Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 163:3-164:4. Interest: Buying Back the Loaned Wheat; Eating From a Mortgaged Field

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 163:3-164:4. Interest: Buying Back the Loaned Wheat; Eating From a Mortgaged Field · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:01
  Let's say that OK and Kusan of Kimmel, let's see if Kimmel I'm
• 0:09
  rather have any money. It's a listener.
• 0:12
  I need I need a money. Give me 100 money means 100.
• 0:19
  I'm really money only I don't have another 100.
• 0:21
  I don't have 100 heating money issue, but I have heating which
• 0:25
  are worth worth 100, but not on the he gave him he agreed to
• 0:35
  take it whatever the you know, that was the price then because
• 0:40
  and a little bit later because listen, I need I need the I need
• 0:48
  the here I have 100 here. I'll give you 90 for the team,
• 0:53
  you know, the guys happy to get, you know, at least you know 90
• 0:56
  most of all the money he needs and you know, and the guy gets
• 0:59
  his wheat back. The dieting Chavimane.
• 1:02
  It's still on the same time period that it's worth.
• 1:07
  It's worth 100. It's a very close, it's a very
• 1:10
  close time period, whether it's within 20 minutes or whether
• 1:13
  it's in the day, whatever it is the pretty close time in Parla
• 1:17
  Levasov Harmana Pedos motor. If in the end he pays him back
• 1:22
  money in Paris, that's OK because of the loan is about the
• 1:30
  is the violent type loan and you eat or whatever.
• 1:34
  I will also look for the most if he can't pay him back 100,
• 1:39
  paying back 100 if they have almost ribous because then it's
• 1:43
  like a haramos ribous since he said, listen, lend me money,
• 1:49
  lend me money, right? And it seems like, you know, in
• 1:57
  looking at the overall picture, however, the mechanics work, it
• 2:00
  seems like OK, he says, listen, let me I'm on it.
• 2:03
  And in the end, in the end, he lent him 90 like in the key he
• 2:09
  lent him 90 and I was giving back 100.
• 2:10
  Now the truth is that that's not how it worked.
• 2:12
  And that's in this is only horrendous for this because he
• 2:17
  he he lent them, he lent them cheat him.
• 2:19
  He let the guy, he let the little cheat him.
• 2:21
  That's why he pays him back and cheat him.
• 2:22
  It's OK. He let he, he let him treat him.
• 2:26
  And the fact that he, you know, he bought it back in the middle.
• 2:28
  It's a separate, it's a separate Mecca, whatever, you know, So
• 2:31
  technically it's not Ribius, but it seems like Karamas Ribius.
• 2:35
  You know, the mall there was like, listen, I don't have them
• 2:39
  on there. I'll give you this and I'll buy
• 2:40
  it back In the end. He gets in the end he gets you
• 2:43
  know, he he in the end, he know he might get more than what he
• 2:47
  the the the the the what he gave him the e-mail of also right who
• 2:52
  might see Menukov Badin. He's allowed to take back.
• 2:57
  He's allowed to if he did do the loan like this, he he is allowed
• 3:01
  to go ahead and collect 100 right up.
• 3:04
  He did the model can't get 100 because he he lent of 100.
• 3:11
  It's just because it looks fishy.
• 3:16
  Put it that way. You know, it could be that they
• 3:18
  didn't really didn't intend that.
• 3:20
  It could be that that's that was the intent in order to like they
• 3:24
  did. They did a Mecca in the middle
• 3:26
  and sidestepped Ribius. It's hard to know exactly what
• 3:29
  they're, you know, that could be so therefore ousted it.
• 3:33
  So it's not even about Ribius. So therefore he can actually
• 3:36
  it's not a he can actually collect the money that he lent
• 3:38
  them or the heat him he's showing the hobby.
• 3:41
  So the middle exchange of naive. Or you.
• 3:46
  Saw is. Considered.
• 3:48
  A method method, right a separate method, but the overall
• 3:52
  picture looks like a whole looks like a whole of the ribis.
• 3:56
  He showed the hobby of the ribis.
• 3:57
  Some say no, no, it's taka of ribis, and therefore we'll be
• 4:00
  also to collect the money the hosalamari Elibus Shiloh again,
• 4:05
  this is only if this is the way things played out.
• 4:07
  It's not that they they made this is the deal.
• 4:10
  They originally made high ribbons.
• 4:15
  Gomer that's straight ribbons. If he told them, OK, listen,
• 4:18
  I'll lend you this and tomorrow I'll come back and buy a few
• 4:20
  less and you're going to get so then already that's that's
• 4:23
  that's straight ribbons. This just happens to be it
• 4:25
  played out that way. So it looks like it Philip
• 4:29
  Parrillo payers even he gave him back payers.
• 4:30
  It still looks like it's still that's still straight ribbons
• 4:34
  because when you when you when they make it tonight and in the
• 4:37
  end, he's going to end up getting going to end up getting
• 4:40
  more. So then that's you know, that's
• 4:43
  good straight ribbons. They say over here.
• 4:45
  The reason why we don't just say, you know, the reason why
• 4:49
  Tairamis ribbons is also this thing took place in a very short
• 4:52
  period of time. Like if it took place over like
• 4:56
  a couple, let's say one year, you know, it was like one time
• 4:59
  he he gave him the thing and then they comes back and later
• 5:01
  on and says, you know, few months, you know, I need that.
• 5:04
  I mean that that week back, you know, it's like, ah, whatever
• 5:06
  that he bought it from him. That's OK.
• 5:08
  Yeah, that's just like it's called.
• 5:09
  That's like I said, it's a straight matter.
• 5:10
  The problem over these, the freshmen say is that it happens.
• 5:13
  So, you know, within within, you know, doesn't usually happen.
• 5:18
  The guy he lends him the money and then go immediately goes
• 5:20
  back and buys it back to him. Already it seems it seems fishy.
• 5:23
  So that's why the cause has all said that it's it's almost
• 5:26
  Rubius and therefore and therefore it would be it would
• 5:30
  be also Kusama Dalit Aleph Misha Isa saw that in Mushkan is the
• 5:38
  other someone who has a field who was which is which is a mash
• 5:44
  gun, right? What we call nowadays would be
• 5:46
  selling to a mortgage. You have to figure what we're
• 5:48
  going to get the silkies of mortgages are much later on and
• 5:51
  this is applied. Is it the same way?
• 5:54
  But Mushkun started Loyaki Reno. No, Loyaki Reno, he can't rent
• 6:03
  it out. So So what happened was someone
• 6:05
  wants some money and Lovis said, listen, I you know, I gave him
• 6:10
  his field as a mashkun. Now there's two types of of
• 6:17
  mashkantas. There's a there's about there's
• 6:21
  a mush counter than if he also, which is motor and if he also
• 6:24
  is, as he takes, he slowly deducts from the loan.
• 6:27
  If he he, you know, harvests the wheat or let's say he gives him
• 6:30
  an apartment or he and he gets he rents it out, whatever it is
• 6:34
  the the profits from this, from this land, if he knocks it off
• 6:39
  the loan. So then that's OK.
• 6:41
  And over the number of years he knocks off the heat.
• 6:46
  Does he have to knock off a? 100% Oh, OK, we'll get we'll get
• 6:51
  to those Halafos venture. If he hits 100% then yes and he
• 6:54
  has to then then the loans finished.
• 6:56
  If he keeps on going 100%. Of the of the rental that he
• 7:00
  gets from that he uses. For it's not oh, I don't know, I
• 7:03
  don't know about that, that that we'll have to see.
• 7:05
  I don't I don't, I don't know that that again, let's it gets
• 7:08
  in in the cofines. All these dinner are more much
• 7:11
  warmer for ish over here. It's just touching.
• 7:12
  It's touching upon the Russia program, so to speak.
• 7:16
  So in the case and then there's and then there's a there's a
• 7:21
  there's a Mushkanta that the guy pays him back.
• 7:23
  He's about to kick him off and there's a Mushkanta.
• 7:26
  You know all the different. The loop game is also.
• 7:28
  And then there's A and there's a Mushkanta de Sur where he just
• 7:31
  keeps it until he pays him back as a Stan Mushkanta.
• 7:35
  So over here he has a stardom. Mushkan is beyond, though, Lo
• 7:38
  yaps. If he just has it in his hand,
• 7:41
  it's also for him to go ahead and take any profit from it.
• 7:43
  That would be Ribis if he's not knocking it off the Hove.
• 7:47
  So Misha is Misha is sorted and it's going to be all the below
• 7:51
  yachts or the asteroids. So he can't go and rent it out
• 7:54
  to someone else. The bottle yeah, the bottle
• 7:57
  suddenly can't go back and rent it out to the Balasada himself.
• 8:03
  The age Mishimante Lasas cane. Some say it is multi Mushkanta
• 8:06
  Desura in in the Mushkanta Desura that that that it's it's
• 8:18
  a different type of Ashcanta. It's it that it's kilo by the
• 8:22
  way, the tosses the lotion. I use a hitch Kino, but often
• 8:25
  shallow eat star liftos. You know, he doesn't have to.
• 8:30
  He doesn't have to repose it for him.
• 8:34
  Basically he that's that's the same idea.
• 8:37
  So that he eats, he'll take the profits from it until the loan's
• 8:41
  finished, then he gives it back. So some say that that's OK.
• 8:45
  He can rent it out. However he wants to rent it out.
• 8:48
  Even if he rents it back to the to the bottle of soda, that's
• 8:51
  OK. If if he's going to take off
• 8:53
  from the from the loan, but the first sheet to hold that.
• 8:58
  No, it doesn't that it's it seems like he's taking more
• 9:05
  money. It's all to Ravana more money
• 9:06
  from the liver than what he than what he you know, than the
• 9:10
  halva. Even if it's not, but it's
• 9:13
  that's what it comes out to be. As long as it wasn't again, like
• 9:18
  it's it's like sort of a handshake of the last sieve.
• 9:21
  As long as it wasn't it's not like that, then it's OK.
• 9:25
  The gum chakvar hits like a model of the soda.
• 9:27
  It's also time of the case with the mother already already has
• 9:32
  the soda of a blah blah blah Kuyama.
• 9:34
  Also, if he doesn't have it already, then it's kilo.
• 9:37
  They made it. It was even though it wasn't a
• 9:40
  time of the loan, but before he, you know, before he settled down
• 9:43
  into the into the southern. It's kilo.
• 9:46
  That was a time. It's Kilo that he's going to
• 9:48
  rent it out to the low there and get money and get more money.
• 9:51
  So that that would be awesome. Sif bees Meshkanta de Surah
• 9:57
  Meshkanta de Surah Inba after the Sakharis Samuel Malva.
• 10:01
  If someone else comes and makes it from the Malvet Mutter Lazar,
• 10:05
  the hospital, he sell the bottle of soda.
• 10:06
  That person that the middle man is is allowed to go ahead and
• 10:11
  rent it out to to the bottle of soda himself, because already
• 10:15
  it's not because then the even if even if, let's say the middle
• 10:18
  man, you know, he sublets the apartment.
• 10:21
  Let's say it's an apartment. Let's say it's a field, sublets
• 10:23
  the field and that money he pays to the to the mall there, but it
• 10:26
  doesn't come directly. So that's already already that's
• 10:29
  separated. So that's going to be motor, I
• 10:32
  guess, unless obviously that's something that was like the
• 10:34
  tsunami Cara now you know, whatever, but that's but because
• 10:42
  he he's giving, he's giving because he's giving in more
• 10:44
  money on paper. If I'm from straight to the
• 10:48
  lobby, he's paying more money to the Malva.
• 10:50
  So it's it's the revolver Gimmel motor Leancor Sadehu, the echoed
• 10:57
  Lahasa's emotion. You're allowed to sell a field
• 11:01
  to someone. Well, a hassle.
• 11:05
  Simo pirish akraker who ish Shimakaba love soda Kavera.
• 11:11
  A lot of the someone who he's renting a field to go ahead and
• 11:15
  work the field like in our race, but it's a little bit different.
• 11:17
  It's nice eating about Kaka kak Peres benyasa.
• 11:21
  So the Peres benyasa, so the Haasa it's yeah.
• 11:29
  The difference between Hakiras and Arisus is that Arisus gives
• 11:32
  a percentage and Hakiras gives it's like a straight renting.
• 11:35
  He gives them a set. He gives a set return no matter
• 11:38
  no matter what what profits he makes from it or not.
• 11:42
  So, so one second, so multiple. Because the first case was
• 11:55
  because the reasons it's both here, because it's Makira, even
• 11:58
  though you say it, because it's, you know, it's maybe it's
• 12:01
  haramus ribis that you're you're selling him Kilo, you're selling
• 12:05
  and you're getting money back and you're, you know, makule
• 12:08
  makule. It might seem like haramus ribis
• 12:11
  of the last sit last Simon, but it's not since it's a straight
• 12:14
  Makira. It's not Halvaney, it's a
• 12:16
  straight Makira. So they're just pointing out
• 12:18
  that the that it's that don't get confused.
• 12:21
  And and that's that's considered a straight Makira.
• 12:24
  That's OK. No, but he rents it out to him.
• 12:34
  He rents the field out for him. Africa.
• 12:37
  It's simple. Yeah.
• 12:38
  It's a time thing. It's.
• 12:43
  Yeah. Even if he makes the time at the
• 12:44
  beginning, it doesn't make a difference.
• 12:45
  It's it's a Bakira Dal and Hilvey also they who if he he
• 12:52
  lends, you know, he borrows money, you know with the also
• 12:55
  there is a mashkin. He gives him a song that
• 12:57
  Vomerlei you know T didn't leave me Khan the ad Gil Oshanim
• 13:01
  racially, but if you don't pay me back, but it's going to be
• 13:11
  the mother says it's going to be mine below Omar may action.
• 13:14
  He doesn't say it's mine from now.
• 13:17
  It'll be mine in three years. The Indian Shane Hameka Kayem
• 13:22
  Tofkim Oshanim Loya Paris until the until the Mecca is Kayem
• 13:29
  after three years. It's also for him to eat, to get
• 13:32
  to eat the payers from it to to, you know, to get the you know,
• 13:36
  to get the profits because again, it's still alone until
• 13:41
  until until he get until he gets it.
• 13:46
  You know the EIN, because during that, even though he says,
• 13:49
  listen, what's the big deal? I, I know this guy's not going
• 13:51
  to pay me back. Give me a break.
• 13:52
  He's always has the money and I'm definitely going to get
• 13:55
  this, you know, get this. But OK, you know, so I'm just
• 13:58
  going to take, you know, I'm going to take, I'll take some,
• 14:03
  I'm going to take, start taking the profits out.
• 14:04
  If you talk, it pays me back. I'll give it back to him.
• 14:06
  Whatever. So that's what it was too.
• 14:08
  So because it's all it's all and just like a regular mash gun,
• 14:12
  the guy says, let's say it's a regular mash gun.
• 14:14
  You know, this is mash gun Simon ring whatever.
• 14:18
  And he said, listen, if I don't pay you back in three years, so
• 14:20
  then you get to keep the ring, right.
• 14:22
  So that's a regular that's that's a regular mashka.
• 14:25
  And here too, it's a mashka and it's not not an abnormal Mashka
• 14:27
  and zeal. But with the saw there, if he's
• 14:30
  going ahead and he's and he's and he's taking pay your payers
• 14:34
  before. So that's straight of his tuta.
• 14:36
  That's keel. OK, Yeah, yeah, I'll be, you
• 14:38
  know, I'm lending you money and you're, you know, I get the
• 14:42
  field and I get the you know, I'll get the field eventually
• 14:44
  and I'll get all the payers in the middle and that middle
• 14:46
  before it's a Mahira, it's straight rivers.
• 14:50
  No, he's not taking it off. He's just getting extra.
• 14:53
  What? He's making money.
• 14:54
  What? That's what Susa, he's not
• 14:56
  taking it off. He doesn't want to like I said
• 15:00
  Kobe, he thought that he could just take it early anyway
• 15:03
  whatever, but that's not let's say he just says you don't have
• 15:06
  a right to take it's in my fields of my possession.
• 15:08
  I'm just taking extra money. Why not it's free money yeah,
• 15:12
  that's what it's Tutsa agaviation in the Masha Akhotoki
• 15:15
  will shine in Lahavi A Lavakri, but something that that's not
• 15:22
  it's not it's it's just like a mash content below that he also,
• 15:26
  which is the author, but it's only also where he holds it and
• 15:31
  gets payers, but he doesn't take off from the loan.
• 15:33
  It's this is similar. It's well, it's not different.
• 15:37
  Therefore it's only avacra this again we're going to get into
• 15:43
  these bays, although it's really this is over here.
• 15:49
  Like I said, it's a Hampshire from the Sif gimmel.
• 15:52
  The last simian of these things are sort of haramas and the
• 15:55
  question is they mutter or not of a Masha Akho la Aqua Shani
• 15:59
  and circle hapsir, the Hain the Hain icker.
• 16:06
  So, so wait one second. But I understand they say the
• 16:16
  case is over wrong. Hold on one.
• 16:24
  Second. Yeah, one second.
• 16:33
  No, he says that, but it says it seems to be Yeah, the case is
• 16:44
  the case is that he doesn't give the the I'll just refine the
• 16:48
  case a little bit. It's not that it's sometimes you
• 16:51
  look at the those ribbons, sometimes you understand, you go
• 16:53
  back over and you see wait a second.
• 16:55
  It seems like the, the the soda is in the reshus of the of the
• 16:58
  lawyer and, and therefore and therefore, whatever the whatever
• 17:10
  the you know, whatever the Louisa, you know, whatever the
• 17:15
  if the so she's at awful Bagenzo.
• 17:18
  If if he's if after three years, it changes ownership.
• 17:21
  So he's eating it. He's taking the payers Bagenzo
• 17:24
  because it's not his. No, no one paid it back.
• 17:31
  No one paid anything back here. Loads of shows should otherwise
• 17:40
  should have caught hold on. So one second, let me just get
• 17:59
  this clear because I learned it a little bit.
• 18:04
  No, no, they didn't pay him back.
• 18:05
  They didn't pay him back. We'll have a second here.
• 18:08
  Apologize. One second, let me just.
• 18:10
  Put this case a little clearer. Ah, OK, fine.
• 18:23
  The the, the kuda we're missing over here, which it points out
• 18:27
  is it is kla whether the, whether the sale will be hollow,
• 18:31
  hollow. It's a separate din.
• 18:32
  And this is the Shiloh of asmatta that it could be that
• 18:37
  that the sale, the pasture says the sale is not is not called
• 18:40
  because it's a sale of what's called an asmatta.
• 18:43
  And therefore the, the, the labia never had Camir Rizdas to
• 18:47
  go ahead and to actually actually, so it's called
• 18:50
  Asmarta. Asmarta is the case that someone
• 18:52
  makes a deal like so it's not if I don't do this, if I don't pay
• 18:56
  you back, whatever, then you'll get this.
• 18:58
  You know, it's like you get you get the whole field right.
• 19:01
  And so the truth be told. So that's called Asmarta because
• 19:04
  they say that the the the person selling it doesn't really have
• 19:08
  have Gamira's dots. He doesn't really mean to to
• 19:10
  sell it. He's just saying it.
• 19:11
  It's just words. So therefore look here is not
• 19:14
  how so here in the the the the model doesn't really get to saw
• 19:18
  there. So that's why the end of the
• 19:20
  remote finishes and all in of a Masha Akha Akhar Shaolin that
• 19:24
  which the the Malda says that he thinks it's his now what she ate
• 19:29
  after Kim LL Shawn named Sarah Lahaczer the faint acre.
• 19:32
  That's not me Tom Vivis. It's like a separate din.
• 19:35
  That's really Hoshi Mishmatin that even though the show gig
• 19:43
  whatever, but he you know, and the the and the lover thinks
• 19:46
  that everyone thinks it's his and they go to bed and say, Nah,
• 19:49
  it's not yours. So whatever he whatever he has,
• 19:51
  he has to return. He has to read.
• 19:53
  You know, whatever he took, he has to return because of Zayla
• 19:56
  and it's and the load, even if the lover thought it's his it's
• 19:59
  called Machila Bataud. So he.
• 20:01
  You know, he, he let him have it the pulse and you're allowed to
• 20:04
  to go back from that, but it's a it's a separate, it's a separate
• 20:07
  point. All right, maybe we'll we'll
• 20:11
  stop here for some.