Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / The Chagatai Khanate's Last Khan: Tarmashirin's Gamble
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about the Mongol Empire's fractures, the civil wars, the rival khans. But there's one figure who almost put the Chagatai Khanate back together, and he did it by doing something no one expected: he converted to Islam. His name was Tarmashirin, and his reign lasted only seven years, but it changed everything. Luna: Wait, I thought the Chagatai khans were the ones who stuck to the old ways? That's what I remember from earlier episodes. Lucas: Right, Chagatai himself was famously conservative about the Yassa, the traditional Mongol law. But by the early 1300s, his descendants were caught between the nomadic world and the sedentary world of Transoxiana, the rich agricultural region around Samarkand and Bukhara. Tarmashirin was the one who tipped the balance decisively toward the settled side. Lucas: He had a Buddhist upbringing, actually. His name, Tarmashirin, is Sanskrit for 'the great law' — a Buddhist echo. But after he became khan in 1326, he embraced Islam openly, took a Muslim name, Ala ud-Din, and started issuing coins in the name of the Abbasid caliph. It was a radical break, and it was deliberate. Luna: Deliberate how — like he was courting the Muslim merchants and city people? Lucas: Exactly. The Chagatai Khanate was sitting on the Silk Road, and a huge part of its wealth came from trade. The nomads collected tribute, but the merchants and urban elites were the ones who actually made the money move. Tarmashirin saw that aligning himself with Islam, the religion of the trade routes, would strengthen his ties to the cities and to the wider Islamic world, including the Ilkhanate in Persia and even the Mamluks in Egypt. Lucas: He also spent most of his reign in Transoxiana, far from the ancestral homeland of the Chagatai heartland, the steppe regions to the east. That was a signal: he was a khan for the cities, not just for the felt tents. And he pushed it further by actually making a massive invasion of India. Luna: An invasion of India? That's a big deal. What happened? Lucas: In 1327, Tarmashirin led an army south through the Khyber Pass and sacked the city of Delhi. The Delhi Sultanate was one of the wealthiest states in the Islamic world at the time, and the sultan, Muhammad bin Tughluq, had to buy him off with a huge ransom. It was a classic Mongol raid, but it also echoed the old days of Chinggis Khan and the world-conquest ambitions. Lucas: The raid made Tarmashirin's reputation as a military leader, but it also deepened the resentment among the nomadic commanders back home. They saw him spending his time in Samarkand, surrounded by Persian-speaking administrators, wearing silk and sitting on a throne in a palace. That was not how a Mongol khan should live, in their eyes. Lucas: And then there was the legal issue. Tarmashirin started applying sharia law in his domains, which meant putting the Yassa, the traditional Mongol code, on the back burner. That was a direct affront to the elders who saw the Yassa as the sacred law of Chinggis Khan, not something to be overridden by Islamic jurisprudence. Luna: So he was trying to be a sultan, not a khan. And that's what cost him. Lucas: It's more than that, because it wasn't just a matter of personal style. It was about who had power in the khanate. The nomadic princes had always been the kingmakers, the ones who elected the khan at the kurultai. Tarmashirin was essentially saying that the future was with the cities, and the nomads were going to be sidelined. Lucas: The rebellion that killed him came in 1334, led by a coalition of eastern princes who saw Tarmashirin as a betrayer. They were led by a cousin named Buzan, and they caught Tarmashirin near the city of Balkh, in present-day Afghanistan. He was captured and executed, and the khanate was thrown back into a period of chaos. Luna: Interesting. So did that mean the conversion to Islam was reversed? Lucas: Not exactly. The khans who followed Tarmashirin — there were at least eight in the next fifteen years — mostly reverted to the old ways, but the seeds had been planted. Islam kept spreading among the Chagatai Mongols, especially in the cities and among the western half of the khanate. And the eastern half, the steppe regions around Almaligh, became more and more isolated, economically and culturally. Lucas: That split is something we've seen before, but Tarmashirin's reign was the moment it became irreconcilable. The khanate effectively turned into two parts: the western, urban, Muslim half, and the eastern, nomadic, traditional half. And each saw the other as illegitimate. Luna: So he kind of caused the very thing he was trying to prevent. Lucas: In a way, yes. But that eastern half remained powerful enough to eventually give rise to a different kind of emperor, Timur, who claimed descent from the Chagatai line and who used a kind of hybrid of steppe and Islamic legitimacy to build his own empire. So Tarmashirin's gamble didn't just fail — it created the conditions for a new, more resilient power. Lucas: And that's what makes Tarmashirin so fascinating. He's not just a failed khan; he's a hinge point. Before his reign, the Chagatai Khanate was a conservative, steppe-centric state. After his death, it was a land of ferocious internal conflict, but also a place where Islam and Mongol identity were fusing into something new. Lucas: You know, that tension between the nomadic and the settled, the steppe and the sown — it runs through all of Central Asian history. And Tarmashirin is one of the clearest examples of someone trying to bridge it and getting torn apart for his trouble. It's a story that echoes even today in the region's politics. Luna: It's like the empire's worst dream come true — the old Mongol unity just shattering along a cultural line. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a line that never really healed. The Chagatai Khanate would continue to fragment, and by the time Timur came along, the memory of a unified khanate was just that — a memory, a useful myth to legitimize new empires. Tarmashirin was the one who made that myth necessary. Lucas: Sometimes I think about how much of history hinges on these personal conversions, these moments when a leader decides to change everything about how they rule. Tarmashirin's decision to embrace Islam and the cities wasn't just a religious choice; it was a political one, and it backfired spectacularly. Lucas: But it also shows how the Mongols weren't just a monolith of horse-riding nomads. They were a people grappling with the same questions of identity and power that every empire faces, just in a particular steppe idiom. Luna: So if someone were to ask you, what's the one thing to remember about Tarmashirin, what would you say? Lucas: I'd say he was the khan who tried to make the Chagatai Khanate into a sultanate, and in doing so, he doomed it. But he also opened a door that later warlords would walk through, especially Timur. So he's not just a footnote; he's a pivot. Luna: That's a good way to put it. And you know, I was thinking about what you said earlier about the nomads and the cities. It reminds me of that old saying, 'Whose steppe is it, if not the nomads'?' Lucas: Exactly. And that's the question Tarmashirin couldn't answer. He chose the cities, and the steppe answered. Lucas: I also think about how different it might have been if he'd managed to hold on for another decade. Maybe the Chagatai Khanate could have become a stable Islamic state like the Ilkhanate did, and the map of Central Asia would look completely different. But history doesn't give us do-overs. Luna: No, but it gives us plenty to talk about. And I think this is a good point to mention something that I've been wanting to bring up, if that's okay. Lucas: Sure, go ahead. Luna: Well, I know we don't usually do this, but you know how we're always saying that this show is ad-free and listener-driven? If you've been enjoying these deep dives into the Mongol world, and if a coffee-sized amount is something you can spare, there's a link in the show notes where you can support us. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: That's really what keeps us going, honestly. It's not a big ask — just a small token that says this kind of long-form storytelling matters to you. And it keeps the show free for everyone. Luna: Yeah, no pressure at all. Just if you feel like it. Now, back to the steppe — you were talking about how the eastern half of the Chagatai Khanate became isolated. What happened to it after Tarmashirin? Lucas: So the eastern half, centered on Almaligh and the Issyk-Kul region, became the Moghul Khanate — literally the 'Mongol Khanate' — which survived for centuries, long after the western half had been absorbed into Timur's empire. But it was a pale shadow of what the Chagatai Khanate had been, constantly fighting off raids from the Oirats and the Timurids, and eventually it got swallowed up by the Uzbek conquests in the sixteenth century. Lucas: And the irony is that the western half, the one Tarmashirin tried to build up, didn't survive either. Timur didn't even bother to keep a Chagatai khan on the throne; he used a puppet for a while, then just styled himself 'Emir' and claimed the whole legacy. So in the end, both halves lost their distinct identity. Luna: It's like Tarmashirin's conversion was the last real chance for a unified Chagatai state, and it self-destructed. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I find this period so compelling. It's not just about the big names like Khubilai or Hulegu; it's about these lesser-known figures who made choices that shaped the world for centuries. Tarmashirin might be little more than a footnote in many history books, but his story is a key to understanding why Central Asia looks the way it does today. Lucas: So if you want to impress your friends with a deep cut from Mongol history, Tarmashirin is a good one. Just remember — he's the khan who tried to turn the steppe into a garden, and the steppe pushed back.