Latest / Film And Whiskey / Prisoners (2013) / Almost Old Bones Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:01In 2013, director Denis Venez and star Hugh Jackman gave the
- 0:08world a quietly violent thriller that keeps you captive till the
- 0:13final moment. In 2025, we could not have
- 0:17picked a better thematic bourbon to pair this thing up with Brad.
- 0:20Better. More more apt.
- 0:22I think worse might have been. More apt, we'll say that.
- 0:26Oh man, the film is prisoners. The whiskey is almost Old Bones
- 0:31bourbon. That's bad, bro.
- 0:36Oh, we're going to review both of those things today here on
- 0:41the. Film and whiskey.
- 0:42Podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 1:03podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:06glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:09I'm Brad G. And this week we are looking at
- 1:11the 2013 Denis Villeneuve film Prisoners.
- 1:17Dude, I've been waiting a long time to watch this one with you
- 1:22and I fear that I like, I don't think I ever tried to hype it up
- 1:26as like this is the best movie you'll ever see.
- 1:29But I fear that just like kicking it the can down the
- 1:32road, so long really did not set you up for what an absolute
- 1:37downer of a movie this is going to be for you.
- 1:42I think if anything, I have worked out my, as you said, last
- 1:47episode, I've worked out my cinematic critique muscles
- 1:52enough that I think I have enough heft to actually like,
- 1:55say, why I don't like this movie.
- 1:59OK. All right.
- 2:01Because The thing is, this is a. This is like a solid 9 out of
- 2:0510. Really well made a Mystic River
- 2:10esque type film right? Sure.
- 2:14I don't like the decisions that Denny makes.
- 2:23Now are you talking? Like the like the moral, like
- 2:26emotional decisions that he makes.
- 2:29Throughout this film. So here's the thing, you're
- 2:33supposed to bury the lead a little bit, man.
- 2:35Like, we are 1 1/2 minutes into this episode and half our
- 2:40audience knows exactly where we're going already, and the
- 2:42other half is just along for the ride and they're waiting for the
- 2:44whiskey segment. So hang with us.
- 2:48But I want to drill down immediately on like, what you're
- 2:51talking about here. So you say you don't like this
- 2:54movie. And it sounds like what you're
- 2:56saying is like, I feel gross having watched this movie, and I
- 3:01don't like where it goes. And you also said I don't like
- 3:04the decisions that Denny makes. So is it, is it like where the
- 3:08story goes 'cause that's a writing thing, or is it like
- 3:11visually decisions that the director is making that irk you?
- 3:17Oh, it's absolutely Denny's decisions.
- 3:21And sure, like the script maybe calls for it, but specifically,
- 3:28this is a movie about how everyone is a prisoner to their
- 3:33own story, right? Do we want to do?
- 3:37Brad explains real quick. So get it out of the way this
- 3:40is. The weirdest episode we've ever
- 3:42done there is. This feels so chaotic, dude.
- 3:44Sure, let's do, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 3:48movie plots with only 60 seconds ticking on the clock, so let's
- 3:51go ahead and do your take with this little segment that we
- 3:55call, Brad explains. Brad explains is the part.
- 3:58You know what? No, we're not going to do Brad's
- 3:59blades. This feels so chaotic.
- 4:02Yeah, we'll do Brad explains in like, 30 seconds.
- 4:04Let me say this. It's still so early in the
- 4:06episode that I haven't said welcome into film and whiskey,
- 4:09folks. If this is your first episode,
- 4:11this is a wild one. So far.
- 4:13What we do on this podcast is we talk about movies and whiskey.
- 4:17And this season, we're looking at films from the past 20 years.
- 4:20And we're asking the question, does this movie deserve to be
- 4:23considered a modern masterpiece? Now, Brad, this is at least the,
- 4:29I don't know, 3rd or 4th Denis Villeneuve film we've done on
- 4:32the show. We've done Sicario, we've done
- 4:36Arrival, We've done Dune Part 2. So this must be 4.
- 4:39I don't think we've done any others, but we've done, yeah.
- 4:42I think that's. We've done enough that we know
- 4:44our boy Denis likes himself A very dark tale and this is his
- 4:50first big American film, so I think it's worth us talking
- 4:54about, it's worth us exploring and it's worth getting into,
- 4:57Brad explains. Brad explains.
- 5:00Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 5:02plot of the film that he has just seen, often for the first
- 5:06time. Brad, this was absolutely your
- 5:08first time with the movie. Prisoners, a film that I totally
- 5:13forgot, has a runtime of two hours and 33 minutes.
- 5:16It's a long movie. Oh, it's so long, dude.
- 5:20It's very long. It is.
- 5:21It is only like 15 minutes shorter than Dune Part 2.
- 5:25That's how long this movie is. Yeah, and I I would say that
- 5:29Dune 2 feels longer though. This movie moves fast, man.
- 5:35There's a lot going on in this movie.
- 5:36It it's a very simple premise, but it gets very twisty.
- 5:40It's very plot heavy. So Brad, I'm going to go ahead
- 5:43and let you explain the movie folks.
- 5:45If you have not seen Prisoners, man, do we do we want to say go
- 5:50watch it and then come back. It's a very heavy movie.
- 5:53I think that like if you've seen films like Brad said, Mystic
- 5:57River or you know, Zodiac, I think would be a good comparison
- 6:02or seven like Fincher's. I think Fincher's 7 is a pretty
- 6:05good comparison point to like the kind of heaviness and
- 6:09griminess and grossness that you're going to get here.
- 6:12And if that's your bag, go watch Prisoners Come back and join us
- 6:16for the rest of the episode. Brad, you get 60 seconds to
- 6:19spoil this movie and go. Prisoners is a film that follows
- 6:24Keller Dover, played by Hugh Jackman, as he tries to solve
- 6:28the mystery of his and his friend's abducted daughters.
- 6:35Jake Gyllenhaal plays a detective who is on the case as
- 6:39they follow a promising lead of a creepy RV with a creepy Paul
- 6:45Dano and which kind of leads somewhere, kind of leads
- 6:49nowhere. Eventually they find out that
- 6:52it's Paul Dano's creepy aunt who has been doing it for decades
- 6:56now with her husband, and they're evil and bad and they
- 7:00want to turn people into monsters.
- 7:02And in the middle of all that, Hugh Jackman tortures Paul Dano
- 7:09and it's it's pleasant and just the easy breezy lemon squeezy
- 7:14kind of a movie it. Certainly is, man, just a
- 7:18delight this movie, I tell you. All right, So I'm going to kind
- 7:22of walk through the movie in terms of like things I thought
- 7:26in sequential order and the very first thing I thought when the
- 7:30go ahead. You didn't let me finish.
- 7:32I I said we need to get in, Brad explains.
- 7:35So I don't spoil anything because I got thoughts, Bob.
- 7:38Oh, OK, so my thoughts are getting put on the back burner.
- 7:41Go ahead, give your thoughts. Yes, you already spoiled.
- 7:44You're supposed to bury the lead, man.
- 7:46Wait for things to come up, dude.
- 7:49All right, give give your. Thoughts.
- 7:52Denny knows where this movie is going.
- 7:56He knows that the entire purpose of the film is to portray how we
- 8:01are all prisoners of our own story.
- 8:03And yet at every single turn that there could have been any
- 8:08emotional catharsis, he fades to black every single time.
- 8:15You can have any sense of like, OK, like the like this all bad
- 8:21stuff has happened. And yet, and yet, oh wait, we
- 8:25just faded to black. There's no catharsis.
- 8:27And I think that's my problem with this movie.
- 8:32It's that if you're going to make a movie about one of the
- 8:37most horrifying thing that can happen on this earth, you can't
- 8:43take away the emotional catharsis of seeing things be
- 8:46OK. And like that is a capital C
- 8:51choice from Denny. And I think I just, I'm just in
- 8:58utter disagreement that that is a OK way to make a movie.
- 9:04It's like it would be better if the movie ended with the
- 9:09children dying and allowing you to sit with a grieving family.
- 9:15Yikes. You heard it here first, folks.
- 9:17Brad G Huge proponent of the bleakest possible ending to this
- 9:21film. I am a huge proponent of movies
- 9:25being an emotional medium that allow us to, it brings things
- 9:32out of us that we might not normally be able to do in real
- 9:36life. And a movie that refuses to
- 9:40allow you to have catharsis. I, I think it's AI, don't,
- 9:48what's the word I want to use? I don't want to say like, I
- 9:53think there's malintention. Interesting.
- 9:55Of some sort that that you would refuse to allow the audience to
- 10:00experience catharsis all. Right.
- 10:01Let me let me response, please. Yeah.
- 10:04So this is an interesting episode for us because I don't
- 10:07know that you've ever jumped on a call to discuss a movie as
- 10:12soon after the movie is finished as we just did today.
- 10:15Like you literally just finished this movie and I can tell that
- 10:19like you're still grappling with it.
- 10:21And that's really cool because usually we give ourselves like a
- 10:23day to kind of collect our thoughts and and put some
- 10:26structure around things. This is a very visceral response
- 10:29from you, which is great. I think it's going to make for
- 10:32an interesting episode. I'm with you, man.
- 10:35I think that the the utter bleakness of this movie is
- 10:39intentional. Danny is purposely not allowing
- 10:42any emotional catharsis to happen, and it's underscoring
- 10:45his point that the world is kind of a cruel and punishing place,
- 10:50and it's a place that we make cruel and punishing through our
- 10:54own machinations. However, I also think that part
- 10:58of the reason it doesn't totally work and this is crazy.
- 11:01Have you ever seen the movie 7 Brad?
- 11:04I have not. OK, and that's another one I've
- 11:06been kicking the can down the road on.
- 11:08It is. It is perhaps the bleakest crime
- 11:12movie ever. And the the general premise of
- 11:15the movie, I don't know if you're familiar, but there's a
- 11:17serial killer who is murdering people in the pattern of the
- 11:21seven deadly sins. So basically punishing people
- 11:23for their sins. And the ending of that movie is
- 11:26just horrifically bleak. But.
- 11:28What's in the box? Yes, yes.
- 11:30So it it goes all the way with its premise and I feel like this
- 11:36one kind of pulls its punch a little bit at the end.
- 11:39So I'm with you. Like, I didn't, obviously I
- 11:41don't want to see the kidnapped children meet their demise in
- 11:44this film. However, there's something about
- 11:48the like, oh, things kind of ended well.
- 11:51And maybe things will kind of end well for Hugh Jackman's
- 11:54character, who, spoiler alert, is literally still a prisoner
- 11:59and hoping to be rescued at the end of this film.
- 12:02And, and those weird moments of not even hope, but like, I don't
- 12:08know, respite from what's been going on just don't really fit
- 12:14with the way the film has been made for 2 1/2 hours.
- 12:18And so I'm with you that like, there are certain points where
- 12:22you, you wish for a little bit of relief and the movie is
- 12:25unrelenting. And then as it hurdles towards
- 12:28its climax, it tries to give moments of relief when it needs
- 12:31to just fully commit. Does that make sense?
- 12:34100% the only relief that you get are the small moments of
- 12:41humanity that that Hugh Jackman chose.
- 12:45Like, dude, when he is about to turn on the the hot or cold
- 12:50water tap on Paul Dano again and instead the tears roll down his
- 12:56face, like that is the extent of the respite you get for this
- 13:02movie. Yeah, it's freaking brutal, man.
- 13:07So I I want to dive into performances, but before we do
- 13:11that, let let me go back to what I was going to say right after
- 13:14Brad explains. The very first thought I had
- 13:17about this movie is as the credits are coming up that just
- 13:20say like the title of the movie and it's in this like really
- 13:23cheap looking like Times New Roman font that you could just
- 13:27tell like somebody did a drop down on Microsoft Word.
- 13:31I was like, who else does cheap fonts like that?
- 13:33What does this remind me of? And I was like, oh, it reminds
- 13:36me of the beginning of like every Clint Eastwood movie, like
- 13:39the fade in on the town. And throughout the 1st 10 or so
- 13:43minutes of the movie, I was like, oh, this really is like an
- 13:46Eastwood movie. This is like it reminded me of
- 13:48Mystic Ripper. It reminded me of he did a great
- 13:51movie called Changeling about 15 years ago.
- 13:54And I was prepared for the Eastwood Moral Quandary movie.
- 14:01And I feel like this might have actually been a better movie if
- 14:05it was more of an Eastwood movie and less of a plot driven twisty
- 14:12serial killer movie. Because it kind of hints at I, I
- 14:16mean, obviously it portrays like Hugh Jackman is a very broken
- 14:21man who is willing to go to some horrific places and really not
- 14:26like he kind of feels conflicted at parts, doesn't make many
- 14:29apologies for it. And then you watch like Terrence
- 14:31Howard and Viola Davis and like the places they're willing to
- 14:34go, and it's. Bro, when Viola Davis stops
- 14:38Terrence Howard, Yeah, from letting him out.
- 14:41Yeah, and I I like that they explicitly show that people will
- 14:48allow their own morals to get bent or broken when they're
- 14:51pushed far enough or they feel like they need to.
- 14:54It's an interesting psychological experiment.
- 14:57I just think Eastwood is way better at plumbing the depths of
- 15:00those things than what Ville Nouve does in this movie.
- 15:03Because ultimately those things take a back seat to like, but
- 15:07who's the real killer? Do we pull the rug out from
- 15:10under you now and do this twisty thing?
- 15:12Like, how are we going to find these kids?
- 15:14And, and I, I feel bad saying this, but like the heart of the
- 15:18movie really isn't even in the like, will the kids get found as
- 15:22a, as an audience member, right? Because halfway through the
- 15:25movie, they've like given up on ever finding these kids.
- 15:28It's in like, what is this going to do to these people's souls?
- 15:32And I feel like about 2/3 of the way through the movie, they just
- 15:35stop exploring that and they have to like, Yep, wrap it up
- 15:38with a bunch of plot stuff. Totally agreed.
- 15:41I, I think structurally one of my issues with this movie,
- 15:46putting all the morals of it aside, I do think that at the
- 15:49end of the day, the creepy Ant who's very obviously the
- 15:55kidnapper like that, that was the big thing for me.
- 15:59If you're going to make this movie feel like a whodunit
- 16:04mystery thriller, then like do a better job of hiding the real
- 16:09suspect. As I don't know about you the
- 16:11first time you saw it, it felt very obvious to me that Paul
- 16:15Danos creepy Ant was the one who did it.
- 16:22The the last third of the movie just kind of felt like, well, I
- 16:27guess we got to wrap it up now we're we're almost 2 1/2 hours
- 16:30in. So wrap it up.
- 16:33And it wraps up so neatly, like every character that you've been
- 16:36like, who's this random guy you know, she confesses to like, oh,
- 16:40he kidnapped that kid, too. He's just a really messed up
- 16:42kid. Now that we let him go
- 16:43eventually, it's like, wait a minute, like you guys still live
- 16:46in the same city or like, what's what's going on here?
- 16:49And I think that like comparing it to Zodiac from earlier in the
- 16:53season, a movie that you weren't crazy about.
- 16:56And it's it's funny because I think Gyllenhaal got on a real
- 16:59tear with these dark like between Zodiac this and
- 17:02nocturnal animals. Like my guy was in a state for a
- 17:06while there. But at least in Zodiac, they
- 17:10kind of just let the loose ends be loose ends.
- 17:13And it's acknowledged that like, that's part of a police
- 17:16investigation. You're going to get introduced
- 17:18to some real weird dudes and think that they must have done
- 17:21it. And then they just didn't.
- 17:23And I kind of appreciate that more than what they do in this
- 17:26movie, which is like everybody you've met in this movie is
- 17:29going to tie back into this in this one monologue that our Bond
- 17:33villain lady is going to give at the end of the film.
- 17:35It just it didn't quite click for me.
- 17:38It works too neatly. Yeah.
- 17:41Yeah. I, well, especially in a movie
- 17:43that's all about like chaos and messiness, like to wrap up that
- 17:47neatly just feels false. I think the most fascinating
- 17:50like plot, mystery, intrigue that happens is the fact that
- 17:55the wife doesn't know that her husband, who committed all these
- 17:59crimes with her, had himself locked in a priest's basement so
- 18:04he would die and not not kidnap children anymore.
- 18:08Is that what the priest says or I, is it I my read on that scene
- 18:12when Gyllenhaal's like forcing him down the cellar and he says
- 18:16like, he came back to me. I, I convinced him to come back
- 18:19here again. I just thought the priest just
- 18:21locked him in there until he died.
- 18:23I didn't realize that he let himself do it.
- 18:27Yeah, the. Priest.
- 18:28Said he forced me to put him down there because he didn't
- 18:35want to commit these crimes anymore.
- 18:38Oh, interesting. And like that, that to me, it
- 18:42was the thing I walked away from going like, that's an
- 18:45interesting, like, well written, sucks me in kind of plot point
- 18:50of like this dude who has done abject evil with his wife and,
- 18:56like, finally hits a true breaking point where he feels
- 19:00like his only penance is to starve himself to death in a
- 19:05priest basement. Yeah, like I that that to me,
- 19:09was the most fascinating plot point of the whole movie.
- 19:11Well, and I it sounds like we're complaining a lot about this
- 19:14movie. I think this is a a good movie.
- 19:16Like not even a pretty good movie.
- 19:18I think it's a good movie. It just kind of misses
- 19:20greatness. And I think that it mostly
- 19:22misses greatness in the script. The script wraps up too tidally
- 19:25and the the reveal at the end that Melissa Leo's character is
- 19:31the villain, she really does give like a Bond level
- 19:35monologue. And then, you know, walks him
- 19:36out to the car, puts the gun to his head and says, like, this is
- 19:41our war against God. And A, A, like, yes, we gathered
- 19:46that from what you said prior in the film.
- 19:48Like, I get it. I know what you're doing here.
- 19:51B, Like, human beings will never communicate like that.
- 19:54Like no one will ever say, I need you to understand that my
- 19:58evil plot is a metaphor and this is the metaphor.
- 20:02It's like it just doesn't work that way, you know?
- 20:04I don't know man, what about the the Manson murders?
- 20:07What did what did he say? I'm the devil and I'm here to do
- 20:10devil shit that might not be verbatim.
- 20:17All right, let's talk about these performances.
- 20:19This is a kind of unnecessarily stacked cast.
- 20:22Like, yeah, obviously you think about Jackman and Gyllenhaal,
- 20:26but Maria Bello, Jackman's wife, is a like moderately famous
- 20:30actress in the mid 2000s to 20 teens.
- 20:33And then you've got like Terrence Howard, who is
- 20:36struggling post Iron Man and getting cut from Marvel.
- 20:39And so they they get him here. Viola Davis is on the come up
- 20:43after the Help. And it's like, this is not the
- 20:45kind of performance you would get Viola Davis in after 2013,
- 20:50but she just happens to be here. So.
- 20:53So I think let's talk a little bit about the two main
- 20:56performances then maybe. We could even mention Paul,
- 20:59Paul, Dano, Paul. Dano and then the other creepy
- 21:02guy, David Dasmalchian, who is just made a name for himself
- 21:06playing creepy guys, apparently like a lovely person and a good
- 21:11actor. Really.
- 21:12But yeah, I, I feel like, I feel like it's him and Paul Dano that
- 21:18any casting director gets a note.
- 21:20Like OK, we need a super creepy dude.
- 21:24Like kind of androgynous. Somewhere between 25 and 45.
- 21:29Yeah, and they're like. Do you got Paul Dano and David
- 21:32Dasmalchian? Do you?
- 21:33Do you want him? To have a super Bony face or
- 21:36like a very round cherubic face, pudgy face, that's it.
- 21:39Those are the 2 differentiators. Let's start with the two people
- 21:45at the top, Brad, and then I think we could probably go to
- 21:47break. Jackman, I think, is the better
- 21:50one for conversation because this is one of his bigger
- 21:55dramatic roles, you know, kind of in the midst of his 11
- 22:00Wolverine appearances or however many it's been.
- 22:03And I think it's a really good performance.
- 22:06I also think that sometimes when these guys that are coming from
- 22:10superhero movies get a chance to go do something else and reset,
- 22:15you can almost see them trying to relearn how to not be a
- 22:20superhero, like on screen. And I think Jackman has moments
- 22:25where it's like not just really good, but believable, like where
- 22:29when the emotion takes over. And then there are other times
- 22:32where it's like, oh, he he's just really going for it.
- 22:35You know, the first scene where Terrence Howard is helping hold
- 22:40him up against the wall and he's got the hammer and he's like
- 22:42destroying the sink. And that was like, a big Hugh
- 22:46Jackman did this unexpectedly, and everybody was terrified.
- 22:49And I'm watching that. Like, if I'm another actor in
- 22:52this scene, I'm like, silently pleading with him with my eyes
- 22:56to, like, dial it back a little. It just there are moments where
- 22:59he goes so over the top that it almost takes me out of the
- 23:02movie. I I think I kind of disagree.
- 23:06On that Oh. Interesting.
- 23:07I if I, I don't know man, if my 678 year old daughter was taken
- 23:15like I, I don't know if I wouldn't do very similar things,
- 23:22I wouldn't do very similar things because I'm a good
- 23:24person. Sure you are.
- 23:25Sure you are. That's what this movie posits
- 23:28Brad, are you? Let the let the record show that
- 23:31Brad, she would not do those things.
- 23:33It didn't seem over the top to me OK if someone would want to
- 23:36do those. I'm not saying necessarily that
- 23:38like his actions seem over, I mean that his actions are
- 23:41obviously over the top. But like, I think even the way
- 23:44that he portrays an unhinged man felt more like a guy trying
- 23:50really hard to play an unhinged man than a than a believably
- 23:53unhinged man, if that makes sense.
- 23:56Yeah, I, I think. It's the quiet moments for him
- 23:58that that I already mentioned that make the the wild moments
- 24:02believable. I agree.
- 24:03Like be because he's not one-dimensional, he's not just
- 24:08like a singular thread. There's an entire tapestry to
- 24:12his character. Like I believe the anger and
- 24:15rage and violence because I believe the tears, the prayers,
- 24:21the inability to say as I forgive those who have forgiven
- 24:25it. Like it's those moments that
- 24:29make me believe this is a well-rounded, fleshed out
- 24:32character and I don't mind the ridiculousness as much.
- 24:37All right, let's talk about Gyllenhaal then, because I I
- 24:39said all that about Jackman specifically because I think
- 24:42Gyllenhaal just kind of runs laps around him in this movie.
- 24:45Like Jackman may not be A1 dimensional character, but I
- 24:49think the way he chooses to play that character limits his range
- 24:54a little bit. And I think ultimately, even
- 24:58though Gyllenhaal is not top billed in this movie, this is
- 25:00kind of Gyllenhaal's movie. I think he really runs away with
- 25:03it in a way that like, you know, you had commented on his Zodiac
- 25:07performance as I don't quite know what he's going for here in
- 25:10this character. And it didn't click for me.
- 25:12I think Gyllenhaal is just like in complete command of this
- 25:15movie dude. Well the reason I like him
- 25:18better in this movie is that they give you just enough
- 25:22fleshed out of who he is. Like just a few tiny comments of
- 25:28like, I grew up in a group home. He's wearing a Freemasons ring
- 25:32throughout the entire movie like that.
- 25:34Like there's just enough hints of like if he didn't become a
- 25:40police officer, he might have ended up as a serial killer like
- 25:46that. I like his character here.
- 25:48And he has the tics, the, you know, the facial tics and he
- 25:54explodes just often enough that you're like, oh, this is a real
- 25:58human being really struggling with understanding his own
- 26:03emotions, understanding what's happening in this case.
- 26:07He he just, he just nails everything about this role.
- 26:11I I think this is my favorite Gyllenhaal performance.
- 26:14It's really good, man, and I think that he's got to be the
- 26:17MVP of the movie for me. I can't think of somebody else
- 26:20that would be. Totally, Yeah.
- 26:22I mean, nobody else has enough meat to to chew on.
- 26:25Like, Viola Davis is really good, but she's just kind of a a
- 26:28background character. Terrence Howard is basically
- 26:32like, hey, can you be kind of a Sissy and not stand up to Hugh
- 26:37Jackman as he's wild and he nails it.
- 26:40He does a great job at that. But you know, there's nothing
- 26:45too wild to write home about, really.
- 26:47It's Jack and Hall that that. Have everything to work with.
- 26:52I I did find myself throughout the movie wondering, like, I
- 26:55wonder if there's going to be a read on this film that like Brad
- 26:58and I interpret the Jackman character just completely
- 27:01differently. I mean, because I think you
- 27:04would agree, like the movie does not want you to root for Hugh
- 27:06Jackman or or even approve of his methods, right?
- 27:11I think everyone has a spectrum of like, hey, I understand what
- 27:16would cause somebody to do this. But even within that, like I
- 27:22really liked the Terrence Howard character.
- 27:24I didn't find him to be a Sissy. Like I I felt like he was the
- 27:27only one that was like, you guys, like, we can't do this is
- 27:31not right. We can't go forward with this.
- 27:34And then finding himself not necessarily just getting peer
- 27:38pressured, but also like, yeah, I guess there is a little part
- 27:42of me that kind of wants these answers.
- 27:44And he's the most conflicted person in the whole movie.
- 27:48And I found that he played that super well.
- 27:50Like, is there a lot of tears? Absolutely.
- 27:53I don't necessarily know that I would say that makes him like a
- 27:55Sissy. I just think that he's he's
- 27:58probably got the strongest moral backbone of anybody in the
- 28:01movie. And to watch him even have that
- 28:04moral backbone get bent was one of the more compelling
- 28:08characters for me. No, he he hands the reins over
- 28:12at multiple points in the movie. He has morals, tries to stand up
- 28:18for them. And then people who people just
- 28:23bulldoze over him, right? Like, like Hugh Jackman bulldoze
- 28:26over him with a hammer and, you know, iron conviction and his
- 28:32wife bulldozes him over with a soft word.
- 28:36So I like, in my mind, he is portrayed even when the thing
- 28:43that cemented it in my brain is when Viola Davis and he show up
- 28:49at Hugh Jackman's house. It's the way Hugh Jackman looks
- 28:54at him, like, you betrayed me, bro.
- 28:55Like, like we were in this together.
- 28:57And the way he looks at Hugh Jackman is just kind of like a
- 29:00beaten yuppie, Like, oh, well, my, my wife had to know and you
- 29:05had to know. And I'm caught between my my
- 29:07boyfriend and my girlfriend. I mean it.
- 29:09And I can't. Yeah.
- 29:10It is. I just wonder, maybe I'm just
- 29:11the most like him in terms of how I think I would react in a
- 29:15situation like this, because like, watching.
- 29:18Them I'm Hugh Jackman. You're clearly Hugh Jackman.
- 29:21I don't trust you at all, bro. But like, I think that watching
- 29:26the psychological manipulation of him was really interesting,
- 29:29like the way Viola talks to him, like implying that if we let off
- 29:33of this guy, you will be responsible if something bad
- 29:37happens to our daughter. And that like, accusation
- 29:41sitting with him and ultimately causing him to be kind of
- 29:44cowardly in that way, it's at least understandable to me.
- 29:47I like, I didn't look at him and be like, you freaking coward.
- 29:50I was like, yeah, dude, I get it, man.
- 29:52Like if somebody came at me and said like, we can stop, but it's
- 29:57all your fault if something goes wrong, That's that's hard to
- 30:00live with, dude. Yeah, 100%.
- 30:03And the fact that Viola Davis trusts Keller more to, like,
- 30:09save their daughter than Terence, like that is the most
- 30:12emasculating thing I think I've ever seen on film.
- 30:16Well, it's like, hey, hey buddy, you need to step aside and let
- 30:20our big jacked white friend take over.
- 30:25And Brad, if I can awkwardly segue us into our whiskey for
- 30:29the day, what she's ultimately saying is you need to prevent
- 30:32these beloved members of our family from becoming almost Old
- 30:36bones. Brad, it is time to get into our
- 30:39bourbon. What do you say, man?
- 30:42Let's do it. All right, today we are checking
- 30:50out Almost Old Bones Bourbon. This is a nine year whiskey,
- 30:55it's called Almost Old Bones 9 year reserve.
- 30:58This is batch #1 which is interesting to me, Brad, because
- 31:02I've literally never heard of this brand before.
- 31:05This was included in a bunch of samples we received from our
- 31:08buddy Zach Johnston. I thought it sounded cool and
- 31:11it's, you know, when I saw the name almost Old Bones, I
- 31:13figured, oh, this is going to be like a two year whiskey.
- 31:16This is a cool way of them saying this is not quite old
- 31:19enough. No, it's nine years old.
- 31:20I was a little shocked by the title here.
- 31:24Yeah. So the the whiskey comes from
- 31:29Backbone Bourbon Company, which is located in Indianapolis, IN
- 31:34and they start in 2014. They are sourcing their whiskey.
- 31:39Originally they had a supplier that stopped supplying them
- 31:44because they didn't have enough representation or something.
- 31:49And so they were like, oh, we wish our supplier had a little
- 31:51more backbone and like helped us out.
- 31:55And that's that's where they got the name.
- 31:57Yeah. You see what they did there?
- 31:59They have a flagship product Backbone Uncut and they have an
- 32:03old product called Old Bones, which is A10 plus year bourbon.
- 32:09And this specific bottle comes from some barrels that they were
- 32:13like this is 9 year product and it's way too good to let it go
- 32:18any further. But it's not our old bones at 10
- 32:21plus years and it's not our regular stuff at like 5 or 6
- 32:24years. So they decided to make a new
- 32:26skew. They called it almost Old Bones.
- 32:29It comes in with a mash bill of 75 corn, 15 rye, 10 malted
- 32:34barley. It looks like it was distilled
- 32:37in Bardstown, KY. So yeah, I wonder, wonder where
- 32:41that happened? And it's 110 proof.
- 32:44Yeah, and at the time that it was released to, the retail
- 32:46price on this was $89.00. I'm not sure if that's gone up
- 32:50or down. This is a little over a year old
- 32:52as a skew. So I'm excited to dive in.
- 32:54Man, it's been a while since we've had a good well aged
- 32:57bourbon. You've drank it already?
- 32:59I'm drinking it live. So why don't you give us your
- 33:01nosing notes? Dude, this is just a really
- 33:06beautiful honey caramel apple peel, brown sugar like it's got
- 33:13all sorts of really deep, rich bourbon notes going on with the
- 33:19the honey is what stud out to me of like a little bit of a
- 33:23lightness to the flavor that accentuates all of the really
- 33:28rich notes. I get really beautiful on the
- 33:31nose Bob. I give it an 8 out of 10.
- 33:33Yeah, I think I'm going to give it a nine out of 10.
- 33:35It's been a minute since I've had a nose that reminds me of
- 33:37some of those great classic foolproof or higher proof
- 33:41bourbons from the big boys. This reminds me a little bit of
- 33:44like a wild Turkey rare breed on the nose even more so.
- 33:48It reminds me of 1792 foolproof. So I'm wondering if Barton might
- 33:51have actually distilled this for them.
- 33:54It's really spicy on the nose and I think that the 15% rye is
- 33:59really coming through here. But there's there's a layer of
- 34:02almost like a saline kind of thing too.
- 34:03It smells a little bit like, I don't not quite salted caramel,
- 34:08but more like a salted Maple. I really, really like this man
- 34:12and it is closer to a classic bourbon than anything we've had
- 34:16in a while. I'm at a nine out of 10.
- 34:19Yeah, and the palate just continues to improve upon the
- 34:22nose, Bob. It gets a little bit oaky, but
- 34:26in a really beautiful enhancing type of way.
- 34:30There is tons of brown sugar. There's apple the the creaminess
- 34:35and vanilla. Like I, I feel like I just had a
- 34:39big scoop of like homemade vanilla ice cream at the at the
- 34:42County Fair like that. There are all sorts of really
- 34:47rich flavors it it almost gets spicy enough that it feels like
- 34:52a fall apple cider, like there's a little bit of cinnamon there.
- 34:58I like this a lot. I'm going to give it an 8 1/2
- 35:02out of 10. I don't find that it has quite
- 35:04enough sweetness to be like a Bob book staple.
- 35:08It really stays on the spicy side and this is like super
- 35:11prickly on the tongue. You probably could have
- 35:13convinced me that this was even higher proof than 110 because it
- 35:17drinks barrel strength. That said, I think that this is
- 35:21right in line with a lot of those whiskeys, Brad, that like
- 35:24when we go to Kentucky Bourbon Festival every year and we line
- 35:27up at that tent of all the single barrels that have been
- 35:30picked, this is this is like barrel strength Bardstown, KY
- 35:35whiskey. I really like this a lot.
- 35:38I do wish it was a little bit more viscous and a little
- 35:40sweeter, but I think that like, even though it's not my
- 35:43preferred wheelhouse, I can't go any lower than an 8 out of 10 on
- 35:47the pallet. The finish has like a little bit
- 35:50of oak char going on, it's got brown sugar, the vanilla sticks
- 35:54around and it definitely gets more spicy on the back end.
- 35:58I I still like it a lot. I think the palette is the real
- 36:01All Star here, but I will give it an 8 out of 10 on the finish.
- 36:05Yeah, I think that it gets, man, I feel like it was maybe last
- 36:09week that I was talking about the kind of minerality this gets
- 36:12a little bit of like that mineral water quality again for
- 36:14me, not quite like irony or metallic, but it kind of tips
- 36:19into that. I don't know, maybe maybe some
- 36:23salt, maybe some like limestone. It's a little bit oaky and it
- 36:28loses all sweetness on the finish.
- 36:31And so the finish is my least favorite part of this.
- 36:33Now again, I don't think that it's like out of character for
- 36:37what I've tasted so far. It's just not my preferred
- 36:40thing. So I'm going to give it a 7.5
- 36:42here and I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10.
- 36:45On the balance, just because it is not my favorite kind of
- 36:49bourbon doesn't mean that the kind of bourbon it is is in any
- 36:53way out of character. Like this is a very cohesive
- 36:56drinking experience. I like this a lot.
- 36:58I'm in an 8 out of 10. I, I'm also at an 8 out of 10 on
- 37:03balance. I, I think that they're, they,
- 37:07they put together a really great grouping of flavors and I'm kind
- 37:12of with them like they, I, if I tasted this out of the barrel, I
- 37:16also would be like, you know, we can't wait any longer.
- 37:19This is delicious as is. I'd be very nervous about it
- 37:23souring becoming a little too oaky if it was left in the
- 37:27barrel any longer. Now I will say MSRP on this is
- 37:31$90.00. Everywhere else that I'm seeing
- 37:34it is like 110 to $130.00. So I, I don't know, Bob, do you
- 37:40want to price this at 110? Do you want to price it at 9:00?
- 37:43So is that like is that just for the batch 1 and because there's
- 37:46like limited supply or is that for newer batches you're seeing
- 37:49that? It looks like they're still on
- 37:53batch one. OK, so I guess if you're in
- 37:55Indiana, you can get it for $90.00.
- 37:57Let's go with that then because it, it may just be a thing of
- 38:00like the price has gone up because there's more of a
- 38:02limited supply now. And so when they come out, if
- 38:04they come out with a batch 2, I'm sure that it will be closer
- 38:07to 90 at $90.00. This is, this is still a little
- 38:10bit steep for me. It kind of reminds me of like
- 38:14some of those Hardens creeks that we've had from the Jim Beam
- 38:16Company. Not the two year one, but the
- 38:18more well aged 1 where it's just like, man, you got to really
- 38:21knock my socks off to charge me $90.00 for a bourbon.
- 38:25Now it's it's nine years old. I get that this is still like a
- 38:29$70 bourbon to me. So I'm going to give it just a 5
- 38:33out of 10 on value. Oh wow, yeah, we're going to be
- 38:38pretty far off on that. I I initially thinking it was
- 38:42110, was thinking it's about 20 to $30.
- 38:45Too expensive. So for me at like I think 80 to
- 38:49$90.00 fits for this product. It's not like an All Star value
- 38:55by by any stretch of the imagination.
- 38:57I don't think it's a 5 out of 10.
- 38:59I'll give it a 7 1/2 out of 10. I think it's a decent value for
- 39:05what you're getting. And I will say, like I overall,
- 39:08I was really impressed with this whiskey, Bob.
- 39:10What are you coming out to you Brad?
- 39:12I'm at a 40 out of 50. I'm at a 37 1/2.
- 39:15So even though I gave it a much lower value score, like this is
- 39:18definitely a recommend for me and it's a pretty solid thumbs
- 39:21up. We're coming out to an average
- 39:23of a 38.75 S kind of just below that 40 mark where we kind of
- 39:28say this is a no brainer. You've achieved the 40 mark.
- 39:32Brad, is this a, is this a qualified recommend or is this
- 39:37like a absolutely pick it up if you see it anywhere?
- 39:41No, I I would say that if you want a good classic bourbon
- 39:45experience that has a richness and depth that you don't find on
- 39:51most you know, 40 to $60.00 bourbons at like this is a good
- 39:56pick up. All right, man.
- 39:59Well, that that was pretty painless.
- 40:01What do you say we get back into talking about prisoners, which
- 40:03is not at all painless? Let's, let's do it, man.
- 40:07I'm ready. All right, everybody, that was
- 40:13almost Old Bones bourbon. It feels like it almost hit the
- 40:18right notes for you, Bob. Almost.
- 40:20It was good like I think what, 37 1/2 not, not a bad score by
- 40:25any stretch of the imagination. It's so funny how you know we
- 40:29were 2 1/2 points apart. I was at a 40 and yet I feel
- 40:33like if you just listen to our audio without any scores, we
- 40:37would be like eight points apart and.
- 40:40And it's also funny sometimes, like, you and I get that
- 40:42impression about each other, and it's like, oh, I feel like
- 40:45you're super negative on this. And then it's like, surprise,
- 40:47motherfucker. 37 1/2, like, right.
- 40:51Yeah. Oh, man.
- 40:54All right, dude, it's time for us to get into two facts and a
- 40:57falsehood. And I have to say, I am
- 41:00incredibly disappointed in our friend Patrick Williams.
- 41:03He's a busy man, so I know he's not listening to this.
- 41:06I am. I am debating whether to ever
- 41:08let him back on after giving me two freaking losses last week on
- 41:12this Brad. The the comeback is happening.
- 41:14Bob, I'm going to get you all. Right, let's get into this
- 41:17segment called 2 Facts and a falsehood.
- 41:19Brad is going to try to stump you.
- 41:22Bob 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 41:292 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad
- 41:32presents me with three items as fact about the making of this
- 41:35movie, one of which is a complete lie.
- 41:38Brad, I haven't tallied up my wins and losses in a couple
- 41:41weeks, but like I said, they are.
- 41:44They have increased by two in the loss column and that
- 41:47freaking sucks. So I'm hoping for some
- 41:50redemption here. We've only got 12345 episodes
- 41:54including today left on the season, so I'm doing kind of a
- 41:58mad dash to make sure I finish with a winning record here.
- 42:00Yeah. I think if I'm counting
- 42:02correctly, you're sitting at 10 losses and I'm guessing probably
- 42:08like 13 to 15 wins something in that area so well.
- 42:11I. Mean it sounds.
- 42:12Like it has been. Yeah, it sounds like 16 wins
- 42:15'cause there was one week where we did not do a 2 facts and a
- 42:19falsehood given the subject matter of the movie spotlight.
- 42:23And honestly, we probably could have done the same thing today,
- 42:26man. But yeah, I you were a trooper.
- 42:29Yeah, I was sitting there like, man, how do I write a falsehood
- 42:35or facts and be like, yeah, don't worry about the two little
- 42:39girls you just watched get kidnapped and the torture you
- 42:41saw Paul Dano experience. Did you know that Denny smokes
- 42:45Lucky Strikes? You should have done it in like
- 42:52an old timey game show announcer voice.
- 42:54Like did you know that? You know the kind of things.
- 42:58Yeah, and now you know the. Rest of the story.
- 43:02All right man, hit me with those two facts and a falsehood.
- 43:05Fact number one director Denis Villeneuve first met Rodger
- 43:09Deakins at the Academy Awards when Denis was up for Best
- 43:13Foreign Language Oscar in 2010. A huge fan of the film, Deakins
- 43:17told Villeneuve that he would love to work with him, and it
- 43:20just so happened that Villeneuve was able to send him the
- 43:22screenplay for Prisoners shortly after.
- 43:26Fact #2 The impossible maze shown throughout the film was
- 43:29actually created by Adrian Fisher, a famous British maze
- 43:34designer. He allowed it to be used in the
- 43:37film only once he knew that the children in the film did not, in
- 43:40fact, die. Fact #3 To play Holly Jones,
- 43:44Melissa Leo wore a Gray wig and a foam rubber posterior prepared
- 43:49by costume designer Renee April in order to ground her
- 43:52character. Leo also requested the props
- 43:54assistance to avoid cleaning her glasses after each day's
- 43:58shooting. All right, so #2 and #3 both
- 44:03stick out to me for for kind of smallish reasons #3 because I
- 44:09feel like you could have inserted A commentary about
- 44:11someone's fake butt. It just seems like it could be a
- 44:15Brad Pitt invent, a Brad Pitt, a Brad G invention.
- 44:18Yeah, I know. Brad Pitt, baby.
- 44:21I think Butts, I think Brad Pitt, you know #2 could
- 44:26potentially be a falsehood, because I find it hard to
- 44:30believe that they wanted this maze so badly for this movie
- 44:34that they'd be willing to spoil the end of the film to some
- 44:37rando just to use his maze when they could have just easily
- 44:41designed a maze that looked unsolvable for the three seconds
- 44:44that it's on screen. And in fact, I think that I've
- 44:47already talked myself into it #3 could very well be the
- 44:50falsehood. I think I'm going to go with
- 44:52two, Brad. That seems like the biggest
- 44:54stretch to me. So I'm going to lock in #2 as my
- 44:57falsehood. Bob, you have nailed it once
- 45:01again. This is your season of
- 45:03victories, my friend. Yeah, not so much dude, given
- 45:06that I am coming off 2 consecutive losses, I guess 3
- 45:09consecutive losses based on last week.
- 45:12So I'm glad to get back in the win column.
- 45:15Nicely done on the falsehood though.
- 45:17That was a pretty good 10. Thank you.
- 45:19Yeah, I I thought it was pretty decent.
- 45:21Brad, let's give the to listeners a peek behind the
- 45:23curtain here a little bit. How long does it typically take
- 45:26you to do your like? Not just to collate the two
- 45:30facts, but to write your falsehood?
- 45:34It's probably like a 20 to 30 minute process.
- 45:38Oh wow. OK.
- 45:39I, I used to, I used to find the two truths and then write the
- 45:44falsehood. I, I can't do that anymore
- 45:47because there's like too much information in my head and it,
- 45:50it makes the creative process difficult.
- 45:53So nowadays I sit down and I just kind of ponder like things
- 45:59about the movie, stuff that I found interesting, stuff that
- 46:02stuck out to me. And I'll like write a few
- 46:05falsehoods and then try to find the one that makes the most
- 46:09sense. That might trick you.
- 46:11I love it man, I I'm glad. And then it's probably like 10
- 46:15minutes or so browsing the IMDb page trying to find innocuous
- 46:20facts about the movie, but facts that are interesting enough that
- 46:23like, once you know they're true, it's like, oh, wow, that
- 46:26is kind of interesting. So it's like a hard, it's a hard
- 46:28balance, man. Well, and you made a good point
- 46:31a little bit ago, Like with a movie like this, it's got to be
- 46:34hard to find facts that don't feel too flippant, that like
- 46:37undermine how heavy of a movie we're talking about.
- 46:40Yep. Or there's like 1 was about
- 46:44Holly Jones. So the the character is Alex
- 46:47Jones is antis Holly Jones. And apparently that's like the
- 46:50name of a child in Toronto who was abducted and killed.
- 46:54I'm like, I don't, I don't know if that's a fact.
- 46:57I like want to throw in my game here.
- 47:00Yeah. And I feel like that also might
- 47:01just be a like, I, I can't imagine that like the
- 47:04screenwriter would be like, Oh yeah, let's throw that in here.
- 47:06That would be a horrific thing to do, right?
- 47:10Let's make the name of our of the most evil character.
- 47:13Right. A child who was abducted.
- 47:16Yeah, that that seems a little on the nose in a very not so
- 47:20good way. All right, man.
- 47:22So we've talked about Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal.
- 47:24We've touched a little bit on Terrence Howard, Viola Davis.
- 47:28We haven't really gone in on. Go ahead.
- 47:31Can I, Can I say one thing? We never see Terrence Howard in
- 47:35movies anymore. No.
- 47:37So anytime I see him, I have to remind our audience that he is
- 47:42into some weird stuff and not in a bad way.
- 47:46He's. Just.
- 47:47Like I mean. Maybe not in a good.
- 47:49Way he's like into weird maths and like Pythagoras theorem and
- 47:55platonic ideals and solids and he is a weird dude and you
- 48:00should just Google Terrence Howard.
- 48:04Platonic solids I think is his whole thing.
- 48:07It's pretty wild. He's gone off the deep end a
- 48:09little bit and he keeps re emerging on on podcast.
- 48:12I want to say he did Rogan a couple years ago and that was
- 48:14like his big I'm back. Listen to me now be a scientist.
- 48:19And I've just seen many, many videos of like real scientists
- 48:22being like, I don't know what the hell this dude's talking
- 48:24about like this. It it's kind of the equivalent
- 48:27of like if all of the girls from your high school that got really
- 48:31into essential oils for three years instead were Terrence
- 48:35Howard getting into like, I read a science book one time.
- 48:39Here's my thoughts on quantum physics, you know.
- 48:42It's it's kind of like Tom Cruise doing Scientology, but
- 48:46instead of like going Zero Dark 30 about Scientology, after a
- 48:50while he just like ramped it up and got more crazy about it.
- 48:54Like that's what it feels like to me.
- 48:56So Bill Simmons has this great thing that he does on some of
- 48:59his podcasts where he talks about how certain actors get
- 49:01market corrected by a new actor that comes after them and kind
- 49:04of takes all their roles. And I feel like Terrence
- 49:07Howard's in this really interesting place from, you
- 49:10know, 2005 to 2012 or whatever it is.
- 49:14He does crash and he does hustle and flow and he's Oscar
- 49:18nominated. And then, you know, he shows up
- 49:20in this movie. He's obviously an Iron Man.
- 49:23And the unfortunate reality of like, being a Black Star in
- 49:26Hollywood is like there's, there's not a lot of great parts
- 49:29for black males or black females.
- 49:31And so they're all competing against each other.
- 49:33And I feel like he got really typecast as the sensitive
- 49:37leading black man in Hollywood. For a while there.
- 49:40He always cried in his movies and he kind of market corrected,
- 49:45like Cuba Gooding Junior had come, you know, a decade prior
- 49:48to him. And by this point, he's hitting
- 49:50about 40. His roles are starting to dry
- 49:52up. Terrence Howard comes and then
- 49:53Terrence Howard kind of makes his own career nosedive.
- 49:58And it's not for a couple more years after this.
- 50:00But I feel like now the person who's kind of in that typecast
- 50:04role in a lot of ways is Sterling K Brown.
- 50:07If you've ever watched This Is Us, like he's he's the guy that
- 50:11you get in your movie when you need an African American man and
- 50:14you need him to cry in a movie. And like I said, it's it's an
- 50:18unfortunate reality that we typecast people like this.
- 50:21But I do miss seeing Terrence Howard.
- 50:24I think that like, regardless of how cuckoo he may or may not be
- 50:27in real life, he's a really good actor man.
- 50:31I I don't know if I've ever. Been able to separate the
- 50:35kookiness from the acting because I like, I never really
- 50:39saw him in anything other than Iron Man growing up.
- 50:43And so for me, it's like, Oh yeah, he was in Iron Man and got
- 50:46replaced by Cuba Gooding Junior. And then I saw videos of him.
- 50:50Trying to explain, replaced by Don Cheadle.
- 50:53Oh, I. Apologize.
- 50:54Yes, replaced by Don Cheadle. So he was a replaceable actor
- 50:59that I eventually saw him trying to explain crazy weird
- 51:04philosophical math and so I've never had a super great
- 51:12impression of him I suppose. That stinks.
- 51:15Yeah, I like him a lot. Come back, Terrence Howard,
- 51:18drop, drop the science stuff and start acting again.
- 51:22Brad, anybody else in the cast that you think we should touch
- 51:24on? Like should we talk a little bit
- 51:25more about Paul Dano or Melissa Leo, or do you think we've kind
- 51:29of hit what we need to hit here in terms of the performances?
- 51:33I I think Paul Dano is really good, especially he his
- 51:37performance is one of those ones where he plays everything so
- 51:42close to the chest that like his role takes on different nuances
- 51:48as the film progresses and as you kind of waver on whether or
- 51:52not he's guilty. And then he like chokes his dog
- 51:55and you're like, Oh yeah, he's totally guilty.
- 51:58And then you find out at the end that he's like semi partially
- 52:03guilty, but mostly not. He's mostly just a traumatized
- 52:06kid himself and let you're like, his performance takes on so many
- 52:11different layers when you know the entire back story that like
- 52:16you're like, yeah, this is a great performance with the tiny
- 52:21amount of screen time that he has.
- 52:22I mean, his eyeballs have a lot of screen time in the film.
- 52:25His whole body doesn't have quite as much.
- 52:28Yeah, man, I think it's a good performance.
- 52:30Part of what pulls me out of Paul Dano's performance is that
- 52:33he's always struck me as a really intelligent actor who's
- 52:36able to play slimy. I think There Will Be Blood is
- 52:39maybe my favorite performance of his.
- 52:41And so watching him play a person with an IQ of a 10 year
- 52:44old, it's a little bit like you're watching a smart person
- 52:48try to figure out in real time how to portray limited mental
- 52:51capability. It's also so similar to his
- 52:55Riddler from The Batman that came out a couple years ago,
- 52:58which I just did not like that movie that that's kind of, I
- 53:02feel like, I feel like Dano's getting a little bit typecast
- 53:05here as well. If I can kind of pivot us for a
- 53:08second, the Paul Dano character. So at the end of the film, it's
- 53:11revealed not only is he not really Alex Jones, he is this
- 53:15kid who had been abducted 25 years prior and never returned
- 53:21because this family just kept him and, like, is now making him
- 53:24an accomplice to all the horrific things they're doing to
- 53:26children. And you only get this at the
- 53:29very end of the movie, but there's like a newspaper
- 53:31headline that's like, hey, Paul Dano got returned to his
- 53:34original family. And it's like, wait a minute.
- 53:37Is that how that would work? Like you, this guy has been
- 53:40party to like numerous child abductions and or murders and is
- 53:45clearly like almost mute from being so traumatized and you you
- 53:51aren't going to institutionalized that guy like
- 53:54he just gets to go home. What?
- 53:56That doesn't seem like it's going to end well.
- 53:59Yeah, his family's going to be totally chill about the whole
- 54:01thing. It's going to be a very easy
- 54:04transition. Nothing to see here.
- 54:06Moving on. Well, that coupled with the fact
- 54:09that Jake Gyllenhaal gets mad during an interrogation that's
- 54:14taking too long, goes in and assaults the guy, who then grabs
- 54:18his gun and commits suicide in front of him.
- 54:21And they're like, damn, Jake, tough day at the office.
- 54:24All right, get back out there and keep knocking on doors.
- 54:26It's like, wait, hold on. You're not suspended.
- 54:29You're not off the case. Yeah, not just knock on doors.
- 54:33Go to the relative of the man who was just kept in captivity
- 54:38for a week and tortured, you know, within an inch of his
- 54:43life. Go let her know what was going
- 54:45on. I trust you.
- 54:46You're the guy to do that. You're clearly in a good
- 54:49headspace right now, so just go do that for us.
- 54:52Exactly. And honestly, that's kind of my
- 54:54thing with this movie where there's a lot about it that's
- 54:58really great and really done well.
- 55:01Like Deacons is a master, he's the best.
- 55:04But there's stuff like this that I'm just kind of like, oh, I
- 55:08don't know if this was. I don't, I don't know if it was
- 55:11well. Thought out I I don't know if
- 55:13there was plans for it. It feels like an early effort
- 55:18from a really great director that he would have cleaned up a
- 55:22lot if he made it 10 years later.
- 55:25I agree, and I think he would have done more work on the
- 55:27script himself. You know, I remember seeing this
- 55:29movie and being like, oh, that was a really good movie.
- 55:32And then the following, I guess it was the following year that
- 55:35Sicario came out and didn't really make a huge splash at the
- 55:39box office. But I remember seeing like this
- 55:42is the guy that did Prisoners and I was like, oh man, I should
- 55:44go watch this movie. I remember seeing it when they
- 55:46still had the dollar theater and I went to the dollar theater and
- 55:49watched Sicario and I was like, oh, this dude took a jump.
- 55:52This is like, this is a big movie, is a huge undertaking and
- 55:57he is in total command of the material here.
- 56:00And I think revisiting Prisoners, Brad, my big take
- 56:04away is that Denny Villeneuve is a master film maker who at this
- 56:09point of his career, the material was dictating what he
- 56:13could do rather than him being in control of the material.
- 56:17Absolutely. I, I think there's a lot to love
- 56:21about prisoners and it really does point to where he's going
- 56:24to go. I'm with you, man.
- 56:26The fact that Sicario came out, you said a year later.
- 56:30Yeah, either one or two years later.
- 56:32Yeah, is mind boggling to me because I really do think it is
- 56:38a pretty vastly superior movie to this.
- 56:42And and that's like I said, it's it's not to put this down.
- 56:45I I, I, I do struggle with like the morality of taking your
- 56:51audience to in a place of emotional destitution and then
- 56:56leaving them there at like, I don't think that that's what
- 56:59people deserve for having spent their money on watching your
- 57:02movie and not from the sense that like we should just feel
- 57:05happy feelings from movies. I think that it needs to come
- 57:08more full circle. But even beyond that, there
- 57:12there's a few things in this movie that he just needed to
- 57:16work on, and he does it quickly and becomes such an incredible
- 57:20director. Well, it sounds like we're
- 57:21tipping into final scores here. But before we get there, we have
- 57:24one more segment to get to. It's our final segment of the
- 57:26day, which we call. Let's make it a double.
- 57:30We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 57:33the film and Whiskey show. Let's have another film with
- 57:36this one, even if it's struggling.
- 57:37It's the final segment of the day.
- 57:38Now let's make it a double. Let's Make it a Double is
- 57:41presented by Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 57:44It's the part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with
- 57:47this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 57:49Brad, we've thrown out a lot of titles today.
- 57:52I don't really have any like cute clever thing here.
- 57:56I think the best movie to pair. I really hope you don't.
- 57:59You got right. The best movie to pair this with
- 58:02in terms of just like this is a dour sad heavy movie would be 7.
- 58:07I don't personally like that flavor of film, so I would I
- 58:12would choose to pair this with a movie like Gone Baby Gone, which
- 58:15is also very much about similar thematic territory of a missing
- 58:19child. But it does a better job to me
- 58:22of asking those thornier questions and leaving you in
- 58:25ambiguity instead of just in a a bleak, dire place.
- 58:32So I prefer that movie to this. I think they'd make an
- 58:34interesting pairing. But once again, I I keep coming
- 58:37back to the fact Ben Affleck's first movie to me is his best
- 58:41movie. So I'm going to continue to
- 58:43recommend Gone Baby Gone. That is actually what I was
- 58:47going to pair it with as well, Bob.
- 58:48Oh nice. Like.
- 58:50Yeah, I think Gone Baby Gone has the same a similar, you know,
- 58:56level of moral ambiguity. It feels like it comes more full
- 59:01circle though. I.
- 59:03I think that he's more responsible with the things that
- 59:06he shows you and I, I actually think there's multiple times
- 59:10throughout the film where Denny pulls his punches and, and
- 59:15whether it's giving you catharsis or going as far as,
- 59:18you know, this grossness goes. I feel like Gone Baby Gone is
- 59:26more willing to dive into the grossness of what takes place
- 59:30and what happens and more willing to go into the catharsis
- 59:34and the feeling better. I, I just, I prefer that.
- 59:39If I had to pair it with something else, I think I'd
- 59:42probably go with Mystic River. I know I mentioned it earlier,
- 59:45but I think that you are right in calling out a Clint Eastwood
- 59:49comparison here. And I think that that would be,
- 59:53it would make for a very sad, depressing night of cinema.
- 59:55But I mean, you could watch this with with the up and it would be
- 1:00:01a sad, depressing night of theater.
- 1:00:03All right, well, there you have it folks.
- 1:00:05Those are our picks for Let's Make it a Double.
- 1:00:07But no matter what you choose to pair it up with, you can always
- 1:00:11make it a double with Blackwood Distilling Company.
- 1:00:14And once again, go to our special link on Bourbon
- 1:00:17outfitter.com. That's Bourbon
- 1:00:19outfitter.com/film Whiskey. And if you use our code film
- 1:00:24Whiskey at checkout, you'll get 5% off your bottle of Blackwood
- 1:00:28Distilling. Brad, I've been sipping on this
- 1:00:31rye 1:05 that I just brought back from Kentucky.
- 1:00:34Freaking delicious, man. I like to the point where I I
- 1:00:39don't know if we need to just dedicate a whole episode to
- 1:00:41talking about it, but like one of my favorite like in the
- 1:00:45rotation rise right now. Yeah, it it.
- 1:00:48Sits next to my desk and whenever I need a drink like Don
- 1:00:51Draper in the middle of the work day, I pour myself some
- 1:00:54Blackwood 105 rye. There you go.
- 1:00:57All right, man, let's give this movie some final scores.
- 1:01:00I think this is an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 1:01:03And it's like it is both overachieving what a somewhat
- 1:01:09limited script is doing and it is underachieving at what I know
- 1:01:14Denny is capable of. And so it's, it's a weird, you
- 1:01:19know, sometimes we talk about like, oh, it's an 8, but it's a
- 1:01:20really good 8 bordering on an 8 1/2.
- 1:01:23It's an 8 in every way that a movie could be an 8 for me.
- 1:01:27That's kind of where I'm landing.
- 1:01:29Yeah, I I think that craft wise, this is like, I'm with you, this
- 1:01:37is an 8 out of 10 movie through and through.
- 1:01:39I, I think that I personally just didn't vibe with it and,
- 1:01:44and I understand why and I don't necessarily hold it against
- 1:01:47Denny. It just doesn't totally work for
- 1:01:50me. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 1:01:5110. Oh, OK.
- 1:01:54I'm glad we watched it because it was kind of the big glaring
- 1:01:58hole in our Denisville Move filmography, and I'm glad I
- 1:02:02revisited it because I haven't watched it in like a decade.
- 1:02:05So it's good. I think I probably, I don't
- 1:02:09know, like it's on par with Arrival for me, a movie that I
- 1:02:11don't feel like totally works. It's definitely a step down from
- 1:02:14Sicario and then I think both Dune movies easily surpass this
- 1:02:19one for me. Yeah, I, I, I would say so.
- 1:02:22I think Sicario might still be my favorite from him, with
- 1:02:27probably Dune 2 and Arrival being right behind it.
- 1:02:30I all three of those films are just so incredible.
- 1:02:34I, I can't recommend Denny enough.
- 1:02:36He he's such a great film maker. And yet I feel like he's never
- 1:02:40quite had a 10 out of 10 movie yet.
- 1:02:43Even Sicario's like a nine bordering on a 9 1/2 for me, but
- 1:02:47I just want that one perfect movie that is undeniable from
- 1:02:51him and he hasn't quite gotten there yet.
- 1:02:54I totally agree and and I think for a lot of people Dune 2 will
- 1:02:58be that. I, I I just.
- 1:03:01Feel like once again with Dune 2 he is so restricted by the the
- 1:03:06source material that he can only do so much and the only so much
- 1:03:11is like a 9 1/2 out of 10 fantasy epic that I'm so happy
- 1:03:17he brought to the big screen. I'm with you.
- 1:03:19It's not a 10 out of 10. It doesn't have his stamp on it
- 1:03:22the way some of his other movies do.
- 1:03:24All right, so it's a 7 1/2 on average from us, but we'd like
- 1:03:28to know what you guys think of the movie Prisoners.
- 1:03:32Brad, I'm going to assume that it's a no from you on modern
- 1:03:35masterpiece. Is that fair to say?
- 1:03:37Yeah, yeah, I'm going to say the same.
- 1:03:39I'm going to say the same. I think they're better crime
- 1:03:42like procedural movies. I think they're better serial
- 1:03:45killer movies. I think they're better moral
- 1:03:47quandary movies than this in the 21st century.
- 1:03:50So it's a no for me. But again, you can find us on
- 1:03:55all of our social media channels to tell us what you think of the
- 1:03:58movie prisoners. We're on Facebook, Twitter,
- 1:04:01Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:04:05Or if you'd like to join the conversation, we have our very
- 1:04:08own Discord server where we talk all things movie, whiskey, and
- 1:04:12pretty much anything else going on in our lives.
- 1:04:15So if you want to find a nice community, you can head on over
- 1:04:18to our Discord server. There's a link at the end of
- 1:04:22every single one of our show. Notes.
- 1:04:24Next week, another movie I have not watched in a while that I'm
- 1:04:26really excited to revisit. It's the 2019 Sam Mendes film,
- 1:04:301917. So we're going into World War
- 1:04:34One territory here, Brad. The most uplifting of times,
- 1:04:39Bob. All right, so join us for that
- 1:04:42next week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:04:45I'm Brad Gee. And we'll see you next time.
- 1:05:12Music.