Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E010: Vijay Boyapati – Bitcoin’s Bullish Case
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international.
- 1:14Asset. We are spending like drunken
- 1:17sailors. Bitcoin is the only economic
- 1:19entity where the supply is unaffected by the demand.
- 1:25If you want to preserve your wealth.
- 1:27You have to convert. That currency into an asset
- 1:31that's scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and
- 1:34maintainable. Hello, I'm Andy Edstrom and I'm
- 1:44happy to welcome you to the 10th episode of Scarce Assets, a show
- 1:48that examined scarcity, the most fundamental driver of economics
- 1:51and markets, and the scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 1:54I'm excited to be here with my great friend and Co host Jesse
- 1:57Myers and our guest, the brilliant VJ Boyapati.
- 2:01Now, VJ is simply one of the most impactful Bitcoin educators
- 2:04in the world. He's best known in the Bitcoin
- 2:07space for writing The Bullish Case for Bitcoin, which was an
- 2:10essay on Medium that he subsequently expanded into a
- 2:13fantastic book. I first read his thesis during
- 2:17the bear market of 2018 and it helped me and so many others
- 2:20strengthen our huddle grips and harden our convictions about
- 2:24bitcoins prospects. And it's really one of the
- 2:26cornerstone pieces of writing in the overall Bitcoin pantheon.
- 2:30So it's a key milestone on my Bitcoin journey and I'm
- 2:33delighted to talk with the author himself.
- 2:36By the way, he's been building products and doing great Bitcoin
- 2:40education work at Swan lately, and as always, he's talking
- 2:45about Bitcoin and educating us all.
- 2:46So VJ, it's great to see you. How are you?
- 2:49I'm doing great. Thanks for having me Andy, and
- 2:52and thanks for the kind words. Always makes me feel really
- 2:55happy hearing that I I was part of someone's Bitcoin journey, so
- 2:59I really appreciate that. Yeah, and it's absolutely true
- 3:03for many who will be listening today.
- 3:04So Viji, I think we first met in person in Santa Monica at the
- 3:10old King's Head, which is an English pub, and we were there
- 3:13to watch the real Bedford football team, and that was
- 3:17before they got good. In fact, I think they may have
- 3:19lost that game pretty painfully like 4 to one or something, but
- 3:24they've come a long way since then.
- 3:25I think they've won their league championship at least twice.
- 3:28So hats off to Peter and Danny and the and the management team
- 3:32there. But I think it's a good example
- 3:34of Bitcoin helping to improve a business, and I'm curious if
- 3:37you've seen any models of businesses adopting Bitcoin that
- 3:42are interesting to you. That's a good question.
- 3:47I've never been asked that question.
- 3:48I mean, obviously there's the big example of micro strategy.
- 3:52That's a company which really wasn't going anywhere for two
- 3:56decades if you looked at their stock price.
- 3:59It didn't, hadn't done anything. It's kind of a boring business
- 4:02as well. And then Michael Saylor, the
- 4:05CEO, came across Bitcoin and realized, wow, this is the
- 4:08greatest savings vehicle that's ever been created.
- 4:12And he came up with this strategy, which I think it's
- 4:16kind of amazing that no one else has figured this out, that you
- 4:21can start putting your savings from corporate earnings and
- 4:24profits into Bitcoin and that this can do great things for
- 4:30your company's stock price. And then he went even further
- 4:34and recognized, hey, there's this equity premium.
- 4:37Companies on the stock market seem to have a premium over what
- 4:40you really believe is the true valuation because the flows into
- 4:44the equity market, a lot of them are not very considered flows.
- 4:51They're just people throwing money into index funds.
- 4:55And the index funds just kind of sprinkle money across all of
- 4:58these companies without any consideration for whether the
- 5:00companies are good or not. They're not selecting stocks.
- 5:03So the equity market has a premium.
- 5:06And then Sailor realized, hey, wait a second, maybe I can, you
- 5:09know, take some of that premium, which isn't really very logical
- 5:12and put it into the the hardest asset that's ever existed.
- 5:16And then he went even further and did something even crazier
- 5:19and went, you know, the equity market is great, it's it's
- 5:22pretty big. But there's an even bigger
- 5:24market. There's the bond market.
- 5:26And and he figured something out that no one else had figured
- 5:29out, which is I could sell to raise money to buy Bitcoin.
- 5:33Convertible debt and convertible debt then gives the bond market
- 5:37exposure to Microstrategy's equity and through their equity
- 5:42gives them exposure to Bitcoin. Because MicroStrategy has become
- 5:46essentially a Bitcoin holding company.
- 5:49So I I find this absolutely fascinating.
- 5:52And you can look at Microstrategy's market
- 5:54capitalization has just ballooned since he figured this
- 5:57out. It tells you that there is a lot
- 6:00of appetite in these markets, the equity market and the bond
- 6:05market, even more fascinatingly to me for Bitcoin exposure.
- 6:11And it's not hard to understand why, right?
- 6:14The bond market is a tough place to be.
- 6:17You're surrounded by bonds which are yielding very little in.
- 6:22In some sovereign bonds are yielding near 0 or even negative
- 6:28rates. So if you're a bond investor and
- 6:31you're thinking how do I juice my returns, Well, he's Bitcoin.
- 6:33He's the greatest savings vehicle that's ever been
- 6:36created. Now I can get exposure to that.
- 6:39So I'm absolutely fascinated that he figured this out.
- 6:43This is like a cheat code that he figured out for juicing his
- 6:46stock price. And equally fascinating is that
- 6:49no one else has paid attention and looked over at MicroStrategy
- 6:53and said, Oh my goodness, this is this is a nothing burger
- 6:56company that didn't really do much of anything for 20 years.
- 7:00I mean to be fair, is profitable and well run, but the business
- 7:04itself is quite boring. And now this, this stock is out
- 7:08of control and it's sort of gained mean stock status.
- 7:11So people are piling into it just because it's the cool
- 7:14company to invest in and then you can kind of get into the
- 7:17issue, is it overvalued now because it's gone up so much?
- 7:20But yeah, that that's one example.
- 7:23Yeah, I love that. I love that example.
- 7:24I was also surprised at at him accessing the convert market.
- 7:28I think it was on swan signal when I when I hypothesized that
- 7:32he might do a debt offering but but I hadn't even considered the
- 7:34convert market as being the source of most of most of his
- 7:38capital and and that's been billions billions of dollars
- 7:41raised now. Really, really incredible.
- 7:43Yeah I want to point out that I almost feel like Sailor has been
- 7:48on the the VJ path of understanding of Bitcoin for for
- 7:54my personal journey of like you know I was I was into altcoins
- 7:58and I didn't really understand the purpose of Bitcoin.
- 8:02You know from the altcoin lens it's it's slow and and old right
- 8:06but so I didn't really understand and then 2018 bear
- 8:10market happens and Bitcoin does better than altcoins in that
- 8:15environment and OK what's going on here.
- 8:17Then I read your article Bullish case for Bitcoin and it explains
- 8:21really this like that core idea that you keep talking about is
- 8:24like a savings technology, savings vehicle, digital gold,
- 8:29gold that gets better and better and that's the that's the real
- 8:33line of reasoning to dig into to understand bitcoins true
- 8:37potential as an asset. And then the sort of for my
- 8:40personal journey that was continued with Bitcoin Standard
- 8:43and I think I know that Michael Saylor sort of points to the the
- 8:48Bitcoin standard as like the book that he read that changed
- 8:52his whole view on how to run his company.
- 8:54But in my in my opinion it kind of started with with your piece
- 8:59of bullish case for Bitcoin. I'm clearly articulating that
- 9:02this is how people should think about Bitcoin and how they
- 9:05should engage with Bitcoin as a savings vehicle.
- 9:07An asset that grows in value over time and all the other
- 9:11stuff is noise, and micro strategy has been using that
- 9:15understanding of Bitcoin, and I agree with you.
- 9:18I'm surprised that nobody else has has really figured out that
- 9:20that's the way to engage with it, though.
- 9:23In my view, it's just a matter of time still.
- 9:25That's a great point, Jesse, and it's something that I have
- 9:28written about on Twitter and I think in my book as well that
- 9:32monetary goods do not compete on the technological attributes,
- 9:36they compete on their monetary attributes.
- 9:39So I think one of the things is often an engineering mindset in
- 9:43in this sort of crypto space. I don't like using that term,
- 9:47but in the crypto space there's this engineering mindset and
- 9:50people are just like so drawn to the cool tech and they don't
- 9:54really look at the bigger picture that This is Money.
- 9:57And so they get attracted to, oh, there are all these bells
- 10:00and whistles or wow, Litecoin has a faster block time.
- 10:04But they miss the fact that the the, the, the, the real
- 10:09attributes that determine which one will win at the monetary
- 10:12attributes. And one other comment about
- 10:15Michael Saylor is what you said reminded me that very early on,
- 10:19just after he'd made his first purchase, he reached out to me
- 10:21and we had AI think it was an hour chat because he was just
- 10:25trying to learn. And one of the things I thought
- 10:28was really cool was that he was very curious.
- 10:31He'd gone down the rabbit hole himself and read everything he
- 10:35could. And then he took a bunch of
- 10:36materials. He took my article and he took
- 10:41Safe's book and he gave it to the the board of directors and a
- 10:44bunch of employees in his company and said this is
- 10:46important, I want you to understand this.
- 10:49And he forced them to go down the rabbit hole too.
- 10:52And I recall that call very early on and he very humble guy,
- 10:57very curious, and thankfully that gave me the connection to
- 11:01ask him to write the foreword to my book.
- 11:06Good move Sir, very good move and it is a great book and I
- 11:09highly recommend people read it, buy it and read it.
- 11:13And it confirms my suspicions that Michael Saylor sort of on
- 11:17the the bullish case for Bitcoin and Bitcoin standard view of
- 11:21what Bitcoin is first and foremost.
- 11:24Yeah, that's right. I think, I think Vijay your your
- 11:27work was definitely a milestone on on his journey.
- 11:30So hats off. So Speaking of the book and the
- 11:35essay, I think you mentioned the Gartner Hype Cycle.
- 11:39I'm curious how you might apply that framework to where Bitcoin
- 11:46sits today. Does it still apply?
- 11:48Where are we? Yeah, I think this was one of
- 11:51the most interesting observations about Bitcoin's
- 11:54monetization. That is a new, a new economic
- 11:59good becoming money. I mean, this process took
- 12:03thousands of years for gold, going from a shiny rock to
- 12:05becoming the global unit of account in the 19th century.
- 12:11And we've never seen this process happen in real time in
- 12:14the way that it is with Bitcoin, because we live in a digital
- 12:17world and things just happen much more quickly.
- 12:19Information travels much more quickly, Adoption happens more
- 12:23quickly. And you know, most economists
- 12:28prior to Bitcoin would have told you something like Bitcoin was
- 12:31impossible and that you just can't create money out of thin
- 12:35air. No one's going to accept it.
- 12:36Why would they accept it's not backed by anything.
- 12:40And so one of the things I find most fascinating is that there
- 12:44is a shape to monetization. We can sort of be students of
- 12:48economics and just look what happened with Bitcoin and it
- 12:52seems to adoption seems to grow in these fractal patterns of
- 12:56increasing magnitude. And what that really means is
- 13:00that you get these hype cycles which look very much like the
- 13:03shape of a Gartner hype Cycle. And you know you get this sort
- 13:08of slow steady growth and then this exponential blow off top
- 13:12and then a crash and then you crash to a level or a plateau
- 13:16which is higher than the previous level that you started
- 13:18at. And then it starts again.
- 13:21And if you take one of these cycles and superimpose it over
- 13:23another, they they look very similar.
- 13:26Not not exactly the same, but very similar.
- 13:28That's what I mean by a fractal pattern.
- 13:31I think this will continue. I think it's inherent to the
- 13:36social dynamic of monetization. And one of the things I found
- 13:40most fascinating when I was thinking about this and, you
- 13:43know, forming my ideas and writing my article and my book
- 13:47was I looked at the shape of monetization of gold.
- 13:50And I looked at the price chart of gold from, you know, the
- 13:541970s to the mid 2000s when I really started thinking about
- 13:59this. And I was like, wait a second,
- 14:01this actually looks very similar to what happened with Bitcoin,
- 14:03just over a longer time horizon. And So what I thought was if you
- 14:08have a free market monetary good, this is the shape of of
- 14:12monetization. It's part of the social dynamic
- 14:15where people recognize it as a good form of money.
- 14:18It has better attributes than what it's competing with.
- 14:21They get involved and slowly but surely, other people get
- 14:24involved. And as the price starts to creep
- 14:26up, other people pay attention and speculators start to join
- 14:29and they're like, wow, this is just a great profit opportunity.
- 14:32Then you get the madness of crowds, phenomena, and people
- 14:35pile in. People use leverage, they get
- 14:37ahead of themselves. And then you get the crash.
- 14:42I think free markets, this is just a phenomenon of free
- 14:45markets. People kind of go crazy
- 14:46sometimes, but the underlying dynamic is adoption is growing.
- 14:51That's why these cycles don't crash to a level lower than the
- 14:54prior cycle as a general rule. And it's also why I believe this
- 14:59is going to continue. I think this is just how the
- 15:02free market works. People kind of act in this herd
- 15:06behavior. And while we would like the
- 15:09monetization of Bitcoin to be very steady and predictable and
- 15:13linear, that would make a lot of economists feel better.
- 15:16That's just not how free market works.
- 15:19Those poor economists, you know, they just, they just they have a
- 15:22tough time. It's tough being economists
- 15:24these days. Let's let's talk a little bit
- 15:27more about the, you know, about the cycle and the development.
- 15:30I guess Bitcoin is about 15 years old.
- 15:33Where would you say it is on its path to monetization?
- 15:39Do you have a, do you have a view on that in terms of, OK, 15
- 15:42years behind? You know, what does the next
- 15:435-10 fifteen look like? Yeah, I think, I think we're
- 15:47very, very early in the adoption.
- 15:49If you just look at ownership of Bitcoin globally, I think we're
- 15:54probably, if we're going to be very generous in the order of
- 15:57like 2% of the world's population and bitcoins existed
- 16:03for 15 years. If I sort of superimpose that on
- 16:06adoption of the Internet, I'd say that we're somewhere in the
- 16:10you know, area of like 2000 and three 2004.
- 16:14But even that I think is kind of too optimistic.
- 16:18I think Bitcoin's probably closer to the like the 90s,
- 16:21maybe mid 90s in terms of adoption.
- 16:24Even if we, you know, took took the more optimistic view of
- 16:29Bitcoin's adoptions 2005. If you look back at the Internet
- 16:33in 2005, there really wasn't much there that you recognize
- 16:37today. You know, things like Facebook
- 16:41wasn't really big. I think that was around the time
- 16:44when Google Maps became free and you know, before everyone had
- 16:49like in their cars, they had the Tom Toms and and we didn't
- 16:55really have smartphones. That was kind of more 2006 or 7.
- 16:59So it's prior to what we kind of think about in terms of the
- 17:02Internet being like a ubiquitous part of our life.
- 17:05The Internet was kind of important and useful.
- 17:07But now it's like clearly one of the most important and impactful
- 17:10things in our society as an institution.
- 17:14So I think we're still super early.
- 17:17The the important question for me though is when when does the,
- 17:20the, the vertical part of the S curve have happen?
- 17:24It's a very interesting question.
- 17:25I didn't have a definitive answer on that, but I I do think
- 17:29that this sort of mainstream institutional adoption of
- 17:34Bitcoin as a financial asset is going to help that that vertical
- 17:40part of the S curve happen, Especially the approval of the
- 17:44ETFs. Because you have this large
- 17:46majority of people out there who don't quite have the
- 17:50technological savvy to figure out.
- 17:52I mean it may seem easy to us where Bitcoin is but to figure
- 17:55out like a Bitcoin exchange or Bitcoin brokerage service,
- 17:59figure out what a wallet is what, what's a Bitcoin address
- 18:02and then not shoot themselves in the foot by like self custodying
- 18:06and then losing their keys, that's a that's a heavy lift for
- 18:11a lot of people. And for people like my parents
- 18:14for instance, it would be much easier to go to a brokerage
- 18:16account and they've already done KYC and everything that most
- 18:20investors have a brokerage account.
- 18:23And if it's as easy to buy a Bitcoin exposure as it is to buy
- 18:26a stock, the the cohort of people who are reachable in this
- 18:32cycle is much, much larger. So I I dwell on that and I'm
- 18:38fascinated by that and whether or not this vertical part of the
- 18:41S curve is going to happen this cycle.
- 18:45That makes a lot of sense. That's very interesting and I I
- 18:49do I wrestle with this myself of like you know you can look on
- 18:52chain and say see that there's 4 million addresses that have 0.1
- 18:56Bitcoin or more in them. And and I tend to lean towards
- 19:00that as like true Bitcoin adoption is like if you
- 19:02understand Bitcoin enough you're going to take self custody of
- 19:060.1 Bitcoin of of Bitcoin savings.
- 19:09But you're right that like for a huge cohort of the world,
- 19:15they're just not going to be comfortable with that.
- 19:17And Bitcoin exposure does constitute some level of
- 19:20adoption. Does it?
- 19:21Is it true adoption? Maybe not.
- 19:23Is it good enough? Probably.
- 19:25And so then it's hard to place like exactly where we are in
- 19:28that adoption curve. But obviously if we're only at 4
- 19:31million out of 4 million addresses out of 8 billion
- 19:35people that puts us like the very early stages of the
- 19:39innovators phase still versus you know how Wall Street has
- 19:43been talking about this as sort of crossing the chasm moment
- 19:46with the ETS bringing us into the mainstream like bulk of the
- 19:50adoption curve. And I think it's somewhere in
- 19:52between and and obviously it's it's up to how you define
- 19:55adoption and and what you think end state behavior with Bitcoin
- 20:01will be for all people. But yeah I wrestle with that too
- 20:05and I I I haven't figured out how I view it.
- 20:08Do you do you think that there's like?
- 20:10Do you think that the ETF investors will eventually become
- 20:13on chain Bitcoin holders? Do you think that we will never
- 20:16get there? What are your views there?
- 20:19So I have a a bit of a controversial take on this and I
- 20:21haven't spoken about this very much.
- 20:23I've only spoken about it once with Stefan Lovera.
- 20:28It's controversial because I think a lot of people haven't
- 20:30very. A lot of people in the Bitcoin
- 20:32community have a lot of have a very egalitarian streak and they
- 20:36they want everyone to own Bitcoin.
- 20:40I don't think that's possible. I do not believe and the way I
- 20:45framed it with Stefan was Bitcoin is not for everyone.
- 20:49And then I kind of contradict myself in explaining this and
- 20:52explaining it is actually for everyone, but it's not for
- 20:54everyone in the sense that not everyone will be able to own or
- 20:59control Bitcoin a UTXO. They will not be able to have a
- 21:02a private key controlling a Bitcoin on chain.
- 21:05It's just not economically possible given what Bitcoin is
- 21:10and the difficulty of changing Bitcoin.
- 21:12We don't, in at least in my view, we don't want to change
- 21:16Bitcoin or make it so malleable that it becomes essentially like
- 21:21the our current system, like the Federal Reserve.
- 21:23We want to be able to trust that Bitcoin supply is fixed.
- 21:27And the only way we can trust that is if it's an immutable
- 21:30institution in the world and currently it's structured in a
- 21:32way that it is basically immutable because it is so
- 21:36difficult to make any change to Bitcoin And I believe it's
- 21:39becoming more difficult with time as people and and nodes in
- 21:44the network become more skeptical of new changes to the
- 21:47to the Bitcoin core code. I think you're going to have
- 21:51less willingness to adopt changes or is it is it or more
- 21:57specifically less willing to adopt consensus changes even if
- 22:03they're soft forks? And this I think is important.
- 22:06So given that assumption, it's just not economically feasible
- 22:10for everyone on earth to control UTXO.
- 22:13It's more likely that you can have 10s of millions somewhere
- 22:17in the order of like 50 to 100 million people control UTXOS.
- 22:22But what I think is going to happen is we're going to have a
- 22:24world where there'll be a lot of financial institutions
- 22:27controlling Bitcoin on behalf of their customers.
- 22:30And the very early form of that is the ETF, where you have a
- 22:35bunch of people who have Bitcoin exposure because they own a part
- 22:39of the ETF, and then BlackRock is the one that custodies that
- 22:42ETF for them. I think this is going to be much
- 22:45more common. This is, I think, a painful
- 22:48realization for some people who really wanted Bitcoin to be a
- 22:51tool for ultra financial sovereignty where everyone
- 22:55controls their their UTX. So I don't think that's
- 22:59possible, but I think the benefit here is much bigger.
- 23:02The benefit is that the world will be on a hard money standard
- 23:06and that that has profound implications for, you know,
- 23:10geopolitics, for economies, for everything, and generally it's
- 23:15very, very freedom promoting. I think the world on a gold
- 23:19standard was much freer than the world on a Fiat standard.
- 23:24So for me, the big picture perspective, even if we can't
- 23:27get to a place where everyone controls the UTXO, it is a world
- 23:32which Bitcoin is for everyone because we all benefit from a
- 23:35superior monetary standard. So Bitcoin is not for everyone.
- 23:39Not everyone is going to control UTXO, but it is for everyone
- 23:42because we're all going to benefit from it.
- 23:45So to to that recent comment plus your earlier one about the
- 23:49earlier stages of mapping and everyone having a TomTom in
- 23:52their car, it makes me think, it makes me wonder if one you know
- 23:57is self custody hardware wallets, are we in the TomTom
- 24:00stage, are we unfortunately going to move, going to move
- 24:03past that And if we move to the smartphone stage, you know is
- 24:07that analogous to the sort of intermediated Bitcoin for the
- 24:11majority of people I guess? I I, I think that's a great
- 24:15comment. And yeah, I I would say I am not
- 24:18bullish on the hardware wallet market because I think it's a
- 24:23limited market just by the observation that you can't have
- 24:27more than say 100 million people controlling their UTXOS.
- 24:31So if they do really well, they'll capture the entire
- 24:33market, but that's still a small percentage of the overall
- 24:36population of the globe. So I am, I'm somewhat skeptical
- 24:40of the the hardware world market and that's not to say that I
- 24:43think fully of the, I have friends who work in that space
- 24:47and who I have deep respect for brilliant people.
- 24:51But it's not something that I really think is.
- 24:54I would, I would be super excited about investing in,
- 24:57let's just say that. Yeah, I guess, I guess the
- 25:00nature and the architecture of Bitcoin has limited the total
- 25:02addressable market for hardware waltz, unfortunately.
- 25:05Yes, that's a good way of saying.
- 25:06Fortunately or unfortunately. But, but that would also mean
- 25:10that not to put words in your mouth, but that you are bullish
- 25:13on like Bitcoin banking or flavors of that.
- 25:17I'm very bullish on layer two solutions to scaling Bitcoin,
- 25:23and I think there's too much of. This is not to disparage
- 25:27Lightning. I think there is too much
- 25:29fixation that Lightning is the solution.
- 25:32Lightning could be a solution and could be part of the
- 25:36solution, but I think we're going to have a lot of
- 25:38experimentation with layer two solutions, Fetti mints.
- 25:42Centralized custodians even like.
- 25:44To be perfectly honest, if I want to use Bitcoin for
- 25:47purchasing coffee, I don't care if I keep like you know, $200
- 25:51worth of Bitcoin in a centralized custodian.
- 25:54There's certain things that I don't worry about ceding some
- 25:58control in terms of my savings. I hope there's a way that, you
- 26:03know, people can have sovereignty of their savings
- 26:05without necessarily having a UTXO.
- 26:08There is some kind of layer two solution that's decentralized in
- 26:13a way maybe not quite as decentralized as the underlying
- 26:16base layer network, but we need a lot more experimentation
- 26:21there. And I don't think Bitcoin should
- 26:24be too defensive about criticisms of Lightning.
- 26:27I think it's OK to listen to those criticisms and say, well,
- 26:31there are some shortcomings to Lightning.
- 26:33That's OK, but it doesn't matter because we have a lot of other
- 26:36things we can try here. It does not as the big blockers
- 26:40like to try and portray. It does not mean that Bitcoin is
- 26:44flawed because it didn't choose bigger blocks for scaling.
- 26:47It just means we need a lot more experimentation at layer 2.
- 26:52Yeah, I like that that that optimistic take we we don't have
- 26:56to put all the eggs in, in one basket in terms of any of the
- 27:01protocols that get built above the above the base layer.
- 27:05What we've been talking you know long cycle long term adoption
- 27:08let's let's zoom in a little bit.
- 27:11I think I heard you on Swan Signal talking a little bit
- 27:13about the phases of a bull market and I'd like to touch on
- 27:19that topic again. Could you enlighten us with
- 27:21respect to your model on that topic?
- 27:24Oh yeah, I I said in a bull market there are three kind of
- 27:28price movements and let me see if I can remember get the get
- 27:33the order of these correct. So the first is, I've forgotten
- 27:41the way I described it, but you you have basically a sideways
- 27:44movement, a zone of accumulation, that's what I call
- 27:47a zone of accumulation where you have the price kind of just
- 27:50drifting sideways for a prolonged period of time.
- 27:54And I wanted to explain what like what is the underlying
- 27:56dynamic of market participants that's causing this?
- 28:00And what you have is the price gets to a level where you have
- 28:03enough sellers who are motivated to sell at that price level and
- 28:07where supply and demand during approximately equal balance.
- 28:12And one analogy I use is of an iceberg and and ocean waves
- 28:18crashing against an iceberg and eventually you'll have a sheet
- 28:21of ice crash and break off and hit the ocean.
- 28:24And this is kind of what happens as the price of Bitcoin goes up.
- 28:27It goes up and up and up and then you hit some big holder of
- 28:31Bitcoin who's like it's hit my magic number.
- 28:33I want to diversify or I want to you know spend some of this
- 28:38money. And so they sell a big chunk and
- 28:40they they're attracted to the the current price and you can in
- 28:43the zones of accumulation you can have the price move a fairly
- 28:46significant amount, right. You can go up 10,000 or go down
- 28:5010,000 and that's because you have a lot of chop where it's
- 28:55some big seller comes in and they they dump on the market
- 28:58like we've had a few in in the last few weeks who've sold big
- 29:02chunks of Bitcoin and then you have buyers when it drops
- 29:04sufficiently but who are like I I know this is a bull market I'm
- 29:07attracted now to start accumulating.
- 29:11Eventually though, the people who are attracted at selling at
- 29:14these price levels, they they've sold all that they want.
- 29:17And then what happens is the price breaks out of this zone of
- 29:20accumulation. You get a zone of price
- 29:22discovery. And this is where the price
- 29:24starts shooting up very rapidly because there is no natural
- 29:28supply that wants to sell at that new level and the price is
- 29:31just moving all over the place. It's trying to figure out where
- 29:35the next zone of accumulation is.
- 29:38And so this is when this is the most exciting time, you know, to
- 29:42be a Bitcoin holder is in in these zones of price discovery.
- 29:47And one of the things that's most fascinating as a Bitcoin
- 29:50investor is these zones of price discovery compressed into a
- 29:55very, very short period of time, right.
- 29:58If if you are out of Bitcoin for 10 days in a bull market, you've
- 30:02lost almost all of the returns. It's during those zones of price
- 30:06discovery. And then eventually, I'm trying
- 30:10to remember what I called it. But we you, you have these air
- 30:15pockets in a bull market. And what happens is when you get
- 30:19price discovery, people start to get ahead of themselves.
- 30:23And you have speculators who are just really interested in
- 30:26Bitcoin just for the profit motive and not necessarily
- 30:30because they believe in or even understand the technology.
- 30:33And so they start piling in using leverage.
- 30:36And what happens is people get ahead of themselves, they get
- 30:38over leveraged and then a small movement in the price downwards
- 30:42causes liquidation, forced liquidations that moves the
- 30:45price down even further. And then other people who had
- 30:47leverage are liquidated and these air pockets, when the
- 30:50price drops very rapidly and these are a common feature of
- 30:54bull markets, you'll see you know 5 to 10 of these 20 to 30%
- 30:59moves down. This is common in all Bitcoin
- 31:01bull markets. So what I wanted to do when I
- 31:06was talking about this is to try and explain to people what's
- 31:09happening behind the scenes in the market, what what's
- 31:12happening with market participants and what explains
- 31:14these price movements. Right now we're in a a zone of
- 31:18accumulation. I expect eventually we're going
- 31:21to break out of this and we're going to get into price
- 31:24discovery mode and then we don't know where it goes.
- 31:26Is it going to go from 70 to 80? Is it going to go from 70 to 90
- 31:30in a straight shot? Price discovery is a really
- 31:34crazy, exciting process because no one really knows where you
- 31:38land. Yeah.
- 31:40And we're recording this on April 25th here, 2024.
- 31:44So could happen at any time. That's the thing about the I'm
- 31:47looking. At the price over here.
- 31:49Yeah, that's right. The accumulation happens for a
- 31:52while and then it stops and then you get a big move and you never
- 31:55know when that's going to happen which is why you know at on ramp
- 31:59we basically think that one should hold one's position,
- 32:03secure it very well in a multi institution, multi sig
- 32:07arrangement and not get too tricky with the with the
- 32:10trading, but people love to chase the rabbit, they can't
- 32:12help themselves. Yeah, the hardest thing as a as
- 32:15a Bitcoin investor is doing the simplest thing.
- 32:18It is very, very difficult to just sit and hold and do the
- 32:22boring thing. Human nature is herd based and
- 32:26we see what other people are doing and unfortunately we our
- 32:30emotions can take hold. So if you're able to just do the
- 32:33boring thing, you will outperform 99% of people who are
- 32:36doing complex trading strategies.
- 32:39Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 32:41exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 32:44about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 32:47allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 32:52We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 32:55So, so maybe let's talk a little bit about if you're comfortable
- 32:58about someone who didn't do the boring thing.
- 33:00I'm talking about Barry Silbert. I know you have views on his
- 33:08business activities, including at Grayscale.
- 33:11Curious if you'd like to make any comments about how that's
- 33:15gone, you know, where we are with respect to how that has
- 33:20affected the Bitcoin market, you know, whether we're past it or
- 33:24yeah, just any thoughts you have on it?
- 33:27Yeah. So Barry Silbert is the CEO of
- 33:28DCG. And DCG aspired to be the
- 33:31Berkshire Hathaway of the crypto market.
- 33:34And that is how be the be the owner of a bunch of companies
- 33:38that are very important in in that space.
- 33:41And so he owned actually two of the most important companies in
- 33:44the the crypto space, Grayscale and Genesis.
- 33:50And Genesis was a company that provided prime brokerage
- 33:53services, which meant that they they lent and borrowed Bitcoin,
- 33:57they provided options, they did this for institutions and then
- 34:01they did it for whales, high net worth individuals.
- 34:06And he also owned Grayscale, which is a company that provided
- 34:09the first kind of product in the equity market, GBTC, which gave
- 34:14equity market investors exposure to Bitcoin.
- 34:17The problem with GBTC as a product was that it was not an
- 34:22ETF, it was a trust, It was a trust based product.
- 34:26And while the the trust, the GBTC trust owned bitcoins and so
- 34:30gave equity market participants exposure to Bitcoin, it didn't
- 34:35have a redemption mechanism. And so the problem there is that
- 34:39you can this premium can develop where the value of GBTC as a
- 34:45fund exceeded the value of the assets underneath.
- 34:49And why? Why could that happen?
- 34:51It happened because equity market participants didn't have
- 34:54other ways of getting Bitcoin exposure.
- 34:57And there was so much demand to get Bitcoin exposure in, you
- 35:01know, from 2014 to 2021 that people were willing to pay a
- 35:05premium when buying GBTC over the value of its underlying
- 35:09assets. This premium then created an
- 35:13arbitrage trade that's been called the Widowmaker trade
- 35:16because everyone who got involved in this trade blew up.
- 35:19Everyone who got involved in this trade went into bankruptcy.
- 35:22And there's a lot of firms that this happened to.
- 35:25And what they did was you would put put Bitcoin into GBTC and
- 35:31six months later you'd get shares of GBTC for the the
- 35:35Bitcoin you put in. And because GBTC was trading at
- 35:38a premium to Bitcoin, you're essentially making free money,
- 35:42that premium. And so a lot of companies
- 35:44recognized this by 2020 and they're like, wow, free money,
- 35:49Free money is great. And and what they did was they
- 35:51started piling into this trade with leverage.
- 35:54And so you had a lot of companies, most prominent of
- 35:57which was 3 Arrows Capital and but unfortunately for these
- 36:02companies, the premium went away by early 2021.
- 36:07And the reason it went away was both because so many people were
- 36:10chasing the premium and they got arbitraged away and also because
- 36:14you had alternatives to to get Bitcoin exposure in the equity
- 36:18market and micro strategy became one of those.
- 36:21So you had competition as well. And when the premium went away,
- 36:25it actually went the other direction.
- 36:27GBTC turned into a discount. So people recognized that, hey,
- 36:34this you can't get your bitcoins out of here.
- 36:37There's no redemption mechanism. Maybe I don't want to own this.
- 36:40Maybe there's better ways of getting Bitcoin exposure.
- 36:43And then the the fund became worth half of its assets under
- 36:47management, which was absolutely crazy, right?
- 36:49Like it's got all of this Bitcoin.
- 36:52At one point it had 600,000 plus bitcoins and what was really
- 36:57gross about this was Grayscale was charging a 2% fee on on the
- 37:01assets under management. They're not really doing
- 37:04anything with those bitcoins. They're just sitting in cold
- 37:06storage. It's not like they're this hard
- 37:08work involved in managing these bitcoins.
- 37:11They were collecting 12,000 bitcoins a year on this fund.
- 37:16So here's the problem, right? DCG is sitting above these two
- 37:19companies, Genesis and Grayscale, and it has this
- 37:24perverse incentive to encourage people to borrow from Genesis
- 37:28and do this arbitrage trade. They really like it.
- 37:32They're like, this is great, go 3 Rs capital, borrow as much as
- 37:35you want and put it into, put it into grayscale.
- 37:39Because then what happens is when they do this trade, they're
- 37:42putting bitcoins into GBTC and those bitcoins are stuck in
- 37:48GBTC. This is why the assets under
- 37:50management went as high as 600,000 because GBTC was a Hotel
- 37:55California. You can go in but you can never
- 37:57come out. So DCG is looking at this and
- 38:01it's great, everything is great and and so it even took part in
- 38:06this trade. DCG even took part in this
- 38:08trade. But the problem is when the
- 38:09trade blew up, Genesis have lent money to all the companies that
- 38:15were doing this trade. It lent money to three Rs.
- 38:17Capital and it lent money to various other people who are
- 38:21doing this trade. And they all blow up.
- 38:22And then all of a sudden Genesis has a massive hole in its
- 38:26balance sheet. They suffer a $1 billion loss.
- 38:29Now what do you do when you have a $1 billion hole in your
- 38:32balance sheet when you're a prime broker?
- 38:34Well, the the correct thing to do, the legal thing to do is to
- 38:38declare bankruptcy. Hey, guys, hey, creditors, you
- 38:41know, you lend us Bitcoin, but we can't pay you back.
- 38:44Now we'll distribute whatever assets we have, and that's not
- 38:47what they did. What happened was DCG came in
- 38:50and created this promissory note, this fake promissory note
- 38:56to kind of fill the hole, the loss of $1 billion and to create
- 39:01the impression that Genesis was fine.
- 39:04They did not want Genesis to go under.
- 39:06And why did they not wanted Genesis to go under?
- 39:10Because Genesis had lent DCG money, and if they Genesis went
- 39:14into bankruptcy, it would pull it would call on all those loans
- 39:18that it made and call them immediately.
- 39:20And so DCG would have been forced to pay back a loan and
- 39:23DCG probably would have gone into bankruptcy as well.
- 39:26And then being liquidated. And you know what, Barry Simple,
- 39:29where did he come from? Oh, that's right.
- 39:31He is an expert in bankruptcy. He worked on the Worldcom
- 39:34bankruptcy and the Enron bankruptcy.
- 39:37He's an expert. And so he is an expert in
- 39:39structuring these things. And so with together with
- 39:42Genesis, DCG created a promissory note to make it look
- 39:46like Genesis was solvent. The problem is this promissory
- 39:50note was not real capital. It was not like cash or Bitcoin
- 39:54or something that you could easily sell.
- 39:56It was a promise to pay back a billion dollars in 10 years,
- 40:00which could not be redeemed and paid below market interest
- 40:04rates, so paid like 1%. So really Genesis was still
- 40:08insolvent, but it was going out to the market and telling
- 40:11people, hey, we're fine, we're fine, we've done stuff to
- 40:14mitigate the losses. You can actually, these tweets
- 40:16are still on Twitter. You can go look at the CEO of
- 40:18Genesis, Michael Morrow, and his tweets.
- 40:20They were actively lying to the public to solicit more loans
- 40:24from creditors. And DCG was part of this.
- 40:28So this was discovered. And the New York Attorney
- 40:32General sued DCG. It sued Barry Silbert
- 40:35personally. It sued Michael Morrow
- 40:37personally. And it.
- 40:40And it's arguing that they, DCG should no longer be able to do
- 40:44business in New York. They were involved in an alleged
- 40:49fraud alleged by the New York Attorney General.
- 40:52If anyone's interested, I think reading the complaint of the New
- 40:54York Attorney General is very interesting.
- 40:56It's very detailed and has very substantive allegations against
- 41:00DCG. But my problem and why I was
- 41:04really keen on explaining this is not many people understood
- 41:09what had happened with DCG and Genesis.
- 41:11It was kind of hiding in the shadows.
- 41:13Everyone was interested in the SPF fraud and what happened and
- 41:16all the drama involved in that. But I thought that that was far
- 41:20less important than the fraud that happened with DCG because
- 41:24that was at the heart of the 2022 market collapse.
- 41:28And FTX was just a domino that fell in that collapse.
- 41:31It wasn't really the precipitating thing.
- 41:33The precipitating thing was this, you know, very incestuous
- 41:40corporate relationship between DCG Genesis and and grayscale
- 41:45and and and the the catastrophe this cause for millions of
- 41:49investors. So that's why I I was interested
- 41:52in, that's why I, you know, wrote a Twitter thread on this,
- 41:55which got 2 million views. People were like, whoa, Barry
- 41:59Silbert's not actually a good guy.
- 42:01He was part of this horrendous collapse and he really needs to
- 42:05be held accountable for it. Yeah, that's well said.
- 42:09I remember that thread and it was, it was fascinating to read.
- 42:13And yeah, I have not read the complaint, but I do recommend
- 42:16people check out that thread the VJ that you put out on Twitter X
- 42:21Great, great detail, very important series of events in
- 42:26the history of the market for Bitcoin and therefore yeah, for
- 42:31Bitcoin itself. A lot of details.
- 42:33I I didn't. I didn't have the full picture
- 42:36until you walked us through that right there.
- 42:38So thanks for bringing all that to light.
- 42:40I knew the isolated events, but how it all connected together as
- 42:43a series I I actually didn't fully know.
- 42:46Yeah, I think it is. Sorry, sorry.
- 42:48Just go ahead. Just respond to Andy and say I
- 42:51agree with you that it's a historic event in the history of
- 42:53this space. It's as important, I think, as a
- 42:56collapse of Mount Gox. And people will look back on it
- 42:59and do sort of historical excavation and realize that
- 43:02Barry Silbert was really a big part of the reason the market
- 43:06suffered so much in in 2022. And I expect eventually he will
- 43:10be held accountable for what he's done.
- 43:12He hasn't gone to jail like SBSBF has, but once all the
- 43:15facts come out, I think the general perception of him as
- 43:19like the good guy and the responsible businessman will be
- 43:22completely blown out of water. What?
- 43:24What is it about? What is it about Bitcoin and
- 43:27people who have tons of success in Bitcoin that there's so many
- 43:30Icarus stories here? Bitcoin Derangement Syndrome or
- 43:34whatever you want to call it? Why does this happen?
- 43:36Vijay I. I think it reminds me of a quote
- 43:40that I heard about the US Constitution, that it was, it
- 43:43was written by geniuses so it could be interpreted by idiots.
- 43:47And I feel like Satoshi created this incredibly important
- 43:51invention. And unfortunately, a lot of the
- 43:53companies in this space that built up around it were just
- 43:57criminal, malfeasant, incompetent, just every kind of,
- 44:02you know, bad adjective you could throw at it, especially in
- 44:06the early days. So for instance, Mount Gox, Mark
- 44:09Coppelles had no idea what he was doing.
- 44:12I mean, he he bought the business when it was insolvent,
- 44:14and he he didn't realize that he had lost like hundreds of
- 44:18thousands of bitcoins in a hack until it was too late.
- 44:23We we really are. I think it's gotten a lot
- 44:26better, but I still think we're starving for great
- 44:29entrepreneurs. And so there's a huge
- 44:31opportunity here for folks because I think at some point it
- 44:36will be less obvious that the better investment is Bitcoin
- 44:40rather than Bitcoin companies. And for a long time, I said
- 44:43there's no point in investing in Bitcoin companies because the
- 44:45upside of Bitcoin is still too high.
- 44:49But eventually Bitcoin's value gets large enough that you
- 44:51really want to invest in picks and shovels and people who build
- 44:54the ecosystem around Bitcoin. And so if you're an
- 44:57entrepreneur, I this is a great time to start building on
- 45:01Bitcoin and building products or services or education like you
- 45:05guys are doing, there's huge opportunities ahead.
- 45:10Fully agree. So why don't I invite you to
- 45:14speculate a little bit about the future of VGA?
- 45:18Let's suppose I agree and say yes, you know some of the riff
- 45:22raff has been washed out. However, wouldn't it be a
- 45:26miracle if all of it had been? In other words, I'm trying to
- 45:30say it might not be the end of the story with respect to hubris
- 45:35and people building and then blowing things up in the Bitcoin
- 45:39space. Are there any areas of concern
- 45:43that are on your radar for potential future blow UPS?
- 45:49Yeah, I mean I still look at Binance as a company that I'm
- 45:52concerned about. It's not not like it has had the
- 45:56best history in terms of being responsible.
- 46:01I I think, you know, one of the things I'm optimistic about is
- 46:06that grayscale is this is something that should be talking
- 46:09about as well. This is great irony that
- 46:11Grayscale was the the company that fought for the Bitcoin ETF
- 46:15the hardest, but really damaged their business the most by doing
- 46:18so. They had more than 600,000
- 46:21bitcoins under management and when they were approved as an
- 46:25ETF, they started bleeding bitcoins like a stuck pig.
- 46:30They and they continue to bleed bitcoins and I actually see this
- 46:35as a very healthy thing. I think those bitcoins going
- 46:39leaving Grayscale and going to other companies, be it Fidelity
- 46:43or BlackRock, you know, the actual more responsible players
- 46:48in the room, I think would be really helpful.
- 46:50I think having that value no longer under Barry Silbert's
- 46:54control is great for the market. And you know, there are only so
- 46:57many days that GBTC and Grayscale can lose $100 million
- 47:02worth of Bitcoin before they don't have any Bitcoin left.
- 47:05They in the first three months of after Bitcoin's ETF approval
- 47:09and the the ability of people to take bitcoins out of GBTC, it's
- 47:14dropped from over 600,000 to down to 300,000.
- 47:18Whether that pace continues is an open question, but I believe
- 47:21it will continue at a pretty steady pace.
- 47:24There's no reason to want to keep your money in grayscale
- 47:27when they're charging 1.5% fee when everyone else is charging
- 47:33me 0. Like, why do you want to stay
- 47:35with Barry Silbert? I I wouldn't.
- 47:39Fair enough. I've I've heard a few anecdotes
- 47:42from people I know of of unrealized capital gains is the
- 47:46only reason holding them there and and that's that's pretty
- 47:49compelling for some people who have been holding on to GBTC for
- 47:53quite some time. Yeah, absolutely.
- 47:55I I I think that's true. There is a circumstance if you
- 47:59own GBTC in a taxable account and you've got say you know a
- 48:03large capital gain on it, it may be more painful to sell and take
- 48:07that capital gain. But my view is that people who
- 48:11are using GBTC are not the same kind of people you'd think of as
- 48:15hardcore hodlers in general. I think people who become
- 48:19hardcore hodlers are, are people who are more inclined to want to
- 48:23own Bitcoin on chain. So I think this is part of my
- 48:27thesis that even though there isn't a disincentive to sell
- 48:30GBTC if you own it in a taxable account, I think the time
- 48:34horizon for some of those folks is probably, you know, six
- 48:36months to a year and eventually that turnover will happen.
- 48:39And once they leave GBTC, they're never coming back.
- 48:43Because Grayscale does not have the sort of natural organic
- 48:49client base that Fidelity has or Black Rock has.
- 48:52Like Fidelity has millions of clients that they can just
- 48:55market to directly, right, And say, hey, we've got this Bitcoin
- 48:58product, you want to Who does Grayscale?
- 48:59Have they? They're not like a major fund
- 49:01manager or anything. They just have some crappy
- 49:03crypto products. So once people leave Grayscale,
- 49:06they'll never come back. That's right.
- 49:09I have a a friend who sells fund products for a living, and he
- 49:14joined Grayscale. I can't remember how long ago.
- 49:18It was sometime in the prior cycle and he figured out pretty
- 49:22quickly what was going on, including that it might be
- 49:26difficult to sell new products because that was what he was
- 49:30hired to do, right? It wasn't.
- 49:31He wasn't hired to sell more of the Bitcoin Trust or more of the
- 49:35Ethereum trust or something. He was.
- 49:36He was there to sell new altcoin products and he figured out
- 49:40pretty quickly that this was going to be a a tall task for
- 49:44him to to approach the market this way.
- 49:46Yeah, could I just make one last comment on on this.
- 49:49Grayscale has one other very large product E which is similar
- 49:56to GBTC and it has quite a lot of assets on the management.
- 49:59I think it's, I think it's something in the order of 200
- 50:02and Oh no, sorry that's not true.
- 50:04It generates 200 and it has over $10 billion in this fund and it
- 50:08generates $250 million in cash flow for Grayscale because they
- 50:13charge a 2.5% fee on this fund. It's just it's even grosser than
- 50:18GBTC because they're not doing anything with this fund either.
- 50:21The ether is trapped in there. They have an interesting
- 50:26question to answer. Do they actually want to pursue
- 50:29ETF approval? I think behind the scenes they
- 50:32are hoping, they're praying that the SEC will say no, no ETF for
- 50:38Etherium. We're not going to approve it
- 50:40because then they maintain that those cash flows, if the SEC
- 50:44does approve it, they're going to have the same outflow from
- 50:46this fund that they had with GBTC and their business is just
- 50:50going to crumble before their eyes.
- 50:52If I were them, I would actually be lobbying behind the scenes.
- 50:55The SEC, please don't approve this.
- 50:57Please do not convert our fund to an ETF.
- 51:01But hey, that's that's the situation they're in right now.
- 51:03It's not a good one. Yeah, agree.
- 51:06Agree completely there. It's a it's a tough situation.
- 51:09They have to put on that brave face.
- 51:12I think that I I agree with you. If it gets converted, it will
- 51:17likely be due to the legal efforts of one of the other
- 51:21providers. Maybe it's BlackRock that just
- 51:23makes the decision that they really want to continue to grow
- 51:26the space and they want to be a leader and they've managed to
- 51:30sort of take pole position in the Bitcoin ETF space, so why
- 51:33not the rest of it? But we'll have to see how it's
- 51:36we'll have to see how it plays out.
- 51:38I I I hope that that doesn't happen because I do have this
- 51:41fear that once you've greenlit an ETF, you've kind of that that
- 51:46really adds to the case of this is not a security, it's a
- 51:52commodity. And my view is that Ethereum is
- 51:54a is a security. It does not fly flies afoul of
- 51:58the Howie test and I have this fear that once you know once the
- 52:03green light an Ethereum ETF, then it's kind of no going back
- 52:08towards classifying it as a security, which I think it is.
- 52:12And I think if you know, once regulators do their homework
- 52:14enough, that's the nature of of what happened at the genesis of
- 52:19Ethereum. I think it also opens Pandora's
- 52:22box, Jesse, and I think it would be a very irresponsible for the
- 52:27SEC to let the market, the wider market, the people who are not,
- 52:31who do not have much sophistication, get exposure to
- 52:35all of these shit coins. I think it would be very, very
- 52:37dangerous. And I think they need to draw
- 52:40the line and they really should draw the line after Bitcoin and
- 52:43recognize that all of these things really were securities.
- 52:46I mean, Ethereum was a security. It started out as basically a
- 52:50share offering. You had a bunch of insiders
- 52:53dumping on the public, and if that had happened today,
- 52:56everyone would recognize that was a security, it was a
- 52:59securities offering, and it's it's it's clear for all of the
- 53:03other shit coins out there, they're all securities.
- 53:06And the SEC would do a huge disservice to the public in
- 53:09general if they expose them to this.
- 53:11Especially all the marketing scams around all these all of
- 53:16these shit coins that convinced the most unwary people to get
- 53:20involved at the worst possible time.
- 53:23Completely agree. Lots of lots of money.
- 53:26Lots of naive money has been lost, The public basically has
- 53:30been has been preyed on. So makes me think of one of the
- 53:34factors that may make Ethereum a security was that they changed
- 53:37the consensus mechanism. How could one do that if it were
- 53:43not a security? As an example, and it makes me
- 53:46think about the issue of ossification and upgrades within
- 53:50Bitcoin, and I know Vijay, you had some thoughts about that.
- 53:55You've been pretty clear that you don't want to see too many
- 53:59rapid improvements on Bitcoin because there are risks
- 54:02inherent. Can you tell us more about your
- 54:04current thoughts? Well, this is really cool.
- 54:06We're touching on 2 hot button topics in one episode.
- 54:11Yeah, I would call myself or describe myself as an
- 54:14ossification maximalist and yet might might re characterize what
- 54:19you said a little bit and say they're not improvements.
- 54:23I think changes to Bitcoin in in a lot of ways are detrimental to
- 54:28Bitcoin, even if they seem cool from a technological
- 54:31perspective. And I'll go so far as to say
- 54:33perhaps just to add some spice or controversy to this point.
- 54:38I would have been fine with Bitcoin not adopting SegWit.
- 54:42I think Bitcoin would have been as valuable today if SegWit had
- 54:47not been adopted, and it would have been more difficult to
- 54:50build Lightning on top of Bitcoin without SegWit.
- 54:54But I think the fundamental value of Bitcoin is that it's an
- 54:57immutable institution for transferring value across the
- 55:00world, and that you can be certain that your savings will
- 55:04not be debased. Those are the twin pillars of
- 55:07Bitcoin's value proposition. And I think this kind of fast
- 55:10and loose attitude to adding things to Bitcoin really
- 55:13undermine those pillars, those two pillars.
- 55:17So I am very much against, and I know I have colleagues who I
- 55:21deeply respect, who disagree with this.
- 55:25I'm very strongly against almost any change to Bitcoin at this
- 55:28point. I don't want covenants.
- 55:30I don't want anything else. I don't want any changes to the
- 55:35consensus mechanism. I I want it to be known that
- 55:38Bitcoin is essentially impossible to change.
- 55:41And actually the good thing is you can have ossification at the
- 55:44individual level by people who run notes saying, Nope, not
- 55:49going to upgrade. I don't want to upgrade and I
- 55:51don't believe that we need these changes.
- 55:55I think there's only one exception that I would support
- 55:58if there was a catastrophic critical bug.
- 56:01If we were in gravest extreme of Bitcoin being unusable, I would
- 56:06support a change to fix that bug.
- 56:08But I am against any so-called improvements because I actually
- 56:12think they're not improvements at all.
- 56:14They are changes that undermine Bitcoin's fundamental value
- 56:18proposition and I am against that.
- 56:19So I would say I'm an ossification maximalist.
- 56:23Love it, and I think we're living through the the
- 56:28unexpected unintended 2nd order effects of changes made with
- 56:34ordinals right now. I I learned this recently at the
- 56:37at the MIT Bitcoin conference from Gustavo from Wasabi wallet.
- 56:42But that block space is 30 to 40% cheaper for ordinals than it
- 56:49is for regular transactions because of SegWit and an
- 56:53additional 4% cheaper because of Taproot.
- 56:56And so it's that those two changes created an uneven
- 57:01playing field for block space and I and I don't think that
- 57:05that was properly appreciated when the pushes for SegWit and
- 57:09Taproot what were happening. A fantastic point.
- 57:13I think there are unintended consequences to economic
- 57:15changes. This is true for the greater
- 57:17economy and also true for Bitcoin.
- 57:19And it's important to understand, look back and to
- 57:23learn from the fact that the engineers who are involved in
- 57:27Bitcoin were very excited about these changes.
- 57:30I'll confess also that I was excited about the adoption of
- 57:33SegWit. But I think we need to learn
- 57:36lessons from what has happened. And I think if we do learn
- 57:40lessons from it, it's that we should be extremely cautious
- 57:43about changing Bitcoin. We have this precious thing in
- 57:45the world and it's really ours to fuck up.
- 57:49And I I hope we don't. And I hope people sort of take
- 57:52this stance that I don't want changes.
- 57:55You're going to have to really sell me on this change.
- 57:57If you want me to upgrade my node from, you know, version 26
- 58:00or whatever it is to version 27, because I don't, I'm not going
- 58:04to do it anymore. I don't believe that it's worth
- 58:06it. And it might might be fun as an
- 58:08engineering project, but not, as you know, changing the most
- 58:12important monetary institution in the world.
- 58:16Well, and it's nice to, it's nice to hear very intelligent,
- 58:24experienced Bitcoiners say things like, you know, I wanted
- 58:27one thing before and you know, it may or may not have been the
- 58:31right thing. And so everyone learns in
- 58:34Bitcoin. We all make mistakes.
- 58:35We're all wrong at one point or another.
- 58:38And that's clearly an important lesson and clearly important
- 58:42lesson that Bitcoin imposes, let's say, on probably every
- 58:47single one of us. Even Satoshi probably couldn't
- 58:51have imagined the way this had gone, or imagined what Bitcoin
- 58:54would become in the long run. Well, notwithstanding that
- 59:00Bitcoin is now for Wizards, it's also for for everyone else, like
- 59:05we talked about earlier. Speaking of which, I think I saw
- 59:07you VJ, on the agenda for the Bitcoin is for Everyone
- 59:11conference in Portland. Shout out to Eddie, I'm going
- 59:14to, I'm going to try to make it up for that one myself.
- 59:16I'm trying to nail down logistics so.
- 59:19That's awesome. I hope people can make it out to
- 59:21that one. It's going to be a lot of fun.
- 59:22Yeah, I totally agree. I'm going to do my best and and
- 59:25and people should definitely come out and check it out, but
- 59:29we're we're coming up on time here.
- 59:31What else would you like to leave us with?
- 59:33Any final thoughts with respect to how people can check out
- 59:37either what you're working on right now or your Canon of work
- 59:40that you've produced over the years?
- 59:46You're on mute there. Sorry, I'm muted.
- 59:47All good. What am I working on?
- 59:51I I'd say right now, mostly I'm working on both being a dad,
- 59:55being a Bitcoin evangelist, and being part of SWAN.
- 1:00:00I'm super excited to be part of SWAN.
- 1:00:02It's such a cool company and I think.
- 1:00:05One of the things I really appreciate is Corey's vision of
- 1:00:08a Bitcoin only company. It's very rare actually.
- 1:00:10There are a bunch of companies who work in the space, in the
- 1:00:12Bitcoin space, and they don't have this mission of being
- 1:00:20Bitcoin only. And the fact that it's not just
- 1:00:24in product vision but in terms of the staffing, I think is what
- 1:00:28makes it so exciting. I love being surrounded by
- 1:00:32people who also care about the same thing and having the same
- 1:00:35values. There's no better workplace.
- 1:00:39And I I'll leave with a a message that I got very early on
- 1:00:42in my career, which was the only I I was trying to decide between
- 1:00:47whether I joined Google or Yahoo back in the early days when
- 1:00:50Google was very small and Yahoo was offering me a lot more money
- 1:00:54and I was just out of college. And I asked a friend of mine
- 1:00:59what I should do. I I really didn't know.
- 1:01:01And he said the only rational point of having money is if it
- 1:01:04can make you happy. So if you can work at a company
- 1:01:07that makes you happy, that's worth a lot of money.
- 1:01:10And that really made the decision very easy for me.
- 1:01:13I knew I would be happier at Google, the people much more
- 1:01:17exciting. It was a much less corporate
- 1:01:18environment. It was just like a crazy place
- 1:01:21to be, a great place to work. It worked out financially too,
- 1:01:25but I didn't know it at the time.
- 1:01:27So I have that same feeling about Swan.
- 1:01:29I get a lot of happiness from being at Swan because it's
- 1:01:31Bitcoin only. So that's part of what I'm
- 1:01:34working on. And you know, if other people
- 1:01:36are interested in in working the Bitcoin space, I would encourage
- 1:01:39them to consider SWAN as well. Well, I love that.
- 1:01:43I agree completely as a swan investor and a former swan
- 1:01:47employee as well. So 100% under score what you
- 1:01:50said And just to return to the theme of our podcast, which is
- 1:01:53scarce assets, it's great advice.
- 1:01:56Bitcoin is an extremely scarce asset.
- 1:01:58Also extremely scarce are work environments with great people,
- 1:02:02visionary people that are building amazing products.
- 1:02:05And I couldn't agree more. So VJ, this has been a
- 1:02:09tremendous conversation. Thank you so much.
- 1:02:12We really learned a ton and hope to do it with you again
- 1:02:15sometime. Awesome.
- 1:02:17Thanks guys. It's great speaking with both of
- 1:02:18you. Thanks VJ.