast is,
- 14:03where Lincoln Hospital is, Waldo and Pen Bay, we have, you know,
- 14:06still small hospitals that are really, you know, delivering,
- 14:09you know, 400 to 500 or so deliveries a year.
- 14:13And I think where we can strengthen our work together is really, again, on having some,
- 14:21system level leadership that is clinical based, that is thinking about quality,
- 14:26safety, it's thinking about competencies, thinking about skill building.
- 14:30To Kat's point, thinking differently about how we work with our OBGYNs,
- 14:35our obstetric providers, family practice docs, I think are going to be all the,
- 14:40ways that we can work together to make this a success. Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:45So Kat, I was wondering if we could dig a little deeper into the role that the
- 14:52different types of providers really can help play in the future of the workforce.
- 14:57Because workforce shortages, they're there inherently in all areas of specialty
- 15:03and clinical care, again, not just in Maine, but across the country.
- 15:08What role do, you've talked about midwives, certified nurse midwives,
- 15:13family medicine physicians, advanced practice providers, where do you see their
- 15:19roles really playing in this space?
- 15:22And to your point, is there like a set model in which we should be thinking
- 15:28about how all these different types of providers come into play?
- 15:33Or do we need to be a little more open to how we use and complement the workforce?
- 15:40Yeah, I think it's a really good question that it's something that's come up
- 15:44in lots of different conversations.
- 15:46And I want to just sort of go back to a point that Maureen made earlier about standardization.
- 15:52And standardization of different guidelines of how we treat common obstetric
- 15:56problems, just common obstetric occurrences, and having that system-wide and
- 16:01even coordinating across the state.
- 16:04You will commonly hear a counter to that is that people are trained as professionals,
- 16:09as clinicians, and, you know, they're able to make the decisions for patients.
- 16:12And it starts to sound sort of cookbook is what I hear.
- 16:17And I actually would push back against that and think that.
- 16:21When you standardize and have guidelines, some policies, some ways that you
- 16:26do things regardless of which hospital you're at,
- 16:29it actually helps us start to build this newer approach to obstetric care because
- 16:34then you can have a float system and you can be someone who
- 16:39is at Lincoln Hospital and then maybe they need to have some turn on a dime
- 16:45just in time coverage at Franklin Hospital and they're able to go there.
- 16:49And success in obstetrics, it actually, you can compare it really closely to sport.
- 16:55It's very much a team-based specialty. We rely on specialized roles from our
- 17:01specialized nursing care to obstetricians, to midwives, to family medicine doctors,
- 17:07and everyone has their own role.
- 17:09And if you can have similar expectations at different hospitals,
- 17:14then you can start building in a care model that can work in a rural state like Maine.
- 17:19And that's where you also have this collaborative care, because I do agree the
- 17:22workforce shortage is real.
- 17:25This is not unique to Maine. It's happening in other states as well.
- 17:28And it's even happening in states that have urban populations.
- 17:32And so I think there have been models where success comes from having your trainees local.
- 17:39Inviting trainees from outside programs into Maine to do their rotations where
- 17:44they get to know people. It's very common where people do their training and
- 17:48get to know the system and the people.
- 17:51It increases the likelihood that they stay.
- 17:53And so I think we need to be thinking about that. And MaineHealth has really
- 17:57done a good job, right, with the collaboration with Tufts, having the Maine
- 18:01Track medical students.
- 18:02Many choose to stay in Maine for their residencies, and then they set up and
- 18:06they practice medicine here in Maine. And I think we need to be thinking about
- 18:09that for other team members that are part of an obstetric team.
- 18:12It's like, right, how are we training our surgical technicians?
- 18:16Where are we training our ultrasonographers? Are we giving them good access
- 18:20as young people entering the workforce so that they could train here and have a job here?
- 18:25And thinking about midwife rotations, family medicine rotations,
- 18:29you know, I think it's come up commonly, family medicine, OB with cesarean delivery
- 18:35skills, and there are fellowships across the country.
- 18:38Is that something? We don't have a fellowship right now.
- 18:41Is that something that would be beneficial to us? And I think when we get to
- 18:45train our workforce, then it also helps us with the standardization because
- 18:51it becomes an expectation. And so I do believe in collaborative obstetrics.
- 18:55I do think we provide the highest level of care by bringing these various OB
- 19:00providers with different areas of expertise together.
- 19:03It does take some coordination. And I think too, it takes trust.
- 19:07You know, I've worked in inpatient obstetrics my whole career.
- 19:11And as you're getting to know other people on your team, there's always that
- 19:15period of time where you just, if you don't know the other person,
- 19:18it just takes a little bit of time until you know,
- 19:21how you're going to work together, what they're able to do, how you're going
- 19:24to communicate. And so I think that's important, too, in building your teams.
- 19:27But I think the diversity is going to help us thrive.
- 19:30Maureen, you mentioned this a few moments ago, a little bit about,
- 19:34you know, within our system, the Medical Center in Portland is
- 19:38really our tertiary center, highest level of care for most specialties,
- 19:44not just within our system, but the state is delivered.
- 19:47Can you speak a little more about how can,
- 19:50more tertiary providers or larger community hospital settings really partner
- 19:56with rural community hospitals providers,
- 20:01really to stay connected and support patients closest to their home?
- 20:06Because, you know, and Kat, you mentioned it earlier, you know,
- 20:09pregnancy is a long journey.
- 20:11Our patients, we always want them to, as most times as possible,
- 20:16receive their care closest to home.
- 20:18Talk to me about, like, how you see that working in today's environment and
- 20:22or in, you know, other environments you've worked in in Maine.
- 20:26I think the single most important thing that we need to continue to build,
- 20:31which I think has improved over the course of my career in Maine is communication and relationships.
- 20:37I was sharing with Kat that until I joined MaineHealth, I didn't really know
- 20:42the MFMs, maternal field medicine doctors, other than a phone call for a transfer here and there.
- 20:47And I didn't really know the OBGYNs that work at Maine Medical Center.
- 20:51I didn't train at Maine Medical Center.
- 20:53And there is a difference when you make a phone call and you know the person
- 20:58you're talking to and the way that you communicate and the trust
- 21:02and the ability to be like, I have your back and we're going to figure out how
- 21:07we're going to best take care of this patient.
- 21:08And I think we're making great strides at building and fostering those relationships,
- 21:14because it will benefit our patients if we're all working together,
- 21:18if we're all speaking the same language, and if we're all, you know, have the same vision.
- 21:24That is my goal with, you know, kind of bringing the Mid Coast and Lincoln teams
- 21:29together in an integrated fashion is that by communicating well,
- 21:33by having relationships, by knowing one another, we can all be stronger and
- 21:37we can take care of patients better.
- 21:39Yeah, absolutely. And so I think that hub and spoke model that is going to be
- 21:43essential for obstetric care across the state is really going to rely on outreach,
- 21:49and relationship building. Yeah, absolutely.
- 21:53One, I want to thank you both for engaging in the really the first part of this
- 21:57conversation, which is kind of outlining and better understanding not just the
- 22:02challenges, but the other factors that really are shaping the environment we're in.
- 22:06And as we think about rural obstetrics delivery into the future,
- 22:11We're going to wrap up the conversation, but we hope everyone stays tuned for
- 22:15part two of the podcast where we're going to move from kind of the challenges into,
- 22:21how our health systems making these hard decisions and what aspects do we need to consider.
- 22:26So thank you both and look forward to continuing the conversation. Thank you. Thank you.
- 22:32Well, I hope that you found this episode informative and provides a deeper insight
- 22:36into one of our major areas of focus.
- 22:38As we continue to enhance how we work together as MaineHealth to achieve our
- 22:43vision of working together so that our communities are the healthiest in America.
- 22:48If you have ideas for topics for
- 22:50future podcasts, please email those to workingtogether@mainehealth.org.
- 22:56Thank you and have a blessed day. ---