Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 33 - Shopify's AI Traffic Triples: Etsy Layoffs, TikTok Shop's $100B Run, and Fraud Up 33%
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to the Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's eCommerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by Blicket.
- 0:12[Max] These twenty minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Hey everyone, welcome back to The Checkout Point.
- 0:29[Speaker 3] Good to be here.
- 0:30[Speaker 3] Busy week in commerce, huh?
- 0:32[Rachel] Wildly busy.
- 0:33[Rachel] Shopify just posted a monster quarter.
- 0:35[Rachel] We're talking thirty-plus percent growth across the board.
- 0:38[Speaker 3] With their AI-referred traffic tripled year over year.
- 0:41[Speaker 3] I wanna know if that traffic actually buys anything.
- 0:44[Rachel] That's exactly where we start.
- 0:46[Speaker 3] Then there's Etsy.
- 0:47[Speaker 3] They just banked a billion four from selling Depop, and turned around
- 0:50[Speaker 3] and laid off two hundred people.
- 0:52[Rachel] Wait, right after a windfall like that?
- 0:54[Speaker 3] That's the puzzle.
- 0:55[Rachel] Oh, and before I forget, live commerce is having a moment.
- 0:59[Rachel] China's market is closing in on nine hundred billion.
- 1:02[Rachel] TikTok Shop chasing a hundred billion in GMV.
- 1:05[Speaker 3] Whatnot just raised over half a billion.
- 1:07[Speaker 3] eBay's doubling down on live shopping too.
- 1:09[Rachel] Wow.
- 1:09[Rachel] We'll poke at whether the margins hold once you count returns and
- 1:12[Rachel] hosting costs.
- 1:13[Speaker 3] And we're closing on fraud.
- 1:15[Speaker 3] Signifyd's new numbers show attack pressure up thirty-three percent.
- 1:19[Rachel] Account takeovers, card testing, none of it's pretty.
- 1:22[Rachel] We've got a couple fixes sellers can actually use before Q4.
- 1:26[Speaker 3] Lots on deck.
- 1:27[Rachel] So Rachel, let's start where the money is, Shopify's number.
- 1:30[Speaker 3] Right.
- 1:30[Speaker 3] The growth number's loud.
- 1:32[Speaker 3] I wanna know what's underneath it.
- 1:38[Rachel] Three easy ways to get your questions to us.
- 1:41[Rachel] Check the description for a web form, text us at seven four
- 1:44[Rachel] seven, two nine three, four six one two, or call the same
- 1:48[Rachel] number to leave a voice question.
- 1:49[Rachel] However you reach out, we can't wait to hear from you.
- 1:57[Rachel] Okay, three X.
- 1:58[Rachel] Shopify's AI-referred traffic tripled year over year.
- 2:02[Rachel] Not up ten percent, not doubled, tripled.
- 2:05[Rachel] You know what I mean?
- 2:06[Speaker 3] Tripled from what baseline, though?
- 2:08[Speaker 3] Because tripling a rounding error is still a rounding error.
- 2:12[Rachel] Fair, but it's not a rounding error anymore.
- 2:14[Rachel] Shopify's own Wednesday numbers back it up.
- 2:17[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 2:17[Rachel] Revenue up thirty-four percent, gross merchandise volume up over thirty, free cash
- 2:22[Rachel] flow margin at eighteen percent, and here's what I'm seeing.
- 2:25[Speaker 3] Okay, that's a real quarter.
- 2:27[Rachel] Mm-hmm.
- 2:27[Speaker 3] Shares popped on that print, right?
- 2:29[Rachel] Yeah.
- 2:30[Rachel] Financial Post covered it.
- 2:31[Rachel] Yvonne Lau's piece quoted the president telling analysts AI is, quote, "Baked
- 2:35[Rachel] into every decision, every experiment, every merchant interaction."
- 2:39[Rachel] That's wild, right?
- 2:41[Speaker 3] Everybody and their cousin called Shopify an AI casualty last year.
- 2:45[Speaker 3] ChatGPT's gonna eat retail.
- 2:47[Speaker 3] Nobody needs a storefront, blah, blah.
- 2:50[Rachel] Right?
- 2:51[Rachel] The Motley Fool literally ran that headline.
- 2:53[Rachel] Daniel Sparks, "Shopify was supposed to be an AI casualty," and instead,
- 2:57[Rachel] AI traffic tripled and fed it buyers.
- 3:00[Rachel] Come on.
- 3:01[Speaker 3] Okay, but here's my actual question.
- 3:03[Speaker 3] Is that traffic converting, or does it just look good in a
- 3:06[Speaker 3] board deck?
- 3:07[Rachel] That's a fair point.
- 3:08[Speaker 3] Because PYMNTS ran a piece this week.
- 3:11[Speaker 3] AI is bringing retailers their best customers, but not closing the sale.
- 3:15[Speaker 3] Etsy's own CEO said something close to that on their call.
- 3:19[Rachel] So there's a gap between an assistant sending you there and an
- 3:22[Rachel] assistant actually closing you.
- 3:23[Rachel] That's the real question.
- 3:25[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 3:26[Speaker 3] A ChatGPT referral isn't the same shopper as someone who typed best
- 3:30[Speaker 3] running shoes into Google with a card already out.
- 3:33[Rachel] Sure, but Shopify's not disclaiming traffic.
- 3:35[Rachel] The revenue and free cash flow numbers are real dollars, you know?
- 3:39[Rachel] Rafael Sotelo's piece on this ties AI and Shopify Payments straight to
- 3:43[Rachel] that financial performance.
- 3:45[Speaker 3] I'll give you that.
- 3:46[Speaker 3] Growth is growth.
- 3:47[Speaker 3] I just want the take rate on that AI traffic before I
- 3:50[Speaker 3] call it a trend instead of a headline.
- 3:52[Rachel] Totally fair.
- 3:53[Rachel] So if assistants are the new front door, what changes for merchants
- 3:56[Rachel] today?
- 3:57[Speaker 3] Go.
- 3:58[Rachel] Product data, real structured data, size, material, return window, spelled out, not
- 4:04[Rachel] buried in a PDF.
- 4:05[Rachel] An assistant can't guess your return policy.
- 4:07[Rachel] You know what I mean?
- 4:08[Speaker 3] Wait, it's that basic?
- 4:10[Rachel] That basic.
- 4:11[Rachel] A small furniture client of mine, their dimensions only lived in a
- 4:14[Rachel] hover tool tip.
- 4:15[Rachel] An AI agent can't hover.
- 4:17[Rachel] It just skipped them entirely for the competitor who listed it plainly.
- 4:21[Rachel] That's wild.
- 4:22[Speaker 3] Of course it did.
- 4:23[Rachel] Second thing, page structure.
- 4:25[Rachel] One clear headline, one price, one call to action per product.
- 4:29[Rachel] These tools are skimming for the answer, not admiring your hero image,
- 4:33[Rachel] you know?
- 4:34[Speaker 3] So the stuff that used to be nice branding is now actively
- 4:37[Speaker 3] getting your product ignored by a bot.
- 4:40[Rachel] Pretty much.
- 4:40[Rachel] And real text reviews, not just star ratings, because that's what gets
- 4:44[Rachel] quoted back to the shopper.
- 4:45[Rachel] That matters.
- 4:47[Speaker 3] So the winners aren't the flashiest sites.
- 4:50[Speaker 3] They're the ones built like they're doing a robot's homework.
- 4:53[Rachel] Which is weirdly also just good for humans.
- 4:56[Rachel] Clear info, clear price, real reviews, and honestly, that's exactly what Shopify
- 5:01[Rachel] rode to this win.
- 5:02[Speaker 3] Funny how that works.
- 5:04[Rachel] Right?
- 5:05[Rachel] Shopify rode that wave and got paid for it.
- 5:08[Rachel] Stock up, margins up, traffic up.
- 5:10[Rachel] That's the move.
- 5:11[Speaker 3] Which makes what's happening over at Etsy this week kind of jarring
- 5:15[Speaker 3] by comparison.
- 5:16[Rachel] How so?
- 5:16[Rachel] What's the disconnect?
- 5:18[Speaker 3] Same AI pressure, same front door problem, except instead of a victory
- 5:23[Speaker 3] lap, they cut two hundred jobs days after pocketing a billion four
- 5:27[Speaker 3] from selling Depop.
- 5:28[Rachel] Wait, cash in hand, and they still cut people?
- 5:31[Rachel] That doesn't track.
- 5:33[Speaker 3] That's what I wanna dig into.
- 5:34[Speaker 3] Where's that money actually going, and does it answer the same AI
- 5:38[Speaker 3] question Shopify just seemed to solve?
- 5:45[Rachel] Two hundred jobs cut, one point four billion just landed.
- 5:49[Rachel] That timing's brutal.
- 5:51[Speaker 3] It's not brutal.
- 5:52[Speaker 3] It's textbook.
- 5:53[Speaker 3] I watched this exact move at Walmart.
- 5:56[Rachel] Wait, seriously?
- 5:57[Rachel] Walmart did layoffs right after a windfall?
- 6:00[Speaker 3] After we sold off a division, yeah.
- 6:02[Speaker 3] Leadership took the cash and immediately funded three new tech hires for
- 6:05[Speaker 3] every ops role we cut.
- 6:07[Speaker 3] Nobody wanted to hear it framed as growth.
- 6:09[Rachel] So the money's not sitting in a bank account, it's already spent.
- 6:13[Speaker 3] Ina Steiner's reporting on this lays it out.
- 6:15[Speaker 3] Etsy sold Depop for one point four billion, and days later announced
- 6:19[Speaker 3] two hundred layoffs.
- 6:20[Rachel] Mm-hmm.
- 6:20[Speaker 3] That's not a company in trouble, that's a company reallocating.
- 6:24[Rachel] Reallocating towards what, though?
- 6:26[Speaker 3] AI search and discovery, mainly.
- 6:28[Speaker 3] Etsy's been open about wanting shoppers to find things without digging through
- 6:32[Speaker 3] 40 pages of listings.
- 6:34[Speaker 3] Smaller head count, heavier ad and AI spend.
- 6:36[Speaker 3] That's the trade they're making.
- 6:38[Rachel] Okay, but here's my question: What does that do to seller take
- 6:41[Rachel] rates?
- 6:42[Speaker 3] That's the piece I'd watch closest.
- 6:44[Speaker 3] If Etsy's leaning harder on AI-driven discovery and paid placement, sellers who
- 6:49[Speaker 3] don't optimize for that get buried.
- 6:51[Speaker 3] Same margin squeeze Amazon put on third-party sellers years ago.
- 6:55[Speaker 3] Spend more to be seen or disappear.
- 6:57[Rachel] Man, and that's rough for the small shop owner who's just making
- 7:00[Rachel] candles in their garage.
- 7:02[Speaker 3] Right, and Etsy's marketplace segment actually grew this quarter.
- 7:06[Speaker 3] Steiner's piece notes that.
- 7:07[Speaker 3] So it's not a company shrinking, it's one trimming staff while the
- 7:11[Speaker 3] AI bet plays out.
- 7:12[Rachel] Okay, so real talk.
- 7:13[Rachel] If I'm an Etsy seller staring down Q4 right now, what do
- 7:17[Rachel] I actually do?
- 7:19[Speaker 3] Go.
- 7:20[Rachel] All right.
- 7:21[Rachel] One, get your listing titles and tags matched to how people actually
- 7:25[Rachel] phrase searches now, because if Etsys search engine's getting an AI brain,
- 7:29[Rachel] keyword stuffing from 2019 isn't gonna cut it.
- 7:32[Speaker 3] Two?
- 7:33[Rachel] Two, watch your ad spend budget for November.
- 7:36[Rachel] If take rates creep or promoted listings get more aggressive, you want
- 7:39[Rachel] room to flex, not scramble.
- 7:41[Speaker 3] And three?
- 7:42[Rachel] Build a buffer.
- 7:43[Rachel] Layoffs mid-quarter usually means slower support response times.
- 7:47[Rachel] If something breaks with your shop, you might wait longer than usual.
- 7:51[Rachel] Nothing like finding that out during Black Friday week.
- 7:54[Speaker 3] Exactly the wrong time to learn it.
- 7:56[Rachel] So bottom line, Etsys betting layoff savings plus the Depop cash on
- 8:01[Rachel] AI discovery paying off before the holidays hit.
- 8:03[Speaker 3] And whether it pays off depends on something we haven't even touched
- 8:06[Speaker 3] yet: Where shoppers are actually spending attention right now.
- 8:10[Rachel] Meaning?
- 8:11[Speaker 3] Meaning Etsys chasing shoppers through search boxes.
- 8:14[Speaker 3] Theres a whole other world where discovery already solved itself.
- 8:17[Speaker 3] People aren't searching, theyre just watching.
- 8:20[Rachel] Oh, you're talking live commerce.
- 8:22[Speaker 3] I am, and the numbers there make Etsy's one point four billion
- 8:25[Speaker 3] look small.
- 8:26[Rachel] Okay, now I wanna know how small.
- 8:33[Rachel] Shifting gears, live commerce just stopped being a China thing.
- 8:37[Speaker 3] Wait, what do you mean stopped?
- 8:40[Rachel] So RetailAsia ran a piece using NIQ's numbers, and China's live commerce
- 8:45[Rachel] market hit around nine hundred billion dollars in 2025.
- 8:49[Speaker 3] Nine hundred billion?
- 8:51[Speaker 3] That's closing in on all of US e-commerce.
- 8:53[Rachel] Yeah.
- 8:54[Rachel] Yeah, yeah.
- 8:54[Rachel] And NIQ thinks the wider social commerce market in China gets to
- 8:58[Rachel] one point eight trillion dollars by 2030.
- 9:01[Speaker 3] Okay, but that's China.
- 9:02[Speaker 3] What's happening here?
- 9:04[Rachel] This is the part I love.
- 9:06[Rachel] TikTok Shop is tracking toward a hundred billion in GMV for 2026.
- 9:11[Speaker 3] A hundred billion?
- 9:13[Rachel] Tubefilter reported it, citing MomentumWorks.
- 9:15[Rachel] TikTok Shop already crossed 50 billion in gross merchandise value in just
- 9:19[Rachel] the first half of the year.
- 9:21[Speaker 3] And that's US-led?
- 9:22[Rachel] US sales are driving it.
- 9:24[Rachel] It's not some export experiment anymore.
- 9:26[Rachel] It's happening in American living rooms.
- 9:28[Speaker 3] Right.
- 9:29[Speaker 3] Right.
- 9:29[Speaker 3] So who else is chasing this?
- 9:31[Rachel] Whatnot just raised five hundred and forty-five million dollars, Series G, specifically
- 9:36[Rachel] to speed up AI features.
- 9:37[Rachel] PYMNTS covered the raise Friday.
- 9:40[Speaker 3] Five hundred and forty-five million just for live selling?
- 9:43[Rachel] For live selling plus AI.
- 9:45[Speaker 3] Mm-hmm.
- 9:45[Rachel] And eBay's leaning in too.
- 9:47[Rachel] PYMNTS reported eBay just posted 15% growth in Q2, and part of
- 9:52[Rachel] that credit went to live shopping.
- 9:54[Speaker 3] eBay, the company everyone wrote off a decade ago?
- 9:57[Rachel] I know, right?
- 9:59[Rachel] It's basically QVC, except the algorithm knows exactly who's watching and what
- 10:03[Rachel] they already almost bought.
- 10:05[Speaker 3] Okay, but here's my actual question.
- 10:08[Speaker 3] Everyone's throwing GMV numbers around like confetti.
- 10:11[Rachel] Uh-oh.
- 10:11[Speaker 3] What's the margin?
- 10:12[Speaker 3] Because I sat through enough Walmart category reviews to know top line
- 10:16[Speaker 3] growth and profit are two different meetings.
- 10:19[Rachel] That's fair.
- 10:20[Speaker 3] Live selling means a host on camera, sometimes hours at a time.
- 10:24[Speaker 3] That's payroll or influencer fees you didn't have before.
- 10:27[Rachel] Sure, but compare that to running paid ads all day.
- 10:30[Speaker 3] No, hear me out.
- 10:31[Speaker 3] Then factor in returns.
- 10:33[Speaker 3] Impulse buys during a live stream, people click faster than they think.
- 10:36[Rachel] Nodding.
- 10:37[Rachel] Live commerce return rates do run hotter than a normal product page,
- 10:40[Rachel] yeah.
- 10:41[Speaker 3] Right.
- 10:41[Speaker 3] So you've got host cost, plus platform take rate, plus returns eating
- 10:46[Speaker 3] the margin from three directions.
- 10:48[Rachel] So does it pencil out or not?
- 10:49[Speaker 3] Depends who's asking.
- 10:51[Speaker 3] If you're a small brand with one SKU and no camera presence-
- 10:54[Rachel] Skip it
- 10:55[Speaker 3] ...
- 10:55[Speaker 3] skip it.
- 10:56[Speaker 3] Or test it small, one 30-minute stream.
- 10:59[Speaker 3] Track the actual return rate before you scale.
- 11:01[Rachel] But if you've got a personality or a founder who's already comfortable
- 11:05[Rachel] on camera-
- 11:06[Speaker 3] Completely different math.
- 11:07[Speaker 3] You're not paying an agency for reach, you're the reach
- 11:10[Rachel] That's basically me arguing that live commerce works best for the merchant
- 11:13[Rachel] who was already going to make content anyway.
- 11:16[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 11:17[Speaker 3] It's a channel for people who show up, not people who outsource
- 11:19[Speaker 3] showing up.
- 11:20[Rachel] So don't buy the ring light unless you're already the type to
- 11:23[Rachel] talk to a camera for fun.
- 11:25[Speaker 3] Right, and test with actual products, not your hero SKU, because if
- 11:29[Speaker 3] the return math is bad, you wanna find out cheap.
- 11:32[Rachel] Makes sense.
- 11:33[Speaker 3] So small brand with thin margins already, probably wait and watch.
- 11:37[Rachel] Founder-led brand with a following, jump in now while the platforms are
- 11:40[Rachel] still hungry for sellers.
- 11:42[Speaker 3] Now, all that traffic, all that speed, live checkout happening in real
- 11:46[Speaker 3] time while people are emotionally hyped up watching a stream.
- 11:49[Rachel] That's a lot of surface area for something to go wrong.
- 11:52[Speaker 3] It is, and we've got numbers on exactly that.
- 11:56[Rachel] Numbers?
- 11:57[Speaker 3] Fraud pressure, because more traffic and faster checkouts don't just mean more
- 12:01[Speaker 3] sales.
- 12:06[Rachel] Building on that speed problem, there's a number that ties this whole
- 12:10[Rachel] hour together.
- 12:11[Speaker 3] Which number?
- 12:12[Rachel] Signifyd's 2026 State of Fraud Report says fraud pressure jumped thirty-three
- 12:17[Rachel] percent year over year in the first four months of 2026.
- 12:20[Speaker 3] Wait, thirty-three percent?
- 12:23[Speaker 3] That's a steep climb.
- 12:24[Rachel] And it's not the fraud you'd picture.
- 12:26[Rachel] The same report has account takeover attacks up seventy-eight percent-
- 12:30[Speaker 3] Wow!
- 12:30[Rachel] ...
- 12:30[Rachel] and card testing surging a hundred and seventy-five percent.
- 12:33[Speaker 3] Okay, so everything's up.
- 12:35[Speaker 3] What actually changed for merchants watching this?
- 12:38[Rachel] Signifyd also flags buy online, pickup in store fraud up sixty-five percent,
- 12:44[Rachel] plus first-party fraud, chargeback abuse climbing nine percent.
- 12:48[Rachel] Attackers aren't stopping at the card anymore.
- 12:50[Speaker 3] So it's stolen accounts and abused policies now, not just stolen numbers.
- 12:55[Speaker 3] Different fight entirely.
- 12:57[Rachel] Right.
- 12:58[Rachel] CPA Practice Advisor covered the same report and called it a shift towards credential
- 13:03[Rachel] theft, with AI cutting the cost of running each attempt.
- 13:06[Speaker 3] And that loops straight back to where I opened this episode, Shopify's
- 13:10[Speaker 3] AI traffic tripling.
- 13:13[Rachel] Same technology, opposite side of the ledger.
- 13:16[Rachel] AI's sending merchants better shoppers and better scammers at once.
- 13:20[Speaker 3] SecurityBrief.Asia ran that same thirty-three percent and tied it to AI lowering
- 13:25[Speaker 3] attackers' cost per attempt too.
- 13:28[Rachel] So before Q4 peak hits, two things merchants need to actually do.
- 13:33[Speaker 3] Go.
- 13:34[Rachel] One, move fraud rules off the card and onto the account: login
- 13:38[Rachel] patterns, device signals, that kind of behavior check.
- 13:42[Speaker 3] And two, tighten return and refund enforcement, since that first-party number is
- 13:47[Speaker 3] climbing right alongside it.
- 13:49[Rachel] Because nothing kills a great AI-driven traffic spike like eating the fraud
- 13:53[Rachel] bill on the back end.
- 13:55[Speaker 3] Convert the traffic, then actually keep the sale.
- 13:58[Rachel] That's been the thread all hour.
- 14:00[Rachel] AI's rewriting the front door and the back door at the same
- 14:03[Rachel] time.
- 14:04[Speaker 3] Worth watching closely once Q4 volume hits.
- 14:12[Rachel] Okay, so if there's one thing to walk away with today-
- 14:16[Speaker 3] It's that AI is not replacing the checkout, it's just changing who
- 14:20[Speaker 3] shows up to it.
- 14:21[Rachel] Right.
- 14:21[Rachel] Shopify's traffic tripling was wild, but your question stuck with me.
- 14:26[Speaker 3] Traffic's cheap.
- 14:27[Speaker 3] Conversion's the real scoreboard.
- 14:29[Rachel] Fair.
- 14:30[Rachel] And that Etsy story, layoffs funding AI hires, not to stress.
- 14:34[Speaker 3] Yeah, that's straight out of my Walmart playbook, honestly.
- 14:37[Rachel] Makes sense.
- 14:38[Rachel] All right, quick homework for sellers.
- 14:40[Rachel] Fix your product data, tighten your CTAs before Q4 debts.
- 14:43[Speaker 3] And watch that fraud number.
- 14:45[Speaker 3] Thirty-three percent isn't nothing.
- 14:48[Rachel] Totally.
- 14:49[Rachel] Lot to chew on this week.
- 14:50[Speaker 3] Thanks for spending the time with us.
- 14:52[Speaker 3] Seriously.
- 14:53[Rachel] If you liked it, subscribe, drop us a review.
- 14:55[Rachel] It actually helps a ton.
- 14:57[Speaker 3] We read every one.
- 14:58[Speaker 3] Well, Max reads every one.
- 15:01[Rachel] Guilty.
- 15:01[Rachel] All right, we'll catch you next week.
- 15:03[Speaker 3] See you then.