Latest / The Morning Rundown / A Fridge Hack, a Honeypot Probe, and California's Billionaire Tax Falls
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I have a question nobody asked me this morning.
- 0:17[Maya] Do you know what your refrigerator is up to right now?
- 0:20[David] Keeping my leftovers cold?
- 0:22[David] Judging me?
- 0:23[Maya] Wrong.
- 0:24[Maya] Possibly getting hacked.
- 0:26[David] No way.
- 0:27[Maya] I'm Maya, and this is the Morning Rundown with David, who is
- 0:30[Maya] now side-eyeing his kitchen.
- 0:32[David] I am.
- 0:33[David] I'm checking the freezer for suspicious activity.
- 0:35[Maya] So we've got three stories, and every one of them involves somebody
- 0:39[Maya] getting surprised: a government, a company, and a whole lot of voters.
- 0:44[David] Um, one of them involves a honeypot, which sounds like a snack
- 0:47[David] and absolutely is not.
- 0:50[Maya] Right?
- 0:51[Maya] And the third one is a tax vote in California that did
- 0:53[Maya] not go the way people expected.
- 0:55[David] Quick run through each, nothing too heavy.
- 0:57[David] Well, maybe a little heavy.
- 0:59[Maya] And fair warning, there's a little bit of everything in here: a
- 1:02[Maya] hacking accusation, a boardroom question mark, and a ballot box surprise, all
- 1:06[Maya] before your coffee gets cold.
- 1:08[David] I'd like the record to show I'm not saying my freezer is
- 1:11[David] part of a foreign plot.
- 1:12[David] I'm just saying I'm watching it.
- 1:15[Maya] We'll keep it brisk.
- 1:17[Maya] So anyway, let's start with the weirdest one.
- 1:19[David] The fridge.
- 1:20[Maya] Somebody's fridge got hacked, David.
- 1:23[Maya] Somebody's fridge.
- 1:25[Maya] Okay, so France is not treating this as a prank.
- 1:28[Maya] The foreign minister blamed Iran directly.
- 1:31[David] Wait, Iran for refrigerators?
- 1:34[Maya] For refrigerators.
- 1:36[Maya] The Washington Post reported that he called it an attack of unprecedented
- 1:40[Maya] scope and aggressiveness.
- 1:42[David] Those are big words.
- 1:44[David] How big was the actual reach?
- 1:46[Maya] Nearly 700 sites.
- 1:49[Maya] That's a lot of cold storage all getting poked at from a
- 1:51[Maya] distance.
- 1:52[David] I mean, come on, somebody sat at a keyboard and messed with
- 1:55[David] a milk aisle.
- 1:57[Maya] Right?
- 1:58[Maya] But the minister isn't laughing.
- 2:00[Maya] CNN reported that Barrot called it the first large-scale cyber attack aimed
- 2:05[Maya] at sabotage on French soil.
- 2:07[David] Sabotage.
- 2:09[David] So not a ransom thing.
- 2:11[Maya] That's how he framed it, and he promised sanctions.
- 2:14[David] Which matters, right?
- 2:16[David] Ransomware wants money.
- 2:18[David] Sabotage wants damage or a message.
- 2:20[Maya] Exactly.
- 2:22[Maya] Calling something sabotage is saying it was meant to hurt, not to
- 2:26[Maya] pay for itself, and that's a much heavier thing to say out
- 2:29[Maya] loud about another country.
- 2:31[David] What did Tehran say?
- 2:33[Maya] Nothing yet.
- 2:34[Maya] CNN noted there was no immediate comment from Tehran.
- 2:37[David] Hmm, of course.
- 2:39[Maya] Silence isn't a denial, though, and it isn't a confirmation either.
- 2:42[Maya] It's just a gap in the record right now.
- 2:45[David] Right.
- 2:45[David] So all we have at this point is France's side, and France
- 2:48[David] is making a very serious accusation in public.
- 2:51[Maya] Now, here's the detail I can't shake.
- 2:54[Maya] BFMTV, the French channel, reported that the hackers triggered defrost cycles remotely.
- 3:01[David] Defrost cycles.
- 3:03[David] Oh, that's nasty.
- 3:06[David] You don't need to break anything.
- 3:07[David] You just tell the freezer to warm up.
- 3:09[Maya] And food spoils on its own schedule.
- 3:12[Maya] Quiet, cheap, and deniable.
- 3:14[David] Deniable is the word I keep chewing on because the question with
- 3:18[David] any of these is attribution.
- 3:20[David] Who says it was Iran?
- 3:22[Maya] The French cyber agency, ANSSI.
- 3:24[Maya] Quartz reported that it traced the attack to a hacking unit called
- 3:27[Maya] Shahid Kaveh.
- 3:29[David] And that unit belongs to?
- 3:31[Maya] It's tied to the IRGC, Iran's Revolutionary Guard.
- 3:35[David] So not freelancers in a basement, a state military arm, allegedly.
- 3:40[Maya] And Quartz says investigators cite Farsi language work and IP addresses linked
- 3:44[Maya] to equipment in Iran.
- 3:46[David] Okay.
- 3:47[David] That's the kind of breadcrumb you'd expect to see, though breadcrumbs can
- 3:50[David] be planted, so I'd wanna know how strong the whole case really
- 3:53[David] is.
- 3:54[Maya] Allegedly, and it's early.
- 3:56[Maya] These are claims from French officials, so keep that in mind.
- 3:59[David] Fair, but Paris isn't just talking.
- 4:00[David] Prosecutors opened a judicial investigation.
- 4:03[Maya] And they want international arrest warrants.
- 4:05[David] Ha, good luck serving those.
- 4:06[Maya] Totally.
- 4:07[Maya] Nobody's extraditing a Revolutionary Guard hacker, but the warrants are a signal,
- 4:12[Maya] and the sanctions are the real lever.
- 4:14[David] Signal for who, though?
- 4:15[David] Tehran or the rest of Europe?
- 4:16[Maya] Probably both.
- 4:18[Maya] It tells Tehran France is serious, and it tells partners France wants
- 4:21[Maya] company.
- 4:22[David] What kind of sanctions?
- 4:23[Maya] France is pursuing European ones like entry bans and asset freezes.
- 4:27[David] Which only bite if the rest of Europe signs on.
- 4:29[David] That's the part to watch, honestly.
- 4:30[David] Brussels moves slowly, and Tehran knows it.
- 4:32[Maya] Yeah.
- 4:33[Maya] Still, it's a pretty clear line.
- 4:35[Maya] Go after a country's grocery stores, and you've made it a diplomatic
- 4:38[Maya] matter.
- 4:38[David] And think about it from the store side.
- 4:40[David] Cold storage is boring infrastructure.
- 4:42[David] Nobody plans for a villain who shows up through the freezer settings.
- 4:45[Maya] Right.
- 4:46[Maya] Boring equipment turns out to be a target, and it makes you
- 4:48[Maya] wonder what else is sitting online that nobody ever thought of as
- 4:51[Maya] a security problem.
- 4:52[David] So from here, I'd watch two things: whether the sanctions actually get
- 4:55[David] support and whether Tehran ever says a word.
- 4:58[Maya] Right.
- 4:58[Maya] Until then, it's France's case laid out in public, and we're all
- 5:02[Maya] just reading it as it develops.
- 5:03[David] Speaking of foreign governments allegedly reaching into places you'd never expect, there's
- 5:07[David] another one this week.
- 5:08[Maya] Oh, the tech CEO story, another allegation of foreign targeting, only this
- 5:13[Maya] time, the target wears a leather jacket instead of a hairnet.
- 5:16[Maya] Okay, so Nvidia, the board has opened an independent investigation into its
- 5:22[Maya] own CEO, Jensen Huang.
- 5:24[David] Wait, the board is investigating Huang himself.
- 5:27[David] That's the guy who runs the company.
- 5:29[Maya] Yep.
- 5:29[Maya] Kotaku's write-up says it came after reports in The New York Times
- 5:32[Maya] and Financial Times that Huang was targeted by a foreign intelligence effort.
- 5:37[David] A honeypot, which for anyone who skipped the spy novels, means somebody
- 5:41[David] tries to lure a target into a compromising situation.
- 5:44[Maya] Right, and here's what makes it unusual.
- 5:46[Maya] Huang himself wrote in a company memo that he was unfaithful to
- 5:50[Maya] his wife.
- 5:51[David] Huh.
- 5:52[Maya] So nobody's guessing about that part.
- 5:55[Maya] He put it in writing to his own employees.
- 5:58[David] That's a hard memo to write and a harder one to have
- 6:01[David] leak.
- 6:02[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 6:03[Maya] Delete that draft folder.
- 6:05[David] Okay, but the business question matters more than the gossip.
- 6:07[David] Nvidia makes the chips everyone's fighting over.
- 6:10[David] If a foreign service is working the man at the top, that's
- 6:13[David] a security issue, not a tabloid one.
- 6:15[Maya] Totally, and the company knows it.
- 6:17[Maya] Nvidia's line, as Kotaku reports it, is that Huang stays on as
- 6:21[Maya] CEO.
- 6:22[David] So he's not stepping aside while the board looks.
- 6:25[Maya] That's what Nvidia says, and Nvidia also says it has no reason
- 6:29[Maya] to believe national security or company secrets were compromised.
- 6:33[David] Hmm, no reason to believe.
- 6:35[David] That's carefully built.
- 6:36[Maya] It is a lawyer sentence, yeah.
- 6:38[David] Which isn't the same as, "We checked, and nothing happened."
- 6:41[David] Though to be fair, that's exactly what the independent investigation is supposed
- 6:44[David] to settle.
- 6:45[Maya] Right, and that line is about the practical question: Did anything actually
- 6:50[Maya] leak?
- 6:50[Maya] That's the thing everyone outside the company wants answered first.
- 6:54[David] Which is why I'd treat today's statement as a starting position, not
- 6:57[David] a verdict.
- 6:57[David] The company's telling us where it stands while the board does its
- 7:00[David] work.
- 7:01[Maya] Right, and the Washington Examiner piece says the board opened that investigation
- 7:05[Maya] on Sunday, so it's days old, not months.
- 7:08[David] Early innings, then.
- 7:09[Maya] Very, and China's already answered.
- 7:12[Maya] The foreign ministry denied any involvement.
- 7:14[David] Let me guess: unsubstantiated.
- 7:18[Maya] Well, close.
- 7:19[Maya] The Washington Examiner says the ministry called the allegations unsubstantiated and said
- 7:23[Maya] they were meant to smear China.
- 7:25[David] Which is the standard reply.
- 7:27[David] Deny, then say it's a smear.
- 7:28[David] You could print it before anyone asks the question.
- 7:31[Maya] Fair, but notice who's accusing whom here.
- 7:35[Maya] The reporting says a foreign intelligence effort.
- 7:38[Maya] It doesn't have a smoking gun on the page.
- 7:40[David] Right.
- 7:40[David] So we've got the memo, the board, and a denial.
- 7:43[David] Everything past that is allegation.
- 7:46[Maya] Which is why I think the honest answer to what actually happened
- 7:49[Maya] is that we don't know yet.
- 7:51[Maya] We know a probe exists, we know what the CEO wrote in
- 7:54[Maya] the memo, and we know what the company and Beijing are saying.
- 7:57[David] And the board being independent matters, at least in principle.
- 8:01[David] When it's the boss under review, you want somebody other than the
- 8:04[David] boss holding the clipboard.
- 8:05[David] That's the whole point of calling it independent.
- 8:08[Maya] And the internet, of course, did not wait for the board.
- 8:11[David] Oh, no.
- 8:12[Maya] Oh, yes.
- 8:13[Maya] TechCrunch ran a piece saying the web is having a field day
- 8:16[Maya] with memes about the alleged honeypot scandal.
- 8:19[David] Of course it is.
- 8:20[David] A chip company, a spy angle, and an affair memo.
- 8:24[David] The meme factories must have worked overtime.
- 8:26[Maya] I haven't looked at a single one.
- 8:28[Maya] Professional discipline.
- 8:30[David] You've seen all of them.
- 8:33[Maya] I've seen all of them.
- 8:34[Maya] Some are good.
- 8:35[David] Look, it's funny, but it's still an allegation, and the board's work
- 8:38[David] only started on Sunday.
- 8:40[David] There's a lot of the story we simply don't have yet.
- 8:43[Maya] Yeah, fair.
- 8:44[Maya] Laugh, then wait for the board to finish.
- 8:46[David] And we'll see whether anything beyond the memo ever surfaces.
- 8:49[Maya] Speaking of billionaires, David, and the fights people have about them, now
- 8:53[Maya] to a different kind of fight over billionaires, this one decided at
- 8:56[Maya] the ballot box.
- 8:57[David] California.
- 8:58[David] Voters had their say.
- 9:01[Maya] Okay.
- 9:01[Maya] California.
- 9:02[Maya] Voters there just said no to a one-time 5% tax on billionaires.
- 9:08[Maya] NPRs Larry Kaplow wrote that it wouldn't hit most of their overall
- 9:12[Maya] wealth, including their ownership in companies.
- 9:15[David] Ownership in companies.
- 9:17[David] That's the part that matters.
- 9:18[David] Not cash in a checking account, but stock.
- 9:20[Maya] And that's what made it so unusual.
- 9:23[Maya] Most taxes hit income or sale.
- 9:25[Maya] This one was aimed at what somebody owns, even if they never
- 9:29[Maya] sell a share.
- 9:30[David] Which is where the fight comes from, right?
- 9:32[David] Paper wealth versus money you can actually spend.
- 9:35[David] I'd guess supporters and opponents land very differently on that.
- 9:38[Maya] Right, and NPRs headline says the proposal divided Democrats in California, where
- 9:44[Maya] Democrats are pretty much the whole show.
- 9:46[David] Wait, really?
- 9:47[David] Divided how?
- 9:48[Maya] The sources don't spell out the camps.
- 9:51[Maya] CalMatters just says the vote exposed a rift among California Democrats.
- 9:56[Maya] I'll leave it at that.
- 9:57[David] Fair.
- 9:57[David] So what was it called on the ballot?
- 9:59[Maya] Prop 40.
- 10:00[Maya] CalMatters reports it was defeated after the AP confirmed results.
- 10:05[Maya] That was Monday evening, November 9th.
- 10:07[David] And the money.
- 10:07[David] Come on, tell me the money.
- 10:09[Maya] Opponents donated about $378 million against it.
- 10:15[David] Million, with an M.
- 10:16[Maya] With an M, for one ballot measure.
- 10:19[Maya] That's a staggering amount of money to pour into a single vote.
- 10:23[Maya] You know what I mean?
- 10:23[David] It really is.
- 10:24[David] Money like that tells you the people writing the checks thought this
- 10:27[David] was worth a serious fight.
- 10:28[Maya] Right, and supporters had a big pitch.
- 10:31[Maya] They said the tax would raise $100 billion for healthcare and education.
- 10:36[David] Hundred billion.
- 10:37[David] That's a pretty good sales line.
- 10:39[David] Healthcare, schools, who's against that?
- 10:41[Maya] To be fair to them, those are the kinds of things people
- 10:44[Maya] say they want funded.
- 10:45[David] Sure, but a promise on a flyer is one thing.
- 10:47[David] Once it's on a ballot, voters weigh what it costs and who's
- 10:50[David] asking.
- 10:51[Maya] Apparently a lot of voters, or enough of them.
- 10:54[David] Hmm, and I'd say that's the interesting bit.
- 10:56[David] You had a huge promise attached in a deep blue state, and
- 10:59[David] it still lost.
- 11:00[Maya] So the pitch only goes so far?
- 11:02[David] Maybe.
- 11:03[David] I wouldn't stretch it too far.
- 11:04[David] One vote, one state.
- 11:05[David] But it suggests a tax on wealth, especially a novel one on
- 11:09[David] company ownership, has limits on its appeal even where you'd expect it
- 11:12[David] to sail.
- 11:13[Maya] Novel is NPR's word, by the way.
- 11:16[David] Right, and voters tend to get nervous when it's an experiment and
- 11:19[David] they're the ones holding the bill if it goes sideways.
- 11:22[Maya] Is that the lesson, though?
- 11:23[Maya] That voters don't love being the test case?
- 11:27[David] It's one reading.
- 11:28[David] I'll admit my own lean is that taxing ownership stakes is a
- 11:30[David] hard sell, but that's opinion, not fact.
- 11:33[David] The vote itself only tells us what happened in one election.
- 11:37[Maya] Okay, but there's a twist.
- 11:38[Maya] There was a second measure, Prop 42.
- 11:41[David] Which does what?
- 11:43[Maya] Would bar future wealth taxes, period.
- 11:46[Maya] CalMatters says it was narrowly ahead Monday evening.
- 11:49[David] Narrowly, so not final.
- 11:51[Maya] Not final, so we don't know yet if California slams the door
- 11:55[Maya] on this idea for good.
- 11:56[David] Right.
- 11:56[David] Monday evening is a snapshot, not the finish line.
- 11:59[David] Huh.
- 12:00[David] So the billionaires could win twice in one night.
- 12:02[Maya] Could.
- 12:03[Maya] Let's see what the count says.
- 12:05[David] And with a lead that thin, I wouldn't write the last chapter
- 12:08[David] until the count is done.
- 12:09[Maya] Agreed.
- 12:10[Maya] Narrow lead, open count.
- 12:11[Maya] So we'll leave it right there.
- 12:13[David] That's the rundown for today, Maya.
- 12:15[David] Time to sign off.
- 12:17[Maya] Okay, one quick lap around the table before we go.
- 12:20[Maya] Iran accused of freezing, or rather defrosting, a supermarket chain.
- 12:24[David] A tech CEO whose own board is now asking questions.
- 12:27[Maya] And California voters telling the billionaire tax no.
- 12:31[David] Hmm.
- 12:32[David] Here's my takeaway, Maya.
- 12:33[David] Every one of those big claims is still moving.
- 12:36[David] Prosecutors are still working, the board is still working, and a vote
- 12:39[David] count can still shift.
- 12:41[Maya] So nobody gets to spike the football yet.
- 12:43[David] Not yet.
- 12:44[David] Wait for the paperwork.
- 12:45[Maya] And honestly, that's a decent rule for a lot of headlines.
- 12:48[Maya] The big accusation comes first, and the details trickle in later.
- 12:52[David] Right, and the details are usually where the real story lives.
- 12:55[David] So we'll keep an eye on all three.
- 12:57[Maya] The careful words matter, too.
- 12:59[Maya] Alleged, reported, early.
- 13:01[Maya] They're not just filler.
- 13:02[Maya] They're the honest description of where things stand.
- 13:04[David] That's our whole brand.
- 13:06[David] Say what we know, say what we don't, and try to be
- 13:08[David] funny in between.
- 13:10[Maya] And maybe check your fridge door on the way out.
- 13:12[Maya] Just a peek.
- 13:14[Maya] Thanks for hanging out with us, everybody.
- 13:15[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 13:16[David] And I'm David.
- 13:17[Maya] This has been the Morning Rundown.
- 13:18[Maya] We'll see you next time.