Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / 2025-2026 SCOTUS Preview: Erwin Chemerinsky and Kimberly Atkins Stohr
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the 2025 -2026 SCOTUS Preview with
- 0:10Dean Erwin Chemerinsky and Kimberly Eckenstor.
- 0:14I'm Rachel Cogan. the chair of BHBA's litigation
- 0:18section. And I would like to start off by thanking
- 0:21the National Association of Women Lawyers for
- 0:24co -sponsoring today's program. NAWL's mission
- 0:28is to provide leadership, a collective voice,
- 0:31and essential resources to advance women in the
- 0:33legal profession and advocate for the equality
- 0:36of women under the law. BHBA and NAWL have many
- 0:41members in common, and we look forward to continuing
- 0:44to partner. Now, I am very delighted to introduce
- 0:48our speakers, Dean Erwin Chemerinsky and Kimberly
- 0:51Atkins -Storr. Both really need no introduction.
- 0:55I know you want to get right to their discussion
- 0:57of the Supreme Court term, so I will keep their
- 1:00bios brief, especially knowing all of their comprehensive
- 1:03information is in your materials. Dean Erwin
- 1:07Chemerinsky is the Jesse H. Chopper Distinguished
- 1:10Professor of Law and Dean at Berkeley Law, and
- 1:14was previously Dean at UC Irvine School of Law.
- 1:17He's one of the country's most respected constitutional
- 1:20law scholars, advocates, and speakers, the author
- 1:23of 19 books, and hundreds of law review articles.
- 1:28Kimberly Atkins -Storr is a senior opinion writer
- 1:31and columnist at the Boston Globe. She is an
- 1:35on -air political analyst for MSNBC, a frequent
- 1:39panelist on NBC's Meet the Press, and co -host
- 1:42of the popular Politicon legal news podcast Sisters
- 1:47in Law. Before launching her journalism career,
- 1:50she was a civil trial and appellate attorney
- 1:52in Boston. Erwin and Kimberly, over to you to
- 1:56tell us about what we should expect from this
- 1:58October term of the US Supreme Court. Thank you
- 2:01so much. Rachel, thank you so much for the kind
- 2:05introduction. It's really an honor and pleasure
- 2:07to do the program again. And it's terrific to
- 2:10get to do this with Kim. What we're going to
- 2:12do is each offer some overview thoughts about
- 2:15the Supreme Court, where it is now and where
- 2:18it's likely to go. And then we're going to take
- 2:20up several topics. We'll talk about elections
- 2:23in the political process. We'll talk about tariffs.
- 2:27We'll talk about the removal power. And then
- 2:29we'll talk about cases that most easily have
- 2:31been thought of as culture were ones before the
- 2:34Supreme Court. We'll take turns presenting and
- 2:36commenting, and we'll save a few minutes at the
- 2:38end for questions. So let me just begin with
- 2:41a quick overview. For the last five years, at
- 2:45the end of each Supreme Court term, I've written
- 2:47a book for the American Bar Association, recapping
- 2:50the cases and trying about their significance.
- 2:53I try to find a theme in the decisions and have
- 2:56it reflected in the title of the book. Sometimes
- 2:58it's easy. Remember the term a few years ago
- 3:02when the Supreme Court overruled Roe v. Wade,
- 3:05dramatically expanded gun rights, significantly
- 3:07changed the law with regard to the religion clauses?
- 3:10I just titled that a momentous year in the United
- 3:14States Supreme Court. My title for the book on
- 3:17last term was Taking Sides. Our country is more
- 3:22ideologically divided than it's been at any time
- 3:24since Reconstruction. Many of the cases last
- 3:28term reflected that ideological divide. They
- 3:31came from the so -called culture wars. They involved
- 3:34challenges of President Trump's initial actions
- 3:37after doing this term in office. Almost without
- 3:40exception, the Supreme Court came down on one
- 3:44side, the conservative side, of that ideological
- 3:47divide. Now you may agree with what the Supreme
- 3:50Court was doing, or you may disagree with what
- 3:52the Supreme Court was doing, but I think there's
- 3:54no doubt that it was a term of taking sides.
- 3:58It certainly proceeded that way. There was recently
- 4:01a Gallup poll that showed that of those who self
- 4:05-identify as Republicans, 75 percent approve
- 4:09of the Supreme Court's performance. Of those
- 4:11who self -identify as Democrats, 11 percent were
- 4:15approving the Supreme Court's performance. It's
- 4:17the largest gap as long as it's been measured.
- 4:20I think the profound question, as we think about
- 4:22the Supreme Court this term, in the foreseeable
- 4:25future is at a time when our country is so deeply
- 4:28ideologically divided, what will it mean to have
- 4:31a court that's perceived so clearly, solidly
- 4:35on one side of the ideological divide? A few
- 4:38statistics about last term as we think about
- 4:41this term. Last term, the Supreme Court decided
- 4:4456 cases with signed opinions after briefing
- 4:47oral argument. In the 1980s, the court was deciding
- 4:51about 160 cases a year. In William Rehnquist's
- 4:55last term as chief, October term 2004, the Supreme
- 4:59Court decided 85 cases. To go from 85, let alone
- 5:04160, down to 56 is truly notable. Even more stunning
- 5:09was the increase in the number of rulings on
- 5:12the Supreme Court's emergency docket, its so
- 5:15-called shadow docket. In October term 2023,
- 5:21just two years ago, The Supreme Court had 40
- 5:25matters that it resolved on its emergency docket.
- 5:28For October term 2024, it was as of June 27th,
- 5:33the last day opinions resolved 113 matters and
- 5:37overall for the term 144 matters. That means
- 5:41the number of matters on the emergency docket
- 5:43tripled over the course of a year. To me, there's
- 5:47much that's troubling about the Supreme Court
- 5:49shadow docket. how the Supreme Court is implicitly
- 5:52overruling long -standing precedent. How the
- 5:55Supreme Court is now treating its rulings on
- 5:57the shadow docket is binding on lower courts.
- 6:00Maybe most of all I'm concerned that the Supreme
- 6:02Court is often handing down crucial rulings,
- 6:06including ones affecting life and death without
- 6:08a word of explanation. But I do think one of
- 6:11the most important developments as we go forward
- 6:13is how the emergency docket of the Supreme Court
- 6:16has transformed and what it means for the court
- 6:19and for society. Well, thank you, Erwin. It's
- 6:24good to be back with you here again. I agree
- 6:28with your assessment, your opening assessment
- 6:31about where the Supreme Court is in this term
- 6:34and where we've come from. I will just add a
- 6:37few more themes when I'm thinking about the overview
- 6:40of this term. And it really is about power. That's
- 6:44the overarching issue. One of the biggest themes
- 6:48is presidential power. Several cases we're going
- 6:51to talk about really get to the heart of the
- 6:55Supreme Court having an opportunity to really
- 6:58embrace the so -called unitary executive theory,
- 7:02this idea that the president of the United States,
- 7:05when it comes to matters of the executive branch,
- 7:08is the decision maker. And a lot of the checks
- 7:12and balances that were put in place to sort of
- 7:15share that power among the other branches are.
- 7:19Being eroded and the Supreme Court could come
- 7:22in and really tear them down Completely to make
- 7:25the office of the president as powerful as it's
- 7:29ever been Under our current president. I also
- 7:33have been thinking a lot about the power of the
- 7:36other branches It's really hard to elevate the
- 7:40power of the executive without really whittling
- 7:43away the power of for example the legislative
- 7:46branch now Congress has is in the process, in
- 7:50my opinion, of abdicating a lot of that power
- 7:53themselves. But the Supreme Court is providing
- 7:56a powerful assist. in that endeavor. It's also
- 8:01about the power of the court itself, not just
- 8:04as the judiciary in the power, because in some
- 8:09cases, when you broaden executive power, you
- 8:11reduce the power overall of the judiciary to
- 8:15a large extent. But it seems that the Supreme
- 8:17Court is doing it in a way to preserve its own
- 8:20power while really whittling away the power of
- 8:23the appellate and trial level federal courts
- 8:26in the process. that the Supreme Court is finding
- 8:30itself through the shadow docket that Erwin talked
- 8:33about, increasingly at odds with lower courts
- 8:36that seem to be putting in place. injunctions,
- 8:41for example, against certain presidential actions,
- 8:44while the legality or constitutional issues that
- 8:47are raised by such actions are worked out, putting
- 8:50a pause on them. But the Supreme Court has repeatedly
- 8:53gone on to lift any stays that were put in place,
- 8:58increasingly saying that there is an interest
- 9:00that the potential damage that could be done
- 9:03to the president by not allowing him to carry
- 9:05out his objectives is greater than the negative
- 9:09impact. that it could have to the other parties
- 9:12in the case. I see that as an alarming theme
- 9:14that is happening with this court, too. And finally,
- 9:19I have written a little bit about my concerns
- 9:21about the erosion of stare decisis. As a law
- 9:25student, stare decisis really was presented as
- 9:28an crucially important principle to provide stability
- 9:31and reliability in the law, just to make society
- 9:35work and to make democracy stronger. And it seems
- 9:38the Supreme Court Court is very, very willing
- 9:41to abend past precedent just because they disagree
- 9:44with it, which isn't the standard that I learned
- 9:46in law school. So those are some of my opening
- 9:48thoughts as we dive into the cases this term.
- 9:52And I think I am going to start in that endeavor
- 9:55by getting into some of the cases related to
- 9:58democracy and elections. And the biggest one
- 10:01is a case called Louisiana v. Calais, which is
- 10:05a opportunity for the Supreme Court not only
- 10:10to revisit a map of Louisiana, a congressional
- 10:14map that was drawn in an effort to adhere to
- 10:17the Voting Rights Act, but the Supreme Court
- 10:19may take out a significant part. one of the remaining
- 10:23functioning parts of the Voting Rights Act while
- 10:26we are at it. So I want to go back first to 2022
- 10:30when the Supreme Court decided a case called
- 10:32Allen v. Milligan. Now, at that time, I and others
- 10:35were watching that case closely, worried that
- 10:38the Supreme Court may strike down or effectively
- 10:42nullify Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act. Section
- 10:452 is the section that allows individuals to bring
- 10:48claims to enforce the Voting Rights Act. based
- 10:53on claims that there are racially discriminatory
- 10:58voting practices put in place. For example, in
- 11:00that case, it involved a gerrymandered map in
- 11:04Alabama. There was concern that the Supreme Court
- 11:07would not only strike the map down, even though
- 11:10it was drawn in a way to try to adhere to the
- 11:12Voting Rights Act, but that, as I said, it could
- 11:15overturn and nullify parts of Section 2. But
- 11:18they didn't. They actually applied Section 2
- 11:21and found that... that that Alabama map was indeed
- 11:23an illegal racial gerrymander under that because
- 11:27it packed black voters. into a single section
- 11:31in a way that diluted their votes. Well, several
- 11:34states after this ruling, including Louisiana,
- 11:37adopted new congressional maps with that in mind,
- 11:41trying to adhere to the Voting Rights Act. And
- 11:44one of those states was Louisiana. Black voters
- 11:47had sued because at the time, although black
- 11:51residents made up about a third of Louisiana's
- 11:53population, there was only a significant number
- 11:57of them in one of its six voting districts. They
- 12:01sued, alleging that that was an unconstitutional
- 12:04racial gerrymander packing them into one district,
- 12:07and they won. There was a new map drawn that
- 12:10created two black opportunity districts. Now,
- 12:14what that means under the Voting Rights Act,
- 12:16it doesn't mean that black People can for sure
- 12:21get the candidate that they want or that they
- 12:24get an additional black candidate. It's misunderstood
- 12:26in that way. What it means is there's enough
- 12:29of them in a district that there are other parameters
- 12:32to that. It's sort of naturally configured that
- 12:35it keeps communities together and other factors
- 12:38just to show that it's not just a completely.
- 12:41the kind of gerrymander you think about in a
- 12:44long, drawn -out district. But that it is a way
- 12:48to ensure that they have a real opportunity to
- 12:51select the voter, a candidate of their choice.
- 12:55And in these cases, two of these districts were
- 12:58made up of at least 50 % Black voters in that
- 13:02state. while a group of self -described non -African
- 13:06Americans then sued over the new map, stating
- 13:10that it violated the 14th and 15th Amendments
- 13:13of the Constitution. The 14th Amendment provides
- 13:16that there shall be equal protection under the
- 13:19laws, and the 15th Amendment prohibits discrimination
- 13:23in voting on the basis of race. These are reconstructural.
- 13:28Amendments that were put in place at the time
- 13:31in order to ensure that black people after the
- 13:34Civil War were able to become fully functioning
- 13:36members of society And so that case has is now
- 13:41before the Supreme Court for the second time
- 13:44it was before the court last term and rather
- 13:46than issuing an opinion they re they put this
- 13:50they put the case back on the docket this term
- 13:52and Held arguments earlier this month Based on
- 13:57those arguments, it seems pretty clear that these
- 13:59Voting Rights Act, if Section 2 is not actually
- 14:03overruled as unconstitutional, it will be severely
- 14:06whittled down to almost nothing. Two of the people
- 14:10who were in the court's majority in that Milligan
- 14:13case that upheld the Alabama map, Chief Justice
- 14:16John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh, both
- 14:20seemed to cast real doubt that they would come
- 14:24to the same conclusion this time. John Roberts
- 14:27has long since the Shelby County case, Shelby
- 14:33County v. Holder back in 2013. 2013, 2012, Erwin,
- 14:38am I forgetting which one? 2013. 2013, that was
- 14:43close. It struck down section four. nullified
- 14:50part of section five of the Voting Rights Act.
- 14:52This was a pre -clearance requirement that in
- 14:55districts that had a long history of creating
- 14:57racially discriminatory maps or imposing other
- 15:00racially discriminatory laws had to get their
- 15:03plans pre -cleared by the federal government,
- 15:06the Justice Department, before they could be
- 15:08put in place. And rather than with section two,
- 15:11people can sue after an alleged discriminatory
- 15:14law is already put in place. Well, that was struck
- 15:17down in part because because John Roberts felt
- 15:21that the perpetual formula that was in place
- 15:24to determine what districts were covered could
- 15:29not be, the plaintiffs could not show that those
- 15:32factors were still in place at the time. It wasn't
- 15:35a... clear time limit, but it seemed clear that
- 15:41the point of the Chief Justice is, look, just
- 15:44because there was racism to be found in the past,
- 15:47we cannot continue perpetuating it. The way to
- 15:50stop discrimination by race is to stop discrimination
- 15:53by race. Well, Brett Kavanaugh seems to have...
- 15:57joined that view. He asked a lot of questions
- 16:00about time limitations within this, and he pointed
- 16:03to other cases such as the affirmative action
- 16:06case, which the Supreme Court took what I believed
- 16:08was dicta from the late Justice Sandra Day O
- 16:12'Connor in a previous case that said she hoped
- 16:16in 25 years that affirmative action would no
- 16:19longer be necessary to create diverse student
- 16:21populations as a deadline and the Supreme Court
- 16:2522 years after that decision struck down affirmative
- 16:28action entirely, was really asking about what
- 16:32the time limit on racial discrimination laws
- 16:35or the use of race in rectifying racial discrimination
- 16:38under the VRA should last. So to me, that points
- 16:42to a likely victory on the part of the non -African
- 16:48Americans and severe damage to the Voting Rights
- 16:51Act. I'm just going to flag a couple other election
- 16:54related cases quickly. One is called the National
- 16:57Republican Senatorial Committee versus the Federal
- 17:00Election Committee. This could be the biggest
- 17:04campaign finance case, I think, since Citizens
- 17:07United was decided back in 2010. In this case,
- 17:11the court will consider one of its past president.
- 17:13We talked about starry decisis there in Federal
- 17:17Election Commission v. Colorado Republican Federal
- 17:20Campaign Committee. That 2001 case upheld federal
- 17:25limits that prevents campaigns from coordinating
- 17:29with outside political parties things like super
- 17:32PACs are not allowed to they're allowed to spend
- 17:34money in federal campaigns but they're not allowed
- 17:36to coordinate with campaigns this case could
- 17:39challenge that and could very likely strike that
- 17:42distinction down on a first amendment claim that
- 17:45was the same basis in citizens united that the
- 17:48court uh really opened outside spending and striking
- 17:52down those limits in federal campaigns. So I
- 17:53would keep an eye out for that. There's also
- 17:55a case called Bost v Illinois State Board of
- 17:59Elections. That case is about standing, who has
- 18:02the right to sue over election rules, such as
- 18:06in this case, Illinois's mail in voter law. One
- 18:09candidate who says that the law would make a
- 18:12difference in the way candidates run their election
- 18:14want to bring to state that he has standing to
- 18:18challenge that case. I think the court will likely
- 18:21find standing. I'm not sure that that will have
- 18:23a huge impact. I think most cases will find that
- 18:26candidates would have that, too. I don't think
- 18:27that's going to open a floodgates, but I do think
- 18:29the other two are really important and worth
- 18:31paying attention to. Thank you. I just wanted
- 18:34to comment on Louisiana versus Calais. I so agree
- 18:37with Kim that I think this is one of the most
- 18:39important cases on the docket, and it could be
- 18:42one of the most important civil rights cases
- 18:44in decades. I regard the Voting Rights Act of
- 18:471965 as one of the most important federal laws
- 18:50adopted in my lifetime. In 1964, in Mississippi,
- 18:56only 6 .7 % of eligible black individuals were
- 19:00registered to vote. That was in a state where
- 19:02almost 70 % of white individuals were registered
- 19:04to vote. In Alabama, only 19 .5 % of eligible
- 19:09black individuals were registered to vote. across
- 19:12what we regard as the South, the states that
- 19:14comprise the Confederacy, less than a third of
- 19:18eligible black individuals were registered to
- 19:20vote, or again, more than twice as many as white
- 19:22individuals were registered to vote. The Voting
- 19:25Rights Act changed that and changed that rapidly.
- 19:28By 1966, in almost all of the states that comprise
- 19:33the old Confederacy, more than half of eligible
- 19:36black voters were registered to vote. And there
- 19:39were two key parts to the Voting Rights Act.
- 19:41is what Kim was talking about. One is section
- 19:45five that required pre -clearance. It said that
- 19:48before a jurisdiction with a history of race
- 19:50discrimination could change its election system,
- 19:53it needed approval from either three judge federal
- 19:55court or the attorney general of the United States.
- 20:00Hundreds of instances of proposed voting changes
- 20:03were denied pre -clearance and didn't go into
- 20:06effect as a discriminatory impact. In Shelby
- 20:10County versus Holder, as Kim said, the Supreme
- 20:12Court effectively declared pre -clearance unconstitutional
- 20:15and therefore nullified Section 5 of the Voting
- 20:19Rights Act. But in the Shelby County case that
- 20:21Kim mentioned, Chief Justice Roberts said, well,
- 20:23don't worry, we still have Section 2 of the Voting
- 20:26Rights Act. which says that state and local governments
- 20:29can't have election systems and practices that
- 20:32discriminate based on race. In 1982, Congress
- 20:35amended this to say that proof of a discriminatory
- 20:39impact was sufficient for liability. There'd
- 20:42never be proof of discriminatory intent. Kim
- 20:45described how this case presents to the Supreme
- 20:48Court the question of whether section two is
- 20:51unconstitutional, whether section two is limited
- 20:54by the court. I would just offer two comments
- 20:57about this. One is, why should the passage of
- 21:00time matter? Kim rightly points to what Justice
- 21:04Kavanaugh said at oral argument and what he said
- 21:07in a concurring opinion, Allen versus Milligan,
- 21:09that maybe so much time has gone on, we don't
- 21:12need the Voting Rights Act anymore. But why is
- 21:15that for the Supreme Court to decide? And on
- 21:18what basis? I'm reminded that in 1883, in the
- 21:23civil rights cases, just 18 years after the end
- 21:26of the Civil War, the Supreme Court struck down
- 21:29the Civil Rights Act of 1875 and said, it's time
- 21:32to get past slavery. It's time to get past the
- 21:36need for remedies for racism. There's this constant
- 21:39temptation to say the problem is over when it's
- 21:43clearly not. But second, I want to say why I
- 21:46think this case could be important beyond voting
- 21:48rights. In 1976, in Washington v. Davis, the
- 21:53Supreme Court said that proof of a racially discriminatory
- 21:56impact isn't sufficient to show race discrimination.
- 22:01There has to be proof of discriminatory intent.
- 22:04It's very difficult to prove discriminatory intent.
- 22:07Rarely do legislators or policymakers openly
- 22:10express a racist motive. Also, we know a lot
- 22:14now about implicit bias and unconscious racism.
- 22:19That's why there's a number of federal statutes
- 22:21that allow for liability on proof of disparate
- 22:25impact. Title VII does this in employment discrimination.
- 22:29The open housing law does this with regard to
- 22:31housing. And 1982 amendments to the Voting Rights
- 22:34Act. On August 1st, the Supreme Court in Louisiana
- 22:38was clay asked for new briefing and argument
- 22:40on the question of whether Section 2 of the Voting
- 22:43Rights Act is unconstitutional, is violating
- 22:46equal protection. The argument is that in order
- 22:49to avoid disparate impact liability, decision
- 22:52makers have to consider race, and that would
- 22:54violate equal protection. In fact, on June 27th,
- 22:59Justice Clarence Thomas did something I've never
- 23:01seen before. When the court set the case over
- 23:03for re -argument, Justice Thomas dissented and
- 23:06said he would just declare Section 2 unconstitutional.
- 23:10But this isn't just limited to voting rights.
- 23:12In 2009, in a case Richie v. DeStefano. Justice
- 23:17Scalia wrote a concurring opinion where he argued
- 23:19that under Title VII employment discrimination,
- 23:22disparate impact would be unconstitutional because
- 23:24it would require decision makers to consider
- 23:27race to avoid liability, and he thought that
- 23:29violated equal protection. So the courts narrowing
- 23:34and validating Section II and disparate impact
- 23:36would be devastating for voting, but... If the
- 23:40Supreme Court says that disparate impact liability
- 23:43violates equal protection, it will put in jeopardy
- 23:45Title VII, the Fair Housing Act, and state laws
- 23:49that allow disparate impact liability. Should
- 23:55I talk briefly about the next theory of terrorists?
- 23:58I think so. Next Wednesday, the Supreme Court
- 24:02is going to hear oral arguments in two cases
- 24:05regarding President Trump's legal authority to
- 24:08impose terrorists. These are Learning Resources
- 24:11versus Trump and V .O .S. Selections versus Trump.
- 24:16President Trump now has imposed over a trillion
- 24:19dollars in tariffs. And the question is, does
- 24:24he have the legal authority to do so? President
- 24:27Trump is claiming that the International Emergency
- 24:31Economic Powers Act gives him the authority to
- 24:35impose tariffs. In the first of the case I mentioned,
- 24:39Learning Resources, the United States District
- 24:41Court for the District of Columbia said that
- 24:43the statute doesn't give the power to impose
- 24:46tariffs. Before the D .C. Circuit could hear
- 24:50the matter, the Supreme Court granted review.
- 24:54It's unusual for it to do so, but not unheard
- 24:57of. It's called certiorari before judgment. And
- 25:01then subsequently, In the other case I mentioned,
- 25:04V .O .S. Selections v. Trump, the United States
- 25:07Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in a
- 25:09seven -to -four en banc ruling held that President
- 25:11Trump lacked the authority to impose most of
- 25:14these tariffs. So the primary issue before the
- 25:18Supreme Court is one of statutory construction.
- 25:22Does this statute give the president the power
- 25:25to impose tariffs? The two lower courts said
- 25:29The statute doesn't do that. The statute gives
- 25:31the president the power to, quote, regulate importation
- 25:36in an emergency. The lower court said, where
- 25:40Congress wants to give the president the power
- 25:42to impose tariffs, it uses the word tariffs or
- 25:47synonym. This statute doesn't do so. Also, the
- 25:52challengers say, there's a difference between
- 25:55giving the government the power to regulate as
- 25:58opposed to the power to tax. And then there's
- 26:02the underlying issue. Is there really an emergency
- 26:05here? President Trump is saying that it's clear
- 26:08that the power to regulate importation is the
- 26:10power to impose tariffs, whereas the challenge
- 26:13is saying, no, if you look at the plain text
- 26:16of the statute, tariffs just isn't there. There's
- 26:19also an issue with regard to the administrative
- 26:21state. In recent years, the conservative justices
- 26:27And a series of six to three decisions have said
- 26:30that the executive branch of government can't
- 26:32act on a, quote, major question of economic or
- 26:36political significance without clear guidance
- 26:38from Congress. You might remember just a couple
- 26:41of years ago in Biden versus Nebraska, the Supreme
- 26:44Court six to three invalidated President Biden's
- 26:49student loan relief program, saying this is a
- 26:51major question and Congress hasn't been sufficiently
- 26:54specific. The Federal Circuit said, tariffs are
- 26:58a major question of economic and political significance,
- 27:00and Congress hasn't been sufficiently specific
- 27:03in giving the President this authority. The President
- 27:07claims that he has the authority under Article
- 27:092 of the Constitution, because this relates to
- 27:12foreign policy. The counter -argument, of course,
- 27:14is Article 1 gives to Congress the power to tax
- 27:17and tariffs a form of tax. I found most interesting
- 27:21in the Solicitor General's brief the explicit
- 27:23statement that the Court's shouldn't be able
- 27:27to review the tariffs at all, that the courts
- 27:31should just leave this to the president in the
- 27:33political process. That's of course the same
- 27:36argument that the Solicitor General is making
- 27:38with regard to the president's use of troops
- 27:40in cities, that there can be no judicial review.
- 27:44Just to include, what I find interesting here
- 27:46is if the conservative justices follow their
- 27:50traditional principles, this should be an easy
- 27:53case for them. Conservative justices say, follow
- 27:56the plain text of the statute. The text doesn't
- 27:59mention tariffs. The conservative justices say
- 28:03the executive branch can't act on major questions.
- 28:06These are major questions. On the other hand,
- 28:09it is a court majority that's been very deferential
- 28:12to the president, and so the appeal of the Solicitor
- 28:15General to just leave this to the president might
- 28:17resonate with some of those justices. Yeah, Erwin,
- 28:21I think you're exactly right. I am not certain.
- 28:24Usually in cases like this with challenges involving
- 28:27the president, I think the odds are in the president's
- 28:32favor. But in this one, I'm not so sure for the
- 28:34reasons that you pointed out, including the strict
- 28:37statutory construction argument really works
- 28:40against the president here. One thing that I
- 28:43just found interesting about the brief by the
- 28:46Solicitor General, too, was that it echoed what
- 28:48Donald Trump has been messaging, which is we
- 28:51need the tariffs or we're not going to have a
- 28:53country. There will be an economic collapse.
- 28:56If these tariffs are overturned, the country
- 28:59just wouldn't survive it. economists, including
- 29:02people who are conservative from places like
- 29:04the Cato Institute, are saying that's actually
- 29:08not true. The president is exaggerating the impact
- 29:12of this. Yes, they will feel it. It would be
- 29:15a significant loss of revenue, but the government
- 29:18can make that up in other ways. And historically,
- 29:20it also has. So it really cuts against this idea
- 29:24that there is an emergency. think that President
- 29:28Trump, I like to call him the president who cries
- 29:30emergency because he's declared emergency power
- 29:33to do all sorts of things. By and large, the
- 29:37Supreme Court has allowed him to get away with
- 29:39it, at least as the challenges move forward.
- 29:42But this is one that I think could be a place
- 29:45where they say stop. I just want to highlight
- 29:48one thing that you said. I found looking at the
- 29:51amicus briefs particularly interesting because
- 29:53so many traditional conservative groups are against
- 29:57President Trump on this. I'm not surprised the
- 30:01Chamber of Commerce is against the tariffs, but
- 30:03this is a court that's very receptive to arguments
- 30:05in the Chamber of Commerce. The Washington Legal
- 30:08Foundation, you mentioned the Cato Institute,
- 30:10the Goldwater Foundation, all of these are groups
- 30:14that would traditionally be on Trump's side.
- 30:16And it'll be interesting whether that has some
- 30:18influence in the justices. There are far more
- 30:21amicus briefs against the tariffs than there
- 30:24are in favor of President Trump's position. Yeah,
- 30:27that's really interesting. So I'm going to say
- 30:29a little bit about the removal power cases. One
- 30:32key feature of President Trump's second term
- 30:35is his desire to fire leaders of federal agencies
- 30:39based on his policy differences with them or
- 30:42some other reason. He sees and the government
- 30:45is now arguing that the president as the head
- 30:48of the executive branch has the authority to
- 30:51hire and fire his subordinates within that branch
- 30:55again. a broad reading of the unitary executive
- 30:59theory. But federal law and Supreme Court precedent
- 31:03can put some limits on that. It has put some
- 31:06limits on that, some agencies, if they were deemed
- 31:10to be... quasi -legislative or quasi -judicial
- 31:13or quasi -private, the court has previously held
- 31:17that there are some limits on the president's
- 31:19ability to fire the heads of those agencies based
- 31:22on the language of the federal law that created
- 31:25and governs them. Still, three times this year.
- 31:30When the president moved to fire heads of agencies,
- 31:33despite federal law that clearly stated that
- 31:35he cannot do so without cause, the Supreme Court
- 31:39on its emergency docket lifted stays that were
- 31:42put in place by lower courts that allowed the
- 31:46president to carry out those firings, at least
- 31:49in the short term, until the challenges in those
- 31:55cases continued through the appellate. process.
- 31:59One of these was a shadow docket order in the
- 32:02case called Trump v. Wilcox in which the court
- 32:06allowed Donald Trump to remove a member of the
- 32:09National Labor Relations Board and the Merit
- 32:11Systems Protection Board. And in lifting the
- 32:14stay that had kept them in place, the court,
- 32:17the majority of that order reasoned that they
- 32:21exercised those, the fired heads exercised, quote,
- 32:25a significant authority and reflects the judge.
- 32:28It reflects the judgment that the government
- 32:30faces a greater risk of harm from an order allowing
- 32:34a removed officer to continue exercising the
- 32:37executive power than a wrongfully removed officer
- 32:40faces from being unable to perform. her statutory
- 32:43duty. Now think about that for a minute. The
- 32:46court has already laid down the gauntlet and
- 32:48said, we see that in this fight is a greater
- 32:51harm if the president cannot fire whom he chooses,
- 32:55then it would be to the people who are actually
- 32:58being fired. I would remember that as we're watching
- 33:02these cases. And this also seemed to conflict
- 33:05with yet another precedent, a nearly centuries
- 33:07old case called Humphrey's Executor. This stemmed
- 33:11from President FDR's attempt to fire the head
- 33:14of the Federal Trade Commission because he didn't
- 33:17agree with him on policy. But the statute creating
- 33:20the FTC and its leadership said that the officer
- 33:23could only be fired for cause. So William Humphrey
- 33:26had challenged his firing. Well, he passed away,
- 33:30but his estate, which is why the case is called
- 33:33Humphrey's Executor, sought back pay for his
- 33:36firing and won. And the Supreme Court said at
- 33:39the time, because it is an agency where Congress
- 33:44established this rule, that that created it,
- 33:48that made it quasi -legislative, and that he
- 33:50could not, for no reason, fire someone. Well,
- 33:54that case suffered a huge blow with the Wilcox.
- 33:59The Supreme Court on a shadow docket case did
- 34:03not expressly overturn Humphrey's executor, but
- 34:06that order was a pretty strong nail in Humphrey's
- 34:09executors. in Humphrey's executor's coffin. So
- 34:13now there is a chance for the court to do what
- 34:16it failed to entirely do in the Wilcox case.
- 34:19And that comes in a case called Trump versus
- 34:21Slaughter, which basically has the exact same
- 34:23facts as Humphrey's executor. You have a FTC
- 34:26administrator who has been fired by the president
- 34:29for no reason other than he doesn't like her
- 34:32policy. She fought it. she was removed from office.
- 34:36The Supreme Court allowed her to be removed,
- 34:38but the case is still making its way to the court.
- 34:41I don't think it looks good. One interesting
- 34:44thing in that Wilcox order, though, is that the
- 34:48court stated, now people are worried about the
- 34:50Fed. They're worried about the Federal Reserve.
- 34:53We don't think that the Federal Reserve is the
- 34:56same. Clearly, they're a quasi -private organization
- 35:01that has nothing to do with the FTC. So that
- 35:05sort of laid down the gauntlet that where the
- 35:07Supreme Court may draw the line on the president's
- 35:10authority. And sure enough, the president tried
- 35:12to fire a member of the Federal Reserve, Lisa
- 35:15Cook. And that case is also before the Supreme
- 35:18Court as she fights that case. I'm not going
- 35:22to make any. predictions on that one or when
- 35:24maybe you will, but it would be interesting to
- 35:27see after that Wilcox note how they get around
- 35:32saying that the president can fire. Lisa Cook,
- 35:38and which could in turn also mean that it can
- 35:40fire the chair of the Federal Reserve Bank, Jerome
- 35:43Cook. I'm told on good authority that Jerome
- 35:45Cook is not worried about losing his job. So
- 35:48we'll see how this plays out. It's looking good
- 35:50for Lisa Cook, but I'm still not going to make
- 35:52a prediction here. I'm always reluctant to make
- 35:55predictions. I long ago learned that he who lives
- 35:58by the crystal ball has to learn to eat ground
- 36:00glass. But I will point to a fact that distinguishes
- 36:04the two cases that might be relevant in making
- 36:06a prediction. With regard to slaughter, the Supreme
- 36:11Court stayed the preliminary injunction that
- 36:13restored him to office. So he's been fired while
- 36:17this has been litigated. with regard to Cook,
- 36:21the Supreme Court did not stay the preliminary
- 36:24injunction, and she's allowed to stay in office
- 36:27while this is being litigated. That's at least
- 36:30some indication that the justices see a difference
- 36:33between this. I want to put these cases in a
- 36:37larger context, and that's they ultimately relate
- 36:41to the so -called unitary executive theory. The
- 36:45unitary executive theory is a theory developed
- 36:48early during the Reagan presidency by young lawyers,
- 36:52including John Roberts and Samuel Alito, that
- 36:56the president is in charge of the entire executive
- 36:59branch of government. In January 2006, when Samuel
- 37:04Alito was nominated for the Supreme Court and
- 37:07considered by the Senate Judiciary Committee,
- 37:09many of those who testified against him, including
- 37:13me, focused on his support for the unitary executive
- 37:17theory. It was very frightening to think that
- 37:20the president is going to have total control
- 37:23over the executive branch of government. Humphrey's
- 37:28executive, as Kim says, was set in 1935. It's
- 37:31been followed ever since. But when President
- 37:34Trump took office, he said he believed that Humphrey's
- 37:37executive was wrongly decided. It's a unitary
- 37:39executive, and he can fire anyone in the executive
- 37:42branch of government. When the Supreme Court
- 37:46first considered the unitary executive theory,
- 37:49it was in a case Morrison v. Olson in 1988. It
- 37:53involved a law adopted after Watergate, the Ethics
- 37:56in Government Act, that allowed for the appointment
- 37:58of an independent counsel when there are allegations
- 38:02that the president or high -level executive officials
- 38:05had engaged in misconduct. It only allowed removal
- 38:08of the individual for cause. And the question
- 38:11is, did this violate the unitary executive theory?
- 38:14The Supreme Court, seven to one, expressly rejected
- 38:19the unitary executive theory. Chief Justice William
- 38:22Rehnquist, no liberal, wrote the opinion for
- 38:25the court and talked about how the Constitution
- 38:27creates interdependent branches of government,
- 38:31not independent ones. Only Justice Antonin Scalia
- 38:35in his dissent expressly embraced the unitary
- 38:38executive theory. Now I think we have a majority
- 38:41of the justices who regard Justice Scalia's lone
- 38:45dissent as the appropriate law. In the slaughter
- 38:50case that Kim was talking about, the Supreme
- 38:52Court's granted review in two issues. One is
- 38:56whether Humphrey's executor should be overruled.
- 39:00That would be dramatic in itself. But let me
- 39:03read you the second issue the Supreme Court has
- 39:05granted review on, and that is whether a federal
- 39:09court may prevent a person's removal from public
- 39:12office. either relief at equity or at law. And
- 39:16what the Trump administration is saying is the
- 39:18president can fire anyone in the executive branch
- 39:21and no court can overturn that or destroy the
- 39:24person to office. This would not only mean being
- 39:26able to fire agency heads, but it'd seemingly
- 39:30make civil service unconstitutional, protections
- 39:33that have existed since the 19th century. Should
- 39:41I move to the what I called the culture where
- 39:43issues let's get into it Let me before talking
- 39:47about the cases that we've identified as cultural
- 39:51issues this term Talk about a case that came
- 39:54down on Wednesday, June 18th last term because
- 39:57I think to understand the cases on the DAC at
- 39:59this term We need to start with United States
- 40:02versus scrimmety United States versus scrimmety
- 40:06involved a Tennessee law that prohibited gender
- 40:09-affirming care for transgender youth. This was
- 40:13about prohibiting puberty -blocking hormones
- 40:17or cross -sex hormones for transgender youth.
- 40:21Federal district court issued a preliminary injunction
- 40:25saying this is likely unconstitutional. The district
- 40:28court said this is sex discrimination and also
- 40:32it's discrimination based on gender identity.
- 40:35The district court said An immediate scrutiny
- 40:38is the appropriate test. Under an immediate scrutiny,
- 40:41a government action is constitutional, only if
- 40:44it's substantially related to an important government
- 40:46purpose. And there has to be a searching inquiry
- 40:49by the court to make sure the law serves an actual
- 40:53important purpose. The United States Court of
- 40:55Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed. Chief
- 40:58Judge Jeffrey Sutton wrote the opinion for the
- 41:00court, and he said, great deference should be
- 41:03given to the Tennessee legislature. only rational
- 41:06basis review, and the Sixth Circuit upheld the
- 41:10law. The Supreme Court, in a six to three decision,
- 41:15affirmed the Sixth Circuit and upheld the Tennessee
- 41:17law. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote for the
- 41:21court. There were concurring opinions by Justice
- 41:24Thomas Alito and Barrett. Justice Sotomayor wrote
- 41:27of vehement dissent, joined by Justices Kagan
- 41:30and Jackson. Justice Kagan wrote her own short
- 41:32dissent. Chief Justice Roberts began his opinion
- 41:37and stressed the need for deference to the political
- 41:40process in Tennessee. He said, this isn't sex
- 41:45discrimination because the law treats boys and
- 41:48girls the same, preventing gender -affirming
- 41:51care for either. And he says, this isn't gender
- 41:54identity discrimination. He relied on a 1974
- 41:58Supreme Court case, Goduldig Versailla. That
- 42:02involved a California law concerning what disability
- 42:06benefits would be provided to state employees
- 42:09for medical conditions. And California provided
- 42:11disability for all medical conditions, except
- 42:15for pregnancy. And the question is, was excluding
- 42:18pregnancy sex discrimination? And the Supreme
- 42:21Court, in opinion by Justice Potter Stewart,
- 42:23said no, it's not sex discrimination. He said
- 42:25there's two categories of persons, pregnant persons
- 42:29and non -pregnant persons. He said since women
- 42:32are in both categories, it can't be sex discrimination.
- 42:35Likewise, Chief Justice Roberts in Skrimeti said,
- 42:40there are two categories of people with regard
- 42:42to receiving these hormones. There are those
- 42:45who receive the hormones for other than gender
- 42:49-affirming care. And he said this includes transgender
- 42:52individuals. And then there are those who receive
- 42:55this just for gender -affirming care. These are
- 42:58transgender individuals. But since transgender
- 43:00individuals are in both categories, it can't
- 43:02be discrimination based on gender identity. Justice
- 43:05Sotomayor strongly disagreed. She disagreed with
- 43:09the premise. She said this shouldn't be an instance
- 43:12of deference to the political process. That at
- 43:15least since 1938, in the Carolyn Products footnote,
- 43:19it's always understood that courts have a special
- 43:21role in protecting so -called discrete and insular
- 43:24minorities, groups that can't and likely to protect
- 43:27themselves in the political process. Transgender
- 43:30individuals are such a group. She says, this
- 43:32is sex discrimination. There's drugs that can
- 43:35be given to boys that can't be given to girls,
- 43:37and drugs given to girls that can't be given
- 43:39to boys. If a boy has delayed puberty, he can
- 43:42give testosterone to enhance his male characteristics,
- 43:45but a girl who's transitioning can't be given
- 43:47testosterone to enhance male characteristics.
- 43:50If a girl has delayed puberty, she can give estrogen
- 43:52and other hormones to enhance female characteristics,
- 43:55but a boy who's transitioning can't be given
- 43:57for that reason. And as to the latter issue,
- 44:00Justice Sotomayor essentially said, Goduldig
- 44:02is one of the most ridiculed Supreme Court cases
- 44:04ever. She quoted Justice Ginsburg that the case
- 44:08was wrong when it's decided and wrong today.
- 44:11So the whole point of this law is to discriminate
- 44:13against transgender individuals. I mentioned
- 44:17circummedia at the beginning because I think
- 44:19there's a direct relationship between what the
- 44:21Supreme Court did there and the cases that are
- 44:24in the docket for this term. The first of the
- 44:27cases for this term is Childs v. Salazar, as
- 44:31argued on October 7, second day of the term.
- 44:35Colorado adopted a law prohibiting so -called
- 44:38conversion therapy for gay, lesbian, and transgender
- 44:42youth. This is therapy that's designed to change
- 44:46somebody's sexual orientation or gender identity.
- 44:51The Colorado legislature found that such transition
- 44:54and such prohibitions of conversion therapy are
- 44:58justified because conversion therapy is unsafe
- 45:02and ineffective. A challenge got brought to this
- 45:07by a therapist who wished to engage in this practice.
- 45:11She said it violates her freedom of speech to
- 45:15prevent her from trying to engage in conversion
- 45:18therapy. Now it's notable that the Colorado law
- 45:22went into effect in 2019 but nobody has ever
- 45:26been prosecuted under it. The law has never been
- 45:28used. But nonetheless, the therapist brings a
- 45:31challenge. The United States Court of Appeals
- 45:34for the 10th Circuit in a two -to -one decision
- 45:37upheld the Colorado law. The majority stressed
- 45:42the appropriateness of deferring to the Colorado
- 45:45legislature when it comes to making decisions
- 45:48with regard to medical care practices. The majority
- 45:51said that this is regulating professional speech.
- 45:56The law often regulates professional speech.
- 45:58Doctors have to give warnings before they provide
- 46:01medical treatment or prescribe drugs. If a therapist
- 46:05knows that a patient is likely to harm someone,
- 46:09the therapist has to warn that individual of
- 46:11the harm. The 10th Circuit said, this is similarly
- 46:14the government making your choice, but what medical
- 46:18care here, what kind of therapy is appropriate?
- 46:22Judge Harris -Harts dissented on the 10th Circuit
- 46:24and said, this is a content -based restriction
- 46:26on speech, strict scrutiny, and the law should
- 46:29fail. I'll be into what Kim thinks, but my sense
- 46:33of the oral argument is that the Supreme Court
- 46:35is likely to reverse the 10th Circuit and strike
- 46:38down this statute. Maybe the court will remand
- 46:42it for additional evidence or concern about rightness
- 46:46has never been used, but my sense was that the
- 46:48conservative justice on the court here very much
- 46:51agreed with the dissent from the 10th Circuit.
- 46:54And I compare this to Scrimetti and that in Scrimetti,
- 46:57the conservative justices said, we've got to
- 46:59give deference to the Tennessee legislature.
- 47:02I don't think we're going to see the same deference
- 47:04by the conservative justices to the Colorado
- 47:07legislature. The other cases that I want to talk
- 47:11about are Little versus Hickox and West Virginia
- 47:15versus BPJ. They involve respectively Idaho and
- 47:20West Virginia laws that prohibit transgender
- 47:24youth from participating in athletics corresponding
- 47:28to their gender identity. What it's really about
- 47:31is preventing transgender girls and women from
- 47:34participating in girls and women's sports. The
- 47:38United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth
- 47:40Circuit and the United States Court of Appeals
- 47:42for the Fourth Circuit respectively declared
- 47:45these laws unconstitutional. No issues. are more
- 47:50central to the culture wars than restricting
- 47:52the ability of transgender girls and women to
- 47:55participate in girls and women's sports. Now,
- 47:58it relates to Scrimetti in many ways. I mentioned
- 48:02in Scrimetti the court didn't identify the level
- 48:05of scrutiny to be used for discrimination against
- 48:07transgender individuals. That issue is before
- 48:10the court in Little v. Hickox and also in West
- 48:14Virginia v. BPJ. And it's notable that in Scrimetti,
- 48:17Justices Thomas Alito and especially Barrett
- 48:21wrote concurring opinions saying only rational
- 48:24basis review for discriminating against transgender
- 48:26youth. Also, I think that these cases together
- 48:31with Scrimetti will give a real sense of will
- 48:34the Supreme Court provide any protection under
- 48:36equal protection for transgender individuals.
- 48:41Yeah, I agree with that. And it's also interesting
- 48:46the way the court has considered, continued to
- 48:50move away when it comes to these sort of statutory
- 48:53questions from its ruling in Bostock, which held
- 48:58that. that Title VII employment protections,
- 49:03the federal statute that prohibits discrimination
- 49:05on the basis of a number of things, including
- 49:08sex, applied to both sexual orientation discrimination
- 49:12and discrimination based on gender identity.
- 49:17That seemed to be held up. That was argued in
- 49:20scrimmety to try to advance the idea that the
- 49:23same analysis should be applied when it comes
- 49:26to constitutional protections under equal protection.
- 49:29and the court declined to do that. seems that
- 49:34this is an even more direct case that would run
- 49:38afoul of the likely court rulings here, I fear,
- 49:42in both PPJ and Hickox. And when it comes to
- 49:47Salazar, one thing that stands out to me in Childs
- 49:51v. Salazar is that this is a free speech case.
- 49:55And increasingly, the court has been in cases
- 49:59that are really at heart religious. discrimination
- 50:02cases. The therapist in Childs v. Salazar is
- 50:07somebody who is religious and who deeply believes
- 50:11that the best way to treat people who are suffering
- 50:14from gender dysmorphia are feelings of. uh, that
- 50:18they are gay or LGBTQ is conversion and is to
- 50:22try to, uh, treat them, but she's bringing this
- 50:26as a free speech, uh, claim saying that it prevents
- 50:30her as a professional from speaking in the way
- 50:33that she normally would, uh, do it again to,
- 50:36to the standing, uh, and ripeness issue that,
- 50:40uh, Erwin brings up. She's, she does not identify
- 50:43any patient that she's turned away. She does
- 50:45not say that this has stopped. to practice in
- 50:48any way or harmed it. But still, this challenge
- 50:50somehow made it there, which I find is really
- 50:53interesting. But I've seen increasingly challenges
- 50:56that are really religious challenges being made
- 51:00under the First Amendment's free expression case.
- 51:02We saw that with a couple years back with a case
- 51:05involving a flag on Boston City Hall, that the
- 51:08city had a policy of opening anybody to request
- 51:12a permit to fly whatever flag they chose. Someone
- 51:15chose to fly a religious flag, and that was rejected.
- 51:19And the Supreme Court said, no, if you open it
- 51:21up, you can't discriminate on the basis of viewpoint.
- 51:24That's a free speech objection. That was something
- 51:26that was really a religious freedom case wrapped
- 51:30up in First Amendment free speech clothing. And
- 51:34so I think you're only going to see that increase.
- 51:39You're muted, Erwin. And so we can take the start
- 51:43with the question and. invite other questions,
- 51:47but if not, we can pick up some other cases that
- 51:49are on the docket that we haven't talked about.
- 51:52Let me read the question. Do you have concern
- 51:55that the court is consciously engaged in a pattern
- 51:58of appeasement of Trump and hopes they won't
- 52:01flout the court's positions when they move against
- 52:03his positions? I am concerned that Well, I am
- 52:13concerned about what might happen if the Supreme
- 52:15Court rules squarely against Donald Trump. He
- 52:18has consistently shown no compunction about defying
- 52:23lower court orders. There are various news organizations
- 52:26that are keeping track as to how many lower court
- 52:28orders Trump or the administration has violated
- 52:31up to now. That is certainly concerning if I
- 52:36were a federal judge, that the administration
- 52:38would be flouting my authority when I issue a
- 52:40ruling. But the Supreme Court so far, as we said,
- 52:44has ruled in favor of him and not against him.
- 52:49So we haven't really seen that. I do think that
- 52:52the justices are aware for the sake of, as I
- 52:55said, holding on and protecting their own power
- 52:57of the possibility of that and what that would
- 53:00mean if he does defy them. And perhaps that is
- 53:03one reason why they are stepping very carefully
- 53:06and handing down rulings that would be less likely
- 53:08to defy. to be defied, but I think we'll really
- 53:13have to see that test. I think perhaps with the
- 53:17Cook case might be one of them that we see that
- 53:19with. But I am concerned if President Trump does
- 53:23not think that a Supreme Court ruling applies
- 53:26to him, as Justice Barrett recently said in remarks,
- 53:30they only have the ability to issue opinions.
- 53:33They can't, they don't have the force to go out
- 53:36and enforce them. So we'll see. I agree with
- 53:40everything you just said. To begin with, I share
- 53:43your concern that there could be defiance of
- 53:47court orders. President Trump said this year,
- 53:51and I quote, he who saves the public violates
- 53:55no law. Vice President J .D. Vance on a number
- 53:58of occasions, the president doesn't have to violate,
- 54:00follow court orders that limit the president's
- 54:03powers. And if the president defies the court,
- 54:07There's relatively little the courts can do about
- 54:10it. Somebody can be held in criminal contempt
- 54:13if they violate a court order, but a president
- 54:17can't be criminally prosecuted for anything he
- 54:19does with his official duties. That was Trump
- 54:21versus United States a year ago. And the president
- 54:23can pardon anyone, including for criminal contempt.
- 54:27There could be civil contempt where somebody
- 54:29is put in jail until they are fined until they
- 54:32comply with a court order. but civil contempt
- 54:35is enforced by the United States Marshals and
- 54:37they're controlled by the Attorney General, Pam
- 54:40Bondi. While I share this concern, you then get
- 54:43to the next step. Do I believe that the Supreme
- 54:47Court is refraining from limiting the president
- 54:51out of concern that their orders might be defied?
- 54:54And I don't know. The pattern is that the Supreme
- 54:57Court is overwhelmingly sided with President
- 54:59Trump. in virtually every one of the cases that's
- 55:02come up on the emergency docket. Is that because
- 55:05they agree with him on the merits or is that
- 55:09because they're afraid that they'll be disobeyed?
- 55:13I don't know. There's no indication from the
- 55:16justice and the majority. Virtually all of these
- 55:18have been 6 -3, occasionally 7 -2 in terms of
- 55:21the dissents. I had thought over the course of
- 55:24the summer that maybe the Supreme Court was going
- 55:26to draw a distinction between separation of powers
- 55:29cases and individual liberties cases. And maybe
- 55:33we would see a great deference on the part of
- 55:35the court when it came to separation of powers
- 55:37issues, like the removal power that Kim was talking
- 55:41about. But when it came to individual liberties,
- 55:43the court was going to draw a line. And then
- 55:45on Monday, September 8th, the court handed down
- 55:48Noam versus Perdomo. This involves the federal
- 55:52district court judge in Los Angeles, Judge Frimpong,
- 55:55who had found that ICE agents were stopping people
- 55:57without reasonable suspicion, using impermissible
- 56:01factors, and enjoying them from using parent
- 56:05race or ethnicity, language or accent, what kind
- 56:09of jobs somebody has or where they were found.
- 56:12The Ninth Circuit did not stay the preliminary
- 56:15injunction, but a 55 -page opinion essentially
- 56:18upholding Judge Frimpong. On September 8th, the
- 56:21Supreme Court, six to three, stayed the preliminary
- 56:26injunction. There was no opinion from the court,
- 56:30not a word of explanation. Justice Kavanaugh
- 56:32wrote an opinion for himself. Justice Sotomayor
- 56:35wrote a blistering dissent, joined by Justice
- 56:37Kagan and Jackson. This was a case very much
- 56:40about individual liberties. It was about the
- 56:43Fourth Amendment keeping any law enforcement
- 56:46from stopping people without reasonable suspicion,
- 56:48and yet the Supreme Court sided with Trump there.
- 56:51And that really undermined my sense that maybe
- 56:53they were going to draw a distinction based on
- 56:54separation of powers versus individual liberties.
- 56:59There's another question. Is it too generous
- 57:02to the Court's conservative majority to interpret
- 57:05their seemingly endless support of Trump to be
- 57:07this Court's version of judicial restraint similar
- 57:10to Marbury v. Madison? What do you think, Erwin?
- 57:15Well, when I teach Marbury versus Madison, I
- 57:18always point out that Chief Justice John Marshall
- 57:21knew that if he'd ruled in favor of Marbury,
- 57:25his order would be ignored and the Supreme Court
- 57:28would be forever rendered a meaningless institution.
- 57:32He knew he had to rule in favor of James Madison
- 57:37and Thomas Jefferson, but he used it as a brilliant
- 57:40occasion proclaiming a much larger power for
- 57:43the court, the power of judicial review. So in
- 57:46that sense, one could say, well, just as John
- 57:49Marshall was afraid that his order would be disobeyed,
- 57:52so is this court afraid. But the problem here
- 57:56is that when you look at all of the things that
- 57:58President Trump is doing, there are challenges
- 58:01in court. If the Supreme Court refrains from
- 58:03reviewing any of them, then it's basically saying
- 58:06the president can do whatever he wants. Yeah.
- 58:09I agree with the con law expert extraordinaire.
- 58:18The next question, I don't even know how to answer.
- 58:22From the perspective of legal theory and ideology,
- 58:25would you characterize the current composition
- 58:27of the court to be more deontological, i .e.
- 58:31Kantian versus Utilian, Jeremy Bentham Mills
- 58:34in the collective view to choose between these
- 58:37two normative theories? Do you teach legal philosophy?
- 58:41I don't. And I think I last read Bentham and
- 58:44Mills and Kant back in college, not even in law
- 58:48school. My answer is I think none of the above.
- 58:53I think this is a majority that's very much animated
- 58:56by the current conservative Republican ideology.
- 59:01Think about what conservative Republican ideology
- 59:04is about. It's about such things as there not
- 59:07being constitutional right to abortion. It's
- 59:10about such things as substantial protection of
- 59:13gun rights. It's about ending affirmative action.
- 59:17It's about providing much greater protection
- 59:20for people in the name of religion. It's about
- 59:22not having an enforcement of an establishment
- 59:24clause. It's about giving the president great
- 59:27powers. That's the Republican platform. That's
- 59:32where the six conservative justices are. So I
- 59:35don't think it's about philosophy, certainly
- 59:40not a philosophy in that abstract sense. I think
- 59:43it's justices who were put on the court to implement
- 59:47a conservative ideology, and that's what they're
- 59:49doing. Yeah, I think that that's true and it
- 59:52just when I go back to covering the chief justice's
- 59:57confirmation hearings when he said the job of
- 59:59a Supreme Court justice is to call balls and
- 1:00:02strikes uh the court has gone so far afield from
- 1:00:06doing that it's really difficult for me uh when
- 1:00:09asked after years of saying no the you know the
- 1:00:11court rules in the way that they see the constitution
- 1:00:15or they read a statute and you may disagree with
- 1:00:18that but that's what it's about um now it seems
- 1:00:20really difficult to defend the court against
- 1:00:23those who say that they have become legislators
- 1:00:26in robes they They are overturned precedent just
- 1:00:30because apparently they disagree with it, which
- 1:00:32isn't the standard. And to what Erwin said, they
- 1:00:36seem to have an outcome in mind and figure out
- 1:00:40the judicial path to get there as opposed to
- 1:00:43the other way around, looking at a case and letting
- 1:00:45the law apply to the facts and inform the outcome.
- 1:00:50It's sadly the way that they seem to be going,
- 1:00:53and I don't see how that would change in any
- 1:00:56time soon. And I apologize that we didn't get
- 1:01:00to some of the questions that just came in, but
- 1:01:02I think we're at the end of our hour. And I also
- 1:01:05know it's late where you are on the East Coast.
- 1:01:07It is. I'm out East. But it was delightful to
- 1:01:10spend an evening with you, Erwin, as always.
- 1:01:13Wonderful to do this with you as well. Thank
- 1:01:14you so much. And thanks to the Beverly Hills
- 1:01:16Bar Association for inviting us. Thank you.