Latest / Her Moment: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / Why I Buried My Dog Before My Dad: The Unspoken Grief Hierarchy | Her Moment
Transcript
- I held my father’s hand as he took his last breath, and then I walked out into the rain to bury the dog who had been there for every single one of them. It felt like a betrayal of the natural order, didn’t it? Like I was supposed to grieve in a specific sequence, and I got the timing all wrong. There is a script we are handed when we are children about how life ends. It’s written in invisible ink, but we know the lines by heart. First comes the grandparent, maybe the great-grandparent. Then the parent. Then, if we are lucky, we live long enough to outlive our own children. But nowhere in that script does it mention the golden retriever who slept at the foot of your bed. Nowhere does it prepare you for the visceral, shattering reality of watching a creature that loves you unconditionally slip away, while the person who gave you life is still breathing, still arguing with the doctor, still asking what time dinner is. When Barnaby died, I was twenty-eight. My father was sixty-two. He was healthy, vibrant, a man who ran five kilometers every Sunday regardless of the weather. I knew this because he told me every Sunday morning. I had never imagined losing him. I had assumed he would be there for my wedding, for my first house, for the inevitable mid-life crisis I was planning to have around thirty-five. So when Barnaby passed, I thought I had lost the most important relationship of my life. And in many ways, I did. But I also carried this heavy, confusing guilt that I was mourning the wrong thing. Why was I crying over a dog when my father was still here? Why was my heart breaking for a small, furry body when my human family was perfectly intact? Society loves a hierarchy of loss. We rank grief like a ladder, assuming that the deeper the blood relation, the heavier the sorrow. If you cry more for your spouse than your sibling, people look at you sideways. If you mourn a pet with the same intensity as a human friend, you are called dramatic, sensitive, or perhaps just confused. But grief is not a math problem. It is not a scale where you can weigh the value of a life against another. Barnaby was my anchor. When I moved to the city alone, when I started this podcast before anyone listened, when I was navigating the terrifying early stages of adulthood, Barnaby was constant. He didn’t care if I had a bad haircut or if I failed a project. He didn’t judge my choices or offer unsolicited advice. He just existed, warm and solid, a testament to simple, uncomplicated love. My father, on the other hand, was complex. He was loving, yes, but he was also distant, critical, sometimes absent in ways that cut deep even when he was physically present. Losing him would mean losing history, context, origin. Losing Barnaby meant losing my present peace. Both were devastating. Neither was less real. Let’s talk about the silence. You think you know silence until you lose a pet who lived in your space completely. There is a specific frequency to the absence of a dog. It’s the lack of nails clicking on hardwood. It’s the empty spot on the rug where they always curled up. It’s the sudden awareness of how loud your own breathing sounds when there is no soft snoring beside you. For three days after Barnaby died, I walked through my apartment feeling like a ghost in my own home. I kept waiting for him to jump up on the couch, to nudge my hand with a wet nose, to remind me that I was not alone. My father came over during that time. He brought soup, which was his way of speaking love. He sat in the chair opposite me and looked at the empty space where Barnaby used to sleep. He didn’t say much. He didn’t try to fix it. He just sat with me in the quiet. And in that moment, I realized something profound. He wasn’t there to comfort me because I was sad about a dog. He was there because he understood that grief is a language, and I was fluent in pain. He saw the hole in my life, and instead of minimizing it by comparing it to his own potential future loss, he honored it. He acknowledged that Barnaby mattered. That I mattered. That this hurt was valid. Here’s the thing about burying a pet before a parent: it forces you to confront your own mortality in a way that feels premature. When Barnaby died, I looked at my father and saw how fragile humans are. I saw the gray in his hair, the slight tremor in his hands, the way he leaned on the cane now that he was sixty-three. I realized that he, too, would leave me. And that thought was so terrifying that I couldn’t process it. So I focused on Barnaby. I focused on the death I could control, the death that had already happened, rather than the death that was looming like a storm cloud on the horizon. It’s easier to grieve what is gone than to fear what might come. Burying Barnaby was a rehearsal. It was a dress rehearsal for the final act. I learned how to hold a shovel. I learned how to dig a hole in the backyard. I learned how to stand in the rain and say goodbye without saying anything at all. These are skills I wish I hadn’t needed. They are heavy, practical tools that belong in the kit of someone who has watched their world shrink. But I had them. And when my father eventually fell ill, years later, I didn’t panic. I didn’t freeze. I remembered the rain. I remembered the dirt under my fingernails. I remembered that love doesn’t end when the body stops moving; it just changes shape. We need to stop apologizing for the order of our grief. If you are mourning a pet and your parent is still alive, you are not broken. You are not ungrateful. You are not failing at being a good daughter or son. You are simply experiencing the full spectrum of human attachment. Pets are not accessories. They are family members who ask for nothing but give everything. To dismiss that bond is to dismiss the capacity for deep, pure love itself. I remember standing over Barnaby’s grave, a small mound of earth under an old oak tree. I placed his favorite toy on top—a frayed rope ball. I whispered, 'Thank you for keeping me company.' And I felt a sense of completion that surprised me. It wasn’t the end of sadness, but it was the beginning of acceptance. I accepted that I loved him deeply. I accepted that he was gone. And I accepted that my father was still here, still fighting, still living. Two truths could exist at once. One loss did not cancel out the other. It just made room for both. In the years since, my father and I have grown closer. The distance that once existed between us has closed, bridged by the shared understanding of impermanence. I see him differently now. I see the man who loved a dog. I see the man who sat in silence with me. I see the man who is learning to let go, just as I did. And I cherish every moment with him more fiercely because I know what it costs to say goodbye. Barnaby taught me that. He taught me that presence is the greatest gift we can offer. Not perfection. Not wealth. Not status. Just presence. Sitting in the quiet. Holding space. Being there. If you are holding this grief right now, if you are carrying the weight of a pet’s absence while your parent is still with you, I want you to know that you are seen. Your love is valid. Your pain is real. And you are not alone in this strange, non-linear journey of loss. We are all just trying to make sense of the connections we’ve made and the ones we’re forced to release. Let yourself feel it all. Every bit of it. Thank you for letting me share this piece of my heart with you. I’m Heidi Ashman, and I’ll be here next week, ready to unpack whatever life throws our way. Until then, take care of each other, and remember to check on your dogs. Goodnight.