Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / When Mentorship Becomes a Mirror: Guiding Without Controlling | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I watched my friend freeze in the middle of her career pivot, waiting for me to tell her what to do, and I realized with a jolt that I had become the very thing I was trying to help her escape. It wasn’t guidance she needed; it was permission to trust her own messy, uncertain voice. Let’s sit with that for a second. That moment where you realize your friend isn’t looking at you as a peer anymore, but as a compass. I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately because it’s such a quiet, heavy trap to fall into. We love our younger friends. We see their potential like a bright light flickering on, and we want so badly to shield them from the dark spots we walked through ourselves. But here is the hard truth: when you step into the role of mentor, even unintentionally, you change the dynamic. You stop being just another person sitting across the table having coffee, and you start carrying the weight of their expectations. And they start carrying the weight of your approval. I remember calling Sarah last week, and she asked me, 'Rhiannon, would you say yes or no?' about a job offer. Just two words. Would you say yes or no? And in that pause, I felt the entire history of our friendship shift. She didn’t want advice. She wanted me to take the wheel. But if I took the wheel, who was driving her life? That question has been haunting me all weekend. I need to be vulnerable here because I’ve been there too. A few years ago, I was mentoring a young woman named Elena in my community organizing days. I was so convinced that I knew the path because I’d already walked it. I gave her templates for emails, scripts for difficult conversations, and schedules for her self-care routines. I thought I was helping. I thought I was being a good friend. But one day, she looked at me with these exhausted eyes and said, 'You’re making me feel like I’m failing before I’ve even started.' Ouch. That hit me right in the chest. I realized I wasn’t empowering her; I was replicating my own anxiety onto her shoulders. I was trying to control the uncontrollable. I wanted her success to prove that my way worked. But her life wasn’t a proof of concept for my past. It was her own story, still being written, full of plot twists I couldn’t predict. When we mentor without checking our ego, we aren’t really seeing the other person. We’re seeing a mirror of our younger selves, and we’re trying to fix the parts of us that we never fixed. That’s not friendship. That’s projection disguised as care. Tell me more about why that matters to you. Because when we try to fix things for our friends, we accidentally strip them of their agency. Agency is such a big word, but it just means the power to act. When you give someone the answer, you give them safety for a moment, but you take away their confidence for the long haul. They learn to look outward for validation instead of inward for intuition. And that is a dangerous habit to form, especially when you are navigating the complex, messy waters of early adulthood or career shifts. I see this happen all the time in my own life. I’ll get a text from a friend saying, 'I don’t know what to wear,' or 'Should I reply to this email?' And my instinct is to jump in, to solve it, to be useful. But usefulness isn’t always the same as support. Sometimes, the most supportive thing you can do is hold space for their confusion. Let them sit in the not-knowing. Let them feel the discomfort of making a choice without a safety net. It’s scary, I know. Watching someone struggle is painful. But growth doesn’t happen in the comfort zone. It happens in the friction. If we smooth out every bump for them, we rob them of the muscle memory they need to navigate life alone. So how do we navigate this without becoming distant or cold? How do we stay close without taking over? It starts with setting gentle but firm boundaries around advice. I’ve started using a simple phrase with my younger friends. When they ask for my opinion, I ask them first, 'Do you want my perspective, or do you want my support?' It sounds small, but it changes everything. It forces them to clarify their needs. Usually, they say, 'Just listen.' And then I just listen. I don’t offer solutions. I don’t share my war stories unless they ask specifically. This distinction is crucial. Support means being present, validating their feelings, and reminding them of their worth. Perspective means sharing your experience only if it serves them, not if it soothes your urge to control. I have to remind myself constantly that my experience is not universal. What worked for me might be completely wrong for them. Their values, their circumstances, their energy—they are different. Respecting that difference is the highest form of love. It says, 'I trust you to figure this out. I believe in your capacity to handle the mess.' That belief is more powerful than any piece of advice I could ever give. We’re all just figuring it out as we go. I keep coming back to this idea of being a witness rather than a guide. A guide points the way. A witness walks beside you and acknowledges the terrain. When I shifted my mindset from 'I need to help her succeed' to 'I need to honor her journey,' the pressure lifted. I stopped feeling responsible for her outcomes. I started enjoying the conversation again. We laughed more. We cried more. We talked about the fear, not just the strategy. And strangely, when I stopped pushing for answers, she started finding them herself. Last week, she made a decision that surprised me. It wasn’t the path I would have chosen, but it felt right for her. And she owned it. She stood tall in her choice. That moment was better than any success I could have engineered for her. It was authentic. It was hers. As listeners, think about the friendships in your life where you might be holding too much authority. Where are you trying to save someone from a fall they need to take? Where are you silencing your own doubts to appear more certain than you are? It’s okay to admit you don’t know. It’s okay to say, 'I’m scared too.' Vulnerability invites vulnerability. Certainty invites dependence. If you want deep connection, choose uncertainty together. There is a profound intimacy in admitting that you don’t have the map. When you drop the mantle of the expert, you create room for true equality. You become a fellow traveler again. And that is where the magic happens. The magic isn’t in the perfect advice; it’s in the shared humanity of being lost. I’ve learned to cherish those moments when my younger friends and I sit in silence, unsure of the next step. Those silences are sacred. They are where intuition grows. They are where we learn to trust ourselves. So, my challenge to you this week is to practice the art of asking. Instead of telling, ask. Instead of fixing, wonder. Ask, 'What does your heart say?' Ask, 'What are you afraid of losing?' Ask, 'What would you do if you weren’t afraid?' These questions open doors that answers never will. They invite depth. They invite courage. And they remind your friend that they are capable, worthy, and strong enough to face whatever comes next. You don’t need to be the hero of their story. You just need to be the safe harbor where they can dock, rest, and remember who they are when the storm passes. Thank you for letting me into your space today. For listening with such an open heart. Remember, you don’t have to have it all figured out to be a good friend. You just have to show up. Be kind to yourself. Be patient with your friends. And trust that you are exactly where you need to be. Until next time, I’m sending you so much love. Take care of yourselves.