Latest / James O'Brien Daily / The school phone ban won't fix our addiction
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:07Welcome to today's James o' Brien Daily.
- 0:10Sit back and enjoy all the best bits from my daily LBC show where we get into the biggest news stories of the moment.
- 0:18I'm going to go in first this morning on the story about phones being completely banned in schools.
- 0:24But I don't really want to talk about your children.
- 0:27I want to talk about you.
- 0:28Or possibly as usual, I want to talk about me.
- 0:32I've been really trying for a while to pin down my misgivings.
- 0:39This really weird sense I have that something really bad has happened to me.
- 0:45Something really bad has happened to me.
- 0:47And because I don't watch like weird stuff online, I don't know if you saw the Russell T.
- 0:52Davis drama Tiptoe.
- 0:55I mean, absolutely haunting, think of it most days.
- 0:58But David Morrissey's character in that, watching such vile and corrupting content that he ended up vile and corrupted.
- 1:08So because I've never really fallen into that trap and I don't particularly doom, scroll or suddenly notice that two hours have gone and all I've been watching is cat memes.
- 1:20I came off Twitter some time ago, so the temptations of spending too long on there into pointless arguments with people who are probably running 500 accounts from a cellar in St.
- 1:32Petersburg.
- 1:33My Internet usage, in other words, is pretty healthy.
- 1:39And if I were to remove the laptop from that equation, then it becomes even healthier because the laptop can sometimes be on your lap.
- 1:48That's why it's called laptop Keith.
- 1:50The laptop can sometimes be on your lap while you're supposed to be watching a film and you get a little bit distracted.
- 1:56This is obviously when you're at home, slightly strange behavior in a cinema.
- 2:00So my Internet use, my phone use is pretty healthy.
- 2:05You know, I can't really leave my phone off because of, I mean, various reasons.
- 2:15I've got, I've got youngish children, young adult children, and I've got a poorly mum.
- 2:20So I don't really ever want to be uncontactable.
- 2:26That's all family based.
- 2:27I spent parts of my career where I couldn't afford to be uncontactable for professional reasons.
- 2:32So I need a phone that can be used to contact me.
- 2:37And I also recognize that I have not fallen into many of the really horrible traps with regards to smartphones and, or the Internet that an awful lot of people have fallen into.
- 2:51So what do I think is wrong with me?
- 2:53What is this weird thing that's happening to me that I have been really struggling to articulate?
- 2:59And I think this is going to be one of those phone ins where we possibly abandon it entirely in 4 minutes time.
- 3:06Because I only had this thought 27 minutes ago and it may turn out to be an absolute load of old toot.
- 3:15I don't think it is.
- 3:17I don't think it is.
- 3:18And I've mentioned it to you a couple of times.
- 3:20I've mentioned it to you a couple of times and haven't fully nailed down what it is that I want to talk about.
- 3:29And something happened last night that fits in with what I'm about to say.
- 3:35Not last night.
- 3:36About five o' clock yesterday, I was reading a book that I'm really enjoying and I caught myself putting the book down when I got to the end of a chapter and checking my phone to see if complete strangers
- 3:51who I've never met had had their turn yet on a word game that I like to play on my phone.
- 3:56That is healthy, educational and, you know, if I was of an age where dementia was becoming a possibility, it would be one of the things that the doctor encouraged you to do to keep your brain whirring so completely
- 4:06healthy.
- 4:07Right.
- 4:07And yet for some reason there was a, there was a bit of a glitch in my brain because I thought I shouldn't have done that.
- 4:18I really, I'm really enjoying this book now.
- 4:21My relationship with reading changed during lockdown and I found that, and continue to find that incomprehensible.
- 4:29When lockdown started, I think I'm.
- 4:31I thought to myself, right, I've got nothing else to do.
- 4:33I'll do the job, I'll do the show in the morning, and then I've got all that time that I often dream of having, you know, and, and I'm going to read all the books that I've never got around
- 4:43to reading.
- 4:43I'm going to read or I'm going to reread.
- 4:46I thought about, I talked to one of my daughters about starting at the beginning and reading all of Dickens in chronological order.
- 4:52I just thought that lockdown would deliver this extraordinary opportunity to read every word that had ever been written.
- 5:00Almost special prize to everybody who knows that the last man reputed to have read every word that had ever been written was St.
- 5:07Augustine of Hippo.
- 5:09And then I actually read less during lockdown than I do the rest of the time.
- 5:16And I didn't clock at the time really what I was doing instead.
- 5:21But I bet if I could hop back in time, which is quite apt given the book that I was finishing off last night, if I could hop back in Time.
- 5:30I bet you I spent five hours a day on social media or just on my phone during lockdown.
- 5:37I bet you I spent four or five hours a day on there.
- 5:41And I think it broke something inside me.
- 5:45So that now when I am reading a book that I'm really enjoying, I get an urge.
- 5:54I get an almost.
- 5:55Well, I would say it was actually an uncontrollable urge.
- 6:00And I've never had that in my life, ever.
- 6:06I've never been addicted to anything.
- 6:10When I was a kid, I thought I might be addicted to nicotine, but I wasn't.
- 6:13It turned out incredibly easy to give up and never really smoked much anyway.
- 6:19Other times in my life where I thought I might have been addicted to cannabis, but I wasn't.
- 6:22We'll talk about people who are a little later in the program, but I wasn't.
- 6:26Getting expelled from school can be a fairly swift crash course in whether or not you have some sort of chemical dependency or not when you're under house arrest in your own home.
- 6:38I've never been addicted to anything.
- 6:40I understand what a craving is.
- 6:42I know what wine o' clock is.
- 6:43You know, six or seven o' clock comes around in the end of the day and you think, oh, I might just pour myself a nice glass of Pinot Grigio, or is it Friday?
- 6:51I might just mix a martini or something like that.
- 6:54But I've never sort of woken up in the morning thinking I'm just going to have a little nip before I go to work.
- 7:01I've never had a craving for a chemical that is comparable to the craving.
- 7:09I get to check my phone.
- 7:13And the most important element of this conversation, for me, and you may disagree, and of course you can disagree in all the usual ways, the most important element of this conversation is that I am not doing anything unhealthy
- 7:27with my phone.
- 7:29You know, I'm not trolling people.
- 7:32I'm not looking at porn, I'm not looking at illegal stuff.
- 7:36I'm not gambling.
- 7:37I'm not doing anything that might be considered to be a vice.
- 7:42I'm reminded of the fact that you can get addicted to exercise, and it is not necessarily a good thing.
- 7:47But I can't really think of anything else that might qualify as an addiction but is not necessarily unwholesome or corrupting or unhealthy.
- 8:01Well, it is unhealthy, but not for the most obvious reasons or even unpleasant.
- 8:07And I was trying to pin down what it was that had been bothering me, what had been bugging me.
- 8:14And I realized so two things happened in the last 12 hours or so.
- 8:21But the first was the way I leant over to my bedside table.
- 8:25I was reading on my bed, I leant over to my bedside table, I put my book down, cover up, and I leant over to my bedside table and I picked up my phone.
- 8:33And it felt as if the correct word to use, it felt as if I was reaching for a packet of cigarettes.
- 8:43It's suddenly, you know, it's the same shape, roughly.
- 8:47You pick it up, you're in the middle of doing something else.
- 8:50You're not doing this thing instead of doing the thing that you're doing.
- 8:54I'm not.
- 8:54I'm not putting my book away.
- 8:57I'm not putting it back on the shelf or sliding it under the bed.
- 9:01The book is an ongoing process.
- 9:04I'm just going to have a quick blast on my phone.
- 9:07I'm just going to have a quick toke on my phone.
- 9:10I'm just going to have a quick puff on my phone.
- 9:13And given that I've never been addicted to cigarettes, I don't know why that was the thing that popped into my head.
- 9:19And then it went away again until I got to work this morning and read about the crackdown on distractions in class.
- 9:26That we'll see pupils handing in their phones at the start of the day from next year.
- 9:31Not the crackdown on what is on the phone.
- 9:36You know, we've made this.
- 9:37I don't think it's a mistake because some of these algorithms are engineered in a way that is phenomenally addictive, very deliberately, very cynically, very dangerously and very consciously.
- 9:49But I'm not looking at that stuff.
- 9:51I'm addicted to the distraction.
- 9:55It's not.
- 9:55I'm not even addicted.
- 9:56What is going on here?
- 9:59What is actually going on here?
- 10:02What's the psychology that's kicked in?
- 10:05So I honestly think now, and I've been thinking for some time, that I should probably try to do something about it, not least because I may have another book in the pipeline.
- 10:14And that means that distractions become a hundred times more problematic than they are when I haven't got a book on the go.
- 10:21But I honestly think that I am addicted to my phone and I don't know who to ask.
- 10:31Not for help, necessarily, but in the first instance, I don't know who to ask for confirmation except people who have been addicted to other things.
- 10:42If you get this, and I think cigarettes are the most obvious one.
- 10:45It's not like heroin, you know, or even alcohol in that.
- 10:49It's not going to make such massive behavioral changes to you that everyone around you is going, you've got to knock that on the head.
- 10:55Most people who are in love with or the children of nicotine addicts probably prefer it when they're not really short tempered and snappy and angry.
- 11:03So it's, it's.
- 11:05And what happens when I don't, I can't even tell you what would happen if I didn't pick up the phone.
- 11:10What would actually happen.
- 11:13I would get antsy because I always succumb.
- 11:15I always give in to the urge.
- 11:17I always give in to the crave.
- 11:19I mean, what's it like trying to give up smoking?
- 11:22What's the hardest thing about giving up smoking?
- 11:24I've got no idea.
- 11:25It's the habit, right?
- 11:27Is it the breaking of the habit?
- 11:30So question number one.
- 11:34Are you addicted to your phone?
- 11:37And I mean genuinely addicted to it, as in you've possibly tried to go cold turkey or you've tried to cut down and you are astonished to discover that you can't.
- 11:50I don't want to talk about the children today.
- 11:52We always talk about the children.
- 11:54We never talk about you.
- 11:56We never talk about me.
- 11:57We always talk about the children.
- 11:58We got to look after the children.
- 11:59Oh, won't somebody think of the children?
- 12:01Oh, I believe that children are the future.
- 12:03Treat them well and let them show the way.
- 12:05Someone's got to think of the children.
- 12:06It's not the chi, I mean, it is the children.
- 12:09What about you?
- 12:09What about mum and dad?
- 12:10What about their teachers?
- 12:12We need to have a conversation not about what is on the phone, but about what is happening to us psychologically, addictively, behaviorally.
- 12:25I think this is huge.
- 12:26You know, let's start with Stephanie, who's in Kelso.
- 12:29Stephanie, what would you like to say?
- 12:31One of the major problems that I have with the use of smartphones is that it actually, it creates a feeling of being connected, for example, with young people who are speaking with other young people that they've never met
- 12:46or continue to deal with, speak with people that they don't have much contact with.
- 12:51There's a false feeling of connection.
- 12:53And young people are losing the skills to relate to other people.
- 12:57They're losing social skills because of smartphone use.
- 13:01I mean, what is going on in the brain?
- 13:03God only knows.
- 13:04And the neuroscientists are trying to find out.
- 13:07But I honestly believe that the brain is being remodeled and there is some research that is starting to evidence this is being remodeled from the use of smartphones.
- 13:18I mean, some of this I know Some of this I don't.
- 13:20And maybe it doesn't strike anybody else as significant to own this phenomenon and call it addiction.
- 13:28People who've never been addicted to anything in their lives and who sit there stroking their chins and nodd sagely when we have items on the radio about children.
- 13:36And I think you're right to remind us that the impact on an unformed brain is going to be greater than the impact on a supposedly formed brain.
- 13:45Of course it is, in a million different ways.
- 13:47But using the word addict, using the word addiction is not hyperbole.
- 13:52It's correct.
- 13:53Because if I was reading a book and had to put it down to light a cigarette, nobody would question that I had an addiction.
- 14:00But I'm reading a book and I have to put it down to check my phone.
- 14:03Yeah, well, yes, yeah, absolutely.
- 14:05But something you just said is that it has an effect on the unformed brain.
- 14:10It has an effect on the formed brain.
- 14:12No, I know it does, but they're different effects, I think.
- 14:16Yeah, slightly different effects.
- 14:17But what's happening is that the adult brain is also being affected quite significantly by the constant use of a screen that they can interact with as they choose rather than having to interact with somebody who is more unpredictable.
- 14:35Do you know what?
- 14:36Because I've got a real blind spot on this.
- 14:38It takes me about five different goes to find the thing I'm talking about.
- 14:42And I've written about it at length.
- 14:44State corporate harm maximization.
- 14:47Yeah.
- 14:48Where most obviously with fixed odds betting terminals, where you have structures that prioritize corporate profit and state revenue over public health.
- 15:00Maximizing public harm rather than minimizing it.
- 15:03I think smartphones are in that category now.
- 15:06Well, programs on smartphones are.
- 15:07For example, Facebook is proven to be.
- 15:10Yeah, but so are my word games.
- 15:13I've not sorted that because I don't play word games.
- 15:15I don't have.
- 15:16But I can't.
- 15:16That's all.
- 15:16I check.
- 15:19But you might have an addiction to keeping your brain occupied.
- 15:22Sometimes I just check the time or I check that no one's messaged me or I just check.
- 15:26I check, I check, I check, I check.
- 15:28I don't even know what I'm checking.
- 15:29I'm not looking at the bad stuff.
- 15:31I'm not looking at the stuff that we always talk about like social media.
- 15:34I hardly look at social media.
- 15:35I'm just check.
- 15:36What's that going on there?
- 15:37Just checking.
- 15:38I wonder if we watch this show back on YouTube, how many times I check my phone while I'm doing this.
- 15:43And this is Quite, I mean, don't laugh, I appreciate you're a psychotherapist, but this is quite a high intensity job.
- 15:50You have to concentrate when you're doing this job.
- 15:52But how many times do I check my phone in the course of an hour or three hours?
- 15:56You may have a problem.
- 15:57Do you, do you have a problem?
- 16:00I do have a problem.
- 16:01I'm having to fight the use of my smartphone.
- 16:03I've noticed, or I've noticed that I'm scrolling, I'm researching, I'm doing too much on this phone and I was quite shocked to find that had spent about two and a half hours on my phone just, just doing nothing.
- 16:18About,.
- 16:18Faffing about.
- 16:19But it's, it's really a really difficult activity to stop because that phone has become what we call a self object.
- 16:28A self object is, for example, a child's teddy is a self object.
- 16:34A child doesn't have the internal mechanism to be able to self soothe and to feel calm, so they're given a teddy.
- 16:40So the teddy is an externalized form of self soothing.
- 16:44So a Filofax used to be a self object.
- 16:47I used to have a Filofax because I can't remember dates for the life of me.
- 16:51I needed the Filofax to have my appointments and dates written down where I can see them.
- 16:56The smartphone has replaced that.
- 16:58But there's a difference.
- 17:00Whereas the Filofax is static and a teddy is static, a smartphone's programs will interact with you and they're designed to hook.
- 17:09Full stock.
- 17:10They're designed to hook.
- 17:10And they just really, really work.
- 17:12And it's a bit of a red herring to put all of our attention into worrying about the kids and, or worrying about the unwholesome content.
- 17:21Because everything is designed to hook,.
- 17:23Right?
- 17:23The interesting anomaly, if you scroll Doom scroll, say TikTok or pleasure scroll, TikTok, you'll get one nice thing, one horrible thing, one nice thing and an advert or something, something sort of similar, an equation similar to that.
- 17:40It is designed to hook.
- 17:41They're all designed to hook you.
- 17:43And they work because they've paid millions of pounds to the best psychologists to help create it.
- 17:50Yeah,.
- 18:57Of course, to max it, to do it all.
- 18:59And, and I, I mean, I, I, I mean some people don't get it.
- 19:03Some people can have a cigarette, have 10 cigarettes, be social smokers, they're not addicted at all.
- 19:09There are people who look at their own partners picking up their phone every five minutes and think there's something wrong with them.
- 19:14And there is they're addicts.
- 19:16But it's.
- 19:17It's a curiously difficult admission to make, actually, until you make it and then what the heck do you do with it?
- 19:23Time for a short break now.
- 19:25Afterwards, the best callers in the business.
- 19:35We're all addicted, aren't we?
- 19:36What the hell are we going to do about it?
- 19:38Andreas is in Malmo in Sweden.
- 19:40Andreas who?
- 19:40Mordu.
- 19:44Hello, James.
- 19:45How are you?
- 19:46I just did that.
- 19:51What's on your mind?
- 19:53So I'm ringing because I.
- 19:56I feel quite strongly about this and I always compare it to my nicotine addiction.
- 20:01I have smoked for many years.
- 20:02I've sort of relapsed currently.
- 20:04Don't tell my husband, please.
- 20:07And the biggest issue in knocking that habit on the head was always the ubiquity of accessibility to tobacco.
- 20:14Yeah.
- 20:16Whenever you go to the grocery store, you need to decide, I'm not going to smoke today.
- 20:19Whenever you're waiting for the train, you have to decide not to nip into the kiosk for it.
- 20:24And with phones, that issue is just exacerbated so many times.
- 20:29A million.
- 20:29Because it's in your pocket.
- 20:30Exactly.
- 20:30It's in your pocket.
- 20:31You can't live your life without it.
- 20:33You have absolutely crucial apps on it that you just need to function in society.
- 20:37You don't have the option.
- 20:39And what's worse is that we have sort of.
- 20:43I'm 31 years old and was when I was teenager, that's when kids started getting smartphones.
- 20:48Yes.
- 20:50And we have sort of lulled our entire culture into a.
- 20:55Into a place where every child needs to have them at a very young age.
- 20:59We're basically legitimizing, expecting children to have something that is hugely addictive on them all the time, every day.
- 21:11Everything about is addictive.
- 21:13Is that feeling the same somehow?
- 21:15The same?
- 21:16Because I've never been addicted to nicotine.
- 21:18But when you.
- 21:19You're in the middle of doing something else.
- 21:21Yes.
- 21:21And you think, I just need a smoke.
- 21:23And is it the same when you think, I just checked my phone?
- 21:26It is exactly the same.
- 21:27I was thinking of.
- 21:29I was thinking of it just.
- 21:30Just the other day I woke up in the morning.
- 21:32Usually what I would do first thing was go make a cup of coffee and then go out on the balcony, have a smoke.
- 21:37Yeah.
- 21:38I woke up the other day, the night previously my train home had been delayed and I'd made a compensation claim.
- 21:44Yeah.
- 21:44I turned over in debt.
- 21:45I took my phone.
- 21:46Very first thing I did that day, I hadn't even gotten out of bed, was to see the status because I got in an email.
- 21:53That was how my day started.
- 21:54And it's how it always started.
- 21:56It's not that it's something else.
- 21:57There's always something there.
- 21:59Everyone does that.
- 22:00First thing you do is check your phone and the more even.
- 22:02If you.
- 22:02Tell yourself you're just checking the time, but if there's a notification on your screen, you're going to click on it.
- 22:06Have a look.
- 22:06What's that coming?
- 22:07Delivery coming later today.
- 22:08Oh.
- 22:09Yeah.
- 22:10Lolo has played on Crossplay.
- 22:12I'll go and have a look at what they've done and see if I can smack them with a seven letter or even an eight letter word, ideally using one of the letters that they've put down overnight.
- 22:19And we're off we go in our brain can't be good for us.
- 22:22It can't be good.
- 22:23And it's exactly.
- 22:24I used to, you know, it was especially when I was going outside to the shops and to the bus and that sort of thing that, you know, it just becomes part of your routine at a certain point to
- 22:34feed your addiction.
- 22:35Whenever.
- 22:36Whenever it's convenient.
- 22:37You know,.
- 22:38Just had it then.
- 22:39I just had it then.
- 22:40I don't know whether you triggered me by saying that.
- 22:42Yeah, well, I.
- 22:43Just wanted to check it and Keith's got it.
- 22:45I can't check it.
- 22:45I'm fine.
- 22:46I'm not like climbing the walls or anything like that.
- 22:48But I just had it then.
- 22:49That little impulse.
- 22:51How do we.
- 22:51How did you give up smoking, albeit that it wasn't a complete success?
- 22:55Well, well, when I met my other half, he looked at me and said, you certainly do cover ups.
- 22:59Should you maybe go to the doctors and have that checked?
- 23:01And apparently I had asthma at that point.
- 23:03So.
- 23:05Yeah, yeah.
- 23:06I started when I was 17 and even then it took two years to knock the habit.
- 23:10Even after I knew I had asthma.
- 23:11Right.
- 23:12I.
- 23:12Still.
- 23:12It's.
- 23:13A proper addiction.
- 23:14It is a proper addiction and so is the phone.
- 23:16I,.
- 23:17I think you're right.
- 23:18And, and you know, I don't.
- 23:19It doesn't mean we shouldn't be talking, but we're doing it in a slightly complacent way.
- 23:25Talking about social media.
- 23:26And look, some of those films are great, the ones about all the tech bros saying I'd never let my own children near it.
- 23:32But they were the software builders.
- 23:34They weren't the hardware builders.
- 23:36And the psychotherapist in Kelso's Point notwithstanding, it's the usage you're addicted to.
- 23:43But the distinction to me seems to be moot some people will just be checking the time.
- 23:49Can you be addicted to your watch?
- 23:51I'm not somebody who would ever use the phrase or the letters OCD in a knockabout way.
- 23:57I used to be, you know, I used to be one of those people who would say, oh, I'm a bit OCD about car radio being on even numbers.
- 24:04But I know people for whom OCD is an absolutely life limiting condition.
- 24:10And I'm not talking about that.
- 24:12I'm talking about something different.
- 24:14I'm not talking about an obsessive compulsion.
- 24:17I'm talking about an addiction.
- 24:19They are very different things.
- 24:20Andreas, thank you.
- 24:21There it is, the smoker who sees them as more or less identical psychologically, which means the addiction to the smartphone use must be chemical.
- 24:31It's about what gets released.
- 24:34David Zinwigan.
- 24:35David, what would you like to say?
- 24:36Hello.
- 24:37I've been listening carefully, trying to convince myself that I'm not addicted.
- 24:42But as the conversation got deeper and deeper.
- 24:45Yes, I am addicted, completely addicted.
- 24:48And it took me right back to my earlier days of being about 10 or 11.
- 24:55So I'd like to go back to the Internet and an age where it was dial up.
- 25:01Yeah.
- 25:02Baron, it was basic.
- 25:04There was no algorithm.
- 25:06It was the amazing tool that we would connect the world.
- 25:11Yes.
- 25:11And I was addicted to it then.
- 25:13There was nothing going on there.
- 25:16I would sit and click refresh on the email inbox waiting for something to happen.
- 25:21I just couldn't resist it.
- 25:22So that's, Is that fomo?
- 25:23Is that just you thinking there might be something going on and you can't bear to miss it?
- 25:28Yeah.
- 25:28And I also think I was getting the anticipation.
- 25:31Yeah.
- 25:32But I think that's different.
- 25:33I mean, maybe not for you actually, but I didn't have that.
- 25:36I did, I never had that.
- 25:37I had that.
- 25:38I remember dial up Internet.
- 25:39It's a bit like waiting for jet set Willie to load on the ZX Spectrum, wasn't it?
- 25:43It was with the ye certain knowledge that five times out of 10 it would crash and burn anyway.
- 25:47I never really had that.
- 25:48I don't think mine kicked in until I had the phone, until I had the smartphone.
- 25:53And do you think it's the same now?
- 25:55I was just about to say the, the, the, the connection and addiction that I had and I have now, probably on par, probably worse.
- 26:06When I was, I was younger, a bit more mature now, but I can remember getting out of bed, absolutely hung over to hell and brawling myself to that screen because obviously I couldn't lie in bed and check My
- 26:18phone.
- 26:19I'm waiting for that dial up.
- 26:20I'm just.
- 26:21Yeah,.
- 26:22Just being haunched over that screen.
- 26:26Nothing happening at all but the.
- 26:28Your consciousness of the world outside your window and a really weird gnawing sense that something might be happening.
- 26:39And you're addicted to the need to know.
- 26:41Yeah,.
- 26:42I thought that's why it works actually.
- 26:44So you were a very, very early.
- 26:45You're like a canary down the coal mine in a way on this stuff.
- 26:48This is the nature of the tech.
- 26:50This is before they engineered it to make you addicted.
- 26:53Exactly, that's my point.
- 26:55You got addicted to the.
- 26:56To the essence.
- 26:58Yeah.
- 26:58Of the technology.
- 27:00And I can't even tell you now what I was doing on that computer.
- 27:04No, I hear you.
- 27:06Well, I can probably work it out, mate, given your age.
- 27:12To be fair, there wasn't.
- 27:13There wasn't a whole deal of that.
- 27:15But I remember just, you know, having a.
- 27:17Yeah, something is happening.
- 27:19Something.
- 27:20I mean that is it actually that's the same thing.
- 27:22Something's happening on my phone now and I haven't got it.
- 27:23Keith's got it.
- 27:24So there's that little bit of a nibble.
- 27:27And you had that with the whole of the Internet, not just the stuff that was tailored directly for you.
- 27:31It was.
- 27:33What's going on out there?
- 27:33I need to know and I don't know what the pre tech.
- 27:36Thank you, David.
- 27:37That's absolutely fascinating.
- 27:39What would the pre tech equivalent of that be?
- 27:42My dad was probably addicted to the news.
- 27:45He couldn't walk past a television on the hour, you know, on the 9 o' clock or the 10 or the 6.
- 27:51He couldn't walk past the television without turning the news on.
- 27:54He couldn't drive in his car with music playing.
- 27:57I don't remember ever having music playing when we were kids.
- 28:00It would always be Radio 4 for the tops of the hour and then off.
- 28:04I didn't grow up in London, otherwise obviously we'd have been listening to lbc, which wasn't national at the time.
- 28:10But he was a journalist, he was a newspaper journalist.
- 28:12So that's a bit like describing a jockey as being addicted to horse racing.
- 28:16It was both his job and his hobby.
- 28:19And I'm not doing that either.
- 28:20Just because a few of you have asked.
- 28:23It's not to do with my job.
- 28:24I don't actually listen to some of the news shows anymore that I used to listen to in the morning because they just get on my nerves.
- 28:31The presenters get on my nerves.
- 28:33Talk about pot Kett.
- 28:36But obviously I listen to Nick.
- 28:38Cause he's on in the office upstairs.
- 28:41But on my way into work, I don't really.
- 28:44I'd much rather listen to sort of Paganini these days.
- 28:49Or the Ratons I was listening to this morning.
- 28:50Cause they popped up on the Conversation yesterday.
- 28:53I was listening to the Kids from the Estate and the rest of that album by the Brilliant, brilliant Ratons.
- 28:58And so it's not the news.
- 28:59It's not that I've got this job, so I have to be on top of everything.
- 29:02Quite the opposite.
- 29:03It.
- 29:03I can do a.
- 29:04I can, I can get into work in the morning and do a kind of Hoover of the news in search of things that we can talk about together.
- 29:12So who's, who's cracked it?
- 29:13Who's come out the other side?
- 29:15Kaya is in Lewisham.
- 29:17Kaya, what made you pick up the phone?
- 29:19Well, I'm at war with my phone.
- 29:21I don't know about anybody else, but it's really bad because it's like, you know, they bring out these new AI movies now that's like what, 10 minutes long?
- 29:34And it lasts about four hours.
- 29:36And you think you're gonna go to bed until the next one comes along and your doom scrolling all over again.
- 29:42Oh, you mean the sort of soap operas that are, in short, I was reading about these yesterday and they're even more engineered to keep you up forever up.
- 29:51There.
- 29:52And then you have stuff like the algorithms.
- 29:54You go on Amazon typing in, oh, I want to change my living room around.
- 29:58And now you're on Tick Tock and Instagram and it's showing you different ways of how you can change your living room.
- 30:03But you was even on that.
- 30:04He was on Amazon.
- 30:05So how did you find out I was on Amazon?
- 30:07You know?
- 30:08Yeah, I mean that, that.
- 30:10It's a slightly different conversation, but it's part of the process of addiction.
- 30:14When you're saying, when you say you're at war, do you.
- 30:17What you mean is that you know you shouldn't be doing this, but you can't help yourself.
- 30:21And that's an addiction.
- 30:22That's an.
- 30:23Addiction.
- 30:23And I'm waking up, up, I'm going bed at 4am in the morning.
- 30:26I've got.
- 30:26Knowing I got work at 7 like that.
- 30:29You.
- 30:29Can't.
- 30:29Be doing.
- 30:30That.
- 30:30Exactly.
- 30:31What.
- 30:31Have you tried?
- 30:32Have you tried anything?
- 30:33Have you locked it in a cupboard?
- 30:34Give it to.
- 30:34Keith.
- 30:35Yeah, I'm gonna give it to Keith.
- 30:38I'm gonna give him my address instead of to come at this time.
- 30:42But have you tried anything?
- 30:44Have you?
- 30:44I've tried.
- 30:45Okay, so at the moment, I'm just.
- 30:46Literally just said, okay, my limit is 12 o'.
- 30:49Clock.
- 30:50Yeah,.
- 30:5012.
- 30:51Midnight.
- 30:51Yeah, midnight.
- 30:52And if I don't, I'm just gonna.
- 30:54I put my phone in the living room and I go into the bedroom.
- 30:58Because if the phone's next to me, and that's the problem, if your phone is next to you and you hear any sort of buzzing and even down to, like, games that you're playing, it will buzz.
- 31:05It would say, oh, look, come back.
- 31:06You didn't completely.
- 31:08This anytime it buzzes like, oh, my eyes are open straight away.
- 31:11No, it has to go in.
- 31:13The other room has to be locked away.
- 31:14There's no alternative to that.
- 31:16It's just kind of like cold turkey.
- 31:19I mean, we can smile about it and chuckle about it, but we are actually talking about something very serious.
- 31:25And you mentioned not getting enough sleep before you go to work.
- 31:28That's quite a big deal.
- 31:29But what other things would you be doing, or should you be doing that you're not doing?
- 31:34I think it's more like a distraction.
- 31:36Finding out what can distract you.
- 31:38What do you like to do?
- 31:40Just to be clear, you're not personally ignoring that screaming child in the background at the moment, are you?
- 31:44Yeah, I work in a nursery.
- 31:46Okay.
- 31:46All right.
- 31:47And you're on your break.
- 31:48Break.
- 31:48Yeah.
- 31:49Right.
- 31:49I just wanted to clarify that because otherwise I feel that I was somehow part of the problem rather than the solution at this point in the conversation.
- 31:56This is why I need to go to my bed on time because I've been working.
- 31:58Grief.
- 31:59If there's any job where you want to be absolutely compost.
- 32:01Mentors.
- 32:02Oh, yeah.
- 32:03But there's lots of other things you're not doing.
- 32:05You know, you're probably not seeing friends as much as you could do.
- 32:07You're not doing.
- 32:08Literally, you're not crying.
- 32:10Yeah,.
- 32:11It's.
- 32:11It's.
- 32:11Well, I'm seeing my friends online because that's where I am.
- 32:14We're all on there.
- 32:14And that's for the only place or the place that you mostly see them.
- 32:17I'm gonna get.
- 32:18I don't know whether I enjoy your break.
- 32:20I don't know how you can relax, but I guess you get used to it.
- 32:23It's like working in Lush, isn't it?
- 32:25And getting used to the smells, which are glorious.
- 32:27But you always think when you go in as a shopper that you would not be able to cope with it eight hours a day.
- 32:32Same same with children in the background.
- 32:33Kaya, brilliant call and absolutely on the nose.
- 32:36We all know it, what are the stages of addiction?
- 32:39Is it like grief?
- 32:40Are there seven stages of addiction?
- 32:42Acknowledgment.
- 32:43Would it be like, well, I like it but I haven't got a problem.
- 32:45That's where you start normally, isn't it?
- 32:47And then, and then it is.
- 32:49Well, I could, I could give it up whenever I wanted.
- 32:51That's the second bit.
- 32:52Well, has anyone ever done this?
- 32:53Should we write this down?
- 32:54This sounds quite good.
- 32:55I, I haven't got a pro, so I like it but I haven't got a problem.
- 32:59Yeah, all right, maybe I do it a little bit too much, but I could stop whenever I wanted.
- 33:03Yeah, we say that, don't we?
- 33:04I could stop whenever I wanted, I like it, but I've got.
- 33:07Not got a problem.
- 33:07What comes after that?
- 33:09I don't think there are seven stages.
- 33:11What comes after?
- 33:12I, I do it a bit too much, but I could stop whenever I wanted.
- 33:15What comes next?
- 33:15It's, it's.
- 33:16I turn, I can't stop.
- 33:18That's the third stage of addiction.
- 33:20Acknowledgement.
- 33:21You just go from, yeah, all right, I like it but I haven't got a problem to all right, I do it a bit too much, but I could stop whenever I wanted to help.
- 33:30I can't stop.
- 33:32Stage three.
- 33:32And we're all there, every single one of us.
- 33:34Time for a short break now, but when we get back we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 33:50Just in case you thought that I had taken leave of my senses when I suggested that this was the same phone in as the last hour.
- 33:55We're just swapping the word phone for the word cannabis.
- 33:58Alcohol consumption among the younger generations has gone off a cliff as well.
- 34:02It's why they're trying to dress everything up in new clothes, new packaging like buzz balls and all the rest of it.
- 34:08What if.
- 34:09And just think about this for a moment.
- 34:12It's not my thought, it's Emma's.
- 34:16What if young people are replacing the substances that change their brain chemistry with their phones?
- 34:25So why are young people not smoking weed and middle aged people still are?
- 34:29Answer.
- 34:30Well, because they're never bored.
- 34:33They're bored, but not bored.
- 34:36I just, just, I don't know, worth chewing on for a moment.
- 34:40Matt's in Bradford.
- 34:40Matt, what made you pick up the phone?
- 34:43Yeah, just explaining to your, your producer that I've had a long involvement with, with cannabis over the years and it, I said, I just said to her, actually it just dawned on me the year just the other day
- 34:53that it must have been 21 years since I've started cannabis and I smoked it every single day and not just, just small quantities, incredibly large quantities as I'd probably get to an ounce a week even now.
- 35:07And it's.
- 35:09I don't know, I mean I would, I would love to stop you.
- 35:11Could I really?
- 35:12If you wanted to.
- 35:13Could you?
- 35:15Have.
- 35:15You ever tried?
- 35:16Have you ever tried?
- 35:17I tell you what, the withdrawal symptoms I, I experience if I, if I've gone short or there's a shortage of supply and I cut down my usage.
- 35:28Oh God, I'm sick as a dog for about three days.
- 35:32Put more detail there, you're climbing the walls.
- 35:34But you're not, you're not physically ill, you're just, you just can't think.
- 35:37I'm.
- 35:37Actually physically ill.
- 35:38Like I will have the, you know, whether it be diarrhea or whatever, I won't be able, my appetite will die a death.
- 35:46I mean.
- 35:46But I think that I'm, I'm an ex, I'm an exception to the rule because I've always had sort of, I've had a very liberal mum.
- 35:54She was always very much of the belief that she didn't want me on street corners.
- 35:59I probably still think that's a healthy, healthy approach to take.
- 36:02She.
- 36:03But at the same time, you know, my, my house became sort of the go to for everyone in my, in my village so all my mates, all of us used to sit there smoking weed in the bedroom and,
- 36:14and eventually, yeah, mum started getting back into it and a lot of it was sort of tales of old.
- 36:19When she was in the 70s, she used to tell me she used to grow cannabis on her roof and yeah in off Wimpole street in London and yeah, she used to smoke it with her friends but albeit, you
- 36:31know, as you just explained, the cannabis strength and the smell and everything that's sort of associated with this incredibly different.
- 36:37So.
- 36:37When did it become, when did you first think?
- 36:41Because I mean everything you're describing now sounds like an advert for it.
- 36:44So when did you first start thinking?
- 36:47I.
- 36:47Don't intended to.
- 36:49No,.
- 36:49I know you don't intend.
- 36:50I know the bit about diarrhea probably wasn't.
- 36:52But the, but, but you know, being the center of the social grouping when you were a kid, having, you know, nice open relationship like that with your mum that you could talk about everything, some people will be jealous
- 37:04of that.
- 37:04It's not because of the cannabis but you paint quite an alluring picture.
- 37:08When did you first clock yourself going, this isn't really Fun anymore.
- 37:13This isn't a want, this is a must.
- 37:15This, I think it's more the.
- 37:18The lack of fitness and.
- 37:22So it's the lungs.
- 37:23Element, like.
- 37:24The lungs.
- 37:25I mean, yeah, I try and get out and do some sport and make myself, force myself to do it, but it takes every fiber of my being to generate the necessary motivation.
- 37:34Not just do exercise, but even just engaging my work.
- 37:37You know, I run a business, so I've got, you know, I've always got demands.
- 37:41I mean, I'll spend the day in front of my computer answering phone calls, doing what I need to do while also, you know, toking away on.
- 37:48On split.
- 37:49What.
- 37:49Time do you have your first one of the day?
- 37:53What, this morning?
- 37:53Yeah,.
- 37:548 o'.
- 37:54Clock.
- 37:55Really?
- 37:55With your coffee?
- 37:56Yeah, I mean, I probably had one 10 minutes ago.
- 37:59Keeps you regular.
- 38:00Yeah.
- 38:00But a lot of people, I think, really suffer with ill effects from it in the sense that.
- 38:04You clearly don't.
- 38:05You're complete.
- 38:06You're smoking it like other people smoke cigarettes.
- 38:09Very, very.
- 38:10Yeah, I would say, yeah.
- 38:11I mean, if.
- 38:12You run out of.
- 38:13If you run out of cannabis, what happens when you smoke tobacco?
- 38:17Are you addicted?
- 38:17I don't.
- 38:18I don't smoke.
- 38:18I knew you were going to say that.
- 38:20I don't know why, but I knew you were going to say that.
- 38:22Yeah, I don't.
- 38:24Yeah, I never smoke cigarettes.
- 38:26It's.
- 38:26But.
- 38:27You smoke your cannabis with tobacco.
- 38:29Yes, yes,.
- 38:29I do.
- 38:30Yeah.
- 38:30But a.
- 38:31Bag of tobacco will last two or three weeks.
- 38:32Yeah.
- 38:33You know, it's.
- 38:33Only a sprinkle on top.
- 38:34And then you kid yourself when you've run out that you can somehow meet some of the craving.
- 38:38I don't.
- 38:39Even kid myself.
- 38:39Don't even pretend anymore.
- 38:41You don't even roll a tobacco cigarette.
- 38:43I dread it.
- 38:43I dread it at the moment, but I try and spread it.
- 38:48Yes.
- 38:48And it's so many different levels to it.
- 38:52Yeah.
- 38:52But I think as liberal and as accepting and as accommodating as Mum was, I think if we both took a step back and had assessed it, I think we both realized that we didn't do either one of us
- 39:03any favors.
- 39:04I mean, Mum got heavily into it with me to the point where we would buy together continuously throughout my childhood.
- 39:11So I would go pick up 2 or 3 ounces and we'd have that for a few weeks or whatever.
- 39:16And yeah, it was.
- 39:17It was a strange last year.
- 39:21Yeah.
- 39:22Yeah, I mean, it was.
- 39:23It's always been me and her, so I haven't really got it.
- 39:25I've got no Extended family.
- 39:26There's no one left.
- 39:27So it was.
- 39:29Yeah, it just became.
- 39:30I don't know, it became a culture, but it also became an incredibly easy way of fitting in with the local lads who.
- 39:37Go.
- 39:37To school with in the village.
- 39:38So it was.
- 39:40Yeah, I mean, and it was fun as well.
- 39:43Let's not beat about the bush.
- 39:44You know, it was fun and it made.
- 39:46And it made you feel good and all of those things were true.
- 39:48But now you need it to stop yourself feeling bad.
- 39:51The days of it being something that made you feel positive are probably quite far behind you.
- 39:56I just feel like I'm gonna die.
- 39:57Yeah, if you don't have it.
- 39:58If you don't, everyone I know.
- 40:00Not when I die.
- 40:01No.
- 40:01I mean, if I continue doing it.
- 40:02Right.
- 40:03Oh, okay.
- 40:03So you've got, so you've got to stop.
- 40:07Yeah, I do.
- 40:07I do feel there's significant ill effects that are creeping in to my day.
- 40:12To day life and you know, just.
- 40:14Just smoking the, the vast quantity that I have over all the years.
- 40:17I mean, I'm.
- 40:17I'm a functioning user.
- 40:19I mean, listen, no one listening to this who didn't know that you'd had a joint 10 minutes ago would.
- 40:23Especially people who are not okay with the habit.
- 40:26They would not believe that you had just had a joint 10.
- 40:2910 minutes ago.
- 40:29Because you don't sound like the, the, the.
- 40:31The dealer in Withnail and I, or, you know, or, or Danny in with talking about your hairs being.
- 40:39But you, you clearly.
- 40:40I mean, you would have more mental clarity if you weren't stoned always.
- 40:43Oh,.
- 40:44I'm so much more.
- 40:45I'm so much more agile.
- 40:46I mean, even now I'm having to think incredibly hard just to get my words out.
- 40:50I'm a bit of a nervous wreck anyway.
- 40:52I'm dripping sweat.
- 40:53You should see the state of me.
- 40:55Oh, yeah.
- 40:56I'm just a mess.
- 40:56The anxiety, it can.
- 40:58It can induce in certain situations.
- 41:00Yeah.
- 41:00It doesn't help.
- 41:01It actually makes things worse.
- 41:03Yeah, yeah, it definitely does.
- 41:04I mean, it can calm you down.
- 41:06I mean,.
- 41:06One thing.
- 41:07I will say, find you'll be incredibly grumpy.
- 41:09I mean, the after effects of not having it in the morning, for instance, say I can be incredibly aggie.
- 41:16I really can be.
- 41:17I mean, the, the only time I'm truly happy is when I've had a couple gin and tonics and a couple doobies and I'm just.
- 41:24I hit a level.
- 41:25I hit a level.
- 41:26And it's a fake happiness.
- 41:27It's just a.
- 41:28It's a.
- 41:28It's a.
- 41:29It's a kind of.
- 41:30It's your body.
- 41:31Yeah.
- 41:32It's a reaction.
- 41:33It's.
- 41:33Whether it be chemical imbalance or whatever.
- 41:36You were going on about smartphones.
- 41:37And that's.
- 41:38That's one thing that I've never had either.
- 41:40So I've never had to deal with the addiction of social media or any of that.
- 41:42I've never really been interested in it, no.
- 41:46But my mates do.
- 41:47My mates.
- 41:47Could have gone both ways.
- 41:48And how many of your mates still smoke?
- 41:51As I was saying, we all.
- 41:52The amount of them that say they're quitting and they've quit, and within, what, a month to three months, they'll be straight back on it.
- 42:00So weird, isn't it, that?
- 42:01Having this conversation and everyone will be nodding sagely, going, oh, yes, it's the evil weed.
- 42:05But when you have exactly the same conversation, using the same words about smartphones.
- 42:10We weren't.
- 42:11We weren't ready to acknowledge it yet, but they both sound identical to me.
- 42:14Everyone I know who's been through what you've been through or going through, what you.
- 42:18Yeah.
- 42:18Has been through what you are going through just hit a wall.
- 42:21I don't know why.
- 42:22I mean, it's interesting that 55, and I know that's not much comfort to you because you're only 44, but they just.
- 42:28I'm 35.
- 42:29I.
- 42:29Was 35.
- 42:30Sorry, I got misinformed.
- 42:32Yeah, 35.
- 42:33Yeah.
- 42:33So you.
- 42:34You're not gonna hit that point.
- 42:35You don't really feel mortal.
- 42:36Even though you just said you're worried that you're gonna die.
- 42:38You don't feel mortal at 35.
- 42:40Maybe because.
- 42:41And I say this with great compassion and care, but maybe because you've lost your mum quite recently, it's come into your head for the very first time.
- 42:48Contributed hugely to her isolation.
- 42:51She.
- 42:51Had.
- 42:52Yeah.
- 42:52I mean, don't.
- 42:53Duh.
- 42:54We don't need to go there.
- 42:55We don't need to.
- 42:56Yeah.
- 42:56I.
- 42:56Mean, I miss her every day, but I.
- 42:58Can't help.
- 42:58But think that her hype.
- 43:00She died at 68.
- 43:01She was very young, but she used.
- 43:03To.
- 43:03Smoke and drink every day, like I do, in just replica routines.
- 43:07We would sit there drinking wine, gin and tonics, whatever, Playing Mastermind on TV with each other, whatever it was, you know, sad as it sounds.
- 43:16Doesn't sound sad at all, mate.
- 43:17Not to me.
- 43:18It was a bond.
- 43:20I mean, she was.
- 43:21She was crazy.
- 43:22I mean, she.
- 43:22Yeah, she got to the point where she was so into it when I'd opened her eyes to Amsterdam.
- 43:26Yeah.
- 43:27I mean she used to, she used to trek out on day trips to Amsterdam and fly back with sort of 2 ounces of, of hash from the places.
- 43:34And we used to, you know, we used to do regular trips out to Amsterdam continuous.
- 43:38I mean it doesn't matter now she's passed away.
- 43:40No.
- 43:40You know, no one can arrest her.
- 43:42Yeah, I know, I know.
- 43:43But she did get caught a couple of times.
- 43:45But there was incredible leniency shown.
- 43:48But yeah, we used to have a very weird life and I don't think people would believe.
- 43:52Well,.
- 43:52I do and I can see why you miss it as well because it was, it was bonding.
- 43:56The, this is where I get a bit patronizing and, and remind you that I, I do have, I do have the benefit of 20 years on you.
- 44:04But, but therapy would help.
- 44:07I, yeah, I, I, I do, I do sort of half consider it.
- 44:12Because.
- 44:13It's been a cynic and I just know.
- 44:15With me too, mate, you should.
- 44:16Feel like a conveyor belt.
- 44:17Like you're just being shipped into a therapy session and they've got the next face waiting for them around the corner and they're adopting the same approach.
- 44:24Exactly how I was.
- 44:25She, yeah, it's like a universal app.
- 44:27Exactly how I was.
- 44:28That's exactly how I was until I'm sitting there, right?
- 44:32And.
- 44:32You always say, I listen.
- 44:33To you, you've heard it a million times and suddenly it drops.
- 44:37And that is why you are doing things to fill a hole inside you.
- 44:41You need to know what dug that hole.
- 44:45I, I don't know.
- 44:47I mean, I do.
- 44:48God knows how many different reasons.
- 44:50It doesn't matter.
- 44:50Make a list.
- 44:51When, when you, when you know what dug that hole whole, you will feel the need to fill it diminish.
- 44:57I mean I, I have a very good idea of what it is that I'm feeling.
- 45:01I do, I do.
- 45:02There you go.
- 45:02There it is.
- 45:04And I don't think a therapist is going to tell me any differently to what I already know.
- 45:07But you just continuously sort of bury it, bury it and just keep sort of self medicating.
- 45:13Exactly how I felt until, I.
- 45:16Mean.
- 45:17Yeah, I know, I know.
- 45:19I just thought you'd be, I don't know, I mean, it's funny when your producer said, what do you want to say?
- 45:27I think it's something you're gonna have to prompt me with the questions and I'll be able to answer what you know, whatever you need to know.
- 45:33But I mean it just, it's consumed so much of my life, my friends lives.
- 45:38Yeah, we had I had a similar issue at school as you did with.
- 45:43With cannabis in school.
- 45:44And we were all threatened with expulsion, but luckily no one dobbed, so we sailed through it.
- 45:50But I got.
- 45:52I remember that time.
- 45:53That was.
- 45:53That was crazy.
- 45:54And I remember how worried everyone was about the letters being received from school because they send them out in the summer holidays, so there was no way of us intercepting them a long time after the actual event.
- 46:04Cons.
- 46:04Outweigh the pros.
- 46:05From early, quite early on, the cons start outweighing the pros.
- 46:08But here we are.
- 46:10Listen, I can't frog march you into a therapist's office, but I've heard, heard.
- 46:18I've heard this voice before.
- 46:21Yeah, yeah, I'm sure you have.
- 46:23I'm sure you have.
- 46:24That's all I'm gonna say.
- 46:25I've heard it before.
- 46:26It does make.
- 46:27It does make life.
- 46:29I don't know, it's funny.
- 46:30It makes it worse, especially.
- 46:34No,.
- 46:34No, no, no, no.
- 46:35It's.
- 46:35The booze.
- 46:36When you said it was the gin and tonics with the spliff.
- 46:38I never used to drink as much, but.
- 46:40Yeah,.
- 46:40But you're filling a hole and it's probably got worse than since your mum passed, right?
- 46:45Yeah, I mean, I got a lot of sleepless nights and.
- 46:48As I.
- 46:48Said, it was always me and her from start to finish.
- 46:50We've got no family.
- 46:51And.
- 46:52Yeah, I mean, she was only 68 when she passed away and with her high blood pressure and everything, that was a huge root cause of.
- 47:01Yeah, everyone listening, get your blood if you're high blood, if you've got high blood pressure, address it.
- 47:05There.
- 47:06Is.
- 47:06No doubt about it.
- 47:07Yeah,.
- 47:07You can do the things that need to do.
- 47:09And also.
- 47:10Awful state at the end.
- 47:11If you're smoking weed and drinking gin every night.
- 47:13Get on it.
- 47:14Yeah, yeah,.
- 47:17I.
- 47:17Think you're completely right.
- 47:26I got some breaking news for you.
- 47:28The famous man who failed to.
- 47:30This has just been reported by the Press Association.
- 47:33The famous man who failed to get a High Court injunction against two media organizations to prevent them from reporting allegations against him, can now be named as David Walliams.
- 47:47More details as and when they emerge.
- 47:50But David Walliams, who has already been dropped by his publishers and been dropped by the TV talent show that he used to be a judge on, has been in court a lot lately seeking to prevent the Guardian and
- 48:06ITN from reporting allegations against him.
- 48:11And that is now over.
- 48:15That legal battle is over.
- 48:17He failed to appeal against the last finding, which was that he wouldn't get the injunction that he sought partly on the grounds that his own mental health was so fragile that he would harm himself in the event of
- 48:30these allegations being made public.
- 48:32And he has now been named as David Walliams.
- 48:37It's funny, you know, if I wasn't.
- 48:39I couldn't find a way into the Russell Brand story this morning, despite the fact that it's obviously one of the biggest stories in town.
- 48:46Did it yesterday, we did it on Friday.
- 48:48I have a slight sense that the questions I have about the experience of sexual abuse and the judicial system, that you are more comfortable talking to a female presenter than a male presenter about that, which is perfectly reasonable
- 49:08and natural as well.
- 49:11But it kind of just struck me this morning.
- 49:14I don't want to sound as if I'm sitting outside a courtroom like some old crone knitting at a public hanging.
- 49:23Do you know what I mean?
- 49:24I couldn't find the question that I wanted to ask and I can't really find find a question to ask you about this and an awful lot of you getting in touch to tell me that you already knew.
- 49:34All I'd say on the crossover between David Wallace and we must wait to see what sort of allegations and accusations he is facing and Russell Brand is that in the world of rumor, they often got mixed up.
- 49:52So when I was told, when I heard people talking about someone incredibly well known facing all sorts of allegations, the temptation, or not even a temptation, just thinking it was one and not the other.
- 50:06So we will get more on that as and when it emerges.
- 50:09And of course, the nature of the allegations will no doubt become clear before closer play today.
- 50:16ITN and the Guardian have been working on this story for a long time in the way that the Sunday Times had been working on the Russell Brand story.
- 50:23So stand by for that.
- 50:27I'll bring it to you as and when I have it.
- 50:30But I think in the meantime, we'll crack on with the conversation that we were going to have anyway.
- 50:35And that is a conversation prompted by the conversations in the last hour and the way that they both led, particularly the second one about cannabis addiction and in Matt's case, about the use of cannabis and alcohol.
- 50:49In conjunction, they both led towards a conversation about therapy, which I went through a phase of talking with you about all the time.
- 51:02The reason being that I was one of those people who couldn't quite believe that I had become one of those people who talks a lot about therapy.
- 51:14So forgive me if you've heard this before and if you listen to the program on a regular basis, you probably have, although not For a while.
- 51:22Not for a while for me, going back about 10 years, we had.
- 51:28One of the people that I love most in the world got quite poorly, and I wasn't doing a very good job of helping.
- 51:35I wasn't doing a very good job of looking after them.
- 51:39I wasn't an addict or a habitual user of any of the things that we were talking about in the last hour, either alcohol or killing cannabis.
- 51:48But I was conscious, on some level, of being less than what I wanted to be.
- 51:55I'm not an unempathetic person, but I have this habit.
- 52:03I had this habit of thinking that I could talk you out of trouble.
- 52:09So if you said to me that you had broken your leg, then I.
- 52:15I wouldn't have said it quite as crassly as this, but I would have tried to comfort you by saying, well, at least you haven't got cancer.
- 52:26Do you see what I mean?
- 52:27I would always try and find a positive, for want of a better word, with which to alleviate your negative.
- 52:36And that's fine if you're trying to encourage someone to cheer up up in some relatively trivial circumstances, but it's not fine if you are dealing with someone who is really poorly.
- 52:52You can't jolly someone out or bully someone out, or cajole someone out or talk someone out of being poorly.
- 53:00And I hope I'm remembering everything correctly.
- 53:04I'm pretty sure I am.
- 53:05And I've written a whole book about this process, actually, which I should probably send a copy of to Mata if he's interested.
- 53:14And you notice, if you're lucky, and if you have people around you who care for you, even as you are being less than you could be or less than you should be in some circumstances, you notice that this
- 53:26is probably not authentic.
- 53:30This is probably not the real you.
- 53:32It's not the natural you.
- 53:33Why on earth, if you got punched in the face, would I try to cheer you up or comfort you by telling you that, well, at least you didn't get stabbed?
- 53:44Do you see what I mean?
- 53:45I don't know.
- 53:46Do you do this?
- 53:47Do you recognize this at all?
- 53:48Because if you do, you're probably coming from a similar place that I was coming from.
- 53:52And I can still come from there.
- 53:54Don't get me wrong.
- 53:55It's a weird thing.
- 53:59So, you know, somebody said, well, why don't you try therapy?
- 54:01And I, at the time, I'd have tried a caffeine enema if I thought it was going to help me become more useful to the people that I wanted to be more useful To.
- 54:11So I went along to therapy, absolutely cynical, absolutely skeptical.
- 54:19Completely, completely expecting.
- 54:22Is it really called toxic positivity, Lily, what I just described.
- 54:25Ooh.
- 54:26Well, I don't like that description.
- 54:28Thank goodness I don't really suffer from it anymore.
- 54:30Maybe if I had known that phrase, I'd have woken up a little bit earlier to how unhealthy it was.
- 54:34I think you'll feel a little bit sorry for me when I get to the point of realization about where mine had come from.
- 54:41But I went along to therapy fully expecting to laugh my socks off.
- 54:46I was kind of doing it more as a way of showing willing than in expectation of anything serious happening, anything genuine happening.
- 54:57And you've got to be lucky.
- 54:58You gotta be able to afford it, which means you're lucky.
- 55:00And you've gotta be lucky, which means you get into contact with somebody who's good at what they're doing and is the right fit for you, which is far from guaranteed.
- 55:09Far from guaranteed.
- 55:12So I went along.
- 55:14The first thing she said was, well, anyway, this is just a sort of audition.
- 55:19Not an audition.
- 55:19She didn't use that word.
- 55:20But this is a meeting to find out whether or not we're going to be able to work together.
- 55:24And my arrogance kicked in, my conceit, my ego kicked in.
- 55:27I thought, well, hang on a minute.
- 55:28Minute.
- 55:29I'm.
- 55:30I will decide whether or not this goes forward, not you.
- 55:33I'll be the one that decides whether or not this goes forward, not you.
- 55:39And.
- 55:39And that's part of what I was poised to discover.
- 55:44And then we.
- 55:46We talked for about an hour, and it was helpful.
- 55:49And we talked about why I'd come to see her.
- 55:52And we talked about why it was.
- 56:02Why I was there, I suppose.
- 56:05And then at the end, she said, well, I think you should come back next week if you think this is gonna be helpful.
- 56:09I think we're gonna be able to work together.
- 56:12Toxic positivity.
- 56:13I've never heard that phrase before.
- 56:16And I went back the following week, and about 20 minutes into the conversation, she starts talking about childhood.
- 56:22And I start thinking, oh, here we go.
- 56:24Here we go.
- 56:25It's probably because I didn't get a teddy bear when I was 10.
- 56:27Or it's because, you know, I was only allowed sweets on a Friday.
- 56:31Here we go.
- 56:32Because I really was one of those people not to malign people who are still like that.
- 56:36It's absolutely how we are conditioned to be, particularly as boys and men who went to the kind of school that I went to.
- 56:42These are the schools that trained People to run empires.
- 56:46You know, the idea that you could arrive in the middle of the subcontinent and truly believe that you had a God given right to be in charge of everybody who was born there does not happen by accident.
- 56:55Vulnerability, susceptibility, sentiment, all of these things are anathema.
- 57:02You are trained from a very, very early age to get rid of them.
- 57:04To get rid of them.
- 57:08And so I'm sitting there and she says to me, and then what happened?
- 57:13What were the punishments like at your school?
- 57:15And I said, well, I got beaten a lot.
- 57:17Really?
- 57:17I said, yeah, I got beaten a lot.
- 57:19And what do you mean you got beaten as well?
- 57:20I used to have to put my hands out and the head teacher would then hit me really hard with this specially designed implement.
- 57:31And this is the mad moment and this is the story I tell to help people like me who think that therapy is either a waste of time or strictly for the birds, to hopefully persuade them that it isn't.
- 57:45Because if I tell you about a child regularly being hit, then you probably don't think that's okay, right?
- 57:54If I tell you it just in isolation about a theoretical child being regularly hit hard by an adult in a formal structure or an informal structure because the adult has lost his temper or because the child has done
- 58:09something wrong and he's been queuing up outside the office with three other kids waiting to be battered, then you probably think that that's wrong.
- 58:16The younger you are, the more likely you are to find that obscene.
- 58:19Seen, right?
- 58:21But I tell this story to this therapist and she says, that sounds awful.
- 58:25And I immediately go, no, it was fine.
- 58:30And she said something like, well, it must have hurt.
- 58:35And everything changed.
- 58:37Everything in my life changed in that moment.
- 58:39Well, it must have hurt.
- 58:40And I'm about to go, no, but I couldn't deny that it hurt.
- 58:47So you could claim that it was fine, but you couldn't deny that it hurt.
- 58:55And as soon as I said, yeah, it did, actually, it really hurt.
- 59:00And then, you know, you start the long process of working backwards, working forwards, working around.
- 59:08There's lots of other things would have gone on in your background, but talking about it and acknowledging it, and of course, the reason that I mentioned toxic positivity, although I didn't even know those words in that conjunction until
- 59:20five minutes ago, is because that's what I had learned.
- 59:25That is exactly what I had spent the rest of my life doing.
- 59:28So I got beaten.
- 59:30It didn't really hurt.
- 59:31At least you didn't get expelled.
- 59:34Yeah, it did really hurt.
- 59:36And so what That I didn't get expelled in that moment at that time.
- 59:39That was awful.
- 59:40That was horrible.
- 59:41That little boy should never have been treated like that.
- 59:43It was grossly unfair.
- 59:44It was unjust, it was vicious, it was violent, it was painful, it was trauma.
- 59:49So therapy, what did it do for you?
- 59:52And how cynical were you?
- 59:53To start with, let's start in Scarborough.
- 59:55James is there.
- 59:55James, what would you like to say?
- 59:57Good morning, James.
- 59:58I think it's a really up time with the news.
- 1:00:00So I was a victim of childhood sexual abuse.
- 1:00:03Oh, God.
- 1:00:04And no, it's fine.
- 1:00:06I could talk about knockout therapy.
- 1:00:10It's.
- 1:00:11Yeah, I was.
- 1:00:11I was one of those guys who it.
- 1:00:14To me, it was a dirty little secret.
- 1:00:15I didn't want anyone to know.
- 1:00:16No one knew.
- 1:00:17My friends, even my partners didn't know.
- 1:00:19And it was.
- 1:00:20It was just in there.
- 1:00:21And it was two people, actually.
- 1:00:23I heard an album by this New York rapper called Homeboy sun man called Don't Feed the Monster.
- 1:00:28And I was like, how.
- 1:00:29How on earth is he just talking about all this stuff that happened to him so openly, like, that's really brave.
- 1:00:34And then it was yourself, and I can't remember if it was your book or.
- 1:00:38Or listening to it and you were talking about it and I.
- 1:00:40Didn't go through anything like what you went through.
- 1:00:43No, but it's still trauma, isn't it?
- 1:00:44That.
- 1:00:45Shouldn't have happened.
- 1:00:46And so you're being toxic positive now.
- 1:00:50And I was kind of like, ah, he's.
- 1:00:53He's kind of wording my feelings of like, why would I talk about the inner child?
- 1:00:56What nonsense.
- 1:00:57You know, And I'm coping, I'm doing well.
- 1:00:58You know, I'm a working class lad, you know, I raise my kids.
- 1:01:02I go to work every day.
- 1:01:03I'm surviving, you know, I'm doing good.
- 1:01:05Yeah.
- 1:01:05And then I.
- 1:01:07It was you two that kind of inspired me.
- 1:01:09And I saw a homeboy, someone, and I told him and he just went, oh, man.
- 1:01:11I gave me a hug and start crying.
- 1:01:13That was amazing as well.
- 1:01:15But I went therapy and I realized there was a part of me that was owned by someone else, that.
- 1:01:20That was mine to own.
- 1:01:21And it was like a reclamation of self.
- 1:01:23And I noticed as well that there seemed to be this kind of poison that I didn't realize was there.
- 1:01:28And it was just inside my body.
- 1:01:30And by going to therapy, it kind of sipped out of me each and every time.
- 1:01:36And I noticed afterwards, and don't get me wrong, for anyone listening, keep going.
- 1:01:40Because at first it's hard And I was a mess for the first few weeks, and my girlfriend said I was literally screaming in my sleep.
- 1:01:48And then.
- 1:01:49You've opened the box that you'd locked.
- 1:01:51Yes, really deeply locked.
- 1:01:53Really deeply locked.
- 1:01:55And then I was.
- 1:01:56I just know it's like someone had cut me up and instead of getting angry, I was just like, oh, they're silly, you know, and that was it.
- 1:02:01Just like so much lighter on my feet and just being a lot happier.
- 1:02:05And I went from it being a secret to now I talk about it on stage and.
- 1:02:09And sing.
- 1:02:10Sing a song about it.
- 1:02:11And then other people have come, spoke to me about it.
- 1:02:13So it just keeps going, but.
- 1:02:16It becomes.
- 1:02:16I mean, I'd love that idea of somebody else owned a part of you, somebody awful, someone who did awful things that's owned a part of you.
- 1:02:23And, and, and it's a survival.
- 1:02:26I mean, you had successfully survived by telling yourself things that weren't true.
- 1:02:31I'm okay.
- 1:02:32I've.
- 1:02:32I've moved on.
- 1:02:33I've dealt with it.
- 1:02:34Yeah.
- 1:02:35Yeah.
- 1:02:35And.
- 1:02:36And my.
- 1:02:36My brother took his own life and he went through similar.
- 1:02:39So I think the difference is.
- 1:02:41Is enormous by.
- 1:02:42By having that.
- 1:02:43And it was a charity because I.
- 1:02:45I can't.
- 1:02:45You know, I was a single parent and I couldn't afford it.
- 1:02:48And this amazing charity paid for the therapy called Survive North Yorkshire.
- 1:02:55And they've changed my life.
- 1:02:57Well, clearly.
- 1:02:58And you've kind of answered the question that I wanted to ask you, but I'll ask it anyway and get maybe a little more detail.
- 1:03:04So the point is, for people who are skeptical, and I sense you probably were to start with, the point is, is that it's not about addressing the past for the past's sake.
- 1:03:19It's about addressing the past for the present's sake.
- 1:03:22It changes.
- 1:03:23Changes who you are today.
- 1:03:24And you've mentioned temper and anger.
- 1:03:27That was the biggest thing, was it that you just became.
- 1:03:30You had this anger and because you weren't directing it to the place where it should have been directed, you would end up directing it almost like a scatter gun.
- 1:03:40Yeah, it was mainly when I was driving and I did.
- 1:03:43You know, it wasn't like I harmed anyone, but it was just.
- 1:03:45I noticed the reaction was like, this isn't me.
- 1:03:48Where's this kind of coming from?
- 1:03:49Because I dealt with other things in, in life quite well, but it was there.
- 1:03:53And, and just.
- 1:03:55It's.
- 1:03:55There's a greater capacity that poison's gone, and there's a greater capacity to just philosophize on life on Everything in general.
- 1:04:02You.
- 1:04:03Sound lighter.
- 1:04:04You sound.
- 1:04:04You sound like that.
- 1:04:05I love that phrase.
- 1:04:07The poison's gone.
- 1:04:08That's such a powerful image, isn't it?
- 1:04:10Was there a moment when you felt it working when you.
- 1:04:13Cause I'm very lucky like that in that for me.
- 1:04:16I may have mythologized it slightly in the telling, James.
- 1:04:19Who knows?
- 1:04:19Cause there's no way I can go back in time and be there.
- 1:04:22But it certainly feels entirely authentic to me that in that moment when she said that must have really hurt, I suddenly felt the portcullis get pulled up again and everything came out to almost entirely positive ends.
- 1:04:37Did you have a moment like that or was it a much more process?
- 1:04:41A much more drawn out process?
- 1:04:43I think when I realized the difference it made was when I couldn't even just mention it without literally bursting into not just tears, but overwhelming emotion.
- 1:04:56And it was when after a few weeks you said, said, did you notice?
- 1:04:59You just told me that and you didn't even cry.
- 1:05:01And I was just like, oh, yeah, yeah.
- 1:05:04I mean, like this, this would have been impossible to do without.
- 1:05:07Not just crying, but like probably hyperventilating to talk to you.
- 1:05:12You'd be back there.
- 1:05:13I mean, that's it, isn't it?
- 1:05:15That's extraordinary.
- 1:05:19And we're done for another day.
- 1:05:20Huge thank you to all my contributors for some truly special conversations.
- 1:05:24I'll be back on lbc tomorrow from 10 or right here shortly afterwards.
- 1:05:29This has been a global production.