Latest / Newcomer Pod / AI, Longevity, and the Health Revolution with Nayeema Raza
Transcript
- 0:00What is your outlook on what the Trump administration has done in
- 0:02healthcare so far? What kind of grade would you
- 0:04give? RFKI don't know if there's a
- 0:06grade low enough F minus minus. We're at a crazy moment in
- 0:11health. We've got AI disrupting
- 0:14traditional medicine. Doctors don't want to rely on
- 0:16Chachi BT, but they're happy to rely on open evidence.
- 0:19RFK and the Trump administration with their Maha Make America
- 0:23Healthy Again movement is transforming American health for
- 0:26good and bad. I'm gonna let him go wild on
- 0:29health. And then you've certainly seen
- 0:31people like Brian Johnson and other billionaires who are
- 0:34interested in figuring out how they could try to live forever.
- 0:37You will die. False.
- 0:41We brought together some of the most serious people in Silicon
- 0:44Valley and the startup world who are thinking about all those
- 0:46changes in the health at newcomers brand new event Deus
- 0:50Ex Medicina. I hosted the event with Naima
- 0:52Raza and she's here to join me to talk about some of the major
- 0:56themes. We'll play some of the
- 0:57highlights for you and give our reactions and help you make
- 1:01sense of the crazy stuff and help that's going on in Silicon
- 1:04Valley right now. This podcast is supported by
- 1:07Google. Hey folks, Steven Johnson here,
- 1:10Co founder of Notebook LM. As an author, I've always been
- 1:13obsessed with how software could help organize ideas and make
- 1:16connections. So we built Notebook LM as an AI
- 1:20first tool for anyone trying to make sense of complex
- 1:23information. Upload your documents and
- 1:25Notebook LM instantly becomes your personal expert, uncovering
- 1:29insights and helping you brainstorm.
- 1:32Try it at Notebook lm.google.com.
- 1:35Name it, you're not wearing your hat.
- 1:37My, Oh my God, I have another Hon.
- 1:39You know, I'm an Aspen, so I have like, you're moving.
- 1:41On to the next thing. You're like, we just wrapped up
- 1:44Deus Ex medicina. You're like, oh, I've got a new
- 1:46hat, new new things on my mind. I love the hat.
- 1:50You know, we're always going. I'm wearing the hat.
- 1:52You're not. That's sort of like the the
- 1:54dynamic overall. I think you're a little.
- 1:57Too look at this hair, you want to cover this hat?
- 1:59All the time. Exactly.
- 2:01Anyway, we have wrapped up Deus Ex Medicina, our inaugural AI
- 2:06Health and Longevity Summit that we hosted together.
- 2:09Obviously, you are the wonderful host of the Smart Girl Dumb
- 2:13Questions. I got my plurals and singulars
- 2:16right, Smart Girl Dumb Questions host.
- 2:18And yeah, thrilled to be here with you.
- 2:20What was your reaction to the event and what was what
- 2:23surprised you the most? What surprised me the most, you
- 2:26know, I thought one of the things that was electric in the
- 2:28room every time it came up was the Trump administration's
- 2:32policies surrounding healthcare. And what I thought was what did.
- 2:38You call it like a brick or? Electric, I said it was.
- 2:43Electric. Oh, OK.
- 2:44Yeah, it was electric in the room because I think people were
- 2:47just like, really curious to know what other people thought
- 2:49about it. It was kind of like everybody
- 2:51had a thought about it, but everyone wants to know what
- 2:52someone else thinks before they talk about what they think.
- 2:54Exactly why, sort of in our predictions episode, I said I
- 2:57don't know if people are going to want to talk about it, I
- 2:59think. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:00But I think people love talking about it and loved hearing what
- 3:02people said about it. So there was a real, I would say
- 3:06split not within the room, but within many of the people that
- 3:09we heard from on stage. People would split their opinion
- 3:12between what they thought of vaccine policy.
- 3:15No good, very bad, as Vino Khosla put it, F minus, minus
- 3:19for RFK. Pretty much across the board.
- 3:21People voiced concern about it. But then a lot of optimism
- 3:25around, you know, the kind of kill the clipboard campaign that
- 3:28you're seeing out of CMS and Medicare, Medicaid, A lot of
- 3:33hope for the administration's willingness to work with the
- 3:35private sector on revolutionizing some of the
- 3:38technology and processes around healthcare in America.
- 3:42And I, I kind of left thinking, OK, is this self interested?
- 3:45Is this what companies say? Because like, they need to be
- 3:47doing business with government here?
- 3:49But I really felt it was sincere.
- 3:51You had people on stage like Tom Hale, CEO of Aura, saying, look,
- 3:55I'm not a Republican, but showing some bullishness around
- 3:58what the Trump administration has done or could do in policy.
- 4:02Yeah, policy obviously loomed large.
- 4:05I mean, the government and Trump are affecting what everything,
- 4:08everything like Tiktok has grown in private.
- 4:10But health obviously more than anything, a highly regulated
- 4:12industry. Silicon Valley cares a lot about
- 4:15health. Vinod giving them an F minus was
- 4:18obviously like a moment and I but I don't know, I'm more on
- 4:24the view that everybody plays their role and if I'm the CEO,
- 4:30it's like gotta go for whatever win with the government I can
- 4:33get. And so you have to leave some
- 4:35room for like what? It's like you're you're
- 4:38parenting a small child. You know, as I'm preparing to do
- 4:41you, you're you hope for you teach them.
- 4:43You're aspirational. Like, yo, the your intentions
- 4:45are so good. You're trying to do this thing,
- 4:48you're trying to privatize the thing we all want.
- 4:50Whenever I hear them say they're really gonna let businesses run,
- 4:53it's sort of like leave us alone, let us do our thing.
- 4:56But then when you actually push them on, what about the FDA?
- 4:59It's either what about the FDA like it's bad or I, I haven't
- 5:03read or looked at anything on that.
- 5:05It's like, I don't think anything specific.
- 5:06They're like pretending they sort of like have no clue what's
- 5:09going on. Well, I like that.
- 5:11I, I feel like when I really like your metaphor in which
- 5:14Donald Trump is a baby in diapers and Tom Hale's like the
- 5:16big daddy being like you're doing great.
- 5:18You keep crawling up here. But that's not, but I, but see,
- 5:22I think that if that were the case, they would be wary because
- 5:25those I, I think we taped right before Trump had even kind of,
- 5:28or maybe it was just around Trump kind of distancing himself
- 5:31from RFKS vaccine policy, but saying that the White House
- 5:34still stands behind him completely, whatever that means.
- 5:37But you know, it was in the specifics for me.
- 5:39Like when we had the conversation with Strand
- 5:42Therapeutics, Jake Bacraft and Janice Chen from Mammoth
- 5:45Biosciences and Janice told the story of how this
- 5:48administration, which so hates mRNA vaccine technology.
- 5:54I mean, two things that came out of that conversation. 1 Jacob
- 5:57Bacraft clarified that what the administration had done in terms
- 6:02of cutting $500 million in mRNA funding, which was widely
- 6:05reported as such, was really around the vaccine funding.
- 6:08There continues to be a lot of investment dollars when it comes
- 6:11to Cancer Research, cancer specific vaccines, etcetera.
- 6:14It was in the in the other world of vaccines, flus, etcetera,
- 6:17that they they had cut this research, the respiratory stuff.
- 6:21But then Janice made the funny point that, you know, RFK hates
- 6:25mRNA, loves CRISPR, which relies on mRNA technologies.
- 6:29And so there there is clearly a disconnect.
- 6:31Hopefully he doesn't learn the science anymore.
- 6:33Like if he figures it out, he's going.
- 6:35To hate curse personal, it's better.
- 6:36That he just like stay, stay, just stay out informed on this
- 6:39connection. Yeah.
- 6:41So I guess I'm less skeptical of their bullishness about policy
- 6:46and more by it. But I'm curious, what surprised
- 6:48you, Eric? Yeah, I mean, the pure, the
- 6:52business person in me, the sort of student of the Silicon Valley
- 6:56startups, I'm very interested in the rivalry between a bridge and
- 7:00open evidence. It's not, it's not a rivalry
- 7:02yet, but these are two companies that are core to how do we bring
- 7:06foundation models to doctors, a bridge we're going to sell to
- 7:11health systems. You're going to you're your
- 7:13doctor talking to your note taker app.
- 7:15We're going to help you make sense of that.
- 7:16And then very importantly, we're going to help you sell to tell
- 7:20your insurance company why they owe you a lot of money.
- 7:22You know your patients, you know a lot of coverage.
- 7:24And basically we're going to sort of be your tool and your
- 7:27the fight with insurance companies and making sense of
- 7:30those messy doctor notes. On the other hand, you have open
- 7:34evidence, which is like, no, we're going to help doctors
- 7:36actually diagnose patients, figure out what's going on.
- 7:39And you know, it helps the patients probably don't want to
- 7:42hear that their doctor is going to chachi BT to figure out what
- 7:46to do. So no, we're going to open
- 7:47evidence. The doctor official trained on
- 7:50medical journals tech and and they're like basically having
- 7:53doctors just choose to use their free product and then, you know,
- 7:58getting pharmaceutical ads. The good old fashioned business
- 8:01model. Yeah.
- 8:02Anyway, so I thought there are two super interesting companies
- 8:05that eventually are going to compete with each other.
- 8:06But do you have a prediction on who's going to win, Eric?
- 8:08Are you now going to be, are you going to be like, oh, you know,
- 8:11I think everyone's doing a good job.
- 8:13Keep crawling, babies. Interesting.
- 8:16Who do I think is going? I haven't actually.
- 8:17I mean, without the numbers, it's always hard to tell.
- 8:20It's a great like Silicon Valley tech question because it's like,
- 8:23oh, a bridge is sticky. They're selling to health
- 8:26systems. And so the real threat, of
- 8:29course, is open AI coming, coming for them both.
- 8:31So I do think a bridge is building deals that might be
- 8:35hard for open AI to dislodge. I think open evidence is
- 8:40providing like free advice, something that Touchbt does
- 8:44really well. So I guess I think open evidence
- 8:47faces more threat from open AI. But you know, people love a
- 8:53Silicon Valley business that's like so good.
- 8:55Everybody just wants to use it. It grows because people tell
- 8:58each other about it. So I guess I'm betting a little
- 9:02bit on a bridge if I had to pick, but they're really great
- 9:04companies. And I thought that was a good
- 9:05moment in your interview with the Abridged founder where she
- 9:08was like, Oh yeah, we are basically going to compete with
- 9:10them. We're going to go in that game
- 9:12with open evidence. I also like the moment in my
- 9:15conversation with the Hippocratic CEO, Manjal Manjal
- 9:18as well as Daniel Kahn from Slingshot AI.
- 9:20And they had kind of back and forth about whether or not
- 9:23there'll be 1 foundational model that eats the rest or not.
- 9:26And Daniel kind of came to Manjal was saying, oh, you know,
- 9:32someone unnamed AKA Sam is pushing this idea.
- 9:35Sam Altman, Open AI. Sam Altman, Open AI, is pushing
- 9:37one idea of one big model, and he thinks it's going to be Manny
- 9:40and Daniel. Daniel was saying, actually, Sam
- 9:42doesn't necessarily believe that it's going to be the case, but
- 9:45that is, yeah, the back end of all this.
- 9:47Like where is this all going to be powered?
- 9:49And who's going to own the models?
- 9:50And who does? Who own the models, own the
- 9:52system Or, you know, or who attracts the doctors, owns the
- 9:56system? We'll see.
- 9:58I mean, and drug discovery was very important, but I think
- 10:00that'll come up in the clip. So I'll, I'll hold my my drug
- 10:03discovery takes for that. All right, let's play our first
- 10:05clip and it's I think me in conversation with Jonathan
- 10:08Swirlen, who's the CEO of Function.
- 10:10Do you see trends that are geographically distributed?
- 10:12When you see the data, it upsets your stomach a little bit
- 10:14because we see how many people are suffering needlessly with
- 10:18things that are actually really solvable, that don't even
- 10:20require medical intervention, but are things you solve in your
- 10:23life. The level of cardio metabolic
- 10:24disease in this country, even amongst people you you would
- 10:27consider healthy is so high. And the result of that is like
- 10:31in 20-30 years, if they're, if they're in their 30s or 40s,
- 10:34like there's a likelihood they're going to have a heart
- 10:36attack and they might leave their families behind.
- 10:39And these things are, I know what happens when you pull the
- 10:41thread on some of these issues. It's a little nauseating to see
- 10:44that at such a scale. And then it's also at the same
- 10:46time encouraging because you, you, we flipped the lights on
- 10:49like people are in the dark. Wow, you guys just really chose
- 10:52the the least spicy moment of that whole interview.
- 10:55Because I thought it was a very Silicon Valley moment.
- 10:57I wanted to start there just because he really hit that chord
- 11:00you expect from Silicon Valley. It's just we want to save the
- 11:03world. I'm a true believer.
- 11:04You gave him a hard dime. And it was definitely amusing.
- 11:06And people go, we could, we're posting the full clips on
- 11:09YouTube so you can go listen to it and watch them sort of rough
- 11:13him up a little bit. But I did think, what did you
- 11:15think of his, the sincerity of his sort of, there's so many
- 11:18people that need our help and you can explain the business a
- 11:21little bit to people. What sincerity do you see what I
- 11:25did there? They have no, I, I don't.
- 11:29I think that look, he has to say that I was curious what they're
- 11:32doing. Like my big my big question was
- 11:33what are you doing with all this data?
- 11:34Right, because function health is one of the fastest growing
- 11:37companies they've had. I think it's 450% year on year
- 11:40growth. Like if you're on any social
- 11:42media platform, you have seen the ads.
- 11:44It's 500 bucks. Get all these blood panels that
- 11:46you'll never have from your doctor.
- 11:47Earlier in the day, Annie Lamont, investor at Oak HCFT,
- 11:51had made the point that, you know, 90% of what you see in
- 11:54some of these blood panels, etcetera are actually covered by
- 11:57insurance. And so there's some marketing.
- 11:58Will every you know, sure rich people will pay for functions
- 12:02branded we're going to help you figure everything out test.
- 12:06But as it reaches mass market, those people are just going to
- 12:08go to health insurance companies if this is possible.
- 12:10That's that's basically the trade off with.
- 12:12Functions and Jonathan brought up like the geographical
- 12:15distribution of their of their company so I'm like great what
- 12:18does that data look like are are people healthier in parts of the
- 12:20country or not and I got this kind of soft answer back So what
- 12:23do I think of the sincerity of that look I don't think you get
- 12:26into the healthcare business because you're.
- 12:27Trying to. Am I struggling to stay on
- 12:30topic? Or no, no, no, you're I'm, I'm
- 12:33saying you're struggling with sincerity itself.
- 12:36I like I. I no, because I think actually
- 12:38like I, I mean, I believe that most people get into their
- 12:41fields because they care about the thing.
- 12:42So yes, I do believe that Jonathan is someone who cares
- 12:46about the health Americans. I think Markimas someone who
- 12:48cares about that. They might have different
- 12:50perspectives on you about that, but they have their own stories
- 12:52that brought them to it. Yeah.
- 12:54What I think is interesting about the business is you are
- 12:58providing services that are then executed on by Quest Labs and
- 13:02now with their recent acquisition of Ezra MRI scans
- 13:04that are done by third party vendors.
- 13:07What you have value in is the data.
- 13:09And are you going to move into the actual labs business?
- 13:12And Jonathan didn't say no. He said not today, which to me
- 13:15as a journalist says, OK, tomorrow, you know, choose
- 13:18whatever length of time. Why do you choose?
- 13:20The medical system is built to treat sick people and like the
- 13:26longevity insight, you know, and I think there are a couple, but
- 13:29a key one is, well, we should the medical system should be
- 13:32doing more for healthy people and say you're healthy.
- 13:36Doctors would say don't get a bunch of tests and scare
- 13:39yourself. Like just you're healthy, be
- 13:40healthy, don't worry about it. Like do these, you know, eat
- 13:43healthy, exercise and like leave us alone.
- 13:45And I think like companies like function where they're like, no,
- 13:48get a scan. Like things could be wrong or
- 13:50you could be better. Like, I just think businesses
- 13:52coming at something with a different mentality and saying
- 13:56we, you know, we believe in medicine, but we should like
- 13:58look at these things differently.
- 13:59I think there's opportunity there just to like take a new
- 14:01lens to something where there's so much consensus and how
- 14:05medicine is thought about something.
- 14:07So I think they have opportunity and just that they clearly have
- 14:09a fresh lens for how most of you know medical testing is getting
- 14:14done. Yeah.
- 14:15And also, I mean, that is a shift that I think is here to
- 14:18stay preventive. I mean, call it longevity, call
- 14:20it whatever, but preventative health and people's own kind of
- 14:24end of one healthcare like treating yourself as your own
- 14:28baseline of what good health looks like and not shifting all
- 14:31those costs onto the system or onto the back end.
- 14:33Now I think what's important is like, can everyday clinicians
- 14:38compete and will they upgrade and start providing a lot of
- 14:41these indicators and tests? And as Andy said, many of them
- 14:44would cover it, but you would have to ask, your insurer would
- 14:47have to agree, etcetera. And that bureaucratic process is
- 14:50really hard. So it's easier to, you know,
- 14:52swipe and and get the blood done.
- 14:56I think we have a clip on GLP once, maybe we go to that
- 14:58because I think that fits great directly with this longevity
- 15:01conversation we're having. Probably and this will probably
- 15:03be our conversation with Noom CEO, Seju Zhang and.
- 15:07Yeah, all yours are the best, I guess.
- 15:08You know, we're doing all Naima. Clip No, no, I'm just, I'm just
- 15:11introducing the clip. No, it's good play that they're
- 15:14not the best. I can make fun of myself.
- 15:17Yes. Do you think pharmaceutical
- 15:18companies are going to double down on GLP ones and other kind
- 15:21of preventative care over the R&D that they're doing for
- 15:24cancer treatments? Or there's definitely a lot of
- 15:27rumors that they're going to get into explicit aging and
- 15:30longevity and like have an aging division, which would be the
- 15:34sickest thing ever. And I hope it happens.
- 15:36Like an aging drug or longevity drug sounds so radical, but it's
- 15:39just a preventative medicine for multiple diseases, right?
- 15:43Ozempic is preventative medicine for the downstream negative
- 15:46consequences of obesity. Statins are preventative
- 15:48medicine for certain forms of age-related cardiovascular
- 15:51disease. That's all a longevity drug is
- 15:53too. And oh, by the way, statins are
- 15:54the most successful drug class in history.
- 15:57GLP ones are probably going to beat them, right.
- 15:59And so the minute people see that, and I'm sure people there
- 16:03already do, they're incredibly smart.
- 16:05Yeah, I think it's going to happen.
- 16:06So this is Celine, who's the founder of Loyal, which is you
- 16:09might think she's doing drug life extension for humans, but
- 16:12in fact she's doing life extension for dogs, which is
- 16:14such an interesting play, but came up in human sciences.
- 16:17Why do you think of her prediction, Eric?
- 16:18What I love about Celine is that like, she's sort of doing this
- 16:22like Tesla strategy, right? You start with like the Roadster
- 16:26and then you're like, from there, we'll save the planet.
- 16:28Elon might have gotten lost on his save the planet with clean
- 16:32energy. But Celine, it's like, OK, if we
- 16:34can figure out how to save your dog, which is a lower regulatory
- 16:37burden then everybody else, then we'll be able to do it with
- 16:40humans and do much more. And so she's a true believer in
- 16:43like longevity. How can we make healthy people
- 16:46live higher quality lives? And I, I think she's right that
- 16:50like pharmaceutical companies are going to wake up and say,
- 16:52oh, there's clearly money in it. Silicon Valley's investing in
- 16:54it. GLP ones made a bazillion
- 16:56dollars and we should take this more seriously.
- 16:59Yeah, to quote the the great artist Cuba Gooding Junior, it's
- 17:03like, show me the money. This is the money.
- 17:05This GLP ones have fundamentally shifted how we think about
- 17:09people's willingness to pay for healthcare.
- 17:11This is an industry that you would rather pay for.
- 17:14Like you don't think twice about buying a new pair of sneakers,
- 17:18but when it comes to something for your health that might cost
- 17:21a fraction of that, you're like, no, because it should be covered
- 17:24by my insurance. I already paid for my insurance
- 17:25and the insurance should cover it.
- 17:26So there's this whole psychological wrap up.
- 17:29And what we're seeing with GLP ones is what we've seen with,
- 17:32say, Botox, where people are willing to pay for a medical
- 17:36product out of pocket all of a sudden.
- 17:38And no doubt pharmaceuticals want to get in that space.
- 17:42And they also I think she and Seiju from new made this point
- 17:46will want to increasingly go direct like Celine has chosen to
- 17:49own distribution end to end from during clinical trials and
- 17:52putting, you know, to putting shots in pause, I guess is the
- 17:56analogy in this case. And.
- 17:59I think a subtle thing people learn with GLP ones is like, the
- 18:03story of the drug matters so much.
- 18:05You know, it's like they had been around, you know, has
- 18:08helped people with diabetes. And obviously, you know, you
- 18:11need it to be sort of primarily useful for obesity, which, you
- 18:16know, allowed for this It's. Blow up, yeah, it's still
- 18:19heavily regulated. You still need a BMI of 25 to
- 18:21qualify for Ozempic. I think Newham has introduced
- 18:24this micro dosing GLP ones, which I'm very interested in.
- 18:28I think this will move over time.
- 18:30It's someone who's not at that BMI.
- 18:31I would like to. I mean, I've thought about oh,
- 18:34should I be micro dosing GLP ones because all of a sudden if
- 18:37it's anti-inflammatory and really had longevity benefits
- 18:40which are still being borne out and being tested and studied.
- 18:43But if that is the case, then why would we reserve it only for
- 18:46a portion of the population? All right, let's play the next
- 18:49clip. And this is you, Eric, talking
- 18:51to Doctor Han Park, who's the head of digital health at
- 18:53Samsung. 40% people in the US do not know they have sleep apnea.
- 18:57There was a study that showed when you reach 61% decrement per
- 19:01year in deep stage sleep increase your dementia risk by
- 19:052527%. And so our users use our
- 19:09wearables a lot for tracking their sleep.
- 19:12One of the top reasons for sleep issue has to do with sleep
- 19:16apnea. So we have a software as a
- 19:18medical device, we'll screen for you and say we think you have
- 19:22sleep apnea. 40% people in the US do not know they have sleep
- 19:25apnea. So the watch actually uses PPG
- 19:28signals. We validated this in a sleep lab
- 19:31and so and we got the FDA clear based on the standard we met and
- 19:35essentially we're able to screen to a very good accurate degree
- 19:39as to whether you have sleep apnea.
- 19:41I have to say, after that moment, I was like, I think I
- 19:44have sleep apnea. It's just the most people's
- 19:47reaction to that moment. What did you think about that?
- 19:50I have two very contradictory takes.
- 19:52I guess the, this is the one that sort of fits with what I've
- 19:55been saying is just, you know, it, it's good to help people
- 19:59sort of, you know, you're already wearing these devices
- 20:02like get the data, figure out what's wrong with you, like find
- 20:05some improvement. There is another part of me
- 20:08that's like, man, it's what capitalism does best.
- 20:11It's like, you don't realize you have a problem.
- 20:14Let us sort of plant the seed that you have a problem that we
- 20:17can then sort of sell you a solution to.
- 20:19And I, I do think that's where the medical establishment gets
- 20:22wary. It's like some of these things.
- 20:25Are only really problems if you feel like you're suffering and
- 20:29if they suggest you, you might be now all of a sudden you might
- 20:32have a need that you didn't have before.
- 20:34So I think it just depends on the seriousness of an issue.
- 20:37I mean, I do think sleep apnea is a real thing, but you can see
- 20:40how, taken to an extreme, suggesting people should be
- 20:44worried about this new thing or that could be stressful for
- 20:47people. Yeah.
- 20:48Sleep apnea is a very interesting use case for it
- 20:50because it's the kind of thing that you might not know you have
- 20:53it. And especially if like you're
- 20:54asleep, you think like you're asleep.
- 20:56And if you're not in a relationship, right?
- 20:58And like, if you're in a relationship, you might know,
- 20:59someone might say to you, hey, you're snoring or hey, you seem
- 21:02to stop breathing in the middle of the night.
- 21:03But if it's just you having bad sleep, you have no idea what
- 21:06that is. And, and third kind of thing
- 21:08that it triggers in me is these basic elements of health, which
- 21:12is like health, you know, it's like, are you hydrating?
- 21:15Are you eating good food? Are you moving your body?
- 21:17Are you having good communal relationships?
- 21:19Are you, well, kind of those are your five real indicators of
- 21:22health and or like drivers of health, most people would say.
- 21:25And so, but this is 1 where. Yeah, I think it's interesting
- 21:28the way they've been able to work with the FDA to get that
- 21:31use case out there. And certainly will be a way that
- 21:36we see a lot of these devices start to compete with each other
- 21:40is I think in their ability to diagnose, slash, prescribe or at
- 21:44least get proximate to that, give you readouts that are
- 21:47doctor friendly and or talk to you like the OR Tom Hale.
- 21:51I was like, when is your ring going to talk to you?
- 21:53And he's like, Oh yeah, we've been talking to Manjal, the CEO
- 21:56Hippocratic about that for years.
- 21:58Like could your ring just call you?
- 22:00I mean, to get like philosophical for a second,
- 22:03yeah. I feel like there's a funny
- 22:05realization with health where you're like, oh, I'm in charge
- 22:07of it, You go to your doctor. But then at some point, like
- 22:11your doctors like barely see you, they're like oblivious and
- 22:14you realize like, oh, it's like it's just me.
- 22:17Like no one is really your doctors definitely know less
- 22:20than you. They have more expertise, but
- 22:21they're like they're not dialed in.
- 22:23And it's not that high stakes. Like if you have an issue, you
- 22:25sort of need to conclude you have an issue or not.
- 22:28And this is like a very like, I don't know, you're alone in the
- 22:31universe sort of revelation that I think people have at some
- 22:35point. And it's funny with technology
- 22:37that I do think there is this real potential that it's like,
- 22:40oh, we emit all this data and AI is getting very smart.
- 22:44And like, someday soon there will be another force sort of
- 22:48like watching out for you and saying, I'm worried you have
- 22:51this thing. And like, will that change for
- 22:54good and bad, the sense that there's a protective sort of
- 22:58layer around us that that we pre that force didn't have?
- 23:02Yeah. And the data around it is really
- 23:04interesting because all of a sudden you have that data and
- 23:07then it becomes is it what signal, what's noise in that
- 23:09data? And that's where you're really
- 23:11dependent on the device and the authorizations for people
- 23:13telling you. But like, you know, one of the
- 23:15greatest innovations of the Aura ring in the last six years has
- 23:18been their ability to tell you where you are in your cycle.
- 23:21And people are using that for for sexual health, for for
- 23:24fertility tracking, for trying to get pregnant.
- 23:27And you're taking something that was a really terrible experience
- 23:30of like you spend your 20s trying not to get pregnant, then
- 23:32you spend your 30s trying to get pregnant and peeing on sticks
- 23:35and doing all kinds of things. And whereas making that, I think
- 23:39the studies show that it's much more accurate than time
- 23:41thinking. It's probably.
- 23:42I don't. I don't know if it's as accurate
- 23:44as peeing on a stick, but. I mean, part of what you're
- 23:47getting at, I think is this like it's a tool to inform you.
- 23:51It's like it's your data, it's giving you advice, but you still
- 23:55feel like the actor. It's not this sort of like
- 23:58other, which is like, hey, like I've made this unilateral
- 24:01decision for you. It's like it ultimately
- 24:03reinforces the sense you're in control because you're getting
- 24:06information that allows you to be as sort of more informed
- 24:10decision. Maker though health is, you
- 24:12know, one of these industries that you still have to rely on
- 24:15potentially going through someone else or at least seeking
- 24:17the advice of someone else because data has a bunch of
- 24:19numbers and that's where I think they use a bill.
- 24:22Like a lot of what will drive the competitiveness or not of
- 24:26these companies is how usable and glanceable glance ability is
- 24:29a metric that Apple, for example, looks a lot at.
- 24:31So when they create these PDF readouts, I know one of the
- 24:34things that they look at is how quickly can a doctor digest that
- 24:36information? Because a problem in the
- 24:38clinical setting that you're having is people are coming in
- 24:41with all this information and saying to their doctors, but I
- 24:43have this massive MRI report and they're saying, why are you
- 24:46doing this? Like you're in your 30s, you
- 24:48seem super healthy. Why are you having a full body
- 24:50MRI scan? Doctors talk a lot about the
- 24:53cost on the medical system from people having too much data and
- 24:57wealthy people in particular coming in with more data, taking
- 24:59more time. That's taking away time for them
- 25:02to see other patients. So the health system has to
- 25:04think about how to absorb or compete with what we're seeing
- 25:07here. One question I have for you is
- 25:09we have talked about whether or not they'll be 1 bundle for
- 25:13healthcare or not or if there'll be, you know, like what the
- 25:16future of healthcare looks like. Will it be like streaming where
- 25:19you have all these different bundles competing with each
- 25:21other or will these stay disaggregated companies?
- 25:25Did you have a prediction or more of a thought on that coming
- 25:27out? Of no, it's beyond me.
- 25:28It's just so hard with the insurance layer.
- 25:31Like your vision is like sort of a Netflix type subscription
- 25:35where it's like you have insurance and then you have your
- 25:38like additional I'm willing to pay.
- 25:40And the way you get people to do that is you sort of offer them a
- 25:43bunch of stuff and they. Well, I'm just saying that
- 25:46vertical integration like function health buying as well.
- 25:48Like all of a sudden it's like, oh, are you part of the, you
- 25:50know, I'm making this up obviously or something.
- 25:52Are you part of the Ponuvo Aura Newham bundle or are you part of
- 25:55the function Health Woop whatever bundle.
- 25:59It makes, I mean, I, you know, I used one medical like it's, you
- 26:01know, a relatively small fee, but certainly I would be happy
- 26:06to pay much more if it was like, OK, here's do all these things,
- 26:10you know, lead you to it tied in with we're going to try and get
- 26:14insurance to cover everything we can, but we've sort of thought
- 26:18through what the supplemental stuff is that you should pay
- 26:20for. Yeah.
- 26:21I imagine the future we're going to be paying for like they'll
- 26:24still be insurance, which will largely be employment driven.
- 26:26And then you'll have a set of subscriptions that you pay, but
- 26:29instead of paying 10 different providers, you're going to pay 1
- 26:32bundle price. That's going to be a discount on
- 26:34like 4 things that you're getting.
- 26:35Here's a question to Chevro, the CEO of a bridge, the company
- 26:39that I talked about that was selling 2 medical systems giving
- 26:43doctors transcription services. My mother is so worried about AI
- 26:48is going to deny all my claims and the insurance companies are
- 26:52going to just be so empowered to like find every way to weasel
- 26:55out delivering care and that could get extended to Medicare
- 26:58Advantage. How worried are you about
- 27:00insurance companies weaponizing this technology?
- 27:02My, my sense so far is that there is a ton of opportunity
- 27:06for us to figure out the right way forward.
- 27:08And when you think about risk adjustment, it's so difficult
- 27:12for a clinician to capture the whole story.
- 27:14And as technology can do that and that's a win, win for
- 27:17everyone involved. I used to be on a clinical
- 27:19documentation improvement team at a health system at UPMC in
- 27:22Pennsylvania. And we used to do these lunch
- 27:23and learn. So we go from department to
- 27:25department and do pizza and PowerPoints and try to teach
- 27:27doctors about risk adjustment, about what they call meet
- 27:30criteria, about documenting what you discuss monitoring,
- 27:33evaluating, assessing or treating against any given
- 27:35problem. We try to teach them about
- 27:37utilization management and versus OP status or E&M criteria
- 27:41or medical decision making. Did you document it completely?
- 27:44All of this stuff in one year out the other Every single
- 27:46clinician in those sessions wanted had 1000 yards there and
- 27:50just wanted to get back to clinic, see their patients and
- 27:52then get home and see their families.
- 27:54And So what happens when you can take these models to risk
- 27:56adjustment school to revenue cycle school?
- 27:58What happens when you take them to prior authorization school?
- 28:01What happens when they're behind the scenes reasoning through and
- 28:04what happens when they go to medical school and they can help
- 28:05the like the clinician feel like a superhero in front of their
- 28:09patient. And so that's that's sort of the
- 28:11high level journey that we're on.
- 28:13Pizza and PowerPoint, I think very different things happen in
- 28:15all of those settings. I mean, I imagine insurers are
- 28:18going to use that AI to deny, deny, deny, and clinicians to
- 28:22diagnose, diagnose, diagnose. But what do you think?
- 28:24I mean, Shiv is, you know, on the side of doctors, They're
- 28:27they're going to work with insurance companies some, but I
- 28:30think, you know, doctors are their customers.
- 28:32So they are trying to help doctors get more out of
- 28:34insurance companies. So he's sort of the feel good
- 28:38story. I don't think the insurance
- 28:39companies have any incentive to shout about how they use AI.
- 28:43And so we'll hear less about it, but certainly it's going to be
- 28:46going on. But I take Shiv's point that
- 28:49like insurance companies, their job is to figure out like, oh,
- 28:52you didn't do the right thing. Like we're not going to pay for
- 28:54that. That's not how it's supposed to
- 28:55go. And so doctors, you know, get
- 28:57into the business of being a doctor business.
- 28:59They want to help people, not because they want to file
- 29:01claims. And so perhaps they have more
- 29:04room to benefit from having this tool than insurance companies
- 29:09do. But I definitely think an arms
- 29:11race is very possible. And that's in a lot of domains.
- 29:14The most dystopian case for AI, which is, I mean, sort of like
- 29:19the law in America, you have your expensive lawyer, I get my
- 29:22expensive lawyer and we fight it out.
- 29:24Like you get your great AII, get my great AI, and we fight it
- 29:26out. Then it's like, are we any
- 29:28better with all that spending? Yeah, it'll be a three-way arms
- 29:32race because, you know, like my big excitement when chatbots
- 29:36became mainstream and 2023 is like, I dreamed of a chat bot to
- 29:40fight the United chat bot, United Airlines chat.
- 29:44Like, just like I will just put this thing to work.
- 29:46So it's not my time. It's like you deal with my
- 29:48agent. And I think over time it will be
- 29:50bad. It'll be the doctors, you know,
- 29:52it'll be the agentic Dr. and the agentic insurer and the agentic
- 29:55patient fighting it out about what's going to be the right
- 29:59solution. So there is that arms race.
- 30:01Reality is something that I think we're driving towards.
- 30:04And Speaking of this great arms race, it's probably a good time
- 30:06to play the conversation that we were talking about earlier
- 30:09between Manjal Shah, Hippocratic AI, and Daniel Kahn from
- 30:13Slingshot AI about whether it'll be 1 foundational model that's
- 30:17going to really power all of the healthcare companies in the
- 30:20world or if it's going to be competing models out there.
- 30:23Certain people who will remain unnamed have been running around
- 30:26the world saying you know 1 ring will rule them all.
- 30:29Yeah. And it's just not true.
- 30:31We have tried it. We have tried.
- 30:32There's only one model that we trained ourselves on, 6,000,000
- 30:35calls of nurses talking to patients.
- 30:36And you can't get there 'cause these models, even when they
- 30:39have a million token context window, they can't pay attention
- 30:42to all of it. And so you have to multiply
- 30:44attention span by multiplying models.
- 30:46It could be that closed source or open source models dominate.
- 30:49It's extremely hard to predict. But wherever the the world goes
- 30:51it, it is entirely possible that it's fine tuning.
- 30:54It could be a whole new paradigm of fine tuning that emerges.
- 30:56Who knows, we might be building on top of foundation models.
- 30:58We might be able to be building separate models.
- 31:00I think it's personally, I just think it's kind of pointless to
- 31:03predict. I think machine learning
- 31:04engineers on the ground, we don't really care.
- 31:07So that's such an interesting take because now Daniel Kahn,
- 31:11who's arguing that it doesn't really matter, is actually from
- 31:14Slingshot AI, which has built its own foundational model for
- 31:17behavioral health. It's a mental health provision
- 31:19company that's really probably like really competing with
- 31:22ChatGPT and one of their prime businesses right now.
- 31:24What they wanted necessarily, but it is a big use case therapy
- 31:28versus the Hippocratic AI model. It's really like 20 plus
- 31:33individual models. I think they're largely based on
- 31:35another outside foundational model, but it's like 26 models
- 31:40because they need one mean 1 and 20 plus nice ones to deal with
- 31:43the patient. So the patient is getting all
- 31:46the information they need. But when the patient isn't
- 31:47behaving, patient isn't complying, taking their
- 31:49medicine, doing their walk, doing their PT, the mean model
- 31:52can come in and say, hey, you really got to be doing that in
- 31:55the world of kind of agentic voice nurses slash medical
- 31:59assistants that they're in right now.
- 32:00So they're just like taking points of view that I thought
- 32:02was like, that's kind of interesting given what your
- 32:04company is actually doing. What do you think?
- 32:08I mean, you know, I feel like I spend my life debating this
- 32:11question. You know, Cerebral Valley, our
- 32:13AI summit. It's like will open AI rule it
- 32:15all or will be lots of different models?
- 32:17I think having a super smart model is very valuable in
- 32:21getting you customers associating me with the thing,
- 32:24right? If Daniel Slingshot, it can be
- 32:27the best at therapy or one of the best, it'll be easier to
- 32:30build a brand for therapy and get people doing it.
- 32:34And you need to sort of be competitive.
- 32:36But I think the Moat more and more is like people download
- 32:40ChatGPT, people download your app like you need to have users
- 32:44engage with it. Teach them what am I getting out
- 32:47of it? Teach them the rhythm of that
- 32:49and that matters more. And if you're, you know, using
- 32:52small models and paying ChatGPT, like I think to me the customer
- 32:58relationship matters more than your proprietary model
- 33:03intelligence. And I think that's how things
- 33:04have been developing. Yeah.
- 33:06So like you're saying, whatever's in the front of the
- 33:08house matters more than what's in the back of the house?
- 33:10Yeah, shuffle a bunch of models and like all this stuff is still
- 33:13happening where like price is somewhat abstractive because
- 33:16they've been able to raise a bunch of money.
- 33:18And once price matters, you know it's nice to use open source
- 33:21models because they're cheaper. 100% that is interesting.
- 33:24I feel like I'm I less have a clear point of view on this in
- 33:29some way. I'm with you that what what the
- 33:32harder thing is, is the adoption.
- 33:34But then I think you have one bad news story, especially like
- 33:38in mental health, one bad news story about a diagnosis in the
- 33:41medical world. It's like if your model is
- 33:43feeding inaccurate information, that's that's really
- 33:47challenging. And that's why so many of these
- 33:49companies, including Hippocratic, including
- 33:51Slingshot, are staying away from prescription and diagnostics
- 33:56because that is the scary, scary world, you know, of, of
- 34:00medicine. I have like older parents.
- 34:03And so I have been in the healthcare system as like an
- 34:06advocate for my parents for a long time.
- 34:08And my sisters and I know so much about the healthcare
- 34:10system. The doctors will often be like,
- 34:12or the nurses will say, are you guys medical professionals?
- 34:15I'm sure it's racial profiling also because we're brown.
- 34:17But, and I'll always say to them, Oh no, I'm a malpractice
- 34:20attorney. Oh my God.
- 34:22And they literally look like they're going to pee.
- 34:24And I'm like, I'm just. Kidding.
- 34:26I don't know, I'm just kidding, but I know some, but I'm just
- 34:29kidding. But you know, I always get, I
- 34:31always think, I always think you get more bees than honey.
- 34:35But it's so funny. It's so funny to see people's
- 34:39reaction to that because the only thing I think doctors hate
- 34:43more than insurers are these like, right?
- 34:47All right, let's play our last clip, the spiciest of the day.
- 34:51I think we teased this at the very beginning of the episode.
- 34:53What grade would Vinod Khosla, star investor, give Health
- 34:56Secretary RFK Junior RFKI don't know if there's a great low
- 35:01enough F minus minus. He obviously cut a deal with
- 35:06Trump during the election, which is a sad state of affairs where
- 35:10our health portfolio and vaccine policies are auctioned off
- 35:14during an election. But they are doing a lot of good
- 35:17things. Doctor Oz has a very sensible
- 35:20view of how to use AI. I think the FDA is very
- 35:24interested. And you head of AI at the FDA.
- 35:28All right, he had some nice things to say about Doctor Oz.
- 35:32By the way, we didn't keep that clip running, but he was talking
- 35:34about how Doctor Oz had run his what was it 2012 or 2016, 2016
- 35:39paper or treat us on the future of healthcare and and do we need
- 35:44doctors or do we need algorithms kind of take and that doctor Oz,
- 35:48now head of of Medicare and Medicaid had responded to him
- 35:52and engaged with him on this. So Venona, very good things
- 35:54about to to think about the administration overall, but no
- 35:57love for RFK, right Junior? I think that's a consensus view.
- 36:01The only non consensus thing is whether you're willing to say it
- 36:04or not. Anyways, this was so fun.
- 36:05I, you know, I learned a lot. I think that we should
- 36:07definitely do it again. We should go to Austin or we
- 36:10should go to New York next. Weigh in where where should we
- 36:13bring daily sex medicine? And this was a lot of fun.
- 36:15Plenty, plenty more to dig into. And yeah, great to coast with
- 36:18United. Yeah.
- 36:20Thank you. Yeah, it was great to Co host it
- 36:21with you. I'm glad that we made this thing
- 36:23happen. Great.
- 36:24Sounds good. All right.
- 36:26Thanks guys.