Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / The Murder of Lynette Dawson
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two one one one one
- 0:22one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. The advancement of criminal investigative systems have been responsible for solving decades old
- 0:43cold cases and providing respite and justice to the victims. This story is exactly
- 0:48that. The disappearance and potential murder of Lynette Dawson became a household conversation in
- 0:52Australia after the launch of the podcast The Teacher's Pet by the Australian public pressure,
- 0:58and that alone has found a man responsible for the woman's death. We
- 1:02know much more about the case than we did before, and despite the police's
- 1:04insistence that the lack of a body is no obstacle in murder crimes, there
- 1:08is much left up to conjecture. However, the courts have arrived at a
- 1:12verdict the accused guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. In the spring and summer of
- 1:15nineteen eighty one, the diaries of Helen Sims documented a troubling atmosphere at Too
- 1:21gilwinga Drive, Bayview. These writings came to light in the months following the
- 1:25mysterious disappearance of her daughter Lynett Dawson from her Sydney Northern Beaches home. At
- 1:30this residence, she lived with her husband, Chris Dawson, who, at
- 1:33age seventy three, has pleaded not guilty to charges of murdering Linette and disposing
- 1:38of her body. According to Chris Dawson, Lynette was last seen on January
- 1:42ninth, nineteen eighty two. He reported that he had dropped her off at
- 1:45a Mona Vail bus stop, from where she allegedly fled, leaving behind her
- 1:49two children, whom she deeply loved. Despite extensive searches, Lynette Dawson's body
- 1:53has never been discovered and she has not made any contact with her friends or
- 1:57family since her disappearance. During the tri yles initial week, it was revealed
- 2:00that mister Dawson, a former teacher and prominent rugby league player, claimed to
- 2:06have received a phone call from Lynette on the day she vanished. This call,
- 2:08he said, came while he was working at the Northbridge Baths. In
- 2:12this conversation, as per mister Dawson's account, Lynette informed him that she would
- 2:16not be joining him at the pool as planned and had no intention of returning
- 2:20home. This news, he testified, left him visibly shaken, a sentiment
- 2:23he shared with Helen Sims, who was present that day. The prosecution,
- 2:28on the other hand, posited that mister Dawson's desire to have unrestricted access to
- 2:31j C, a teenager who initially joined the Dawson family as a student at
- 2:36the high school where mister Dawson taught and later as a live in babysitter,
- 2:39drove him to murder Miss Dawson. Jay C later moved into the Dawson home
- 2:43following Lynette's disappearance and eventually married mister Dawson. Contrary to this, mister Dawson
- 2:49maintains that although he failed Lynette, he had no motive to kill her,
- 2:52suggesting evidence existed that she was alive after she was last seen. Helen sims
- 2:57diaries presented in court show her deep concern for her daughter's family life. Towards
- 3:00the end of nineteen eighty one, she wrote about Lynette's distress and depression,
- 3:05her sleepless nights filled with worry, and her husband lends belief that jac should
- 3:08leave their household. Unseen family photos of Lynette Dawson, including images from her
- 3:14wedding day to Chris Dawson at Saint Jude's Church, Randwick in March nineteen seventy,
- 3:19were also tendered in court. These pictures depict the Dawsons as an idyllic
- 3:22couple, having met in high school and later having two children. Throughout the
- 3:25nineteen seventies, Chris Dawson juggled various jobs, including a stint as a professional
- 3:30rugby league player, part time model, fitness instructor, and garbage truck worker.
- 3:35His life took a significant turn in nineteen seventy nine when he began teaching
- 3:38at a Sydney high school, where he met Jay C in nineteen eighty,
- 3:43marking a pivotal change in his family dynamics. One of Helenson's diary entries from
- 3:46December sixth, nineteen eighty one, recounts a telling conversation with Chris Dawson,
- 3:52highlighting his apparent disregard for Lynette and his focus on his daughters. Similarly,
- 3:55Lynette's brother, Greg Simms, recalled an interaction where mister Dawson disparagingly referred to
- 4:00Linette, indicating his diminished respect for her. J C's testimony detailed the beginnings
- 4:05of her relationship with mister Dawson, which she described as initially grew evolving into
- 4:11a romantic and sexual relationship by the end of nineteen eighty She recalled receiving cards
- 4:15from mister Dawson with affectionate nicknames and promises of a future together. The court
- 4:19also heard j c's account of a disturbing episode in nineteen eighty one where mister
- 4:25Dawson allegedly visited a building to hire a hitman to kill Lynette, but later
- 4:29decided against it. This claim, however, has been strongly denied by mister
- 4:32Dawson's defense. By late nineteen eighty one, the relationship between Lynette and Chris
- 4:36Dawson had deteriorated significantly. Jac moved into the Dawson home as a live in
- 4:42babysitter, and following a confrontation with Lynette, she temporarily moved out. However,
- 4:46in December of that year, mister Dawson and j C attempted to start
- 4:49a new life in Queensland, an endeavour that was cut short, leading them
- 4:54back to Sydney. J c's testimony continued with the events leading up to and
- 4:58following Lynette Dawson's disap appearance. She detailed how mister Dawson informed her of Lynette's
- 5:02departure and invited her to return to Sidney to help care for his children.
- 5:05Subsequently, jac moved back into the Dawson home, occupying Lynette's former bedroom,
- 5:11where Lynette's belongings still remained. Chris Dawson reported his wife missing over a month
- 5:15after her disappearance, citing her involvement with a religious group on the North Coast
- 5:19as a possible reason for her absence. On March twenty seventh, nineteen eighty
- 5:24two, which would have been their twelfth wedding anniversary, mister Dawson publicly appealed
- 5:28to Lynette through a newspaper ad expressing his love. Christopher Dawson, now seventy
- 5:32four, has been convicted in the decades old murder of his former wife,
- 5:36Lynette Dawson, in a high profile case on Sydney's Northern Beaches. Despite the
- 5:41absence of Lynette's boy and Dawson's persistent denial of involvement in her disappearance, New
- 5:46South Wales Supreme Court Justice Ian Harrison pronounced him guilty. Justice Harrison and his
- 5:50ruling pointed out that no single piece of evidence conclusively proved Dawson's guilt. However,
- 5:57he emphasized that the cumulative weight of the evidence presented left him with no
- 6:00doubt. He concluded that Lynette Dawson's death around January eighth, nineteen eighty two,
- 6:04was a deliberate act by Christopher Dawson. The case had gained significant attention
- 6:09after being featured in a popular true crime podcast. Harrison concurred with the prosecution's
- 6:15argument that Dawson's obsession with his teenage lover, known as j C, whom
- 6:18he had taught and later employed as a babysitter, drove him to murder Lynette
- 6:21Dawson. This was to ensure the continuity of his relationship with j C.
- 6:26The judge also highlighted the variety of falsehood's Dawson propagated following his wife's murder.
- 6:31These lies fell into four distinct categories. False statements about his relationship with j
- 6:35C, assertions about his desire to maintain his marriage, claims suggesting Lynette was
- 6:41still alive, and suggestions that she might have left voluntarily. According to Harrison,
- 6:46these lies were crafted to divert suspicion from Dawson's involvement in the murder.
- 6:49Greg Simms, Lynette's brother, spoke outside the court urging Dawson to disclose the
- 6:54location of Lynette's body. He emphasized that Lynette, a devoted family woman,
- 6:59would never have voluntarily abandoned her family. Sims accused Dawson of betraying Lynette's trust
- 7:03earlier, just as Harrison had dismissed the notion that Lynette Dawson had willingly left
- 7:09her family, including her two young daughters, without a trace. He also
- 7:12refuted claims that she had been seen alive after January nineteen eighty two, or
- 7:15that she had been in contact with her husband. Harrison, who presided over
- 7:19the case as a judge only trial, had to make his reasoning clear,
- 7:23unlike injury verdicts. The trial's format was partly due to the widespread publicity surrounding
- 7:28the case, fueled by the Teacher's Pet podcast by the Australian newspaper, created
- 7:32by investigative reporter Hedley Thomas. This podcast, listened to by millions, was
- 7:38instrumental in bringing new evidence to light and critiquing the police investigation and the NSW
- 7:44Office of the Director of Public prosecution's decision not to charge Dawson despite two separate
- 7:48inquest findings. Dawson, who was charged with murder in December twenty eighteen and
- 7:53extradited from the Gold Coast, had attempted to obtain a permanent stay in the
- 7:57preceding He argued that the long duration since the alleged murder, potential contamination of
- 8:01evidence, an alleged collusion between prosecution witnesses hindered his ability to defend himself.
- 8:07However, these arguments were unsuccessful. The prosecution built a strong circumstantial case suggesting
- 8:13Dawson murdered Lynette to maintain an unimpeded relationship with j C. Dawson's defense contended
- 8:18that the police's failure to investigate reported sightings of Linette, combined with an illogical
- 8:24motive, made the murder accusation doubtful. Dawson himself did not testify during the
- 8:28trial. In his verdict, Harrison stated that the prosecution had the burden to
- 8:33prove beyond reasonable doubt that Lynette Dawson was dead, killed by Dawson, possibly
- 8:37with help, and that her body was disposed of. He found the time
- 8:39frame provided by the prosecution credible concluding that Lynett Dawson had died on the date
- 8:45alleged, dismissing Dawson's claims of post disappearance communication with his wife's fabrication. Dawson's
- 8:50lawyer, Greg Walsh indicated that Dawson would likely seek bail before sentencing and plans
- 8:56to appeal the verdict, maintaining his innocence. Walsh also mentioned Dawson's diagnosis of
- 9:01dementia, possibly related to his rugby league career, which would make custody challenging.
- 9:05Dawson's twin brother, Paul, left the court without commenting to the media.
- 9:09Shanel Dawson faced a profound tragedy at just four years old when her mother
- 9:13Lynn Dawson mysteriously disappeared in nineteen eighty two, an event that wouldn't be classified
- 9:18as murder until two thousand and one. Her father, Chris Dawson, was
- 9:22eventually found guilty of the crime in twenty twenty two. Following her mother's disappearance,
- 9:26Shanell's teenage babysitter, Joanne Curtis, quickly assumed a significant role in the
- 9:31Dawson household, moving into Lynne's bed and later wearing her clothes and wedding ring.
- 9:35Chanell, in her new book My Mother's Eyes, co written with journalist
- 9:39Ali Pascoe, expresses her feelings of being unloved by Curtis, who had started
- 9:45a relationship with her father while she was his student. Shanell didn't confront her
- 9:48father about his role in her mother's death until twenty eighteen. He was sentenced
- 9:52to twenty four years for murder in twenty twenty two and three years for sexual
- 9:56offenses in twenty twenty three. The podcast, following the trend and of true
- 10:00crime journalism popularized by Sarah Konig's serial, focused on meticulous research and storytelling,
- 10:05contributing significantly to the legal proceedings against Dawson. Thomas's work in The Teacher's Pet
- 10:11is notable for its in depth investigation, which involved reviewing transcripts, conducting interviews,
- 10:16and following leads. His commitment to the case and the challenges he faced
- 10:20in reporting are evident in his book. The podcast and book highlight issues in
- 10:24the formal investigations into Lynn's disappearance and offer insights into Thomas's investigative process. Shanel
- 10:30Dawson's book, on the other hand, provides a personal and emotional account of
- 10:33her experiences. She writes candidly about her anger and grief, her complex relationship
- 10:39with her father, and her struggles with the public attention brought by the case.
- 10:43She acknowledges Thomas's role in bringing justice to her mother's case, despite her
- 10:46discomfort with some aspects of the media coverage. A portion of her book's proceeds
- 10:50will support women's community shelters in New South Wales. The stories of Shanel Dawson
- 10:56and Headley Thomas intertwined to reveal a tragic family history, quest for justice in
- 11:00a decade's old cold case, and the role of media and true crime journalism
- 11:05in bringing attention to unsolved crimes. Their works, each in their own way,
- 11:07contribute to understanding the complexities of such cases and the lasting impact they have
- 11:13on those involved, and remind us of the power of public interest and investigative
- 11:16journalism in meeting out effective justice.