Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / From Crisis to Healing: Phyllis Leavitt Explores America's Mental Health Landscape
Transcript
- 0:26None. Welcome to this very special
- 0:28edition of the KIJ Master Class Live, the show which ensures
- 0:32that you profit from your time spent here with experts, either
- 0:36through their insights, information or simply learning
- 0:39from them. And today we have Phyllis
- 0:42Leavitt. She is an author and
- 0:44psychologist. She has a master's degree in
- 0:47Psychology and Counseling from Antioch University, and she has
- 0:51done a lot of things. Her latest book, America in
- 0:55Therapy. We will discuss about that.
- 0:57Welcome to the show, Phyllis. Thank you so much for having me
- 1:00here today. Thank you.
- 1:02You are welcome to the show. You are welcome to India in this
- 1:06online form and I am sure not just in India, but a lot of
- 1:10people would be interested to know.
- 1:12Phyllis, why do you do about your book America in Therapy?
- 1:17So tell us about this book of yours, America in therapy.
- 1:21And especially, you know, why Do you think America is suffering a
- 1:24mental health crisis? Well, actually, I think the
- 1:28human race is suffering a mental health crisis.
- 1:31But I'm talking to America because I live here and I'm
- 1:34familiar with this country. And yes, I think we're suffering
- 1:38a severe mental health crisis. Because kind of in a nutshell,
- 1:43what I would say, and I think this is true for a lot of people
- 1:46around the world, that what we condone, what we fund, what we
- 1:51condone in terms of war and weaponry and persecution of
- 1:56marginalized people and withholding of resources from
- 2:00people who need it the most, What we condone we would never
- 2:03want in our own lives. And that gap between what we
- 2:07consider right and just and appropriate for ourselves and
- 2:12what we're willing to condone and perpetrate for other people
- 2:16is a mental health issue. And we have all been sort of
- 2:20conditioned to believe that it's an ideological issue.
- 2:23But it's not because mentally healthy people don't hurt other
- 2:28human beings deliberately and for their own profit and gain or
- 2:33power or influence or any of the other motivations that have us
- 2:37act out on our brother and sister human beings.
- 2:43Right, right. Phyllis, help us understand.
- 2:46Elaborate what you just said because you know, so that people
- 2:51understand why exactly Who is responsible for all these
- 2:56problems? Is mental health a creation of
- 2:59our own minds or is it that Is it the society that we live in?
- 3:03Then what happens to the people who are supposed to make things
- 3:07all right? Why are they not making things
- 3:10all right? Where is the of the people?
- 3:12By the people, for the people? Where has that concept gone?
- 3:16Very good question and you know the answer.
- 3:19The answer I think is multifaceted.
- 3:22So, you know, I can say a few things in the time that we have,
- 3:25but by taking a psychological look at what's going on and I'll
- 3:30just say in America. But I think we can apply this to
- 3:32a lot of places by taking a look through the lens of psychology
- 3:36rather than ideology. We can see my training a lot was
- 3:43in family systems, and that's really a very important lens
- 3:48when we're doing psychological work with people.
- 3:50We used to think that people were just sort of like their own
- 3:53problem. If you're messed up, there's
- 3:55something wrong with you. But we now know that we're very,
- 3:59very conditioned by the family systems we live in, the role
- 4:02models of our parents, what's expected of men and women, how
- 4:06we deal with conflict, who we're supposed to be as adults or
- 4:10treat children, or, you know, any of the other expectations
- 4:13that we put on ourselves. We learn in our family systems.
- 4:17And to begin with, we sort of focused on our family of origin,
- 4:21our parents, our extended family.
- 4:23But now we know that our community, our state, our
- 4:28federal government, they're all family systems.
- 4:31They're large businesses. They all operate on the same
- 4:34principles of family systems. And so, you know, as a psych
- 4:38psychotherapist, I have been trained and done a lot of work
- 4:43over the years with many, many families.
- 4:45And I'm not alone in what I'm going to say that we see what
- 4:49are some of the dynamics that make up a healthy family?
- 4:53What are the things that heal a family of dysfunction and
- 4:56violence if there's violence and abuse?
- 4:59And the whole point of my book, America and Therapy, is to take
- 5:04that lens of what creates a healthy family and what causes
- 5:09dysfunction and what are the results of dysfunction and abuse
- 5:13if it's not stopped and if people don't get treatment and
- 5:17take that lens and apply it to our country.
- 5:20Because I think it's not, you know, it's not hidden that a lot
- 5:26of the policies and practices that come down from the top
- 5:30mirror abusive family dynamics, discrimination, withholding of
- 5:35resources, investing in weaponry and the military and police
- 5:40violence. When we could actually help heal
- 5:43people, we could help people deal with what's causing their
- 5:47problems and their symptoms rather than just keep on
- 5:50punishing them and making them other for the symptoms that they
- 5:54have. So, so let me just go back to
- 5:58your question for a minute. So I think in in saying that
- 6:01it's multifaceted, it comes from the the bottom up from
- 6:05dysfunction in our homes and our families and dysfunction from
- 6:08the top and they intersect. So the more people don't get
- 6:13help and they're discriminated against or they're they're
- 6:18assaulted in one way or another, the more symptomatic they're
- 6:22gonna become, whether that's in their homes or from the larger
- 6:26institutions that they depend on and are a part of.
- 6:30And so we have an increasing number of people who are being
- 6:34hurt by their family systems, by dysfunctional family dynamics.
- 6:39And that gets passed down intergenerationally.
- 6:43You know, so many people that I've worked with, for instance,
- 6:46over the years who who have been abused in their homes.
- 6:51And let me tell you, it's widespread in America and I
- 6:55think probably all over the world.
- 6:57The level of abuse and violence and dysfunction and negative
- 7:00messages and negative role models that people received
- 7:04growing up, whether it's in their family of origin or in
- 7:08their school system or in their state or in their religious
- 7:11organization, sometimes even or in the place of business, is
- 7:15rampant. That we don't treat people the
- 7:18way we want to be treated. And it's that gap that I keep
- 7:22coming back to as a mental health issue.
- 7:25That's a severe mental health issue when we don't practice
- 7:28with others, what we preach for ourselves.
- 7:33Carry on. Carry on, Phyllis.
- 7:35I'm listening. Yeah, carry on.
- 7:37So, So what? One of the things, there's so
- 7:40many things that I stress in my book.
- 7:42I really go into what are the dynamics of an abusive family?
- 7:46Because we're seeing some of those same dynamics mirrored in
- 7:50our largest institutions and from people in power.
- 7:53So one of the things that we see is in an in a family where
- 7:58there's someone who is abusive of spouse or children or both,
- 8:04what happens is people. There's two main outcomes if
- 8:08abuse isn't stopped for people. And and this is a
- 8:12simplification, but it's an important simplification and
- 8:16that is that people tend to fall into two categories and one is
- 8:21they learn to be helpless because they really were
- 8:23helpless. They couldn't stop the abuse or
- 8:26the violence. Or they identify with the
- 8:29aggressor and become aggressive themselves as a way to try to
- 8:32protect themselves and not feel the vulnerability of being a
- 8:36victim. But both the person who becomes
- 8:39passive or helpless and the person who identifies with the
- 8:43aggressor are both untreated victims, and they play out their
- 8:48victimization as they become adults.
- 8:51If there's no help for them, if there's no place where they can
- 8:55find safety, if there's no place where they can process safely
- 8:59what happened to them. And so in our world, it's not
- 9:03really just in America, but in our world.
- 9:05We are creating thousands and millions of traumatized people
- 9:10on a daily basis who have no access to help or rescue or
- 9:16treatment or safety. And we have to know that they're
- 9:20going to act out and act in. So we're creating a world that's
- 9:24unsafe for all of us. The more we act out on our
- 9:28neighbors and imagine that, that it's OK to do that or that we're
- 9:33protecting something by doing it, because we're not.
- 9:36We're making all of us less safe and we're actually making the
- 9:40world, the whole globe, less viable because what do we have
- 9:44in our hands to create the biggest aggression?
- 9:49We have weapons of mass destruction that we could use
- 9:54and hopefully we won't, But what's to stop us if we don't
- 9:57get what we're doing? Right, right.
- 10:03Phyllis, you wanted to add something more Gary, if you
- 10:05want. Do you have another question?
- 10:08Yes. Yes.
- 10:10Go for it. Go for it.
- 10:11So Phyllis, I want to understand who is doing this, why they are
- 10:17doing this. Obviously they are smart people
- 10:20also may be with vested interest and they want to achieve.
- 10:24So what is it that they want to achieve through doing this?
- 10:28As you said it is not just about the US.
- 10:32It is almost like a human race is suffering from crisis, mental
- 10:36health crisis. So that is where this whole
- 10:40thing I want to understand through you.
- 10:43Yeah. And again, I don't have the
- 10:45whole answer. And certainly there are many
- 10:47aspects to the question that you asked.
- 10:49But one of them is that we have, we have, at least here in the
- 10:54United States, and you'd have to speak for your own country.
- 10:57But in the United States, we have developed this very
- 11:01powerful narrative that we're independent, that we're great,
- 11:05that we don't need each other. And that goes for individuals.
- 11:09We're supposed to be independent.
- 11:11We're supposed to be able to take care of ourselves, make our
- 11:13own money, have our own house, Dr. our own car, you know, have
- 11:16our own 50 TV's in our different rooms.
- 11:19And the truth is, we're not independent.
- 11:23We rely on each other for our physical well-being, for our
- 11:28physical safety. We rely on each other on an
- 11:31individual level. We couldn't have any of the
- 11:34things that we think make us independent if it wasn't for all
- 11:37the millions of people in the world who produce those things,
- 11:41I wouldn't have a computer here to talk to you on if there
- 11:44weren't people all over the world making the chips and
- 11:46fabricating the computers and sending them to me and selling
- 11:49them to me. But we have this myth of
- 11:52independence, which keeps us from understanding that we
- 11:56actually need each other and if we need each other.
- 11:59And that goes for individuals in their own families, and that
- 12:02goes for us as a country or a state or a religious group or a
- 12:06gender. We need each other to survive,
- 12:10and we need each other to survive more and more and more
- 12:13as our society becomes technological.
- 12:16And we don't grow our own food. We don't create our own energy
- 12:20sources. We need everyone.
- 12:23But in the United States, I'll say we still have this myth of
- 12:26our supreme independence. And so the part becomes more
- 12:31important than the whole. One individual or one country or
- 12:36one sect or one party or one gender somehow imagines it's
- 12:41more important than the whole. And so when we talk about mental
- 12:45health on that level, we're really talking about a whole
- 12:48paradigm shift that the good of the part, the welfare of the
- 12:53part, whether it's me as an individual, the state that I
- 12:56live in, the gender that I belong to, whatever is the
- 12:59economic group I'm in, whatever it is, that the part depends on
- 13:03the whole and the whole depends on the health of the part.
- 13:07And we've forgotten that here in the United States for sure.
- 13:11So we end up having people in power who are focused on their
- 13:16part and not on the good of the whole, not not even on
- 13:20necessarily the people that they were elected to represent.
- 13:23Because somehow they're standing.
- 13:25Their power, their influence, their something becomes more
- 13:29important. And so we have to change that
- 13:32whole narrative, actually, I believe, if we're going to
- 13:35survive as a human race. Right, right, Phyllis.
- 13:41So in my sense, if I understand, it's about control, it's about
- 13:46market dynamics because the more families get divided, the more
- 13:51number of people will demand things which which could have,
- 13:55you know, been less if it was a much more collective effort.
- 14:00For example, in in the US it is fine.
- 14:02People have that individualistic way of looking, which is fine,
- 14:07but an extreme is not very good. Secondly, in the world, in every
- 14:11other part of the world, the cultures are different.
- 14:13In India, we have got a very close knit family system.
- 14:18Now people move from one place to another.
- 14:21That's a different thing altogether.
- 14:23But you try to inject or the market tries to inject
- 14:28individualism, which is benefiting only to the market or
- 14:33to some people who want to control you.
- 14:36Then it is a problem and that is where it can lead to isolation
- 14:39instead of individualism. And that is a very state of
- 14:43affairs. I totally agree.
- 14:45And if we just look at the model of an individual family where
- 14:49that is run by someone who's abusive or exploitive, then they
- 14:53don't want to give up their power, you know?
- 14:56So how do you keep your power? You keep your influence strong.
- 15:01You keep your control strong. And some of the ways that people
- 15:04do that are by the threatening harm.
- 15:08And there's and there's a lot of ways that they do that.
- 15:10One is by threatening harm. One is by actually harming
- 15:13people and showing that as the this is what's gonna happen if
- 15:16you define me or if you tell anyone.
- 15:21One of the ways is to shame people and blame them for their
- 15:25for calling out the abuse. One way is to ostracize them and
- 15:30you know, don't listen to them and jail them or attack them.
- 15:36There are many ways that we silence the people who could
- 15:40expose the violence of an abusive person or an abusive
- 15:44government. And we see the same things here
- 15:47in America. You know, peaceful
- 15:48demonstrations where people are tear gassed and shot with rubber
- 15:52bullets, who are demonstrating for peace, who are demonstrating
- 15:55for justice, who are demonstrating for equal rights.
- 16:00And it's a terribly sad state of affairs because then the message
- 16:05is it's dangerous to stand up for human rights and this this
- 16:10is abuse coming down from the top and it's role model from the
- 16:13bottom. But we have to remember that
- 16:16many people are conditioned in their homes and in their
- 16:18communities to believe that they have a right to that kind of
- 16:22power. And if they get into positions
- 16:24of power in government or business, then they can exercise
- 16:28that power that way. And it's very, very scary.
- 16:33Right, right, Philly. So what is the way out in your
- 16:36book? Tell us a bit more about your
- 16:38book. Secondly, there you talk about a
- 16:40new approach to open healing correlation in crisis, So that's
- 16:44a very nice way of looking at it.
- 16:47Yeah, and I'm so glad you asked that, because it's so easy to
- 16:50focus on what's not working right and we have to focus on
- 16:54what's not working. If you go to the doctor, you got
- 16:56to tell the doctor where the pain is in your body or they
- 16:59can't help you. But then you have to focus on
- 17:02what's healing. And that's why I think the world
- 17:05of psycho psychology and psychotherapy is so helpful at
- 17:08this time because it's not partisan.
- 17:11You know, to be advocating for mental health doesn't mean
- 17:14you're a Democrat or a Republican or anything.
- 17:16It means you're advocating for mental health and safety and
- 17:19well-being for everyone. So some of the principles that
- 17:24that we find in the best healing that we do in our psychotherapy
- 17:29offices is what I would like to apply to America.
- 17:33And so there's some principles and there's you know, of course
- 17:37more than I can talk about here, but I'm going to name some of
- 17:40the important ones. So when people come to therapy,
- 17:44and I'll use a couple as an example because that's two
- 17:47people trying to work out disagreement and we have
- 17:50disagreements between countries and religions and races and you
- 17:54know men and women and all of that.
- 17:56So when a couple comes to therapy, they've already been at
- 18:00war or they wouldn't come. They're already suffering from
- 18:04some kind of, you know, conflict, or they feel abandoned
- 18:10or they feel mistreated or they feel misunderstood or something.
- 18:13So there's there's already a rift when they come, and that's
- 18:16what we're looking at. Like with the United States,
- 18:19there's a rift between different economic groups and a rift
- 18:23between religious groups and genders and cultural groups and
- 18:26the government and the people, the rich and the poor.
- 18:30So when a couple comes to therapy, we have them lay down
- 18:35their weapons. And that means obviously people
- 18:38don't come to therapy with a gun, but if they did, they
- 18:41couldn't come, right? So we we have them lay down
- 18:46their emotional and mental weapons, the ways that they
- 18:49attack, the ways that they blame, the ways that they malign
- 18:54each other and and and that's that's what I would call
- 18:59disarmament. So we we need that in our
- 19:02government. We need to come to the table to
- 19:06work out our differences and lay our weapons down.
- 19:09That means the angry rhetoric, the horrible things that that
- 19:13legislators say about one another or walk out of the room
- 19:16or put them down to the media or threaten them on social media.
- 19:21We have to lay those weapons down if we want to have any hope
- 19:26of changing the dynamics and the hurt and the violence, the
- 19:30extreme violence that's going on in America today.
- 19:33That's number one. Number two is we have to be
- 19:37willing to look at ourselves when people come to therapy most
- 19:43often, and this is just human nature, There's nothing wrong
- 19:46with it. It just doesn't work.
- 19:48Most people come wanting to blame the other person.
- 19:51He did this. She did that.
- 19:53She doesn't do this. He doesn't do that.
- 19:56And while all that may be true, just pointing fingers and
- 20:02blaming just almost exclusively evokes a defensive response.
- 20:08And if you have attack defense, attack defense, you don't make
- 20:11any progress. You just stay and attack
- 20:14defense. And that's what brings people to
- 20:16therapy in the 1st place, because what they're doing isn't
- 20:19working. And yet we're doing that all
- 20:22over the world. Attack.
- 20:23Defend. Attack.
- 20:25Defend. And now we have weapons that
- 20:27kill thousands of people, innocent people, babies,
- 20:32children. It's just, it's so heart rending
- 20:36to see what that dynamic of attack defend is doing on an on
- 20:41a national level and on a global level.
- 20:44And that's why I talk about these principles, because one of
- 20:48the bottom lines of healing is to take responsibility for our
- 20:52own part. If someone you know beats me up,
- 20:56I'm not responsible for them beating me up.
- 20:59You know they're responsible for that.
- 21:01But there may be something that I can work on that has left me
- 21:05in a powerless position where I can't defend myself or I can't
- 21:09get help. And again, that's not about
- 21:11blame. It's about healing.
- 21:15And that's the whole point of psychotherapy.
- 21:17So let's just say you have a really aggressive person in a
- 21:20relationship and a kind of passive person who gets battered
- 21:24emotionally or in some other way.
- 21:26And this is pretty common. I don't know about where you
- 21:29live, but where I live and the with the people I've worked with
- 21:31over the years, this dynamic is very common and it's a it's a
- 21:35dynamic of domination and submission and we see this and
- 21:41and there's a whole legacy of it.
- 21:43The person who learned to be submissive learned that
- 21:45somewhere. The person who learned to be
- 21:47dominating and aggressive learned that somewhere.
- 21:51And So what we what we try to do in the best psychotherapy is
- 21:55heal the wound that created that response rather than blame our
- 22:01victims or blame the perpetrators.
- 22:04And this is a whole new mindset, and yet it's not new.
- 22:09There was, there was a role model for that in truth and
- 22:12reconciliation in South Africa, where the victims of terrible
- 22:18racial violence and the perpetrator, some of them came
- 22:21to the table and told their truth to one another for the
- 22:27purpose of healing, for the purpose of stopping, you know,
- 22:30ending apartheid for the purpose of creating a democracy in South
- 22:34Africa. And if we had that goal, the
- 22:37goal of healing, then we could take responsibility for the
- 22:41terrible things we've done, as well as speak safely about the
- 22:45ways we've been hurt because both are needed in the United
- 22:51States. This is, you know, my
- 22:53perception, and I think it's the perception of a lot of people,
- 22:56that there are some people in our country, certainly not all,
- 22:59who still have the narrative that we're the good guys and we
- 23:05have perpetrated terrible things against black people and Native
- 23:10American people. We still haven't passed the
- 23:12Equal Rights Amendment, which guarantees equal pay for equal
- 23:16work for women. There's terrible injustice going
- 23:20on and discrimination in our justice system.
- 23:23Black people are incarcerated at much higher rates, killed by the
- 23:28police at much higher rates than white people, and the list goes
- 23:31on and on. So yes, we have strengths.
- 23:35There are beautiful, generous, kind people in America who do
- 23:40amazing things for their neighbors.
- 23:42They don't necessarily reach the news, but they're out there
- 23:45doing wonderful things and probably more people than not
- 23:50are kind and generous. But we also are very, very
- 23:55hurtful. And as a country, we need to be
- 24:00accountable for the harm that we've done, not just the ways
- 24:03that we feel like other people have trespassed on us.
- 24:07And that's one of the one of the healing principles of all good
- 24:12psychotherapy is that yes, we talk about the pain we've
- 24:15endured, but we also take a fearless and honest look at the
- 24:19ways we might have not been so stellar ourselves, and we'd be
- 24:22accountable for that. And we don't fall apart when we
- 24:26look at our own, you know, flaws or our own missteps, but we make
- 24:31amends to the people that we've hurt.
- 24:33And the biggest demand that anyone can make is to do it
- 24:38differently in the present. And that's what we, we need to
- 24:42be committed to doing is treating minorities and the poor
- 24:47and women and people of different gender, you know,
- 24:52associations. We treat them differently
- 24:56because. There's absolutely, there is so
- 25:00much to understand about this. There is so much to learn about
- 25:04this and for that a lot of you know to get things right, there
- 25:08is so much of healing needed. There is so much of hope needed.
- 25:13So a lot of people who would like to understand more about
- 25:17this, read your book. What's the best way for them to
- 25:20get hold of this book? Secondly.
- 25:23What is the best way for them to learn directly from you and also
- 25:27to engage with you professionally if that's what
- 25:29they're looking? For Absolutely, Please, my book
- 25:32is coming out next year. It's not, it's with a publisher
- 25:35right now. So it will be published next
- 25:37year in 2024. And the best way to get in touch
- 25:41with me is to go to my website, which is www.phyllislevitt.com.
- 25:45And that's just because my name can be spelled so many ways.
- 25:49I'll spell it. It's PHYLLISLEAVITT.
- 25:54And just sign in with your e-mail.
- 25:58You can ask questions, You can contact me, You can consult with
- 26:02me. I can speak on your show, I can
- 26:06speak at your conference. You know, I'm I'm just so
- 26:09anxious and willing to talk about this in a really big
- 26:13public way. One of the the original title
- 26:17for my book was Out of the Office and Into the World, But
- 26:20now that's just one of my chapter titles, Because really
- 26:23that's what I want, is to take everything we've learned in the
- 26:26in the field of psychology and psychotherapy and bring it to
- 26:30the world. Because a lot of people don't
- 26:32know anything about psychology or how how our minds and hearts
- 26:36work on that level and what the results are if we're not treated
- 26:40well. Because there are terrible, long
- 26:43lasting results for people who are harmed by other people.
- 26:47And one of the biggest things, and I'll just say this, and this
- 26:50could be a whole other discussion, is that abuse and
- 26:54neglect and violence break the bonds of our human connection.
- 27:00It's not safe to connect if you're being hurt by someone.
- 27:04And the legacy of that, passed down from generation to
- 27:07generation, is part of what's responsible for the violence and
- 27:12the cruelty that's going on in the world today.
- 27:15You've lost connection to one another.
- 27:18Absolutely, absolutely. And it's time, that high time we
- 27:21start doing that, connecting with others, connecting to self
- 27:25and making it a much more better place than what it is now with
- 27:30this, with this. It's a wrap on this very special
- 27:33edition of the KJ Master Class Life.
- 27:36Thank you so much indeed for joining us.
- 27:38Thank you for having me. Thank you so much.