Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / 50 Years of Collapse: What Happened to Ordinary Romans?
Transcript
- 0:00We picture Rome's fall as a blockbuster.
- 0:03Barbarians at the gate, a mad emperor, fire in the streets.
- 0:07That's the movie. Here's the autopsy.
- 0:11For 50 years, the Roman Empire didn't collapse in battle.
- 0:15It collapsed in the marketplace, in the tax office, at the border
- 0:19crossing where no one checked anymore coins so debased they
- 0:24were practically tin forts along the Danube, standing empty, laws
- 0:30still written, but no one left to enforce them. 26 emperors in
- 0:3550 years, most murdered. None of them mattered.
- 0:40Because empires don't collapse on the people who run them.
- 0:44They collapse on the people who carry them, the farmers, the
- 0:48merchants, the soldiers who hadn't been paid in months.
- 0:53This is how ordinary Romans survived A50 year free fall.
- 0:58And you recognize the pattern. It's because you're living.
- 1:20Welcome back to the Roman pattern.
- 1:22I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, CEO of Command your
- 1:26brand. We help our clients to appear on
- 1:29some of the biggest podcasts on the planet.
- 1:32Check us out via the link in the description.
- 1:35And now our story. So let's start with the money,
- 1:39because that's where empires always start to die.
- 1:43Not on the battlefield, but in the mint.
- 1:46In the year 235, a Roman farmer in Syria held a coin in his hand
- 1:51called a denarius. It was supposed to be silver.
- 1:55His grandfather's denarius was silver, nearly pure.
- 1:59But this coin, if he scratched the surface, he'd find bronze
- 2:03underneath. A thin wash of silver over base
- 2:06metal, a lie you could hold in the palm of your hand.
- 2:10This wasn't an accident. This was policy.
- 2:13For 200 years, Roman emperors have been quietly reducing the
- 2:16silver content of coinage to pay for things that they couldn't
- 2:20afford. Wars, bribes, the Praetorian
- 2:24Guard, grain subsidies, public games.
- 2:28Every emperor needed more money than the last.
- 2:31And every emperor found the same solution.
- 2:34Make the coins cheaper to produce, stamp them the same on
- 2:38the face, and hope nobody noticed.
- 2:41People noticed. Here's how the basement actually
- 2:44worked at the street level. Because this is the part the
- 2:48textbooks skip. A merchant.
- 2:50Antioch doesn't care about monetary theory.
- 2:53He cares about what he can buy with what he's paid and when.
- 2:57The coins coming into his hands are visibly lighter, visibly
- 3:01darker, and visibly worse than the ones his father used.
- 3:05He does the only rational thing. He raises prices not because
- 3:10he's greedy, but because he's not stupid.
- 3:13And this is the trap. When everyone raises prices
- 3:16because the money is bad, the government needs more of the bad
- 3:20money to buy the same things. So they debase further, which
- 3:25makes the prices go up further, which forces another debasement.
- 3:29This isn't a Roman problem, it's a pattern.
- 3:33The same death spiral appeared in Weimar Germany, in Zimbabwe,
- 3:37in Venezuela. The mechanism is identical.
- 3:40Every single time a government spends more than it has, it
- 3:45debases or prints to cover the gap.
- 3:48Prices raise, the debasement accelerates.
- 3:51And the people holding the currency, the ordinary people,
- 3:55the people who can't move their wealth into land or gold, well,
- 3:59they get crushed by the reign of Gallianus in the two 60's, the
- 4:03antoninianus, the coin that had replaced the denarius, contained
- 4:07less than 5% silver. Some issues had no detectable
- 4:12silver at all. They were bronze slugs with a
- 4:15memory of silver like a ghost. Purchasing power and the prices.
- 4:21The edict of maximum prices under Diocletian, issued decades
- 4:25later in three O 1, but reflecting trends that have been
- 4:28building for 50 years, tells us that amodeus of wheat that once
- 4:33cost about 8 dinarii now cost 100.
- 4:37A soldiers cloak, perhaps 25 dinarii to thousands.
- 4:41These weren't luxury goods. This was bread.
- 4:45This was the tunic on your back. Now imagine you're a farmer in
- 4:49Syria. You've been paid in these coins
- 4:51for your grain, but the tools you need, iron, leather, rope,
- 4:55well, those prices have sky rocketed.
- 4:58The tax collector, well, he still comes.
- 5:01He doesn't care that your coins are worthless.
- 5:04He wants the same number of them or more.
- 5:07So what do you do? You stop using coins.
- 5:10This is the part that's almost never talked about the great
- 5:13monetary achievement of Rome. A single currency that worked
- 5:17from Britain to Mesopotamia, from the Rhine to the Sahara,
- 5:22simply stopped functioning in large parts of the empire during
- 5:27the crisis of the 3rd century. Not because anyone declared it
- 5:31dead. It just became irrelevant.
- 5:33The economy didn't vanish. People still grew food, they
- 5:37still made things, They still needed things, but they reverted
- 5:42to barter. Grain for labor, pottery for
- 5:45meat, cloth for iron. Networks of exchange that hadn't
- 5:49been necessary since before Augustus.
- 5:52Suddenly they're the only thing that worked.
- 5:55And here's the critical detail. The people who survived this
- 5:59transition best weren't the wealthy.
- 6:01They were the locally connected. The farmer who knew the
- 6:04blacksmith personally, the veteran who'd settled near his
- 6:08Legion's supply routes, the merchant who dealt in things
- 6:12Rather than money, wealth steered in coin was wealth that
- 6:16evaporated. Wealth stored in relationships,
- 6:19in land, in skill and community. Well, that held.
- 6:22This wasn't a Roman problem. It's a pattern.
- 6:26When the money dies, the people who survive are the people who
- 6:29never trusted the money completely.
- 6:31If bad money was the disease, well, taxation was the fever
- 6:35that came with it. Because here's what most people
- 6:38misunderstand about the Roman tax system during the crisis.
- 6:43It didn't collapse, it intensified.
- 6:46The empire was falling apart and its response was to squeeze
- 6:49harder. A farmer in Roman Egypt, around
- 6:52250, faced a tax burden that will be almost comical if it
- 6:57weren't so devastating. There was the land tax, the
- 7:00tributeum, solely assessed on the productivity of his plot.
- 7:04There was the head tax, the tributeum cactus for every adult
- 7:08in his household. There were requisitions, forced
- 7:11contributions of grain, livestock or labor for the army.
- 7:15There was the main area, compulsory public duties,
- 7:18maintaining roads, housing soldiers, transporting goods for
- 7:22the state. And here's the twist that made
- 7:25it unbearable. The cure aisles.
- 7:28The cure aisles were the municipal middle class, town
- 7:31councillors, local elites. Under normal circumstances,
- 7:34being a cure aisle was an honor. You got to run your city,
- 7:39administer justice, sponsor games.
- 7:41But here was the catch. And this would slowly destroy
- 7:45the Roman middle class over the course of 50 years.
- 7:50Pure owls were personally responsible for collecting taxes
- 7:53in their district. Not as a job, as a liability.
- 7:57If the people in your district couldn't pay because money was
- 8:00worthless, because the crops failed, because soldiers had
- 8:04taken everything, you made-up the difference out of your own
- 8:09pocket. Think about that for a moment.
- 8:12You're a prosperous olive merchant in a mid sized town in
- 8:15North Africa. You own land, you have a nice
- 8:18house. You've been elected to the town
- 8:21council because you're successful and respected, and
- 8:25now the imperial government tells you that you are
- 8:28personally financially liable for every denarius your neighbor
- 8:33owes. Your neighbors who are paying
- 8:35their taxes and coins that are 95% bronze.
- 8:39Your neighbors, who just had half their harvest requisitioned
- 8:43to feed a legion passing through your neighbors, some of whom
- 8:47have already abandoned their farms and fled.
- 8:50This wasn't rare. This was policy, and the result
- 8:53was predictable. Cure Isles.
- 8:56The backbone of Roman municipal government, the class that kept
- 8:59cities running, began to be destroyed by the very system
- 9:04they served. Some were bankrupted, some fled,
- 9:08some tried to join the army or clergy to escape their
- 9:11obligations, and the government passed laws making it illegal to
- 9:15cur Isles to change their social status.
- 9:18You were born into this class. You died in it.
- 9:21Your sons die in it. The empire was so desperate for
- 9:24tax revenue that it began to trap people in their economic
- 9:28roles. Farmers were bound to their
- 9:31land. Bakers were bound to their
- 9:33ovens. Soldiers sons were required to
- 9:36serve the free economy that had made Rome great.
- 9:40The ability of a man to move from a province to province, to
- 9:44change trades, to climb or fall on his own merit, was slowly
- 9:48replaced by a system that looked less like a Republic and more
- 9:52like a caste system. This wasn't just a Roman
- 9:55problem. It's a pattern.
- 9:58When states face financial crisis, they don't cut spending,
- 10:01they don't reform, they freeze. They lock people in place
- 10:05because movement means lost revenue.
- 10:08The Soviet Union did it with internal passports.
- 10:12China did it with the Hoku system.
- 10:14When the state can't produce prosperity, it settles for
- 10:18preventing escape. And the ordinary Roman the
- 10:21farmer, the Craftsman, the small merchant, they adapted in the
- 10:25only way to them. They went underground.
- 10:29They stopped reporting their real production.
- 10:31They hid grain. They made deals off the books.
- 10:35They built a shadow economy that existed alongside and eventually
- 10:39beneath the official one. The Roman Empire didn't just
- 10:43lose its economy during the crisis of the 3rd century, it
- 10:47lost visibility into its economy.
- 10:49The government was issuing edicts and collecting taxes
- 10:52based on a reality that no longer existed.
- 10:56The maps didn't match the terrain, and in that gap between
- 11:00what Rome thought was happening and what was actually happening,
- 11:04ordinary people built their survival.
- 11:06So let's talk about the armies, because the army is where all
- 11:10three fault lines, money, borders, and power converge into
- 11:15a single catastrophic failure. And 2:35 the Roman military was
- 11:20the largest, most sophisticated fighting force on earth.
- 11:24Roughly 400,000 men under arms spread across thousands of miles
- 11:28of frontier. Legions on the Rhine, legions on
- 11:32the Danube, legions in Syria, legions in Africa.
- 11:37A network of forts, roads, supply lines, and command
- 11:40structures that have taken 3 centuries to build.
- 11:44But a military machine that size has a fatal dependency.
- 11:48It has to be paid. A Roman legionary in the mid 3rd
- 11:52century was supposed to receive a salary, the spendium plus
- 11:57periodic cash bonuses called donativa, plus a discharge bonus
- 12:01after 25 years of service. The total package, in theory,
- 12:06was enough to make military service attractive.
- 12:09Not luxurious, but stable. Except the coins were worthless
- 12:14when the Anthony Anus lost 95% of its silver content.
- 12:19A soldiers pay didn't go up 95% to compensate.
- 12:23His nominal salary might have been adjusted upward, but never
- 12:27enough to match the real loss of purchasing power.
- 12:30A legionary in Gallianus's army was technically paid, but
- 12:34practically destitute. So what does an armed man do
- 12:37when his government doesn't pay him?
- 12:39Well, he pays himself. This is the moment the Roman
- 12:42military stopped being a protective force and became a
- 12:46predatory 1. Not by intent, but by necessity.
- 12:50Soldiers began to supplement their worthless pay through
- 12:53requisitions, extortion, and outright plunder of the civilian
- 12:57population they were supposed to be protecting.
- 13:01The papyri from Roman Egypt are devastating.
- 13:03On this point, we have actual letters, ordinary people writing
- 13:08to officials, to family members, to anyone who might help,
- 13:12describing soldiers seizing their animals, demanding food
- 13:16and lodging, beating those who refused.
- 13:19One letter from a farmer named Aurelius Izodorius catalogs a
- 13:23litany of abuses. Soldiers took his donkeys,
- 13:27consumed his grain stores, and when he complained to the local
- 13:30centurion, he was beaten and threatened with imprisonment.
- 13:34This wasn't an aberration, this was the system functioning as
- 13:38the crisis demanded. And this is where the border
- 13:41fault line cracks open, because those soldiers weren't just
- 13:45underpaid, they were overwhelmed.
- 13:47The 3rd century brought simultaneous pressure on
- 13:51virtually every Roman frontier. Goths and other Germanic peoples
- 13:55crossed the Danube repeatedly. 252 fifty 125326268 The Sassanid
- 14:02Persian Empire launched major invasions into the eastern
- 14:06provinces. Support the first capture the
- 14:09Emperor Valerian himself in 260, the first time a Roman emperor
- 14:13had ever been taken prisoner by a foreign enemy.
- 14:16The army couldn't be everywhere, and when it couldn't be
- 14:19somewhere, it didn't just leave a gap in the defense.
- 14:22It left a vacuum that ordinary people had to fill themselves.
- 14:26Frontier communities began to fortify on their own.
- 14:29Towns that hadn't needed walls for centuries because the Pax
- 14:33Romana had made walls unnecessary suddenly began
- 14:37building them. Not the grand fortifications of
- 14:40a professional military. Crude walls, repurposed stone
- 14:44from demolished public buildings.
- 14:46Amphitheaters turned into defensive perimeters, temples
- 14:50cannibalized for their cut blocks.
- 14:53This is what survival looks like at the municipal level.
- 14:56You don't wait for the legion to come back because the legion
- 15:00isn't coming back. You tear down the bath house and
- 15:03use the stone to build something that might keep the Alemani out
- 15:07for one more season. And the soldiers who were still
- 15:11stationed on the frontiers? Well, many of them began to look
- 15:14less like professional Roman legionaries and more like the
- 15:18barbarian enemies they faced. They married local women.
- 15:23They adopted local customs. They wore trousers, Brachi,
- 15:27which would have horrified a Roman citizen 2 centuries
- 15:30earlier. The line between Roman soldier
- 15:33and armed frontier settler blurred until it was nearly
- 15:36invisible. The empire didn't lose its
- 15:38borders all at once. It lost them in 1000.
- 15:42Small surrenders, each one rational, each one necessary,
- 15:47each 1A tiny death. In 260.
- 15:50Something happened that tells you everything you need to know
- 15:54about how far the rot had spread.
- 15:56The Roman Empire broke into three pieces.
- 16:00Not from a barbarian invasion, Not from a natural disaster.
- 16:04From abandonment. Emperor Valerian was captured by
- 16:07the Persians. His son Gallianus was left to
- 16:10hold together what remained. But Gallianus was fighting on
- 16:13the Danube, and he couldn't defend the east.
- 16:17He couldn't defend the West either.
- 16:19So the provinces decided to defend themselves.
- 16:22In the West, a general named Posthumous declared himself
- 16:25emperor of what historians call the Gallic Empire, Gaul, Britain
- 16:30and Hispania. He didn't claim to be
- 16:32overthrowing Rome. He claimed to be Rome, the real
- 16:36Rome, the one thing that actually showed up when the
- 16:38Germans crossed the Rhine. In the east, Zenobia Palmyra
- 16:42extended her influence over Syria, Egypt and much of Asia
- 16:47Minor. Again, not as a foreign
- 16:49conqueror, as a Roman protector filling the vacuum that Rome's
- 16:53central government had left. And this is the crucial insight
- 16:57for understanding how ordinary people survived.
- 17:00They didn't care who is in charge.
- 17:02Not really. A farmer in Gaul didn't weep for
- 17:05the unity of the empire. He wanted someone, anyone, to
- 17:09keep the road safe, to stabilize the currency, to prevent the
- 17:13next Gothic raiding party from burning his farm.
- 17:16Posthumous actually delivered on this for about 9 years.
- 17:20The Gallic Empire was arguably better than the Central Roman
- 17:24Empire. The currency was slightly more
- 17:27stable, the frontiers were defended, the courts functioned,
- 17:31local elites. Those same cure Isles being
- 17:33crushed under the central tax system found that a nearby
- 17:37emperor was more responsive than a distant one.
- 17:40This is the pattern that recurs every single time a large state
- 17:44begins to fragment. People don't cling to the center
- 17:48out of patriotism. They cling to the center because
- 17:50the center provides services, security, currency, law.
- 17:56When it stops providing those services, loyalty evaporates.
- 18:00Not with a revolution, with a shrug.
- 18:03The break of of the Roman Empire in the two 60s was, for millions
- 18:07of ordinary people, not a crisis.
- 18:09It was a solution. A messy, imperfect, temporary
- 18:13solution, but better than what they had.
- 18:16And that should disturb you, because it means the collapse of
- 18:19civilization doesn't always look like a disaster from the inside.
- 18:24Sometimes it looks like a relief.
- 18:26The Roman Empire was an urban civilization.
- 18:29That was its genius and its pride.
- 18:32Cities connected by roads, aqueducts, feeding fountains,
- 18:36public baths where a laborer could soak alongside a senator,
- 18:39markets where goods from three continents changed hands daily.
- 18:44The herbs. The city was the foundation of
- 18:47Roman identity. During the crisis of the 3rd
- 18:49century, the cities began to die.
- 18:52Not all at once, not everywhere, but the trend was unmistakable
- 18:57and once started, almost impossible to reverse.
- 19:01Here's why. Cities are concentrators.
- 19:05They concentrate people, trade, wealth and talent into a small
- 19:09space. That concentration produces
- 19:11incredible efficiency and creativity when the system
- 19:14works, but it also produces incredible vulnerability.
- 19:19A city depends on trade routes staying open, on a currency
- 19:23being stable, on food arriving from the countryside on
- 19:26schedule, on law and order being maintained by someone other than
- 19:30the citizens themselves. When all four of those
- 19:33dependencies fail simultaneously, which is exactly
- 19:36what happened during the crisis, cities become traps.
- 19:40Trade routes collapse because roads weren't maintained and
- 19:44bandits operated openly. Currency was worthless, so trade
- 19:48broke down. Food didn't arrive because
- 19:51farmers were hoarding or had fled.
- 19:53Law and order disappeared because the Garrison had been
- 19:56redeployed to fight the latest usurper or barbarian incursion.
- 20:01A Roman urbanite in 260 faced a terrible calculation.
- 20:05Stay in the city and starve, or leave for the countryside and
- 20:09survive. Millions made that calculation
- 20:12and millions left. The archaeological record is
- 20:15stark. Urban populations in the western
- 20:17provinces declined dramatically during the 3rd century.
- 20:21Cities that have housed 10 or 20,000 people shrank to two or
- 20:25three thousand. Public buildings fell into
- 20:28disrepair, aqueducts broke and weren't fixed.
- 20:32The baths closed, not because bathing was unpopular, but
- 20:36because there was no one to maintain the infrastructure and
- 20:39no economy to support it. Where did these people go?
- 20:42They went to the villi, the large rural estates owned by the
- 20:46landed aristocracy. And this is where the social
- 20:50structure of the Roman world underwent A transformation that
- 20:54would define the next 1000 years of European history.
- 20:58A Roman villa in the mid 3rd century was evolving from a
- 21:01country house into something more like a self-contained
- 21:05community. It had its own fields, its own
- 21:08workshops, its own storage facilities.
- 21:11Increasingly it had its own defence.
- 21:13And it had a growing population of former urban workers, former
- 21:17independent farmers, and refugees from the frontier who
- 21:21attached themselves to the estate in exchange for
- 21:24protection and a share of the harvest.
- 21:28The legal term was colonists. A colonist was technically a
- 21:31free tenant farmer. But in practice, the
- 21:34relationship between a colonist and the estate owner looked
- 21:37increasingly like something else.
- 21:40A colonist couldn't leave. Laws bound him to the land.
- 21:43He owed a portion of his crop to the owner.
- 21:46He was subject to the owner's authority and disputes.
- 21:49He wasn't everything but name a serf.
- 21:52This wasn't just a Roman problem.
- 21:55It's a pattern. When a centralized state
- 21:57collapses, people don't become free, they become dependent on
- 22:02whoever can offer them protection.
- 22:04The price of that protection is always autonomy, always.
- 22:08The great Roman estates, the 3rd and 4th centuries, were the
- 22:12embryos of medieval feudalism. The transformation didn't happen
- 22:16overnight. It didn't happen because anyone
- 22:18planned it. It happened because ordinary
- 22:21people, facing a broken state in a hostile world, made the
- 22:25rational choice to trade freedom for survival.
- 22:28The tragedy is that they were right to do it.
- 22:31The estate system worked, at least in the narrow sense of
- 22:34keeping people alive. The villi produced food,
- 22:38produced shelter, and offered defense.
- 22:41They were the institutions that actually functioned when the
- 22:44Roman state couldn't. But the cost was enormous.
- 22:49The independent farmer, the backbone of the Roman Republic.
- 22:53The man who voted and served and owned his piece of the earth was
- 22:58slowly replace a dependent tenant.
- 23:01The citizen became the subject. The Republic became the Manor.
- 23:06And this is how civilizations actually change, not in dramatic
- 23:09collapses in quiet trades. Security for freedom, protection
- 23:15for autonomy, survival for dignity. 1 farm, one family, one
- 23:20desperate bargain at a time. When everything else fails, The
- 23:24money, the government, the army, the law.
- 23:28People look for something that can't be debased.
- 23:31The explosive growth of Christianity during the crisis
- 23:34of the 3rd century is not a coincidence.
- 23:37It's a case study in what fills the vacuum when institutions
- 23:41collapse. In 235, Christianity was a minor
- 23:44religion, tolerated in some provinces, persecuted in others,
- 23:49but nowhere dominant. By 300 to 65 years later, it had
- 23:53become a mass movement that no emperor could ignore.
- 23:58Constantine would legalize it in 313 and embrace it himself.
- 24:02Within a single century, the faith of marginal Jewish sect
- 24:05became the organizing principle of Western civilization.
- 24:09Why? Because it did what Rome
- 24:11couldn't. Consider what a Christian
- 24:13community offered to an ordinary Roman during the crisis.
- 24:17First, belonging. In a world where the old social
- 24:20structures, the Guild, the municipality, the patron client
- 24:24network were collapsing, the Christian ecclesia provided a
- 24:29new community. You belong to something you were
- 24:32known, you mattered. Second, material support.
- 24:36Christian communities collected donations and distributed them
- 24:40to the poor, the sick, and the widowed.
- 24:43They maintained burial funds, crucial in a culture that feared
- 24:47an unmarked death. They organized food distribution
- 24:51during famines. They cared for the sick during
- 24:53plagues. At a time when Roman medicine
- 24:56was essentially powerless and Pagan temples offered only
- 25:00prayers. There were multiple devastating
- 25:03plagues during the crisis period.
- 25:05The Plague of Cyprian beginning around 2:49 may have killed as
- 25:09many as 5000 people a day in Rome at its peak.
- 25:14Pagan Romans fled. The sick Christians, following
- 25:17the teachings of their faith, stayed to nurse them, and some
- 25:20died for it. But the ones who survived, and
- 25:23the Pagan neighbors who survived because Christians nurse them,
- 25:26well, they remembered. 3rd, and this is the most powerful
- 25:30Christianity offered a narrative.
- 25:32It explained the suffering. The world was broken, and
- 25:36Christianity said because the world was always meant to be
- 25:39temporary, the empire's agony wasn't meaningless.
- 25:43It was part of a larger story that ended in redemption.
- 25:46When your coins are worthless, when your soldiers take your
- 25:49food, when your children die of plague, and when the emperor
- 25:53changes every 18 months and one of them is worse than the last,
- 25:59the human need for meaning doesn't disappear, it
- 26:02intensifies. And the old Roman religion, with
- 26:06its transactional relationship to the gods, I sacrifice you,
- 26:10bless my crops, couldn't provide meaning in an era of systematic
- 26:14failure. You can't sacrifice your way out
- 26:17of a debased currency. Christianity could.
- 26:20Well, not materially, but psychologically, socially,
- 26:23structurally. It provided A framework for
- 26:26enduring what couldn't be fixed. And this too is a pattern.
- 26:31When empires fracture, faith movement surge.
- 26:34Not just Christianity, Any system that provides community
- 26:37meaning and mutual aid in the absence of functioning
- 26:41institutions. The early Islamic UMass served
- 26:45the same function during the fragmentation of the post Roman
- 26:48Middle East. The Buddhist Sangha did the same
- 26:51in periods of Chinese dynastic collapse.
- 26:54When the state fails the people, the people build a new state,
- 26:59and they often build it in a temple.
- 27:01The ordinary Roman who joined a Christian community in 260
- 27:05wasn't making a purely theological decision, he was
- 27:08making a survival decision. He was joining the only
- 27:11institution that was growing while everything else shrank.
- 27:15We need to talk about the plague because it intersects with every
- 27:19other crisis, and it reveals something essential about how
- 27:23ordinary people survive when everything happens at once.
- 27:26The Plague of Cyprian, named after this Christian Bishop who
- 27:30documented it, began around 2:49 and lasted about 15 years.
- 27:36Some scholars think it continued in waves for nearly 20 years.
- 27:40At its peak, sources claim 5000 deaths per day in Rome alone.
- 27:45We don't know exactly what the disease was.
- 27:48Descriptions of the symptoms? Bloody diarrhea, gangrenous
- 27:51extremities, hemorrhaging from the eyes and secondary
- 27:55infections. I've LED some historians to
- 27:58suggest it was a phylovirus similar to Ebola.
- 28:02Others suggest a particularly virulent strain of smallpox or
- 28:06measles. The truth is, we don't know.
- 28:08What we do know is devastating. Conservative estimates suggest
- 28:12the empire lost 15 to 25% of its population during the plague.
- 28:18Some provinces were hit harder. Egypt may have lost a third of
- 28:22its people. Parts of Africa were similarly
- 28:24devastated. Now the layer that tops
- 28:27everything else, the currency, is collapsing.
- 28:30The frontiers are under assault. The emperors are being murdered
- 28:33every two years. Tax collectors are squeezing a
- 28:36population that's shrinking. And now, on top of it all, a
- 28:41plague is killing one in four people.
- 28:43This is the overlapping crisis that makes the 3rd century not
- 28:47just a political problem or an economic problem, but an
- 28:51existential 1. And it's the overlapping nature
- 28:53of the crisis that makes the survival strategies of ordinary
- 28:57people so instructive. Because people did survive.
- 29:01The empire didn't. The population eventually
- 29:04recovered. Life went on, changed,
- 29:07diminished, restructured. But continuous.
- 29:10How? 3 mechanisms.
- 29:13All three of them carry lessons that extend far beyond Rome.
- 29:17First, decentralization. The communities that survived
- 29:20best were the ones that depended least on the central state.
- 29:24Remote villages that grew their own food, made their own tools,
- 29:28and resolved their own disputes. Barely noticed the change of
- 29:31emperor. The plague hit them less hard
- 29:34because they were less densely populated.
- 29:36The currency collapse mattered less because they'd already
- 29:39reverted to barter. They were, in a sense, pre
- 29:42adapted to collapse because they'd never fully been absorbed
- 29:46into the Roman system. Second, skill diversification.
- 29:50The individuals who survived best were the ones who could do
- 29:53more than one thing. The farmer who could also do
- 29:56metal work. A soldier who knew animal
- 29:59husbandry. A merchant who can navigate by
- 30:01the stars. When systems collapse,
- 30:04specialists are the most vulnerable.
- 30:06The cobbler who only makes shoes needs a functioning economy to
- 30:10eat. The generalist who can grow
- 30:12food, mend his own roof, and trade directly with his neighbor
- 30:16needs only his neighbor. The Roman military reorganized
- 30:20this instinctively. Legion areas had always been
- 30:23trained in engineering, construction, and agriculture,
- 30:26as well as combat. During the crisis, those
- 30:29secondary skills became primary. Soldiers stationed on the
- 30:33frontier became in practice armed farmers.
- 30:37They grew what they ate. They built what they needed.
- 30:40They became self-sufficient communities that the city could
- 30:44no longer be. Third was network preservation.
- 30:47People who survived best maintain social connections
- 30:50across distances. Letters in the papyri, even
- 30:54during the worst years, show family networks operating to
- 30:58move information, resources and people.
- 31:01A cousin in Alexandria warning a brother in the Follum about
- 31:06approaching soldiers. A merchant maintaining contacts
- 31:09in three provinces so that when 1 route closed, another opened.
- 31:13A Christian community in Carthage sending grain to a
- 31:17sister community in Rome during a famine.
- 31:20Networks, family, religious and commercial, where the invisible
- 31:23infrastructure that held Roman society together.
- 31:26When the visible infrastructure crumbled, the roads might be
- 31:30dangerous, but the information still moved.
- 31:33The currency might be worthless, but the relationships still had
- 31:37value. This, too, is a pattern in every
- 31:40societal crisis, ancient or modern, The survivors are the
- 31:44people who maintain their networks.
- 31:47Isolation kills, connection saves, not connection to the
- 31:51state, connection to each other. By the two 60s, a new figure had
- 31:56emerged in the Roman world who tells us everything about what
- 31:59survival looked like at the macro level.
- 32:02The military strongman who was also essentially a local
- 32:05government. The formal title didn't matter.
- 32:08Some were called a Dukes, a leader.
- 32:11Some were called provincial governors who happened to
- 32:13command troops. Some were outright usurpers who
- 32:16controlled a single province or a handful of cities.
- 32:21What mattered was function, not title.
- 32:23These men collected taxes or simply took resources.
- 32:27They defended borders, or at least their personal territory.
- 32:31They administered justice, or they at least settled disputes.
- 32:35They maintained roads, or at least the ones they needed.
- 32:39The Roman Empire in the two 60s was in practice a patchwork of
- 32:43local power structures held together by memory of unity and
- 32:47the aspiration to unity, but not functionally a single state, and
- 32:52this meant that ordinary people's survival depended
- 32:55almost entirely on the quality of their local strong men.
- 32:58If you lived in a region controlled by an effective
- 33:01military leader, someone who would keep the roads open,
- 33:04prevent raiding, maintain some semblance of order, your life
- 33:08was hard but survivable. If you lived in a region that
- 33:12was contested between rival claimants or in a frontier zone
- 33:16that no one was effectively defending, your life was a
- 33:19nightmare of random violence, confiscation, and uncertainty.
- 33:23The literary and papyrological evidence from Egypt during this
- 33:27period shows exactly this dynamic.
- 33:31The blem eyes nomadic Raiders from the South launched repeated
- 33:34incursions into Upper Egypt during the two 60s and two 70s.
- 33:39In regions where the local military commander was competent
- 33:42and present, these raids were contained in regions where the
- 33:46commander had been recalled or had been declared himself
- 33:50emperor and marched his troops. Elsewhere with a civilian
- 33:54population was left defenseless, and the defensive measures
- 33:58people took were extraordinary. Temple complexes were converted
- 34:02into fortified refuges. The Temple of Luxor, for
- 34:06example, was turned into a military camp during this
- 34:09period, with the sacred spaces literally walled off and
- 34:12repurposed. Civilian communities organized
- 34:15their own militias, wealthy land owners fortified their estates
- 34:19and armed their tenants. This is the birth of what would
- 34:22eventually become the medieval castle and the feudal Lords
- 34:25obligation to defend his people. It started here in the 3rd
- 34:29century as an improvision, as a desperate response to a state
- 34:34that couldn't perform its most basic function.
- 34:37The power fault line had cracked wide open.
- 34:40Power was no longer centralized. It was localized, fragmented,
- 34:44personalized, and ordinary. People had to navigate a
- 34:48landscape where the rules changed every time they crossed
- 34:52an invisible line between one strong man's territory and
- 34:56another's. Some adapted, but many didn't,
- 34:59and the ones who adapted best were again, the ones with
- 35:03networks, skills and, crucially, mobility.
- 35:07A merchant who could travel between territories carrying
- 35:09goods and information was valuable to every local power.
- 35:14A farmer rooted to his land was at the mercy of whoever showed
- 35:17up with the biggest army. So let's pull back and look at
- 35:20the composite picture. Because by the time Diocletian
- 35:24restored order in two 8449 years after the crisis began with the
- 35:28murder of Severus Alexander, the Roman world had begin
- 35:33transforming beyond recognition. And the people who survived that
- 35:37transformation shared a set of characteristics that we can
- 35:41identify, we can document them, and we can learn from them.
- 35:44First, they divested from the center.
- 35:47They stopped relying on the imperial government for
- 35:49anything. Currency, security, justice,
- 35:53infrastructure. Not out of ideology, out of
- 35:56observation. The center had failed
- 35:58repeatedly. Predictably, the survivors were
- 36:02the ones who noticed early and built alternatives.
- 36:05Second, they localized. They built or strengthened local
- 36:09networks. Family, community, religious,
- 36:12commercial. They could function
- 36:15independently of the imperial system.
- 36:17They traded with their neighbors.
- 36:19They defended their own territory.
- 36:21They resolved their own disputes.
- 36:23The empire became, in practice, a collection of localites that
- 36:27happened to share a name. Third, they diversified not
- 36:31financially. That's a modern concept imposed
- 36:35Akronistically. They diversified their
- 36:38capabilities. They learned multiple skills.
- 36:41They maintain multiple sources of food.
- 36:44They kept multiple social connections to multiple places.
- 36:48They made themselves anti fragile.
- 36:51Not rigid enough to break when one pillar failed, but flexible
- 36:55enough to shift 1 weight to another 4th.
- 36:59They store real value. Not in coins, in land, in tools,
- 37:04in skills, in relationships, and things that had intrinsic
- 37:09utility. Regardless of what some distant
- 37:12emperor stamped on any piece of bronze.
- 37:15The farmers who kept producing survived.
- 37:18The Craftsman who made essential goods survived.
- 37:21The merchants who dealt in necessities, Grain, iron, cloth,
- 37:25salt, well, they survived. The speculators, the financiers,
- 37:30the people whose wealth existed only in a number on the Ledger
- 37:34or face on a coin, well, they were wiped out. 5th and this is
- 37:38the most uncomfortable one, they accepted a lower standard of
- 37:42living. The generation that entered the
- 37:44crisis in 235 expected Roman standards, baths, roads, courts,
- 37:49entertainment, imported goods and currency based trade.
- 37:54The generation that emerged from it in 284?
- 37:56Well, they expected much less. They expected to eat.
- 38:00They expected not to be killed. The bar had been lowered so far
- 38:04that survival felt like a victory.
- 38:07And this is perhaps the most important pattern of all.
- 38:10Civilizational collapse doesn't feel like the end of the world
- 38:13to the people living through it. It feels like a long series of
- 38:16adjustments, each one slightly worse than the last one, each
- 38:21one becoming the new normal before the next downward step
- 38:25arrives. The Romans who survived the
- 38:27crisis of the 3rd century didn't think of themselves as living
- 38:31through the fall of civilization.
- 38:33They thought of themselves as getting by, managing, adapting,
- 38:38making the best of a bad situation.
- 38:41The bread was worse, but there was bread.
- 38:44The roads were dangerous, but there were roads.
- 38:47The coins were worthless, but you could still trade grain for
- 38:50tools. Normal moved.
- 38:52It moves slowly, it moved downward, and at every step,
- 38:56people adjusted their expectations to match the new
- 38:59reality. Because the alternative was
- 39:02despair, and despair doesn't grow crops.
- 39:05In 284, a general named Diocletian took the throne, and
- 39:09against all odds, he held it for 20 years.
- 39:13No usurper killed him, no barbarian defeated him.
- 39:17He reformed the army, restructured the provinces,
- 39:20reorganized the tax system, and split the empire into four
- 39:24administrative units. The Tetrarchy, to prevent the
- 39:27power vacuums that had caused the crisis.
- 39:31History calls this the Restoration.
- 39:33The textbooks breathe a sigh of relief.
- 39:36The Empire was saved, But was it?
- 39:39Let's look at what Diocletian actually restored.
- 39:42The currency was stabilized by introducing new coins and
- 39:45issuing an edict of maximum prices, which attempted to
- 39:49freeze prices by law. It didn't work.
- 39:52Black markets flourished and the edict was eventually abandoned.
- 39:57The army was reorganized by drastically increasing its size
- 40:01to perhaps 580,000 men. This was paid for by increasing
- 40:05taxes, which were now collected more efficiently through
- 40:09reformed census. In other words, the tax burden
- 40:13on ordinary people increased under the Restoration, the
- 40:16social stratification that emerged during the crisis.
- 40:20Cole and I bound to the land, Kur Isles bound to their duties,
- 40:23sons bound to their father's professions, wasn't reversed.
- 40:27It was codified, made permanent, written into law.
- 40:31The emergency measures became the architecture of the late
- 40:34empire. Diocletian didn't restore the
- 40:37Roman Empire of the 2nd century. He built something new on its
- 40:40ruins and called it by the old name.
- 40:43The prosperous, mobile, urbanized, monetized world of
- 40:46the anti emperors was gone. What replaced it was a
- 40:50militarized, stratified, increasingly rural society
- 40:55organized around largest states, local strongman and compulsory
- 40:59obligation. And here's what that means for
- 41:02the ordinary Roman who survived to see the restoration.
- 41:06His life didn't get better. It got more organized.
- 41:09The chaos was reduced, the violence was contained, the
- 41:14borders were defended again. But the freedom, the mobility,
- 41:18the prosperity, the sense of possibility had defined Rome for
- 41:22centuries was gone, traded away for order.
- 41:26This wasn't just a Roman problem, it's a pattern.
- 41:30Every civilization that survives A systematic crisis pays for its
- 41:34survival with liberty. The crisis demands civilization
- 41:38control and sacrifice. The restoration codifies those
- 41:42demands, and the people who lived through the chaos accept
- 41:46it gratefully because they remember how bad it was.
- 41:50The generation that remembers the crisis accepts the chains
- 41:54their children who don't remember start to pull at them.
- 41:58So what does the crisis of the 3rd century teach us?
- 42:02Not as historians, but as people.
- 42:04It teaches us that empires don't fall on their rulers, they fall
- 42:09on their carriers. The people at the top have
- 42:11options. They always have options.
- 42:14They have gold when the coins are bronze, they have estates
- 42:18when the cities die, they have private armies when the legions
- 42:21fail. The crisis has survived
- 42:24differently at different levels of the pyramid, and the people
- 42:27at the bottom always pay the highest price.
- 42:31It teaches us that the money is the 1st and the last lie to be
- 42:35admitted. Every Roman knew the coins were
- 42:37bad, every emperor knew, the merchants knew, the soldiers
- 42:42knew. But the system continued as if
- 42:44the coins were real, because admitting the truth would
- 42:47require confronting the spending causing it.
- 42:50So the fiction continued for decades while ordinary people
- 42:55slowly drowned in it. It teaches us that borders are
- 42:58not just lines on a map, they are the promises that someone is
- 43:02watching. When that promise breaks, when
- 43:05the forts empty, when the patrols stop, when the response
- 43:09is slow. The border doesn't just fall as
- 43:13a defensive line, it fails as a societal contract.
- 43:17And the people who live near the borders know first.
- 43:19It teaches us that power, when centralized in a failing state,
- 43:24doesn't just become ineffective, it becomes predatory.
- 43:28The same tax system that built the roads and funded the baths
- 43:32becomes the system that bankrupts the middle class and
- 43:36binds the farmer to his field. The institution doesn't change,
- 43:40It's context does. And when the context becomes
- 43:44desperate, the institution eats the people it was built to
- 43:47serve. It teaches us that the survivors
- 43:50are not the strongest, they're the most adaptable.
- 43:54They're the ones who build redundancy into their lives.
- 43:58Multiple skills, multiple connections, multiple sources of
- 44:02sustenance. They're the ones who see the
- 44:05trend before the crisis and then begin to adjust while the
- 44:08adjustment is still possible. And it teaches US1 more thing,
- 44:12the most important thing. The Roman Empire lasted another
- 44:15200 years after the crisis of the 3rd century.
- 44:19It lasted because ordinary people, farmers, soldiers,
- 44:23merchants, Craftsman, mothers, and priests found ways to keep
- 44:27going when every system designed to support them had failed.
- 44:31They didn't save the empire. They saved each other in small
- 44:35ways, in local ways, in ways that no historian ever recorded
- 44:41because they were too mundane to notice.
- 44:43A farmer who shared grain with his neighbor.
- 44:46A soldier who stated his post when his pay stopped.
- 44:49A woman who organized her community's food when the market
- 44:52closed. A merchant who kept trading when
- 44:55the currency died, accepting goods instead of worthless
- 44:58coins. They didn't know they were
- 45:00living to the death of civilization.
- 45:03They just knew that the bread was a little worse every year,
- 45:06that the road was a little more dangerous, but the coins didn't
- 45:10quite buy as much. Normal moved.
- 45:13They adjusted. They survived.
- 45:15And if you've been watching closely, if you recognize the
- 45:18pattern, you know that what I've just described isn't just
- 45:23ancient history. It's a diagnostic.
- 45:25And the patient is on the table. It is just Rome.
- 45:28This has been the Roman pattern. I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 45:32Please like this video, Leave us a comment, and smash the
- 45:35subscribe button if you want more of the Roman pattern.