Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When Online Abuse Becomes a Legal Matter: Cyberbullying, Harassment and Digital Misconduct
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:06When Online Abuse Becomes a Legal Matter, Cyberbullying,
- 0:10Harassment, and Digital Misconduct. I'm Alla
- 0:13Policastro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:15Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:18and it's my pleasure to introduce our speaker
- 0:20today, Joseph McNally. Joseph is the Director
- 0:24of Emerging Litigation at McNicholas & McNicholas,
- 0:27where he leads the firm's practice at the intersection
- 0:29of technology, privacy, and public accountability,
- 0:33including social media liability, data breaches,
- 0:36online exploitation, and whistleblower false
- 0:39claims actions. He brings nearly two decades
- 0:42of federal prosecution experience to his work,
- 0:45including service as acting United States attorney
- 0:48and first assistant United States attorney for
- 0:51the Central District of California. Joseph is
- 0:55a fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers
- 0:57and a recipient of the U .S. Department of Justice
- 1:00Director's Award for Superior Performance. Joseph
- 1:03has trained prosecutors nationwide as a faculty
- 1:06member at the DOJ's National Advocacy Center
- 1:09and taught trial advocacy at the University of
- 1:11California Irvine School of Law. We're so excited
- 1:14to hear what he has to share with us today, so
- 1:16I'm now going to turn it over to him. Well, thank
- 1:19you and thank you everybody for spending an hour
- 1:22with us this morning talking about what I think
- 1:25is an interesting and certainly a timely topic.
- 1:29I'm Joe McNally. I am a trial lawyer, plaintiff's
- 1:33trial lawyer at McNicholas and McNicholas. My
- 1:35practice is wide ranging. I handle technology
- 1:39related cases, some of which we'll talk a little
- 1:41bit about today. Mass torts, matters like the
- 1:45Boyle Heights fire. And then just really any
- 1:48type of individual action where somebody has
- 1:51suffered a catastrophic type of injury. And I
- 1:56came to that practice after being a federal prosecutor
- 1:59around 18 years where I spent my career. representing
- 2:04victims and advocating for the rights of victims
- 2:07in the context of criminal cases. And that was
- 2:11wide ranging from racketeering cases to exploitation
- 2:14cases to fraud cases. And in plaintiff's practice,
- 2:18I've found a way to continue to obviously advocate
- 2:22for victims. But with that, there's also an educational
- 2:24component and educating people on how they can
- 2:28avoid. becoming a victim in the first place.
- 2:31So today I'd like to talk to you a little bit
- 2:32about digital misconduct, cyberbullying, harassment,
- 2:37online abuse. And I'll talk a little bit about
- 2:40the current threats in this environment, what
- 2:43we're seeing in terms of the landscape out there,
- 2:47how some of those threats are dealt with legally.
- 2:51And lastly, about how to prevent yourself from
- 2:55becoming a victim. Everybody here is obviously
- 2:58a lawyer or involved in legal profession, but
- 3:02many folks are also parents, brothers, sisters,
- 3:06family members, who oftentimes encounter this
- 3:11type of abuse. Online abuse is something that
- 3:13unfortunately is not decreasing, it's increasing.
- 3:16Part of my goal today is to, again, talk about
- 3:19the threats, how you can handle those threats,
- 3:22and also how to prevent yourself from becoming
- 3:24a victim in the first place. With that, let me
- 3:28go ahead and share some slides that I put together
- 3:31for purposes of today. All right, great. So if
- 3:49you think for a minute about cyber bullying,
- 3:54Before we even get to the cyber part, I like
- 3:56to just step back and think generally and take
- 3:59all this back to when we were kids, when we were
- 4:03in school. The reality is that bullying has been
- 4:06around as long as the human race. Whether it's
- 4:12bullying or harassment and different types of
- 4:15settings, really what bullying involves is the
- 4:19use of you know, strength, popularity, power,
- 4:23sometimes information, to harm and oftentimes
- 4:27try to manipulate others. That happens in the
- 4:30school setting through gossip, demeaning comments,
- 4:33offensive conducts. Sometimes it escalates into
- 4:36more serious conduct threats, but we're all familiar
- 4:39with, you know, bullying. We're familiar with
- 4:43harassment, statements and conduct that's...
- 4:47directed to make others feel uncomfortable. And
- 4:51so what I like to talk about this topic, there's
- 4:56all of the types of conduct that you see with
- 4:59bullying in the cyber context or harassment in
- 5:02the online context really are things that we've
- 5:06grown up with even before the internet became
- 5:09as powerful as it is today. I think that this
- 5:13is a space where the internet has obviously improved
- 5:16our lives in lots of different ways. But this
- 5:20is a space where I think the internet has led
- 5:23to an increase in types of harm that we see in
- 5:26terms of cyberbullying, online harassment, some
- 5:30data for you. In the last... A couple of years,
- 5:34there's been increased studies on the impact
- 5:37of cyber billing, bullying, and online harassment.
- 5:40We'll talk a little bit about that today. You
- 5:42know, roughly, the data is today that roughly
- 5:4532 % of kids in school under 15, within the last
- 5:5130 days, have either been the victim or seen,
- 5:54had a close friend who was the victim of cyber
- 5:56bullying or some sort of online harassment. The
- 6:00amount of online harassment and cyber bullying
- 6:03has increased by about 300 % in the last five
- 6:09years. Much of that is a result of applications,
- 6:14whether it's TikTok, Instagram, another application,
- 6:18Fizz, which is used on college campuses that
- 6:21allow that conduct to occur. and you know the
- 6:26the the difference between the bullying that
- 6:28probably many of us on 46 but saw when we were
- 6:31kids um you know 35 years ago and today is what
- 6:36I like to refer to as kind of the four key tools
- 6:40or key reaches with cyberbullying and online
- 6:43harassment. And that is one, anonymity. It's
- 6:48a space now where people are able to talk and
- 6:51able to, whether it's make a threat or make a
- 6:54comment without any accountability. And so that's
- 6:57led to a significant increase in the bullying
- 7:00that we've seen, the online harassment. Two,
- 7:04if you go back to 20, 30 years ago, you could
- 7:07deal with bullying and harassment by taking yourself
- 7:10out of the environment where you're being threatened
- 7:12or harassed. It's a lot harder for kids to do
- 7:14today in a world where kids are on Instagram,
- 7:17on TikTok, on other applications. they cannot
- 7:22extricate themselves from an environment the
- 7:24same way that an employee could or a school kid
- 7:27could by going home and having a safe environment.
- 7:31In so many ways, this threat is greater than
- 7:33it is or have been before. And third, third and
- 7:37fourth, third, the audience size, the number
- 7:40of people that can be reached. through bullying
- 7:43today. It's no longer limited to people who are
- 7:47within earshot of demeaning or threatening comments.
- 7:51Very quickly through shared posts and messages,
- 7:56threats and harassment can reach thousands of
- 7:59people very quickly. And so that is why I think
- 8:04that this threat has more of an impact on particularly
- 8:07kids today. than ever before. I think it's a
- 8:10more challenging environment to grow up in for
- 8:13those reasons. So I want to talk about some of
- 8:15the patterns that we're seeing in these spaces
- 8:17and what you can do about it if you know somebody
- 8:20who becomes a victim. So I get roughly, I would
- 8:25say, five or six calls a month just based on
- 8:29my background of people that are dealing with
- 8:31some sort of online harassment threat. whether
- 8:36it's doxing, deep state, deep fakes, or other
- 8:40types of online conduct. And I'll talk a little
- 8:43bit about. you know, each of these in a moment.
- 8:47And so I'll start off just with with harassments
- 8:50and threats and, you know, the landscape that
- 8:53we commonly see there is, you know, starts off
- 8:58as maybe a demeaning, abusive message and then
- 9:01quickly will oftentimes, you know, be weaponized
- 9:06in a way. that eventually evolves oftentimes
- 9:10into criminal threats, which I'll talk a little
- 9:13bit about more. But the most common that we see
- 9:16is harassment and online threats that, like I
- 9:19said, start off as maybe a comment about somebody
- 9:21and then that threat actor, even after being
- 9:23blocked, finds a way to continue to make those
- 9:28threats, send abusive messages. The common pattern
- 9:32that we see, I got a call two weeks ago from
- 9:34an individual whose child have been the subject
- 9:37of initially one or two comments about an incident
- 9:41at a school. They blocked the person and then
- 9:45the threat actor ended up creating new accounts
- 9:49and bombarding the child. This is middle school
- 9:52aged kids bombarding the child with threats on
- 9:56a regular basis. And so I'd say that that is
- 9:59typically the most common that we see in the
- 10:02threat space. Like I said, it may start out as
- 10:06something innocuous, not innocuous, but something
- 10:09that's maybe less threatening and then escalates
- 10:12and reaches a point where even after taking basic
- 10:16safeguards by blocking somebody, the threat actor
- 10:19continues to send threats. You know, doxing is
- 10:24the second area and we'll talk a little bit about
- 10:27that and what that looks like and the law on
- 10:29it. I think everybody probably knows what doxing
- 10:32is, and that's publishing a home address, workplace,
- 10:35school, or other personal identifying information
- 10:37with the goal of harassing or threatening another
- 10:41individual. Third, non -consensual images that
- 10:47I like to divide into two categories. One is
- 10:51typically revenge porn, where somebody shares
- 10:56intimate relationship images, maybe with a partner,
- 11:00and ultimately those images are used to retaliate
- 11:03against that person and try to manipulate that
- 11:06person. And then the second bucket within that
- 11:09that we commonly see. are different types of
- 11:12sextortion that I'll talk a little bit more about
- 11:15the landscape there. And then lastly, you know,
- 11:19this is I think with the growth of AI, particularly
- 11:22over the last five years, we've seen a significant
- 11:24increase in deep fakes and talk a little bit
- 11:27about, you know, what that conduct looks like
- 11:30and what to do if you become a victim of it.
- 11:32So let's start off and just talk a little bit
- 11:36about, you know, harassments and threats. And
- 11:39what I find in most, you know, harassment, cyber
- 11:43harassment, cyber stalking cases is, look, the...
- 11:46the Internet online is really a method or means
- 11:53or tool to ultimately harass, stalk others. But
- 11:59that type of conduct, like I said, has gone on
- 12:02well before the Internet. The difference is that
- 12:04the Internet can be used as a powerful tool.
- 12:08to in many ways aggravate the harm, create more
- 12:12significant consequences for victims. But the
- 12:16types of conduct that we've seen with people
- 12:19using online threats and harassment is not that
- 12:21different than pre -internet. And what the common
- 12:25pattern that we see is it's repeated, abusive,
- 12:28threatening messages, communications. Those used
- 12:31to 40 years ago come in the form of telephone
- 12:34calls or a note. And now with technology, it's
- 12:39a much harder space for victims. So the common
- 12:42harassment and threats that we see that I typically
- 12:46had called of and I saw as a prosecutor are Somebody
- 12:50generally who has a relationship with somebody
- 12:52has a falling out either professional environment
- 12:55or a school environment and then the person who
- 12:59chooses to escalate that typically will do an
- 13:03initial conduct contact to the victim and then
- 13:06escalate the conduct from there. frequently employing.
- 13:11What I will say is not direct threats, but implied
- 13:14threats related to safety, health, and welfare
- 13:16that I'll talk a little more about. The common
- 13:20patterns that we see are uses of fake profiles,
- 13:26posts in the victim's name by creating accounts
- 13:28and impersonate them. That continues to increase.
- 13:34Like I said, I think that the online harassment
- 13:37and threats are roughly about 300 % just over
- 13:40the last couple of years. And certainly social
- 13:43media applications are a key part of that. So
- 13:51doxing continues to increase. I had a case last
- 13:59week where A lawyer called me and a lawyer had
- 14:02a client, a former client who didn't get a result
- 14:06that they wanted in a particular matter. And
- 14:10ultimately the lawyer in the case, like many
- 14:14of us, online home addresses, telephone numbers
- 14:17are searchable. The lawyer in the case, former
- 14:21client, created a number of profiles and then
- 14:26started posting. the lawyer's home address, and
- 14:30not only started posting it, started having delivery
- 14:33services deliver in the middle of the night at
- 14:352, 3, 4 AM, and then started putting false information
- 14:40out about the lawyer. alleging that the lawyer
- 14:44had a criminal record and had been charged with
- 14:48fraud, listing his number. And the goal here,
- 14:51obviously, was to destroy his reputation and
- 14:53also ultimately instill fear into the lawyer.
- 14:59And the question for me was, what can I do about
- 15:02it? And we are increasingly seeing, like I said,
- 15:07an increase in the number of doxing out there,
- 15:08photos of being posted of cars home. schools,
- 15:14oftentimes, like I said, the common one that
- 15:16we've increasingly seen is people ordering delivery
- 15:20to a particular person, all of which is designed
- 15:23to harass and intimidate. Many of you as lawyers
- 15:28may be familiar with a number of acts of violence
- 15:32related to the judiciary. You know, one of the
- 15:36examples of that was back in 2020, a federal
- 15:39judge who had ruled against a particular person
- 15:42in the case. You know, ultimately the perpetrator
- 15:45was able to find the judge's name and address
- 15:48online, showed up the... the judge's house and
- 15:52ultimately killed Judge Salas's son. And that
- 15:57wasn't exactly a doxing case, but the point that
- 16:01I use it to illustrate is really the significance
- 16:04of harm from the publication of personal information
- 16:09addresses in other information on the internet
- 16:11and certainly can be used as a tool to... to
- 16:16harass and stalk people. In California, in recent
- 16:20years, the legislature has taken action. And
- 16:23in California, if you dock somebody, you publish
- 16:27their name and personal information, their address
- 16:29for the purposes of harassing or intimidating
- 16:32them. It's a crime and you can be charged. In
- 16:35the federal system, the coverage is a little
- 16:36more narrow. You have to be a covered person,
- 16:39which usually requires that you're a government
- 16:41employee in order to fall within the scope of
- 16:45the statute. But it's crime. That's something
- 16:48that really has come up in the last couple of
- 16:51years, where legislatures have seen the harm
- 16:53from doxing and begun to act as a result. you
- 17:01know, area and one that I'd say in addition to
- 17:04kind of your general threats, we continue to
- 17:07see a lot, particularly with young people, is
- 17:09revenge porn and sex torsion. So let me talk
- 17:12a little bit about that. You know, typically
- 17:15in the revenge porn space, the conduct that we
- 17:19see is the manipulative conduct that you oftentimes
- 17:22see abusers and harassers engage in. whether
- 17:27it's online or offline, a jealous ex -boyfriend
- 17:31or girlfriend who wants to try to ruin a former
- 17:35partner's life. And revenge porn now is a key
- 17:39way that some of these individuals use to do
- 17:41it. So frequently what we'll see in these cases
- 17:44is... pictures that starts with a threat, a threat
- 17:49to the former partner. If you don't do acts,
- 17:51you don't meet with me, you don't come back to
- 17:53me, I'm going to post your pictures. Starts out
- 17:56with a threat, an extortionate threat. And then
- 17:59oftentimes, is used to try to manipulate the
- 18:03partner that they're trying to get back to. The
- 18:05common cases that we see are usually consensual
- 18:08images that were taken. Certainly, sometimes
- 18:11there's hacking, but usually consensual images
- 18:14that then there's a threat to post on porn sites,
- 18:17social media, send to family, friends, or employers.
- 18:20And obviously, once these are posted, they can
- 18:22be devastating for the victim in both under California
- 18:26law and federal law. It's a felony for individuals
- 18:32to engage in revenge porn. In the last couple
- 18:36of years, there's been some really significant
- 18:38prosecutions against commercial entities that
- 18:42had created revenge porn websites. A guy in San
- 18:46Diego had created a revenge porn website where
- 18:50you could submit your photos to him and then
- 18:52he would publish them for the world to see. People
- 18:54could go on there and obviously view the images
- 18:57that had been provided. He was ultimately prosecuted
- 19:01by the state. I think received more than a decade
- 19:03in prison. legal tools to deal with not just
- 19:06the individuals, but the organizations who are
- 19:09putting these out there commercially. So revenge
- 19:13porn is certainly something that continues to
- 19:16be used by folks to manipulate others. And then
- 19:20sextortion, which if you have kids, I encourage
- 19:26people to talk to their kids about what this
- 19:27is and what to do to avoid it. probably tell
- 19:35you about kind of two different areas where this
- 19:38typically comes up. So it usually arises from
- 19:42somebody being in a chat room, oftentimes kids
- 19:45who are in their teenage years. Oftentimes, find
- 19:50themselves in a chat room chatting with somebody.
- 19:52I've had cases, though, where it's also a CEO
- 19:55of a company who ends up in a chat room and develop
- 20:01some sort of online relationship or romance with
- 20:04somebody. And the folks who target others for
- 20:10these sextortion threats and eventually financial
- 20:14extortion. have a game plan, and typically that
- 20:18game plan is to start off chatting, they'll impersonate
- 20:22somebody the victim's age, they'll try to get
- 20:25as much personal identifying information as they
- 20:28can about the victim, where the victim lives,
- 20:30the victim's true name, and like a lot of different
- 20:34types of fraud schemes, to slowly lure the victim
- 20:37in by developing some trust. and developing a
- 20:41relationship. Most of the groups that target
- 20:45individuals for sextortion are abroad, oftentimes
- 20:50in Southeast Asia. Sometimes in Africa, but oftentimes
- 20:55more often than not are abroad and they will
- 20:58go into those rooms with the purpose of targeting
- 21:01a 15 or 16 year old or in some cases charging
- 21:04and adults and the goals are typically two things.
- 21:07When it's a child oftentimes these people are.
- 21:10pedophiles, and they will eventually, after developing
- 21:14a relationship with the child and telling them
- 21:16to send sexually explicit images, the child will
- 21:20send one, and then the perpetrator will say,
- 21:23look, if you don't send me five or 10 more, I'm
- 21:26going to send this to your entire school. This
- 21:29is your Facebook profile. This is your Instagram
- 21:31profile, and this is how I'm going to put it
- 21:33out there. And that results in the child providing
- 21:38more images and getting into the cycle where
- 21:41now they've got, you know, five, 10, 12 images,
- 21:45sexually explicit images out there. And the person
- 21:48on the other end of that has total control over
- 21:51them mentally and emotionally. Really, really
- 21:54sad stories. In the United States, there's...
- 21:57probably been about 25 to 30 suicides in the
- 22:01last decade of kids who were on the other side
- 22:04of a sextortion plot where you had a predator
- 22:07trying to get their images and then pump them
- 22:08out. You know, it rarely after the first image
- 22:12ends, you know, once the perpetrator realizes
- 22:15that they have control and they have their personal
- 22:18identifying information, they can control and.
- 22:21frequently, it doesn't stop until a parent learns
- 22:24about it and hopefully is able to intervene.
- 22:26So that is what I'd call the kind of the child
- 22:29pornography, child exploitation bucket of sextortion,
- 22:33which you, like I said, you oftentimes see with
- 22:36minors. I think in, you know, I put up a number
- 22:39here, about 12 ,600 minors have reported to generally
- 22:46boys. to law enforcement, different acts of sextortion.
- 22:52And so this continues to, like I said, increase.
- 22:54It's another tool used by child predators. On
- 22:58the other end of that is individuals that engage
- 23:00in sextortion for financial gain. These typically
- 23:04target men, married men, and they typically are,
- 23:10like I said, operate the same way where they
- 23:12lure them in. They develop a online relationship.
- 23:16They learn their true name. They learn intimate
- 23:19details of their life. I had a circumstance involving
- 23:24an executive at a company where he was lured
- 23:26in. At the time, he was in a relationship with
- 23:28somebody that got his identifying information.
- 23:31They made a financial demand that he ultimately
- 23:35pay out the demand in digital currency. to the
- 23:39tune of seven figures, and at some point he was
- 23:43wise enough to contact me, and I was able to
- 23:46put him in touch with law enforcement, because
- 23:48these, even after you pay the demand, typically
- 23:51don't stop. The typical threat is, I have these
- 23:54images of you, sexually explicit images. I will
- 23:57put them on the internet. I'll post them on LinkedIn.
- 24:01And frequently, the actors will then identify
- 24:04family members through public record searches,
- 24:06say that they'll send them to your in -laws,
- 24:09they'll send them to family members, they'll
- 24:11send them to your employer, all for the purpose
- 24:15of trying to get this money. And in the United
- 24:17States, tens of millions of dollars are paid
- 24:19out every year in different sextortion payments.
- 24:23The move, whether it's revenge porn or sextortion,
- 24:27and I'll talk about this towards the end, to
- 24:30never, never pay the ransom, oftentimes really,
- 24:33really hard to walk people through that circumstance
- 24:36and convince them why you don't want to go through
- 24:39with a payment. Typically, once a payment is
- 24:42made, that conduct only escalates over time.
- 24:45And so we'll talk a little more about sextortion
- 24:47and how to deal with those types of demands.
- 24:50And finally, deepfakes. And this is, as many
- 24:54of you have probably seen in recent news, continues
- 24:58to be a topic, you know, both here in California,
- 25:02but throughout the country, frequently students
- 25:05in school environments, classmates taking pictures
- 25:09of a student and then creating a circumstance
- 25:13where an image where, you know, they appear to
- 25:16be nude and AI getting so good. that it's really
- 25:21hard for people to tell the difference between
- 25:23a real image and an AI image. These are often
- 25:26used to humiliate, harass, extort the legal remedies
- 25:30here. Congress has actually acted pretty quickly
- 25:32in the last year after, excuse me, a number of...
- 25:37Suicides at school of kids who have fallen victim
- 25:40to this, the take it down act not only creates
- 25:43criminal liability, federal criminal liability
- 25:45for individuals who create new deep fakes, but
- 25:49also requires tech companies to remove deep fakes
- 25:52within 48 hours. That's a program that's administered
- 25:55by the FTC. So if somebody produces a deep fake.
- 26:01The victim can go to Google or go to Instagram
- 26:04and demand that it be taken down. The tech companies
- 26:07have to act within 48 hours or face significant
- 26:10fine. That came into place into effect this past
- 26:14year and so provide some good criminal and civil
- 26:18tools to ultimately deal with that type of conduct.
- 26:23As I said before, when I think about these spaces
- 26:28and people ask me, you know, is it a crime? Is
- 26:31it a civil matter? Is it nothing? I like to just
- 26:35go back and talk a little bit about the statutes
- 26:39that are in place. And, you know, the way I like
- 26:42to think about this, like I said, is the crimes
- 26:45that have been on the books for decades, the
- 26:49federal and state criminal statutes usually are
- 26:52adequate to address the type of online harm that
- 26:56we see when that online harm becomes a criminal
- 26:59threat or criminal in nature. And so many of
- 27:02the criminal statutes that DAs and federal prosecutors
- 27:06have used for many years are being applied to
- 27:12threats that are now coming over the internet
- 27:15or over some sort of electronic communications.
- 27:19criminal threats have always been illegal under
- 27:21both federal and state law. Typically, when I
- 27:25was a prosecutor, if a threat would come in,
- 27:26whether it was online or in any type of medium,
- 27:30we'd still evaluate it the same way. Certainly
- 27:32the threats over the internet have additional
- 27:35power in terms of the audience that they can
- 27:38reach, the anonymity. And so investigating them
- 27:41can be harder in terms of determining who they
- 27:43came from and tracking that back to somebody
- 27:45based on an IP and unraveling that. But the statutes
- 27:49that we've used to protect people from threats,
- 27:52extortion are the same statutes that are in play
- 27:54today. When you have a sex extortion case, it's
- 27:58the same federal statute related to extortion
- 28:00that we've been using in the United States for
- 28:03many decades, just being applied in a different
- 28:05contact. for, you know, sextortion involving
- 28:09minors. Typically when we prosecuted those, when
- 28:11I was a prosecutor, we'd use the same statutes
- 28:14to prosecute those cases. And specifically those
- 28:17involve the production of child pornography.
- 28:20If somebody engages in sextortion and tries to
- 28:23get images from a 12 or 13 year old, they're
- 28:25actually producing child pornography. And so
- 28:28many of these statutes that we use are the same
- 28:31statutes that have been on the books well before,
- 28:33frankly, the advent of the internet. coming up
- 28:36with the Internet. Usually, the conduct that
- 28:39we see fits lots of different places. You may
- 28:42have criminal threats. You may have extortion.
- 28:45The one place where I'd say we are, you know,
- 28:48Congress, I think, has started to act is in the
- 28:50deep fake space, where they've begun to enact
- 28:54specific legislation to address those types of
- 28:59conduct specific to AI. Like I said, federal
- 29:03law 875 is a statute we've used for decades to
- 29:09address any type of threat and now continues
- 29:12to be used in the context of online harm. So
- 29:15there's lots of statutes. This is in an area
- 29:17where I think that there are gaps in federal
- 29:20law. I think that there's adequate both federal
- 29:22and state laws to address the conduct when law
- 29:24enforcement investigates it. So going back to
- 29:29the point I made earlier, when you see a threat,
- 29:31the question often comes, becomes, is it a crime?
- 29:35Is it civil? Is it none of them? And where are
- 29:41those lines and where do they fall? And typically
- 29:45the way I like to think about it is look, if
- 29:47it's offensive conduct, opinion -based, broad
- 29:53statements, no implicit or explicit threat of
- 29:55harm, physical or emotional harm, probably not
- 30:01going to fall in the category of a criminal or
- 30:04even civil threat that can be addressed. Uh,
- 30:07you know, we live in a world where, you know,
- 30:09people can say harmful things. It's first amendment
- 30:12protection. People can, um, you know, use offensive,
- 30:15uh, language towards others. Uh, certainly there's
- 30:19at times, uh, depending on the circumstances,
- 30:21you may have a civil action related to defamation,
- 30:24but you know, in general, um, you know, lawful,
- 30:28but awful speech, really harmful, um, bullying
- 30:31speech is not, you know, oftentimes In itself,
- 30:35sufficient to rise to a both either a criminal
- 30:38or civil matter. I think that where that that
- 30:41line is is once you have a victim who begins
- 30:45to take basic steps to protect themselves and
- 30:48that, you know, perpetrator that bully or harasser.
- 30:52finds ways to, you know, work arounds to continue
- 30:55to engage in that harassment. And so, you know,
- 30:57from a prosecution standpoint, when I advise
- 30:59people whether they should go to law enforcement
- 31:01or not, what I like to think through is, you
- 31:03know, number one, you know, is this a communication
- 31:07that's directly targeting the victim? Is it directly
- 31:10targeting them? Is it personal with them? In
- 31:14order for it to... be a crime, it has to one,
- 31:18objectively be viewed by a reasonable person
- 31:21as something that's threatening or designed to
- 31:24threaten or harass. And two, there has to be
- 31:28intent. There has to be specific intent by that
- 31:30person or recklessness. And I'll talk about a
- 31:33case called Cotterman in a moment. But typically,
- 31:37what is required is both the statement, the threat,
- 31:41is, like I said, directly to a reasonable person,
- 31:48going to be something that is understood to be.
- 31:52designed to frighten them or cause them a tremendous
- 31:56amount of fear. And two, there has to be specific
- 31:58intent. So how do you go about typically proving
- 32:01that? Well, in a criminal case, we look for patterns.
- 32:04We look for patterns where, as I said, somebody
- 32:07blocks the person who contacted them. And then
- 32:10that person goes and creates five or 10 other
- 32:13accounts to get around the block. And if it's
- 32:17telephone calls, do they, after their number's
- 32:20blocked over a messaging service or blocked over
- 32:25a phone, do they then go buy a burner account?
- 32:28Are they creating names and victims? And so you
- 32:30look at all this in the totality to see, one,
- 32:33whether those threats, not taken in isolation,
- 32:35but... in as a whole constitute a threat. Cotterman's
- 32:40an interesting case that went up to the Supreme
- 32:42Court. It was a case where he was a man who targeted
- 32:46a local musician who he had issues with in Colorado.
- 32:51He sent hundreds of messages on Facebook to this
- 32:54musician who somehow he got sideways with. I'll
- 32:58give you a couple of the threats that he ended
- 33:00up getting charged with. They were, you know,
- 33:04odd statements. They were not direct threats,
- 33:05but staying in cyber life will kill you. Are
- 33:09you in that white Jeep? Fuck off permanently.
- 33:13You're not good for human relations. Die. So
- 33:18all of those are statements that certainly would
- 33:20make somebody feel uncomfortable. And the question
- 33:23is like, how do you charge that then criminally?
- 33:26And first issue is again, objectively not taken
- 33:30on a single message, but when these are coming
- 33:33across. you know, somebody's phone or email,
- 33:37hundreds of them, hundreds of them in a short
- 33:39period of time, would that threaten somebody?
- 33:41And would it threaten, you know, a reasonable
- 33:43person in an objective sense, view that as a
- 33:46threat? And I think most people would, particularly
- 33:48when you've taken reasonable steps to block somebody
- 33:50and you continue to be threatened because that
- 33:54person finds a workaround through creating additional
- 33:56accounts to message you from. And then two is,
- 34:00you know, what is the intent of the speaker?
- 34:02Is he intending to threaten? And I think when
- 34:05most people would look at statements like this
- 34:07and not just the statements, but the volume and
- 34:10the patterns, of course, when somebody says,
- 34:13is that you and the white creep? You're going
- 34:15to be thinking, you know, okay, this guy's now
- 34:17following me. So Koderman, ultimately, the Supreme
- 34:20Court found that, look, in order for this to
- 34:23be criminalized, the intent here can be reckless.
- 34:28And the statements that this defendant made to
- 34:31the victim, you can infer intent based on the
- 34:35pattern of conduct and the frequency of the communications.
- 34:38And ultimately, his sentence was upheld. Let
- 34:48me talk a little bit about civil remedies. I'd
- 34:53say that when I get called probably about Half
- 34:58the time I end up, you know, connecting the individual
- 35:01with somebody in federal or state law enforcement
- 35:03because it's something that's, you know, clearly
- 35:06a threat. The pattern where they've done all
- 35:09they could to avoid the person and the person,
- 35:11you know, is now using accounts to continue to
- 35:13contact them, threaten them, putting out their
- 35:16personal information. Obviously, in a case of
- 35:19sextortion or revenge porn, those are easy calls.
- 35:23Oftentimes, though, you know, the reality is
- 35:25in the California and Southern California and
- 35:28the city of Los Angeles. We have a police department
- 35:31that's relatively understaffed and doesn't always
- 35:34have the bandwidth to focus on what I would say
- 35:39online threats to the extent I think we'd like.
- 35:41And I saw that also with federal law enforcement
- 35:44and federal prosecutions. Certainly the most
- 35:47serious cases get... pursued, but there's many,
- 35:51many cases given the volume of threats that frankly
- 35:54don't get addressed adequately in the criminal
- 35:56justice system. And so the same tools that apply
- 36:00in the context of any type of civil harassment
- 36:03are certainly in play when it comes down to electronic
- 36:09communications. Typically with any type of civil
- 36:14harassment, whether it's text contacts or online,
- 36:18you can go and get a civil restraining order
- 36:20much like you would. um, in any type of situation
- 36:24where you're dealing with neighbors or, um, you
- 36:27know, acquaintance or a firm or partner, um,
- 36:30that applies with equal force to online harassment.
- 36:32And, you know, so typically I tell people, um,
- 36:35that once that, once you've taken basic steps
- 36:37to try to stop of communications with that person
- 36:40to go and get a restraining order. And ultimately,
- 36:43it's a restraining order that's in those circumstances
- 36:45served by the sheriff's department and puts that
- 36:48person on notice. It also puts you in a position
- 36:50where I think if a criminal case is going to
- 36:52be pursued, it's another, you know, what I say,
- 36:56benefit for a prosecutor to have something that
- 36:59was done before initiating a criminal prosecution
- 37:02that they were on notice and they were told to
- 37:04stop the conduct and not only told to stop, but
- 37:06ordered by a court. School related orders under
- 37:12the California education code. Every school is
- 37:15required to have in place a harassment and bullying
- 37:18protocols and policies. And we've seen here in
- 37:24Southern California, both in the space of deep
- 37:27fakes and other online harassment schools increasingly
- 37:30taking action because. of the liability that
- 37:34comes to them if they don't, and obviously the
- 37:36concern and the need to protect students. So
- 37:42let's talk a little bit about one question that
- 37:45I frequently get from folks is, why aren't there
- 37:51more penalties for tech companies? And what are
- 37:56the tech companies doing to protect online harassment?
- 38:02That pattern I'll throw out there is, you know,
- 38:05tech company ultimately could screen their messages.
- 38:13There's threats being conveyed over a different
- 38:17platform, whether it's Instagram or one that's
- 38:20commonly used. I've learned about recently in
- 38:22colleges is Fizz, which allows for anonymous
- 38:26comments to be made about students at. at school
- 38:29and the way that you get on Fizz is through your
- 38:33.edu account at the school that you go to. And
- 38:38so one question that people have is like, why
- 38:39aren't the platforms doing more? You know, when
- 38:42a post is made and then ultimately somebody is
- 38:45either threatened or harmed or... A post is made,
- 38:48and then somebody goes to somebody's house and
- 38:50actually physically harms them. Why isn't there
- 38:52accountability for Instagram or Facebook? And
- 38:55that goes back to what many of you may be familiar
- 38:57with, which is Section 230 of the Communications
- 39:00Decency Act. And what Section 230 says is that
- 39:04in almost all cases, an internet service provider,
- 39:09a platform, Instagram, Facebook, pick your social
- 39:13media application, does not have liability. for
- 39:17a cause of action that arises from a content
- 39:21that is being posted on its website. So somebody
- 39:24goes and posts something on Facebook, harm happens.
- 39:27The law is pretty settled that that tech platform
- 39:30is not accountable and they don't have any duty
- 39:33to police the speech or liability of the consequences
- 39:37from the consequences or harm that flows from
- 39:40the speech. So they're ultimately not liable.
- 39:43And that is something that Congress has continued
- 39:45to take a look at. And there's a great debate
- 39:49that continues to go around Section 230. You
- 39:53may have, for those that follow social media
- 39:56litigation, much of the Facebook trials and other
- 40:00litigation that's played out over the last year
- 40:03really focused on Section 230 and whether or
- 40:07not Section 230 made and other companies immune
- 40:14in these civil actions that were filed in LA
- 40:16Superior Court in New Mexico and San Francisco.
- 40:19I won't talk a ton about that today, but generally
- 40:22there has been a movement towards holding these
- 40:26platforms accountable because of the power that
- 40:28they have and the reach that they have for users
- 40:31on their site. But as we currently stand, when
- 40:34there's harm that results from content that's
- 40:38posted on the platform, that platform is immune
- 40:41from civil liability. So frequently, what you're
- 40:45left with in civil cases, potentially going and
- 40:49suing the individual individually. Oftentimes,
- 40:52the people that do this, frankly, have mental
- 40:53health issues, oftentimes aren't going to have
- 40:57assets to make a victim whole, or going after
- 41:01somebody else who had a duty to the victim to
- 41:07protect them from this type of harm. You're not
- 41:08going to be able to necessarily get the platform,
- 41:10but does the school have liability? If the school
- 41:13knows that the student is continuing to use FIS
- 41:17or some sort of application in the context of
- 41:21the school environment, and that's resulting
- 41:22in harassment that then leads to harm, there's
- 41:26cases out there where the schools or a company
- 41:29or workplace have been held accountable, just
- 41:31like they would be if that conduct had happened
- 41:34in their workplace without technologies being
- 41:37used as a means to perpetrate the harm. So increasingly,
- 41:41we're seeing lawsuits, again, not necessarily
- 41:44against the platform, but against environments
- 41:46that the platform has been used in and harm has
- 41:49resulted in. So I'll talk about a couple different
- 42:05cases where we have in recent years seen increased
- 42:13civil liability. So DC versus RR was a case where
- 42:20classmates had posted threatening and homophobic
- 42:22messages about a student on a website. And, you
- 42:26know, the question there was whether or not,
- 42:28you know, this was free speech. And ultimately,
- 42:31the California Court of Appeals held that, look,
- 42:34when you are repeatedly posting homophobic messages,
- 42:37threatening messages about a student, this crosses
- 42:39into the line away from, you know, protected
- 42:42speech into true threats and ultimately, you
- 42:47know, resulted in, you know, liability, not just
- 42:51for, as I said, you know, the the perpetrator,
- 42:57but ultimately liability for school that allows
- 43:00that to happen. Barrett versus Rosenthal, recent
- 43:05California Supreme Court case. And again, This
- 43:09is the challenge of two thirty two thirty was
- 43:12a case where there is sorry this is a case where
- 43:14there is a lawsuit and you know ultimately a
- 43:18defamatory information was posted the plaintiff
- 43:22alleged that it was threatening and harassing
- 43:24and ultimately the way that it played out was
- 43:26California Supreme Court held the platform did
- 43:28not have liability under section two thirty because
- 43:33the platform was simply republishing defamatory.
- 43:37content posted by another. So again, under that
- 43:40circumstance, you're going to have to find liability
- 43:41and ultimately sue the author and not the platform
- 43:46provider. So let me shift gears a little bit
- 43:51about how to protect yourself. We've talked about
- 43:53the threats. We've talked about the increase
- 43:57in some of the threats landscape that we're seeing
- 44:00and some of the ways that you can seek accountability.
- 44:03So let me talk a little bit about how to prevent
- 44:06this in the first place. So one is If you have
- 44:10kids, sit down with kids and have an honest conversation.
- 44:14A large number of the calls that I get end up
- 44:16dealing with kids who are between 12 and 17 years
- 44:21old. And I think that in many of those cases,
- 44:25if a parent had sat down and talked to them about
- 44:26the threats out there, talked to them candidly
- 44:29about sextortion, talked to them about how they
- 44:32can be taken advantage of online, it could have
- 44:35potentially prevented some of the harm. A couple
- 44:37of tools that I'll flag. So one is in California,
- 44:42the DROP Act is something that was created. It's
- 44:46run by the California Privacy Protection Agency.
- 44:48That allows you to have data brokers, people
- 44:54that would put your information out there online.
- 44:56So if you Googled me, finding my home address,
- 45:00my telephone number, information that somebody
- 45:02seeking to dox me would take advantage of. The
- 45:05DROP Act allows you to go to the Privacy Protection
- 45:08website and ultimately have your information
- 45:11deleted by all data brokers. What I've typically
- 45:14seen is that results in information online about
- 45:17you typically going away over a period of time.
- 45:20It makes it a lot harder to find information
- 45:21about you. Two, making sure that people have
- 45:26their social media on private, that they ultimately
- 45:29turn off location checks. tags, they're careful
- 45:33about photo backgrounds and showing where they
- 45:36are. I've seen a number of cases where folks
- 45:41ultimately, you know, are victimized because
- 45:44somebody ultimately hacks into a Facebook account,
- 45:47an Instagram account, a hick -tick -tack account.
- 45:51I oftentimes tell people, you know, use two -factor
- 45:54authentication. All of these are ways just to
- 45:57keep your, keep control over your social media,
- 46:00keep control over your devices so that somebody
- 46:04is not able to, you know, ultimately take advantage
- 46:07of you and subject you to harassment and sextortion
- 46:10because they don't have the information and your
- 46:14personal information in order to perpetrate it.
- 46:17Parents and schools, you know, I think that every
- 46:20workplace and every school has needs to have
- 46:24a policy under California law schools are required
- 46:26to have it now. teaching, you know, digital citizenship
- 46:30and bystander intervention, talking to kids about
- 46:32what you do if somebody, a classmate is being
- 46:35bullied, who to report it to, how to handle it.
- 46:39Really, really makes a difference. As I said
- 46:42before, kids can't be extricated from a school
- 46:44environment. Employees can't be extricated from
- 46:47workplace environment and go home like they once
- 46:50would because these messages continue to reach
- 46:54them online. Well, after they've left their workplace
- 46:57and so having a policy and having typically most
- 47:01schools that I see have a coordinator and somebody
- 47:03who specializes in addressing. Uh, any type of,
- 47:07um, cyber bullying or cyber harassment issue,
- 47:09but it happens. Um, you know, there has been,
- 47:12as I said, an increase, I think, you know, in
- 47:15Beverly Hills. Uh, I think it was last year,
- 47:17there were 5 students who were ultimately expelled
- 47:19for, um, you know, AI conduct, but that was an
- 47:21example where they did an investigation. Uh,
- 47:24and ultimately took action in order to create
- 47:26a search safe learning environment. Um, so by
- 47:324 things that, that, uh, I typically tell people,
- 47:34um, when. uh you know harassment starts so one
- 47:38is never engage hard hard to do uh i've talked
- 47:41to people who uh have been you know being there
- 47:45on the other side of this extortion threat the
- 47:47uh criminal actor is saying that they're going
- 47:49to send this to their workplace or send this
- 47:51to you know family members um and you know very
- 47:55very tempting as you might imagine for somebody
- 47:56to just pay it and engage because of the fear
- 48:00of what would happen if they don't But it never
- 48:03gets better when people engage. And so one is
- 48:05don't engage. Two, I tell people to screenshot
- 48:09everything. If you ultimately report this to
- 48:12law enforcement, they're going to want to be
- 48:13able to see what the communications were when
- 48:15it happened, what the username is. And so screenshot
- 48:19everything. I oftentimes tell people take a separate
- 48:22phone or camera and record the communication
- 48:26so that there's a full accounting for all the
- 48:28messages. And then report. The FBI operates,
- 48:33and I'll leave, it's with the materials, an online
- 48:38platform where you can go on, you can report
- 48:39it. The reason that they do this online is typically
- 48:43Uh, you know, these threat actors or these, you
- 48:46know, criminals are doing it or not in one particular
- 48:48city. Uh, they're oftentimes abroad. And so by
- 48:51having the initial report made online, um, the
- 48:55FBI has a team of intelligence analysts who are
- 48:57back in Washington, DC, who are able to look
- 48:59at the threats and then figure out, you know,
- 49:02there's a threat or sextortion event happening
- 49:04in LA. Does that link to an event happening in
- 49:07New York? Is the bank account that they said
- 49:10to send the money to or the Bitcoin or digital
- 49:13currency instructions the same here as there?
- 49:16So they can try to link these cases together
- 49:18and link as many victim cases as they can. And
- 49:20so it's typically through an online reporting
- 49:22process called IC3 where you can submit that
- 49:25information. And certainly they're going to want
- 49:27all the records that I indicated should be preserved.
- 49:31The other upside of, like I said, the Take It
- 49:35Down Act now provides for social media companies,
- 49:40any platform has to remove, you know, revenge
- 49:43porn or other non -consensual intimate images
- 49:46within 48 hours. By reporting it to them, you
- 49:52put them on notice and they'll do that. And then
- 49:54obviously, you want to report it to law enforcement
- 49:56so that they can investigate it as well. You
- 49:59know, I typically tell people that it's worth
- 50:02Early on, if it's something serious, consulting
- 50:05with counsel, getting a lawyer to help navigate
- 50:07through the process, through the law enforcement
- 50:09process. I always tell people that I'm available
- 50:13to, I typically don't end up taking most of these
- 50:15cases on, but happy to help point people in the
- 50:18right direction when these types of events occur.
- 50:22I like to typically tell people. uh, you know,
- 50:27start creating a log of, you know, a timeline,
- 50:29not just no messages, but you want to save profile
- 50:32pages, all of this so that law enforcement or
- 50:35civil lawyer can ultimately recreate what happened
- 50:37and figure out who's responsible. Um, I think
- 50:41that in most cases, if it's, uh, garden variety,
- 50:47harassment, threats of violence, stalking. I
- 50:49recommend that people start with local law enforcement.
- 50:52They typically just have more individuals on
- 50:55the ground. They can go out and they can quickly,
- 50:58more quickly deal with that. If a kid's being
- 51:01bullied at school. um online um and you know
- 51:05who the person is i think it's good to start
- 51:07with the police they oftentimes can go and knock
- 51:09on a door and that oftentimes i'd say 75 percent
- 51:12of the time will end the conduct um if it is
- 51:16a circumstance involving sextortion uh which
- 51:19like i said are typically being perpetrated by
- 51:22individuals abroad uh if it's for money if it's
- 51:26for images You can call the local police, but
- 51:29I'd report it right away to federal law enforcement.
- 51:32Sextortion in the federal system, if you're somebody
- 51:34who's extorting a minor for their sexual images,
- 51:38carries really significant penalties, 15, 20
- 51:40years, mandatory minimum in prison, depending
- 51:44on the circumstances. And so federal law enforcement
- 51:46is. oftentimes ready, willing, and able to prosecute
- 51:51those cases. But I think it's often good to get
- 51:54a lawyer involved and direct somebody who has
- 51:57some experience, frequently a criminal defense
- 51:59lawyer will know how to navigate the system.
- 52:02As I said, I'm always happy to talk to people,
- 52:04try to point them in the right direction. And
- 52:06then lastly, the fact that there's these other
- 52:09tools doesn't mean that the school or the employer
- 52:11is off the hook. They have an obligation to have
- 52:14a policy and make sure that there's a safe work
- 52:16environment. and so always report the threat,
- 52:19the conduct, both to school and the employer.
- 52:26Warning signs, particularly for people with kids.
- 52:32People have to, of course, know their kids, but
- 52:34I think, again, having an affirmative conversation
- 52:36with kids on the front end about what the threat
- 52:39environment is, how this can hurt you, and what
- 52:42happens if you fall victim. really goes a long
- 52:45way. The common warning signs that law enforcement
- 52:49often talks about is kids wanting to hide the
- 52:53screen, avoid the phone, distress after communicating
- 52:57with friends or people on Facebook. And then
- 53:01oftentimes, withdrawal is a common symptom that
- 53:05I think parents see in kids who are suffering
- 53:07from this kind of stuff. So there's lots of resources
- 53:09out there to get help. glad that I had the opportunity
- 53:14to talk about some of these topics with you today.
- 53:20Let me switch and see if there are some questions.
- 53:43All righty. So it does look like we do have two
- 53:44questions so far. Of course, more questions always
- 53:47appreciated. So the first one is from Nicole.
- 53:51Let's see, how will you familiarize judges and
- 53:54court staff about Deep Fake AI Revenge Barn,
- 53:56Ticket Down Act, Defiance Act, and other tools
- 53:58available? Most judges and their clerks are not
- 54:01familiarized with these new laws and new cause
- 54:03of action. Attorneys are also not familiarized
- 54:07with these case and refuse to take it. Isn't
- 54:10these causes of action the new quote unquote
- 54:13personal injury lawsuits that can be filed by
- 54:16LASC? So, well, let me let me kind of step back
- 54:21and answer it a couple ways. So look, I think
- 54:24that generally, there needs to be more education
- 54:28out there about online threats, whether it's
- 54:32doxing, particularly for, it sounds like that
- 54:35the questions in the context of superior court
- 54:39employees who are oftentimes. Unfortunately,
- 54:42the subject of threats and harassment by litigants
- 54:48that happened to me as a prosecutor, and I know
- 54:50what happens to public employees generally. Look,
- 54:54I think that my advice to people is you're now
- 54:57aware of the landscape, you're aware of some
- 54:59of the laws here as it relates to deep fakes
- 55:04and AI, and I think that you can ask for education.
- 55:08Both the FBI in Los Angeles, the Sheriff's Department,
- 55:14LAPD, all will go out and educate about online
- 55:18threats and how to deal with that if, you know,
- 55:20there's an interest in that by, like I said,
- 55:23I... My take is this is maybe coming from somebody
- 55:26who Nicole, if you have a connection to the superior
- 55:28court, I can put you in contact with some of
- 55:31the FBI and I know they would do a online threats
- 55:34educational program for employees, the superior
- 55:38court. So does that answer the question? All
- 55:47right, we'll see if Nicole gets back to us and
- 55:50we have another question. from Noah, asking,
- 55:54when the harasser is anonymous, what must a plaintiff
- 55:57generally show before a court will allow discovery
- 56:00to identify them? Yeah, that's a good question.
- 56:04So typically, if you don't know who's harassing
- 56:08or, you know, harassing, abusing you, you can
- 56:13file what's called a John Doe lawsuit. And the
- 56:17purpose of that is to use the power of the court,
- 56:19use subpoenas in order to try to identify them.
- 56:22But you're going to have to make out at least
- 56:24a prima facie case that it constitutes harassment.
- 56:28And so going back to some of the things I talked
- 56:30about earlier, what's the pattern? It's usually
- 56:32not one statement, but a pattern of conduct where
- 56:37somebody is using the internet, using accounts.
- 56:40You've tried to block them, and they're continuing
- 56:42to contact you. And you're going to have to show
- 56:45that that has, through declaration or otherwise,
- 56:47resulted in some sort of emotional. um, harm
- 56:49or reaction. And so, uh, you're going to have
- 56:52to make out, you know, a bare bones, prima facie
- 56:54case, um, just in terms of pleading, um, you
- 56:58know, being able to plead the elements and, and
- 57:00have enough, you know, meat on the bone, so to
- 57:02speak. But after that, um, you can use the power
- 57:04of the court in order to get subpoenas, uh, and
- 57:07try to identify that person. Uh, writing it and
- 57:12it looks like we have another question or. Perhaps
- 57:15two from Rhonda. One, is it considered doxing
- 57:19if you disclose someone's workplace? And two,
- 57:22is it harassment to invite people to demand a
- 57:24player action over some specific conduct? Let
- 57:28me start with the first one. So if you disclose
- 57:33somebody's personal information, there's two
- 57:36parts of it. So one is the disclosure of the
- 57:38information. Home address is covered. telephone
- 57:42numbers covered. I don't know, and I'd have to
- 57:44look at the law whether a workplace is covered.
- 57:47It would be, I think if it's a place that would
- 57:50reveal like, you know, where you are at certain
- 57:53times, but I would have to look at that. I don't
- 57:55recall whether a workplace is covered. But the
- 57:57second part of it, remember, is it has to be
- 58:00for the intent to, you know, harass and intimidate.
- 58:04And so, you know, the second question is, you
- 58:06know, what's the purpose and why is it being
- 58:08done? But, you know, Definitely your home address
- 58:11is protected. I'd have to look at the California
- 58:14statute to see if a workplace address would be
- 58:18protected as well. The federal statute is more
- 58:21narrow than the California statute. The federal
- 58:23statute only protects covered people, which are
- 58:26generally elected officials and sometimes government
- 58:31employees. So when I was a prosecutor, somebody
- 58:33doxed a prosecutor or an FBI agent, that would
- 58:36be covered conduct both under federal and state
- 58:39law. But I don't know the workplace part. And
- 58:41what was the second part of that question? Let's
- 58:46see. It was is it harassment to invite people
- 58:49to demand employer action over some specific
- 58:52conduct? No, not necessarily. I think that, you
- 59:00know, again, going back to harassment is, you
- 59:04know, so not necessarily that I'd have to know
- 59:06more facts, you know, typically for something
- 59:08to be harassment. Again, it needs to be a pattern.
- 59:11of conduct and designed to intimidate or cause
- 59:18somebody to feel emotionally unsafe. So it is
- 59:21not harassment in itself to make a demand that
- 59:26I understand to be described. All right, and
- 59:31I have another question from Christine. Thank
- 59:35you for this presentation. In family law, some
- 59:37judges seem to discount disturb the peace claims
- 59:40if there is no temporary criminal protective
- 59:43order. Your thoughts? Yeah, I mean, so I think
- 59:50that's a fair point. I do think that, so if I
- 59:55understand the question, judges will discount
- 59:59a disturbing the peace without a criminal protective
- 1:00:03order. Yeah, look, I guess my general advice
- 1:00:06about knowing more of the facts or circumstances
- 1:00:08there is the sooner you can get law enforcement
- 1:00:10involved, the better because they're able to
- 1:00:15develop a case factually, they're able to go
- 1:00:18out and do interviews. And also I think once
- 1:00:20there's been a law enforcement contact, what
- 1:00:22I've typically seen is if there's harassment,
- 1:00:26law enforcement goes out there. tell somebody
- 1:00:28to stop doing something, and then the person,
- 1:00:31the perpetrator, continues to do it or finds
- 1:00:33a workaround, I think you end up with a far more
- 1:00:36receptive audience with courts concluding that
- 1:00:41it's now crossed the line from what I will say
- 1:00:44is like uncomfortable conduct or lawful but awful
- 1:00:47into textbook harassment that would have potential
- 1:00:53criminal liability and penalties. Okay. Let's
- 1:01:04see, Nicole, I think this might be in reference
- 1:01:06to a previous question. Let's see, I guess the
- 1:01:11question is in reference to about litigants appearing
- 1:01:14in front of judges who have no clue about deepfake
- 1:01:17or revenge porn lawsuits saying that most employees
- 1:01:20don't know about revenge porn and deepfake. Yeah,
- 1:01:24so look, there's an educational component. I
- 1:01:26mean, part of obviously our role as lawyers is
- 1:01:28to educate. educate the court, I think that yes,
- 1:01:35most judges probably don't know about whether
- 1:01:38it's a take it down act or deepfakes generally.
- 1:01:43And I think that that is a place where you need
- 1:01:46to continue to educate the judiciary. I mean,
- 1:01:51frankly, look, there is a little bit candidly
- 1:01:53of an age Age awareness. I mean kids who are
- 1:02:00in high school and you know now in college frankly
- 1:02:04know more about the workings of online harassment
- 1:02:08and how people carry it out than, you know, most
- 1:02:11people, including lawyers, including myself.
- 1:02:13I mean, I just grew up in a different world and
- 1:02:15I don't think that, you know, judges are immune
- 1:02:17to that. I think that, you know, most people
- 1:02:20who, you know, particularly once you enter the
- 1:02:22bench, if you're not exposed to that, you're
- 1:02:24not going to necessarily understand what it is,
- 1:02:27how can it be... carried out and harmed. And
- 1:02:30so, yeah, I think it's an educational area for
- 1:02:33everybody, including the bench. And obviously,
- 1:02:38lawyers have a role in educating the courts when
- 1:02:42they make decisions. All righty. Looks like that's
- 1:02:50it for questions. Joseph, do you have any other
- 1:02:52concluding remarks you'd like to make for the
- 1:02:54audience to take home today? No, thank you. Thank
- 1:02:57you very much for your time and attention. And
- 1:02:59hopefully the information was helpful to you.
- 1:03:03Great. This concludes today's presentation. We'd
- 1:03:05like to thank Joseph McNally for an excellent
- 1:03:07presentation today, and I'd also love to extend
- 1:03:09a warm thanks to our audience for joining us.
- 1:03:12Have a great day, everyone.