Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Evergreen Insights: 10 Reasons Why NCUA Should Not Regulate Succession Planning
Transcript
- 0:00Samantha: Evergreen Insights: 10 Reasons Why N C U A Should Not
- 0:04Regulate Succession Planning.
- 0:06Since the agency recently reintroduced an new proposal on Succession
- 0:09Planning, what better time than now to look back on our historical
- 0:13take on why this is not necessary.
- 0:16Also in the the near future watch for another episode on this
- 0:19proposed rule and our comment letter to N C U A on this topic.
- 0:23You can also watch for more Evergreen Insights which are
- 0:26past episode that are timeless.
- 0:28This episode is called evergreen insights.
- 0:3110 reasons why.
- 0:33Should not regulate succession planning.
- 0:36Since the agency recently reintroduced a new proposal on succession planning.
- 0:41What better time than now to look back on our historical take
- 0:44on why this is not necessary.
- 0:47Also in the near future watch for another episode on this proposed rule
- 0:50and our potential comment letter to NCUA.
- 0:54On this topic.
- 0:55You can also watch for more evergreen insights in the future, which are
- 0:59past episodes on timeless topics.
- 1:03Samantha: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 1:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 1:10your exam with Flying Colors.
- 1:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 1:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 1:18If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 1:21team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 1:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 1:28com.
- 1:28Hey,
- 1:36Mark Treichel here.
- 1:36Thanks for joining me for another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:39Today, I've got a quick take on succession planning or the proposed NCOA
- 1:44succession planning rule, and I'm going to provide 10 reasons why a succession
- 1:49planning regulation is a bad idea.
- 1:52So in January of 2022, at its NCOA board meeting, the board voted to
- 1:56approve a proposed rule on succession planning by a vote of two to one
- 2:01with three Board member, Rodney Hood voting against the proposal.
- 2:05Now, according to NCOA succession planning is the process through
- 2:09which an organization identifies, develops, and retains key personnel
- 2:13to ensure its viability and continued effective performance.
- 2:18NCOA goes on to say that succession planning also allows an organization to
- 2:22prepare for the unexpected, therefore minimizing service disruptions
- 2:27during management transitions.
- 2:29Now, as an editorial comment on that, in 33 years at NCUA, I don't
- 2:35recall a lot of service disruptions related to succession planning.
- 2:39Matter of fact, I can't think of any.
- 2:41Anyway, so, one of the biggest proponents of this proposed rule,
- 2:45of course, is succession planning.
- 2:46Chairman Todd Harper, who issued a statement on it after the board
- 2:49meeting, which included what I'm about to share with you.
- 2:52So Todd said, moreover, succession planning is recognized as vital
- 2:56to the long term succession of any institution, including credit unions.
- 3:00A board's failure to plan for the transition of its management could
- 3:04potentially come with high costs, including the potential for the
- 3:09Unanticipated merger of the credit union upon the departure of key personnel.
- 3:14Put another way, Todd said, succession planning helps to safeguard credit union
- 3:18members choice of financial institution.
- 3:21So what does the proposed rule require?
- 3:23You might ask.
- 3:24So the board of directors of the credit union or an appropriate committee picked
- 3:28by the board of directors would be required to review and approve a written
- 3:33succession plan regarding the specified federal credit unions and officials.
- 3:37Now, notice I said federal credit union, this proposed rule does
- 3:41not apply to state charters.
- 3:43The succession plan must at a minimum identify the credit union's key positions,
- 3:47necessary competencies and skill sets for those positions and strategies to
- 3:52identify alternatives to fill vacancies.
- 3:56The board also must review the succession plan in accordance with
- 3:59the schedule established by the board, but no less than annually.
- 4:04Also, in addition, the proposed rule would amend 701.
- 4:084b3, which sets forth certain educational requirements for federal credit union
- 4:13directors and require that directors have a working familiarity with the
- 4:17federal credit union succession plan.
- 4:20Now, relative to succession planning efforts, this proposed rule is intended
- 4:25to strengthen current succession planning efforts at credit unions
- 4:29and to require others that do not yet have such planning to commence
- 4:32their succession planning processes.
- 4:35The proposed rule is also consistent with the guidance issued by other banking
- 4:39agencies to address succession planning.
- 4:42Notice I said guidance at other agencies, not regulations at other agencies.
- 4:48All right, so.
- 4:50My top 10 reasons why NCUA does not need a succession planning rule.
- 4:55Number one, I did a poll of this on LinkedIn.
- 4:57There's a book that I'm going to do a story on called the wisdom of crowds.
- 5:01Well, I sought out the opinions of crowds and the crowds clearly
- 5:06favored guidance over regulation.
- 5:0872 percent of the many voters on my poll indicated they
- 5:11prefer guidance over regulation.
- 5:14Regulation now, 22 percent said no regulation, no guidance.
- 5:19Let's have neither.
- 5:20And quite frankly, that's where I think NCUA should be.
- 5:24Although I'm sure they'll either land on regulation or guidance.
- 5:28And lastly, only 6 percent of those who voted felt that there was a regulation
- 5:33required for succession planning.
- 5:35So number two.
- 5:36I mentioned that the rule says that other agencies have guidance.
- 5:40So that's number two, other banking agencies do not have a
- 5:43regulation on succession planning.
- 5:45And two admits this in their proposed regulation by stating quote, the
- 5:49proposed rule is also consistent with the guidance issued by other banking
- 5:53agencies to address succession planning.
- 5:55So Bank of America doesn't need a, doesn't have a regulation that requires this.
- 5:59Now, do they have a policy?
- 6:01I would bet that they do.
- 6:02But if it's not required of big banks, why are you requiring it?
- 6:06Of small credit unions?
- 6:07They have enough regulatory burden going on and don't need
- 6:10another regulation from NCA.
- 6:12Number three, the proposed regulation is a solution in search of a problem.
- 6:17It's flawed to think that a succession planning regulation,
- 6:20guidance, or policy will have a material impact on slowing mergers.
- 6:24That's just not reality.
- 6:26It's easy to say in a proposed regulation, and it's, in my opinion, flawed logic.
- 6:32Number four, if NCUA does not have enterprise risk management
- 6:36regulation, it doesn't need a succession planning regulation.
- 6:39Think about it.
- 6:40That's a far more appropriate, uh, Topic to regulate.
- 6:44And quite frankly, maybe you don't need either, but a succession planning
- 6:47regulation to me is inappropriate, especially if there's other things that
- 6:51you could regulate before regulating succession planning, by the way, I'm
- 6:55going to have a podcast on enterprise risk management coming up with a special guest.
- 6:59So watch for that soon.
- 7:01Number five, lack of a written succession planning is not unsafe and unsound.
- 7:06NCUA, focus your regulations on things that create unsafe and
- 7:09unsound conditions in credit unions.
- 7:11In my opinion, there's nothing unsafe and unsound about not having a
- 7:16succession planning policy in place.
- 7:20Number six, benefits of succession planning can be achieved by guidance.
- 7:25If it's good enough for the banks to have guidance, I think credit unions can handle
- 7:30this issue, if you will, with guidance.
- 7:33And NCOA issues a plethora of letters to credit unions each year, most of
- 7:38which, many of which are still active.
- 7:40You can find them on NCOA's And quite frankly, again, why not guidance?
- 7:46I would push for guidance.
- 7:47And if, if I was one of the three board members or one of the two voted, yes, I
- 7:51might change, I would be changing my vote to, to now and pushing this with guidance.
- 7:56Now guidance is nimble and can be achieved more easily.
- 8:02Then having a vote of the NCUA board, the NCUA board chairman controls guidance.
- 8:07They have the ability to issue that guidance on their own.
- 8:10They can seek the input of staff.
- 8:12They can seek the input of credit unions.
- 8:13They can seek the input of other board members, but they can do it without
- 8:17having to have a formal board vote.
- 8:19And it's more nimble that way it can be changed more frequently.
- 8:22So if you put guidance out and then want to tweak it the next year,
- 8:25it's easier and takes less time and burden from NCUA and quite frankly,
- 8:29creates less of a regulatory burden.
- 8:31Number eight, the proposed rule lacks clarity regarding key positions in a
- 8:37credit union succession plan, which Positions are required to be part of it.
- 8:42Where do you draw the line?
- 8:43And so it gives no guidance relative to that.
- 8:46And if there's going to be a regulation or guidance, I think there should
- 8:49be more information relative to which positions should be included.
- 8:53Number nine, if it's not required for state chartered credit
- 8:56unions, don't require it for federal chartered credit unions.
- 9:00State charters already have a competitive advantage relative to fill a membership.
- 9:05Why create a regulation that only applies to federal credit unions?
- 9:09It just doesn't make sense to me.
- 9:10If you can't apply it to everybody, then don't apply it to anybody.
- 9:16Number 10.
- 9:17Studies show that flawed succession planning can be a demotivator.
- 9:21For example, if your position is not defined as a key position or if you do not
- 9:26get accepted to enjoy the benefits of a succession planning program, it can create
- 9:30morale problems at your, at lower levels.
- 9:33So I indicated that NCOA does not say who needs to be included.
- 9:36So let's say you have a policy and you include all vice
- 9:40presidents, but not all managers.
- 9:41Well, guess what?
- 9:42Your managers May not feel that they should have been excluded
- 9:47from participating in this program.
- 9:49So you think you can come up with a policy that's going to help in this regard.
- 9:53If it's not done right and carefully, you're going to find that it creates
- 9:56more problems than it solves.
- 9:58And again, I don't think a regulation in this arena makes any sense at all.
- 10:03So NCUA sought comment on this regulation, the comment period closed in April.
- 10:10It'll be interesting to see what happens with this.
- 10:13My bet is that.
- 10:14It will not get finalized as a regulation.
- 10:17I have a belief that maybe the two Republican board members will join forces
- 10:24and lead to this being issued as guidance.
- 10:27By the way, CUNA and NAFCU both wrote letters to NCOA saying that they believed
- 10:33it would be better to have guidance and.
- 10:35The things that I've referenced here, like the CUNA letter, the NAFQ letter,
- 10:39the proposed regulation, Chairman Harper's statement on this, and my blog post on
- 10:45LinkedIn about the top 10 reasons why NCWA does not need succession planning
- 10:49rule, I will include in my show notes.
- 10:52All right, that's it for this With Flying Colors quick take.
- 10:56I appreciate your time today and I hope to see you next time.
- 10:59Have you here listening again soon.
- 11:01Thank you.
- 11:08Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 11:12your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 11:16of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCOA.
- 11:20If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions,
- 11:23check out our services at markteichl.
- 11:26com.