Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Does Trump Know NCUA Has Zero Board Members?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 2: It's an emergency.
- 0:04What is it?
- 0:06Just waiting to see
- 0:13Policy shifts quietly
- 0:17New direction, leadership in question.
- 0:20Insurance fund, CAMEL watch, examiner attention.
- 0:24We don't wait for next week when the meeting's on the-
- 0:30Now it's in your head.
- 0:31Ooh, ooh, ooh, ooh
- 0:59The signals start flashing red.
- 1:04We hit record, you know
- 1:09Speaker: everyone.
- 1:10This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:13This is an emergency episode on Wednesday, the 12th of August.
- 1:18Why am I doing this?
- 1:19Because NCUA has zero board members.
- 1:23In history, NCUA usually 99% of the time has three.
- 1:30Occasionally, they have two.
- 1:32They've had one on a couple of instances, but the most obvious and telling instance
- 1:38recently was Kyle Hauptman being the only one after Trump fired Bootska
- 1:43and Harper, what, over a year ago now.
- 1:47I'm gonna walk through what's going on, but it hasn't really been covered
- 1:52in the press as to the fact that there are zero, and that's because
- 1:56I don't think they quite understand because Congress has put somebody
- 2:00in, that doesn't mean they are in.
- 2:02And NCUA has not updated their website to say that Kyle Hauptman
- 2:05is gone, even though I have it from good sources he resigned this week,
- 2:10and he was sworn in at his new job.
- 2:12So I don't know if his commitment was, "I'll stay until s- the Senate nominates
- 2:17crews," and he felt it was time to go.
- 2:19I think he left NCUA and the Trump administration in a lurch.
- 2:23That's just my take.
- 2:24As a former insider on the outside looking in, I think it's a bad look.
- 2:29Zero is not good.
- 2:31Fortunately, NCUA has a robust set of delegations that were
- 2:35in existence when I was there.
- 2:37Most of those, I believe, I know, are still in place.
- 2:42And I'm gonna walk through what it means, what it doesn't mean
- 2:44for NCUA and credit unions.
- 2:46Now, funny story a lot of times I can tell when one of my podcasts gets
- 2:51circulated around NCUA 'cause the what do I wanna say, the downloads
- 2:56are vastly higher on some of the ones that go into inside baseball at NCUA.
- 3:01The industry likes hearing that, but I can tell when a couple of my
- 3:05subscribers are NCUA folks, and they send it around to their friends at NCUA.
- 3:09'Cause there's not a lot of people at NCUA that understands how
- 3:12the delegations actually work.
- 3:14There's not a lot of people at NCUA left, particularly after the
- 3:17buyouts, that have anything to do with when there were one board member
- 3:21back in the Dollar administration.
- 3:23Of course we have the Hauptman era.
- 3:25But I'm gonna jump into what this all means, but zero's not a good thing.
- 3:31So how did we get here?
- 3:32Over the last couple of weeks or over the last week as a reminder
- 3:37Hauptman's term ended August 25th.
- 3:40There are six-year terms at NCUA that really don't mean anything now as
- 3:43long as the legal actions recently about the firings at other agencies.
- 3:50And Harper and Oates, if Harper and Oates don't win their appeal we're
- 3:53gonna be in an era when a president comes in, they fire the ones that
- 3:57are there, and they bring others in.
- 3:58But having zero the act says the board will do X, Y, and
- 4:03Z, and staff can't do that.
- 4:04So there are things th- that theoretically cannot be done while there are zero
- 4:09board members and I'll walk through that.
- 4:11But, so Hauptman's term expired in August of 2025.
- 4:15A year later, August of 7th of 2026, just la- last week the
- 4:20Senate confirms John Cruz to take over presumably as chair, right?
- 4:26'Cause he's gonna be the only one, and the deal cut was Hauptman said
- 4:28he would stay until Cruz was in.
- 4:30To me that's like the the Seattle Seahawks when they could've beaten the Patriots,
- 4:36and they could've they could've run the ball from the two-yard line, but they
- 4:39decided to get cute and throw a pass, and it got intercepted, and they ended
- 4:42up losing the game and the Super Bowl.
- 4:44To me, that's what Hauptman's deciding to leave on a Saturday really is.
- 4:48Now, will the agencies survive it?
- 4:51Probably.
- 4:52Will press get attentions of bankers to show that this is a little
- 4:55bit of what they always accused NCUAs of as the Keystone Cops?
- 4:59I really wish Hauptman had sucked it up and stayed instead of
- 5:03getting over to his newer job where he's making a few dollars more.
- 5:07Y- but again he, I don't know his life.
- 5:09I don't know what he's dealing with personally.
- 5:12One half week or a week or two weeks less of the higher pay so that there could
- 5:17always be a board member in place seems like something a prudent person, a person
- 5:23that cared about the industry would do.
- 5:24All right, enough about that.
- 5:25Kyle's gone.
- 5:26We're just waiting for Cruz.
- 5:27Enough said on that.
- 5:29So Hauptman departs, like I said, August 10th.
- 5:32He resigned, and he took the oath to become a board member of the PCAOB
- 5:36at and he, at a ceremony at the SEC.
- 5:39So now we're waiting for a ceremony at NCUA, but we can't get to that yet
- 5:42'cause the paperwork isn't done, and I think that's what the press is missing.
- 5:46So again, the seat is unfilled, waiting for Cruz to come in, tick-tock.
- 5:52I'm sure Larry Fazio is fielding a lot of questions from within and without of NCUA.
- 5:57Larry's the current executive director.
- 5:59And there are some delegations that theoretically would say he
- 6:02could run the agency as the board.
- 6:05But I don't think that applies and I'll get into that here shortly.
- 6:08So the math, there's three authorized.
- 6:11Two re- two are required for a quorum, and you can get into that whole were
- 6:15the 11 regulations that Hauptman finalized last week w- wereâ¦
- 6:19are they legitimate because they didn't have a quorum?
- 6:23Some people say a quorum of one is one.
- 6:25The NCUA's regulations say you need to have two to vote on something.
- 6:28I don't think anybody's gonna contest that, 'cause it's deregulation,
- 6:31and why would anybody who has an interest contest it unless it was
- 6:35a consumer compliance type group?
- 6:37But anyway, I digress.
- 6:38And now members currently qualified to serve are zero, because again, they're
- 6:42waiting for paperwork from the White House, which can can get political.
- 6:47It can get slowed down.
- 6:48And we're gonna have to wait and see, what happens.
- 6:51By the time I post this today, who knows, maybe Cruz will be in.
- 6:55But that's why I'm doing this one as an emergency, 'cause it, it's shelf life is
- 6:58gonna be between now and whenever Cruz and the White House get their ducks lined up.
- 7:03So the Senate confirmed, that was done.
- 7:06Then what happens is there's a commission that is issued, and what happens is it
- 7:09gets signed by the President whether that's electronically or otherwise.
- 7:14I'm not gonna get into that debate.
- 7:15Wink.
- 7:16And the document comes over.
- 7:17It goes to the NCUA's SCIF, the Secured Compartmentalized Information Facility.
- 7:24The general counsel at NCUA is the person that's in contact with the White
- 7:28House to find out that that someone is coming over that the documents are
- 7:32coming over, and then the, the head of security will bring it up to general
- 7:37counsel and/or the chief of staff.
- 7:39And now the chief of staff, interestingly right now Sarah Bang, it's my
- 7:43understanding left NCUA the last day of July, and Nate Kroger, who is the acting
- 7:49chief of staff, a political appointee.
- 7:51Sierra Robinson is another political appointee over public affairs.
- 7:56Oftentimes what happens when a party, when there's a new board member who
- 8:00becomes chair, they either look from the Schedule Cs that they have, which
- 8:05are political appointees that have to be approved by the White House, not
- 8:08by Congress, but by the White House.
- 8:10Each agency has a number of Schedule Cs that they're allowed to fill.
- 8:14The, theâ¦
- 8:15My recollection is each board office has two, and then the chairman has
- 8:20four or five which is an alarmingly not a lo-- a shockingly large number
- 8:25for an agency of NCUA's size, but it's been that way for forever.
- 8:29So what happens is the new person will come in.
- 8:32They've either identified someone they want to be their chief of staff that
- 8:35they will then get approved through NCUA, or they'll pick from the people
- 8:39that are there, which I believe would be narrowed down to Nate and Ciera.
- 8:44I've heard some rumblings that that and I know historically what happens
- 8:48is those Cs start to fight for that position, just like at any organization.
- 8:51You're running a credit union, you got three VPs, you got your CFO and, yeah
- 8:55you announce the position and you v- you have peers competing against each other.
- 8:59That's what happens in the Schedule C world typically, and my guess is both
- 9:03those people probably wanna be the chief of staff instead of being in charge of
- 9:07public affairs, which is the OIAC office.
- 9:10So right now it looked like Hauptman preferred Kroger because he was the acting
- 9:14chief of staff when he left over Ciera Robinson, but I could be wrong on that.
- 9:18That just could've been that they rotated it, and each one of them did two months.
- 9:22I don't believe, though, that's what-- No, it couldn't have been that
- 9:24because, 'cause Sarah Bang just left.
- 9:26So anyway when I was at NCUA at the end of the Clinton administration Yolanda Wheat
- 9:31worked hard to get Norm D'Amour fired.
- 9:34And Yolanda came in for a cup of coffee one or two months as chair of NCUA, and
- 9:40she got that paperwork moved at in s- at the White House Office of Personnel
- 9:45by hiring five or six people from that office to get the documents moved.
- 9:49And there were some politics going on that I won't get into here.
- 9:52If we're ever chatting at a conference, I can explain it to you.
- 9:55There's some real inside baseball.
- 9:57But Wheat basically, these are my words got influence with the White House press
- 10:03to get her appointed as chair because she said, "Okay, if you do that, if you move
- 10:08that paper, get it moving for me, I will hire your, you over here at NCUA for a
- 10:12month or two or as long as I can keep you here," because Clinton was on his way out.
- 10:15His term was up, et cetera, et cetera.
- 10:17The commission has to come from the White House, has to be signed by the president.
- 10:21That's the bottleneck, right?
- 10:23We're seeing in the press that they have to have the oath of office signed.
- 10:26Excuse me, the oath of office where he raises his hand and usually it's
- 10:30the general counsel who will swear him in, but sometimes they'll bring
- 10:32in other people to swear him in.
- 10:34It'll happen in NCUA's boardroom typically.
- 10:37They'll invite all their political friends and it's an exciting day for the person
- 10:41getting sworn in, it's it's very cool.
- 10:42But that, before that can happen, the paperwork has to move from the White
- 10:46House to NCUA saying the President has named Cruz the chair and has signed off
- 10:53on the paperwork so that he can start.
- 10:56Haltman should have waited till that happened.
- 10:57He didn't.
- 10:58So NCUA's kind of in no man's land right now.
- 11:00Here a little bit kind of not no man's land, and you can assume
- 11:03it's gonna be resolved quickly.
- 11:04But, in the Trump administration, who knows?
- 11:06Sometimes things happen real quick under the mantra of Elon Musk
- 11:11Silicon Valley, move fast and break things, and sometimes they move slow.
- 11:15Hopefully this moves fast.
- 11:17So
- 11:19the finish line on- only, Only now, o- only after the oath of office does
- 11:25the, the, is the seat filled and then can they come in and serve as chair.
- 11:30What the statute permitted, the Federal Credit Union Act lets a member
- 11:33keep serving after a term expires until a successor has qualified.
- 11:37That provision is why the outgoing chairman was able to stay a full year past
- 11:41August 2025 and had he stayed, it would've covered this gap, but he left too soon.
- 11:47What actually happened, he left three days after the Senate vote
- 11:50before a successor qualified.
- 11:52The vacancy isn't something the statute forced, it's the product of
- 11:56Hauptman's departure, and it could've been avoided if he had waited a
- 12:00few days, a few weeks, whatever.
- 12:03But, again board, NCUA board members' pay is capped at essentially what
- 12:07Cro- Congress makes, and Hauptman is getting a big raise at his new position,
- 12:12and that may have influenced him.
- 12:13Who knows?
- 12:13There may have been something behind the scenes that led him
- 12:16to believe he had to leave.
- 12:17But in any event, leaves NCUA in a predicament.
- 12:21So the agency was built to handle unique situations like this.
- 12:26So again, the Federal Credit Union Act establishes what the board
- 12:31can do, and it can only be the board unless they delegate things.
- 12:34And I viewed the delegations of authority as my Bible my equivalent
- 12:39of my NCUA Bible when I was there.
- 12:40Here's what this office can do.
- 12:42There, here's what I can do.
- 12:43Here's what the board has retained.
- 12:44Here's what the chair can do.
- 12:46And there's a lot of delegations that build into what can be
- 12:52done by staff and what can't.
- 12:55So here's what, what keeps NCUA running.
- 12:58The delegations allow for exams and supervision.
- 13:02Field staff keep examining and supervising on the normal cycle.
- 13:05It allows for, that means you can still have doors and findings issues.
- 13:09That means you can still have letters of understanding, which
- 13:11are the first step towards formal formal administrative actions.
- 13:16The regional directors have the delegated authority to take temporary
- 13:20cease and desist orders, not permanent, but temporary cease and desist orders.
- 13:24And that really doesn't matter 'cause they don't do that much.
- 13:26The FDIC does cease and desist orders much more than NCUA, and that's more
- 13:30of a cultural difference than a, a real functional difference in my opinion.
- 13:35Charters and mergers can go on.
- 13:37And this actually I typed this out, I typed this out wrong.
- 13:41Resolutions, conservatorships, and liquidation authority
- 13:44actually sits with the board.
- 13:46So you can't end a conservatorship, you can't make a conservatorship
- 13:49without an NCUA board member.
- 13:50Quite frankly, I think it was risky for NCUA to conserve credit unions
- 13:54with one board member because, again, a g- is one a quorum, but that's
- 13:57a, the story for a, a- another day.
- 13:57So what stops rulemaking?
- 13:57There will
- 14:03be no rules.
- 14:04NCUA just did a dump of ⦠That's probably n- not
- 14:09the r- the best word to use.
- 14:10The NCUA just issued 10, 11, 12 final regulat- regulations from
- 14:15their, the big project they did.
- 14:17Most of those are changing happy to glad.
- 14:19I'm gonna be working on a podcast in the next few days walking through those.
- 14:24But indirect loans, there was a, a good change there, and
- 14:27a couple other good changes.
- 14:28But Kyle Hauptman, before he left, got all of those done as final,
- 14:33presuming that he has the ability to do a board action of one.
- 14:36But p- appeals, appeals to the board cannot.
- 14:39So if you have appeal that's about to go to the board, it could be
- 14:42slowed down until Cruz gets on.
- 14:45And then when he gets on, he's gonna be drinking water from a fire hose, right?
- 14:48He has to learn the agency.
- 14:50Everybody and his brother's gonna wanna come in and meet him.
- 14:52He's the only one.
- 14:54Being chair is not an easy job at NCUA.
- 14:56Very time-consuming for the staff.
- 14:58And oftentime what happens if someone serves as a board member and a
- 15:02chief of staff for that board member and they become chair they find
- 15:06out the difference between being a board member and being the chair.
- 15:09It is huge.
- 15:10So he's gonna come in.
- 15:11He's a smart guy from what everybody says.
- 15:14He knows the financial world, and so that part'll be easy.
- 15:16But the nuances of NCUA, and he'll be relying on heavily on
- 15:20the executives that are left.
- 15:22Hopefully he taps into the breadth of the the wisdom of crowds at NCUA and
- 15:27doesn't rely on one person at NCUA to tell him how credit unions work.
- 15:32I'm hoping that happens.
- 15:33I've heard that didn't happen recently under Hauptman, that it was really more
- 15:38of of a fiefdom, if you will at many levels at NCUA, but I don't really,
- 15:42again, want to get into that here.
- 15:43Actions that are delegated above, so there's actions NCUA can take staff
- 15:48can take to resolve losses in credit unions of certain dollar amounts.
- 15:51If they're bigger than that, they have to come to the board.
- 15:53So that would be probably why the rumors are that they've made
- 15:58their decisions on Jackson Area.
- 15:59I haven't seen the final decision on where that's going.
- 16:02But the decision to allow that to be merged or purchased in a, purchased,
- 16:07P&A'd purchased and assumed Into another institution acknowledges a loss that
- 16:12staff doesn't have the ability to do.
- 16:14So I'm sure Hauptman signed off on that before.
- 16:16Asset guarantees, which they don't do very often, are not allowed.
- 16:20Appointments and removals or promotions of senior personnel,
- 16:24people are gonna be locked in their positions until Cruz comes on.
- 16:28And no, no budget changes beyond the $50,000, I believe, that the
- 16:32executive director can reprogram.
- 16:34But they have a budget.
- 16:35They're probably under budget 'cause they got rid of so many staff.
- 16:38But it's a little bit of kind of like flying around the airport
- 16:42hoping nothing bad happens and you have enough gas to land the plane.
- 16:46So the one that reaches your members theoretically if you were
- 16:51going to appeal, it goes from the examiner to the regional office to
- 16:54the supervisory review committee.
- 16:56You can take it to the Office of Examination and Insurance
- 16:59in there, in along that path.
- 17:01I don't recommend that.
- 17:02And then ultimately to the NCUA board.
- 17:03Now, I'd be shocked if somebody appealed today and it worked through
- 17:07all the timelines before Cruz came on.
- 17:10That would be real dysfunction at the White House, and I don't
- 17:12think that's gonna happen.
- 17:13My guess is Cruz will be on before the end of the month,
- 17:16maybe before the end of the week.
- 17:18But without without a board, appeals can't be decided upon by the board, right?
- 17:24Th- there's the separate cloud of Otsuka and Harper who have continued to sue.
- 17:29And theoretically, they could come back on.
- 17:31I think everybody thinks that the way that the Supreme Court and the
- 17:34courts are working right now, that they're gonna be told, "No, you were
- 17:38fired and Trump had the authority."
- 17:40But theoretically, they could come back and join crews at some point in time.
- 17:44And if that happened, I'm sure they'd be there the next day, assuming
- 17:47they weren't out of the country.
- 17:49M- but they'd get there immediately, and they would you'd end up having
- 17:52the wisdom of crowds of three board members that the Federal Credit Union
- 17:55Act had suggested would be the case.
- 17:58There is y- this final slide I have here, the agency runs fines
- 18:02without a board until it doesn't.
- 18:04And that's like Mike Tyson said, it's great to have a plan.
- 18:06But when you get punched in the face the plan ends.
- 18:10Y- I talk I quote a, a song often, what's the sound of one hand
- 18:14clapping as it relates to, to NCUA having zero board members.
- 18:19And in that regard g- there's another Elton, there's an Elton John song.
- 18:23That first one was Van Morrison.
- 18:25There's an Elton John song called Too Low for Zero.
- 18:27And yes, NCUA is too low for zero, and they have zero.
- 18:31So I'm going to stop sharing my screen here, and I wanted to hit one other item
- 18:36that some people are saying does allow the NCUA board and staff to take action..
- 18:42there is a delegation that I don't have in front of me, but I'll
- 18:45paraphrase from when I was at NCUA.
- 18:48And I've had some conversations with some people that think that this delegation is
- 18:52in play now with zero board members, and I would argue unless they made a change
- 18:57recently to this delegation, and then that change would've been made by one board
- 19:01member, so it probably could be contested.
- 19:05There's a delegation that was put in place presuming that there was a
- 19:09national emergency that y- like 9/11 and a, a plane went down, and however
- 19:15many board members were on the board were no longer available, whether they
- 19:21died in a plane crash and there w- or there was only one and that person
- 19:25died in a plane crash which speaks to it being a national emergency.
- 19:30In a national emergency, whoever is highest up the chain can
- 19:35exercise everything the board normally keeps to itself, right?
- 19:39The chain runs from the chairman to the vice chairman, then whichever
- 19:45single member would remain.
- 19:46If there are things that the acts, for example, the act says the
- 19:50chairman is the spokesperson of NCUA.
- 19:52If the chairman died in a plane crash, then the vice chair would take over those.
- 19:56If the chairman and vice chair were driving in a car together and they
- 20:00were in comas on their death bed then the third board member would
- 20:04take over what the board could do and what the chair could do.
- 20:08You couldâ¦
- 20:08Y- then you get into that whole debate of what's a, w- what they could do as
- 20:12far as a regulation which would require a vote of two and a quorum and all that.
- 20:15But if none of those people are there, it falls to the executive
- 20:18director, who can push that authority further down as needed to keep the
- 20:23agency running on a day-to-day basis.
- 20:26But this is not a national emergency.
- 20:30This is a paperwork issue.
- 20:32This is Hauptman shouldn't have resigned until the paperwork was done.
- 20:37This is the White House just has to sign paperwork.
- 20:40This is not a national em- emergency.
- 20:43So the things that this delegation contemplates is not something that,
- 20:48that Larry Fazio, the executive director, can do, in my opinion,
- 20:51because there is no national emergency.
- 20:55It's just a stupid decision to let somebody or somebody resigning not
- 21:01understanding how the flow went somebody resigning because they were ticked
- 21:05off that they had to stay there a year and they wanted to get their paycheck
- 21:07higher, somebody resigning because they had a real-life situation and felt
- 21:12like they needed to move over there.
- 21:15I don't know.
- 21:15It just, it's just, commit no minor blunders is one of my favorite quotes.
- 21:20This minor blunder of leaving too soon could have material impacts on NCUA.
- 21:25It might not, 'cause again, by the time I cl- click end recording and upload
- 21:29this maybe Cruz will be on board.
- 21:31All right, that's enough on this.
- 21:33I also have a podcast coming out on those 11 final regulations.
- 21:37I've got one slotted for an analysis of the recent recent merger data
- 21:41that NCUA has, and I've got some really cool guests coming up as well.
- 21:45I hope your summer is going as well as mine, and I- if you're listening,
- 21:49I wanna thank you for listening.
- 21:50If you're watching, I wanna thank you for watching.
- 21:53I hope you will do again soon.
- 21:55This is Mark Trakel signing off this Emergency Podcast with Flying Colors.