Latest / Seasons of Joy / That We Might Have Joy: Desire, Divinity, and Intimate Love with Dr. Jennifer Finlayson-Fife
Transcript
- 0:00I cannot wait to share this conversation with you.
- 0:04I recently read Dr. Jennifer Finlayson Fife's book entitled That We Might Have
- 0:09Joy, Desire, Divinity, and Intimate Love.
- 0:12This is a book that may challenge much of what you might have grown up believing
- 0:17about sexuality, about marriage, and about what it means to be a woman of faith
- 0:22trying to live wholeheartedly. Dr.
- 0:26Jennifer Finlayson-Fyfe is a therapist, an educator, and a coach with a doctorate
- 0:32in counseling psychology.
- 0:34For over two decades, she has helped individuals and couples,
- 0:39particularly within the LDS community, to strengthen their relationships and
- 0:44develop a more integrated view of sexuality.
- 0:47Through her acclaimed online courses, live workshops, and a widely followed
- 0:52Room for Two podcast, she has supported the emotional and sexual development of thousands of people.
- 0:58She is known for her clarity, her compassion, her depth, and her humor.
- 1:03Dr. Finlayson Fife is a sought-after voice on the topics of faith,
- 1:08intimate relationships, and personal growth.
- 1:11Near the end of her book, she wrote something that I have been thinking a lot about.
- 1:17She said this, quote, This kind of intimate love requires our faith that we
- 1:22are worthy of pleasure and care, faith in our lovability and our capacity to love.
- 1:28It asks for our courage, the courage to witness and to be witnessed, to know and to be known.
- 1:35Above all, it affirms our trust in a generous God who longs for us to know joy,
- 1:41not avoiding our bodies, not transcending our humanity, but choosing courage
- 1:48in our most intimate relationships.
- 1:50That's where we find the divine. I don't know about you, but that's not necessarily
- 1:56what I was taught growing up. And Dr.
- 1:59Finlayson-Fyfe is trying to change that narrative.
- 2:02So today, I am sharing my conversation with Dr. Jennifer Finlayson-Fyfe as we
- 2:08explore these ideas together.
- 2:10We're going to talk about eros and spirituality, about what it means to move
- 2:15from a role-based marriage to a collaborative partnership,
- 2:19about how to stop managing each other's egos and how to start actually knowing each other.
- 2:25I think that this is such an important topic and conversation to have as midlife women of faith.
- 2:33This conversation might stretch you. It might make you feel a little uncomfortable,
- 2:38but I think it might also open up something beautiful, a way of seeing your marriage,
- 2:45your body, your faith in a way that feels more whole.
- 2:49More integrated, more true. So let's dive in.
- 2:54Are you a woman of faith who is struggling to navigate your current season of life?
- 2:58Do you feel like life is just happening to you instead of for you?
- 3:02My name is Jill Pack, and I'm a certified faith-based life coach and a member
- 3:07of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
- 3:10I want you to know that no matter your season or your circumstance,
- 3:15it is possible to create a more
- 3:17joyful life, and I would love to show you how. Are you ready? Let's go.
- 3:27All right. I am so excited for this conversation.
- 3:31I am interviewing Dr. Jennifer Finlayson-Fyfe about her new book,
- 3:38That We Might Have Joy, Desire, Divinity, and Intimate Love.
- 3:42I've read it a few times, actually.
- 3:45Lovely. We can call you Dr. Jennifer. Oh, you can just say from now on. Okay. No problem. Yeah.
- 3:51And you go on so many podcasts. Most people of my listeners will know exactly who you are.
- 3:57So I'm so excited to have you here.
- 4:00I'd love to know what drew you to write this book. I've been teaching couples
- 4:05and religious couples and LDS couples even more specifically for about 15 years.
- 4:13And so much of the work I've done has been in response to the need that I perceived
- 4:19people saying we need help in this way, help to grow closer together,
- 4:23help in our sexual relationship.
- 4:25And so as I have developed these courses and taught them over and over again,
- 4:30And I always had this sense that,
- 4:33there is a spirituality that's fundamental to what I'm doing with couples.
- 4:38Because I would watch couples grow in their capacity to love each other,
- 4:43grow in their capacity to be intimate with each other.
- 4:46And so I was approached by the publisher, which is Faith Matters,
- 4:50that they wanted a book about the relationship of sexuality and spirituality.
- 4:54And I'd actually said no to a lot of invitations to write a book by other entities.
- 4:59But when they approached me with that topic. It was a topic that I really cared about.
- 5:05Like it was a problem I wanted to think through.
- 5:08And or I guess I should say it was a question I wanted to think through. And so I said yes to it.
- 5:13I imagined it was going to be like a one-year project. It turned into a four-year
- 5:17plus project because it was very much something that I was really sorting through.
- 5:25What is spirituality? how is intimate love connected
- 5:28to it how do i articulate the process i've
- 5:31seen couples engage in and evolve through so
- 5:35it was very rewarding to write it and a labor of love and yeah and something
- 5:41i'm grateful i did yeah i am too and i've talked to many people that that love
- 5:48the way you articulate and share your perspective on this matter yeah so thank
- 5:52you for the hard work, that labor of love.
- 5:55In the book, you say that desire is a spiritual act.
- 6:00And I think for a lot of people, that can feel on the radical side.
- 6:06So could you explain that a little bit?
- 6:10Let me start by saying what I don't mean, because I think, yes,
- 6:15one of the things I kind going to start out with in the book is the perceived
- 6:18incongruity between desire and spirituality or pleasure and spirituality—,
- 6:25Because we are right to be suspicious of that in the sense that many of us relate
- 6:32to pleasure and desire in an indulgent way,
- 6:35in a way that undermines our peace with ourselves, our peace with divinity.
- 6:42Because we're using pleasure and desire as a way to escape from life,
- 6:46as a way to not do difficult things, as a way to just cave into the impulses of the body.
- 6:54And yeah, when we relate.
- 6:57To desire that way. And I sometimes call that wanting because wanting is more like filling a void.
- 7:04We feel to want is to try to make up for a lack.
- 7:08And so a lot of times we try to, we feel depressed or empty and we try to fill
- 7:13it with buying things or eating things or pornography or some kind of thing
- 7:19that actually, as we emerge from that, we feel even worse.
- 7:23And so that kind of indulgence will always entrap us.
- 7:28So that I stand by. But that's different than our higher desires.
- 7:33The desire, one of the things I talk about as a fundamental principle in the book, is eros.
- 7:39And eros is the human longing. It's human longing, and it's human longing to
- 7:44commune with divinity, with the highest in us, with one another,
- 7:51with mystery, with what we don't yet know.
- 7:54It's this desire for more than what we are currently.
- 7:57And so that is fundamental to growth.
- 8:03It's fundamental to love, that I'm willing to step out of my comfort, out of my ego.
- 8:11Out of my sort of justified self, into the uncertainty of caring about another,
- 8:18of being a better person,
- 8:20of learning something that matters to me, and yet I don't yet know how to put
- 8:27it all together, because that's what transforms us.
- 8:31And as it transforms us, maybe paradoxically, it makes us more fully true to
- 8:37ourselves, more who we were meant to be.
- 8:41And so I see it as a kind of faith, faith in the goodness of God,
- 8:46goodness of the world, goodness of our own souls, that we let life teach us
- 8:51and grow in the process. Yeah. Oh, that's so beautiful.
- 8:56And so if what I'm hearing you is there's the wanting, which is on one end of
- 9:01the spectrum where fully desiring in a progressive developmental way are two
- 9:08different things. That's right.
- 9:09One is fear-driven, the other is faith-driven. Yeah.
- 9:14And I love that, just the idea of loving someone so much that you are pushing
- 9:23yourself to love in a different way than what the world shows us.
- 9:27Yeah.
- 9:57And sometimes you say eroticism, that use of that term, again,
- 10:02can feel a little uneasy.
- 10:05Yeah, for sure. And you describe it as that life force that encourages us to become something more.
- 10:11So how did you get to this understanding of Eros in that different light?
- 10:20Yeah, that's a good question. Like, when did I start thinking about that?
- 10:24I think it was before I read this book, but when I read this book,
- 10:29it was clarifying, which was C.S.
- 10:32Lewis talked about the four loves, four forms of human love,
- 10:36and he talks about brotherly love and parental love, and he has different Greek
- 10:42names for them, but Eros love was one of them, and.
- 10:46And so it just was part of thinking about what really is at the core of Eros love.
- 10:52Carl Jung writes about it. Plato writes about it. A lot of people have written about it.
- 10:57And one of the things I knew is that when couples were coming into me for help,
- 11:03I wrote my dissertation on LDS women and sexuality.
- 11:07And so a lot of people started coming to me around issues in their sexual relationship
- 11:12because of that research and that work.
- 11:15But a lot of times people would come in complaining of frequency as a problem,
- 11:20and it was, but the solution wasn't just to have more sex.
- 11:24That wasn't actually going to solve it because the real problem was that the
- 11:28relationship felt dead.
- 11:30It felt formulaic or stilted or
- 11:34that you're pretending an intimate relationship, And so it feels awkward.
- 11:38And yet it wasn't how the marriage started usually or most often.
- 11:43Most often they felt that sense of aliveness and hope and possibility,
- 11:48that spark that drew them together.
- 11:52But then their resentments and their differences and their self-protections
- 11:58were killing, were snuffing it out.
- 12:01And that's really what people were looking for was this feeling of people often
- 12:04talk about it as wanting to go back and we can't really go back.
- 12:07But how do we bring that feeling forward even when we know each other and how
- 12:12different we are and how frustratingly different we can be?
- 12:15How do we actually create more of that honest feeling?
- 12:20Magnetism between us that we once felt.
- 12:24And I think that's really what Eros is speaking to.
- 12:27And it's really, it's not the yearning for sex.
- 12:31This is an idea that C.S. Lewis talked about, which I really appreciated his perspective on it.
- 12:37It's not about the pleasures per se.
- 12:40It's about, he puts it in this way, it's the desire for the whole woman, right?
- 12:45Not just the sex, not just the pleasure, but for all of her.
- 12:49That's Eros. It's our yearning for another soul.
- 12:53And I since read other theologians on this, which is you feel the sort of yearning
- 12:58for the other person, the mystery that's in them.
- 13:00And that's what we feel when we fall in love. We're drawn to difference.
- 13:05And it's compelling to us, and it's even spiritually important to our growth.
- 13:10But then what we tend to do is once that dopamine has settled down,
- 13:15and we're not just in the intense falling in love stage, we start thinking,
- 13:19why are you ruining my life? Like, why do you do everything the wrong way?
- 13:23And so then we cope with that in ways that start killing the sense of attraction and aliveness.
- 13:30And that's where we have the most ability to grow and confront our differences
- 13:36and offer more compassion and kindness to one that does the world differently
- 13:41than we do. Yeah, that's so funny.
- 13:44I've heard it said, we're attracted to these qualities of our partner,
- 13:47and then they're the very thing that drives us absolutely crazy.
- 13:52100%. But it speaks to that. Yes, yes.
- 13:55Yeah, exactly. And I think attraction has a lot of that tension in it.
- 14:00And I think we should not...
- 14:03How to say it, treat it as if a good marriage is just placid.
- 14:07Because I think a good marriage has that tension in it, which is a little bit
- 14:11of, I love you, I hate you.
- 14:13And I know some people are like, oh my goodness, you should never feel that.
- 14:16But I think when we're being honest, there's certainly moments where we're like, ah!
- 14:19And that's okay, because I think that's a part of the yin-yang tension that's
- 14:25a part of attraction and what brings forth more capacity within us.
- 14:32And so if we can understand it for what it is, it actually helps us not resent
- 14:36so much or say, oh, gosh, I must have married the wrong person.
- 14:39Because if I'd married the right person, we would see this the same way.
- 14:43Yeah, yeah. That's beautiful. I think with the people I work with,
- 14:47sometimes we'll talk about this idea of like, when life is messy,
- 14:52I think our tendency is to go, oh, I'm doing it wrong.
- 14:56Yes. Which whatever it is, whether it's marriage or parenting or whatever,
- 15:00it's all this mess. That means I've done wrong.
- 15:03Yeah, I messed up somehow. I'm a terrible lover.
- 15:06Yeah. And it's no, like, actually, that's the purpose of all this.
- 15:10And how can we become our better selves if we're never stretched beyond where we are?
- 15:16That's right. So. Yeah, exactly. I know. I love that. It's just,
- 15:19no, nothing's going wrong.
- 15:21It's like, you don't know how to be a parent until you're parenting.
- 15:24You don't know how to be a partner until you're partnering. And so we're often
- 15:28figuring it out through failure, through the uncertainty.
- 15:32And again, that's why faith is a virtue is like, I still believe in the good.
- 15:37I still believe that love matters here. And I don't know how to do it yet.
- 15:41I don't know what it means for this child or this relationship.
- 15:45But sorting through that is a valuable process.
- 15:49And grows our souls up if we'll let it. If we just sit in resentment and victimhood
- 15:54and bitterness and hostility, then our souls don't grow. And it's an easy thing to do that.
- 15:59But if we manage ourselves and stay open to what there is to learn,
- 16:05then we can really become better people in the process. Yeah.
- 16:10Yeah. So good. So in your book, this leads into my next question,
- 16:14is you say intimacy's raw exposures and how they are this gift for our girl.
- 16:21And so how can we build that capacity to receive that gift of expansion without
- 16:29just shutting down or pushing away?
- 16:32Like, you know, it's one thing to talk about, it's another thing to do it.
- 16:36So how can we build that capacity in that exposure? Yeah.
- 16:42What I would say is, first of all, recognizing that's part of what it is.
- 16:48Because I think a lot of us have the idea from movies and even our own minds,
- 16:54which is, if you love me, go blind to the lesser parts of me.
- 16:58And there probably is a tiny bit of that in romantic love. I think you're the best.
- 17:02I think you're the most beautiful, even if it's not objectively true. Okay.
- 17:07But a lot of times we feel like, okay, I'll go blind to your lesser parts if
- 17:11you go blind to my lesser parts.
- 17:13Or I don't want to talk about that because if I do, then there'll be friction
- 17:17and we're not supposed to have friction. So I just will push it down,
- 17:21even though it's undermining our happiness.
- 17:25And so the thing is, when you share a life with someone, the differences emerge.
- 17:31My husband and I were just having a conversation this morning,
- 17:34and we're trying to think about how to make a decision.
- 17:36And we both approach it from different positions, yin-yang positions.
- 17:40And I always have a choice to make. I can just go into resenting that difference
- 17:44and then fighting for my view and
- 17:46trying to get my view to trample his or whatever. And he can do the same.
- 17:50Or we can just settle down and say, look, there's gifts in each of our perspectives.
- 17:54And even if we don't think of them as gifts, we're still going to stay together.
- 17:58So how are we going to do this as a partnership?
- 18:02How are we going to find a way by understanding each other that we can choose
- 18:07something that we can truly both be at peace with?
- 18:12Because we want a partnership and to solve this other question,
- 18:18right? I think it's like normalizing it and keeping your eye on the prize.
- 18:23Let's say you have a parenting issue. Then you're like, okay,
- 18:25my spouse approaches it this way. I approach it this way.
- 18:28Keep my eye on the prize. First of all, we both have right things in our statements
- 18:32and we both have wrong things, right?
- 18:34We both have limitations in our view, but we both have limitations.
- 18:39Fair points. And so I need to stay open to the best in me and the best in him or her.
- 18:45And then by keeping my eye on the prize, we want to be good parents to this child.
- 18:51Or we want our financial situation to work to our benefit ultimately,
- 18:56or whatever the situation is, we want to, I don't know, I'm trying to think
- 19:01of all the things, we want a good relationship with our extended family.
- 19:04So whatever the thing is, how do I hold on to what our larger goal is?
- 19:09And how do I stay open to my blind spots while holding on to the best in my
- 19:15perspective and stay open to the same in my spouse?
- 19:19So I think holding on to what the point is of your struggle helps tremendously.
- 19:24And then I think just calming down a little bit, trying not to just go into reaction.
- 19:30Because I think when we have an idea and we feel like we're not getting what
- 19:34we want, we tend to go into reaction.
- 19:37The ego will push us into our favorite behavioral pattern.
- 19:43For some, it's shutting down and resenting. For some, it's getting loud and demanding.
- 19:49For some, it's just disinvesting from the conversation, just withdrawing and
- 19:55go talking to friends or something.
- 19:57So think about what do I do in the midst of those differences that doesn't actually
- 20:02help us, even though it may feel better in the moment.
- 20:05And how do I calm myself in the conflict?
- 20:09And I don't mean contempt and contention. I just mean in the conflict,
- 20:13the different perspectives, and stay in the conversation to get to that shared goal.
- 20:20Those are the couples that do best they can handle the tension of those differences
- 20:26they handle themselves in it and they get better at it the more they do it.
- 20:32They trust each other and themselves more in it. Yeah.
- 20:35And I loved, I think the word you used was the and, right?
- 20:39Having that duality of, yeah, I've got some good points and I'm probably off the mark here. Yeah.
- 20:45He's messy and he has some good points. Like, I think it's being honest with
- 20:50ourselves that we are all flawed human beings.
- 20:54Yes. And if we can hold on to the good that you said and stay in the conflict.
- 20:59I think so many people think that the conflict is wrong.
- 21:03It kind of goes back to that idea of the mess. And it's like that conflict,
- 21:08that different perspective is the very thing that's going to draw you closer
- 21:13if you'll let it. That's right. That's right.
- 21:15And we can do conflict without contempt. But most of us think conflict is contempt.
- 21:22And it's not. You can say, I think about it this way.
- 21:25You think about it that way. How do we do this? Like you have every right to
- 21:29think about it the way you want. You are built differently than me.
- 21:32I have a right to think about the way I do. I'm built differently than you,
- 21:35but we want to do something together. So how are we going to do that?
- 21:38Because that is where the friction point at which people grow. Yeah.
- 21:42They get more able to hold a more balanced view, hold more complexity. That's human growth.
- 21:48Yeah. So really what it comes down is, as I'm sitting here thinking, is not to be afraid.
- 21:54Yeah, that's right. Of the mess and the... That's right.
- 21:58Trust it more. Friction. Yeah. Lean into it a little more.
- 22:01That's so good. So my next question is,
- 22:05as we go through this book, you build on a lot of these ideas that we've talked
- 22:09about, but you also touch on
- 22:11the beliefs around sexuality in the different genders as women and as men.
- 22:17And so I wanted to talk about that a little bit because as a midlife woman,
- 22:23I resonated with what was outlined in this book and just my experience as an
- 22:31LDS woman and the things that I grew up believing.
- 22:34And one of those was meeting the needs of your husband, right?
- 22:39And in your book, you talk about this difference between those women who thrive
- 22:45versus women who struggle in their sexuality.
- 22:49And for me, this was really big in my experience.
- 22:53So I wanted to spend a little bit of time on this. just what does that shift
- 22:58look like going from survival to thriving?
- 23:03And what's different about those women that get there?
- 23:08Yeah. So, yeah. So first of all,
- 23:11what I would say, one of the things that I talk about in the book is that we
- 23:14are all in development and where we are in our development will shape how we
- 23:21think about many of the messages that we receive.
- 23:25But a place where humans, probably most humans...
- 23:29Evolve to and stay is in what I call the social stage, which is,
- 23:36in short, it's I need you to feel good about me for me to feel good about me, right? I need to belong.
- 23:43I need this group to validate that I matter, that I have value,
- 23:49that I have something to contribute to the group.
- 23:53And so our sense of self is highly connected to other people's judgment in this
- 23:59stage, and it's very valuable.
- 24:01Nothing's going wrong. This is how you internalize values. This is how you internalize language.
- 24:06This is how you start to develop a sense of who you are as an individual.
- 24:11The pursuit of validation is an important driver, but if we stay stuck there,
- 24:18It makes it really hard to be capable of intimacy, as in really letting somebody
- 24:24know us, and especially know us sexually,
- 24:27because we're afraid if they really know me, and if they know me flaws and all,
- 24:33or they know me sexually,
- 24:34maybe I won't be considered acceptable.
- 24:38And so I have to forge a marriage while not being too intimate.
- 24:43Now, the reason I say this is because men and women have different versions of this,
- 24:48But one of the ways that probably has a considerable amount to do with women's
- 24:53wiring to be women as the primary caretakers through millennia have learned
- 24:59to map what others want, even when they don't say it.
- 25:02They track that a baby needs to eat, okay, and they mobilize to resolve that concern.
- 25:09But then many women also learned in their religious upbringings and in their
- 25:15familial and societal upbringings that a good woman attends to her husband's
- 25:20needs. A good woman is selfless.
- 25:22A good woman doesn't have desires that compete with her husband's desires.
- 25:26And therefore sexually a good
- 25:30woman is virginal and virtuous and desireless
- 25:33and accommodates her husband's
- 25:36sexual needs so a lot of people heard those
- 25:39messages and in that social stage learned the way for me to have value to a
- 25:44spouse is to be a need fulfiller to his emotional and sexual needs and to not
- 25:49be selfish and to not be too sexual sexual enough for his needs but not so sexual
- 25:55that I'm considered less virtuous.
- 25:58And that sort of internalization of the way to have a self is to deny a self,
- 26:04meaning the way to earn value in your eyes is to suppress kind of my inner compass,
- 26:12my desires, my beliefs, my feelings to keep others happy with me.
- 26:18And so a lot of us grew up learning that's what virtue is. You're selfless.
- 26:25And look, I really do believe that in loving others, sacrifice is fundamental to it.
- 26:32But that's a different idea than suppressing yourself to keep conflict low,
- 26:39to keep yourself out of honest engagement in relationships.
- 26:44A lot of times people that I'm working with, when I'm teaching women,
- 26:49they're like, I don't want to be selfish, so I need to be selfless,
- 26:53as if there's only one or the other.
- 26:55And many of us grew up learning that it was.
- 26:58And gosh, I want to be selfless because that's the right kind of woman and that's
- 27:02a desirable woman and I want to be desired.
- 27:05And so I will be that self-denying creature. And I think that's just a very
- 27:12poor setup for intimate sex, and I'll talk about the women who did well.
- 27:16But the reason it's a poor setup for intimate sex is, especially for women's
- 27:20sexuality, is very much circles around wanting to be the object of desire,
- 27:26wanting to feel attractive.
- 27:29Sexy even, like desirable to her husband, and she believes in her desirability.
- 27:33She also wants to feel that she's an equal and that her desires matter to him, right?
- 27:41And that she's even the center sexually.
- 27:45So we really socialize women in exactly the wrong reason. I'm sorry,
- 27:50in exactly the wrong way.
- 27:52To meet what women's eroticism naturally is.
- 27:56And so a lot of women feel like, I shouldn't be thinking that.
- 27:59I shouldn't want that. I shouldn't feel that way.
- 28:02And so as long as they're busy serving their husbands, they're exactly on an anti-erotic muscle.
- 28:09Okay. And so it doesn't mean go be wanton and reckless either.
- 28:12Okay. Again, I'm not saying that, but to let your desires matter in the sexual realm.
- 28:19Now, the women who did well, and this will help clarify this point,
- 28:23is that they had, and I didn't have the language for this at the time.
- 28:27I was just doing research and kind of writing up what were the characteristics
- 28:31of the women who did well.
- 28:32But as I've continued to study and learn about it, I'm recognizing that these
- 28:37women that did well had moved out of the social stage into a self-authoring stage.
- 28:43They were much more self-determining. They were religious, took their faith
- 28:49very seriously, took their relationship with God very seriously,
- 28:53so they weren't like flippant about faith at all.
- 28:57But, or and, they saw that as their desires mattered.
- 29:03And their desires vis-a-vis men mattered. Not mattered more, but mattered equally.
- 29:09And their sexuality mattered. And their pleasure mattered.
- 29:13And not more than, but equal to their spouses.
- 29:16And they tended to marry men who saw them in the same way. So they really were
- 29:21capable of partnership.
- 29:23And they didn't make their husbands' desires more important than their own.
- 29:29So when they were in conversations about how to handle their finances or career
- 29:37decisions or kids, they worked together as partners.
- 29:42And again, it wasn't about, oh, whose idea prevailed.
- 29:46It's that they saw themselves as on equal footing, and they believed in a God
- 29:52who valued them and valued their pleasure and valued their sexuality,
- 29:57and so they didn't do things to make men happy with them. They did things to
- 30:01be at peace with themselves.
- 30:03And so many of these women made a lot of sacrifices for kids and all those things,
- 30:08but it was not driven by this desire to make everyone think they're good.
- 30:12It was driven much more by an internal reference point of what they believed
- 30:16was good and allowed them to thrive also in that.
- 30:21And so they didn't apologize for sexuality or sexual pleasure,
- 30:25and they saw sex as a gift to them as much as it was to a man.
- 30:31So fascinating. Yeah. Did you find, was that percentage of women that were thriving smaller?
- 30:38It was smaller. I did a qualitative study, so I can't say like I know if I were
- 30:44to go, but based on my work and my experience, I think there's no question it's a smaller percentage.
- 30:50But important in thinking about how we grow and how we can claim a deeper internal
- 30:57source of strength that actually allows us to create more goodness,
- 31:02to love more deeply, to have deeper intimacy with a spouse.
- 31:06Yeah. Yeah. So good. So my next question to tag on that is you're working with
- 31:13women and teaching them how to embrace this self-authorship.
- 31:17If you're working with someone my age, I'm going to be 57, or I have a daughter
- 31:22who's 24, who's just starting her, She's in a relationship. She's not married yet.
- 31:29And I have a lot of other kids, too, that are married. But if you're working
- 31:32with someone younger versus someone my age, is there a difference?
- 31:37Do you notice a difference in the
- 31:39way they view themselves and how they interact in the world in that way?
- 31:46It's a really good question. I haven't worked a lot with people in their 20s
- 31:51because they're often just not in the struggle yet in the same way.
- 31:56But I do often wonder about how things are changing culturally because, yes, I also am in my 50s.
- 32:04Women who grew up in that era really were hit hard with some of those messages.
- 32:09Because unapologetically, you should be supporting your husband,
- 32:13you shouldn't be out working, and all those kinds of things.
- 32:16And so I think that generation grapples with those questions more,
- 32:21plus has seen and been exhausted somewhat by,
- 32:26I gave up everything, and now I feel depleted, and I'm looking for something different.
- 32:32I also think not only has society changed, and I don't yet have a good handle
- 32:37on how people in their late 20s and early 30s are functioning in those questions,
- 32:43but I would say that there's also...
- 32:45That women, I think, are somewhat wired before menopause to be very attuned to what others want.
- 32:55And it doesn't even require the socialization to feel somewhat bombarded by
- 33:01an awareness of what a husband wants,
- 33:03what kids want, what friends want, and to feel the challenge of regulating their
- 33:09own sense of self in the midst of that.
- 33:12A lot of women, when they become menopausal because estrogen levels drop and
- 33:17so on, and so women actually often are like, okay, I'm done, okay.
- 33:23And the hormonal shifts can actually help, plus some disillusionment around
- 33:28the limits of what they did, which doesn't mean that was wrong or that they shouldn't have done it.
- 33:35It's just how gross happens. And so sometimes as our kids are leaving the nest
- 33:40and we're looking at our marriage and we're looking at our sense of self and
- 33:44we're left in some real questions about who am I and maybe this didn't go the
- 33:51way I thought it was going to go.
- 33:52And I'm in some disillusionment and some crisis, right, of self.
- 33:57It can feel like everything's dreadfully wrong when actually it's a pretty normal
- 34:02experience to find a different level of wisdom, a different relationship to oneself.
- 34:10And so I think a lot of women in their 40s and 50s are really looking for something
- 34:16better and stronger to orient them into a new stage of growth.
- 34:22Yeah. Yeah. And it will be interesting to see as my kids get to this stage I
- 34:27am, if their experience will be the same.
- 34:30But yeah, again, to your point, it's almost just the experience of life.
- 34:36I think at some point you get to that point where you can look back and you're
- 34:42reflecting on your experience and there's going to be some sense of, wait a minute.
- 34:48Yeah, I think that's just so connected to life in general because there's things
- 34:54I'm like, oh, gosh, if I can go back, I would parent differently in this way.
- 34:57I would definitely do that differently.
- 34:59But it wasn't for lack of trying or lack of desiring to be a good parent.
- 35:05It's just for lack of knowing. You can't know until you're looking in the rearview
- 35:09mirror and you're like, oh, wait a minute. Yeah.
- 35:14Unfortunately, that's how we have to do it. We have to just keep moving forward
- 35:17when we don't have the whole picture. Yes.
- 35:20And so it's very easy to be critical of ourselves looking backwards.
- 35:23But if I had known better, I would have done better.
- 35:26I just didn't know it until I knew it. And the only way you can know things,
- 35:29or at least think you know them, is by going through them.
- 35:33And so it's easy to be hard on ourselves and angry at life, but I don't know of another way to do it.
- 35:40It's just how it's set up.
- 35:44Compassion for ourselves is a good thing. Yeah, yeah.
- 35:47And so as we've talked about that self-author stage in women,
- 35:52it's a little bit different in men's experience.
- 35:55And so I wanted to talk a little bit about that idea when I read your book about
- 36:00how men are taught to fear their sexual nature and to see something corrupt in their soul.
- 36:07So we're both struggling as men and women to self-author, but it just is a little different.
- 36:13So maybe talk to that a little bit about LeBron's experience.
- 36:18I think a lot of critique, cultural critique,
- 36:22and understandably, has been focused on the fact that women have been kind of
- 36:29robbed of a sense of legitimacy around sexuality,
- 36:31where men have been granted the fact of desire and sexuality and haven't been
- 36:38asked in the same way to be selfless and desireless and suppress their sexual—they
- 36:44can at least identify as a sexual being.
- 36:46And that's, yes, that I can see that.
- 36:51At least conceivably be better than feeling like sexual feelings are undermining
- 36:56my femininity and my desirability.
- 36:59At the same time, I think men, religious men in particular,
- 37:03and even non-religious men in a Me Too environment, and I obviously want women
- 37:12who've been perpetrated against to be understood and to be able to talk about
- 37:17and reveal their experiences.
- 37:19And in a culture that has become very aware of that, I think a lot of men can
- 37:24feel like men's sexuality is inherently toxic or what's the word I'm looking for, like corrupting.
- 37:31And therefore, can I be at peace with my sexuality?
- 37:36If my sexuality is going to harm or potentially harm or destroy the virginity
- 37:42and the virtue and the innocence of my spouse, Then men, especially sensitive men,
- 37:48good men, can feel really ambivalent about sexuality.
- 37:52And if you grew up in a religious culture and home that, you know,
- 37:56is really panicked about sexual feelings and masturbation and so on,
- 38:02the anxiety around that can actually drive a lot of both fear and even compulsive behavior.
- 38:11Because I shouldn't be thinking that. I shouldn't want that.
- 38:14And the fixation and the shame around it can actually drive people into more behavior.
- 38:22I talk about this sometimes with respect to food. I've had clients who...
- 38:26Learned they shouldn't want sweets, like the parents were very hard on them,
- 38:29would force them on diets and things.
- 38:31And then they would get compulsive about their food consumption because they
- 38:35would feel this, I shouldn't have it, I shouldn't want it, I can't have it.
- 38:38And then they'd indulge and feel terrible and then either would turn into bulimia
- 38:44or like then suppression, but then back into indulgence.
- 38:47And so that's when we shame the pleasures of the body, we actually usually interfere
- 38:53with our ability to regulate our choices around the pleasures and the sensuality of the body.
- 38:59And what we need is the ability to hold on to our higher aims around pleasure.
- 39:05We can't be joyful and suppress pleasure. We can't be joyful and just shame
- 39:10it and think any pleasure is a bad thing.
- 39:12But the pleasure that leads to joy is pleasure that accrues to our strength
- 39:19that gives us deeper peace in our lives.
- 39:22It's not an escape from life, but a way to more deeply appreciate and value life.
- 39:27And so we have to help our kids and ourselves relate to it in that way.
- 39:33But for men too, they're often looking to their wives to make their sexuality okay.
- 39:38And often she's in no position to do it because she has her own anxieties, right?
- 39:42And so it often turns into intimate and painful struggle for both men and women.
- 39:50Yeah. Yeah. And trying to, it's like both are living in a shame place.
- 39:57It just looks differently. That's right.
- 40:00One's in sort of high desire and the other often in low desire,
- 40:03depending on the man and woman, but that's not an unusual combination.
- 40:07And both have shame and anxiety and uncertainty around it. and they're looking to the other person,
- 40:14make something okay and neither one is able to. And again, it's when we get
- 40:19stuck in that social stage rather than moving into deeper self-acceptance and
- 40:24being more able to make room for another person,
- 40:27learn from each other and develop something together where you can share more
- 40:31of yourself and be more at peace with yourself.
- 40:34Yeah. And that kind of goes along with that idea of so many of us have,
- 40:40in this certain age, have that idea of a role-based marriage.
- 40:44And in your book, you talk about this different moving from a cooperative to
- 40:49a collaborative and equal.
- 40:51And we talked about that a little bit, but yeah, what does that mean?
- 40:55How can move from cooperative?
- 40:57Because we've all heard, let's cooperate.
- 40:59We've got to cooperate. We've got to compromise where you think collaborative and equal is different.
- 41:05It's a little different. Yeah. A lot of times we think of it in terms of compromise.
- 41:10And compromise, it doesn't mean you split something down the middle necessarily
- 41:13when you're collaborating.
- 41:15You either move to another state
- 41:18or you don't move. You can't agree to disagree and still be a couple.
- 41:22You either have a baby or don't have a baby. You have sex or you don't have
- 41:24sex, but you can't agree to disagree and still be a couple around these shared experiences, Right.
- 41:31And so couplehood pressures the ability to collaborate.
- 41:37And what that means is what I was speaking to earlier in the conversation,
- 41:42which is holding on to what is our shared aim.
- 41:45We want to be good parents. We want a good sexual relationship.
- 41:49We want to be at peace with how we're relating to our finances,
- 41:53whatever it is. and you hold on to your larger goal, and then you deal with
- 41:58your role relative to that goal.
- 42:01Does it mean I need to speak up more honestly for that to happen?
- 42:05Do I need to talk about what I don't like about our sexual relationship?
- 42:08Not to blame or to say it's not my problem, but to solve the problem.
- 42:13Do I need to deal with my own problematic behavior, let's say, around money?
- 42:18I'm spending too much. I'm not actually being considerate of our financial well-being
- 42:26and I keep finding a way to justify something in myself.
- 42:29Or deal with my problematic behavior in our intimate relationship.
- 42:33Maybe I'm just avoidant and let my higher desire spouse do all the pursuing
- 42:38and the managing of this part of our relationship.
- 42:41So it's often dealing with our limited selves to the end, the goal that we're focusing on.
- 42:48It also is often speaking honestly, not accusingly, but honestly about what
- 42:54in your spouse's part in the problem, not again to lay blame, but to solve.
- 43:01Because a couple that can collaborate is more invested in what's true than in who wins.
- 43:10Right. They're more invested in how do we solve it and what will actually be
- 43:13good for the two of us rather than getting my way.
- 43:17And a lot of people don't want partnership as much as they think.
- 43:22They want a spouse that's going to give them what they want.
- 43:26But that's very different than I want a partner that I'm going to share a life
- 43:30with and deal with who I am and how I impact their happiness.
- 43:33Many of us are just focused on how do you impact my happiness,
- 43:37not how do I impact yours.
- 43:40And you never create a collaborative relationship if you can't get to that second question.
- 43:46Yeah. And I think that ties on to this other phrase that you used is being able
- 43:54to be more unselfconscious and joyful together.
- 43:58Yeah, that's right. 100%. Yeah.
- 44:01Go ahead. Yeah. I was going to say, when we're very dependent on the other person
- 44:05to make us feel okay, we're going to be self-conscious. I need you to see me
- 44:10as pretty. I need you to see me as good.
- 44:13And then we feel like I can't just be me. I can't just open up and let you know me.
- 44:20Where the more you reveal yourself honestly, you really are trying to bring
- 44:25your best self to the challenges in your life and in your relationship.
- 44:30You're really trying to care about the other person. You're still going to be flawed.
- 44:33I have no question that letting my spouse know me is to look at many flaws, okay? But you also...
- 44:40Know that there's integrity in it. There's decency in it. There's a willingness
- 44:44to keep facing what is lesser in you for what is better.
- 44:48And so you can trust that there's enough goodness there that it's right to be
- 44:54open, that it's okay if they see a lesser part,
- 44:58both because you know you want to deal with the lesser part and because you
- 45:02trust your ability to love and forgive each other.
- 45:05And so I think that's how you become no longer self-conscious,
- 45:10because I don't have to pretend anything here.
- 45:13I'm known here. I'm known and I'm accepted.
- 45:16And that is what we long for most in marriage and in our sexual relationships.
- 45:21But it's something we create through our choices.
- 45:24It's not just a given. And granted, not all marriage partners are the same,
- 45:30and some people marry a person much more capable of love and acceptance than others do.
- 45:35We just want to make sure that we are operating in a way that's possible.
- 45:40Because if we indulge our lesser selves, even if we are met with some acceptance
- 45:46and love, we won't believe it or be able to take it in because we know we're
- 45:50living indulgently in the marriage.
- 45:52So how do you, what are some ways that
- 45:55you help couples kind of like maybe they've
- 45:58walked on eggshells maybe they have not taken the
- 46:01time to know themselves or their spouse and here they are 35 years later yeah
- 46:06going what is this what now yeah what's something where can someone start i
- 46:13think it's getting facing the fact that you're enacting all of the dishonesty and the hiding,
- 46:21and you're living out that reality,
- 46:25and that if it's going to change,
- 46:27you have to take what you both know but pretend you don't see and bring it into
- 46:32the present, bring it into the conversation.
- 46:35I tiptoe around you, I find.
- 46:39Might be something you say, because I'm afraid of your reaction to me,
- 46:44or I am afraid of letting you know me.
- 46:48Now, the spouse might be like, what are you talking about? What do you mean?
- 46:51Why? I don't know. Scary.
- 46:54And then it might be the courage, because this takes courage to say,
- 46:58for some reason, you are scary to me, not because I think you're going to hurt
- 47:01me, but because I fear rejection by you, whatever it is.
- 47:06I'm not just saying whatever is actually true to say it.
- 47:09And it may be coming from me even more than you, but I'm afraid of rejection.
- 47:14And I don't often tell you how I feel. And I want to change that.
- 47:18That's just like the beginning of creating something real. And so when I work with couples.
- 47:24What I'm often trying to help them do is to get more truth between them,
- 47:28because as much as that can hurt and feel scary,
- 47:32like the truth is going to destroy us, what actually destroys people is denying
- 47:37the truth and not living it and acknowledging it.
- 47:40And so when people can face more truth, they build more capacity.
- 47:45And as they build more capacity, they build more freedom into their marriage.
- 47:50I think this circles back to really what we've been talking about this whole time.
- 47:54But that, and you said the word courage, I think conflict can feel scary,
- 48:01but when we can tap into the courage and be able to self-confront and be honest with our partner,
- 48:09it just, yeah, it just builds so much more room for both of you to be there.
- 48:14Yeah. Yeah, that's right.
- 48:17And again, it is a form of faith, like, that I believe in truth and love enough
- 48:22to tolerate revealing more truth.
- 48:25That takes courage because we want the deception and the hiding to work in our
- 48:31favor because it protects our ego, it protects our fear.
- 48:34But to submit to the process by bringing more truth between you,
- 48:39including truth about yourself, that's really where our souls grow. Yeah.
- 48:45Beautiful. So we basically run out of time.
- 48:49I could talk to you for hours. I think everyone could, but you just have so
- 48:53much wisdom, and I'm just appreciative of your graciousness to share what you know.
- 49:00So as we end out today, and speaking to the women in my audience,
- 49:06I will say get this book, and I'll share your website and everything on the show notes.
- 49:11But as we end, could you speak to the women who are trying to navigate this
- 49:18season and figure out how to create a stronger relationship,
- 49:22whether it's sexually or just sexually?
- 49:26Relationship in general, and they're trying to reconcile where they've come.
- 49:33And you call it a generous receiving from God.
- 49:37Through the tension that we've lived in and that we're maybe being more mindful
- 49:42of at this season of life, how can we do that?
- 49:47How can we step into that generous receiving.
- 49:52So one thing I would say is that for many women in midlife,
- 49:58it feels like something's gone terribly wrong, and it feels disillusioning often,
- 50:05or like maybe I've just not figured this out and there's something broken about me.
- 50:11And I would say you've done a lot of good.
- 50:14Many good things have come from the years you have lived, and you are now in
- 50:20a position to receive more light, like more possibility into your life.
- 50:25Because of a certain disorientation, disillusionment, that is natural.
- 50:32I guess I should say it's just part of the pattern of how people grow.
- 50:36And so in this period, you may actually The...
- 50:42Find a deeper strength within yourself, a deeper trust in yourself,
- 50:48deeper wisdom, and in a way, deeper faith to, I don't need to earn my value
- 50:55anymore. I don't need to prove anything.
- 50:57Maybe it's always been there. We don't tend to think of faith as having something
- 51:02to do with believing in our own implicit value, but sometimes that's the most
- 51:07courageous act of faith we can enact, Right?
- 51:11That I actually have value, that I have value equal to men, that God sees me
- 51:17as worthy, that my joy in life matters, and is not only good for me,
- 51:23it's good for my relationships.
- 51:25And maybe I could even see myself more truthfully than I have in the past,
- 51:32even as some of the sort of outward measures of self seem to be falling away
- 51:38to find the truest measure of myself within me.
- 51:41And so I think I've seen a lot of women make that transformation,
- 51:47find a deeper capacity, a deeper wisdom, and,
- 51:51And they're so grateful for it because that self-trust is something that they've
- 51:56often been lacking and start finding it and finding a lot more capacity to love and be loved in it.
- 52:06So certainly don't give up hope and there's a lot of good to be gleaned from this period.
- 52:12Oh, that's so beautiful. I would, what you said just summed up my experience,
- 52:18because as I have been able to step into the uncomfortable of seeing myself
- 52:25and my spouse and my adult kids,
- 52:27all of the dynamics that go in this season of life and trust that it's all been for my best good,
- 52:35the painful parts.
- 52:37And just stepping into that trust of self expands us in so many ways.
- 52:45We can't even see at the beginning of that journey. Yeah.
- 52:50Yeah. Beautiful. Thank you for sharing your time with me today.
- 52:53And is there any last words that you'd like to offer as we close out?
- 52:59Oh, gosh. Just have courage and goodness is real. Like, love is real.
- 53:06I just see it over and over as people lean in that direction.
- 53:09They get stronger and they have more to offer themselves and others.
- 53:15So don't give up hope in that.
- 53:17Awesome. Thank you so much, Jennifer. Yeah, thank you.
- 53:21Thank you for tuning in to the Seasons of Joy podcast. I hope you enjoyed today's episode.
- 53:26And if you like what you heard, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review,
- 53:30and share with your friends and family.
- 53:32If you want to learn more about me or how to work with me, just visit my website,
- 53:37www.seasons-coaching.com, and have a joyful week.