Latest / CXOTalk / US Healthcare System Punishes Prevention: Former CDC Director | CXOTalk #911
Transcript
- 0:00He said to me, we've studied it, the ROI for good diabetes care
- 0:08is positive, but it takes seven years to turn positive and our
- 0:13average beneficiary is only with us for four years.
- 0:18So I have a fiduciary responsibility not to provide
- 0:22good diabetes care. Doctor Tom Frieden ran the CDC
- 0:26under President Obama. He was health commissioner in
- 0:30New York City and is now CEO of Resolve to Save Lives, a global
- 0:35nonprofit. His new book is The Formula for
- 0:39Better Health. Doctor Frieden, Why is Our
- 0:42Health System Set Up to Fail? You get the system that has been
- 0:48designed, and our system gets the results that it was designed
- 0:53for, and those results are failing too many people.
- 0:57Now, the real question then is both why does that happen and
- 1:02how to fix it? And if it were easy, it would be
- 1:05done. But fundamentally, it's about
- 1:08incentives. Let me put it bluntly.
- 1:12If you're a provider and you do a lot of great work and you
- 1:17prevent your patient's heart attack or stroke, you and your
- 1:22health system make a whole lot less money than if you don't do
- 1:26a great job and your patient has heart attack and stroke.
- 1:29I don't think there is a single clinician in this country who
- 1:33wants their patients to have a heart attack or a stroke, but I
- 1:37know that because our system is set up the way it is, we have a
- 1:41massive number of predictable heart attacks and strokes.
- 1:45Please elaborate on this. Explain to us how this
- 1:51disconnect takes place, the the causes for it and how it
- 1:56manifests. We have an extraordinarily
- 1:59complicated healthcare system, but one of the things that I
- 2:03discuss in my book is the importance of keeping things
- 2:08simple. Not simplistic, but simple.
- 2:11And if you keep it simple, one of the major flaws in our
- 2:15healthcare system is the weakness of primary healthcare.
- 2:18Primary Healthcare is where you get most of your healthcare and
- 2:22that is true for every clinical encounter from a pregnant woman
- 2:30to a senior who is dealing with end of life care and everything
- 2:34in between. It goes so much better if you
- 2:37have someone who is your advocate and your translator in
- 2:42the healthcare system. And yet we under invest in that.
- 2:46The number that you said it, 100 million, it's just stunning.
- 2:50I mean, really keep a good sense of just how dysfunctional that
- 2:54is in this country. We spend nearly a 5th of every
- 2:59dollar in our economy on healthcare.
- 3:01We spend about twice as much per capita as the next highest
- 3:05spending country. And nearly one in three people
- 3:09don't have the single most important thing that is needed
- 3:13in our healthcare system. And if you look at the outcomes,
- 3:16something like blood pressure control, which should be really
- 3:20simple, that's done right less than half the time.
- 3:23So we're spending $4.5 trillion a year and we're getting the
- 3:27most important question right less than half the time.
- 3:31It would be really hard to spend more and do worse.
- 3:35In fact, no country in the world does.
- 3:37But I do really want to make clear that this is not about
- 3:41healthcare facilities or the clinical services.
- 3:45I have no doubt also that if you've got a complicated medical
- 3:49problem and you're in the right place with the right team, you
- 3:53can get better care here than anywhere in the world.
- 3:55I'm not claiming that the US isn't doing a great job at many
- 3:59things in healthcare, but at preventing things.
- 4:02We're a laggard. Can you talk about the economic
- 4:08relationships and economic incentives?
- 4:11You mentioned insurers, hospitals, we have primary care
- 4:14specialist, we have the government and so forth.
- 4:18What is the confluence of these groups that leads to the
- 4:25situation you've just described? First off, our system developed
- 4:30over so many years in so many ways with so many different
- 4:34interest groups that it's really difficult to unpack the
- 4:38problems. Sometimes it's clarifying to
- 4:41look at the exceptions, and one of the things I discuss in the
- 4:44book is the Kaiser Permanente healthcare system.
- 4:48When there are rigorous assessments of the quality of
- 4:51healthcare in the US, usually the top five systems in the
- 4:55country are Kaiser Permanente. And that's because it has
- 4:58different regions that operate quasi independently.
- 5:01And they're not a little bit better than the rest of the
- 5:03healthcare system. They're a lot better.
- 5:05And there's a simple reason for that.
- 5:08Wonderful as Kaiser physicians are, it's not that their doctors
- 5:11are better, It's that their incentives are different.
- 5:15If Kaiser prevents heart attacks and strokes, the system is more
- 5:19stable. It makes more money, it has more
- 5:21money, it can invest in more things.
- 5:23If it allows health patients to have preventable heart attacks
- 5:29and strokes, it ends up making less money.
- 5:31That's the exact opposite from most of our healthcare system,
- 5:35and that's the fundamental detail that we need to fix.
- 5:38That detail being the the alignment of economic
- 5:42incentives. Yes, and people talk a lot about
- 5:45value based care. If you don't make more money by
- 5:51preventing a heart attack then by treating it, you're not in a
- 5:53value based care system. Folks who are watching you can
- 5:58ask your questions. Right now there's a tweet chat
- 6:01taking place on Twitter X Use the hashtag CXO talk.
- 6:06If you're watching on LinkedIn, just pop your question into the
- 6:09chat. Please, folks, take advantage of
- 6:12this opportunity. When else can you ask one of the
- 6:16most prominent healthcare advocates in the world?
- 6:20Pretty much whatever you want. So take advantage of this.
- 6:25Doctor Frieden, you've been talking about the alignment of
- 6:30economic incentives. How does that work differently
- 6:36at Kaiser Permanente than the broader system that yields the
- 6:41results that the positive results you described?
- 6:43Kaiser Permanente has a capitation model, so you're paid
- 6:47by the number of people who you care for and there's some
- 6:53adjustments, but basically you get a a lump sum.
- 6:56And then there are a few things that will change that with
- 6:59incentives. And importantly, Kaiser's
- 7:05clientele are very stable. So the same people are treating
- 7:09now are likely to be the people they treat in 20 years.
- 7:13The payer and the provider are in the same organization.
- 7:17So in most of the healthcare system, you got the pair over
- 7:21here, and the providers are here and the patients are there, and
- 7:24they're all fighting. The patient wants to get access
- 7:27and wants to be healthy. The provider, you know, doesn't
- 7:30want to be hassled with insurance forms and wants to be
- 7:34able to provide good clinical care without administrative
- 7:37burden. And the payer is struggling to
- 7:39provide more, better services with increasing costs while
- 7:44controlling costs and making profit.
- 7:47The Kaiser model flips that. All of the players are on the
- 7:51same side of the table, working for the same goal, better care
- 7:55at lower cost with more independence, healthier people.
- 7:59And it's just striking if you step back and say that's
- 8:02actually not the goal in most of our healthcare system.
- 8:04In fact, Michael, I'll tell you a painful story from the time
- 8:08when I was health commissioner in New York City.
- 8:10I met with the head of a large insurance company and I was
- 8:14pushing for better care of people with diabetes.
- 8:17And the care of people with diabetes is really substandard
- 8:21in, in this country. You know, everyone with diabetes
- 8:25should have their blood pressure controlled less than 130 / 80.
- 8:29They should have treatment with either a statin or another
- 8:33cholesterol lowering drug drug if they're 40 years of age or
- 8:36older. And their glucose should be
- 8:39controlled ideally to an A1C of 7 or less or 6 1/2 or less.
- 8:43And, and really those first two things are going to provide them
- 8:46most of their health benefit, but it's very important to give
- 8:50comprehensive care and there are other aspects as well.
- 8:52So I was going over this with the CEO and he said to me, we've
- 8:57studied it. The ROI for good diabetes care
- 9:03is positive, but it takes seven years to turn positive and our
- 9:08average beneficiary is only with us for four years.
- 9:13So I have a fiduciary responsibility not to provide
- 9:17good diabetes care. I'm speechless and this was from
- 9:20a healthcare CEO. Yes.
- 9:22I can take this in and understand it rationally, but
- 9:26emotionally it's very hard to absorb this.
- 9:31Let me ask you about another type of healthcare provider that
- 9:35does have the pieces all under one roof or very closely
- 9:41aligned, and that is CVS. You described Kaiser Permanente
- 9:46where the pieces are together and it yields these really great
- 9:51outcomes. But then we have CVS, which owns
- 9:55the pharmacy and owns the PBM and now owns clinics.
- 10:02All these folks are together, working together to turn a
- 10:06profit. So how is that so different from
- 10:08Kaiser Permanente? Doesn't have a hospital, doesn't
- 10:12have ongoing primary care. So yeah, you can go there for
- 10:16episodic care, but they don't know you, your family, your
- 10:21concerns. This gets back to Primary Health
- 10:24care. Primary Health care is where you
- 10:27get most of your care when you need help.
- 10:31And this is what's so lacking in this country and around the
- 10:36world. And I hope we'll get into more
- 10:38discussion of global health issues.
- 10:40But I I believe that Primary Health care is the way we have
- 10:46to improve our health systems so that we can close this deadly
- 10:51gap between all these great treatments that we have and what
- 10:55actually happens in the real world.
- 10:58Now there are those who say, oh, primary care, that's so old
- 11:01school. You know, the family doctor
- 11:03horse and buggy, We're past that specialist know everything.
- 11:07No, you know when if you've got a simple medical problem, fine,
- 11:12you can get that addressed one time.
- 11:15But for most people who have a chronic illness, there are many
- 11:20aspects of their care. And only a really good primary
- 11:24healthcare team can address those interests and help you
- 11:30manage it. Not because they're going to
- 11:32tell you what to do, but just the opposite.
- 11:34They're going to make clear to you what are the options so that
- 11:40you can do what you want to do for longer.
- 11:43But we don't do that. And you are seeing some
- 11:45measures. I thought you were going to go
- 11:46in a different direction. I thought you were going to ask
- 11:48about concierge medicine because this is a new direction in in
- 11:52U.S. healthcare system. And you can definitely
- 11:55understand it from the patient perspective and the provider
- 11:58perspective. Concierge medicine is kind of as
- 12:01it sounds like it's kind of very high, high class.
- 12:04Some of it is not so expensive, some of it is super expensive,
- 12:07but it basically says we're going to give you a team, we're
- 12:10going to give you an individual, You going to know who your
- 12:12doctor is and they're going to manage the system for you so you
- 12:17don't have to. And then we have a dividing of
- 12:21the healthcare system between people who can afford to pay for
- 12:27essentially being outside the initial aspect having having the
- 12:31outside the core system. Concierge medicine is what Lewis
- 12:35Thomas used to call a halfway technology and that you know it.
- 12:39It does address the issue, but it doesn't address the problem.
- 12:43And the problem is a broken healthcare system.
- 12:45It's very expensive and doesn't deliver the kind of value that
- 12:48people need. We have a very interesting
- 12:52question from Arsalan Khan, who's a regular listener.
- 12:56He asks incisive questions and he asks this, he said.
- 13:00He says the for profit nature of healthcare, a few key players in
- 13:06healthcare technology and the resistance to change from
- 13:10various stakeholders are the issues.
- 13:13One entity can't fix this. Who can really fix all of these
- 13:19problems? One of the characteristics of
- 13:22these intractable problems that we face is that no one is
- 13:26clearly accountable. The system is complicated.
- 13:30That's why I think the approach has to be not so much to think
- 13:35about who can do it as what is the technical package.
- 13:39And I talk about this in the book.
- 13:41What is the approach that we need?
- 13:43And then to think about what can be done by state governments,
- 13:47what can only be done by the federal government?
- 13:50Are there things that insurers can do?
- 13:52Are there things that providers or healthcare systems can do?
- 13:55Where are the positive outliers? You know, even absent something
- 14:00like Kaiser Permanente, one of the things that we've analyzed
- 14:03is the different medical groups in the Minneapolis, Saint Paul
- 14:07area. And even though they are in
- 14:11different systems, they've coordinated in ways that improve
- 14:14patient care. So just 'cause we can't fix
- 14:17everything doesn't mean we shouldn't fix anything.
- 14:20We can, on the one hand, make incremental change wherever is
- 14:24possible. On the other hand, we need to
- 14:26really try to make the bigger changes that will drive very
- 14:30rapid health progress. Do you want to talk about your
- 14:34solution? You talk in your book about see,
- 14:38believe, create, and also as we have this discussion, if you
- 14:44would weave in examples from international health, as you
- 14:48mentioned before, that would be great.
- 14:50There is a formula that has already saved millions of lives.
- 14:54It can save millions more, including your own.
- 14:58And that formula is see, believe, create, see the
- 15:03invisible, believe that what may seem inevitable actually can be
- 15:08changed and then work collaboratively, strategically
- 15:12to create a healthier future. Each of those 3 aspects is
- 15:18essential. That is the formula for better
- 15:20health. So start with CD Invisible.
- 15:22We need to see the the threats. What are the microbes and toxins
- 15:27and also the trends that might be killing us?
- 15:31See also why we tend to ignore the biggest threats.
- 15:34And I discussed the Cassandra curse.
- 15:36Cassandra was a priestess in Greek mythology.
- 15:40She could see the future, so she knew which tragedies were going
- 15:43to come. But she was cursed.
- 15:45Nobody would believe her. And so those tragedies that she
- 15:49foresaw came to pass. For all too long, we've been
- 15:52like Cassandra. We can see the tragedies, but we
- 15:54we walk right into them. I go through why that happens
- 15:58and how to counter it. And also using rigorous
- 16:02scientific fact based evidence, see the pathway to progress, See
- 16:07how we can make progress. So that's the see the invisible
- 16:09part. And in in global health, we
- 16:13resolved to save lives to organization.
- 16:14I run, we partner with countries to see things like what's the
- 16:19trend in pandemic risk and how can we bring that down?
- 16:23What's the trend in blood pressure control?
- 16:26Because high blood pressure is actually the world's most
- 16:30neglected condition. It kills more people than any
- 16:35other condition. 11,000,000 a year.
- 16:37That's nearly one out of every five deaths in the world.
- 16:40And that's more than all infectious diseases combined.
- 16:43It's more than COVID at Covid's deadliest and at a younger age.
- 16:48So see the trends and see the pathway forward, what's called
- 16:52the technical package, what you need to do to make progress.
- 16:55That's seeing the invisible then comes to believing the
- 17:00impossible, shattering an illusion of inevitability.
- 17:04We, we kind of assume the world is as it is and it'll stay that
- 17:07way. But it's changed a lot and it
- 17:09can change more. And I go through how to
- 17:11strengthen belief in the possibility of progress.
- 17:14And one of the ways is what we do at Resolve to save lives, to
- 17:17support countries to make phased progress, because making phased
- 17:22progress shows that progress is possible and builds momentum.
- 17:26And then the really hard part comes after you can see the
- 17:29invisible and believe the impossible.
- 17:31You have to create a healthier future.
- 17:33And that means or being very rigorously organized, it means
- 17:38simplifying, communicating well and overcoming barriers because
- 17:42there are always going to be barriers to health progress.
- 17:46One of the things that we've done at Resolve to Save Lives
- 17:48with more than 50 countries around the world is to support
- 17:52them to enact regulations or laws to ban artificial trans
- 17:57fat. Artificial trans fat is a toxic
- 18:01substance. It's added to food.
- 18:04It's now banned in the US and banned in more than 60
- 18:07countries, fifty of which we supported to do that.
- 18:10And in those countries, people don't have to worry about, oh,
- 18:14is there trans fat in my food? You've changed the default value
- 18:18so it can't be in the food. And that kind of policy change
- 18:22does requiring does require overcoming opposition.
- 18:25But having done it, once done, it's going to be durable.
- 18:29It's going to be sustained when we're done and we're called with
- 18:33the World Health Organization for the global elimination of
- 18:36trans fat. When that's over, no child will
- 18:40ever be exposed to trans fat again.
- 18:42Because if you think about it, programs that eradicate a
- 18:45disease are the ultimate in both equity and sustainability
- 18:51because they are for everyone and forever.
- 18:53Can you describe how this see believe, create approach could
- 19:01be applied, for example, to the current measles outbreak that we
- 19:05see in different parts of the US right now?
- 19:08With measles, it's really important to see what the threat
- 19:12is. I began my career as a disease
- 19:16detective and Epidemic Intelligence Service officer
- 19:19working on measles in New York City.
- 19:21We had many thousands of cases, hundreds of hospitalizations,
- 19:26tragically, children who died from measles.
- 19:28Measles is perhaps the most infectious of all infectious
- 19:32diseases. You can see situations where one
- 19:38child with measles was in an emergency department and then
- 19:41left and people coming in for the three, 4-5 hours after, if
- 19:48they were susceptible to measles, they got measles
- 19:51because it stayed in the air. It's really susceptible, it's
- 19:55really effective, it's spreading, and the vaccine is
- 19:59highly effective and safe. So we, we need to see the
- 20:03pathway to progress. We need to believe, hey, we got
- 20:06rid of measles. For the last 25 years there
- 20:10hasn't been any measles in the US.
- 20:12All the cases have come from a traveller who went visiting and
- 20:16then came back and brought it or someone who was here and, and
- 20:21spread it. We're going to lose that status
- 20:24in the next few days or few weeks as a symptom that we've
- 20:27allowed measles to get a toehold again.
- 20:30But believe we've made progress, believe we can make more
- 20:33progress because we have and then create a healthier future.
- 20:37So what does that mean? Simplifying Simplify the vaccine
- 20:41recommendations, Organize well. Make sure that when there are
- 20:46outbreaks, we respond rapidly. Time is lives in an outbreak,
- 20:51even a couple of days can make a huge difference between a small
- 20:55outbreak and a large outbreak. And communicate well.
- 20:58And here is where we really do have a problem.
- 21:02Misinformation and disinformation are perhaps the
- 21:05most lethal health threats facing this country and the
- 21:10world. Why?
- 21:12Because they undermine everything, every single step
- 21:15that people can take to live a longer, healthier life, whether
- 21:19that's what they do in their own lives or what medicines or
- 21:22vaccines they take, or who they consult for information or what
- 21:26advice they follow. All of that is at risk because
- 21:30we are facing a fire hose of falsehoods driven by the
- 21:36monetization of misinformation. Fire hood of falsehoods driven
- 21:41by monetization of misinformation.
- 21:43We need to address that by revealing it, also by
- 21:47communicating well. And that starts with listening.
- 21:50What are people hearing? What do they believe?
- 21:52And it turns out that in fact, the vast majority of Americans
- 21:57understand that vaccines work and they're safe and they're
- 22:00effective. I think there is a way to apply,
- 22:03see, believe, create to the measles outbreaks in this
- 22:07country. It's also going to require real
- 22:09focus. And this is one of the insights
- 22:13I have from my career, that if you don't have an indicator of
- 22:18how well you're doing, it's very hard for government systems to
- 22:21function well. And we should be looking at
- 22:23things like vaccine rates by different states, by different
- 22:27groups and then where their problem is not about blaming.
- 22:30All right, let's work together and see how we can fix it.
- 22:33Let me just ask you to elaborate on a point you made.
- 22:36You said the monetization of misinformation is such a such a
- 22:40serious problem. Who is monetizing this
- 22:45misinformation or disinformation?
- 22:47If anyone is selling you anything, don't believe anything
- 22:52they tell you about what may improve your health.
- 22:55What we're seeing from social media is enormous efforts to
- 23:01sell products, usually with very high profit margins, sometimes
- 23:05with some evidence of efficacy, but usually without.
- 23:08And this really preys on people's legitimate desire for
- 23:14objective information and a route to a healthier future.
- 23:18And I'm going to go right back to this.
- 23:21This is why having a primary care team is so important,
- 23:24because you want to have someone who has your best interest at
- 23:29heart and ideally in a good system, will actually do better
- 23:32economically. If you are healthier, who is
- 23:35interpreting this information for you and answering your
- 23:37questions? Let me go to a question again
- 23:44from Arsalan Khan, just because this is usually I like to spread
- 23:47the questions out among folks, but this question from Arsalan
- 23:50is really, really great. He says.
- 23:53Have we tried using the power of AI to quote UN quote, fix this
- 23:58multi set of multi level healthcare problems?
- 24:02Do we need a political push behind that?
- 24:06I'm a huge believer in the quality and potential of AII use
- 24:12it constantly in my, in my life. I, I kind of think I'm, I'm
- 24:17partly becoming a, a Cyborg. I'm, I'm part AI and part part
- 24:22person in what I do. I've said before and I I believe
- 24:27that it is now malpractice not to care for a patient with an AI
- 24:34as part of the team. That's a that's a pretty bold
- 24:38statement. But as a physician, I can tell
- 24:41you there are just a massive number of articles coming out,
- 24:46drug, drug interactions just in the last 24 hours.
- 24:53I was consulting on treatment and a new article on a rare
- 24:59disease came out within the last 12 months.
- 25:02That suggests that one treatment should definitely not be used.
- 25:05Now I'm I'm familiar with that rare disease.
- 25:08I didn't know the article had come out.
- 25:10The doctor caring for the patient didn't know the article
- 25:13had come out. So this is just one type of
- 25:17example of the power of AI. What we have to always remember
- 25:23about AI is that it has really bad judgement.
- 25:27It has a great information bank, and some of the models
- 25:32hallucinate a lot less than others.
- 25:35Some of them are tuned for medical work specifically, and
- 25:40that's important. And even those need to look
- 25:43really carefully at the different use cases within
- 25:47health and public health. So we're learning more.
- 25:50We need to try things and learn. I think it has enormous
- 25:55potential, but at this point it's mostly just potential and
- 25:58documentation that it's improved outcomes, improved efficiency.
- 26:03I, I'm optimistic that will come, but we don't have it yet
- 26:07and we haven't figured out all the ways to make it work in a
- 26:10way that is safe and includes efficiency.
- 26:14I was speaking with someone who, who is high up in one of the
- 26:18companies doing this and I asked him about something I've been
- 26:21interested in for the work that we do in countries around the
- 26:24world, which is could you use it to help with triage?
- 26:27Triage is, you know, you've got a full waiting room and what do
- 26:31people need and who should be seen first.
- 26:34And, and I've, I've thought from a naive standpoint, not knowing
- 26:38a whole lot about this. Oh, that sounds like a great use
- 26:41of AI. And, and that individual was
- 26:43very reluctant. They said was, hey, you know, I
- 26:46understand the need, but that's really serious because you get
- 26:50it wrong and something bad is going to happen.
- 26:52And that's almost more like a medical device than, than just
- 26:56answering questions or being part of a team or transcribing
- 26:59or being ambient listener. So I think, yes, I think AI has
- 27:02a lot of enormous potential, but we haven't yet figured out how
- 27:06to use it and use it safely. And that'll be, I think the, the
- 27:10challenge of the coming weeks and months.
- 27:13The, the, there's so much to keep in mind about AI.
- 27:17One of them, one of the things is that it's changing really
- 27:20fast that some of these systems are getting better, you know,
- 27:23day-to-day, week to week. And two is that it's
- 27:26inconsistent. You can ask the same question in
- 27:29the same way on two different days and get different answers.
- 27:33And and that's scary when you're thinking about medical advice.
- 27:37It's probabilistic rather than deterministic.
- 27:41I, I have to tell you, I had a, a medical thing and I put all of
- 27:46the data into an LLM and then I wanted to find a new physician,
- 27:51but I wanted the best person. And it was Claude.
- 27:55I was using of the paid version of Claude.
- 27:57So you get some more depth there.
- 27:59But Claude recommended like the right guy who's the chairman of
- 28:03the department, one of the big hospitals here in Boston, and
- 28:06then described why what he researches match what I have.
- 28:10And then I was going, then I was able to research that person's
- 28:16papers and lo and behold, I was able to get an appointment with
- 28:20like the top guy literally in a week, well, with his PA, but I'm
- 28:23in his queue. It armed me.
- 28:27It was amazing. It armed you with information so
- 28:30that you could take more control of your life.
- 28:33And that's, that's a great use of AI.
- 28:35This is from Julia Goldberg Raffman, and she says she was
- 28:41struck by the story about diabetes care not being
- 28:45profitable. How might we encourage
- 28:48healthcare leaders to balance moral leadership with fiduciary
- 28:53leadership? Diabetes care is very
- 28:55profitable. What's not profitable is
- 28:57prevention of complications for patients with diabetes and and
- 29:01that's a a structural problem in our healthcare system.
- 29:05There are examples of parts of the healthcare system where
- 29:07that's not the case. Some of our community health
- 29:11centers work that way. There are some demonstration
- 29:15programs under Medicare such as the Accountable Care
- 29:19Organization program, working with doctor operated accountable
- 29:24care organizations, where when you prevent a heart attack or
- 29:29stroke, you actually save money and make money.
- 29:33So I think the most important changes are the structural ones.
- 29:37I don't think this is the result of a moral failing.
- 29:39I don't think that our system is lousy because people are greedy
- 29:44or selfish. I think we have to of course,
- 29:47look for the caring clinicians, look for the team that meets our
- 29:51needs. But but we also have to try at
- 29:55the local level, at the facility level, the system level, the
- 30:00state level, the national level. We have to try even if it's
- 30:04incrementally to have our system change so that when people are
- 30:09healthier, the clinicians make more money.
- 30:12And and that's that's a big change.
- 30:15You're making the assumption of healthcare practitioners and
- 30:22business leaders being morally responsible, but we need to
- 30:29align their goals more effectively.
- 30:33Would that be the right way to say it with positive patient
- 30:36outcomes and prevention? Yes, absolutely.
- 30:39Basically, our healthcare system needs to reward health rather
- 30:45than reward volume or procedures.
- 30:49And, and again, in the book The Formula for Better Health, I
- 30:53talk about how to overcome barriers because there are big
- 30:57barriers to making progress here.
- 31:00There are, for example, hospitals and specialists that
- 31:06will make less money if we do this and they're going to oppose
- 31:11as if we, if we say, oh, you know, let's pay primary care
- 31:14practitioners more and let's incentivize team based care
- 31:18where you have a whole team because that provides better
- 31:21care with nurses and pharmacists and outreach workers as well as
- 31:24the doctors. It provides better care at lower
- 31:27cost. Well, that money has to come
- 31:30from somewhere and the places it come from, the places it comes
- 31:33from are going to oppose it. All right.
- 31:36So what are the ways that we can analyze who wins and who loses?
- 31:41Who are the deciders and who are the influencers?
- 31:45Who are the advocates and who are the partners?
- 31:48Who can make a difference? What's what are the pragmatic
- 31:51compromises we can make, and what's the timing for those
- 31:54compromises? And with all of that, we can
- 31:58make incremental progress. I talk in the book about Vinnie
- 32:02de Marco. He's an advocate in the state of
- 32:05Maryland. He spent over a decade
- 32:08advocating for really important healthcare improvements.
- 32:12He built a coalition, and because of that, Maryland has
- 32:15some of the best health policies in the country.
- 32:18And they can actually do things that allow them to pay for
- 32:21health. It gets a lot of opposition, but
- 32:24they've been able to make some progress and it really shows how
- 32:28much difference an advocate can make.
- 32:31What we generally see is that you need entities within the
- 32:35government, you need people who are reform minded, who want to
- 32:39make progress. You need advocates pushing them
- 32:43to do the right thing and supporting them when they do,
- 32:46and you need a rigorous monitoring system to track
- 32:50whether those changes are on track.
- 32:52Keep everybody honest so that you can make more progress.
- 32:56One of the real challenges about doing things in the public
- 33:00sector generally and in healthcare specifically, is that
- 33:04we don't have the kind of feedback loops that you have in
- 33:07the private sector. In the private sector, if you're
- 33:09selling something, no one's buying it, You stop selling it.
- 33:12That doesn't happen in the government sector.
- 33:15In the healthcare sector, the people buying healthcare are
- 33:19generally companies buying it for your employees.
- 33:22The employees or the patients getting healthcare are maybe
- 33:27paying Co payments or other things that really aren't
- 33:29correlated with the value of the care that they receive.
- 33:33So we have this very broken system and to try to improve it
- 33:38so that patients get the care they need, the providers aren't
- 33:41being hassled with administrative requirements that
- 33:45take them away from patient care, and we end up providing
- 33:48more care that does more for more people.
- 33:51This is from Chetna Mehrotra, Naima.
- 33:54And she says, Doctor Frieden, she's always been a fan of your
- 33:58work. Given how the CDC has been
- 34:02dismantled and has little say in public health messaging,
- 34:07including vaccine utilization, how can we build trust in what
- 34:11public health agencies, including local and state health
- 34:15departments, do and their communication?
- 34:18It's been difficult for me as a former director of the CDC to
- 34:22see what's been happening to CDC.
- 34:23I don't know if that will get better in the coming months and
- 34:26years, but we shouldn't understate the damage that's
- 34:31been done front and center has been a damage to our vaccine
- 34:35infrastructure. We're highly respected,
- 34:39independent experts who did not have conflicts of interest were
- 34:45all fired from the key entity that recommends vaccines and
- 34:51advises doctors on what works, the Advisory Committee on
- 34:55Immunization Practices. And that committee was then
- 34:58stacked with ideologues, many of whom have economic interests in
- 35:04the anti vaccine movement. So we really have a takeover, A
- 35:08hostile takeover of what was really a model program.
- 35:14And we're seeing other assaults on our vaccine infrastructure
- 35:17that will be very important to monitor.
- 35:20One of them is a very little known fund called the Vaccine
- 35:24Injury Compensation Fund or VICP.
- 35:27And what what that does, it says, OK, there are times when
- 35:31vaccines do cause problems. There's about a one in a million
- 35:35rate of serious adverse events for various reasons.
- 35:39And rather than make all of those people go through our
- 35:45legal system and some of them get big payouts and many of them
- 35:48spend years and years and don't get anything.
- 35:50Let's have a a schedule, say if you have this from that vaccine,
- 35:54you get this much money. Now, that system isn't perfect.
- 35:57The the number of judges or adjudicators hasn't changed in
- 36:03decades. The amounts provided haven't
- 36:06changed in decades. So, yeah, it needs to be
- 36:08modernized. But what Secretary Kennedy and
- 36:12his colleagues are trying to do is to put the autism into that
- 36:22injury compensation fund because they're arguing that the measles
- 36:28vaccine causes autism, which has been studied repeatedly.
- 36:32There is no evidence to suggest that the measles vaccine causes
- 36:36autism. But if you opened up for every
- 36:39child who has a diagnosis of autism and virtually everyone's
- 36:43gotten the measles vaccine, so to, to sue that fund, you're
- 36:46going to sink that fund. So, and then the, the parents
- 36:50who, who do have problems won't be able to get their, their
- 36:55response. But the broader issue of CDC
- 36:59really is that it's an agency that has worked for 3/4 of a
- 37:05century keeping Americans safe. And there are still thousands
- 37:12and thousands of dedicated health professionals there who I
- 37:17know have turned down jobs where they could make more money in
- 37:20the private sector because they care about protecting Americans
- 37:24and keeping Americans safe from threats.
- 37:27I hope what we'll see in the coming months is Congress
- 37:32insisting that the money they allocate for CDC in the programs
- 37:36they they support for CDC actually get implemented because
- 37:40that didn't happen last year. Congress said do this, and the
- 37:43administration didn't feel it had it had any need to do what
- 37:46Congress told it to do. Let's see if that happens this
- 37:49year because a lot rides on that question.
- 37:52Building trust starts with listening.
- 37:55So local health department, state health department needs to
- 37:58understand what people are hearing, what they're seeing,
- 38:01and then to speak with the right messages and the right
- 38:05messengers in ways that people can understand.
- 38:08But this issue of where is there a beacon for valid health
- 38:12information? This is the most common question
- 38:15I get asked. And right now you can look at
- 38:19medical societies, Pediatrics, obstetricians and gynecologists.
- 38:24They have guidance out there. But if people are selling
- 38:29anything, don't believe what they say.
- 38:32Do you have any thoughts or explanations why the CDC is
- 38:38acting the way it is? Well, I think the real question
- 38:41is why is the CDC so much in the crosshairs of this
- 38:44administration? And, and I don't know the answer
- 38:46to that. A lot of it does come back to
- 38:50the the COVID pandemic and a belief, well founded or not,
- 38:55that the CDC was behind mistakes that were made.
- 39:00I talk about this in the book at some length.
- 39:02I do think there was a serious mistake made in 2020 where the
- 39:06CDC messed up a lab test. This was incomprehensible to me.
- 39:10During my time at CDCA, new flu strain came out.
- 39:14We came up with a new lab test. We distributed 1,000,000 primer
- 39:19versions of it to more than 100 countries, all the ones needed
- 39:22in the US, without a glitch within weeks.
- 39:26But this time there was a mistake.
- 39:28Someone at CDC made a mistake, or a team made a mistake, and
- 39:30they sent out a test that didn't work.
- 39:32It cost about 3 weeks of time early in the response, and that
- 39:36was a very costly 3 week because it was just as COVID was coming
- 39:40in. So I think the hostility to the
- 39:42CDC is bound up in our frustration with what happened
- 39:45with COVID. I do want to emphasize that
- 39:48there are still thousands and thousands of dedicated health
- 39:51professionals at the CDC. They work hard, they're the
- 39:55experts in their area, and they're really dedicated to
- 39:58protecting people. New polling data just came out
- 40:01yesterday showing that Americans do trust the scientists at CDCA
- 40:05whole lot more than the politicians who sometimes are
- 40:10speaking for it. Folks, ask your questions.
- 40:14We have a little bit of time left.
- 40:17If you are working in healthcare, what else will you
- 40:23have the chance to ask Doctor Tom Frieden?
- 40:26Pretty much whatever you want. So if you're on LinkedIn, pop
- 40:29your questions into the chat. If you're on Twitter X, use the
- 40:33hashtag CXO Talk. And this would be an excellent
- 40:36time to subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter.
- 40:39So we can we want you as part of our community.
- 40:42You guys are great. Doctor Frieden, your book
- 40:46describes a system that you call 717 where accountability is the
- 40:55goal. Can you talk about that?
- 40:58We have been working for many years with countries around the
- 41:02world and realized that fundamentally when it comes to
- 41:06infectious disease threats, our goal is to find problems faster
- 41:11and stop them sooner. And working with countries, we
- 41:14Co created this 717 approach. Seven days to find every new
- 41:20threat, whether it's suspected outbreak or a real outbreak, one
- 41:25day to report that threat to the relevant public health authority
- 41:30and seven days to have all essential control measures in
- 41:33place. 717 When we began looking at this, only about two out of
- 41:3910 outbreaks met the 717 criteria.
- 41:44We've been able to work with countries to look at that and to
- 41:48use every single outbreak as a way of improving outbreak
- 41:52preparedness. So whether it's a foodborne
- 41:57outbreak or measles, or in parts of the world where yellow fever
- 42:02is still present, yellow fever or cholera, dengue or other
- 42:05problems, to to ask the question not as a way of blaming people,
- 42:09but as a way of doing continuous quality improvement.
- 42:13Did we find it quickly and stop it soon or didn't we?
- 42:17And if we did or if we didn't, what were the things that went
- 42:21well, what were the enabling factors and how we strengthen
- 42:24those? And what were the bottlenecks,
- 42:26the things that didn't go well? And how do we address those and
- 42:29break those down? Currently, about 50 countries
- 42:33around the world are already using the 717 approach.
- 42:36It's been adopted by many national and international
- 42:39organizations. It's a way of making visible
- 42:44what's usually invisible when we stop an outbreak.
- 42:48Nobody knows, right? Nobody woke up this morning and
- 42:51said, oh, thank goodness I didn't die from smallpox, but
- 42:54smallpox used to kill millions of people a year.
- 42:58My organization resolved to save lives a publishes a periodic
- 43:05spotlight on that's called epidemics.
- 43:07That didn't happen, and we identify a great team from
- 43:11somewhere around the world that found and stopped an outbreak
- 43:15before it spread so that we can begin to see the invisible, the
- 43:17outbreaks that didn't happen. And what 717 this approach to
- 43:21measurement does is allows us to see whether or not our systems
- 43:28are keeping us safe. And that two out of 10 is going
- 43:31up to 3456 out of 10 in many of the places where we're working.
- 43:36It's not perfect yet. We need investment in public
- 43:39health because that's investment in our safety, but this is one
- 43:42way of giving accountability and accelerating progress.
- 43:47Does this kind of approach work effectively in the United States
- 43:53as it has overseas? We believe so, and there are 10
- 43:59or 20 health departments around the US using it.
- 44:02They've generally found it to be very positive.
- 44:06It doesn't cost much to do. You just need a systematic way
- 44:10of tracking what happened with each outbreak and what was the
- 44:13timeliness, and then spend a couple of hours looking at Oh
- 44:17well, what worked well, what didn't work well and what can we
- 44:20do better next time. In the public sector generally,
- 44:24we need to have ways to track our performance so that we can
- 44:29improve because we don't have inbuilt tracking systems and
- 44:34this is one that we think is quite relevant not only globally
- 44:37but also in the US. What is different about other
- 44:42countries than the US that causes our healthcare costs and
- 44:49results to be so far inferior to to other countries?
- 44:55There's certain things that are different in different
- 44:57countries. And when we look around the
- 45:01world, it is striking the degree to which each country's health
- 45:05system is different. It evolved in a different way.
- 45:08It has different ways of delivering services.
- 45:11And so the right answer for any one country, including the US,
- 45:15is going to have to include some understanding of where it's
- 45:20been, what's what's called path dependency.
- 45:23So your next step is going to be pretty dependent on where you
- 45:26are now. But what we see consistently in
- 45:29the countries with the highest performing health systems is a
- 45:33much bigger emphasis on primary care.
- 45:36As you said at the outset, less than 5% of our Medicare costs
- 45:41are spent on primary care. That's really pathetic.
- 45:45There's one estimate that suggests that if it were done
- 45:48right, we could triple the amount we spend on primary care
- 45:51and reduce the overall amount we spend on Medicare.
- 45:54So we could triple our spending in this one area, give people,
- 45:58doctors and teams the care for them and then reduce our overall
- 46:03spending. I think the primary care is
- 46:06really one of the the essence of, of the challenge.
- 46:10And of course, other countries take a different approach to
- 46:13saying, hey, everyone's got a healthcare and we're going to
- 46:16reduce administrative burden. When I talk to people who gotten
- 46:20injured or sick abroad and they've gone somewhere in Europe
- 46:23or Scandinavia or Latin America with a good health system,
- 46:27they're really stunned. You know, the costs were so low
- 46:30and there was no administrative complexity.
- 46:31It's it's pretty pathetic how much time we spend on paperwork
- 46:36instead of caring for people. How do we start to unravel this
- 46:43not hit all of string in order to start addressing that?
- 46:49I think we find the threads that are working well and we extend
- 46:53them, and this goes back to the believe part of see, believe,
- 46:58create, find the positive areas and make phased progress.
- 47:04This means health systems that have ways to make progress or
- 47:08states can take action. But really the federal
- 47:12government is on the hook here because it drives so much in our
- 47:16Medicare especially, but also Medicaid and other insurance
- 47:20systems. And of course, you know,
- 47:23Michael, in in the last chapter of the formula for better
- 47:25health, how to save millions of lives, including your own, I
- 47:28talk about the including your own and I apply that C believe
- 47:33create formula to personal health.
- 47:35Because there's so much hype about personal health, it's
- 47:39tempting to kind of throw up your hands, say, oh, we don't
- 47:41know what to do. You know, everyone's debating
- 47:43things. But what I go through is that
- 47:45there are really six things that are the most important for
- 47:49everyone's health. And here they are.
- 47:52One, control your blood pressure 2.
- 47:55Control your cholesterol 3. Get enough sleep 4.
- 48:00Move. Get regular physical activity,
- 48:03The closest thing we have to a wonder drug 5.
- 48:07Avoid toxins, including tobacco, alcohol, and the newer toxins.
- 48:13And, and also, you know, don't neglect nutrition.
- 48:16Nutrition sounds complicated, but there are parts of it that
- 48:19are really quite simple. And for each of those six
- 48:22things, there's a fair amount of detail.
- 48:24Those are the big six. They may sound obvious, but the
- 48:27details are pretty complicated. So blood pressure should ideally
- 48:31be reduced were kept at less than 120 / 80.
- 48:35For cholesterol, you want to look at your LDLC and your APOB
- 48:39and you want them under 70. For sleep, you want 7 to 9
- 48:42hours. For physical activity, you want
- 48:44at least four days a week at least 30 minutes.
- 48:48For toxins, you really want to stop smoking.
- 48:52If you smoke, limit alcohol intake and think about those
- 48:57newer toxins and for nutrition, you know, some of it is
- 49:02complicated, some of it is not so complicated.
- 49:06More fruit and vegetables, more fiber, more potassium, less free
- 49:12sugar, less processed meat, not that complicated.
- 49:17None of that has changed in decades.
- 49:20There are a lot of nuances. Dairy is a debate.
- 49:24What kind of fiber and how do you get it?
- 49:27There are lots of details, but the big picture, More fruit and
- 49:30vegetables, less added sugar. Not that complicated.
- 49:33This is a question from Elizabeth Shaw, who says part of
- 49:38the Affordable Care Act aimed at aimed at improving healthcare by
- 49:44shifting outcome incentives. Why didn't it work to improve
- 49:50health and healthcare? Part of it is having some
- 49:54promising results. I mentioned the Accountable Care
- 49:58organization approach and the analysis I've seen suggests that
- 50:03those AC OS as they're called, that are operated by doctors, by
- 50:09physicians have been a good example of delivering real value
- 50:16for less money. And some of them are reducing
- 50:20healthcare costs by hundreds of millions or billions of dollars
- 50:23by keeping people out of the hospital.
- 50:25And and that's really important, that's doing well by doing good.
- 50:30So I think there are aspects that has worked, that have
- 50:33worked very well. Getting rid of the previous
- 50:38pre-existing condition exclusion, extremely important.
- 50:42There's no way that you can provide decent healthcare if you
- 50:45say, oh, but if you're sick, you can't have health insurance.
- 50:48And making sure that preventive care is free of charge.
- 50:52The patient is really important. And this is something we have
- 50:56seen in the work that we do at Resolve to save Lives.
- 50:59We've focused on patient Co payments are really good if you
- 51:02want to reduce utilization, but if you want people to do more of
- 51:06something, you really have to make sure it's free and easy.
- 51:10So if if we want to have fewer heart attacks and strokes, that
- 51:14means people need to take medicines to prevent heart
- 51:16attacks and strokes and that means that should be easy for
- 51:19them. There should be 0 co-pay 0, not
- 51:22$5. Zero big study done in Canada
- 51:26showed a $5 co-pay for medicines significantly reduced use and
- 51:31that will increase heart attacks and strokes and cost us more
- 51:35money later. So there there are some things
- 51:37that are working and there's more that we can do as well.
- 51:40Arslan Khan comes back again. He's really on a roll.
- 51:43He says the real time availability of shareable
- 51:47healthcare data is needed. Why hasn't anyone created a
- 51:52dashboard for doing this? There has been incremental
- 51:56progress and there have been a series of failures.
- 51:59Failures first, there have been multiple attempts to build
- 52:02something that people, patients will use that will have all of
- 52:06their information and they they can look at it and share it with
- 52:10others. That's been enormously difficult
- 52:12for a variety of reasons, trust and systems and others that I
- 52:16don't understand, but it hasn't worked.
- 52:18Apple has tried, Google has tried, many other entities have
- 52:22tried, and it just hasn't hit its stride.
- 52:26There is increasing ability to share information among health
- 52:31systems and with different health packages.
- 52:35But some of this is the challenge of, you know, you have
- 52:39one electronic health record provider and getting their
- 52:43information to another provider with another system is still
- 52:47something that's not easy. But this has gotten
- 52:50significantly better in recent years.
- 52:53It's just not as as good as we would wish.
- 52:55I think to finish up, I have to ask you for your advice, your
- 53:01prescription for policy makers at at whatever level and, and,
- 53:07or, and, or corporate healthcare leaders, what advice you, you're
- 53:13uniquely qualified among everybody on the planet.
- 53:16You're uniquely qualified to offer this advice.
- 53:18So please share your your advice.
- 53:21Progress is possible. That's the bottom line.
- 53:25Don't get discouraged by setbacks or the news of the day.
- 53:31We are healthier than we've ever been as a species.
- 53:37We have more potential to be even healthier than we've ever
- 53:40had as a species. And yes, there are terrible
- 53:44things happening and lots of problems that have to be
- 53:47addressed. But if we take this approach of
- 53:51rigorously finding, seeing the invisible, seeing the threats,
- 53:55seeing the pathway to progress, seeing why we're blocked from
- 53:59that pathway all too often, seeing whether or not we're
- 54:01making progress, building belief in the possibility of progress,
- 54:06recognized past progress, make future progress, and cultivate
- 54:10optimism, which is enormously important.
- 54:13We can create a healthier future where we organize well, we
- 54:17simplify, we communicate and listen well, and we overcome the
- 54:21barriers to longer, healthier, more productive lives,
- 54:26communities, countries, and a society.
- 54:29It's possible. Progress is possible.
- 54:32What should policy makers in the government do now?
- 54:37I think we need to be really clear about what our goals are
- 54:40and then really transparent about what we're doing to
- 54:44achieve those goals. So if our goal is to get that
- 54:48100 million people, not having primary care doctors down to 50
- 54:53million, what's the plan and how are we going to track it?
- 54:57Because unless we track it, unless we hold ourselves
- 55:01accountable, it's not going to happen.
- 55:03Your advice to the very large healthcare organizations,
- 55:09whether it's CVS or United Healthcare or any others, to the
- 55:13leaders running these large, large healthcare organizations,
- 55:17what thoughts do you have for them?
- 55:20Think about the prevention that we're leaving on the table.
- 55:23Think about the preventive things that are not happening.
- 55:27Controlling blood pressure, reducing cholesterol, promoting
- 55:31As a very simple intervention, at least for everyone with
- 55:35healthy kidney function, potassium enriched low sodium
- 55:40salt may be the easiest healthcare hack.
- 55:43Change the brand of salt you use and you can significantly reduce
- 55:48your chance of a heart attack, stroke, or early death.
- 55:51So there are things that will make a really big difference.
- 55:55Think rigorously about which of them will make the most
- 55:57difference. Come up with a plan, then
- 55:59monitor your implementation of that plan, and if you need to
- 56:03adjust it, adjust it. OK.
- 56:06And with that, a huge thank you to Doctor Tom Frieden.
- 56:11He is now CEO of Resolve to Save Lives.
- 56:15Doctor Frieden, thank you so much for taking your time to be
- 56:18with us today. I'm very grateful to you.
- 56:21Thank you, Michael, it's been a pleasure speaking with you and
- 56:24with your audience. And everybody who watched, you
- 56:26guys are great. Be sure to go to cxotalk.com and
- 56:31subscribe to our newsletter. We want you as part of our
- 56:35community. Thank you so much, everybody,
- 56:37and we'll see you again next time.
- 56:39Have a great day.