Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / ATM Milano Electric Bus Fleet and Strategy
Transcript
- 0:09When a city as dynamic and complex as Milan sets a target
- 0:14for, well, 0 emission urban transport by 20-30, you have to
- 0:18ask how, right? That's not a goal you reach by
- 0:22just, you know, asking nicely. It takes deep structural change,
- 0:26and that's exactly what you sent us to investigate.
- 0:28It's a huge question, especially for a major European hub like
- 0:32Milan. We have this really detailed
- 0:34report here from TRT for the Clean Cities campaign.
- 0:37And it doesn't just ask how it actually models for potential
- 0:41paths to get there. Exactly.
- 0:42And the starting line is it's pretty daunting.
- 0:46In 2019, Milan's urban transport was generating 911 kilotons of
- 0:51CO2 equivalents. OK.
- 0:53And we should probably clarify what that number means right up
- 0:55front. We're talking about tank to
- 0:56wheel emissions. So for you listening, that means
- 0:58the emissions generated right there on the street.
- 1:00Yeah, you know, from the fuel being burned in the car's
- 1:02engine. It's.
- 1:03Not the whole life cycle. No, it doesn't count emissions
- 1:05from producing the electricity or refining the fuel, but
- 1:08focusing on tank to wheel it really lets us isolate the
- 1:11impact of the mobility choices happening right there in the
- 1:13city. Precisely.
- 1:15And the report breaks down that journey from 9/11 kilotons to
- 1:19hopefully zero through these 4 scenarios.
- 1:23Each one has a totally different policy focus, so. 1st we have
- 1:25SO1, they call it the active and collective scenario.
- 1:28The behavior change route. What maximum focus on bike
- 1:31lanes, public transit and pricing measures to manage how
- 1:35many people are driving? Then you have SO2.
- 1:37That's the technology forward path simply called All Electric.
- 1:40Just electrify everything. Yeah, get the.
- 1:42EVs on the road build the charging stations and let
- 1:45technology solve the problem. SO3 is, I guess, the compromise.
- 1:50It combines policies from both SO1 and SO2 at levels the report
- 1:54calls ambitious but attainable. And then there's the big one,
- 1:57the one we really need to dig into.
- 1:59SO4. Emission 0.
- 2:02This scenario takes all those policies from SO3 and just
- 2:06cranks them up to the absolute limits of what's feasible to see
- 2:08if that zero target is even possible.
- 2:10So our mission today is really to see what that actually costs
- 2:13the city financially and, you know, socially to get anywhere
- 2:17close to that target. Let's start with, I guess, a
- 2:19piece of good news. Milan isn't starting from
- 2:22scratch. Not at all.
- 2:25Even if the local government did absolutely nothing, a pretty
- 2:29significant reduction is already baked in.
- 2:31From Global Trends. Exactly.
- 2:33We call it the technological innovation trend.
- 2:36This is stuff like EU level mandates on engine efficiency,
- 2:39just the natural process of people replacing old cars with
- 2:43newer, cleaner ones. The report estimates this trend
- 2:46alone accounts for an automatic 24% reduction in those tank 2
- 2:49wheel emissions by 20. Thirty 25%.
- 2:51That's 223 kilotons of CO2 gone before a single new bike lane is
- 2:57even painted. So that's the floor.
- 2:59Any policy discussion has to start from that 24% drop.
- 3:03Now this is where it gets really interesting.
- 3:04When the city does start intervening, if they choose to
- 3:07focus purely on behavioral change, that's SRO one, the
- 3:10total reduction hits 54% OK, But if they focus purely on
- 3:14electrification, SRO 2, the reduction is 56%.
- 3:18Which is striking because those are two completely different
- 3:21philosophies, right? Pushing people out of cars
- 3:23versus just making the cars cleaner.
- 3:25And they get almost the exact same result.
- 3:27Yeah, they both get you about halfway there.
- 3:30It suggests that up to that 55% reduction point, you get pretty
- 3:35similar climate benefits whether you focus on modal shift or a
- 3:38big tech swap. So this is the part I don't get.
- 3:40If one is 54% and the other is 56%, why did so 3, the scenario
- 3:45that combines them, only get the total reduction to 60%?
- 3:49You'd think adding them together would get you much higher, but
- 3:52the data says no. This is the critical systems
- 3:55interaction. The report flags.
- 3:57It's the. But wait, there's a catch
- 3:58moment. When you model policies
- 4:00together, they can sometimes, well, they can work against each
- 4:03other. So they dilute each other's
- 4:04effectiveness. Give us an example of how that
- 4:06works. OK, think about a low emission
- 4:08zone. An LEZ right?
- 4:10It's designed to be a painful tool.
- 4:12It bans old polluting cars and that forces the owner to either
- 4:16buy a cleaner vehicle or switch to public transport.
- 4:18So it's a stick. It's a stick, but if Milan also
- 4:21follows the SO2 path which pushes for rapid EV uptake, a
- 4:25huge chunk of those old diesel cars just get replaced by new
- 4:28electric vehicles. I see.
- 4:30And because the new electric car is exempt from the LEZ.
- 4:33The driver is never forced to make that bigger behavioral
- 4:36change. They're never pushed onto the
- 4:37tram or onto a bicycle. So the LEZ succeeds in cutting
- 4:41emissions, but it completely fails in its other goal, which
- 4:44is reducing congestion and car dependency.
- 4:46Exactly. That rapid EV uptake becomes an
- 4:49obstacle to the modal shift that SO one was all about.
- 4:53And that lack of additivity is why SO3 only gets us to 60%.
- 4:57That tension brings us straight to the mobility data SO2 that
- 5:00all electric path. It gave Milan a great GHG
- 5:03reduction. A 56% drop.
- 5:05But it resulted in the lowest reduction in private car vehicle
- 5:08kilometers or V kilometer, only an 18.6% drop in how much people
- 5:13were actually driving. Now compare that to SO 1, the
- 5:16behavioral scenario. That one achieved a much
- 5:18stronger 26.5% reduction in car use.
- 5:21Because it targeted the driving itself, not just the tailpipe,
- 5:24right? The core message here for you,
- 5:26the listener, is that just because the tailpipe emissions
- 5:28are 0, it doesn't mean the city's problems with traffic
- 5:31and, you know, just the sheer space cars take up have been
- 5:34solved. And Milan has a really unique
- 5:36challenge here. The city isn't an island.
- 5:38No, far from it. Nearly four out of every 10
- 5:41trips, 39% are commuters flooding in from the surrounding
- 5:44counting areas. If all those commuters just swap
- 5:47their old SU VS for new electric SU VS, the city center is still
- 5:50completely choked with traffic. And managing that traffic, it
- 5:53comes with a trade off, a cost to the individual.
- 5:56We see it clearly in the modeling.
- 5:57Travel time goes up. It does policies like expanding
- 6:01traffic calming measures. The report estimates these will
- 6:04cover 85% of the core city in that SO4 scenario.
- 6:07Or shifting people to modes that are just slower, like walking or
- 6:11public transit. It all adds up.
- 6:13So across all the scenarios, the average travel time increases a
- 6:16little bit, but in SO 4, the most ambitious one, it's up by
- 6:208.5%. That's a real political
- 6:22challenge to sell. It is, but it's a challenge that
- 6:25comes with enormous social gains, which we'll get to.
- 6:27But first, let's pivot from passenger trips to logistics.
- 6:29Curb and freight. Yeah, because free was a
- 6:32surprisingly big piece of the pie.
- 6:34It accounted for 20% of all transport CO2 in 2019.
- 6:38So how? Does the report clean up that
- 6:40sector for the delivery vans, the light duty vehicles for?
- 6:43Those SO2 and SO3 get a very respectable 55% EV uptake, but
- 6:49SO4 the near 0 scenario that requires A genuine radical shift
- 6:55in how goods move around the city.
- 6:57It means an absolute explosion in cargo bikes.
- 6:59How? Big of an explosion?
- 7:00Are we talking? The cargo bike vehicle
- 7:02kilometers, It rises to 404,000,000 V kilometers per
- 7:06year in SO4. That's a volume that tells you
- 7:08these aren't just for delivering small packages anymore.
- 7:11This is serious commercial and industrial delivery inside the
- 7:14city core, replacing whole fleets of vans.
- 7:16It's a fundamental change in the city's DNA.
- 7:19And for the biggest polluters, the heavy duty vehicles, the
- 7:22HDVS. SO4 pushes for serious change
- 7:25there too. The fleet share of battery
- 7:27electric and hydrogen trucks jumps to 36.7%.
- 7:30Almost 40%. And crucially, that's almost all
- 7:33battery electric. 35.4% Bev, only 1.3% hydrogen.
- 7:37It's a huge jump from the other scenarios, which only see about
- 7:40a 4% shift for heady trucks. It really confirms that to get
- 7:43near 0 you have to decarbonize the big rigs.
- 7:45Let's shift now to the Co benefits, the stuff people in
- 7:48Milan would feel immediately. Air quality software.
- 7:51Fantastic gains. The data on nitrogen oxides Knox
- 7:55is particularly impressive. How impressive.
- 7:57Knox. Emissions see the most striking
- 7:59reduction. They drop it by over 80% in the
- 8:01moderate scenarios. And in SO4 they hit a reduction
- 8:04of over 90%. Wow.
- 8:06And that's a direct result of getting cleaner engines on the
- 8:09road and, you know, aggressively pushing the oldest, dirtiest
- 8:12trucks and cars out. When you clean up combustion,
- 8:16those exhaust pollutants just plummet.
- 8:18But the. Reductions for a particulate
- 8:19matter, PM 2.5, they're not as good.
- 8:22They range from a 39% reduction in SO1 up to about 57% in SO4.
- 8:28Why the gap on PM 2.5? That's another.
- 8:30Key finding for you to think about.
- 8:32Even a fully electric vehicle, it still generates PM 2.5 from
- 8:35the tires. And brakes exactly.
- 8:37We call them non exhaust components.
- 8:39Particulate matter from tire wear, from brake wear, and from
- 8:42just churning up Rd. dust. So even though SO4 has fewer
- 8:46cars and they're all electric, those non exhaust emissions mean
- 8:49the total PM 2.5 reduction is structurally limited.
- 8:52OK, now. For the massive societal gain,
- 8:54the one that actually pays the biggest financial dividend in
- 8:57the whole report, Rd. Safety.
- 8:58The safety. Dividend, as they call it, the.
- 9:00Correlation here is just it's stark.
- 9:03If you look at SO1SO3 and SO4, the scenarios that all
- 9:07prioritize infrastructure, traffic calming, and getting
- 9:10people out of their cars, they all see Rd. traffic deaths drop
- 9:14by 47% to 49% almost. In half.
- 9:18What about SO2? The scenario that just swapped a
- 9:21gas car for an electric car that.
- 9:23One only achieved a 12% reduction in traffic deaths 12.
- 9:26Percent versus almost 50 that. Comparison is maybe the most
- 9:29powerful piece of evidence in the whole study.
- 9:31It proves that policies focused on infrastructure, on slowing
- 9:34cards down, on getting people onto safer modes.
- 9:37They provide these profound quantifiable safety benefits so
- 9:41much. So that the money saved from
- 9:43fewer accidents is the biggest win It is.
- 9:45When you monetize all the external savings from GHDS, from
- 9:49air pollution, from noise, the savings from improved Rd. safety
- 9:52are actually the largest single portion of that benefit.
- 9:55That's a huge. Insight The policies that save
- 9:57lives are the biggest financial win for the city, even before
- 10:00you start counting carbon. Absolutely.
- 10:02And the good news for policymakers is that overall the
- 10:04economics are positive. In all four scenarios.
- 10:07The total external savings, the value of cleaner air and fewer
- 10:11deaths outweigh the total net costs of actually doing it.
- 10:15So the. Investment pays for itself, but
- 10:16let's look at SO4, the path to near 0.
- 10:19That's the most expensive one, right?
- 10:20We're talking €2.05 billion in total net costs.
- 10:25Yes, it costs the most, but it also achieves the most.
- 10:27And because SO4 gets that massive 91% emissions reduction,
- 10:31the sheer volume of CO2 it abates means it actually
- 10:34delivers the best cost effectiveness ratio of all four
- 10:37paths. So it's.
- 10:37The best bang for your buck only. €309 per ton of CO2
- 10:41equivalent reduced so the. Lesson isn't just spend less,
- 10:45it's that massive coordinated investment pays off best when it
- 10:49achieves the highest level of abatement.
- 10:51Volume matters, correct? The data is definitive on this.
- 10:55If Milan actually wants to get close to 0, they have to be
- 10:57talking about SO4. It's the only one that gets them
- 10:59a 91% reduction but that. Requires truly radical changes.
- 11:02It means pushing policy to the absolute limit.
- 11:05So let's detail some of those, because this is where the
- 11:07behavioral reality really hits home.
- 11:09What does SO4 demand from the average person living in Milan
- 11:12It. Demands an immediate and
- 11:14probably painful increase in pricing.
- 11:17Specifically, the report models tripling parking fees compared
- 11:21to what they were in 2019 triple.
- 11:23That's a major deterrent and. Access restrictions go way
- 11:27beyond a normal low emission zone.
- 11:29SO4 implements A0 emission zone AZEZ that covers 100% of the
- 11:34study area the entire. City.
- 11:35So what does that mean? In practice?
- 11:37It means. Virtually no internal combustion
- 11:39engine vehicles allowed in at all.
- 11:41Only fuel cell well plug in hybrid and full battery electric
- 11:45vehicles can get access and on. The behavioral side, the social
- 11:48demands are even bigger. Oh yeah.
- 11:50Instead of, you know, maybe one car free Sunday a month, SO4
- 11:53requires one car free day every week 1.
- 11:55Day a week, that's a fundamental lifestyle change for the whole
- 11:58community, Not just a policy, but a constant weekly reminder
- 12:02of the transition and to. Support that you need heavy
- 12:05investment in infrastructure. We're talking reserved public
- 12:07transport lanes covering 25% of the entire Rd. network and.
- 12:12For the EVs that are allowed, you need way more chargers.
- 12:15A lot more. The target in SO 4 is at least
- 12:17one charging point for every 5 EVs.
- 12:20That's a much denser network than the 1 to 8 ratio in the
- 12:23other scenarios, but the. Scale of the so four challenge
- 12:25is probably captured best by one final statistic to get that 91%
- 12:29reduction you. Need to reduce overall car
- 12:32ownership in the city by 27%. Get rid of more than 1/4 of all
- 12:36cars that. Kind of reduction demands both
- 12:38the massive tech change and these profound behavioral
- 12:42shifts, all driven by price signals and infrastructure that
- 12:44just makes public and active transport easier and cheaper
- 12:47than owning a car. So what?
- 12:48Really stands out to me is that the data is just.
- 12:52It's crystal clear Milan cannot just electrify its way out of
- 12:55this problem. That SO2 path.
- 12:57It only gets them halfway there, and it still leaves them with a
- 13:00congested, less safe city. They have to embrace the
- 13:02comprehensive approach from SO4. The only viable route is this
- 13:06combination of hard constraints like the 100% per CEZ and the
- 13:10tripled parking fees, but matched with compelling
- 13:12alternative new metro lines, heavily discounted public
- 13:16transport fares, especially for young people and the elderly.
- 13:19You have to offer a carrot with the stick.
- 13:21And there's one last piece of information in the report that,
- 13:24for me, makes the case for SO4 even stronger, right?
- 13:28This gets into what the analysis didn't quantify exactly.
- 13:32While the report monetized the huge savings from cleaner air
- 13:35and fewer Rd. deaths, and that was already enough to justify
- 13:38the cost, it's specifically noted that it did not try to
- 13:41monetize the health benefits from increased physical
- 13:43activity. All that.
- 13:44Extra walking and cycling. Yeah, the.
- 13:46Simple cumulative health benefits spurred by that massive
- 13:49modal shift in SO4. Since those policies rely so
- 13:53heavily on getting people active, the true economic and
- 13:56social benefits could actually be far higher than the already
- 13:59impressive figures they calculated.
- 14:01It's a. Powerful incentive to look
- 14:02beyond just the tailpipe. Absolutely.
- 14:05The decision from Milan, and really for any major city with a
- 14:080 emission target isn't whether to invest, but how
- 14:13comprehensively to invest. Well said.
- 14:15Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into Milan's ambitious
- 14:18future. We hope this exploration of the
- 14:21source material was clear and interesting for you.
- 14:25We. Certainly appreciate you
- 14:26trusting us to synthesize this really critical information.
- 14:29Please be sure. To follow the channel for more
- 14:30deep dives into complex topics that matter to you.
- 14:33We'll see you next time.