Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Buckeyes Drop To Sixth In CFP Rankings - Is There Still A Playoff Path
Transcript
- 0:01Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdaman
- 0:05here with Kevin Dude because Tom Orr is running late, but also because it's
- 0:11a Tuesday CFP selection show, so we're doing our live watch along as always.
- 0:16Kevin, how's it going, Oh, it's going. Sitting here at
- 0:28the kitchen table, got a dog who is like tugging at my pant leg.
- 0:33I've got a cat who's sitting on the table staring at me. So
- 0:36I've got an audience going on, excited, curious. I guess to see
- 0:42what we get from the college football playoff rankings here and what that path is
- 0:49and how open the door may be for Ohio State to potentially sneak in to
- 0:54the playoffs. Seems a little, a little unlikely, but you know,
- 1:00this team has managed to find that side door before. They really only need
- 1:06one big upset, but obviously you need you need four things to happen,
- 1:11and Oklahoma State beating Texas is the most unlikely. But that is the very
- 1:15first thing that needs to happen on Saturday at twelve pm in the Big twelve
- 1:21championship game. If that stuff, if that game happens, if Oklahoma State
- 1:23beats Texas, then I think you can start to get excited and really start
- 1:29to get invested. And I don't know, I'm Texas is a type of
- 1:34program to choke away a big opportunity, so you might not even want to
- 1:38get your hopes up on that with Kevin Well. That series overall is twenty
- 1:44six to eleven, with Texas having the major edge, but oak State has
- 1:49won the last two games. There is a forty one to thirty four win
- 1:53in Stillwater and then that thirty two to twenty four win in Austin, So
- 2:00you know, you never know. And for all Texas likes to talk about
- 2:05being back, are they ever really back? And when games really matter the
- 2:12most does Texas answer that call? Now? Granted I lived in Dallas for
- 2:17five years. I got the full weight of listening to utlums and hangers on
- 2:23and everything else, and I quickly became somebody who rooted against them unless it
- 2:30came down to A and M. And then if it came down to A
- 2:32and M, then I rooted for Texas. But we'll see, we'll see
- 2:37well and Oklahoma State has the nation's leading rushier and Ali Gordon Texas has like
- 2:40the number five rush defense in a nation, so that'll be an interesting matchup
- 2:46there. The other things that need to happen. Obviously, Michigan needs to
- 2:50beat Iowa because if Michigan loses to that one, Michigan's out and they're not
- 2:53going to jump Ohio State over Michigan. You also need Florida State to lose
- 2:59to Louisville, and that's I think Louisville is like a three point underdog in
- 3:06that one right now, so that's not out of the realm of possibility.
- 3:09And then of course you need Georgia to beat Alabama, and that is also
- 3:15not out of the realm of possibility. So it all hinges for the most
- 3:17part on that first game. That's you'll know right away whether or not to
- 3:22get your hopes up or to uh to just maybe finally take a Saturday off
- 3:28from football. We will see. The Friday night Pac twelve game, to
- 3:30me, doesn't really have any factor in this because we know the Committee doesn't
- 3:37like Washington, so if they lose, they're gonna cast them off. The
- 3:40Committee really likes Oregon, so obviously they're in. But if they lose,
- 3:45then you're not. They're not gonna put a two loss team in there.
- 3:46So the Pac twelve is getting on one spot one way or the other,
- 3:53they're not not gonna get to So you don't really need to factor that one
- 3:54in my opinion, and so we can just everybody can just walk the Friday
- 4:00night game and watch the spectacle of Oregon versus Washington and what should be a
- 4:04shootout. I'm expecting Utah to come in there and tag in cash the money
- 4:11in the bank briefcase and do Ohio State's bidding for them, and then all
- 4:15of it to be interrupted by c empunk. Maybe I'll actually get back into
- 4:21wrestling because it seems that they're trying their best to make it interesting. But
- 4:28yeah, I think I think Louisville over Florida State. I feel pretty good
- 4:31about that one. Okay, Florida State beat Florida. Congratulations. So whatever
- 4:42you still have, you know, you still have your you know, your
- 4:44backup quarterback that isn't exactly the most I don't know, consistent guy. I
- 4:53think that there are just some issues when it comes to to Florida State.
- 4:58And I think that Louisville, wh I don't think it's a great Louisville team.
- 5:00I think that they have enough offense that they should be able to put
- 5:04a lot of pressure on Florida State just to try and keep up in scoring.
- 5:11I don't know how many Buckeye fans are going to be watching the selection
- 5:14show because there's going to be a lot of painful images there. I do
- 5:17wonder how far Ohio State drops tonight. Do they drop down to do they
- 5:25boy? Do they split up Texas and Alabama? Do they fall in there
- 5:29at like seven? Do they stay ahead of Oregon? I don't think so.
- 5:32Oregon with a big win over Oregon State, they may drop all the
- 5:38way down to eight behind Alabama. That seems they're sixth in both both the
- 5:44coaches poll and the AP pole. And I don't know that the committee really
- 5:47wants to punish Ohio State that much for losing on the road to the number
- 5:53three team at the time by six points. So I think dropping them seven
- 5:59spots for losing that game would be a bit much. I wonder if it
- 6:03would be a lot much in my opinion. No, I mean if they
- 6:08do that, then everything we've watched last month is did you just bleep yourself?
- 6:19Yeah? And that's why I think maybe we'll see them more in line
- 6:21with the AP and the coach pool at six. I wonder what they do
- 6:30with Florida State. Do they keep them at to move them up to four?
- 6:32I guess because they are still undefeated. Tom. Hey, everybody,
- 6:38let's welcome in Tom or Tom. I already used a very long pause on
- 6:42Kevin, So you're not even gonna get a welcome. How are you doing?
- 6:45How's it going? Nothing like that? Yeah, I'm late. Sorry,
- 6:48Sorry, everyone had to do a different podcast about Ohio State football schedules.
- 6:54Everything's wonderful, everything's great, as you all know, everything's great or
- 6:58anything involving Ohio State football right now. So, yes, it's all all
- 7:01good. Happy to be here here with you, Tony and Kevin and with
- 7:04of course the wonderful audience. Do you have a television on your time?
- 7:10I do? I mean not on me, but like right there, so
- 7:13yes, Ward Manual right now sitting there. Wonder how hard Ward Manual was
- 7:19arguing for fellow Big Ten member Ohio State to remain close to the top of
- 7:25the college football playoff rankings this weekend. Probably as hard as Jesse Minter.
- 7:32So they will, and they're just getting the show starting. They're going to
- 7:35start with the twenty five and go on down. And really at this point
- 7:42that is, I don't know that there's gonna be much debate anymore. Like
- 7:46this is all going to work itself out pretty well, I think over this
- 7:50these next few days, and so I don't even know that they need to
- 7:54do much maneuvering down towards the end of the rankings this time around. And
- 7:59they're here and yeah, here we go. So number twenty five is Kansas
- 8:01state number twenty four, Liberty number twenty three, Clemson number twenty two,
- 8:05Tulane number twenty one, Tennessee So one big twelve, one CUSA to Liberty.
- 8:13It moves up one spot, one ACC in Clemson, one sun belt
- 8:18right or no AAC for Tulane, and one SEC for Tennessee. And so
- 8:22that's your that's your bottom five in the top twenty five. That's a really
- 8:26bad poker hand right there. There's like everything is off shoot. I didn't
- 8:28even know there were five suits, but you got them right there. Number
- 8:33twenty, Oregon state number nineteen, North Carolina state number eighteen, Oklahoma state
- 8:37number seventeen, Notre Dame number sixteen, Iowa so one Ohio state opponent in
- 8:45the top in the you know, in the sixteen through twenty five range.
- 8:50Michigan will only have Iowa in the sixteen to twenty five range. Just kind
- 8:58of another kind of royal old sampler of teams. Yeah, Iowa was a
- 9:03boxed punt return touchdown, and they went over Michigan away from playing in the
- 9:07playoffs at number fifteen, Arizona number fourteen, Louisville down only four spots,
- 9:16number thirteen, LSU number twelve, Oklahoma number eleven, Ole miss they get
- 9:22not a ton of movement that we were so close to a complete bloodbath at
- 9:26the top of the sport last week and then everyone sort of just barely won.
- 9:33Yeah, and if Oklahoma State could have lost to BYU, then I
- 9:39really think I had a would have had a pretty decent chance of getting into
- 9:43the playoffs, certainly a much better chance than they do now. But we'll
- 9:48we'll see what Ali Gordon can do against the Longhorns as we get ready for
- 9:52the top ten here and they'll go ten nine, eight seven, Yes,
- 9:58yes, so number ten. Penns stay there's so Ohio State's second second ranked
- 10:03win there and now it is a top ten win. So that's more than
- 10:07it did last week when Penn State was eleventh, so it would be pretty
- 10:13significant. Well, it doesn't really matter, but not seeing Ohio State in
- 10:16this group, which should be ten, nine eight, seven would fall right
- 10:20in line with the other polls. Number nine missoo unchanged after their win over
- 10:26Arkansas. And then this should be Alabama, you would think, unless they
- 10:37want to use Ohio State to split Texas and Alabama, but it would still
- 10:41be Alabama here. Yeah, I would have a very hard time justifying dropping
- 10:50Ohio State. What six spots for losing on the Yeah, there's number eight
- 10:56out I would have, Yeah, yeah, number eight Alabama and frankly,
- 11:01I think they should be number seven Texas. There should be again, not
- 11:05that not that it really matters a whole heck of a lot, because it's
- 11:07going to sort itself out next weekend. But I think that would be very
- 11:11hard to justify dropping Ohio State. That many spots for as close loss on
- 11:15the road. Yes, number seven Texas, I think so seven Texas,
- 11:20eight, Alabama, nine Missouri, ten, Penn State. What is the
- 11:24highest you could see Ohio State potentially being? You know, is there an
- 11:28argument and I'm not making the argument, but I'm asking is there an argument
- 11:31for Ohio State to be number three because you know, if you know,
- 11:35hey, maybe they jump Michigan to number one for their big win over Ohio
- 11:39State or whatever Ohio State is. You know, just lost to a team
- 11:45who is, you know, number one or number two in the country on
- 11:48the road by you know, one score final minute, had a chance to
- 11:54win the game outright on the road in the final minute. You felt the
- 11:58resume was the second best resume in the country last year. Is there an
- 12:01argument to drop them only one spot? Kevin? I don't. I think
- 12:07three is too high. I could make an argument for four, and even
- 12:11with their I think I am kind of getting into the a little a little
- 12:18bit of the wishful thinking sauce. But three, really no, I just
- 12:24I can't see that. I mean, they're you could be committed to the
- 12:28bit, but you can't completely sell out. I just can't see three being
- 12:31there. What's the what's the argument that the rest? I mean, let's
- 12:35remember the top of the sport looked like absolute butt cheeks last week. So
- 12:41are you jumping Washington a bunch of spots because they barely won against Washington State?
- 12:48Are you, you know, Alabama looked like crap. They obviously didn't
- 12:52move. You know, Oregon had a good win over had a good win
- 12:58over Oregon State, but they didn't move up a ton, all right,
- 13:01So there you go Ohio State. So there you go. I was gonna
- 13:03say, I just don't know how you would have been able to put Ohio
- 13:07State above an undefeated team at at whatever point. So that's just, you
- 13:11know, that's just my feeling. I mean, I mean, Florida neutral
- 13:16field right now, Ohio State, Florida State. What's the line and who
- 13:18are you picking? I don't know what the line is, but I'm taking
- 13:22Ohio State right and that you're tim, you're absolutely correct. But the committee
- 13:30is also looking at the zero. They're looking at the twelve and zero,
- 13:33and that's what's getting it done right now for Florida State and Washington, because
- 13:39we know the Committee does not like Washington. The Committee would love to see
- 13:43Washington loose so that they can just drop them off. And there you go
- 13:46Oregon number five, and then this will be Florida State Washington, and then
- 13:52does Michigan move to number one. I don't Georgia if you lost it,
- 14:00yeah, but if you lost on the road against the number one team in
- 14:03the country. There's really no you just dropped them below Oregon. Who what's
- 14:07Oregon's best win this year? Is it as good as Penn State? Is
- 14:11it as good as no Notre Dame when they had a very similar loss.
- 14:18They had a very similar loss to Washington. So I don't think you could
- 14:22drop Ohio State to six, drop them four spots and then also say,
- 14:24and that was such an impressive win for Michigan that so Florida State up to
- 14:31four, so three Washington two. Michigan won Georgia probably presumably, Well,
- 14:37I haven't hit go on my graphic yet because I want to see what we
- 14:39get. Yeah, if I have to flip the top two teams or not,
- 14:43how I haven't built. Now, let's be fair. Georgia did beat
- 14:48their rival by eight points, and Michigan only beat their rival by six,
- 14:52So this is you know, let's let's stay real in all of this.
- 14:58There's so many us to be thankful for, family, friends, food,
- 15:01and NFL football all week long. Draftking Sports Book is keeping your Thanksgiving week
- 15:05full of action. New customers can bet just five bucks on the NFL Action
- 15:07to score one hundred and fifty instantly in bonus bets. No matter your appetite,
- 15:11there's something for you money, aliones, parlays, props, live bets,
- 15:13and so much more. You name it and they've got it. So
- 15:15download the DraftKings Sportsbook AP now and use code huddle up. New customers can
- 15:18bet five on the NFL Thanksgiving action to score one hundred and fifty instantly in
- 15:22bonus bets only on Draftking sports Book and official sports betting partner of the NFL
- 15:26with code huddle up. The Crown is yours. Gambling problem called one hundred
- 15:28gambler in New York call eight seven seven eight Hope n Y or text Hope
- 15:31n Y four six seven three sixty nine West Virginia. Visit www dot twenty
- 15:35hundred gambler dot net. Please play responsibly. In Connecticut, help is available
- 15:39for problem gambling called eight at eight seven eight nine seven seven seven seven or
- 15:41visit CCPG dot org on behalf of Boothell Casino and Resort. Kansas. Must
- 15:45be twenty one or older in most eligible states, but age varies by jurisdiction.
- 15:48See DraftKings dot com slash Sportsbook for details and state specific responsible gambling resources.
- 15:52Eligibility and deposit restrictions apply. Bonus bets expire one hundred and sixty eight
- 15:56hours after issuance. Terms at sportsbook dot DraftKings dot com slash football term David
- 16:03of Judea who needs to lose to the Ohio State get in. We will
- 16:08go over that. But basically, you need Texas to lose in the Big
- 16:12twelve Championship at twelve pm on Saturday. You need Alabama to lose in the
- 16:18SEC championship game, you need Florida State to lose in the ACC Championship game,
- 16:25and you need Iowa to lose any Big ten championship game. Really,
- 16:27the only big time massive upset would be Oklahoma State beating Texas. The others
- 16:33are either significant favorites or three point dogs in the Louisville things. So there's
- 16:38your one or two Georgia number one, Michigan number two. Go ahead and
- 16:42hit, go ahead and hit that graphic, Kevin show up. I have
- 16:48to save at first, give me a second. I still had it sitting
- 16:52in Photoshop and save that as a JPEG, not as a project. Yes,
- 16:59I know, I squashed layers, dot tnng, flatten the image,
- 17:04all that good stuff. Let me let me take the comment out and then
- 17:11boom, So there you go. Basically, Ohio State needs to be able
- 17:15to move up two spots. But right now, the SEC is guaranteed a
- 17:21spot with either Georgia or Alabama, and if Alabama wins, they're gonna probably
- 17:26there's a chance they get to in there. The PAC twelve is guaranteed a
- 17:30spot with the Washing the winner of Washington and Oregon. I don't think the
- 17:33committee's gonna put a Washington team that loses in there, and they're certainly not
- 17:40going to put an Oregon team that loses in there and gets a second loss.
- 17:42So there's a guaranteed spot for the PAC twelve, the SEC, and
- 17:48if Michigan wins, then the Big Ten and if Michigan loses, Ohio State's
- 17:52not jumping Michigan. So effectively, you have to consider the Big Ten already
- 17:56having a spot. So those three conferences have spots. So the ACC lose,
- 18:00you need the Big twelve to lose and then Ohio State can jump in
- 18:03there. Thank you. Yeah, I mean there are people in there that's
- 18:14saying that only Florida State needs to lose. You're going to have, you
- 18:18know, if Alabama wins you're getting two SEC teams in the championship, but
- 18:22in the final four ahead of Ohio State. If you know, the one
- 18:26of the Pac twelve teams is getting in for sure, Michigan is not is
- 18:30going to get in ahead of Ohio State. And you know, it's just
- 18:36I think there's lots of different ways that Ohio State could finish five. It
- 18:40feels like we're having this conversation every year is Ohio State, Four is Ohio
- 18:42State, five is Ohio State? Three is Ohio State? Six? Every
- 18:47year Ohio State is right in this range. It feels like, well,
- 18:51and the thing that people need to remember is once Texas wins the Big twelve
- 18:56championship, they have an extra data point over Ohio State. And the committee
- 19:00takes these four data points that they have, whether it's strength to schedule,
- 19:03do you have a conference championship, your record overall, there's one other thing
- 19:10in there, but when they are comparing teams, they're looking at the data
- 19:12points. How many ranked wins do you have. Ohio State has the win
- 19:17over Penn State, and that is it at this point in Notre Dame,
- 19:22and they don't have a conference championship. So when you're comparing them against a
- 19:25Texas who is either four or five or six or whatever. They have that
- 19:30conference championship, so they have that added data point over Ohio State, So
- 19:34you can't you don't want to be compared to a one loss conference championship champion
- 19:41because you guys have the same number of losses, probably the same number of
- 19:45ranked wins and actually one fewer perhaps, and you also don't have that conference
- 19:51championship data points. So they want they want to have conference champion champions in
- 19:56there if possible, and I'm not I just don't see them jumping Texas,
- 20:00especially if Texas has that win, and not jumping Texas staying ahead of Texas,
- 20:06I guess. But once Texas gets that extra data point, they're jumping
- 20:10to Ohio State. I guarantee it. And yeah, especially and you know,
- 20:14I think I think there's an argument to have Ohio State higher than six
- 20:18right now. But if now that they're six, you know, Texas,
- 20:23if they win, they have an extra data point, they're jumping one spot
- 20:26ahead of Ohio State. If Alabama wins over Georgia and beats the number one
- 20:33team as deemed by the committee, then they're jumping two spots and getting over
- 20:37Ohio State. That's that's why you're looking at this, you know, that's
- 20:41why we're saying that you probably need those three results to all align. Bama's
- 20:45possible, I said, Bama. If they beat Georgia, they probably go
- 20:51to depending on what happens in the fact twelve, two or three. You
- 20:55know, somewhere in there, Georgia drops to four and probably Michigan won two
- 21:00and fource that they don't play again and right my finals. Yeah, so
- 21:07so then you have Michigan number one. Great news, you get the you
- 21:10get the freebie, you play the number four team in the nation, and
- 21:12it's Georgia. Good luck with that boy. That's uh, that would probably
- 21:18not be how you know, whoever's lord know, who knows who's going to
- 21:22be coaching Michigan a month from now, But whoever it is, that would
- 21:25probably not be how they would wish to see that shakeout. Put Obama and
- 21:29Georgia out at the Rose Bowl, make them play in the Semis, and
- 21:32put them out at the Rose Ball. Now, if if Texas does win
- 21:36as expected, then yeah, I think at that point Buckeye fans would probably
- 21:42be rooting for Alabama to beat Georgia, so that there are two SEC teams
- 21:48in there to make road life maybe a little bit more difficult for Michigan.
- 21:53Well, and what's interesting is as well, yeah, I mean yeah,
- 21:57the PAC twelve is probably getting someone in and and you know, and then
- 22:02it's the question of does Texas get in over I mean, Oregon is ahead
- 22:06of I don't know that Texas is an automatic to get in because if Alabama
- 22:11beats Georgia, they're not leaving a one loss SEC champion Alabama out. They're
- 22:15not leaving number one Georgia, who's been number one all year and no one
- 22:21has got you know, they've been you know, Ohigo State jumped on with
- 22:22the one week or whatever. But I don't think you're leaving Georgia out.
- 22:29And whoever wins the PAC twelve is ahead of Texas right now and has is
- 22:37going to have a better win this weekend than whatever Texas is going to get
- 22:40against Oklahoma State. So I don't see Texas jumping the PACK twelve champion.
- 22:45So in that case, it's you know, one one Michigan, two Alabama
- 22:53or two or two PAC twelve champion, it doesn't really matter. That's that's
- 22:57one of those situations where the two three game is just about what color jersey
- 23:00you're wearing. Two versus three makes no difference at all. So one one
- 23:06Michigan versus four Georgia, and two versus three is Alabama versus whoever wins the
- 23:10Pac twelve probably at that point well, and then this super chat from Todd
- 23:14Shreeves makes things a little bit more difficult. Will Obama jump FSU if they
- 23:17beat Georgia. Florida State still undefeated at this point, playing Louisville in the
- 23:22ACC championship game, that's going to be something that they kind of like Ohio
- 23:27State, although Ohio State was not undefeated in twenty fourteen. I think Florida
- 23:32State needs to look good against Louisville to earn the benefit of the doubt with
- 23:37a backup quarterback. And I don't know is the second team guy he got
- 23:41banged up against Florida and they went to I believe Rock Glen they're number three
- 23:47at some point in there. And not that you can't win it all with
- 23:48a third string quarterback, but you're asking Florida State can't. You're asking the
- 23:55committee to give an awful lot of benefit of the doubt there when they do
- 23:59pay attention to injuries, and they have talked about that in the past and
- 24:03with the way like I don't think you can leave Oregon out over an undefeated
- 24:07Florida State. You also want to have you want to have the four best
- 24:11teams, and you want to have for the two best three best games and
- 24:17having Florida State and there. If you don't have to have them in there,
- 24:19the committee is not gonna want to want them in there, and so
- 24:22they're going to find a justifiable way to to keep them out. And you
- 24:29need you need Oregon. Like I gues, I believe the PAC twelve is
- 24:33getting one in there. The fun part is the the Texas, Alabama,
- 24:37Florida State thing. If all three of those teams win, what they're going
- 24:42to do there, because the committee has held Alabama behind Texas all season long
- 24:48since since Texas got that win, or since the rankings started a few weeks
- 24:52back, I have said that I don't think that Alabama will remain there behind
- 24:59Texas with a win over Georgia because that's that is something that is very significant,
- 25:06beating Georgia and in the SEC Championship game, that's an added data point,
- 25:10and once Texas got their loss, then you start you throw things into
- 25:15question like you can out. You don't just stick with head to head once
- 25:18there is another loss in there, because they will take that Texas loss to
- 25:23Oklahoma into consideration. Whoever it was like that that's going to come into play
- 25:29more now it was Oklahoma. Yeah. I want to address this because I
- 25:33think people are saying, like, oh, look, there's a lot of
- 25:36like I can't believe you're saying this, and I'm like, what are we
- 25:37saying that that controversial? I can't believe you're saying an undefeeded underfeed underfeed Florida
- 25:44State shouldn't get in ahead of you need your head examines. This is either
- 25:48this is either a bit or someone who doesn't understand words, and based on
- 25:55the spelling, I'm guessing it is the latter. But no one is saying
- 25:56that. No one is saying that they're saying. We're saying they might not
- 26:02get in over a one loss Alabama or a one loss Texas or a one
- 26:07loss Oregon. No one is making the case for Ohio State to jump and
- 26:11undefeated Florida State. That's very obviously not going to happen. Florida State is
- 26:18if they win, they're undefeated or underfeed and are a couple spots ahead and
- 26:23get the conference championship bonus. That's very obviously not going to happen. So
- 26:26no, that's not what we're saying. Nop never said that. I wouldn't
- 26:30say that, because again, the conference championship is not only one data point,
- 26:36but the undefeated season is another data point. So Florida State would basically
- 26:41have two data points over Ohio State no matter what the line would be,
- 26:45which I think Ohio State would be favored on a neutral field without Jordan Travis.
- 26:51I believe that's not an outrageous statement. No, and that was something
- 26:56we said earlier in the show. I mean, yeah, I truly believe
- 26:59with all of Ohio State's wards at Ohio State would absolutely beat Florida State on
- 27:03a neutral field based on both of the rosters right now, in a high
- 27:07leverage game where there were no opt outs, or in which the College Football
- 27:11Playoffs semi final would be a high leverage game, I believe Ohio State would
- 27:15win that game for you know, eight out of ten times. I'd say
- 27:22eight out of ten times. I'm not sold on this Florida State team without
- 27:25Jordan Travis. They've had to deal with some other injuries as well along the
- 27:30way. And that's on one side. But on the other side, we're
- 27:33talking about what the records are. And they're undefeated, and they go on
- 27:37and they win to acc and are thirteen to zero. It doesn't matter what
- 27:41would happen on the field. At some point, you do have to look
- 27:45at the records. Ben Higgins with the Oklahoma State, Michigan, Loleusville,
- 27:49and Georgia money line. Parl line is plus eighteen hundred. Parlay is plus
- 27:53eighteen hundred. I looked at that the other day. It was like plus
- 27:56seventeen hundred, So that the odds are getting longer longer. If you throw
- 28:00ten bucks at it, you went one hundred and eighty bucks. What more
- 28:03could you want from life? And you what if they're twenty you can win
- 28:07even more. But just know parlays are not anybody's friend. Yeah, I
- 28:15put ten bucks. I have a little bit of a different one. I'm
- 28:17trying to log in, but it's like ten bucks to win like seven hundred
- 28:21dollars or something like that, and I don't I left the big ten out
- 28:25of there because you added the Pack twelve. I added the Pac twelve.
- 28:29That's right. And now, of course DraftKings is making me hit all sorts
- 28:32of extra buttons. Did you see what the first half over under for yes
- 28:37Iowa is, Yes, zero point five. Did you see what the second
- 28:41half over under for Iowa is a zero point five? And it's very good,
- 28:48close enough to even money that you can just say, will they score
- 28:52some points in one half of this game? And it's basically a straight up
- 28:57bet. It was like minus one thirty or something like that. When I
- 29:00saw it, minus one twenty something like that. It was it was close
- 29:03enough. It is even in a year when they have invented new ways to
- 29:07come up with lions that are like, this team is so bad on offense,
- 29:12this is this is remarkable even by those standards. I would take the
- 29:15under in the first half the over in the second half. Yeah, I
- 29:19think that's fair. Looking at the strength of schedule rank on the Alabama Ohio
- 29:26State strength of record Alabama seventh, Ohio State fifth. Strength the schedule Alabama
- 29:30thirty first, Ohio State sixth. But again, there's no point comparing them
- 29:36right now because the next datade is gonna be the most important between those two,
- 29:40whether it's a second loss for Alabama or an SEC title. I just
- 29:47I saw and just to address the comment that's on the screen, that issue
- 29:51has been resolved. I was wondering if this person was literally that stupid or
- 29:55trolling, and at this point I can't determine. And so now and now
- 29:59we're done. Tom is much meaner than me. I generally let the chat
- 30:03take care of people and just tell them that they're stupid rather than be given
- 30:07them the gate. But I'm off for it. I mean, he needed
- 30:10to go on the trolls fort Wayne Buck as of today, are any of
- 30:15you picking Bama over Georgia? And the Alabama that I saw on Saturday,
- 30:21I would say no. However, the Georgia that I saw on Saturday,
- 30:25I would say yes. So I don't know what to that that Georgia team.
- 30:29Their three top receivers were out Maconkey, and I can't tell you who
- 30:33the other guys are. I'm sure it was kind of a precautionary measure.
- 30:38In a large amount, this Georgia team is not the most explosive team that
- 30:45they've had during their championship run by any search of imagination. But I think
- 30:51that Georgia, with the defense of mind coach will have a pretty decent answer
- 30:55for what Jalen Milroe can do, which is run the ball and throw deep.
- 30:59That is what Jalen Milroe does, and I think that I really,
- 31:03I really like Georgia to win in that game. I'm not super impressed with
- 31:07either Ohio State according to the All State Playoff predictor, nine percent chance of
- 31:14making the playoffs, so just shy of one in ten. That's still you
- 31:18know, pick a number between one and ten. You pick that every so
- 31:22often. It's better. It's better than Kenow. I wonder what that number
- 31:27would be if Oklahoma's state had lost to BYU this week and it was Oklahoma
- 31:32versus Texas. I bet you'd it'd be in the twenties, maybe maybe thirty
- 31:36percent something like that. Yeah, I mean you're I mean, nine percent
- 31:41honestly feels high because what did we say the parlay was for Ohio State.
- 31:45It was plus eighteen plus eighteen hundred, So that's that's higher than you know,
- 31:52that would be a plus eleven hundred to get to a nine percent result,
- 31:57So you know, I mean nine percent honestly, feels a little bit
- 32:01high. You're trying to hit like a you know, an inside straight or
- 32:05something here You're not it's you're It's possible, but it's not super likely.
- 32:13But it feels like how many how many years have we sat this weekend?
- 32:16I go back to the BCS. The first year of the BCS in nineteen
- 32:19ninety eight, no Ho State had lost to Michigan State. It was a
- 32:22different system. You had to be top two, and they needed who was
- 32:28it, Kansas State to lose to Texas A and m and then that happened
- 32:32in the Big twelve championship game and they needed something else to oh it was
- 32:36UCLA to lose to Miami in the hurricane makeup game, and that happened,
- 32:43and then they needed Mississippi State to beat Tennessee in the SEC Championship game,
- 32:47and then that almost happened, and it was it went down to the final
- 32:51five minutes and then Tennessee one, and so Tennessee got to play Florida State
- 32:54for the national title that year. But it feels like we do this just
- 32:58about every year that it's always are they in? Are they out? Are
- 33:01they? You know? Ohio State has been perpetually one of the third,
- 33:06fourth, or fifth best teams in the country for basically the entirety of the
- 33:08college football playoff system. Really quick plus eighteen hundred has implied odds of five
- 33:15point two six percent. So yeah, yeah, and Tooma just wanted to
- 33:21correct you. It was Clint Starter and Arkansas with the fumbball. That was
- 33:25no, that was that was weeks before I was. That was the week
- 33:30of the Ohio State Iowa game. That was the week of the House Date
- 33:31Iowa game. Yeah, that was also a significant thing that if that doesn't
- 33:37happen, Tennessee is but yeah, then the Mississippi State thing. But a
- 33:43lot of things could have happened for high states. Some of it did obviously
- 33:45that one was one of them. And then even the season opener with Tennessee
- 33:52getting a win over Syracuse to start the season because we listened. I think
- 33:57we listened to that in the parking lot of the West Virginia game and like
- 34:01there's a fumble late in that game in Tennessee looked out in that one.
- 34:07Like if they don't get that, then their issues there as well for Ohio
- 34:10State. Are chances there for Ohio State. So not everything is like two
- 34:15thousand and seven, but some years are close in parts. When when do
- 34:20you have to I'm not trying to rush you off. I'm trying to get
- 34:22to dinner after this. When is Boo Corgan's call seven, Kevin, it's
- 34:28not really ex wanted to explore the room for a little while after just hang
- 34:32out. Well, you guys know how to turn the chat offs. That's
- 34:37fine. As long as I'm out of here by ten after eight, I
- 34:40won't get yelled at their Just going to the local pizza place next like a
- 34:44mile from the house, yeap, won't be an issue. But yeah,
- 34:47I'll jump off here like five minutes or so. When I was hoping the
- 34:52show, I was hoping with a thirty minute show, that they were going
- 34:55to have him on the call at like thirty five and not forty five.
- 35:00I mean, who's going to get on there and demand stuff? I demand
- 35:05to know why this is the this is the case for this, I'm sure.
- 35:07I Mean, there's the big question is why Georgia won over Michigan two
- 35:13with you know, with Michigan having the best win of the season so far
- 35:16over Ohio State. Even though Michigan fans in there, you know in their
- 35:22lee have tried. You know, it's like the overrated chant. You should
- 35:24be sitting there saying, wow, this is like the greatest Ohio steep State
- 35:29team ever to try and sit there and add more juice to the win.
- 35:34Well. In fact, I have not heard any any Michigan fans touting Ohio
- 35:37State's skill levels or talents or or toughness following that game. So I think
- 35:44they've they They've diminished to win plenty on their own, So I don't think
- 35:49we need to worry about that. But sorry, I got my cat bothering
- 35:54me. Yeah, I don't really understand the rush to diminished that win.
- 36:06That was you know that that was two teams that are top I mean five
- 36:10teams in the nation in terms of how many teams would they be favored to
- 36:14beat, and the game came down to the final minute. Like I mean,
- 36:17you can make a case that, you know, if you want to
- 36:22argue, oh, this just proves at I say, it's terrible. I
- 36:24mean, you can do that, but I you know, I would certainly
- 36:30hope that if I was going to be a top two team in the nation,
- 36:31I would be able to beat a terrible team by more than you know,
- 36:36thirty seconds worth of football and forty yards or so. But you know,
- 36:40that's that is the nature of rivalry as we see it. You know,
- 36:45who right now to you is the team that you're picking a national champion?
- 36:51Who is the team that you're picking right now of the you know,
- 36:54assume it's Chalky or Chalk adjacent. Who are you actually picking to win the
- 37:00national championship right now? I'm trying not to get swept up in Oregon's dominance
- 37:07and their explosive offense and just the constant pressure then that they're putting on there.
- 37:15Carson Beck has throwing the ball really well. For Georgia, they're running
- 37:19the ball well. I think the ugliest luggest thing against Georgia Tech is it's
- 37:23Georgia Tech. You know, you don't have to give them much, and
- 37:27so that that can be a sleepwalk game. I'm I'm not picking up picking
- 37:34against Georgia right now because they can also take it easy against Alabama if they
- 37:37want to. It's just they can almost pick their opponent in terms of you
- 37:43know, do you want Alabama in the playoff again, then go ahead and
- 37:46lose the game or obviously they're not going to do that on purpose. But
- 37:51I need to see Georgia lose to one of these teams before I would believe
- 37:54it. And really, to me, the two best teams right now are
- 37:58Georgia and Oregon, and I think that's what it comes down to. I
- 38:01just I would be disappointed if the committee puts them in the same bracket unless
- 38:07there's just no other way to do it. Yeah, you pick the teams
- 38:09I had there. I would say Georgia just because they know how to win
- 38:15these games. They know how to win this little four team tournament, don't
- 38:20I think of the three Georgia teams, this one is by far the worst
- 38:23of the three Georgia teams. I think Oregon is by far the scariest team
- 38:30in terms of a matchup in a small series, I would prefer. I
- 38:36would prefer to play Oregon in the semi finals and have a month of preparation,
- 38:42then play them in the finals and have a leak. So there's that.
- 38:47I mean, Obviously, I don't think that the noise around Michigan is
- 38:53going away anytime soon. They've done a great job of blocking it out.
- 39:00You do get Jim Harbaugh back. I mean, you certainly have some battle
- 39:05scars in terms of winning three games down the stretch, the only three games
- 39:10on your schedule under adverse situations, and then that fourth spot, whether it
- 39:16be Florida State or whoever. You know, please please collect your your gift
- 39:23suite voucher and your your your logoed hat on your way out the door,
- 39:30and please clean up your locker room on the way out. Yeah, Florida
- 39:35State. Just that feels like every year there's a team. Normally that team
- 39:39is coached by Lincoln Riley. But normally there's a team that comes in and
- 39:43it's just kind of like, well, that's a first round by and the
- 39:45only you know, normally that team comes out of the Big twelve. This
- 39:50is you know, which that was true every year right up until last year
- 39:53when something weird happened. I don't I wouldn't want to speculate and what happened
- 39:58that was weird last year, but something weird happen. But it's generally the
- 40:01team that sort of squeaks by all year that is not the most you know,
- 40:07if you look at the blue chip ratio, it's not the team with
- 40:09the most talent. It's not the team with them. But you know,
- 40:12the the you know that all the guys who are going to be future top
- 40:16top ten draft picks. It's the team that you know is the heart of
- 40:20the champion and whatever, and they scrape by, and it's it's like the
- 40:25twenty fourteen Seminoles where you know, yeah, they were the defending national champions,
- 40:30and well, you can't drop it. You can't leave them out,
- 40:31even though they've looked like crap all season. You can't leave them out.
- 40:36And then you don't leave them out, and then they give up fifty fifty
- 40:38nine to twenty to Oregon and the Rose Bowl that year, and it's like,
- 40:42Oh, turns out the rent game due? How about that? That
- 40:45feels like that's going to be if Florida's date gets in this year, that's
- 40:50they are going to be a Rent comes due team this year. For sure.
- 40:52Yeah, they would be the sacrificial buy basically. And at this point,
- 40:57you don't need to do that. You don't need to do what you
- 41:00know is inevitable. You can put somebody else in their congratulations on your season,
- 41:07but you're you're not the same team. You're you're no longer the team
- 41:12you have out there now is not the team that went eleven and zero.
- 41:15This is the team you have out there now has been two and oh,
- 41:20three and ohor whatever. It is, so congratulations there, but they have
- 41:22not looked the same since Jordan Travis went down. And at this point you're
- 41:28just trying to argue. I don't know if it's semantics or just like it's
- 41:31like a gotcha, but but we're we're still undefeated, so we've got to
- 41:36be let in. And that's why I say, you gotta they have to
- 41:39look really really good in the conference championship game and you can't struggle with the
- 41:44Louisville team that has now lost to Pittsburgh and Kentucky. You've got to you
- 41:50might have to do a fifty nine nothing for nothing, forty two seven something
- 41:52like that. And I still don't think that's gonna be enough to get in
- 41:57over all Obama or Georgia in terms of whoever, you know, whether the
- 42:04SEC gets two in there, I just they're not going to get the benefit
- 42:07of the doubt. They're gonna have to blow Louisville out and then still also
- 42:12I think get a little bit of help and have other teams not look nearly
- 42:16as impressive. And with that I will I will drop out here. I'll
- 42:21go jump on the call and we'll come back and see book. Organ is
- 42:24gonna answer a bunch of questions with we don't look ahead, because people are
- 42:28gonna say what if, and he's gonna say, we don't do what if,
- 42:30we don't do hypotheticals. Please next question, So I will ask him
- 42:35if they start with a clean sheet every week? Please done for you,
- 42:38Kevin anything, Thank you. I'm just kind of scrolling through this and a
- 42:45few quick things I think we can handle. Joe says, I think Washington
- 42:50is out as if they lose. I don't think there's any argument to keep
- 42:52Washington in because Washington their best win is against Oregon, and other than that,
- 43:00they've had a bunch of really close games recently. They looked. They
- 43:02were close against Oregon State two weeks ago, they were close against at Washington
- 43:07State this week. They have not been overly impressive. If you beat Oregon
- 43:13again, sure you're in. And if you don't beat Oregon, I think
- 43:15you're pretty clearly out and you're pretty clearly fall because that was a Washington team
- 43:20that was judged way behind, you know, well behind Ohio State, well
- 43:25behind Michigan, before, you know, before last week, and I don't
- 43:30you know Oregon's gonna jump them. I think I think that they're pretty clearly
- 43:35out if they don't if they don't win, Jordan Kapler apparently has changed teams.
- 43:39Glad I joined in as soon as Tony is leaving. My two favorite
- 43:43people, Tom and Kevin. Is all we need. Kevin your reaction.
- 43:49I'm glad that Jordan has finally seen the light. Apparently the year ends on
- 43:53November twenty seventh and starts on November twenty eighth, and we all can recognize
- 43:58Tony for the rat master that he is. It is. It is an
- 44:04odd way to do your fiscal year, but I am you know, I'm
- 44:07not a CPA, so I'm not in a place to in a place to
- 44:10judge. Joe s wants to know why is Ohio State behind Oregon and the
- 44:16closest, because I do agree the resume for Ohio State right now is better
- 44:21than the resume for Oregon, just in terms of they beat number ten Washington
- 44:25or number ten Penn State, they beat number fifteen or whatever. It is
- 44:30notre dame. Those are better wins in Oregon. Has the loss is you
- 44:34know similar in terms of top four team on the road down to the last,
- 44:39you know, last minute of the game, similar losses. I think
- 44:43to me, Kevin, the difference there is when when did you lose your
- 44:46game? Oh, we know that that matters so much. When you lose
- 44:51your game certainly is you know, it's fresh on their minds and they see
- 44:55that and suddenly you you don't know what at SOS or so O R or
- 45:00any of that stuff is because of when it happens, and there needs to
- 45:06be immediate action because you lost your game. And we're talking about Ohio State,
- 45:12a team that moves down when it wins and moves much further down when
- 45:15it loses. I mean, I'm not I'm not explaining the loss away.
- 45:20I'm not saying the loss didn't occur. I'm not saying that Ohio State shouldn't
- 45:22have dropped. Ohio State absolutely should have dropped. But I went into tonight
- 45:29thinking that five was going to be where they would land because at the end
- 45:34of the at the end of the whole argument, it really doesn't matter because
- 45:37once you get that to thirteenth data point, the numbers are going to change
- 45:40again. So we've seen teams lose and drop two spots. So and based
- 45:49on just the number of undefeateds, you could have easily made an argument that
- 45:52Ohio State would drop to the top of the one loss teams just based on
- 45:55how they viewed everything prior. But it didn't. And you know, on
- 46:00the other side, it doesn't really hurt Ohio State because if Ohio State goes
- 46:05runner Runner on fourth and fifth Street, what their ranking was on the twenty
- 46:12eighth in November is has nothing to do with what their ranking is going to
- 46:15be on whatever that is December fourth. I saw a comment from Teddy earlier
- 46:22and about how we're extremely rational ninety percent of the time in ten percent were
- 46:25complete OSU homers, and I have been trying to figure out what fan is
- 46:30he? What kind of fan is he that he finds we're homers. I'm
- 46:35scrolling back. He said, I don't think Ohio State should be rewarded for
- 46:37not having to play this weekend. They should not jump Georgia, Michigan or
- 46:39Washington in the case of any of their losses. What is the case.
- 46:45I mean, Ohio State was ahead of Washington all season, like Georgia and
- 46:51Michigan. Sure, that's fine. I would agree with that make the case
- 46:54for me that Washington should be ahead of Ohio State that they're I mean,
- 47:00they beat Oregon like two months ago, close last play the game, what's
- 47:07their second best win. I mean, they look like crap against Oregon State.
- 47:09They look like crap against Washington State. They have not looked the same
- 47:14the last few weeks. And it's not like there's not a ton of precedent
- 47:16for teams losing in the championship game and teams not playing in the championship game
- 47:22jumping over them, especially if those teams were ranked ahead of them a week
- 47:25or two earlier. We just saw that last year with Ohio State over jumping
- 47:30over USC after USC lost the Pac telve championship game. Like, I think
- 47:35that's to say that I think is probably not reflective of understanding how the committee
- 47:40generally works. I think that's just, you know, there's plenty of there's
- 47:44plenty of examples of that happening. So I don't think that requires being Ohio
- 47:47State homers to say that that's a possibility this year. And here's a dirty
- 47:52little secret. The networks would much rather see you know, ties going to
- 47:58go to bigger draw on TV and Ohio state. I don't care how many
- 48:02households there are in Seattle. The Washington Huskies turn on about thirty four televisions
- 48:08and maybe one bar in Ohio state is one of the biggest draws out there.
- 48:14And call it, you know, call it, you know, conspiracy
- 48:17theory, whatever. I truly believe that that is considered when it when you
- 48:22come down to making some of those decisions. Now, that did not keep
- 48:27Cincinnati Cincinnati out the year that it went there, but I think that there's
- 48:32something to be said about that, and I'm not We can all argue who
- 48:37was the best conference this year? Wasn't the Big ten and it was two
- 48:39and a half teams deep, and you could still believe that the PAC twelve
- 48:44was the best conference out there and does not deserve two teams in the playoffs.
- 48:50And you know that's I and that's why I think that if if Washington
- 48:54loses, I think, you know, they've been they've tried everything they can
- 48:58to keep Washington down as much as possible, and if they lose to Oregon,
- 49:05they're gone. They're gone, They're they're just they're not going to be
- 49:08part of the equation. Yeah, I mean, you go through Washington schedule,
- 49:13and they beat Arizona, which is now looking like a pretty decent win
- 49:17thirty one, twenty four on the road. They beat Oregon by three at
- 49:22home, but they have had a lot like they're basically they're last since that
- 49:27Oregon win, which was October fourteenth, fifteen to seven against Arizona State at
- 49:31home, fifteen to seven, forty two, thirty three against against Stanford,
- 49:36fifty two to forty two against USC thirty five, twenty eight against Utah,
- 49:40twenty two to twenty against Oregon State, twenty four to twenty one against Washington
- 49:44State. Washington might be a the rent comes do team this year, even
- 49:51if they do beat Oregon, I just I don't they're fine. They have
- 49:57a really you know, that's a good win against Oregon, for sure,
- 50:00but you know, you go through the schedule and it's like it's not they're
- 50:02not dominating anyone. The Oregon is I think the better team. I would
- 50:07certainly pick Oregon to win this weekend, and I would pick I think I
- 50:12would pick any of the other teams we're talking about in this conversation Georgia,
- 50:17Michigan, Ohio State, Texas. I think I would pick Oregon all of
- 50:23them, I think to beat Washington outside of you know, Florida State,
- 50:28who I think is Florida State is the ultimate. The rent is about to
- 50:30come do team, whether that happens this weekend or in the first round of
- 50:34the playoffs, right, I mean, I just don't think that, you
- 50:37know, obviously, with the injury to Jordan Travis and everything else, and
- 50:43if we're talking about maybe the worst conferences this year, the ACC, I
- 50:46don't care how much you prop up. You try to prop them up with
- 50:50you and c and everything else, the ACC was by far the least competitive,
- 50:54least enjoyable product to watch out there, with Miami being Miami and Clemson
- 51:00not really being all that good, and you would see despite having Drake may
- 51:05not being worth a crap. I mean it's there. They are operating with
- 51:10a smaller net than anybody, and I think any excuse to get them out
- 51:15is going to be going to be used. Marcus Earlias Maximus says, if
- 51:20Bama beats Georgia, one of the odds there is no SEC team in the
- 51:22playoffs this year based on the College Football Playoff commtee MATH, neither will move
- 51:25up enough and Georgia will be out of the top four. I think the
- 51:30odds of that happening are zero. I think that in that case, if
- 51:35you set the over under on you know, Bama beats Georgia over under on
- 51:39number of SEC teams in the playoff, there's you know, some of that's
- 51:45going to depend on what else happens this weekend. But I would put the
- 51:49over under on the number of SEC team teams in the playoff at one point
- 51:52five, and I would probably lean pretty heavily towards betting the over in that
- 51:55case. Yeah, I agree. I think that there's not a scenario in
- 52:01my mind of where there is not an SEC team in there. If Georgia
- 52:07wins, obviously they write in I guess as the one. If Bama wins
- 52:13a close one, then you know, where where do you go from there?
- 52:16I mean, how are you not having a team in at that point
- 52:19with you know, a one lost Bama that's you know, still kind of
- 52:22a darling. And Bama comes in and crushes Georgia, Then you know where
- 52:25do you go from there? I mean, then then it's even that much
- 52:28more impressive. I just I think one point five. I think it's going
- 52:31to be one. I think they're going to get one team in. I
- 52:35don't think that, you know, I'm kind of I'm kind of arguing against
- 52:39the point of Ohio State finding a way to sneak itself in. I think
- 52:43this is going to be the year if they can make sure that it is
- 52:46four conferences represented, that's what they're going to do. This is the last
- 52:51year of the four team playoff. There's going to need to be a really
- 52:53compelling case to have two teams from any conference in there. And I know,
- 52:59again hurts the argument for Ohio State, and you know, it is
- 53:02what it is. When your games, Yeah, when your games is exactly
- 53:07right, Todd says PACK twelve is complete trash. Look at their non conference?
- 53:14Is that that is one of those statements that would have been true any
- 53:16of a number of the past oh probably like five out of the last five
- 53:22years. I don't think that's true. This year, the PAC twelve is
- 53:23actually really good non conference. Now, some of those have not necessarily stood
- 53:28up in the way that you might have thought. You know, I go
- 53:30back to Week one when Utah beat Florida and it was like, oh man,
- 53:36look at that, and then Florida is what six and six something like
- 53:40that. There were a bunch of you know, Washington beat Michigan State.
- 53:45Well, that one didn't hold up very well either in terms of impact.
- 53:47Washington State beat Wisconsin, that one didn't hold up really well in terms of
- 53:52impact, but they won their games. They were I think at one point
- 53:57they were like the last team to be completely un defeated in as a league.
- 54:01They were nineteen and oh or something like that at the start of the
- 54:04season, and not all of thosees have held up, but they certainly this
- 54:08was a better, much better Pac twelve than a lot of recent years.
- 54:12I think a lot of that comes down to quarterback play. You know,
- 54:15you look at USC with Caleb Williams. They got off to a good start
- 54:17the season. What happened after that, Well we're out of time. But
- 54:22you know, Oregon with bow Nicks, Washington with Michael Pennix, that is
- 54:25a level of quarterback play that the Pac twelve has not had for a long
- 54:29time. They had it this year. All those guys are to be gone
- 54:31next year when those teams are playing in the Big Ten, So I think
- 54:34that might be you might have a little regression to the mean for all of
- 54:37those teams next year. But the PAC twelve is not complete trash this year.
- 54:42No, I mean, we all think about the you know, I
- 54:44don't think anybody plays Cal State Bakersfield, but it feels like it. But
- 54:49you have Donkey games in every you know, in every conference, and it
- 54:53does feel like there's a lot of middling in the in the in the PAC
- 54:58twelve. And part of the issue I really think with why other conferences had
- 55:04more ranked teams is because the Big Ten was so top heavy. You never,
- 55:08I mean, you had Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State always ranked
- 55:14throughout, I mean and ranked highly. You know, Maryland came pretty close
- 55:17to sniffing Iowa's been ranked in the CFP rankings before, but nobody else has
- 55:23really deserved to be even mentioned in there. So when everything is so high
- 55:28and you have twelve toero eleven and one ten and two right there, it's
- 55:32a zero sum game once you get into conference play. Somebody wins a game
- 55:37and somebody loses a game. And there were just a lot of losses out
- 55:40there. So I understand what Todd was saying about the PAC twelve, you
- 55:45know, potentially being trash, but I don't agree. Utah, who normally
- 55:52is a team that seems to represent them a little bit more was down because
- 55:57Cam Rising never played this year. I mean we all had to we all
- 56:01had to listen to all of the bullpucky about Colorado to start the season.
- 56:08You know. That's that's kind of sorting itself out with where it is now.
- 56:13It's recruiting classes falling apart. Sean Lewis, who got taken out of
- 56:16the play collar role, looks like if he, if it hasn't happened why
- 56:21we've been on the air, is going to be the next head coach in
- 56:22San Diego State, you know. And then of course you have the cold
- 56:28and Stanford, who just are not very good period. Yeah, Stanford lost
- 56:31to Sacramento State. There were only like three or four FCS over FBS upsets
- 56:37this year, and that was one of them. And you know, that's
- 56:38a that's a first year coach for Stanford, so transition year and all that,
- 56:43and that was actually the former Sacramento State head coach. Is it Troy
- 56:47Taylor or am I thinking of the wrong person. I think it's Troy Taylor,
- 56:51but it's not Trooper Taylor. Yeah, it's not Trooper Taylor. No,
- 56:55with his with his towel from Nadimchmed. If Florida State loses in Texas
- 57:01wins, does Texas get the spot over Ohio State. Yes, that that
- 57:05is Texas is right now one spot behind Ohio State. If if Ohio State
- 57:09had dropped to four, for example, in Texas was seven, then you
- 57:14could potentially see a scenario where that extra extra data point of winning that packed
- 57:20the Big Twelve Championship wouldn't be enough to jump them one, you know,
- 57:22jump them three spots over Ohio State. With Ohio State dropping all the way
- 57:27to six, Texas jumping one spot for a you know, in the scenario
- 57:31where they win the win the Big Twelve. Yeah, I think I think
- 57:35that's pretty unquestionable. You got the Big Twelve Championship game, you got the
- 57:37win on the road in Tuscaloosa. That's you know, that's that's reasonable to
- 57:43me. Even if Ohio State had been two spots ahead, I would not
- 57:45have been you know, I would have expected Texas to jump over Ohio State
- 57:50before Ali said and done. Fort Wayne Buckeye just read that Mark Cuban is
- 57:52selling a majority stake in the MAVs. Think that's in part to pay Tom
- 57:57Allen's buyout. I mean, I also know that Mark Cuban said this is
- 58:04going to be his last season of Shark Tank, so maybe he's maybe he's
- 58:07going to start his own space company to go against other eccentric billionaires out there
- 58:13or something. I think that he probably has Tom Allen's buy out twenty million.
- 58:20I think it was probably in his sofa cushions. So I don't think
- 58:24that's why he's dumping them, But I know I can appreciate, you know,
- 58:29the joke that was being made there. Yeah, Sam Kim says Bama
- 58:34winning is a real headache for the committee. That is definitely when you potentially
- 58:37have something real crazy happening where you have like a real argument, because it
- 58:43feels like right now. Obviously, if it's chalk, it's real straightforward.
- 58:47If it's Georgia wins, Michigan wins, whoever wins the PAC twelve, and
- 58:54Florida State really takes care of business against Louisville, that's a real no drama.
- 59:00Top four one. If you get any of those top four teams losing
- 59:06other than you know, other than Washington. If you have any of those
- 59:08top four teams losing, that's where it gets real messy. You know,
- 59:13if Iowa, let's just say Iowa beats Michigan. If Iowa beats Michigan,
- 59:15Iowa's not getting in. So then it's at that point it's do you want
- 59:19Michigan in or not? If Alabama wins that Sam is exactly right. That's
- 59:23where it gets messy where you potentially have two teams from the same conference.
- 59:29That's where it gets you. You could have pretty much everyone else win and
- 59:31that's where it does get real, real messy, real dicey. You know
- 59:35for Ohio State taket and you need a lot of what you know, we
- 59:37talked about three other teams would need to lose to get Ohio State in at
- 59:42that point. So well, I'm not expecting that the you know, the
- 59:47the real chaos scenario, that's the most likely chaos scenario is Alabama beating Georgia
- 59:52because that does kind of throw everything into into chaos. Yeah, I'm just
- 1:00:00I I think it does create a lot of questions there because you know,
- 1:00:05we know that we know they love them some sec and Alabama has has come
- 1:00:10along as the season has progressed, and once they kind of figured out what
- 1:00:15they could do with Jalen Milroe and everything else. But again, we were
- 1:00:20we were driving back from Man Arbor listening to the Iron Bowl on on the
- 1:00:24radio like on the on the serious XM Whip Around or whatever, and Auburn
- 1:00:32Auburn at the end of the game, they they had Alabama dead to rights
- 1:00:37and Alabama willed themselves to victory, and Auburn decided it was just like,
- 1:00:44we're fine being Barners, and that's what happens. Yeah, you were so
- 1:00:47close to a complete chaos week in college football where Florida State was losing in
- 1:00:54the second half to Florida and if that, if that happens, they're out.
- 1:00:58The ACC is done for the season. You know, take your we
- 1:01:01have a we have some lovely parting gifts, including the home version of our
- 1:01:05game. We'll see you next year. Alabama almost lost to I mean really
- 1:01:08should have lost to Auburn, where not only did you have the fourth and
- 1:01:14thirty one, you had Auburn muffing a punt before that. Either of those
- 1:01:17don't happen, then Alabama loses. You had what was the other one,
- 1:01:22oh Oklahoma State against BYU that was another close one where that really changes what
- 1:01:30the big twelve Championship game odds are if Texas has to play Oklahoma again as
- 1:01:35opposed to Oklahoma State. So yeah, there were three that really would have
- 1:01:38thrown thrown a wrench into this weekend and made it given Ohio State a much
- 1:01:44better chance of making the CFP. None of the you know, all of
- 1:01:47those were almost but not quite. And Washington Washington against Washington State and the
- 1:01:52Apple Cup two that was another one that went right down to the wire and
- 1:01:55Washington had to kick a kick a field goal right at the end to win.
- 1:01:59So you know, it was almost, you know, almost four for
- 1:02:01four. Instead you at zero for four. So now you need a lot
- 1:02:05of different stuff to happen this weekend instead. And it is what it is.
- 1:02:08And you know what we haven't even gotten into. And I know Tony
- 1:02:12will be getting off of the book, Horgan call, and then we'll try
- 1:02:15to get those things and wrap up so I can get to dinner and not
- 1:02:17get in trouble. But what does this mean for the ball game? And
- 1:02:22where you know, if Ohio State does not get help, you know what
- 1:02:24happens? Do they go to the Orange to potentially play Louisville? Is there
- 1:02:29some horse trading that goes on. Could we see a situation if Alabama does
- 1:02:32not get into the playoff that maybe you see Ohio State in Alabama at the
- 1:02:37Peach Bowl. I mean, you know we're not seeing that on a lot
- 1:02:40of the predictions, But would you rather have Ohio State Alabama there and then
- 1:02:45just do Louisville Penn State is kind of a throwaway, Sorry, Orange,
- 1:02:49We'll catch it next time around. Or have Ohio State, Ohio State Louisville
- 1:02:53and Penn State Bama and two games that are just not really going to be
- 1:02:59all that app taxing. I'm just kind of scrolling through here. Yeah.
- 1:03:06Doug Shepherd says the only way the SEC doesn't get a team is if they're
- 1:03:08four undefeated conference champs, and that isn't happening. Yeah, that is that
- 1:03:15is not happening this year without without an SEC champion. Teddy is a Yukon
- 1:03:22fan, So you could have given me one hundred and twenty five guesses and
- 1:03:25I would not have gotten that one. I mean, do they still have
- 1:03:30football? They did last year? This year less? So super tip from
- 1:03:36Treasure of the Tour. What's up Kevin and Tom just saying Hi, Hope
- 1:03:37all as well. I would like to know your thoughts on some rumors right
- 1:03:39here in regards to the QB position. I'm hearing we may be looking in
- 1:03:44the portal. They're always there's going to be things that are going to be
- 1:03:49said about the portal up down, left right. I still am not of
- 1:03:53the mindset that Ohio State is looking for a portal quarterback at this point,
- 1:04:00because if you bring in a portal quarterback, not only do you lose Kyle
- 1:04:04McCord, you probably lose Devin Brown. If it's a one year rental.
- 1:04:09If you get somebody who could be multiple years, then you really could screw
- 1:04:13up your room. So you bet, I mean, unless unless it's like
- 1:04:15a Drake may or somebody like that, you better be you better be awfully
- 1:04:20certain that you are making the best decision for your program at that point,
- 1:04:27especially when we see portal quarterbacks go somewhere else and it doesn't work out.
- 1:04:33Spencer Sanders transfers from Oklahoma State to Ole Miss, can't beat out Jackson Dart.
- 1:04:40You know, we've seen Wisconsin quarterbacks transfer elsewhere it doesn't work out.
- 1:04:45Granted that was you know, Wisconsin quarterbacks under Paul Christ, but it's not
- 1:04:51always something that you're not always going to hit on a Justin Fields. Justin
- 1:04:56Fields was a special type of player and you make special type of adjustments when
- 1:05:04you do that. But normally going to the portal and a position as as
- 1:05:10pivotal and important as quarterback is not the best thing for your locker room and
- 1:05:15for your quarterback room together. And you know, without with all that being
- 1:05:21said, could could somebody change their thoughts on that, maybe, But as
- 1:05:27of right now, I'm not of the thought of the thought process that that's
- 1:05:30what they're looking to do. And I think that the if you go back
- 1:05:33and look at the Michigan game, I think Kyle McCord there were little There
- 1:05:39was some extenuating circumstances on both of those interceptions, because think people after the
- 1:05:43game immediately said, you know, two interceptions terrible lost in the game.
- 1:05:46The first one Marvin har You know, Bill Johnson beat Marvin Harrison to the
- 1:05:50spot. Harrison didn't really fight through that as much as he maybe could have.
- 1:05:55And then on the last one, I didn't see. I didn't see
- 1:05:58either of these live because I'm down on the field and do not have a
- 1:06:00great view of things. He got hit right as he was throwing that last
- 1:06:04interception, and you know, yeah, there were there were other places he
- 1:06:08could have gone with the ball, but he did not have a ton of
- 1:06:10time to go through a lot of reeds. So I don't think either of
- 1:06:14those are entirely on McCord. So, you know, I don't think I'm
- 1:06:17ready to write off Kyle McCord as this guy's a bomb, they'll never win
- 1:06:21with him. That's not I think that's that's probably pretty pretty early. He's
- 1:06:27not c J. Stroud. That is that is Kyle McCord's greatest sin is
- 1:06:29he is not c J. Stroud, right exactly who who is? Stephen
- 1:06:34Cherry says we should beat our rifles if he wanted to get in. Tired
- 1:06:38of Buckeye beat reporters lobbying to get in. We're not lobbying for Ohio State
- 1:06:41to get in. We're saying, here is the scenario in which they could
- 1:06:45get in. That is just sort of telling you here's how things could happen.
- 1:06:47We're not saying that it's likely to happen. We're just saying, since
- 1:06:51you are a largely an audience of Ohio State fans who was watching a college
- 1:06:55football is Playoff Selection Show live feed. We were assuming you were interested,
- 1:06:59Inky, well, what does this mean for Ohio State? So we're telling
- 1:07:02you what this means for Ohio State. That's that's not lobbying. That's not
- 1:07:06saying this is the greatest outrage in history. This is not saying Ohio State
- 1:07:10should get in over Michigan just because like, that's not what we're doing.
- 1:07:14We're just answering the implied question. So and it's not as if there isn't
- 1:07:18a precedent set that Ohio State has been able to get in in these types
- 1:07:23of situations. So all we're doing is laying out the facts. And this
- 1:07:27is just a conversational type of show. Nobody's up there, you know,
- 1:07:31saying that this needs to happen for you know, damn it. They need
- 1:07:34to change this and fix this and adjudicate that it's just Ohio State has a
- 1:07:42nine percent chance according to the ESPN Playoff Predictor, which doesn't necessarily mean much.
- 1:07:46I don't know if five point thirty eight did one this year not,
- 1:07:50you know, the imply odds based on what we think the draw Ohio State
- 1:07:56needs is five point twenty six percent, So I mean they have a.
- 1:08:00You know, they have a puncher's chance of maybe things going right. And
- 1:08:03even if things go right, it's up to the committee, and the committee
- 1:08:06may sit there and say, yeah, but we're going to go this other
- 1:08:11way. Let's see Rick sa speaking of the portal, how come there's no
- 1:08:17corporate naming rights yet for the portal? Hello, doctor Pepper, Hello,
- 1:08:21they have commercials about it. Rico's time is now so good. I think
- 1:08:30I'm watching Tony getting his earphones, maybe in his ear plus ear bugs.
- 1:08:35All right, we got a thumbs up. I'm bringing them back. So
- 1:08:38everybody talk nice about them. Still continue to talk nice about me? You
- 1:08:45mean, is that correct? Yes, it's dinner time. Let's go Where
- 1:08:54where to begin? On? Ohiers stay dropping four spots? How could you
- 1:09:01drop them four spots after you lose closely to the number two team? Now
- 1:09:06on the road, Boo says, you're not specifically looking at one team as
- 1:09:11much as you are a group of teams and teams around them. So it's
- 1:09:14not just what Ohio State did, it's also what Oregon did, Florida State,
- 1:09:18Washington, that sort of thing. It involves teams moving up as much
- 1:09:24as Ohio State moving down. More on Ohio State them not playing this weekend.
- 1:09:30How much does that complicate things in terms of comparison. They said,
- 1:09:35it happens every year, so they're accustomed to doing this, to comparing a
- 1:09:41conference champ to a non conference champ, and basically just said, wait,
- 1:09:45what we talked about. It's an extra data point to evaluate, so obviously
- 1:09:49it's an advantage. He said, it's never a single data point, it's
- 1:09:53everything combined, and it's thirteen different people, so there's no specific weight you
- 1:09:59have to give any of these things. But when everybody is factoring it in,
- 1:10:02it's going to carry its own way. That's not his words, that's
- 1:10:05me. The discussion between Oregon, Ohio State, Texas and Alabama counts a
- 1:10:12lot of talk early and late, and then again today all teams are eleven
- 1:10:17and one. They all have good, good wins, they all have a
- 1:10:19loss. After talking through it, they liked Oregon in Ohio State and Texas
- 1:10:26and Alabama. It's more on Ohio State. How close was it between Washington
- 1:10:33and Florida State at three and four and then Oregon and Ohio State at five
- 1:10:38and six? And he's used the same joke a couple of times now.
- 1:10:42And he says not to be funny before he says it, so that's how
- 1:10:44you know it's a good joke, but not to be funny. But you
- 1:10:47can't get closer than three and four and five and six. And basically the
- 1:10:51rivalry games are crazy last week, all they know that these are just different
- 1:10:56games because players know each other, teams know each other. So you're gonna
- 1:10:59get some donkey as a results or just you know, it's it's you.
- 1:11:05You don't want to like put too much into the way things go, but
- 1:11:10obviously it's a result, so you're gonna you're gonna factor that in anything else.
- 1:11:15On Ohio State, not really a good question coming in on Florida State
- 1:11:23and their performance against Florida without Jordan Travis, and the quote is they're a
- 1:11:28different team. It's pretty obvious, so uh and any da just as any
- 1:11:32team would look different if they lost their starting quarterback. But they they're evaluating
- 1:11:36the body of work throughout the season. But the quarterback situation is a quote
- 1:11:43big part of the conversation when factoring in what Florida State is doing. So
- 1:11:48Uh, he basically put out there pretty clearly that the Florida State that got
- 1:11:54ranked in the top four is not the Florida State that they are talking about
- 1:11:58now. But you're still looking at the thirteen, the twelve weeks of action
- 1:12:01so far. Next week they'll look at the third on Sunday, Saturday,
- 1:12:04they'll look at the thirteen weeks of action, and then I think at that
- 1:12:09point you see maybe what we saw with Ohio State. Where's We're not just
- 1:12:12looking at Florida State. We're also looking at the other teams. And once
- 1:12:15you start comparing these teams, I'm expecting Florida State, if they win,
- 1:12:19to possibly drop if the right teams below them win. And then if you
- 1:12:28got any questions, any other concerns, you know, somebody did ask,
- 1:12:34as I expected, what is Hey, hey is their road for Alabama?
- 1:12:40And boos and hey, good question, fair question, But you're asking us
- 1:12:45to project and they don't project. And so the guy just just wanted to
- 1:12:49be told that, yes, Alabama, you ever wrote, because he did
- 1:12:53say. The guy asking the question said that no team at this point has
- 1:12:56ever come from the eighth spot to make the playoffs, so that is an
- 1:13:00interesting thing. But also Alabama has never been at the eighth spot at this
- 1:13:06point with a an SEC championship on the line, So I don't think that
- 1:13:12precedent will hold serve on that one. No, this and this, with
- 1:13:17this being the last year of a fourteen playoff, what are you worried about
- 1:13:23setting a precedent for you know, that doesn't seem like that's you know,
- 1:13:29well, the next time we hold a four team playoff, we're going to
- 1:13:30have to keep this in mind. I go, okay, cool. And
- 1:13:33the last thing I will add. Somebody called in and said, hey,
- 1:13:36boo, is it the best or is it the most deserving? And that's
- 1:13:41what Bill Hancock, the chairman or the director of the CFP said. I
- 1:13:47got this boo, and he said it is best. Most deserving is not
- 1:13:53anything in the committee's lexicon. They are to rank the best teams in order,
- 1:13:57and that's what they do. And they also make sure to talk about
- 1:14:00recency bias, and they leave that stuff at the door. A head to
- 1:14:04head win in week two is the same as the head to head win in
- 1:14:08week twelve week thirteen, so it's not its best. They want the four
- 1:14:12best teams. And while Florida State going undefeated would be deserving, clearly they
- 1:14:18are not one of the four best teams at this point, so more evidence
- 1:14:21that Florida State is about to get the boot unless they look like one of
- 1:14:28the four best teams this weekend. Yeah, it's interesting that Florida State is
- 1:14:33clearly not one of the top four best teams and get their number four right
- 1:14:36now. That sure is interesting to me. But yeah, I think there's
- 1:14:42plenty of I think there are plenty of scenarios where Florida State wins and still
- 1:14:46doesn't get in. If you know, you win twenty one to twenty over
- 1:14:49Louisville, you know, I don't know that that gets you in. If
- 1:14:53Texas wins, or if Alabama wins. I think there's plenty of plenty of
- 1:14:58ways that they don't get in, even at even at thirteen and oh all
- 1:15:01right, so that will do it. I want to thank you all for
- 1:15:04joining us on a Tuesday night. I always appreciate you guys showing up for
- 1:15:08the college football playoff breakings reaction. This was the last one of the year
- 1:15:13essentially, so Kevin, watch out. You've got a cat behind you.
- 1:15:16I just want to warn you. Nice job anyway that will do. Of
- 1:15:20course, if you have watched, if you have not yet liked this video,
- 1:15:24please do so, and if you have not yet joined us at bucke
- 1:15:26huddle dot com, please become a member and do so and say hello to
- 1:15:29us there on the message board. So thank you all for tuning in and
- 1:15:32we'll talk to you guys later