Latest / The Vegan Report / Cage-Free vs. Egg-Free
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the vegan report, my name is Ryan
- 0:02and yesterday the organization InDefense of Animals
- 0:06hosted an interesting webinar about the Beyond
- 0:10Cage Free initiative, featuring Anita Krantz,
- 0:15who recently joined us on the show when this
- 0:17campaign was first launched, as well as Dr. Feras
- 0:21Harcini and Robert Griot, two other past guests
- 0:24of the show, and amazing activists. This episode
- 0:29is the recording of that webinar edited to make
- 0:32it podcast friendly. You'll hear them discuss
- 0:36what they find problematic about K3 campaigns.
- 0:41Why they believe leading pro -vegan campaigns
- 0:45is a better alternative. What they think about
- 0:49precision livestock farming and effective altruism.
- 0:54Why they signed the Beyond K3 petition. and much,
- 0:58much more. This conversation was hosted by Leah
- 1:02Wilburn, Farmed Animals Campaign Specialist,
- 1:06alongside Lisa Levinson, Campaigns Director at
- 1:10InDefense of Animals. I want to thank them for
- 1:14their amazing work and for allowing me to turn
- 1:17the webinar into a podcast. You'll find links
- 1:21in the episode notes to connect with InDefense
- 1:24of Animals and the organizations founded by Anita,
- 1:29Faraz and Robert, as well as a link to sign the
- 1:33Beyond Cage Free petition. As always, share this
- 1:37episode with the vegans you know, let's spark
- 1:40a conversation about the future of this movement,
- 1:44follow and subscribe for more thought -provoking
- 1:46conversations, and leave a good review. Thank
- 1:50you for tuning in every week. Hello, everyone.
- 1:53Thank you so much for joining us today. My name
- 1:56is Lisa Levinson. I'm the Campaigns Director
- 1:58for In Defense of Animals, and we are here with
- 2:01a very special program for you. We will be doing
- 2:05a Beyond Cage Free expert panel with leaders
- 2:09in the field, and this will be shared with all
- 2:17of you and with our supporters on Facebook, and
- 2:22it's going to be moderated by our Farmed Animals
- 2:27Campaign Specialist, Leah Wilborn. Hey, Leah.
- 2:31Hi, everyone. Hi, Lisa. And we are here with
- 2:34- Hi, everybody here. We're here with Mary Easoncy,
- 2:38who is our development specialist. Hi, Mary.
- 2:42Hey, everybody. And we also have some esteemed
- 2:46guests today who Leah will be introducing shortly.
- 2:51Thanks, Leah. All right. Yes, I'm beyond beyond
- 2:56happy to for the H free coalition to welcome
- 3:00these three incredibly powerful leaders in the
- 3:04animal rights movement. They all three of them
- 3:08founded and run their own organizations. So first,
- 3:12we're going to say a quick hello and then I'm
- 3:14going to introduce each of them before they speak.
- 3:17But hello, Anita Crane's. Dr. Faraz Harsini and
- 3:21Robert Grillo, welcome. Thank you, Leah. Thank
- 3:26you. Thank you. Good to be here. Wonderful. Okay.
- 3:31Hi, Faraz. Okay. All right. So I'm just going
- 3:35to share my screen. And I will speak for about
- 3:3810 minutes. And then each of the speakers will
- 3:41also speak for about 10 minutes. And then we're
- 3:43going to have a Q &A at the end. Faraz is giving
- 3:47three other talks in universities today. So he
- 3:51will be needing to leave us about 15 minutes
- 3:54early. And then we will take some questions from
- 3:57the chat. So, the Beyond Cage Free Coalition,
- 4:01this only started in the last few months. It's
- 4:05had an incredible takeoff and the other three
- 4:08speakers will be getting more into what it's
- 4:10all about. We have in the coalition now almost
- 4:15100 other organizations from around the world,
- 4:20and numerous experts have signed on to this open
- 4:23letter that we'll be talking about. But I wrote
- 4:26an article for In Defense of Animals, the cage
- 4:28-free scam, and beyondcagefree .org has an open
- 4:33letter to the effective altruist community and
- 4:37the AI industry because so many of us advocates
- 4:42and not just for animals, but in many different
- 4:44sectors, are very concerned about a large portion
- 4:49of animal advocacy, especially the funding being
- 4:54invested in primarily welfare campaigns, but
- 4:58particularly cage -free egg campaigns. And the
- 5:02concern is based on years of research that's
- 5:07been compiled and was published in... the white
- 5:11paper that PETA put out earlier this year. And
- 5:15it shows that from experts in many different
- 5:19fields, including veterinarian studies done at
- 5:22universities, government studies, even industry
- 5:25studies, that the welfare for hens in cage -free
- 5:29systems is either marginally improved, unchanged,
- 5:32or in some ways worse. If you look at that, that
- 5:37white paper or the beyondcagefree .org website
- 5:41or my article, you'll find out some of the ways
- 5:44in which hens can suffer more, like increased
- 5:47keel bone fractures, adding more pain, respiratory
- 5:51infections, increased feather pecking due to
- 5:55more stress because of how many thousands and
- 5:57thousands of birds are crammed together in one
- 6:00big cage, and more mass killing, more infectious
- 6:04disease spread, and I'll get into that in a moment.
- 6:06And cage -free egg labels also risk reassuring
- 6:11consumers, sustaining or increasing egg consumption,
- 6:15and entrenching the egg industry, the last thing
- 6:18we want, which can risk increasing suffering
- 6:22over time because people keep buying. and are
- 6:27encouraged to, sadly, when they see a cage -free
- 6:32label on an egg carton. Now these are two alerts
- 6:35that we've done. focusing on the bigger picture
- 6:40beyond just the cage -free egg system, but one
- 6:43of the things that's not addressed in cage -free
- 6:46campaigns and when you see a cage -free label
- 6:49is the increase in zoonotic disease spread, pandemic
- 6:53threats heighten as bird flu spreads and subsidies
- 6:56drive the risk. So animal egg is subsidized up
- 7:00to 800 times more than plant -based alternatives
- 7:03and Now it's spread to the dairy industry. Right
- 7:10now, there's actually now a spread into the mink
- 7:14fur industry and a facility experts are warning
- 7:18that that is a dire, dire sign that things are
- 7:22getting very, very scary as far as the threat
- 7:26for another pandemic. We also had an alert on
- 7:29urging the American Veterinary Medical Association
- 7:31to reject ventilation shutdown and the mass killing
- 7:35of animals. That is also Another horrific way
- 7:40that animals are killed. So the oxygen is shut
- 7:44off and the heat is turned up and animals suffered
- 7:47absolutely horrific death for over hours. And
- 7:50we have a new alert coming out this Friday on
- 7:53the mink bird flu situation. So better welfare,
- 7:57small family farms. That tends to be the alternative
- 8:02that's offered. when we're talking about factory
- 8:06farms as the problem, but it's still enslavement,
- 8:09cruelty, and killing. So we did an alert targeting
- 8:13the humane certifiers, the top three, and it's
- 8:18my mission to expose humane washing. So what
- 8:22is left out often when we're only talking about
- 8:25treating them better within the systems of exploitation
- 8:28is... the other ways that they're tormented and
- 8:31killed, but also the slaughterhouses. And for
- 8:34instance, that image on the right, gas chambers
- 8:36for pigs, the most common method of killing pigs.
- 8:41And it's, they don't fall asleep. It's excruciating
- 8:44death and they fight for their lives to get out.
- 8:48Animal farming hurts everyone. So it's... goes
- 8:51far beyond even animals. It is unnecessary animal
- 8:55suffering and killing when the majority of the,
- 8:59it's pretty much consensus now that we do not
- 9:02need to eat animal products to survive and thrive.
- 9:04And in fact, we are better off without doing
- 9:07so. Other ways that it hurts us, public health,
- 9:11increased leading human diseases, antibiotic
- 9:13resistance, pandemic threats. a leading cause
- 9:17of the climate crisis, deforestation, species
- 9:20extinction, water scarcity, and pollution. The
- 9:23great alternative that's often suggested to factory
- 9:26farms is grass -fed and regenerative ranching.
- 9:29But in fact, if everybody were to switch to that...
- 9:3380 % of ag land is already used for animal ag.
- 9:37So there would be virtually no arable land left
- 9:40on the planet, if everybody switched to that.
- 9:43And then other human rights and social injustices,
- 9:46food insecurity and world hunger due to the massive
- 9:49amounts of land and crops that are used to grow
- 9:52feed to the farmed animals so that we can kill
- 9:55them and eat them. It's a massive waste of resources.
- 9:59And then slaughterhouse workers, some of the,
- 10:01you know, highest rate. of suicide, depression,
- 10:04drug abuse. So we call for a massive food system
- 10:09transformation, not to just reduce suffering
- 10:13within the systems, but to reduce the number
- 10:15of animals forcibly bred into the system itself.
- 10:19Through education and policies, expose humane
- 10:22washing and green washing and the inherent cruelty
- 10:26of all animal farming. Plant -based nutrition
- 10:29education menus and defaults, we can get way
- 10:32more into that later. And instead of cage -free,
- 10:36pasture -raised, organic, small local family
- 10:39farm, humane -certified, egg -free, animal -free,
- 10:43slaughter -free, there is no humane way to exploit
- 10:47animals. This is the message I get across all
- 10:52the time because I think it is the most important.
- 10:55So... Going beyond just the food system, we are
- 10:58focused on ending the exploitation of animals.
- 11:02And if we're advocating for veganism and we're
- 11:05using the V word that a lot of advocates these
- 11:08days seem to be resistant to using, in some ways
- 11:11that's understandable because there's a big misunderstanding
- 11:14as to what it is. But it's really about justice
- 11:17for animals. It's a principle that humans should
- 11:19live without exploiting them. So it goes far
- 11:22beyond just a diet and a way of eating. So this
- 11:25is a movement for the liberation of animals.
- 11:28It's a movement for non -violence and peace.
- 11:32We are all animals. So we welcome people and
- 11:36institutions in and we welcome opportunities
- 11:42to learn while not compromising on the message
- 11:45and being clear about our goal, that our goal
- 11:48is to end the exploitation of animals and we
- 11:51speak up for and champion who animals are as
- 11:56individuals and their right, inherent right,
- 12:00like all of us, to be free and why it is wrong
- 12:04to use torture and kill them when we don't have
- 12:08to. Thank you everyone for your support. Thank
- 12:12you so much for being here. And now I am going
- 12:15to turn it over to our first incredible activist
- 12:20leader and speaker, Anita Kranz. I am going to
- 12:27read a little short bio for her now. She is the
- 12:31executive director of the Animal Save Movement,
- 12:35a global network of groups bearing witness to
- 12:38farmed animals and the co -founder and global
- 12:41campaign coordinator for the Plant -Based Treaty.
- 12:45She received her PhD in political science from
- 12:48the University of Toronto and is co -author of
- 12:51The Secret Life of Pigs, Stories of Compassion.
- 12:55and the animal save movement. Welcome, Anita.
- 13:01Thanks so much, Leah. And thanks for that presentation.
- 13:04It was a great introduction. So the Beyond Cage
- 13:07Free open letter was launched in September this
- 13:11year. And it's an urgent call for AI companies
- 13:18and animal philanthropies to go beyond cage free
- 13:22and to pivot to a plant -based systems approach
- 13:27to addressing the animal health, climate, and
- 13:29eco crises. And we were inspired to start this
- 13:35campaign in Toronto at the AVA Summit or the
- 13:40Animal Vegan Advocate Summit after hearing Tracy
- 13:43Ryman, the head of PETA, speak. The PETA white
- 13:49paper, many of us didn't know was released earlier
- 13:52this year in January of 2026. The white paper
- 13:55is called White Paper on the Failure of Cage
- 13:58-Free Housing Systems to Reduce Overall Hand
- 14:01Suffering. And what they did is look at around
- 14:05200 journal peer -reviewed articles and found
- 14:10that when you look at different aspects of welfare,
- 14:16some of them are in their words, either marginally
- 14:19improved, others are unchanged. And in other
- 14:22cases, welfare is actually worsened in cage -free
- 14:27as compared to battery cages. So what we did
- 14:30in our open letter is put this all into a table
- 14:34of visual. And as you can see, there's a column
- 14:37for caged, cage -free, and plant -based. And
- 14:41if it's worse, it's in red. If it's better, it's
- 14:44in... light green, if it's the best, it's plant
- 14:47-based. As you can see, that cage free is good
- 14:54on some issues, such as the ability of hens to
- 14:58spread their wings and preen, to turn around,
- 15:01to forage, and to build nests, compared to battery
- 15:03cages, which are absolutely abhorrent. But on
- 15:07the other hand, they're very similar because
- 15:10both... cage -free and battery cages are in factory
- 15:14farms, and they all suffer with respect to ovarian
- 15:18cancer, egg blockages and prolapses, male chick
- 15:22killing, beak searing, induced malting, and disruption
- 15:27to the biological rhythms due to lighting. And
- 15:31then in some cases, cage -free is worse than
- 15:34battery cages with respect to higher bacterial
- 15:37and fungal infections. social hierarchy, stress,
- 15:40and conflict, poor air quality, which can be
- 15:4410 times worse, leading to pulmonary tracheal
- 15:50skin and eye injury. There's injurious pecking,
- 15:54feather loss, and cannibalism. And keel bone
- 15:58injury can be as high as 90 % because the hens
- 16:03lose so much of their calcium because they're
- 16:06exploited to produce 300 eggs, whereas in nature
- 16:09it would just be a dozen or two. So that when
- 16:14they even fly a little bit and land or bump into
- 16:17another hen, they can get a heel bone injury.
- 16:21And then there's also more mass killing due to
- 16:24infectious disease. So as you can see, this report
- 16:29by PETA, was a change in its position because
- 16:33a couple of decades ago they were working on
- 16:36welfare issues, but they have changed their minds
- 16:39and very, I think, courageously took a strong
- 16:44stance on it. And so I think all of us should
- 16:47try to amplify the incredible work that they've
- 16:50done. They call for animal welfare campaigns
- 16:54and... funders to switch to a focus on plant
- 16:58-based food systems. So worldwide, there's about
- 17:0012 ,000 data centers, and they're most heavily
- 17:03concentrated in the US, where it has, as you
- 17:07can see, about half of the data centers. They're
- 17:11also concentrated in Europe and Asia, particularly
- 17:15China. And in their drive to secure access to
- 17:18compute, AI companies are not slowing down to
- 17:21ensure that the power is renewable. So in this
- 17:23particular picture, it's XAI, Musk's, one of
- 17:31his data centers, this one's in Mississippi.
- 17:33And as you can see there, there are a bunch of
- 17:37natural gas turbines to power it. So Musk in
- 17:41a rush to catch up with OpenAI, Google, Anthropic,
- 17:44started using methane and natural gas, just building
- 17:47his own plants with no public hearings. He only
- 17:51spoke to real estate and utilities, and he situated
- 17:54his largest facility in Tennessee with 300 ,000
- 17:59graphics processing units and 35 natural gas
- 18:02turbines. That's enough to power 280 ,000 Memphis
- 18:09homes. And the budget was $40 billion for these
- 18:14three data centers in Tennessee. And he called
- 18:16it Colossus I and Colossus II after a 1970 science
- 18:20fiction novel about the supercomputer autonomously
- 18:25launching nuclear weapons at the USSR. And then
- 18:28he called his third one hard, sorry, macro hard.
- 18:32And the name comes from Microsoft. So it's what
- 18:36Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor call a juvenile
- 18:40troll in their book End Times Fascism. So he
- 18:45built this data center next to Box Town, which
- 18:47is a working class majority black neighborhood
- 18:49in Southwest Memphis. And here in this picture,
- 18:51you can see House of Representative Pearson speaking
- 18:59out against this. And I wanted to ask two questions
- 19:01in this presentation. Is AI funding climate change
- 19:03and is AI philanthropy also funding climate change
- 19:07and the next pandemic? When you think of the
- 19:11power that the data centers need, they buy from
- 19:15the grid is one method. And because there's so
- 19:18much demand, some AI companies and hyperscalers
- 19:22are now buying on -site natural gas turbines,
- 19:26and so bypassing utilities. For example, Anthropic,
- 19:29which is a source of massive funding for animal
- 19:33philanthropy, has just joined the natural gas
- 19:36frenzy and bought 3 .4 billion worth of natural
- 19:38gas turbines. So there are groups that have rose
- 19:44up, like the Memphis Community Against Pollutants
- 19:47and the House of Representative Pearson, said
- 19:54that Musk is a man who preached from the rooftops
- 19:57for a decade about climate change and renewable
- 19:59energy, only to spew clouds of toxic fossil fuels
- 20:02into poor black neighborhoods now. And so this
- 20:05summer, a major article came out. It's the first
- 20:07ever study of the US energy use by the industry.
- 20:15And what they found is that within four years,
- 20:19up to 2030, If plans go ahead, which now they
- 20:24might not, thanks to the blue wave, but if plans
- 20:26go ahead, the increase in greenhouse gases would
- 20:29be 28%. And this is after two decades of flat
- 20:35energy use and electricity in the US. So suddenly
- 20:38there's a surge because of the data centers.
- 20:41And most of these data centers depend on natural
- 20:44gas. And this would result in stranded assets.
- 20:47This is a very important concept. The stranded
- 20:49assets is investing in long -term technology
- 20:52when we need to stop using fossil fuels due to
- 20:56the climate emergency. And we'll find the same
- 20:58concept is useful when understanding investments
- 21:01in cage -free facilities. That's billions of
- 21:04dollars in assets which should be rather spent
- 21:07on plant -based. So another important article
- 21:10came out this summer as well, and it was on the
- 21:12UK egg industry. And it found that the greenhouse
- 21:16gas emissions from organic free range was double
- 21:19compared to cage systems. It also found that
- 21:23more hens are required to produce the same number
- 21:25of eggs in the UK. So in one year, you would
- 21:28require 1 .68 million more hens to match the
- 21:31same quantity of eggs produced from battery cages.
- 21:34So in other words, moving towards a plant -based
- 21:36food system is much better. And so in our open
- 21:38letter, if you go to beyondcagefree .org, you'll
- 21:42see that we start with this. chart which shows
- 21:45again the environmental health impacts of cage
- 21:50versus cage -free and then looking at plant -based
- 21:53as well and that's the win -win solution across
- 21:56the board. So the impact of climate on animals
- 22:00in the open letter, we look at cases such as
- 22:052 .5 to 3 million hens died this summer. due
- 22:10to the heat waves. And we have a few other examples
- 22:13in our open letter. Here's a photo of some of
- 22:15the wonderful activists that have been already
- 22:17acting on this issue. So in Argentina, and in
- 22:21New Jersey, and I know in Chicago, Robert has
- 22:25taken action. So in the book, End Times Fascism,
- 22:29which I strongly recommend by Naomi Klein and
- 22:31vegan Astra Taylor, they talk about different
- 22:34solutions like asserting democratic control,
- 22:37And there's a beautiful quote, instead of a 10
- 22:40trillion build out for data centers, how about
- 22:42investing in subway systems, monorail, building
- 22:45solar and wind, helping switch our food system
- 22:47to plant -based, eliminating food deserts and
- 22:49so forth. And there could be a wealth tax. Unfortunately,
- 22:51that wealth tax barely lost by a few points.
- 22:55In California, there would have been a 5 % wealth
- 22:57tax on billionaires. And these are the recommendations
- 23:00in the open letter. So we feel that we need to
- 23:03go beyond utilitarianism to the duty to respect
- 23:08the rights of animals and develop an action plan
- 23:11for a plant -based future and develop the high
- 23:14ambition coalition for plant -based systems.
- 23:17And finally, what you can do, and I think probably
- 23:19Robert will talk about some of this, but we're
- 23:22working on a petition calling on AI companies
- 23:25and animal plantaries to invest in win -win plant
- 23:27-based campaigns, not larger cages and welfare
- 23:30tech. And we also want there to be a serious
- 23:35of town halls next year. So we're planning that
- 23:39as well as a documentary. And we have social
- 23:42media that you could follow and please post on
- 23:45social media about this and you can download
- 23:47graphics. And we do have some leaflets that we're
- 23:49going to be putting on our website this week.
- 23:51So thank you very much. Appreciate your ability
- 23:54to speak on this important topic. Thank you.
- 23:58Fantastic. Thank you very much, Anita. All right.
- 24:02On to our next speaker. Dr. Faraz Harsini is
- 24:07a biomedical and food systems scientist, founder,
- 24:11and CEO of Allied Scholars for Animal Protection,
- 24:16ASAP. and former Alternative Proteins Senior
- 24:19Scientist whose work spans animal protection,
- 24:23public health, environmental sustainability,
- 24:26and human rights. With ASAP chapters at 40 universities,
- 24:30over 40 I believe, across the United States,
- 24:33Dr. Faraz Harsini is building the largest infrastructure
- 24:37for effective animal advocacy on university campuses.
- 24:42Welcome, Faraz. Where should I begin? I guess
- 24:57my biggest frustration with cage -free campaigns
- 25:00is that I get these emails about new funders.
- 25:06Every single week, there is a new funder that's
- 25:08funding cage -free campaigns. And the emails
- 25:13usually say, we measure the effectiveness of
- 25:15your work based on effectiveness of cage -free
- 25:20campaigns. And to me, it's absolutely crazy that
- 25:24we are putting all of our vegan eggs in one basket,
- 25:27given the fact that we are not even considering
- 25:29the risks of this assessment. So there are a
- 25:32few things that I see extremely wrong with kids
- 25:36free campaigns and why I think it's a very risky
- 25:38thing. One is that from the utilitarian perspective
- 25:42that, you know, chickens, you know, the way they
- 25:45think is that, you know, every chicken suffers
- 25:47a little less. There is a gazillion chickens,
- 25:50so that's a big number, and that's how it works.
- 25:56We have to challenge that idea. I mean, the PETA's
- 25:59white paper already shows us that that's not
- 26:01a good assumption. But on top of that, as long
- 26:07as people think that they have to have eggs,
- 26:10their consumption is going to go up. There's
- 26:13gonna be a growing population of non vegan peoples
- 26:16as long as we are not educating people why they
- 26:18shouldn't be having eggs or you know meat and
- 26:21dairy No matter whether animals are in cage or
- 26:25out of cage animal consumption is gonna go up
- 26:28and As a result of that total suffering will
- 26:32increase anyways There is one thing I think if
- 26:37that was the case I would have been more convinced
- 26:40that cage free campaigns are a good idea And
- 26:46that's like if the cost went up drastically to
- 26:49a point that consumption came down and actually
- 26:52more animals were saved. But that's also a false
- 26:56assumption. And here's why. We hear about a law
- 27:08of supply and demand that the more, which basically
- 27:12says when a product is more expensive, the demand
- 27:14should go down. But that only works in vacuum
- 27:17if there is no other changes. In this case, when
- 27:21the price goes up, they actually use it as a
- 27:23marketing tactic to sell people a premium product.
- 27:27There are many reasons that the egg prices are
- 27:30not elastic. In economics, there is this idea
- 27:32of elasticity. So if it's one, it just means
- 27:36that price goes up, consumption goes down. But
- 27:39eggs are actually the least elastic item in grocery
- 27:45shopping lists. And that's because one, it's
- 27:49a small share of the cost of groceries. Two,
- 27:54people think it's necessary for being healthy.
- 28:00And because of that, I think its elasticity is
- 28:03around 0 .3. That means that even when the cost
- 28:06goes up, the consumption is not really impacted.
- 28:10Also, can you imagine if we wasted hundreds of
- 28:14millions of dollars, just so that potentially
- 28:18the egg prices will go up. And then as long as
- 28:21the society is not culturally educated, all it
- 28:24takes is for the government to just say, you
- 28:27know, here is just more subsidies to lower the
- 28:29cost. So that also doesn't work. It's also a
- 28:34bandage. It's always irritating to me that as
- 28:38long as we are not working on the root cause
- 28:42of issues, the system stays in place. And that's
- 28:48exactly why catchery campaigns get a lot of money,
- 28:51because there are a lot of people who just don't
- 28:53want to address the root cause, which is like
- 28:55not eating eggs, and they try to just do these
- 29:02band -aids. And it's a band -aid. It's not gonna
- 29:05really address the root of a problem. Like Leo
- 29:10said, I spend a lot of my academic research working
- 29:14on pandemics and zoonotic diseases. You have
- 29:17the climate issues, as Anita was talking about.
- 29:20Casualty campaigns are not addressing any of
- 29:23these issues that effective altruists usually
- 29:25say they care about. On top of that, I think
- 29:30it also makes it harder for people to change.
- 29:34So I run Owlette Scholars, which is the largest
- 29:36animal advocacy group in universities. And we
- 29:39started doing this thing this semester. So we're
- 29:42making these videos, we're walking to students
- 29:44and we ask them, when you hear cage -free, tell
- 29:47us what you think. And then, you know, they describe
- 29:50all these chickens walking around, you know,
- 29:52freely. And then we show them male chicken going
- 29:55to grind and we're like, this is also a standard
- 29:57practice for cage -free. Did you know? They're
- 29:59completely horrified when they see that their
- 30:03image of cage -free campaigns or cage -free chickens
- 30:06is not exactly what the realities. So I think
- 30:13that now when you talk to people, the first thing
- 30:15they say when you talk to them about veganism
- 30:17is like, you know, but yeah, I agree, factory
- 30:20farms are bad, but humanely raised, grass -fed,
- 30:23organic, Uncle Joe's farms, that's okay. But
- 30:28they don't understand that there is a lot of
- 30:30cruelty in those farms as well. So in some ways,
- 30:32it actually makes it harder for people to change.
- 30:35And here's the thing, I'm not against small steps
- 30:38and gradual changes. One of the things we do
- 30:43at Allied Scholars is we work with dining halls
- 30:45to take small steps to increase plant -based
- 30:48options. But I think that it's actually in the
- 30:54right direction. So when somebody reduces meat,
- 30:58eggs, dairy consumption, they're actually saving
- 31:00animals. But we know that by choosing cage -free
- 31:03or grass -fed or humanely raised, you're not
- 31:06actually saving animals at all. thing I really
- 31:12want to talk about is that there are two things
- 31:16that I think are extremely important and they
- 31:18go hand in hand. One is alternative proteins
- 31:20or plant -based food system and the other one
- 31:23is education. We can't win without these two.
- 31:30I want you to pay attention to this. When you
- 31:32go to Starbucks now or every other coffee shop
- 31:37you can get soy milk, almond milk and oat milk
- 31:40at the same cost All you have to do is to ask
- 31:43for your cappuccino to be made by oat milk or
- 31:46soy milk or almond milk. Significant majority
- 31:49of people still choose dairy. The promise of
- 31:53alternative proteins is that when they reach
- 31:56price parity and taste parity, consumers will
- 31:59choose that. I'm not sure if that's true because
- 32:02we already can see that consumers still choose
- 32:04what they're used to eating. However, I think
- 32:07alternative proteins or platen -based food system
- 32:10the accessibility of these vegan options, I think
- 32:13about it as a chemist, I think about them as
- 32:16a catalyst, that they will not be the solution
- 32:20by themselves, but they can accelerate significantly,
- 32:24reaching our goals. That today, when I talk to
- 32:26someone about veganism, it's very helpful for
- 32:29them to know that they can get their vegan burger
- 32:31at, I don't know, Burger King without paying
- 32:37for animals to get killed. But the missing piece
- 32:42I think is the education. So we can't win without
- 32:46educating college students and consumers. And
- 32:51the last thing I want to talk about is actually
- 32:54two more things. One is that as far as education
- 32:58is concerned, one of the most heartbreaking instances
- 33:02I had, I was giving a talk at Yale and this EA
- 33:06guy comes and before my talk I'm chatting with
- 33:08him. I'm like, so are you vegan? And he says,
- 33:11I used to be, but now I offset my harm by, you
- 33:16know, donating to pastry campaigns. And I hate
- 33:21to hear when people talk about like being vegan
- 33:25or being on a plant -based diet, that when people,
- 33:32you know, this Yale student could very well get
- 33:35into food system transformation, could become
- 33:37passionate, could become an activist. But now
- 33:40these future bright minds are reduced to, you
- 33:44know, you don't have to be the change. You can
- 33:47still eat your eggs, eat cage free, just donate,
- 33:50you know, to these campaigns and we'll do the
- 33:52work for you. So I see that a lot of capacity
- 33:55and talent is wasted. Just imagine the number
- 33:59of people who animal rights movement could have,
- 34:01but we no longer have them because now there
- 34:04are... Doing some random work that it's nonsense
- 34:07just so that they can donate however much instead
- 34:10of becoming the next generation of Ethan Browns
- 34:12and Pat Browns and All the other people who are
- 34:15working really hard to change the food system
- 34:17fundamentally And the last thing I say is opportunity
- 34:20cost. That's probably the most frustrating thing
- 34:22for me. It's not that even we are treating these
- 34:25campaigns as Let's have different things that
- 34:28we are trying. No day after day more funding
- 34:31is taken away from Alternative Protein and Education
- 34:34and is put into cage -free campaigns. Almost
- 34:37the entire money in the animal rights movement
- 34:39is going there now. And so aside from a few organizations
- 34:43who are on this call right now, and maybe PETA
- 34:47and Physicians Committee and a few others, there
- 34:50is no one else who's actually working on education.
- 34:52And I think that without education, there is
- 34:54just no chance to win. And, you know, as a CEO
- 34:58of a nonprofit, the part of my job that I hate
- 35:01the most is fundraising. And this year, it's
- 35:03going to be extremely challenging because more
- 35:06and more and more funding is cut for education
- 35:09and it's going to cash -free campaigns. So thanks
- 35:14for having me. I'll be around for some of the
- 35:16Q &A. And if you have any questions, please send
- 35:18it my way. I'll also put the link to allied scholars
- 35:21if you're a student who want to fight for animals
- 35:24with relentlessly, you know, If you know any
- 35:28students, send them our way and please also consider
- 35:30donating because we are the only organization
- 35:33focusing systematically changing the animal rights
- 35:36movement in universities. Thanks again for having
- 35:39us. Thank you very much, Faraz. Fantastic. Okay,
- 35:44on to our final speaker, Robert Grillo. He is
- 35:48the founder and director of Free From Harm, which
- 35:51is dedicated to advancing plant -based, animal
- 35:54-free food systems for a safer, more humane,
- 35:58and sustainable future. He is also a founding
- 36:00member of the Beyond Cage Free Coalition and
- 36:04the author of a book that I have and have read
- 36:07and is fabulous, From Farm to Fable, the Fictions
- 36:11of Our Animal -Consuming Culture. Welcome, Robert.
- 36:15Thank you, Leah. Thanks for having me. And hello,
- 36:19everyone out there. As Leah said, I'm one of
- 36:23the founding members of the Beyond Cage Free
- 36:26Coalition. And for those that might know Free
- 36:29From Harm, the coalition strongly aligns with
- 36:34Free From Harm's mission of holding the most
- 36:37powerful people in our food system accountable,
- 36:41either in the private sector or in the public
- 36:43sector. And the theory of change there is based
- 36:47on the simple idea of following the money and
- 36:52holding those powerful decision makers in our
- 36:55food system accountable. Because otherwise it's
- 36:59business as usual and they make decisions, huge
- 37:03decisions that affect billions of animals and
- 37:05consumers and our planet behind closed doors
- 37:10with no public input. in a democratic society
- 37:14and if we don't step up and demand transparency
- 37:20and accountability, no one else will. The Beyond
- 37:25Cage Free Coalition is focused on an open letter
- 37:30to tech leaders and the effective altruism community
- 37:33at large on how to fund animal welfare, climate
- 37:38change, and public health all at the same time.
- 37:42rather than see them as separate compartments
- 37:46that need separate funding. And the problems
- 37:50that emerge from this compartmentalization is
- 37:55that you might fund one cause area like animal
- 37:59suffering or animal welfare, and it actually
- 38:04negatively impacts another cause area like climate
- 38:07change, right? So as Anita pointed out earlier,
- 38:11In one study, 20 % more hens were required to
- 38:16produce the same number of eggs in a cage -free
- 38:19system, 20 % more. So that means not only are
- 38:25you reducing animal suffering, you're actually
- 38:28increasing the number of animals in the system
- 38:31and all of the negative impacts that come with
- 38:35an increase in the animal population. The climate
- 38:38impact, the water, the land use, the zoonotic
- 38:42disease threat, and public health outcomes, all
- 38:46of that stuff. All those impacts are multiplied.
- 38:50So it's a holistic approach. It's an urgent message
- 38:54to some of the most powerful people in the tech
- 38:58industry that we need a holistic approach to
- 39:04solving all of these interconnected and interrelated
- 39:08problems that a plant -based system addresses.
- 39:16So beyond cage -free emerges, this coalition
- 39:19emerges out of an urgent need to expand the dialogue
- 39:22beyond just the idea of the least we can do or
- 39:28the worst forms of suffering, the worst practices
- 39:31in the industry. that we should set the bar that
- 39:35low. Expanding the dialogue means thinking beyond
- 39:41the worst case scenario and to what's the best
- 39:47we can do. We need to challenge that dominant
- 39:51narrative in our movement that we need to just
- 39:54first start with the worst practices because
- 39:59in reality we can do a lot more than just that.
- 40:05And the other problem is, as Faraz, I believe,
- 40:09and Anita and Leah had pointed out, is that when
- 40:15so much is invested in cage -free campaigning
- 40:18and so -called tech welfare, we are entrenching
- 40:23factory farming when our goal should be to actually
- 40:27reduce our reliance on factory farming and on
- 40:31the animal industries. in general. So the effective
- 40:38altruist community says that one of their core
- 40:41tenants is to end factory farming, but cage -free,
- 40:46all this investment in cage -free is actually
- 40:49entrenching our reliance on it. I'd also like
- 40:54to just point out that I think what's often overlooked
- 40:57is we don't start from a place of, ah, what's
- 41:02the least we can do? or what does the data show
- 41:06us as far as what is the most practical or evidence
- 41:11-based goal we should have? No, social movements
- 41:16start from a place of looking at the pains that
- 41:21society has, some urgent issues that society
- 41:25has, and forming a movement around giving society
- 41:31what it needs. And so every social movement is
- 41:38based around these anxieties and fears and pains
- 41:43that people suffer. A plant -based food system
- 41:47is no different, and advocating for plant -based
- 41:50food transition is no different than other social
- 41:53movements in the sense that we will improve public
- 41:58health. We will improve our chances of surviving
- 42:03and having life on this planet survive by advocating
- 42:11for plant -based systems and not other kinds
- 42:15of reforms. And I would argue that we're ready
- 42:18for this because we already have people in Congress
- 42:24and major leaders. in our food system that are
- 42:29advocating for such kinds of changes. We just
- 42:32need to build a grassroots momentum behind the
- 42:37efforts that are already underway. So it's very
- 42:40much a practical thing. It's not some pie in
- 42:43the sky idea that we came up with. That is, by
- 42:48the way, one of the big objections that we hear
- 42:51in the effective altruism community and by some
- 42:53of the top funders is that, well, we just don't
- 42:56have enough evidence showing that plant investing
- 43:00and plant based systems is effective. But that
- 43:04what that overlooks is one of the most important
- 43:08lessons that we actually have. All we need to
- 43:11do is look at the tobacco and meat industry playbook
- 43:14for the last several decades to see how they
- 43:18have. They have gone to the best advertising
- 43:23and marketing executives in the country and said,
- 43:26we want to increase our market share by X amount
- 43:29over the next several years. And those executives
- 43:33say, sure, no problem, because they know how
- 43:36to create the market for the products that they
- 43:38want to sell. They decide at the top of our food
- 43:42chain, which items and which product lines are
- 43:45going to be available, accessible, affordable,
- 43:50mass distributed. And that's why we need to be
- 43:55in front of those kind of people that have that
- 43:58kind of power. I just want to also just kind
- 44:01of point out something connected to this. There's
- 44:07a concept called corporate co -optation. And
- 44:11this is something that all movements need to
- 44:14be aware of. There's a certain playbook at play
- 44:17here that we need to be highly sensitive to,
- 44:22and that is when corporations come to co -opt
- 44:25a movement, the strategy is essentially to isolate
- 44:28or criminalize the radical flank, the ones that
- 44:31are really asking for huge change or transformative
- 44:36change, and then to buy off the pragmatists,
- 44:39the people that can be given jobs and maybe some
- 44:44sense of power and bought off. So it's a divide
- 44:49and conquer strategy. It's the idea is to divide
- 44:52these two factions of a movement rather than
- 44:56to create a balanced and respectful ecosystem.
- 45:00So that's why it's critical for us to be aware
- 45:02of this divisive and disempowering co -optation
- 45:07strategy that is very much alive in our movement.
- 45:11Because otherwise, if we fall for this, we risk
- 45:15becoming the tools of the corporate donor class
- 45:18rather than effective activists and effective
- 45:23for the movement. Last point I just want to make
- 45:31is that, well, I did say that plant -based campaigning
- 45:36is very practical. And I'll say that the time
- 45:39to do it is now. There's an urgent need to do
- 45:42it from a from an animal suffering from a climate,
- 45:46land use, water use, pollution, pesticide use,
- 45:49antibiotic use, zoonotic disease risk. The time
- 45:53is now to act on this. And there are power holders
- 45:56already spearheading the change. So we need to
- 46:03build the coalition. We need more signatures
- 46:07from individuals, from experts, celebrities.
- 46:10Congress people, UN officials, EU parliamentarians,
- 46:15and everyone has a role to play in this coalition.
- 46:19Thank you so much. Thank you very much, Robert.
- 46:24I just want to say a personal thank you to all
- 46:28three of these leaders because you are the outliers.
- 46:34The courage that all three of you have shown
- 46:38in your advocacy is just really awe -inspiring
- 46:43to me and honestly, deeply influences me as an
- 46:47activist too. So, since our guest speaker Faraz
- 46:52has to leave at around 10 minutes from now, a
- 46:56little less than that, I will have him answer
- 47:01this question, but I'd love to hear from all
- 47:03three of you on this topic that has now come
- 47:07up by all of us in this presentation. So effective
- 47:13altruism, it's a philosophy. It's an organization.
- 47:17And they do seem to kind of dictate in the animal
- 47:21protection movement where the majority of the
- 47:23funding goes. So we've already talked a little
- 47:25bit about that. But I would like for all three
- 47:29of you to maybe say what you'd like to say about
- 47:31that. But also, what is your take on the new
- 47:38research and funding that's going into AI, quote,
- 47:42welfare tech, otherwise known in some circles
- 47:45as precision livestock farming. One of the biggest
- 47:50leaders in the effective altruism space shared
- 47:53an article around called Meat Without Misery
- 47:56that basically proposes genetically altering
- 48:01animals for eventually... having brainless animals
- 48:04who can't feel pain as a solution to reducing
- 48:08suffering, which I think is absolutely a dystopian
- 48:12nightmare and not anything that we should be
- 48:14considering. And it was shared around as the
- 48:17most thought -provoking piece that he has read
- 48:20all year, and quote, the inevitability of factory
- 48:24farming. So I'm starting to hear more language
- 48:27and talk that's implying that sort of a, if you
- 48:31can't beat them, join them. And that is really
- 48:36alarming to me and a lot of us I know. So starting
- 48:39with Faraz and then Anita and Robert, what do
- 48:41you have to say about that? Yeah, I think we
- 48:47are basically doing the animal industry job for
- 48:49them. I'm actually at Penn State. I'm in the
- 48:52Department of Nutrition. I want to walk around
- 48:54and look at the posters. They're already using
- 48:57AI to make animal industry more effective. We
- 49:00don't need to be doing that for them. And it's
- 49:04very interesting that we can come up with this
- 49:06hypotheticals of having brainless chickens and
- 49:09all that, but we are not thinking about how we
- 49:12could potentially use AI to make cultivated meat
- 49:15or plant -based foods more accessible and available.
- 49:22But yeah, going back to what I was saying, the
- 49:29movement seems very disappointed about education.
- 49:33And the part that pisses me off and I hear that
- 49:36all the time is we tried education and vegan
- 49:39activism and it didn't work. But that was 10,
- 49:4320 years ago. And that was basically as far as,
- 49:47I'll just give you one example. I'm sure this
- 49:49is the case in every field, but you know, in
- 49:55college campuses, what animal advocacy used to
- 49:58be was basically The Humane League and Mercy
- 50:02for Animals and all these groups went to college
- 50:04campuses for one day, handed out a gazillion
- 50:07leaflets. And I'm not even saying that that was
- 50:10bad. I think that some of the vegans we have
- 50:11today are the result of that little bit that
- 50:14we did back then. And I think when we talk about
- 50:16the effectiveness of something, it's like divided
- 50:19by the amount of money you spend on it. We always
- 50:23treat cage -free campaigns as if it's free. That's
- 50:27my main issue. It's not free, there is opportunity
- 50:29cost. We're taking most of the resources that
- 50:32could go to building a plant -based system, lobbying
- 50:35for a better food system, education. We're taking
- 50:38all that money away. And remind you that we treated
- 50:43leafletting with the same confidence, and we
- 50:45just decided that didn't work. So yeah, what
- 50:47pisses me off is that we never really actually
- 50:50systematically educated consumers. We just tried
- 50:52one or two things, and we are now today deciding
- 50:55that education didn't work. Not to mention that
- 50:58I was talking to some of the leaders of alternative
- 51:01proteins. Almost seven out of 10 are already
- 51:05plant -based, are coming from animal space. So
- 51:08now those are the people who are changing the
- 51:10food system the most. But now we are saying that
- 51:13education doesn't work. Effective altruism is
- 51:16the only group that I have to convince that education
- 51:19is important. Whereas every other organizations,
- 51:24religious organizations, political organizations,
- 51:26they are all organizing, educating. We just decided
- 51:30that it doesn't work anymore and we should focus
- 51:33on precision factory farming and do the dirty
- 51:37work of animal industry for them. Thank you.
- 51:42Anita or Robert? Go ahead Anita if you'd like
- 51:48to chime in. I totally agree with Dr. Farras.
- 51:53Education is central in any social movement along
- 51:56with other strategies. There's a one of my favorite
- 51:59books on climate is called Saving Us by Katherine
- 52:03Hayhoe and her main recommendation is talk to
- 52:07other people have a conversation talk about climate
- 52:09change in our case talk about animal rights talk
- 52:11you know just talk to everyone every chance you
- 52:14get. you know, everywhere at the dinner table,
- 52:18at the school and at work and community centers,
- 52:21to strangers in a supermarket, you know, just
- 52:24talk, you know, never remain silent. In terms
- 52:27of your question, Leah, so my perspective on
- 52:31it as someone who's studied in political science
- 52:37would be to look at interests. So in political
- 52:41science, there's three I's, ideas, interests
- 52:44and institutions. Ideas are like animal rights
- 52:47versus utilitarianism. And for a lot of us, that's
- 52:51enough to convince us, the morality, the ethics.
- 52:55But interests play a really important role, as
- 52:58well as institutions, like the role of law and
- 52:59democracy. But interests. So my concern with
- 53:04all this interest in welfare tech is that there
- 53:11might be a profit motive. So Anthropic is related
- 53:18to coefficient giving and is giving a lot of
- 53:20money to them. And they're the main animal philanthropy.
- 53:24And they've really been pushing cage -free and
- 53:26welfare tech. And is it because they have an
- 53:32interest in working with big animal egg? Are
- 53:37there strings attached to the donations that
- 53:39are coming to animal funders? Is it a donor -determined
- 53:44campaign? It's not coming from the grassroots.
- 53:46If you talk to the grassroots groups, many of
- 53:50them that are doing cage -free now, that idea
- 53:52never came from them. It was a donor -imposed
- 53:57campaign. So just like money in politics has
- 54:03gone against the American interest, hence the
- 54:06blue wave, hence the people power and the organizing,
- 54:09The same thing has to happen here. We need to
- 54:12organize, not only in the animal protection movement
- 54:15in order to save it, and save it so that we can
- 54:18work on the real, the true aims of this movement,
- 54:24which is animal rights and animal liberation
- 54:26and animal equality, but also because you need
- 54:32to take a layer cake approach where there are
- 54:35many reasons to do the right thing. first and
- 54:38foremost for the animals. But as Robert, you
- 54:41know, iterated, for the climate, you know, we
- 54:45are going to pass the 1 .52 degrees Celsius Paris
- 54:49target if we don't change our food system. And
- 54:52that's self -defeating. And then there's also
- 54:54the pandemic risk and there's the health issue.
- 54:58So in the open letter, we cover all these issues.
- 55:01And in order to evaluate different types of campaigns
- 55:05like the animal charity evaluators do. They can't
- 55:09just look at, you know, one measure like, oh,
- 55:11it was a cage free and like, no, they have to
- 55:14look at all the welfare issues and they have
- 55:17to also look at rights. And then they have to
- 55:19look at climate, water use, land use, health,
- 55:25and so forth. So for me, the bottom line is we
- 55:30need to adopt a systems approach. And that's
- 55:32why we launched beyond cage -free. So please,
- 55:35you know, take a few minutes to read our open
- 55:38letter. It's quite long, but we also have an
- 55:39attached report. And we have a lot of book recommendations,
- 55:43and I'd also add for the bigger picture, I'd
- 55:47really encourage you to read End Times Fascism
- 55:50by Naomi Klein and Astor Taylor, and Astor Taylor's
- 55:53vegan, as well as her sister's as well. And it's
- 55:57just in a remarkable book on sort of the big
- 55:59picture. And so I think it's... and the solutions
- 56:04that flow from there. Great. Thank you, Anita.
- 56:12Thank you, Robert. Yeah, I just wanted to...
- 56:14I'll keep it real brief because I know you got
- 56:16to get to Q &A, you know? But the same person
- 56:20who authored that piece, Meet Without Misery,
- 56:23I had a conversation with a few years prior and
- 56:28the gist of it was the idea of campaigning against
- 56:34factory farming or animal agriculture and demanding
- 56:38that Congress defund animal ag and instead fund
- 56:43plant -based producers was a crazy idea to him
- 56:49and that that will never work, that system will
- 56:53never change and it was a bad idea. I mean we
- 56:58pursued it anyway and actually He couldn't be
- 57:05more wrong about that because there's already
- 57:09efforts in Congress and in the EU Parliament
- 57:13and in many other governments to do just that,
- 57:16to shift the funding in the right direction.
- 57:19And that following the money and shifting the
- 57:22funding is critical to incentivizing the farming
- 57:26system to go where the money is, to go where
- 57:29the programs and funding is. we need them to
- 57:35take that leadership in order for the farming
- 57:38system to move in that direction. And then consumers
- 57:42are the last stage of this process because consumers
- 57:46buy what's marketed to them. So when they see
- 57:51the options more prevalent and they're marketed
- 57:54more prolifically and they're more affordable,
- 57:57they're gonna be looking at plant -based options
- 58:00in a very different way. OK, thanks, Robert.
- 58:07That's interesting, that last part that you said,
- 58:09because that's almost starting to sound like
- 58:12you're more on the side of start with systemic
- 58:15change first and not advocate for individual
- 58:18change. And I know that that is certainly a big
- 58:22conversation that all of us advocates have. But
- 58:25do we not agree that we need both? Yes, but we
- 58:31simply don't have enough impetus and momentum
- 58:35on holding those that are really making the big
- 58:38deals and decisions on our behalf. There's very
- 58:41few people in groups engaged in that kind of
- 58:45work, and we need more of it. Challenging Congress
- 58:49and challenging the power holders of our food
- 58:50system. Congress and private sector and the tech
- 58:53industry, the tech leaders, the people that are
- 58:56going to invest millions of more in cage -free
- 58:59instead of plant -based unless we intercept this
- 59:02conversation. One other question I would like
- 59:09to ask all three of you is what is one thing
- 59:11that you would like to say to a non -vegan today
- 59:16and or any advice for vegans who are not active
- 59:20for us? Hey I think that this is the biggest
- 59:30moral crisis of all time and I really think that
- 59:37just being vegan is not enough Here's my theory
- 59:41of change. I think that the reason that we haven't
- 59:45reached animal liberation is mainly because vegans
- 59:48have been inactive. I want to tell you something.
- 59:53So today I gave two nutrition lectures and I
- 59:57showed three minutes of dominion in my lecture.
- 1:00:00And we had to really consider like, because like
- 1:00:03a professor and the professor is vegan herself.
- 1:00:06And I told her, you're going to get some complaints
- 1:00:08from some, somebody is going to get mad. And
- 1:00:11she said, we just have to do what we have to
- 1:00:13do, you know. And that's as opposed to a lot
- 1:00:17of other professors I've seen who are so shy
- 1:00:20to even talk about this. I just recently gave
- 1:00:23a talk at Georgetown Law School and the students
- 1:00:26were there, the vegan students were telling me,
- 1:00:29please make sure you don't talk about veganism
- 1:00:31and vegan propaganda. And when I was talking
- 1:00:34about veganism, they were like from embarrassment,
- 1:00:39the vegan ones. By the way, the taco is completely
- 1:00:41academic That shows a difference between like,
- 1:00:46you know, you have that vegan and you have this
- 1:00:47vegan That's the kind of vegan we need we need
- 1:00:50to be courageous. We shouldn't give a shit about
- 1:00:54You're not here in this we didn't become vegan
- 1:00:57because it was easy we did it because it was
- 1:01:00the right thing to do and you also don't become
- 1:01:02active because it's easy you do it because you
- 1:01:05just have no choice you have no choice as Philip
- 1:01:08Walden says, you know, if you've seen what I've
- 1:01:10seen, you'd be just like me. I'm a prisoner of
- 1:01:12what I know. I'm a victim of what I've seen.
- 1:01:14I can't change. I won't change. I will never
- 1:01:16change. I'm only going to become worse. And so
- 1:01:20we should all become worse. Amen. Thank you.
- 1:01:25We didn't get into this to be liked, right? And
- 1:01:28we've got to accept and know that this is inherently
- 1:01:32uncomfortable. Speaking up for animals in the
- 1:01:35way that we must. and advocating for veganism
- 1:01:38and doing what needs to be done despite being
- 1:01:42uncomfortable. That's what every justice movement
- 1:01:45had to do. So thank you, Faraz. If you need to
- 1:01:51move on. So happy you can be here. Thank you.
- 1:01:55Thanks for having me. Okay. And Anita, how would
- 1:02:02you like to answer that question? Or do you remember?
- 1:02:05Shall I ask again? Yeah. Can you just repeat
- 1:02:07the question, please? Well, two parts, so whichever
- 1:02:10you want to answer. What is one thing that you
- 1:02:13would say to a non -vegan today and or advice
- 1:02:16for vegans who are not active? Okay, yeah, good
- 1:02:20questions. I think it's really important to bear
- 1:02:25witness and not look away. It's morally weak
- 1:02:28and cowardly to look away when someone is suffering.
- 1:02:32So, animal safe movement, the group that I'm
- 1:02:35associated with that goes to slaughterhouses.
- 1:02:37and invites the community to bear witness and
- 1:02:41to give water to the animals and rescue animals
- 1:02:43when possible. And it's life changing. It's quite
- 1:02:48transformative. A film made me go veg and then
- 1:02:51vegan. But when I started bearing witness, it
- 1:02:53made animal rights a priority in my life. So
- 1:02:57it takes you to another level. And so I just
- 1:02:59recommend that everybody go to a pig vigil, cow
- 1:03:02vigil, rabbit vigil, whatever, go to a slaughterhouse
- 1:03:04in your community, because unfortunately, these
- 1:03:06slaughterhouses are all over. And it's a life
- 1:03:09-changing moment. And it could get non -vegans
- 1:03:12to go vegan and inactive vegans to become active.
- 1:03:16And one other piece of advice, I read on the
- 1:03:20Effective All Tourism Forum, there was a blog
- 1:03:23by Pablo from Prove Edge. recently. And he noted
- 1:03:31that for people to remain vegan, it's very important
- 1:03:35that they have a network around them. And so
- 1:03:39he's suggesting that when you do activities,
- 1:03:42bring your friends and family. So I'm thinking
- 1:03:46about how do we apply this to vigils or other
- 1:03:48actions? So instead of inviting just individuals,
- 1:03:51oh, join us. What if we get a group, like say
- 1:03:54a group of students in a classroom or a religious
- 1:03:58group, like everybody knows each other, bring
- 1:04:00them all, because then they talk to each other.
- 1:04:02And then, so anyways, I just thought that was
- 1:04:03fascinating that the retention was so much higher
- 1:04:07if there is what he called peer support. And
- 1:04:11I found this kind of evidence in another area
- 1:04:14about facts. Like 10 % of us, if we see facts,
- 1:04:19that'll persuade us. But most people, they won't
- 1:04:22be persuaded unless it's popular in their network
- 1:04:27or in public or something. So that was just on
- 1:04:29the biggest podcast in the world for climate.
- 1:04:32It's called Outrage and Optimism with Christiana
- 1:04:35Figueres and two other co -hosts. And they were
- 1:04:38talking about that recently about how facts are
- 1:04:42great, but they're not sufficient. You need to
- 1:04:45also hit people multiple times and in a social
- 1:04:49way so that It's something that, because the
- 1:04:52argument is that humans are herd animals. Nice
- 1:04:58balloons. Yes. Love that. Thank you, Anita. Robert.
- 1:05:03So about the suggestions for vegan activism.
- 1:05:09Sure. Did I get that right? Yeah. Or what would
- 1:05:12you say to a non -vegan today or any advice?
- 1:05:15Yeah. So I have the pleasure and... of being
- 1:05:19able to speak. I used to avoid it like the plague
- 1:05:23to speak to people that weren't vegan. And I
- 1:05:26used to really, really dread those kinds of conversations
- 1:05:29of having to deal with all the the, you know,
- 1:05:33the different excuses and justifications and
- 1:05:36the things we hear all the time. Right. But then
- 1:05:40I guess my tune has completely changed now. In
- 1:05:43the last year, I have met I have met a ton of
- 1:05:47non -vegan people in so many different settings,
- 1:05:50and they ask me what I do, and I give them my
- 1:05:53little elevator pitch, and it doesn't actually
- 1:05:56bring the word vegan up, because we're talking
- 1:05:59about the plant -based, yeah, the Beyond Cage
- 1:06:03Free Coalition, sorry, and plant -based systems,
- 1:06:08and funding that, funding plant -based systems
- 1:06:11instead. It's amazing to me and fascinating to
- 1:06:17me how many people that I speak to across the
- 1:06:20political spectrum, across age groups, across
- 1:06:24races and ethnicities, across class, from the
- 1:06:30people that are on the street selling Streetwise,
- 1:06:35the magazine, to wealthy people. They come to
- 1:06:43the conclusion, without me having to say anything,
- 1:06:47that we basically need to eat a lot more plants,
- 1:06:50and yeah, ideally, we should all be vegan. And
- 1:06:54I feel like it's fascinating to see people come
- 1:06:58to that conclusion by just giving them some cues
- 1:07:01and framework for how to have this discussion.
- 1:07:05And I've already established trust with those
- 1:07:07people. So when they come to that conclusion,
- 1:07:11they're like, yeah, that totally makes sense.
- 1:07:14I totally get where you're coming from. And,
- 1:07:16you know, I'm not vegan, but I really value the
- 1:07:19work that you're doing. And I'm really going
- 1:07:21to think about it a lot more. I get that all
- 1:07:23the time. And I think that's to me, that's a
- 1:07:27win. The more people we can get even at least
- 1:07:31thinking about it. Yeah. Yeah. And what Anita's
- 1:07:36organization and and animal save is done, too
- 1:07:39That was it was something like that that that
- 1:07:43was the facilitator and the catalyst for me to
- 1:07:46change Because I had heard about things were
- 1:07:50bad, but I again I had the association that well,
- 1:07:53those are factory farms So it wasn't until I
- 1:07:56saw the truth for myself that I changed so I
- 1:07:59think all of these different all of these different
- 1:08:02uh ways I mean you seem to really have a gift
- 1:08:05Robert for talking to people about the plant
- 1:08:07-based food system that gets them to consider
- 1:08:10going vegan good I've just found that um most
- 1:08:14people I know who became activists became activists
- 1:08:17because they were confronted with the horrors
- 1:08:20and the truth and not wanting to be part of violence
- 1:08:25but yeah yeah all right Um, I think we probably
- 1:08:31have a ton of questions from the chat. Did you
- 1:08:34have a burning one that you see in the chat?
- 1:08:36There are a number of good questions in the chat.
- 1:08:39I'm looking at this one that says, uh, what are
- 1:08:43your recommendations for creating or developing
- 1:08:45a beyond cage free group slash campaign in our
- 1:08:50city? I feel like where I am, we have many people
- 1:08:53scattered around, but don't have a lot of a community
- 1:08:56or organizational hub to focus on this work?
- 1:09:00So I thought that was a really great question.
- 1:09:03Yes, Anita. That's a great question. That's exactly
- 1:09:07what needs to happen. So like right now what's
- 1:09:09happening is cage free is spreading around the
- 1:09:12world community by community. And we can't have
- 1:09:15it overturn the animal rights protection movement.
- 1:09:19And we got to get together. And so one method
- 1:09:22we were thinking of are organizing town halls.
- 1:09:26Let's just start seeing what we can do and just
- 1:09:28bring the community together. And the model is
- 1:09:29the UK climate emergency briefing. So what they
- 1:09:33do is they show a short doc to get everybody
- 1:09:35on the same page with experts. Like we can have
- 1:09:37PETA and various experts talk about it and then
- 1:09:39just have the community just talk about it. Like
- 1:09:41how do we, you know, what can we do? And then
- 1:09:45do positive constructive actions like encouraging
- 1:09:48people not to eat eggs. um talking about hens
- 1:09:52like just that beautiful film that that IDA and
- 1:09:55in defense of animals and Leah showed earlier
- 1:09:57um just this is an opportunity to educate people
- 1:10:00about hens and how incredible they are and and
- 1:10:03so I would think it's it's about in -person gatherings
- 1:10:06this is online which is very important but we
- 1:10:08also got to do in -person things in communities
- 1:10:10and um you know we have this website but we we're
- 1:10:14thinking of starting a volunteer uh sign up and
- 1:10:17then maybe starting to set up you know, like
- 1:10:20I said, town halls, but also maybe teams, maybe
- 1:10:23that you can sign up by teams. And there's a
- 1:10:26couple of groups that already did actions, like
- 1:10:28Robert did an action in Chicago. Dipty did something
- 1:10:32in New Jersey, and then Alexis, Sebastian, and
- 1:10:36others did something Buenos Aires. They already
- 1:10:38had leaflets and everything. So we're gonna have
- 1:10:40materials. Somebody in the chat also asked for
- 1:10:41a material, like a package. So we're gonna work
- 1:10:43on that. That was a great suggestion. But yeah,
- 1:10:46I think that is the next stage. So everybody
- 1:10:51should stay glued to the website, right? Because
- 1:10:53there's going to be updates on the website with
- 1:10:54how everyone can get involved at a local level,
- 1:10:57right? And all the events that we're going to
- 1:10:59be having, both online and in person town halls.
- 1:11:03Yes, Robert. Yes. And for now, keep a lookout
- 1:11:07for our weekly info session. Sorry, our bi -weekly
- 1:11:11info sessions. so we do an online workshop every
- 1:11:17two weeks where we update everyone on where we're
- 1:11:19at in the campaign and How people can get involved
- 1:11:23to take action. So for now, please look for those
- 1:11:27those info sessions and Robert isn't that via
- 1:11:31free from harm or is that Right. Yeah, it's a
- 1:11:36for anyone in that we have its plant -based treaty
- 1:11:39and free from harm and other coalition members
- 1:11:43that want to get involved. Yeah, IDA will hopefully
- 1:11:46join that for sure as well. Great. Okay. And
- 1:11:50which website, people are asking. So everybody
- 1:11:52right now go to beyondcagefree .org. But one
- 1:11:57other person asked, how about a group on Signal?
- 1:12:00We do have a Beyond Cage Free group on WhatsApp,
- 1:12:04right? So you can join that. But is a Signal
- 1:12:06group coming? A lot of people have issues with
- 1:12:11WhatsApp and just like privacy and stuff. So
- 1:12:14signal, we can do that as well. So thank you
- 1:12:17for that suggestion. We can certainly start a
- 1:12:20signal chat. And that can, all of this will eventually
- 1:12:23be added to the Beyond Cage Free website, right?
- 1:12:26So people will be able to join in. Okay, so Robert,
- 1:12:29I guess people can contact you at freefromharm
- 1:12:32.org. Yeah, if someone wants to contact me directly,
- 1:12:34they can email me at robert at freefromharm .org.
- 1:12:37And I would say, keep the focus on the BeyondCageFree
- 1:12:42.org website. Free from Harm is under construction.
- 1:12:46We're updating our website. But for this campaign,
- 1:12:49that's the BeyondCageFree .org is the place to
- 1:12:55go. Great. And Anita? Yeah. The animalsavemovement
- 1:13:02.org and plantbasedtreaty .org. This current
- 1:13:07campaign obviously is beyondcagefree .org. If
- 1:13:12you want to contact me, it's anita at plantbasedtreaty
- 1:13:15.org. Thank you. And individuals can sign the
- 1:13:18open letter too. So organizations of all kinds,
- 1:13:23doesn't have to be an animal advocacy group and
- 1:13:26experts in all fields and individuals. So please
- 1:13:28share that website with everyone you know. Robert
- 1:13:33and Anita, it's been an absolute honor to have
- 1:13:36you and Faraz. Thank you so much for all the
- 1:13:41incredible work that you are doing and I am going
- 1:13:43to amplify your voices and we are going to empower
- 1:13:46this movement more and more. So, and thank you
- 1:13:49everyone for joining us and back to Lisa. Yes,
- 1:13:52it's really been an honor and a pleasure to have
- 1:13:55you here and to share. This is one of the hottest
- 1:13:57topics in the animal rights movement right now.
- 1:14:01And we're wanting to bring it to you. We think
- 1:14:06it's important to talk about what's going on
- 1:14:09and to have these conversations within our community.
- 1:14:13So thank you, Leah and Robert and Anita for bringing
- 1:14:18this to In Defense of Animals. And this is a
- 1:14:21big part of our programming for World Vegan Month.
- 1:14:24And there's more that we haven't. for you that
- 1:14:28Leah has graciously prepared. So you're welcome
- 1:14:31to find out more by going to idausa .org forward
- 1:14:36slash world vegan month. So thank you all. We
- 1:14:40hope that you enjoy world vegan month. We do
- 1:14:43have some support services for all of you, especially
- 1:14:47regarding Thanksgiving, which is a tricky holiday
- 1:14:51in the United States. So we have a support group
- 1:14:53available for those of you who are interested.
- 1:14:56on the actual day to talk about your vegan values
- 1:15:00with others who relate and appreciate what you
- 1:15:05stand for. And we are very thrilled to be part
- 1:15:12of the Beyond Cage Free initiative. We will be
- 1:15:16sharing more about it and stay tuned for a new
- 1:15:21alert coming out about the minks experiencing
- 1:15:26bird flu. which covers a lot of what we talked
- 1:15:30about today in terms of advocacy. And that will
- 1:15:33be coming out in In Defense of Animals eNews
- 1:15:35this Friday. So stay tuned, everyone. We hope
- 1:15:40you have a great rest of your day. And thanks
- 1:15:43for all of our people who tuned in and all of
- 1:15:47our speakers and to Leah for putting this together.
- 1:15:51My absolute pleasure and honor. Thank you, Lisa.
- 1:15:53Thank you very much. Thanks everyone for joining.
- 1:15:57Thank you everyone for listening. I kindly invite
- 1:16:00you to share this podcast with the vegans you
- 1:16:02know. Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:16:07Again, thank you so much for caring and I will
- 1:16:09see you next Tuesday for a new episode.