Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / Russell Watkins - Lean Transformation Expert & Co-founder @ SempaiGuide
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series Leaders, managers and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:22Russell Watkins: And the ideal world is you get everybody in the business thinking like they own the business.
- 0:27Russell Watkins: So it's a shift from return and investment thinking to return on assets.
- 0:31Russell Watkins: And it's a problem in manufacturing.
- 0:33Russell Watkins: Any professional manager not any most professional managers in manufacturing they are well versed in return and investment.
- 0:40Russell Watkins: How do I put a compelling case together to buy something new and shiny?
- 0:44Russell Watkins: Yeah're pretty good at that.
- 0:47Russell Watkins: Working out net present values, discounted cash flows um, we don't want that.
- 0:52Russell Watkins: That's a professional manager mindset.
- 0:54Russell Watkins: We.
- 0:54Russell Watkins: We want to return an assets mindset first, which is look, I've already sunk x thousands and millions into this business.
- 1:01Russell Watkins: Please convince me that the assets I have you are getting the best out of them.
- 1:06Russell Watkins: So where are the losses?
- 1:08Russell Watkins: Where am I getting downtime?
- 1:09Russell Watkins: Where am I getting problems and defects?
- 1:11Russell Watkins: Where is it difficult?
- 1:13Paul Shrimpling: and let's optimize what we've got and only then will we spend money a good question to ask yourself about how your department runs, or how your whole firm runs, is how do you improve the fees per full-time employee?
- 1:25Paul Shrimpling: How do you drive them up by 20%, 50%, even, or maybe even more?
- 1:30Paul Shrimpling: Well, on this podcast with Russell Watkins, who's spent 30 years embedded in the world of lean process improvements within manufacturing businesses and others, you'll discover a number of key questions, key insights that help you change the conversation between you and your team.
- 1:52Paul Shrimpling: That helps you transform the results in your firm.
- 1:55Paul Shrimpling: Let's go to the podcast with Russell now.
- 1:58Russell Watkins: Hi, I'm Russell Watkins from Senpai.
- 2:00Russell Watkins: Senpai was formed in 2007, helping manufacturers and other companies who are committed to improving their businesses.
- 2:07Russell Watkins: We transfer true lean capability to people who are running those businesses, both at front end sharp end and at the top level, and the company was formed I'm co-founder.
- 2:19Russell Watkins: We've worked on four continents with about close to 100't know close to 100 companies now training 1,000 people, and we love being in and out of about 60% manufacturers and 40% other businesses from various sectors.
- 2:33Russell Watkins: When I'm not doing that, I like craft beer and I like walking around our local area, which is Derbyshire and Staffordshire, and any time I can combine the two on a circular walk is a tremendous thing.
- 2:45Paul Shrimpling: Well, a walk is not a walk, russell, unless there's a pub involved.
- 2:47Paul Shrimpling: In my view, there's just no way that works, so I've got to go there straight away.
- 2:53Paul Shrimpling: So, given that I'm also, with the Derbysh Dales Favourite pub walk, more interested in the pub than the walk Favourite pub walk.
- 3:02Russell Watkins: Well, anything that ends up near the old dog at thorpe is very good that's a very good pub.
- 3:07Speaker 4: It is um and.
- 3:09Russell Watkins: But to be fair, you know, we, we, we keep discovering new pubs, because if you're lazy, you end up going where everyone goes stepping stones at dovedale.
- 3:16Russell Watkins: And we, we bought the os app years ago, so we map our own routes, yeah, um, and so we end up seeing practically nobody throughout the day, but having to hack a new path through three places sometimes, yeah to get to the pub.
- 3:30Russell Watkins: To get to the pub, yeah, which which, by the by, is always worth it, absolutely so.
- 3:35Paul Shrimpling: We just recently rediscovered the uh, the george at um, um, alston field.
- 3:41Paul Shrimpling: Alston field, that's the one, the one which had different owners a little bit a while back.
- 3:46Paul Shrimpling: Now they've got this Essex geezer in who's really really welcoming.
- 3:51Paul Shrimpling: It's now changed.
- 3:51Paul Shrimpling: Oh, fabulous, we're really enjoying that and the food's good.
- 3:54Paul Shrimpling: Simple but good.
- 3:55Paul Shrimpling: Anyway, let's get into the meat and potatoes just to make the restaurant stroke pub reference.
- 4:00Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the podcast, russell.
- 4:03Paul Shrimpling: We've known each other uh, a while and uh, I know you're deep into you know lean capability and it was interesting your intro we talk about you know working with you know um front of house, uh, sharp end, top level, the you know cross section of human beings across the firm.
- 4:22Paul Shrimpling: I'm just wondering what the phrase humanize the numbers from a lean process improvement space actually means to you.
- 4:32Russell Watkins: Yeah, that's an interesting question and it hits on a really, really nub point in manufacturing and in other businesses.
- 4:40Russell Watkins: We're talking about socio-technical systems.
- 4:42Russell Watkins: There's.
- 4:42Russell Watkins: There's stuff has to happen, but it's all.
- 4:44Russell Watkins: It's all run by humans and if you think about the numbers in most businesses that would be things like safety, quality, delivery, cost, people or there'll be a series of metrics that are used to run the business.
- 5:00Russell Watkins: This I see a lot of businesses who who use those, um, as very hard, non-human things and they forget three critical things about humanizing numbers.
- 5:13Russell Watkins: The first is strategic, the second is about a thinking way and the third is about how you can make people engage with the numbers.
- 5:20Russell Watkins: Do you want to start anywhere, particularly with those, or should?
- 5:22Paul Shrimpling: I just take them one at a time.
- 5:23Paul Shrimpling: So strategic thinking and engagement, yeah, Okay, let's start with the engagement piece.
- 5:33Paul Shrimpling: We work on the basis that you know, if you're going to humanise the numbers and you don't engage with the team, aren't engaged with those numbers, they aren't engaged with the customer and client and they're not engaged with the you know we'll get into strategy for sure then they're either, if they're not engaged, they're either neutral or they're disengaged, and there's just no way you can deliver on client value, client care, deliver on time, deliver quality product services, unless you've got an engaged team.
- 6:01Paul Shrimpling: So that's a hot button for me.
- 6:02Paul Shrimpling: So let's go with the engagement.
- 6:05Russell Watkins: So that's also partially linked to the strategy point and I'll come back to this later.
- 6:14Russell Watkins: There's a really smart fellow who once said you want to give people something for the heart and something for the head.
- 6:17Russell Watkins: Well, I'll park that point for a minute.
- 6:21Russell Watkins: In terms of engagement, people have to have a reason to do something beyond what they normally do.
- 6:27Russell Watkins: So almost everybody I meet anywhere working in any company, has an eight and a half hour to a nine hour day and 12 to 13 hours of work to get through every day.
- 6:36Russell Watkins: So if you're going to want them to engage with the numbers, you have to make it easy and give it a purpose.
- 6:41Russell Watkins: If people have to work hard, they have to interrogate.
- 6:45Russell Watkins: It's a real pain and a ball ache to get to the numbers.
- 6:48Russell Watkins: They ain't going to do it.
- 6:50Russell Watkins: Whereas if you take a Toyota style approach, which is a 1-3-10 approach you visualize everything and you make it simple to see how we're doing then they are more likely to engage.
- 7:01Russell Watkins: And a 1-3-10 approach is one second, three second, 10 seconds.
- 7:05Russell Watkins: Whatever business you're in a charity or an accountancy practice or a solicitor practice, whatever within one second you should be able to see whether we're on target or not.
- 7:18Russell Watkins: Within three seconds, you should be able to see what the biggest problem are that's stopping us meeting our target, and within 10 seconds, you should be able to see what the biggest problem are that's stopping us meeting our target, and within 10 seconds, you should be able to see who's doing what about it and who do I go and ask to get involved or find out what state this is.
- 7:30Russell Watkins: Whatever your version of 1, 3, 10 is, make it easy for people to do the right thing and become engaged so?
- 7:38Paul Shrimpling: so one second to see whether you're on target or not, three seconds to see what the biggest problem that's holding you back is, and 10 seconds to identify who's doing what to rectify the problem.
- 7:47Paul Shrimpling: Have I understood that right?
- 7:48Russell Watkins: yes, yeah, yeah, and and and to go and see them.
- 7:51Russell Watkins: And the.
- 7:52Russell Watkins: The critical one there is the three.
- 7:54Russell Watkins: You visualize this so that people, uh people see it, it's in their face and um, the three.
- 8:01Russell Watkins: Second bit is really important because the, the thinking behind, is Pareto You've never got enough time to get across everything you have to.
- 8:09Russell Watkins: And if you, if you follow our Italian economist friend Pareto, 80, 20, 80 percent of your problems come from 20 percent of your things.
- 8:17Russell Watkins: As leaders, as managers, is to point out and make it obvious which small number of things are causing the biggest number of problems.
- 8:34Russell Watkins: Because, after all, there's various definitions of leadership.
- 8:36Russell Watkins: My favourite current one is leadership is doing the right things when it's hard.
- 8:41Russell Watkins: Now, you can unpick all sorts of stuff from that, but at the very least, our job is to take noise and complexity and make it simple to see which way we should all be pointing and helping.
- 8:57Paul Shrimpling: So our job is to simplify process, manage identifying or helping our team identify the problems so that they can go and fix them.
- 9:10Russell Watkins: Yeah and yeah well.
- 9:12Russell Watkins: So this takes us into strategy, so something called Hoshin Kamri, which is policy deployment.
- 9:17Russell Watkins: It's basically every year you've got to run the business, yeah, you've got to run your accountancy practice, but also you have to improve it, otherwise you get left behind.
- 9:25Russell Watkins: But your time to improve it is scarce, of course, because you're running the business.
- 9:29Russell Watkins: So, any mechanism you have to work out how to improve the business, it better be simple and it better be easy.
- 9:37Russell Watkins: One of the key things you need to do is find out the vital few.
- 9:42Russell Watkins: So, rather than have a long list with a long tail of these are our problems in the business?
- 9:47Russell Watkins: Look, there's 60 things.
- 9:48Russell Watkins: Zero in on what are the key major things that we can align people around and really get some effort going Right.
- 9:56Russell Watkins: So, rather than broad, go narrow, narrow 80-20.
- 10:01Russell Watkins: Because the long tail will distract you, whereas the one or two top things because you think about it.
- 10:11Russell Watkins: You've got people in a business who are naturally wired to want to do things better, because they like an easier life, which is fine, and also they want the business to thrive.
- 10:20Russell Watkins: And then there's a whole load in the middle who are, you know, I come here and I clock in and I do my best while I'm here, and then there's a, there's a chunk at the end who are as long as I draw breath.
- 10:31Russell Watkins: I am not going to do anything to improve.
- 10:32Russell Watkins: I hate these people, but they're paying my mortgage.
- 10:35Russell Watkins: So all of those that top 80%, some of whom are keen if they're making improvements to the, to the business, if they know that, for example, as a business, we need to improve our retention rate on this, or we need to improve our quality on that, or we need to become smarter and faster at doing this bit, then their mind can start to think about ways to do that and you're aligning all the small bits of effort towards a good goal all the small bits of effort towards a good goal.
- 11:07Paul Shrimpling: So have you got an example story, russell, that can take you, know those insights and show how they unfold in a practical way.
- 11:13Russell Watkins: Sure.
- 11:13Russell Watkins: So let me talk about a manufacturing business.
- 11:18Russell Watkins: So, please, manufacturing business needed.
- 11:24Russell Watkins: Its quality wasn't good, it was losing customers and wasn't winning any new work, so they decided that they needed to become a b-hag a big, hairy ass goal from, uh, harvard approach.
- 11:35Russell Watkins: Um, we need to become number one in our market on quality.
- 11:38Russell Watkins: Now, that's all, that's all well and good.
- 11:41Russell Watkins: Saying that, i'm'm banging up my poster, how do you actually do that?
- 11:45Russell Watkins: So they then went and benchmarked what is our current gap in terms of quality from us to the number one in the market?
- 11:53Russell Watkins: They worked out it was 15%.
- 11:56Russell Watkins: Then they go to the senior management team and say OK, we are 15% worse on quality.
- 12:01Russell Watkins: So for every 100 parts that we or our competitors send out, 15 of ours are crap compared to our best in the market.
- 12:09Russell Watkins: They then go to the senior team and say right, how do we fill this gap?
- 12:13Russell Watkins: Any ideas?
- 12:14Russell Watkins: And the senior team come up with ideas and maybe manager a takes five percent of it, manager b takes seven percent and manager c takes the remaining three percent.
- 12:22Russell Watkins: And then they go to their teams and they look at their data and say, okay, 7% for me means that I've got to reduce our scrap by £135,000 this year.
- 12:33Russell Watkins: Let's have a look at a parietal of our scrap and let's focus on this one and this one and problem solve them.
- 12:40Russell Watkins: Because we know if we take 50% out of each of those that adds up to 135 grand.
- 12:45Russell Watkins: That contributes our bit to the goal and everybody's happy.
- 12:48Russell Watkins: So it's taking a large desire like a vague business desire and deploying it downwards and so there's hard numbers showing up in each of those spaces.
- 13:03Paul Shrimpling: Uh, how does that then impact on the level of engagement, given that we're in the you know that engagement space?
- 13:11Paul Shrimpling: What?
- 13:11Paul Shrimpling: What's going on there?
- 13:13Russell Watkins: so there are I'll.
- 13:14Russell Watkins: I'll flip the question.
- 13:15Russell Watkins: There are two ways that you'll lose people and turn them off there.
- 13:18Russell Watkins: Three ways first is if there's no what's in it for me?
- 13:21Russell Watkins: The second is if you just tell them what to do.
- 13:25Russell Watkins: And the third one is the third one I've briefly forgotten.
- 13:32Russell Watkins: It'll come back to me.
- 13:33Russell Watkins: So the first one, the first one, was what's in it for me?
- 13:38Russell Watkins: What's in it for me?
- 13:40Russell Watkins: The really smart businesses that I work with.
- 13:46Russell Watkins: They catch on fast to the fact that as a business, you might need to improve X at the top, but if you can align that to the pain of somebody doing the purchase orders or who's doing the billing all through the business, then as we are improving the business, they're also making their life better.
- 14:05Russell Watkins: You've got an alignment of incentives there.
- 14:07Russell Watkins: It's worth us doing it because there's purpose to it.
- 14:10Russell Watkins: If people can't see a purpose to it, it'll fall to the bottom, whereas if they can, you've got a strong chance of doing it.
- 14:17Paul Shrimpling: So you've just said, make their life better.
- 14:19Paul Shrimpling: So if we're going to align whoever's in the billing or purchase order department or unloading the van with all the gear on it, all people at all levels, something has to happen.
- 14:33Paul Shrimpling: There's a piece of communication that has to take place which is helping them see that it's going to make their life easier.
- 14:39Paul Shrimpling: How does that come to happen?
- 14:43Russell Watkins: How does that come to happen?
- 14:44Russell Watkins: You ask there's something called catch ball, where you go to your team and say we've got a target and the target is to improve this and that's because we're falling behind in the market.
- 14:56Russell Watkins: What have you got in your daily life?
- 14:57Russell Watkins: That's difficult and creates a problem for you and contributes to that waste.
- 15:01Russell Watkins: In Two Second Lean, they call it fix what bugs you.
- 15:05Russell Watkins: If you want to get people engaged in improving the business, you just say I'll tell you what, fix what bugs you and we'll try and work out how that connects to the business.
- 15:14Russell Watkins: I'll give you a practical example.
- 15:15Russell Watkins: I'm working with a company in Worcester at the moment.
- 15:18Russell Watkins: They're a multi-billion pound engineering services business.
- 15:20Russell Watkins: They don't manufacture a thing, nothing, but what they do is a design, spec and project management project, manage the installation of massive test beds and engineering things.
- 15:31Russell Watkins: I'm working with them because, uh, they're finance people and they're purchasing people hate each other and uh, the finance people.
- 15:42Russell Watkins: Uh, so I swear in blind that the purchasing people are giving them bad information and vice versa.
- 15:48Russell Watkins: The impact for the customer, the impact for suppliers is that they are getting paid late.
- 15:53Russell Watkins: The impact for customers is that things are being delivered late.
- 15:56Russell Watkins: So let's take that from the business has recognised this and the senior team I'm working with has recognised it, down to the people actually doing the work.
- 16:08Russell Watkins: If you're doing the work, if you're a purchase order clerk here and we know that problems with purchase orders are creating lateness for the customer if you ask a purchase order clerk, what problems do you have?
- 16:20Russell Watkins: They'll quite often say, well, this is a bit rubbish, that's a bit rubbish, there's nothing tangible to look at.
- 16:24Russell Watkins: But if you ask them a specific question, you'll you'll not be able to stop them talking and the question you ask them is around how often when you get a purchase order requisition, is it complete and accurate and you can make a percentage out of that and complete and accurate has three parts to it.
- 16:44Russell Watkins: Firstly, is it filled in correctly?
- 16:47Russell Watkins: Has every box been filled in?
- 16:48Russell Watkins: Or have you got to go and spend your time in your shoe leather and write multiple emails chasing people to give you to fill boxes in?
- 16:55Russell Watkins: They should have in the first first place.
- 16:56Russell Watkins: So is it complete?
- 16:59Russell Watkins: Second, is it accurate?
- 17:00Russell Watkins: Have you is?
- 17:01Russell Watkins: How often do you get them filled in and they're just plain wrong.
- 17:04Russell Watkins: There is wrong information and so you've got to go back and effectively rework.
- 17:08Russell Watkins: And then the really interesting one is how often do you get uh, requisitions where they are unclear?
- 17:18Russell Watkins: There is information that came to light later that would have been helpful to have first time round.
- 17:22Russell Watkins: So you say to that purchaser I tell you what, for two weeks, every PO that passes your desk can you fill in this simple data sheet as a gate chart right Against those three categories, and at the end of it I promise you we're going to pick the number one and number two and we're going to find out the reason why and their pain in doing that.
- 17:49Russell Watkins: If we can solve their pain in having to chase around, we'll also be solving what's making it late for the customer no-transcript and they can see that that is helping them.
- 18:07Paul Shrimpling: Therefore, they'll help you achieve the strategic goal or target.
- 18:11Russell Watkins: As long as you draw the link from them, from listen.
- 18:16Russell Watkins: There's an old Zen fable and do you like?
- 18:19Russell Watkins: Do you like a Zen fable on this podcast?
- 18:21Paul Shrimpling: Oh, I love a Zen fable, russell absolutely.
- 18:24Russell Watkins: It's the.
- 18:25Russell Watkins: It's about the.
- 18:26Russell Watkins: It's the rabbit and the fox one.
- 18:28Russell Watkins: So a Zen master is out walking with his student and the student observes a fox chasing a rabbit.
- 18:35Russell Watkins: And the student says the fox will get that rabbit and eat him.
- 18:38Russell Watkins: And the master says no, the rabbit will evade him.
- 18:40Russell Watkins: And the student argues well, hang on, the fox is faster, it's cunning, it's a fox, it's faster, it'll find it.
- 18:53Russell Watkins: And the master says the rabbit will.
- 18:54Russell Watkins: It will elude it.
- 18:55Russell Watkins: And that's because the fox is running for his lunch and the rabbit is running for his life.
- 18:57Russell Watkins: When you're running for your life, you tend to post a good time, so we have to create some urgency around this.
- 19:01Russell Watkins: So, as long as to get back to your question, when you are encouraging your purchase order clerk or your billing clerk to um to log data for you to find what bugs them, if you can draw a line from that to and, by the way, that will sort pain for you, but also it'll help us as a business with our number one problem, which is retaining clients because we're giving them late billing information or incorrect billing information.
- 19:27Paul Shrimpling: You have to draw that line so there's you're doing a job of um.
- 19:34Paul Shrimpling: Make the problem clear, transparent, measurable, draw a connection between solving that and making their job easier better day actually feels better and then tackle the one thing or the one or two things with a degree of urgency so that they can see quick progress.
- 19:59Paul Shrimpling: Is that the key here?
- 20:00Russell Watkins: There's a sense of progress.
- 20:02Russell Watkins: Yes, but there's two things there.
- 20:05Russell Watkins: Hang on, I'm just going to write something down.
- 20:07Russell Watkins: There's two things there.
- 20:08Russell Watkins: The one is um, you want to start on small things?
- 20:14Russell Watkins: Uh, so sometimes people aren't used to this and sometimes people don't trust their management team.
- 20:22Russell Watkins: Uh, paul, you'll be, you'll be stunned to hear that sometimes management teams have have initiatives and drop them, and then have another initiative and drop it.
- 20:29Russell Watkins: Yeah, um, it it's everywhere.
- 20:35Russell Watkins: So, uh, you end up with a team of people thinking, look, I could help these, these fools, but, um, why jump on this bus?
- 20:43Russell Watkins: There'll be another one along in in 10 minutes.
- 20:45Russell Watkins: Uh, so, if a bit of a tip, if you have got a team who are initiative fatigued and need some help to get on board, you have to be as honest and say look, I tell you what.
- 20:58Russell Watkins: We'll raise one, then we'll investigate it and we'll close that one.
- 21:02Russell Watkins: And only when we've actually done something about a problem will we ask you to give us another idea, idea.
- 21:08Russell Watkins: So I'm not going to try and persuade you, I'm going to show you that we're serious about this.
- 21:13Russell Watkins: Um, and the other thing is you can, you can do a brainstorm so you can gather the office together and say, right, we got this.
- 21:21Russell Watkins: This kind of problem can we?
- 21:22Russell Watkins: Can?
- 21:23Russell Watkins: We have a number of ideas about what could go wrong and what what's going wrong.
- 21:27Russell Watkins: You could end up with 40, 30 to 40 post-it notes on a flip chart.
- 21:33Russell Watkins: Yeah, you create a problem for yourself there and your problem is where do I start to get some momentum going?
- 21:39Russell Watkins: And that's where something like a a simple four box matrix of short-term low cost, short-term high cost, long-term low cost, long-term high cost and you put them into how long will it take to solve this and is it going to cost us anything?
- 21:55Russell Watkins: So short-term low cost is where you put the quick fixes in, and then long-term high cost is where, um, yes, it's a good idea, it's going to take a while to think about, we need to make some changes to the system and it might even cost a bit.
- 22:10Russell Watkins: You put them in there and then you focus initially on the short-term load cost, just to get some momentum going, to get a bit of momentum.
- 22:20Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, that taps into all the research that we've ever come across in that leading and managing change.
- 22:24Paul Shrimpling: It's when you're kick-starting this or you're fighting that upward battle of initiative overload that you describe well is start with the easy, quick wins before you dive into the costly but important big wins.
- 22:40Paul Shrimpling: It's built some momentum.
- 22:43Russell Watkins: There is only one caveat there, paul, and that's in a factory.
- 22:47Russell Watkins: The caveat is number one factory rule is safety.
- 22:51Russell Watkins: Everyone goes home with the same fingers and toes they came with in an accountancy practice.
- 22:57Russell Watkins: If you are losing people to mental health issues or you're not retaining your people, you've got a high turnover because they're burning out.
- 23:05Russell Watkins: There's overburden.
- 23:06Russell Watkins: They don't like something about the environment.
- 23:08Russell Watkins: I'm not sure the ease of sorting it comes into it.
- 23:13Russell Watkins: You have to decide how keen you are to keep people in a good condition.
- 23:20Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, that taps into.
- 23:23Paul Shrimpling: We've got a great story of a firm £5 million turnover firm, approximately 65 people, head of department it's a £5 million department.
- 23:36Paul Shrimpling: Head of department decides they've had enough, so they go to the competition.
- 23:39Paul Shrimpling: There's lots of other people within that team wondering whether they should say or not, because they're overworked.
- 23:47Paul Shrimpling: Classic, you know, overworked, underpaid, too much hassle, no sense of progress and there was no way a quick and easy initiative was going to have any impact whatsoever and so they had to resort to OK, core purpose of the business put the team first.
- 24:05Paul Shrimpling: What big thing do we fix?
- 24:07Paul Shrimpling: And that was in that case.
- 24:10Paul Shrimpling: It was lose some of the pain in the neck clients in order to demonstrate to our team that we're serious about their mental health, about their future enjoyment of the role, so that we could get the commitment to the next level of change Gotcha.
- 24:28Russell Watkins: So on their parieto of problemscha.
- 24:29Russell Watkins: So so on their on their parito of problems.
- 24:31Russell Watkins: One was uh, difficult customers are causing a high amount of stress.
- 24:35Russell Watkins: Yeah, it's essentially yeah, and then, and that's that's, that's a, that's a good, strong commitment to get rid of customers.
- 24:42Russell Watkins: I'm assuming they were customers that they ideally they didn't want anyway.
- 24:49Paul Shrimpling: Ideally, you know there's the high risk, low margin, disrespectful.
- 24:53Paul Shrimpling: There's three big boxes to tick aren't there?
- 24:56Paul Shrimpling: And OK, you might look at it and go, oh yeah, but they're contributing to the financial performance of the business, yeah, but if that results in you putting at risk lots of your key people, then that's a risk that you know.
- 25:14Paul Shrimpling: It's that one risk versus the other which you need to make a decision here.
- 25:17Paul Shrimpling: If you think this is real and they did and all credit to them were brave enough to make those, uh, the big, well, several big decisions around exiting the wrong clients, what's fascinating though there rus Russell is within 18 months they've clawed those lost clients back, plus more of better clients, and so a team almost the same size is doing instead of 5 million, is doing 6 million within 18 months, with less stress and a view that the future looks bright, and became arguably the best performing team in that firm.
- 25:53Russell Watkins: So, as well as offloading customers they didn't want, did they also make an effort to be clearer on the kind of work they wanted to take on?
- 26:02Russell Watkins: Correct, absolutely Okay.
- 26:04Russell Watkins: That makes sense, because that's the flip side of that coin, isn't it?
- 26:07Russell Watkins: It's really interesting, though you say about people who are disrespectful and low margin In manufacturing.
- 26:19Russell Watkins: You see a lot of businesses hanging on to a long tail of products they don't want for difficult customers because they say it's contribution.
- 26:28Russell Watkins: It's contributing to our finances fixed cost, variable cost and sometimes we end up fooling ourselves because it introduces noise and destruction to the business.
- 26:40Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, workflow goes out the window.
- 26:42Paul Shrimpling: You're hacking off your team because they just know that they're doing work that they can't buy into, can't be fully engaged, because we're in that engagement space here.
- 26:52Paul Shrimpling: It is a big deal but it takes, like you say, it takes a brave business leader or department leader to go.
- 26:59Paul Shrimpling: All right, we're going to exit 300 grand's worth of clients.
- 27:05Russell Watkins: So the question is how can you encourage accountancy firms to do that before the crisis happens?
- 27:10Russell Watkins: This is always interesting.
- 27:12Russell Watkins: We act in a crisis because we have no choice.
- 27:15Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, so if that, crisis hadn't have happened.
- 27:17Russell Watkins: Can you create that crisis?
- 27:19Russell Watkins: Can you?
- 27:21Russell Watkins: Create the crisis.
- 27:23Russell Watkins: Yes, did you say yeah?
- 27:25Russell Watkins: So this is creating the crisis.
- 27:28Russell Watkins: Jcb, who are local to us in is Daffodil, derbyshire.
- 27:31Russell Watkins: They, they had a let's create a sense of urgency thing, trying to create urgency all the while, toyota have a really interesting approach and that's I'm going to tell you it, and it is.
- 27:43Russell Watkins: It is a delicate line to walk in terms of Stretching your capability without breaking people, and so creating the crisis is, let's say, for a manufacturing company.
- 27:58Russell Watkins: Let's say you have an assembly line that's performing beautifully 20 people on there and it's performing beautifully, no problems and it's getting a bit complacent.
- 28:08Russell Watkins: What Toyota would do is they would take somebody off of that line to surface the problems that are currently being hidden and then solve those problems so that it can run beautifully again with 19.
- 28:20Russell Watkins: So they would stress the process.
- 28:23Russell Watkins: That's one way of doing it, but you have to be a very mature culture to manage that, otherwise you just end up breaking people.
- 28:30Russell Watkins: But you have to be a very mature culture to manage that, otherwise you just end up breaking people.
- 28:35Russell Watkins: The other way they do it is when they set goals for the year.
- 28:37Russell Watkins: They'll set a very vague goal.
- 28:37Russell Watkins: So they set one a few years ago called MR50, maintenance Reduction 50.
- 28:40Russell Watkins: They didn't explain what it was and they said please tell us how you can contribute.
- 28:44Russell Watkins: And some people took it as Maintenance Reduction 50 is we're going to try and hold 50% less spare parts.
- 28:50Russell Watkins: Some said we're going to try and fix stuff 50% faster.
- 28:54Russell Watkins: So they created a.
- 28:57Russell Watkins: This is a something for the head, something for the heartbeat.
- 29:00Russell Watkins: They created a rallying cry and then opened up for people's creativity to fill the gap by creating the crisis On the basis that you're best off.
- 29:13Russell Watkins: You're best off fixing the roof when it's not raining, hmm, in fact, when it's sunny.
- 29:22Paul Shrimpling: Hmm, there's, there's something built into that, though, isn't there?
- 29:25Paul Shrimpling: It's about you've got high expectations of your team's ability to contribute to the fix here.
- 29:31Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, if you haven't got that expectation, are you?
- 29:35Paul Shrimpling: You think, uh, the resolution is all going to sit with the leaders and managers, it's not going to sit with the people on the tools?
- 29:42Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, because I think that's a challenge.
- 29:44Paul Shrimpling: The reason I bring it up I think that's a challenge in accountancy as a profession is that initiative, uh, innovation is a top-down piece mostly not not completely, but you know, I think that dominates.
- 29:58Paul Shrimpling: As opposed to having come from a manufacturing background a long time ago myself, having been into toyota at bernestown, having been into other lean process places the innovation initiatives are coming from the people on the tools.
- 30:15Paul Shrimpling: That's an uncomfortable concept in the world of accountancy.
- 30:20Russell Watkins: Yeah, but maybe, yes, I mean I was, yeah, I'd have to agree.
- 30:26Russell Watkins: Actually, many, many years ago I started my first degrees in finance.
- 30:30Russell Watkins: Unfortunately, so many years ago I was in finance in a function, paul, I think it comes down to the management of it.
- 30:39Russell Watkins: That doesn't happen by magic in Toyota.
- 30:43Russell Watkins: They're not somehow selecting a different breed of person.
- 30:47Russell Watkins: These are all just people who have marital problems, they have elderly relatives, have, uh, alcoholism, they have health issues.
- 30:54Russell Watkins: These are normal people.
- 30:55Russell Watkins: Yeah, the difference is the way we're managing um, and it doesn't have to be hard either.
- 31:00Russell Watkins: I, I was telling somebody, I was telling somebody's story the other day.
- 31:04Russell Watkins: It's to be a little bit generous of spirit here as well, because we we have to hold a mirror up to them and it's not pleasant.
- 31:10Russell Watkins: But also we have to recognize that if you've built a practice from 5 million to 10 to 15 million, you've been so focused on building that practice, winning and keeping clients doing the work that is on oil platforms.
- 31:24Russell Watkins: Yeah, yeah a firefighter, essentially.
- 31:26Russell Watkins: And and I said I said, I said to him you're very tired.
- 31:29Russell Watkins: I said to him you're very tired.
- 31:31Russell Watkins: I have rapport with him.
- 31:32Russell Watkins: You look very tired.
- 31:33Russell Watkins: I'm not surprised You're trying to put fires out all over the show.
- 31:36Russell Watkins: And his answer was well, my team isn't capable.
- 31:39Russell Watkins: I have to manage them hard a micromanager, because my team isn't capable.
- 31:42Russell Watkins: So well, you know, I'm not here to.
- 31:47Russell Watkins: I'm here to both hug you and to encourage you along.
- 31:51Russell Watkins: Some of that is your fault, my friend, and it's your fault because whenever somebody comes to you with a problem, your first question should not be your first response, should not be well, you should do this, because then you're just creating chicks in a nest who are waiting for a worm.
- 32:06Russell Watkins: Your first question should be what do you want to do about it?
- 32:10Russell Watkins: And then shut up and leave it five, 10 seconds, and leave a nice pregnant pause.
- 32:14Russell Watkins: And if they say I don't know, then you say okay, give me three options and then I'll advise you on what I think is best.
- 32:22Russell Watkins: And it will be painful to begin with, but you start to tease out of them.
- 32:26Russell Watkins: What do you think Now?
- 32:29Russell Watkins: There are multiple benefits for that one is you buy yourself some time.
- 32:32Russell Watkins: It's not so tiring, so if you don't know the answer, you can think of it.
- 32:36Russell Watkins: Second is you get a good sense of where that person's at in their capability.
- 32:40Russell Watkins: And the third is you're going to learn something, sometimes because you're shutting your mouth.
- 32:44Russell Watkins: Those small habits, if coached correctly, they're not difficult to do and you wouldn't do them all day long because sometimes you need to give the answer.
- 32:54Russell Watkins: But it's not hard, it's just a constancy of purpose, giving it a go.
- 33:00Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, brilliant, brilliant.
- 33:02Paul Shrimpling: So that's us discussing the engagement space you were talking about.
- 33:08Paul Shrimpling: You, you know, three critical questions one strategic one, thinking, one engagement.
- 33:14Paul Shrimpling: So we very much um dived into, we've got to build bridges using pre-trial principles and focus around one, three, ten and so on um so that, uh, you align whoever's in production, purchase orders, goods in, uh, you know, the, the juniors on the accounts job or the people who are reviewing the file, are all connected with the big challenge opportunity you're trying to fix strategically.
- 33:43Paul Shrimpling: So I guess the next question is is going to be, because it's connected, you know, from engagement to what's the strategic piece here in and around bringing lean to bear so that we're a better firm of accountants well, I think so we've.
- 33:56Russell Watkins: We've, we've kind of explored that uh a bit as well, and that that that was all around the hoshin camry.
- 34:01Russell Watkins: How do we set the strategic need for the business that high level and link it to the, to the um, all the way through the business throughout um?
- 34:11Russell Watkins: There's a.
- 34:12Russell Watkins: I have one point to say on strategy.
- 34:15Russell Watkins: Um, so I I work from boardroom to shop floor.
- 34:18Russell Watkins: I gotta say I enjoy.
- 34:20Russell Watkins: I enjoy all of them.
- 34:23Russell Watkins: My favorite times are when I can get the leadership onto the shop floor listening to and talking to their people and understanding what's actually going on, the magic to do.
- 34:38Russell Watkins: You know, there's a fellow called Fujio Cho who said six words that I will never be smart enough.
- 34:43Russell Watkins: To sum up, I can live a thousand lifetimes, paul, I'll never be this smart.
- 34:49Russell Watkins: He was summarising how he wanted people to behave in their business and his managers to behave and he said go see, ask why show respect.
- 35:02Russell Watkins: Go see, ask why show respect, show respect.
- 35:09Russell Watkins: So go see means don't assume what you're told.
- 35:12Russell Watkins: Don't just look at your numbers.
- 35:13Russell Watkins: Go and look at what's actually happening and go and talk to the people who are doing the work, and that can be an office or a shop floor.
- 35:19Russell Watkins: It could be anywhere.
- 35:20Russell Watkins: That's go see, ask.
- 35:21Russell Watkins: Why is not ask who made this error it is, why do we think this happened in the first place?
- 35:27Russell Watkins: Or why is this such a difficult thing to do?
- 35:29Russell Watkins: And that takes you towards the problem solving five.
- 35:33Russell Watkins: Why's?
- 35:33Russell Watkins: Getting to the root cause and then show respect is be clear that, um, in a manufacturing plant, the people who truly add value are those who are putting stuff together.
- 35:45Russell Watkins: The rest of us are just here to support that.
- 35:48Russell Watkins: And so, for example, in an it's, it becomes really interesting when you, when you talk about an accountancy or a or a firm of lawyers, because nothing is made except the definition of value is is very clear for me.
- 36:02Russell Watkins: So, in a manufacturing plant, the definition of value is something that transforms the product towards what the customer wants physical transformation.
- 36:12Russell Watkins: In an accountancy firm or this engineering services firm, I define it as you are anytime you pass on usable information.
- 36:21Russell Watkins: Usable information for the next step in our process that delivers something for the customer, because accountants and, uh, all other financial services, for example, they are full of unclear processes with necessary unnecessary steps and multiple rework loops, the kind of things I was talking about earlier.
- 36:43Russell Watkins: Sorry, paul, I answered a different question and I'm I have a habit of answering a question.
- 36:48Russell Watkins: Don't worry about it, it's because we're in that.
- 36:53Paul Shrimpling: I think you've dropped into a really powerful space actually, because you know team engagement and strategic connection and you've gone to like go see us.
- 37:05Paul Shrimpling: Why show respect as the methodology for resolving the thing that's holding your firm back from achieving what you want to achieve.
- 37:17Paul Shrimpling: And, by the way, what you want is to deliver better for your clients, because only if you've got client loyalty will you improve the results of your firm, and I think that that's often not connected up in most firms.
- 37:30Paul Shrimpling: So if you go to, whether it's a three-person team, a 30-person team, a 300 person team or a 30,000 person team of accountants, have they really got the bridge crystal clear in their minds and their hearts around?
- 37:47Paul Shrimpling: We're here to serve the client, the customer key point.
- 37:51Paul Shrimpling: How do we deliver value to the client?
- 37:55Paul Shrimpling: And what you're saying is we're doing our job if we give them usable information.
- 38:00Paul Shrimpling: Now I might challenge that in a little while, because usable information.
- 38:06Russell Watkins: I'm talking internally.
- 38:07Russell Watkins: We are passing on from stage to stage usable knowledge that can create what the customer needs.
- 38:12Russell Watkins: Brilliant, ok, but but.
- 38:16Russell Watkins: But.
- 38:16Russell Watkins: But, paul, I 100 percent agree.
- 38:18Russell Watkins: Funny enough, I I train a lot of team leaders and supervisors and engineers and I've done a training program for a couple of billion pound business.
- 38:28Russell Watkins: In fact they're about a 40 billion group.
- 38:32Russell Watkins: This is about two billion um.
- 38:35Russell Watkins: And the very first part of the course is do you know who?
- 38:39Russell Watkins: Do you know who your customer is?
- 38:41Russell Watkins: Let's connect you to your customer.
- 38:42Russell Watkins: We have to take you and cast you forward into your customer's life so that you can understand what matters to them and what you do can cause them pain.
- 38:51Russell Watkins: Because if your customer's crying, you want to know about it.
- 38:54Russell Watkins: And so, for example, in in an automotive company, we ask them uh, who do you think your customer is and how come what you do affect their drive in their car?
- 39:03Russell Watkins: And what's the impact of you passing on or creating a defect?
- 39:08Russell Watkins: So let's say you have a specific defect of a hole in this or a defect.
- 39:10Russell Watkins: So let's say you have a specific defect of a hole in this or a gap on that.
- 39:12Russell Watkins: How's that going to affect your customer?
- 39:14Russell Watkins: Because you're trying to connect them to the end customer pain.
- 39:19Russell Watkins: That's step one.
- 39:20Russell Watkins: Step two is starting to understand, and this is what the totals of the world get right, it's a series of customers and suppliers.
- 39:28Russell Watkins: So if you that, that company I'm working with, purchasing and finance.
- 39:33Russell Watkins: Finance, excuse me, is a customer of purchasing.
- 39:38Russell Watkins: They purchasing past paperwork to them all the while and emails.
- 39:43Russell Watkins: Purchasing is a customer of finances, information and feedback.
- 39:49Russell Watkins: So it's that customer supplier thinking way.
- 39:50Russell Watkins: The next stage is a customer of finances, information and feedback.
- 39:51Russell Watkins: So it's that customer-supplier thinking way.
- 39:52Russell Watkins: The next stage is my customer.
- 39:53Russell Watkins: I'm with you is what I'm saying in a long-handed way.
- 39:59Paul Shrimpling: So I just want to extend that further for Ken and go let's go to the end of the chain, the end of the journey.
- 40:04Paul Shrimpling: And so, whether it be a car buyer, it's their experience of living with that car for the next two years or whatever.
- 40:11Paul Shrimpling: There's all sorts of detailed description about their appreciation of the value of that driving experience From an accountancy perspective is they've got their tax return, they've got their annual accounts, they've got their management accounts, the payroll has been delivered every month.
- 40:32Paul Shrimpling: They're the outcomes of the services.
- 40:35Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, does everyone in the team appreciate the value of that to the client and the pain that they may cause if they don't get it delivered in the right way?
- 40:48Russell Watkins: Yes, the very specific pain that they might cause by not doing their bit thoroughly and on time, and it's yeah but, but, uh, but also you can.
- 41:00Russell Watkins: You can put up, you can put a positive slant on that, as in, you are critical here.
- 41:03Russell Watkins: You know this, this step in.
- 41:05Russell Watkins: It might appear tiny to you, but it is a critical part in the chain and a cog in the engine kind of a way.
- 41:10Russell Watkins: But it takes us to a broader point, paul, which is whatever your business is, how are you harnessing the voice of the customer?
- 41:17Russell Watkins: And the voice of the customer is really important, so I wouldn't.
- 41:24Russell Watkins: Somebody is hopefully somebody is asking the customers somehow that works for them.
- 41:31Russell Watkins: How is it going?
- 41:32Russell Watkins: Are we giving you what you want Beyond just questionnaires?
- 41:37Russell Watkins: Whoever that person is, they have to work for somebody who hasn't got skin in the game.
- 41:42Russell Watkins: They have to work and directly report into the MD or the person running the business, so that there isn't a functional neutering of the message or a massaging of the message.
- 41:54Russell Watkins: What's the problem there that you're referencing?
- 41:57Paul Shrimpling: Russell.
- 41:58Russell Watkins: So the problem is right.
- 42:00Russell Watkins: I'll give you a manufacturing example.
- 42:02Russell Watkins: If you buy anything, if you buy a washing machine, and you have a problem with warranty, that warranty, the washing machine seal leaks.
- 42:11Russell Watkins: You'll, you'll, you'll, you'll shout at Curry's or Amazon and they will then contact the company and they'll get in touch with the quality department.
- 42:19Russell Watkins: Yeah, quality might pass on to operations, but there is a chance that quality will solve it.
- 42:27Russell Watkins: There is a chance that quality will solve it.
- 42:30Russell Watkins: There is also a chance that it will get lost in quality's massaging of the information so that they don't get a shooing or a bollocking off of the MD.
- 42:38Russell Watkins: So, whatever the voice of the customer is, however you harness it, it has to go unfiltered, raw into the person running the business in a time efficient way so that they can see without filter what our customers think of us that's interesting.
- 43:00Paul Shrimpling: There was a, an md I work with I'm going back over a decade now and nigel, when he stepped in as managing partner, managing director, he said wherever there's a customer complaint, I want it in my inbox.
- 43:13Paul Shrimpling: Boom, I don't care what complaint it is, I want it in my inbox.
- 43:18Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and I will credit the people who put those complaints in my inbox.
- 43:24Paul Shrimpling: They will be recognised as doing something really good for this business.
- 43:29Paul Shrimpling: It is safe to send me the complaints.
- 43:33Paul Shrimpling: And what's really interesting is, over time, nigel took that firm to one where the people costs as a percentage of fees was down towards 26%.
- 43:43Paul Shrimpling: Now that's a very strong number in the world of accountancy.
- 43:47Paul Shrimpling: I was with the firm yesterday and they they had, um, uh, people costs, salaries, national insurance, training costs, outsourcing, pensions and so on.
- 43:58Paul Shrimpling: The people costs at 48 percent of the total fees of the business.
- 44:03Paul Shrimpling: So contrast that with 26.
- 44:05Paul Shrimpling: You can get a sense as to how nigel was doing something really well.
- 44:10Paul Shrimpling: And one of his fundamental pieces was we've got to always be connected with what really really matters to the client, the customer.
- 44:19Paul Shrimpling: We've got to be really connected to the numbers that really matter every day and every week in the business.
- 44:24Paul Shrimpling: I would argue very strongly that they were Nigel's two really powerful approaches as managing director, and he transformed that business.
- 44:33Russell Watkins: It sounds like a smart approach and it circles back to our earlier conversation about how do you engage people.
- 44:38Russell Watkins: But there is a mindset shift here that it takes a bit of strong leadership for, and that's that problems are treasure.
- 44:45Russell Watkins: The mindset shift is problems are treasure and what I mean by that is, um, accountants will be will be acutely aware that they have to keep becoming competitive to keep hold of their, their client base.
- 45:01Russell Watkins: Uh, there's nothing I can.
- 45:02Russell Watkins: I can tell you about the existential threat of ai and uh and and other means of doing the lowlevel accountancy stuff that they need to move up the food chain.
- 45:12Russell Watkins: But you can either hope that you find a silver bullet to improve your business or you can create a culture where people will be honest about the customer issues and you've got a voice of the customer coming through.
- 45:26Russell Watkins: But people will also surface problems.
- 45:28Russell Watkins: They'll tell you about their problems coming through.
- 45:30Russell Watkins: But people will also surface problems.
- 45:31Russell Watkins: They'll tell you about their problems.
- 45:32Russell Watkins: Then you have a whole pot of potential improvements you can make to improve your business.
- 45:36Russell Watkins: They're giving you the way to improve the business, to make you more competitive, to make things quicker, to reduce that labor time.
- 45:43Russell Watkins: You're talking about the uh human time and to get things done right first time brilliant and I think aren in this change the thinking space.
- 45:53Paul Shrimpling: You teed up those three critical questions you know, in the strategic space, the thinking space and the engagement space.
- 45:59Paul Shrimpling: Isn't this one of those thinking pieces?
- 46:02Paul Shrimpling: You know, a problem isn't a problem, it's a treasure.
- 46:05Russell Watkins: Yeah it is, it is and the other part of that.
- 46:11Russell Watkins: Coming back to humanize the numbers and where you started from, um, I think there needs to be a thinking switch and that's listen, these are.
- 46:20Russell Watkins: These are all in and of themselves.
- 46:24Russell Watkins: None of these are simple, but in the hurly-burly of running a business, it's hard to do all this stuff in it.
- 46:28Russell Watkins: So you have to, you have to, you have to pick your approach and stick with it for a few months and see if it works.
- 46:34Russell Watkins: It's all just running a series of sensible experiments and learning from them.
- 46:37Russell Watkins: And as long as you're running experiments that are useful, you can mitigate the risk and you give it a few months.
- 46:44Russell Watkins: If it doesn't work, just run a different experiment.
- 46:47Russell Watkins: And I guarantee you, if you do that, for three years you've run eight or nine experiments and somebody else has run none.
- 46:58Russell Watkins: And of those eight or nine, one or two might work.
- 46:59Russell Watkins: Well, that's one or two more than everybody else.
- 47:00Russell Watkins: But the thinking way, this other thinking way I, we want people to think like a founder.
- 47:05Russell Watkins: I was listening a while ago to charlie munger and warren buffett um, and the ideal world is you get everybody in the business thinking like they own the business.
- 47:17Russell Watkins: So it's a shift from return and investment thinking to return on assets and it's a problem in manufacturing.
- 47:22Russell Watkins: Any professional manager not any most professional managers in manufacturing they are well versed in return and investment.
- 47:29Russell Watkins: How do I put a compelling case together to buy something new and shiny?
- 47:33Russell Watkins: Yeah, and they're pretty good at that.
- 47:36Russell Watkins: Working out net present values, discounted cash flows um, we don't want that.
- 47:41Russell Watkins: That's a professional manager mindset.
- 47:43Russell Watkins: We, we want a return on assets mindset first, which is look, I've already sunk x thousands and millions into this business.
- 47:50Russell Watkins: Please convince me that the assets I have you are getting the best out of them.
- 47:58Russell Watkins: So where are the losses?
- 47:59Russell Watkins: Where am I getting downtime?
- 48:00Russell Watkins: Where am I getting problems and defects?
- 48:01Russell Watkins: Where is it difficult?
- 48:02Russell Watkins: And let's optimise what we've got and only then will we spend money Return on asset thinking rather than return on investment does that?
- 48:11Paul Shrimpling: just flipping it into the accountancy space?
- 48:13Paul Shrimpling: Does that, um, is it worth it?
- 48:16Paul Shrimpling: Because there's not many assets in an accounting practice, there's lots of people, because that's the number one excuse the language the number one cost, the number one charge to the business.
- 48:27Paul Shrimpling: The number one investment is in salaries and training and development.
- 48:32Paul Shrimpling: Albeit, there's a question mark where there's enough time, effort and money spent on training and development, but let's just go.
- 48:39Paul Shrimpling: Is it a return on assets or is it return on the people, capital, you know, the intellect, the number of people?
- 48:47Paul Shrimpling: Is that the sort of shift from manufacturing into the professional service space?
- 48:53Russell Watkins: uh, I that that wasn't where I was thinking, but it can be, I've got, I've got no issue, that that makes sense as well.
- 48:58Russell Watkins: I was thinking, um, I buy, there isn't much kit, but there are some large non-people outlays that go on.
- 49:06Russell Watkins: In accountancy firms, for example, there's probably a not a, not insignificantly costed, uh, mis information system, saying you've got all kinds of packages and software, yeah, uh, where somebody somewhere is, and, and, by the way, all sorts of legacy systems that are joined up by excel, because excel runs the world, um, and are trying to link everything together, as well as some infrastructure issues.
- 49:31Russell Watkins: How much office space have we got?
- 49:32Russell Watkins: How are we making the most out of our investment in our operating expenses?
- 49:40Russell Watkins: So I would encourage people to think along information systems first off.
- 49:47Russell Watkins: Are we getting the best we can out of what we've got?
- 49:50Russell Watkins: And, by the way, this is where where low code, no code, is very useful.
- 49:58Paul Shrimpling: I've gone right off beam now, but low code.
- 50:00Paul Shrimpling: No code is.
- 50:00Paul Shrimpling: So what's that low code?
- 50:01Paul Shrimpling: What we're doing?
- 50:02Russell Watkins: what's this about?
- 50:02Russell Watkins: Uh, so you know, you know in ah a question first.
- 50:07Russell Watkins: Do you see and have you seen in many accountancy practices they have multiple systems, legacy systems, that are joined up.
- 50:16Russell Watkins: There's problems with some of them and people use Excel to bridge them and run parts of the business.
- 50:22Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and they might tap into Power BI as a way of smoothing the flow of that.
- 50:28Russell Watkins: But yes, yeah, so low-code, no-code, is an approach whereby there are intuitive front ends like Yellowfin, Power BI, and you can it's APIs effectively.
- 50:41Russell Watkins: So I think we're talking the same stuff.
- 50:43Russell Watkins: You can link legacy systems and make intuitive interrogations.
- 50:48Russell Watkins: To be clear, that is containment.
- 50:52Russell Watkins: So I'm pretty certain that accountants they need their information systems to work well To use things like Power BI and APIs.
- 51:03Russell Watkins: That is a containment.
- 51:04Russell Watkins: So you are finding a way around your current information system IT carnage around your current information system it carnage.
- 51:16Russell Watkins: The question is, the question is what?
- 51:17Russell Watkins: What are you doing longer term to position yourself with a, with a better system that doesn't need that front end to sort it all out?
- 51:21Russell Watkins: I?
- 51:24Paul Shrimpling: love that.
- 51:24Paul Shrimpling: It carnage which, just on the back of a meeting yesterday with a two-office firm where they're doing everything they can to help with their team to overcome that inverted commas IT carnage.
- 51:40Paul Shrimpling: The house that Jack built, approach to management information within the firm and also in terms of what they're delivering for the client on a consistent basis as well terms of what they're delivering for the client on a consistent basis as well.
- 51:56Russell Watkins: But I think, paul, we have to be a little bit generous of spirit here as well, because we have to hold a mirror up to them and it's not pleasant.
- 51:59Russell Watkins: But also we have to recognise that if you've built a practice from 5 million to 10 to 15 million, you've been so focused on building that practice, winning and keeping clients doing the work that the chances of your IT system not having evolved to keep up is slim.
- 52:16Russell Watkins: So it's not surprising that the sin isn't that systems evolve.
- 52:23Russell Watkins: The sin is that at a point when you can take a breath and do something differently, you walk past the opportunity.
- 52:30Russell Watkins: That's the sin.
- 52:34Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I remember going to.
- 52:34Paul Shrimpling: I visited.
- 52:36Paul Shrimpling: You might be familiar with ProDrive on the M40.
- 52:39Paul Shrimpling: If you drive up the M40, you can't avoid the ProDrive site.
- 52:42Paul Shrimpling: And it was when they were working with Subaru in the World Rally Cross Championships and they also had the top three cars in the saloon champs across the UK as well Really successful.
- 52:59Paul Shrimpling: And the day we were in there they just sold 49% of the stock for 75 million or whatever.
- 53:07Paul Shrimpling: I can't remember the numbers specifically, but the founder was a very happy bunny, still pickled from the night before when he came in and introduced himself.
- 53:15Paul Shrimpling: Understandably so, you know, understandably so.
- 53:18Paul Shrimpling: But the the most fascinating part of that visit was talking to the uh, the, the head of.
- 53:25Paul Shrimpling: He wasn't the uh ops director, uh, he reported to the ops director.
- 53:29Paul Shrimpling: He reported to the ops director but he was in charge of systems development and he said what's happened at ProDrive three times now and we're just about to go into a fourth is we grow rapidly for 18 months and then we have a six-month moratorium on winning new work and in that six-month moratoriumatorium we then look to all of the key systems and make them fit for the next stage of growth.
- 53:57Paul Shrimpling: So very much a preventative approach to it all breaking down and using.
- 54:02Paul Shrimpling: You know we talked earlier, didn't?
- 54:03Paul Shrimpling: We say let's not wait till it's too risk.
- 54:06Paul Shrimpling: The risk's so high on losing customers that we change it.
- 54:09Paul Shrimpling: We actually go.
- 54:10Paul Shrimpling: No, hang on a second, let's just take a little time out six months and then around the key logistics systems, because the you've got to ship engine parts all over the world to the different rallies and different races and so on.
- 54:23Paul Shrimpling: Uh, they, they had a deep dive.
- 54:26Paul Shrimpling: Look at all the key handful of key systems that would determine whether they can go from let's just choose a number 75 million in turnover to 150 million turnover.
- 54:37Paul Shrimpling: Right, we've got to make these systems fit for purpose, invest some of the hard earned cash we've generated over the recent growth period.
- 54:45Paul Shrimpling: And I just thought that was a.
- 54:46Paul Shrimpling: Because we work with accountants, they go, yeah.
- 54:49Paul Shrimpling: You just can't stop growth.
- 54:50Paul Shrimpling: I said, well, thought that was a um, because we work with accountants, they go, yeah you just can't stop growth and say well, yes, you can, yeah, yeah, you can just say we're not taking new clients for a little while builds huge credibility in your marketplace because we want to make sure they were looking after our existing clients.
- 55:00Paul Shrimpling: And, by the way, we're in a systems improvement so that we can be better, better placed to work with you in the future paul.
- 55:07Russell Watkins: That's, that's a fabulously enlightened mindset.
- 55:10Russell Watkins: That that is a tremendous example, um, but it takes us back to humanize the numbers and it takes us back to lead a mindset.
- 55:17Russell Watkins: So, um, I've got a good friend who's who's run many manufacturing businesses, um, and he was from, uh, northern scotland.
- 55:27Russell Watkins: He had a very, very poor upbringing, always struggled for what he had, yeah, so he had.
- 55:35Russell Watkins: Naturally, he's hardwired for a scarcity mindset, as in, I never want to go back to being hungry.
- 55:42Russell Watkins: Now, if your leader has been driven from a place where they had a scarcity mindset, from a place where they had a scarcity mindset, to ask them to pause or to expect them to pause, there is some, some reframing, some psychological work to do to make that pause palatable and to have a good reason for it, because, um, uh, there there are these things.
- 56:05Russell Watkins: So, and where someone like you can can have value, I suspect, is to challenge the right person one-to-one in a rapport way and say hang on, this is where this is coming from.
- 56:17Paul Shrimpling: So it's really interesting yeah, I've been revisiting an old mentor of mine and a couple of conversations with him recently, peter thompson, and he has a phrase which goes something like people won't consistently do who they aren't.
- 56:30Paul Shrimpling: So if they're coming from a you know that scarcity mindset, they're going to behave like they're coming from, because that their identity are connected with themselves, is in that space.
- 56:42Paul Shrimpling: That's who they are.
- 56:43Paul Shrimpling: Therefore, they know they're going to behave like that or even unconsciously will behave like that, without even knowing.
- 56:49Paul Shrimpling: And unless that's challenged and they can work on just to use your reference point, which I think is very powerful both their heart and their mind to see themselves in a different space, then they'll behave just like they've always behaved and the human brain's set up to be habitual and do what we've always done, unless there's something significant, an event or conversation challenges the way they look at things strategically, the way they think and the way they engage with their team just to use your big three points of this podcast and the way they feel.
- 57:25Paul Shrimpling: Absolutely Well, you've just tapped into a whole raft.
- 57:28Paul Shrimpling: I always think.
- 57:29Paul Shrimpling: Ultimately, ultimately, what's going on in this is, uh, all of your uh key questions and key comments in this podcast which I'm going to have to revisit and pull out and highlight.
- 57:40Paul Shrimpling: For my own learning is connected with changing the conversation between you and a team member so that they're better connected with the value equation for the client and how it makes their job easier.
- 57:52Paul Shrimpling: That's how I'm trying to summarize this conversation, cause if you're in that space, you're moving in absolutely the right direction.
- 57:59Paul Shrimpling: How would you respond?
- 58:00Russell Watkins: Yeah, Uh, I, I a hundred percent agree, and I think you are in a really interesting market because so it is all about people.
- 58:16Russell Watkins: You know, even as I say that I realize how bland it sounds.
- 58:21Russell Watkins: I hope some specifics have come across about how you can actually engage your people, but we've talked about the need to engage people throughout and in the latter part of this conversation we've talked about the leader and the leadership team and their thinking way.
- 58:40Russell Watkins: There's one thing we have to be mindful of, we have to talk about.
- 58:47Russell Watkins: We have to encourage people to talk about how they feel their backgrounds.
- 58:51Russell Watkins: What's stopping, what's the constraint on growth, what's the bottleneck here?
- 58:54Russell Watkins: And quite often it'll be found in the leader's mind, because you find me, somebody who runs a 5, 10, 20, 50, 100, 200 million pound business, who at some point hasn't gone all in and remortgaged their house or something of that ilk, and I'll show you somebody who has some fear about.
- 59:12Russell Watkins: Maybe they have some fear about doing that again or maybe it's liberated them, but we ought to explore that space as well as engaging people in the business.
- 59:25Paul Shrimpling: The journalists have occasionally asked us you know what's holding the profession back from?
- 59:32Paul Shrimpling: You know achieving greater results for the firm?
- 59:36Paul Shrimpling: Sure, I would then push that and go well, they'll only do that and you made this point earlier They'll only do that if they deliver brilliantly for their clients, their customers.
- 59:43Paul Shrimpling: Because only if you deliver brilliantly for the customers do you earn the right to earn great results.
- 59:47Paul Shrimpling: And I think what you've also done today is built a bridge with.
- 59:51Paul Shrimpling: Well, if you want great results, we've got to deliver for the client.
- 59:53Paul Shrimpling: But we can only deliver for the client if we work better with our team.
- 59:56Paul Shrimpling: And we'll only work better with our team if the managers and leaders of the business get into their own heads in terms of how they change, they communicate strategically, think differently and better engage with the team so that they can deliver for the clients.
- 1:00:11Paul Shrimpling: That delivers the results for the film, I mean, it's a simple chain of the connection, isn't it?
- 1:00:16Russell Watkins: nice summary.
- 1:00:17Russell Watkins: Yeah, you know.
- 1:00:18Russell Watkins: Do you know?
- 1:00:19Russell Watkins: Do you know I've been, uh, I was speaking at a conference this week and, um, I told the story about.
- 1:00:27Russell Watkins: For the last 20 years, I've written down regularly my definition of lean, my definition of lean, and it's changed over the last 20 years.
- 1:00:35Russell Watkins: In fact, I'm up to definition 22 now and it's gone from very basic to very complex to, I think, wildly off the beam.
- 1:00:45Russell Watkins: My current definition of lean, 30 years deep into this, is's very simple now and it's all we're trying to do is create useful habits.
- 1:00:54Russell Watkins: Um, uh, I don't think it's complete.
- 1:01:01Russell Watkins: It's missing some, some stuff.
- 1:01:03Russell Watkins: You know, I can talk about alignment to customer, I can talk about all sorts, and I can go and, and and and, but I'm trying to, given the complexities of cruise day, I'm trying to distill in my mind what have I learned, and I raise that because there's a risk here of there are a million podcasts out there and every day podcasts are added to that great big podcast bin and I would suggest that anybody should just take something that resonates and maybe feels a bit uncomfortable, that is small and doable, and try it for a bit.
- 1:01:36Russell Watkins: Don't try and do everything you hear on every podcast, because it's just not doable into how you take lean thinking, lean strategic insight, lean team engagement into your firm.
- 1:01:56Paul Shrimpling: why not check out the business breakthrough that you'll find in the show notes unpacking how you can make lean-made, simple work in your firm?
- 1:02:04Paul Shrimpling: Try and create a different habit.
- 1:02:08Paul Shrimpling: Yeah Well, like Yoda would say, there's no trial, there's only do or do not, isn't there so?
- 1:02:14Paul Shrimpling: which is a bit glib it's a bit glib, but it's not glib, it is not glib.
- 1:02:17Paul Shrimpling: No, no, it's right.
- 1:02:18Paul Shrimpling: It's right and your point earlier in this discussion was you know, pick something up and run with it for a few months, because installing a new habit doesn't happen on, because you do something once.
- 1:02:29Paul Shrimpling: It happens because of repetition.
- 1:02:30Paul Shrimpling: So multiple days, multiple weeks, a few months gives your chance, yourself a chance, your team a chance to hardwire that new habit that then looks after the future success of your business.
- 1:02:44Paul Shrimpling: Because you've looked after the value of you, of your clients quite right, and it's it is.
- 1:02:50Russell Watkins: It is just about constancy of purpose, and that habit can be as simple as going to a different person once a week in your practice and saying how do you do that and do you have any problems, and that can be a five minute conversation once a week.
- 1:03:03Russell Watkins: From there, the correct habit will reveal itself.
- 1:03:06Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah um, russell, I could.
- 1:03:09Paul Shrimpling: I could talk to you for another hour or two or three or a week on all sorts of things I'd like to unpack, so maybe we'll have to revisit this conversation another time.
- 1:03:17Paul Shrimpling: My last question, russell, of everything we've covered in this discussion if you were to pick on one thing to leave with the people who've taken time out to listen to this podcast, one thing that you'd want them to pick up and run with and do something with, what would it be?
- 1:03:42Russell Watkins: Get an understanding of where you're hurting your customers specifically and where, also, that makes life difficult for your people.
- 1:03:49Paul Shrimpling: Because you can't fail If you your people, because you can't fail If you can find that you can't fail, and I love that because you've connected with the two most important people in all of our lives as business owners, leaders, managers which is our team and our clients, and what we're looking to do, our job as leaders and managers, is to help prevent or resolve those challenges and we'll end up with a better business and a better life as a consequence.
- 1:04:09Paul Shrimpling: Love that, yeah.
- 1:04:10Paul Shrimpling: Love that, yeah.
- 1:04:10Paul Shrimpling: Love that, russell.
- 1:04:11Paul Shrimpling: It's been a joy.
- 1:04:12Paul Shrimpling: I can't believe we've been on in a discussion for the best part well, just over 60 minutes.
- 1:04:16Paul Shrimpling: It's just flown by.
- 1:04:17Paul Shrimpling: Um.
- 1:04:18Paul Shrimpling: Really appreciate you taking time out and sharing some really powerful insights.
- 1:04:23Paul Shrimpling: Uh, some of the questions you've posed, I think, are profound and I'll be looking to flag those up in the in the show notes and we'll get you know how people can hook up with you and connect with you on LinkedIn and what have you in the show notes as well.
- 1:04:36Paul Shrimpling: Great, can't thank you enough.
- 1:04:37Paul Shrimpling: Thank you, my pleasure.
- 1:04:40Paul Shrimpling: Thanks, paul.
- 1:04:40Paul Shrimpling: Isn't it funny how often, when you think you finished a conversation, another gem or two shows up.
- 1:04:47Paul Shrimpling: Thankfully, our sound engineer, joe, kept the recording running following the podcast and here's a couple of extra gems which only takes a minute or so for you to grasp.
- 1:04:58Paul Shrimpling: I think Russell makes a couple of really powerful points here, russell.
- 1:05:02Paul Shrimpling: The potential in every firm we work with is off the charts.
- 1:05:07Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, helping them tap into that potential is, um, what we do, and it's really hard and, um, you know, we're talking to them about strategy, we're talking to them about how they think differently and we're talking to them about how they better engage with the team.
- 1:05:22Paul Shrimpling: So you've just essentially given us a shot in the arm in terms of all.
- 1:05:27Paul Shrimpling: Right, we're on the right bloody path if we're connecting with the sense and history of the Toyota production system and everyone else who's picked up and run with that piece of genius that it is.
- 1:05:38Russell Watkins: Great, great.
- 1:05:38Russell Watkins: And there's something you know, there is something in the room that's there's an elephant in this room.
- 1:05:46Russell Watkins: A lot of it comes down to what does the person who's in charge want?
- 1:05:50Russell Watkins: So for me.
- 1:05:53Russell Watkins: So for me, that's uh.
- 1:05:55Russell Watkins: Whenever, whenever I'm contacted by, by a manufacturing business who want to talk, my initial qualification, informal qualification, is uh, if you wanted to talk to me because you want to do lean, that's not a strong enough reason.
- 1:06:08Russell Watkins: Tell me about some specific pain or gain and what do you want from this?
- 1:06:10Russell Watkins: Tell me what you want.
- 1:06:10Russell Watkins: And if, if that's not a strong enough reason, tell me about some specific pain or gain and what do you want from this?
- 1:06:12Russell Watkins: Tell me what you want.
- 1:06:12Russell Watkins: And if what they want is tepid, it's hard to make it work Because at some point somebody has to stand up and make this happen when you're not on site.
- 1:06:27Paul Shrimpling: You're absolutely bob on, which is why, for us, we talk about helping ambitious accountants humanise the numbers.
- 1:06:34Paul Shrimpling: Yes, because if people aren't ambitious enough for their clients, ambitious enough for their team, ambitious enough for their firm and themselves.
- 1:06:43Paul Shrimpling: They won't deal with the pain.
- 1:06:46Paul Shrimpling: They won't do enough consistently enough, habitually, around what really matters in order to move the pain.
- 1:06:49Paul Shrimpling: They won't do enough consistently enough, habitually around what really matters in order to move the dial.
- 1:06:55Russell Watkins: Yeah, yeah, it's interesting.
- 1:06:57Russell Watkins: That makes perfect sense.
- 1:06:58Russell Watkins: So you're essentially pre-qualifying in your tagline in the way you market your business.
- 1:07:04Russell Watkins: A final point on that so you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.
- 1:07:10Russell Watkins: That means that we think quite binary in this way.
- 1:07:14Russell Watkins: Either they're up for it or they're not.
- 1:07:16Russell Watkins: Somebody told me a while ago that that saying is missing a bit on the end.
- 1:07:20Russell Watkins: You can lead a horse to water, you can't make him drink, but you can make them thirsty on the way.
- 1:07:24Russell Watkins: Yeah, I love that.
- 1:07:27Paul Shrimpling: Well, how is he can if you put some salt in the oats there?
- 1:07:30Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I love that Well hour as you can.
- 1:07:31Paul Shrimpling: If you put some salt in the oats there, you go, which is so that means.
- 1:07:34Paul Shrimpling: Your job and my job isn't it?
- 1:07:37Russell Watkins: Yeah, well, still to this day, we end up working with people where I'm thinking I'm not sure about this, and sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't.
- 1:07:45Russell Watkins: But I prefer that to being too binary and writing off people who shouldn't be written off.
- 1:07:56Paul Shrimpling: And you know what I'm.
- 1:07:57Paul Shrimpling: I'm 100 with you on that because there's the well, this looks hard, this one.
- 1:07:59Paul Shrimpling: But you know what I'm going to do it?
- 1:08:00Paul Shrimpling: Because I'm going to learn shed loads here.
- 1:08:01Paul Shrimpling: I'm going to learn shed loads on how to better work with.
- 1:08:05Paul Shrimpling: You know, the firms are people that aren't easy.
- 1:08:08Paul Shrimpling: They're hard.
- 1:08:10Russell Watkins: Yeah, yeah, fair play Well, Paul.
- 1:08:14Russell Watkins: I also enjoyed that.
- 1:08:15Russell Watkins: It was fun.
- 1:08:21Paul Shrimpling: Yeah good.
- 1:08:22Paul Shrimpling: In the discussion with Russell, he unpacked a whole variety of different ways to change the conversation between you and your team, connecting everyone better to the way you deliver value for the clients, which, ultimately, is what the Accountants Growth Academy is all about.
- 1:08:42Paul Shrimpling: We want you to improve your fees per full-time employee in your firm, and you can only do that when you work better with your team and better with your clients.
- 1:08:50Paul Shrimpling: If you want to find out more about the accountants growth academy, check out the link in the show notes.
- 1:08:56Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms.
- 1:09:01Paul Shrimpling: At humanizethenumbersonline, you can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 1:09:20Speaker 3: You're about to hear a short excerpt of a conversation with Sherlyn Cowles, the Chief Business Development Officer at Gooding Co.
- 1:09:23Speaker 3: If you want to hear more, go to humanizethenumbersonline or wherever you get your podcasts from.
- 1:09:30Speaker 4: Yeah, so we set up a training academy.
- 1:09:32Speaker 4: Basically one day a week every week, all the new trainees come in and the people who are doing the AAT and Sam.
- 1:09:40Speaker 4: He trains them all up.
- 1:09:41Speaker 4: They go away, do their exams at the local centre, which is actually Local Twisters in Bristol, and they've all passed their exams so much quicker than if they were at the local college.
- 1:09:53Speaker 4: They're progressing so quickly.
- 1:09:55Speaker 4: They're all getting really high pass rates, as well as being trained by one of our guys.
- 1:10:02Speaker 4: It's all there.
- 1:10:04Speaker 4: If they've got any queries, he's there on hand to ask all the time.
- 1:10:08Speaker 4: So it's worked really well.
- 1:10:10Speaker 4: So the idea is that we could maybe roll that out further in the future.