Latest / I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin / The death investigator: Hugh Dillon Pt.1
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: The public has had a long held fascination with detectives.
- 0:05Speaker 1: Detective see aside of life the average person is never
- 0:08Speaker 1: exposed to. I spent thirty four years as a cop.
- 0:11Speaker 1: For twenty five of those years I was catching killers.
- 0:14Speaker 1: That's what I did for a living. I was a
- 0:16Speaker 1: homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead,
- 0:20Speaker 1: I'm taking the public into the world in which I operated.
- 0:23Speaker 1: The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories
- 0:26Speaker 1: from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw
- 0:28Speaker 1: and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some
- 0:31Speaker 1: of the content and language might be confronting. That's because
- 0:34Speaker 1: no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged.
- 0:38Speaker 1: Join me now as I take you into this world. Today,
- 0:47Speaker 1: I had the privilege of sitting down having a chat
- 0:49Speaker 1: with former New South Wales Deputy State Coroner Hugh Dylon.
- 0:54Speaker 1: I say privilege because Hugh shares a passion very much
- 0:57Speaker 1: aligned with what I considered the most important I had
- 1:00Speaker 1: as a homicide detective. That was looking after the families
- 1:04Speaker 1: of people who have died in the tragic, violent and
- 1:07Speaker 1: unusual circumstances, bringing whatever comfort possible to the deceased. Families
- 1:11Speaker 1: by providing answers as to what happened to their loved
- 1:14Speaker 1: ones and where possible prevent unnecessary deaths. Throughout his career,
- 1:19Speaker 1: Hugh presided over more than three hundred inquests, including the
- 1:23Speaker 1: horrific School of Happiness case where one man hunted police
- 1:27Speaker 1: with a crossbow in the middle of the night during
- 1:29Speaker 1: the Hippie festival. He also oversaw murders, suicides, and tragic
- 1:35Speaker 1: accidental deaths.
- 1:36Speaker 2: As you'll find.
- 1:37Speaker 1: Out in our discussion, the coroner's court is filled with sadness.
- 1:41Speaker 1: In the motion, Hugh takes us through the cases of
- 1:44Speaker 1: the oversaw, how the system can be improved, and the
- 1:47Speaker 1: personal impact of dealing with death on a daily basis.
- 1:52Speaker 1: Hugh Dylan, thanks for coming on I Catch Killers.
- 1:55Speaker 3: It's a great pleasure. Gren very nice to see you again.
- 1:57Speaker 1: Well, it is good to see you, and I always
- 2:00Speaker 1: I had a lot of respect for the role that
- 2:02Speaker 1: you did as a coroner, and you were the deputy
- 2:06Speaker 1: state coroner or is a coroner for nine years. Yes,
- 2:09Speaker 1: that's right, and in prepping for it, I believe that
- 2:13Speaker 1: you oversaw probably three hundred roughly three hundred question.
- 2:17Speaker 3: Yeah, it's a bit hard to work. It out exactly,
- 2:21Speaker 3: but a round about three hundred, I'd.
- 2:22Speaker 2: Say, yeah, it's a lot.
- 2:24Speaker 1: And I don't think people fully appreciate the impact that
- 2:29Speaker 1: the coroner's court has. I found it in all the
- 2:32Speaker 1: areas of policing I work. That's when I saw the
- 2:35Speaker 1: most emotion at coroner's courts, because you're talking about someone's died.
- 2:41Speaker 1: That's generally what the inquest is about. And you've got
- 2:44Speaker 1: the families and loved ones there holding on to hope
- 2:47Speaker 1: or trying to get answers.
- 2:49Speaker 2: Is that how you felt?
- 2:50Speaker 3: Yeah, Look, it's a surprising place. It's a surprising niche
- 2:58Speaker 3: in the legal system, and most people in the law,
- 3:02Speaker 3: most people in society have no idea. But I can
- 3:07Speaker 3: remember the first day I went to the coroner's court.
- 3:10Speaker 3: I was a new magistrate and I was really surprised
- 3:15Speaker 3: by it. Apart from anything else. The coroners were doing this,
- 3:21Speaker 3: this kind of work that no other lawyers in our
- 3:24Speaker 3: society do. And also they're working in teams and as
- 3:30Speaker 3: you say, their concern is or who has died, how
- 3:36Speaker 3: they've died, why they've died, but also what can we
- 3:40Speaker 3: say to the families and the families My father was
- 3:44Speaker 3: a coroner's case himself around about forty years ago, and
- 3:49Speaker 3: I remember, I remember very very well getting the news
- 3:54Speaker 3: that he died suddenly, and the shock and the confusion
- 4:00Speaker 3: that that throws you into. So to walk into this
- 4:04Speaker 3: place as a coroner, and to try and grapple with
- 4:10Speaker 3: that confusion, the bewilderment, and of course the sadness was
- 4:16Speaker 3: somewhat bewildering to me as well. But Garry I really
- 4:22Speaker 3: liked being a coroner, and some people would be astonished
- 4:27Speaker 3: to hear me say that, I guess, because of course
- 4:31Speaker 3: you're right. It is a very sad place in lots
- 4:33Speaker 3: of ways. Families are devastated, they're confused, one answers. Sometimes
- 4:40Speaker 3: they have interesting theories about how someone they love has died.
- 4:48Speaker 3: Some of those theories are right, but some of them
- 4:50Speaker 3: are wrong. And it's very difficult to walk people into
- 4:55Speaker 3: the evidence and through it and then bring them to
- 4:59Speaker 3: some sort of understanding, some sense of what happened. I
- 5:06Speaker 3: think some people might call this sense making, you know,
- 5:08Speaker 3: how do we make sense of these terrible events.
- 5:11Speaker 1: There's a lot of expectation when people get to the
- 5:14Speaker 1: coroner's court. I saw that over the years with families
- 5:17Speaker 1: and it's almost like, Okay, the answer is going to
- 5:20Speaker 1: be forthcoming when the matter gets to the coroner's court,
- 5:23Speaker 1: and I think meeting the family's expectation or that's a
- 5:27Speaker 1: difficult part too, because sometimes the facts don't present the
- 5:31Speaker 1: way the family expected it to, and quite often the
- 5:34Speaker 1: evidence that is given at a coronial inquest is quite
- 5:38Speaker 1: confronting to the families and loved ones of the deceased person.
- 5:42Speaker 3: Well, that's right, And although you're always very glad as
- 5:46Speaker 3: a coroner if you have found the answers, there are
- 5:51Speaker 3: lots of cases where you don't, and you, as a
- 5:53Speaker 3: homicide or an ex homicide detective, would be very familiar
- 5:57Speaker 3: with some of those cases. You know, there are unsolved
- 6:01Speaker 3: homicides as well as you know all the I want
- 6:05Speaker 3: to call them happy endings, but they're cases in which
- 6:09Speaker 3: there is an answer for people. And to leave people
- 6:13Speaker 3: without answers is it's not only very frustrating, but it's
- 6:17Speaker 3: also very sad because you can't help empathizing and feeling
- 6:23Speaker 3: for them but also with them. You know, if you
- 6:27Speaker 3: lose a daughter, you know, I'm thinking about my daughter
- 6:30Speaker 3: as I'm talking to you about you losing yours. What
- 6:36Speaker 3: a shattering and incomplete kind of sense of life you
- 6:43Speaker 3: might have. So, as I say, sometimes you can provide
- 6:47Speaker 3: answers and that can give people a sense of resolution.
- 6:51Speaker 3: I don't believe there's any such thing as closure. I
- 6:54Speaker 3: think that's a false hope.
- 6:57Speaker 1: I'm glad you say that, and that tells me you
- 7:00Speaker 1: understand the situation that families go through. And I got
- 7:04Speaker 1: clipped very early in my career when use the word
- 7:08Speaker 1: closure to a family and they pointed out very very
- 7:12Speaker 1: clear to me, it's not the closure. You never get
- 7:14Speaker 1: closure from that. And that's what happens when and it's
- 7:17Speaker 1: not always homicide. If someone's I would find that in
- 7:22Speaker 1: the courrner's court. Those tragic accidents are hard to deal
- 7:25Speaker 1: with too, because I look at homicide and often the
- 7:30Speaker 1: families can allocate blame to a particular person. Where there's
- 7:34Speaker 1: accidents where there's the fault, like there's built up anger
- 7:38Speaker 1: and sadness and that it's nowhere to channel it.
- 7:41Speaker 3: That's right, and I think the families of missing people
- 7:46Speaker 3: have a particularly onerous load to bear. I guess if
- 7:51Speaker 3: you can bury your your loved ones, you can have
- 7:57Speaker 3: a sense of not camp or anything like that. But
- 8:01Speaker 3: you can say goodbye, but all you have is your
- 8:06Speaker 3: last memories of them, and then they disappear off the
- 8:10Speaker 3: face of the earth. How do you deal with that?
- 8:14Speaker 3: I really don't know, and I never really learned how
- 8:17Speaker 3: to how to give people a sense of peace or
- 8:23Speaker 3: any sense of forward movement. I think the only thing
- 8:28Speaker 3: you can do for people where their loved ones disappear
- 8:34Speaker 3: is respect, recognition. You know, we will do our best
- 8:38Speaker 3: to find out what happened, but sometimes the answer is
- 8:43Speaker 3: beyond reach.
- 8:44Speaker 2: That's not there.
- 8:45Speaker 1: I saw with families on missing persons cases quite often
- 8:49Speaker 1: that I felt like it was a step that helped
- 8:51Speaker 1: them in processing what had happened when the coroner would
- 8:54Speaker 1: declare the person deceased. Because what I've seen with families
- 8:59Speaker 1: and friends of people who have just disappeared, they always
- 9:03Speaker 1: hang on to that smidge and of hope that the
- 9:05Speaker 1: person's going to walk through the door one day and
- 9:08Speaker 1: they're going to yell at the person, go what have
- 9:09Speaker 1: you done? And then they're going to give each other
- 9:12Speaker 1: a big cuddle and get on with their lives. So
- 9:15Speaker 1: I think sometimes they hold on to hope, and quite
- 9:18Speaker 1: often I've seen it in cranial inquest where the coroner's
- 9:21Speaker 1: declared the person deceased manner and cause might have known,
- 9:25Speaker 1: but believe that the person is deceased because of checks
- 9:29Speaker 1: that have been done, and I feel like it's a
- 9:31Speaker 1: step forward. But the coroner's court I always found the
- 9:35Speaker 1: expectations were high by the families. It was a lot
- 9:39Speaker 1: of it's built up like if the investigation into the
- 9:43Speaker 1: death of someone hasn't revealed the information or the person responsible.
- 9:48Speaker 1: Quite often the hope is, well, we'll get the answers
- 9:50Speaker 1: at the coroner's court. But that's not always the way,
- 9:52Speaker 1: and that must have carried hard on you being a coroner,
- 9:56Speaker 1: that the family is steering. But where else do we go?
- 9:58Speaker 1: And the sad part is sometimes there is nowhere else
- 10:01Speaker 1: to go after the coroner's court.
- 10:02Speaker 3: Yeah, and it's very frustrating. And from time to time
- 10:09Speaker 3: I think coroners I think they fail people by not
- 10:15Speaker 3: saying what they really think. Sometimes, I think, and I've
- 10:19Speaker 3: seen this happen, particularly within experienced coroners, they will simply
- 10:24Speaker 3: because they know how sad people are and how hard
- 10:28Speaker 3: it will hit them. If you say I think your
- 10:31Speaker 3: loved one is dead, they say, oh, well, you know
- 10:36Speaker 3: the evidence isn't quite sufficient, so maybe they're still soften that. Yeah,
- 10:41Speaker 3: And I to be honest, I think that does not
- 10:47Speaker 3: help people cope with what has actually happened. If someone
- 10:52Speaker 3: has disappeared and they've I mean very occasionally people do
- 10:57Speaker 3: turn up. I know, we all know that, but it
- 11:00Speaker 3: is so rare. It's just once in many, many blue moons.
- 11:06Speaker 3: And I think as a coroner you have a duty
- 11:09Speaker 3: of care both to the dead in respect to them,
- 11:13Speaker 3: but also to the families to be upfront with families
- 11:17Speaker 3: and say, the investigation has got this far, we don't
- 11:22Speaker 3: know precisely what happened, but your loved one more than
- 11:27Speaker 3: likely is dead. We can't prove it beyond a reasonable doubt,
- 11:31Speaker 3: aps but it's almost certain. So that's all we can do.
- 11:36Speaker 2: I think.
- 11:36Speaker 1: I think that's kind of false hope. Can be a
- 11:39Speaker 1: very cruel thing if false hope is offered out. So
- 11:43Speaker 1: I think roll of a coroner and that is quite
- 11:46Speaker 1: often the final step for families trying to find out
- 11:49Speaker 1: what's happened to their loved one, especially with people who disappeared.
- 11:53Speaker 1: Tell us what was your story into becoming a coroner?
- 11:56Speaker 2: Ah?
- 11:56Speaker 3: Well, I obviously did a law degree in Australia, coroners
- 12:01Speaker 3: are lawyers. In New South Bales, they're all magistrates. I
- 12:06Speaker 3: did some legal research, I worked for a judge, I
- 12:11Speaker 3: worked for the New South Bale's ombudsman, and then I
- 12:13Speaker 3: got a job as a Comwealth prosecutor. So I worked
- 12:16Speaker 3: for the Commonwealth DPP for a number of years. Then
- 12:20Speaker 3: I was appointed a magistrate. Did about twelve years as
- 12:24Speaker 3: a magistrate and I was on the point of leaving
- 12:27Speaker 3: the magistracy and my friend Mary Durham, who was the
- 12:32Speaker 3: new state coroner, heard that I was contemplating leaving and
- 12:37Speaker 3: she got in touch with me and asked me whether
- 12:40Speaker 3: i'd like to have a go as a coroner. And
- 12:44Speaker 3: to be honest, I thought, oh my god, this is
- 12:46Speaker 3: so depressing, this kind of work. But I really liked Mary,
- 12:52Speaker 3: and she said, well, she said a few flattering things
- 12:56Speaker 3: about me, so I found it out to say no
- 12:59Speaker 3: to her, to be me very forthros, very forthright. She
- 13:04Speaker 3: also is very persuasive, and I thought, okay, well, I've
- 13:09Speaker 3: put off going to the bar for six months, I'll
- 13:11Speaker 3: go and see what this is like. You know, all
- 13:14Speaker 3: experience is good experience, and I really when I got there,
- 13:20Speaker 3: I really liked the work, partly because I was working
- 13:25Speaker 3: with really good people like Mary. But one of the
- 13:28Speaker 3: things i'd really missed as a magistrate was working in
- 13:31Speaker 3: a team. And Gary, you know what it's like working
- 13:35Speaker 3: in teams most homicide cases.
- 13:40Speaker 2: You share the pressure, so the pressure.
- 13:42Speaker 3: But it's also sharing ideas and a community, a small community,
- 13:49Speaker 3: a team can generate more ideas than a bunch of
- 13:54Speaker 3: single individuals, definitely, and so strangely enough, although the work
- 14:02Speaker 3: could be very confronting and very sad and saddening, I
- 14:08Speaker 3: really enjoyed working with the team of people I was
- 14:11Speaker 3: working with. So instead of leaving after six months, I
- 14:16Speaker 3: stayed and I just stayed on until basically the chief
- 14:20Speaker 3: magistrate said, well, your time's up. You've had enough time
- 14:25Speaker 3: here and you're coming back to the local court. And
- 14:28Speaker 3: I thought, well, no, I'm not. I like being a coroner.
- 14:32Speaker 3: I don't want to be a magistrate anymore. So that's
- 14:36Speaker 3: when I.
- 14:37Speaker 2: Left, decide to leave.
- 14:39Speaker 1: It's funny that you get rotated, or a tap on
- 14:43Speaker 1: the shoulder that you've been there too long. I would
- 14:45Speaker 1: imagine something in the role of a pathway as a coroner,
- 14:50Speaker 1: you'd be learning all the time. Yeah, yeah, you'd be
- 14:53Speaker 1: learning how not just the processes in place, but how
- 14:56Speaker 1: to deal with families and all that. I could imagine
- 14:59Speaker 1: every day you went to work.
- 15:01Speaker 3: Look, I think that's absolutely right. And I remember saying too,
- 15:07Speaker 3: we had this rotation, three year rotation thing, and I
- 15:10Speaker 3: remember saying to the Chief Magistrate, I don't think I
- 15:14Speaker 3: was any good at this job until I've been in
- 15:17Speaker 3: it for two years, that makes sense. And then so
- 15:20Speaker 3: three years I'm just starting really to get good at it.
- 15:25Speaker 3: And I thought I wasn't an expert coroner until i'd
- 15:29Speaker 3: been doing it for five years. But look, after I left,
- 15:34Speaker 3: I've done further study. I've done a PhD, which is
- 15:36Speaker 3: a study of then you Saitho's coronial system, and I've
- 15:42Speaker 3: learned so much more. So I know that you're absolutely right.
- 15:47Speaker 3: Nine years I was learning all the time, and since
- 15:50Speaker 3: I left the Coroner's Court, I've been learning even more.
- 15:54Speaker 3: So you need to stay in these jobs to get
- 15:56Speaker 3: really good at that.
- 15:57Speaker 1: Well, it is a specialist field. I would imagine that
- 16:00Speaker 1: the role of a magistrate as compared to the role
- 16:02Speaker 1: of a current is vastly different.
- 16:05Speaker 3: Very very different. A magistrate's job is primarily running small
- 16:11Speaker 3: summary trials and sentencing. So some days you sit in
- 16:16Speaker 3: a court and sentence people who are pleading guilty to
- 16:20Speaker 3: various things. Other days you have hearings. You might do
- 16:25Speaker 3: bails and apprehended violence applications and that sort of stuff.
- 16:31Speaker 3: After a while, it becomes very repetitious. You'd become to
- 16:34Speaker 3: be perfectly honest, I think I was quite a good magistrate.
- 16:39Speaker 3: But practice makes perfect and you're doing a lot of practice.
- 16:43Speaker 3: So after a couple of years of that, I think
- 16:45Speaker 3: I was pretty pretty good at it. After five years
- 16:49Speaker 3: of it, I really needed a change, and so I
- 16:52Speaker 3: did civil civil cases mainly. And again, it took me
- 16:57Speaker 3: about five years before I thought I was experted that,
- 17:01Speaker 3: and then the coroner's job came on.
- 17:04Speaker 1: Okay, can you explain what the role of the coroner's
- 17:07Speaker 1: court is? So I obviously aware of it, but if
- 17:11Speaker 1: you could explain to the listeners, because I think there's
- 17:13Speaker 1: a misconception on some of the aspects of coroner's courts
- 17:16Speaker 1: what their role is.
- 17:17Speaker 3: If you could explain, it's death investigation, So if someone
- 17:23Speaker 3: dies suddenly or in an unexplained or difficult to understand way,
- 17:30Speaker 3: or due to an unnatural cause, accidents, suicide, homicides, these
- 17:37Speaker 3: sort of things in our society, and since the twelfth
- 17:42Speaker 3: century actually there have been coroners who investigated these sudden,
- 17:47Speaker 3: unexplained or unnatural deaths. The coroners are one of the
- 17:52Speaker 3: oldest legal institutions in the world and so Australia imported
- 17:59Speaker 3: coroners when first Fleet arrived. The first in quest in
- 18:03Speaker 3: Australia was in December seventeen eighty eight a convict diet
- 18:07Speaker 3: and a inquest was held. And so we've had this
- 18:12Speaker 3: two hundred and fifty odd years of people inquiring into
- 18:17Speaker 3: how a death came about. And it's a very different
- 18:21Speaker 3: process from a criminal trial, as you're well aware.
- 18:25Speaker 1: If you could break that down as well, because I
- 18:27Speaker 1: think people think sometimes it mata goes to the coroner
- 18:30Speaker 1: and the coroner could find this person guilty of in
- 18:32Speaker 1: the fence, but that's not the case at all, and
- 18:34Speaker 1: that's a whole different set of rules.
- 18:36Speaker 3: Well, even if you think a person is guilty of
- 18:39Speaker 3: criminal offense, you have no jurisdiction to decide that. That
- 18:44Speaker 3: has to be decided elsewhere by that first of all,
- 18:47Speaker 3: by the DPP and then by a criminal court. But
- 18:51Speaker 3: to go back, what's the process. Well, first of all,
- 18:55Speaker 3: I talked about teams. The coroner's seigners work in a system,
- 19:01Speaker 3: a coronial system, and it's a multidisciplinary system. You were
- 19:06Speaker 3: part of it. I was part of it. Forensic pathologists
- 19:09Speaker 3: are part of it. Family counselors, support people, administrators, etc.
- 19:14Speaker 3: Are part of it. But the first thing that happens,
- 19:17Speaker 3: of course, is that someone reports a death, and that's
- 19:21Speaker 3: usually done by police officers. So police might be called
- 19:28Speaker 3: to a hospital because someone's diet of injuries or something
- 19:32Speaker 3: like that. The doctors will report to the police, the
- 19:36Speaker 3: police will report to the coroner, and then there'll be
- 19:39Speaker 3: a medical examination. The coroners and the forensic pathologists will
- 19:45Speaker 3: decide how to examine the person's body for evidence of
- 19:51Speaker 3: the physiological or the medical cause of death. So that's
- 19:55Speaker 3: the first stage. Of course. Families are notified and there's
- 20:01Speaker 3: a whole process of informing them, which is a shattering event,
- 20:06Speaker 3: as I was talking about a little while ago, really
- 20:10Speaker 3: shattering event for people. So there's a process of talking
- 20:18Speaker 3: family members into this strange process. They may have heard
- 20:23Speaker 3: about or may not have heard about, but most of
- 20:27Speaker 3: them will never have experienced before. So how do you
- 20:32Speaker 3: bring people into that. That's part of it. So we
- 20:35Speaker 3: have a team. We had a team at the Corners
- 20:38Speaker 3: Court family Support team and the forensic pathologists also had
- 20:44Speaker 3: social workers who are dealing with families. Then we have
- 20:49Speaker 3: police involved. If the circumstances of a case look like
- 20:54Speaker 3: they're unnatural, if the cause of death is looks like
- 20:58Speaker 3: it's unnatural, then the police will do an investigation on
- 21:02Speaker 3: behalf of the coroners. Sometimes that will look like a
- 21:06Speaker 3: homicide investigation, and if it is a homicide, it'll be
- 21:10Speaker 3: a very very thorough investigation. If it's an accident, there
- 21:14Speaker 3: will also be a police investigation. There may be other
- 21:17Speaker 3: experts called in aviation experts or all sorts of people.
- 21:23Speaker 3: If someone takes their own life, there will also be
- 21:27Speaker 3: a police investigation, and that will be somewhat different from
- 21:32Speaker 3: a homicide investigation because clearly, not only has a person
- 21:39Speaker 3: whom other people love died taken their own life or
- 21:43Speaker 3: apparently so, the family will be so psychologically shaken by
- 21:50Speaker 3: this that they need real care. And that's difficult because
- 21:56Speaker 3: the first responders will usually be young. Police office is
- 22:00Speaker 3: followed by detectives. The detectives are usually much more experienced
- 22:06Speaker 3: and have seen terrible things usually, but there are lots
- 22:15Speaker 3: of things going on in those scenarios, the shattered love relatives,
- 22:21Speaker 3: but also what happens to the young police officers who
- 22:25Speaker 3: are possibly seeing these sort of scenarios for the first
- 22:29Speaker 3: time in their lives.
- 22:31Speaker 1: Yeah, you mentioned you mentioned the police and what we'll
- 22:33Speaker 1: talk further about that later on, but the impact of
- 22:37Speaker 1: police because we mentioned at the start the full range
- 22:41Speaker 1: of emotions and the heavy emotional toll inquest take. But
- 22:45Speaker 1: there's a lot of people that are affected by it.
- 22:48Speaker 1: On the issue of suicides too, they're difficult ones. And
- 22:51Speaker 1: I know from earlier because quite often the family don't
- 22:55Speaker 1: want to accept that someone's taken their own life, so
- 22:58Speaker 1: their minds.
- 22:59Speaker 2: Sticking over it.
- 23:00Speaker 1: You know, there must be something more to this, so
- 23:03Speaker 1: you're dealing with that aspect of it as well.
- 23:05Speaker 2: But yeah, it's.
- 23:07Speaker 1: Confronting the whole range of things. And then accidents. The
- 23:11Speaker 1: purpose of investigating an accident is to find out ways
- 23:16Speaker 1: of preventing that accident from occurring. Again, that's something that
- 23:19Speaker 1: the coronial process is involved in as well.
- 23:23Speaker 3: That's rightight, And although I think we do that quite
- 23:27Speaker 3: well in in a lot of cases we only hold
- 23:31Speaker 3: about it one hundred inquests a year in the South Bales,
- 23:34Speaker 3: but there are eight thousand or roughly eight thousand deaths
- 23:38Speaker 3: reported every year, so and around about forty percent of
- 23:43Speaker 3: the reported deaths to unnatural causes. So we don't really
- 23:53Speaker 3: investigate enough enough accidents, I think to learn all the
- 23:58Speaker 3: lessons that could be learned. Ideally, a cronial system should
- 24:03Speaker 3: really thoroughly investigate all the accidents that occurred, that fatalities
- 24:10Speaker 3: and try and put them into patterns or identify trends
- 24:14Speaker 3: so that we can we can pull out life saving lessons.
- 24:19Speaker 3: One thing that people don't often think about, and frankly
- 24:24Speaker 3: I didn't think about when I was a coroner, but
- 24:26Speaker 3: I have thought about since is the economic value of
- 24:30Speaker 3: a human life. The Australian government puts an economic value
- 24:38Speaker 3: on an Australian life. It's called the value of a
- 24:41Speaker 3: statistical life, and that in twenty twenty four it was
- 24:45Speaker 3: estimated to be five point seven million dollars and a
- 24:50Speaker 3: life year is valued by actuaries at around about two
- 24:55Speaker 3: hundred and forty or two hundred and fifty thousand dollars.
- 25:00Speaker 3: So investigating thoroughly the causes of accidents should be regarded
- 25:07Speaker 3: as an investment in life saving because if we could
- 25:12Speaker 3: save more lives, if we could prevent more accidents, then
- 25:16Speaker 3: it would be obviously good for the families and the
- 25:21Speaker 3: community in general if this human cost wasn't spent or incurred.
- 25:27Speaker 3: But there's also a value to the economy. So if
- 25:33Speaker 3: you think about it, three thousand unnatural deaths a year,
- 25:37Speaker 3: that's possibly fifteen billion dollars just putting it in dollar terms,
- 25:43Speaker 3: which is a very crude an unsatisfactory way to put it,
- 25:48Speaker 3: but it's really worth looking at. This is not just
- 25:54Speaker 3: a lot of grief and a lot of sadness. It's
- 25:57Speaker 3: an enormous cost to the society that we live.
- 26:01Speaker 1: In that we've lost the life these things like I'll
- 26:05Speaker 1: pluck this as an example because it's fairly topical at
- 26:10Speaker 1: the moment or current, like eese scooters, when there's a
- 26:13Speaker 1: death on an new scooter, we see that these scooters
- 26:15Speaker 1: on long foot paths, or the role of a coronario
- 26:19Speaker 1: would imagine I'm talking hypothetically here, is if there's a
- 26:23Speaker 1: series of accidents in quests, Okay, well how did this accident?
- 26:26Speaker 1: There might be recommendations like the helmet recommendation there is
- 26:30Speaker 1: an obvious one or not the right on footpaths or
- 26:33Speaker 1: certain things that might prevent deaths as well.
- 26:35Speaker 2: That's the role of a corona.
- 26:38Speaker 3: Yeah, and ideally most in quests would result in recommendations
- 26:43Speaker 3: to public health and safety officials who would then work
- 26:49Speaker 3: through the practicalities of their I mean coroners are not
- 26:53Speaker 3: engineers or those sort of things. But a good in
- 26:57Speaker 3: quest should bring in experts, experts, that's right. And then
- 27:04Speaker 3: and very often families also have good ideas about how
- 27:08Speaker 3: to because they've given a lot of thought to how
- 27:11Speaker 3: their loved ones have died. They often have good ideas.
- 27:15Speaker 3: So in New South Wales, if we could increase the
- 27:19Speaker 3: number of cases in which recommendations were produced, or if
- 27:24Speaker 3: we could identify more patterns and trends of fatalities and
- 27:28Speaker 3: serious injury, then we would have a more effective and
- 27:33Speaker 3: more productive coronial system than we have at the moment.
- 27:38Speaker 1: Is there any accident you've seen that's really stuck in
- 27:42Speaker 1: your mind?
- 27:43Speaker 3: Well, one of them is a terrible collision on Sydney
- 27:47Speaker 3: Harbor which I spent some weeks inquiring into. Yeah, that
- 27:54Speaker 3: was very very interesting.
- 27:58Speaker 1: Is that the one where for people were killed.
- 28:02Speaker 3: Four people were killed. There were passengers on board a
- 28:06Speaker 3: pleasure cruiser which was proceeding from west towards towards Circular Key,
- 28:14Speaker 3: and a river cat ferry came out of Circular Key.
- 28:19Speaker 3: It was on its way back to the Balmain dockyard.
- 28:24Speaker 3: Were at Birthed Yep and right under the harbor bridge
- 28:29Speaker 3: on the on the southern side. The boat was run
- 28:33Speaker 3: over by the by the ferry.
- 28:36Speaker 1: How many people were on the boat, I can't quite remember.
- 28:39Speaker 3: I think it was around about nine people.
- 28:41Speaker 2: Right, and four.
- 28:42Speaker 3: People were killed.
- 28:43Speaker 1: Yeah, what was it about that stuck in your mind,
- 28:47Speaker 1: that that particular matter.
- 28:50Speaker 3: Well, there were a number of things. Really. My council
- 28:55Speaker 3: assistant and I and my team went out on Sydney
- 28:58Speaker 3: Harbor and you know, it took a view as it were,
- 29:02Speaker 3: and we went up that the river with you know,
- 29:04Speaker 3: in a ferry in a river cat. The father of
- 29:09Speaker 3: a young dancer who was killed was representing his family.
- 29:15Speaker 3: He didn't have a lawyer and he was on the
- 29:19Speaker 3: he was on the ferry trying to talk to me.
- 29:22Speaker 3: And one of the one of the difficulties you have
- 29:26Speaker 3: if you're a coroner, as you you can't really talk
- 29:29Speaker 3: to the lawyers and the families in the course of
- 29:33Speaker 3: either taking a view or taking evidence of that sort
- 29:35Speaker 3: of thing. And I could see this poor man really
- 29:40Speaker 3: trying to understand what the hell are these lawyers up to?
- 29:43Speaker 3: You know, why can't I talk to the coroner? And
- 29:46Speaker 3: my council assistant was trying to say, look, the coroner
- 29:50Speaker 3: is very, very interested in what you've got to say,
- 29:53Speaker 3: but we've got certain rules about all of this sort
- 29:57Speaker 3: of stuff.
- 29:58Speaker 2: So that was one thing just on that.
- 30:02Speaker 1: It's difficult, isn't it, Because I know I've seen at
- 30:05Speaker 1: scenes and locations circumstances like that, and the coroner's there
- 30:09Speaker 1: and you've got the families there or the people that
- 30:12Speaker 1: have a vested interest in the situation. Obviously they want
- 30:16Speaker 1: to speak to speak to the coroner, but you can't.
- 30:18Speaker 1: You've got to have that independence that you're not speaking
- 30:22Speaker 1: to them directly or on specifics of the evidence.
- 30:24Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 30:25Speaker 3: Actually, since I've finished as a coroner, I've given more
- 30:29Speaker 3: thought to this, and I wonder whether sometimes coroners might
- 30:35Speaker 3: not be better off at least having a meeting with
- 30:38Speaker 3: the family with representatives or you know, someone to ensure
- 30:44Speaker 3: that you don't make any false promises or cuddle up
- 30:49Speaker 3: if you like, become biased towards families. But I wonder
- 30:55Speaker 3: sometimes whether we could do more to show the family
- 31:00Speaker 3: is that we actually care about them as well as
- 31:03Speaker 3: care about finding out what the answer to the question
- 31:07Speaker 3: about how their loved ones died.
- 31:10Speaker 2: It carries a lot, doesn't it.
- 31:12Speaker 1: If the families know that you care, whether that's a
- 31:14Speaker 1: police officer or a coroner, a legal person or anyone
- 31:17Speaker 1: that gets caught up in these situations. If there's you're
- 31:21Speaker 1: showing that you care, that can help the family so much.
- 31:25Speaker 3: Well, I think so, And sometimes not always, but sometimes
- 31:29Speaker 3: after an inquest I would step down from the bench
- 31:33Speaker 3: and I talk to the family. That's after I've given
- 31:36Speaker 3: the decision. And I remember a particular case, I was
- 31:42Speaker 3: doing an inquiry into an inquest into a murder suicide case.
- 31:48Speaker 3: A father who had separated from his wife had taken
- 31:55Speaker 3: his three children off in a car and put a
- 32:00Speaker 3: I won't describe what happened, but anyway, he killed himself
- 32:04Speaker 3: and the three kids. The mother came to the court
- 32:08Speaker 3: and this was I think three years after the murder suicide,
- 32:15Speaker 3: and she was pregnant. She had repartnered since and after that,
- 32:20Speaker 3: and she spoke about how much she missed her children,
- 32:24Speaker 3: and so on and so forth, and I just admired
- 32:27Speaker 3: this woman so much, her courage in not only putting
- 32:32Speaker 3: up with what had happened. And as I said, I
- 32:35Speaker 3: don't think there's any such scene as closure. That she'd
- 32:39Speaker 3: managed somehow to face the world and go forward, and
- 32:43Speaker 3: now she'd repartnered, and now she was bringing new life
- 32:46Speaker 3: into the world. And I just thought, respect, and I
- 32:53Speaker 3: spoke to her and I said, how do you do this?
- 32:58Speaker 3: And she said, look, I'm not going to let this
- 33:01Speaker 3: guy get away with killing my kids. I'm not going
- 33:05Speaker 3: to be crushed by it. I'm not going to allow
- 33:10Speaker 3: him to destroy the life that I had. I'm going
- 33:15Speaker 3: to give new life. And I just thought, Wow, she's amazing.
- 33:21Speaker 3: And very often I saw things like that happen in court.
- 33:26Speaker 1: I'm sure you took strength and the inspiration from the
- 33:29Speaker 1: way some of the families conduct themselves. So that's what
- 33:32Speaker 1: I saw, and I thought where I would often think,
- 33:35Speaker 1: where do you get that strength, whether you get that
- 33:38Speaker 1: strength to carry on? And also they can even see
- 33:42Speaker 1: joy in life, like the ability to get through as
- 33:45Speaker 1: you just described with the mother there, that she's going
- 33:49Speaker 1: to live a life despite what's happened.
- 33:51Speaker 2: That's right.
- 33:51Speaker 3: And some people are obviously very angry and they never
- 33:56Speaker 3: really get over their anger. But some people can be
- 34:00Speaker 3: remarkably forgiving. People can make mistakes, and sometimes those mistakes
- 34:08Speaker 3: cause deaths by a mission or commission. So sometimes you know,
- 34:13Speaker 3: for example, nurses or doctors miss clues. Let's suggest a
- 34:20Speaker 3: child is very, very sick and needs some sort of
- 34:23Speaker 3: virgent intervention, and by the time there is an intervention,
- 34:27Speaker 3: it's too late. I remember a case involving a little
- 34:32Speaker 3: boy who died and he'd been seen by well by
- 34:37Speaker 3: the time he died, he had been seen by six doctors.
- 34:41Speaker 3: The last two doctors realized what was happening and tried
- 34:45Speaker 3: to give emergent care, but the four previous doctors thought
- 34:51Speaker 3: he was sick but had a flu or some sort
- 34:54Speaker 3: of viral thing, but he'd get over it anyway. In
- 34:58Speaker 3: the inquest, some of the medical and health practitioners, once
- 35:04Speaker 3: they had finished their evidence, turned and faced the family
- 35:07Speaker 3: and said how sorry they were. But there was one doctor,
- 35:12Speaker 3: young doctor, and I still feel quite sorry for her,
- 35:16Speaker 3: but she couldn't bring herself to apologize. And I don't
- 35:20Speaker 3: know why not, but I really feel that she lost
- 35:25Speaker 3: an opportunity because the family were very willing to forgive
- 35:32Speaker 3: all these other people who did apologize, and I just thought, gosh,
- 35:38Speaker 3: if you turned and said you were sorry, that this
- 35:41Speaker 3: had really affected you as well. And I'm sure she
- 35:45Speaker 3: was affected, but maybe she got legal advised. You know,
- 35:49Speaker 3: I don't speak. Who knows. Maybe she just couldn't bring
- 35:52Speaker 3: herself to say anything. But I just thought, if you
- 35:58Speaker 3: could turn around and talk to them, I think it
- 36:01Speaker 3: would make both of you, the family and this doctor
- 36:05Speaker 3: so much happier than they were.
- 36:09Speaker 1: I think you've just encapsulated when they talk about the
- 36:11Speaker 1: emotion that comes in the corner's court, just with that
- 36:15Speaker 1: one story that's on the thing that lives are shattered,
- 36:19Speaker 1: and it's about how people move forward. But I think
- 36:22Speaker 1: you might be right, And yeah, saying sorry can often
- 36:26Speaker 1: be the thing that helps people move forward.
- 36:29Speaker 3: Can I tell you another story ago?
- 36:30Speaker 2: Yeah?
- 36:31Speaker 3: Yeah, this one had a happier ending. Really a young woman,
- 36:36Speaker 3: she was nineteen years old. She got very sick. She
- 36:40Speaker 3: was working on a sharing team somewhere in the southwest
- 36:43Speaker 3: of New South Wales and it looked like she had
- 36:48Speaker 3: a flu. So her boyfriend, who was on the team said,
- 36:51Speaker 3: go to bed. The sharing team boss was this marry guy.
- 36:56Speaker 3: Little murry guy said, going like and she just got
- 37:02Speaker 3: sicker and sicker though, and at some point in one
- 37:06Speaker 3: of the breaks, her boyfriend went in and saw him
- 37:09Speaker 3: and thought, oh my god, she's really sick. So they
- 37:12Speaker 3: called an ambulance, but it took nearly an hour for
- 37:15Speaker 3: the ambulance to get there. It was way out somewhere.
- 37:19Speaker 3: They got it to the hospital, but she was very,
- 37:22Speaker 3: very sick, and despite getting urgent attention, she died. We
- 37:29Speaker 3: held an inquest because one of the difficulties was there
- 37:32Speaker 3: wasn't a clear diagnosis of what was killing her, and
- 37:37Speaker 3: we still don't really have an absolute diagnosis actually, but
- 37:41Speaker 3: in any event, we held the inquest and her father,
- 37:46Speaker 3: who was a Victorian farmer, very big man, six foot
- 37:51Speaker 3: four or something, came in and we went through the evidence.
- 37:57Speaker 3: The family was represented by a very good arrister from Victoria,
- 38:02Speaker 3: and I had a very good counsel assistant. You may
- 38:05Speaker 3: know her, Peggy dwy a Silk or so. It's the Victorian.
- 38:12Speaker 3: And one of the great things about this inquest I
- 38:15Speaker 3: thought was that there was no bitterness, and at the
- 38:22Speaker 3: end of the case, I gave my decision and my reasons,
- 38:26Speaker 3: and I explained how you know, what had happened, and
- 38:29Speaker 3: as best we could what the diagnosis we thought was
- 38:34Speaker 3: most likely to be. Give my decision. I walk off
- 38:38Speaker 3: the bench. I'm sitting in my chambers, and Peggy comes
- 38:41Speaker 3: out and says, Hugh, he come to the come to
- 38:45Speaker 3: the door of the court. So I got up and
- 38:47Speaker 3: I went to the door of the court and we
- 38:49Speaker 3: pulled it out in a little bit and there was
- 38:51Speaker 3: this enormous Victorian farmer with his arms around the little
- 38:57Speaker 3: Marory shearing boss, both in tears, both embracing, and both
- 39:05Speaker 3: so sad, but so happy to have this moment with
- 39:10Speaker 3: one another. They were both they both loved this girl, the.
- 39:17Speaker 2: Mary.
- 39:18Speaker 3: Boss was so devastated by her death. I mean when
- 39:22Speaker 3: he gave evidence, he was just weeping, pouring tears pouring
- 39:26Speaker 3: out of him, very very emotional, as was her dad.
- 39:32Speaker 3: And so there was this moment of cathasis. It doesn't
- 39:36Speaker 3: always happened some you know, some people walk away still
- 39:40Speaker 3: feeling angry or whatever. But this was one of those
- 39:43Speaker 3: moments where thought, today we did something good. And having
- 39:48Speaker 3: spent a lot of time in criminal courts, I can say,
- 39:51Speaker 3: I don't think on a lot of days I ever
- 39:54Speaker 3: walked out of a criminal court thinking today we did
- 39:57Speaker 3: something good.
- 39:58Speaker 1: Well, yeah, there's not not many people walk out happy
- 40:02Speaker 1: out of the criminal court. That if the person's convicted,
- 40:06Speaker 1: he or she's angry. If the person gets off, that's
- 40:08Speaker 1: the police or the prosecution angry.
- 40:11Speaker 2: But the way you've.
- 40:12Speaker 1: Described that, I can picture it, and that is doing
- 40:15Speaker 1: something good, like.
- 40:17Speaker 2: True.
- 40:17Speaker 3: And it was a moment of grace really, you know,
- 40:22Speaker 3: there's there's very generous hearted men were embracing each other
- 40:29Speaker 3: and owning the loss that they both felt.
- 40:33Speaker 1: Yeah, and you could imagine the types that you're describing,
- 40:37Speaker 1: they could bottle it up. But the fact that they
- 40:39Speaker 1: let the emotion go, and you see that quite often
- 40:41Speaker 1: in the coroner's court. It is it is that emotional place.
- 40:46Speaker 1: The breakdown of the adversarial system for the criminal courts
- 40:50Speaker 1: and inquisitorial for the inquest. What's the difference in the
- 40:54Speaker 1: way that evidence is allowed into those courts.
- 40:57Speaker 3: Well, the two things rely on different ways of thinking.
- 41:03Speaker 3: So in a criminal trial, one party the prosecutions as
- 41:10Speaker 3: a theory a hypothesis. The hypothesis is you Gary have
- 41:17Speaker 3: murdered me Hugh, you deny that allegation, and either prosecutor
- 41:25Speaker 3: have to try to prove my hypothesis. And I do
- 41:29Speaker 3: that by producing proof which I hope will satisfy people
- 41:35Speaker 3: in the jury beyond a resumal doubt that this is
- 41:38Speaker 3: the only reasonable answer you could come up with. That's
- 41:42Speaker 3: deductive thinking. The other way of thinking is inductive thinking,
- 41:47Speaker 3: which is to say, we look at all this evidence,
- 41:50Speaker 3: which may be scattered and fragmented in different ways, and
- 41:55Speaker 3: we try and come up with a theory. What theory
- 41:59Speaker 3: may sense of all this stuff that we have collected.
- 42:06Speaker 3: So that's theory building or inductive thinking. Now, of course
- 42:12Speaker 3: the adversarial side. There is an adversarial side to inquest
- 42:16Speaker 3: and you've experienced that, and that's where people who have
- 42:22Speaker 3: a different theory or have a particular theory challenge the
- 42:28Speaker 3: range of theories that have been developed. So current might thinking, okay, well,
- 42:31Speaker 3: the possibilities available for me are suicide, homicide, jumped off
- 42:40Speaker 3: a cliff, fell off a cliff, accidentally, was kidding up
- 42:47Speaker 3: by by by martians and assaulted who knows what. So
- 42:53Speaker 3: there might be a range of possible theories, and some
- 42:56Speaker 3: of the people who have an interest in this it
- 42:58Speaker 3: might be police, or it might be persons of interest
- 43:01Speaker 3: as we call suspects might want to challenge some of
- 43:06Speaker 3: these theories because they don't want the coroner to ultimately
- 43:12Speaker 3: settle on a particular theory that blames them. So there
- 43:18Speaker 3: is a degree of adversarialism in it in it or
- 43:21Speaker 3: can be in an inquest. But it's all about really
- 43:25Speaker 3: this inductive thinking. What is the most satisfactory theory we
- 43:30Speaker 3: can come up with that explains this death and the
- 43:35Speaker 3: circumstances that surrounded it, And that means you have to
- 43:38Speaker 3: look as carefully as you can at the surrounding circumstances,
- 43:44Speaker 3: and that might mean that you take a wide look.
- 43:47Speaker 1: Does that allow for opinions to come in? Yes, because
- 43:52Speaker 1: rare in the criminal court that you get off your opinion,
- 43:55Speaker 1: but in the coroner's court, quite often opinions the coroner
- 43:59Speaker 1: takes that account.
- 44:00Speaker 3: Opinions can be very important and they can be quite persuasive.
- 44:06Speaker 3: And also hearsay evidence. So here's some heresay evidence. Obviously
- 44:12Speaker 3: can get into a criminal trial, but only under very
- 44:15Speaker 3: limited circumstances because there are questions about the reliability of
- 44:20Speaker 3: hearsay and of opinions. Juries have to come up with
- 44:25Speaker 3: their own opinion about whether someone's guilty or not. That's
- 44:28Speaker 3: the idea about opinion evidence unless it relates to some
- 44:31Speaker 3: sort of area of X that's beyond common knowledge, etc.
- 44:38Speaker 3: But coroners are running an inquiry, not a trial, and
- 44:44Speaker 3: that's the fundamental difference. And that's what I'm saying inductive thinking,
- 44:49Speaker 3: that's I'm thinking about, what's the question, How do I
- 44:53Speaker 3: answer the question? What's the theory I can come up
- 44:55Speaker 3: with that answer answers the question question is how did
- 45:01Speaker 3: this person die? How did this death come about? What
- 45:05Speaker 3: explains it? But if we go to a trial, the
- 45:08Speaker 3: prosecution thinks it knows the answer to that, then it's
- 45:12Speaker 3: got to persuade a jury to agree with that answer.
- 45:18Speaker 1: I'm just reflecting back on my first experience at an inquest,
- 45:23Speaker 1: and I think it was even in my uniform days,
- 45:25Speaker 1: where a young child, the mother was in the bathroom
- 45:30Speaker 1: and the hair dry fell into the bath. The two
- 45:33Speaker 1: kids in the bath just toddlers, and one died and
- 45:38Speaker 1: one survived from that. And I remember, and this was
- 45:42Speaker 1: probably the first sort of situation I've been to like
- 45:45Speaker 1: that where a brief had to be put together for
- 45:47Speaker 1: the coroner, So we put together a coronial brief. A
- 45:50Speaker 1: lot of questions were asked by what sort of system
- 45:53Speaker 1: did they have in the fuse box with the electrical work,
- 45:56Speaker 1: wasn't the safety Why didn't the circuit break a trip
- 45:58Speaker 1: at the time, and think like that long time ago.
- 46:02Speaker 1: But I think some recommendations came on the back of that.
- 46:05Speaker 1: That's the type of incident that would be bought before
- 46:10Speaker 1: the coroner.
- 46:10Speaker 3: Yeah, definitely, And it's the very kind of incident that
- 46:15Speaker 3: should be brought before the coroner because there's obviously if
- 46:19Speaker 3: you explore that scenario thoroughly enough, there are there's real
- 46:26Speaker 3: potential for saving life in future.
- 46:28Speaker 1: And warning's about electrical appliances near the bath and where
- 46:32Speaker 1: powerpoints are located near the bath.
- 46:34Speaker 3: All of that, and yeah, well I would imagine a
- 46:39Speaker 3: good coroner came up with a number of recommendations, and
- 46:43Speaker 3: no doubt the police, which might have been you Gary,
- 46:47Speaker 3: contributed to that thinking process.
- 46:49Speaker 1: It was I remember it because it was such a tragic,
- 46:53Speaker 1: tragic accident, and that's what it was.
- 46:55Speaker 2: It was an accident.
- 46:56Speaker 1: But whether the accident could have been safeguarded against by
- 47:00Speaker 1: you know, putting things in place or just letting people
- 47:02Speaker 1: be more aware of the situation. Another one, and I'm
- 47:06Speaker 1: just reflecting on all the different experiences I've had in
- 47:09Speaker 1: a coroner's court. The bower of all matter, you're familiar
- 47:14Speaker 1: with it, and people that have listened to the podcast
- 47:16Speaker 1: would be familiar with it. The murder of Evelyn green Up,
- 47:19Speaker 1: Colin Walker, and Clinton Speedy in nineteen ninety and ninety one.
- 47:23Speaker 1: Over a five month period, a person had been a
- 47:27Speaker 1: charge with one of the murders, went to court and
- 47:31Speaker 1: the person was acquitted. I became involved in a reinvestigation
- 47:35Speaker 1: and we just saw that we reinvestigated. We thought we
- 47:40Speaker 1: had enough information for the matter to go back before
- 47:42Speaker 1: the courts for the other two because the double jeopardy
- 47:44Speaker 1: legislation wasn't in on the other two matters that a
- 47:48Speaker 1: person hadn't been charged with, but the DPP knocked it back.
- 47:52Speaker 1: We then went to an inquest and had an inquest
- 47:55Speaker 1: where it was the first time witnesses in regards to
- 47:58Speaker 1: all three matters had provided any form of evidence in
- 48:02Speaker 1: a court environment because the person that was charged with
- 48:06Speaker 1: that crime was only dealt with the facts relating to
- 48:09Speaker 1: the murder of Clinton Speedy. We've gone to the inquest.
- 48:15Speaker 1: The inquest ran over a number of weeks. Everyone gave
- 48:19Speaker 1: evidence and there was opportunities for people to be cross examined.
- 48:24Speaker 1: On the back of that, I think it was John Abernathy,
- 48:26Speaker 1: was a coroner at the time, made a recommendation to
- 48:30Speaker 1: the DPP that he has reasonable cause that the known
- 48:34Speaker 1: persons involved in the matter and that all three matters
- 48:37Speaker 1: should be looked together. On the back of that, the
- 48:40Speaker 1: DPP then a little bit down the track, but the
- 48:44Speaker 1: weight that was carried from the inquest and John Abernathy's
- 48:48Speaker 1: recommendations decided to exo fishao, indict diet the person. I
- 48:53Speaker 1: raise that as an example because that's where I see
- 48:56Speaker 1: the coronial court working in an investigation. In that gave
- 49:00Speaker 1: the witnesses the opportunity to give evidence in a court
- 49:04Speaker 1: room environment, and then an assessment could have been was
- 49:07Speaker 1: made on the weight that could be placed on the evidence.
- 49:10Speaker 1: Is that how you see a coroner's court can be used. Yeah.
- 49:13Speaker 3: And in fact, in New South Wales, if a person
- 49:18Speaker 3: has died and homicide is the suspected cause of that
- 49:23Speaker 3: and death and inquest is mandatory and so yeah, I
- 49:28Speaker 3: was thinking about this the other day. I'm quite sure
- 49:31Speaker 3: how many homicide inquests I did. It's probably I would
- 49:36Speaker 3: say probably twenty CYCA. In some cases I did refer
- 49:44Speaker 3: cases to the DPP. In other cases we didn't get
- 49:49Speaker 3: far enough. And in fact, the very last case I
- 49:52Speaker 3: did as a coroner was in Newcastle. It was a
- 49:55Speaker 3: double murder and we we had a person of interest
- 50:02Speaker 3: who gave evidence, but there simply wasn't enough evidence in
- 50:09Speaker 3: my opinion, the opinion of my counsel assisting or the
- 50:13Speaker 3: police investigators to refer to the DPP. An interesting, very
- 50:18Speaker 3: interesting case. Yeah, And you know, you never know. Sometimes
- 50:25Speaker 3: people say things or do things which pushes a case
- 50:31Speaker 3: where the DPP has doubts that the evidence is sufficient
- 50:36Speaker 3: over the line. And so a couple of a couple
- 50:39Speaker 3: of times I referred cases to the DPP after they
- 50:44Speaker 3: had initially decided there wasn't enough evidence. And sometimes they
- 50:51Speaker 3: put people on trial, sometimes they don't. Sometimes they take it.
- 50:54Speaker 3: You know, once they have a look at all the evidence,
- 50:58Speaker 3: they think, ye, that will work or not work.
- 51:01Speaker 1: And I think that's what perhaps the public caren't fully
- 51:05Speaker 1: informed on that when the coroner maker makes a recommendation,
- 51:09Speaker 1: it's still that's not the end of the story. That
- 51:11Speaker 1: doesn't mean the person's going to trial. The DPP's got
- 51:14Speaker 1: to assess it from a criminal point of view, whether
- 51:18Speaker 1: there's sufficient evidence to warrant charges.
- 51:21Speaker 2: Against a person.
- 51:22Speaker 1: I suppose I lost my faith and I'm sorry to
- 51:25Speaker 1: say this when you're seeing here as a coroner, very
- 51:28Speaker 1: early in my career, but got it back. Naive young
- 51:32Speaker 1: detective working on a case. It was a brutal case.
- 51:36Speaker 1: A person had been shot with a shotgun and dumped
- 51:39Speaker 1: in the boot of his car, and his car was abandoned.
- 51:43Speaker 1: Locals called the police out. It was a horrendous, horrendous scene.
- 51:47Speaker 1: It was during the heat wave and the deceased body
- 51:49Speaker 1: was in the back of the boot for five days.
- 51:52Speaker 1: I remember the case well, I remember the post mortem.
- 51:55Speaker 1: It was a horrendous situation. There was what I considered
- 52:00Speaker 1: evidence a person person of interest. We won't mention the
- 52:02Speaker 1: names or the case. Young detective thinking, this is frustrating.
- 52:07Speaker 1: We know this person has done it, and it was
- 52:09Speaker 1: sort of suggested, let's take the matter to the coroner
- 52:14Speaker 1: and maybe further evidence will be forthcoming. What and I
- 52:19Speaker 1: knew this was a possibility, but it shocked me when
- 52:21Speaker 1: I saw it actually work. In the process, the person
- 52:25Speaker 1: of interest got in the witness box. We had presented
- 52:28Speaker 1: the brief to the coroner. I was excited as a
- 52:30Speaker 1: naive young detective, thinking, Okay, well this is We're going
- 52:33Speaker 1: to watch this person get carved up. He got in
- 52:36Speaker 1: the witness box and he was said, I declined to
- 52:40Speaker 1: answer any questions on the ground I might incriminate myself.
- 52:43Speaker 1: He got thanked by the coroner and left the court,
- 52:46Speaker 1: and it was sort of my expectations were high, the
- 52:48Speaker 1: family's expectations were. My expectations were high because I was
- 52:53Speaker 1: naive as the workings of the court. But I thought
- 52:56Speaker 1: there I just lost a little bit of faith in
- 52:59Speaker 1: that that write the silence. I fully understand the concept
- 53:02Speaker 1: of the silence, but a coronial inquest is to find
- 53:06Speaker 1: out what's happened to a person, and this person clearly
- 53:09Speaker 1: had relevant information about about how this person died, but
- 53:15Speaker 1: was allowed to just say I'm not going to say anything.
- 53:18Speaker 2: What's your thoughts on that?
- 53:19Speaker 3: I have mixed feelings about that from a purely coronial
- 53:23Speaker 3: point of view, Like everybody else, I would like to
- 53:28Speaker 3: hear the story from the person who probably knows most
- 53:32Speaker 3: about it. On the other hand, if there is a
- 53:36Speaker 3: strong case against a known person, I'd be quite reluctant
- 53:42Speaker 3: to force them to give evidence. The reason being that
- 53:47Speaker 3: if you force them to give evidence, they object, and
- 53:50Speaker 3: then you say no, no, no, you're going to give evidence.
- 53:54Speaker 3: They have to give evidence, and then they talk, but
- 53:58Speaker 3: whatever they say can be used, and it can't be
- 54:02Speaker 3: used in any way at all. So you can't be
- 54:06Speaker 3: used directly against them or indirectly against them, which is
- 54:10Speaker 3: even worse. So if you force someone to speak, my
- 54:16Speaker 3: view was that you run the real risk of jeopardizing
- 54:21Speaker 3: what may be a strong case at trial, because they'll
- 54:25Speaker 3: be able to say, oh, well, the cops went and
- 54:28Speaker 3: got this evidence.
- 54:30Speaker 1: It's not just the evidence that provided can't be used.
- 54:33Speaker 1: It's a flow on, that's right.
- 54:35Speaker 3: All the evidence that is obtained indirectly as a result
- 54:39Speaker 3: of them speaking is inadmissible.
- 54:42Speaker 1: Well, I'm sure you are for me with the Matthew
- 54:46Speaker 1: Levison cases and that was an interesting I found that
- 54:50Speaker 1: an interesting case for a whole range of reasons. But basically,
- 54:55Speaker 1: and we've had Mark and Faye on the podcast, so
- 54:58Speaker 1: people have probably heard talk about the situation. Matthew disappeared.
- 55:04Speaker 1: He'd been out Saturday night at Oxford Street in Sydney
- 55:09Speaker 1: with his partner and disappeared. The partner was eventually circumstances
- 55:15Speaker 1: around the disappearance was a bit strange. They've waken up
- 55:18Speaker 1: and that Matthew's gone and the partner got on with
- 55:21Speaker 1: his life. And then Mark and fayr initi when they
- 55:25Speaker 1: were contacted by Matthew's employer he hadn't turned up for work.
- 55:29Speaker 1: They went to the police and reported that Matthew missing.
- 55:33Speaker 1: There was an investigation and I can say the name
- 55:36Speaker 1: that he hasn't been convicted of the murder, but it's
- 55:39Speaker 1: all public record. Michael Atkins, he's partner at the time,
- 55:42Speaker 1: was charged with murder. A murder trial was conducted, and
- 55:46Speaker 1: we should note that Michael Atkins was acquitted of murder
- 55:49Speaker 1: and manslaughter in two thousand and nine. So Mark and
- 55:52Speaker 1: Fayer left in and I'm sure you'd understand the situation.
- 55:56Speaker 1: Left in this horrible situation where they've okay, they've put
- 55:59Speaker 1: their faith in the justice system, it's gone the court
- 56:02Speaker 1: and then what have we got. Well, we've got no
- 56:05Speaker 1: answers because we've been told that this person wasn't responsible
- 56:08Speaker 1: for son's son's murder by the court during the trial
- 56:14Speaker 1: I became involved in it. They spoke to me and
- 56:17Speaker 1: we looked at okay, we could go to a cranial
- 56:20Speaker 1: inquest because and I think the representations they made to
- 56:23Speaker 1: the coroner were we put our faith in the justice
- 56:26Speaker 1: system as in the court system. We still don't have
- 56:29Speaker 1: answers for our son. Can we have a corannial inquest?
- 56:33Speaker 1: And on the back of that, there was a decision
- 56:36Speaker 1: that an inquest would be held. There was a lot
- 56:39Speaker 1: of layers to it, but it got to the point
- 56:42Speaker 1: where I was satisfied from a homicide to take this
- 56:45Speaker 1: point of view that we'd taken the investigation as far
- 56:47Speaker 1: as we possibly could. There was not going to We'd
- 56:51Speaker 1: gathered all the evidence of available evidence, so there wasn't
- 56:54Speaker 1: an opportunity because double jeopardy legislation had come in by
- 56:57Speaker 1: that stage. There wasn't going to be an opportunity to
- 56:59Speaker 1: reach uge because we hadn't gathered fresh and compelling evidence.
- 57:04Speaker 1: So then a bit of a conundrum. And you know,
- 57:06Speaker 1: Mark and Fay would on weekends go look for Matt's body.
- 57:10Speaker 1: They were desperate to get Matt's body back. And I
- 57:12Speaker 1: still remember having the conversation with them about what do
- 57:15Speaker 1: you hope to achieve from the inquest? And I think
- 57:17Speaker 1: it was Elaine Truscott was the coroner and very very
- 57:21Speaker 1: considerate of everyone's feelings and the appropriateness of the whole
- 57:27Speaker 1: way the matter has been run. And the decision was
- 57:30Speaker 1: made to give Michael Atkins a Section sixty one certificate
- 57:35Speaker 1: so that he could and when the listeners hear this,
- 57:38Speaker 1: they think this is ridiculous. But he could have got
- 57:40Speaker 1: in the witness box and said, yes, I murdered Matthew
- 57:44Speaker 1: Levison and this is how I did it, and that
- 57:46Speaker 1: we couldn't use that evidence.
- 57:48Speaker 2: But that's the.
- 57:49Speaker 1: Deal that we made a lot of processes that we
- 57:52Speaker 1: had to go through to do that, and it was
- 57:54Speaker 1: contested at court and Michael Atkins's defense were doing a
- 57:59Speaker 1: great job in protecting them. Eventually a decision was made
- 58:02Speaker 1: that he could give evidence with a section sixty one certificate.
- 58:07Speaker 1: He purjured himself whilst giving evidence in the witness box
- 58:10Speaker 1: for a week trying to answer questions and dodge around,
- 58:15Speaker 1: and then he was given the indemnity from the Attorney
- 58:18Speaker 1: General if he took us to Matthew Levison's body, which
- 58:21Speaker 1: he did. That's using an inquest in a way that
- 58:25Speaker 1: I don't think those said the circumstances would present themselves
- 58:28Speaker 1: very often. I know there was some sort of pushback
- 58:32Speaker 1: on people thinking, oh, well, are we really usurping the
- 58:34Speaker 1: person's right to silence? To me, I felt that it
- 58:38Speaker 1: was the right thing to do. I think Mark and
- 58:42Speaker 1: Fay have got their son's remains back. No one's been
- 58:44Speaker 1: charged with the murder. I'm just interested in to getting
- 58:49Speaker 1: your thoughts because I know it caused some different opinions.
- 58:52Speaker 1: I won't say controversy. Everyone wanted to see it resolved
- 58:55Speaker 1: in some way. What's your feelings on that?
- 58:59Speaker 3: Yeah, well, and I've talked to various people about this.
- 59:05Speaker 3: Some people I know and respect, some lawyers I know
- 59:09Speaker 3: and respect very much don't like it at all, for
- 59:14Speaker 3: the very reasons you've just explained that it seems to
- 59:18Speaker 3: run against the ethos of our criminal justice system. On
- 59:23Speaker 3: the other hand, I couldn't help feeling for the Leveson
- 59:27Speaker 3: family to be honest, to get their son's body back,
- 59:32Speaker 3: to be able to bury him, to at least get
- 59:35Speaker 3: some idea of what actually happened to him. I think
- 59:40Speaker 3: was worth the cost. In that particular case. There's are
- 59:48Speaker 3: very rare circumstances, and I don't think the principle that
- 59:52Speaker 3: people are concerned about of protecting people's right to silence
- 59:57Speaker 3: is in any way undermined, and in fact, in some
- 1:00:02Speaker 3: ways it's strengthened, I suppose, because it's shown that if
- 1:00:09Speaker 3: you if you force someone to speak against the against
- 1:00:14Speaker 3: their own interests, to tell the truth, in other words,
- 1:00:18Speaker 3: then there is a price to pay for that. And
- 1:00:23Speaker 3: you know, when you when you go back and think
- 1:00:25Speaker 3: about the right to silence, it goes back to the
- 1:00:27Speaker 3: days when if you were found guilty of an offense,
- 1:00:31Speaker 3: you were hung for it. So obviously there had to
- 1:00:35Speaker 3: be some protection against people being hung on the evidence
- 1:00:39Speaker 3: that came out of their own mouths. You know, that's
- 1:00:41Speaker 3: torturing people, really, one way or the other. So I
- 1:00:45Speaker 3: fully support the right to silence, and you know, would
- 1:00:48Speaker 3: always do that, but I think in this particular case,
- 1:00:54Speaker 3: and I really respect Elane, trust God as well as
- 1:00:57Speaker 3: a human being, as well as as well as a coroner,
- 1:01:01Speaker 3: I think she made the right decision.
- 1:01:03Speaker 2: Yeah, it was a difficult one.
- 1:01:06Speaker 1: I suppose even though a precedent has been set like that,
- 1:01:09Speaker 1: it hasn't opened the floodgates because it was such a
- 1:01:11Speaker 1: rare combination of circumstances requiely and it's one that yeah,
- 1:01:19Speaker 1: I won't say sleepless nights, but there was a lot
- 1:01:22Speaker 1: of thought that went into that, and there was a
- 1:01:24Speaker 1: lot of counterviews and different things. But the safeguards were
- 1:01:27Speaker 1: put in two and his defense team pushed it as
- 1:01:31Speaker 1: hard as they could on defending his right to avoid
- 1:01:35Speaker 1: giving evidence in those circumstances. But look, I feel satisfied
- 1:01:39Speaker 1: by it. I think the system worked. It was a
- 1:01:42Speaker 1: different way of approaching the system, but the system worked
- 1:01:45Speaker 1: in that regards.
- 1:01:47Speaker 3: And you'd know from your general career as a police
- 1:01:51Speaker 3: officer too that sometimes for the law to work, you
- 1:01:55Speaker 3: have to give people who have done bad things and
- 1:01:59Speaker 3: indemnine tea for the greater good. Yeah, it's a utilitarian concept,
- 1:02:04Speaker 3: I know. But you know, when I was at the
- 1:02:07Speaker 3: come of DVP, we're quite often we did indemnify people
- 1:02:12Speaker 3: who would give up major drug importers and so forth.
- 1:02:16Speaker 3: So you know that was that was the price you
- 1:02:18Speaker 3: paid for the evidence.
- 1:02:19Speaker 1: It's a necessary tool, and I break when there's a
- 1:02:23Speaker 1: different narrative or different discussions on what should be done.
- 1:02:26Speaker 1: And with the leves and matter I said, okay, well
- 1:02:30Speaker 1: the option is we don't do that, but we're not
- 1:02:33Speaker 1: going to find out where Matt's bodies, So.
- 1:02:36Speaker 2: What are we risking here?
- 1:02:38Speaker 1: Like it's we ever just just pack up our tools
- 1:02:42Speaker 1: and go home.
- 1:02:43Speaker 3: But you're right anyway, Gary, that the floodgates have not opened.
- 1:02:47Speaker 2: Yeah, well I saw.
- 1:02:49Speaker 1: I saw that and many a debate and discussion in
- 1:02:52Speaker 1: parliament with the double jeopardy legislation when that came in,
- 1:02:55Speaker 1: and that was on the back of the bearable thing.
- 1:02:59Speaker 1: People we know about it. In summary, if you'd been
- 1:03:03Speaker 1: acquitted of a crime before the double jeopardy legislation came in,
- 1:03:06Speaker 1: you couldn't be retried. So again the analogy at the extreme,
- 1:03:10Speaker 1: you could be acquitted of murder, walk out on the
- 1:03:12Speaker 1: steps of court and say I did it, I got
- 1:03:14Speaker 1: a way of it, and we couldn't charge that person.
- 1:03:17Speaker 1: The double jeopardy legislation came in, and there was a
- 1:03:20Speaker 1: lot of pushback about that. I was involved from the
- 1:03:24Speaker 1: Bowable point of view, using it sort of as a
- 1:03:27Speaker 1: test case and the world the sky was.
- 1:03:30Speaker 2: Going to fall.
- 1:03:31Speaker 1: The naysayers that didn't want the want this legislation come in.
- 1:03:36Speaker 1: If this comes in, it's going to turn our legal
- 1:03:38Speaker 1: justice system upside down. I think to this day the
- 1:03:42Speaker 1: legislation still hasn't been acted upon, but it's in there
- 1:03:45Speaker 1: as a safeguard if circumstances happened in bearable so.
- 1:03:49Speaker 3: And the you would hope would be very careful in
- 1:03:53Speaker 3: any event. Yeah, you know, you wouldn't want people being
- 1:03:58Speaker 3: dragged up from years and years and years ago with
- 1:04:01Speaker 3: some sort of weak evidence. You're right, it has to
- 1:04:06Speaker 3: be very compelling. Is compelling, it's a very high state.
- 1:04:12Speaker 2: It's a high high standard.
- 1:04:13Speaker 1: And look, I understood there was an argument there that
- 1:04:17Speaker 1: it would allow and it was fresh and compelling evidence,
- 1:04:20Speaker 1: and it's got to be in the interest of justice,
- 1:04:22Speaker 1: and it had to be an offense that carries a
- 1:04:25Speaker 1: minimum of twenty years. There was a lot of things
- 1:04:27Speaker 1: that went into it, but I understood. One of the
- 1:04:30Speaker 1: arguments I understood was it would allow police or investigators
- 1:04:34Speaker 1: to do a half hearted job the first time, and
- 1:04:37Speaker 1: if they lost the trial, I will do it properly
- 1:04:39Speaker 1: this time. And I could understand that concept that that sloppiness,
- 1:04:43Speaker 1: but it clearly hasn't come into play. But yeah, they're
- 1:04:48Speaker 1: interesting thoughts on the way justice can be approached.
- 1:04:52Speaker 2: When we get back.
- 1:04:53Speaker 1: We might take a break now, but when we get back,
- 1:04:55Speaker 1: I want to talk about some of the cases that
- 1:04:57Speaker 1: you've overseen, some very seen cases and your reflections on
- 1:05:02Speaker 1: those cases and something that you're very passionate about, and
- 1:05:07Speaker 1: full credit to you.
- 1:05:08Speaker 2: I support what you're.
- 1:05:09Speaker 1: Trying to do in how we could make the crannial
- 1:05:13Speaker 1: process or the Coroni's court a better place, because I
- 1:05:17Speaker 1: know you've been doing a lot of work on that
- 1:05:19Speaker 1: since you've left.
- 1:05:20Speaker 3: Yeah, I have Okay, great
- 1:05:22Speaker 2: Okay, we'll be back soon.